Supreme Court mistakenly posts what appears to be Idaho abortion case doc: Bloomberg

According to Bloomberg, the Supreme Court accidentally posted what appears to be a draft of the Idaho abortion decision. NBC News' Yamiche Acindor, former federal prosecutor Paul Butler, University of California, Davis law professor Mary Ziegler and MSNBC medical contributor Dr. Kavita Patel join Chris Jansing to discuss the potential impact.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#supremecourt #SCOTUS #Abortion

[@robertortiz6749]

They are trying to have it both ways! They are trying to help Trump and the GOP.

[@johnbrowneyes7534]

Don’t let this fool you. Opinions can be changed in the future. Vote blue.

[@josephpeluchette191]

Msnbc does that 24 hours a day they give trump mire air time than all other org combined mxnbc works for trump all they do is say stuff get proved liars then it's oh look he's bad

[@AverageJoe483]

What do you mean both ways ?

[@salviaspuzzle]

There is no pro life. It's either the mother's choice....or someone else's! Why would it be anyone else's choice, ever?!?! You can hate abortion all you want, but if you vote against it, you're saying it's your choice and not the mother's. It's all about controlling women! None of your business, folks!

[@californianorma876]

🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@terrencekane8203]

3 ghouls on SCOTUS, Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch, decided it's ok for a woman to bleed to death in a hospital parking lot. Fortunately, for the women of Idaho, the other 6 voted against them.

[@lillianmatthew3880]

What's her name OMG

[@winstonsmith8565]

Ironic that you care about that, considering how much you seem to loveWar

[@Muttinchopsforever]

​@@lillianmatthew3880Thats low even for you old lady spinster

[@johnbrowneyes7534]

For now. This can be challenged again and it will. Vote blue!

[@kimberlyaustin6677]

​@@lillianmatthew3880Kimberly Austin is her name. Only I survived because the medical staff got me inside in time to perform the legal and necessary procedure. And it was in Michigan.

[@RTew021]

This is called "floating a position." Politicians do it all the time. Oh, that's right: SCOTUS isn't a political body, right?

[@kimberlyaustin6677]

Well.....🤷

[@walterhoenig6569]

Yep. Which is why alito just heavily criticized Biden for working with social media to stop covid disinformation.

[@kcw1879]

Golly gee, they are going to allow SOME women in a FEW circumstances make choices for their own body. How "generous". 🙄

[@RebelandDave]

Does the possible woman in her stomach have a choice to live?

[@kathyweis7451]

​@@RebelandDavethis is about medical emergencies....

[@swimminginthoughts]

​@@RebelandDaveWe justify that murder by saying they're not really a person.

[@RotisserieCrematorium]

@@swimminginthoughts abortion is not murder

[@Weird-z3d]

It makes them feel important to control others' lives.

[@maggiemims5063]

If a life is in danger and they don't due anything then they should be charged with MURDER!!

[@somoody9322]

They also need to be sued. They want to go that route then they need to be prepared to be legally responsible. A bunch of right lunatics won't be dictating what I can and can't do.

[@kathyweis7451]

They should be sued for practicing medicine without a license and medical malpractice....

[@whatsthebigfndeal]

You feel the same way about the people allowing violent criminals to enter the country illegally, right?

[@jenniferjones1987]

Boomers deflecting the issue in 3…2…1…

[@your_being_led_by_your_nose]

Don’t “due”? Read a book.

[@justine7083]

Impeach Alito and Thomas.

[@winstonsmith8565]

I'm sure that any day now, the Biden administration will charge them each with at least 34 felonies

[@JasonDrvmz]

For what reason?

[@swimminginthoughts]

​@@JasonDrvmzBecause he hurts our feelings!

[@davidsonowski414]

Not Happening

[@kathyweis7451]

​@@JasonDrvmzcorruption, taking bribes....

[@user-ln3bd9gz5v]

Women and men’s health and lives should be respected equally. Women are not less of a life. Women’s votes count. Vote blue.

[@saltyshaker5069]

Black Women for Trump All Democrats do is lie

[@kathyweis7451]

Our vote doesn't count to Thommas and Alito....

[@maxalberts2003]

Fundamentalist "Christians" believe that biology is destiny, like it or leave....

[@EternalEyeofRa]

Abort the Supreme Court!

[@gilbertcanul996]

👍🏼

[@alisoncraig983]

Im appalled this is even an issue.

[@marblegal7372]

“Mistakenly posted”? And we’re supposed to believe that! The BIGGEST issue to the majority of Americans is Trump’s immunity situation, but SCOTUS keeps stalling. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not ignoring women's rights and our bodily choices. I’m just sick and tired of SCOTUS delays! Vote BLUE! 💙💙💙

[@Elmer.Mcscrotum.]

Supreme Court needs to stay out of our Doctor's office and our bedrooms. Vote blue.

[@jaydeshaw3394]

We said the same thing when you were forcing vaccines on us But you didn't care then

[@swimminginthoughts]

I agree, unless it's a vaccine, then everyone should be strapped down and forced to take it.

[@dcy665]

Cute picture. Well done.

[@gabrielhernandez6255]

Your ignorance is hilarious. 😂

[@MateoJoel-d8h]

😂😂 baby killer 😂😂

[@musicgodess80s]

Please...just like there was a "leak" when the overturned ROE....

[@lillianmatthew3880]

Democrats like to leak

[@barbaralouise_]

Well isn't that good of them. To ALLOW abortion in emergencies.

[@roseromans8497]

How and WHY do these things get posted in error??? The communications people should not have any documents to post until its official😡😠

[@EdgeOfNowhere2024]

It’s called accidentally on purpose . It’s a carefully orchestrated leak

[@spiceyhotpot]

@@stevebeegreat right, same as the Dobbs leak. Might have Alito's hands on it yet again, you'll know as he will be yelling the loudest about it.

[@dcy665]

@@EdgeOfNowhere2024 Roberts is guaging the political reaction. Of course, they used Dobbs to rout Roe V Wade regardless of Reproductive Rights and the removal of rights for over half of USA's citizens.

[@kimberlyaustin6677]

​@@stevebeegreatyou spelled Biden wrong. And yes, we will be celebrating bigly.

[@mickimicki]

A spam bot copied this comment.

[@johnbrowneyes7534]

To the maga base: Didn’t Republicans want SCOTUS to send this issue back to the States? You were thrilled about it. Well, you got what you wanted.

[@mrloanagentman]

Wow how progressive. AllowWomen to live ?

[@user-ln3bd9gz5v]

Security breaches at SCOTUS level is a national security threat. Treat it as such.

[@dcy665]

We need a real time balance of Alito's and Clarence's various bank balances. This one suspects that Crow will do direct deposits for individual cases.

[@Melrose51653]

Since when has the Court become a leaky sieve ?

[@christibrown5956]

???? Interesting given the overturning of Roe vs Wade is built around individual states making their own decisions.

[@janetmelton6890]

Whose chain are they yanking in Idaho? Subtle ping to someone!!!

[@jerryjerry7561]

lets divide America sommore! yay putin.

[@josephpeluchette191]

Right a mistake you mean grounds for mistrial from 9 cowards

[@FranklinWilson-ev9dq]

ACCIDENT, AGAIN??!! I DON'T, THINK SO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@johnbrowneyes7534]

This is to fool Americans that the conservatives aren’t that mean. All these opinions can be changed in the future.

[@RonnieTom]

FOR ALL MAMA OUT THERE VOTING FOR BLUES AND VOTE FOR WHO IS FIGHTING FOR ALL MAMAS OUT THERE AND PRODUCTS YOUR FREEDOM RIGHT AND SAVE YOUR HEALTH CARE AND THANKS FOR OUR GOD FATHER FOR HIS WONDERFUL GIFT 🎁 FOR ALL MAMA OUT THERE 💕, TOGETHER WILL SAVE FOR ALL MAMAS OUT THERE AND PROTECT FOR ALL MAMAS HEALTH CARE

[@lillianmatthew3880]

This MAMA is voting MAGA to keep my babies safe from Democrats

[@maxalberts2003]

Corruption in the Supreme Court? Say it isn't so!

[@jerryjerry7561]

scotus left it up to the states! are they saying whoopsie?

[@TylerDurden-yk4dh]

@@stevebeegreatwhat idea was right? It should be left to the states? or that the SCOTUS should intervene and override state decisions?

[@maryadams-vs1zk]

I control my own body and i will defend my body over anyone that tries to tell me what i can and can not do with my body. God gave me this body and free will, not stupid Republican politicians

[@KeithGordon-f8v]

for the umpteenth time can you tell Luke to stop yelling at me !!

[@commonsense3632]

Sounds like a lot of speculation. I would just wait for the actual facts before reporting on it.

[@lillianmatthew3880]

MSNBS reporting FACTS 😂😂

[@flashgordon6752]

States rights...push the FED out of the states!

[@jenniferhowser3252]

So you feel that it is Constitutional for Idaho to deny access to abortion care when the overcome will be permanent medical disability and permanent medical damage to patient? Weird flex.

[@michaelbogan3940]

Our Supreme Court is a pay for rulings clearing house. "I've got five on it"😢

[@evolutionistheflyingspaghe2702]

It’s compassionate and reasonable to assume every developing human still in the womb would be zealously pro life if given a voice!

[@SpecialSP]

Alito "accidentally" leaked his third decision. Ooooospie …

[@fletcherreed3259]

Kbj’s office again

[@marlo9380]

Disgusting

[@clive3490]

"Accidentaly"

[@carlosjauregui7951]

Vote red!

[@jaygibson5057]

Nope

[@TheErik249]

States need to decide on abortion. Stop wasting time.

[@jenniferhowser3252]

Before commenting, you should really read what this case is about because that was the issue. Idaho had passed the law where the only time you can get an abortion is if you’re going to die. Meaning permanent disability, and permanent medical damage was an acceptable outcome. It is unbelievably vile to think that a state has the right to subject women to hysterectomies rather than abortion care. To subject women to blood transfusions and kidney damage, liver damage, brain damage rather than abortion care.

[@jpan7071]

This was no accident, right Justices Alito and Thomas?

[@Dnn411]

OMYGAWD, these “far right conservatives” judges, biased, accepting grifts for quid pro quo influences are as conflicted, dumb, and biased as they appear.

[@markmierzejewski9354]

Jamaal Bowman needs moving boxes

[@mrmacq-jk4td]

he didnt lose his home, dude just the election

[@terrencekane8203]

Jamal Brown is in Congress until January. George Santos needs the moving boxes.

[@TylerDurden-yk4dh]

The article is about abortion. But here you are, all up in the kool aid but dont know the flavor

[@Elmer.Mcscrotum.]

How's Siberia?

[@dons3073]

Stop abortion

[@PenelopeHall-vl3gr]

Stop telling women what to do with their own bodies

[@EdgeOfNowhere2024]

I watching the Georgia international men’s soccer team on tv and I am appalled by the lack of diversity. They are all white Georgian men

[@joebloe923]

I'm so glad we only have 5 more months of Biden. Thank god.

[@Anonymous-cg1vo]

Dream on. Trump is going to lose just like he did in 2020. Buckle up!

[@Immaculatemessenger]

Only 5 months before Joe is re-elected; thanks to people who believe in the Rule of Law inherent in the U.S. Constitution.

[@RobertMcSherry]

That 8 million more votes for Brandon is going to turn into 16 million

[@joebloe923]

Yes, as a border processing agent, I tell all the people that cross that they have to vote for Trump if they want to see their family again.

[@saltyshaker5069]

@@Anonymous-cg1vo I'm voting for Trump to keep Democrat Men out of my daughters bathrooms and sports

[@Pickn4Gold]

The abortion case is a big deal, but we really should talk about how the Republican Appointed Justices just made bribing government officals legal.

[@Pickn4Gold]

@@BrattyBetty no, I want to talk about a more consequential case where they basically gave themselves freedom to be bribed. Are you ok with Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito taking more bribes legally to get rid of more of your rights? This Idaho abortion decision isn't the final decision its a leak, but the bribery case is now the law of the land.

[@williamblake827]

The only card left in the deck. Never saw that coming. 😂😂😂

[@markmierzejewski9354]

Fun fact, Bidenflation and open borders will decide the election 😂😂😂f j b

[@jerryjerry7561]

then its already decided! tell donny he lost, AGAIN

[@relentlessprofanity]

You don't know what "open borders " means.

[@vitalsigns2679]

​@@jerryjerry7561you enjoy inflation and imported welfare thieves?

[@andrewhcit]

Among the lowest inflation rates in the world at the moment? Sure, I'll take that.

[@alisoncraig983]

​@@andrewhcityou are so brainwashed

[@davidsonowski414]

Democrat spin and BS and GARBAGE on full display way to go MSDNC

[@Elmer.Mcscrotum.]

May want to get your trigger checked, it's really flaring up.

[@davidsonowski414]

Democrat spin and BS Propaganda and GARBAGE on full display Elmer deal with it ha ha ha ha

[@gab4690]

Bacteria is life on Mars, but a heartbeat isn't life on Earth? Weird

[@mickimicki]

Everything is weird if you're stupid enough

[@lillianmatthew3880]

Just at the beginning of the week There was a 100,000 women's march for abortion rights No one show up that's why they didn't talk about it after only before. This is how much abortion really means to women

[@Muttinchopsforever]

Women will show up at the voting booth and cast their ballot women know their bodily autonomy is on the line they will be voting blue

[@krankynstyns_lair]

What MSDNC knows could fit in a thimble....propagada machine....

[@TylerDurden-yk4dh]

FOXNews... 700 million dollar fine for lying. What's MSNBC's amount?

[@UglyAzzDonold]

Someone got fired.

[@linuxpatriot200]

Are we really supposed to believe that it was listed by mistake?

[@amydavis4945]

"Accidentally"?? LOL... Some clerk is about to lose their job.

[@user-ln3bd9gz5v]

Amy- This, as others leaks - is intentional. Politicians are playing RUSSIAN roulette with women’s lives!

[@Muttinchopsforever]

I still fully support a woman's right to choose her body her choice separation of church and state

[@lillianmatthew3880]

Good fight for it in your country Here in America it will be voted on at the State level so every woman has a voice

[@Muttinchopsforever]

​@@lillianmatthew3880Where am I from then you Maroon and why do you hate America

[@lillianmatthew3880]

@@Muttinchopsforever Oh Porkchop I'm not the American hater that would be you and You know you can't vote in our elections so why meddle in it B.T your granny is calling

[@pam7500]

Where is the baby's voice?

[@Muttinchopsforever]

​​@@lillianmatthew3880Oh i see you think i am B.T so wrong there's only one muttinchops forever and always what state do you live in Lilith?

[@shaystern2453]

they sure look inept

[@a.michelle9289]

See: "1851 French Coup D'etat"; President Louis-Napoleon's presidency would end in 1852 so he travelled the countryside garnering support from farmers & laborers then attacked protesters in a street in Paris killing over 300, wounding hundreds. Then he sent commanders throughout France arresting anyone suspected of opposing him - 28,000 people - who were exiled to Algeria and elsewhere. Then he crowned himself Emperor of France and became a dictator.

[@jenniferhowser3252]

The number of commenters that have no idea what this case was about is staggering. The Idaho law that was in question allowed for permanent disability and permanent medical damage as acceptable outcomes when denying abortion. Simply put, if denying the patient an abortion resulted in the patient hemorrhaging, losing the baby, and then requiring a hysterectomy that was acceptable. It was preventing doctors from providing stabilizing care for preeclampsia patients and other pregnancy complications. So all the pro lifers commenting on this video, if that is acceptable to you, you’re not pro life.

[@jasonweinstock1282]

I don't call them pro life..I call them pro birth

[@jenniferhowser3252]

@@jasonweinstock1282 totally. I can not understand why any decent human being would want to force a pregnant patient to experience permanent medical injury because of some BS. This is beyond extreme, it’s sadistic.

[@jasonweinstock1282]

@@jenniferhowser3252 I hear what you're saying..anti abortion/pro birth people and groups claim "oh, we're not forcing anyone to do anything"..if you read between the lines, though..

[@WayneMcCoy-wk8bs]

Another ALITO LEAK HUH😅

[@johnbrowneyes7534]

45: Women should be punished for abortions. (March 30, 2016)

[@nerissarowan8119]

Which is ironic when he has *allegedly* paid for abortions himself.

[@your_being_led_by_your_nose]

How inept and unprofessional.

[@joelclaus288]

Great to know that nine people in black robes get to decide what you have for medical care and treatment, ladies.

[@samschweder2524]

As a woman I have lost all faith in our government, to the point where I'm getting sterilized before that option gets taken away too.

[@Kiki-en9vm]

This will end if we vote blue ,top to bottom.

[@jaydeshaw3394]

TRUMP 2024!!! Keeping Democrat men out of our daughters bathrooms and sports

[@g11rfe87]

this is a left wing comedy we have seen before

[@jerryjerry7561]

scotus left it up to the states? what are they doing now? sorta leaving it up to the states? my! how legal!

[@Franimus]

We don't need laws or anything about abortion, as long as we acknowledge the truth that the unborn child's life is inherently just as valuable as any other person's life.

[@jenniferhowser3252]

@@Franimus so you support women being permanently medically disabled, and permanently medically damaged because of your view that you don’t think should be law? That’s a strange statement.

[@Franimus]

@@howardj602 Yes. The primary goal of capital punishment should be to protect others because someone dangerous cannot reasonably be contained. That should be a very rare case in modern developed countries. So in other words, even with the death penalty your goal should still be to save lives.

[@Franimus]

@@howardj602 Why, because we have a problem with convicts escaping prisons, or corrupt politicians releasing them? For all the issues plaguing the US, I don't think inability to contain someone to their sentence is one.

[@howardj602]

@@Franimus You mean like the 4 persons serving time in federal prison for murdering 17 Iraqi citizens that were pardoned by the former president. That kind of corrupt politician.

[@johnspindler9732]

It doesn’t change anything killing an innocent baby is murder

[@walterhoenig6569]

An embryo is not a baby.

[@jenniferjones1987]

You have no idea what this case was about do you?

[@jenniferhowser3252]

@@johnspindler9732 that was not what this case was about, but good try.

[@skylark1250]

The Court is sending a signal that will help Trump’s radical abortion rules. It’s also signaling they will side with Trump on immunity.

[@milehighgimpster]

Did Jamaal Bowman win? I know Lauren Boebert won her primary! FJB

[@TylerDurden-yk4dh]

Are they related? Is there a specific connection to Lauren and Jamal? You look desperate. But whatever helps you cope with 4 more years of Biden POTUS.