Spyderco Paramilitary 2 VS Manix 2 - Discussion

[@metal_complex]

My Amazon store! - The VERY BEST knives & gear! - www.amazon.com/shop/metalcomplex

[@rodagoose]

You guys convinced me...I just bought both...

[@metal_complex]

Atta boy 👊🍻

[@rodagoose]

@@metal_complex Just got the Manix 2 in the mail. I went with the black on black version like you have in the video. It's beautiful! I'm so happy I finally went for it! Can't wait to get the other one!

[@rodagoose]

Got the PM2 also. It's a really nice knife as well, but my heart belongs to the Manix 2!

[@GreyRock100]

YTMND

[@appalachiangunman9589]

I have a PM2 and the Manix 2 LW is on the way, I’m pretty excited for it.

[@Loawks]

Manix2 was my first. Just got para2 yesterday. Surprised how much lighter it is. If you play with the para for a while. Then pick up the manix, it feels ‘more premium’, heavy and solid. It was once said. The manix is Rambo. And the para is James Bond. Best description in my opinion. Love you guys

[@ligitmuffin]

And the shaman is the termintor

[@jimcarlson6157]

the ladybug is mrs doubtfire

[@akanesoratobu8889]

@@jimcarlson6157 lol i loved that movie.

[@oleboy7615]

IMO, the PM2 is THE BEST knife Spyderco produces. I have several, and love them all, but none of them compares to the PM2 for me.

[@metal_complex]

The PM2 is definitely an excellent folder.

[@Damen0530]

Manix 2 with a compression lock, would be the ultimate spydie!

[@mtb8396]

Compresion lock is the best. Easy to clean and there is no springs !

[@spike141962]

I agree with you I own both the manix 2 definitely has a stronger lock and that has been proven

[@kubogio]

Isn't the Shaman essentially a Manix 2 with compression lock ?

[@metal_complex]

No. Ths shaman is substantially more robust all the way around

[@retardno002]

Sage 5 is closer to a Manix 2 with a compression lock, but blade size is closer to a Para 3 if I'm not mistaken.

[@jeffreyfink2964]

I ordered 2 Delica 4s (with purple scales) from Amazon and received 2 Manix 2 lightweights. Both boxes were in a plastic bag with the wrong label. I kept one since I liked it so much.

[@TheMhannah100]

Manix 2 is the best knife I've ever owned, by far. I own a Benchmade and many others. Spyderco build quality is fantastic.

[@silverwiskers7371]

well, your post here just sold me a manix 2, i shall order one asap

[@TheMhannah100]

@@silverwiskers7371 you will not be disappointed.

[@adamedwards2261]

The ball bearing lock on the manix2 is equivalent to or better than the axis lock on Benchmade. I’ve seen the test. They blow compression and liner locks away.

[@evictioncarpentry2628]

Doubt it. The ball bearing is housed In a plastic cage. The axis bar is made from hardened steel or Titanium depending on model. You would need to completely bend the bar plus the steel liners on a Benchmade to break it. Secondly, having just purchased a manix 2, it's nowhere near as smooth or awesome as an axis lock.

[@jpbernie72]

I have owned 5 Benchmade knives and returned 4 of them. As soon as I get the parts in to customize the one I have kept I’m going to sell it. I just don’t like Benchmade knives.

[@Malehanger]

The axis lock is good until the springs which make it function wear or worse, break

[@abc456f]

The para 2 is a great knife, no doubt. But in my opinion, the manix 2 is better. Fits my hand like a glove. Para 2 blade to handle ratio = too much handle. The manix 2 is just perfect. I first bought the version you show here, all black, g10, s30v. I liked it so much I ended up buying two more versions. The burl g10 with s90v, and the carbon fiber, cruwear. Those two are my safe queens and I use the regular one with a casey lynch deep pocket clip. This is the only knife out of about 90 that I own that I have more than one version of, that's how impressed I am with it. Also have a manix 2xl which is beastly. Have you done a review of the Shaman? It's another great spyderco, more heavy duty with a super comfortable grip.

[@Jsmith9055]

I prefer the Manix 2 personally. I like the leaf shape blade, rather than the bird beak. I also got the Sage 5 LW, over the Para 3, for the same reason. Either way, you cant go wrong with a Spyderco

[@Dmhlcmb]

I love them both, I have the both, but I like a compression lock on my Spyderco knives. The Manix 2 is an amazing edc knife but the para 2 is everything Spyderco does better than anyone else, all in one package.

[@frogturtle]

that’s a great way to describe it!

[@marty1685]

Which one is better for skinning an elk? Which one is easier to clean blood out of? Which one has the strongest tip? Which one is better for breaking down wood? Which handle has the least hot spots after carving a spoon? Do you guys do anything except review how good they flip open and close? That means pretty much zero when it comes to cutting things, make one of those fidget spinner things out of S30V, it will be more fun for what you guys use knives for.

[@LB-np5zv]

Pm2 would be better for everything mentioned outside of breaking down wood

[@MultiPcExpertGhost]

@@LB-np5zvYou really believe the paramilitary 2 has a stronger tip than the manix 2? That’s arguably the weakest point.

[@lawrencewilhelm3031]

First time here. Entertaining video. Keep it up! I’m a Manix 2 guy, but love the PM 2 as well.

[@metal_complex]

Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks!

[@TheShuk59]

Great review I love my “lightweight” manix 2

[@chrissexton6634]

Have that and the manix 2 xl... The lightweight is. Nothing weight wise but great knife. The xl is so much knife for a pretty good price around the same as the p.m. 2. Feels beefy.

[@appalachiangunman9589]

I have one on the way, I can’t wait.

[@ScottieG59]

Though I am right handed, I also use things in my left hand, such as handguns and knives. The ball lock is easy to work with either hand, but the compression lock is not. All my compression locks are for right handed use. I have seen the compression lock made for left handed users, though I do not know if that is a regular catalog item. Still, the compression lock is not as flexible in usage as the ball lock.

[@kevinosborne8308]

I have 3 manix 2's just bought the para 3 two days ago, bought the paramilitary 2 yesterday. Can't wait!

[@revolvermaster4939]

They’re both awesome for work and play. I’ve cut steel bands with the S30V with minor nicks that came out with/out much effort on a diamond then a black arkansas stone.

[@ferrisbueller9991]

Must learn how to do that.

[@AGC828]

How they feel in one's hand matters as does the lock mechanism. I don't 'prefer" the Axis-Lock type mechanism because it's "recommened" we pull down BOTH nubs simultaneously to release the blade....rather a "one finger motion"....liner locks and the compression (haven't owned a compresion lock knife)....plus, if you've never owned or handled a Spyderco I think the PM2 would be THE best choice...does more things right according to Syderco desgin ideas... Manx 2...$40 cheaper....Axis style lock...might fit your hand better....maybe as a 2nd Spyderco knife?? Don't know if pocket knives ever go on sale....i haven't ever noticed if they do...

[@pauldayton5285]

The Manix 2XL all day ! I'm in love with this knife ! As a lefty the Manix 2XL perfect. It's been my EDC for 5yrs now. It's the fastest opening & closing folder out there with a Emerson wave zip tie modification. I've never had an issue with the ball bearing lock & prefer it over any other locking design I've tried with the back lock being a close second.

[@thorshammer5134]

I went with the para3 in s45vn with the black on black. Had the pm2 but feel the 3 is the ideal size. Like it way more than my bench grip in 154cm. Probably even more than my zt0350 , which is saying something. It was a tough choice over the manix but the compression lock took the win for me. Just so smooth and fidgety.

[@mikeappleget482]

How’s Spyderco’s S45 holding up? My first PM2 a couple days ago it should be here this week! Went with the camo G10 with satin S45 blade.

[@ToRo909r]

I have 7 PM2 and 1 Manix. The PM2 is just a beast and comes in different blade shapes 😊

[@BUBBA1J]

I've got the manix 2 lightweight with S110v.....perfect slicer and EDC.

[@gaigehurtz7302]

If the para just had a wider blade not as wide as the manix but close it’d be perfect

[@WristWatcher]

Why do you need a wider blade?

[@I_Might_B_Wrong]

My preference is the Para 2 for the easier to manipulate lock and the slimmer profile in the pocket. Gave my Manix to a friend. I would love a nice Manix 2 Sprint in XHP, M390, or something else that’s Stainless with good edge retention. I also wasn’t a fan of the protrusions of the Manix because they dug a little too harshly into my fingers. All just preferences of course. The nice thing about the Manix handle is it’s basically identical to the Hinderer ergos which are great. If it just didn’t have such sharp jumping in the liners where the fingers go I would be a lot happier.

[@metal_complex]

Fair points. I would LOVE to see an m390/blue g10 sprint Manix 2. I'd be all over that!

[@I_Might_B_Wrong]

Decided to say screw it and order an S110V Blurple Manix 2. I’ll enjoy having another one and I’ve never had any S110V so it’ll be interesting to give it a whirl.

[@metal_complex]

Haha thats great! I've had the blurple PM2 in s110v. Fantastic stuff! You'll love it!

[@frederickj.7702]

@ IMightBeWrong... You can file or grind back that metal jimping to *excellent* aesthetic effect, if you procede cautiously and have the proper tools and "good hands"... probably without the headaches of dissassembly, by the looks of it. See 'Google Images' for the finished example. I myself have zero issues with the jimping on either my CPM Cru-Ware Manix or my BD1 Lightweight. I like it, especially as a tactile reference point for my fingers.

[@DarrellHaigwood-cc7ep]

Have both, had different versions. Love my PM2 AFTER installing CMEs and contured ti scales. It felt cheap b4. Love my Manix2 AFTER installing a weaker spring and contured scales. Spyderco steels absolutely rock, but their flat scales are uncomfortable out of the box.

[@DoomOfConviction]

I’m 30 and collecting knifes for 15 years. Dam you let me realize my problem ;D

[@swampdonkeyoffgrid190]

Wonderful review. Have a pm2 coming to me as we speak, have been waiting to pull the trigger and i’m excited to own one. Thanks !

[@anon6952]

I own one of each but I prefer to carry the Manix 2. I don’t mind a heavier knife

[@zactwhite]

Hi I have recently bought Spyderco Manix s110v and have no idea how to sharpen it what grit , weather to microbevel and if to strop and how to maintain the edge on this steel etc ...and also have no sharpening equipment I was thinking about purchasing Lansky sharpening system for this knife and all my others. cheers ,Zac.

[@metal_complex]

S110V is one of those steels that can be really, really tough/time consuming to sharpen even with good sharpening equipment. I'm not a pro when it comes to sharpening, but if you're going take on s110v, I would practice on some softer steels first. I hear 110 tends to be slightly chippy, so keep that in mind. Wish I could offer more advice! Bladeforums is a great place to find that kind of info. I would check there. Good luck!

[@seanb6986]

Use a diamond stone, preferably coarse, up to around 600 grit, then remove the burr with a ceramic rod and strop with leather. s110v works better with a toothy edge, it’s less prone to chipping, and a deep scratch pattern is useful too.

[@abc456f]

I have a sharpmaker and it's great for touch ups, but wanted a fixed system. Got the Lansky and promptly returned it. Frankly put, it was a pain in the ass. Went ahead, spent more money, and got the KME. Worth every penny.

[@exposetheheart]

That compression lock is not fun at all for a lefty like me. The Manix 2 lock is way better for a lefty. I feel you that metal latches on the Manix 2 would be nice. Great vid.

[@BN-cr2pu]

They make lefty pm2s now

[@brodon4886]

I have the original manix mini. It’s a beast & I’ve used it hard for years with no discernible loosening of blade or lock. I’m thinking pm2 next so this video really helped.

[@dalelamar7371]

I currently own a manix 2 lightweight translucent blue, and a blacked out manix 2 xl. Both of them are my babies, and probably my two favorite knives ever, (and I've owned a lot). EVERYTHING about them is perfect in my opinion. The ergonomics are the best i have ever felt. I don't currently own a paramilitary 2, but i did back in... 2015 i believe. In fact it was the black blade and digi camo scales. And that thing was a total beast! I used to baton logs with that thing. I mean i was hard on it, for years. And all that happened to it was developing a little bit of blade play. So from experience, both are fantastic. But i looooooooove my manix 2's. But eventually i will get another pm 2 and love it as well lol, again.

[@Mundo-702]

I own both knives and love them both spent a lot of time with each and I came to enjoy the PM2 just a little bit more i like the looks of the manix2 a little bit more but the PM2 action weight and the absolutely solid blade lock drop shut with 0 blade play so the PM2 took my pocket.

[@thaknobodi]

💯

[@CAborn1112]

My new favorite knife reviewer on KZbin!

[@JoEYHiiGHRoLLER]

I legit just bought the pm3 and manix 2 all black. I got scales for both too. I’m feelin it

[@anthonyschutz7201]

The manix 2 and para 3 lightweight can both be found at $115. Which one should I get.

[@DeffoZappo]

The manix or the sage 5. Much better

[@LordLoss]

The blade hang on the para 2 makes the blade just fall out and wobble to gravity, ooh baby. But the manix 2 handle liners feels so nice on the hand and fingers. The worst part of the manix is hands down the difficulty of opening it with two fingers as well as needing to apply palm grip force… the para is sooo easy to press with a finger…

[@BePrepared1992]

I'm gonna get hate on but out of the spydercos it's still hard to beat a good old simple tenacious !

[@gwailotus9154]

@Metal Complex - at 11:30 did u flip that pm2 open w your middle finger?

[@metal_complex]

Yes. Thats a reverse flick. The hole in the blade makes it easy. You should try it!

[@savetheelephants]

Spidey flick

[@ronniebragg6764]

I put mine in back pocket so I always take the pocket clip off can you manipulate it whit out the pocket clip

[@eddiecastellana9339]

I own the Kapaa which is my only spyderco. I tend to use it a lot in the kitchen and the compression lock is uncomfortable during hard push cuts, mostly cheese. I’ve been considering the manix but there’s so many incredible choices in the industry I’m not sure which one I should get. My budget is much less limited than “MC”!

[@cgmiller82]

I wanted a PM2 so badly, but I carry on the left side, and closing it is very awkward. I love my Manix 2, with Flytanium CF scales and aluminum lock. Great video, thanks!

[@LES7131]

there are lefty pm2 Chris, have fun

[@mikeappleget482]

On Amazon I saw a PM2 made for lefties.

[@mikewhite255]

I own the manix 2 and it's basically the perfect edc for me. Next up is pm2 , pm3 , then maybe a shaman or sage . Some day lol 😜

[@Mandarintoenail1]

Bentoboxshop has a bundle with k390 PM2 and Sage 5. Good value if you want to check two of those off your list. The k390 steel is amazing

[@menacewithaknife4045]

Was going to get the manix 2 LW because I'm left handed then I discovered the pm2 LH . Ended up with the pm2 🐱

[@nyinfamous2k2]

waaaaaaat , didnt know they had a lefty pm2. I just ordered the manix 2 for that reason also. might have to pick that up also now .lol

[@menacewithaknife4045]

@@nyinfamous2k2 definitely a great knife, got mine at the Cutlery Shoppe for under a 120 , hope this helps.

[@nyinfamous2k2]

@@menacewithaknife4045 sweet. Thanks.

[@HowardTDuck-tv8le]

LOVE my lefty PM2!

[@menacewithaknife4045]

@@HowardTDuck-tv8le glad to hear it, I feel the same way

[@smokingunclefrank6037]

I'd really like to see a comparison between the Manix 2 along with the Manix 2 XL & Para 3

[@ryangraham6756]

This video helped me quite a bit, but Im still torn on what my first spyderco should be. The para2 or manix. I like the manix for its blade shape and the lock, but I worry it will be too big in the pocket for me to edc( used to edc a BM 940). And the para2 is great but I hear the tip is very brittle (I hard use my knives) and Im not a fan of the lock. Can anyone give me and insight to my concerns? Thank you!

[@metal_complex]

My vote is Manix 2, but I own both. You can't go wrong!

[@ryangraham6756]

@@metal_complex I appreciate the quick reply! Im think I got it narrowed down to the manix. Last question how comparable is the size of the manix to the para2? That's my real hang up!

[@metal_complex]

Its 0.3" in favor of the PM2. The PM2 feels kind of "tall" and the manix 2 feels kind of "fat" if that makes sense. Maybe "long" vs "wide" is a better verbal comparison.

[@ryangraham6756]

@@metal_complex Thats exactly what I was looking for! Im havent handled eithier or so thats why I was worried! But I guess Ill be ordering the manix tomorrow. Thanks again for the help brother!

[@metal_complex]

😁👍

[@montyhighsmith2785]

I got the para lw with the compression lock I love I but when I first got it I dropped opening and it dropped on my dog point down ....I felt sooooooo bad ....( No damage to dog or knife) thought about getting rid of it ...but didn't and lol over it

[@omocigotoocasio761]

For me the PA#2 is the one.

[@paulthompson661]

Only spyder I have is the yojimbo the only other might buy later would be manix 2

[@crimsonw1ld829]

I have a Gerber Chameleon and I feel it would be much more natural to use the Manix 2. I've held and used the PM2 and I feel it is a bit much with the compression lock.

[@Damen0530]

I just might have to get one....:)

[@frogturtle]

I own multiple Benchmade knives and I absolutely love them. But with my latest purchase I wanted to change things up and grab my first Spyderco. The Manix 2 seems like a great knife, but the locking action seems similar to Benchmade’s Axis lock. I wanted something that was totally different and unique to the Spyderco brand in every way, and the Para 2 was the obvious choice for me. The compression lock, the design, the history, it’s just a great representation of a great brand. Not that the Manix 2 isn’t, but the Para 2 just sold itself to me.

[@ronniebragg6764]

I was hoping maybe you could help me I bought a new pm-2 I love this knife I've had it for a week the action is still kind of stiff let's be locked stick is the worst I've ever encountered on a knife and I have a lot of them any suggestions on how to fix it myself I called Spyderco they said send it in turnaround time was about three weeks I have fixed the lock stick on several of my cheaper folders and I'm sure I could do it on this I wondered if you had this problem

[@timseal4792]

just ordered my firstspyderco

[@warmachine1770]

I like both,lost two Para2.Getting Manix and Pm2,I carry a Griptillian as a work knife.

[@Damen0530]

Different strokes for different folks, I have XL hands. Manix 2 is a small knife in my opinion.

[@metal_complex]

You need a Manix 2 XL 😉

[@matthewsmith1612]

The size diff btween manix 2 & paramilitary 2 is negligible.

[@metal_complex]

Overall yes. But the hand space on the PM2 is much larger. I think the comments above are more about the Manix 2 vs the Manix 2 XL.

[@matthewsmith1612]

@@metal_complex what is the exact blade length of the XL ?

[@metal_complex]

3.9 inches maybe?

[@thealarmclock9307]

Manix... Lock strength

[@MasterBetty69]

Great video. Subbed.

[@thewaterwarrior9817]

Love my pm2, but the leaf style blade on the manix makes it an great slicer. It's on my list

[@Kris_Stiletto]

I like the Spyderco Manix XL's ergonomics the best. It's just like my all-time favorites handle, the Demko Knives AD20S. :-) Peace, Stiletto :-)

[@anthonyp7051]

I run the PM2 plenty,,,looking forward to owning the Manix 2 cause it’s in the same vein but different enough with that sorta axsis lock

[@exyuvucko]

My favorite Manix 2 XL 😊

[@isaiahgray3057]

Own both the Manix 2 LW and Para 3 LW. Both are amazing.

[@woofman4796]

i have 3 folders, the rat 1, the spyderco tenacious and the para 2,, all black

[@woofman4796]

my para 2 is my edc,, i've been looking at the manix 2,, i love spyderco knives

[@rahbee6266]

Just got my first premium knife in a pm2 Now I really want a manix 2

[@kenglenn6688]

This is reminding me of the two guys in a truck sceen of boogie nights. But No one gets their hat handed to em.

[@NonApplicable1983]

I’ve seen some people make titanium cages for the Manix 2 lock.

[@metal_complex]

Yes! I looked into it a while back. Someone on bladeforums made some incredibly high quality ti cages with perfect fitment. I tried to track the guy down, but he had apparently long since stopped making them, and was no longer active on BF. I would personally pay extra money for a Manix 2 with an upgraded lock cage!

[@NonApplicable1983]

Same tbh. I'm looking for an "if you could only have one" knife and I can't decide between these two. The Manix would be perfect with a metal cage since toughness is a high priority.

[@metal_complex]

100% agree. The Shaman is becoming more and more tempting...

[@NonApplicable1983]

It's a very tempting knife, but it doesn't meet that sub-3.5" sweet spot you need to be safe in some states I'd like to visit often. And it's even more expensive than the blurple knives. And lastly I've never liked that thing Spyderco does where it puts a lanyard hole inside the clip. It just doesn't look good to me.

[@metal_complex]

Believe it or not, it actually is the exact same length as the Manix 2! Except I think the blade is a tad longer, you're correct. And ya, had they not bumped the price up, I definitely would have grabbed one immediately.

[@JimRennix74]

Manix 2 is and was the best buy iv ever bought from spyderco 🕷Co . Iv 16 from the the Chicago Cliptools with 3in and small bottle opener cliptool delica 4 dragonfly endura 4 Matriarch squeak tenacious multi colours . All great 👍🏻

[@one-of-uschannel2614]

Manix is nice, just not for me. Your video made that apparent. Thx. Para 2... I got my eye on you!

[@jakezadra7521]

manix 2 will be my next purchase lol thanks

[@Ezdrumms]

Just bought the pm2 cant wait!

[@birdlaw1019]

Your PM2 is really stiff, gotta tune that blade!

[@metal_complex]

It's fine for me.

[@WStar4Life]

I prefer the weight and solid feeling of the manix.

[@ARes13FOX]

"that's just like,....you're opinion man"

[@chiefslief1886]

The dude..?...😂

[@chiefslief1886]

Jackie treehorn?..

[@jeremiahbuck2450]

the para 2 is more aesthetically pleasing but the manix 2 looks like a better build. I want both lol

[@DeeGetGuap]

Waiting for my maxis 2 now 🎉

[@JimRennix74]

Manix2 for me great handling 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇮🇪👍🏻

[@Tombstonecross]

nice relaxing video

[@godsfriend4120]

I love my p2. But be careful. I did drop it on my leg. It sunk like a arrow. Gotta love that sharp tip but not if it gets you. Not sure how much blood I lossed but it seem to take forever for it to quit. I was on the verge of going to ER. My trash can was full of paper towels

[@matthewlangley5565]

The base Manix is $30 cheaper so you might want to take that into consideration. I say buy both.

[@appalachiangunman9589]

Lightweight Manix 2 is $105. Regular Manix 2 is $126. $21 more for G-10 scales and S30V blade so the regular version is probably a better deal.

[@mtb8396]

Put both to the mud. Para2 win, simple.

[@vinnier6]

Yep

[@darrenelwood5103]

Any reason why?

[@yeti_369]

@@darrenelwood5103Easier to clean, without the liners, and inner mechanisms

[@del-marmare1646]

This is gold, thanks guys

[@nickhathaway4617]

Super late to the party on this video LOL but people carry cell phones all day long so the weight of a manix or similar in opposite pocket should be absolutely no big deal. And I like the wait it just seems like it's built better even if it's not for me manix all the way

[@kcleveland1987]

Literally bought both in the last month

[@xzane85x]

Imagine a manix with compression lock

[@mackhomie6]

Like a shaman?

[@xzane85x]

@@mackhomie6 yeah but the shaman looks like its a lot beefier. The only doubt i have with the manix is all the jimping.

[@MrKitty-zv3dl]

Manix more slashy and Paramilitary more pokie.

[@JoEYHiiGHRoLLER]

I got the knife fevva!

[@drewrubercheck5704]

That's not a knife, this is a knife. Great upload daddy

[@jojojaykay]

down with the thiccness I call KZbin knife reviewers daddy too.

[@sinisterdeer7601]

I have had 2 pm2s as of today, and a manix 2. I at first hated the pm2, but i just got a new one to give it a second try. I love the weight of the manix, substantial but not heavy. The lock is definitely more durable, it’s ergonomics are better imo, the g10 wasnt as rough which is great. I prefer the compression lock for general use, the neutral shape is pretty good for most people compared to the grooves on the manix, i wish the backs of both were completely closed on both for the sake of getting dirt in them in pockets. Im personally biased to the manix 2 because its just such an amazing knife, but the pm2 is suitable for more tasks because of the thicker blade. Both are good but im still not a huge fan of the pm2

[@hiramysumundowalky-talkytv7719]

you are the dude from bird shot? i love you voice men!!!!

[@cwrowe]

Good video...👍✅

[@donaldmcgregor8152]

#1. Shaman, #1.5. Manix 2. # 3 pm2.

[@TheGamerGuy1981]

Para 3 LW for my light EDC, manix 2 G10 for my heavy EDC.

[@bobsag1164]

Crazy, I actually have both of those in my cart for the exact same reason. After weeks of knife research

[@spy8464BB]

The Manix 2 xl is my edc . No problem with the size. I also have the discontinued Spyderco Manix 2 Burl G10 Sprint run Black DLC S90V blade . It's a little smaller but really good looking

[@lukejodoin3449]

Manix 2 all day for me. I could never warm up to the para2, always felt weird in the hand to me. Manix feels like it was made for my hands...almost the same exact grip as my xm-18's

[@marklawrence855]

I had to get both because I couldn't make up my mind

[@stacygriffin9796]

Where's Rickey now?!? Y'all should do another vid! #BringBackRickey He doesn't even talk much lol

[@Clambelly]

Manix 2 without point down carry is NO GO

[@metal_complex]

The Shaman might work better for you.

[@Clambelly]

Thanks for the info ... BTW ... very good review, interesting setting too. Shaman looks big. I will get Para 2.

[@metal_complex]

I originally also thought the Shaman looked big. But the specs show it as 8 inches overall, which is the same overall length as the Manix 2, and 0.5 inches shorter than the PM2. I think its the design that makes it look so big. But the PM2 is also a great choice!

[@abc456f]

@@Clambelly For heavy duty tasks, the Shaman outclasses the pm2. Much beefier blade.

[@wills.8662]

Just carry a Manix2 on one side and a PM2 on the other side.

[@Will-W]

I'm so late to this party, but I totally get the knife snob thing. I have my nice knife and my beater knife with me normally. The cheapo 2" lock-back I got with my NRA membership sees more use for box opening duty than any of the expensive knives, unless I need to do it one handed.