Sin Triangle - hollyleaf amv

[@NeatoDragons]

THE END WITH HER SOUL CREATING A NEW STAR ABOVE THE OTHERS SHOWING SHE HAS SELF WORTH,,,, SCREAMING

[@peppermint-moss]

yes !!! hell yeaaaaa

[@LunarFoxes1]

@@peppermint-moss she’s my favorite character, I hate she couldn’t be with her siblings in the Prophecy.

[@Arsonlovingfrog]

@@LunarFoxes1 honestly it really adds to her character tho-

[@LunarFoxes1]

@@Arsonlovingfrog Very much fair.

[@whatshouldbemynamep3701]

@@LunarFoxes1 Same. When I get my first ever cat Im naming it after Hollyleaf shes such a great character I love her lmao

[@Winterpelt]

Okay but the part where you pan down to show Hollyleaf killing Ashfur to the lyric "what did you do" is amazing

[@juliadonati8245]

3:09

[@butterfly__sky]

i feel honored to be the 1,000th like 🤭

[@baileylovelace]

@@juliadonati8245 Am I the only one who is still mad at Hollyleaf for killing Ashfur

[@baileylovelace]

@@Carottleamen no

[@veronica3662]

​@@CarottleamenI'm also glad that he's gone

[@ariachermansky7836]

The little toe beans while walking make my day

[@mockingbird_lullaby4962]

I just wanted to point out how Hollyleaf's star rose higher than the Power of Three stars when she died. How it symbolized she made the ultimate sacrifice for her clan and finally let go of all her anger to finally rise above her bitterness and jealousy, and prove that she was just as good as her siblings if not more. How she earned her spot in StarClan.

[@unioncrossed7384]

the way you incorporated the song title “sin triangle” with the three stars is absolutely wonderful. and the symbolism of holly becoming her own star at the end. magnifique. this is gorgeous

[@Frog12]

omg this is so pretty, this song fits her and her feelings of not belonging to her clan, her family, and to the prophecy so well!!! the fact that so much of this is animated is incredible, it must have taken so much work to complete, im in awe!!! also i adore the emphasis on parts of her story not covered as often by other hollyleaf pmvs, most focus on her downward spiral after the fire incident and ignore most of the other factors that led to her breakdown, but this one has so many other moments from earlier in her life! excellent work!

[@ian-ux6sn]

adhfdfgbsh,, listen,, hollyleaf is arguably my favorite warrior cats character ever, and i have seen So Many Holly amvs but this one by FAR takes the cake. the composition is LOVELY and the black and white theme is so so nice,,, the song choice fits so well for holly and the little snippets of animation among all the photos is so pretty,,, ur designs are so nice and simple and they fit so well with what youve done. especially the second recording bit about personality and holly working through her fears of being halfclan,,, MAN,,, my favorite bit is the "what would you do?" and panning down to ashfur!! its rare to see a holly video focus on her life prior to ashfur's death and focus on her FEAR rather than her anger and its really refreshing to see youve done that here!! this video is INCREDIBLE and i love it so much. ive already watched this thing like 4 times and i do NOT plan on stopping any time soon!!!!

[@peppermint-moss]

thank u thank u!!

[@sailorr]

i absolutely ADORE this amv!!! :D i think it was really cool how you touched on parts of her story that are often overlooked- how she wanted to become a medicine cat before she chose to be a warrior, how she took the prophecy more seriously than her brothers while also feeling alienated and frustrated by not knowing “her power”, and how sol spoke to her specifically in terms of not feeling like she belonged / wanting to do good by her clan to her full potential!! i think including these ideas, and pairing them with this song paints hollyleaf in a light that a lot of ppl don’t!! (not to say there’s anything wrong w focussing on parts of her story, but i think you were really faithful to hollyleaf as a whole!! and thats cool to see! :D ) i also absolutely love how clear the layout of the video is!!! :D you captured + communicated all of hollyleaf’s life really well!! even though the video was in black and white, i could tell exactly who each cat was without needing color!! the animated bits and your style in general are also GORGEOUS!!! :D 💖 this is one of my favorite warriors amvs!!

[@peppermint-moss]

thank you soso much!!

[@shrircle_table]

I first saw this video over 2 years ago, but I still get happy every time I’m recommended it

[@chloeithsad]

poor hollyleaf was so preoccupied with stress and worry abt everything going on her life, she didn't fully realize what she had done until it was too late(killing ash), which made everything worse for her. it's cool how you portrayed that.

[@MudshadowYT]

oh my GOD I love everything about this, your movement and transitions are so amazing.... I love how your cats look theyre simple and yet so solid UGH I LOVE THIS I know Ill be watching and rewatching it for a long time coming!!!!

[@picklesocks8087]

"What did you do?" Holly leaf: *I killed someone!*

[@TheArgo_]

that was honestly an amazing. way of communicating hollyleaf’s confusion and conflicting feelings about herself and the prophecy. the ending gave me goosebumps!!

[@softpumpkinswirls1471]

I love how this shows absolutely EVERYTHING Hollyleaf went through! This is an amazing PMV!

[@shellyrose7123]

Ok, this is officially my favorite hollyleaf amv.

[@ChelShiChoo]

The symbolism in this AMV about Holly's story is BEAUTIFUL in every possible way. It's absolutely amazing, art art is wonderful, and the animation is absolutely fantastic! I especially love the detail you put into the scene where Ashfur is killed, as it is kind of a downwards spiral turning point for Holly. Godspeed!!!

[@ash3342]

The way you incorporated the lyrics into the scenes you were showing was absolutely astounding, and the expressions and transitions blew me away too! When the screen panned down to Ashfur's body during the line "What did you do?" I actually got goosebumps it hit me so hard. Amazing work!!!

[@peppermint-moss]

yess i really wanted to give ppl chills with ashfur's body reveal thats fantastic thank you!!

[@pioneer_ten]

@@peppermint-moss very late BUT I rarely ever feel much of a reaction to videos like these. I'll be like "oh, that's sad, sucks that he died." This video? Chills throughout the entire thing. I dont know what magic this is but it's one of the first times ive ever FELT something from an animation. Nice one.

[@hotdog2611]

Dang this actually made me cry a little bit. You showed more emotion and really focused on her whole life and downfall more then the books did. I adore this

[@NeatoDragons]

I LOVE how you included her not killing Sol. No one ever mentions that!

[@Artyskepty]

not gonna lie I have been watching this RELIGIOUSLY since I found it on Monday. this is such an amazing video, I couldn't possibly sing enough praises about it!!! i'm literally obsessed bro,, i've been sharing this around as much as I can and I sincerely hope it blows up!

[@TotallyNotAToastOrAnything]

I feel so bad for hollyleaf. She was overshadowed by her brothers amazing destiny and powers, while being convinced she was the third cat of the prophecy. Then, she was a disgrace to the warrior code (one of the MOST important things to her), and all of a sudden was forgotten about when she presumably "died" from the cave falling, only to realize she wasn't "important", since dovewing was the third cat afterall. Then she gets killed off (saving ivypool aka probably the only cat who feels the same as her) and was almost never bought up again.

[@brackenblaze6225]

3:50 to the end made me cry- you were able to show so much emotion with just black and white, why am i crying about some battle cats?

[@jaybvg]

it’s been almost a year and i still can’t stop watching this video at least twice a week. thank u so much for creating this hghh

[@mothercereal4438]

Oh sameee, I even have it downloaded in case the wifi is down!

[@Fas-n4d]

Yeeees holly leaf is my girl she is the best of the best I’m sorry I don’t care how many times you tell me jay feather is better

[@helpra]

Yeah same! It’s like- honestly the best one I’ve seen just like someone else said in the comments! It’s pretty cool :>

[@wrenpaw]

Bro this is by far my favourite Hollyleaf AMV! I love the aesthetic to it! I feel like this tells her story really well! ❤

[@redpanda2076]

I just want to say thank you, for not only creating this masterpiece, but for also introducing me to Sidney Gish. I first watched this amv years ago, and I still to this day find that your animation style paired with the music is perfect. Thank you, I had Sid on repeat for the year following me watching this, and every time I listen to Sin Triangle, your animation comes to mind. Thank you.

[@duckeatsrice]

OH MY LORD THIS IS SO GORGOUS!! ive never got why holly was never apart of the three, she never even died. the sadness and conflict is displayed so strongly, and the song matches everything perfectly!! love your art style!

[@ThatScruffyDuckling]

THIS IS AMAZING. THERE ARE SO MANY NICE SHOTS AND ITS GIVING ME SO MANY EMOTIONS AAAAAAAAAAA This has to be a new favourite pmv of mine

[@kahbob3791]

hi yes i am still coming back to this amv every month😐 you’re work is literally so inspiring, and ADDICTING TO WATCH. you’re ability to storytell and express emotion in your drawing is literally so crazy!! keep up the AMAZING work, also thank you for introducing me to sidney gish’s musiv

[@peppermint-moss]

thank you so much !!

[@roundestrow1et]

this introduced me to sidney gish who is now one of my all time fav artists thank youuu 😭😭😭😭😭

[@stupidcatschningle]

I’ve seen this video so many times over the course of like. Three years and ive got to say its my all time favorite warriors amv. Like this song has been my favorite since i first heard it from this video, not to mention this video is so well made and cool. This thing has literally inspired me so much i cannot express with words how much i love this amv

[@peppermint-moss]

thank you!! its also one of my favs haha so I'm really glad you like it so much ;w;

[@OrqinusOrca]

HI I'M THREE YEARS LATE BUT HOLY FREAKIN MOLY If I could describe to you the absolute CHILLS I had throughout in words I would. This is amazing.

[@mixedberry_juicebox]

helped me discover one of my new favorite songs

[@honeycombpersonalacc4563]

This is the most expressive AMV I’ve ever seen! I love the speech bubbles and the dynamic animation

[@allhailthesnail5017]

I only just saw this amv and it's a fantastic watch ! Definitely one of the more unique holly leaf videos (and there are a lot of them). I love how you show her gradual isolation from her family and clan, (all the symbols in the speech bubbles r rly clever) I like how you show how much of her life was revolved around her family and how not being able to relate to her brothers importance really got to her. A lot of holly leaf content kinda misses the mark and only shows "holly leaf magically kills Ashfur in rage wow she's CrAzy" this Amv really explores how complex her character was and how her killing ashfur wasnt the main part of her story but the "tipping point"

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!!!

[@katkitters]

every time you post smth w sidney gish's songs it makes me so happy, this amv is GORGEOUS and amazingly done, i cant stop watching it !!

[@awayforever3469]

when she attacks hawkfrost gave me CHILLS this amv has to be the best hollyleaf amv ever. i like the speech bubbles too!

[@dragonfan3934]

This honestly never fails to make me cry

[@tigerscar7008]

I used to not care much for hollyleaf because why would she kill ashfur but also reveal the secret, but than I watched this and I feel like I understand her character way better now. You did such a great job!

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!

[@VixenLovelove]

This is absolute perfection. The flow is so smooth and in sync with the music. There’s so many pictures and they’re all drawn so beautifully. Defiantly going to be revisiting this one a lot cause its fantastic and beautiful just like you!

[@Pinkstarclan]

still my favorite warriors amv, period. made me go from liking to LOVING hollyleaf. it's the perfect summary of her story, really. encapsulating and creative. genius. i cant stop watching this. i rp'd a crossover with a friend unfamiliar with warriors recently, sent this to them as a sum-up for holly's character. excellent. amazing. my guy god damn

[@Stormwolf4]

Your expressions and transitions are just out of this world! There was so many great expressions, but I think one of my favorites is just the reactions Brambleclaw had to knowing he had kits. It's such a pure combination of surprise and love! But the way you draw sadness and shock is also so great!! 3:11 and onwards, there was SO MANY great expressions there, you really feel for all these cats, its so great!! Like, it brings tears to my eyes when you show everyone reacting to Hollyleaf's death!

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!! expressions are my fav to draw im so glad you liked em!!

[@lursauu]

THIS IS ONE OF MY FAV HOLLYLEAF ANIMATIONS EVER??? i love how you put in significant events in her life that people usually forget about, the song lyrics fit her and the events perfectly, the art style is really great for the song and the feel, and i especially love that shot that pans down to her over ashfur, really 10/10!!!!

[@Hickorypaws]

one thing I love about this song is how it paints a picture that your personality is something you control and it controls you but not a part of you idk I just think it’s cool

[@Doodlecrisp]

I never like Hollyleaf that much ( only because I liked Ashfur ) but this makes me see her in a different light. Also your art style is incredible and has inspired me to try and draw more!

[@Elkemistical]

OH. OH THIS IS GOOD. You really went off with this, i cannot lie. The song fits so well with Hollyleaf, and the way you conveyed it?? mwAH. Literally amazing. 10/10.

[@elm-ishh5718]

I love your AMVs/Animatics SO MUCH “She Wants Me (To be Loved)” is always always gonna be my favorite but this is a close second

[@micaiahborchers8914]

OMG this is so good??? how???? the power you have I- the whole thematic style and aesthetic of this amv is immaculate

[@emmagrenz321]

i love this so much, the song fits her so nicely and the art is AMAZING especially when you show the parts that most animators don't like how her brothers were doubtful about sol but she was desperate for answers and how she was unsure about what her power was and really wanted to know and how she struggled to be a medicine cat apprentice but was more skilled with battle moves, and the part when she was sad and Fallen Leaves was behind her looking concerned and ESPECIALLY the part where she came back and they were all calling her name out of surprise and jooooy and all the different emotions and how she became a star higher than the others...

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!!

[@Ivy-Tellers]

1:13 this is the best frame of all lmao

[@fireworkcat25]

i just found this amv and holy SHIT by GOD this is SO COOL...ive been listening to this song for the past few days and i love this video SO much!!! you included a lot of parts in the books that i dont see a lot of other warriors amvs include that often!!! its just so lovely to watch !!!!

[@peppermint-moss]

thank you!!

[@miffie.]

I have watched this amv more times than I can count.. it has been on loop for a while I love it SO MUCH!! thank you peppermint moss for creating this masterpiece!

[@parker9095]

the way i have watched this at least a dozen times in the past few days since finding this video,,,,,,, and the way i fall deeper in love with it each viewing.......

[@peppermint-moss]

ty!!

[@doctordd-ey]

Thank you for introducing me to a new artist and also this AMAZIGN pmv omg

[@dr.redactedkondraki463]

i hope you know how much this amv means to me

[@spiki7234]

Omg this did not disappoint! I live your art style and the song fit it perfectly! Amazing!

[@soap-plant-guy]

Oh my god this amv is 2 years old. Holy cow. Hi this is still my favorite (along with twewgmo because the. the detail you put in that one. oh my god. every time i think about how its not your top video i get mad /lh) and i just wanted to say that i freaking LOVE the camera shake at the end when she falls after being wounded. I still havent read the books but I've osmosissed the vague plot points from videos about power of 3 and while i still don't know what's going on with sol, you portrayed the whole "wait if im not in the prophecy but my brothers are where do i go? :(((" feelings REALLY well!!!!! The ending still KILLS me and seeing the deathberries scene after watching Fine, Great is just. wow. Her face. Like her face both in the den and when she's talking to the starclan cat. Perfect. Could not be better omg

[@peppermint-moss]

!! tysm!!!

[@soap-plant-guy]

oh my g o d I don't even know who these characters are (yet! I'm gonna read the series asap) and the pure r a w emotional bits in the last half still really hit me. You did a phenomenal job on this, I'm inspired by it! I love the song as well, I'm gonna give that a listen :D Btw how did you make this? It looks like it was made with a square/rectangular brush but I'm not sure

[@peppermint-moss]

its some kind of brush in photoshop?? it seems to be titled "oil heavy flow dry edges" fjkdsl idk i tried it one day and it just looked nice so now i use it lots

[@soap-plant-guy]

@@peppermint-moss Hmm okay! I don't have photoshop but I'm sure I can find something similar, thank you! ^^

[@helpra]

When tell you at that one part with the triangle of three stars (showing the lion representing Lionblaze, the dove representing Dovewing and the blue jay representing Jayfeather, also representing the three prophecy cats) is amazing, I mean it! It’s just so cool! Hollyleaf looking up and seeing those three stars is just- AGAGAGAGA

[@Cherivinca]

Ooooh MAN this is SO GOOD I really like the black/white stylistic choice and the part with the eclipse was really cool!! The song choice worked really well with how you portrayed Holly's story too, awesome!

[@Siji-j4h]

This amv looks so cool! You did a really great job on this!!!!!!!

[@suns..moon.]

3:07 "what did you do..?" IM SCREAMING the way you portrayed this is wonderful!! when first reading PO3, i didn't really like how hollyleaf got so angry, and didn't really understand her character. but now, i realize there is so much more to her! great job animation + drawing! i love the way this amv came out, even if im 3 years late :)

[@FISHSOCKS]

IM IN LOVE W THIS god the storytelling is so good and the style you chose for this works so well I adore it so much,,,,???? the character acting I'm screaminggg 😳😳 this is so underrated I'm so mad I hope it gets all the love it deserves!!

[@norrieslibrary]

holy shit after a while of perusing animatics i was so pleasantly surprised to find one that was so... fluid and clever with how it showed its story!!!! hollyleafs story!!! aaah :]

[@etourvol]

this is AWESOME... beautiful symbolism and a really fitting art style with the music, i love this SO much! Everything flows so nicely too

[@GriffynTheDragon]

you, amazing artist dear, are a MASTER of expressions. Seriously, ive been rewatching ur amvs for-- a month?? yeesh time flies-- and ur cats just evoke SO MUCH EMOTION in me by BEING SO DAMN EMOTIONAL themselves and their dramas and tears come across as very earnest and real and just??? yes???? love ur styles and the naratives u choose to animate, ur very good at making stuff easy to read and sensible-- i learned more abt hollyleaf in this than when i read the dang series so !!! much appreciated content, have a nice day!!!

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!!

[@MangoMoose16]

Ok, but this is the best Hollyleaf AMV I've ever seen, and I love it when her star in the sky shines so brightly around the others!!!👍P.S=My favorite part is probably at 1:41!

[@nothinpurrsonal]

I love this PMV so much! Thank you for introducing me to this song!

[@valectronica1812]

Thank you. This is one of my favorite animations, if not works of art, of all time. I come back to it every few months and each time am just stunned by the quality of the animation, and by the care and emotion, that you put into it.

[@crumblyairship]

yeah i've watched this like twenty times and every time i realize something new, i love this amv

[@noiraut9972]

You literally make the best amv I've ever seen, awesome song choices and awesome style, never get enough of those keep up the great work!

[@luna_emlm2970]

THIS IS AMAZING!! I LOVE YOUR ART STYLE OMG!!

[@sproutz5014]

hi. i havent watched this in like a year or two but youtube randomly re-recommended it to me and im crying holy shit it's still so good

[@kcsroyalpythons8249]

OMG. Your use of monochrome color, the expressions, how in beat it is with the music- I keep coming back to rewatch your animations cause DAYUM, they are AMAMAZING.

[@pawbcat8654]

commenting again because i CANT STOP WATCHING THIS!!! it just captures what i love of hollyleaf so well, and makes me so emotional. absolutely beautifully done!

[@LightningStrike0KAR]

just watched this twice and it brought me to tears both times!! I had to hold in an actual goddamn SOB over here! seriously amazing work, thanks for sharing this. and the song really fits too.

[@claireb5499]

I just- fuck, i absolutely adore this. I haven't seen anyone address this yet, but the expressions were PERFECT. It's difficult to convey emotions through lineart alone, and you pulled it off fantastically. The devastation, love, panic, fear, sadness, surprise, anger, it's all there and so well done. I kept pausing just to look at the faces!

[@amarylily]

NO I'M NOT CRYYING,,,,IM SOBBING JUST INCREDIBLE GOSH I LOVE THE SYMBOLS AND HOW WELL THIS FITS WITH THE SONG AAAA

[@blumax1969]

4:13 sooooo sweet im crying🥺🥺🥺🥺

[@acacti]

U are the best I’ve ever seen if anyone said otherwise they are wrong you inspired me to make animations myself and I realized how hard it is but you are still so freaking good I just wanted to say that I love your videos they have an amazing meaning and they hate us should f### themselves

[@glitchsage8633]

I CANT STOP WATCHING THIS…. THE ANIMATION, THE SONG, THE THEME, THE CHARACTER, YOU FIT THIS SO WELL HONESTLY I PROBABLY COMMENTED SOMETHING SIMILAR ALREADY BUT

[@tracyaustin2129]

This is amazing. The artstyle the animation the song EVERYTHING IS GOOD!!! Especially the while to black with the eclipse is just too good!

[@TRISKELKION]

I've never cried so much to an AMV about silly cats in a forest fighting each other. For real though, this is absolutely amazing. I'm sad and surprised that you're not more well known among the Warriors community. You deserve more views, subscribers and recognition!

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!!

[@TRISKELKION]

@@peppermint-moss No problem, can't wait to see more of your work!!

[@dogsocks252]

That was...I can't even get the words to describe it! The song fits so well, and it's not like all the other generic Hollyleaf stuff! Using black, white, and some grey, you made this more impressive than stuff I've seen in color! I'm 100% subscribing to see all the wonderful content that's next!

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!!

[@lokiwarriorcat6167]

Holy shit I'm about to dive right back into this fandom. I haven't read a Warrior Cats book in years and I'm so behind but damn this video made me remember how much I loved it. Hollyleaf was always one of my favorite characters and it's horrible how she was pushed to the side like that. Also just amazing work on this amv it was killer dude

[@fareclipsinq]

Thank you, you finally made me like Hollyleaf. I do not like the way she is written, but what she could've been and how you've portrayed her I love.

[@tokiia_]

ive watched this soo many times and i still feel like i wanna cry everytime i do. i love this so so much.

[@cookiecat8758]

Omg this is beautiful!! I love your art style and how it switches to black and white! The animation is stunning and it flows so well!! This is awesome :3

[@sarahtrujillo5751]

how is it so good holy frick. Love this song, glad it got its own amv

[@anngreen5845]

Me sitting here re whatching this 4 like an hour bc it’s just like so amazing 🤩

[@mqsstars1503]

This map is amazing! Can't express how much I love it. The simple black and white theme is amazing. But also how does the song go SO well with it? It's like as if it was made for this lol. Stunning job, all your maps are absolutely amazing! Keep up the good work! Like one of the comments said, ADORE IT!

[@mono414]

“Therefore I never lie” Well… after the Gathering, that’s certainly true Jokes aside, this is SUPERB!! AWESOME WORK OF ART DUDE, GREAT JOB!

[@saramclain1567]

I loved how you let Hollyleaf add a star at the end. That was beautiful

[@claireb5499]

hhhhholy shIT THE ANIMATION ON THIS. I was absolutely BLOWN AWAY by how good this is!!!

[@subtleshenanigans5983]

Dude this is absolutely GORGEOUS. And I feel it captures Hollyleaf and all she went through wonderfully. Thank you for sharing.

[@camelliasalazar]

Man, everytime I watch your animations I notice how clever they are with the stories and characters. That's cool, the animations are cool, and you're cool, too! Also you find the best songs for each character/animation, I love to listen to them now! The songs are so good! Most of them are my favorite songs, like TOWGMO and She Wants me (to be loved)! I love those songs now because I found them from your animations! You are my favorite animator of the whole warriors fandom and I will always watch your animations. Even if I don't comment on them, I still love them and I love the hard work you put into these, I appreciate your hard work. (I get it since I'm an animator, too.) Sorry this comment is longer than I wanted to, just want you to know that I love you and your animations. Can't wait to see more! :3

[@peppermint-moss]

tysm!!

[@camelliasalazar]

@@peppermint-moss np at all! Just keep being a star. ⭐♥️✨

[@KROOK_WCUE1]

IM SORRY THE HEARTS MADE ME CRY AT 4:15

[@maple5228]

this song!! the animation!! the way you incorporated the lyrics!!! *chef's kiss*

[@frostipineappls]

this is brilliant! i love the style, the expressions and emotions and the lyrics fit perfectly! this is so great, probably my favourite pmv!

[@smirsfailurez]

To be honest.. I use to really dislike Holly leaf, however when how I use to read was by skimming over alot of important details, so this really put some perspective on hollyleaf and now that I look back I find amazing things from hollyleaf and I really enjoy this animation

[@helixtheraptor9374]

I love this,I’ll never gonna get tired of it, it’s to pretty.