Sephiroth - A Deconstruction of Villainy

Everything Sephiroth thinks he knows about the world and about himself is wrong.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Intro
03:08 First Mentions
05:37 At the Shinra HQ
12:13 Five Years Ago
24:35 Constructing a New Identity
36:39 The Lifestream
38:13 Return to Nibelheim
42:59 The Temple of the Ancients
50:36 Aerith
55:25 Jenova
60:04 Identity as a Weapon
01:04:42 Final Revelations
01:07:55 Final Questions
01:12:13 Conclusion

[@fatbrett]

This video will spoil the entire plot line of the original Final Fantasy 7. I have not played Rebirth yet, so I don't know how closely the Remake follows the original, but the video will undoubtedly spoil several key moments of the story for you if you have not finished either game yet.

[@BigPanda096]

Dude I'm ready for every version of anything you cover IDC what it is or if I ever heard of it. There just really isn't any other content creator I've found that scratches the itch quite like a FatBrett video.

[@ggmasterguiltygear6315]

Very nice video! can you do Kefka next? He actually suceeded in his plan multiple times, which is a first in a mainline FF game.

[@1Hollowgoku]

I often wonder if the devs of dead space got some inspiration from FF7 because the moment I saw a necromorph I instantly thought about JENOVA like she can really be the matriarchal necromorph…..connected universe anyone??😂

[@TytheGuy6867]

Hey are we gonna get a Songbird Video for Phantom Liberty soon?

[@zenone9698]

@Fatbrett You should analyze Xenoblade character Jin.

[@the_well-known_stranger2275]

This man made a 1 hour+ video about Sephiroth and didn’t play One Winged Angel even once. The sheer restraint on display is staggering.

[@TheDennisjeppsson]

only thing missing xD

[@Thecommander248]

There's nothing more to say.

[@FeelingWitchyArt]

Doesn't it play in the background in the start or am I tripping??

[@AsteroSloth]

@@FeelingWitchyArtthat’s “Listen to the cries of the planet” 😭

[@FeelingWitchyArt]

​@@AsteroSloth Upon a relisten, I don't know how the fuck I heard it lmao it doesn't even sound remotely similiar

[@ThatOneGuy9556]

My favorite quote about Sephiroth is "You know how they tell stories about someone and often they don't live up to them? With Sephiroth it's the exact opposite."

[@LordMalice6d9]

Sephiroth does all of the things that a great villain should do. He is like a literal checklist of all of the things that a great villain should entail.

[@gubbothehuggo2771]

The secret of Sephiroth's success is the writer's restraint in keeping him offscreen. Allowing the drip feed of information to build up the mystique. But also not making him too irrelevant off in the background where you forget about him. His actions are usually offscreen but CONSIQUENTIAL. You always just miss him after it's too late to stop him.

[@Zerorenren4761]

Remake looked at this and did the opposite, Sephiroth appears so much that they completely fucked up him.

[@beezybaby1289]

@@Zerorenren4761hard disagree. It’s just different

[@CaptainTitforce]

​@@beezybaby1289Nah, SPOILERS FOR REBIRTH EARLY GAME: The moment you show the giant snake being killed by Sephiroth, you've fucked it up.

[@fecal_position6412]

​@@CaptainTitforce you're high dude, that scene was great.

[@elevate07]

​@fecal_position6412 it really wasn't. The video touched on it but the gulf in strength between yourself and Sephiroth was very apparent in game. Initially you only had stories, but when you scrape past the Midgar Zolom only to find Sephiroth not only killed one but put it through a tree, you realize Cloud was not exaggerating. Sephiroth really is THAT strong. I don't understand why Cloud and friends are impressed by Sephiroth's ability to kill a big snake in Remake. Cloud has already defeated the metaphysical embodiment of fate and destiny. Why should anyone in the party be threatened by a big lizard? And it's because Remake couldn't help itself. It had to show its p*nties on the first date and leave nothing else to impress us with later.

[@Xehanort10]

20:20 As evil as Sephiroth is Hojo is FF7's real monster.

[@THELYRICALTMAN]

It's only fitting that the time stamp is 2020.... Same release as Remake and the year we don't speak of....

[@stoneyfbabypsn6733]

Facts

[@Cman04092]

Yeah i agree. Sephiroth is somewhat sympathetic, considering he didn't ask to be a science experiment with alien dna injected into him as a fetus. Sephiroth was even somewhat decent before he found out the truth and went psycho, which is all traced back to hojo. Not to mention, all the thousands of others hojo hurts with no remorse, and hojo creates all the villains, other than jenova, of course. but even then, jenova shoulda just been left alone and locked away but hojo had to be a f**kwit.

[@ZeroOmega-vg8nq]

Still wish they kept hojos updated design from crisis core and dirge of cerberus instead of the remake look. He felt more unnerving as a clean scientist

[@therealbs2000]

Why no one talk about hojo being a real person

[@CJusticeHappen21]

The contrast between Sephiroth and Cloud extends to their identity crisises. Cloud loses his identity but, thanks to his friends, he is able to recover. Sephiroth also loses his identity, and embraces a lie, that Jenova is his Mother, that he is entitled to rule the world. He embraces this final fantasy (yep) so completely that eventually it completely overwhelms him, and whatever was left of the original Sephiroth is utterly and completely destroyed, sacrificed for the sake of power.

[@codynoth4183]

A much better narrative is that Sephiroth is just another victim to Jenova and Hojo. He died in Nibelheim and his entire legacy and honor as a soldier is being smeared because Jenova is wearing his body like a meat suit.

[@CJusticeHappen21]

@@codynoth4183 Sadder, maybe. I like to think that the best parts of Sephiroth abandoned him, and attached themselves to Cloud instead, as Cloud values the things that Sephiroth claimed to value, back before Nibelheim. Not only that, but Sephiroth is aware of this transformation, that in his efforts to try to control Cloud, the human part of him chose an unremarkable human, rather than remain as part of him; and that just makes him hate Cloud all the more.

[@323starlight]

That and Sephiroth did spend 7 whole days, without sleeping, reading the research conducted on Jenova. Research that, mind you, misidentified Jenova as a cetra. That misinformed research, combined with approx 168 hours of uninterrupted consciousness, of course someone would go loony.

[@323starlight]

@@codynoth4183 Except thats nor really it at all. Sephiroth won out against Jenova in a battle of wills and now all parts of Jenova are puppets of Sephiroth.

[@codynoth4183]

@@323starlight Thing is that's never stated in any of the games. We see far more evidence that Sephiroth died in the Nibelheim lifestream/reactor.

[@Ronin11111111]

20:48 If Sephiroth knew Hojo was his dad, he'd have gone insane much sooner. Knowing he's related that walking ball of grease would have broken his mind so hard Jenova could've overtaken his mind from the opposite side of the planet.

[@moruemourue9692]

Isn't Vincent his father ?

[@johnvrabel3]

​@moruemourue9692 did you play the game at all?

[@SableWind]

​@@moruemourue9692 That's just a fan theory. Hojo identifies himself as Sephiroth's father, and no other character ever posits otherwise. Would be interesting if the third game indicates otherwise (no talks of Sephiroth's dad in Rebirth, I just finished a 113 hr playthrough last night). That said, I wouldn't put Hojo above calling himself Sephiroth's father from the perspective of having "created" him, regardless of the actual genetics of the matter

[@Ronin11111111]

@@SableWind I don't know what is funnier, Vincent getting cucked by Hojo of all people or the image of Sephiroth and Vincents edgy father-son time together.

[@elizabethchint2391]

@moruemourue9692 No. That's just debunked theorists coping. Hojo being his father has been confirmed several times.

[@justaguy2182]

I love when the villain has enough of a presence that you shudder just hearing about them. You don’t ever see him until later on in the game, but you hear so much about him that you don’t forget him. Sephiroth is one of the few examples of this that I can think of, and it’s done very well.

[@reubencaldwell8494]

Sephiroth invented the the gorgeous edgy nemesis trope and yet somehow doesn’t manage to fall into the trappings his contemporaries did. The Remake also added a dash of strange mix of angst and mutual pining between him and Cloud.

[@chimerakait]

Because Sephi exists as long as Cloud is haunted by his memories. The moment Cloud dies at this stage, Sephiroth looses, so he is manipulating fate to keep Cloud alive, acting like a god in a world where their isn't one.. He needs cloud's help to fulfill his goals, either willing or unwittingly helping. its not Pining for, but a parasitical, abusive relationship; Cloud is a tool to be used and cast away. Just like in OG7. Also ya no one else can seem to get edgy characters correct. Sooooo many wanabe edgelords.

[@jairizard]

​@@chimerakait"There's no reason to be sad. There's no reason to be mad either. Because, Cloud, you are... A puppet."

[@CountDoucheula]

*Kefka: "Am I a joke to you?"*

[@mr.j3rs3y]

I’m sure there were plenty that fit that trope before him but he is certainly a poster child of the trope!

[@chimerakait]

@@jairizard "I will never be... a memory!" 😉 living rent free in clouds head.

[@THELYRICALTMAN]

Sephiroth is just one of those villains who is so compelling, EVERYONE has a shared respect for, wether it be from a point of inspiration, or outright fear.

[@MasterKombatBro]

As a wise prince once said. "HES SO...DAMN...COOL"

[@johnbyorgan6969]

​@@MasterKombatBro HIS POWER IS..... MAXIMUM

[@aliastheabnormal]

He is REGEND, and saved France on the side.

[@ImPrettySureThisIsMax]

The Kefka fans have a few things to say

[@8-bitsarda747]

not quite everyone. I played FFVII for the first time a few years ago, and was confused about what all the hype around Sephiroth was about. This may have been in part, because people kept saying he was one of the greatest villains of all time, which made me anticipate someone in the same league as Mithos from Tales of Symphonia (which is an unfair expectation for any villain). Pretty sure if I hadn't had people talk him up so much, I may have actually been impressed. I mean, I personally found Vayne and Cid from FFXII more interesting than Sephiroth, and I don't see nearly as many people singing that game's praises

[@SamsarasArt]

The gradual way Sephiroth is introduced to the player is nothing short of brilliant, that along with the pacing of his backstory. From beginning to end you are drip-fed bits of information regarding who he is and why he became what he did. Sephiroth goes from a legendary war hero who seemingly died 5 years ago, to an artificially produced Cetra obsessed with taking the planet back from humans, to being part of Jenova itself; and finally the full story was revealed. Sephiroth is human. His parents are both human, his mother being Lucrecia and his father the mad scientist Hojo. While still in the womb, Sephiroth was injected with Jenova cells by Hojo and that was why he was different from other people, why he was so powerful. To quote Sephiroth himself, "Ever since I was a child I felt different, special in some way but....not like this." In the end Hojo is the true villain responsible for most of the suffering in Final Fantasy 7, with Sephiroth being one of many victims of his cruelty.

[@yourehereforthatarentyou]

not to mention all the other rotten behavior hojo gets up to in his spare time

[@SamsarasArt]

@@yourehereforthatarentyou Hojo's a depraved monster.

[@Okkotsu86275]

The remake made me fall in love with Sephiroth all over again, reminding me why he is so iconic and one of my favorite villains in fiction. He is the Morning Star and Dark Angel of the FF franchise.

[@yourehereforthatarentyou]

who’re morning star & dark angel

[@DioBrando1996v]

​lucifer @@yourehereforthatarentyou

[@Omarthedemigod]

@@yourehereforthatarentyouI assume he’s referring to Lucifer Morningstar (The Devil/Satan) and for Dark Angel I assume those murderous soldiers of god, or that one tv show in the early 2000s

[@easytos]

This part in 21:28 is still one of the goofiest scenes to me. Just seeing Sephiroth having to pull himself up to see in the port hole... This being of unfathomable power, having to clamber up to peak into the pod like a curious child makes me chuckle every time I see it.

[@XAngelsNeverCryX]

It's oddly cute. 😮

[@KatoCoyoteCombatWorkshop]

I think it's a nice detail too. Like it was designed so rank and file Shinra staff couldn't peek inside and see what they were really working on.

[@thomascheckie2394]

I was going to watch this video Then suddenly, Sephiroth intervened

[@mywifesboyfriend5558]

1:13:55 Until the end. But what will you do with them?

[@liammcnicholas918]

It has a little something for everyone

[@Deepstab1]

Have heard people saying they are disappointed how the story begins fighting an evil corp but moves to sephirot but to me sephirot also represents the results of what happens when the greed is left unchecked, a human built for the ambitions of others, same greed that lead them to experiment with jenova, giving raise to the apocalypse

[@Cthululululu]

He's a product thereof, and is on many ways, before Nibelheim, pitiable. He's a puppet himself, for the first section of his life- ironic, in regards to the accusations he makes towards Cloud, but that's almost certainly intentional. He's the fruit of a company pushing into matters beyond human control, for pure greed and rampant need. And the man he was before Nibelheim is, in a way, the first victim of the monster he becomes.

[@iantaakalla8180]

I agree with that. Sephiroth may be a force of nature, but he is one that Shinra unleashed. In that sense, FF7 is a classic “human makes thing they can’t control and pays the price for it” story.

[@ThePa1riot]

I’m all but relieved by that switch. It’s not like we’re lack for games where the plot is fighting yet another Megacorp and I’m frankly sick of them. I like that Sephiroth offers a more global, cosmic threat beyond the scope of mustache twirling Captain Planet villains.

[@GodOfAI_]

Sephiroth is the perfect definition of the nemesis that always destroys your plans no matter what you do.

[@andrewrogers3067]

The man himself is covering the man himself… This is going to be legendary

[@carpetbombjesus]

man moment

[@motherfuckingenterprises7436]

"You always admired me. And now you've experienced the pain I felt for so long. Isn't that what you wanted, Cloud? To be just...Like...ME" I never played the original game, but that scene of the abridged left dead cold. Honestly, Sephiroth deserves all the praise and dick riding

[@robinanwaldt]

Honestly, I think that scene from Machinabridged went way harder than the original. That line sadly isn’t in the game.

[@maellesaliou5871]

Somehow I feel like Sephiroth is gonna say something like that to Cloud in FF7R Part 3, because he already implied that he expected Cloud to follow the same path of rage and destruction as he did when he snappen during the Nibelheim incident.

[@itsdantaylor]

1:02:07 after Rebirth we can see this happening again. It's implied that Sephiroth's new reunion can now only be attempted thanks to the group beating the arbiters of fate in Remake. So once again, Sephiroth has manipulated his enemies to get exactly what he wants.

[@amharbinger]

One of the best things that came from the prequel Crisis Core was highlighting Sephiroth's humanity. We learn he did care about people and their lives. Even giving Zack time off to see Aerith knowing it how much she meant to him. It pairs so well with the core game to the point it almost felt natural and they planned it out from the beginning. How losing Genesis and Angeal was basically him losing any attachments to his humanity and the only family he ever had.

[@EvelynL.1112]

EXACTLY

[@LordMalice6d9]

I never liked Crisis Core. Its story was a mess. At least Zack is a likable protagonist.

[@Rman94]

Unlike Cloud, Sephiroth didn't have his close friends with him to pull him back from the brink, those guys were either dead or messed up by related events.

[@EvelynL.1112]

Yeah, that's what's tragic. Cloud had loved ones who were willing to help and support him. Sephiroth lost all of the loved ones he had.

[@michaelcooper3126]

Another cool thing about Sephiroth is that he not only is a dark reflection of Cloud, but the other party members as well. Aerith, for example, is pretty much everything that Sephiroth initially believes about himself: a descendant of the Cetra race, chosen by the planet. Barret and Sephiroth both hate Shinra for what they done to the planet and themselves, but Sephiroth wants to kill all of humanity, whereas Barret limits himself to Shinra instead. Red was experimented on by Hojo like Sephiroth was. Cid, Vincent, and Cait Sith were former employees of Shinra that were wronged by them like Sephiroth. Tifa is similar to how Sephiroth is in Crisis Core, in which both are forced to watch as their friends descend to madness as a result of Shinra’s actions. The biggest difference between Sephiroth and the party is how they choose to deal with their traumas and the path they take.

[@LeadLeftLeon]

And dead guy Zack is the only person whose parents are still alive

[@EvelynL.1112]

@@LeadLeftLeon Yeah, until Hojo dies later in the OG, and Sephiroth's mother is his only parent left alive.

[@swordscion6212]

I wonder... And this is just a thought. Perhaps the reason why Sephiroth is silent during the final battle, is because he is still dead. He died at Nibelheim, and his soul entered the life stream, but the jenova cells took what was left of him and regenerated his body. The Sephiroth we see through the game is all Jenova, the mad and insane ramblings come from a Jenova clone of Sephiroth. I might be wrong as I haven't beaten the game in a while, but does the Sephiroth from the crater say anything at all? Maybe... What we fight at the end isn't Sephiroth the man, but the fully realized successor to Jenova, the god among mortals and destroyer of worlds? And... Well, at this point, since we killed Jenova, prior to fighting Sephiroth, there is nothing more to give him direction. Besides, Sephiroth was a chameleon, he adopted the philosophies and identities of those he viewed as family. When he worked for shinra, he was the greatest soldier. When he thought he was an ancient, he adapted to become the Cetra's avenger. When he realized he was the successor of Jenova, he became the calamity of Terra. Sephiroth never had an identity, besides being mentally broken and scarred. So the final true Sephiroth, has no dialogue because he has no identity anymore as he is subject to the life stream. All he knows is calamity, and for someone who relies on others to give him purpose. He was never able to conquer the life stream.

[@swordscion6212]

I admit, this is as tenuous a theory as any regarding Sephiroth's character. Most of it relies on Jenova being the dominant party. But perhaps... In a tragic way, it displays the story of Jenova as a mother, desperately trying to bring back the only true family she has. Sephiroth died after finding Jenova, what if, this whole story was just Jenova trying to bring her boy back? An alien, but worried mother fighting against the life stream for the only person who loves her as family. So she parades around using his image, leading to the events where Sephiroth's true body would be bathed in the life stream and hopefully regain his soul, and inherit her mission, to become a calamity.

[@swordscion6212]

Leave it to fatbrett to get your mind working on character theories...

[@belot217]

This marvelously parallels Cloud!

[@yagirlmayalazarus6713]

@@swordscion6212This on relies on the headcanon that Jenova even has motherly instincts. It has a feminine form but that simply could be the form it took after arriving on Gaia to blend in and slowly begin draining the planet. Jenova is a parasitical alien from space after all.

[@SUpersaiyajinjerkbag]

Sephiroth never wanted to avenge the ancients (that was more clouds "testimony"), more likely he found out he was "related " to Jenova and basically gave up on humanity

[@thesilverwolfofnyc5077]

The library scene on onward was masterfully created to help peoples understand what was going on with him in rebirth. I hope you do another video talking about his character in advent, remake and rebirth with how much of a manipulative villain he becomes instead of the typical physical.

[@thefirefridge5187]

I like your theory that Sephiroth is able to mind control Cloud because of his willpower and Cloud's weak mind. However, I don't think that's mutually exclusive from the Jenova cell explanation. Those two explanations can work together and compliment each other. In fact, I'm not sure the willpower explanation works without the Jenova cells. One can't just control someone's mind through force of will alone. There has to be some sort of fantasy mumbo jumbo to justfiy it too.

[@loregasmic]

Somewhere in the Shinra Mansion library it's written that the third dose of Mako protects them from Jenova cells or something. Zack had gone through the full process while Cloud was incomplete and left in a catatonic state. When he falls in the Lifestream in Mideel that is when he gets the 3rd dose, if I remember right. Wisdom from RPGamer summarized this up perfectly years ago if that article is still around anymore.

[@loregasmic]

Ah, found it: "The journals in the adjacent library provide our explanation. I must infer from this editorial, and countless others like it, that most gamers did not take the initiative to search the bookcases in the back. They describe the escape and subsequent pursuit, but they also show that while Zack did not experience a reaction to JENOVA treatment, Cloud did. We discover that the soldiers let Cloud go, (they say he “escaped” in the report), because of his “diminishing consciousness.” He’s not considered a threat, because his treatment was incomplete. (Didn’t you ever wonder why Cloud had glowing eyes, even though he was never a SOLDIER? There’s your answer.)... He is subjected to experimentation that leaves him physically and mentally instable. We have no idea how long he was kept in the basement, so there’s no real way of measuring the damage done. And unlike Zack, Cloud has a reaction to JENOVA-in fact, he’s SO reactive that Hojo takes him to Phase II of the experimentation! (Unfortunately, Phase III grants stability and conscious control over the JENOVA-and Cloud escaped before he could be given the third injection.)...This explains Cloud’s helplessness. He’s two-thirds of a Mako experiment, people. He’s completely subject to outside interference. His cells are incomplete. He can’t consciously control them; his body lacks the chemical stability to do so. He’s unaware they even exist in the first half of the game! Faced with JENOVA, Cloud is virtually powerless to exert his own will. Only in situations of extreme duress can Cloud force his body to obey his commands, rather than JENOVA’s. (This speaks VERY highly of Cloud’s physical and mental discipline, because according to Hojo, Cloud shouldn’t be able to exercise free agency at all.) Keep in mind that none of what I’ve said so far is opinion-I’m going off solely what the game provides. But there’s still one question left unanswered. Why is Cloud able to reject Sephiroth’s control at the end of the game, if it wasn’t simply psychological? Our answer lies in the northern crater. After Cloud collapses when he realized he cannot remember how he joined SOLDIER, Ultima Weapon wakes up and starts going berserk. This causes the crater to collapse, and the companions barely escape-Cloud does not. The party flees, and eventually makes its way to Mideel, where they find Cloud washed up on shore, babbling incoherently. (Hmm... does this seem familiar?) When Tifa takes him to the resident doctor, he’s diagnosed with Mako poisoning. In fact, it’s so severe that the doctor says Cloud should not have survived. Now, Cloud is one tough SOB, but that’s not why he pulls through. He already had Mako in his bloodstream from the earlier experiments. News flash, ladies and gents: Cloud just got his third injection."

[@IceTenjho11]

That’s the sad truth of Sephiroth’s character.To quote a certain CEO of a major company “You are not a god. You are simply bad product”

[@enzoarayamorales7220]

Holy shit I never realized how alike homelander and Sephiroth are until now

[@elizabethchint2391]

@IceTenjho11 You really know nothing about Sephiroth. A person who has demigod abilities and now confirmed to control and create timelines and you're trying to compare him to a flop character like homelander is fucking hilarious.

[@branastasia8013]

@@elizabethchint2391I mean yeah, Sephiroth is leagues more powerful than Homelander could ever be, but OP’s got a point. They were both treated as less “human” and more “product”

[@IceTenjho11]

I’m not saying he’s not powerful, I’m saying their situations are similar. They both were created by a company. They were both robbed a childhood. They both seeked a new identity, trying their best to feel superior to others, claiming to be gods. But in the end of the day, they were products. Just another victim of Vought and Shinra.

[@owenleal]

​​@@elizabethchint2391 lil buddy, Sephiroth aint gonna be your mate because you defended his honour. There are narrative parallels is what OP meant.

[@anthroposmetron4475]

This is a thoughtful video. An interesting watch. For the people saying 'But it was all Jenova!', well - I suppose it depends on how much store you set by the ultimanias, but Ultimania Omega states flat out that Sephiroth was in control of Jenova, not the other way round. Not that I think the source material of the original game suggests anything differently though. It's pretty clear in the OG that Jenova is his meat puppet, not the other way round. The 'cosmic horror' bit is spot on. In keeping with that, the evidence for Jenova even being sentient is pretty limited. I mean I think it's pretty obvious that Jenova is based on The Thing, and I don't think The Thing is sentient. It's cunning, but ultimately an organism of instinct. But really the reason I don't like 'Jenova did it' is because it reduces one of the best video game villains of all time to a cipher, supposedly on behalf of an actual cipher who, curiously after more than a quarter of a century, still has absolutely no characterisation. It reduces Sephiroth to Jenova's level - a nullity. He is so much more than that.

[@Yurikon3]

Or perhaps that is the greatest irony of Sephiroth. Revered badass who still in the end of it all is not really anything else than glorified parasite. Whether Jenova or Sephiroth is in control does not matter, they both ride for same function. Like Shinra was the leech sucking planet dry for greed, Jenova for instict , Sephiroth did the same for delusion.

[@viper-the-great]

if jenova was only a creature of instinct and not actual intelligence or sentience how could she have been so catastrophically damaging to the actual cetra or the planet for that matter?

[@anthroposmetron4475]

@@viper-the-great Not sure I understand the question. I mean... have you not heard of the black death? Or the Bronze age collapse? Of course it's possible to have massive civilisation-level devestation which doesn't have someone centrally directing it. You don't even need to step into fantasy hypotheticals on that one, you just need to look at actual human history. The Cetra were devestated twice over because Jenova came on the back of a meteor impact which left a crater literally the size of Midgar. That is a big impact, and it would have had global consequences.

[@anthroposmetron4475]

@@viper-the-greatI'm not sure I understand the question. I mean, you've heard of the black death and the bronze age collapse, right? Of course civilisation-level catastrophes don't need to be directed by someone. You don't even need to get into fantasy hypotheticals there, you just need to look at human history. Jenova was partly so devestating incidentally because it came on the back of a meteor impact which left a crater the size of Midgar. That impact would have been globally devestating in of itself, not just the immediate impact but also the impact it would have had on climate for years.

[@Aoki3997]

Sephiroth is him. Sephiroth is soooo badass, that he has a theme song that CHANTS HIS NAME

[@hartantoanggoro]

To be honest the true antagonist of FF7 is Hojo, Sephiroth falls because of him.

[@Cthululululu]

And exists because of him, at that. Hojo may not be the scientist who started Jenova research; but he's the man who was consumed by it, who couldn't stop. Gast, as we discover latter, had a crisis of morality- he wanted to stop, so on. Which is why he is killed. And Hojo, Hojo never hesitates to push even further than before...

[@guidofedeli851]

I've always seen Sephiroth as an extremely tragic villain, born of an equally tragic misunderstanding, who kills what in other circumstances would be a sister figure to him, the daughter of professor Gast, Aerith, just because they're on opposite sides. The true, revolting villain of FFVII will always be Hojo for me. So many of the other games misinterpret Sephiroth's character in a fundamental way by making him evil "just because", and because he's popular. I can't wait for you to cover the rest of my favourite game of all time. Edit: to answer your questions about JENOVA, the way I've always felt about the final battle (and most of Sephiroth's appearances ingame) is that it's the other way around. JENOVA is in control, and was always in control ever since the end of the events of NIbelheim. Sephiroth's real body never left the crater, all we've seen of him were bodies created out of JENOVA cells (which we can see everytime Sephiroth attacks us, like in the ship to Costa del Sol and after Aerith's death and we don't fight him, but JENOVA) and while he was partially in control of the objects (most likely JENOVA's tentacles) through which he summoned the aforementioned facsimiles of himself, at the end she simply didn't need him anymore. Sephiroth's mind was already damaged by the revelations he suffered in the library, and even further when he was thrown into the Lifestream directly when "killed" by Cloud. Sephiroth freed JENOVA from the Shinra building because his weak sense of self, his need to attach his identity to SOMETHING, anything, made him the perfect host for JENOVA's will. He did it because he was compelled to. All he ever said he wanted was what JENOVA wanted. When he summoned Meteor, he was equally silent and unresponsive. At the end he says nothing because JENOVA, having reached her SYNTHESIS status, is in full control. He lived and died serving and loving a "mother" who couldn't have possibly cared less about him. I would love to know your newer or revised interpretation if you come back to this topic, however.

[@Ashendrot]

How does your edit tie in with Advent Children, out of curiosity, when he comes back? /Genuine

[@guidofedeli851]

@@Ashendrot it doesn't. Anything Sqenix did after the Squaresoft days differs quite a bit from the source material. I said "other games" but what I meant is "other material", in general, after almost all the original team left.

[@albertnonymous9759]

Yeah, that's the double twist, the original sentiment, "Sephiroth died five years ago" is correct. He was genuinely a great guy, despite his horrific upbringing he's kindhearted, selfless, dedicated and modest, a true hero. He has every reason to be something like Homelander but he's not, him fighting for "the bad guys" is not a fault of his character, rather the propaganda he's been fed his whole life. That goes for a lot of Shinra, they really run the full breadth from complete monsters like Hojo and President Shinra, to great people like Sephiroth and Reeve (Cait Sith's pilot). Until JENOVA finally gets a hold of him and he dies soon after, that is. Remember that JENOVA is very openly inspired by The Thing, and is such a master of shapeshifting and mind control it killed almost all of the Cetra, and Sephiroth really is a perfect candidate on account of his JENOVA cells (Same as Cloud, as we see in e.g. That Aeris scene). It's never explicit but it's not too unreasonable to conclude that since Sephiroth fights for Shinra and was raised by Hojo, he is more susceptible than most to propaganda and mental influence, add mommy issues to that, another thing that's merely implied (raised by Hojo, not raised by Hojo and Lucrecia) and how JENOVA often misled the Cetra by appearing as loved ones, and it's no wonder he was controlled. After that it's all JENOVA, wearing the disguise of Sephiroth (or on one occasion, Tifa, when Cloud hands it the black materia), from the very first encounter in the Shinra HQ onwards. That's probably why Cloud is let out, too. Cloud has JENOVA cells and needs rescue just like the main body, if Hojo's Reunion Theory is correct which it appears to be. JENOVA has no reason to suspect Cloud will put up such a fight when Sephiroth was so easily controlled. The only possible exception is the very last battle/interactive cutscene in the Lifestream, that may actually be Sephiroth but it's hard to say. Is there even a separation between Sephiroth and Jenova at that point? Jenova is clearly rebuilding Sephiroth's body in the Northern Crater, but is anything of Sephiroth's mind even left at that point?

[@albertnonymous9759]

@@Ashendrot AC is a retcon, as it is a new team with different design priorities. Lots of lore changes, Sephiroth being one of them. But you can sort of square the circle at least if you squint, and keep it somewhat consistent with the original, if you say Sephiroth/JENOVA is Kadaj doing what Vincent does with his limit breaks, Galian Beast, Death Gigas, Chaos and so on. With this interpretation, its possible Sephiroth/JENOVA could crystallize into a Summon Materia down the line, like Ramuh, Ifrit, Bahamut and so on, but it is well and truly dead, just powerful enough to not get fully dispersed by the lifestream, thus able to crystallize into Materia.

[@guidofedeli851]

@@albertnonymous9759 RIGHT! Man, I can't believe I forgot the fake Tifa in the Northern Crater! That, too, is pretty much a smoking gun proving JENOVA pulls every string. Sephiroth's influence stays in name but even in the end, what Cloud defeats is the Sephiroth inside his mind, and it's a battle he can't lose since he has grown as a person and shed his false Zack persona. Man, I gotta replay FFVII.

[@Xehanort10]

49:47 Sephiroth's obsession with Jenova and belief that she's his mother reminds me of Silent Hill 4's Walter Sullivan who was convinced by the Order cult's Dahlia Gillespie that he could be reunited with his mother if he committed the 21 Sacrements ritual murders. She was actually just using him as a backup plan to bring back the Order's god.

[@richvestal767]

There's an almost throwaway line in Rebirth when you're in Cosmo Canyon where the group is discussing Sephiroth and Barret says something like "If Sephiroth is trying to save the planet then why are we fighting against him?" That's when Cloud quips back, "Its not that Sephiroth wants to save the planet that's the problem, its how he wants to do it." That's the essential ethic that makes every villain great. Its the ethic of that the ends always justify the means that makes a would be hero into the most horribly cruel, spiteful, vindictive, Faustian villain.

[@djx7134]

Sephiroth has never really cared about the planet, though. Only himself and his "mother". After the Nibelheim incident, that is. Before that, his brain functioned somewhat normally. He intended to sacrifice the entire planet in order to attain quasi-godhood, after all.

[@richvestal767]

@@djx7134 My comment wasn't so much about Sephiroth in particular as much as for what makes for a really compelling villain arc. Cheap villains have really weak and obvious moral problems, their ends are obviously evil as are their motivations. Compelling villains are compelling precisely because what they're doing comes from the desire to want some good end. They're trying to save something they love. They're trying to preserve some good nut in the most heinous and abhorrent ways. Or improve something that is good but they believe that they can make it "better." It's the difference between villains like Darth Vader, Emperor Palpatine, or Thanos vs whoever that weak idiot villain from Wonder Woman 2 that Pedro Pascal was supposed to be. Sephiroth is the epitome of the Luciferin archetype, like Morgoth in the Silmarillion. As shown before their arrival at Nibelheim, Sephiroth gave every indication of being an honest, forthright, honorable, well-balanced, and generally nice guy who had a deep sense of humor and right and wrong. Sephiroth still believes what he's doing is good and righteous. Where he falls is that he completely mistakenly believes that he's the heir of some sort of divinity when he's simply a human who's deluded himself into believing that he's something he's not, but because of the machinations of Hojo has been granted the ability to tap into powers that he doesn't have any business being allowed to tap into.

[@djx7134]

@@richvestal767 Is that really correct, though? Pre-lifestream, probably. After, he had direct access to all the information in the world, more or less. And he still chose the darkest, most evil and selfish possible route. I guess you could argue that Jenova had more influence upon him than it appears at first (he suddenly adopted her entire lifecycle out of nowhere, after all, despite this conflicting with all that he previously believed about himself and the world). But I don't think he was misguided or deluded at all by the bombing of reactor 1 and beyond. He 100% knew what he was doing. He knew everything except for small stuff like Hojo being his dad, possibly. At that point, I doubt he'd give a damn. Talking about Sephiroth is almost like trying to discuss three separate characters while referencing the same name. There's normal human Sephiroth (I don't agree that he was somehow not human just from the procedure he underwent in utero), who was actually well-adjusted considering the lifestyle he was forced into. Then he had the psychotic break and his personality underwent a dramatic transformation in like 1 week. This was when he was deluded and arguably insane. Then there's lifestream Sephiroth. The line between him and Jenova is a little difficult to discern.

[@Archon3960]

Oh wow. This was a treat. 😮 I did not expect duch a long video on such a famous character. Respect. B/

[@Damienx247]

1:05:07 That scene has made me wonder for years WTF is Cloud? A level 1 Shinra Guard tanks the Masamune stab and then Hulk tosses the highly trained eldritch horror that is Sephiroth. My head canon is Cloud has some degree of telekinetic power, displayed in his ability to use massive swords and from his limit breaks, such as Blade Beam, Climhazzard, Meteor Rain and of course Finishing Touch. These limit breaks display a force projection power far beyond the Ki abilities of Tifa and Yuffie. He doesn't even summon real meteors, it looks more like he gathers together debris in the area, compacts it and launches it at the enemy at high speeds.

[@Palemagpie]

I have a pretty good answer to the fantastic Jenova synthesis question poised at the end. Which i feel fits with the eatablished lore and the thematic points brought up in the video. Come with me here. This will take a minute to go through. Its pointed out when Aerith dies. That what makes a person isnt just their life energy, its who they were, their thoughts, feelings, motivations. What have you. The Jenova we see, shes been dead for millennia, biologically alive, sure. But her own life essence was long since exstinguished. But through Shinra tomfoolery. Nicking her cells, pumping her corpse full of Mako, what have you. You could stretch the definition of "alive" pretty far, especially in a setting like this. Her cells are certainly alive. And pumping through Sephiroth, Cloud, and half of SOLDIER among many many other places. Jenova also tricked the ancients initially by mimicing their loved ones, people they cared about, people they had a strong emotional connection to, but its stated it happened when they got close to her. So when the Jenova sample first wakes up in Shinra HQ, its not Sephiroth who woke it up. Its Cloud. By being close to it, Cloud who too, is chock-full of Jenova cells, living Jenova cells. If we make one wild assumption that i believe is kinda backed up in both ff7 and the exstended games and movie and stuff based on it. (Please feel free to fact check me on this if im wrong on this, im going from memory) Jenova cells, even when they enter the lifestream, share a connection. So Cloud, in Shinra HQ, being close to the...soul dead? For lack of a better term. Mindless husk of Jenova. It mimics his mind. And because Jenova has no conscious will left. It doesnt pick a calculated person to mimic. It just goes for the strongest emotional connection. And his mind has the strongest emotional tie to Sephiroth. He idealised the guy since he was a kid, and the dude slaughered everyone he knew, burned his village to the ground and slashed Tifa across the chest. Even with his memories all messed up. Id imagine Cloud would have a hell of an emotional response to Sephiroth. The same guy, lest we forget. Clouds last memory of, before beating him in the reactor was the guy screaming and blinding about getting even with Shinra. So the Jenova mimic, now acting and thinking from the logic of Clouds version of Sephiroth, does just that. Goes and gets even with Shinra. The whole way through the first half of the game. The Jenova Mimic isnt doing things because Jenova would want to, or even because Sephiroth would want to. It acts on the intention of what Cloud thinks the real Sephiroth would do. Once the real Sephiroth is revived. Its not Cloud, but he, who has the strongest collection of Jenova Cells. So the mimic latches onto his mind unconsciously. Aaand the person Sephiroth has the strongest emotional connection with....is Jenova, admittedly a fictionalised Idealised version of her. But still her, in a sense. So now, the Mimic is emulating a fake version of itself, while still technically being itself. The best example i can think to give, would be like an actor, with a very carefully crafted public persona, playing themselves in a movie. The Jenova we fight at the end of FF7. Is just as the name implies. Its a synthesis. Of both the remains of the real Jenova, and Sephiroth's mental version of what Jenova "the mother" should be, mapped onto it. Jenova Synthesis. To quote tropic thunder. "Im the dude, playing the dude, disguised as another dude"

[@TheNavyGonzo]

I still remember walking through K-Mart with my mom... I got $60 in birthday money and I saw this game for 49.99 on the shelf I picked it, and that was it... Still hooked to this day

[@kilimachevsk623]

"This is the first time we see Sephiroth outside of a flashback, the first time we see him in the present day." Looks like SOMEBODY forgot about the ship to Costa Del Sol... In all seriousness though, great video, great analysis!

[@jaywillis7940]

That's what I was thinking too! But then you open yourself up to the "well that's technically not him", but then again "well that's technically not him" either😂😂

[@SableWind]

That was Jenova, not Sephiroth. Sephiroth is only actually present in FF7 3 times in the whole game. You see him in the Nibelheim flashback, you see him when he is encased in mako/materia in the Northern Crater, when Cloud gives him the black materia, and you see him in the very end, deep in the Northern Crater for the final fight of the game. Every other time you see him in the game, you are just seeing a piece of Jenova taking on Sephiroth's appearance to fuck with Cloud and encourage Cloud to retrieve the black materia and bring it to Sephiroth's real body the Northern Crater.

[@kilimachevsk623]

@@SableWind The degree to which you have missed the point is immense. Yes, most times you meet Sephiroth, it's Jenova; but I gave a direct quote from the video which says that the encounter in Nibelheim is the first time you meet Sephiroth in the flesh; even if both I and the maker of the video know it's not the 'real' Sephiroth, that's not the point. Also, really, for all intents and purposes Jenova IS Sephiroth, since at this point its pretty much acting as an extension of his will. Jenova talking to you as Sephiroth is likely no different from what the real Sephiroth would say if he was there.

[@SableWind]

@@kilimachevsk623 I'm guilty of reading comments before I finish the video, didn't realize that's what you were referring to in your comment. Meant no disrespect.

[@troyrowlett5225]

I’m almost 34. Didn’t play ffvii til 2024. Everytime I hear a new perspective on the plot, the more fascinating it gets. Truly a classic with so much to examine and analyze!

[@LordMalice6d9]

I didn't play FFVII for the first time until 2008, about 11 years after it came out, so I already knew about some of its major plot twists, like Aerith's death. But hearing Fatbrett go into detail about why her death is so tragic still made me feel sad even though I already knew before playing FFVII that it was an infamous moment in video game history.

[@nerodevil.24]

YOUR DOING FINAL FANTASY VILLAINS 😱😱😱 An amazing day

[@peternguyen1911]

We need Kefka next

[@waywardwriterryu7185]

I think in general the most tragic part of Sephiroth's character is had he not found out about the jenova project and snapped he would have been a good guy

[@iantaakalla8180]

At least with the Compilation, Sephiroth was literally one mission off from putting off Shinra for good. That makes his villainy even more tragic; he literally was going to blow off Shinra and be a normal person because they saw what they did to Angeal and Genesis.

[@Cthululululu]

He was also shown to, prior to that, to be basically someone who was just following the path laid out for them, seeking a deeper sense of purpose. Someone who had just lost his two best friends, and Zack was basically the closest he had left- and their relationship was inherently strained. Because Zack was both his friends student- and the man who killed him. There's a contrasted duality in that. So of course. He's in a massive state of emotional vulnerability, a cross roads in life, when Jenova strikes.

[@iantaakalla8180]

I guess this then technically means god-complex Sephiroth is really just permanent psychotic-break Sephiroth, given he hastily constructs his god complex over six days, and then is forced by Lifestream mechanics to maintain his god complex and obsession over Cloud both in OG FF7 and Advent Children

[@imthatguy89]

Jenova’s influence over people really reminds me of hive mind entity where instead of being each person she can influence those with weak wills or jump into them and use them as an avatar for her monstrous forms.

[@fullb4nd761]

FatBrett Gang where u at

[@isakfolkhage]

We on the Fatbrett channel rn

[@reubencaldwell8494]

Here.

[@FrankMuniz]

We are FatBrett

[@doroginn]

Hell yeah brother

[@hexotshalatsi9007]

Boomshakslaq

[@tylerdurden7965]

This was one of the best most accurate analysis of Sephiroths character I've seen, very well made. Well done!

[@noahwysocki1233]

If I had to take a guess as to why Sephiroth doesn't speak in the final battle it would be because he has, on some level, either been succeeding or realized that it's not going to work and broken again. He's spent the last four years bathed in the collective unconscious of the planet, gathering more and more fragments of the World-Soul into himself to be both healed and empowered, add onto that his continued exposure to Jenova and his cultivation of her form of life within himself, and I'm not entirely certain he's still /in there./ His ambition and goals are still alive, but he has cast off his human form, and in doing so he may have also cast aside his personality and self, all the things he does not value in others, to become something like the will of his new World-Soul, stripped down to little more than a manifested spear of Intent. And it would be done to solve the continued pain he suffers at the repeated breaking of his Identity. Because there is no Identity to break, no capacity to question himself or his purpose in a form like that. He has everything he needs, he will become a God, and if shedding every part of himself that hurts is the price for that, he will pay it gladly. This would contrast and mirror directly with Cloud, who instead of pivoting to center his whole world around each new thing he learned about himself, has instead had to integrate these revelations with the rest of who he is. So Sephiroth is stripped down to a single thing each time he breaks, and Cloud instead grows into being more of himself. It would also make the way their swords are later depicted make some thematic sense, Cloud is many truths coalesced into a single whole, while Sephiroth is a single truth honed to its very edge, which, given their inspiration, would definitely track.

[@alexhastings1227]

I love the perspective but I always viewed sephiroth as a more tragic villain. I think that jenova did a mind break to sephiroth the same way sephiroth did to cloud. Sephiroth just wasn't as successful as jenova was. I think that at this point there isn't much of a difference between sephiroth and jenova, that jenova has completely subsumed sephiroth. Also, sephiroth/jenova absolutely won at the end of the game. They may have lost the battle, but it doesn't matter at that point because sephiroth has already poisoned the life stream and that's what geostigma is

[@SableWind]

Devs have also said that the original game's timeline ends with humanity being eradicated. Still not Jenova's full plan, since she wants the destruction of all life, but still not the "good ending" a lot of players assumed

[@Neo-Midgar]

I agree with this. People talk all the time about how Sephiroth dominated Jenova's will. But did he? My take ever since I played the game has been that Sephiroth at best was able to become a sort of equal parts gestalt consciousness of himself and his genetic mother, a human avatar. His personality, his body, his memories, but Jenova's will has clearly twisted his motives. After the Nibelheim Mansion, Sephiroth was never the same, and especially post timeskip he and his motives are completely different. He has changed from an internally tortured hero, to a madman, to a being seeking to end the planet, just as his 'mother' did. He begins using the same abilities as 'her' to control and warp minds, twist bodies, etc. His own plan even involves mutating himself beyond recognition just as Jenova does. I personally believe Sephiroth was the first, and greatest, casualty of the Reunion, and is driven by the same primal, mimetic instincts for control, destruction, Reunion and propagation. Hojo unwittingly created the perfect harbinger of the calamity; a human host. The single biggest example of why I believe this is in Advent Children. There, he specifically states that at this point he purely shares the same exact motive as Jenova.

[@Neo-Midgar]

This may be a crap analogy, but it's the best one I can think of at the moment for how I see the Sephiroth vs Jenova debate: Think of an addict, a drunk, or anyone else with a dependency. They'll tell you to the moon and back. "I'm in control, I'm doing this of my own volition." But by the contrary, everything they do, every decision they make, is driven by that need, that imperative. Not to say Sephiroth is addicted to Jenova. 😆 Jist the best example i could think of of someone who can't help but be driven by an need beyond their control.

[@EvelynL.1112]

@@Neo-Midgar I agree, I think JENOVA took advantage of his fractured mind and then established a mutual connection between them. Sephiroth controls JENOVA as a puppet, yes. But I'd like to think JENOVA is also keeping her claws in his brain as he happily commits atrocities for his "mother."

[@lp1spiritguidance577]

Honestly I hope it is revealed to be this and from my opinion it would fit well enough. But it turning out that it’s been jenova running the show this entire time would be just fine a reveal. She made her move at sephiroths most vulnerable. She’s manipulated him into seeing her as his mother. She took the earths greatest champion and made it her destroyer. I would like to see sephiroth come to his senses before he loses more than he already has.

[@JessieShadowhold]

Sepharoth making Cloud doubt his identity feels like the Clone Saga in Spider-Man comics.

[@wallacewisdom]

I've always loved the irony of Sephiroth believing he has no home town, and then proceeding to burn his home town to the ground.

[@elevate07]

I've played this game for decades and never caught that. Thank you for your wisdom Wallace

[@RavenDreadful]

This was literally everything I wanted! Sephiroth has been my favorite antagonist since I was 8 and a full on breakdown of his character from a narrative perspective FOR A FULL HOUR was everything I wanted and more. Literally when I go on dates with people, I talk about Sephiroth (bitches have autism). This was an incredible breakdown of his character. An additional reminder of why I fell in love with your content!

[@Cranzon-qw9od]

Talking about video game characters outside of hardcore writing/gaming circles is already kinda unusual right out of the gate, but out of all the possibles you could discuss, Sephiroth is probably one of the last on the list... He isn't that good lmao. I love Sephi, but his popularity is because he happens to align with a lot of peoples' personal tastes like his design, not cos there's anything objectively perfect about him that's worth exchanging notes on lol.

[@RavenDreadful]

@@Cranzon-qw9od oh yeah, Sephiroth in recent games has become somewhat of a characature of himself rather than embodying the actual aspects of himself that made him narratively compelling. Funny enough, I’d argue that Caius Ballad from FFXIII-2 is probably the best villain in the franchise but even if blinded by nostalgia in someways, I love this character ,and by extension, this video

[@Cranzon-qw9od]

@@RavenDreadful Sephi to me is most appealing when you were questioning what the hell was going on with Cloud in relation to him as I wasn't even sure if he was real at some points... He definitely has been overcommercialized recently to the point where his showing up is less sincere and enlightening and more like he's just fan service cameo eye candy... I can't really speak on other villains in the franchise since I've only recently got started on 8 thru to 10, but in terms of the general landscape, I don't want to think Sephiroth is the highnote. He's not Dr Eggman bad or anything, but he's still not exactly matching up to the best villains in film and such.

[@Zerorenren4761]

​@@Cranzon-qw9odI like Sephiroth because of his desing, song, his tragic backstory and he feels a lot like a horror villain, Sephiroth is like Darth Vader but for videogames imo. He definitively isn't the most well written character in the series or media, but he's so simple yet so interesting and appealing, his dynamics with Cloud also make him stand-out a lot from other villains.

[@Cranzon-qw9od]

@@Zerorenren4761 Yeah as said, my favourite part of Sephiroth as a character are his connections to Cloud. I really should appreciate his backstory, but ultimately I can't really say I remember much of it other than the vague outline of him being born in a lab, and don't remember it being particularly interesting, definitely not interesting enough to paint all his monstrous actions in any kind of tragic light. People say Hojo is the real monster, but that's the thing, while he probably is, I can't really say I'm aware of why he is as all I remember him from is his experimenting on Red XII... You'd have to be following atoms of in game canon to realize Hojo is the worst and that's the same with Sephiroths' backstory IMO. Of course it all adds texture, but since they're making it too highly tailored for that universe, it really restricts how easy it is to understand it, let alone remember.

[@lordtaeke2908]

An hour plus of a calm voice telling me Sephiroth's story is just a win.

[@ETHomerin]

What I thought was truly crazy is the first time Sephiroth's name comes up is when Cloud tells Tifa he wants to be a hero like Sephiroth on the water tower. Cloud idolized him.

[@d4rkz3r011]

Your video essays are so intriguing and you transition so smoothly between each topic! This gave me a lot to think about how the Remake series is writing Sephiroth. I'm hoping you'll do another one of these when the Remake series is over!

[@Vigilante1717]

I first subbed for the Last of Us essays. Now your covering my all time fav? Let's freaking go dude!

[@mikegordon9545]

Damn, I love your analysis videos. Can’t wait for the next one!

[@johnparx]

Fantastic video! Very much looking forward to the one covering Cloud!

[@marcoatef8669]

I think your great bret the way you offer content that is different and makes gamers appreciate their favourite protagonists and antagonists while expertly dissecting characters and plots by using literary principles as an english major i really enjoy your content and wait for every video keep it up and love from egypt❤

[@VaughnColeman]

Fantastic video. Despite spending a lot of time analyzing this video, this video provided some insights, perspectives, and theories I had never heard before. Looking forward to your video on Cloud!

[@rockkandyplay5692]

This was truly fascinating. Thank you for the upload

[@stephen8342]

Another point about the info sephiroth finds is that hojo seems to have very intentionally made sure sephiroth would find it. Not hard to believe hojo would also edit documents, remove certain texts, and leave extra red herrings to ensure there’s no way he won’t snap

[@TAM_Smithy]

Cloud and Sephiroth's relationship is probably my favourite Hero vs. Villain bond from all the games I've played. Cloud was essentially a nobody, Sephiroth didn't even know who he was until he confronted the party. This goes past the stereotype where the villain simply acts like the hero is not worth their time and feigns ignorance. Because Sephiroth simply doesn't know who Cloud is. Then by the time the game ends, Sephiroth now has a geunuine interest in Cloud, this supposed nobody who should be under his control has just defeated him in both body and mind. Then AC comes around, Sephiroth lives on inside Cloud's memories, and when they fight again there is a vendetta between the two, a true rivalry born. Now the Remake series depicts Sephiroth with knowledge of future events. Now he knows who Cloud is from the beginning, and his obsession with him has continued throughout this altered iteration of the timeline. Even stating that he will not allow himself nor Cloud to end.

[@reloadpsi]

What I like (or technically, love to hate) about Sephiroth is that his motives are based on inconclusive findings that might not even be based in fact in the first place, yet he's so up himself that he commits to the bit instantly. It takes an unbelievably awful person to think that highly of oneself that just a tiny bit of confirmation bias is enough to make them act on it to such an extreme extent. That's what makes him so frightening in concept. He is the personification of ignorant jingoism.

[@beezybaby1289]

He was raised in a lab. With powers. What else would you expect?!?!

[@fecal_position6412]

He's also had the cells of an alien lifeforms injected into him, an alien life form that has psychic powers. Psychic powers wich the game goes to great length to demonstrate can have profound impacts on the mental state and actions of the people who have been exposed to it.

[@Zerorenren4761]

Sephiroth was created in a lab and constantly told about how he was supposed to be a killing machine and the best SOLDIER of all, he was treated like Superman by Shinra and all he knew was pretty much killing and the fact that he was supposed to be above everyone else and with all that, an Evil Alien gene within himself, Sephiroth's insanity and arrogance was fueled by Hojo and Shinra from his creation.

[@reloadpsi]

​​@@Zerorenren4761Yeah, being half Hojo didn't help. Hojo was a callously hubristic tosspot in his own right _without_ the influence of Jenova, so now add the ambitions of a malevolent alien being and, well, you get a selfish A-hole with beautiful hair.

[@reloadpsi]

​​@@Zerorenren4761 I think Susan's bots instantly deleted my reply so I'll try again. Yeah, being half Hojo did not help. He was a very bad person without Jenova's influence, and while Jenova isn't so much Sephiroth's literal mother as much as he was genetically modified after it, that certainly wouldn't have been a good combination. It would be like if Myra Hindley had Charles Manson's baby, and then that baby was fasttracked up the ranks in the military, then one day read a bunch of forum posts that said "Charles Manson Jr. might be a god" and he instantly believed it.

[@dustin3933]

Great video! I really enjoyed your breakdown of Sephiroth. I am excited to see you analysis on other characters and your thoughts to how it pertains to each character in Rebirth.

[@RangerMcFriendly]

Absolutely fantastic job, dude!!

[@dudemcguy1227]

Fantastic Video! I'm really looking forward to your Cloud character analysis as well. The Identity crisis element is the real key to understanding what made the Cloud vs Sephiroth rivalry so compelling beyond just the classic Hero vs Villain tropes. It's what really makes Sephiroth the hero's shadow in this story. (Something that I think the Compilation and Remake titles have lost along the way.) You don't see this aspect of Sephiroth discussed as much, but I feel that it's absolutely CRITICAL to understanding him as a villain. Pre-Nibelheim he is led to believe that he's just "special". That he earned his status through his superior battle prowess. He was just so much better than the rest. He was practically untouchable, and he and everyone else knew it. But at this point, we can still see this as primarily Shinra's fault. That by treating him with such importance and high status that they massively inflated his ego. However... During the Nibelheim incident he's confronted with the possibility that he actually might just be an experiment. That he might not have earned his status as the greatest SOLDIER ever purely through superior talent and skill. That he may have been genetically engineered to be that way from birth. This moment shattered his identity, but lucky for him, he found professor Gast's (inaccurate) research that allowed him to believe that he and Jenova were Cetra. Something that would allow him to claim that he was not just superior to all of his peers, but to all of humanity. Basically, when confronted with the idea that he might not be "the best of the best" based on his own efforts, he latched on to the first piece of evidence he could find that would still allow him to believe he was superior to everyone else... and then he instantly made that his new identity. And then he does the exact same thing, AGAIN, when he drifts through the life stream and sides with Jenova. But this time it's a new justification that allows him to believe he's not just superior to all of humanity, but all living things in the world. As he decides to absorb the very essence of their being into himself. Like a Vampire sucking the life blood of an entire world. It's just very clear to me that even if you see certain aspects of Sephiroth's origin story as sympathetic/tragic, the real purpose of him as a Villain is to be a symbolic representation of completely unchecked ego/Narcissism. In contrast, when Cloud's identity is shattered by Sephiroth at the Northern Crater, the only way he can recover is when Tifa eventually helps him to pick up the pieces. With her encouragement he's able to remember and accept that he never made it into SOLDIER, that he wasn't special or superior compared to his peers. He had to check his ego and accept himself for who he truly was. The sad part is that Sephiroth didn't have someone like Tifa in his life at that critical moment who could relate to him and steer him back on the right path. So he ultimately chose the path of Ego/Selfishness, because that's how he was raised to be. I believe this is what actually gives the Cloud vs Sephiroth rivalry it's thematic depth. (Which imo has been lost in the Sequels/Remakes). When faced with the idea that their sense of superiority was built on lies, one of them kept clinging to the idea that he must still be superior to others somehow, and became the villain. But the other acknowledged that his feeling of superiority was just masking his insecurity, and he accepted his own weaknesses as a part of his identity and became the hero. And in the end, the weaker one who was actually able to check his ego surpassed the stronger one who couldn't accept anyone else as an equal. But I feel like this core thematic point has been lost on like 80% of the fanbase due to the characters' portrayals in the Compilation, Kingdom Hearts, and Remake media. So many fans getting into FF7 now just seem to think: "Sephiroth has always been obsessed with Cloud since he lost to him at Nibelheim 5 years ago. He wants his revenge. So that's why they have to fight all the time." The original story concepts and themes have become obfuscated and confused with all the Compilation/Kingdom Hearts/Remake stuff. Videos like yours are very important analysis of how the story was originally portrayed and intended. Thank you!

[@iamthehobo]

I forgot how absolutely fantastic your style of documentary psychological analysis what have you is. After this I'm going to go back and re-watch that Metroid Prime video

[@supremefankai5480]

Everyone always blames Nomura for the wackier final fantasy stories but that's not true, he gets his jollies off with Kingdom Hearts. No, it's Nojima who we need to look to for the real storyteller. I'm glad he is writing the remake trilogy so there is consistency with all the characterizations, when you include all the compilation you see Sephiroth constantly trying to reinvent himself, his ego never accepting being less than the best.

[@elizabethchint2391]

@supremefankai5480 You do understand that it's Nojima and Kitase doing coming up with the multiverse and whispers and the one who decided to show Sephiroth early? It was Hamaguchi himself who had to stop them from coming up with more terrible ideas like trying to change the design of the reactors. Nomura just green lit everything. Nomura himself even wanted to keep Sephiroth hidden. Please do some research before jumping on the blame Nomura bandwagon.

[@supremefankai5480]

@@elizabethchint2391 uh, I don't know what you read but I wasn't blaming Nomura for anything, I said that it was Nojima doing the writing.

[@tieuwest]

I was like 1 hour video, crazy. But hell I finished watching without skipping. Incredible detail and thoroughly explained. Thank you so much. I really like Sephiroth because I see him as a victim of Shinra. He was treated as an asset instead of human. He had no life outside Shinra, no family or so isolated. So eventually he would snap with enough pressure.

[@MochaZilla]

You've got a great storytelling voice. I enjoy the videos you make.

[@Umbrum_Silvermoon]

"I see now that the circumstances of one's birth are irrelevant. It is what you do with the gift of life that determines who you are." -Mewtwo Sephiroth has a choice after learning he was created and not born. He could have chosen to accept his creation and use the power he had to help rather then harm like he did in the beginning but he chose to do different.

[@flyaroundyourfire]

I have completed FF7 many times since 1997. And I still love to listen to these hour long synopsis videos 😍❤️ Thank you for your effort

[@jellykelli]

this is a very well made video dude! it's cohesive and from someone who has never gotten into this franchise, you managed to grab my attention and keep it for the entire hour lolol i can't wait to see your video on cloud, but for now i'll check out your stuff on the last of us :] 10/10 video and channel, can't wait to see you grow!

[@Ragnarok-ot2tq]

Still a big fan of you outro music, nothing better to end a deep analysis then twilight princess after boss music. Well done

[@Greysterization]

My Interpretation is always connected to what to me are the key messages on Shinra (Capitalist Critique/ Environmentalism) and Cloud (Identiy). Cloud, in pretending something he isn't represents a pretty common feeling that many feel (Especially men in regards to identity and what "men should be like") Having to pretend, fake it til you make it, feelings of inadequateness and being a failure. Sephiroth on the other hand, quite literally crafted by the status quo and the systemic oppressiion (Represented by Shinra) What I found really intriguing in Rebirth (Only tiny spoiler) is that little line Hojo gives about what a Hero should be and how he has to look, it really fits in amazingly with what Sephiroth is, a blank slate of a person, in fact, not even really human, but told, raised and bred to be what he turned into, a War hero, someone everyone looked up to, who was gorgeous and fit right into the narrative Shinra (The dominant power in that society) wanted. This obviously fostered the feelings of being Special into Sephiroth, but he wasn't really, everything that he was told is that he was special, a war hero, but he knew something was rotten and wrong about that, only to delude himself deeper into the false promise of actually being special, a cetra, and not the perverse creation of unfettered desire to control and expand by a totalitarian Company. This is really the counter opposite of Cloud believing he is not special at all, deluding himself into being someone he thought better,, while deep down his empathetic, caring, anxious and shy self was always present and in turn is why everyone grows to like Cloud, while Sephiroth entirely gave in this false narrative that was spun to him, and in this delusion of being special wanting more and more. I am ranting a bit, I never really ordered these thoughts and its more of my personal interpretation of this very interesting dynamic between Sephiroth and Cloud, that while always antagonistic, had this air aboout it that we should see these two characters as two sides of the same coin in terms of how they struggled with their very identity.

[@beastslayer8729]

It's interesting to see that in FF7 Remake and Rebirth, Sephiroth has actually succeeded in merging/overwriting the lifestream with his own soul. He takes over a faction of the whispers, which are a fundamental protector of the lifestream and it's course through time.

[@rinzi1123]

Very cool video! Looking forward to the cloud one

[@deanmckenna7641]

Talking online with so many recent fans who think they understand this story but have such a literal reading this is a breath of fresh air. So much of it is ambiguous, open to interpretation, operates on multiple layers, and yes is intentionally unknowable

[@stevenriddell595]

Thank you for making this video...epic

[@ZTLGsmashultimate436]

Your analysis videos are so educational

[@tsuritsa3105]

This is wonderful. It made my day

[@sparktenks]

My head canon on why Sephiroth also has his break is his sudden close proximity to Jenova

[@BronnyDinasty]

For me the silence in sepiroth final boss is the culmination of him becoming a eldritch being. Perhaps he is speaking but is so utterly alien that we cannot even perceive as a language..

[@rastaboy_gamesnstuff7778]

Can NOT wait for one of these videos, about KEFKA

[@rjdiii1224]

You earned a new sub...keep going!

[@doubtfulhenry]

Well constructed and insightful video, 👏 well done sir

[@anthonyfanchin1144]

I guess that’s what the Joker says. “All it takes is One Bad Day.”

[@UltraInfernoJ]

Love these videos

[@ChrisDeVarro]

Thanks for your video brother.... amd now I am a subscriber

[@jamesross8765]

Great video on one of the best villains to grace the genre and my favourite game ever. Just a couple of points though. - The first time you 'meet' Sephiroth face to face in OG is actually on the ship from Junon to Costa Del Sol. (Although technically this isn't Sephiroth...so you could actually say the first time is at the Northern crater when Cloud gives his physical body the black material). - Also, Sephiroth is definitely using the Jenova cells in Clouds body to control him, not just pure willpower. If he could do that he would just do it to everyone. Great video though. Really enjoyed it and the focus on the theme of identity and how Clouds identity crisis mirrors most people struggle with their ego. A lot of gamers and critics miss this and I think it's one of the key points that make this game amazing.

[@Schmurgan]

Brilliant analysis. Thanks!

[@tyrantravealpha]

I cannot remember where I first saw it, but I remebr seeing Cloud and Sephiroth's artwork for the game and I was immediately intrigued. Playing through the first time, seeing that flash back terrified me when I was younger. I can really appreciate the mystique and symbolism he carroes with him. A one-winged angel of death.

[@joaoluc]

Great video!

[@spiralgamer333]

I really like listening to your analyses and after covering Final Fantasy, I'm practically praying that you'll cover the Persona series someday as the characters and themes of those games would make for interesting videos.

[@steelcurtain187]

This was brilliant 👏

[@Indikissa]

How could you not bring up his theme song just to prove the point how powerful he is.

[@JohnBGang]

One very minor correction: A few times you refer to the planet as "Earth," when it's actually not called that in-game or out of game. In game, it's exclusively "the planet," but it has been referred to as "Gaia" in some outside material.

[@damiannova5207]

What an amazing video! I absolutely loved this. Your long-form analysis is always just *chef’s kiss* and I’ve been on such a Final Fantasy VII fix lately, so this perfectly hits the spot! Out of curiosity, what music plays about 29 min in when you’re describing Sephiroth building his new identity?

[@tokidensetsu]

Great video! Just one thing: @40:00 Nibelheim isn't the first time "Sephiroth" shows himself on the present day. Before that, he appears in the Ship from Junon to Costa Del Sol before taking off.

[@scionixx9568]

Feel like they made him a bit gay in the remake strictly for the shippers of him and cloud

[@lCebolitosl]

Great video on my main dps Calcharo. Keep it up.

[@sudolinuxfish]

Really great Video Essay