smash or pass bookish edition ep. 2 with

[@Cubehead27]

Carolyn's complete incredulity whenever Emma disagrees with her is way too funny 😆

[@brandonmoles]

What I got out of this is that Emmie highly values intelligence and sophisticated charm.

[@rowanjoy419]

sometimes even murders, I mean Carolyn too, but Emmie say smash to Ramsay bolton, she was probably joking but I can recover from that hhahahahaha and don't blame Carolyn if she does recover too.

[@brightlights956]

Passing on Peeta is genuinely crazy i understood Carolyn's reaction on that one lol

[@madisonbourret4597]

I feel like I barely paid attention to him throughout the story lol

[@em_mmeow]

i would never ever ever pass on peeta

[@july3817]

nah I have to agree with Emma on this one I kinda hated Peeta

[@kathhqq7]

He is so boring

[@skhariling]

Hopefully this whole cascade of collaborative content is annual ❤️❤️

[@nissasbookcorner]

“yeah but he’s obsessed with industrialism” i never thought i’d hear that sentenced uttered about toad of all things

[@hobbyjournals]

Omg the ending bit is killing me 😭 Carolyn is totally thinking of the original by Tracy Chapman whereas Emma is thinking of the Luke Combs cover 💀

[@chloanthite]

Ohhh ok this clarified it. I was so confused how Tracy Chapman would be considered country lolol

[@CarolynMarieReads]

THE THEME SONG!!! I love it 🥹

[@anitas5817]

This had me laughing for 30 minutes. Thank you. Love you both ❤️

[@hyemiyah]

i love how much fun you and carolyn seem to have every time you're together

[@isibellee]

At least you guys will never have to fight over any man :D You should definitely re-read the Hunger Games btw! It's one of the few YA Series that actually holds up and maybe you won't hate the ending so much this time I feel like it was really fitting for her character and the messages about war.

[@my_19th_personality]

littlefinger is a definite smash. but i loved at carolyns presentation of him 😂

[@sj3530]

I easily fall for morally grey characters. They make things complicated and feel like they actually have character and depth. I loved this video. It's really genuine and fun.

[@gretab211]

Omg, Emma I totally agree with you😂 Had a crush on Gale the first time I saw the first film and read the book, never really liked Peeta and wish they wouldn’t have ended up together😂 Great video, love to you guys 🥰

[@Heymsbrightside]

So funny! Loved pass or smash. Never thought I’d see you two in the same room instead of shared screen like in the old days. How fun!!!

[@none8680]

I got you Emmie, little finger *IS* a smash.

[@Clubsandwich2]

Hope they do a classics ranking vid together

[@VictorAugustus]

Both living the meme "what murda?" haha

[@nannybells]

the way carolyn just crushes on the actors 🤭

[@collagecult]

I love that you started out with Holden caulfield- I was NOT expecting that! First thing I thought was, isn’t he a kid?? 😅

[@fandomshark]

The thing that gets me about that is that Peeta is also supposed to be 16 I think, but that never came up for him.

[@july3817]

@@fandomshark well at least he isn't 16 in the movies (the actor isn't) and they said that it's been some time since they read it/never read it in the first place so they probably didn't remember

[@ELPages]

OMG yes, I can completely understand being attracted to someone because of their voice. Happens to me too! It's called auralism and can make explaining why you're attracted to someone quite complicated XD

[@Emmareads]

Littlefinger and Theon Greyjoy is smash material 😂

[@kathhqq7]

Book version Theon is unironically the best character in that series

[@ipshitajee]

Not Emma telling Alexsey to shut up in the ball😂 Lmao in the intermission 😂😂😂 Rolling on the bed about little fingers 24:14 Pedro Pascal SHOULD BE INCLUDED HERE from GOT

[@willadkins1354]

This video truly is a modern Sense and Sensibility.

[@neoneko280]

the peeta section...so much chaos i love it 😂

[@doreene11]

I agree with Emma on Littlefinger 😅. Also, I met the actor in a Dublin pub in 2016, he is super nice, he even asked me if I want him with the hat or without it (he had one, he was about to live), in the photo 😊.

[@elysianemily]

Emmie's opinions about Littlefinger are so valid and I think she should say them (however, I pretend to not hear the whole Peeta debacle)

[@chuucake]

omg i love this >< the presentation too!!

[@caerrie]

Emma, you are so valid, I agreed on almost every turn. When Littlefinger came up, I *did* almost spit out my tea tho. I completely get it, but I could see the huge disagreement a mile off and it was so funny

[@FranFellow731]

The end bit with Fast Car really shows the difference between you two and what you pay attention to also 😂

[@Lyleelou11]

This music and editing was everything

[@lila3618]

Ma'am Vronsky is an instant smash 😌

[@circleofleaves_zigzag]

Nooooooo!!! There were supposed to be women on this year's list for Emma!

[@xxzcfdxc]

We are too old for Leo 😂😂😂😂😂

[@DianaWodnoff]

"as in like a corpse??" hahahaha

[@KerryAnnGL]

Will stare longingly in your direction “I don’t wan’t to be witnessed”

[@atticusmasselink]

Emma not being Team Peeta had me on the verge of leaving

[@xxzcfdxc]

He says a lot of God damn things 😂😂😂😂 the pun

[@baxtermaxtor]

23:09 I hope she said "I see the prose" as rebuke

[@sjmsutherland]

This made me giggle so much!! Calcifer wanted to join in, obviously!!! Another fun and funny video!!xxx

[@nissasbookcorner]

NOT THE PEETA GAIL DEBATE OMG. 😭😭😭😭 i was a peeta STAN

[@leonasindlerova1727]

I mean Littlefinger is basically Heathcliff, of course he's a smash 🤣

[@treeforged9097]

Heathcliff dug up his lovers grave after she had been dead for a year and sleeped in her coffin with her decomposed corpse. He then abused his child because he reminded him of his wife that he hated. You girls are insane this is why domestic violence is so common. Men are trying to be the opposite of what you want, men need to just be dangerous degenerates to appeal to you guys.

[@neshkavirdure8289]

🤣🤣🤣On Heathcliff and Jay Gatsby Bit😊 and Calcifer🤣🤣🤣😊Thank You So Much For Posting This📚😊

[@pendragon2012]

LOL, you two are amazing! P.S. Poor Toad--according to the book, "He was indeed an altered toad."

[@loulelou]

Emma passing on Peeta! I can't believe it ohmygod

[@kimbarbeaureads]

Emma likes the bad ones.

[@bookoffholicbookwart5945]

This video is giving bamboozled vibes😅😂😂😂

[@Taylor1998taylor]

Thanks for posting!❤

[@victoriah.2083]

EM? NO SHAKESPEARE ADAPTATIONS? GET THE PADDLES! CODE BLUE! I'M SLIPPING!😮 You both gotta see 👀: "Hamlet" (Kenneth Branagh). He directed & starred- full length version. Compare w Olivier's performance (Oscar winning). RECHARGE PADDLES!

[@ReadingNymph]

I loved the GOT bonus round 😂😂

[@hannahandherstories]

I feel like The Night King and his army are supposed to represent the slow, inevitable march toward death. Fine at surface level for the existentialism, but not that compelling for a villain.

[@megbern2416]

okay but ramin karimloo who played the phantom in the 25th anniversary??? i'd smash, none of this butler nonsense edit: carolyn's face as the camera went down omg lmao

[@chloanthite]

I'd smash Butler's phantom as long as he doesn't sing ever lmao

[@megbern2416]

@@chloanthite fair point 🤣

[@sofiaborges3853]

Such a fun video, Emma’s choices were a bit strange overall but still TOTALLY AGREE WITH LITTLEFINGER idk what it is but I get it 😅😅😅😅

[@jackiesliterarycorner]

This is too funny. You guys are adorable.

[@denisefreitas6727]

I loved the vídeo! Emma passed almost everybody Carolyn smashed! But Calcifer stole the show! 🐱😻😅

[@e.milija]

I LOVE YOU TWOO💞💞

[@indigo92099]

omg this was hilarious, I was laughing tears!

[@readknitwithcheryl]

Carolyn, I am old enough to remember Leonoardo Dicaprio when he was a young teen in Growing Pains, the tv show with Kirk Cameron. Kirk was my first celebrity crush, but Leo became my close second once he guest starred on the show.

[@emilyreads5207]

I am with you!

[@nocturnal.literati]

love this so much! me passing on all of them but 2 😂

[@Bribri-us9yh]

The ending was unexpected😲!

[@yoshimitsu4]

16:57 the crime of not using Lon Chaney to represent Erik

[@nannybells]

i'm fully on emma's side here tbh i get her

[@MsGloomyLamp]

Littlefinger is a total smash, I'm with you, Emma.

[@wnctube1]

Fun romantic millionaire Gatsby (DiCaprio), pass...murderer Macbeth, smash 😂😂

[@AnaluzMarinho]

I love you both together 😅

[@pageturner242]

emma you are such a contrarian

[@charlesspringer4709]

Smart girls and crafting! This could be a double date from The Hardy Boys or Tom Swift Jr.

[@Blondie101010100]

I'm with you Emma, smashing the same guys.😁 Love Aidan Gillen 😍

[@moonflower1616]

I was exactly the 1000th like on this video. Also, I laughed like hell. I have loved all these videos with you two. XDD ❤️ 💙 💜 💖

[@markkenney6806]

I agree with Emmie. I preferred Gale way more than Peeta. I couldn't stand Peeta at all 😆

[@xxzcfdxc]

Liam is so hot 😂

[@kathhqq7]

Peeta’s main issue is having no personality

[@hhenze322]

You guys should do a smash/ pass Shakespeare edition

[@anitas5817]

Gatsby - Redford - smash!!

[@juanhernestogomez433]

"hard smash" lol

[@WolfishMagic]

i was a peeta hater. his entire personality is im clingy for a girl who doesnt even look at me. thats cringe not sexy. them getting together when they had 0 chemistry was wild. Gale got done dirty

[@KMort]

I am surprisingly agreeing w both. Cause yeah, sometimes hot is hot. But I am a voice girlie, I really am. If I like the voice, that's it😭

[@siobhan110]

8:02 😭

[@bethmw28]

Gale is a big no for me 😂 but i hard agree with the Jon Snow pass!

[@mjd9931]

You two are so adorable ☺💝

[@celescoles]

I mostly agreed with Carolyn's taste but I would smash Littlefinger. I do understand you Emma.

[@newbooksmell9221]

this was just so much fun ❤

[@jacquelinelopez5220]

Littlefinger is definitely smash!

[@nicolemiller8883]

I agree with Emma.

[@kathy2539]

Agree with Emma on Peeta and Carolyn on Jon Snow. This was so funny and love you to do these again, often.

[@nikolaiquack8548]

I feel like Jorah Mormont and Tyrion Lannister are only smashable in the in the show tbh. The books describe them as being waaaaay less attractive, both as people and physically.

[@mawley3266]

Where are the women .-. I thought Emma was bi but I might be confusing her with someone else

[@circleofleaves_zigzag]

I was looking forward to women being on the list for Emma this year. Last year, Emma said to Carolyn "are there any women on here?" and when Carolyn said "should I have put women on here?" Emma mouthed "yes" emphatically at the camera.

[@cosmicteatime]

Vronsky ❤

[@maiasolaris3255]

22:50 I am... baffled

[@chelseaseashell22]

I support the Littlefinger crush Emma. I won't lie, some of your opinions were a little crazy, but this wasn't one of them

[@r.l.3316]

My best friend and I have the same debate about Littlefinger lol. For the record, I'm with Carolyn :)

[@StavrosGaredakis]

funny thing, as I'm a straight man, but I do agree Littlefinger is hot as f.

[@eryngr1992]

the actor who plays Littlefinger IS hot as fuck!

[@MB-hc9tk]

That was so fun!😂 Emma I’m with you all the way with Aidan Gillan and Liam Neeson , not with you on leonardo because I’d definitely smashhhhh jay gatsby. Hmmm 🤔 Don’t know whether you’d change your mind about Aidan if you saw him as the bad guy in the Irish Tv series Love/Hate BUT probably not 🤣 yeah he’s a ride as we Irish say lol

[@tinagarcia3571]

So funny but yes Tyrion so smash, yes Jon Snow is dumb. LOL!

[@carolines416]

Emma needs to watch Who Is Eating Gilbert Grape. I guarantee she will change her mind about Leonardo!

[@lunaginebra]

Carolyn is dangerously close to being CANCELLED lmao

[@tiffanyanne7861]

Okay but I understand littlefinger lolol. I’m not proud of it but I understand.

[@stopbeingana-hole4151]

I’m dying 😂😂😭

[@maiasolaris3255]

16:04 SMASH hahahhaha

[@InsidiouSTomaz]

Calcifer ftw!

[@cassylk22]

yeah emma definitely has better taste in men ngl 🤣

[@ernabro2723]

I was with Emma until Littlefinger lmaooooo

[@AdrianasWonderland]

i would die for jorah