Punjab's Financial Crisis

Follow me on LinkedIn: / mohakmangal
******
📃Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1P...
******
🔍✍️Research:
Antara: / that_musical_note
✂️🎛️Editing:
Yash Vyas: / yashvyas24
CharanTej: / mograph.charantej
Utpal Singh Jadon: / utpalsinghjadon
🎨Thumbnail :
Aanchal Verma: / aanchal_creates
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
Punjab has been handled, or more like mishandled by many governments until today.
Once India's second-richest state during the Green Revolution, today Punjab has become a current debt-ridden one. But how did it get here?
In this video we unfold the intricate details of Punjab's financial woes, its overdependence on subsidies, and how political decisions have contributed to the state's fiscal challenges. With insights into the recent actions taken by the AAP government, you'll gain a comprehensive understanding of the state's economic situation and its uncertain future. But the question is, will Punjab be able to ever reclaim its former glory?
Markers:
0:00 Intro
05:10 What do the broad indicators tell us?
08:51 Punjab’s Revenue and Expenditure
13:58 Punjab’s History
19:56 Aam Aadmi Party

[@mohak_mangal]

Start your journey to Freelance Freedom here: courses.sochbymm.com/

[@Sheikhfaizan788]

Make a video on Kashmir current situation especially after abrogation of article

[@AkSingh-eu6ew]

Please make a video for jharkhand 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@VanYog.206]

Make a video on the downfall of Maharashtra due to politics

[@nee1383]

Bhai , please make a video on khalistani

[@MITAAN_Official]

Please make a video on Chhattisgarh economy and how india is not growing collectively. Because some states are going up and some are going down, some are stagnated. Trust me, it feels very bad to see your state in bad situations.

[@irfanmomin123]

My state is West Bengal. The main problems here are - corruption (ssc recruitment scam, sarada chitt fund etc) , political violence and gundaraj, unemployment

[@universal_lover]

You didn't mention crime...

[@Abu_Tahir_Al-Jannabi]

First time seeing a Muslim criticizing the Non-BJP ruled State

[@bloodwargaming3662]

Crime? Kolkata reported 19 rape cases . Delhi 2000 . Sure is bengal in a bad place but pls don't fall for media bs who is ready to paint out a Venezuela type image of every opposition ruled state

[@Shirsh09]

Main Problem Is TMC

[@Abu_Tahir_Al-Jannabi]

@@Shirsh09 No main Problem is Communalism and Appeasement Politics.

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

Delhi - Air pollution Uttrakhand - why development is limited to Dehradun side and not in pahadi places Bihar - why is Bihar so hopeless state Andhra Pradesh - same debt problem Chattisgarh, jharkhand and odisha - why naxalite movement is mostly in tribal districts of these states Gujarat - why Gujarat lacks in social indicators when its economy is so good Telengana - why is telengana dependent on Hyderabad only

[@BabuMosahi]

You forgot MP why so corrupt eating money through govt project? And U.P. why so berozgar and so many ra*es.

[@FireandIce-eh7mx]

how would you even develop on pahadi areas, joshimath yaad he kya

[@kundanborakb]

​@@FireandIce-eh7mxdevelopment ka mtlb only road/building nhi hota or pahadi areas bhut bde h joshimath chota area h...

[@addicssy_]

Ropeways bnao Paryatan ki wajah se joshimath khtm hua na ki development ki wajah se

[@meghdoot8608]

Naxalite movement is limited to south chattisgarh not in Odisha and jharkhand

[@HarishKumar-ji6hq]

I'm proudly from Punjab, but our people here are arrogant and aloof from the reality af. Great video by the way.

[@pjammin00]

That and rice is not a crop for Punjab, (it needs power to keep rice in 4inch water, depleting groundwater) it grows in the south or southeast Asia because of rain. Punjabi's are lazy, don't want to work hard on the fields. Punjab lacks industry, but sells a lot of alcohol. Plus the debt from 80's and 90's.

[@sidharth-mx2lf]

Being a young Punjabi,my heart just breaks everytime i hear such news about Punjab,everyone is leaving for Canada,Uk and Australia,but no one wants to improve the condition of Punjab,i am worried about my future in Punjab,I just hope things would get better❤ I don't want to leave Punjab,i want to build a good future in Punjab😢

[@balmeet86]

I moved to Punjab from Delhi to try my luck here so that if I can set my business here then I can do something good for Punjab. Even I also think about what you wrote

[@noteasytohandle]

but no one here in punjab is understanding the problem ,the young generation only wants to leave for abroad for there own better future nobody is thinking to improve punjab's future so we all live here without any problem

[@jasneetkaur6782]

We in Punjab know that there is no hope.We are forced to send our children abroad.

[@dr.santanic_marco1800]

There is nothing we can do, Loka nu free subsidy , bijli chahidi hai , vote krn lge sirf ehi 2 points dekhde hun , kise nu inna akal nhi ke baki cheeja vi dekhniya , I bet ki adhe toh jyada Punjab nu ta economy ki Hundi aa eh nhi pta . That is why we are leaving Punjab ❤

[@noteasytohandle]

@@jasneetkaur6782 yes but if we are financially stable , i think we atleast first say our children to study here and apply for some government exams/business career computer ,online freelancing,etc not just in punjab why dnt we put them into other states for jobs? like ias ips

[@sukhwindersinghbl-7943]

I am from Punjab, thankyou for covering the issues. I think you are the only creator who made videos about Punjab's economy.

[@gayatricasey6618]

Really... youtube is filled with videos of punjab doom..

[@prabhjotsran5851]

Bro where you live,, KZbin is filled with issues of Punjab only, always being defamed by Godis

[@honeysauravladoo]

​@@prabhjotsran5851why cant u digest failure? Cant u see the data? R u mad? Ya fe dimag ch bs kanneda aa?

[@vkone7162]

@@prabhjotsran5851 no wonder Punjab is dooming

[@ayzzk]

Can we all talk about the Bangladeshi and Burmese illegal immigrants living all over North-Eastern states even after the implementation of laws against these illegal immigrants, especially in the states of Assam, Meghalaya and Tripura? As a northeastern myself, I feel that this problem needs to be addressed more and talked about. I love your videos, Mohak Sir. Kindly consider this as a topic for future videos. Would really appreciate if people pay more attention to how NorthEast is simply seen like a "haven for refuge" by the Bangladeshi and Burmese and how the locals are getting affected.

[@What_do_you_want.]

Who locals are getting effected..??

[@abhishekadhikary2206]

Absolutely As a North Easterner I feel the same

[@stxfdt1240]

Hmm

[@thevishleshak]

They are also in Jharkhand

[@shivendra4489]

Yeah true

[@harshdeepbhatia88]

1. Stop diverting water from Punjab to Delhi. 2. Promote subsidised solar energy. 3. Camps for farmers. 4. Stop catfight between political parties. 5. Reduce quota system. ( Hope these things can help)

[@aloysiussaldanha3200]

You need to start a movement ie get the public involved and demand these things of the current dispensation.

[@dakshsharma4360]

How will stopping the water will help

[@rameshkumardas5732]

Absolutely sir. Bhawant Maan Government should be implement these Schemes.

[@RandeepSingh-rr5oi]

As a punjabi very well and balanced video you made. Our government need to look into this seriously

[@harrysinghsidhu303]

Punjab is in it's downfall period but still better than 90% of indian states in standard of living, low level of poverty and many other things. We'll surely get out of this phase soon. WMK. ✌️

[@ashishkp9999]

I agree, I think punjab should reduce its expenditures on freebies for a while. I'm from Karnataka and I know what freebie does to the economy

[@mr.perfectbeing2466]

💀 standard of living Bro there's something called population

[@youtubersdub4339]

Stop living in dream...brother

[@gurkanwalsingh1333]

That's a dilemma I used to think same

[@blackbrute2504]

Standard of living lol

[@jaidhaliwal421]

Some people are criticising you for saying truth but thankyou brother for opening the truth about Punjab economy... Love from Punjab❤

[@VkrmRandhawa]

❤ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਵੱਸਦਾ ਗੁਰਾ ਦੇ ਨਾਂ ਤੇ ❤ ❤️ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਪੰਜਾਬੀਅਤ ਜਿੰਦਾਬਾਦ ❤️

[@Kulwarn]

Excellent report! I was born in a Punjab village, lived and studied there till high school in 60's. Village school was pretty bad, lacking teachers, and those teachers were there not to teach but to collect the salary. After high school, my parents took me to Chennai and only then I realized how much harm the Government schools in the rural villages were doing to the students. I spent a year going to tutoring institutes to catch up. Luckily, I was was able to get into government engineering college in Chennai and that changed my life and even migrated to US 40 years ago. During my last visit to my village school in 2017, I was shocked to find my high school had only one functioning classroom, one small office room, two teachers, and no lab. All other classrooms were decrypt, leaking, and non-functional. Even these 2 rooms were functional with the financial help by a native son who now lives in Canada. If my school is a sad model of how the state governments have degraded education all across the rural villages, it is complete destruction of future for the rural youth. It is not just a loss for the community, or the Punjab state, it is loss for the nation! Imagine for a moment if the government had educated their rural youth, how much wealth these educated would have created that would have raised the state revenue.

[@Nishit_Alby_Alfredo]

Im from punjab and punjab has very very bad education system and also punjab is on top in whole country where most college and school children fail in exams and i doubt they are knowingly failed by employees of government universities and schools to get huge money through reappear exam fees and also no foreign students come to study in punjab's govt. universities anymore because of degraded education system but in my childhood i would see many foreigners in Guru nanak dev university as me and my family would pass sometimes by guru nanak dev university for some reasons but now not even other indian states students want to come to punjab for study let alone foreigners as its extremely hard to pass without reappears in punjab

[@vipanbatra8303]

Ett or b.ed krke lgge teachers nu kisi v competition exam ch bah do Ena to passing marks v nhi lye jane ..

[@parassharma-lv3zv]

Being a Punjabi, its really disheartening, Hope we will get out of it soon 🙏🙏

[@247montage]

Bhul joo 😂

[@khojiinsaan123]

Bhai i recently visited Punjab and there is desi daru sold at just 20 rupees 😢. Even the principal of the school is drunk during school time 😢

[@500Places]

​@@khojiinsaan123Humko bhi dilwa de bhai... Visit pe kahan kahan chla gya tu

[@khojiinsaan123]

@@500Places Bro fatheigarh saheib 🙂 As per new report of Times of india Ludhania is new hub for drug and after that next is kashmir 🙏. Eventhrough i am from jammu same happening in gurdaspur and many other area which are adjecent to kathua 🙏

[@500Places]

@@khojiinsaan123 times of India is trustable according to you? And the question was regarding 20rs for alcohol...? Which school did you visit... And why you visited school?

[@animetime7619]

I think the biggest state issue you should discuss is how National Capital of 5th largest GDP in World is still suffering from pollution .

[@jagyadhaireya88]

When reporters asked kejriwal about the pollution in delhi as well as punjab , keju ran away in between the intervuew Keju op

[@alphabetagamma4142]

He already has a video on that.

[@amishsurani4765]

India growth fake

[@f1re534]

Sikkim gives financial help to increase their population

[@ankkkit]

​@@Vizorfamwhy u can't hear the truth?

[@jagteshwarsingh2720]

what a great and informative video,as a punjabi i am happy to see someone talking about punjab

[@024_harkiratsingh8]

THANK YOU FOR HIGHLIGHTING THE PROBLEMS OF PUNJAB. IT WAS REALLY SURPRISING THAT PUNJAB WAS IN SUCH DEEP DEBT TRAP. IT IS HIGH TIME THE PUNJAB GOVERNMENT TAKE THIS VERY SERIOUSLY.

[@sehajpreetsingh492]

Bro itna spend nahi hota mostly ministers kha jaate Hain paise or suffer aapke or hamare jaise log karte hain yeh baat aap bhi bohot acche se jaante hon

[@SinghSoldier]

The thing is that, the living standards of the Punjabis is good, people are economically far better as compared to other states so they don’t give attention to this issue and our so called leaders are taking full advantage of this. People are too busy to take visas and make money from abroad that they don’t even bothers to question their politicians on this.

[@dhirajmasodgi007]

Same is applicable and turning true about whole nation…. 55 lakh crore to 155 lakh crore in 9 years and people are thinking nation is shining. On small eg no one asks the 60 USD per barrel oil from Russia was not consumed by nation but some Indian companies processed it and sold to the developed nations and made huge money. Common people have no idea or questions about it. 😢

[@rajuping4627]

Your comment reconfirms that why punjabis have no potential left to bring turn around. A typical denial mode jatt dimag, despite of getting pure statistics that once backward states like MP & Jharkhand have now become better economy than Punjab, you still want to ramble and prove yourself better than others. Punjab has low poverty rate because no new migrant wants to come there as it is hopeless place which has nothing to offer, people are rather escaping it, dont consider consolation given in video literally 😂

[@AbhishekSharma-uh9cx]

Bilkul shi kha Peoples are more focus go to abroad via political issue or politics

[@prabhjotsran5851]

@@rajuping4627😂you said no migrant wants to come?? All industrial labour is from UP Bihar Rajasthan

[@rajuping4627]

@@prabhjotsran5851 labour will go eventually where their contractors will take them, but is anyone ready to consider moving to punjab or want their kids to grow up there?? Forget about other communities, sikhs from other states wont consider permanently shifting to punjab . Who is responsible for this situation? Try to get to bottom of it then escaping with lame excuses and finger pointing.

[@Doyiti]

I am an IT professional living in Kuala Lumpur. I am from West Bengal. I have never able to practically think of moving to Kolkata, because of the laid back work culture and quality of projects. Can you dig deep in to West Bengals economy. Its prospect. Mostly my hometown neighbourhood is filled with parents whose son and daughter are staying either outside of the state or working abroad. Its the sad reality. Can you please research and make a video? Thanks in advance.

[@satyaambler]

Same problem with Kerala & andhra Pradesh. All the educated people have left both states to move abroad or to Bangalore & other metropolitan cities for jobs. Main problems are militant trade unions & criminal politicians.

[@harshdahiya1009]

😊

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

​@@satyaamblerMain problem is jagan and communist😂😂

[@tharabhai1794]

​@@satyaamblercommunism ???

[@Aman_Khan982]

Malaysia mein inflation kitna hai bro ?

[@birbaldev8216]

Thank you respected Mohak Bhaiya for your in-depth and detailed video analysis on Punjab I would request you to make a video on the bad condition of public infrastructure and the underlying problem of the State of Nagaland.

[@noteasytohandle]

here is my small message for all my punjabis , i dont know your thinking about living in punjab but at this level i think we have to take a stand for our punjab's condition even its finically or religious . punjab is gift which is given us by our gurus than why we are leaving this place nd going abroad just as name of money. we all know that there is alot, literaly alot of the struggle for jobs even in abroad ,i request to every single person reading my comment please make punjab safe and a good state in every field . remember this one person can change the whole village . and one whole village or city can change punjab. if i said anything wrong, i am sorry

[@mahakalkedeewane3578]

Mohak Plz make a detailed video on Rajasthan as well. Here main issues are- 1. Unemployment rate - 28.5% 2. Lack of Manufacturing Sector 3. Lack of Good Quality Education 4. Debt issue in the state as well around 5 lakh 32 thousand crores debt on Rajasthan 5.lack of proper IT sector setup in the state and infrastructure growth is too slow bcz of lack of funds. Govt. Has money but their intent is not to make Rajasthan a developed state😔😔😔😔

[@khojiinsaan123]

Jandk and Rajasthan have the highest unemployment rule 😂.

[@LordofGod12]

Rajasthan is top in women rape cases, Rajasthan is top in corruption, rajasthan is top in paper leaks..

[@faltuadmi4260]

Why always a state has to be a IT hub to provide job to unemployment why the youth always asks for unemployment and never thinks to generate it. I think if a state has a rich history why not promoting it's tourism sector and make Rajasthan a national epitome for tourism for all the world and especially for west. And For manufacturing sector it's not a one day show to begin it requires decades of planning both state and central coordination.

[@ShobhitTechVideo]

@@faltuadmi4260 well most people in IT sector get good salaries compared to other fields. So they also spend a lot, in food, clothes,maids,cars, tourism,home services that creates a huge market for the people of the IT city to grow and increase revenue and lots of jobs. Once an IT city is generated the state government also gets a lots of tax too when the IT people spend money. Then other developments happens or follows.

[@gaurangmangukiya9889]

@mohakmangal Please make video for this one too.

[@avan7757]

This was a topic which really needed limelight . There is way more to punjab than what these singers and politicians show. There's a lack of employment , industrialisation , infrastructure and discipline among people. We all need to grow with time. Stop highlighting 'oh how rich our punjab was ' Look at the present time! We have a long way to go!

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

There is lack due to resistance against land acquisition. Read about delhi Amritsar katra expressway status in punjab. Land acquisition is near impossible there.

[@avan7757]

@@ShubhamMishrabro I will definitely read about that. You can suggest more I would love to learn more✨

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

@@avan7757 read about latest nhai plea in punjab HC. They said they have already compensated gurdaspur farmers 2 years ago which was i think 250 crore but they have got only 9% land from that district till now. For punjab bad economy i can suggest some things to read - first de industrialisation due to china economy growth. Second influence of unions and socialist in punjab politics who resists industries in punjab. Second point is very underrated topic not many know like kerala and west bengal! punjab has strong socialist influence which leads to punjab not being buisness friendly. You can see this in Bihar too where nitish and lalu party favours socialism due to them being involved with jp movement

[@PULKITKAUL-great]

No one cares about state treasure. Everyone wants personal wealth to grow.

[@avan7757]

@@ShubhamMishrabro do you think a specific punjab government party can be blamed for it? Because the lack of industries were also deeply rooted with the influence of the green revolution. Pushing more towards agriculture than industries which is a major set back . Which obviously wasn't pushed by one government. Or this thing is just a part of the whole process of this depleting wealth?

[@aryaarjun1385]

Really appreciate your efforts on this reserch. Its really good that you do all your reserch from authentic source thanks a million from bottom of my 💜💜 for providing the authentic source for your reasech as most of the youtubers depends on NEWS ARTICLES thats soo don't know what to say childish But you have done amezing really love it.❤❤

[@gumnaam7]

Thanks for covering this issue, I am a Punjabi and I am very much concerned of forecoming situations of Punjab, I've very less hopes from this pro khalistani and non visionary govt. because of theri expenditure and less revenue

[@Maratha382]

Once known as the most developed state in India, the same Punjab is now reeling under unemployment, crime and drugs.

[@Time-waste319]

This is aap revolution enjoy 😂😂😂

[@Vizorfam]

All thanks to previous govts now aap will save

[@ankkkit]

​@@Vizorfamaah so you are from aap it cell . I thought you are a geniune person 😅

[@SuperZinu89]

Fool people are very obsessed with Canada, youth doing balle balle with daddy money on drugs, shameful

[@alookachalubetapotato6216]

AAP can only give freebies.@@Vizorfam

[@DSinghBeniwa_77]

Being a Punjabi, I told you very good information about Pride of Punjab India.

[@harshitbad]

Thanks for the very rare investigative journalism!!!! Respect!

[@meghnauniyal6360]

Very good Mohak...While watching Rajasthan unemployment video I was wondering if you can make state videos addressing their issues separately and here you are. Well done... Look forward for more from you. God bless you.

[@amitsinghbora_UK01]

I am from uttarakhand and the main problem with Uttarakhand is land law reform (bhu kanoon) . It's my humble request, please make a video related to this topic.

[@gauravnilay]

Uttarakhand land law is at best, There is no such issue, Himanchal pradesh infact needs land reforms to allow all citizens equal rights as enshrined in constitution. Onky greedy people demanding bhu kanoon in uttrakhand like congress which destroyed this country.

[@lavpreetsinghsahota4709]

Don't expect or request right-wing content makers to cover issues in BJP governed state. They would lose their funding and views. Try to digest this truth.

[@soulhighlander]

Uttarakhand

[@dhananjaysinghchauhan453]

​@@gauravnilaykidr se bhai ? English likhne se facts change ni hote ...thoda or padho

[@sumitsingh7835]

Main problems of uttrakhand are Lack of proper health facilities High corruption Lack of employment There are schools but teachers are either absent or they don't take their profession seriously Low per capita income Unremunerative agriculture Menace of wild animals led to downfall of farming in hills Lack of hill centric development Most of the work that has been is roads, highways which don't add anything to state:s economy nor do these provide jobs

[@smokerrr1]

really thankful for this video on the status of my state. I hope the leaders of Punjab understand this situation practically and try to solve this situation with a long term plan.

[@albertishu9066]

What a video...what a analysis...you are a gem❤

[@arvindsohal8779]

Mind blowing. Clearly governments are making things worse... Whichever party it may be. Deep insight and proper not popular decisions needed urgently

[@ThinkifyIndian]

History, Science, Sports, Religion, Politics, Movies, Business whatever the topic is Mohak explains it in a simple manner... Keep it up❤❤

[@ydid687]

yes however its only cursory knowledge many a times, not enough to form an informed opinion on something but then again the onus of that is on the viewer itself

[@gaurisankartamuly959]

Right completely

[@rushabhshah.2768]

Sab log viideo download karo Mohak delete karke reupload kare uske pehle

[@Aditya_Singh_Shakya]

Could you please create a video about Delhi? It's disheartening that despite the significant direct and indirect taxes residents pay, the city struggles with a fundamental issue: poor road infrastructure. While central Delhi and affluent neighborhoods may seem to have improved, the majority of Delhi's population lives in areas with subpar roads. I reside in Sector 22, Rohini, and the journey to the nearest mall takes me through Begumpur, Sector 23, 24, 25, and Rithala. Unfortunately, you can hardly find a 1km stretch on this route without encountering potholes. North West Delhi is in pathetic conditions and the govt is completely ignorant about it. I have written to the departments and the email is forwarded to some IAS but after that no action is not taken.

[@axel3895]

He is a spokesperson for aap. He would never criticize them

[@harshitchoudhary9875]

Rajasthan politics, Rajasthan unemployment

[@ghtrkljvivek]

Kabza McD khtam karegi sab ko vote chaiye koi action nahi leta

[@tayenderkumar3366]

central govt delhi ko sirf 375 crore de rhi hai 2013 se, as tax revenue share, jbki UP ko or haryana ko bahot diya hai jst bcs same govt hai

[@itsgood3494]

Then wbt Kerela it has worst transportation 😂

[@MandeepSingh-fg8pu]

Punjab cha Babe nanak te guruadi kirpa he ..... aan dhata Mera desh Punjab

[@Locolearner]

Babe nanak ne kam krke khan nu kiha c na ke free da leke khau Free da khane da hisab tan dena hi pau ga

[@herrybhanot4459]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@rounaksinghbuttar9083]

Thank you for making this video Mohak.

[@AD-gg2sr]

Request you to make a video on recent political scams in West Bengal and their impact on the state. BTW, today's video was awesome. Specially loved the conclusion part. It is truly thought provoking. Keep up the good work!

[@shubhamsingh9508]

Nothing is happing in india except whataboutry AAP Blaming BJP, BJP blaming AAP& congress doing caste politics 😔 noone is listening to middle class people

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

Middle class and tax payers. Inke paise politicians udate rahenge aur log freebies ke piche bhaagte rahenge

[@shubhamsingh9508]

@@ShubhamMishrabro exactly bhai

[@chinmoy48]

True

[@prajakt0789]

AAP is the best. It is cleaning Punjab now.

[@hardikkumar1737]

​@@prajakt0789seriously it's pushing my punjab under debt

[@surreshtarasingh9]

Excellent and deep report based video on Punjab aapka fan ho gaya

[@backpropagation8365]

Punjab per capita income at $2200 while Haryana’s at $4400. Punjabis thought freebies like agri subsidies will help. And they are now in this bad state. 😢

[@sowdeshramadoss5662]

Your team is really doing a great work💯💯 Continue to enlighten today's youth. I have spent 30mins on your video and I am glad about it. Let these content reach government ears

[@Life-yi7uf]

I live in Kharar, Punjab and I face two big issues here: Power Outage and Water crisis especially in Summers. Even Mohali faces these two issues many times. I've lived in Kota, Rajasthan; Purnea, Bihar; Shirdi, Maharashtra and some of the remote villages of India but the power outage issue is surprisingly more than these places.. even in October November we sometimes don't get water on Sunday and on some weekdays also.. In my opinion subsidies should only be given to the needy not to all. Most of the people in Punjab are rich enough to afford these basic amenities. Govt can utilise these money on making govt hospitals and schools better. Govt hospitals are very crowded often.

[@tubeginie9940]

Bhai free ki rebdi me to yahi maja hai. I am living in Karnataka, after Congress party coming to power I am getting very less electricity bill but in return 4-8 hours power cut in a day, needs spend 500-1000 a week to get water tanker .

[@Dil-Sacha-hai]

Aap Andh Bhakt ho.....I live in a village and have never faced power outage even in summers except major fault. Punjab Rocks.....ਭਇਆ

[@Life-yi7uf]

@@Dil-Sacha-hai have you lived in Kharar??

[@ShobhitTechVideo]

well i think the show off is also killing punjab.. i live in noida.. and have travelled in both UP and punjab.. in UP people buy a car and continue to use it normally.. in punjab people buy a car.. they they go for alloys and wide tyres and other modifications.. that is only about cars.. also in punjab there are so many liquor shops everywhere.. also i saw so many people with ipones in punjab and in UP people still use android phones mostly.. and invest in real state.. i think the punjabi youth doesn't save money and living in debt .. but in UP people are simple and save a lots of money in banks or real state..

[@SatpalVerma000]

​@@ShobhitTechVideothen don't come to Punjab. Why you up biharis flocking to poor Punjab? Pls stay in your states.

[@harry.7534]

Thanks Atleast for making a video on Punjab , people must know what’s going on factually

[@VivekRai05]

Well done Mohak. I hope my Punjab comes out of this trap soon🙏

[@ujjwalgandhi951]

The level of detail you go into plus your clean and clear communication of information Keep up the good work mate :)

[@saishree1340]

Heyy hi Mohak, keep up the great work. Kudos to ur tremendous efforts and research. A humble request from my end to make a video on The Company Secretaries, The Chartered Accountants and The Cost Accountants too. Their contribution to the economy is huge but they never into the limelight. Thanks in advance

[@lakhihere]

Great work. Keep working, stay strong and bro stay safe 🙏

[@RaviSingh-rc4up]

Proud to be Sikh Love Punjab 💓

[@rohitupadhya6449]

Please do a video on the deplorable living conditions of Meghalaya. Loved your videos on Nagaland and Sikkim, I feel like NE states like Meghalaya, that have been ignored for decades, also deserves some level of attention...

[@faltuadmi4260]

I think you should consider that a state which has low lok sabha seats and not a manufacturing or IT hub will always have this problem. Until the state stands on is own problems and be something unique it's is inevitable truth for them to be neglected I think sikkim stands out by this aspect

[@rohitupadhya6449]

@@faltuadmi4260 the journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step. Where were China and India 50 years ago. Meghalaya(Specifically Shillong) was considered a hub for education and culture for the North East not even 30 years ago, now it is the second worst performing state in terms of education behind just Bihar. And just because there wasn't any industry doesn't mean a place should be left to rot, how do you think industry came to other parts of the country? The North Eastern states have plenty of potential, both in terms of raw resources as well as human resources. Corruption from the state governments and general apathy from the Central Government have led to such a sorry state of affairs.

[@mdrohit8896]

West Bengal's debt ratio is also quite high. Probably this is the reason why road and metro projects are delayed.

[@tanmaypaul6044]

Metro & nh projects under central...but wb govt is not interested in infrastructure development.,.. Such as highway, bridge

[@user-rk9gb8hi6t]

i am from west bengal please make a vedio on current situation of west bengal and most importantly on ways to inprove it what steps can be taken by the government and as an individual to inprove the condition in all aspects i know changes can't by made in a day but atleast we can sow the seeds of development for future generation

[@MrBadhanyp]

I agree with the excellent analysis. No one is focusing on the issue. Preference is for the individual/ parties interest rather than solving the issues of the state.

[@sddu]

You always brings for us new and informative topics, salute to you sir for your work 😊

[@Abhishek-wq3sl]

Great video. I would love an indepth video about Bihar, a state that is so culturally rich and has immense potential but we know things haven't been favourable lately. It would be great if you break it down for us.

[@poojaashokpoojaashok8270]

Great research and excellent video.. Could you make video on new Education policy and why it is not implementing if you do this will be very helpful 😊😊

[@arpandeole2976]

My state Is maharshtra, Maharashtra's development is majorly focused on the western side and there are very less job opportunities on the eastern side of Maharashtra state , same goes for infrastructure and development

[@prasadshingane2332]

Right 👍

[@arshguraya7202]

Hey brother I’m from punjab basically, living in other country right now . This is the first and foremost hindi logical n true word about the situation... keep it up brother .

[@iamworstgamer]

a well researched video, thank you

[@Dudsky]

Bda mjaa aya ji video dekh k sachi Baki partiyo ki subsidies kharab Aam admi party ki subsidies bhot bdia Bda acha lga bhai dekh k video Sau topon ki salami bhai unko jo ye video ko dekh k very good analysis bolre h

[@aussiboy100]

Great video about Punjab economy . Sadly, previous govt and current govt are just making situation more worse.

[@gauravkumargupta9622]

I recommend a video on the worsening states of IITs and NITs regarding student welfare. Overaccomodation of hostels, lack of faculty, lagging infrastructure, less funding, babu culture in administration etc

[@dairytech1086]

Waheguru di bhut mehar a Punjab ty Eda de data nitt bdlde rhnde

[@whatwillyousay3705]

ਧੰਨਵਾਦ ਵੀਰ ਤੇਰਾ ਸੱਚ ਦਿਖਾਣ ਲਈ❤

[@aviralsharma6826]

State- Madhya Pradesh Issue- Unemployment, Women safety, bad health infrastructure, zero industrial development, Tourism, IT development, lack of vision which adds in making it one of the most ignored state after the north-east in our country.

[@drsumitra3001]

Bro in the vid itself there was a map of unemployment and mp was one of the lowest with only 1.9% I belive so I belive that is not the problem

[@adityaawasthi1748]

​@@drsumitra3001mam sabse jyada mp ke log bhi bahar jaate job ke liye Indore ni jaate

[@RamCharan-oc1ow]

​@@drsumitra3001 M in BIMARU stands for Madhya Pradesh.

[@drsumitra3001]

@@RamCharan-oc1ow mp is no longer a bimaru state

[@RamCharan-oc1ow]

@@drsumitra3001 Haha good joke, GDP per capita of MP is around 1.1 Lakh, if that is not BIMARU then what is ?

[@Samreen_kaur]

I just love your videos ❤❤ Love from punjab You're the one who is addressing the real problem of PUNJAB ❤❤

[@PunjabSingh1984b]

Je punjab gareeb aa ta Up ,bihar,bepal,odisa,kashmir states de lok ki lyn aunde ne punjab ch😂

[@sulabhverma640]

​@@PunjabSingh1984bpoora video sun la veere ...fer eh gal bolii.

[@navjotsingh5335]

​@@PunjabSingh1984b😂😂❤

[@upscaspirantdelhi9561]

​@@PunjabSingh1984bje punjab de lok ene Ameer ne fr Canada ja ke bhaiye vale kamm kyoo krr rhe ne..............

[@AniketSingh-vx6pj]

Nice explanation 👍

[@MagicMeadowCartoons]

Unemployment in Jammu and Kashmir is a very serious issue in our state as our JKSSB are struggling from the time of independence to provide jobs to Students

[@brominete9]

Hey Mohak. I have been a long time fan of yours(about the last 2 to 2.5 years) and i really wanted you to look into the issues of how the auto rickshaws in mumbai tend to run fairly on price in comparison to every single other auto rickshaw driver in our country. It might seem mundane and very less could be explored but atleast it would truly open to how most cities are discouraging the idea of public transports(except metros)!Or you could look into Mumbai’s land crisis and how at average Mumbai’s land is more expensive than a land in Los Angeles or in new york(kinda)

[@harpartapsinghclass9414]

State: Punjab Topic: drugs and gangs Kindly make video on this also

[@sandeepshortx]

super video and easy to understand and master in explaination love from chandigarh

[@anshulgupta4289]

Thanks for the content and keep it up

[@kaustubhG18]

Hi Mohak, really informative and great video as always. I would like to see the effect of Adani, Ambani, Tata groups on our dialy life. What if they suddenly disappeare, what is inpact on our economy

[@chiragrana2323]

Mohak - Brilliantly done. Really well explained. It actually comes down to the grass root level of the spendthrift nature of Punjabi’s and attitude of “koi naa, dekh laange aapa”. Furthermore, would really want you to make an in-depth case study of the lacklustre and complacent attitude of Himachal Pradesh and it’s locals. How only focusing on tourism or moving to places like Chandigarh or Delhi is the only scope of growth for literate career oriented people. Awaiting your reply.

[@_manaha_kamal]

Please make a video on Financial Crisis in Himachal Pradesh too. Thank you 🙏

[@INDIANNZ]

Sir ek video india ke loan ke upar bhi bnao Jo 2013 me 400core USD da aaj woh 1700core USD ho gya nearly 16. trillion INR , iska bhi ek detail video bnao sir

[@pranavpatil515]

Punjab is the pride of India. Govt. should fully focus on sectors like services, manufacturing, tourism and heavy industries. It's not possible for any govt. to collect money from agriculture. India largely consists of small farmers who themselves barely earn any income. It's high time for Punjab to retain its youth and focus on generating capital. Punjab must Exist! Vande Matram!

[@RaviranjanKumar-tq1cz]

But Punjab want freebies 😅😅😅

[@sodabutnofizz1294]

no longer "pride". Drugs, violence, freebies have corrupted it to the last bits.

[@MackyMehra]

​@@RaviranjanKumar-tq1czJust like MP where Mama ji is giving Freebies through Ladli Behna scheme ? Just like Gujarat where BJP write off businessmen's capital loans. Just like Modi wherein just 3 days ago he decided to give Ration free to 80 crore people, of whom mostly are from Hindi belt ? Truth is that every Indian wants Freebies. Every Government be it INC, BJP etc have failed Indians.

[@vishalsolanki6984]

@@MackyMehrabro start to AAP ne kiya tha ye sab obvs hai dushre bhi follow karenge kyuki freebies har jagah overwhelm karega baki chezo ko

[@abhiraajsingh5878]

Agricultural sector needs to be reinvented , it's one of the biggest industry in the world

[@_vikram]

About the air connectivity situation for businessmen, both the Chd. Airport and the Amritsar Airport Authorities have to step up their game. Punjab Govt. has stakes in both of them, yet nothing has been done. As someone who belongs from Chandigarh, we have been longing to get more international flights. Even if it is to nearby countries like Singapore, Vietnam or Sri Lanka that can work. All we got, Dubai [UAE], Sharjah [UAE] and one in Thailand. Now the only international flight is to Dubai from Chd. The over-dependence on Delhi airport has made the wait all the more bitter.

[@mistersingh6470]

Yeah, now they are saying that flights will start from Adampur Airport but nobody knows when

[@vinodbhandari3251]

Bro, I'm Punjabi living in Amritsar, I recently visited UP and was observed that the state is not much developed as compared to Punjab.

[@That_misfit]

You live in city

[@TheUndertaker2408]

It never will be because the majority of that state is criminal minded and illiterate.

[@penpineapple11]

​@That_misfit Even our villages in Punjab are far better off than some prominent cities of UP. TO put in context, my house in one of the village of Punjab is about 1.3cr.

[@dakshsharma4360]

But Up is growing and Punjab is in a debt trap

[@TheUndertaker2408]

@@dakshsharma4360 that does not affect the average person in Punjab. Only the government.

[@mikepurewal5816]

Thanks from Canada. Very informative video.

[@sabbi057]

Make 2nd part also and cover everything of last 30 years ❤

[@SparshKumarS]

Electricity bill in Karnataka has truly skyrocketed. Would appreciate if you could make a video describing it.

[@_kartik_chauhan]

Sorry for Bangalore 😢 They didn't voted for crap ... But 😂 for Mumbai and Kalyan Karnataka ... You should get what you have voted for

[@mistersingh6470]

Eega gruh jyoti yojana bande, adu namma sahaymadtini maybe.

[@1008apocalypse1008]

It is being used to pay for free bus rides.

[@sapien2503]

congress will use that money for minority vote

[@user-io7sh7nx7c]

​@@_kartik_chauhan economically backward people have more votebase but they're not utilizing it for the right candidates/parties. South Karnataka is 1000× better than North Karnataka. I've observed this personally, even though many times candidates from North Karnataka get elected as CMs and important cabinet ministers.

[@SritamaDutta_Asansol]

Please make a video on the West Bengal education system crisis...

[@nspireworld]

Yes analysis on rising up❤

[@vishalrawat5530]

Hey Mohak I really love the way to explain in your Videos, I'm from Uttarakhand and I'd love to see you make a video about some of the issues faced by our state, such as migration from the hills, natural disasters, or the history of the Garhwal and Kumaon divisions, Nepal Invasion etc. I think a lot of people would be interested in learning that❤❤

[@TheOneWhoKnocks969]

Yess

[@memully2323]

No.

[@deepikasingh9374]

Bhu kanoon mass migration from plains

[@atul7173]

haa yaar really I also need information related to development in uttarakhand specially kumaun region.

[@NishantKumar-nq6nl]

Great video✨, but a Small correction, The compensation cess which was provided by the CG to states have already been ended after the completion of 5 years since implementation of GST (i.e. on 30th June 2022), now it is used by CG itself to payoff its own debt which it incurred because of such compensation it provided to states in the initial 5 years, so Punjab is not receiving any compensation for not collecting enough GST, sorry for going this deep, , I am no expert just a tax student, i can be wrong 😅 Please correct me if i am Bro love your work btw, please keep up the good work❤

[@Harshkumar_051]

Bhai bahut hee ashii video thee apki mere bss aap se itne se request hai aap thoda or details mai batayo ya ek video banayo Punjab pr ke isko kaise thik kiya ja sakta hai ya phir Punjab ki new generation ko kya karna chahiye Punjab pr bharosa ya phir canada

[@user-ym6kq9gv2w]

Panjab ko Bachana hi to full majority ki BJP Sarkar hi one Solution hai Example Kashmir UP, MP, Goa, Gujrat, No Drug, No Danga, No Gangwar, No Terarist, No Curaption

[@pranavrohit7105]

Hi Mohan, can you please do a video on Kerala and how despite being the most developed state socially, it lags behind economically and talk about the politics of the state? Thank you.

[@phoenix3660]

Please explain the current Economic and Political issue of West Bengal and the historical reasons behind it , Many Bengali intellectuals started saying that West Bengal have now became worser than UP and Bihar of the 1990's

[@rishuarora789]

Hey I am from Punjab, please make video on job opportunities in Punjab and how to resolve ielts culture of Punjab and how to solve drugs culture of Punjab....... It's a request Big brother. ..... Thankyou । ਪਾਜੀ please ਮੇਰੀ ਗੱਲ ਸੁਣੋ, ਥੋੜਾ ਬਹੁਤ ਭਲਾ ਹੋਊਗਾ ।

[@Haryanaboys602]

punjab is much better than all india states ! but central govt did this with punjab every time

[@samirpadhan3701]

I'm thankful to the current govt of Odisha. Although the progress is very slow, but at least it's not stagnant and definitely not downwards. The improvement I've experienced in the past 8-10 years is commendable.

[@amberbank1986]

Orissa is nowhere near to be considered as a "progressing economy"

[@ShubhamKumar-vd9xy]

​@@amberbank1986oh plzz everyone knows better that orrisa does better 😏😏😏

[@thesagarmahapatra]

@@amberbank1986 Going from the poorest state in India(below Bihar) to overtaking 11 states in gdp per capita in 20 years is not progress? Fastest growing GDP per capita after Karnataka and Telangana is not progress? Only Yogi Raj is progress I guess.

[@amberbank1986]

@@thesagarmahapatra If you are a fanboy of some political party, then it's okay. Gdp per capita of 1600$ within 20 years time is something that you call progress ?! Based on population density, mineral deposits & tourism potential of orissa. Present gdp is comparatively low. 20% tribal population in orissa is still living tribal life. They aren't contributing anything to the economy. Tourism in orissa is a place for scammers and touters. No major companies are located in orissa.

[@khojiinsaan123]

​@@thesagarmahapatraYa bro even many companies from maharastra shifted to gujarat and many on the north side they shifted to UP 😊

[@Dil-Sacha-hai]

Punjab is a rich state....people are mind blowing.....I love Punjab......❤

[@prabhjotsingh2495]

Thanks!

[@sisirghosh09]

Wonderful analysis

[@suhashg8664]

As a kannadiga, it is sad that my state will have the biggest blow due to the 15th finance commission......🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻. No leaders have the guts to talk.....

[@PS-ug7nm]

You do have guts to vote... Utilize your vote ✌🏻

[@suhashg8664]

@@PS-ug7nm no leader across the political spectrum have the spine.. That's the most frustrating thing....

[@blazingguyop]

What happened bro?

[@blazingguyop]

@@PS-ug7nm already their election over😂

[@mistersingh6470]

Parvagilla aana, nimma rajyadalli shumaru IT sector sansthagalide. Nanu kuda bengalurudalli kelsa maditini. Naanu Panjab rajyada chenna bhavishyagagi prarthana maditidini waheguru mondina🙏

[@rishabhkumarsingh8067]

Hello sir, I am writing to request that you make a detailed video on the unique prison system of Finland and Norway. I am very interested in learning more about how these countries have achieved such low recidivism rates and created a more humane and rehabilitative prison environment.I would be especially interested in hearing from you about the following aspects of the Finnish and Norwegian prison systems

[@vishnu6398]

Why you are so concerned about recidivism. Any individual's concern would be about, how we can produce things in lesser cost and export, how the people's living conditions could be improved, how to decrease the poverty. How everyone can get equal opportunity to excel based on their talent, irrespective of cast and creed. But why you are concerned about recidivism.

[@rishabhkumarsingh8067]

@@vishnu6398 Dude I honestly don't understand your comment. You started by asking that why I am so concerned about recidivism, and then you started saying the solutions of avoiding recidivism. It's like saying India should invest heavily in education, industries,research and development but India should not be concerned about corruption, crime, poverty and unemployment

[@vishnu6398]

@@rishabhkumarsingh8067 Ok, now, I understood the intent behind your question. Means, not only recidivism, but also crime rate can be reduced by curbing unemployment problem, corruption, etc. Right?

[@vishnu6398]

@@rishabhkumarsingh8067 But recidivism, can be avoided by counseling them, making them to get habituated to live by hard-earned money. Until that a close watch is kept on them. On Quora, they had explained more clearly.

[@AmanSingh-nw7lw]

This needs a follow up video after a couple years

[@user-sm2gv6pz1h]

Good analysis.