Ranking all 3 Starters in Pokémon Scarlet & Violet!

Ranking all Starter Pokémon in Scarlet & Violet! Note that this video contains spoilers up to but not including the champion fight and post game.
Twitter: / thesmithplays
Instagram: / thesmithplays
Credits: Craig Livingstone (Script & Research), Weebra (Editing), Shane Williams (Production & Content) Business Inquiries: [e-mail]

[@DarkKnight-q2d]

I really hope one day we finally get a Pokémon game that’s so massive that you can literally choose any starter you want from any and every single Pokémon generation. Plus you can find and catch any Pokémon in the world known to man. I really miss the Generations 1-5 Pokémon, especially 1-3 because that’s my childhood and what I remember the best.

[@nickdentoom1173]

They will never do this, since it means they cannot milk that cash cow anymore + it costs more to make than it will return in profits.

[@RayFChung]

Seeing the quality of Violet/Scarlet I think you could expect that to never happen

[@zxstealthypotato3021]

pixlemon

[@iloveowls90]

@@zxstealthypotato3021 that s not an offical thing though, thats just a fan made thing.

[@MrFudge2016]

@@nickdentoom1173 there is a way, make it online servers where you can go with friends and compete in multiple tournaments and explore caves etc. There's so much potential, and they can charge monthly subs to keep money flowing its really not difficult to figure out. Plus they can release new games and than charge for expansion packs to have the new pokemon. Its endless cash cow but Nintendo were always 10 steps behind Microsoft and sony

[@trevhart2124]

I really love the 3 choice with these starters -Slow but Strong Tank -All around Heavy Hitter -Fast and Versatile Sweeper I hope more Starters get choices like these

[@Ravii697]

One thing I really like about Skeledirge's Torch Song is how smoothly it pairs with overheat, you can start a battle by casting 2 TS to kill the first mon, and then have a +2 Overheat that can oneshot almost anything even if when resisted, and you go back down to regular sp. atk, you can rinse and repeat.

[@laszlowlewis2024]

Equip throat spray, you'll only have to use it once and not twice #TeamSkeledirge

[@Ravii697]

@@laszlowlewis2024 totally viable, but i prefer good ol' lefties along with protect

[@haydenfantasticfan3251]

@@laszlowlewis2024 RAT

[@sinteleon]

Though with 2 TS, you are already one-shotting most things anyway without the need for overheat. :P

[@SkillHunterThousandManPlan]

Good in theory bad in practice.

[@ProfPoke]

That's actually a really good point about the game having other options to fire pokemons. What I also realized is that the 3 storylines were probably implement to give each of the starter a chance to shine. It's even hinted at in the game (Fuecoco - Victory Roads, Quaxly - Starfall Street, & Sprigatito - Path of Legends)

[@marcosmc3709]

True

[@marcocruz1143]

it needs the same gameplay as gold and silver but with graphix from pkmn stadium 2 . and no buggs or frame lagg. then ill buy

[@haydenfantasticfan3251]

Sprigatito victory road is well

[@krisspychissp]

Don’t even remember psychic as a sprigiato user. But ice on the other hand… That was my first loss

[@haydenfantasticfan3251]

@@krisspychissp lool

[@thejlew3265]

The ranking is spot on, I am going with Meowscarada cause I want to use the other ghost types in the game and I need to show grass starters some love after so long of neglect.

[@fionarudd5789]

i agree

[@Lockstock16]

Bro that is legit me 😂

[@PrivateSparky]

Indeed. The last grass starter I liked and used for a first playthrough was…. Bulbasaur in LeafGreen. Like shite. That’s not to say there haven’t been solid grass starters since but the Water and Fire types end up grabbing my attention those other times.

[@DoofeyDoober]

Nintendo's tired of people sleeping on grass starters. They are soo OP, just need a little patience. Slow and steady wins the race

[@tyrandgg345]

Agreed , it is very helpful against the late part of the game however it doesnt do well against the team star bosses but for elite four, geeta and nemona is very good

[@nat2501]

I typically opt for fire types in pokemon, but this time I went with Sprigatito just bc I liked the look. I ended up being blown away by the time it evolved into Meowscarada between using flower trick and being so fast it could avoid most of the attacks coming to it. Grass type isn’t the best, but tbh it encouraged me to go out and catch more Pokémon to cover all my bases. In the past I only used very few Pokémon beyond my fire type starter.

[@marbtv6313]

@ me lol

[@Nergicuga]

Same bro. I only use other mons for hm moves lmao. Thats on old gens tho.

[@LastStandJudie]

Same Lmao. Every game prior I picked fire but I saw this grass type and said. I’m going with that one 😂

[@andersgalterudhgda6226]

I really like how you analyze them all individualy and points out what they’re good at and what they are not so good at! My favourite of the three has to be quaxly😃

[@weallstilldie]

Fuck I chose Quaxly

[@demiboi0315]

I named my Quaxly, Quarlos haha

[@Random_Hooman]

I also loove quaxly! Many people hate the final evolution but i think its pretty nice

[@demiboi0315]

@@Random_Hooman they just cant handle fab lol

[@TheShiny_Spiritomb]

Love Quaxly

[@silb1030]

I love how thorough your evaluation is! I personally always pick the starter who’s role is hard to replace (infernape in Sinnoh or Blaziken in Emerald), therefore I’d pick the grass 1 :)

[@frogdog209]

I found this reply on my comment as well, so I searched a little and found it here too. Don't trust it it is a scam!

[@robbyv8729]

Honestly I like the insight you provided. It kept the spoilers to a minimum. I haven’t played the games as of yet but if I had to rank the starters as to viability on my end game, I would go Grass, Water, Fire. Like you said the fire type stater is easily replaceable while the grass type not so much. The duel typing of grass/dark meshes well with the typing I typically use for a competitive build and while water types are my usual go to starter it is hard to deny the usefulness of that grass/dark overt water/fighting. I do feel bad that our fire/ghost boi falls off a bit, but as you said he is a very good starter I just can’t get over the fact he’s easily replaceable.

[@drnanard9605]

It kept spoilers to a minimum? He literally showed almost all titan pokémon seriously...

[@drago5268]

@@drnanard9605 he didnt say NO spoilers he said minimum

[@drnanard9605]

@@drago5268 I didn't say he said "no spoiler" tho? Do you know how to read? I said he didn't keep spoilers to a minimum.

[@Lyokoheros-KLPXTV]

@@drnanard9605 honestly I didn't see in the video ANYTHING I would consider a spoiler...

[@drnanard9605]

@@Lyokoheros-KLPXTV you don't consider seeing all the Titans of the game a spoiler? You enjoy knowing each and every boss you'll fight in a game prior to playing it?

[@danbrads4711]

I personally agree with the tie, however I do prefer Fuecoco because of Torch Song and it’s build alone. I also love the fact that this is one of the first quadrupedal starter we’ve gotten in a while. And I mean a WHILE. I like the other two, but sometimes too humanoid can really change my opinion. For that, I’m choosing Fuecoco as my starter!

[@MASTERROSHIdb]

I hate the look on that duck and the cat looked nice at first but it evolved into human-cat hybrid and looks stupid.

[@Mwazon5]

When I heard Meowscarada had a move that always critical hit and doesn't check accuracy, I knew it would be good. (Well done pokemon for a great grass type starter that's a cat!)

[@jmurray1110]

Also the auto switch moves are always great Uturn was a staple when I got it

[@awful999]

u turn spikes taunt this cat is so good

[@DarkBlackGod14]

weed cat do be stronk

[@smithplayspokemon]

Spoiler Warning: this video evaluates starter performance through the entire game! It contains all major fights UP UNTIL THE CHAMPION AND POST GAME (which are not shown).

[@chrisgropp8551]

I really like the Fuecoco. Ranking was spot on and I like the final evolutions typing.

[@Droopsnooot]

i named mine steve...for obvious reasons

[@Axo_Dude1]

I named mine bubba because I saw a Ryan Trahan vid and decided to name it bubba

[@anarchyfairy7400]

You're ranking is spot on honestly 🤩 Meowscarada is definitely the best of the three and the other two a team could go with or without and I feel like it wouldn't make too much of a difference

[@henryhuangstar3270]

Doesn't meowscarada have a crap ton of weakness? (4x bug)

[@arcanelight8365]

@@henryhuangstar3270 you know type matchups right? then why you will use grass/dark against a bug type. you use your fire type pokemon to do that job. if you are talking about bug coverage then I can surely say no trainer in this game uses bug coverage frequently like dark,, ice and fairy( these are most used coverage moves used by other trainers). fairy and ice type moves are problems but you can somewhat tank them if you are high level because these moves will be none stabs.

[@Cloud_that_looks_like_a_cat]

I wouldn't say it's the best. I mean, for you it is. But for me, it isn't (but that's probably because I usually rate Pokémon depending on how much I like the design), for me, it's Skeledirge. But you're still allowed to have that opinion! So, for you it's the best, but not for everyone.

[@phantomslay5612]

I absolutely love Meowscarada. It might actually have one of my favorite designs of all time in Pokemon

[@camicow3329]

I feel bad for quaxly, i am still gonna choose him

[@danielhodson6411]

I like Meowscarada's design so much that I don't even care that it's bipedal, I knew that going with Sprigatito was a good choice

[@alessandromazzini7026]

Eww bipedal

[@RomenKay]

My choice was sprigatito

[@azuremk__3101]

I went with Sprigatito because one of the Violet exclusive Pokémon is also fire ghost. Then I eliminated Quaxly as I think there are more good water types than grass types.

[@rajjakpatel82]

@@alessandromazzini7026 meowscarada is literally categorised as the magician pokemon

[@LPSsloth]

I love cat starters ngl

[@GambolMuse]

The speedy attacker is usually my go to for a starter regardless of typing, and grass happens to be my favorite of the 3. Hearing its tied for best then makes my choice even easier!

[@jalinbulding6744]

I loved that you went so into detail into the ranking and saying both pros and cons it really wasn't 1sided . Coming from a pokemon fan since I was little. I want to give this game a try so bad but been tight financially lately hopefully I can win n try out the game! Well love the video keep it up!!! 💯

[@kiefer4359]

Very insightful, I definitely feel more confident about all of the starters usefulness now as they all appear to be solid pokemon

[@kiefer4359]

Yo no way, I won a scam bot

[@proffesortypo6783]

I'm definitly going with meowscarada, definitly my favorite model, the moves it has is amazing, and I just love cats

[@MASTERROSHIdb]

The cat was cute until it was human cat hybrid model. I wish they kept her cat maybe evolve into a beautiful lion looking creature.

[@badkoba6927]

Your ranking and explanation on each starter was very helpful on picking which starter I am going to choose

[@cowmeatius7151]

Meowscarada is an example of bipedalism done right (looking at you Incineroar) and I was immediately sold when I saw it's mask and carnival performer design. Do not regret my choice one bit. Grass-Dark is a great offensive combo and it has a ton of coverage (also the most broken grass type move in the series lol). It's hard to find a mon in either version that can replace Meowscarada

[@goni2493]

Just need to avoid bug types at all cost.

[@notmithosis7350]

@@goni2493 yeah. first impression is enough to faint meowscarada

[@jonnymario771]

@@notmithosis7350 You mean non stab first fury cutter? xD

[@leoplays8118]

They did floregato RIGHT it’s like the badass kid in the class

[@espio329]

I like meowscarda's design but i also think incineroar also hits a good design too. One, and elegant sword fighter and the other a brute of a heel wrestler.

[@mistressnom]

I really liked your ranking, you went through not only their abilities, but also by level on how well they will scale throughout the game. Ive seen Fuecoco and he looks adorable, but I think I'm going to go with Sprigatto its just too cute and its final form looks mysterious and cool. It also reminds me of the rowlet line which I absolutely adored. Much appreciated your ranking :).

[@sc6the]

samee

[@JKeepsItReal217]

I chose Meowscarada and I’m so glad that I did. She hits like a beast & is so fast. Fuecoco was my second choice so the fact that you tied them makes sense to me. If I decide to get Scarlet, I’m going w/the fire

[@zyl5156]

Ive only played emerald and heart gold my entire life, but watching this walkthrough. i am so intrigued to play the new pokemon games even before scarlet & violet. no doubt meowscarada is a fan favorite and a mon thats diversed in all of the gyms a starter youd wanna hold on to throughout the playthrough ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

[@tryhardagain7531]

I love skeledirge and meowscarada and Quaxly’s line is growing on me. I love to have sweepers on my team but skeledirge’s design is the best in my opinion.

[@danielcunningham4339]

Was really debating about our lil pepper croc just because he's got this look of "I got nothing between my ears but I'm happy to be included" and I love him 😊💓

[@mikhanch1228]

Omg 😂😂 i just started playing and I'm literally looking at home to decide who to pick, and that boy looks like he has downs 😭

[@danielcunningham4339]

He's such a sweetie tho I highly recommend him

[@Sespar27]

The added context on other Pokémon you can get in Scarlet and Violet were key! Think that put me over the edge on Meowscarada! Great video!

[@TheMimic-kn2ef]

I picked Quaxly at first due to it having the fewest weaknesses to worry about. You are right about them not tanking too well, but I found a couple of fun things to do to cover that flaw. One of them is having roost and a fun item on hand to annoy others with. I have also experimented with using chilling waters to slow opponents down until getting fainted and use a tankier pokemon afterward. I had found that building them like meowscarada made it easier to wreck the field with them. The build I had set up for my gal made her take out half of the champion team because I was breaking down the opposition's speed and boosting my own with recovery on the side. I only had to rely on three pokemon total to beat the champ. Meowscarada is similar in building and can be more unpredictable. Easily the top starter in my book to be a support for teammates in a team battle. Getting all of those weaknesses covered is the hardest for me among the starters, especially the double weakness to bug. It seems to be able to be altered to handle either attack or special attack, making it the trickiest of the starters to play with. I won't be able to tell what is up this cat's sleeves...will it pollen puff an ally or play a dirty trick? A great sweeper in the end. Our fiery croc is definitely the tank among the starters. It can just concentrate on its defenses to fight against its many weaknesses instead of hunting strategies to negate them. It seems to be the easy starter this round despite the risks that come with it due to how straightforward you can be to make it a powerful sweeper, as the video displayed. I haven't played with it enough to evaluate all of the potential it has. I love all three starters and these pokemon will only shine brighter if the teams they get set with are just as grand.

[@alexmacleod7269]

Loved the design of Sprigatito when Pokémon Scarlet/Voilet was announced, and hearing its a great starter gameplay-wise as well makes me all the happier. Definitely a my choice for this gen’s starter.

[@elliotrenaud1140]

I didnt spoil myself enough beforehand. I only saw first stages Pokémon. My ranking then was water grass fire. You kind of convinced me because it’s the first time I’m seeing any type of video about the starters. Nice video

[@knighttrax4237]

Good ranking I think Skeledirge and Meowscarada are the best for beginners. And Quaxly is good for a second play through.

[@mariamlaleen4897]

your ranking is so detailed and reliable i always come to your videos for pokemon help

[@PRDGL_WindyBW]

I was initially gonna pick Quaxly and then I see it's final evolutions design. I then chose Sprigatito as a second option. Not only is it powerful, I'm starting to really like it's design. Meowscarada is probably my new favourite pokemon.

[@valfodryonsirius7698]

Alright here goes something: The ranking and analysis is amazing. It's sound, reasonable, and understandable. Overall, despite the stats and moves of Quaxly and its evolution line. I like its design of all 3 cause it feels more energetic with its flowing design. Not saying the others are designed bad, but the way Quaxly conducts itself in its movement and animations draws me in more than the rest. Thanks for the video my guy!

[@beariedare]

I am going to choose Sprigatito because of Meowscarada. I like how that Pokémon is able to hit first while also being a dark type. I rather use a different ghost type like Gengar.

[@stebo1122]

Very good video I love how he explains all of the starters

[@gnaixgnaw]

After watching again and thinking about it, I want to say that Skeledirge isn’t just big, bulky, and like a tank, it’s also really good at defeating other Pokémon in one hit with moves like Flamethrower, Hyper Voice, Hex, and Shadow Ball.

[@PadawanIan]

i’ve been watching you since BO2 and been watching NiftySmith why am i just now finding out ab this channel man love all your content!

[@bluaurax]

I love Meowscarada. Easily my favourite design and favourite to battle with.

[@chimuoma390]

Could Meowscarada Beat Gatomon/Ophanimon In Digimon Battle Spirit 1.5?!With Gatomon/Ophanimon,I Got 1000 D-Spirits On Extreme Mode!And I Have Her In Dawn/Dusk,With The Moves:Call Dramon,Holy Destroy,Royal Cannon,Royal Slash,Sephirothic Crystal!And The Traits:All Elements,Mind's Eye,Assassin,Status Barrier,SpiritUp5!With 3 Legend Swords Equipped,Ophanimon Is Critting Almost As Much As Meowscarada's Flower Trick!And Hitting With The Force Of A Royal Knight!You Should Hack Digimon Dawn/Dusk And Try Her Out!

[@BeastMode-bw2ry]

Nobody asked

[@andrewmueller9182]

Such a great video. All of these are simply so entertaining that I'll sometimes listen to them while I'm working (in other words when I can't be playing pokemon myself lol). Hope you keep putting out these types of videos as I'll continue to watch!

[@wjasonwelch8524]

❤❤😂 311

[@justinesaguid9788]

I AM SO HAPPY THAT SOMEONE IS PRAISING MEOWSCARADA. It's always the fire types that are everyone's favorite ya know? And I just really fell in love with Sprigatito at first sight and the only downsides were that it was grass-type. My brother told me that Fuecoco was the way to go and that grass was not the best. I'm so glad that you showed how good Meowscarada actually is.

[@XEclipse360]

Because fire types are usually the best looking. Meowscarada is just furry bait

[@elektroplatine4821]

@@XEclipse360 i don't think so only furrys thinks that it's a furry bait you are probably a furry

[@XEclipse360]

@@elektroplatine4821 I am not a furry

[@Unholy_Triforce]

@@XEclipse360 not really though

[@leff2051]

I like how you demonstrate every starter's pros and cons. From the start I liked the grass one and I am sticking with it. Plus I tend to use grass starters more often than not. So team grass all the way!!

[@KegorianRune]

I'm so glad I chose Sprigattito as my starter in Violet, I went in as blind as I could, and I never regretted it ^w^

[@dustinmccrary9463]

Pretty good ranking, you never miss SmithPlays

[@fallout560]

Note that you can get Ceruledge or Armarouge really early on in the game if you want a fire type pokemon

[@adfuunture8902]

Yes, you can easily farm for Charcadet also 😁

[@jmurray1110]

It depends on where you go it could literally be in the first area you visit

[@fancycat8128]

spot on ranking, im happy that the sprigatito line was number one also love your narrating

[@miquelaragones7774]

In pokémon you really always want to go first and one-hit the opponent for your main run, so I'd say Meowscarada takes the edge

[@frogdog209]

I really like how deep you went and it didn't sound biased to me so that was a plus. I'm going with quaxly no matter what because he's the cutest 😄!

[@zappypow]

I completely agree with your readings, but one thing is, I am definitely getting Violet 100%

[@DanOnStilts]

I got Scarlet cause futurism puts me off

[@zappypow]

@@DanOnStilts IDC about the futurism but good for you😁

[@Kumpelvonpaule]

Great ranking! I couldn't decide until just now! Thanks for this!

[@EdgardoJCruz-dk5kv]

This was a great and informative video. Though what I learned the most was that these starters have great attack animations and movements.

[@josephknieper3019]

I think you hit the nail on the head. You actually changed my mind to pick sprigitito over fuecoco

[@shreckwes]

After watching, I think I’ll switch my pick from Fuecoco to Sprigatito. A fast sweeper is definitely the way to go, especially with its insane signature move. Skeledirge is cool, but like you said it can be pretty easily replaced, so there’s no sense in using it to fill a niche on your team comp.

[@gabobeast8419]

You didint win its a scam the account that commented saying that you won is fake just click on the yt acc and it says no subscribers

[@presidential3228]

@@gabobeast8419liar

[@anjimotomura5570]

the ranking of the starters gave me a good understanding of the stats of each starter and was extremely helpful! definitely will pick sprigatito for my starter pokémon!

[@Daniel-im7zs]

I will be going with Quaxly 😎 and looking forward to getting Pokémon Scarlett!! 🎉🎉 Excited to build around

[@MASTERROSHIdb]

Quaxly looks like a transgender weirdo.

[@ayo-joyyt4981]

I like the way you gave good info in this video just seeing your video for the first time really gave me a good idea on who to pic if I ever get the game

[@spac3r89]

I’m absolutely going to go for Spriggatito, especially since I want a Ceruledge on my team! This game looks like it’ll be a blast!

[@Byobmofo69]

That’s the only reason I got violet 🤪

[@Amelia4111]

*THERE SHOULD BE ONLY ONE G IN SPRIGATITO, ONE!*

[@jmurray1110]

Yeah that was a good combo for me

[@nanojimenez7079]

@@Amelia4111sprigggatito

[@Daniel-im7zs]

I disagree with the final ranking in that there is a tie and I would give the slight nudge to the grass/dark fellow due to there being less alternatives to replace it with. I will give fuecoco the fire/ghost mon second place since it is bulky and capable of being a massive attacker with its boosted special attack shadow balling all opponents but considering it can be somewhat replaced typing wise with Ceruledge in Pokemon Violet and then the other mon Annihilape in which both games have. Then lastly I agree Quaxly to be tha last but considering its Fighting type and not great 1st and 2nd stages due to its move pool I would take the honor of being able to build a team built around him as the least favourable of the bunch in the ranking of this Video! ❤ Great Video! Congratulations to whomever wins the Giveaway!!! 🎉

[@dshane8731]

Agree with the rankings you did a realy good job on this one pat another great video I was going to go for quaxly but now thanks to your video sprigatito has been seen in a new light

[@macawweb2211]

i love all of sprigatito’s evolutions with all my heart ❤️

[@hommesimple5326]

Truly informative. Thanks! Always considered their initial advantage when picking a starter. Not so much the endgame.

[@darthbronchitis3802]

Thank you for this! I'm a bit disappointed to hear my boy Quaquaval isn't quite on par with the other two, but I guess that just means I'll have to give my team building a little more thought. While he's not as immediately deadly as Meowscarada, I think I could definitely make something work with Swords Dance and a berry to help him regain health while he's setting up!

[@l4zybo1]

Buddy, if they add porygon to the game i have a lot of strats to give the mad quack

[@darthbronchitis3802]

@@l4zybo1 Please elaborate!

[@Amelia4111]

DO NOT CALL QUAQUAVAL A BOY!

[@darthbronchitis3802]

@@Amelia4111 But it's a species. It can be either.

[@nickdentoom1173]

Wait until the Hidden Abilities are released, then Quaquaval is instantly elevate to top spot due to Moxie (Meowscarada will be less good, because Protean is nerfed, meaning its really easy to prepare for, since it most likely carries Flower Trick, Dark Move and U-Turn + with the Protean nerf, Terra on Meowscarada is bascially useless).

[@devon7391]

Sounds good! Meowscarada seems amazing!

[@norweagle2926]

When I saw Skeledirges design and stats I was sold on Fuecoco, and I think this list is good and informative while reinforcing the fire croc supremacy

[@BeastMode-bw2ry]

You do know Meowscarada and skeledrige tied for first, right?? He isn't the actual best because they were tied. But Meowscarada is still better because of the signature move, Flower Trick. Skeledrige's signature move is a better Charge Beam.

[@EshaanRajan]

I've always been choosing fire types as my starter Pokemon since the first game I played (Pokemon fire red) so I'm glad to see that I can still have faith in this Pokemon even multiple generations into the game. Thanks for the information.

[@ghostofmoredishesmorebitch1507]

Charizard was so bad back then lmao

[@Ravii697]

I feel we're gonna see a lot of teams including both starters in online battles

[@aurj2822]

I'm the type that picks the one with the final form that I'd absolutely love without looking at stats, since they don't matter to me. For me, that's usually grass types, with some exceptions like Gen 1's Charizard, Gen 4's Infernape, Gen 6's Greninja and Gen 8's Inteleon. Sprigatito pulled me in from the beginning out of the three starters. Hearing your analysis and the way its final evolution Meowscarada pulls me in, I know for sure Sprigatito would be my pick.

[@jessiebatz]

I was fixed in choosing Sprigatito but eventually chose Fuecoco because of its irresistible cuteness in Pokemon Violet. Good thing though I bought the Double Pack, so I will definitely choose Sprigatito, because of this video.

[@katepotter2926]

Fab video! I was leaning towards fuecoco but now you have put sprigatito back up as an amazing choice!

[@larrylemmyiggyplayz]

My favourite is fuecoco

[@levizl2695]

lol i just realized this is smithplays lol, I've never watched anything besides zombies from him but this vid was great

[@keyblademasterclark]

I'm usually a water starter user, but this time I went with grass kitty and I'm so glad I did! Meowscarada is now one of my favorite starter pokemon, right up there with Greninja and Blaziken.

[@PoisonxTea]

Your ranking makes total sense to me, tbh. My favorite is probably the Quaxly line, but that's just barely and has nothing to do with stats -- I just love them! Taking stats into account as well as design, and the Sprigatito line actually shoots up to my faves. They're all super close though; this may actually be my favorite group of starters.

[@Timlba63Jonesy]

The duck Pokémon is the best

[@tarotreadingsbysteven8545]

That commercial break 🤣 "that means it outspeeds. . ." "Mr Clean!" Lmao

[@Raven58600]

Where my Quaxly boys at 💪🦆

[@SplashMalone]

I never thought in my life thought I’d pick a grass starter; but I’m happy you helped me decide

[@connorsevick9707]

Sprigatito was the starter I chose cause I thought it was cute, and then I saw that it would end up being grass dark, and knew I made a good decision. The fire starter was a close second for me though. The water type just didn't appeal to me this gen. Also, I'm glad to see you doing pretty well with the pokemon stuff. I used to watch you speedrun origins like every week way back when. You seem just as informative and knowledgeable in pokemon as you were in zombies. Keep up the good vids, I got really lost(Cause I skipped a lot of dialogue lmao) and these vids are helping a lot.

[@TheIllusionist1990]

Great video as always!

[@noahtheplayer8902]

I loved how you ranked these pokemon! I'm going for Skeledirge because I love offensive pokemon that can hit hard throughout my playthrough!

[@demonxking2638]

Great at explaining it!!! I agree at the ranking they all cool in their own way but dang sprigatio is awesome.. I can’t wait to play! Keep up wit the videos!

[@mapleshade3099]

Great video, I'm choosing Fuecoco :D the design is adorable

[@emilyhe5093]

No matter what, the starter choice is yours, all of them are REALLY good.

[@kerrygligorovic9758]

I am definately going to pick Sprigatito as my starter Pokemon for both Scarlet and Violet games for Christmas because I like it's middle and final evolved form designs.

[@nuaitutreaba3760]

this helped tbh,i was anyway gonna pick fuecoco but this made me more confident about me,nice ranking tho!

[@davidmacleod6017]

The ranking was amazing im still going with quackly but love the idea of ranking all the starters thanks for all the information

[@zachjohnson7046]

I think you are very right on the rankings as both have there strengths and weaknesses as for the water starter he can be good at some points but doesn’t match up with the others you explained this really well

[@AveryShipley-z1g]

I found this video very helpful for if i decide to play Scarlet or Violet!

[@jeffgillis6431]

Nice analysis! Never thought the grass starter would be on the same level as the Fire and Water stater!

[@datdankdj8264]

I think it was a well thought out ranking. I was torn between fuecoco and sprigatito when I first got scarlet, and quaxly wasn’t even a question…I hated it

[@joshuabeck8735]

Great stuff! I’m glad the starters seems like viable Pokémon throughout the game.

[@luzthegoose1845]

Ranking is SPOT on, I am going with Sprigatito FOR SURE! I love the design but also the good sweeping build it has! Even though it would have been cool if it had stayed on all four feet I’m so happy with how it turned out! Keep up the great work :)

[@shimogane2474]

Meowskarada is the fast physical grass sweeper we all waited for years.

[@JakeGoesBoom]

AMAZING ranking. Personally, all the starters seem to be pretty good, but if I had to pick, I think I would go with the fire starer. Sure, Meowscarada is amazing and all but I think honestly that It’s design, it’s stats, My gosh, I can’t believe how good they made this fire little crocodile. Come on, it even has it’s own signature move. It also matches up pretty well with the gyms inside of this game, also, I really loved all the evolutions new evolutions scarlet and violet gave us, especially the Primeape. This definitely is one of the best generations that I find really entertaining.

[@Unholy_Triforce]

To be fair, all the gen 9 starters have their own special move

[@SeniorSuiki]

I’ve never been a grass starter type (always choosing fire because they were just better looking) but S & V played with my heart by having a cat starter. BOIIIIIIIII I was on top of that like white on rice, and ngl I couldn’t have been happier with my choice

[@derekthompson1054]

I liked how you presented sprigatito differently. Other videos claim that route is the “hardest” starter but after this video I’m going with Sprigatito

[@alxan3942]

I beat the "hard" gym (no 7) as my 4th gym - the game is so open you can do whatever you like, so just pick whatever you like 👍

[@verevo8236]

You didn’t mention quaquavals hidden ability. Pairing moxie with Aqua step makes it S tier.

[@jonathanmurray007]

Really sweet video and i cant believ how powerful they are all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!