Should you buy the Rolex Submariner? Or a Tudor Black Bay 58?

Rolex Submariner or... Tudor Black Bay 58? Tudor Pelagos? FXD? Pelagos 39? Omega Seamaster? Breitling Super Ocean? Should you buy the Rolex Submariner? Or one of the infinite other offerings?
So the Rolex Submariner is a watch I have nothing but respect, love and admiration for. I think it is an absolute icon and will forever have a prominent place in horology. The only problem is... I don't really like the way it looks on me. I want to like it so bad! I just.... Don't!
Should you buy the Rolex Submariner...? It depends! What do you want from a watch. I've chosen the Tudor Black Bay 58 because the size makes more sense for me and fits my lifestyle better! But hey, that's just me!
HOW TO GET IN TOUCH WITH ME:
email - [e-mail]
insta - watch.gringa
patreon - britt pearce
TIME STAMPS:
0:00-2:40 - Why I Chose the BB58
2:41-4:59 - Which is Better?
5:00-6:32 - Specifications
6:33-9:07 - Case & Design Language
9:08-11:00 - Is Tudor the Poor Man's Rolex?
11:01-11:54 - Outro & Thank You Patrons
11:55-13:16 - Marvel Secret Ending (Watchfinder)

[@trebm3]

The Submariner is what got me into watches when younger. Was able to afford the BB58 a few years ago and haven’t wanted a Submariner any longer. Love my BB

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ahhh excellent choice! Big congrats on owning the BB! 🎉

[@Kevinx3]

I chose the 58 over modern sub since I liked the size better and preferred an aluminum bezel. Look into a steel reef extension link. Made my 58 so much better. 👌

[@BrittPearceWatches]

I couldn’t agree more! 😍🎉

[@FlyWithMe_666]

Fun fact: Tudor Submariners were actually worn by Swiss Navy U-Boat crews in WW to time their torpedos.

[@jamesblonde2271]

🤣🤣🤣

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh. Nothing in this video is an accident. 😜

[@bcleerdin]

That can't be right. The Submariner came out 5 to 10 years after the end of WW2.

[@davidr2802]

@@bcleerdin Swiss Navy U-Boats wasn't a clue?

[@SB-Kiwi]

Pahahaha yeah right. Swiss U-boats?! In WW2?! Which ended in 45 ten years before the submariner was first created?! 😂 😂 😂 Man I hope you were joking.

[@sojirou]

Better yet get both. Sub for the weekends and BB58 with leather strap for the weekday.

[@alexgoya9245]

I have a BB58 blue, but it never filled the void of the Sub for me. 2 months ago, I picked up my black Sub at an AD! I’ve been wifed up since.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Man! You gotta get what you really love! James has a similar story with the GMT! Biggest CONGRATS EVER on owning a sub!!! What a watch!

[@authorjohnwquinn]

Let's not forget the difference in price between the Rolex and Tudor models. A big factor for so many people, including myself.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

You know, this is sooo true! And I know it's a factor for me too!

[@BobbyRagnar]

“Dressed like granola is my favorite food.” Awesome. Love the point that you wear the watch outdoors and active, which is what I believe they were meant for.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

I know there’s a few different schools of thoufht - but for me, what’s the point of getting sports watches if you don’t wear em rough! 🙈🙈✨

[@BobbyRagnar]

@Britt Pearce Absolutely. A watch is to be worn, not kept in a display. Mine have been skydiving and kayaking with orca and camping and polar bear swims......They are built to be worn in the outdoors. Otherwise, all that water resistance is just a bit silly?

[@explorerjlc1743]

The Pelagos T fit clasp is horrendous. It is way too long and the micro adjust feels a bit gritty. They need to make a smaller version.

[@cistm_un-do_]

Hey Britt. If you see this comment it might be worth you looking into buying a Ranger bracelet. it fits the 58 perfectly as they have the exact same case. No rivets. T-Fit! It is around £700 direct from Tudor, but when I added one to my BB58 it elevated it in both looks and comfort instantly 🥰

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuuu now THIS IS A VERY INTERESTING THOUGHT! 😱😱 I need to look into this! Thank you so much for this tip😊

[@cistm_un-do_]

@@BrittPearceWatches I posted it on my Instagram a while back, if you’re interested in seeing the combination ☺️

[@wisamal-hakim5531]

That’s cool!

[@bipennate]

Completely agree on all points. For me, the Seamaster 300 60th anniversary from the 2017 Trilogy Collection is absolutely sublime. I've had that one on my mind since its release, but never pulled the trigger

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Omg! Love the 60th anniversary SMP! But you know, I'm sooo about preceramic Omega!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Great show WG! To me the Tudor black bay is a 40 year old proud of there history and happy to talk to anyone who brings it up! The Sub!! Well that's someone that's had a past, only wants to look forward and doesn't want to talk about the past!!?? AM I RIGHT??? If the BB had the knurling of the sub on the bezel that would ooooffff I prefer the 60 click on a bb than a 120 sub! Bracelet, the Rolly is unbeatable! Have a lovely Sunday!!!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh now this is just poetic! You hit the nail on the head Russell!!! Hahaha. Man, I definitely prefer the sub 120 click. But I love the BB too!

[@michaelriera6277]

Well said!

[@marcustahoun]

I'd go with the Tudor. I am not that fussed with Rolex.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Right?! Well… I’m totally fussed with Rolex! 😜 but with divers - I love a Tudor!

[@adamkidson4444]

Totally agree, Tudor every day

[@mdlim24]

Submariner is just the most classic watch ever. I think it's the best everyday wear.

[@racebannon2332]

Had both the 41 Sub (no date) & Cermit and I preferred the Tudor Pelagos Blue or BB 58. I’m not a cyclops fan and the no date was meh. I have an explorer 39 full lume and SD’s 16600 & 116600…however my daily wear is the new Pelagos 39! It’s phenomenal. I also prefer my Omega 300 blue heritage over the submariner. The great thing about timepiece, it’s personal & there are so many magnificent choices

[@BrittPearceWatches]

It’s such a shame that the no date only comes in black. -.- I want a no date but something a bit funky!! You’re soooo lucky to have the P39 tho!!! Not an easy watch to get my friend. Absolutely love the titanium and the sunburst bezel!

[@daviddesrosiers1300]

I really like my Tudor heritage black bay steel on its bracelet…but I bought a crafter blue fitted end link rubber strap and I LOVE it.

[@EP-yi3gy]

The Patagonia reference nailed it. A bunch of finance geeks appropriated the Patagonia vest for office work. Only difference is Patagonia hates that bankers wear their vests.

[@stevedoyle74]

Tudor makes me sad and I agree that I think that it is a great watch for the money. Unfortunately, I can't stand the snowflake hands nor the slab sides. I also don't think that Tudor would be half as popular if it wasn't tied to Rolex. Still a great watch.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Gaaaah I know so many people agree!! Snowflake hands snd the side slab definitely arent for everyone! 🙈✨

[@mikecosslett1421]

Walking and hiking in the UK in February 🥶fingers crossed you get more watches in for review maybe Adrian can hook you up and we will see you in Switzerland 🇨🇭 🙂keep up the good work and doing what your doing 😎

[@RichardKoppinger]

I like the look of the Tudor better than the Rolex. The Submariner case looks very blocky compared to the more refined look of the Black Bay. Have a great camping trip, and a big thanks to WatchFinder for loaning out that beautiful Submariner to Britt for this video. Two of my favorite watch channels coming together to make an awesome video.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

I couldn’t agree more woth the sub looking blocky! I think the new 2020 versions kinda got less blocky. But still! A bit chunky. ^_^ As for my channel to be mentioned alongside Watchfinder. 💀💀💕💕💕 I am still fan girling!

[@travr6]

Please do a color series. Best red watches in different budgets/ watch types. Best blue watches... Best green watches... Best gray... Etc... You could make a bunch of content or if that one series. You can even

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh I love this!!! I have taken a screenshot and added this to the gringa idea log!

[@travr6]

@@BrittPearceWatches Would be cool to see.

[@travr6]

That's a cool model. Check out the Titanic lego set. You could do a review of the UBoat watch to go with the model after the build.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

BAHAHA ooooomg! I need to check out the titanic Lego set now!

[@amcluesent]

The Black Bay Bronze Bucherer has been on my (large) wrist for the last few weeks.

[@kiljaeden7663]

Britt: "I'm building this submarine!" Me: "I love you!" Britt: "I'm going camping!" Me: "Oh well - it was good while it lasted."

[@BrittPearceWatches]

LOL! Our whole 10 seconds of being kindred spirits!

[@bernardhossmoto]

The blue on the Tudor is beautiful.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Right?! I always descirbe it as a handsome, subdued blue. But I don't even know how to describe its loveliness!

[@christopheredwards6727]

I think the Tudor wears better on smaller wrists.. smaller case size and slimmer lugs. Plus it a little less blingy… I say for you stick with the Tudor..

[@BrittPearceWatches]

I couldn’t agree more! This is basically this entire video summed up in 4 sentences. 😂💕

[@bm5192]

With sub prices coming back down, I’d say keep saving towards a sub if that’s what you really want and don’t settle for a BB. Both great watches but no comparison IMO.

[@explorerjlc1743]

Just goes to show how the lug to lug measurements and dial size matters more. The Tudor looks almost the same size as the sub.

[@reconjaguar]

Hi Britt, you know my thoughts on dive watches. We need to discuss in person with you and Papi next time I see you both.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ahhh and hopefully that is SOON!! 💕💕💕 beauty of a day! Perfect day for a Caterham ride!

[@reconjaguar]

@@BrittPearceWatches Thought you were off grid??? Give me a shout if you're in my neck of the woods

[@typebflieger]

This is a great comparison, and it only reinforces my feeling that I massively prefer the BB58 on every level: price/value, aesthetics, materials (can’t stand ceramic), dimensions, wearing experience, and brand (I don’t love the unwanted attention Rolex brings). The only areas the Sub wins for me are movement, water resistance, and bracelet (which i never wear) but those margins are so fine they simply don’t matter to me at all. For the price, the BB58 is as close as I could image a watch getting to perfect.

[@Timjacks01]

Britt, why do you do this to me!!!! I was all set to sell all my Tudors, now you have me questioning my decision 😬 Great video as always!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

LOLLL OOOOOMG!!!! Tell me MORE! Why do you want to sell your tudors?!??

[@Timjacks01]

@@BrittPearceWatches Trying to slim down my collection and want a dress watch. Thought get rid of 4 Tudors to buy an entry level Patek. Good idea?

[@wristroll_vlad]

Always thought I liked the BB58 better… until I got the magic call for my Submariner. I sold my BB58 shortly after.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

OUUU HOOOO! what sub did you get?!

[@wristroll_vlad]

@@BrittPearceWatches it’s the 124060… the no date. Thanks for replying!

[@mpikers]

I have a bb58 and 114060 Sub. While I love both, the bb58 gets way more wrist time simply because it’s more comfortable. The smaller size, lighter weight and slimmer case back fits my wrist perfectly.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

You know, this is a really good point too!

[@mpikers]

@@willharris8441 I think you'll really like the Pelagos 39 if you find the BB58 too small. I tried the Pelagos 39 on at my AD and it feels like it falls in between the BB58 and Sub on my wrist.

[@nkass8593]

@@BrittPearceWatches what size wrists do you have?

[@johnacteson5503]

There is so much negativity around rolex that it has spoiled my experience of putting my name down for even the basic oyster perpetual.

[@matthewhuh9004]

I swore off rolex submariners and moved on long ago..just got the call from AD to come in to pick it up. In love again. I am a clown.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

LOL! Ooooh it’s all apart of the watch geek life! This was me and the Daytona! 😂🙈

[@jasonchaney5382]

You should try to get your hands on an old 40mm Sub. It might make you change your mind.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ahhhh! Love an older sub!

[@alpinistbear]

Great review Britt. Since you are going camping, best watch for camping and outrunning natural predators? Tudor Ranger or Rolex Explorer II? Please tell us before your go. Just in case.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Bahahah! I’ve been an now I am back again! ✨✨ does the Speedmaster make you any faster?! Speedy for outrunning predators?! 😜😂

[@alpinistbear]

@@BrittPearceWatches I am not sure that the timepiece that aided the crew of Apollo 13 would be of much help at Camp Crystal Lake, but if it’s an Ed White, at least we go out in style! Love your reviews! Best of luck on the submarine assembly!

[@camarocarl7130]

The XXI Boat was a technological marvel that was years ahead of anything else at the time. Great choice, you know your U-Boats and your watches.

[@joegarcia3656]

the clasp was out of focus but the black marker was clear as day!

[@DecemberNames]

I enjoyed every second. Please keep it coming.Thank you for another great video

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Whaaaat! This has made my day! Thank you so much. 💕💕💕

[@stewartlogan9894]

Britt, would love to see you compare the Omega Seamaster 300 Heritage vs your Tudor and get your opinion.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu now THIS is a video I would love to make! Let’s see if I can get one in from watchfinder)

[@rangersmith4652]

Britt, nice Orro! One of the really good things about sticking to watches in the

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuuu nothing is more satisfying than a good bezel sound! 🙈🙈🙈I’ve actually never seen an orient in person! I need to change that.

[@carllange3950]

@@BrittPearceWatches My first diver is my Orient Ray II and now I have 6 Orient/Orient Star divers (Ray II, Kamasu, “Baby Triton”, Triton/Neptune-black, Triton/Neptune-blue, Orient Star Diver). My favorite diver is my black Triton/Neptune. I also have divers from Bulova, Citizen, Glycine and Island Watch. The Rolex/Tudor watches don’t really interest me. I recently purchased a Zelos Spearfish GMT and am very impressed by the quality. I am patiently waiting for a future Spearfish diver with an Aventurine dial.

[@barrylattuca5352]

I know I am in the minority. I chose a Tudor 41 with the blue bezel because I prefer it over the sub. The sub is a little to small for my taste and like the look of the Tudor better. I agree the Tudor is more of a legitimate tool watch, as well.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu la la!!! The Tudor 41 is great!!

[@-Medici]

That's a pretty large Sub. The Cermit looks hot, tho. 🔥

[@BrittPearceWatches]

It is!

[@thegorn]

Black Bay 58 every time, and spare the excess cash to help you through the oncoming global recession + world wars

[@SB-Kiwi]

Wise Adamascus. I'd like to see your take on one of those things. 904l steel diver out of Thailand. Cheers

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu I will look into it! ^_^

[@SB-Kiwi]

@@BrittPearceWatches great! 😁

[@barrettgarese2267]

I want to like the Submariner, but I do love my Aquis. I don’t know that they directly compete in any other way than I was personally cross shopping them, but Oris came out on top, weirdly. And I think I feel more comfortable taking my Oris places and using it like the tool watch it was engineered to be. When I want to flex, there’s always Cartier, and the other 90% of the time, it’s Oris.

[@dannysimenauer5745]

Fully agree with you! The fumé dial, 72 hour power reserve are outsanding. Oris is also priced less then Tudor at $3,500!

[@Arturr0]

Best daily ? Pelagos 38 ! Best dressy sportswatch ? GMT Batman ! Best “one watch collection” watch you never heard of ? Horage Supersede ! 😊

[@DultaMooxe]

You should get an aftermarket bracelet (with custom fitted end-links) for your Black Bay.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuuu I should look into it. ^_^

[@notenoughtime7274]

Great video and quality production. I agree, I love Rolex but the Submariner has never really resonated with me personally However, I’m an outlier I think Tudor BB is now also becoming too over hyped and ubiquitous. Yes it’s great value at the price but there are other interesting choices If you really want a diver with vintage vibe I personally prefer the Longines Heritage Legend Diver (bronze and green) or Breitling Heritage Superocean. Both have more interesting dials and are less obvious choices.

[@robinbanderman4151]

Agree with you - Longines and Breitling Heritage are great overlooked alternatives.

[@notenoughtime7274]

@@robinbanderman4151 thank you. I’m not a complete outlier then! However, I didn’t want my comment above to distract from what is another great expertly produced video comparing two great watches, on this, an excellent channel which I enjoy.

[@ZeroSOFInfinity]

Rolex screams "boring". The BB58 gives the "you are the one" feeling.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

You know, I always say Rolex is a good choice. Tudor is a COOL choice!

[@Bemjji]

Where I live, anyone who has a Swiss watch either has a submariner or 36mm two tone datejust. That’s all you see….ever. So no to the sub for me.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh man! It’s similar here. But it’s hard to spot a Rolex in general in Bristol 🙈

[@paddys4236]

I oftentimes prefer to wear the Tudor on some occasions because it doesn’t get that much attention. ;)

[@valisposo4290]

Entrambi belli e particolari , il suono della lunetta del Sub è stupendo.

[@christopherwestpresents]

I think you’d enjoy a vintage Sub - like a 5512 or 5513.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Love a vintage sub!!!

[@m.e.p.r]

The BB58 is basically a neo-vinatage submariner isn't it really? I'm waiting for a BB58 to be released on a bracelet without the fake rivets and then I'll probably buy one. I've owned a sub (black, no date, modern ref) and sold it. I had the same experience as Britt, in that it looked fantastic on my night stand, but on the wrist it just felt a bit meh.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuuu let’s hope this watches and wonders your dream comes true! No faux river BB58. The people would gooo wild!

[@thesouthernwatchcollector8948]

You my want to look at a Rolex Submariner 16610 the fit is almost identical to the Black bay 58 and no fake rivets.

[@m.e.p.r]

@@BrittPearceWatches Haha, the Watch community is so fickle, but I love it. Love your channel Britt, it's the good vibes channel of the watch KZbin world!

[@m.e.p.r]

@@thesouthernwatchcollector8948 that's a beautiful watch I agree. I'd love a no date vintage sub without any crown guards. But I'd need to remortgage to get it these days 😂

[@RATBONES8]

Perhaps the Pelagos 39, although titanium is not for everyone? Greetings from Edmonton Canada! Love your channel and perspective!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh it definitely isn't for everyone!

[@martinkaplan1805]

Britt, I totally get what you’re saying. You’ve captured the nuance of personal preferences, the way the mind and heart don’t always align, with the heart taking preference. Yup, it’s all about how the watch “feels” on our wrist, and there’s an indescribable quality about what feels “right.” Thanks for thinking out loud with us!

[@MADLITS1K]

no way you make a video on this topic as I’m debating this myself lol I’m planning to pick up a bb58 by the end of this year 🤝

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ahhh noooo way!!! Well! When it comes to these two watches - there really is no bad choice. I will always pick the BB58 tho personally. 💕💕 Also! You never know! There might be something at Watches & Wonders this year that really tickles your fancy!

[@TheBigWrist]

I own the (2) Tudor BB41's and a Rolex OP39. Very similar watches, you can see the DNA in the dials. The Tudors are a better value and fit me better, but the OP39 is a more refined watch, thinner, better finishing and just a step above. All three are +2 seconds or better and all have a place in my collection. (I don't own a sub because I HATE Mercedes hands!)

[@BrittPearceWatches]

You know! There's been quite a few people who hate the Mercedes hands in the comments! :O

[@fistymcbum]

I appreciate the time you spent aligning both watches to the same seconds.. like most nerds here, I have an eye for detail.

[@WH-hi5ew]

BB58 looks better on your wrist no mistaking that... colour and size both better suited. Perhaps a pre-ceramic Kermit? My issue with the BB58 blue that I sold is never got used to going without a date function.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh pre ceramic Rolex and omega is my love language!

[@idontgrillonwed]

Now that I have a kid, the prices on both of these are now well beyond what I’m comfortable with, but I’m still in love with the 5 digit subs.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Gah! I can’t relate on the kid front! 🙈 but 5 digit subs… well… 5 digit Rolex in general are just divine!!

[@stephengarratt8027]

Your right it really is " horses for courses" and your own personal preference. My choice is made for me by the price point , but , I'm very happy with my bb58. Like you the Pelagos is driving me " nuts"! Enjoy the camping folks

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Man! I can’t stop thinking of the Pelagos!!!! 🙈🙈🙈 we need to get matching Pelagos’!!!

[@Rhal63]

Great video. I have the JC Rolex dive and the 4000 red. For every day wear I seem to reach for the Tudor. Just saying. Thanks

[@seattlegrrlie]

I am going to give my opinion before I watch the video. I have Submariner money, I could have gotten the Rolex over the Tudor. I bought the BB58 Blue because I think it's a better watch. It's 39mm, it's a dark navy, it is not the supercase, it's not in precious metals. I think the blue sub is too big, too gaudy, too blue, and too expensive for my intended purpose. Also, people who aren't watch nerds think it's a Rolex and people who are watch nerds know what it is. Win, win,win

[@canadianwatchmonkey3992]

Oh a couple great dive watch for you would be the Yema Superman Heritage in 39mm or the NavyGraf Heritage I think you will really like them, I love mine

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu la la! I need to look more into Yema!

[@forestapparel1060]

I love both I have a few tudors just lost interest in rolex now tbh I would put a grand seiko shun-bun and an omega 60th before a sub, And I'm a bit of a scruff and no point owning a rolex no one would believe it was real and I would hate for people to think I was wearing a fake😂😂

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Gah! I sooo relate to this!

[@jasons46]

How about a neo-vintage sub like a 14060M? Slimmer case, aluminium bezel, decent movement and it has charm. Maybe not the bracelet though.. I did this with the explorer 2 and went for the 16570 polar rather than the latest offering that is just too big for me.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Love love love! This is my favourite era of sports watches!

[@pascalp.]

I still love my BB58 Navy Blue. Got it for 2 years. But I would be very glad with a vintage Submariner. 16610LV = Cermit 126210LV = Starbucks

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh man! I love a vintage Sub!

[@h111551]

I have had two Rolexes, an OP two-tone (still owned)!and a Yacht-Master I. Insofar as dive watches are concerned, my choice is the Grand Seiko SBGA229 spring drive. Sophisticated but indestructible horology with fine finishing. I get that Rolex makes better clasps, etc., but Grand Seiko’s finishing and detail trumps Rolex IMHO. It is ironic that Seiko, the king pin of dive watches, has not been more successful with GS dive references but one day that will change. As between a Tudor BB 58 and a Rolex Submariner, I would pick the Tudor as it is more in keeping with what a tool watch should be in terms of the historic values of Hans Wilsdorf.

[@MistaLanky]

Totally did a spit take on the “Patagonia vest type” perfect description!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

LOLLLL! Man. I loathe the Patagonia best banker types!

[@btmontres1423]

Made those models as a kid. But you do need a Sub just because you'll never get it out of your system until you do. BTW, that green sub looks pretty good as a companion piece next to that blue 58. Just saying.

[@Haru-O]

Hi Britt, Many of the points you brought up are the same reasons I think the Pelagos 39 is an ideal watch for me. Just wish P39 wasn’t so hard to get…

[@rolexdatejust2015]

Easy Go for the Omega Seamaster!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu pre-ceramic Seamaster for me ^_^

[@rolexdatejust2015]

@@BrittPearceWatches you Need one!

[@majedalessa8376]

Sub is the better watch with its iconic looks, rich history, and top build quality (ceramic bezel, glidelock, materials used and finishing ). However, the sub wears large on a lady's hand so the Tudor might look better on some smaller wrists !

[@emiliogarromena9563]

The real sentence… you can add a BB58 to your collection and you can waaait lone time for your Rolexsub

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Hahaha amen!

[@Paul.M67]

same opinon …try it several times…not my watch …my BB58 Blue is perfect 😍

[@BrittPearceWatches]

We are two peas in a pod!

[@y3n0]

Love my Pelagos 2-liner. But can't stop looking at the BB58 925! But i'd also settle for a no-date sub. Umm, I need more wrists.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Omg I love the 925!! The silver is sooo magical!

[@dannyg6592]

I own both a 126610LV and a Tudor BB58 black/gilt dial. The Rolex is a stunning watch, it receives a lot of attention every time I wear it (which can be good or bad) and is objectively the far better watch. However, I have bonded more with my Tudor, as it has a certain vintage charm that the Rolex lacks (and it is lighter, especially on its Forstner jubilee bracelet, which adds to its comfort on wrist and its vintage charm).

[@gordonmclees95]

Has you rolex ever attracted the attention of the criminal fraternity ! Is this something i should consider when buying a rolex ???

[@dannyg6592]

@@gordonmclees95I've never had a problem wearing the Sub, but I'm smart about when to wear it and when not to. The green bezel is an attention getter. One needs to have situational awareness when wearing a Rolex in public. Cheers!

[@gordonmclees95]

@dannyg6592 thankyou for your response ! I too will be careful if i manage to get one !

[@pauldevey8628]

No matter how sophisticated you become, you are still our Timmies Girl! I probably wont buy a Tudor but if I was going to, they are so nice. Rolex, no I am hardwired to be an Omega boy.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

TIMMMMMIES!!!!

[@timyoungnc]

Wish the blue Tudor had the T on the fly adjustment clasp.

[@pustap]

I’ve got the blue bb58 like yours. The ranger bracelet is a great upgrade if you can get one! Separate note - do you mind sharing details on that lamp in the background? Been looking for one that points upwards like that!

[@key4duty]

Black Bay is more versatile, looks a bit more dressy and less like a toolwatch. It's a nice watch and does not attract unwanted attention in cities. However sub is iconic and a must have in the collection.

[@canadianwatchmonkey3992]

The black bay 58 is the better looking watch because of the narrower lugs, the Rolex looks to blocky in my opinion.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu now this is really well said and well spotted! I sooo agree!

[@MlkXiu]

Been considering btwn the BB58/ BB36, P39 vintage style, vs the Super Seawolf fresh colorways. Maybe do a vid for the super seawolf and your thoughts on it, would help, thanks.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu I could definitely look into it. :)

[@MJHiteshew]

That submarine is soooooo cool! When I was a kid, I built a Trident nuclear submarine model and it was baaaaad!!

[@lukeos4810]

For me personally the Grand Seiko SLGA015 is a prettier Submariner in Titanium. But 12k is a lot of money. A comparison to a Black Submariner or Black Bay would be really cool.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu now THIS is a fun watch to throw into the mix! But I am sadly still sized out of the GS! ;'(

[@mikaxms]

Given the choice between a Rolex Submariner and Tudor Black Bay 58, I'd go with the Tudor Pelagos 39. ;-)

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Hahaha! Very well said! 😂

[@chrishennemeyer7276]

Isn't the real question for us proletarians: "Should I spend $3,000 or $15,000?"

[@ComicBookVeteran]

Picked up a 16610 about two years ago and it has been absolutely perfect. It was available, has characteristics of vintage and modern pieces, and it has been all I thought it could be. Love it! Unfortunately, I don’t have a Tudor to compare.

[@ComicBookVeteran]

@SaintWill It's an absolutely rock-solid piece of brilliant engineering. The beautiful thing is that it can take abuse - online and in person and still come out unscathed and untarnished on the other side.

[@ComicBookVeteran]

@SaintWill Agreed - I have a few obscure ones as well. Love the oddball watch from time to time.

[@RussianSkiAmateurs]

Tried both. Both are wonderful. Kept the Sub because of 7,5” wrist and overall body frame.

[@jarrodlee1506]

My preceramic black seamaster from 2010 is great value.full set great condition on my omega nato due to the bracelet issue you described with your tudor.wasnt cheap but love it

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Oh BABEH, preceramic Omega is my love language.

[@cosmodoc]

As far as I’m aware, the Zodiac Sea Wolf was released earlier and with a greater depth-rating than both the Submariner and the Fifty fathoms!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu la la!

[@JosephsCoat]

My blue BB58 was a stretch for me and it’s the only luxury watch in my collection, but it’s absolutely perfect. I think I’ll add a Rolex someday, but the Tudor has my heart.

[@ektrolleyboy]

I’ve owned both. A Cermit and a no-date 41mm. And two BB58 blue. Prefer the BB58… So much so that I sold it (Still don’t know why). Then bought another one. Never regretted selling either Sub’.

[@BrittPearceWatches]

😂👏🏻 this sounds like you’ve been on a bit of a journey with your dive watches!

[@dannysimenauer5745]

Britt, enjoy your camping trip. Remember the old adage that if you see a bear, you don't have to out run out. You just have to keep ahead of the person between you and the bear! 😇

[@michellep2682]

I had the new Sub for a bit. My issue was the clasp. I have the Hulk and the clasp is long but doable. The new iteration clasp is too wide. I recently picked up the Tudor Pelagos 39. Love it

[@BrittPearceWatches]

Ouuu Michelle these are some good thoughts! Big big congrats for getting the P39!!! What a watch!

[@daviddicicco195]

I have both and love both. I actually find they are not redundant in the collection which was a concern for me initially. There are a lot of situations where I don’t want the flash of the sub, and the the bb58 slides right in to fill that role. Great vid!

[@BrittPearceWatches]

So what you’re saying is…. I, too, need to buy both…… 😜💕 best go get my name down on the list!

[@TheEagles427]

2-3 years wait list 🤦🏼‍♂️

[@daviddicicco195]

@@BrittPearceWatches haha exactly! Especially since you have the blue dial bb58…a black sub would go perfectly with it. Just sayyyyin

[@Simon_McGee]

I couldn’t agree more… I have a BB58 black and managed to pick up a non-date Sub, 41mm last June (3 month wait 😊) and I must admit I wear them both equally. I had originally planned to sell the 58, but I have removed the bracelet and have about 10 different straps for it (it looks great on anything) all more wearable than the OEM bracelet. The Sub IS superior in nearly every aspect, especially the bracelet, there is just something about the 58 that has made it a keeper…

[@daviddicicco195]

@@Simon_McGee The BB58 is a perfect strap monster watch. I use it the same way as you and keep the on its bracelet because it’s the best bracelet ever. I actually sold my bb58 to get a pro and then ended up rebuying the bb58 to highlight your point about it being a keeper. Now it’s never leaving the collection again.

[@webbezzy]

I have the 41-mm sub. It’s my weekend watch. I can see why you have reservations about its size. I would encourage puppy to buy it and borrow it from him every once in a while 😅

[@t.w.b3707]

The magnum at the end..lol