No betrayal by Gulnihal -what was she supposed to do, say no to the emperor?!
@Redluna322 ай бұрын
It's one of those moments where maybe she could've come up with an excuse of some kind or some other way to refuse him, but it's not as if she had any way of knowing that it'd work. And, honestly, she was absolutely being manipulated behind the scenes without even fully realizing it.
@organiccreme2 ай бұрын
Or she could’ve told Hurrem herself and Hurrem would’ve prevented it. She decided to keep it a secret from her friend. Thats the betrayal. We all understand noone can say no to the sultan but there are other ways of saying No to him without actually saying no. Gulnihal wants to be a sultana just like Hurrem and Hurrem should understand not everyone is meant to serve or want to be a slave. She could’ve been nicer and understood Gulnihal’s point of view. In the end. Gulnihal was wrong for her decision. 🤷🏽♀️
@gl12032 ай бұрын
She should pretend that she doesn't feel well or she pretends that faint.
@ΔημΣΚ2 ай бұрын
No, she should have informed Hürrem sultan that's all and then the two can think what to do
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
Is betrayal cause it was all a plan you wouldn’t know that or realize that because you don’t know the show well and believe anything and don’t even bother to look into the real life version. So don’t talk like you know or blame hurrem for the way she acted cus despite in the end of her doing what the majesty wanted too but he was in the plan as well to get him away from hurrem any woman gonna be like that and your goons see it in any show
@Leah-izSic2 ай бұрын
I will never understand why we as women blame the other woman and not the man. The only way id blame her is if she knew about me. She was chosen for the sultan she had no choice but to go. I dont know what id do but i like to think id run to my friend and tell her before it happened so it wouldnt shes step in and say nope not my girl shes loyal to me first.
@annjohnson80972 ай бұрын
Hurrem has never been her friend, who would make their friend their maid. Hurrem knows if the Sultan ordered her to come she had to go.
@Ebh55.2 ай бұрын
Did they not have a choose though?
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
It was the way it the time tho and they always maid in the beginning if that what they are chose for but some people of power have a choice to be cruel to their maid:servant etc all in history and some can be good and close but once betrayal hits it hits, know you don’t know the show truly and fully and what in real life history happen and wouldn’t know because your too narrow minded.
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
@@Ebh55.yes fr
@smilebackattrashcan2 ай бұрын
Well, Hurrem's a bit psycho here. Not a good friend to Gulnihal. When Gulnihal cared for her from the beginning.
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
No she not psycho and it not about being a good friends yall half of yall would do the same and it was betrayal don’t you realize it was all Ibrahim pasha idea to try get in between relationships with the sultan and very close friend and maid. But what yall forget to realize it that she a maid so hurrem or any one of power can do anything to any maid , servant , slave, what ever you want call it. Get over it and this narrative. Yall really know nothing.😂😘😘🤡🙄😂😭😭😂😂🤡🤡🤡🙈☺️👍🏾👌👍✌️🤷🏾♀️💁🏾♀️😘😘😘😘😘😘😭😘😘
@lenakhan707910 күн бұрын
@@CarissaDethlefsthe irony of a black person saying hurrems actions are justified since she’s the master and gulnihal is just a slave/maid…. Ignorance must be bliss down there eh?
@heatherhowald9822 ай бұрын
Either the women are chosen by his people or by him personally. You cannot refuse without a good reason. You were chosen as a concubine to go into the harem, the concubines purposes are to provide heirs. So it is not a betrayal
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
It is it was set up by Ibrahim pasha don’t you get that. Smh
@user-gs6zm5qk9y2 ай бұрын
@@CarissaDethlefsI don’t disageee that Gulnihal agreed to this, however why shouldn’t she? Should she remain a forgotten servant for the rest of her life? No, everyone in that palace had to look out for themselves at the end of the day.
@heatherhowald9822 ай бұрын
@@CarissaDethlefs it doesn't matter if it was a setup or not either way she can not refuse.
@mistybanik9053Ай бұрын
If hurrem is angry on gulnihal then mahidevran was also not wrong for being angry on her cuz hurrem also did the same thing to mahidevran what gulnihal did to her
@chelsealanesy15 күн бұрын
Nah. This is different. Mahi and Hurrem were never best friends. Sad thing about betrayal is it is never from an enemy
@spark9772 ай бұрын
Even hurrem is punishable actually at mahidevrans end but here gulnihal is getting punished just bcoz she slept with his love 🤦
@LisaKayser-z3t2 ай бұрын
Ibrahim Pasha chose Gulnihal for the Sultan in order to make Sultana Hurrem angry. Gulnihal had no choice but to obey. Poor girl.
@mimioweida93332 ай бұрын
Hurrem always took it out on the girl who had no choice/fault.
@user-gs6zm5qk9y2 ай бұрын
False, she did agree to go after they convinced her she had a chance to come up in the hierarchy if she got pregnant. She refused to go at first but agreed once they compared her to Hurrem, saying she could be like her. I do however agree with this narrative though, why shouldn’t she make the most of her time? She’s a young woman just like Hurrem who must use her time wisely, or remain a forgotten servant for the remainder of her life. The choice was however hers at the end of the day 🙏🏼
@jakiahaque1553Ай бұрын
@@user-gs6zm5qk9y proved yourself as a blind fan of hurrem. As others you will never se any misdeed of that witch
@user-gs6zm5qk9yАй бұрын
@@jakiahaque1553 Sounds like you are talking about yourself, blind fan of Mahidevran 😅
@sowjosh082 ай бұрын
I don't know why this poisonous Ibrahim is so loyal to Mahidevran alone....Except her he is not good to anybody, even to his wife Hatice
@poyznelfАй бұрын
Per historical info, Pargali was a slave and was the lover and favorite of young Suleiman. He was possibly jealous and maybe in history they did not actually get along.
@AnannaAkter-fp6nr2 ай бұрын
I understand that she had to obey sultan's order but in her case it wad not the order of sultan so she could have refused it. Even she couldn’t refuse she should have told Hurrem.
@jagritikumari401228 күн бұрын
1) Orders from people you outrank couldn't be refused . 2) Telling Hurrem about it would have been dangerous because she knew that the latter would lash I at her and wouldn't understand her situation , she was trying to protect herself from Hurrem 's outrage because she was still her slave even if she was chosen to sleep with the Sultan .
@dnd661029 күн бұрын
Sultan is doing the same mistake again. This is the 2nd time he called for Gulnihal, when he knows how close is she to Hurrem
@organiccremeАй бұрын
Yall are forgetting the bigger picture here..this is her FRIEND. All the other girls he’s been with don’t matter bcuz this is her FRIEND we are talking about here. she feels betrayed by her FRIEND. Someone she confided in and seen her go thru all she’s been thru. She betrayed Hurrem by HIDING it from her. It’s not about the sultan. He can have anyone and he didn’t choose gulnihal clearly it was to make Hurrem mad but she was naive and could’ve TOLD Hurrem but she didn’t..That is where the Betrayal comes from. .
@Lazizkins10 күн бұрын
Btw, Gulnihal started being jealous to Hurrem a way before, when she saw Hurrem getting luxurious presents from Sultan. She has run to Sumbul to teach her, to accept Islam and to gen new muslim name. Hurrem paved the way, and instead of just staying with her, Gulnihal just repeated Hurrem's tactics (instead of coming up with own one), got jealous and wanted to become another Sultana, which obviously would put her against Hurrem and make them enemies. Despite this fact, she was okay to become an enemy to Hurrem, which took her out of other concubines as the closest and trusted person around (which was the best option for Gulnihal and the highest position to be provided by Hurrem for that period)
@Lazizkins10 күн бұрын
And Hurrem never did the same to Makhidevran, because: 1. They were not friends, and moreover, Mahidevran was aggressive to Hurrem from the first time. 2. Hurrem did not know there was Makhidevran at all. 3. It was Hurrem's only one chance to survive (and for Gulnihal too, because they were together). 4. Hurrem did not the rules of harem. On the other hand, Gulnihal was in harem a way longer then Hurrem for the moment to be invited to Suleiman's room. She must have known how to reject the invitation (periods, for example), or that Hurrem could prevent it for being strong enough in terms of power and hierarchy. At least, she could know that this is not an invitation from Sultan, but just a game against Hurrem, because Gulnihal was not a simple concubine for halvet - she was a right hand of Sultana. And she knew how it would hurt Hurrem, and that she would become a Sultana is she got pregnant and give a birth. Even when they were dancing for Sultan, and he had chosen Hurrem, Gulnihal did some hypocritical comment, and Hurrem mentioned how jealous Gulnihal was. This comment was innocent for us as watchers, and Hurrem's answer seemed aggressive at first. But coming to these later series, I noticed that Hurrem's aggressive response to gHulnihal during that dialogue was not added randomly.
@Lazizkins10 күн бұрын
And we see, Hurrem was trying to kill Gulnihal even without knowing that Gulnihal was that secret concubine. It shows, that Hurrem definitely realized everything (Gulnihal was not around all the night while Hurrem was giving a birth; she always goes away somewhere with Sumbul and leaves the prince, so Esma probably informed Hurrem). So probably, Hurrem just gave Gulnihal a second chance to confess and letting Gulnihal know that Hurrem knew everything, but Gulnihal just went on with hiding. And how she got interested when Sumbul was telling her about becoming Gulnihal sultana. Neither the betrayal, nor even the fear of death did not stop her from doing the same mistake twice. And why Sumbul was trying to convince her with all that sweet talk instead of just strictly cutting the dialogue since this is the wish of Sultan? Probably this shows, that refusing the halvet with sultan is not such an impossible thing, if you have a serious excuse. So Hurrem would come up with this excuse if she ever knee, right?
@lornakurien79622 ай бұрын
I cant understand why women in general blame the other woman. The husband pursues the other woman, beds her, showers her with gifts. It is the husband who should be confronted, my dears!
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
And the women take two for everything
@carolcarol64252 ай бұрын
Love the story and history really i do, but still just a demonstration of another version of controlled prostitution of that era.
@desireetesoro9495Ай бұрын
Why the man not content of one women only 😒
@Iremchik_Demir2 ай бұрын
21:48 Хафса подписала себе смертный приговор.
@yumekojabami41792 ай бұрын
21:04
@memoonaaaqil99372 ай бұрын
Hurrem is the worst travesty of friendship 🤐 Yazak
@simonadumitrache63962 ай бұрын
Sultan Suleyman should blame Ibrahim for choosing the person which should help Hurrem overnight and with birth. He didn't do nothing instead. He even call her again. He was the one which made the others fight between them. He was the evil too.
@cantfindahairtie3362Ай бұрын
I think the most striking thing between all the other women and hurrem was the pillowtalk. Whenever Hurrem spent the night with Suleiman they wouldn't just be like bang-bang deeds done off you go. They would actually talk to each other about personal things. Not even Mahidevran was shown sharing such intimate conversations with Suleiman
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
Hurrem has every right to do anything and everything no matter what people and the show think
@ΔημΣΚ2 ай бұрын
Hürrem sultan is right , gulnihal should have told her
@marjaenienhi53742 ай бұрын
all the women in the harim belong to Suleyman, why should she report to Hurrem..who was Hurrem to decide what was Suleyman's right..she was just a greedy woman who didn't know herself, she forgot how she came to Suleyman's room..All women in harim had the same right to enter Suleyman's chamber if He wish..
@ΔημΣΚ2 ай бұрын
@@marjaenienhi5374 they are friends, it doesn't matter if they are in the harem, she should have told her
@Unicorn-jf3rs2 ай бұрын
@@ΔημΣΚ Hurrem is a user, she really doesn't consider any one friend
@ΔημΣΚ2 ай бұрын
@@Unicorn-jf3rs ofc she does she had many in later episodes.
@gordanaterzic4121Ай бұрын
@@Unicorn-jf3rs Well said
@micheleford4282Ай бұрын
gulnihal broke the friend rule.. you know with all those concubines it still doesnt make sense for suleiman to sleep with a maid of hers though kind of low.
@judyhamadou490324 күн бұрын
Suliman was a horn dog lol
@harley_puddin_joker5562Ай бұрын
That's to far how they can send her only Best friend to suleiman only to rid of her
@rowenalariza6393Ай бұрын
Hurrem want only one man in her life
@felycariaga6852 ай бұрын
Nkalalabas lng asawa ni jomar sa ospital anak
@debjack52982 ай бұрын
She knows no 😂such thing
@poyznelfАй бұрын
If both Mahidevran and Hurrem put half their jealousy into positive actions and working together, they could have ruled the world. Mahidrevran is a pitiful silly woman in this series, so whiney instead of doing something to try and win her husband back. He's bored by your attitude. Hurrem, understands the game but, lacks subtlety that she will learn in her older years. Mahidevran seems to not understand the assignment. Sultan's job, rule and cast his seed out. He needs heirs. Infant mortality, disease, and unfortunately "accidents" often culled many heirs. The more a dynasty had, the more chance of the family line continuing and maintaining rule.
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
Hurrem has every right to do anything and everything no matter what people and the show think and real people (us) who watch the show yall too narrow minded so you wouldn’t even get it if you watch the series and everything about it what I mean paid attention ,(in other word do your real life homework if something your really interested, and if your watching this show you should be and should know all what the real life history of what happen.) this a DRAMA based show of the real life history of the ottoman empire so a lot of this stuff and scenarios and character predicted in a certain light or way or two characters are at odd was never like that in real life , hope I spelled this in abc so everyone can get it and if you don’t your mind not very open to whole lot of possibilities
@ΔημΣΚ2 ай бұрын
21:33 exactly, it was done on purpose, your time will come hafsa how dare you!
@gordanaterzic4121Ай бұрын
HAFSA HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH IT SO STOP ALWAYS AGREEING WITH YOUR SNAKE SAINT HURRDEVIL.
@nirmalrajpandiyan50022 ай бұрын
Suleman betrayed hurrem
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
Y’all don’t know anything I’ll leave it at that and if your wondering look at some people recent comment to find mine and my explanation if yall want it or asking for it or does this sign, ??????
@memoonaaaqil99372 ай бұрын
Hurrem is the worst travesty of friendship 🤐 Yazak
@CarissaDethlefs2 ай бұрын
Y’all don’t know anything I’ll leave it at that and if your wondering look at some people recent comment to find mine and my explanation if yall want it or asking for it or does this sign, ??????
@memoonaaaqil99372 ай бұрын
Hurrem is the worst travesty of friendship 🤐 Yazak