What if Mace Windu Went to Utapau Instead of Obi-Wan in Revenge of the Sith? Star Wars Theory

in Star Wars Revenge of the Sith, what if Mace Windu went to Utapau? This would leave Obi-Wan Kenobi to fight Chancellor Palpatine with Kit Fisto, Saesee Tin and Agen Kolar. What would happen? Would Anakin Skywalker still turn? Or would the sight of his master dying be enough for his redemption?
Facebook Page - / starwarstheorytoos
Twitter - / toos_swtheory
What if Anakin WAS Granted the Rank of Master -
• What if Anakin WAS Gra...
Anakin's Thoughts While Being Burned on Mustafar and Turning Into Darth Vader -
• Anakin's Thoughts Whil...
8 Jedi Master Who Became Sith Lords -
• 8 Jedi Masters Who Bec...
How Did Anakin Kill All Jedi at the Temple During Order 66? Revenge of the Sith -Star Wars Explained
• How Did Anakin Kill Al...
What if Order 66 Failed? Star Wars Theory
• What if Order 66 Faile...
The Story and Reason Behind Darth Maul's Double Bladed Lightsaber
• The Story and Reason B...
Count Dooku's Reaction to Qui Gon Jinn's Death
• Count Dooku's Reaction...
What If Qui Gon Jinn Trained Anakin Skywalker?
• What If Qui Gon Jinn T...
What if Darth Maul Trained Anakin Skywalker? • What If Darth Maul Tra...
What if Padme Survived?
• What If Padme Survived...
What if Mace Windu Killed Darth Sidious?
• What if Mace Windu Kil...
Music - William Maytook

[@StarWarsTheory]

Hey everyone! Hope you enjoyed the video! What do you think about the outcome? Would Obi-Wan even survive that long against Palpatine? If you liked the vid, let me know and hit like :) I'll see you all in the comments below!! May the Force Be With You!

[@leviweber7724]

Star Wars Theory can u do a vid about them wanting for Yoda and all the other masters

[@TheRyuSword]

Star Wars Theory You mentioned another thing. That Obi-wan could have waited for Yoda and Mace to return instead of going into action. Can we see that one scenario as well?

[@realvenoom]

Star Wars Theory This is your BEST theory

[@AnakinXD-ug8nq]

Star Wars Theory I would prefer for this to happen

[@daiujin]

Star Wars Theory you have a loud ass intro dude

[@Gabsboy123]

"It's over Palpatine, I have the high ground" "I AM the high ground" "Don't try it" "It's treason, then"

[@bd_2213]

**gets burned**

[@ZACHM1LLS]

I am the Senate

[@alivevinnie2935]

wait a minute

[@machochocolate7679]

This is the best comment yet

[@ZACHM1LLS]

Mace - The senate will decide your fate. Palpatine -I am the senate. Mace - Dies.

[@qwertyMrJINX]

Actually, since the entrance to the Chancellor's office is higher up than the Chancellor's desk, Obi Wan would begin the fight with the high ground, and thus automatically wins.

[@FireHawkGaming]

"I have the high ground, Palpatine! It's over!" "Youuu underesti-mate my POWER!" "Don't try it" *Screams and rotates through the air* *Slice* Palpatine is now a turkey twizler on the floor.

[@jameswhite3415]

+qwertyMrJINX Exactly Obiwon can only lose if he is on even ground and even than it’s debatable since he may just transcend physical from by becoming the embodiment of the force.

[@davidfebreeze428]

qwertyMrJINX u r looking at a one legged no hands sidious basicly

[@damonlloyd6025]

qwertyMrJINX right !!

[@bigwsly]

No because palpatine is the senate

[@colonelkernel4808]

So my boy Kit Fisto still died...

[@wrickel0727]

Q wow.

[@acebalistic1358]

I’m sorry, it was prophisized he would die by being slowly stabbed while battling the Sith who was trained by The sith who found the secret to immortality from age, and then the chosen one would kill his killer Little did he know, the chosen one was REYLO What am I saying 😂😂😂

[@jdothuber]

F

[@countdoku1430]

Kit fisto always dies if there is an emporer scene

[@niko-800]

kit fisto’s smile is amazing he shouldn’t have died

[@solerelish]

I would have liked this ending more for some reason

[@Alex-vf7bf]

João Pedro Lopes that’s what I thought

[@jacoblubis520]

No vader? You like that?

[@michaelrobertson714]

Because they all live happily ever after?

[@Jonnyd05]

Still the future would have had another sith rise and they would fight another

[@catkook543]

You must like happyer story's then

[@fatjoseph15]

Did the death stick seller go home and rethink his life?

[@StarWarsTheory]

Find out next time...on SWT lol

[@whsiwkbahw1414]

Fat Joseph he did fact free made a video about it

[@just_jimmyyt5819]

Star Wars Theory do what life luke and leia died with padme

[@shockz9289]

Can you actually do that :DDDD id get so hyped.

[@frenchmasterrace574]

Star Wars Theory lol haha

[@frozen222]

I don't know man, I don't think Obi-wan would rush into the chamber like Mace Windu since he's not as hot headed or as arrogant in his abilities as Mace was. I believe he'd call Yoda and Mace to return to Coruscant and they would plan how to defeat Palpatine. Rushing in to attack this ultimate Sith Lord isn't becoming of Obi-wan.

[@georgewatkins7259]

Complete Facts.

[@xstrawberryicex6852]

frozen222 was mace really arrogant? He won the fight against Palpatine didn't he? Until anakin ruined it?

[@Finkaisar]

frozen222 you know me well

[@SorenDaein]

Calling a council session would be the most logical move for Obi-Wan. They'd however agree that it'd be best to deal with him during said session. Only question remaining was if they'd let Anakin come along or not.

[@KoyotBravo]

True as fuck

[@bernhardfrosdorfer9985]

I am convinced that Obi Wan would have taken Anakin with him...that would change everything.

[@eddie6198]

I think that's right, Obi Wan and Anakin were inseparable.

[@AqwDragulum]

Eddie 666 Exactly. Then the other Jedi masters wouldn’t have to die.

[@larrytinsley4247]

@@AqwDragulum all but kit fisto anakin and obi wan would

[@TbYolo]

Yeah sometimes Star Wars Theory sucks at story writing. I think Obi Wan would of taken Anakin with him

[@sawyercitlau4001]

I think he would have waited for mace and Yoda

[@salomondupper3343]

*HELLO THERE WOULDN’T EXIST*

[@Mrmonroemanmx]

Distinctio grievous said it to him in clone wars which took place before ROTS

[@sithacolol5337]

@@Mrmonroemanmx it's not the same as obi wan doing it, he is just legendary and unstoppable with the high ground

[@Mys10c]

He would’ve greeted Palpatine with it

[@vegetabluueevolution2807]

Its treason then

[@rjphilla]

Yes it would. It's the first line in the first Star Wars movie by Obi Wan. He says it to R2D2

[@13G3ND]

why obi wan is the best 1.Defeated Darth Maul and Anikan(Darth Vader) 2.Killed general Grievous 3.Had the high ground

[@pilkers2]

He only killed grievous because his organs were exposed and because grievous wasn’t actually trying to kill Obiwan he was just trying to Injure him and mock him and escape to mustafar

[@wolfthornnholtzklau4913]

@@pilkers2 no he bitch slapped Grievous. MORE IMPRESSIVELY THOUGH...he fought Jango Fett to a draw.

[@WJS774]

@@wolfthornnholtzklau4913 "Fought Jango Fett to a draw"? Hardly. Jango is good, but he's not on the same level as a Jedi. Obi-wan was soundly trouncing Jango until he made one mistake, allowing Jango to barely escape. Killing Grievous was far more impressive.

[@WalkerVin]

He trolled vader

[@claudioconforti5608]

4 *Hello there*

[@Jack-ck4vi]

Well Anakin could have just stabbed palpatine but ok

[@DanielG1095]

Commander Doom that’s not the Jedi w I mean the high ground way

[@Turtleterr0r01]

It adds homage to how he killed the emperor in the regular continuity.

[@marco002]

first I thought he will cut off his arms because he needed Sidious :O

[@andrewmac5494]

Crushes his pelvis with his super strong mechanical grip. Lmfaooo I had a fucked up imagination.

[@iamlegendATM]

i think he wouldve had to stab palpatine. palpatine was too powerful to be just picked up by anakin and carried all the way over and out the window. he hadnt aged and hadnt been scarred by his own lightning the way he in ROTJ

[@lou3712]

Anakin: You're the Sith Lord! Palpatine: No, I AM THE SENATE

[@sammy135_]

Unity Rise "You're the Sith Lord!" "I know you are but what am I?"

[@theunwantedworld1]

Darth Vader disguised as the Senate!

[@mattdoherty2859]

You knew this was coming. Palpatine: I AM JOHN CENA!!!

[@R3tr0v1ru5]

Not yet.

[@justice4alpacas918]

NO!!!! THIS IS PATRICK!!!!

[@CastorDeEuropa]

How it should’ve went *palpatine kills 3 Jedi masters with relative ease with no sign of Obi-Wan* *Obi-Wan comes bursting through the window in a shuttle, kamikazeing himself just after echoing a subtle “Hello there.”*

[@carrrmickey3279]

Under rated af

[@Anight94]

Another happy landing

[@teddy1022]

LUMBAGO

[@PacisJusticia]

so uncivilized.

[@roaringthunder115]

Yes

[@hayes5595]

What if Anakin went to a psychiatrist?

[@whsiwkbahw1414]

Hayes _ lol

[@jefferfransisco6537]

Hayes _ lol

[@Toxik431]

Hayes _ he would probably be sent to an asylum and then palpatine would kill all the Jedi with the help of the clones due to order 66 then free Anakin from the asylum to turn him to the dark side

[@reichtangle5545]

There is be a star wars Harley Quinn

[@Toxik431]

Zaxio 005 I think so and would have manipulated anakin into thinking that the Jedi had him put in there

[@SirSmilingPhantom]

Got chills when I realised Anakin would kill Palpatine in a similar fashion to his killing of the Emperor in ROTJ. Brilliant. Cyclical. Star Wars.

[@mikebennett2511]

it rhymes...

[@hithere7626]

SirSmilingPhantom uh, what?

[@mercenarygundam1487]

Full circle.

[@randumpotato]

Same here! The music helped a lot!

[@stealthynaxo]

HOLD ON! HOLD ON! - - - -- - - - - - - - Are you suggesting that the circle is now complete and now he is the master?

[@zeropelli7026]

palpatine *being a sith lord* Anakin: I'M TELLING!

[@nursmalik6024]

I'M TELLING MY MOOM

[@acebalistic1358]

Nurs Malik but he told his uncle •_•

[@gangsterringostarr2840]

Tyler McDaniel I’M TELLING MY JEDI MASTER!

[@nursmalik6024]

I'M TELLING THE CHANCELLO- wait

[@nursmalik6024]

I'M TELLING *YOUR* MASTER

[@tiget601]

until someone *accidentaly* says "execute order 66"

[@calebbunting5167]

LMMFFAOOOOO

[@kaizoisevil]

@Martin Happel So Mas Amedda would give the order, right? Or would a new election happen?

[@lostaf2985]

kaizoisevil new election. Mas Amedda would be Charged with high Treason I guess.

[@LeCryx]

Cashier at a place called politics diner: hello! Can I take your order? Obi-wan and Anakin with Cody and rex Obi-wan:hello there! Nothing for me I'm not brave enough for politics. Anakin:can I have an order 66 please? Also give me something for the younglings too. Cashier:ok let me just execute order 66 into our system. Rex and cody:it will be done my Lord. Obi-wan and Anakin:I've got a bad feeling about this.

[@randy3252]

Master window

[@generalgrievous6363]

Mace didn't kill me in this We sat down, drank some Galactic Imported Tea And talked about surrender. Im actually still sitting in the brig of his star destroyer as a I type and comment this.

[@ZerloxGaming]

I dare you..I DOUBLE DARE YOU

[@YohanBlake-hy7gb]

General Grievous 😂 😂

[@gachaelephant6841]

I really want to like this comment but it’s got 66 likes

[@YohanBlake-hy7gb]

@@gachaelephant6841 you can now i disliked it

[@gachaelephant6841]

AmuckAaron thank you for your sacrifice

[@danielinskip8427]

obi wan would have brought anakin with him, he trusted him and would probably want his help

[@miomoses3725]

Brothers!! as obi-wan often called him!

[@benjamindeh873]

Yeah, I dont think obi wan would have left anakin behind. Windu did it because he did not trust anakin.

[@jimmnasium]

he really was unsure about anakin because he could sense his conflict

[@frankdees507]

Harambe Yep. Though none of the Jedi order knew anything of Anakins wife or the circumstances of him killing Dooku or anything, Windu sensed Anakins conflict, as well as Palpatines influence on Anakin. He was the first Jedi to conclude, "the darkside of the force surrounds the Chancellor".

[@leonardkettula9491]

I think he would've waited for Yoda and Mace

[@idgafabtdis]

And then Palpatine comes back and gets killed by some girl who deflects lighting back at him

[@ch0getsu]

Yes because the force is female

[@darkdialga777]

@@ch0getsu not that it helped all those female jedi.

[@ho-wm7jy]

that was the most bullshit scene in the whole star wars series.

[@oneautisticguy]

@@ho-wm7jy the sequels are bullshit

[@CulturalMarxist4985]

Rey was empowered by all of the Jedi at the time.

[@AliHussain-18]

So, Anakin fulfilled his responsibility as the chosen one.

[@IVoeh]

He is still the chosen one, he kills the emperor and himself killing the sith.

[@AliHussain-18]

@@IVoeh Yeah but I wasnt alive soooo yeah

[@ginko8725]

Anakin: umm mister sir did i do good?

[@crunchy-leaf21]

How is it with all the other force ghosts qui gon?

[@AliHussain-18]

@@crunchy-leaf21 Once past the netherworld of the force. It is a new life. Becoming more powerful than you could ever imagine

[@QianBing]

1:05 that glorious editing

[@DangerZone200]

haha it has its charm i suppose XD

[@Nice_Guy3012]

Ryan Liu I know right?

[@jjmm4965]

I thot he pasted obis face over obi wans body lol

[@Youngling_Boi_66]

A suprise to be sure but a welcome one

[@brucexu313]

probably imovie lol

[@Bowfella]

Why would he grab him??? The only reason he did that in ROTJ is because he lost his hand and lightsaber. I still feel he would rather use his weapon at hand.

[@vaporeizied8]

mihajlo525 because palpatine was still trying to turn anakin. If he rushed him with a saber, they both die. Vader could have force pulled Luke’s saber but same thing would have happened

[@Cory9sm]

Oh trust me slicing someone in half is not as stress relieving in that situation as crushing someones pelvis

[@callum493]

@@vaporeizied8 well no because he even said Palpatine was too caught up in the killing you could've of just sliced his head off plane and simple

[@dodoarks3186]

@@callum493 it would lead him into the dark side

[@williamwest9204]

Coulda done what he did to dooku.

[@DeadlyAssassin-fr6ti]

“Obi wan brought the strongest masters kit fisto,Agen kolar and Saesee tiin” Shaak Ti:

[@peculiarpangolin4638]

Well, that way, one of my favorite Jedi still lives.

[@jimjames4875]

He said masters left. Shaak Ti was on Felucia.

[@peculiarpangolin4638]

@@jimjames4875 You mean Aayla Secura, the Twi'lek. Shaak Ti is a Togruta, like Ahsoka.

[@bigdawg8676]

Didn't Grievous killed Shaak Ti at the beginning of episode 3. Thought I saw that somewhere.

[@peculiarpangolin4638]

@@bigdawg8676 It was a deleted scene, so non-canon.

[@xpickpoke2266]

Never heard of this Lego Star Wars Episode III Secret Chapter

[@andy5959]

Would have anikan still joined the sith if he didn't hate sand?

[@deathunicorn8279]

Andrew Gibbons nice

[@ozzy7102]

No.

[@Pandemonium631]

Andrew Gibbons lol

[@KenshiImmortalWolf]

i mean don't most people even the most patient jedi hate sand? it's rough, and course, and it gets everywhere.

[@darthrevanii5424]

Just like all of those parts of your suit, Isin't it ? Lord Vader ?

[@hansolo1983]

What if Ashoka and Obi-wan Kenobi went to mustafar to bring Anakin back to the light side?

[@hansolo1983]

Maybe even Rex?

[@majesthijmenii1976]

Peace Seeker well that doesnt change anything now does it

[@457falcon]

It's an interesting thought but this wasn't too long after ahsoka left the order so she was likely still finding herself and wouldn't be reachable by obi wan

[@majesthijmenii1976]

But if you could just imagine that Obi wan DID reach her. I think it would change a lot

[@457falcon]

Thijmen Vervaet Potentially yes, but it's important to remember that Vader has always been kind of iffy with his stance on the dark side after all had he truly been loyal to the site order, despite the rule of two he would have killed Luke on bespin. There's also that time not too long after ahsoka fought Vader and even looked into his eyes and tried to bring him back and failed. She was his apprentice but past that friendly relationship if obi wan hadn't been able to bring anakin back from the fall I doubt ahsoka would've been much help. There was also when anakin fell to the son then had his memory wiped

[@PromezaProductions]

What if 5's revealed order 66

[@majesthijmenii1976]

Raul Meza good one

[@SorenDaein]

Wait a minute. Fives knew about Order 66?

[@457falcon]

Not the order itself but he stumbled onto the delivery system for order 66, shaak ti was close to figuring it out during the fives arc until palpatine set him up on coruscant and got him executed.

[@aviantheassassin9103]

Soren Daein he knew something was up. But he didn't know what exactly was going on

[@SorenDaein]

And had he been just a little quicker, that knowledge would have been attained by the Jedi. That in turn would prompt them to remove the inhibitor chips. Rex was able to remove his. Without the inhibitor chips to control them, the clones would have the option to refuse to carry out Order 66. Completely botching Palpatine's attempt to destroy the Jedi.

[@ThatGuy-bt7sw]

So Anakin’s lightsaber was just non existent when he chose to attack Palpatine

[@helmetguy6495]

He was probably so pissed he didnt want to give the Emperor a quick death and instead he wanted him to feel pain.

[@tylerjones7592]

He killed Sidious the same way he did in Return of the Jedi

[@GeraltofRivia22]

It doesn't make sense but I understand why he wrote it that way. It's the same way Anakin killed Palpatine in the Return of the Jedi.

[@creeperYT9824]

@@helmetguy6495 and tapped into the dark side for a sec

[@rishabhperi8174]

not sure but ig he didnt want his lightsaber to bleed

[@jamesdonkey7110]

What if Mace Windu allowed Anakin to come with him to face Palpatine?

[@danmarusan2878]

I think one of this scenarios would happen: 1. Anakin would betray Mace Windu and stab him in the back when Palpatine is cornered and disarmed. That's why he wanted Anakin to stay in the temple. 2. Palpatine would say the same he said when Anakin arrived in the office, try to manipulate him with lies of jedi treachery and when the other jedi try to shut him up, he would kill Tiin, Colar and Fisto. Then he would still try to convince Anakin to do the "right" thing and stop Mace Windu. But since I don't think that Anakin could beat Mace, Palpatine would try to use his force to use something like battle meditation to strengthen Anakin's powers in the force. Whitch results in Mace's death. 3. Anakin would switch sides when Mace and the other jedi activate their lightsabers and maybe killing at least one or two of the jedi masters himself. Mace Windu would be the last jedi standing and had to fight Sidious and Anakin. The outcome is pretty obvious.

[@jamesdonkey7110]

I can't imagine 3 happening, even at the end of the rots scene anakin is conflicted and only betrays mace at the end when he has to choose between the jedi order and padme. I think something like 2 would happen, but because it happens over a longer period than in the movie I imagine Mace would have had a longer time to think about what was happening. I don't think Anakin would have directly fought Mace unless Mace threatened Palpatine's life, he might just stand off from the fight confused. In the rots novelisation, it's stated that Mace didn't think to look for Anakin's shatterpoint. If Anakin had been with him from the start he may well have considered this, how this would have changed the final outcome is difficult to say.

[@coops3600]

What shadowstarthe1st said. If anakin was there for the whole fight, he likely never would have turned to palpatine's side.

[@jeffreyjeffrey2263]

Danmaru San well what is the outcome

[@NiightDJ]

Danmaru San Mace Windu could beat palptine and anakin at the same time?? Confused

[@christianbustnes698]

What if anakin died in the pod race?

[@Shushshoes]

Christian Bustnes yes good idea

[@mrgaudy1954]

Christian Bustnes I'll try dying, that's a good trick!

[@Eeeemomo]

Christian Bustnes yes

[@macaronisalad3038]

THEN THE WHOLE STAR WARS UNIVERSE WOULD IMPLODE KILLING EVERYTHING

[@benjamindeh873]

Lollll someone needs to make that a video X)

[@HippytheKid419]

I wanna see what if count dooku never left the Jedi

[@Shushshoes]

Rekxxsource393 Yes!!!

[@bigdaddyboomerfishing4199]

Rekxxsource393 Vlogs that's a good one!

[@willfoulkes7044]

yess!!! Great suggestion!

[@ltb1345]

If count Dooku trained Anakin.....?🤔

[@yomurr]

"This would change the whole timeline" OF COURSE IT WOULD HELLO THERE WOULDN'T BE A THING

[@AshokKumar-wc1sz]

He would go chancellor room and say hello there To which Palpatine will reply general kenobi what brings you here At the name of galactic senate you are under arrest You are a bold one master kenobi but you forgot that I am the senate No, not yet It's treason then See all dialogs included

[@Copernicus91]

He’d def take Anakin!

[@TheOtherNeutrino]

Kenobi: Hello there. Palpatine: Master Kenobi. You are a bold one.

[@echo4428]

What if the clone army split after being given order 66 half on the Jedi side the other half with palpatine

[@denverbax6329]

That would be pretty epic, to see all the clones confused and fighting each other, the Cis would most likely take advantage of this and gain control of the outer rim.

[@denverbax6329]

You're right I forgot, but if Anakin didn't fall to the darkside or grievous/dooku weren't killed the CIS would gain power after a partially failed order 66

[@echo4428]

Denver Bax yes but my theory doesnt state those things it just says the clones split up

[@457falcon]

It's an interesting question but the republic was losing the clone wars and it's pretty likely that if order 66 failed dooku would instead choose to betray sidious and launch a total war on what remained of the republic until his armies eventually overtook the grand army and the remaining jedi

[@echo4428]

but dooku was dead at the time of order 66 and the republic was winning the war during revenge of the sith

[@realvenoom]

What if Palpatine never become the chancellor in The Phantom Menace

[@realvenoom]

What happened Qui-Gon's lightsaber after his death

[@harrisonwoolf6883]

Halorider 003also TM obi wan kept qui gons light saber, and Luke used qui gons kyber Krystal for his green light saber

[@7coloredalice]

I think there was a "what if" that resulted in Palpatine having more of a warrior-type mindset instead of a schemer.

[@nerdy-weirdo3459]

man I would love to see if kylo Ren never killed Han Solo

[@tomrosas3854]

STAR RANGER we could see a much accurate scenario of that after the last Jedi. Great idea though

[@nerdy-weirdo3459]

Tom Rosas thanks😁😁😁

[@sammy135_]

Star Wars Theory Make it so.

[@harrisonwoolf6883]

STAR RANGER the only reason he died was because Harrison Ford didn't want to be in the star wars franchise anymore, also in episode 6 he wanted to sacrifice himself to save his friends but George Lucas refused

[@Power51423]

star ranger it is very unlikely that we will get it before ep 8 and 9 come out

[@sams.8514]

At The End Anakin: Gets all his problem fixed and a perfect life Obi-Wan: +10 Respect

[@arealgamer342]

*MISSION PASSED* RESPECT++

[@Adam-yumyum]

Could you do what if palpatine didn't become Chancellor

[@Adam-yumyum]

Global Owl 😀😀

[@macewindu1828]

FlamingBird257 yes do this

[@fadedadvice4363]

Plz do this

[@ericmiller6607]

FlamingBird257 no whatbif bail organa or padme were chancelor

[@JohnPeacekeeper]

FlamingBird257 Basically what if Jar Jar didn't royally screw up?

[@GiaDante18]

When I heard "CRUSHING HIS PELVIS WITH ALL HIS MIGHT" I lost it😂😂

[@1rishpotat0]

What is a "pelvis"?

[@kodys1492]

@Thomas Madore It is your hips

[@rigatonipasta]

Kody Soaladaob If his pelvis got crushed... no Rey?

[@conorvfx1814]

Kinky

[@AndrewMRoots]

@@rigatonipasta Good

[@FatWhataburgerGuy]

"In the name of the Galactic Senate, General Grievous, you are under arrest." "General Windu, you are a bold one."

[@Remix-pr4xd]

“The Senate will decide you’re fate.” “Senate or not you must realize you are doomed.” “Not yet.”

[@johnregan2238]

@remix123 .1 its treason then

[@tylerw6053]

what if count dooku was a double agent! this one got over 200 likes on past videos!

[@emperorvalkorion6524]

Great idea.

[@jojo123853]

And dooku went with mace to confront sudious lol

[@Crasky1992]

Without his head?

[@villekuronen6242]

what if c3po and r2d2 controls everything and palpatine is their apprentice

[@Voynick]

1:13 I just realized how well Battlefront 2 shows this, by giving Obi-Wan a lot of stamina to block for a long time, lol

[@thiccchungo1041]

Yeah, because of the nature of Soresu it makes a lot of sense and is much more realistic that Obi-Wan wastes less stamina when defending

[@josephollek4977]

So badddddddddddddddd

[@josephollek4977]

Stop get ofe now!!!!

[@spongeboimebobbb]

@@josephollek4977 sir did you have an aneurism

[@liamgorman9319]

Do what if Anakin was the one who met the man with the deathsticks

[@Shushshoes]

Liam Gorman lol

[@bigdaddyboomerfishing4199]

Liam Gorman lol

[@indecisive0249]

I would like star wars to release a "What if" series so we can see all the ending you speak of produced by the makers themselves :D

[@willboon3243]

What if instead of getting captured by sideous ,Darth Maul killed him just after killing savage Opress?

[@EziooAuditore]

Will Boon that wouldn't happen lol. It's like saying what if Jar Jar killed Obi-Wan. I could never happen.

[@willboon3243]

Okan Draman fair point, but still it would still be a cool theory

[@mikleangelo9733]

You never know what if the dark side flowed through Maul to such an intense amount that he used a force choke to break his neck? With star wars you never know

[@bigdaddyboomerfishing4199]

Will Boon he would of just killed all of the other Chancellor's until he was

[@kirby5329]

Okan Draman true but it's still interesting to think about if you believe in the parallel universe theory

[@JackofallWades]

I always wanted a "What if Yoda went with Obi-Wan to face Anakin on Mustafar."

[@eddie6198]

Then there never would have been a Darth Vader. Yoda would have been able to leave out emotion, and would have executed Anakin. No doubt in my mind that's how it would have went down. However with Palpatine not preoccupied with fighting Yoda he may have gone to Mustafar sooner, and stopped the execution. Fun stuff to think on.

[@okthen1296]

@@eddie6198 Which means we could have ended up with an Anakin and Sidious vs Obi and Yoda situation. I personally think it wouldve ended with Yoda getting the upper hand on Sidious, while Anakin kills Obi due to Obi not ending up in an advantageous position from the changed circumstances. Then Anakin blindsides Yoda just before he can finish off Sidious, force pushing him into the lava. I also think upon finding out Sidious didnt really know how Plagueis' secrets, he'd have no further use for him and would kill him to rule the galaxy himself. Without losing his limbs he'd be the most powerful force user to ever exist, and unlock all the secrets of the force, and shape the galaxy as he pleased.

[@lukasgaming8141]

There is one

[@grimsside7796]

I'm certain Yoda would have been able to help clear Anakin's mind and bring him out of his darkness even knowing full well what Anakin had done. Why? Because he would've taken responsibility... Yoda knew he failed Anakin and more than that he knew the Jedi had failed In all aspects. Yoda would have forgiven Anakin, and he would have realized the Jedi needed to rebuild and rethink the way they went about things. Much like with Dooku's criticism of the Jedi not being able to trust the council with their own truths. I'm sure this stuck with Yoda and surely he would've been a force for the redemption of Anakin, rather than his destruction unlike Obi-Wan. Everyone Anakin had ever cared about had failed him and Obi-Wan the most so. Nobody ever really looked to Anakin and how he felt. Nobody tried to ease his burden and so he felt responsible for everyone and yet isolated and alone. The greatest tragedy of Star Wars has always been how easily things could have been different, if not for everyone being so blinded.

[@Pigeon249]

Yoda Fucking Kills Him

[@CheddarMannn]

1:01 They should hire you to Lucasfilm, amazing edit

[@Youngling_Boi_66]

lol

[@Do-Dill-Berrys]

@@Youngling_Boi_66 watch out for Anakin

[@catkook543]

Well, to be fair He'd have access to alot more resorces, and wouldn't be working alone As well as animators and/or actors that would be used to create brand new shots to work with

[@catkook543]

@Zachary Goldberger well, thats not very nice Bit rude actually

[@catkook543]

@Zachary Goldberger maybe

[@Flumy]

He said hello there when he showed up at palpatine’s office

[@olivermyrvangaamb719]

What if obi wan loved padme

[@olivermyrvangaamb719]

***** yeeeee

[@Toxik431]

Katte GudenYT Anakin would kill him without a second thought

[@olivermyrvangaamb719]

***** could still work doe

[@jedione8767]

Katte GudenYT obi wan was like 10 years older than her that would be creepy

[@olivermyrvangaamb719]

Alexandra Yang lol ikr

[@Jojaderr]

Something I don't understand is the ending, I believe Anakin would just thrust his lightsaber into Palpatine

[@Turtleterr0r01]

Yes that would be a logical thing to do, could be said about the outcome for Return of the Jedi, but this way paid homage to what happened in the original continuity.

[@RockFan98]

The activation of his lightsaber could have caught palpatines attention

[@Turtleterr0r01]

Tom he could’ve just put the hilt against Palpatine’s back and then activate it. Quick and simple. Could’ve done the same in ROTJ, but the sacrifice he made was one of, if not THE, greatest moments in cinema history.

[@rowie8503]

Cody in ROTJ Vader didn’t have his lightsaber because it was in the hand Luke cut off.

[@girl-xk2db]

That sounds so weird

[@yingames3280]

Palpatine just got lucky that obi wan didn’t use the high ground

[@therltayab]

the high ground vs the senate!

[@luccirobbins6675]

I have to say, the end to this theory brought a smile to my face...the idea of Anakin able to have everything he needs and NOT turn to the Dark Side...just beautiful.

[@spanish2927]

"crushing his pelvis" *kinky*

[@ponk7147]

The Spanish Inquisition nice

[@MegaMerlin5]

I'm sorry my lord we did not expect you

[@immapenny2355]

That was quite unexpected

[@and7thecandyman859]

Oh shut up 😂

[@HenryRayqu]

What if Qui-Gon Saved Anakin and his Mother from Slavery?

[@1234mwmmwmtrainer]

1909henry ? Wow, that would change the story so much!

[@ericmiller6607]

1909henry ? it eould be the same as the vid h3 made what if anikan saved his mother

[@SorenDaein]

That would have DEFINITELY changed the story a great deal. Had Qui-Gon been able to free both Anakin and Shmi from slavery during his time on Tatooine, the nightmares Anakin had suffered pertaining to his mother's death would not have happened. Many events would indeed play out like it did in the "What if Anakin saved his mother" but he'd go to Qui-Gon about the nightmares he had about Padme. Qui-gon would tell Anakin exactly what he needs to hear. To trust in The Force and to always be mindful. The Sith deemed any offspring Anakin would have to be a threat. Therefore, it'd be necessary to manipulate his nightmares to ultimately drive Anakin to the Dark Side.

[@darthvader5876]

what if Watto was mind tricked into accepting republic credits for the hyper drive therfore not allowing qui gon to discover anakins force sensitivity??

[@dancingintherain111]

I think Qui-Gonn would sense Anakin's strength with the force nonetheless, although it is interesting to think about.

[@iain3713]

Mr Dunn toydarians can't be mind tricked

[@orckiller91]

Plot twist, Plagueis is no longer canon

[@singlepringlereadytomingle8837]

Hisjsshd he said WHAT IF

[@anthonybernardo696]

Not anymore. Not canon.

[@sizorlolz]

I’m convinced that kit fisto would have survived due to kit fisto wanting Obi-wan to be there as he stated in the comics ( I believe )

[@tazmanian5802]

I think so to , plus that combo is knarly

[@gustavramirez2891]

Please do what if Anakin went to Utapau

[@Shushshoes]

Gustav Ramirez yes good idea!!!!

[@JohnPeacekeeper]

Gustav Ramirez OMG yes. Force Crush the heck out of Grievous

[@thedoctorfez1865]

What if Mace Windu warned Yoda about Palpatine being the Sith Lord?

[@tylerkrumsee8504]

Idk why he wouldnt.

[@jme6036]

Oh yeah...

[@tyson5794]

Yoda and windu vs palpatine

[@ReignofIndepence]

Do what if Rey sold BB8 to the portion lord!

[@maxnewcomb7245]

Ryan Campbell ONE QUARTER PORTION

[@Evzone1821]

Ryan Campbell I wonder what's the smallest portion. ONE QUARTER OF A QUARTER PORTION.

[@mber3872]

"anakin would be awoken to see Padme and younglings" i cried :(

[@stephaniekay8444]

do what if Darth Plagueis felt Palpatine's betrayal after Phantom Menace, and killed palpatine

[@hithere7626]

Stephanie Kay interesting

[@sunnex474]

Stephanie Kay didn’t plagueis already know that palpating would kill him

[@sunnex474]

Also we not know who snoke is yet

[@Jan7412]

swift well snoke is dead

[@larrytinsley4247]

plaguis sied long before phantom menace i thought

[@BarberShave19]

What if Luke and Leia died with Padme?

[@gabez8]

kenobi and yoda would have to 2nd think about their exiles in order to save the jedi or thus searching the galaxy for any surviving jedi to confront palpatine and vader. the rest i can't say what would happen.

[@singlepringlereadytomingle8837]

ThePizzadude93 the original trilogy wouldnt exist?

[@darthfirenation7107]

Directed by George Lucas

[@thedoctorfez1865]

OH S**T

[@odd6294]

*End credits start playing with music

[@spencercollins200]

hello! can you please do what if Luke was captured and frozen in carbonite when he was fighting Darth Vader?

[@theevildrummingsithlord1492]

Luke fell into the carbon freezer unit and never escapes. Vader would be laughing so hard his respirator would shatter.

[@crimson5pider]

Basically return of the Jedi's ending sooner, I like it

[@kjellivarkjelsnes5605]

WHY does palpatine always die by falling?

[@ashtraydelicacy5773]

"And again, it's like poetry, it's sort of, they rhyme. Every stanza kind of rhymes with the last one. Hopefully it'll work." - George Lucas

[@ThePhunkyPharaoh]

What if Darth Maul liked Nintendo more than Sega?

[@ThePhunkyPharaoh]

Fun Fact: The only reason Darth Maul was "killed off" in the prequels is because the actor that played him told George Lucas during filming that he liked Sega better than Nintendo. Darth Maul was later brought back in Star Wars Rebels because the producer of that show is an avid Sega fan. True Story.

[@cgroot6504]

👍👑 I think Obi wan would have won. He got lucky against maul, he got lucky fighting Anakin. Let it ride! I am groot

[@CojaGamez]

Obi wan has skill

[@massacrepromotionsofficial4302]

no chance ahah

[@funkyninja9293]

I agree!!! Obi wan would win!

[@nissy9220]

It was luck and situation with both anakin and maul. They both had obiwan beaten until the right circumstance suddenly arrived. Nothing taken away from him though, he's no slouch.

[@youtube_user2379]

I aint going to lie they never had obi-wan beaten he was always ahead to be honest.

[@spaceshef4542]

This would of been the story if George hadn’t of started the movies in the middle of the whole saga I feel

[@S3rp3nte]

What if the Yuuzhan Vong invasion happen during the Clone Wars?

[@rafaelcanovas3921]

S3rp3nte Yes pls

[@S3rp3nte]

Kill them easily? Personally i doubt that they would win that easily.

[@S3rp3nte]

I'm not an expert of the UE of SW. But for what i had understand by see the opinions of many SW forums, it seen that the Yuuzhan Vong would still lose the war, but not without do heavy causalities to the galaxy. But again, i'm not an expert, i just want to see the end result of the what if.

[@godsgiantsuperdick9302]

S3rp3nte Grievous would be public enemy number one to the Vong.

[@RuBy-hh6dz]

Let's see, the Vong where beaten by a crippled Jedi Order and Republic. A full power Jedi Order, Sidious and the CIS/Clone Army would simply stomp the hell out of the Vong.

[@Qwerds7]

While I agree that sidious would destroy Kenobi in a fight. It wouldn't be through saber skills. Kenobi was able to fend off 18 random strikes a second from Greivous. Palpatine is fast but not that fast.

[@thatoscarguy9965]

Well Count Dooku had no trouble against Obi Wan and we all know Sidious is certainly above Dooku. Being a master of all 7 forms Sidious would probably also choose to use form 2 which is the counter to form 3.

[@jasonskeans3327]

@@thatoscarguy9965 dooku used form 2 witch counters obis for 3

[@thatoscarguy9965]

@@jasonskeans3327 that’s why I said Sidious would most likely also use form 2 to win just like Dooku did.

[@izen7170]

@@thatoscarguy9965 dooku defeated obiwan with the force in ep3, in ep2 obiwan wasnt as experienced in form 3 as he was in ep3, dooku knew he cant beat obiwan and anakin with lightsaber in ep3

[@Ice-wu8qq]

You know whats weird? Snoke is not here. Maul is not here! YAAAY!

[@ethanpfeiffer7403]

IceGhostKnight That's what I was thinking

[@velocity_2314]

Notice the fact that he didn’t include anything about mace windu’s fight with grevious

[@thiccchungo1041]

In the 2003 clone war series he literally crushes the collector’s chest instantly removing his ability to fight, Grievous doesn’t stand a chance against Windu using the force

[@trunkydunk2162]

Logic Velocity we all know the ending

[@bostboi4766]

“And a bunch of younglings” of course lol

[@ThePhunkyPharaoh]

What if Obi Wan couldn't believe it was not butter?

[@ThePhunkyPharaoh]

"These are not the carbs you're looking for"

[@CaptainRex-vd6zo]

what if the jedi executed order 65

[@alexlarson8085]

Yes sir

[@RealFabbrik]

What about order 69 😂

[@rippetoe38]

Palpatine still would've won. He would've sensed the betrayal in the clones and shocked them to death.

[@melonlord7443]

order 69

[@GodlygalliganDeadInTheBrain]

@@RealFabbrik rape all jedi order 69

[@klein2042]

I personally think Obi Wan would've wanted Anakin at his side going against Palpatine

[@monsieurorleans1329]

The emperor looked rather chill about falling to his death

[@popawebmeister2966]

Well according to the novel from the movie, Obi Wan is the most balanced fighter in the whole Jedi Order, Yoda having to adopt an acrobatic style to compensate for his height and Windu having to resort to Vaapad to turn his inner darkness into a weapon of light. I honestly think Obi Wan could have taken Palpatine.

[@blandon93]

no chance dude. you saw how easily Dooku overpowered Obi Wan in every fight, right? Sidious is on another level. for sure Kenobi wouldn't get sliced in one second, Sidious tried so hard to turn Anakin, he would need conflicted Anakin, something among the lines "I save Padme if you kill Obi Wan, or I kill both of you".

[@ronniescerri4111]

6:45 actually mace windu chose to rank him to jedi knight 9.99

[@justinlewis8638]

Anakin: has perfectly good lightsaber. Also Anakin: I’m gonna throw this guy out the window. I feel that it will be cathartic to someone for some reason.

[@mysticcrazy3]

Tbh, I think Obi Wan would wait for the other Jedi Masters like Yoda and Mace Windu.

[@SorenDaein]

That indeed sounds like Obi-Wan. But there was still the risk that Palpatine would performing a preemptive strike.

[@mysticcrazy3]

Soren Daein I don't think so truthfully. Anakin at this point was still very conflicted. While yes, Palpatine may have tried to turn Anakin over, and start an early strike, we have to remember Palpatine is very smart. There is still a good chance that it wouldn't work seeing as how Anakin still has the light in him, and the plan could go AWOL really fast.

[@albedo5455]

What if Count Dooku never left the Jedi Order?

[@woodsman9427]

I think he did that one already im not sure tho

[@officerspooder]

1:02 bruhhh I'm fucking done

[@ussmissouri38]

2:22

[@mike104740]

Spooder Man 5:47

[@razorzcoinboi1320]

Spooder Man Q sucks shit

[@brnerikhaukens6597]

mike104740 3:05 😂

[@EugeneOneguine]

Star Wars III : The Revenge of the Sith, edition remastered for a KKK audience.

[@goldbrickstudios6903]

Star Wars Theory, can you please do a story on: What if The Padawan That Saved Organa at The Jedi Temple Lived? That would be cool if you added some alternate story to that, where he teams up with all the other surviving jedi and take back the temple.

[@tylermansell3079]

What if anikan betrayed Palpatine at the temple during order 66

[@frankiebigrings7048]

Good idea

[@rolandarriaga1295]

It would probably be before he killed the younglings seeing himself in them

[@TbYolo]

*Anakin dumbass

[@Ravenclaw022]

Order 65 😌😌

[@vexivero]

3:07 Troll level: Palpatine

[@noahroangoldwing]

I love these “Anakin stays on the Light Side” stories

[@LeFisheboi]

Prequel theory: exist Star Wars theory: Another happy birth

[@ErikMello96]

This would have been such a good ending

[@michaelslegofilms4984]

Do a video on why Obi Wan didn't remember R2D2 and C3PO in A New Hope

[@Nico-xz2ci]

Those were not the droids he was looking for

[@quillproductions377]

Obi Wan definitely would’ve brought Anakin with him. He loved him and trusted him completely. Mace Windu only told Anakin to stay because he didn’t trust him

[@Lerna_Arier]

What if Anakin was taught to heal, taught to analyse visions and received some medical statistics that death in labor was a nearly impossible thing with good medical technologies. He had a chance to understand that the situation wasn't as it was like.

[@jon021ful]

What if Mace killed Dooku on Geanouies in the video you made called how Mace regretted killing Jango Fett please. It would be really cool

[@simplysteve68]

Tom Rhys Jones Geonosis

[@petergriffin457]

Obi Wan would’ve climbed on the desk and tell Palpatine that he had the high ground.

[@straesarchive8204]

This comment is so underrated holy shit

[@kalu1190]

I would definitely watch a movie with this storyline! Great job bro!

[@ZayecValentine]

That would be the most beautiful happy ending In Star Wars history. I actually wished this happened.

[@9Steff99]

why wouldn't anakin just cut palpatine's hands off?

[@rudolf-b3-josefsonbede412]

Because George Lucas has no more space in his basement for more limbs

[@xanderfernald3405]

See now that's a much better end to the 3rd movie! Problem is, now there's no episode 4, 5, or 6, but had Star Wars just been a trilogy that would've been the perfect ending to episode 3

[@bigal9379]

Then we wouldn’t have the hello there line from obi

[@pocketmarcy6990]

Windu, jumps down, “Well Hello there motherfucker”

[@thecreatorlair]

This is probably the most satisfying "What If" you've ever made. Thanks for a great story.