Star Wars Outlaws vs Red Dead Redemption 2 - Physics and Details Comparison

[@DanAllenGaming]

Timestamps: 0:00 - Does the Character get Wet? 0:25 - Melee Combat 1:13 - Jumping from a High Point 1:35 - Running Into NPC's 2:03 - Does the Character get Muddy? 2:37 - Petting Animals 3:18 - Catching on Fire 3:36 - NPC's Eating & Drinking 4:15 - Deadeye 5:00 - Crossing Map Boundaries 5:30 - Getting Arrested 6:48 - Shooting Water 7:19 - Healing 7:37 - Running over NPC's 8:15 - Bush Physics 8:45 - Idle Animation 9:06 - Draw Distance 9:24 - Muddy Footprints 9:49 - Jumping off a Waterfall 10:21 - Death Animation 10:45 - Resuming the Game

[@_MaZTeR_]

Even Rise of the Tomb Raider, 9yo game, looks better than this

[@pratyushxis1787]

4:15 this deadeye feature is a complete ripoff of the mark and execute system(just a slowdown available this time) in ubisoft's splinter cell conviction/blacklist. Can't believe they used the same animations of 2013 game and that too horribly.

[@reloadedspade176]

@@pratyushxis1787it’s Ubisoft, did you actually expect innovation? They’re reusing alot of sounds and assets from decade old AC titles for Shadows too

[@sebastianarevalo9113]

And, Fun Fact, An Ubisoft dev said that Elden ring was trash as Open World, that Ubisoft only knews how to make Open Worlds.....

[@jimsunff1563]

Did UBI not only infringe on the copyright of a Japanese commercial organization, but also steal the functionality of Rockstar Games' Red Eye?

[@mioszsypniewski8539]

Its not fair compare Outlaws that cames out 6 years ago and Red Dead Redemption 2 from 2024........waaaait a minute

[@thesupergameplayer8263]

You win😂😂😂😂🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@2ChainZsensai]

There, right there! XD

[@Packtouchdown]

Hey it’s not fair to compare such a huge company like rockstar to Ubisoft a….huge…company….oh wait a minute

[@matthewchan2442]

Hey it's not fair to compare a AAAA game to a AAA game.....waaaaiittt a minute

[@kotterpike714]

hahaha

[@tylero1689]

IGN saying that outlaws is like “rdr2 in space” might be the best joke of the decade

[@leecroft1983]

Wait… did they actually say that ? I gotta watch their review 😂

[@neutronalchemist3241]

It would, but IGN still being in business beats it.

[@contactokeffisor6213]

IGN is a joke

[@Stickmon_]

@@leecroft1983dont do that, dont give them views lol

[@amp9193]

IGN stan for " i got nothing" on gamingsense

[@TheOriginalEwan]

Horse testicles change size based on the temperature. That alone shows how superior RDR2 is when it comes to attention to detail.

[@bolonekoplo2561]

@@TheOriginalEwan wtf, it's real? Damn awesome

[@geckoop2848]

@@bolonekoplo2561didn’t you know that? Also the bodies slowly decomposition as the days pass by. Rdr2 is just phenomenal beast

[@ronnical2489]

That is good to know but why the fuck do you look at horse balls

[@WoodbabyCYL]

@@geckoop2848it just cant be on a road or something where people can pick it up. Animals too

[@Cod_fella1991]

You were looking at horse testicles??

[@JEFF2002-q7q]

Comparing Outlaws with Rdr2 is just an insult to Rdr2😂

[@nicusorhotin3177]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@DKOIsoul]

Nah insult is that they released AC Odyssey same month as RDR2 and it has most of the same issues as outlaws lol. Ubisoft is just pretty bad now unfortunately.

[@jackson13493]

I think they can compare this game with Starfield, which is not that good, it's the weakest Bethesda game and with the less amount of detail, but compared to this, it's kinda good to be fair, RDR2 it's years ahead from this crap.

[@omarabdul2864]

It's like comparing fermented toad shit to golden apples

[@SunnyV3official]

More like an insult to gta iv

[@cabuscus]

truly a ubisoft original.

[@tmastergaming]

Lol I hate how they started saying that. Like naww.

[@eldkfwkd321]

fucking lazy french

[@Homophobic_racist_sexist_pdf]

Gta 6 leaked videos looked better

[@willbb]

Mfs can’t enjoy a game anymore

[@RealRyanGosling995]

More like Ubislop

[@BillyOnYouTube]

Outlaws is like a Mcdonald's happy meal at a bus stop on a Tuesday afternoon and RDR2 is like a 12 course meal on Christmas Eve with all your family.

[@abrahamz5460]

Facts

[@yuki90286]

but happy meal can always make me happy , Outlaws doesn't .

[@birzhanabdikhan8175]

Outlaws is like lunchables. Expensive shit that nobody asked for

[@BillyOnYouTube]

@@birzhanabdikhan8175 Hahaha

[@IMRANKHAN-yc6sk]

Sad meal*

[@Sound557]

You know what? I’m going to play RDR2 again.

[@bl4z3boss]

You made the right choice here buddy😁

[@Hellapoised]

I’m in the epilogue. Wanted to finish up my 3rd play thru before starting Outlaws. It’s probably gonna make me wish I was still playing RDR2 looking at these reviews. I can live with certain woke shit, just as long as the game is good. But I’m having doubts

[@marioultimateart90]

Great choice 👌

[@wick7599]

Cruel, cruel world

[@jabbypants788]

I recently did and enjoyed it again.

[@user-ot8wl7oh9s]

Ubisoft should won an award for the most uninspired developer of the year.

[@user-ot8wl7oh9s]

there's so many games with such cool ideas and details put into them over the years yet they would still be this complacent and do the bare minimum and think yeah this looks good enough.

[@Mrchiefsaygg]

Ubisoft is not a developer it’s a publisher like EA, Activision, Microsoft. Developers : bingie, treyarch , infinity ward, Turn 10. Maybe Ubisoft games use the same developers bcs all their games have the same flaws literally

[@alvarg]

if it existed they'd win every year

[@friderikuszsanci1767]

They saw elden ring won with a death world and copy paste game so they wanted the same

[@IndefiniteIdea]

Make that of the decade

[@DropoutJerome]

I don’t understand how you could get a license for Star Wars and not try to make the best goddamn piece of media for the franchise that ever existed

[@leejenkins7184]

For sure. Haha it just took one person from the office to think that.

[@x0gucx]

Disney

[@Ascending11]

​@@x0gucxI was going to say just that.

[@JuanDiegoPinillos]

Star Wars is a dead franchise, Disney killed it

[@a.wunderland]

​@@x0gucxDisney standard, ruin all of the sw universe

[@patfer1189]

It's unbelievable that Black flag in 2013 and Far Cry 2 in 2008 had far more details and care than anything that Ubisoft has put out since.

[@woidmoasta4673]

Assassin's Creed Unity from 2014 for me was even more ahead. This game is the best looking Assassin's Creed i think.

[@ni9274]

If by details you mean realistic physic and environmental interactions then you’re completely wrong, recent Ubisoft games have way more of it then Black Flag and far cry 2

[@Bread_Bug]

Well outlaws wasnt even made by the far cry/assassin’s creed team. It was made by The Division team

[@cwcw402]

Even AC Odyssey blows Outlaws out of the water not even close.

[@Rinue618]

@@ni9274 Definitely he talks about the part touched by humans, the details. What you mentioned, most of the merit is given to the engine's resources and not to the meticulous care taken by a person at different points.

[@SilentAssassin01234]

Literally AC2 had Ezio looking wet when swimming. And AC1 had characters react to Altair running into them. It is crazy.

[@ReX_THE_CONQUEROR]

Bro the developing company of this game is not same as of any AC series. Also a gentle reminder UBISOFT is a production house . Not a direct developing house.

[@reloadedspade176]

@@ReX_THE_CONQUERORthey need to PRODUCE a better team then. This is embarrassing for the “first open world Star Wars game” $70 triple A slop

[@napatt.7943]

@@ReX_THE_CONQUERORit doesn’t matter cuz it still shows how much their qc dropped as a publisher

[@whocaresidontfuckoff]

well, they can't have a female character sporting a wet and tight ass.

[@DKOIsoul]

Ubisoft got worse. I love some of their older games but man I refuse to touch anything newer.

[@111uhhhh1]

Bro even just a single town like valentine has more detail and love than the entire outlaws gameplay

[@Mr-Zeilokix]

The doctors office has more love and gameplay than outlaws…

[@dogsoup5561]

Just a friendly reminder.. RDR2 came out in 2018/2019

[@dr_diddy]

RDR2 was developed by like 2000 people. Outlaws had like 600

[@dogsoup5561]

@@dr_diddy Lol and Larian Studios have 470.. so your point exactly?

[@PortugueseBadman]

​@@dr_diddy600 could still do better than Outlaws.

[@willbb]

It was also in development for over 8 years and had a very high budget

[@Thunder4k12]

​@@dr_diddy So? Black myth wukong was made by 100-200 devs and still got insane world detail...

[@nickrios7788]

Red Dead Redemption 2 -retail price for standard edition being $59.99 USD -no cut content to make you pay for higher priced editions or a subscription -most detailed and graphical marvel of all time that blast modern games visuals out of the water even after 6 years -great and compelling characters and story that take you through an emotional journey that will stick with you forever Star Wars Outlaws -retail price for standard edition being $69.99 USD -cut content only unlockable by paying for higher editions or a subscription - lackluster details and graphics from a modern AAA game -generic story and characters that you will forget after you beat the game I think we have a clear winner here

[@yaboiyeets3721]

technically a robbery mission and a hideout is locked behind RDR2 ultimate edition but that’s pretty insignificant

[@Abdool777]

you forgot to add ps2 era controls and mission design to Red Dead

[@jacobantaya7423]

​@@Abdool777 bruh you're tripping. Is your point that it uses a controller? The same could be said for outlaws I'm pretty sure the control scheme is pretty similar. Sometimes you don't need to reinvent the wheel (Wii u anyone?). It does pay off sometimes though (Wii, switch). Man i could never go back to console gaming but Nintendo sometimes tempts me

[@Abdool777]

@@jacobantaya7423 you're still mashing X to run in 2018, every single button press has a second lag before your character does anything if its even possible to do anyhthing thanks to locked animations having a huge priority over responsiveness. Arthur controls like a forklift, not a human. Rockstar has been using the same press left trigger-right trigger template for "gameplay" since GTA 3, the game plays itself in every single shootout. Same goes for missions, GTA 3 era design with instant game over screens the second you slightly deviate from the intended parameters of a mission.

[@jacobantaya7423]

@@Abdool777 the missions make sense, if you're running a heist with the gang and you decide to run off somewhere it makes sense you'd fail but I understand why that could be annoying. Controls I guess you're right (to an extent). It's understandable because Arthur/John are supposed to act/look like real people, not the average gamer ADHD bounding from one thing to another. Once you're immersed in the world though that kinda stops mattering as much but it is a valid criticism. Mashing x isn't something I had to deal with as a PC player but I remember that from GTA 5 and Red dead on PS3 they really should do away with the middle tier jogging when you hold x and just have walk/sprint, gamers do just want to be fast and having to mash a button to be fast is annoying. You can turn off auto aim once I did that I found combat much more engaging. But sure the controls are dated but very serviceable and didn't take me out of the experience, fair criticism though.

[@BelaFox-vt5xu]

RDR2: How to make open-world games Star Wars Outlaws: How not to make games

[@ksaweryjanowski827]

No game has this much realism as RDR2. At best 1% of that, and despite that they're still good games like Witcher 3, Cyberpunk, God of War Ragnarok, Spider-Man etc.

[@exe9790]

​​@@ksaweryjanowski827 yeah even Rdr2 is comparable to the Game of the Year WUKONG

[@alien_824]

SW Outlaws looks pretty decent for a 2018 game, on the other hand RDR2 truly looks like a 2024 game, I'm so happy we are finally having a 9th gen experience.

[@sm0k3y56]

Shame though, Outlaws was limited by the technology at the time. Hasn't aged well at all.

[@LiberatedMind1]

I thought it was 2008.

[@pickleman40]

I wouldnt have played swol on my ps2

[@xzorn2981]

hell naw bub, ps3 era games were better

[@jacobantaya7423]

​@@xzorn2981 I honestly believe the same video could have been made with the first red dead redemption game (not revolver) and red dead would still come out on top. Or gta 5.

[@marjanbaidy9980]

Melee combat in outlaws is literally toddlers fighting 😂

[@vdochev]

She clearly uses the Force because her fists do not physically connect with the enemy.

[@nigelo92]

Her fists are made of steel clearly too, punching helmets like that...

[@IrishDroid]

If you look it looks like RDR1 melee combat. Flailing in a way lol

[@AVERAGEHUMAN22451]

⁠​⁠​⁠@@IrishDroidrdr1 Melee combat is good way better than outlaws

[@mrhungaryshit]

outlaws is the best game, much better than rdr2 IMO

[@martinduebner]

Just saying "Return to the game" is like 0 effort to make the game immersive. That feels like if the last page of a book said "Out of ideas". The laziest solution to just have an invisible wall would have been better.

[@kiasia3219]

omg worst decision ever. make it where someone comes after you and kills you or something

[@CraftyApe]

or have tough terrain like mountains you can't scale, rough rivers you can't cross, the sea, impossible to beat enemies, a border wall with security/turrets, etc

[@230Cheerios]

I’m pretty sure there’s a giant sand worm thingy near one of the map limits, so obviously they decided not to use any of them. Instead of having some of them begin to hunt you down as you try to get to safety

[@Creeper_ofDoom]

Star Wars Outlaws has 0 immersion

[@richtofenify]

Holy, this comparison proves how 70 bucks are not worthy for Outlaws.. imagine 130 lmfao.

[@carljohnson7]

Anyone buys outlaws for 130 dollars deserves to get robbed

[@Undertacoss]

Are you seriously telling me that outlaws costs 70 bucks?

[@liamn.7664]

fuck bro that’s terrible

[@erickalvarez6486]

​@@Undertacosslike every game? Hahaha

[@erickalvarez6486]

What? Do you play the game or just be messing around? Lol, if the second is the case, probably Zelda BOTW is for you.

[@John.Angell]

Devil his due, RD2 was a technical masterpiece. It was a once-in-a-decade game crafted by creative, thoughtful devs who took pride in their work, and went above and beyond to craft the best product they could. Outlaws came from Ubisoft.

[@Dexter01992]

Yes, but it's not us "unfairly" comparing it to RDR2. It was IGN who decided to go with the big claims. People at this point are just performing the comparison in a more practical way. :)

[@CraftyApe]

Yeah but I think even if you compared it to The Witcher 3 instead, or another Ubisoft game Assassin's Creed Unity, it would still similarly be a bloodbath. Maybe not as much, as you said RDR2 is truly the #1 best designed game in terms of its world's ecosystem, animations, physics and interactivity. But those games would still slaughter Outlaws.

[@extract3959]

You mean a rockstar game*

[@Akiyama_Shun]

Ubisoft: “Why would you compare our game with rdr2? It’s a Star Wars game….a STAAAAAR WAARS game! Pay us 90$ immediately now.”

[@Triver24]

If this happened, it's canon

[@liamn.7664]

the fact that this game came out in 2024 and red dead came out in 2018 just shows how much more effort and detail the two different studios put into each of their games

[@Indigo_1001]

One studio had 2000 developers with a whole year delay and the other didn’t

[@liamn.7664]

@@Indigo_1001 doesn’t matter

[@nathanmcguckin9518]

@@Indigo_1001it doesn’t matter Ubisoft still one of the biggest company’s out there u telling me they don’t have the people or money to at least make the game feel alive and but more realistic stop making excuses for a company that literally doesn’t care about their fans

[@FightClass3]

One Studio is 30 billion dollar company, the other studio is 2 billion dollar company, of course bigger company makes bigger games... I swear, 90% people are retarded.

[@xzorn2981]

@@Indigo_1001 ubishit dickrider spotted

[@zyadelmarwany4566]

0:25 man what is this, she didn't even touch them

[@Logan-hh9me]

Maybe she has the force. That is probably their most likely response.

[@Noir-c9k]

The combat is atrocious fr lol why’s nobody talking about it?

[@jobaki]

​@@Logan-hh9me....no.....she doesn't

[@jobaki]

​@@Noir-c9k💰

[@jeremiahjohnson2784]

Drax, still with the godlike reflexes I see

[@BalkanRedneck]

It's like comparing a TV dinner steak, to a ribeye, cooked table-side for you by Gordon Ramsay.

[@Jacob_24]

WTF you're comparing Ubisoft's soggy big mac with Rockstar's highest quality steak.

[@Nightmareof94]

It perfectly shows the level of quality we used to have compared with the slop we get now

[@kiro253]

​@@Nightmareof94Depend on the dev u looking at tbh

[@mr.crowjo_3933]

Big Mac? It's not even a cheeseburger

[@sufferintoilet6231]

That's an insult to all soggy big macs out there

[@Veckler]

​@@Nightmareof94 The quality of RDR2 was outstanding at release too, it wasn't the norm.

[@crazyfnjoey]

The running into people one is utterly unforgivable. I am not being hyperbolic either; during promo videos for AC 1 (WHICH CAME OUT IN 2007!) they spotlighted how Enzio would naturally weave his way through crowds by putting his hand on their shoulder and the individuals in the crowd would move realistically in that space. We are going backwards here…

[@OlejandroAmenabar]

*Altair He was a protagonist of the AC1

[@mikefoster500]

Oh, you remembered about Enzio meme, but you are old, my friend

[@axt2]

Even comparing it to a 7 year old game I knew this was going to be a bloodbath

[@TheRainbowSMASH]

This comment makes me sad

[@braevinmaund1210]

@@TheRainbowSMASHhow so?

[@megapeebs2631]

Can't believe rdr2 is 7 years old

[@megapeebs2631]

​@braevinmaund1210 it's sad because it's insane how a game so much older is better at everything

[@braevinmaund1210]

@@megapeebs2631 true, everything up to gta 6 is just filler at this point

[@Holloaway]

Ubislop really thought they could cash in on big franchises by disguising Watch Dogs as Star Wars Outlaws and Far Cry as Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora.

[@greytakerrev7147]

Wow thats great insight. I never thought of it that way. You’re smart.

[@Akiee98]

And dont forget that they also disguised Assasins Creed as Assasins Creed.... Wait, what?

[@jetnipatteeravithayapinyo2468]

​@@Akiee98don't forget. The first game is a disguised Prince of Persia

[@lum1notryc828]

Youd know. Cuz youve played it. Right?? Lmao it doesnt play anything like watch dogs

[@damigamermx-us8291]

@@lum1notryc828the game is still generic trash

[@etrusco2898]

What's funny is that Ezio in AC2 actually does get wet when he comes out of water.

[@wtklpm]

Even Lara Croft in TR Legends on PS2 got wet with water, this SW game is just lazy

[@Archiephiu]

​@@wtklpm it has been since 2015

[@MirelRC]

AC2 was a game made with soul. This SW: Outlaws is a quick cashgrab‚ lazy AF‚ propaganda game.

[@Jabler-]

@@Archiephiu This getting wet technology has been around since before 2008. Ubisoft is just a shitty developer.

[@exquize1660]

@@Archiephiu It's older than that, it can be by just adjusting specular light, as simple as that, it was Uncharted who popularize it with shader water and such so PS3 era in 2007. Tomb Raider legend use a more simple method but still gets wet (2006) Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty got simple wet effect and even Tomb Raider on ps1.

[@r0ckyr083]

This is the difference when you make 1 game in 8 years vs 8 games in 1 year...

[@DV-ou1yu]

Omg this comment is spot on lol

[@vjxbigbear]

Spot on

[@Mr-Zeilokix]

The outlaws combat is taken directly from watchdog legions.

[@treman722]

Thanks for saving me $70.

[@InternetRez]

If seekng this is what it takes for you to make that decision, gamers are fucking stupid.

[@kalebsithnerd119]

Now you know what you should actually spend that $70 on

[@treman722]

@@kalebsithnerd119 Already got it on PC and XBOX, don't you worry. I hope GTA 6 doesn't fall into modern audience crap traps.

[@kalebsithnerd119]

@@treman722 I’m sure given the decade long wait it’ll be worth it. But I do share the same concern

[@Rootiga]

@@kalebsithnerd119 $70 worth of red dead gold obviously

[@yolimap]

and just remind yall, rdr2 IS A PS4 GAME, and that star wars game is NEXT GENERATION EXCLUSIVE

[@queueeeee9000]

Why are we still marketing them as next gen? Almost half a decade old at this point 😂

[@cystic_0404]

I'm not sure if thats sad or funny :/

[@stevengreene7389]

@@cystic_0404it’s both the best kind of funny lol

[@bighomie9415]

Come on. Rockstars budget for these games is basically unlimited because they know they'll make their money back 100x over. They can invest the necessary resources into these details because they have the money and time to do so. Massive Entertainment can't compete with that.

[@Rag-tagBouvelard]

At this point comparing any open world game with rdr2 would be unfair. Rdr2 had literally ruined gaming for me as now I see every games are half baked especially in term of details and rpg elements

[@blueberrycranberrycherry2025]

Well rockstar games will follow the same path with other companies like Ubisoft

[@ahsandhindsa4550]

Yeah but the point is outlaws is absolute dog water . You could compare it to most games from like the 2015's and they will blow this game out of the water ,eg mad max 2015 .

[@dreamog9918]

cuz IGN saying that outlaws is like “RDR2 in space” might be the best joke of the decade

[@ahsandhindsa4550]

@@dreamog9918 No way they actually said that ?

[@sayankakalita7827]

The thing is games don't need to be super immersive and detailed like rdr2, but the thing is game should have a unique feel to it, outlaws doesn't have anything that makes it feel unique

[@georgemartyn5268]

just a reminder that we got *this* instead of 1313

[@ultraviolet540]

This had every opportunity to be 1313, such a shame.

[@notorious3875]

Republic commando 2, jedi knight 3, clone wars game

[@MrThecrazyzombie]

What makes you think 1313 will be better

[@stephenpatterson8056]

​@MrThecrazyzombie This exactly. Nobody knows what that game would have been. All we ever got was a concept trailer. Also, it's kinda silly to compare basically any rockstar game to any other game. Rockstar has a level of resources that literally no other studio comes close to having. This game may not be as painstakingly detailed as Red Dead. But I personally don't need it to be. As long as it's a fun Star Wars adventure I'll be happy. It's a franchise that is still quite underrepresented in gaming

[@MortalArgon]

​@@MrThecrazyzombie Because it had better action, voice acting, cutscenes, facial animations, humor and companion in a 13 MIN DEV DEMO THEN "SW:OUTLAWS" ENTIRE 20+HOUR 70$ MEDIOCRE STARWARS/UNCHARTED/GTA BOOTLEG OF A GAME. Need I say more 😁

[@jhonygamer7378]

Any game released is compared to RDR 2, even 6 year after it release, that's incredible 😂

[@nathanmitchell7961]

Ok, thats INSANE 7:43 they didnt even bother

[@axt2]

you just blew my mind. That's a very basic thing any player would try. Grim.

[@ultraviolet540]

It’s too pg, too disnified.

[@TheDanks]

@@ultraviolet540 Too PG? Even PG stuff could do this on a daily basis

[@AMALRICAMALRIC]

Lego people get flattened when you run over them, that have more effort than this and is enough PG, lol @@ultraviolet540

[@bl00dy1ng]

Just make them duck or quickly jump out the way to make it pg. Clipping through an npc like they’re not there is not good enough for this type of game

[@namekiz3199]

working for Ubisoft must be great if this is all you have to put effort into for 3 years

[@V3ntilator]

The problem is that it were made in 3 years, so it were rushed. Normal development time Outlaws would but 6 years +/-.

[@Marvin-vs3tu]

​@@V3ntilator Yeah even rdr2 took 8 years+ they can plan out all the details and time to create

[@V3ntilator]

@@Marvin-vs3tu Yeah. They were making The Division 3 at the same time, so i wonder if the main talent were working on that game, while Outlaws were a side project.

[@SteelMckeelZ]

It’s really not from what I heard, a guy I know who worked at the one in Singapore back when skull and bones was in development and he said it was absolutely hell with crunch times and unrealistic deadlines, and then having to scrap major portions that had time and effort put into them, I can only assume Ubisofts head people in charge (not the workers) bc I doubt any of the people who actually love games are satisfied with what comes from the games that they have to rush out or gut after putting so much valuable time into them.

[@imitenotbe]

@@SteelMckeelZ the biggest part of the situation you're mentioning is the Singaporean government had a contract with them to make the game and a grant was issued. This is done sometimes by certain countries in an effort to boost the nations economy (Poland paid a grant to CDPR for The Witcher). This contract was in danger of breaching so Skull and Bones was just wrapped up and shipped. It probably wouldn't have been a good game no matter how much time was spent, but that's the reason for the "crunch"

[@matmat9644]

Compare Star Wars Outlaws, an unfinished game vs Red Dead Redemption 2, a masterpiece. Star Wars Outlaws dev: This is outrageous, it's unfair.

[@kilaudio9984]

5:16 they didnt even bother to set an animation for mounting your speedster

[@kingghxstgaming]

IGN gave it a 7

[@Mindo1004]

They did. There are multiple unique animations. Maybe if you actually played the game and didn't base it in random pointless comparison videos you would know that.

[@kilaudio9984]

@@Mindo1004 not in this example they didnt

[@axiss5840]

​@@Mindo1004 'pay money for crap or you can't call it what it is' doesn't work.

[@prabhakarraj6644]

The hell is that melee combat 💀 0:25

[@Squidgyb128]

Literally just punching air lmao

[@Rootiga]

its what actors do on set lmfao

[@Se1goulien]

I could take a trip to mars and come back by the time she lands a blow and still feel little to no pain at all.

[@Felker93]

„Not Bad still in one piece“ 💅✨💁‍♀️

[@leecroft1983]

@@Felker93See, the Force is female…

[@makar_a8781]

Господи, после выхода рдр2 на консоли прошло 6 лет, а ничего по детализации даже на половину не приблизилось к этой игре. Да, в следующем году выходит гта6 и я более чем уверен, она задаст новый недостижимый потолок по мелким деталям. Ведь не зря между частями прошло уже 12, мать вашу, лет!?

[@Aleks12ss]

Роки умеют делать игры

[@thestarhopper]

while im not one to just hate on outlaws for the sake of it, comparing it to red dead is like comparing a mcdonalds burger to an actual restaurant meal

[@26j9isnotarealperson]

2018 vs 2024 game btw

[@IncomingLegend]

I think its a fair comparison given that RDR2 came out some time ago... but quality wise I agree with your analogy...

[@gamingman5453]

@@26j9isnotarealpersondoesn’t matter I could do the same with black myth and rdr2 or elden ring and rdr2 comparing rdr2 to any game especially a mid one is disingenuous

[@wrangchops]

Ubisoft is one of the biggest gaming companies on the planet. Starfield was great to eh.

[@IHADTHECAKE]

So much I agree with this. Different engines, different dev teams, different goals in mind. The people who outright hate for hate sake have more than this video game they are dealing with. For $18 bucks it’s a pretty awesome game. Pay for Ubisoft plus, cancel it and play for a month.

[@NotSoUpstandingCitizen]

The game should be outlawed because of how bad it is

[@IHADTHECAKE]

Idk I’m having fun with it. It’s more like ghost of Tsushima than RDR2

[@mevans4953]

It’s basically DEI the game. How many people who worked on the game actually resemble real gamers?

[@IHADTHECAKE]

@@mevans4953 your opinion is so far from reality my man. This is not DEI the game.

[@ultraviolet540]

@@IHADTHECAKEthe game is bad lol

[@nicwhites]

@@IHADTHECAKE more like a pos than anything else. its audacious to even compare these games.

[@hannes0000]

Nothing beats masterpiece RDR2 right now,true open world RPG.

[@ysyear]

why you comparing a QUADRUPLE A from Ubisoft with a mere triple A from Rockstar?

[@dissassemblydrone]

Because the triple a is better

[@lordsteppergod7269]

I've been enjoying rdr2 again lately

[@axt2]

I desperately wish there was a new game plus option

[@AtomicEy]

i would if ps5 version

[@notBrocker]

How can you not enjoy rdr2? It’s not possible

[@akashsarkar2001-r5k]

​@@notBrockerI mean, people with a low attention span would hate it. For example, people who play online fps games constantly. They won't like RDR2

[@eviafamily7898]

@@AtomicEy the ps4 version look like a ps5 version already.

[@ZackaryAkes]

Just picked up Star wars outlaws today and I got to say I'm loving it way more than I thought I would, but it's not worth $70 so get it on sale

[@fewkeyfewkey5414]

I was bouta think u actually paid full price for that thing 😂 but yeah a lot of ubisoft games been on sale lately

[@fullsendabeerforme2988]

Ubisoft just makes horrible games in general. The last good Ubisoft game was black flag. Update: I bought Star wars outlaw and am currently a third of the way through. I just wanted something new to play, idc say whatever you got to say. Besides the AI in the game, it literally isn't all that bad. IT doesn't deserve that much hate off a couple of videos. Play it for yourself. It's not too bad actually. Remember, days gone was badmouthed intensely when it first came out and now everyone is saying it's one of the best open world zombie games to date and so was cyberpunk for its bugs.. give it a proper chance before assuming... I did, and I'm still man enough to admit i was wrong about this game. Although, I still believe black flag besides this was the last good game they've made.

[@arkhamknight7236]

Not really but okay

[@bizs_backloggaming]

You sleep on prince of persia

[@Ronuk1996]

Far Cry primal on hard core mode is pretty good but that was 2016. Ac 2018 was decent but yeah there recent games are lacking. How are they charging so much for this.

[@Blaze78x]

Ubisoft is mid af 😂

[@skazleadhoof6406]

Ubisoft games would be white rice if they were a food.

[@sveezyx]

04:02 lol you can look at npcs just eating and drinking in RDR 2 and it's still more interesting, and entertining than playing Outlaws. . .

[@The_Honored_One_69]

also that lady eating was cute lmao

[@DanteYewToob]

I love those Outlaw “Hollywoo punches” where they miss by like 2 feet and still connect somehow… lmao

[@Mythical.History]

Running into people have no effect? This is the same company who made AC in which there's a button to shove people when you're running into crowd

[@BlackSmith6969]

@@AgentParth who the fuck is jade

[@vernonparker5154]

Ubisoft isn’t the same company it was 10 years ago, it’s a husk of it’s former self

[@diseasefaktory]

It's a cash grab, they don't give a fuck about those details or even basic physics.

[@NoxNoctisUmbra]

People know rdr2 has a lot of detail, but people don't realize how much detail there is... It's just mind-blowing.

[@spacemaxi9364]

When a 6 years old game has better physics and details than a brand new one. Really tells you something about the current state of the video game industry.

[@shyboy2112]

and better graphics, story, dialogue, animations...

[@kevinlin3747]

11:05 squat controlling the bike is the peak of gaming history

[@nawabifaissal9625]

when rockstar make a game nobody jokes about it, when ubisoft make a game they get laughed at by everyone lol

[@rameez875]

Because it’s shit bucko

[@propeldragon]

Forget about gta trilogy remake?

[@nawabifaissal9625]

@@propeldragon if i remember the studio behind it was a small one, it wasn't a full experience team from rockstar game that made the trilogy so i'm not sure if that even counts, but from all the game they made this was probably the one that they failed to deliver properly, also it's not even an entirely new game, it's just a remake, yeah we can definitely forget about that one lol

[@BlackSmith6969]

@@nawabifaissal9625 yeah people thought the shitty trilogy was made by rockstar and fans were so stressed out thinking that what would happen to GTA 6 but rockstar told after they release this shit by saying that we didnt made this edition,we just published it and people thought in 2021 that rockstar will announce Trailer 1 of GTA 6 and instead we got this shit so hear me out what other games released after RDR2 2018- RDR2 2021- Trilogy Dogshit 2022- GTA V for PS5 AKA the cash grab edition and yep rockstar released only two games after RDR2 and modders can do better job than this what the fuck happened to rockstar the only one company we loved turned us out every company is after money and so is rockstar which is sad that we couldnt play Midnight club 5,max payne 4,bully 2,RDR2 undead niightmare DLC,GTA V agent Trever DLC when other companies announce games, nobody gives a shit but when rockstar annouced any game, everyone gets hype as fuck I hope roclstar returns to normal and releae other games instead of milking GTA online if rockstar is after moeny and doesnt want people to pirate their games, make those games console exclusive but atleast release other games but this is never gonna happen 😥

[@vaultboy1419]

Depends on what kind of jokes. I still remember people making a foot trail in snow shaped like a penis when RDR2 came out :D

[@dr.doctor4878]

0:32 That was hilarious. You would think she had some training in CQC because of her occupation but nope. Just swing and hope it hits😂

[@goodpesar1744]

Just in case any Ubisoft developer is seeing this You can suggest not to make any game in 5 or 6 years and work on a proper game whichever you had idea(assassin's,far cry,...) about. Panicking and making multiple games like avatar or star wars isn't going to help you out of this muddy situation

[@Timenec1000]

Well the only thing Ubisoft cares about is money and I'm sure they are making lots and lots of it working less in each game they make Valhalla Avatar etc, is sad but is not going to change I'm sure

[@athal6962]

Quantity over quality bro

[@charlesburns7391]

Ubisoft devs don't get to decide... I doubt they want to churn out as many games as they do. Blame the company instead. All of their games in the past 10 years have been the same car with a different body

[@hakeem4099]

Makes me wonder why rdr2 never won gamenof the year.

[@Motylia]

see, atleast it had a fair fight.... If rdr2 came out today, it would win this years GOTY easly.

[@rane7784]

@@Motylia better too without other console support holding them back. We'll have most cut content including the better Guarma chapter

[@andrespolanco3182]

In my opinion it got robbed, GoW is a good game but RDR2 is a gaming achievement.

[@shafkatamin5659]

Tough choice between GoW and RDR2. I personally preferred RDR2, but won't say that RDR2 got robbed. 2020 on the other hand, was a clusterfuck

[@shafkatamin5659]

@@Motylia Wukong would give it a fair fight though.

[@ivanchelo91]

RDR II leaves a trail of water when you get out of it, a detail I haven't seen in other games, and the footprints you leave in the mud fill with water when it rains - not to mention other more subtle details such as when the character buttons the collar of his shirt when he is extremely cold or unbuttons it when it is hot.

[@carljohnson7]

Its incredible how red dead 2 still looks this great all these years later. To the detail for taking a freaking bath

[@50H3i1]

6 years newer but it looks 10 years older . Now that's impressive

[@Mr.PapuXDXD]

Bugisoft never dissappoints

[@diegoknights]

0:30 the way she just drops her blaster for no reason

[@aaronmccutcheon6008]

I don't even think Grand theft Auto 6 is going to have the level of detail that Red Dead redemption 2 has. This game is legitimately next level.

[@WealthyInsuranceOfficial]

Basically you're doing the same as GTA 5 as comparing it to rdr2

[@mioszsypniewski8539]

RDR2 is nex gen today.

[@gtmo55mack20]

It will

[@aaronmccutcheon6008]

@@gtmo55mack20 highly doubt it, real time body decay, the draw distance, the attention to detail with weapons, characters, and NPCs. If they went the direction of GTA 4, I'd be inclined to agree, but the fan base didn't love all those meticulous details. RD and GTA fans are rarely in the same boat. Personal opinion, Rdr trumps GTA, in every aspect...

[@infinite3685]

@@aaronmccutcheon6008 still no online tho

[@AnimichileTV]

Conclusion: Made with love in RDR2. Made with hate in Outlaws.

[@ReikiMaulana]

1:19 PowerPoint presentation ahh death 😭🙏

[@MrPear40]

This is a certified modern audience moment kek

[@iguanobro9925]

TBH the modern audiences are just babies by now (I mean… they’re literally and figuratively the new audiences)

[@ni9274]

What’s the link ?

[@ni9274]

@@iguanobro9925no they’re anyone that started playing games in this decade

[@iguanobro9925]

@@ni9274 those and literal babies and kids aren’t buying said games anyways.

[@grd1184]

Rdr2 gameplay gives me like a warm cozy feeling everytime I watch some. What a great experience it was to play that game, it literally made me feel like I was living through Arthur, there’s nothing like it.

[@CanisoGaming]

10:49 im fookin wheezing 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@PortugueseBadman]

This feels like a jab at the urinalist that called Outlaws RDR2 in space. Love it.

[@David-qw5vr]

i gotta start calling em urinalists now LMAO

[@Cheliz_Diaz]

Bugisoft just keeps lowering the bar as hard as they can.

[@alfmustdie28]

Dont compare shit vs a master piece like red dead redemption 2

[@blazeiii7388]

what happens when resuming the game, Outlaws :- why is my mc floating RDR2 :- Jojo pose

[@apexalaska]

God damn! That melee combat! Did she learn to fight at a windmill farm? Those are the widest, most open, most telegraphed haymakers I've ever seen!

[@brunonascimento3173]

One is a piece of art the other is pure Ubisoft garbage lol. 10:59 Ghost Rider ?

[@thedice5394]

Nah, she uses the force.

[@ИльяЮрьевич-е5п]

To be fair, comparing these two games is like figuring out who is stronger, Mike Tyson, or a 6-year-old child

[@bquick94]

Comparing an older Ubisoft game to ones now would be just as crazy, 2024 and they can’t even have simple bush physics. Far Cry 2 is still one of the best.

[@thegamingbat2104]

its a unfair comparison tbh comparing a 10 yr old star wars outlaws to now released rdr 2

[@BlackSmith6969]

Actually RDR2 is 6 years old compared to Star wars outlaw

[@thegamingbat2104]

@@BlackSmith6969 🤓

[@bullseye28]

@@BlackSmith6969nah outlaws is 10 years old 🗣️🗣️🗣️

[@SlyIdiot]

its a joke lol

[@Neuzuuu]

​@@BlackSmith6969 nuh uh

[@DonCritic]

One is a PlayStation 4 gen game, the other is a PlayStation 5 gen game 😳

[@davidjeffrey8164]

I’ve said for ages that I’d love to play a Star Wars universe game with RDR2 dynamics……That would be wonderful! Outlaws is a million miles from that!

[@6joe16ful]

10:06 the horse was like " you outta ya mind if you think im jumping off, boah...."

[@theLoveRocketjr]

When I saw that, I was like, not the horse!!! Then the horse stopped. 😮‍💨

[@ClémentMartin-l6v]

Makes it even more realistic, he’d rear back if you try to, remember ?

[@6joe16ful]

@@ClémentMartin-l6v yep, best game ever.

[@domingomartinez2479]

10:07 and don’t forget the fish

[@WoodbabyCYL]

@@domingomartinez2479omg this game is the best

[@NumeroCinko]

She hittin melee from 10 km away. Self proclaimed AAAA company 🎉🎉

[@bimmm36]

In shooting water remember that one is a blaster and one is a gun with bullets.

[@ARmy2510]

11:15 it's not a bug. She use the Force.

[@afstangaming9064]

red dead redemption 2 mentioned

[@hadensasser4937]

It’s like comparing a mound of shit to a smoked brisket.

[@thegreathuir]

Funny comparison, but fr

[@ChewieLewis]

I knew outlaws was gonna be bad but holy crap

[@Forum_Mongol_Indonesia]

No game can beat RDR2. Except for GTA VI soon 🤣

[@jackmills7758]

Nah gta6 wouldn’t be better than rdr2. Rdr games are far more immersive than gta games

[@lukemorris9066]

​@jackmills7758 graphics wise it will but ye you ain't f**king with red dead games

[@RomeoooGF]

​@@jackmills7758 Rockstar can focus on other aspects since the assets and coding have already been created in the previous game, heck even GTA 5 had GTA SA code in it.

[@JustRezky]

Gta 6 will definitely beat rdr2 in term of graphics and mechanic... I mean we talking about the newer game of course rockstar will raise the bar again

[@abisheknair2523]

​@@jackmills7758 GTA 6 will most certainly beat RDR2 in terms of graphics, world and detail. Story and character, that's a whole other thing

[@yusronnaim]

the little exciting tail wags at 3:03

[@PassanCat]

This vid is very dishonest. You can't compare a game that crafted with love and care by people who wanted to make a game for fans, with trash that was ordered by some random executives and created without anyone involving having a soul.

[@dayeeter7571]

“Star wars outlaws feels like red dead in space.”

[@Ronuk1996]

It's really silly to say that but this gaming journalists are fools. When you say something is like RDR2 that comes with a high expectation.

[@dayeeter7571]

@@Ronuk1996 When the journo said that I immediately called crap, I don't trust game journalists on a word that they say.

[@axt2]

@@Ronuk1996 It's like saying someone can sing like Adele. You make a bold claim like that you're going to be in a really bad spot if you cant back it up.

[@agony5344]

gaming journalists never touched a video game in their life

[@internetuser6602]

I thought the game was going to be RDR2 + StarCitizen

[@LURLINE_]

I'm not even a star wars fan but I'd be thoroughly impressed by a star wars game with the level of care and world building as rdr2, but star wars has always primarily been for selling toys

[@lilbench5834]

The best star wars game that came out is Lego Star wars

[@ErenSeflek]

It's literally a Ubisoft game, as always Ubisoft

[@yutro213]

Dan, you are Cruel, humiliating Star Wars Outlaws right off the beginning! 😂 Thanks a lot! 🙂

[@RoninSystems]

I judge every open world games against RDR2 when they come out. So far, they've all fallen short.

[@juiciestlemonadeofyoutube]

Half of me hopes GTA 6 is superior, half of me hopes it’s not for some reason

[@weed3728]

$80+ game and the character doesn’t even get wet when she’s in water this is crazy

[@LiverAndOnions69]

4:51 the slow motion, cinematography, sound design of parts of RDR2 are epic gaming history