Songwriter Reaction/Review of Pentatonix "The Sound Of Silence"

[@soullavee]

👉Please subscribe to my new channel for my resin art and help me reach the threshold of 1k Subs and 4k watch hours. Your support is greatly appreciated:) kzbin.info/door/ydgtCNDrv02Gc--UTw1IPw

[@spnbuff6311]

I just subscribed to your other channel. Good luck and I hope you get some more people joining. I can't imagine having one KZbin account, let alone two. I'm too shy to do that.🙂

[@ibemmy225]

Done!! Good luck☺️ I’ll head over and check it out (after I see some more from this channel 🤩)

[@antheaebi4900]

Men, these guys drive me crazy. They are too good. I learnt that dark guy (the original person, the person at the inception) is a Nigerian. What's up bros! They now brought another STRONG guy. Kudos my people.

[@AndieO]

Done :). Also sent it on to my friend who also does resin work.

[@posaidon67]

Hi there , you should see the other video of the sound of silence by DISTURBED. GIVES YOU MORE THEN GOOSEBUMPS LOL

[@dawgeral333]

Matt is now the bass. It used to be Avi, but he left. Matt has a beautiful, beautiful voice.

[@robzombieshot]

Avi was deeper though I do think he'd do it way better then him and Disturbed. He continues to record on his own. He lives not far from me in California.

[@drieuxkoeppel8152]

@@robzombieshot what? That Avi is way better than Matt? It’s been THREE YEARS. Matt isn’t the same. He’s different. Not better or worse. Different.

[@billderuwe9440]

I'm so glad you discovered one of my favorite groups that blows me away every time I hear them, but for WOW Exp#3!!!, I have to recommend "Bohemian Rhapsody" And try artist " Lindsey Stirling" ,Master of Tides, or Roundtable Rival are awesome works.

[@jonasbrofan136]

@@robzombieshot I love avi. His voice is truly unique and amazing. I think Matt does amazing in this song. He has such a soulful voice besides the bass part of his voice. It creates such an amazing sound and addition to the group. Avi is amazing and so is Matt. The group hasn’t lost anything in my opinion.

[@ExotiicButter]

Matt is a perfect fit for PTX.

[@mrbob4u495]

Listening to Pentatonix is a spiritual experience...no matter the song.

[@michelle32855]

I think I've heard this one easily 100+ times and I STILL get goosebumps when Scott comes out for that last verse!

[@atoyshabassene6273]

Yep. I know its coming but it doesn't matter. It's like I'm hearing it for the 1st time

[@sheriraemalfroid-patterson2935]

I agree! When Scott starts belting out emotion, no one can top him! His body gets into it and the beauty of his golden voice is somehow amplified even more…❤

[@baskervillebee6097]

Try PTX singing Dance of Sugar Plum Fairy. But there's no words. PTX: Hold my egg nog.

[@mjbartholomew5317]

They won their second Grammy for it!!

[@lazaprosser1113]

I laughed so much at this lol

[@imastealther]

I was going to recommend the same song.

[@janetburrows137]

Kevin’s beatboxing is the best you’ll ever hear. 😮😂😂❤❤

[@Annap137]

Matt, in the white jacket, replaced Avi. Avi helped pick him when he left for personal/family reasons. When Matt or Avi sings Scott (talk blond) sings base. If there’s ever an instrument you will see it.

[@jkonrad8598]

Yes if u want one with an instrument watch radio active or papatui thoos3 are about the only ones they use them in featuring lindsey Stirling

[@gregsteele806]

@@jkonrad8598 And Say Something, where Kevin breaks out his cello.

[@jkonrad8598]

@@gregsteele806 i complety forgot about that one

[@Spaceydoodle]

@@jkonrad8598 and Shallow :)

[@dangdang4334]

@@jkonrad8598 or Scott's original song "Thank You" that just released today, you actually get to see TWO instruments in that one!

[@bradsouthers7476]

In all fairness, it didn't go straight from Simon & Garfunkel to Pentatonix. Disturbed did an epic, dark cover of The Sound of Silence, and Pentatonix built on that to create this version. There have been thousands of covers of this song over the years, but Simon and Garfunkel, Disturbed, and Pentatonix are the trinity.

[@r0kus]

Absolutely agree.

[@johnwjr7]

4th Impact does an excellent version of this Pentatonix Sound of Silence.

[@tobiasbaldauf2523]

Simon wrote them on FB Site and he liked the Version and meaned that its realy realy near to that what they wanted to bring us over with their song.

[@jenniferlucas3540]

Simon & Garfunkel: aching sadness Disturbed: anger Pentatonix: hope

[@RDramatica]

Amen!

[@carolelewin2054]

Kevin working his socks off !

[@detrix42]

Simon & Garfunkel version is the original message. Disturbed's version is the angry, why have you not listened. PTX version is shouting the message again with hope for a better future.

[@holbeckmax]

Quite agree. Love this version but Disturbed just eclipses it for me.

[@annaanselmo7968]

This is powerful

[@67kemo]

Three sentences that really wrap things up in a very tidy bow. Way to grasp the heart of it, and what a wonderful and concise way to describe each rendition. Disturbed's cover hit me about as hard as this one, emotionally, if not in the same way. Your description helped me recognize why. Thank you!

[@aimeemarie5462]

Wow, you hit the nail on the head!

[@Bostonn8]

Well put!!!

[@chrive8934]

Pentatonix's wall of sound is exquisite.

[@bravehearticus]

I still struggle to comprehend that five people with no instruments other than themselves, can make such a big, deep and rich sound.

[@sandyleewhite]

****THEIR TALENT IS SO MULTI-FACITED, WITH INSANE VOICE RANGES, WRITINGTHEIR OWN ARRANGEMENTS, AND THEIR ABILITY TO TOUCH OUR SOULS!!!**** (That is what I call talent)

[@gwynmartin5004]

Someone finally talks about the incredible key changes in this. Thank you.

[@CarmRees]

Can you please react to their newest song Amazing Grace, My Chains Are Gone? Your reaction is great and you will have a spiritual reaction to Amazing Grace.

[@julielockhart1904]

That thing gave me tears and shivers the first time I listened. It’s unbelievable.

[@AJ-xf7yi]

They recently came out with the most amazing rendition of Amazing Grace that WILL make you cry.

[@laurelwenson928]

Yup -- that and "Imagine" by John Lennon

[@colinhutchinson523]

You think that gave you goose bumps you've only just started the journey enjoy the ride

[@Annap137]

This is more like a mix between Simon and Garfunkel and Disturbeds version 💜

[@scottperil905]

this is what they are known for , elevating songs to a new level. You'll see this as you go along the PTX journey. Great reaction, Thanks

[@briandavis1951]

Thank you for your honest reaction. What Art Garfunkel insisted on for their song was simplicity so people would think about the lyrics and not get lost on the emotion or the musicality. So they stripped the musical interpretation to a haunting minor harmony, natural key changes for each of their voices, and simple rhythm changes. What the song lacked was dynamics and musical color. Because of Pentatonix perfect timing they can articulate the words while adding these elements to increase the interpretation of each lyric including the warm and nurturing sound of Kristy's voice. Her verse changes the song the most to add real hope. Simon and Garfunkel try to achieve an inviting sound in this verse by switching from a minor key to a major key harmony.

[@deannaunruh6116]

I agree!!! I think that PTX does a better interpretation of the intent of the song than Simon and Garfunkel even. It evokes so much emotion! It’s like the turned the song into an “art song” (where the music enhances the lyrics of the song).

[@kimsimpson1494]

AMEN!

[@kaileim970]

Thank you for sharing that! I have always loved this song

[@kaygirly19]

The best part of it: they can reproduce the same quality in a live version. I've witnessed that and it was terrific. Really impressive.

[@stevenyoungerman4748]

You should definitely checkout their Bohemian Rhapsody cover next. You will be absolutely blown away.

[@taztbm223]

When the bass (Avi or Matt) is singing, Scott (tall blond male) takes over the bass. Scott, IMHO, is one of the most talented in this group. He has a huge range and has a big hand in the arrangements. They are all obviously so talented but Scott is so well rounded. He also just seems like such a nice, creative guy when you see him in interviews or on Superfruit.

[@kathrynphelps9771]

So glad you're appreaciating Scott's bass when Matt sings. Its part of his range he rarely shows but he's really good with it. He also showed it off in the Hallelujah version from a few years ago, that you reacted to, with Avi. I love how much Kirstie's voice has grown since then, too.

[@rolandestrandquist6038]

I got goosebumps every time I hear their performance

[@miriamdamato4770]

Please more pentatonix 🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️💖💖

[@Arcusfp1]

Scott was the lead, he usually sings close to the baritone range, he often drops down to handle the base when Avi and now Matt are singing lead...they are all very talented with incredible ranges. Even Kevin the beat boxer has a beautiful tenor voice. From your reaction I don't think you have heard the Disturbed version of this song. I have heard it put as Simon and Garfunkel sent out a letter, Disturbed sent out a call to arms, and PTX sent out a song of jubilation and triumph. Matt has an amazing voice the reminds me of deep brown molasses while Avi had a voice with the warmth of dark chocolate brownies. When Avi left the group he helped to pick Matt to take over as the bass. You ain't heard nothing yet.. Wait until you hear one of their most recent releases, a rendition of Amazing Grace...

[@Deano4322]

I would love to see the legend that is Paul Simon react to this just to know what he thinks of this incredible performance .

[@cazlaming]

I have heard the Simon and Garfunkel one not to long ago actually, it was on the radio at my work, I was a baby when their version came out so I don’t remember it at the time. When I heard it on the radio at work I couldn’t help but think of this Pentatonix version it’s the same with all the songs they cover, everytime the original comes on I always think of Pentatonix version

[@karenmackie2152]

Pure Joy to listen to. Taken to a total new level. Goosebumps, Kevin beatbox Tops the base sheer genius, awesome!!! Xx💖🌟

[@kurtfroberg3608]

They are, indeed, in a league of their own when it comes to not only performance, but also with arrangement/ production (which is a complicated skill set that this group is apparently comfortable with doing on-the-fly). Thank you for pointing that one out.

[@roymeryman8098]

I recommend "Man of Constant Sorrow" by Home Free. Another superlative acapella group.

[@courtannptx]

Since it's Christmas time you should check out some of their Christmas songs 👍 I think you would find Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy absolutely amazing, plus they won a Grammy for it 😄

[@veranilsson9677]

I recommend their original song "Love Again", it's a personal favorite of mine.

[@vickimoran1349]

I love your reaction to and appreciation for this one of a kind, amazingly talented group. They blow me away every, single, time!

[@Bostonn8]

I love how genuine and loving your reactions are! I feel like I'm watching myself. It rips me everytime. Without fail.

[@denisehart7104]

Terrific reaction. This is a powerful song, and they bring that fierceness in their beautiful voices. Do watch their newest song, released today Nov. 25, 2020. Called THANK YOU. It's fantastic.

[@secolerice]

I grew up on the Simon and Garfunkel electric version of the song. I come from the folk tradition. I didn’t think anything could be as good as that but Pentatonix has honored it and matured it in such a wonderful way. It gives me chills every time!

[@dariaestermann2418]

I still miss Avi and always will. But I am happy that he now composes and sings amazing songs as a solo artist. 😍 Matt does a great job too, I like him but Avi's voice is unique and not from this world.

[@markhermans5284]

Amazing Grace, Bohemian Rhapsody, Imagine, Mad World or Mary did you know would be a nice way to keep your PTX experience rolling. Thanks and stay safe.

[@carlawoolard9447]

I can watch your reaction comments over and over again!!! This is probably my 50th time!!! You are GREAT!!!! God bless!!!!

[@justinperry13]

It’s honestly funny. You don’t even realize how much these arrangements imprint on you. I discovered this group earlier this year. Everything they touch is gold.. But this song... this arrangement.... I have listened to this song at least once a day, EVERY DAY for almost a year. Every. Single. Day. It reminds me that even though things seem awful these days, and so divided.. I am happy and so grateful to be alive.

[@samnkacie]

You should also check out Disturbed’s version of this song too! The live version (on The Conan O’Brien show) is better than the studio version, in my opinion. Either way, you won’t be disappointed

[@craptos6938]

Hi Soul just subbed. Hoping you do Bohemian Rhapsody next! Great reaction

[@Danimal525]

If you want to hear dynamic, you REALLY need to listen to their cover of "Bohemian "Rhapsody"..... It's a real mind bender, lots of surprises in that one.....

[@lazaprosser1113]

He’s in for a ride if he watches it.....

[@sandwitch4300]

Brilliant!! They have so much power in a song about silence 🥰

[@shealiaharris8681]

I LOVE Pentatonix..this my favorite Sound if Silence is Disturb...soul lifting

[@dorothytaylor7369]

Yes I remember when this song was first sung my Simon & Garfunkel, which has beautiful during that time fast forward, however this group puts their own spin which makes it ever more beautiful, not taking anything away from the original, I just happen to love this version better, they happen to be my favorite KZbin groups, you must view “Amazing Grace” as well as the 12 Days of Christmas, they won’t disappoint

[@LadyDoe17]

One of my favourite PTX songs! It gives me chills every time I hear it! (And I’ve heard it a lot!. 🤣) great reaction. I look forward to the next PTX.

[@anne-mariegoyette4240]

they give an ethereal harmony to anything they sing !! listen to "Mary did you know" for a religious experience !

[@lindael-hawary8557]

I'm so happy you can share the love for Penatonix... They're amazing... Good luck with your channel

[@amyjones2490]

Whats better than watching Pentatonix? Watching someone react to Pentatonix!

[@jesseriggan1693]

Want some more goose bumps? Listen to their versions of "Mary Did You Know", and "Amazing Grace, My Chains Are Gone"

[@barbaraortega161]

I love this song. It's my favorite song. I was about 9 years old when it came out. I use to sing it all the time.

[@tammyjimenez7047]

Scott will pick up the Bass when Matt or Avi is singing lead!

[@wvob6752]

At your request, done. Listen to Mitch's range while Kirsten is singing solo. Wow!!!!

[@user-mp3ke1sr1u]

Какое открытие для меня!!! Прекрасно! Чудо! Благодаря Соулу теперь буду знать об этом изумительном коллективе! Какой вокал у всех!!! Супер!)

[@janet.4965]

I love your reaction, its so pureeee! Pentatonix are really really awesome! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@JudyCL]

Love your face and eyes as you hear them sing. Well done and enjoy your channel

[@jessegirlb]

Dude, you've barely scratched the surface. And I totally agree: they're brilliant with their use of dynamics. You have to do their "Daft Punk" medly and "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy," "Imagine," "Let's Get it On." And ... well, so many more. I can't list them all. SO many more.

[@kayecastleman6353]

Totally agree. A perfect assortment to experience the true diversity of PTX.

[@karensavage5658]

You should listen to “Mary did you know” I find that song so moving and deep. I’m a new subscriber. I love watching your reactions and reviews ov the song. You are very knowledgeable and have the depth and background to express your thoughts and feelings effectively.

[@user-wk6ln4zs9v]

Шикарная группа!!! Одно удовольствие их слушать!!!

[@mayaleela7749]

I love your reactions!

[@angelathomas5515]

Pentatonix are AMAZING!! You would think that they had some electronic production for the videos, but I can tell you that's not true. I've heard them live from the pit at their concerts, and they sound just as pitch perfect, on point, in the stage as they do on their videos. I LOVE them!!

[@grayeyeslady]

Yeah I love these guys and Voice Play both then there is Home Free they are all so great

[@bettymccarthy4904]

I am right onboard with the our opinions. They blow my hair back also in an unreal way. They are definitely Enough with no instruments. They Are the instruments and music; more than enough at times. Thank you for our viewing

[@duaneedwards4189]

Great reaction! PTX is a wonderful acapella group.

[@thephenomenonofthepropheti264]

Fantastic reaction to Pentatonix Sound of Silence! Right on target!

[@demaramorrow1661]

Having Scott be able to cover the bass to allow Matt (and previously Avi) to have solos without dropping out the bass lines is amazing. Same as having Kevin help cover high with Mitch when needed. This version is my favorite and I love that it's not the folksy version of the Simon and Garfunkel original.

[@ginapearce9157]

Amazing grace by PTX ...just beautiful

[@DallasHarte]

Matt in the white jacket is the New Bass Hand Picked by Avi before he left when Matt Sings Scott the Blonde guy takes over the Bass line just like in Hallelujah when Avi was singing Scott Covered The Bass Line.

[@deborahvretis3195]

IT has been said that they don't do covers, they do updates. I agree.

[@createyourupgrade]

I LOL’ed so loud when you said ... ‘do any of you know the Simon &Garfunkel version’ as I knew exactly where you were going. They are completely different!

[@lauraolsen228]

Scott takes over bass when Matt sings lead. Love you reaction!

[@dejns6945]

This is Matt. He took the place of Avi..who started a solo career.

[@lorlorjb]

Their songs are so multidimensional it just blows your mind.. layer upon layer of sound!

[@jeandoten1510]

You should check out their cover of Imagine. I never really liked the original--John Lennon being preachy--but these guys come of completely authentic, not to mention amazing musicians.

[@elizabethsantersero9597]

I feel the same way- I admired Lennon's musical genius but never really warmed to his vocals, at least not on that song, but PTX made it something that touched me.

[@fmcm7715]

Especially with the signs and the last cards they hold up and the word it spells.

[@NilZed1]

buried in the treasure trove of the PTX page are clips explaining each of their ranges. amazing.

[@melaniebrainerd3255]

Ptx is a pretty special group because of what they do. I like how you say their voices are enough. I agree! They fill out all the holes in the sound perfectly with their vocals. So cool to hear! That being said, I don’t mind at all when on occasion they include cello because Kevin ( the beatboxer) plays one, or piano because Scott can play.

[@user-ee5qw4ii9l]

It’s all their voices. When Matt sings solo Scott fills in on the bass

[@aaronbarlow4376]

The PTX goosebumps are a special kind of goosebumps.

[@lesaahrenstein6360]

This is probably a repeat of what other commentors have said. 1st of all thank you so very much for continuing to do Pentatonix. I adore them More than any instrumental group I've ever heard. And I value your Analysis of the video, the singers and your reaction. I'd be curious To know how many subscribers have you gotten since you 1st did hallelujah. And I am predicting that with each Pentatonix reaction you do your number of subscribers will also increase. So congratulations. The gentleman in the white jacket is matt. He replaced avi As the bass in 2017. Avi left for personal reasons but is on very good terms with PTX. Avi helped to pick matt to be his replacement. When Matt is singing, or avi, Scott does the bass. Avi is a basso profundus you would know the term, that he has blown out speakers. If you listen to there video Of aha live at Singapore the initial singing That they're doing avi blew out a speaker that night. You might want to do radioactive next because the beat boxer, Kevin also plays a cello And he beat boxes at the same time. He calls this cello boxing. If not that Then imagine which I know you will just be blown out of your shoes By the arrangement. Someone mentioned listening to disturbs version of silence. Disturbed is a heavy metal rock band but there cover of sound of silence is not heavy metal. It really comes out of left field For disturbed considering the type of music that they Are known for. And you have to watch the official video Because it is very haunting And you really get to see the rage David Draiman is getting singing with. The official video makes the lyrics take on new meaning And please make sure you start It from the very very beginning Not where you see of the piano keys. Please keep the PTX reactions coming. 1 more and I think you can officially call yourself a Penta halick. Yes there really is such a thing.

[@Ruleno.1SOLOKILLSTREAK]

You listen cant you feel the love tonight this is fantastic😍

[@markhaseley3304]

Yep, I was raised on Simon and Garfunkel. I love that they kept the emotional and philosophic overtones that were part of the original song and built upon it. Cheers!

[@melaniemarceaux9580]

My face looked exactly like yours the 1st time I watched this... I felt something because I think I held my breath the whole song so that I didn't miss anything by breathing lol

[@jjmosher03]

Another phenomenal acapella group is Home Free. Check out their cover of “Man of Constant Sorrow”!

[@elysebaker7368]

Hello 👋🏻 from Canada 🇨🇦 Matt is the new Bass that replaced Avi when he left the group. If you really wanna see Matt shine & enjoy a seasonal song watch their cover of Mr Grinch - my kids love it!

[@AnnaMarie66]

Yep grew up with Simon & Garfunkel!🥰Amusing the younger generation believes this song was originally by the band “Disturbed” which is definitely a shocker too!

[@hello_lydie]

I Love this group so much. I'm 54 so I know the original very well. Good luck with the resin channel Soul 💙

[@efctrein1754]

You already know Mitch be rocking the mullet 😂👌

[@marablemorgan8292]

When Matt sings, Scott always takes over the bass... just like he did when Avi sang...

[@michaelengel3265]

now we are at Christmas...PTX LOVES this time of year....take a listen to their rendition of "How Thou Art"....not only are vocals outstanding but the visuals are way up there....

[@ihateallandme]

I like re-watching this. I love your reaction to this. Of course, I am also a Pentaholic!

[@TheMsCrystalblue]

Avi Kaplan left the group and they now have Matt, the guy in the white jacket. HE has such a soulful voice!

[@stefanengelken9206]

PTX don´t just cover Songs. They RECREATE them on a very different Level.

[@juanitachappell7572]

If Pentatonix gives you chills with your music, then you should listen to them do Mary did you know.

[@oldschool72]

It's like a look into the future...no instruments just waves of heavenly voices.

[@cherylwilliams9360]

That deep bass while Matt was doing his solo is Scott.. like he did for Avi in HALLELUJAH and in all songs while bass is singing solo..

[@teenahagen6333]

Every single one has a fabulous voice! No matter what they sing🌻

[@buddasquirrel]

Your new channel looks fascinating. Great reaction over here! Thanks dude.

[@rmac1042]

Pentaholics: wait till he sees Bohemian Rhapsody and Daft Punk!