So, About "Pink Venom"...

[@nychous]

“I’m a coconut tree, i drop hit after hit” is such a good line. Mera for best songwriter 😭

[@y2klove581]

It’s a weird line tbh but an artist like Nicki minaj could make it work or rewrite it in a clever way

[@traytrayland2279]

Honestly she best copyright it before teddy or bekah boom steals it 😭

[@edvaedan9161]

@@traytrayland2279 album rewrite is in progress as we speak

[@eem8736]

Sounds like something bekuh would give Lisa for an English Rap in a bp Japanese version song, but I know she would pull it off 😃

[@enterfromthesky]

@@traytrayland2279 not bekuh 💀💀💀

[@evenif7431]

What really struck me about the solo shots this music was the sense that they didnt have enough to do, if that makes sense? In past mvs there were bags to whip around and a tank to lay on and popcorn to throw all in one shot, this time around we had three shots of Jisoo raising the mask to her face in the exact same way bc there werent any other props to interact with and tell a story with. The scenes felt sparse, they wouldve been beautiful as photoshoots or just shorter segments (like ocean goddess!jisoo in ddu du ddu du)

[@fluffybunchy]

This!

[@grasarlia]

It also felt like they would try to compensate with many cuts. Especially during Rosé’s parts so many scenes would change and we never got a good look at her. However I haven’t lost hope though as the music video was still pretty good and the title track music video will be really good I’m pretty sure.

[@m20047]

Rosés first solo scene felt so empty as well but i think jenlisas worked well

[@nanaasmah938]

Maturing as a K-pop fan is accepting people with different opinions then yours. But as K-pop snowballs in popularity, there will be more and more fans hating on everyone who doesn’t like every song. Personally, I always find your takes refreshing and love your in depth analysis. They’re always my favorite and I hope to hear more of the times you love a song and more of the times you don’t.

[@AB-yk2pq]

Besides already heard lyrics by Blackpink and underwhelming chorus I realized what else bugs me about Pink Venom. It feels like they took inspo from famous artists and rappers from 90s and early 2000s and still tried to fit into kpop regular song...and with that production it didn't work. Also the song is about venom/poison at least title is and yet even MV doesn't follow it regardless of budget. Jisoo wears mask and have some bits on her hand, Rosé carries a black heart in one scene but everything else looks like regular MV with fashion brands. I genuinely wish they moved from phrase of "being bad girl who is rich" cause they have enough supportive fandom (even too supportive) to talk about something different, they're in their mid 20s. This is probably why I appreciated Lovesick girls and On the ground. Also I hope they stop using this amount of samples, no wonder why people feel their music is the same. I've said in on another channel, Pink venom could've easily ended on The Album and there would be no difference.

[@AB-yk2pq]

If anyone decides to call me "a hater" or whatever don't waste your time, alright. Pink venom still had some good moments and if you enjoy it, I'm happy for you!

[@Milana-ho5qc]

i agree with the references and sampling it seems really lazy on their behalf i understand using one or two and referencing them but there's at least 4 and it seems unnecessary

[@AB-yk2pq]

@@Milana-ho5qc As Mera mentioned it seemed like a nice idea, but with Blackpink who is still finding their music identity I think they carried away.

[@chrisjones2584]

Please. Homage in sampling has been a part of hip hop culture from the beginning

[@beatm6948]

@@Milana-ho5qc the problem is that the sampling is not the "point" of the song. Therefore it is unnecessary and ridiculous.

[@SquishyBeans]

I will say i actually preferred Kill this love then pink venom. They utilized the trumpets and kept a good consistency and beat while pink venom teased us with the string instruments and left me wanting more and giving me nothing. Jisoo looked amazing, but I was bored by the end since It felt like a re-run of all their other videos and was berated with too many scene changes. So looks were awesome, they had me in the beginning then lost it by the end.

[@areyoukirringmeirriyaa]

yess also kill this love made sense because of the lyricss. it all worked out and the choreo was memorable. the rap part is still hot af

[@rhitmakemala]

Oh yeah, i agree with everythinng you said. KTLA prob my fav tt of them. I like pink venom (i know this is NOT a tt) especially the chorus just like mera said but yeah other than that it's just another bp song. Nothing particularly stands out. Especially not the lyric. I'm pretty tired of this type of bragadocious lyrics in their songs. Meanwhile KTL tells you a story musically, visually and ofc lyrically.

[@user3059]

Kill this love so good but it was so overplayed I’m actually kinda tired of it so currently I’m more of a pink venom fan 😭

[@thehardercandy]

Summed it up perfectly for me. Couldn't agree more.

[@ddjsoyenby]

agreed it had a stronger "dub chorus" and felt more like a triumph.

[@nici_2022]

Mera: literally puts out a video about Black Pink colour theory and talking about "The Album" with so much positivity about their journey and how she has been a Fan since the fucking debut Blinks: omg she a hater ???

[@eem8736]

Like it makes zero sense

[@Koko24250]

THIISSSSS is what i don't get!!!!!

[@ilaera7830]

@Alleyesonsana tbh i don’t think armys are keeping tabs on mera enough to wanna dox her. she hasn’t really kicked the beehive, so to speak c

[@m00nl1ghtj3w3l]

@@ilaera7830 she has talked about how people came so close to it she was scared for her safety. I forgot where she does address it though.

[@belxxx3045]

"Blinks"?

[@jichu_rbk8465]

Honestly all this thing about you being a Blackpink hater is so funny to me, you always seem so genuine and happy when talking about them that it remind me of the time I discovered them, you make me remember why I enjoy Blackpink as a group and I’m so thankful for that !

[@CRJCrombo]

I don’t get people. I listened to Blackpink since their debut, been to two concerts and I can still like mera’s content. Criticism and discussion should be welcomed. It is how we improve after all. Fml.

[@abbyc9924]

@@CRJCrombo Totally agree. I’m an aspiring fantasy writer, and I’m always asking for honest feedback. I would hate if I published a book and people were only allowed to say nice things about it.

[@pinksavage9470]

Yass BP gives really different happy vibe and I feel uplifted listening to them

[@JokerCrowe]

After Lovesick Girls, I was honestly disappointed that they were forced back into the DDDD mold. Lovesick Girls had a similar "formula" to their other songs, but I think it did a few things differently enough 1) it has an actual Chorus with lyrics that aren't just repeating the title of the song and nonsense words. 2) it had more of a rock sound, and it actually sounded like a new style from them. Like something from before DDDD, where they tried different sounds and styles. 3) it had interesting lyrics that you could read as much or as little into as you wanted. Their DDDD songs are always about how they're rich/cool/scary , so I appreciated Lovesick Girls being different In that regard. With Pink Venom they went "whole hog" back into the DDDD formula, and it's honestly almost becoming a joke at this point. There are things I like about the song, but I couldn't stop thinking about what would happen next: "oh here comes Jennie with a rap, and now that she's done, here comes Lisa, prechorus by Rosé and - who would have guessed - Jisoo sings the other part of the prechorus? I wonder if they're going to switch lines in the prechorus after the second JenLisa rap verse? What nonsense are they going to put in the final break down? Oh, "Rattattata"? I see". I'm still hoping and wishing for the day we get another "Playing with Fire", or "Stay" or even "As if it's your Last", (or Lovesick Girls) but after waiting 2 years and getting DDDD ver. 4.0, I'm not sure we'll ever see that day. The Ddu-Ddu derivatives do too well - they get so many views - that there's no reason to just not repeat the same thing over and over. Some people might like it, but I'm honestly over it at this point. Edit to split up the wall of text 😅 Edit2: just heard Shut Down, and... well I'm out. If I hear people say that their next song is different, I might check it out, but for now I'm out. Who knows? Maybe I'll feel different in 2 years when the next comeback is out.

[@ashliegh115]

Tell me you didn't listen to the video in it's entirety without telling me you didn't listen to the video in it's entirety. Mera literally explained at the end that this is what they do. You get the hype song as a pre release (just as HYLT) and then you get the brilliant title track when the album drops (just like LSG). I can understand if the song isn't your taste but the fact that they have been releasing the same song over and over again (according to you), why would you keep tuning in to their music? Like I really need someone who thinks this way to explain it to me because for me, if I don't like a certain artist or their music I don't listen to it at all.

[@JokerCrowe]

@@ashliegh115 Oh no, I know that this is a pre-release, but between dddd and Lovesick Girls they only had those dddd derivatives (ktl and hylt). Like I said, I was super happy when Lovesick Girls dropped, because it was different, but that's the only song so far that's been any indicator that they plan on leaving the dddd sound. When they went back to the dddd sound for this song, I was disappointed, because I thought they might break out of it, since Lovesick Girls was so different. And yes, it's absolutely possible that they're going to drop something different to contrast this one, but can we say for certain that it's what they're going to do? As for why I'm listening to this song; part of me was hoping it would be different from dddd, and I've really liked Blackpink up to this point. Boombayah, Whistle, Playing with Fire, Stay, As if it's your last, even dddd are all super solid songs. I'm not someone who drops a group because they have One song I didn't like, but since this is becoming a pattern, I'm very close to just giving up on them. I'm also not someone who listens to music I don't like, but I thought I would give them another chance since Lovesick Girls was so good. It's fine if other people like their music, I'm happy for you if you like their dddd songs, but if this is the pattern we're going to have, I'm probably just going to skip every pre-release, and just listen to every Other BP song. The Lovesick Girls eqivalent. And if they keep taking 2 years between comebacks, and I'll only listen to half their songs, eventually I'm probably going to just drop the group. You can disagree with me, but since this video was talking about what Mera thought about the song, I thought I would share my thoughts.

[@eem8736]

I agree , I just hope they pull an album era . Drop a Pre release with the teddy mold (how you like that and pink venom ) then release a TT that no one expected but loved (lovesick girls and whatever the TT is for born pink)

[@JokerCrowe]

@@eem8736 Agreed! I also hope we get a Lovesick Girls eqivalent for the title track. 😊

[@peonylarkspur645]

literally this - i enjoy dddd, but blackpink is strongest when they lean into the pink side

[@notenoughtreble]

I would always, 100% rather hear an essay filled with actual thoughts and opinions rather than a short reaction video with blind praise. You keep doing you Mera! Speak your mind!

[@norah672]

Thank you for calling out these stans’ hypocrisy. I love your video essays! You’re always respectful and level headed with them. People just want others to be just as hived minded as they are.

[@ivana.malinova]

As a Blackpink fan, what often bugs me, is that Teddy and the YG producers can definitely make a GOOD quality and memorable song that goes out of their typical formula(judging by their earliest releases and bsides), which would definitely shut down most of blackpink's haters.Just imagine Blackpink going off with a goth/rock,metal or horror concept, they would literally shatter the earth.

[@blush3790]

I actually really thought this would be the cb. I saw how popular Tomboy by G-idle was after a steady increase in Dreamcatcher popularity and thought, “this is it. One of the big 3 are gonna tap into the rock concept and have the most memorable concept change ever” and then they didn’t .

[@yeye1031]

That would remind me of pink fantasy in a way

[@Chrono_topher]

@@blush3790 Idk if GbGb counts but Blackpink doing a rock concept would FIT WELL

[@gregmark1688]

Straight up, Teddy was easily the most innovative producer since Seo Taiji himself. wtf happened to him, I wonder

[@ytrewq12345]

Would sound like Jrock, and imagine if they actually do that. Pink Venon had a slight change and was a Shitshow everywhere. I love Dreamcatcher, but some songs are so heavily Jrockpop that I think, what anime this came from? Love G-Idle but they don't follow a "formula" like Blackpink, outside Soyeon being the only rapper, and they had a little of creative freedom. Blackpink cannot fail, Blackpink cannot lose, Blackpink is a product that is overpriced, and cannot afford to lose his value in the market, or will perish. Idle can test the waters, is on them. Blackpink cannot. Is sad, but is truth. And maybe we follow different sources, but compare Idle (BTW TOMBOY was well received? '-.- compared to which Blackpink song? If we are going to compare, let's do the right way) or Dreamcatcher (compared to...) to Blackpink is a stretch that my brain cannot do, doesn't matter how hard I try.

[@dededededede]

"baby's first rap battle" - i LOVE your quips and your writing is SO UNIQUE. as someone who does freelance writing, i think you're commentary is always valuable bc we don't see serious discussion in english language k-pop commentary

[@chanell3166]

That and “Teddy patty formula” sent me

[@nedvicky20]

Unless I’m saying “yasss slay” then someone will literally always wonder why I even expressed myself in the first place because they only want to hug box their faves because they’re so devoted to this culture of blind praise. These people aren’t defending the girls like they would think they’re doing, they’re defending TEDDY and the team at YG picking and producing songs that aren’t breaking the mold and aren’t bringing anything new to the plate. You’re defending the song like you know it is fulfilling the girls’ needs artistically with every drop of the beat and every verse.

[@emmanuelitastephene2702]

Exactly

[@pettybee3860]

My friend (I'm not discrediting her opinion and what she likes) she told me that she liked Lalisa and she didn't understand at first why I didn't like it. I was highly underwhelmed and was cringing through the entirety of the video and song. That was also the same thing for Money. She had the same reaction towards Enhypen's Pass The Mic. For me it was like the boys were trying too hard to act cool, that it was cringy and takes away from their natural charm and charisma. The raps in the song felt so disconnected from the rest of the video as well as the actual singing in the song also. Every part felt different just like Pink Venom

[@babarrett1]

When it comes to the song, since it it is classic Teddy formula I do anticipate negative feedback to the song itself, but I do really want to hear your analysis on the video itself. Performances, choreography, aesthetics, colors, content, there’s a lot of interesting stuff there. Glad you’re still around! Edit: now that I’ve fully seen the video, agree with just about everything you said. I do like the song, give it a C. The one thing I’m concerned about for the album is track count. Last album could barely qualify as an album and more like an extended EP. And since this could be BP’s last comeback, I’m really wanting 12 tracks or more on this album. But knowing YG’s track record, I’m not hopeful about it.

[@AB-yk2pq]

10 songs 1 is Ready for love 1 is tt "Born Kill" based on Target tracklist and one is its English version. This still isn't comfired but doesn't sound untrue to be honest. Edit: it's actually 8 songs including Ready for love. It was even worse than I thought.

[@beatrizletras693]

The MVs are just as formulaic as the songs unfortunately

[@traytrayland2279]

@@AB-yk2pq have you heard about any remixes, more language versions or acoustic versions? I can see them throwing an acoustic version of LSG, korean ice cream and remixes of HYLT or pretty savage to bulk out the song count. Maybe even add the concert remixes. The album and square 1 (their debut) was the only time they didn't pull that trick and I don't trust them not to do it again.

[@AB-yk2pq]

@@traytrayland2279 Well, they're pulling out Ready for love which was 80% leaked a year ago. Born Kill supposedly also have 2 versions (regular one and full English one) and knowing Blackpink, they probably have 2 featuring western artists.

[@pretendtheresaname9213]

I'd advise you to keep the word EP (+LP), out of your vocabulary when talking about K-Pop. The equivalence of EP = Mini Album and LP = Full Album has never existed in practicality, you can find from the beginning 1st gen full album with 7 tracks, that slips into and appears repeatedly in 2nd gen, 3rd and 4th so no, this is not an extended EP, it's a full album from a confused industry that doesn't get it's labels straight. This is not coming from the West. We've seen: • Single albums with 1, 2 and 3 songs; • Mini albums with 3-9 songs; • Full albums with 7+ songs. It's been ridiculous seen people trying to downplay this as a full album while ignoring it's definition, or lack thereof, in K-Pop. And yes, I do agree they need more music and should drop 15-20 tracks, this is simply a rant about labels and "they just got a mini album 😜".

[@plasmakitten4261]

The discussion at the beginning is such an important message for people to hear. I've been into kpop since 2017 and it has always blown my mind how impossible it is to not like something in this community.

[@owaowa4605]

no fr! kpop stan’s will literally drag you for not liking a song and it’s embarrassing

[@softfairry]

i honestly and totally agree with you and what you said in the "Just Say You Don't Like It" section. I love your essays, they are so well written and express a lot. I discovered your channel a year or 2 years ago and i can't be more than happy to say that i am happy i found it💕

[@pregnantleggies3696]

The song is an okay song, however I cannot stand the pre recorded live that they did. They were live on the VMAs thankfully but so many people refused to admit the inkigayo stage was not even live and when i made a comment on it I got ‘they were trained do sound like that’ but then we actually hear them live and people refuse to admit that almost every K-pop group doesn’t sound absolutely perfect. This adds onto what you said, you can make criticism on anything and people will assume it’s hate instead of taking the time to consider you may be making valid points.

[@rubyjane9119]

They were live on inkigayo but the backtrack is awfully loud in Korean shows it wasn’t pre recorded cause you could hear when they skipped some parts

[@si_multifandom_ch_5099]

@@rubyjane9119 YG pre-recorded vocals have always been realistic sounding tho (some little vocal cracks, kinda shaky vocals, some skipped lines), ever since 2020. I wouldn’t be surprise if Pink Venom “live” stage vocals in both Inkigayo and Special Stage are realistic pre-recorded vocals too (LMR)

[@beatm6948]

Let's get "imma stan that" on the case

[@cWjkL8ysxOkrH66]

the ones who denied it are dumb then because idols always lip-sync in the first week of promotions

[@kieuvu-kayser5624]

Why can’t you stand it? A bit dramatic lmao even if they were not live it surely doesn’t affect your life that much

[@mochaamv]

Thank you for that call out in the beginning. Make what you want, and say what you want! Your subscribers love your essays and want to hear what you think. Critique does not = hate and so many people don't understand that.

[@odothedoll2738]

The intro hits so hard for me. Some people don’t realize that analyzing media is fun for some people. Some people don’t realize that you can have negative criticism for something that you like. In fact, you should, nothing is perfect and you should want the things you love to be better.

[@astralwishes13]

“come on goldilocks” GOD i love your commentary your intro was so valid and highlighted the issues i’ve had with blackpink fans recently. they seem to use the “blackpink punching bag” excuse for EVERY SONG. sure, blackpink get hate for dumb reasons, but they can’t seem to differentiate that from genuine valid criticism and all it does is make them look bitter. pink venom was not a good song in my opinion, but i’m glad that for some people it was worth the wait and very good. i’m happy for them. my issue is when they try to say that if another group i liked released the song i would like it. that bothers me for two reasons. 1) it implies that i don’t ‘like’ blackpink. i do, if i didnt i wouldn’t be watching their content. criticism of a group does not equate to disliking them. in fact, learning how to point out flaws in a group you love is a great skill. 2) it’s untrue. pink venom is an authentically blackpink song. from the production to the lyrics to the formula it’s THEIR song. the reason the “other group” excuse doesn’t work here is because no other group WOULD release this song. blackpink is the only group that could possibly pull this song off, and, at least in my opinion, they didn’t. so who else could? at the end of the day no matter what your reasons are for disliking pink venom, whether you have a narrative completed list or can’t gather your thoughts to explain it, kpop fans NEED TO LEARN to accept criticism. no, not everyone is going to like your group’s recent comeback. no, it’s not always hate, targeting, or favouritism. and no, no one owes it to you to be quiet about their opinions. why are yours more important? because they’re positive? constructive criticism is positive too. we all just need to learn to hear each other more. that applies to both sides. but silencing one side of opinions doesn’t benefit anyone.

[@sparkyblue7016]

I agree, so much. I've gotten people say to me under KZbin comments to just leave if I don't like the song. But I like blackpink, and I like their songs. I'm watching them because I like them. Whenever I come up criticism, most of the comments are just plain ignorance like, go write a song yourself then, can you dance like them? As if I will do that for some random stranger on the KZbin. Their entitlement to think that only praises should be showered on their group is insane. Another example is twice, I love them, they're my ultimate group but I do agree that in their albums they have many filler songs. Bts has three very similar and western targeted singles. Blackpink uses the same formula and rarely tries anything new. But whenever I express such opinions I'm bombarded with many nonsensical comments. The most problematic seems blinks, because blackpink rarely gets a comeback they get hypersensitive about anything and everything. Another comment which makes no sense is who asked you. Like excuse me, this is the internet, you put out your opinion for everyone to see, I'm allowed to comment on it. Then there is the comment of you just interact with toxic communities in blink hence you're also toxic. Like why would go to a toxic comment section willinging lol. I just got hate comments for expressing my opinions, the same as I'm getting now. And so many more kpop comments which are simply ridiculous and don't make sense.

[@Maya_hee]

@@sparkyblue7016 The only way I can explain it is that blinks have tied their entire identity around liking BP, even the smallest form of criticism feels like a personal attack on their existence as a person.

[@zanerobbins7604]

My immediate knee jerk reaction to this entire release as a whole (teasers, music video, song itself, styling, general aesthetic) is that blackpink (and yg in general) can afford to be WAYYYYYYY more weird and conceptually literal. i saw the phrase "pink venom" on instagram and immediately thought of so many cool ideas to draw from, evil scientists in laboratories making toxins, snakes and other venomous animals, dying a tragically fashionable death from a snakebite, etc. There was such a cool direction they couldve gone with this, and aside from the gas masks, they didnt. im not surprised, just disapointed. i think the last time any of yg's creative works as a whole have been conceptually interesting was 2ne1's crush album era. i want to see blackpink tackle a song with a much more clear narritive purpose, like come back home. i honestly dont have a problem with them railing about how badass they are 24/7, thats what i go to blackpink for, but i wanna see them be badasses for a good reason.

[@zhangqiling8086]

What makes it worse, is that YG isn't a small poor company, and they obviously got tons of people working there, how come all these people with their high budget couldn't come up with better ideas, filming sets and lyrics?! Like you said there are tons of things they could use and go with for this concept. The Pink Venom in itself is a dope ass title, but the song and MV aren't as half as dope...this was just illogical, even kids could come up with much much better and more interesting results.

[@m00nl1ghtj3w3l]

I am still at the start but let me tell you I'm LOVING the sassiness (and somehow pissy-ness) of the intro because, just. You put everything I thought about into words and I love your attitude while at it.

[@m00nl1ghtj3w3l]

I finished the video and the only things I have to say are 1) I'm glad someone else feels the same way about how the video is cut. It gives me a headache tbh. And 2) I admire your positivity in regards to the girls' career as a group. I honestly lost hope at this point but framing it by your perspective makes me think they can be salvageable still.

[@dn45678]

I honestly feel like when companies spend an enormous amount of videos, it’s to distract the consumers from the fact that the song lacks.

[@plapln9347]

"It's a good rule of thumb not to remind your viewer of all the different entertainment they could be consuming right now." DAMN I have never thought of referencing in that way! Always love your videos, and I constantly look forward to your nuanced analyses. ❤️

[@candacescorner3141]

I love how much Mera has been releasing recently. Of course it’s important to prioritize your health and not overwork yourself, but every time she releases a new video it feels like a treat. I actually enjoy how Mera just makes videos about what she wants to and sometimes they’re about random things but they’re always great. Also great point at the beginning. I think people are having more and more selection bias in terms of criticism and analysis where if you say something bad some people will ignore any praise and just assume that you’re a hater. For Pink Venom itself, there’s not much I can say I feel like it’s just like every other BlackPink title track. Not terrible but nothing new. That said, I’m obsessed with Jisoo’s scenes in the music video.

[@breakthewall.mp3126]

I will never understand why someone would use the "If you don't like it - don't talk about it" line with you. You're never disrespectful, you never use blank statements without explaining, and you never say that your opinion is the only valid one. It's like they don't watch the videos. That being said, i do understand why fans say that to some _other_ youtubers. I noticed more and more fully negative videos where people insult groups, their music and anyone who like it. "Criticizing" (insulting actually) everything from the concept to the idols' facial features. On top of that, they say that everyone who disagrees is tasteless and should stop trying talking about music. Basically twitter trolls on youtube level. And the audience eats it, quotes those videos proudly, like they're some kind of an expert.

[@Angel-te2jt]

The way I RAN here, when I heard the Mera identified BP formula of this song I knew I couldn’t wait for your analysis

[@zozobop]

i absolutely love your reviews because they actually make me revisit songs sometimes with a new idea to think about. i liked On The Ground but I liked it because it was a catchy song. when you spent time talking about it I actually went back and looked and appreciated it a deeper manner. your reviews always give me something to revisit in a song or take me to a new direction so I hope you continue to make essays on songs you like and dislike. love your words, love your work

[@Grogurt1998]

everyday since the album, I wake up, I check if she posted. I go to work, during my break I check if she posted. I get off work, I check if she posted. HELP ME.

[@crm1301]

I’m a boring nerd, so I did a little math, and of the 87 public videos on your channel, only 15 are (strictly) about Blackpink, and the majority of those are praise, edits, or era reviews that are always at least partially positive. the claims that your channel is a “cesspool of hate couldn’t be further from the truth. you’re also never negative towards the girls themselves. i’ve been subscribed since 2019 and I’m actually not sure if i’ve ever seen you get through a BP video without talking about how you’re in love with jisoo.

[@AURORAstuff]

I am more than excited and interested to hear your opinion about this! love your videos

[@bvnditbul7039]

I didn't really like Pink Venom but I didn't really expected to do so no hard feelings. I'm fine with disliking their prereleases as long as I can enjoy the title track of their albums. Music aside I found the MV to be borderline unwatchable. The editing was so hectic and together with the flashing it actually made me nauseous. What a shame because their massive budgets go to waste when you can't even appreciate the sets and outfits. If I had the patience I would count every cut in the video and compare it with other kpop releases just for fun. Someone should get fired

[@k53107]

Star Wars reviewer: I'm sad to say that we do indeed get told all the time to focus on what we love and shut up if we didn't like something. -__- There's a general pushback against critique in recent years, which is sad because critique is a very valid artform on its own, and has a great place in fandom! If we like pieces of art, we're going to want to explore what makes them work, what doesn't, and especially if we like parts of one thing and not other aspects, we want to explore why! Keep doing what you're doing; your critiques are always well-articulated and thought-provoking!

[@cWjkL8ysxOkrH66]

do you think this sudden anti-critic mindset we have now is the result of the MCU's success? any correlation?

[@k53107]

​@@cWjkL8ysxOkrH66 There's a correlation for sure, but correlation isn't inherently causation. Honestly there are a looot of factors influencing it, of which the capitalistic commercialization of art is really only one potential factor. I do think this plays a role in setting certain expectations for mass consumption=above criticism, but I'm more inclined to look at the rise of the internet and publicly available information (which is not a bad thing!) making critique more accessible for artists and fans, and global factors making parasocial relationships (which again aren't actually bad inherently; almost every art fan ever will see a reflection of their own interests/desires in art, which makes it a part of their identity) a good escape from the hellhole that is earth right now. Plus, going back to people making art their identity, I do think there's the factor of people being unable to step back and realize that a critique of something they love isn't inherently a moral condemnation of them as a person. There are also issues leading to the rise of virtue signaling and an overreliance on perceived social morality (which in previous generations was perceived religious devotion). So basically, there are a million factors at play here, and some sociologist will have fun writing about it in about a hundred years. 😆

[@sfukuda512]

As far as video essays are concerned: there is a field of study called art criticism. Many video essays fall under that category. Not liking art or other people's reaction to that art is fine, but not knowing why is a sign of ignorance or mis-education. I like the 500+ word video essay. It helps me form my own opinions into more concrete ideas. I may not agree wholeheartedly with the points in the essay, but I can at least feel like I'm arguing from some foundation. CJ the X did a great video about this. One of his points is that you criticize the art that you love because you want to see the artist do so much better. If I were a music writer, producer, or cinematographer, I would love intelligent criticism. I want people to not blindly consume art. Then again, I recognize that some folks will have a visceral reaction to some art, and not necessarily a well-articulated intellectual reaction. Anyway, I'm not a huge fan of BlackPink. I just dropped by to say that these video essays are a treasure trove of insights into the M/V's, discographies, and careers of the groups you cover. I loved Dodging Disbandment. Please stay safe and warm.

[@Flora-ix3os]

Do agree with the part about maybe too much sampling, every time I hear Lisa’s part I just want to go and listen to Pon de replay way more than carry on listening to Pink Venom

[@RD-oo6yq]

I immediately went to pon de replay after the song so that is some proof.

[@nemo5288]

They move the goalposts because it’s a form of shutting you down - they want everyone to be quiet and I’m so glad you called the behaviour out. Bravo!!! ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥 It’s one of the many reasons why we seems to be unable to have nuanced discussions on the internet. Re On the Ground - your video was the one that made me actually like the song! Without that video, I would still be here disliking it so people commenting so negatively on it are hilarious in the way that I (and perhaps others) would not have gone back to give the song a second/third/fourth chance

[@ThunderJams]

The fact that you write full essays about K-pop and treat it as an art form worth analysing is exactly why I love your channel! The way that you discuss different songs and groups so in depth often inspires me to check out more groups and form my own opinion, so thank you! Also, it's wild to me that people will write you off as a BlackPink hater when... you've made positive videos about BlackPink before? Looking at something as a whole unit and commenting on both the positives and negatives doesn't make you any less of a fan - I'd argue it makes you more of a fan because you have the overwhelming passion to analyse songs and the desire to see groups improve over time!

[@sonyafuks4614]

i don't usually leave comments but it's important the you know that for every person that sends hate comments, there are hundreds and thousands of people who appreciate and love your work that looks beyond the shell and diggs deep unappologaticaly. there's always going to be someone out there that'll disagree with you, so keep doing what you do knowing that your work is thought provoking and not fishing for views. as far as the song goes, as a pre-release it works well at exciting us fans for the album (though lyrically there's nothing interesting in my opinion). and i really hope that the title track is going to be something different that we haven't heard from them yet. stay strong and keep up the genuine work. much love from Israel!

[@emotionalsupportanimal_]

I've been looking forward to hearing your take on pink venom. Your video about blackpink's discography has really helped form an objective opinion on some songs by not only blackpink but other kpop groups . That analytical outlook has carried over into other intrests and work of my own . Thank you for doing what you do . I always look forward to watching your new uploads 😊

[@ArgoBargo]

My favorite thing about your channel is that you DO explain yourself. I love that you dig deep into the artistic value of K-pop. I feel like you’re the only K-pop KZbinr who actually looks at the “why” in K-pop.

[@apolop.r.4325]

6:00 Thank you for bringing this issue to the surface. We need more nuance in Kpop if we truly care about it.

[@FairyRay]

Maybe I am too old, but I always learned at school that it was important to listen to all perspectives or else we won't progress, change etc. Why do people think it is not necessary to voice your opinion? Why do people not understand that a different opinion or criticism is NOT hate?

[@wickedsai]

Please don't stop your essays. It's what brought me to your channel a d what keeps me coming back. I fangirl occasionally but I enjoy looking at things critically. Especially if I'm not super into a song or video and I can't understand why. You help me sort my own brain and often help me get over whatever I didn't like.

[@b-okay]

Mera, haters gonna hate. No such thing as the "right amount" nor do you need to be less "negative". Forget your haters! 🙄 Just know, I am a big lover of your videos and your analyses 🥰 I eat up your 500 words and 20-minute videos. If you ever just wanna do a 1-hr video of whatever, I would listen to it and LOVE it even if I disagree with you. You're a big reason why I started liking Blackpink, particularly Jisoo. So thank you for all you do and thank you for another great video.

[@jacki8106]

Hope you’re doing well Mera!! You deserve the best 💙💙

[@beastghostt]

It's funny that you mentioned the Pink Venom video "not flashing its highlights in your eyes". I get photophobia as a side effect of chronic migraine [bright or flashing lights make me sick] and it's gotten really difficult to watch kpop videos in the last two years as this condition ramped up. Don't even get me started on live stages. Anyway, something I found jarring about the editing in this video is that sometimes there'd be so many quick cuts in rapid succession, I'd actually start to feel it just from that alone. I don't think I've ever experienced that before. Even without a photosensitive condition, that is some whack-ass editing.

[@Linkinstar_Gaming]

The irony behind this. You could use their own argument against them. "Don't watch my videos, if you don't like them." "Just say you don't like it and move on" You can't please anybody. Keep doing how you like it. There's always someone talking shit.

[@matildanorton]

Well to say i have been waiting for this is an understatement, love you mera 💜

[@garretburrow]

Netizens: "Stop spending 20 minutes talking about it..." mera: _makes 20 minute video talking about it_ 🔥🔥🔥

[@eem8736]

As someone who absolutely LOVES kpop videos essays (reasons why I love you , everglow up , midnight theoris , chaebin n out and so on) I really appreciate how you don't listen to what others say but instead continue to give us even longer video essays 😅

[@jk_ilyu]

you're definitely a breath of fresh air and supplier of "grass touched" content and opinions here on kpop KZbin that's why i love your channel so much ❤️ keep doing you

[@emilyisawaytoo5146]

As someone who watches a lot of video essays, kpop fans interactions with criticism will always confuse me. No other community would tell you to not talk about something you didn't like. Other communities have people making hour long videos breaking down how they would rewrite a movie. And when you look at commentary KZbin you see hours and hours of content that criticizes other influencers actions. Fandom allows people to live in an echo chamber, never indulging in opinions other than their own. "Let people enjoy things" is just as important as "Let people hate things". Of course you shouldn't be little others for liking or not liking something. But personally my favorite part of music is it's ability to carry emotion to the listener. I love seeing people get passionate about media, positive or not.

[@iGotBulletproof-Insomnia]

With over 98K subscribers you are very clearly doing something right, Mera. The thing I appreciate the most about your videos is the fact that you don't only gush about a group and say "omg I love them so much! Kings! Queens! Slay!" You tell us why they slayed and why they could have done more. I've started noticing that many of the fans who complain that Kpop/fandom is toxic contribute to the toxicity. Fans need to quit policing "how to be fans" and just let each other enjoy the music. Or not enjoy the music. Someone disliking or criticizing something you like literally has no reflection on you. That's not too hard to understand 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@rishika3410]

i fell in love with ur introduction. U GOT A NEW SUBSCRIBER MERA.

[@kirpelfrey]

Mera, I am so glad you ranted in the beginning. It's ridiculous that fans can't take well rounded, eloquent, CONSTRUCTIVE criticism for a group they love. If people can't talk about popular releases, and their criticism for those releases, why even post it publicly in the first place? It just doesn't make sense. Plus, you always discuss what you like and didn't like about a release. So, the problem is??? I don't get it. Keep doing what you do. I absolutely love you. Your perspective is refreshing and always welcome, even if we don't always agree. 💞

[@phantomgirl_0009]

"I'm a coconut tree, i drop hit after hit. You make like a banana and split." Love it!

[@stephanieb5120]

So many kpop fans want to have it both ways. They want their faves to be seen as incredible risk takers artists who do what’s never been done before!!!!…. But also ignore that creatives who do make waves always ALWAYS make some people mad and/or inspire ambivalence and debate. Like, oh my god, the Beatles are held up as the pinnacle of pop and I can’t can’t how many times they caused a moral panic! Popular culture is designed to get people talking and passionate. If you can’t handle your faves being discussed as artists - with all the critique that can come with it - then you really don’t have confidence in them. ETA: also just gotta add that your video on the framing styles for each member made me realize I’m basically a Blink (whereas seeing people repeating omg slayyyy over and over never did)

[@ceastar]

It makes me happy that you have the strength to post these kinds of videos. It feels like I’m listening to someone who actually has passion for what kpop can be. Blackpink is just “Baby’s First Kpop”, which is why it has such a brutal fandom for the limited amount of effort YG has actually put into them. You take the time to explain that, but you also give it a boost by describing the good things about each of the girls 😊

[@everglowup]

Girl I WANTED to hear what you had to say, I actually couldn't wait lol But on a more serious note, the truth is people can only handle criticism and critique when it's not their faves. They will find anything to discredit any good and proper analysis whatsoever to soothe their ego. They don't have to confidence to just say "hey I like this song coz I find it good" they need other people to validate their enjoyment of the song as well. Their confidence rests in group think, so when someone has an opinion that differs the response is always to bully people out of wanting to express their feelings. Omg something I forgot to mention in my review, The lack of Rosé and Jisoo kind of bothered me ngl. "You better make I like a banana and split" girl is 5am I almost fell off my bed. Lisa in the chorus> Jennie for sure.

[@liesesterben9639]

You always paint such a unique painting of the song you're talking about that I make sure I watch/listen to it before I watch your video, then I watch it after with the new colors you've added to it. A lot of times it helps me like the song more somehow, gives new meaning or pointed something out I didn't notice, and I love it. Whatever people say about your videos, I appreciate each one of them because I enjoy hearing what you have to say and how you say it. Thanks for another great video!

[@dyingforeddiemunson]

i love that you use "too many words", plainly because i fucking adore your writing style and expressiveness. plus plus plus your in-depth discussions are always a treat, and honestly having watched your videos for a while, I can say that you will deal with topics with a lot of nuance and care whether that means you do it in 5 words or 500. your channel is awesome and thank you for making it so fresh and fun~ edit: . critique is necessary, especially when it comes to pop-culture (and no, critique isn't inherently negative). i just don't think it's good to only expect or want blind praise or criticism without any nuance??? like-

[@el-erso]

No but listening to your opinions is so fun!! whether I agree with them or not, it is so nice for me because of all the substance you bring to the table, I love listening to you talk because you’re very creative with your words and everything is so well structured. As someone who speaks english as their second language, I find your diction particularly stimulating and very enjoyable

[@bonesandsnaps]

that segment at the beginning is such a good point but honestly i'd listen to whatever you had to say even if you were talking a foreign language, you're just such a good talker.

[@marisamary7]

Everytime I watch your videos Im so shocked about how interesting you describe and explain everything. Its so fun to watch and listen.

[@janrojasr]

We get it. You are rich and pretty and you don't need love and.. that's it? what else is blackpink? what message they want to send to the world since this may be their last comeback? Blackpink is more like four successful soloists that meet every two years for bussiness. Jisoo is an actress, Lisa and Jennie influencers/fashionistas and Rosé is the only singer. They are not longer passionate about this and i blame YG for that.

[@nonfragile]

I had been waiting on your opinion on Pink Venom, I love hearing your well spoken analysis about songs!

[@eavrrrr7494]

Those comments come from immature people. You craft your sentences in a way that gives me chills and sometimes brings me to tears because you explain so beautifully what I feel. Please don’t stop

[@sur_un_nuage]

i only discovered your channel recently because of your blackpink videos because you both point out their greatness and weaknesses (the music quality nothing against the girls) and you do that so beautifully and as professionally as ktube goes, you helped me appreciate them again

[@codylakee]

Your reviews are so meaningful and honest

[@leeeeemayne]

I'm a massive blink and I personally look forward to your 'essays.' Great video.

[@justinesworld5719]

The way you express yourself is so beautiful. You are very well spoken and i love your intense analysis that bring so many layers and you deserve a lot of recognition for the amount of effort and dedication you put in your work. Please keep going and make content that makes you proud!

[@hihi615]

I don't mean this as hate to anyone, but I actually lowkey enjoy your videos more than I do comebacks sometimes (sure I like the comebacks, but it's just something about the analyzation of it that I'm really addicted too-)

[@louiseirwin9496]

oh thank god someone else who likes the chorus😭 i love hearing your opinions and how well you explain them; you always give so much detail and you’re so passionate about it :]

[@stephendoe7594]

I think for me personally the problem i have with Blackpink stems from the infrequency of their comebacks. In the interim between BP comebacks I end up listening to so much fantastic music coming from other groups in the kpop scene, that when a BP song isn't great it becomes that much more underwhelming. It's like my brain says "I waited 2 years for that?" Since BP's last comeback I've gotten three or four excellent Dreamcatcher albums, four Korean albums alone from Twice, PIXY debuted and blew me away with three fantastic mini albums, Purple Kiss slayed multiple comebacks, Idle released multiple very solid albums, and Red Velvet came back from hiatus to produce Queendom and Feel My Rhythm(possibly my favorite of their albums to date). Through all of this, these other groups have evolved, developed, and refined their sounds into something unique and special, into music that grabs me by the soul and won't let go. Blackpink's sound has barely moved since D4(with the exception of Lovesick Girls). It feels like while the rest of the industry progresses and pushes forward, Blackpink is still locked in a bygone age. I find this disappointing, after all Blackpink got me into Kpop, but they just have been overshadowed by a bunch of other extremely talented groups working their butts off to produce great music.

[@Geetakhr]

I can feel it... I got into k-pop because of BP and When I started seeing new artists like twice, red velvet, G-Idle and Mamamoo I was just really overwhelmed by their amazing music they don't have the same concept all along I mean I get it if they like making girl crush and there are people out there who still like girl crush but the kind of song they produce shouldn't take a year...It feels weird to hear a song and just go like..."Uhm, Did I hear it somewhere else?" And then you realise "Oh, it's the same formula...Jennie opening, then Lisa and rose and jisoo's pre chorus and then a chorus section with two or three minimal words and then Lisa and Jennie coming again with a pretty sassy kind of lyrics rap and at the end a bridge and the YG party chorus with a word chanting" It just feels so annoying....It's like someone took 12 hours in a kitchen and you have expectations you will get s whole meal but all you get is boiled rice Anyways...let's up too the album even If I don't prefer BP's music that Much there's a thing I can't deny....Their B-sides do slap

[@ravenn532]

i love your explanations. they sound smart and qualified and i always like hearing varying opinions even if mine differ, keep doing your thing!

[@oskxzr]

Some people don’t understand the objective perspective that you give. Your content is so great because you don’t pretend to like songs you don’t like; you aren’t afraid to give constructive criticism. Don’t let people who see this as blind hatred get to you. Me and your true fans will keep watching your content.

[@kkurajam]

Thank you for being so direct with your criticism of kpop stans

[@juks23]

congrats on almost 100k! i've been a fan since your old dreamcatcher video, keep up the awesome and entertaining analysis' and high quality content!!

[@SquishyBeans]

I love your video essays, its so interesting and i learn new things constantly, you truly said something that hits hard, people only click on things that will enrage them on purpose. Just like people watch things that make them sad and get mad at the creator for making them upset. it's not on you it's their problem. Just keep on doing your mera; love your videos.

[@Evergladez]

Mera putting out more frequent videos is not the comeback I was expecting but is the best cb of the year.

[@dragonize9826]

Haven't finished the video yet, but I HEAVILY agree with your point about people's fake "ugh just say you don't like it and go" attitudes. I remember watching your video about the BP formula and the jist was "I LIKE them, but I feel like this tired formula is a waste of fans' time and money and an insult to the girls" and I had to agree. Some groups people genuinely do not like but even mild HEALTHY criticism of groups they do like is met with vitriol from rabid stans and it's...spineless?? Cringe? A sign of people further absorbing the media they enjoy as aspects of their personality? Very odd "logged on" behavior.

[@lakshmikrishnan6376]

Honestly you always have good nuanced opinions and always give balanced arguments that look at both sides and i do enjoy listening to you.

[@namiko282]

Thank you for this intro. It sums up exactly how I’ve been feeling whenever I open up one of my discussion based media apps. I’ve been so frustrated lately at how anti intellectual and resistant to true critique most most media has become. I don’t care if you do or don’t like something I like, I came here to hear others thoughts. If I don’t feel like you expressed yours adequately I’ll leave, but so many people seems so entitled to police others past the boundaries of immortality and hatefulness (which are the only things I would call out someone for) in an opinion based piece.

[@sparknmif]

I was looking forward to this not because of the possible unpopular opinion but for the well thought out and eloquent way that you always put forward your opinions. You are always honest and never let anything jeopardise your integrity. You’re a real one never change!

[@blackjackal8453]

0:00 - 06:00 thank you Mera. Finally someone said something factual.

[@blackjackal8453]

I really dislike how some people reacted to the critiques of this song and many other songs. People should be allowed to say that they don't like a something, especially when they have a good explanation for it. I personally am not a fan of BLACKPINK/blink, nor do I like how majoraty of their songs are basically decame firmula over and over again, nor do I go out of my way to listen to their discography on a regular as their songs are just not my cup of tea. I personally enjoy songs that have a bit more thought put into them and that have more interesting melodies. Now I don't dislike the melody or the instrumentation of this song I just think there are better songs out there and that I could be listening to much better music, and I do. I did enjoy On the ground though, the song is very emotional and honest, I really liked the theme of it and it reminded me a bit of some of the oldschool songs that I love to listen to.

[@blackjackal8453]

The members of BLACKPINK are really nice from what I can tell and clearly are more the capable of performing and entertaing, so I don't have that many problems with them.

[@herecomesthesun8805]

I love when you make videos about Blackpink, I like how you share your opinions when it's about Blackpink, like your voice sounds exciting, or with more passion, your jokes too lol, you laugh, I mean, everything colorful in your voice, than other videos you upload about other kpop groups. Idk, I just enjoy so much your videos about the Queens!

[@chrimisu3198]

On your old how you like that video, the criticism part I take to heart till this day. You perfectly explain how I feel about blackpink and that still holds to my current feelings of blackpink as a yg teddy music group. I've outgrown blackpink and don't really resonate with their music anymore. But what that being said, I'm so happy that the girls still got it and looked absolutely stunning (specifically jisoo this era) I gasped because I also like this chorus much more than kill this love and how you like that for sure.

[@enthusiast8017]

I love channels that aren’t afraid to express their opinions with proper explanation. I don’t get people to watch criticism videos just to complain. Not everywhere will agree with you, and just because someone does, doesn’t mean they hate it. Criticism and hate are completely different

[@carmanmyrick4907]

Can I just say I am a massive blink but I LOVE your vids. It makes me love the song even more when hearing it broken down like this, truly!! Also, I agree, I sorely missed rosé in the chorus

[@nick0_]

I don't agree with some things, but i like how you expose facts respectfully and objectively :)

[@its_cocodans]

Pleaseee review the rest of the album. I love the way you go into detail about a song , the chorus, the color palettes and the themes they have all together. You have a way with words mera. :))

[@teddy1642]

I love how you express yourself and your thoughts, I always watch all of your videos even when I don’t know anything about the K-pop bands you mention because I just love listening to you speak so charismatically about how you feel about things. I just tune in every time because I genuinely really like how thoughtful and passionate you are about music and I always learn something more or find a new song to like at the end of your videos. 💜 thank you for making them.

[@iliagonzalez1679]

I think the problem with KZbinrs is no the "essays" (cuz you do it so respectfully that even when I disagree with you, I can still appreciate your thoughts) to me the problem is the lack of respect that we have reached. Especially with girl groups, they have no filter, almost like they've believe that the more aggressive the better. You're allowed to like/dislike that has never stopped anyone from doing it, but c'mon slutshaming or being cruel for views? that has to stop. We can't keep letting that behaviour continue in the name of "opinion" at least that's what I think

[@Rachel-sm7ym]

Exactly. As someone who loves watching critical reviews and is open to hearing other people's opinions about groups I love, the general reaction to this comeback felt SO different than with other groups. People couldn't just dislike the song, they had to say that BlackPink are untalented, don't deserve to have the success they have, slept their way to top, aren't "real" artists, and every other insult under the sun. That is where I feel like it is appopriate to ask people to just say they don't like the song and move on.

[@juangonzalez2488]

THIS!! Alot of videos of youtubers are just 10 min or more of misogynist speech. Theres no balance... there are few exceptions like Mera but the rest are so grotesque... i cannot believe that they would say that in real life

[@ivzooo]

That's so true, that's why I love mera bc she definitely puts her thoughts in such an eloquent way without disrespecting idols, but other than her I don't follow many This week on twitter was so sad cuz all those comments slutshaming the girls saying they're f#cking teddy among other disgusting things I'm just so sad :( there's literally no safe place for girl groups

[@cecigonzalez2842]

That's why I get sometimes upset about how when it comes to BP they pick apart little by little every detail, but with others groups they don't do the same (not talking about mera because she actually gives a real constructive critic) but the rest just wants views

[@abby3681]

@@Rachel-sm7ym on the topic of people saying they "slept their way to the top" or the other variations of that, not only is it extremely mysoginistic, but given yg's (and yg artists') history with treating women, that should be a cause for concern for the girls, but people instead use it as an insult.

[@traytrayland2279]

Been waiting on your opinion on this and 100% agree. I noticed the why focus on it trend and for a while it made me feel guilty for wanting to express why I feel a way about something, which is crazy becuase why not talk about a genre or a group I enjoy? I feel like blinks who aren't happy about the way things are get pushed to the sides and told to just accept it becuase that's all we are getting and we should be grateful or stop being fans if we can't say anything 100% nice so ira good to see I'm not the only one why simply likes to express how I feel about things, whether it be good or bad I like to think about why I do or don't like something. When I first heard the song it made me feel kind of hopeless, it's not my cup of tea bar the chorus stuck in my head but you looking back on how they did it last time in the conclusion really got my hopes up.

[@octo-pops]

Personally I love hearing people absolutely destroying my taste because it's so interesting to hear other people's opinions!

[@yuribaka4809]

Yeah personally I hate the chorus, but I can now understand better how the repetitiveness of the lyrics and the lack of melody can make it feel catchy for others. So if someone play it next to me I'll try to enjoy wt them.

[@MossG]

I BEEN WAITIN FOR THIS ONE!!! God I was so looking forward to your analysis and I can't wait to watch.

[@lobster5755]

5:56 "Dead dove. Do Not Eat." Me at the end of the video: Well I don't know what I expected. Keep em coming! I love your essays, particularly when I don't agree because they push me to think more critically about what I like/dislike. Also, your alternate rap line of "I'm like a coconut tree..." sounds like something I would've heard from Mordecai and Rigby, in the best way possible.

[@emmanuellexu9436]

You expressed EVERYTHING that i thought but couldn't or didnt know how to so thank youuu

[@ladyteruki]

8:45 The "minimal" (your word) or "soft/subdued" (mine) aspect of the song, girl crush as it may be, is in line with what has been, in my eyes, the quiet trend of the year in girl groups. LE SSERAFIM, NewJeans, IVE, STAYC, among others, have all released songs that found a way to be both catchy and surprisingly soft. Not in a ballady way, and that's really what gets me. I don't have your vocabulary for these things, but it's been very impressive to see how many GGs have taken this posture of quiet, creamy, almost whispering confidence. It's not meekness, it's more like feeling less pressured to associate impact with loudness. So for Blackpink to do it is significant. To me it feels like an evolution in the way femininity is expressed in Kpop. I haven't seen anyone talk about it so maybe I'm imagining it, but seeing Rocket Punch (a group I like but that is produced in a way that the biggest quality you can acknowledge is that their team efficiently spots trends and adapts to them) this week kinda sealed the deal for me and I'll die on that hill.

[@HDMIcord]

I really love how you describe things like outfits, scenery etc. in your videos cause it helps my friend who is legally blind! She says you explain it so she can imagine the details better:)