SHINee (샤이니) - Sherlock (Clue + Note) 셜록 LIVE and IU Cover REACTION

A lot of the Shawols out there recommended we check out the live version of this song, so we did! We had to watch the IU cover really quickly first, though... This performance was amazing. Seeing them live looks like an experience!! Let us know what SHINee songs to check out next.
Follow Nick and Joe on Instagram
Nick: / taetro
Joe: / josephmccaffrey
Follow Nick and Joe on Twitter
Nick: / nicktaetro
Joe: / jmccaffrey_

[@Saddlemomma]

Their concerts last for 3 to 3 1/2 hours and the energy is just about the same. For this concert, they did 4 or 5 high octane songs like this without a break. Even their ballads have so much emotion poured into them that the energy is present. They are the consummate performers. This is the reason why they are considered the gold standard in Kpop.

[@Lena-zn4re]

Honestly the opening section for this concert was absolutely ridiculous, there was so much energy that I was genuinely amazed that they kept it that consistent for the entire show.

[@nickjoe5151]

I can't imagine doing that... I feel like most people would be exhausted after just this one song!

[@sarjie5971]

Each SHINee concert lasts around 3-3.5 hours and their energy is on high all throughout. They give it all out in every performance. If you want to see more lives, some I recommend are: - Excuse Me Miss (SWC4) - Stranger (SWC4) - Everybody (Tokyo Dome) Ballads: - An Encore (SWC4) - Sleepless Night - Selene 6.23

[@savaspilletta]

Great recommendations

[@LunaAndreson]

Spoiler and Like a fire SW3 are also legendary

[@nancyl6754]

They perform in Japan with a live band. Just incredible

[@rique4964]

This opening is fire!! “Sherlock” it’s a hibrid song separate in two pieces “Clue” and “Note”, and they play the both versions on the concert. And yeah, all of them can sing very well, and in this show they were still five members as you can see. Jonghyun was the one who hit those high notes on the middle part. I can say that he was one of the best vocalist in the hole kpop industry. One of the members of SHINee, Key, recently said that the missing of one of the most important vocalists of the group leave a huge impact on them, but he hopes that SHINee keep working hard. He said that miss him and don’t want to people talk about it as a sad thing. The reason why i’m telling this it’s because Jonghyun has leave his legacy on k-pop industry for being such a genius man in life and career, and if you guys continue your journey to SHINee, you will see a lot of his work on it and I hope you all can enjoy it with honesty. Thanks for watching the performance :) For recommendation: Since Sherlock it’s a bop, you can watch another hit “Dream Girl” and “Everybody”. Or if you guys want see something more recent, pick up “I Want You” and “Good Evening”. I also recommend “Our page”, the song it’s a Tribute for Jonghyun and talk about how the members will not leave him and will continue writing the pages of that story that doesn’t have an end yet. All the three songs that I said it’s from the album “The story of Light” that was separate in three EP’s, and talks mostly about they history. also, my english is pretty bad so I’m sorry for any mistakes...

[@nickjoe5151]

Your English is great! Thanks for the suggestions! We definitely want to check up some more of the upbeat music, but I think we'll be watching Our Page soon. A lot of people are recommending it.

[@azpcshawol9615]

SHINee 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Five vocals Five dancer Five visual Five legends Thank you for this reaction! Love it Next please: Excuse me miss live Ring ding ding+Lucifer remix live Everybody live Tokyo Dome

[@eydeguy8861]

THAT WAS A PERFORMANCE BOYS!!!! SHINee is known for having a very very good stage presence and live performers. THEY ARE ONE OF THE TOP TEIR WHEN IT COMES TO CONCERTS AND LIVES. Their concert lasts for almost 4 hours since they have a large discography. And imagine singing live without backtrack is insaaane. 🔥🔥🔥💎💎💎💎💎

[@mvp8575]

when you said they have to be exhausted after that and sing ballads i remembered that they performed 3 more very powerful songs after this "stranger" , "shine (medusa 1)" and "picasso" please check them out

[@roxanadelcamencumpallontop4569]

This concert is epic from the beginning to end all the songs performed here are perfect. I suggest Excuse me miss, Dynamite, Evil, Stranger, Woof woof, Replay and Your Number from this 2015 SHINee World IV Concert 💎💎💎💎💎

[@nickjoe5151]

It looks so good. It would have been so fun to be there!

[@V4l3g0]

@@nickjoe5151 this concert is the best concert I’ve seen. I like it even more than Queen+Adam Lambert, I thought than nothing would be better than that :/

[@nazaninr3146]

if you liked this, you HAVE TO watch stranger live performance in the same concert : shinee stranger live in SWC4

[@milindawilson9175]

SHINee's live performance of "Sherlock" is from their SHINee World Concert IV in Seoul (South Korea) in 2015. Official concert DVDs, like the video this clip is from, are usually filmed at the beginning or end of a world tour, so they are almost always filmed in Seoul because they always open and close their tour at home. (That is, unless you are watching a Japanese concert tour, and then those official DVD videos will usually be filmed at the Tokyo Dome in Japan.) And if you think this performance was amazing, just wait until you see a full concert. SHINee concerts last 3+ hours and they are pretty much nonstop just like this. They will perform around 20-30 songs during this concert while singing live the whole time and never sound out of tune or out of breath. They are this powerful the entire time, regardless if it's the opening number or the last song after 3 hours. The outfits they are wearing are supposed to remind you of a stylized version of a soldier, it has to do with the fact that they also perform their song "Everybody" during this set and the concept for "Everybody" is that they are supposed to be toy soldiers. If you continue watching this concert you would also see them perform "Everybody" right after this. SHINee are known for their live performances and there is no one better when it comes to live, than them. It's actually referred to as the SHINee standard, and it's the standard all other groups strive to reach.

[@itsmyblahs]

There is a reason why SHINee is known as the KINGS of live performances. Their live vocals, dance, energy, artistry, performance, stage presence professionalism etc are really unmatched. Each of their concert is really an incredible experience!

[@novihartono9543]

SHINee live performances indeed amazing banger 🔥🔥

[@tian_rui]

All those unmatched stable vocals WHILE dancing like THAT ?? Yep thats SHINee for you 👑👑

[@isid977]

I would recommend Shinee" Married to the music"! The MV has a halloween vibe and it's very funny ❤️

[@MyCode61116]

This performance was part of their FIRST SECTION in the concert. They performed 5-6 choreo heavy songs in this section without break. SHINee concerts last for like 2.5 - 3.5 HRS. And it is a mix of hype songs, ballads, chill jams, choreo heavy, musical esque etc. You get everything!!

[@DisneyBar]

I was actually in the crowd of this SHINee concert in the dvd, their concert run between 3 to 4 hours (In japan it was definitely closer to 4 hours) and the only time we have to rest is during the videos they play between sections so they can change clothes. Even during the ballads you are all in. But you are so high on adrenaline you aren't tired only afterwards you crash hahah Jonghyun once said that after 3 days they do one concert each night they can lose 10 kilograms each in weight. That's crazy! Also this tour isn't even the biggest production of SHINee and definitely not of Kpop. But you are right the west could never! The all standard is completely different. But this is why it's so fun!

[@maje1ful]

Very true!!!!

[@AShawolKpoper]

I will just say "AS EXPECTED SHINee" if you see Korean people reacting to anything SHINee they just say this phrase 'YEOKSHI SHINee' means As expected SHINee,, They have their own standard in industry Juniors idolize them so much,industry loves them and they themselves Hold so much pride in SHINee and they are even more popular in Japan

[@nickjoe5151]

역시 샤이니

[@jennylam002]

It would be great if you could go through their title tracks chronologically to really see their development over the years. It is such a journey! Next song after replay would be Love Like Oxygen I believe.

[@nickjoe5151]

We were actually thinking about doing that! We might take a couple more popular requests and then start going through from the beginning.

[@yeosangi]

aw yay i’m so happy you guys watched this! looking forward to more reactions

[@nickjoe5151]

More SHINee stuff coming soon! We love what we've heard so far AND all the fans have been really nice, so I like interacting on these videos!

[@ideataemni3945]

I'm glad you have a good time while checking SHINee out. SHINee is that magic. You say they'll exhausted after performing like that in a concert. But the truth is they can do 3 or 4 songs with this type of tempo in a row. Even after doing the ballad, they'll perform another fast tempo songs too later and they're not showing any tiredness at all. You'll know if you watch their entire concert. They're really that bad ass for live performance. I suggest you to check out their "Everybody" in Tokyo Dome concert. You'll know i'm not being exaggerated in here.

[@giselacaceres7247]

Yessss ......... baby...SHINee KINGS OF PERFOMANCE AND KINGS VOCAL....!!!!

[@joaniemaloney]

wooow I can't believe you thought of putting the Sherlock cover from IU and SHINee's SWC IV live performance of Clue + Note (a different mix) together! suuuuch different vibes but soooo amazing in their own right! SHINee are live performance kings. ps: SHINee's back as a tagline actually pops up in a few other songs after Sherlock! & they try all different genres not just from album to album but within one album that to call them a boy band with the more narrow range of songs would do them a disservice.

[@nickjoe5151]

We are definitely going to be checking out a lot of their music, so I think we're in for a treat with the different styles!

[@MyCode61116]

This type of production is a normal thing for concerts, even for only fanmeet (more talk, games, some performances, shorter than concert). SHINee’s Japan concert series ( separate from the Korean concerts) is also a blast. The production is massive. Last time for SHINee’s fammeet, they went around the dome in hot air balloons. I was so fun. The dome is huge (55k people) so it was great they did that.

[@TaeminnieLee]

Ahhh yessss... You're gonna end up going down the SHINee rabbit hole 🕳🐇 Recommendations are sooo hard because there's so many good things. There's a lot of famous ones that I'm sure will get recommended by others, so I'll recommend one thing from this comeback, and two older stages that I personally enjoy instead - Code stage mix (it's a compilation of Code, a b-side track from the Don't Call Me album) - Password live from the Japan Arena tour 2013, a live of a b-side track from their Japanese discography. - Why so serious from SWC5 (shinee world concert V). This one has a video clip but I personally like this performance more if I had to choose.

[@nickjoe5151]

We are definitely going down the rabbit hole.. Thanks for the suggestions! We're going to check these out.

[@karbo2]

Love your reaction! Their concert performances are the BEST! Look forward to more SHINee reaction and perhaps Taemin’s solo career...

[@nickjoe5151]

Definitely more SHINee and we'll definitely do some Taemin songs in the future as well!

[@mangoo4749]

In one of their fanmeets with 55k people they performed 7 dance tracks back to back while singing live ☺️

[@lifeofsilvia3481]

They are spactacular regardless, but this concert is EPIC, full stop 🔥🔥 Love your reactions! 🙂

[@isavocadoafruit9750]

Wow you guys, thank you for reacting to their live performances. They're the best at it.

[@nickjoe5151]

More to come for sure!

[@Doyoungismyfave]

Can’t handle An hour of this 😆 there concert is actually about 3-4 hours 👀. Most kpop concerts are like 2-3 hours long 😂

[@santhysaroso6343]

No recomendation. Just watch everything SHINee does on stage.

[@onewgiri]

thanks for reacting to their live stuff - they've always been one of those groups that manage to sound even better live! I think it's partly due to having extremely talented vocalists but they have the breath control to be able to sing songs like Sherlock back to back without a break (they have several high energy songs like Sherlock in their discography). Like what another shawol said here, I'd recommend going through their other older title tracks/MVs chronologically so you can really see why SHINee is known to reinvent themselves every single comeback and the different genres they have experimented with over the years! Hope you guys enjoy your SHINee journey as much as we like watching it!

[@novihartono9543]

You should react to TAEMIN solo songs too.. He is the guy doing like MJ moves , one of SHINee member..

[@nickjoe5151]

We will definitely do that at some point! I get his songs in my recommended on KZbin a lot.

[@maferseguraarmas6056]

@@nickjoe5151 the choreographer of the song is the same one who did the choreographies of Michael Jackson and the outfits that they used were designed by one of the members

[@sirdromos2769]

Yeah shinee concerts are next level

[@peculiarrandom685]

IU & SHINee 🥰🥰🥰

[@nadifakumoratih7395]

Thank you for ur reaction! SHINee's vocal and energy is indeed no joke. If you wanna see another powerfull performance I suggest "Stranger", "Lucifer", "Everybody", or "Evil". But if you want to hear their ballad song I recommend "An Encore" , "Selene 6.23" and "Sleepless Night".

[@Rwin1993]

*SHINee IS GOLD*

[@IrmCik]

SHINee concerts are known to be legendary

[@STaeminie]

ICONIC

[@Dinadinashawol]

Five vocals Five dancer Five visual yes!! everybody and excuse me miss performance and ballad song Selene 62.3 and im with you i suggest to you!

[@abbymolina5143]

you guys need to watch more shinee concert performances!!!! like excuse me miss, symptoms and like a fire!

[@atikafitrirukmana3136]

Thank u so much for reacting to this... all of SHINee's concerts always feel like festival and so powerfull. From SHINee World Concert 1 until 5, then they have Japan Arena Tour, Tokyo Dome Concert and so on. And now i would like to recommend SHINee performing Spoiler and Hitchiking from SHINee World Concert III in Seoul. For ballad songs, Farewell My Love & Don't Let Me Go are great songs to listen.. 😊💎🌸

[@mariposasabia]

SHINee World Concert IV intro of their concert is epic.... SHINee boys in the house!

[@MAMI-nn1zu]

I enjoyed this live! Please react SHINee ‘ Your Number DANCE VERSION (black)’

[@windsl280]

Actually this whole concert was a lit

[@eyes0nyu]

An hour? Try 3. SHINee concerts usually last about 3 hrs long

[@Red-he4yk]

SHINee go hard EVERY SINGLE song 😆..that and always live vocals make them the Kings of Live. I Tokyo dome SHINee World lV tour, They went Straight from Everybody (The craziest high energy physical choreo) into Lucifer, Burning Up and then Sherlock...I was 😱😱....how can they even breathe let alone sing! You don't really know a SHINee song until you've seen the live performance. Five members, five stars.

[@AH-xq9gc]

Actually before they sing this song in this concert, there is an mega intro "shinee in the house". You can hear little bit of reply and jonghyun and onew sing incredibly after that. It is quite short so I recommend you should really check it out. Thank you for your reaction.

[@fabianr4761]

thank you so much for this reaction to SHINee💎 pls check out more SHINee's live stages, my requests are: Excuse Me Miss, Everybody, Stranger and Lucifer+RingDingDong they are amazing live performers! new sub💎

[@valen-flozsot355]

SHINee is SHINee😍💎💎💎💎

[@sayhaRosli]

Wait till you watch their concert. The energy 📈📈📈

[@OcazoDelSol]

Thank U for your reaction! 👏🏻 and taking all our suggestions 😊 A ballad after Sherlock performance? Not for SHINee 🤣 they keep that energy with hype songs 👍🏻 this was when I fell in their back hole 😅 I would love if you keep reacting to them in chronological order, you can see their grow in it 👌🏻😁 next are Love like oxygen and A.MI.GO

[@nickjoe5151]

We were thinking about going back and starting from the beginning. We might take a few more suggestions and then do that.

[@kginmyheart]

You should watch their "Everybody" performance! The opening to this concert. 🔥

[@MindBlinged]

The best thing about Sherlock(Clue+Note) is that it is a hybrid of two other songs in their album Clue and Note, so they have a different arrangement every time they perform it. It's always fun! You should watch some of their performances from Tokyo Dome or Japanese Arena tour, their stage production is INSANE. Also, they are known for their lives since their debut.

[@faniawina]

thank you so much for reacting to this! for more vocal performance you can check out SHINee - An Encore

[@viviennecostanza7093]

sm artists concerts are always so well produced especially EXO and SHINEE! they are the 2 groups that I admire the most too interms of vocals and stability since i watched them live so many times they don't disappoint me. Also the senior groups are already given they are legends too (snsd, suju, tvxq and boa).

[@vivinovika9464]

everyboday or view pleasee

[@nuenyu2844]

SHINee live really something, i become a Shawol (SHINee fan) because i amaze with their live performance. Trust me, try to watch their other live or MV and slowly you will be amaze by their tallent 😀

[@4Peace.]

SHINee is amazing and I'm looking forward to seeing them in concert. I hear the concerts are over 2 or 3 hours, and include ballads, banter, and fan interactions. Thank you for your reactions. My fellow Shawols have suggested some classics (Lucifer, View, Replay) and you can't miss SHINee World IV Excuse Me Miss, Odd Eye, and Evil. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSxoaN7eMSMgck and SHINee-Evil @SHINee WORLD III In Seoul" on KZbin kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4KTfWmijpeln68

[@shinettebombales6010]

Thank u very much😘😘

[@jannyjanecornejo6853]

Subscribed for more SHINee video reactions especially their amazing live performances

[@lndanguyn]

You should react to Shinee's song Everybody, especially their live at Tokyo Dome! best showcase of vocals and intense choreography.

[@ocenavictorialuisap.6272]

Would love for you guys to react to their solo songs! Thank you so much for your reaction!

[@gummytea.g]

Please do check out "Alive" and "Trigger" if you can, it has kinda the same vibe of don't call me song.

[@shatingshinee839]

Thank you for the reaction

[@mymemoorthi9726]

Checkout view and married to the music. View is a completely different song from watched till now.

[@thannystar7077]

Thank you very much for continuing to react to shinee, could you react to Excuse me miss-Shinee is a live performance of this same concert

[@cct3194]

I think that you are ready to watch 'Our Page' the lyrics are very powerful and maybe you should react to the lyrics and MV. Is about the boys and Jonghyun. SHINee - forever 5 💎💎💎💎💎

[@Noor-mx2pv]

Plz more SHINeeeeeee 💚

[@sania2421]

Please more reactions to SHINee !!!🙏🏻 I am waiting

[@oOPrettywinxOo]

Haha you should consider buying a ticket for their online concert that's next Sunday (April 4th). Not sure how an online concert is gonna work without an audience but you better believe they will be 200% it anyways.

[@maferseguraarmas6056]

the choreographer of the song is the same one who did the choreographies of Michael Jackson and the outfits that they used were designed by one of the members

[@jojo-yt8vm]

If your bias is onew, pls check out EVIL live performances from SWC 3 or tokyo dome

[@nickjoe5151]

I'll add it to the list!!

[@jojo-yt8vm]

@@nickjoe5151 thank u

[@jja565]

Shinee had to readjust their vocals since they lost Jonghyun in 2017 and Dont call me proved that the remaining 4 vocals are as powerful then as it is now.

[@sheenababy31]

Please react to more of their live performances. For me they are more amazing live.

[@yasminebecha1987]

React to shineee pleaseeee

[@sel8620]

Actually, along with Shinee, there are a LOT of male kpop groups with powerful vocals. And even more for solo artists. You guys mostly only reacted to the ones who focus on rapping or dancing. For example, BTOB is amazing, Seventeen is also quite good, TVXQ, SG Wannabe (although they're very old), and the list goes on.

[@mariposasabia]

I recommend you listen to SHINee World Concert V song "Romeo + Juliette"

[@mariposasabia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qqatpmCJiLGnmJI

[@jops1004]

i hope u guys can make a reaction to SHINee's Don't Call Me and Taemin's Criminal and IDEA

[@anyaal9248]

Do you have a SHINee reaction playlist?

[@eyes0nyu]

I highly recommend checking out their Dream Girl and Everybody Golden Disk Award performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2XNlXaborJnbJo. And their Seoul concert performance of Evil kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4KTfWmijpeln68

[@kwaveisreal4673]

Please react to Like a fire Live Concert + Girls,Girls,Girls Concert by SHINee HEHEHEHE

[@yusraahsan98]

Thank you for the reaction☺..but if I were to give you a feedback, I think you talk over the video which makes your voice and the video both unclear..so I wish you would pause the video and then talk.😅

[@anfalalhakme4172]

Please react to shinee kind on iu paletta

[@SandraFernandezMX]

THANKS FOR REACTING TO LIVE CONCERTS,NOTHING TO DO WITH MV'S THE VIBE IS DIFFERENT,I JUST HAVE A COMMENT ON YOUR REACTION,THE VOLUME OF THE VIDEO IS VERY LOW ,AND AS YOU BOTH ARE TALKING THROUGH THE SONG,YOUR VOICES ARE STRONGER THAN THE VIDEO,AND IS A LITTLE DIFFICULT TO HEAR THEM,COULD YOU TURN UP THE VIDS VOLUME PLEASE?????? THANK YOUUUUUUU♥

[@edithcaceres4251]

Please!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 subt en español !!!🙏🙏🙏

[@josephlim4233]

Please react to [MV] IU LILAC. It just release!

[@hetache07]

@Epoy Cruz can i request reaction video, IU songs Cover by Super Junior KYUHYUN (Through The Night) and Aespa Winter (Secret Garden) such a good version and highly recommended. SM artists loves IU

[@babywol_3782]

Plz react to EXCUSE ME MISS LIVE STRANGER LIVE EVIL LIVE LIKE A FIRE LIVE VIEW MV MARRIED TO THE MUSIC MV A VERY SHINEE GUIDE

[@winxyagmur]

Üf ne konuştunuz azıcık susun