Super Mario 64 vs. Sunshine vs. Galaxy

[@a_pufferfish3468]

And now they're all being sold together, rather funny, that.

[@slimeygoose8545]

A_Pufferfish yes it is irony in its fullest

[@sophiama5949]

IM SO EXCITED

[@thevisionary5313]

Yeah, so everybody is satisfied. Including me! Played Sunshine and Galaxy when I was younger and they are really really good. How does 64 hold up today? (Take away the nostalgia factor)

[@a_pufferfish3468]

Dylan Hampton This will be my first time playing sunshine and the first galaxy, i'm super excited! In my opinion, 64 holds up well. Im surprised there's people not happy with the collection solely because it doesn't have Galaxy 2, although I guess you can't please everyone.

[@UltraNurture]

Yes indeed

[@sid6722]

This is the most flawless recommendation I’ve gotten in a while.

[@Nintendo64Dude]

I got recommended this too. Kinda funny

[@Horzinicla]

@@Nintendo64Dude how is that funny?

[@vasco35]

Lol i searched for it

[@AliTahan25]

No joke lmao

[@GearTechnique]

@@Horzinicla cuz all of this games r coming soon. This video is 2 years old.

[@euly]

Turns out we get all of them at once. Huh

[@JKing20105]

on an amazing console/handheld no less

[@JR-te9gq]

Fate is interesting

[@thundercat0002]

lol

[@Bombs-_-]

This video is about to be on everyones reccomended

[@Matthew-KC]

yep

[@PopcornTheOfficial]

True

[@nintendostyle3500]

Yep

[@hiimIan1872]

Yeah

[@cadensime9399]

Yep

[@av4d]

64 is the most innovative. Sunshine is the most unique. Galaxy is the most grande.

[@imvirpil]

av4d thanks for putting this 30 minute video to a simple comment ^^

[@ajddavid452]

64 is Great, Sunshine is my childhood, Galaxy was amazing.

[@This_Guy55]

av4d hi

[@TheJWittz]

Seems like a good synopsis to me!

[@LukeOrionMarble]

av4d wat

[@Smash67]

Nintendo: watches this video “Oh so people don’t care about galaxy 2, we don’t have to put THAT in our collection!”

[@MisterFiasco]

Really, I can’t recall even one instance of somebody asking for it until 35 All Stars was announced. So, maybe we didn’t?

[@tyson9670]

@@MisterFiasco it is regarded by many as the best 3D Mario, so yeah I do think people wanted it

[@Christopher-ms5ke]

MisterFiasco I liked it more than the first

[@nathanwanlass3083]

Galaxy 2 is way more fun to me than galaxy 1

[@fleshymeatsac9371]

@@tyson9670 funny. I had never heard anyone speak about it online or in person until 3d all stars was announced.

[@Aaaa-g6u8e]

I'm surprised he didn't mention Rosalina's storybook for Galaxy.

[@pixeldog0568]

Rosalina is one of the only Mario characters with depth.

[@dms8872]

If you watch game theroy cover her back story you would be suprise to know something...

[@Zolomight]

GottaFistDemAll SAME

[@dereknight861]

HE WHAT?!? *Breaks glass bottle in half*

[@RichardsRockin]

this comment made me give up watching this video

[@emPtysp4ce]

God, just hearing the Galaxy soundtrack gives me a fuzzy feeling inside.

[@Boltylool506]

same

[@Tetsu9701]

I feel that way about Sunshine, yet its the one I played the least. Nostalgia from my teenage years. Out of the 3 series talked about here, I've only 100%'d Galaxy 1 & 2.

[@knicholson]

is anyone else here after the announce of super Mario all stars 3d

[@HombreDufff]

No

[@joelaugustestudios]

I am. I can’t wait to hear that he sort of predicted the game with this video.

[@marcy4002]

that’s crazy, it’s almost like EVERYONE in the comment section says they comment in the past 2 weeks

[@SmoothSushi]

Me

[@yuhyeet6829]

No shut up

[@MrHatoi]

I remember once spending an hour in the dock level in Sunshine just surfing around with the turbo nozzle. I really wish they used it more in actual gameplay; it's not even required to beat the game.

[@TimGaukerToons]

MrHatoi You only use it to access one secret area, one blue coin and for a challenge at the Delfino Airstrip near the end.

[@MrHatoi]

Yeah I know; and none of those are actually necessary unless you're doing a 100% run of the game.

[@Hello-bg8hv]

That's why sunshine needs an HD remake adding new areas to the game exetra

[@aamk7837]

Sunshine is my favorite imo

[@WaterKirby1994]

Yeah I remember thinking we should have gotten Sunshine 3DS as a successor to 64ds, although blue coins would need to be kept tracked of by the game itself. Turbo Nozzle needs more use in the game's remake, maybe we'll get a 4th Nozzle as well much like Balloon Mario for 64 & New forms for Yoshi to take.

[@awesomeness1122]

BTW i figured out why yoshi acts strange in sunshine. its simple they are not actual yoshi's they are painted creatures made by shadow marios brush. the yoshi's on the island are extinct and where do you first find a yoshi? with shadow mario. the yoshi's also disintegrate in water like they are made of paint. they also share a trait with alot of the monsters in the game of being able to spit up more paint with weird properties (they spit up watercolor paint that creates platforms) and they change colors by eating different fruit (lots of watercolor paint can be made with fruit).

[@Mellion555]

Huh I never thought of it that way but when you mention it... it actually makes 100% total sense.

[@jarrodsantos7154]

everything else shadow mario paints is made to destroy mario, i find it highly unlikely that shadow mario would intentionally provide mario the tools necessary to complete his adventure, and if it was unintentional, then that’s just dumb. this is a possible justification but i don’t think it’s a good one, just let yoshi swim in a game where water is the main focus pls.

[@awesomeness1122]

Well each monster he created seems to have a mind of its own and acts at least vaguely like there actual counterparts depending how well he drew them, since the Yoshi was his most accurate drawing it stands that he accidentally made him friendly to Mario, He is still a kid so accidentally doing something dumb is completely normal.

[@siegwardinspirit]

especially because the paintbrush wasn't created to destroy, it was invented to create. Only because of Bowser Jr.'s "evil" intentions, the creatures were evil as well. Maybe Yoshi was a mistake? Maybe Yoshi was meant to be something different, after all (if I remember correctly) it was the first creature introduced with a spawnpoint. Maybe it was even created by E. Gadd himself to test his invention. Bowser Jr. was aware of Yoshi being good, trying to run away with the egg.

[@bibasik7]

But hey, that's just a theory! A game theory!

[@SoloPizzaMan1997]

This popping into my recommendations after the 3D collection has been announced I see you KZbin XD

[@ElectroBlastLuigi]

This is all the viewers fault for giving this video a lot of traction xD

[@ObsessedwithZelda2]

Sunshine is my absolute favorite, and there's a few things it does well that I didn't feel the others had a great grasp on: 1. The world actually feels like a world and not so much a level. You're jumping on things carried by cranes and across roof tops a lot more than on a floating brick. 64 aimed for this, but I feel it had some limitations about it, and many of Galaxy's levels didn't feel very grounded at all 2. For a platformer, you can usually find a lot of different ways to get to any one point. I've shaved so much time discovering easier routes to certain areas, and it's really fun looking for different ways than normal to get somewhere. 64 has this a little in some places, but it never feels quite so intentional 3. There's usually a reason for the different missions in each world, and it often even feels connected to one another. Especially in the Noki Bay stages. But even the flash flood plays a role in explaining why the red coins are the only missions left. I feel like Sunshine is the only one that gives a setting that feels fairly real and lets you play around in that world and find new ways of doing things

[@cardboardleaf7971]

ObsessedwithZelda2 I agree entirely! Its a FRESH game... Get it...? I'm an inkling...

[@omenicart6510]

No that was not good bad boy

[@ducks5513]

Perfect. I completely agree. You didn’t mention that the controls are the best. Mario Sunshine just feels so good to play, to hold the controller and to control Mario. The F.L.U.D.D. Mechanic was awesome to add also.

[@VolatileViolet]

Yeah, I agree. It always felt almost like a place that I could visit.

[@themattster]

It's my favorite too :)

[@Thomas-ju4hf]

Mario Sunshine was awesome! I love the tropical atmoshpere and the gamecube charm of this game

[@PKMNmasterJuice]

Best Pokégirl right here!

[@wahmaster2788]

Toukoトウコ no it was not

[@Thomas-ju4hf]

PKMNmasterJuice ✌😄

[@alexh8503]

yep

[@EternaMidnight]

The camera seemed pretty ideal to me. You can move all around and in and out with the C stick, and press L to force the camera behind you even if it goes through a wall. Pressing Y lets you zoom in close while stationary like Super Mario 64 too.

[@kirin1230]

This is shockingly relevant now

[@averageaudienjoyer]

yes

[@cynokaiju]

My favorites are the Galaxy games. I admit it's because of nostalgia. I was born in 1998 and I only played Sunshine on my friend's GC. My first experience with Mario 64 was on the DS. Galaxy was the first 3D Mario I 100%'d and to this day it is the most amazing. The music still brings tears to my eyes.

[@byOrbaa]

Kaiju i was born in 98 i grew up on Sunshine and almost every gamecube mario game like Luigis mansion mario strikers etc and i also was introduced to 64 on DS not 64

[@ancientshiv9837]

@Retendo same bro

[@ttraiin9974]

Retendo who tf asked

[@GODOFAWSOMENESS1]

Retendo man you’re old.

[@Jr-yb8lg]

I was born in 2005 wii was my first console.

[@LuriTV]

So "Super Mario Space Odyssey" would be the next natural progression for this series

[@yuilinkmat9469]

What if I told you there *is* a game called: Super Mario 4: Space Odyssey Yes, it's not oficial, it's a russian bootleg Mario game for the Sega Genesis And it's bad... Really really bad

[@tbone8358]

It will probably not contain space or odyssey in the title

[@mellow_mallow]

if it doesn't have piantas in it I will cry

[@dozonater562]

No, Super Mario 3D Universe

[@Nocturne989]

"There won't be a more relevant time for me to review these three specific Mario adventures" Should we tell him?

[@toadhoward3954]

Tells us about the amazing music Doesn’t let us listen to it

[@Daniel_L9]

Just A Boi copyright laws? I’m not very sure if it’s that though

[@natasha0599]

Thanks Nintendo!

[@EliteEpicGamerz]

I was annoyed by that too. And its not copyright as he uses music from the games as background songs during the vid

[@toadhoward3954]

To be fair, it would make an already too long video even longer

[@mattbabineau197]

Wait. Wait. Wait. You're supposed to JUMP on Big Bully??? I'VE BEEN PUNCHING HIM FOR YEARS WHATTT

[@iceclkeyheart3060]

Explains why ive always had a hard time with him

[@NKRevolution]

U can do both bud

[@anjoliebarrios8906]

Matt Babineau I've been ground- pounding this whole time!

[@ryanschmidt3913]

I just and kick.

[@_lapys]

surprised_pikachu.jpg

[@harvesterman5210]

How convenient is this now

[@jjcjr]

Are you kidding? "Galaxy doesn't have many secrets" IT HAS 36! AND I COUNTED!

[@dms8872]

JohnCJr did you count the secret of rosalina?

[@blockheads2047]

He was counting things like secret levels.

[@einsteiner311]

@/dev/etresevo every secret level in every large galaxy

[@SweeterNova]

@High Definition still nore than 64

[@danielzakgaim2764]

They're secrets for a reason 😉

[@Leonhart]

64. Love those polygons

[@retrosoul8770]

best gameplay as well, the most satisfaction in jumping and movement.

[@squirrelbazooka8033]

Leonhart your here!

[@ash-zk7om]

I've always been so used to that style, that "old days" 3D

[@glitchstudios7885]

Leonhart same

[@alimeski4039]

Wow was not expecting you here

[@KratosAurionPlays]

15:27 You can go on top of the penguin? 20:30 Wait how did you not know this? What else would that shell be there for? XD On another note I found out from another person recently who said they didn't know the snowmen in Mario 64 could die by circling them like the eyeball enemies. That blew my mind too that it wasn't a well known thing. 28:27 No doubt about it. It's still the only Mario game I have beaten 100% (And the Rom Hack Super Mario Star Road as of a couple days ago but that's not an official game of course)

[@thebahooplamaster]

I can just imagine Super Mario Odyssey being alongside these games on this video.

[@aketsuuu]

Apparently it is the HIGHEST rated Mario game in general.

[@boxcar9407]

Yeah I think that Super Mario Odyssey is the most happy go lucky.

[@cinemaslut9034]

thebahooplamaster Sunshine > 64 > Odyssey >>>>>>>>>> Galaxy

[@torashan1]

thebahooplamaster Odyssey is kind of like a combination of them all because of similar movement mechanics from 64, a partner like Sunshine, and different worlds in Galaxy

[@zackDOTexe]

odyssey would win it’s like the combination of the tree

[@LambtacoGames]

Two things. One: The part in SM64 where you cannon into the wall to get the star. That star is called Blast Away the Wall. That's not really all that cryptic. Two: When you play through Mario Galaxy the second time as Luigi he controls more slippery, making it more difficult, and he jumps higher allowing for shortcuts you can't take as Mario.

[@alexv1351]

i 100% the with both Mario and luigi hoping i would get another character but i got a picture instead lol

[@Stratelier]

"Blast Away The Wall" does leave you wondering just which wall ... and launching yourself out of a cannon at random walls until you find the right one. Not difficult, just a bit tedious.

[@Kajidoh]

Actually you play as Mario with Luigi's head. you can tell this by standing next to the npc Luigi.

[@wariolandgoldpiramid]

Stratelier but that corner does look a bit suspicous. I don't think I would have figured it out, but I've seen a Blind LPer figure it out very quickly

[@LambtacoGames]

The model may be Mario's body but he still jump higher. And there are like three walls you can blast into from the level's one and only canon.

[@tbrighton8531]

I really appreciate Sunshine. It's definitely the black sheep of the bunch, but in a good way. My favorite part about the game is that you're exploring an actual place where people live and you're never alone. You can basically see every other level from wherever you are on the island. There are NCP to talk to EVERYWHERE. Mario 64 and Galaxy are very lonely games. In Sunshine you can see how your actions affect the world around you. You slowly bring the island back to life. I was always excited to re-enter the hub world to see what changed after getting a shine sprite. Its awesome, and its unique to the game.

[@dixonb.tweenerlegs4225]

It's honestly the one I play most in the 3d all starts collection

[@alexbasha0508]

Galaxy for me, bloody adored that game when it first came out. It will always be my favourite mario game.

[@LegoTrigger]

Alex Basha Not just my favorite Mario game, but my favorite game of all time!

[@ancientshiv9837]

@@LegoTrigger same

[@Luigi-194]

@@LegoTrigger YES! ^^

[@silverlux7266]

Honestly, that game is a masterpiece

[@rowk19]

Same it was my first ever Mario game so it means a huge deal to me

[@Shiny_Sandshrew]

The correct answer is Hotel Mario.

[@WilfredCthulu]

Amigo J Toasters!

[@ahmirfosterjames9031]

I hope you made lot of spaghetti

[@stevenreyes4791]

Dear pesky plumbers,

[@Goldenpeez]

Sonic the horgeheg is my favorite Mario and weegee anime

[@PrincessAshley972]

I think you mean Sanic

[@pk_kirbo6486]

Well this aged well.

[@noneofyourbusiness1998]

Galaxy is my favorite game of all time.

[@BarentoFR]

Markell Hawthorne no #64

[@somedude7678]

Markell Hawthorne same here! although I love all 3 :)

[@dittom3426]

Barentunium Chew He said was his, not yours.

[@dittom3426]

Labradorite Semicolons Opinions.

[@Dracomut]

Hey I love Psychonauts too, but I still like Galaxy 1 and 2 more

[@chetooisasillyloser6661]

That thumbnail though. Badass as heck!

[@subsug7996]

Theo is SOOO talented. Jish's thumbnails are so great now that Theo does them!

[@vortexluigirosalina5557]

chetoo is a figot dude that's the best thumbnail I've seen so far!

[@cooldude6269]

Rosa’s face

[@op-nl7dj]

chetoo is a figot "badass" "heck"

[@fuzzinator9523]

John Zoidberg lol

[@Genra]

Why have 1, when you can all 3?

[@ianrobinson222]

You really marked this as a spoiler

[@Genra]

@@ianrobinson222 I posted it like 3 mins after the Direct lol, it would have been a spoiler, though now it isn't ye

[@Human-gb8bq]

Out of all 3 of them galaxy is my fav

[@mattbelcher7135]

Agreed

[@fatherthatissopenis7766]

Same here

[@starrod616]

*Preach*

[@helios2664]

Chaos of madness Jah

[@georged366]

I prefer Sunshine but Galaxy is awesome.

[@tumpuga2550]

Every time he used ice Mario, he just walked instead of skating... aahhhhhaaAAAAAHHHHH PLEASE END ME NOW

[@brumbogetbrum2714]

It seemed like a lot of reasoning behind troubles, distastes, and negative critiquing as a whole for the games was stemmed from poor manipulation, yeah. Most game controls and mechanics (as long as they’re of SOME level of quality,) even if they feel janky or even unpredictable at first, can be learned.

[@Condoriano94]

@@brumbogetbrum2714 Agreed. This was an awful review imo and this guy is bad at the games

[@mersumummo4600]

How did he know?

[@KingDanieltheDandy]

I love the sunshine voice acting. its so funny

[@leebydeeby]

HOW DARE YOU DISTURB MY FAMILY VACATION

That is what it makes good. :D

Sunshine by far is my favorite 3d mario game

[@neilisbored2177]

NICE OF THE PRINCESS TO INVITE US OVER FOR A PICNIC

[@toasty_mann]

"A game is fun" -*Reggie 2017*

[@LMan86]

64 is my all time favorite 3D Mario. It has the most replay value for me

[@chrisshep7564]

2007 - MARIO ISN'T CUTE REE- 2017 - Mario can wear Peach's wedding dress.

[@IMakePeopleSaltyApparently]

XD

[@babak1hehexd908]

Mario ended up being a depressed Italian plumber

[@tomsky4751]

Imma just say it mario in peach’s wedding dress, queen slay.

[@koro-tan4938]

"Yokota-san, if somewhere in your mind you have an image that Mario is cute, please get rid of it. ...Mario is COOL." Well said, Koji Kondo. Well said.

[@Benji10109]

“Galaxy has one straight path for every level” Well, mainly. Galaxy also has hidden stars for most if not all galaxies. In these you plop in to a level you already beat, but instead of doing it the same way you did the first time, you run around the whole galaxy looking for a hidden star. Some hidden stars are just on top of mountains you have to climb, but others (like in freezeflame galaxy) are pretty hard

[@shardtheduraludon]

Some hidden stars I got on accident while getting the main ones, such as the one where you reach the peak of the mountain. I was trying to get to the Baron Brrr star

[@davinchristino]

@@shardtheduraludon Unrelated, but the view was awesome from the top

[@theblitz1070]

Personally I like Galaxy the most. The sheer creativity they have trumps the other Marios. There's tons of stages each with new ideas and interesting mechanics.

[@xninja83x67]

theblitz233 hmm sort of like 64 and sunshine at their time of release aswell...

[@Rex67Diego9]

xNinja83 mmm not really. 64 was the oldest game and it revolutionized the game industry, but now the game doesn't really do much, 64 is just too easy, once you know where the star is, the challenge is practically nonexisten, platforming is very easy. sunshine, just added the water thingy mecanic which isn't bad but it really didn't offer anything new, the water thing i felt it was just situational. Galaxy to this day and specially galaxy 2 all have a much efficient set of chalenges through the stages, you need more precise jumping and timing, also while the star spin mechanic is just one mechanic, the many uses you can give to that mechanic is incredible

[@jacobtorres1707]

Rex67Diego9 fandub I think they mean at the time of their own release the same could be said for each

[@chamberlainquench2484]

What a great video but galaxy my favorite game ever so yeah

[@ElectroBlastLuigi]

I see this recommended and I knew there would be comments about Super Mario 3D All Stars

[@chrismuoio9818]

Can this be a series? Like a comparison of different games that people are always arguing about?

[@EliteEpicGamerz]

My childhood. All in one video :')

[@Promethazin3]

EliteEpicGamerz Wtf all of these games were released years after one another do you think you're never gonna grow up lol

[@EliteEpicGamerz]

1-THE_DARK_KING-2 bruh im 16, played these games from like 6-11

[@Promethazin3]

EliteEpicGamerz If you were 11 when galaxy was out and that was 07 and its 17 now wouldn't that make you older than you say you are rn

[@EliteEpicGamerz]

1-THE_DARK_KING-2 i never played the games when they first came out. I was like 8 or 9 atleast when i played galaxy cause i 100% galaxy 2 and i needed to be a semi-functioning human to do that. Im 2001

[@Promethazin3]

EliteEpicGamerz Ok now it makes sense

[@dysperdotted]

my favorite thing about the thumbnail is how both mario and peach look pissed and rosalina looks like she hasn’t gotten her coffee yet.

[@xavierRamoz]

The comet observatory theme was my favorite. It always got stuck in my mind and calmed me down ☺️

[@colerocks7572]

It's strange, 64 really is a great Mario game to replay every once in a while

[@elijahleandre386]

When 3D all stars comes out in 2020: why pick one?

[@MRWINDYMETHANE]

The better question is why omit Super Mario Galaxy part 2? Nintendo really makes perplexing decisions sometimes...

[@Y_5250]

@@MRWINDYMETHANE because they didn't mention sequels or spin offs at all during the direct on purpose.

[@gnarly.bulblax]

Brennan Martinez because the morale on Mario Galaxy 2 was so low it was disturbing

[@MRWINDYMETHANE]

@@gnarly.bulblax What do you mean by morale?

[@gfrewqpoiu]

Brennan Martinez The Developers really hated working on Galaxy 2. They felt like they put everything they had into Galaxy 1 and they felt out of ideas. There are some interviews with the developers that really paint a grueling picture of the game, even though it is beloved by many fans,

[@MajoraZ]

The long jump may not be in sunshine, but the spin jump it adds covers as much distance (more in certain circumstances) and is more versatile. You can also combine the backflip/soumersalt with the slide to get a midair dive that acts basically the same as the long jump.

[@squish162]

Im thinking the final verdict is partially based on nostalgia.

[@davis1733]

Ya think? ;)

[@phoivos]

sunshine is by far my favorite, the tropical setting and movement mechanics are amazing

[@GenJotsu]

Nostalgia is a helluva drug Jwittz

[@fireheartis1]

Mario Galaxy is my favorite Mario game of all time. It's just so magical in my opinion. Mario Sunshine is fun and so is 64 but Galaxy is my all time favorite.

[@jodyjohnston934]

Galaxy 1 and 2 are awesome

[@TechnoTejay]

This video has become a lot more relevant now that they're all gonna be in a switch collection together.

[@danielfinjan2400]

I like what you did here. It is very different then the usual video, Keep it up!

[@TheJWittz]

Thanks! Always trying new things :)

[@danielfinjan2400]

TheJWittz No, Thank you for making this amazing ode to three dimensional games

[@TopHatLucario]

Daniel Finjan I'd say that's subjective. I have fond memories of pretty much every level in the first Galaxy game.

[@ebboy53]

He didn´t say that the video wasn´t even subjective in the first place...?

[@nobunny9362]

I don't care what anyone says or what the ratings say; Super Mario 64 DS is my favorite and personal best.

[@awesomeguy2009]

Shiver no

[@MagicMaster667]

Agreed. :3

[@channelwithout]

64 DS is one of the best examples of a remake done right.

[@samuelbaugh4952]

The games that the Analogue Thumbstick and Dedicated Camera buttons were invented for had those essential features removed and was on a weaker system. I'm sure if you played a modded version on PC with the added Stars and Characters it'd be great, but the original DS release is MILES behind dude.

[@nobunny9362]

Samuel Baugh Well, yes. I've now understand why it was kind of bad. I played it on my DSi, which most likely didn't make it any better.

[@ziggyiggy4525]

Nintendo 2 years ago: *Lets save this for later...*

[@_evanwalsh_]

Galaxy 4 Life!!! Also, great video! I love your content so much!

[@antonbiif0568]

Chibi Who yep Galaxy 4 life😎

[@skyes4552]

Odyssey For Life

[@mariopokemon955]

Chibi Who Galaxy is amazing and clever Galaxy 4 Life 😍

[@KevSB07]

I know I'm late but I agree with all of you, we need a galaxy 4

[@vyskmk]

Many times throughout this video you proclaim that Galaxy loses the exploring vibe from previous three-dimensional Super Mario titles, and you only return to each star one or two times. While Galaxy 2 is definitely very linear, I would like you to realize that Galaxy is simply not as linear as you make it out to be. 1) The large majority of the game takes place in fifteen main galaxies. The exact number is 92 out of 120 stars, equating to a % value of approximately 77. These galaxies are listed below: 1. Good Egg Galaxy 2. Honeyhive Galaxy 3. Space Junk Galaxy 4. Battlerock Galaxy 5. Beach Bowl Galaxy 6. Ghostly Galaxy 7. Gusty Garden Galaxy 8. Freezflame Galaxy 9. Dusty Dune Galaxy 10. Gold Leaf Galaxy 11. Sea Slide Galaxy 12. Toy Time Galaxy 13. Deep Dark Galaxy 14. Dreadnought Galaxy 15. Melty Molten Galaxy Each of these galaxies have six stars, except for Battlerock Galaxy and Dusty Dune Galaxy, which have seven stars. In each of these galaxies, there are three main missions, two prankster comets (one being purple coins) and one secret star, except in Battlerock Galaxy and Dusty Dune Galaxy, which have two secret stars, the second of which being green, further unlocking the Planet of Trials. Out of the remaining galaxies, seven are Grand Stars, with six of those having a boss at the end and one solo star, while the other one has one Grand Star and one Red Star, being the Gateway Galaxy, while also not having a boss. Seven further galaxies are Hungry Luma galaxies, which require feeding the Hungry Luma a certain number of Star Bits, and each of these galaxies has one star. Three further galaxies are located on the Planet of Trials, all of which have one star each, and another one is also located there, but is reserved for the ending and again has only one star. The rest of the galaxies are found in the form of ? blocks before unlocking, all of which having one star besides Buoy Base Galaxy, which has an additional Green Star. There are two of these "mini galaxies" in each of the first three domes, while the final three have only one. I hope you realize the minor mistake you made in the procedure of making your video, and look at the statistical evidence of my research. EDIT: Galaxy 2 tends to stick to a super-linear design, with most galaxies only having two or three stars, and fewer secret stars.

[@luigi64dd91]

While you're correct, the way that the galaxies are designed generally makes you follow a specific path for the star that you are getting. 64 and Sunshine have more open maps where the entirety of the map is sort of circular--just one big area as opposed to different areas accessed through sling stars or a linear path. Galaxy does have these, but out of the fifteen main galaxies you mentioned, only about half of them are designed like this. Furthermore, 64 and Sunshine both have ways of encouraging looking around the map and not just going straight to the star. In 64's case, it's the fact that you can get the stars out of order. In Sunshine's case, it's the blue coins. Both games also have the 100 coin mission where you'll be searching the entire level for coins. Galaxy doesn't have any of these. It does have secret stars that you can go off the main path to get, but there's only one or two per galaxy. In summary, while you're still right, JWittz has a point in that 64 and Sunshine have a greater number of open-ended levels and that they have more reasons to go off the main path and explore the levels.

[@vyskmk]

Luigi 64DD I can understand what you're saying, but even if you have to generally follow an objective, you are still surrounded by the same area over and over again similar to 64 and sunshine. Also, the galaxy games have comets, putting a spin on a familiar setting, and galaxy 2 has green stars, very similar to blue coins in sunshine or some of the power moons in odyssey. I think it is obvious that we are both right, but I felt like I had to point out some things you forgot.

[@luigi64dd91]

I don't really see how most of the comets would have you explore more, since most of them involve doing an objective again but with added difficulty, like a time limit or only 1 health point. However, the purple coin missions where you have no time limit and have to look for 100 coins definitely are an exception in that they totally encourage exploration (and they are mostly at the more open maps, not coincidentally). I didn't mention green stars because I was talking about Galaxy 1. And yeah, we both are right. I think we definitely talked about it in more depth and clarified it more than JWittz did.

[@vyskmk]

Well, I think its settled. But I think that we should start discussing how Sunshine is about as open as galaxy. Think about it: for the most part you are following the missions in a specific order, unless you are going to the secret platforming stages or happen to be very good at the game. And also, Green Stars in Galaxy 2 are not that innovative anyways, they mostly require you to perform a feat of platforming, such as triple jumping and then spinning at the correct alignment. Purple coins are really great in my opinion, although often challenging, and make you feel like you're in a very open world full of collectibles.

[@k-leb4671]

I had some fun exploring what little I could in Galaxy. There's actually more nuances to discover than most people realize. Has anyone here explored Sea Slide Galaxy before the star that actually requires you explore the level? In the first and second star, there's some strange little differences and things to discover. Obviously there isn't any point in which that kind of exploring and messing about leads to something major like a Power Star, but it's still interesting enough if you have the itch to explore.

[@aBatwoman]

Sunshine is the best! I love how it connects to Luigi's Mansion I loved getting a shirt from Nintendo Power too. The only thing that was bad was the jump levels just hard.

[@Aarantula]

I can feel the sunshine, and it does brighten up my day.

[@superzigzagoon]

But can Mario survive in the city?

[@Operation_Bagel]

superzigzagoon it's escape from the city, you uncultured swine

[@superzigzagoon]

Its not that. I assumed living in a city, that Mario would know to survive as well as keeping his dreams alive.

[@haydenthomas692]

Dont bring back memories about Sonic R, we are talking about good games here

[@superzigzagoon]

Its not as bad as some make it out to be.

[@asmremily5987]

Who is watching this while waiting for 3D all-stars to come out on Switch??

[@wyattdoesstuff2425]

Lol

[@prismaticmaniac2084]

I feel like I’m the only one who had no problem with the watermelon festival. Sure it popped from time to time but it was actually my favorite shine in the game for some reason.

[@pokejoseph]

Didn’t really have a problem with it too. You just have to get it away from the Red Cataquacks.

[@adrian_hook]

I always had fun with it. I found it more funny than frustrating when it would randomly break

[@RGamePlayXtreme]

For years, I wasn't able to beat it. A few days ago, I beat it in 1 try.

[@pretzelking4618]

Galaxy is the best Oh boy an opinion Better get ready!

[@buddeman27]

galaxy is best but i have nostalgia for 64 and sunshine... mostly 64; from the ds version

[@silverkrystel5710]

I think you have a good opinion, Galaxy is a good game. Even though it’s not my personal favorite.

[@noahrodriguez2185]

I agree with you lol

[@BigT.Larrity]

Galaxy is the best, but I still like Sunshine more.

[@10gaws71]

Yea...some people in the comments be bashin' for liking galaxy but disliking odyssey

[@thesmellofadventure5370]

Premise: Sunshine (Everything is in a beach) Hub World: 64 (It’s close between this and Delfino) Camera: Galaxy (A flawless camera) Story: Sunshine (FANTASTIC!) Level Design: Galaxy (It’s own spin on classic themes) Music: 64 (Truly iconic!) Controls: Sunshine (The controls are so smooth) Boss Fights: Sunshine (Unique from the series) Graphics: Galaxy (The newest and obviously best) Secrets: 64 (So many secrets inside it) Mechanics/Gameplay: Sunshine (FLUDD changed everything) Overall: Sunshine (My favorite game ever!)

[@kashzen]

I love all, but sunshine will always be my favorite

[@grape_nation]

Sunshine just because the controls are the most fun to mess with. Sunshine has the most freedom when it comes to controls. Look at those speedrunners

[@gengarclefairy3475]

The Bird ? Super Mario 64 is one of the most speedrunned games of all time

[@grape_nation]

Riley O'Neill I know that, but you still got to admit that Mario 64’s controls are pretty stiff. Sunshine’s are better.

[@chosentoaster6626]

Riley O'Neill Mario 64 speedruns more heavily rely on massive glitches that can skip nearly 95% of the game. If we're talking any% Sunshines are a more testament of skill, with well timed button presses and trickier glitch skips.

[@grape_nation]

chosen toaster Lol when a sunshine speed runner plays it’s like watching someone do parkour

[@kylec.9092]

The Bird ? On steroids.

[@gio_ozz]

I haven't seen the video yet, but my guess is that his favorite game of the 3 is either, 64, sunshine or galaxy

[@pix3l_brat]

The hype is real! Can't wait!

[@prox8437]

Friday is gonna be so lit

[@Owlero]

Alright we get it. You're excited for Odyssey. You don't need to copy-paste that comment in every video about Mario.

[@RaisedThird]

SupaPixelGirl wtf, you're the first comment that shows up for me for Chugga, GameGrumps, and now JWittz LOL

[@sprypinegames5390]

SupaPixelGirl just pre ordered my copy today.

[@qwerp3]

Owlero I think she might use like bots.

[@PackedMouse]

Galaxy all day

[@wilytw]

PackedMouse YESSSSS

[@thetruemads4787]

A city fan and loves super Mario galaxy! My man!

[@TheCatLoverLord]

Redixs Eww Sunshine

[@justdaisy7257]

Super Mario Land? No

[@Key-kallum]

Haha he predicted all the games in 3d all stars, he even didn't include galaxy 2 before all the rumours

[@doitfaster9553]

He's a prophet

[@retrokoh]

before all the rumors... IDK when those rumors started but this predates 3DAS by 3 years.

[@minecraftercreeper9840]

Probably because galaxy and galaxy 2 are the same game with different levels

[@sparedchannel73]

Whoever did the thumnail is great

[@mcninjaftw4789]

You need to make a top ten kirby... Something Preferably bosses Plz?

[@mariofox6643]

JWittz: 64 Vs. Sunshine Vs. Galaxy. Me: Why not all 3 instead?

[@Abc-zy7yi]

So... I would ask you to do this for 3d Zelda games but I don't want to start a small nuclear war

[@gotchathespider7850]

It would not be small.

[@Missing_Link324]

The legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time is obviously the best.

[@commonfreak9093]

the rage of completing majora's mask though

[@aster0781]

Yeah, better to not pull the pin on THAT grenade

[@pkjose1343]

That thumbnail looks so good!👌

[@TD0150]

Your picture matches your comment perfectly

[@pkjose1343]

The Trolldier Lol thanks!

[@dayalasingh5853]

PK Jose it won't load for me.

[@cardboardleaf7971]

Can I just refer to you a Ok Ness?

[@jordynisboredyn]

Little did we know, all three of these would be combined one day

[@yellowgamers5996]

I prefer the more Sandbox Exploration style of 3D Mario more than the Progression Oriented ones!

[@jasonvalentino395]

My brother actually passed out he couldn’t believe Super Mario Odyssey was an open world game XD

[@TEKnology]

... I hoped Nintendo weren’t dumb enough to abandon the genre. But I do like new things too.

[@CalebCraft10]

LinkToTheZach 13 Well technically it isn't open world.

[@ColtonMiller6012]

You should take them to a doctor then. And it's a sandbox, not open world.

[@AlfonsoSRT]

Well, he'll be disappointed when he plays it and realizes it's not.

[@peachabutt]

LinkToTheZach 13 When I read this I thought it said pass away! 😆

[@taylorcarlsen9700]

“I wish the spin was mapped to a button” Me: *laughs in 3D All Stars*

[@youtubealt243]

That, along with the more responsive motion controls compared to Wii, makes me believe Galaxy is the best of the three, the Switch essentially solved the biggest problem about Galaxy in my opinion, which made previously hated levels really enjoyable

[@fartchamber12]

KZbin Alt Shoebill

[@lucinatrash3063]

My list from favorite to least favorite including odyssey would be. 1: Galaxy 2 2: Galaxy 1 3: Sunshine 4: Odyssey 5: 64

[@squid_cake]

ARandomOtaku honestly that's exactly what my list looks like.

[@Dragon-ul8fv]

Flip the list and you may be on to something.

[@fabiovercelli4962]

I completaly agree with you!64 and Odyssey are exaggeratedly overrated(Sorry for my bad english...I'm Italian)

[@wilytw]

GALAXY FTW!

[@bryguy1249]

Simon röhrs thats the most wack joke i heard all day.

[@staniam7615]

Yessss

[@octarians]

I'd have to pick SMS. (Sunshine) I've beaten both Sunshine and Galaxy, but I just enjoy SMS more.

[@intentionallybadicon6624]

Local-Idiots Couldnt you just say Sunshine instead of SMS (Sunshine)?

[@octarians]

Not sure. When my father got it he called it SMS, so I called it SMS.

[@Redstone7380]

“But if I have to pick a favorite, Super Mario-“ then my video cut off

[@wowviewer]

I don't think I'll ever complete Sunshine due to those stupid Blue Coins. The big argument I have when someone tells me that's better than 64, I point that out. I feel like had they not have done that... I'm pretty sure there would be more levels. Besides... story wise, it makes no sense! Think about it: The Pinata are in panic after the shine sprites left. Who has 24 of them? The @#$#@ing raccoons! Give them their stars back, sheesh!

[@IMakePeopleSaltyApparently]

Tbh they're not even that hard to find. Its like Spyro where you actually have to put effort into it.

[@SirQuadrat]

@@IMakePeopleSaltyApparently the problem is that the game offers no indication whether you collected all blue coins in a level. This makes it almost impossible to find them all without external help, because you'd have to look through every level again.

[@genetax2371]

@@SirQuadrat when you press Z and go to the map, it says how many blue coins you've collected in each level. Theres 30 in each world, 20 in isle delfino, and 10 in corona mountain. The blue coins are my favorite thing about the game because it rewards people for exploring every inch of Sunshines fleshed out world.

[@foamqueen1075]

I love Mario Sunshine but you perfectly put into words the biggest problem I have with it. The blue coins feel like they are padding the star count so it can get to 120. I know Mario 64 had a lot of repetitive stars but this just seemed lazy to me. It's a stunning game with great music and I have a lot of great memories of it at the end of the day

[@waywardlaser]

THREE. MORE. DAYS.

[@_Silenceman]

not you 2

[@whawhawhawhaaaa]

Mario Sunshine is the Twilight Princess or Skywatd Sword of Mario games, while Mario 64 and Mario Galaxy are the Ocarina of Time and Wind Waker of Mario games. All great games, but two get much more love than the other one, and sometimes they get too much love. I love all three games a lot, but Mario Sunshine is criticized a little too much.

[@sirjediowl7344]

Galaxy is the best

[@eshansanghera4535]

I agree

[@Treetops27]

Hands down

[@aizakmciver322]

No super mario64

[@verdantmischief7092]

Aizak Mciver Wow how dumb are you

[@davidleon6233]

Aizak Mciver please don't start a fight. That's the last thing we need

[@Freeasacar]

Comparing other games in a series to the original is never fair. It's like comparing any other 3D Zelda to OoC. They can't win because they don't have the added advantage of having done it first and blowing people away because of that. Both Sunshine and Wind Waker are my favorites though because motion control is so annoying to use. I want to just sit down and play a game, not wave my arms everywhere like is required in Galaxy and Skyward Sword.

[@PlushiePoogle]

I'm surprised so many people complain about how 'janky' the boats are in Sunshine. I think most people just don't seem to understand how to control them?

[@awesomeguy2009]

And Galaxy 1 and 2 aren't part of the exploratory category according to Nintendo. They're part of the linear category much like 3D Land and 3D World.

[@r.j.etrogames]

Phantom Drags I agree. Galaxy is completely different.

[@TEKnology]

I always think of Galaxy linear but not to the extent of 3D land

[@TinyGuy97]

I count Galaxy as part of 64 and Sunshine because you're still collecting stars on your own pace and not just "reaching for the flagpole" like in 3D Land and 3D World.

[@awesomeguy2009]

Bob omb Guy But Nintendo counts it as a linear 3D Mario. So it is. Plus, since the levels are linear, the stars might as well be a flagpole.

[@TinyGuy97]

Yeah, but you're still collecting stars doing mission objectives all within a hubworld at your own pace. You can go out of order and there's no world map. (Talking about Galaxy 1)

[@maskedwatercress]

WHERE MY SUNSHINE SQUAD AT?! Edit: thanks for the likes m'babes

[@AFTstorm]

Charlie 789 *RIGHT HERE*

[@Reverend_Revenant]

Here.

[@andresc689]

Charlie 789 HERE

[@weegee4theworld]

Charlie 789 yo

[@WikiTay]

here

[@Jordan-fw3qi]

TJW: plays 64, sunshine, and galaxy Nintendo: releases super mario 3d all stars TJW: did you just understand me

[@lojiczimm811]

only took 3 years.

[@wessel4027]

Yes Mario Galaxy is not forgotten ;)

[@oscarmccormack1611]

Wessel van den Broek The only ones that are forgotten are 3D Land and 3D World.

[@Fe_Mikey2015]

It was never forgotten. Sunshine is tho. Nobody really talks about it.

[@TheTanglyHen1026]

Michael the Legendary Super Human. Nah, everybody hyped Sunshine sequel or remake.

[@TheTanglyHen1026]

Oscar McCormack They may have been but they are great games.

[@manuelalbertoromero9528]

+Michael the Legendary Super Human. As if.

[@dynamicpanda6464]

This video makes me want to create a channel where I make versions of Jwittz’s videos with non-Nintendo alternatives. For example, this would be “Sonic Adventure vs. Sonic Heroes vs. Sonic Generations”.

[@tommunism6471]

Dynamic Panda You should, I would watch it

[@Maxwell_Twist]

Where is Sonic Adventure 2? Would it just be combined with Sonic Adventure?

[@raiseasato]

Real talk, I would watch that. Just make sure you maintain enthusiasm during it. It always kills me when an interesting video is killed by an unenthusiastic narrator.

[@op-nl7dj]

Dynamic Panda ok, what's stopping you?

[@intentionallybadicon6624]

Sonic forces is out

[@Its_Sebas_Yk]

Dude, he SERIOUSLY predicted 3D All Star's game selection

[@C0nnie]

Sunshine

[@Walay]

By far

[@youtubewontletmetypeagoodu8128]

Galaxy isn't a sandbox game so it obviously wouldn't have sandbox levels

[@jonysilvax671]

That doesn’t stop it from being such an amazing Mario game though :)

[@grabern]

+Dragon - mil50010 All the main galaxies are very explorable in my opinion. There were a lot of alternate routes, secret stars and secondary missions. In some missions the world would change, like a gate would be unlocked or other things, but SM64 is just the same.