Smith & Wesson 586-8 4” review

[@kevinwilson9589]

That is indeed a beautiful finish. As a hand loader, and the older I get, and the more painful it is to pick up brass, the more the .357 becomes my favorite caliber. My favorite "baby" is a 5" model 27-2 I added a set of "Coke Bottle" target stocks that I picked up at a gun show years ago, along with an old Smith & Wesson wood box, and I enjoy looking at her almost as much as time at the range. My pet load of 5.5 gr. Unique over a Lee mold cast 158 gr. LSWC sized to .358 is very accurate in my revolvers, and rifles. Hits harder than .38 special, yet mild enough to get many loads per case. I hope to one day save up for a Henry lever action when they add the loading gate to the .357. Right now have an IMI Timberwolf, and a Ruger 77/.357 rifle. Incidentally, thanks for your endshake video. I put one .002 shim in my model 27-2, and is now perfect!

[@steveharvey6421]

funny you said you hated picking up brass the same week I am picking up a 586 because I hate picking up brass. Growing old changes you.

[@silverhorder1969]

Nothing like a blued steel revolver and a leather holster that just beats the pants off of a polymer semi auto with a plastic holster..

[@patrickslevin6424]

It does, right up until you have to use it.

@@patrickslevin6424 - Sure ... a .357 will shoot through an engine block. A 9 mm will bounce off windshields.

[@199gonzo]

Exactly!!!!

[@Chris-yy5pj]

@ 357 won't shoot through a engine block. That's a myth. Even 44 won't. Even 50 AE won't. It definitely will go deep but unless it's a little 2 cylinder or straight six it won't happen. Most large rifle rounds like 45-70 or 450bm won't even go through.

[@disco4535]

@ Lmao. Take a class instead of getting trained by Hollywood. 9mm doesn't bounce off windshields, whether shot from inside or out. It does however, change the trajectory of the bullet, just like it does with .357 If you're looking to have soething pretty get a revolver or 1911. If you're looking for the ideal sidearm, go with a "plastic" one. I shoot and love them all

[@ccl198888]

I have an origional 586 no dash, 6" nickle plated S&W I picked up at a shop for 400.00, it is a sweet shooting gun, love the classic line that S&W is putting out, bringing back the guns that made them great.

[@stevenhall9762]

When I was a USAF Security Policeman (66-70) we carried the Smith & Wesson Combat Masterpiece. I liked the weapon itself, but did not like the small (short) handgrip. I do not have large hands but when the small, stock walnut grip got wet (which it did often in the monsoon rains) it was slippery and difficult to keep in my hand. Years later, when I decided to buy a handgun I looked at the automatic pistols, but just wasn't comfortable with them. The simplicity of the revolver appealed to me even though it held only six rounds. I decided to stay with a revolver and chose the brand that I was familiar with, S&W. I purchased the 586 and even though I really love the beauty of the walnut grips, I switched them out right away for the Hogue rubber grips. They are not as thick as the walnut grips so my hands wrap around the Hogue grips much better resulting in more control, especially when firing double action with 357 magnum rounds.

[@jimmyjohnson6232]

This channel is fast approaching becoming my favorite gun channel

[@edwardpetty5401]

I love the older Smiths, but I would be proud to own this beauty!

[@jbloun911]

Original 19-3 and this bad boy

[@jardinero9112]

What a beautiful handgun. It has Americana written all over it. Thats like apple pie and Chevrolet. Thanks for sharing that video and enjoy that beautiful Smith and Wesson.....

[@drdrake63]

Gman 5445 Doing my part to make America great again!

[@crackerjack8115]

Not anymore man

[@C5Z06CarGuy]

I was dead set on a GP100 walking into the gun store, and like you, I walked out with a 4" S&W 586 Distinguished Combat Magnum.

[@drdrake63]

The 586 is so much sexier than any Ruger in my opinion

[@gracom1977]

I went to the local gun store to buy gun cleaner and ended up buying a S&W 686 haha

[@assfacetheclown29]

Congrats, bet you are way happier. 686/586 blows Rutgers out of the water, and unlike the new colt pythons, actually function!

[@Zona-dw9rp]

You made the better choice. I have a GP100 and a 586, and the 586 is better. Enjoy!

[@totljag1]

U should have got the GP100 , way better trigger and no Hillary hole 🔐

[@dmgthree6051]

BEAUTIFUL !! JUST PICKED UP HER LITTLE SISTER THE MODEL 19 CLASSIC TODAY , I WRESTLED BETWEEN THE 586 AND 19 FOR A HALF AN HOUR BEFORE I CHOSE , BOTH GREAT CHOICES !!!!!I THOUGHT THE TRIGGERS WOULD NOT BE AS NICE AS THE OLD ONES BUT THAT IS NOT THE CASE AT ALL , THESE ARE EVERY BIT AS NICE AS THE OLD ONES , I OWN A 1974 MODEL 66 NO DASH AND A 19-3 . THESE CLASSIC SERIOUS ROCK , AND I DONT HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT CRACKING THE FORCING CONES + 100% WARRANTY

[@johndgurk9160]

Hey David, this video inspired me to order a brand new 586 from my dealer. Surprisingly, the first one that came in had a few noticeable blems including a scratched barrel. My dealer ordered me a second and I'm pleased to say its just about perfect. An absolute work of art. Mine came through with exceptionally dark grips...just beautiful! Thanks foe the great content!

[@drdrake63]

You are most welcome! Thanks for watching. Hope you enjoy that 586

[@SAVAGE308SNIPER]

Very beautiful blued finish.

[@briancaine9130]

Great review. I appreciate all the close up angles including looking at the top of the revolver and thru the rear sight. Most videos completely disregard this. I have the 686 4” and am still getting used to it.

[@Elvis68spec]

I have an old 686, 6 inch ( NO HILARY HOLE! ) that I absolutely, love!

[@Eclispestar]

Took mine to the range the other day. Put 100 rounds of 38 special. So easy to shoot. Cleaning it up was easy. Like he said not much recoil. I even put 37 mag critical defense rounds through it. Big fire ball from those but still easy to control. Amazing gun.

[@daspiper8941]

~I own a 4-inch 586-8 that I bought new in 2016. I am so much in love with this handgun. Her Bluing is deep and is as beautiful as any Colt Python. Right now she's wearing Faux Ivory Grips from Altamont. ~My 586 rides with me in a Diamond D Guide's Choice™ Leather Chest Holster. She loves it. ~My Hartford Clone of Colt's SAA is in the .45 Cal Long Colt as she should be, IMO. ~Triple K for being inexpensive makes some very nice holsters.

[@johninphx9360]

I was dead set on the GP 100 as well ..... After looking ....and looking ....and looking, I came across this 586 classic at buds this morning and I bought it on the spot!!! as of march 2021 double action revolvers are in short supply, much less good ones. At this point in history just finding a high quality revolver is harder then finding the ammo to shoot it! Thanks for sharing!

[@JB-cs4jt]

How'd that 586 working out?

[@johninphx9360]

@J B Depends on how u look at it. I liked it so much I also bought a 2.5 inch 686+....Over time, it has slowly bothered me that the two don't match, and I am currently thinking of trading it for a 4 inch 686 + just to Mach my chubby snubby. 😀

[@JB-cs4jt]

@@johninphx9360 but mechanically has the 586 had any problems,?

[@johninphx9360]

@J B none. It has slicked up to as nice and smooth as any gunsmith could make it. It's seen close to 1k rounds of light reloads with zero issues and is better now then when I bought it.

[@JB-cs4jt]

@@johninphx9360 nice I'm sold gotta get one thank you for your info.

[@alanblasczyk1779]

Absolutely Gorgeous Dave! I own a 6" SST GP-100 and it is almost 40 years old. I call it old faithful. A wonderful weapon. It will never leave my collection.

[@199gonzo]

Yup ! Got the same one still makes me moist every time I open up my safe !!! Bought it last year .my local shop ordered mine ,and 4 more for shits n giggles..... he sold them all in two days

[@noahgaray7923]

Double live Gonzo awesome then he’ll probably get more. Stock the shelves with speed loaders as well

[@199gonzo]

Noah Garay absolutely!

[@Chris-yy5pj]

If it makes you moist you should probably get checked out!

[@libtardhunter2880]

Picked up a very good condition 586-3 a few years ago and I'm so glad that I did.

[@bobclifton8021]

I agree with you! A blued gun is the only kind to own. It's even better when it's an S&W blued gun.

[@jimmysapien9961]

Of Coors 👍🏻

[@MTL_Rider]

I have this model in the 6 " barrel and have only shot it once. I can say it is the most accurate pistol I have shot as the recoil is unbelievable manageable. I am thinking of selling but I know I will regret it if I ever do as it's in perfect condition. I think It's one of the most beautiful revolvers ever built.

[@Zona-dw9rp]

Don't sell it!

[@OscarDad]

do you still have this ? interested in it if so. tnx

[@MTL_Rider]

@@OscarDad No sorry

[@OscarDad]

Robert Petrone thank you for your reply 👍 Take care

[@kendo4242]

Hickock 45 called these new models "an abomination" because of the changes from the original iterations, however there is a detailed review here on YT by an older gentleman who is an expert gunsmith. Worked on the original models for leo for many years. Completely disassembled this new model, and explained in detail why these new models are an improvement in many ways over the original models. You can find if you look for it. This will be my next gun purchase, so classic.

[@chrisnedbalek2866]

I've just never been able to join the hickok fan club. I've watched & watched & never could figure out the attraction. Everybody else's mileage seems to vary from mine.

[@totljag1]

They are an abomination 🤮that Hillary hole with an arrow telling u what way to turn the key 😂😂😂 I like the older smiths way way way better , especially the old bluing

[@jimmysapien9961]

@@chrisnedbalek2866he’s great But So are Many others

[@chrisnedbalek2866]

@@jimmysapien9961 that's my point. Others are great, like Paul Harrell. Hickok is just OK, no comparison to Harrell, or even say, Banana Ballistics.

[@BobbyFiermonti]

Hickok is a wannabe gene hackman. Boring. Says nothing about the firearms that bear any importance. Just watching an old guy shoot a gong. Woah whoo basil 🤓

[@johnvillafranca6188]

Love the vid. I'm also a .357 mag man. Got 6 S&W Pro Series and Performance Center revolvers. Can't beat it.

[@regsparkes6507]

David, that first picture in the video frame could be a great piece of wallpaper! It is a beautiful revolver,....thanks for showing it here.

[@drdrake63]

Reg Sparkes my pleasure Sir!

[@1911acolt1]

Wow I’m impressed with that revolver...I’ve had a model 19-4 for years..It was made in 1979..It was at the end of the pinned and recess years.. When I got it years ago they were not expensive guns..So I’ve been shooting it for years..But I’m really thinking about one of these one day.Now that the old ones are getting pricey...

[@stevenh.390]

Found a 586 4" at my local shop--- beautiful blued steel and wood. Looking forward to getting it to the range.

[@dariusjvv3030]

How long does the blued finish last? I'm thinking about getting a 586 4", but my dad keeps saying the blue will weather off quickly.

[@jimmysapien9961]

Congratulations- oh Blue Will wear Some But What do you Expect - then Get a stainless

[@majorlee76251]

drove by the factory yesterday. i have the 686 with 6 inch bbl. fantastic revolver.

[@mikerieck306]

A truly great pistol....I've owned one for over 20 years.....it shoots great and it still looks great.

[@dariusjvv3030]

How long does the blued finish last? I'm thinking about getting a 586 4", but my dad keeps saying the blue will weather off quickly.

[@mikerieck306]

@@dariusjvv3030 I've had mine for over 20 years and it looks mint. It really depends on how much it is used and if it is carried in a holster.

[@dariusjvv3030]

@@mikerieck306 I want to get a leather holster for that "cowboy" style as my dad said haha, I don't like the polymer holsters, they feel way to cheap to be carrying such a beautiful weapon in.

[@anthonybarkasysr5029]

Hi David, first time I am responding to your channel. I have a 586 no dash 4" model. It has not been sent to S&W yet to have the recall done. But it is one heck of a revolver. Like your videos. Keep Minnesota free.

[@travisgary8802]

Picked mine up today she is definitely a high class fast shooting lady!

[@tomrkba4685]

I agree that 357 Magnum is phenomenal as a self defense round and a 4” 586 is a great carry gun (with mods, including different stocks) in a Milt Sparks Versa Max 2. As 38 Special was the “adequate” light load of its day, so too is 9x19mm today. These light rounds certainly work, but 357 Magnum shines in comparison.

[@russelder9743]

Dave----funny you just got this, I love357 mag ( i load for it) I have a S&W 620 that I shoot very well. A guy at the club wants to buy a CZ that I own, I was going to sell it and get a Ruger Blackhawk 357.....than I saw your new baby......guess what? I am getting one...........thanks buddy

[@drdrake63]

russ elder I bet you will not regret it!

[@randyjohnson6845]

Question 1...what does the 8 mean? 2...I remember a pistol similar that was called a trooper. What's the difference? 3...I remember a pistol video of a vice president or sales representative. He was shooting a revolver and he mentioned at the factory they shoot there revolvers and the few that show extreme accuracy they stamp a number or letter at that very moment and add a 100 bucks to the price. Do you know what revolvers are designated like that?

[@SquaficleDude]

I sold my Ruger GP100 Match Champion and picked up a new 686. I absolutely love the 686. I like the double action trigger staging on the GP100, but the 686 just feels smoother overall.

[@palerider964]

I have to disagree with you on a couple of points. I've always been a 357 man, to the point I got rid of all my 9mm's. I edc a 357 daily. I fluctuate between a 3" and a 4". All you have to do is buy an outside shirt 1 size larger. This IS a concealed carry weapon. As far as the "hilary hole," I always disable them. I take them out completely. And before you or anyone else says it, I know it "voids" the warranty. If I did need to send it to S&W for service, I know they will replace it. When I get it back, I would take it out again. No big deal. It's a shame Smith caved to political pressure. I'm soo glad Colt did not.

[@alanhumphrey4198]

Beautiful gun...I have stainless 686-3 with 4" barrel bought new in 1989.

[@199gonzo]

Agreed I absolutely dig on mine .. absolute beast .. well built , great handling .. and I have the same holster lol

[@ShootAUT]

2:00 💯% with you on that. It's a firearm. How much more warning could you possibly need?

[@kevinmccarey5015]

Hi Dave, About beautiful firearm. I am going to have one at some point, it reminds about my dad’s career way back, where you would see this gun everywhere. Thanks again Glad I found you Be well

[@82luft49]

Sure it can be concealed. Try a virtical shoulder holster with the 686 resting comfortably under your arm. Not only does conceal well, but no one is the wiser.

[@louisfeuer9714]

Absolutely love the blued over stainless. Not too long ago I purchased the classic Model 29 and love it. Definitely looking forward on purchasing the 586 4in. Even though the bluing on the most recent firearms could never ever match up to the old it's still a very nice-looking firearm.👍🏻👍🏻. I like the Colt revolvers but can either way to overpriced. In my opinion I'd rather have a Smith & Wesson not just for the money aspect but just the way it feels in your hand.

[@dariusjvv3030]

How long does the blued finish last? I'm thinking about getting a 586 4", but my dad keeps saying the blue will weather off quickly.

[@beniciomoldenado2315]

Dave - Nice revolver and nice video. Thanks. I just acquired a 586 6"; only had it to the range twice and it shoots way better than I do. Thanks again.

[@rtaggs8178]

My local dealer sold all his Pythons, GP 100's , but, did have a new S&W 586 4 inch and I snatched it up. The trigger is definitely better on this new one than the older ones.

[@boricuaarecibo9259]

586-8 classic in 4" is my favorite gun because of the stocks My second favorite is my 629-6 deluxe in 3" because of how well I shoot it And I have 2020 colt python 4" 686-6 plus in 4" M29-10 in 4" 629-6 Talo edition 6.5 "

[@Shadowstep_Cuda]

I was thinking about getting a 586 4” or a 2020 Colt Python 6” as my first revolver. Which one would you recommend?

[@boricuaarecibo9259]

@@Shadowstep_Cuda I would go with the 586-8 classic the python has serrations on the face of the trigger that I don't like because of the feel of the serrations. The smith and wesson 586-8 has a rounded smooth trigger. Also there is something special about a blued revolver weather it be a smith and wesson or a colt python and since colt won't be producing any blued python anytime soon I would get the 586-8. Either one you choose you will not be disappointed. FYI i hit a steel silhouette target from 200 yards with my smith and wesson 629-6 44 magnum Good luck to you

[@marguerittegoetsch2303]

I have the 586 L frame .357mag in 6'' blued and I love it.

[@westchester5865]

I have this gun also. Love it. The key hole does not bother me. Original versions of this revolver are hard to find, so I support S&W for at least still making good revolvers.

[@dariusjvv3030]

How long does the blued finish last? I'm thinking about getting a 586 4", but my dad keeps saying the blue will weather off quickly.

[@joehinojosa8314]

I wonder how many guys sat in Police Squad Cars with one of those 586s in the 1980s! 👮

[@johnolson7319]

I carried 686 4" with full loads when I was a carrier for Wells Fargo Armerd Car Service when I was attending college. After that I carried a Sig P226 in 40 cal when I worked law enforcement after college. I liked the Sig but sometimes I wished I could've carried the 586 or the 686.

[@jimmysapien9961]

Idk but My Dad Carried one I. The 70’s

[@carolannesparkman6938]

Absolutely Gorgeous! 👏👏👏

[@brianlee6849]

Very nice pistol . I agree I love the classic blued steel and wood. I have been seriously thinking about the 19 or your 586 also thinking maybe a 25 . I've also been thinking about a 357 or 45 Colt lever action I've always thought a matching classic pistol and rifle would be nice. How is your accuracy on the 357 lever action I think you said you Uberti but I can't remember? How far do you feel comfortable with the lever action? I'm kind of thinking 45 Colt because it would be great for deer. But much more costly. 38/357 is much more economical. I'd love to hear your opinion. Thanks for sharing

[@k4vms]

A commander size 1911(4”) in 9mm or even better in .45 ACP for CCW will do quite nicely. I purchased a 586-8 4” 6 months ago and love it. But I also use a Glock 21 and 30 for CCW also.

[@hueyrotorhead]

I bought mine in 1982. It is a six inch and will pass it down to m grandkids.

[@chrisnedbalek2866]

IMHO, a 4" 586 is the sexiest gun made. I like my 6" 586, but the 4" is perfection. I'm a total sucker for blued steel & wood grips.

[@infidel9810]

Beautiful revolver! I do have a question, do you think that it is safe to shoot Buffalo Bore ammo with this beautiful piece? Thanks!

[@lunarcat1612]

10:19 that one single action shot did not seem intentional lol. Nice video, I own a 586 but haven't been able to shoot it yet. Beautiful collection of pistols, friend.

[@brianwest5348]

I noticed too!

[@chrisgarland1401]

I saw it. Maybe a little work on those safety rules and trigger controll. Slow it down and I can guarantee he shot through the overhang.

[@jimmysapien9961]

Beautiful Gun Congratulations l 2 have One, But an early model, with A Hammer Pin..Very Smooth Machine. And You Can Use 38 ammo

[@daveb8457]

Yes indeed. I too am a pushover for a high polish deep blue revolver. So much so that I bought a 6" blue Python back on July 1st. What a disappointment. 6.7 lbs. average single action trigger pull and 11+ lbs double action trigger pull. Nothing but a pretty face. I truly wish I would have bought a new 586. Could have saved a bunch of money as well.

[@ewetho]

With the six shooter not seven, get the Safariland speedloaders and put away the HKS. You can concealed carry the gun, just takes bit of effort.

[@Chris-yy5pj]

Why conceal it though? It's a blued gun. Plus open carry is better IMO. Most robbers enter a store and check out customers to see if anyone has a gun with them and they will wait tell they leave.

[@michaelcummings6178]

I do like the older style handles and the older style spurs on the single action. I wish they’d make a double action that look like that they’re awesome if they made a double action that looks like the older guns at the Blackhawk that would be insane but good choice on that 586, the 686 class good guns very good, good choices. I followed your channel often on I see you trying to rescue those old guns. That’s good they need love too.

[@TN-pw2nl]

I’ll buy this as a work of art.

[@jc-vc7xq]

I have a stainless gp 100 and a 586. Both 4in barrels. The 586 is definitely to good looking to carry seriously it’s more of a range gun. The gp 100 gets the backpacking/camping duty. Accuracy is about the same with most loads.

[@jasonwolfe9892]

That’s a gorgeous revolver. Is there a lot of maintenance with the blueing?

[@chriswilson2324]

I agree .357 is my fav I have a Taurus 66, model 65-1 and a highway patrolman 28-2. I have a 9mm as well but I like revolvers better

[@drdrake63]

Wrong there partner. The 686 is a six shot revolver. The 686+ holds seven shots.

[@Moustachebier]

I wouldn’t mind aesthetics of IL if not for recontoured frame. But for shootability I find slightly beefed up IL L-frame balances 6” slightly nicer than pre-lock

[@chrisnedbalek2866]

Beautiful cinematography good buddy.

[@Noah.Farrell]

How does this revolver compare too the model 19 ? I’m stuck between the two

[@beck-tn9gl]

Good looking L Frame. I need to get a 586 or 686, in 4 inch barrel. Thanks for the video.

[@sean7627]

My only stainless firearm is also a Ruger takedown.22lr.

[@gr8livn]

Beautiful piece

[@rtaggs8178]

To state again, Yes you can conceal a 4 inch Magnum revolver. Choice of clothing is the key. There are many holster options that can help you do this. Experiment, and you will find out it can be done. Again, I' 6 foot 1 0r 2 inches tall, about 215 pounds weight, I work a dirty manual labor job. If I can do, then you can too.

[@quickdubbs328]

When I shot the 357 sig I fell in love! But like u said price and availability, hurts that calibur BIG TIME😥

[@ssgpentland8241]

Can't go wrong with a K frame. Will always go "bang" when you need her and will be able to pass down

[@PileofBrass]

I have one just like it in 6" and a mint condition 586-1 4" version. Best revolvers made.

[@boricuaarecibo9259]

In my opinion you should not try to stage the double action trigger pull. Learn how to pull the trigger in one continuous trigger pull. I recently shot a steel silhouette target from 200 yards and was able to make hits. However, I found when trying to make the shot in single action I sent the shot inadvertently because of the very light trigger.

[@GatCat]

Great job with the camera work. That finish is amazing. Im looking for a 6”

[@boricuaarecibo9259]

I have that same 586-8 and it's my safe queen and i have 2 pythons and 5 other revolvers

[@michaelcummings6178]

What we need to do is get you a hot tank bluing machine so we can really rescue all those guns. That would be insane when you really have a psycho collection. Good job.

[@moeynola6747]

I fire all my guns I buy but I have this SW 586 brand new I brought 6 months ago and haven't fired it yet.. I think I'm going to keep it brand new..i also have a SW R8 that I think I might not fire neither lol...all my other revolvers I brought used but in like new condition and those are the ones that see a lot of use

[@tonylinardi3089]

Beautiful pistol!! Congratulations!!

[@daweed4255]

I am actually happy to find out that S&W still builds blued guns... ^^ these stainless models are just not for me.

[@108pel]

beautiful revolver.. got the 686 but this one looks way cooler

[@bobclifton8021]

I'm with you one gun finish. I won't ever own a stainless steel gun. They just don't look right and they show dirt like a billboard. If it isn't blued I'm not interested.

[@shotgundrums]

Beautiful revolver. I looked at one of those new, ugly sleeved-barrel model 69 combat magnums... SW still can’t properly index the sleeved versions... it’s a shame that nowadays you have to look at two of them and choose to buy the best one.

[@108pel]

Great looking gun man love the bleu finish. I’ve got the 686 without the (....) hole ; ) Heard that Colt Will bring out the Python again next year.. that’s gonna be my next one!!

[@erictalkington5674]

Though I'm not big on new Smiths, I've been checking out a couple models and this is one of them. I prefer the 4 inch barrel as well. I'd love to put the old style magna grips on it too. I love the old wood panel grips so much. That model would look nice with those. The other models I've been looking at are the classic 29 4 inch and the snub 69. I've also thought about a 686+ snub buttye 29, 586 and 686 I'd prefer to get older ones without the lock and with the hammer mounted firing pin though they are harder to find and expensive. I really like that they brought back the square butt for the classic 586 and 29. I don't like round butt on 4 inch or longer revolvers. The 686 snub, I'd much prefer an older one as well, but the new ones aren't bad. If they made a 586+ snubby, with a nice blued finish like your's, I'd have to buy it even with a lock and frame mounted firing pin. I don't know why the hell they don't make that. Nice gun.

[@mikepascarella4669]

Eric Talkington 586 L comp little bit smaller not a snub nose but 3 or 2.5 also there the model 19 carry comp that's like a reduced size 586 L comp imo

[@bill-nj6fc]

so how is your water pistol holding up

[@ChuchRT]

Great video!!! Love the finish on this .357, but will be going with a Ruger because of the Hillary hole.

[@minerblue9641]

Wow, talk about nice a looking revolver. Wow! I was under the impression that S&W was only making the plain sandblasted blued revolvers. That one is a jewel.

They're bead blasted, not sandblasted.

[@boricuaarecibo9259]

I have this 586-8 classic and the model 29-10 classic the bluing on both Is amazing

[@michaelcummings6178]

Everybody says the same thing recoil recoil recoil it’s just about right it’s just about perfect. It’s not over bearing sure. 44 is nice. Nothing wrong with the 44 but if you’re going to do it all day 357.

[@calebkiller97]

I own a 686-6 and I also love the .357, nice video

[@SkullStoneTv]

Good review I just got mine and love it

[@selaxlife7621]

Dang u!!!! I own a 2.5.inch and a 4 inch 686 plus..but now I need the 568 thanks to u!!!! There goes another 1000 bucks...smh

[@bluescatreimer]

Beautiful blue finish!

[@jawbaw6471]

Looks like a model 19. What is the diff?

[@Mike-up6go]

Several differences. Model 19 is a " K " frame. Model 586 is a " L " frame. L frame revolvers are some what beefier and heavier then the K frame. L frame has full underlug. K frame doesnt. The K frame 19 ( and its stainless version the 66 ) have a slightly thinner forcing cone that by design is squared off on the bottom , contributing to forcing cone erosion and possible cracking with a steady diet of hot .357 magnum loads. In fact the L frame came about to correct those K frame deficiencies. L frame revolvers will take a steady diet of . 357 without issues. If all you want is to shoot .38 special or an occasional . 357 a K frame should be fine. That heavier L frame will also dampen the . 357 recoil a tad better , having a bit more weight out front toward the muzzle end.

[@ThomasSimmons-j9l]

Still have it ?

[@frankdon581]

Good video, just need to speak up a tad bit. Had my put my volume up all the way and still had problem hearing you.

[@2wheeltommy996]

I was hoping I could find a 586 + out there, but I haven't yet.

[@johnolson7319]

Dave, I have a question for you, I came across a original 4" 586 (manufactured 1987) in excellent condition for $1295.00 So my question is, is this a good price for a classic S&W? Also I was told that they put about 500 rounds though it. Thank you for what ever advice you can give me.

[@call99P]

For that price You could buy a new 586 L-comp Performance Center, so in my opinion that's not cheap at all.

[@boricuaarecibo9259]

I would get a brand new 586-8 classic and save yourself a few hundred dollars. You will absolutely love it and it will have the lifetime warranty which is not transferable

[@gshock3092]

I have the cousin to this. The Dan Wesson and i love it!

[@leonardoiniguez8865]

Stuck between getting this one or the 686 + 🙃