Sinéad O'Connor e Roger Waters - "Mother"

[@TheCarnawall]

Inscreva-se (subscribe to our channel): www.bit.ly/KZbin-TheCarnawall 🎞

[@caravanrose]

Bravo!🎉🎉🎉

[@carlosrevelo6846]

Great voice ❤rest in peace 🙏 ❤

[@carlfriedrich7054]

Gänsehaut pur !

[@DamirValjetic-sw3vb]

Fantasy!

[@amsterdamoriginalsaustralia]

My what a great line up of musicians came together for a truly heartbreaking song & concert ❤❤❤🎆🎇😢🥲😂

[@doguihadf]

Essa apresentação é fantástica! R.I.P Sinéad O'Connor 🖤

[@raquelbriozzo1106]

👏👏👏👏👏❤

[@SERGIOROUSSENQ]

além de excelente atriz.❤

[@finchifinch3316]

Mit Tränen, einem Lächeln und Gänsehaut am ganzen Körper. Sie fehlt.

[@anavillalobos2578]

❤​@@finchifinch3316

[@flaviomattoscardoso7534]

Estas pessoas fizeram parte da minha vida músicas que nunca mais serão esquecidas pela minha geração!

[@alexbiondo5386]

Gran interpretación de Sinead O'connor. Siempre te recordaremos!! QEPD...😢

[@larrymartinez2900]

Su sonrisa ante la respuesta del publico cuando comienza a cantar es demasiado . Ya descansa en la paz del señor.

[@gary.o4682]

Rodger Who

[@AnyoneCanSee]

I was there. The best summer of my life. I went on to visit all the Eastern European states. I hitchhiked and camped out. I was young and free.

[@User73698]

That's sounds beautiful man. I'm happy that you enjoyed those special times.

[@MarioJunior-e9z]

Que maravilha !❤

[@rudigerpatommel2406]

I was there too and saw that Shinned O Corner lost their voice during this song! It was re-recorded AFTER the concert!

[@cloudripples1073]

awesome ! Hope you're still free at least .!

[@ThePriestess-jod]

Never 😮. Manika is a rate tune. What is that mean.? ​@@rudigerpatommel2406

[@carapalida4908]

TOP! Sinéad deixou uma obra!👏👏👏 RIP!

[@petemavus2948]

​@@uddesantosneves7856 True dat. 🤣 Further enhancement but Sinead O'Connor in her inimitable voice and style. A well paired collaboration of greats. 💜

[@ricardo5228]

​@@uddesantosneves7856E ela não gravou nada seu ignorante?

[@jeromemini3552]

Plusieurs,si j'ose dire...😌

[@genereynolds3296]

Garth Hudson on Accordion. Levon Helm and Rick Danko on background vocals. Members of THE BAND for you kids.

[@hiwind58]

Thanks

[@keithchenery8364]

Thanks for confirming that, I thought I was seeing things. Garth Hudson was pretty instantly recognisable, but I was looking for Robbie Robertson. What a line-up. :)

[@kickthestupidbot]

Thank you!

[@ClaudioGabrielSalgado-qt5ee]

Most humble & great musicians in the rock 'n" roll history.(from Jujuy,Argentina)

[@lucasalma.musico]

Only reason I watched this video. Don't care for Sinead or Waters (both are talented, but...).

[@todoubled7970]

Pink Floyd - without a doubt, one of the best rock bands of all time.

[@Webedunn]

For making depressing music, yeah....

[@shawsy3108]

​@Webedunn they have the most tribute acts worldwide.

[@mtadams2009]

@@WebedunnI actually never thought their music was depressing. I always thought it was very beautiful and moving. Just me I guess.

[@Webedunn]

@ did you ever watch "the Wall?" 😆 Wish you were here - DEPRESSING! Mother - DEPRESSING! Machine - DEPRESSING! I could go on and on. Read the lyrics to their songs. I seen them in concert. Was a big fan but now I turn it off.....

[@shawsy3108]

@Webedunn watched it last night

[@jujumulligan43]

Thank you so very much for this awesome performance. I have never seen this until today 11.11.2024. It is sublime and beautiful.❤❤❤

[@erinpayne3207]

Same on 11/11/24 I’m crying So emotionally poetic

[@briangreen1971]

Yep 11/11/24 for me too didn’t have this on my bingo card today,seeing the band playing with sinead and Roger playing mother, just great performance !

[@LaPetiteMort715]

Same❤

[@going.within]

11.12.2024 here. It's the first time I heard it too and I absolutely agree 😁

[@mariannekofoed]

I was there that night and Sinead was pure magic. I still come back here once in a while to watch it again ❤

[@GoranPredovan]

RIP Sinead, we miss you!

[@camionzeta]

Miss you Sinéad ❤ And miss those times when Rock Music would raise its voice loud and strong against apartheid and all wars.

[@oliver9089]

Roger still carries a voice against all war, but the war mongers hurl dirty names at him for that, and the dogs and sheep happily oblige.

[@olderuglierandwiser]

No ...fuck all to do with rock or politics. This song is two deeply distressed people coming together to weep for the inner abused child... The abuse that they both came to understand in later years 😢😢😢😢😔🕊️😟💜💜💜🌍🌎🖤🙌🙌

[@kathrynagoodwin24]

Hugely relevant comment ~ thank you for saying this. The World are failing all the children who are oppressed right now. No outcry, no Rock in Rio, no Live Aid, I’m terrified for Humanity.

[@kathrynagoodwin24]

@@olderuglierandwiserSinead was horribly abused by her Mother yet she fought everything, these were great times for Musicians to stand up to Social Injustices, it didn’t happen anymore, the abuse was a vehicle for their passion. Roger Waters has a strong propelling voice to this day, I wish more were like him. How many genocides are we live streaming and all these “Artists” are quiet. It’s shameful and a deep scar on humanity.

[@CaptPeon]

Those musicians are still out there but they aren't the ones being advertised and sponsored by big business. If you seek them out you'll find them!

[@mikeglynn3676]

bare head, bare feet and bare her soul in this and every performance! the world was too cruel for such a sensitive soul . RIP Sinead

[@bird_dogs_n_bees]

spot on. well said

[@judithbunce9108]

I admired her fully

[@JamesButtermore-o8i]

Ì am 68 years old now! Dark side of moon to this day, I never get tired of Pink. Floyed..... David Ĝilmor! We have been Blessed!!

[@ahill4642]

Sinéad added to every single song she ever covered or contributed to. A unique, extraordinary artist.

[@davidboyle1193]

Dirty Muslim

[@jdrennsport8704]

@@davidboyle1193You sound profoundly moronic.

[@wthomas5697]

@@davidboyle1193 You are one effed up individual.

[@greggusan]

I was a uni student when the wall came down. What a time of optimism and hope. Makes me very sad how things are turning out now.

[@ВалентинШадевский-в7ф]

Узнать бы нынешнее мнение ГДРовцев про стену.

[@rebeccaedwards2106]

Me too xxx

[@doobybrother21]

@@ВалентинШадевский-в7ф no you don't. You wouldn't believe them. You would still prefer to believe your own delusions.

[@Beavusnbutheads]

Storm before the sunshine

[@josecosta2008]

First time hearing this version. I’ve goosebumps all over me, particularly, in my soul. I’m so happy I could made it before completed my journey!!! Sometimes I wonder if Sinead was bless for everybody, except for herself. I still love her. RIP

[@PILATUS1968]

her fight wasnt internal it was with the system but no 1 can beat the system its too corrupted and too powerful it will destroy you just like they destroyed her for speaking up against pedo and child molester (the church primarily).

[@flipper2392]

If you've not seen this before you need to see The Wall-Live in Berlin, mind blowing. This is from the rehearsal as sound failed during the live event.

[@e.t.preppin7084]

@@flipper2392did she die ?

[@maurocoimbra9624]

​@@e.t.preppin7084Unfortunately, yes, on July, 26th last year (2023)

[@oliveiragomes8098]

​@@e.t.preppin7084Yes, unfortunately it's gone too soon😢😢😢

[@marcosalbertoborgesalberto8297]

Descansa em paz Oconor. Obrigado por todos os cantares que pude ouvir e curtir.

[@stephanestermann7451]

​@@vitorrosa2940 malheureusement du tabac😢

[@papacapivarabrasuka.2796]

É foda mesmo brother.

[@CarolineTagand]

Ma douce Sinead repose en Paix au côté de ton fils. Et dans ce Paradis tu chante pour toutes les Âmes. Merci pour toutes les chansons une voix extraordinaire. Rip

[@OhanaNZ]

I was at this concert. I remember most of it.....The best ever. 300,000 ecstatic humans in PotsdamerPlatz just after the Fall of the Berlin Wall. Sinead was spine-tingling.

[@salvadormartins3577]

This girl is a blessing from God, a great singer, may my little brothers of light be holding her hands wherever she is now.

[@rickroll9086]

Which God? Just so we know where she is now. Gotta keep track of these things.

[@slomoichye1832]

עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!!

[@bestebassist]

Thank you, a very warm wish for Sinead.

[@paulcarey1708]

@@rickroll9086 She became some kind of priest at some point. She sure had the catholic church figured out... a little ahead of her time unfortunately and paid the price.

[@chrislea1970]

She was singing that to Ireland.. an absolute Queen.. always. 💚🖤

[@alanashworth9414]

RIP Sinéad O'Connor . The wall was one of the greatest albums ever made. Sinéad's Nothing Compares 2U used to make me cry in my youth when it released. Rest Sinéad O'Connor, we will always remember you.

[@brunodelacruz06]

Sincere artist and honest music. We miss that, now everything is really bad.

[@j.w.r3730]

I'm glad she got that opportunity to be among the legends because she was one of them always. I've never seen this before,and it's so bittersweet to see those times once again,so very touching. To see them at their prime,alive,giving us such gifts of their presence in music. God's above and below,how I miss those golden times I was so privileged to live.

[@pugfest1]

Ohhh so well said !! I’m just finding this ! I love love it !! I too feel blessed to have lived to see the amazing times ! Absolutely adore Sinead 🙏RUP xo

[@skyeagle3123]

Yes there were many great legends, and some of their music plays on til this day, and sorry we lost Sinead, she was great, and my her soul RIP.

[@ikkenhisatsu7170]

Man, all the people who are no longer with us. RIP Sinead, Levon and RIck. Amazing talents.

[@paddystatofield]

I'm glad we still got Roger fighting the good fight

[@gege4707]

@@paddystatofield roger is not that talented really he played second fiddle to Dave (the real talent)

[@theodavies8754]

​@@gege4707maybe post it on a song Dave wrote. He was probably the best guitarist in pink Floyd.

[@gege4707]

@@theodavies8754 dave wrote comfortably numb roger wrote the lyrics lets face it, we dont tune in to the words, do we? the words play second fiddle to the tune the riffs are what i want comfortably numb is known for the guitar playing the words could be in hindi for all i care

[@MesaBoogieman82]

I was gonna ask is that Garth Hudson on the accordion? You say Levon on drums? Who's on backup? Thx for any info. Where and when was this?

[@geoff2212]

The best version of this I've ever heard.

[@geoff2212]

@@nebbiolo702 You are right but I was not comparing it to the original. I have listened to many versions of this song and to me it's the best version of the original not better than the original.

[@Shackleton71]

I was there! It was amazing. 400k strong singing along! ❤

[@kausarmazari9289]

Lucky you🎉

[@rickbullock4331]

I’ve listened to this more times than I can remember and it’s amazing to my ears. I’m almost 80 now and the talent brought together for this extravaganza was extraordinary to say the least. Sinead definitely was a unique talent. This song in particular is so good to listen to.👍👍🇨🇦

[@slomoichye1832]

עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!!

[@superorangeish]

Is that Garth on accordian? I guess so( as I see the Band)

[@labitapopol5297]

pauvre type

[@АндрейЕграшов-к8ч]

Салют, старичок, из России! Музыка объединяет! Твой почти ровесник.

[@bbqgigi5510]

sinead is simply the greatest punk rocker to ever live - xxx

[@elenakuvatova9866]

Такая маленькая хрупкая женщина с большим сердцем бесстрашного борца!Мы любим и помним тебя наша Шинейд ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@zbencz]

Perfect, pure art - rest in peace darling.

[@fortierma64]

Wow, thank you. This is the first time I see this clip since attending that concert in Berlin almost 35 years ago. So many memories and oh how the world’s changed since. And not necessarily always for the better…

[@svdumitrescu]

"And not necessarily always for the better…" -- That's what I keep on saying too. Sadly seems we do not have too much control.

[@therealFearlessBOB]

@@svdumitrescu Don't kid yourself, we don't have ANY control... You need to be a top 1% to even get close to anything in resemblance to control. And if we ever get wise, and rise up, we're gonna get beat down, because they got the firepower and the media on their side. So no chance. It's not like the old days, where you could bring pitchforks and torches to get it done.

[@jogiesantacruz_13]

Thank you Sir / Ma'am 👍🏽❤️🥰🖖👌🤟

[@samsmith4216]

One of the most beautiful artists in the last 100 yrs.. Sinead O'Connor... 😢

[@slomoichye1832]

עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!! עם ישראל🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷חי!!!!!!!

[@Nowhereman123]

Not just musicians but 2 of the most courageous people of our times. Beautiful seeing them together.

[@GPS7749]

Sinéad O'Connor, presente... sempre! Que saudade dessa figura linda de voz encantadora, e essa apresentação com Roger Waters ficou sublime💗❤👏👏👏! Mais alguém curtindo em 2024?

[@dariuszsilski2369]

tak

[@lincetenaz]

♥♠♦♣ 😭😭😭😪

[@paulopintofurtado190]

Fantástica mesmo!

[@francolannutti6318]

Adorabile Sinead 🙏❤️❤️❤️

[@antoniogemma3815]

Brano ed esibizione di rara bellezza. Capolavoro! Grazie Sinéad ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Aftermau]

How long..... How many memories. Mother. An already very beautiful song, enhanced by a majestic set, the historic moment in Berlin and above all..... unforgettable Sinead.... a tormented soul who left us too soon. I hope there is a worthy audience up there!

[@franknguitars7671]

A very touching and moving performance by Sinead O'Connor. R.I.P. - what a talent.

[@Alext165]

Perfect, beautiful lady and what an awesome voice. Gone to early 😢

[@yogi_0911]

I was there live in Berlin. Unfortunately it was too quiet there. It was still a great experience. R.I.P Sinead

[@Brian_ON]

The video you’re watching is from the dress rehearsals. As you say there was recording/audio issues on the concert footage so they had to use the rehearsal footage in the live dvd.

[@zooropaforever]

The night of the show a lot of problems happened. I remember clearly that Danko and Helm made a mistake (one said "clean" and the other "warm" in the same moment) and Waters shook his head smiling bitterly. This video DVD (and the old VHS too) is edited with the performance of the rehearsals. By the way I still envy you for being there in that incredible night. Waters and the O'Connor didn't get along at all. A lot of harsh words between them flew during the years.

[@Latexhandske]

In what corner where you standing? Where I was (and around the 500.000 with me) was load as hell! I can agree that problems with the sound was on/off, but hey.....the wall was gone!

[@kevinhayes2153]

First time hearing this version, what an amazing presence Sinead had . So glad I got to see it. Rodger magnificent talent and soul

[@decaserantes2552]

Fagner eres un sueño puro por hacerme volver a mi España. . ¡ Que sincronismo fantástico! ¡ Mis enhorabuena!

[@kausarmazari9289]

Beautiful person ❤️ God Bless you 🙏 ❤️ Ameen Summah Ameen

[@BIZARBIES]

Levon and Rick's voices together is pure magic. And Garth playing accordion... perfection.

[@marcbesner9457]

100% agree, i frigin love The Band

[@audiosuy]

maybe in this full-edited studio version, but their real live performance was terrible

[@thairabbas1790]

Sinéad & Roger Waters ! Oh God ! I never heard this version before , what a great performance ❤

[@morizkostner1370]

This is the best version of Mother ever❤

[@banjo1434]

Garth on accordion. And the band boys singing together with two legends. Thank you . Free 🇵🇸

[@stephenmiholick7548]

Never saw this till today, love seeing the boys from The Band in there singing and playing accordion. Great version!!

[@adriandarke5393]

Such a performance, and what a blessing, wish i was there!. We were all younger then!. Great Student days. Rip Sinead.

[@Ochao968]

Sublime !!! 💘

[@joaomartins6885]

Ouvindo em nov/2024..Uma intérprete incrível. Uma Deusa. Pena q nos deixou muito cedo.

[@douggillis]

She was just soooooooooo beautiful in everyway!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@alexchwaiewsky8481]

I was fortunate to be there!!! What a time and place!!! Tears of joy in my eyes as I listen...

[@JuneCrossley-p8f]

Love this song, love you Sinead O Connor, R.I.P dear sweet, brave lady, you will always be missed x

[@rafafarm7115]

Maravillosa interpretación, la escucho todos los días y no me canso. D.E.P.

[@Michel-r6m]

Sinéad could be outspoken and humble. The Lion & the Cobra to me is an epic album. Great video, thanks for the upload 👍

[@brianogrady9883]

Came here for the lovely lovely Sinéad. Delighted to see The Band as well. What a grouping. All feelers. All flow - ers

[@brianshickey]

My god are you missed you beautiful banshee. Your music is timeless and you have endless songs right here on KZbin but hearing you live was one of my biggest gifts. ❤

[@AElbadri]

That great Irish touch to this masterpiece elevates it further to greater heights.

[@ChrisLawton66]

And THE BAND!

[@stefankropff]

I was there, fantastic adventure, yes it was actually an adventure not just a concert or event ❤️

[@daviddillon4316]

Me too. The Hilton Hotel on Potsdamer Platz now stands roughly where i was standing that night.

[@sergiovitor7729]

Ouvir um hino desse, é carinho ao meu ouvido. É muito prazeroso

[@madcrops]

I’m more impressed to see Garth Hudson and Levon Helm, amazing talent

[@LanceEads]

and Rick Danko, but Sinéad was an amazing voice and talent as well. So emotive!

[@nadominhoca]

Same here!

[@omartoyos3053]

Donde sea que estés Sinead..gracias!❤

[@Yudishitira]

Sinéad, tem uma das vozes mais lindas que ouvi!

[@alicenunes9702]

Aqui ouvindo . Gratidão aos grandes que sabiam cantar 💗 Brasília DF

[@flaviagoncalves8215]

Mds, to em lágrimas aqui. Como eu nunca tinha visto isso antes???

[@antoniomorais013]

Bonito ❤

[@KNOWHOPE72]

What a rare find! Cant believe we lost Sinead. What a beautiful doe-eyed soul.

[@AndieWalsh333]

Listening from the US, November 2024.

[@rashomon66]

Wow, part of Pink Floyd, part of The Band, [all of?] the Hooters and Sinead O’Connor performing together. I love when you get combinations like this.

[@marcelmallory2761]

This was incredible! I've never seen this. The talent on that stage......amazing. One of my favorite Floyd songs.... they did a wonderful job with it.

[@OlivandojuniorDiaslopes]

Sim ,foi transmitido ao vivo, deixei de sair quando vi q era ao vivo, sonzeira eterna ,o q é bom nunca acaba!!!!

[@tommasosantuari]

Capolavoro

[@MarioBarboza-l8d]

Verdade!!!

[@federicoboccignone7628]

brividi

[@emanuelapagani5786]

Pelle d'oca 😢

[@dude6894]

Think about what it takes to stand up there and belt it out with Roger, Levon and Rick as your backup harmony. What a lady, an angel now and forever.

[@cmale3d]

She's my favorite musician of all time. Voice as powerful as anyone I've listened to in my lifetime. Her best quality however , she gave zero f*cks, fewer than zero if she could. She's the one person who used her platform purely for the good of others. The only one. I miss her. I'll always miss her. I'm welling up writing this.

[@aldodainese6105]

Ho questo album magistrale del grandissimo Roger! Voce sublime di soc.❤❤❤rip.

[@wilsonwilson8086]

Why haven't I seen this before?. Stunning.

[@DenMore1]

Same here, I only heard this one 10 years ago. Best version ever

[@rosiagosto164]

Meravigliosa..dritta al cuore !

[@boydrc]

RIP Sinaead... Brilliant version with Roger

[@nilcedeilanessilva3399]

Isso, é para quem tem ouvidos apurados! Um espetáculo!

[@realtorjames2586]

Awesome version. This concert was celebrating the wall coming down in Berlin and the defeat of communism and the soviets. It was a huge event. Families separated by that wall for decades were re-united, etc.

[@innerhebridean]

Sinead’s voice is the most expressive instrument I’ve heard. And the Band the soul of music; can’t help thinking she and the great Garth had a moment as he put the finishing touches on the piece.

[@tococeliz3818]

Una belleza,gran canción, muchas gracias, Chile

[@vinamerosa1923]

There is something special about Roger and how he makes the magic. I Love David and how he gives us their songs, but Roger is VERY creative ... the accordion is AMZING ! Sinead fits perfectly with the Band guys and this haunting poem of a rock song ... Magic music !

[@maciekabuc4129]

Piękne i cudo - pamiętam z Berlina

[@janssengm]

I was there...amazing moment in history

[@daviddillon4316]

Me too and i still have my ticket from it.

[@kyolookinfo1925]

Garth Hudson, Rick Danko, Levon Helm, what a privilege to have that magnificent band on this song

[@RobertWaldhour]

A true loss of a beautiful soul that I had a world of respect for. Hope she's back with her son now and that they can be together forever

[@franciscdevito8245]

Beautiful

[@rafafarm7115]

Maravillosa interpretación!!

[@KimberlyBarrett-er7sx]

She is a pure soul. God bless her. Another musical spirit God loaned to us , and took back home.

[@stephanestermann7451]

La plus belle voix au monde la plus belle âme Sinéad je t'aime ❤❤😢❤

[@TonyNatale]

She was such a beautiful soul... What a incredible time in history.

[@joeblow42064]

Listened to this in '89 on this old tired radio in Denver Co. We played hacky sack under the street lights afterwards. Great night.

[@daviddillon4316]

It wasnt recorded till 1990.

[@joeblow42064]

@daviddillon4316 That's how much fun we had that July evening, we forgot what year it was! Blessings

[@DamirValjetic-sw3vb]

Great gig on the Sky!!!!

[@salvadormartins3577]

Essa menina é uma benção de Deus nesse momento esteja segurando nas mãos dela mãos dela

[@elainemeyer5062]

👏 - I admit NOT having listened to Sinead sing more than a handful of songs in my 70ish yrs. THIS was a 💖 heart wrenching cover of a 45+ y.o. 🌟 PF song imho - her strong voice came out full of passion, emotion, and ‘life’ that I was close to tears 😥. It’s unusual for me to find someone who I feel does justice to the original, and more rare when I think theirs is better - which in this case I think hers was. And now ✝️ may she be @ ☮️ + forever RIP 🪦 . * I’m very glad 😊 YT ‘found’ this video for me today 🙏!

[@PedroMcQ71]

Foggy dew 0:52

[@HappyWife93]

Best playlist on KZbin ❤

[@ClaudioGabrielSalgado-qt5ee]

Lovely Sinead R.I.P. wherever you are. Garth (accordion), only living member of The Band. Thanks both of you: sweet gift to us❤(from Jujuy,Argentina)

[@bernadette607]

Magnificent

[@stevosd60]

Great version ❤️

[@daniel22opole]

I have never heard a better song about my mother in my life and I never will 

[@sidstewart7399]

Was she overprotective as well?

[@daniel22opole]

@sidstewart7399 of course