♦ Sims 1 vs Sims 2 vs Sims 3 vs Sims 4 : Agnes Crumplebottom

Hey! This is a brief comparison of Mrs Crumplebottom in the main PC games of The Sims. Took me longer to get this one out cause I was on vacation since Cottage Living was released and the internet was pretty slow, took me 10 hours to make the update and download the pack so I decided to just give up lol. But here it is.
What are your thoughts on Agnes Crumpebottom? I think she's a very "controversial" NPC, either you love her or hate her, and man, I do love her and I'm glad Sims 4 brought her back, took them long enough but I'm glad they're starting to listen and make packs that people ask for.
My opinion?
Sims 1 as always was the introduction and I think it was the quite good. She's a very simple NPC when she's not hitting sims, she's just standing around and you wouldn't really tell the difference if it wasn't for her unique voice. I saw videos where she was way more active than in my game, playing and dancing but I could capture none of that cause mine would just sit and rant, let me know how your behaves cause I'm not sure if mine is broken or what. Anyways, love her little animations and quirks, they give her lots of personality and that's all I can ask for in an NPC.
Sims 2's is more clamed than I remembered, she doesn't react to interactions other than woohoo (again, let me know if yours do lol) and she also dislikes when Sims show too much skin, which could be bothersome if there's a pool. Again, I like her unique animations and the fact that she knits when she's bored, also how she distracts herself by drinking, bowling and gambling, considering her strict attitude, she's living her best life here lol
Sims 3 she was a playable character and I honestly never played her, it got me thinking why Sims 2 was so immersive, the premade families put you in scenarios to display new features, but in her case they make it seem like it's gonna be difficult to get her a partner with a ghost haunting her house but that is not the case, Sims 3's ghosts are way less aggressive than Sims 2's, so I was disappointed in that aspect, but hey, it's cool to get to play her in her young years to redefine her.
Sims 4 was just introduced and she was very well made, I liked the fact that she could be added to the family and that they kept a bit of her past traits/interests, and of course, her iconic purse attack. Overall I would've liked if she had a unique voice and if she had more unique dialogue but that's probably just me.
So my order would be Sims 2, Sims 1/4 and Sims 3 last. But that's just my opinion, let me know what you think and tell me if there's something I forgot (aside from the Sims 1 dance lol) see you on the next one, I'm thinking cows MAAAAYYY be next but we'll see, thank you for reading :D
Music
Going on a picnic - Benjamin Rice
Young Love - Rich in Rags
0:00 Sims 1
1:05 Sims 2
2:07 Sims 3
3:12 Sims 4
5:04 Extras

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Thumbs Up For :

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Sims 1

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Sims 2

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Sims 3

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Sims 4

[@ZxNDER2]

how is this comment 6 minutes ago but the video is 1 minute old

[@ElinorMahoney]

The unfinished baby room in her house in TS3 is actually really sad

[@OfficialToxicCat]

Probably explains why she became a bitter old woman tbh.

[@zeyneepsenaa]

When I play with her, I always resurrect her husband & have them remarried and complete that baby room.

[@macymeyers222]

@@zeyneepsenaa awww

[@zeyneepsenaa]

@@macymeyers222 she deserves some happiness 🥺🥺

[@macymeyers222]

@@zeyneepsenaa yes she does

[@stephaniecarroll5081]

Sims 1 Agnes just getting up and leaving if anyone sits beside her is a *mood*

[@silverhowl9331]

Agreed.

[@anonimkullanc489]

Xd

[@Glowinthedarkshark]

And the aggravated sigh in the first clip has me dead

[@MariBerry]

Reminds me of Animal Crossing villagers :(

[@rjformation9038]

Fr

[@jericobongosia3992]

I always hated Agnes Crumplebottom in sims 2 but after knowing her backstory in the sims 3 i actually felt bad about her. That's why whenever i play her in the sims 3 i always revive her husband so they can be together.

[@cuteherogirl15]

That is so sweet omg

[@marine2422]

You’re so pure

[@carlacastrozamora7380]

Aww😞❤❤

[@Wednesday23]

You truly have heart of gold💛

[@coolmanidk]

@@Wednesday23 maybe two golden heart

[@bizarrou]

i think she wants to "protect" other sims that are romancing to make them not experience what she did

[@farah9902]

More like she's envious as hell

[@almosberczelly8560]

@@farah9902 LMAO NO

[@TheLomdr]

Makes sense in the Sims 4 with that peek of her having 2 failed relationships in one of her Notifications when using that Heart to Heart interaction. Looking back...her Sims 1 pose with the purse comes across a bit uncanny to me, and I've played the first game at release.

[@joaolima7131]

I don't blame her, it was a tragedy what happenned to her husband, if this was real life she shouldn't dictate people for living their lives, but as this is a game it's what make her unique

[@Holidayflowergirl]

@@joaolima7131 What makes her backstory even more tragic imo is the unfinished nursery in TS3.

[@crescentblueee]

It’s kinda weird that Agnes doesn’t sound like an old lady in the sims 4 lol. She doesn’t sound like a grumpy old lady at all she just sounds like any other young adult

[@UnstealableJewel]

Looks like she as rushed/poorly done, just like Bonehilda D:

[@grease_monkey6078]

sims3 and 4 didn't uterlize the old folks voice which annoys me, I want my older sims to sound cranky and old

[@JessG_20]

yup this made me realize that they really ought to add an elderly sounding voice option for sims 4!

[@Cychlo]

@@grease_monkey6078 she isn't old in the sims 3

[@666-bpm]

@@grease_monkey6078 makes sense in sims 3 tho since she’s young

[@OddSauce]

sims 1: most annoying incarnation sims 2: funniest incarnation sims 3: most heartbreaking incarnation sims 4: 's alright

[@RubyBlueUwU]

Sims 4 Mrs Crumplebottom, truly a character that exists

[@ag_supersonic]

@@RubyBlueUwU definitely one of the sims of all time

[@LeeDee5]

Ok but in Sims 1 the way she gets up and leaves when another sim sits next to her is hilarious! Like that’s also what I do😅

[@anonimkullanc489]

Same

[@kikiscribbles]

There's a bit of Crumplebottom in everyone, dear

[@missfefeloves]

🤣🤣🤣

[@sqitspanders9057]

Right when I’m about to get up, somebody else sits down and then I stay there for a few minutes so that they don’t think I don’t like them

[@amymcgames8709]

yeah when she does that it reminds me of myself

[@jonwoods4590]

fun fact: if you try to fight agnes on ts4 she’s guaranteed to win and she’ll have a pop up about how she’s been beating people like you for ages (i may or may not have tried to fight agnes🤫)

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Lol, I didn't even think of fighting her! That's pretty cool!

[@culteyeoftaxfraud1143]

What about vampire strength?

[@Masqu33]

HAHA YES I TRIED TO FIGHT HER AND LOST

[@Melmeltheclown]

I love how she'll physically fight sims that try to wish for love, like how savage!

[@kikiscribbles]

Truth coming out of her well to shame mankind

[@nxcrorat]

Dio should have recruited her, Polnareff would have been gone in under a minute

[@Pollicina_db]

@@nxcrorat What are you talking about, Polnareff has been thhrough so much shit an old lady with a purse would be no match

[@nxcrorat]

@@Pollicina_db Well, he wishes for love and flirts with like every woman he meets :/

[@ross1748]

My nickname for her is period woman lol

[@RememberRox]

Agnes climbing out of the wishing well was terrifying

[@user-wq3uw5zc7n]

looks like some horror movie type stuff! 😂 Agnes Crumplebottom: *The Reckoning*

[@aaliyahj6482]

I like her voice in SIms 1/2 better, I feel it gives her more character than in sims 4 xD

[@LeeDee5]

In Sims 4 she sounds 25. In the others she sounds more like a crochety old lady.

[@benjaminmozin1478]

@@LeeDee5 Sims4 don't care about details , worst sims

[@vanyadolly]

No to mention that aggressive knitting 😂

[@stleonia]

I also hate how they didn’t bother about family trees in Sims 4..

[@SnrubSource]

Yeah, The Sims 4's voicelines are really meh in general. Teenagers, young adults, adults and elders sound basically the same but with a slightly different pitch.

[@foranzo1582]

3:50 this entire scene where the shop just CLOSES is so wild like lmaooooo I watched it at least 10 times

[@samsonguy10k]

Carries the same ominous tone as when the shutters close in Papers, Please. Those on the other side are in big trouble.

[@Papismackmyassss]

I LAUGHED MY ASS OFF OMG

[@aidanlol5239]

that and her crawling out of the well like the Ring made me laugh

[@manic_street_starlover]

Aaaah. Agnes Crumplebottom. The cherry on the sims series. A beauty, in a way.

[@menemy4700]

Why I heard Morgan Freeman's voice

[@vaurel_YT]

@@menemy47000

[@JETWTF]

She is a sad tale. Planning on children and her husband dies from drowning on her honeymoon. The unfinished nursery and her husbands grave on the lot says she didn't get over it and expectedly so being a hopeless romantic who loses her love on their honeymoon would be devastating. Then her husbands ghost scaring away any suitor that comes calling she will age up into an elder alone. All her dreams of love and having a family smashed to bits. As a grumpy elder she gets angry when someone is being romantic publicly because it reminds her of what she herself so desired and tragically lost just as it was really starting for her. She is a truly tragic tale and her purse attacks are not funny, but sad.

[@im_creme]

Why does it sound like my life...

[@mylles1112]

And i think she was also expecting a baby through that time on the honey moon, so she lost it because of the trauma.

[@JETWTF]

@@mylles1112 There are no miscarriages in Sims games so it had to have been planning to have a child rather than miscarried one.

[@mylles1112]

@@JETWTF It's just a theory, it would sound more dramatic if we had a miscarriage because her envy and sorrow would be way more impactful because of this narrative. Also, if the game was way more realistic we would've traumas like that, i like the goofy style that the sims has but we need more adult content, after all, the sims games were never a children focus franchise and it slowly is becoming too cartoony.

[@theusov]

Important reminder: NEVER try to add Ms. Crumplebottom or any other special NPC on your household in The Sims 2, it will likely break your game due to incomplete/corrupted Sim data on these NPCs

[@AnymousScreams]

The Grim Reaper never did when I used to play Sims 2.

[@maxiking1859]

@@AnymousScreams How long you played since you added Grim Reaper to family?

[@NikolasoGames]

@@maxiking1859 ded

[@Lex_Quinn]

Fun fact, if you tried to add any of the musical artists from sims sessions to your household it would delete the household.

[@YouKnowImOnMyPeriodYah]

I’ve added the grim reaper 10 times in one household lmao Nothing happened to me I won’t risk it with crumplebottom though

[@OrionAsteriou]

Sims 3 is so tragic. Tragic clown ghost, bella ghost on lunar lakes, kraken, now this woman's life.

[@dundee6402]

It truly had the saddest stories: - The orphan in Sunset Valley that drowned and is burried in the graveyard (Opal Suerley) - The poor woman that got presumably killed by the Racket family - Juan Darer who lost his woman from a fire he caused - Polly Maloney, bless this woman - That girl that got kidnapped and brainwashed in Midnight Hollow

[@OrionAsteriou]

@@dundee6402 once i resurrect opal and another 9 sims in the graveyard with ambrosia. I feel sad about their reactions when comeback to alive.

[@tragicpierrot8448]

I think the Sims 3 is a chance for us to actually change the tragic stories of the iconic NPC's and sims from the Sims 1&2 and also for those other tragic characters as well. A chance to have a better story or we keep the main timeline as is... Just my guess..

[@OrionAsteriou]

@@tragicpierrot8448 i usually let the npc sims do their live. I never play using famous character. Just visit them and find something is wrong.

[@ZimmeR96]

I love how Sims 3 make backstory on every sims

[@mskittygemma]

Sims couple: *kiss* Miss Crumblebottom: I'm about to end their career.

[@isiaadiel3468]

I think Sims 3 really did her story (and many others') quite well. I like good lore in these games.

[@gamgan_]

Agnes Crumplebottom: the only Karen beloved by all

[@pexie7755]

She isn’t really a karen, she had a really sad story in sims 3: -Failed to have children -Lost her husband -Lonely

[@TheEtherny]

Karen is defined as an entitled middle aged white woman, she's not white nor middle aged. She's just an old lady who's trying to enjoy her time and these cutsey couples won't let her lol

[@BKNTD]

I don't really get why they added her in Cottage Living and made her a vendor. She would fit much much more into a pack like Get Together or anything with dating. Here it feels like they just needed nostalgia points for another "iconic NPC" after people forgot about Bonehilda.

[@murfeel1173]

I still have PTSD from Mrs Crumplebottom terrorizing my sims in TS2 Nightlife--I agree; having her run wild in Get Together would've been HILARIOUS! It was so random having her in Cottage Living. She makes more sense even in Nifty Knitting, lol.

[@user-jb7tq7ko7e]

They're apparently updating all the characters and giving them proper storylines because so many people have been complaining about how shitty they are. So yes, the awkward addition of nostalgia characters is going to have something to do with that.

[@SEXgoddess.]

EXACTLY

[@KH0LRA]

Yah, now you mentioned it Get Together is more suitable for them or maybe that one garden stuff (?) DLC where she could be put just yearning in the gardens

[@orbitalpudding1946]

Probably so, though she still works ou twell in Cottage Living for the most part. Gives her a bit more things to do and she can still show up anywhere in the world and scold and hit sims. Too bad they didn't bring back the unsavory charltan yet

[@maykaeppeli]

"Crumplebottomed" the best moodlet right there 😂😂

[@Okamimoto]

The sims 4 Agnes is fine but the way she hits people with her purse is way too slow imo

[@phyxiox]

and her voice doesn't sound old 😭

[@Mlmylji]

@@phyxiox I agree sock, it would've been better if they added a unique voice like they did with the "unspeakable pack" with rey and kylo

[@phyxiox]

@@Mlmylji unspeakable pack 💀

[@ThieflyChap]

It bothers me a bit to see that the person being hit seems to be enjoying it...

[@TheRedPlumbob]

She's not as young as she used to be lol

[@patatoepoop]

Sims 1 looked the best. She had the most character and her voice suited her. She also had a wider range of interactions

[@youregonewiththesin]

i love the dialogue popups too, really feels like getting scolded by an old woman and adds a ton of immersion. shes a really endearing character

[@glanni]

In my Sims 2 game, Vidcund Curious once had a thought bubble with hearts about Mrs. Crumplebottom when she walked by. I couldn't make him repeat that behavior (yet), but I laughed really hard and long about that.

[@glanni]

Another time when they were both in a night club, she was knitting and he was doing the rubrik's orb idle animation, they both looked around, and stopped at the same moment. He then did the "You're crazy" animation when she walked off. Every time people are doing romantic interactions next to Vidcund he disapproves by grunting and waving the people off. And today I learned Agnes Crumplebottom from the Sims 4 loves plants and gardening? What is going on?

[@alfredbelanger8326]

Me too! It happened with Antonio Monty for me.

[@andreamyob9458]

I managed to get her to kiss the mayor in sims 4. My spellcaster sim cast an infatuate spell on her. After the kiss they both just carried on as if nothing had happened. If you add her to a household, or if MCCC finds her a home, the game spawns a new Agnes NPC. I've had three of them walking around.

[@queerlibtardhippie9357]

You made her kiss the cat from Brindleton Bay?

[@lumindoesvideos]

@@queerlibtardhippie9357 for a second I was thinking of the cat in Brindleton Bay named Mayor Whiskers but then I remembered that Henford on Bagley actually has its own mayor NPC too. It's the older lady who judges the Finchwick Fair entries.

[@faithfortuna9227]

@@queerlibtardhippie9357 I believe he/she/they meant the Major from HoB

[@TheAmazingCrackhead]

you made her kiss mayor whiskers!?

[@ThatTurnip]

I have never seen Crumplebottom in a sims game but I have to say Sims 2 is the most funny

[@aturchomicz821]

Yeah I mean 6:38 you can just see how rich TS2 really is full of stuff!

[@kikiscribbles]

She invited my sim to the spice festival in Sims 4 and it was *weird*

[@trans-dragonroger1948]

I’m actually willing to encounter her.

[@nothing-jl2dz]

I've seen her in 2 and 4

[@debravan1167]

How have u not see her? She’s iconic

[@BarbTheBard]

Duuuude! The minute I watched this video I rushed to my sims 3 game to check out the house and when saw the baby room half finished, I felt so bad for her that I spent the next 4 hours trying to revive her husband (no cheats). In the meantime there was a brief romance with a cleaning guy, because "why not"! And just when I thought she will end up with a different dude, the ghost of her late husband bound to the living world with a spell, found the death fish. And so here we are. She is happy, engaged to her husband, pregnant and in reality it's 3:30 in the morning and I have to get up in 3h to go to work.... well done! ;)

[@TheRedPlumbob]

This is the sweetest thing I've heard all day! :')

[@BarbTheBard]

@@TheRedPlumbob ^^ Cheers!

[@RainRemnant]

She finally got her happy ending 😍🥰

[@P3ndejosG4ng]

I love when people give premade sims happy endings

[@Adier_Twigg]

I knew nothing about her. My charismatic guitar-playing sim guy got her attention when playing outside the diner one evening in TS3. They started talking, went on one date, and promptly he proposed and she agreed to marry him. After she got pregnant, I sold both their houses and I'm currently building them a nice home on the coast.

[@user-uc3gi6de8i]

She deserves it

[@vicsz58]

So beautiful story... ♡

[@ivanavidaurreta8799]

Awwwwwww

[@KH0LRA]

The Sims 3 version of her is actually interesting for me, its like we can choose to make her succeed in love eventually or continue making her the bitter anti love lady she's known as now. However, its kinda dissapointing how the ghost of her husband underperforms in comparison to what the bio says 🙄

[@TheRedPlumbob]

It would've been really cool if he was an angry ghost triggered by dates, I think a game like Sims 2 would've done that, since they cared about showing off their mechanics through the families.

[@KH0LRA]

@@TheRedPlumbob True!!! I've been itching for them to return family establishment mechanics 😔 Also, imagine his angry ghost being more subtle than Crumplebottom herself. Perhaps he can start appearing during dates with higher romantic levels, being more invasive than Agnes is with wrecking dates

[@carrot7868]

Perhaps they didn't add special mechanics because of the corruption NPC's caused in Sims 2.

[@cherrislushi]

why is no one else bothered by the fact that sims in sims 4 laugh when she hits you with her purse??

[@coritax3]

THISSSS!!!

[@menemy4700]

It's more like smiling obsequiously to me so I feel OK, I think.

[@BitterJoyXx]

Seems realistic

[@spicyrat2938]

Yeah I HATE it!! Sims 4 always have to laugh so stupidly at everything

[@itkahsramal4983]

Probably the same reason sims don't react to sims face planting on the treadmill. Like can a sim at least laugh and point, giggle, die of hysterical laughter.....something!!!

[@2000foxygirl]

I love sims 3’s story and character so much. Really hits you in the feels. My personal favorite

[@monlightplumbb4755]

The fact that she boos when sims woohoo is such a mood lol. She made me laugh when she did that XD

[@alexandriakotsifas]

Woah I never knew this! I've only played Sims 3 so I just always thought she was a young lonely rich lady. I played as her a lot and as sims who befriended/romanced her, I just liked her so it's so weird to learn she's actually a romance-hating old lady with a sad backstory haha

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Same! The first time I played I thought she killed her wealthy husband or something lol

[@alexandriakotsifas]

@@TheRedPlumbob Lol I love that!!

[@howbowl1496]

i never realized how detailed sims 1 was

[@guillermomasipgamerhd2137]

The Sims 4 with the cottage living expansion pack is the first sims game where miss crumplebottom can be happy and friendly with other sims

[@valeenp4767]

I guess in some point is true, but in the sims 3 u can play with her and make her be friendly

[@valeenp4767]

But it is true that in the sims 3 it depends on you

[@wezen4632]

The Agnes lore we get in sims 3 makes me genuinely sad

[@westanimetutorials6949]

I like that Mrs. Crumplebottom and Unsavory Charlatan can actually interact despite they appear in different expansion packs. 2 different NPCs they have their own drama lol

[@masterkiwius5312]

How did I only now just realise that she only punishes sims in love because she lost her husband… Damn now I feel bad for all those times I was mean to her in ts2 bc she stopped my sims for doing romantic interactions.

[@messyribbonzz]

Her closing the shop right in front of the couple was hilarious 😭

[@romaindelorme5371]

The one from the first sims is iconic. But Mrs Crumplebottom coming out of the wishing well in the sims 2 was so funny and it was "possible" to interact with her in town. The Sims 4 one is okay, sad she doesn't have her own voice like before. Sims 3 one has nothing special, she's just another playable sim.

[@puddingface1902]

Sims 3 one hasn't had her heart broken yet. My Sim will fix that 😈

[@Echoingsunflowers981]

@@puddingface1902 didn’t she lose her husband

[@puddingface1902]

@@Echoingsunflowers981 I think it's implied that she killed him of for his money.

[@bobblinggoblin2g2g2g2]

@@puddingface1902 Then why building a room for a child and being all sad on promo arts?

[@aliceguichard9367]

@@bobblinggoblin2g2g2g2 It is implied in the game that others think she killed her husband for his money, and that she is a black widow, but that in reality she doesnt care about fortune (she even is frugal) and just wanted to have a loving family.

[@ashlynbulsara4238]

I love how she'll physically fight with Sims . Like how savage.

[@docette2015]

Yeah, you think they would have made her voice a bit higher and screechier to make her sound more like Crumplebottoms from the past. . . Still, it's fun, and I like how they reference both the original Robert Crumplebottom from the Sims 1 park and Erik from her Sims 3 counterpart in the Sims 4 heart-to-hearts. Little callbacks like that are fun. :)

[@briannescott536]

I love Agnes in sims 3, that’s all I play and I had my sim have a baby with her. She’s amazing

[@user-wg3js6uv7z]

The first Sims that I played was Sims3, to think about how Agnes is end up being in Sims1,Sims2 and Sims4 is ... lol

[@n0vastar]

She proves you can't judge a book by its cover. As in, some people don't know her backstory so they judge her for being rude when in reality she just lost everything she loved.

[@renatopereira810]

I think The Sims 1 is the most iconic and funny one.

[@darya4993]

she's an icon she's a legend and she is the moment now come on now

[@luaruno]

most of the time i played in sunset valley she always gets married or starts dating with christopher steel, and i feel glad for that cuz christopher is a very cool and kind sim!! but usually for some reason they don't have children, also in some occasions she just adopts a random child and becomes a single mother

[@youisastar3246]

Mrs. Crumplebottom is not Agnes. She is Agnes's cousin's sister in law. She could be Agatha Crumplebottom considering how the Sims are never consistent with facial features.

[@arieltales8952]

I think she is Beatrice, from Sims 3 Supernatural. She has Agnes' traits but she is correct, instead of romantic. In many Western countries and in the past of occidental countries romantic interactions in public such as flirting, hugging, kissing, etc are consider impolite and offensive. However I don't think hitting with a purse is polite either, so her identity its still a mystery. Also, Beatrice is a witch so she will require gardening skill to alchemy despite human and other supernatural Sims are able to develop the alchemy skill. I am very confused, LOL.

[@youisastar3246]

@@arieltales8952 the Sims producers don't care about maintaining story consistency but the fans never fail to tie up the story fragments to make it logical. One example would be the parallel reality of the Goth family in the Sims 4.

[@SpadeSomething]

This!! I was kinda bothered to see they mentioned mrs. Crumplebottom as Angnes, when there's in fact Agnes Crumplebottom's grave in Pleasantview..

[@youisastar3246]

@@SpadeSomething After the death of Agnes, Mrs. Crumplebottom likes to parade about the place posing as her sister-in-law. Only by the Sims 2, did people actually realize that she was instead married to a Crumplebottom.

[@arieltales8952]

@@youisastar3246 Her reaction may be more common in a cousin than a sister-in-law.

[@pexie7755]

I would say Agnes is one of the most saddest sim in sim’s history , I’ve noticed that in her house in sims 3. There’s an incomplete baby room 😢

[@hummingbir6]

Sims 5 intro should be dedicated to her and cast from her perspective. She is that sulky persona that ironically animates the sims, a true gem.

[@ThieflyChap]

Sims 1 & 2: Cantankerous, jealous old bag. Sims 3: You have to feel a little sorry for her. Sims 4: Slightly less cantankerous, jealous old bag. So, does this mean there are two Agnes Crumplebottoms? One who is Mortimer's aunt and the other... a cousin maybe? Am I reading that right?

[@xxGamer101xxx]

Agnes from Sims 3 and Sims 1 are his aunt. The Sims Team has said that Sims 2 Agnes is different.

[@ThieflyChap]

@@xxGamer101xxx Ahh, I see. Thanks for clarifying that.

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Iirc, the only outsider is the one in Sims 2, they didn't make Sims 4's related to anyone but she talks about Erik and Robert, Sims 3's and Sims 1's love interests.

[@dundee6402]

Agnes is a young adult in TS3, an elder in TS and dead and buried in the Goth graveyard in TS2.

[@kunik61]

Cannot believe that this decent widow from TS3 is that legendary angry granny.

[@kevinkhor3956]

it's the time for Sims 4 have a voice for old people. Make the game more fun and realistic.

[@moonkute93]

In Sims 2, my sims just wears pijama in community lot and she keeps complaining and yelling at him the whole day (?) 😅

[@rainbow.ruby.13]

Hi moonkute!! 💓 I never knew you played sims I loved watching you

[@empressp7761]

She will always hitting someone with her purse regardless other life states like vampire od spellcasters.

[@kikiscribbles]

She doesn't discriminate, all that matters is *they were indecent*

[@lachlangenat9067]

I can’t be the only one who thinks her bag looks like an Hermes Kelly

[@gizem10026]

I love sims1 and sims2 version of her. She add soul to the game. You do not feel dullness like in sims4. I hope she come back with sims1 or 2 version. Not everything has to be sugar coated EA😀

[@NoThankYou255]

Wow! Can you do other premade families next, such as the goths and the pleasants?

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Maybe, I'm making the Goths for sure but I'm gonna wait cause Sims 4's team has talked about fixing the lore and it'd be interesting to see what they change

[@NoThankYou255]

@@TheRedPlumbob yay! I can't wait for you to talk about Bella's mystery, or maybe Lilith pleasant... :3

[@user-jb7tq7ko7e]

@Foreva lone look up Plumbella, she's done great videos on Bella Goth, as well are Entire History Of various Sim families

[@oxrea]

sims 1's agnes crumplebottom was the best and most hilarious version of her! Her voice kills me of laughter 🤣🤣

[@xasalia]

sims 2 > sims 1 > sims 4 >>>> sims 3 the sims 2 version is amazing and iconic the sims 1 version is also amazing the sims 4 i think is also actually well done, only i think an extra screechy voice would fit for her lol

[@TheRedPlumbob]

Glad to know I'm not the only one missing her unique voice!

[@idk_who2320]

I mean Sims 3 Agnes isn't that bad, Sims 3 is set in the past and its showing Agnes' life and showing why the way she is. It offers a good explanation and she has that depressed look.

[@xasalia]

@@idk_who2320 yeah it was a fun idea, but she doesn’t have special characteristics in the later and past games, she’s just a normal sim with a backstory which doesn’t really affect gameplay

[@idk_who2320]

@@xasalia Yeah I agree but I think they did it to give you a chance to change her future and give her another chance.

[@Esmerelda4]

Why do I feel like I know mrs crumplebottom

[@ultra16bits59]

It would be interesting to have a video talking about all the dances in The Sims series.

[@Li8aGun92]

1:58 This is a mood: ANGRY KNITTING!

[@zoeb3573]

5:43 Truth Coming Out of Her Well to Shame Mankind

[@yourfutureex7540]

BUT NOOOOO Agnes Crumplebottom and Mrs. Crumplebottom are two different sims !!!!😳😳 In TS2 Agnes is dead and she just can’t be mrs.crump.

[@dianas7549]

It didn't dawn on me that Anges from ts3 was her. I was so used to seeing her as an elderly woman wearing grey, that I thought the one in sims 3 was a random sim. Not to mention, but she was also much easier to get along with in sims 3 in my opinion.

[@alana9205]

her climbing out of the wishing well and immediately fighting the sim is sending me lmao

[@luisocamp2753]

Thank you for making a vid about her! She’s my favorite sim in sims 3

[@leonst.7471]

Psychologist are really needed in their world since the old lady needs some help

[@leodajosh3129]

That could be a career option

[@annahubar1258]

I love Agnes in Sims 3. I put her with Christopher Steel and together They have at least 2 kids before she is an elder.

[@peterkropotkin6806]

I love that in sims 2 she literally crawls out of a goddamn well like The Ring

[@la912]

5:48 I died when I saw her crawling out of the wishin well like the ring 💀

[@thekingkingalpha8283]

Always really love and enjoy these videos! Look forward to them whenever they’re out! Excellent work :D

[@immagonko4261]

The voice acting in Sims 1 and 2 is the best 😂 she sounds hilarious

[@mimifule]

my favorite character in the sims 3, i love playing with her. I made her a great explorer, travelling to forget her lost, she's now richer than ever and I adopted many babies & kids so she can give them love the most absolute love ♡

[@horrorjunky4life50]

I wish Miss. Crumplebottom was a character you could play. I would have had date some of my older Sims. Also, am I the only one who noticed she is knitting a red/green sweater like the one Freddy Kruger wears? Hmmmm

[@bpsara]

If you mean in the Sims 4, you can totally play her. She’s in the households menu, you just need to move her in a house

[@horrorjunky4life50]

@@bpsara Nope. My fave is Sims 2 and 1. When I get some time, I'd love to clone her and put her in my game. She should have been playable from at least the 2nd Sims

[@farishanasa6477]

Despite her grumpy trait, I feel sorry for her love story. She didn't have beautiful experience of wedding life like her sister (Cornelia) 😭

[@Ashana.]

I’ve only played the sims 4 but I love what sims 3 did with making the family tree even though they are dead which adds something the sims 4 lacks a lot

[@JesterofAces]

I love the running gag of “She’ll hit the sim with her purse”

[@kabouterbankje]

3:51 HAHAHAhaAHAH HOW SHE CLOSED IT WITH THAT FACE HAGHAGHAAHGGBAHAGGaBAHA

[@anonimkullanc489]

I love the family tree in Sims 2!(Also ts3)I also love the past-present-future relationship between Sims 1-2-3.My favourite is Sims 2.I like the backstory in Sims 3.Sims 4 is still good.

[@Ocean_Lord_derpfish]

5:44 Sadako? no! it's even something scarier! it's Mrs. crumblebottom!! 🫨

[@Celi_Rosa018]

Dude i love her sm 😭 she seems kinda fun and hilarious to me And also the how she side eye to those couple, it make me remind of myself LOL 😭

[@lem0nplays469]

She never dies.

[@hungrywarnergaming5263]

Actually she did in the sims 2 I think? You can see her grave buried in the goth’s house

[@lem0nplays469]

@@hungrywarnergaming5263 oh that's interesting

[@jonnycolucci7683]

Yeah in TS3 I made the decedents of Horace Mandrake and had her marry one of them. I figured if “Where’s Bella” and “Murder in Pleasantview” were warnings to adjust the timeline 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@LamborghiniDiabloSVPursuit]

So she's a grumpy old coot to everyone as a defense mechanism to prevent her from forming relationships and suffering through the pain of loss and eternal separation again? Dang, that's dark.

[@HeroOfTime64Link]

The Mrs. Crumplebottom from sims 2 is actually a distant relative

[@AliceShinya]

It amazes me how smooth the animations are in the sims 2 truly a game ahead of its time

[@jester6802]

So she’s like Karen in the sims universe

[@hungrywarnergaming5263]

She has a sad backstory though in sims 3 which makes sense why she is a bitter and grumpy old lady. Her husband died on their honeymoon and she was planning to have children with him. Explains the unfinished baby room in her house

[@theflowerbunny]

Best evolution so far!

[@rosegraham5780]

loveeee this video this is amazing, love her evalution and the sims 💖💖💖💖💖💖

[@IndyIsabelle]

3:52 this cracks me up

[@stleonia]

When I was a kid I adored Agnes and always made a life she deserves for her in Sims 3. I think growing up with this character made me very compassionate towards old people that many sees as grumpy and bitter. They’re not like that without a reason and you should treat them with respect 💛

[@orhardlevinsky]

I really in love with this game. It’s just my childhood, part of my personality formation.

[@ambers9756]

I've played all of these, but I just met Agnes for the first time on a date in Sims 4 today! It was a crowded dance floor and so I completely missed what the heck happened, but my date straight up LEFT and my sim had a negative moodlet about her purse after. This video cleared up sooo much because I was lost.

[@mizzphitzbeta]

I remember during one of my sims 2 gameplays, she yelled at my sim for dressing inappropriately at a club 😂

[@mr_ms_who122]

I had no idea she existed, but now I must find her in the Sims world.

[@Nilvou]

I really like how in sims 2 agnes took bringing hands to the next level by coming out of a well