RTX Voice vs Krisp | Discord Noise Suppression

Check the latest prices of products featured in this video
Yeti X: geni.us/jvkN
Blue Compass: geni.us/F33Mc
Blue Radius III Shock Mount: geni.us/Pum7zw
Here I compare RTX Voice vs Discord's Krisp Noise Suppression Feature. Turns out, if you can use RTX Voice, it's a much better implementation and is a lot better sound q quality than Krisp.
RTX Voice on GTX GPUs: • RTX Voice on GTX GPUs ...
My KZbin Gear kit.co/SuprUsrStan
My Amazon Storefront: www.amazon.com/shop/suprusrstan

[@Gadekko]

I feel bad for the Krisp team. They launch their product and a couple of months later Nvidia makes Krisp look like a cheap knockoff.

[@SuprUsrStan]

It is what it is. The steady march of improvement.

[@walterferreira5756]

PLUS RTX voice works better even if loads a little bit the cpu

[@tienatho2149]

But it need RTX graphic card to be working. Krisp can work in any hardware

[@walterferreira5756]

@@tienatho2149 Nope. RTX voice works on GTX too. Not sure if works the same way

[@deadmeat1240]

Krisp is not going to make most of it's money selling to end-users anyway. The big money will be selling it to big companies to integrate it into apps. Discord is the start. Zoom, PS5 or XboxSX/Skype/Teams... I'll be surprised if they've not been bought by the end of the year by MS or some other big tech Co. While it may not work as well as RTXvoice, no special hardware makes it a simple value add for a MS or Sony to lock down to their platforms. For simple comms over the internet, it is more than sufficient and practically magic the first time you use it.

[@FatheredPuma81]

Just tried Krisp today in Discord and it's actually so much better than it was when it came out. It's kind of crazy. Before it sounded frankly awful compared to default Noise Suppression. Now it sounds actually pretty good although it cuts out too much background noise. I'm also unsure how it'll react if my dogs bark.

[@UnityTrap]

Thanks for the video dude! This helped wasn't sure if RTX Voice or Krisp were better. 🤓

[@MyWastedFantasy]

thank you for the video ! it was helpful :)

[@therealestice3780]

Thank you for this Video. Very helpful

[@MegaDubTV844]

Great Video! Stan, where did you get those wonderful looking speakers and stands?

[@SuprUsrStan]

Those are a pair of Adam A5X on Isoacoustic Aperta stands.

[@AlphaXY13]

Krisp has actually improved significantly, don't notice a major chance in voice quality and still doesn't catch my fan or keyboard. The fan part impresses me because this thing is basically a jet engine.

[@davidofug]

Thank you for this review. It will help me make a decision.

[@deadmeat1240]

I've been using the discord implementation for months and never had a problem with voice quality. Granted, I am usually just in one on one chats... So maybe that makes a difference. I also have a 3700x cpu, so that might make a difference too. I think the fact that it can be baked right into apps is it's killer use.

[@darktamer1089]

Krisp from what I've witnessed is surprisingly good, sure it slightly messes with voices a little bit, but the fact that it removes fan and keyboard noises even with my friends having their microphone close and behind their keyboards is insane (Blue Yeti and Razer Seiren Mini). I could only hear keyboard noises if my friends speak and use their keyboard at the same time.

[@OskarSvan]

This whole thing feels like an intergalactic tv thing

[@cesarfonseca4922]

I have not been able to intall RTX. I have a computer with windonws 10 Ryzen 5, AMD, and I could not install RTX, but it was very simple to do it with krisp. I would like to test RTX but I did not find any solution to the "unable to start microphone denoising" situation with RTX Nvidia.

[@humanz8681]

yo this video made me realise i could download krisp lmao thx

[@FateSoulzZ]

I really want to love rtx voice but sometimes it just makes my mic produce a loud af ear rape static noise (it comes randomly, more likely during startup), so fuck that.

[@fuss1ion392]

its really clear

[@JerryFlowersIII]

I wonder if Krisp has changed much since this video Bigger question is if I wonder enough to do the testing myself or just swap to RTX Voice

[@Kmmc2011]

Hi Stan, is RTX also able to suppress the loud noise of a mechanical keyboard? I want to day one for work but I'm on zoom calls all day & don't want to drive others nuts

[@SuprUsrStan]

Yes.

[@Veleenia]

How does krisp compares to iOS voice isolation mic mode?

[@papasquib]

I'm still looking for someone to show if there is a hit to the sound quality when there is no background noise for both of these. It seems like the more noise there is in the background, the worse it gets, so I'm curious when there is little to no background noise if you can tell the difference between noise suppression being on or off.

[@TheGreatCoolykoen]

I haven't tested with Krisp, but i can tell you that when there's little to no background noise, the mic sounds pretty much exactly the same with RTX voice on or off. Ofcourse there will be people who notice a difference, but me listening back to a recording to specifically test that one thing... i feel like it is so tiny thats its easily a negligible difference. Hope that answers atleast part of your question ^^

[@papasquib]

@@TheGreatCoolykoen cool thanks for the reply, I'll have to look into it some more

[@chisaki38]

the only issue i ran into with rtx voice was that it detected my laugh as background noise and made it robotic. but other than thats its pretty superb quality noise gate

[@romanbart]

RTX Voice now works with any GeForce GPU.

[@xvnbm]

Running it with GTX 970 in my computer. This is pretty awesome actually. I think I will go for stand-alone mic instead of headset because of this.

[@freddietwo3418]

@@xvnbm how did u get it for your gtx for me it wont

[@xvnbm]

@@freddietwo3418 There are different links for RTX (NVIDIA Broadcast) and for GTX (RTX Voice) on Nvidia's page. "nvidia-rtx-voice-setup-guide". I think I just downloaded that and then installed it. You have to select your audio devices from the RTX Voice application after you have installed it.

[@gamersanditparadise]

So is there any difference in voice quality between rtx gpus and gtx gpus? Like 3080 vs 1650?

[@Gremlor]

@@gamersanditparadise using it on 1650 now. in my next video I'll be using it, so if you want to hear a difference between now and before you can watch and old vid or sum and compare it to the vid I make tomorrow. yes shameless self promo, but at least It's relevant... somewhat.

[@Anonymous-eo2ey]

Good I was trying to call someone on call

[@JumboFe1337]

Can you use RTX Voice for game chat mic?

[@omar2886]

Thanks for the video, what about this on Mac?

[@SuprUsrStan]

I haven't tried. The mac doesn't have RTX or GTX cards so I guess you have to use the built in noise suppression function in discord.

[@JennFrank]

Krisp sounds freakin' amazing on my MacBook Air-like, good enough for recording voiceovers. For some reason, though, Krisp just didn't sound as clear on my PC (!), so I actually use RTX Voice on one and pay for a subscription to Krisp on the other. (Krisp on Mac also sounds better than voice filtered through Audio Hijack, whereas RTX Voice has far less distortion than either RNNoise or the Reaper noise-learning VST, to my ear.) In any case, if you want your voice to sound clear on a Mac, you'll likely end up having to pay for the software you use. No cool free stuff like with a PC.

[@savion521]

For game chat would you just need to set the mic to the program being used?

[@TheMondi21]

yes, the source will appear as "Microphone (NVIDIA Broadcast)"

[@lce_Poseidon]

have they updated krisp? i don't notice any reduction in voice quality with krisp on/off

[@SuprUsrStan]

It’s been a while since I did the tests. They might have improved it since. 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@robert4124]

So is rtx voice better?

[@mgtowstanleyzoltanov9808]

Does it work while driving on phones

[@Matthew.1994]

RTX voice crashes as soon as i click the remove checkbox

[@j-cuts9396]

as of feb 22 of 2023 Krisp option in discord literally does nothing. its the same if its on or off

[@grandam.]

I use crisp on discord And for voice chat In game I use nivida broadcast

[@DonteWilsonChrisDorner]

I used to use RTX voice but it always fucked up. Sometimes I'd sound like a robot. It'd turn off. Never worked right with Nvidia shadowplay, and it would use like 30% of my 2080. And now I can't even install Krisp. "installation ended prematurely" or some shit.

[@jeremiahk364]

Bruh. Amd better make their version of rtx voice. Or I will cry

[@GLMidnight]

Or NVIDIA should make RTX Voice available for any GPU

[@notel0ck104]

@@GLMidnight it is, it is just buggy

[@GLMidnight]

@@notel0ck104 Can confirm, my CPU hates RTX Voice

[@socialreject2156]

@@GLMidnight Nvidia love to make their stuff close source so nobody else can use them, it's pretty selfish but it is their technologies, they can do whatever they want with it i guess

[@kokoybato4267]

Rtx voice takes up too much of my ram (i have 16gb). It bothers my audio sometimes in games. It used to be good, I don't know what changed,I haven't really done any updates recently.

[@ICEMAN_GLX]

Mine was using almost 2gb I had to let it go

[@dxnwalker]

Nvidia Broadcast(what it's called now) seems to be GPU intensive too. Will give Krisp a try soon!

[@portman8909]

Get 32 gb then

[@sunnydays1238]

Which chair do you use?

[@SuprUsrStan]

Herman Miller Embody.

[@VisibleMRJ]

did anyone accidentally turned the rtx noise on while listening to this video? it got rid of all the ambience noise in this video lol.

[@ozziepilot2899]

I was very disappointed with Krisp. NVIDA Broadcast is superior but what is not well known is that the process should be set in Task Manager with a priority of Realtime and Broadcast is now perfect for my recording. (Running on an RTX-2070) - You'll get random crackling in the audio if the process is not Realtime!

[@evenrik_2214]

Great tip, Paul, thank you!

[@Obbss]

What about if I have a amd gpu

[@SilverScarletSpider]

Do Krisp and RTX Voice work well together? Or does it end up being worse when both are applied?

[@IronSwordRBLX]

rtx voice is enough

[@Magmaa2169]

I do actually use both at once and haven't had any issues.

[@yevolution]

I know I'm super late to this but I think it's better if you just use one. Aside from you using two separate extra voice processing software that put unnecessary extra loads or task on your computer , you will also find that your audio will not be good, since it will be too muffled if you let it pass through 2 suppressions at the same time which will also make your voice input lag.

[@Rain-kw1bn]

Nvidia just change their system requirement it's not compatible with older ones, I wanted to use one 😢 for work

[@erictyson7656]

okay, yea

[@RealRoboKnight]

Too bad I have Radeon, besides that, the Discord version of Krisp is probably better than the downloadable version of Krisp in my own personal opinion

[@TriWaZe]

Surprisingly I find Krisp in Discord works a lot better as for removing the PC fan noise I have. Granted Im using a GTX 1080 rn and not an RTX card but im able to whisper in Discord and it picks me up fine. Where as with RTX Voice I have to set it to like almost 70% to eliminate the fan noise and at that level it cuts out my whispering and any words that arent loud enough which just turns me off from wanting to use it. Although it does limit down my keyboard and other background noises a little better, none of that is really my concern. Problem I have is if I want to use Krisp in OBS it seems I have to route RTX Voice through Krisp in order for it to work. It doesn't work straight routing my Apollo Twin. Strange. And Krisp costs money...

[@TriWaZe]

Krisp app makes my voice sound really processed too. It sounds really good in Discord. Lame.

[@reinaldo1504]

rtx voice is the best.

[@HyDRoTheTrickShotter]

Crazy that RTX Voice is free and that Krisp costs money (You only get 120 free minutes per week without paying). IMO RTX Voice does a much better job.

[@SuprUsrStan]

I’d argue that RTX Voice isn’t free, because you’re just paying upfront for the feature. You’re shelling out top dollar for a RTX GPU and buying into the ecosystem. That said it’s a nice little bonus if you already have the hardware.

[@HyDRoTheTrickShotter]

@@SuprUsrStan Ye I guess. just expressed my opinion from a PC gamer perspective in which basically all PC gamers have a graphics card that will make RTX voice work (also assuming you bypass the RTX requirement of the installation process). Can you still use RTX voice if you don't have a separate gpu and only use a cpu with integrated graphics? would it not work if the cpu didn't have a integrated gpu? Or does it just make the cpu do all the processing instead then? I'm using rtx voice on my 1060 gpu btw :)

[@Bizzn1z]

@@SuprUsrStan I agree, Krisp is very useful for users without access to an Nvidia GPU (mainly notebooks with iGPUs). RTX Voice is surprisingly easy to run on modern Nvidia hardware. It runs well on my laptop's MX330 which is basically a GT 1030 with higher clocks, and is perfect for conference calls and such. Sure, the fans will kick in from time to time but it's nothing to worry about.

[@choojunwyng8028]

RTX Voice as of now isn't fully optimized yet I believe. At least, they haven't perfected it with low-end Geforce cards. When I play Valorant on minimum settings while streaming to discord with RTX voice on, my mic sounds like I am underwater and constantly cuts out. I have a GTX1650 and i39100f setup, so its not even like my PC is a bad one. I even know some people who have this same problem on high end PCs with cards like RTX 20 or 30 series.

[@lukasvideosify1596]

THe actual problem with Krisp is that you can only use it for 120 minutes a week i the free version.

[@dryft7906]

What if I use both? >:D

[@ma-tanica]

With RTX voice I get "unable to start microphone denoising" all the time ;(

[@xXRenaxChanXx]

Not just muffled but it also sounds extremely distorted. Like dropping from a 256kbps+ mp3 to 64kbps. Yuck!

[@memeperor_]

eh, i don't think there's really any software out there to do the job without butchering the quality of sound. unless you wanna use VST plugins which requires something like streamlabs which milks 50% of your CPU so u can't really use it unless u have a beast desktop

[@seri7890]

I don't know what has happened for me personally, but the Noice Supression of Krisp has gotten progressively worse and worse over time, where when I talk it just randomly cuts me off mid sentence. Been using RTX-Voice ever since.

[@InSaiyanShinobi]

is it possible to run rtx voice through voicemeeter like a vst plugin?

[@Alstarpig]

yes but not as a vst plugin. It's easier than that. Just use rtx voice like u normally use it then in voice meter select rtx voice instead of your microphone.

[@fuss1ion392]

Maybe cuz your not using your mic??

[@Ortagonation]

How about bitrate? I mean discord bit rate is so optimized that you get a clear sound chat even at worst connection...

[@fuss1ion392]

for me krisp is nice???

[@IsThatDrak]

so if you have geforce go with RTX, if you have radeon go with Krisp and cry lol

[@laggmonstret]

What happen with your LG screen? Looks empty on your desk man!

[@marbox_onyx]

Wait can it runs on a GT 1030?

[@FPSWizard]

Nice video. Enjoy your work. Just did a vid on the same 38” LG monitor too. Shoot me some feedback. Would love that. Keep up the great work!

[@Marcos_Guitar]

RTX sounds better to me

[@firestriker3580]

It’s not a better q sound quality than crisp

[@Cynthesis21]

It's considerably better than krisp.

[@TriWaZe]

@@Cynthesis21 Not for straight PC fan noise. Krisp > RTX Voice.

[@boraylmaz2456]

Krisp is so soo bad. People can't understand what u re saying when speaking in discord.

[@RealRoboKnight]

I don't think I have trouble with it on Discord

[@typicaltestr1801]

It's prob that just for your mic?

[@wnnd6]

it makes more noise for me when its on lol

[@whiskeythesmoker]

b

[@dilayyilmaz4254]

this is suck dont used