Taemin proving he can't sing for 8 whole minutes

[@shineeingstars]

If this video gets blocked by KBS or SM AGAIN, I'm gonna sue someone. 🙃💕Anyways, don't forget to stream 2 KIDS by Taemin on Genie, spotify, KZbin etc it'll really help to boost his reputation. Let's show him our endless love and support. ❤

[@Auntie67]

Thank you!!!!! Can I post it on Twitter???

[@shineeingstars]

@@Auntie67 Of course. You don't need to ask. I'm always happy to have my content shared. 😊

[@SandraFernandezMX]

SUE SM A** WE DO IT TOO,JUST ASK (IG SANDRA148FC)

[@Kboxxfinessecrewtv]

What song @ 4:56

[@AisingioroDior]

@@Kboxxfinessecrewtv "I'm Crying" from his 1st japan album "Flame of Love"

[@_exists717]

If taemin can't sing y'all can't breath BIE

[@alexnik5132]

+++ 100% Agree

[@alexnik5132]

@@shamilbinanam7667 wdym? I have already voted for him

[@alexnik5132]

@@shamilbinanam7667 why are you calling me kid though

[@alexnik5132]

@@shamilbinanam7667 don't guess when there's no photos, at least. I have been shawol since 2009

[@rheaarora720]

Agreed!!

[@ziwei7278]

taemin and shinee walk so the rest could run

[@franklin13_17]

for their careers 👌

[@mikeya6100]

Say it louder for the people in the back

[@taoxist]

tvxq: CHANGMIN SAENGIL CHUKKHAMDA

[@Marc-rx5xg]

And he's running in Super M, too

[@sunflowersandroses2521]

Obama only stans talent 😔

[@iffahahmad3442]

Not only he can sing, but he's stable af. His range is quite impressive too. like. wow. IMAGINE DEBUTED AS A DANCER AND HAVE A VOCAL LIKE THAT

[@mandarineuijoo]

EXACTLYYY especially considering his huuuge improvement since his singing really wasn't too good when shinee debuted

[@iffahahmad3442]

@@mandarineuijoo Ikr. He's an all rounder 😭

[@Lena-zn4re]

People saying he can’t sing? He was taught by Jonghyun, one of the best and emotional singers in the industry. Even when he’s doing intense choreography he’s still stable. But I mean, haters are going to hate even if they personally go to a live concert and hear the sound coming straight out of their mouthes, there’s no point in trying to have a rational conversation with irrational people.

[@Ace-pp7et]

I showed someone this and they were shook no kid

[@enterchannelname4989]

1:35 what song is this?

[@404-s5x]

"whispering on a track does not qualify a person as a good vocalist" well surely they haven't heard about how much impact taemin's whispers on superm's 100 it was pretty much the highlight of that song

[@j.c8426]

FUCK, HIS PARTS ON THAT SONG GOT ME

[@elivile.]

But isn't that what Billie Eilish does? Hmmm... I love her. Don't be mad at me!

[@marginereyes3083]

periodt

[@promisen8460]

Fr tho as soon as i heard it it blew me away lol

[@alliekerli]

HONESTLYYYY LMAO

[@serionbee8586]

For people who's wondering what makes Taemin so great? He's never stop learning. His thirst for improvement and perfectness are endless. Even until today, he's still receiving vocal lessons to keep growing and growing and keep challenging himself with various styles. That is the mental of GREAT ARTIST. When you stop learning and think that you're on top of the world, you are done. Taemin set his foot on the ground and keep growing higher and higher.

[@alynnshortcakes]

And how he is so humble. He's still the same Taemin from 2008.

[@goff_tj]

jevousvoiv You would think with all the success he has had both with Shinee and as a solo artist that he would change even a little bit, but no, he is the same 15 year old dork he has always been. Just in a grown ups body. I love him.

[@claragameplayssauro4160]

from what i know, singers cannot stop receiving vocal lessons, otherwise they singing kind of get worse?? (pls, correct me if i am wrong) but i agree with you, taemin is such a humble and talented king.

[@lilyovererrantjam9397]

@@claragameplayssauro4160 They can stop receiving lessons, but they have to keep up with all their exercises and so on. Of cource you need to be very confident in said exercises. You don't need to learn new things to maintain your voice.

[@claragameplayssauro4160]

@@lilyovererrantjam9397 aaaah, now i get it. thank you!

[@faithcheam]

imagine trying to discredit 1 of the 5 princes of kpop??? i surely can't relate

[@rebloodcrimson8160]

Say it louder so ppl can hear it in the back!? 🥰😋

[@Erlender]

Poor people must be stressful

[@magroves]

That's probably it is when he debuted he was so young and not nearly the strong singer is he now, but mostly compared to Onew, Key and Jonghyun who were such developed singers. His bandmates were just too good and people compared him to them

[@brxnd1s]

princes needs to be changed to legends 😔

[@user-wp2fu4ck3o]

Say it louder!!

[@kibumspersonalhandcream4597]

instead of his dancing skill, his singing skill also leave people breathless. but what we can do, some people are dumb which shows.

[@amandax1025]

Hi, I understand what you're trying to say here but "deaf and dumb" is actually an extremely offensive term for those who ARE Deaf. Please try using a different phrase.

[@ava_ruth_wagner]

Amanda Palmer, why they are saying that the haters are deaf *and* dumb not that deafs are dumb

[@kibumspersonalhandcream4597]

@@amandax1025 omg i didn't notice this, mind if i edit this comment 😣

[@amandax1025]

@@ava_ruth_wagner Using deaf as an insult is actually ableist on its own, especially because many people who are Deaf are proud of it. That plus the phrase "deaf and dumb" having an insulting historical context, it's just best not to say it at all. :)

[@amandax1025]

@@kibumspersonalhandcream4597 Thank you so much for editing it! I know you had no negative intentions, things like that can slip by the best of us.

[@cki614]

Some people can't see that Taemin has been covering Jonghyun's part when he's not around. And let me remind those people who said that Taemin can't sing, Jonghyun's part are usually high!

[@whatever6701]

Taemin and Jonghyun have sort of a similar vocal register (although Jonghyun could go a lot higher) and style imo. I love the color of their voices it gives me goosebumps

[@valentinavilla1262]

can u please tell me the name of the song in the minute 4:19??

[@whatever6701]

@@valentinavilla1262 rise

[@itadorkyy1963]

@@valentinavilla1262 taemin - rise.

[@cki614]

@@hi1511 yesss!

[@samia399]

Taemin is more than just a dancer, he is also a great singer. Not many male Idols that beside being a amazing dancers are well- rounded like him and usually lack in singing. That’s why he is a legendary male solo artist, a role model to many younger idols and their favorite main dancer is not.

[@valentinavilla1262]

can u please tell me the name of the song in the minute 4:19??? 🙏🏽

[@TAEMXCLUSIVE]

@@valentinavilla1262 Rise by Taemin

[@gauthierpatricia2571]

Absolument raison

[@shawona6891]

Taemin will always be shawol‘s “soldier“ of pure talent

[@yoorukey]

here is the list of the songs in case anyone needs it! 0:43 Ju Hyunmi - Hold On 0:49 Kim Gunmo - Wrongful Meeting 0:56 Patty Kim - After April Goes By 1:05 Park Chunseok - Mapo Terminal those four songs above were his covers for a show called Immortal Songs 2. 1:11 SHINee - Selene 6.23 1:23 SHINee - Everybody 1:34 Taemin - Ace 1:42 Taemin - Drip Drop 1:51 Taemin - Soldier 2:14 Taemin - Tiger 2:23 Taemin - Love 2:40 Taemin - Hypnosis 2:53 Taemin - Sayonara Hitori 3:05 UV x Taemin - You Are My Standard 3:15 SHINee - Colors of the Season 3:27 SHINee - Everybody 3:35 SHINee - Stranger 3:47 SHINee - Juliette 4:01 SHINee - Lucifer 4:15 Taemin - Rise 4:55 Taemin - I'm Crying 5:49 Taemin - Sekai De Ichiban Aishita Hito 6:43 Taemin - Hypnosis 7:39 Taemin - 2 KIDS

[@DokSagwa]

oh, thank you

[@Adriana-kv2cs]

Thank you so much I was about to cry thinking I was never gonna know what these songs were called 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@MOONJIN7]

Taemin and solider is so good

[@saraSara-lo1zo]

thank u so much

[@sofiacabezas2239]

Omg thank you!!!! T-T

[@Empyrean.127]

To my knowledge, he’s the only person in SM who had his positions changed to include main vocalist. Main vocalist and main dancer is a very unique combo; the only other two vocalists from SM that I know that hold similar positions are f(x)‘s Luna (lead dancer, main vocalist) and Red Velvet’s Seulgi (main dancer, lead vocalist). Goes to show his work ethic, very impressive.

[@mfkimkai]

Lay is lead vocalist n main dancer too.. He used to be lead vocal of exom

[@Sophie-bc4cr]

Ten is also a main vocalist and the main dancer in wayv. Talented kings!!

[@samzenzuu1507]

Taeyong is also main rapper and main dancer, love it

[@CR-vs5jo]

@@samzenzuu1507 mark too

[@user-ib1is7ny7r]

@@samzenzuu1507 main dancer + rapper positions is a bit more common but taeyong also has a very nice voice to go with it

[@juliaballaron2684]

This video is such a flex. Taemin has grown so much, in every aspect of his career, but especially with his singing... its not his fault they debuted him too early! He's said it himself in many an interview that he felt that he wasn't ready to debut quite yet. But now we have this brilliant performer and artist 💗 Been a proud Shawoll since 2008 and Taemin bias too. So proud of our boi ☺

[@TY_Track]

I cant stand these kids who disrespect 1st and 2nd gen idols who literally paved the way. Yes, some groups nowadays are much more popular than maybe shinee was but the reason why they are so big is because of legends like Taemin and Big Bang and Shinee and Super Junior. Y'all need to take several seats and respect the legends who paved the way for these talented younger artists. (Same goes with girl groups and of course there are more legendary 1st and 2nd gen idols but im not gonna list all of them)

[@JazmineKiller]

YES!!!!! I will forever go on about all these amazing older groups being the absolute best. There may be a lot of new groups I love, but the way Big Bang made me fall in love with kpop, the way SHINee and Super Junior were instantly recognized when I returned to kpop after a few years amongst others... I could cry that some people just don't get to understand that joy I feel just reminiscing 😌😌😌 we are lucky to recognize greatness

[@logic-jessica1364]

For that one person who commented that his group (SHINee) can't really chart, sis, we're talking about legends here. They've literally imprinted their legacy on K-pop and set the standard for all following kpop groups. Charting is just a small indicator of their success, not really a huge deal to be honest.

[@corneliaseptyani]

I personally think their style really gave impact to kpop nowadays. They really have 'brave' style if I am not mistaken since I was following them since 2010 or so. Previously the clothing style, hair style of kpop boyband is not like today's style, they seems more just... black, white something, mostly showing manly side, not so many boyband wearing colorful cloths, at that time Shinee being brave by showing different style. Many people might forget about this. I personally think they are legend. About talent.. they always great, they didn't waste every single member's talent.

[@Shawol___Atiny]

Right? Also... "can't chart"??? Like... they literally had to bam their songs from students because they were too good and distracted them from studying and made them fail their college entrance exams? Bitch what? Stop clowning on yourself LOL

[@masochisticdoll]

They charting rn with Atlantis 🥱

[@user-ib1is7ny7r]

the fact that they think charting on the US means anything lmao, the US isn’t the world. nothing changes the fact that SHINee is legendary

[@anetann5024]

Just because some new sprouts have come that doesn't mean that the forever SHINee is over... SHINee is FOREVER... and it is meant to be... just like in 2kids those who are looking down on SHINee are "just too young and dumb" to know it.

[@emilyjohn6444]

oohhhhhh preach

[@janetlane2364]

P

[@peytonsharp6159]

sNAP oFF sistA 🙌👏👏👏

[@AE4G97]

What always fascinated me about his vocals is that he wasn't born with a voice like a lot of other idols. He had to work hard and practice for days on end for years to learn how to master his voice and learn his strengths since his voice is so unique. That's one of the reasons that makes him an Ace in kpop in my opinion. His dedication to everything he does is nothing short of amazing and every performance I watch I am just more and more amazed and in awe of his talents and stage presence. Anyone who says these things about Taemin clearly no nothing about real talent. Lol.

[@Odorobol6v6]

Taemin is the best. His vocal control is the best I have seen.

[@shineeeer]

I've been a Shawol since 2009, you can see that he improved A LOT since debut. From singing minor parts to getting more lines, and having a solo. He definitely worked hard to be where he is right now. HE EARNED IT. HE DESERVES IT. Our angel, Taemin's #1 fan, must be so proud and smiling down from heaven. I am so proud of him, all of the shawols are. Can't wait for him to be reunited with his hyungs, and be a baby again ♥️

[@leanott]

since 2009? you're so loyal 😂 congratulations

[@shineeeer]

@@leanott yes 😊 since the Juliette era

[@janya2545]

Well I wish I could HV been since debut but I was just 1 year old when they debut

[@janya2545]

I stanned on 2012 first group first song was replay

[@janya2545]

@@celined2031 hehe

[@pudeongi]

taem’s voice is so distinct, different and amazing, you can instantly tell it’s him singing. it’s one of a kind, no one sounds like him, his style is unique, his range, his tone.. its all something you hear and instantly think “this is taemin”... it’s not his fault your favs all sound the same 🤷‍♀️ he has so much passion in his voice, you can feel the strong emotions he’s trying to let out. not to mention the story of HOW he’s gotten his vocals to this level, name a more hardworking person.. i’ll wait

[@goff_tj]

Real talk, I was watching a kpop related video and I heard a song I had never heard before in the background, and my first thought was “is that Taemin?” It was.

[@Tara-pp1xo]

his natural timbre is breathy and soft, but that doesn't mean he's whispering LOL he can belt in every part they give him so I don't see what the problem is, I love how it sounds!

[@sashaholland3360]

I feel emotional listening to him sing, people really don’t know this man. He is a precious person who can make anyone breathless and emotional from his voice and dancing. He is multi talented and people who disagree really haven’t lived. Thank you for uploading this! Shawol from the Uk

[@faeriegraver]

Hope you're coping with the heat wave okay! I'm also in the UK. I also agree with everything you said.

[@sashaholland3360]

@@faeriegraver Ahhh! It's nice for you to reply. I'm not doing too bad with the heatwave, how are you coping and thank you for agreeing with me. SHINee will always be my favourite regardless and especially Taemin ^v^

[@riverbobbielove3722]

Thing is- when he debuted he couldn’t sing! He was known for being “tone deaf” but he worked his ass off and took notes from his members and teachers and peers and oh my god did he prove himself. I’m so proud of him for making his voice work for him and defying the odds. You can hear who his influences are (especially bling bling) clearly and you can tell how much effort he puts into it and for me that’s so much more appreciated than someone who was born with a “good” voice and stayed at the same level their whole career with no intentions of improving.

[@Jiwon-e9r]

While Taemin: "I (even) like someone who hates me. I guess they might dislike someone because they love someone else a lot, and I think the one they like would be someone I like too. So I like people who hate me." Look at how generous he is. He does not even care about haters lol... literally one of the most genuine artists ever👏👏👏

[@Cia6v6]

Im ready to clock any Taemin or SHINee anti’s 👊

[@staybin1941]

Yes. Me too

[@Sunshine_Ses]

Oh same!

[@shawolblue5718]

Im really surprised that taemin has haters?? Like he is literally the most lovable person in the world? Im guessing theyre just jealous their faves arent getting the recognition.

[@ophirelda3368]

@@shawolblue5718 I agree it's because of Jealousy. Jealous of the fact their faves are not as talented as Taemin. I mean he has artistic vision and is musically gifted. It's unique to him, maybe because he also has a brilliant mind.

[@brooke978]

People who actually think he can’t sing obviously haven’t listened to his solo b-sides on his Eps because he’s actually a skilled singer.

[@goff_tj]

Right! Even is Shinee songs you can hear it. I always think of his part in Sleepless Night. If you listen to that song and still think he can’t sing, I don’t know how to help you.

[@Heartbeatzofficial]

The way he took over Jonghyuns parts is really impressive but also 😥

[@ashm003]

The soldier clip gave me so many goosebumps

[@mickeydahab3144]

"taemin can't sing" is literally the dumbest shit i've ever heard, it literally took one song for me to recognise his talent and that was way before i knew who he is. whoever said that is either lazy or just hateful, taemin has a beautiful, powerful voice he moves me to tears every time i hear rise or love

[@escritora84]

Bless you! Can you do one for Minho too, I feel like he's severely underrated.

[@shineeingstars]

This is a recycled video which I am re-uploading because the last one got blocked a few months ago so I did a little bit of changes to it rn. I am currently busy with school so if I have the time I will definitely do one for Minho. ❤

[@progamermyauml8567]

@@shineeingstars that is very nice. Shawol fighting 💙💙💙💎💎💎💎

[@julissarosales9498]

omgg yess his voice in from now on live 😍😍

[@paragupadhyaya9216]

This is same for all SM artists --- even rappers are really great singers (just underrated)

[@Heartbeatzofficial]

Baritones in kpop don’t get their shine

[@piagebot2943]

Shinee walked so your 3rd generation “oppars” can run and y’all must never forget that

[@MandySam13]

This comment is underrated! SHINee set the bar. To this date no one can match them for performance or song quality. Period!

[@leonerdmccoy]

when he said he was the ace of kpop he did not stutter

[@dancewithbhavyaaggarwal]

Where did he say that?

[@dancewithbhavyaaggarwal]

Where did he say that?

[@katiclystic4171]

Someone recently asked me why I "thirst" for this man so much for this man and I had to explain that I although his physical image and style o very attractive I'm absolutely enamored with his passion. This man came up from being considered a really bad singer to wowing crowds into silence, something which, if you know fans of anything when they're in a concert it is a rare experience to have an all silenced crowd and have it be for a good reason. This man does not give up on perfecting his form, his movement, his vocal, his character and even his discipline. I don't think he will ever stop wanting to be the best he can be. He's always learning. There's something so fiercely appealing about a man who just wants to be their very best 100 percent of the time! Like God damn, do you know how much dedication that takes?? Like the way he moves and sings, it looks and sounds effortless... Like. Just take the song Move and try to mimick his flow. I have yet to see a dancer who can look as attractive and smooth as taemin. He makes every song and dance his to a point when you look at someone else copy it it can look wonderful but it still doesn't hold to Taemin's performance. He is the type of man who will give you soft vibes that break the stereo typical mold for men in music who aren't being pushed out as feminine or androgynous. He can also be very bold and cocky (in like the nicest way, which is like fucking refreshing) and take on the persona of a string male lead... And he is all these things but at his core he is so humble and still so much like a child. And he doesn't even always feel like he deserves praise when in reality he has the absolute right to be cocky and proud of his skills. But instead he just wants to show his art form and is content with just getting any chance to be on stage doing what he loves. And I know this is a rant, but like, if loving a man's passion and dedication to his life long goals is being thirsty or fangirly then bet your ass I'm thirsty for the man who sings songs like Thirsty and switches over to Soldier so easily. Like, I'm rarely emotional over people I don't know but this guy gets me fired up because he truly deserves to be seen in an absolute positive light. Okay I'm done. Thank you for coming to my ted talk! ✌🏼💛

[@Auntie67]

I absolutely loved your Ted talk, cause you’ve very nicely expressed everything I feel and think about Taemin and basically why I love him so much. Thank you for this great rant :)

[@katiclystic4171]

@@Auntie67 thank you for the kind words and I'm so glad more people see Taemin in such a light. I looked back at my original comment and realized it's stuffed with typos, I'm sorry! 😅 But thank you!

[@briannayoung2800]

I'm not even going to lie, I know Taemin is an amazing singer, but I sat here with my jaw on the floor like I've never heard him sing before

[@brandyjohnson738]

I mean if they're from SM there automatically going to be good at singing. Because I said is known for their vocals and they're not going to have somebody who doesn't have a lease an inch of potential in singing

[@wendyhockett608]

Most beautiful voice 🎉Best singer in K-Pop.

[@amanix10]

The reason Taemin can get away with having that sensual, whisper-y vibe to his songs is because it is COMMON KNOWLEDGE that he is an incredible singer. He doesn't have to prove it, because his entire career starting from SHINee proved it.

[@mjj1434]

The sweetness when the fans sang along - red outfit

[@Damidee]

Me falling in love with his soothing voice before realizing he’s actually shinee’s lead dancer. He’s so well grounded

[@michaelshoney]

*main dancer

[@Anonymous-mo7jz]

Humans need to understand that Taemin is GREAT and SUPER TALENTED than most out there because he was consistent! You can see the improvement from 2008 to present. It’s a consistent massive improvement. He is one of the most hardworking. Idols stating that Taemin is their role-model is because they know how difficult it is to be him. His talent is unmatched, you can’t find a legendary dancer who can sing flawlessly. He is an ACE, period!

[@robinmaze2770]

Taemin is shinee baby I don’t think his hyung will let him do solo if he can’t sing! His president fan which is jonghyun is a lead vocalist and his father image jinki also has a good vocal range what about key and minho Versatile performance rap acting dancing and vocal and he his their babies.. those who think he can’t sing is literally insane!

[@JustASHINeegirl25]

Jjong is a main vocalist

[@christinetirimon4232]

Not only was Taemin trained by our very own jonghyun but he also really stepped up to the plate after his passing. I’m so proud of our boy and how hard he’s worked 🥰💗

[@paulineedwards8697]

If a artist or group are not to your taste,then move on to something you like,i really don't understand why people feel they have to put hateful comments,if I don't like something I listen to something else, simple really.

[@alynnshortcakes]

Same here. I just ignore things I don't want to see. Why do they even waste their time to watch something they don't even like and post hateful comments. Sick.

[@zz5219]

Its either wants attention or simply jealous.

[@alynnshortcakes]

Z Z that's exactly the part which I don't and will never understand🤷🏻‍♀️

[@또찬스-v3d]

When they debut, taemin didn't really have so much confidence in singing. He improve more and more thanks to jonghyun. Till now, we can hear a bit of jonghyun in the way taem sing. Just like tame say, he wanted to sing like jonghyun

[@MandySam13]

When listening to Kiss Kiss from the new album you can hear this one harmony and then refrain that Taemin sings and for 1 second it sounded so much like Jonghyun I had to replay. Then I saw others commenting on it & realised they heard it too! Jonghyun must be so proud of Taemin!

[@hiitsdahee9400]

I recently watched a video of Adrian McKinnon talking about how great of an artist Taemin is. I think he said something like "taemin didnt see himself as a great singer but HE IS. He doesnt show it all the time but when he actually uses all his power, he's very good at it". That's not exactly what he said but pretty close to that. Point is, those who criticized taemin's vocal ability usually knows no shit about music and the art of performance. Those who know, well they know how amazing taemin is.

[@hiitsdahee9400]

And good singing isnt just about hitting the high notes. With the dance and everything, taemin still manages to show some dynamics in his vocals is just chef's kiss.

[@arianahansen619]

I really feel like people get distracted by how amazing Taemin is as an overall performer and dancer that his amazing vocals get overlooked! He’s literally the whole package...it’s a SHINee thing! They don’t know what lip sync is...

[@leahgrae8184]

If we r talking abt Tae, there is no place for literally anything bad he’s great dancer, cool singer, amazing performer, and absolutely wonderful artist

[@goff_tj]

And a total sweetheart and dork. There is nothing wrong with this man (except that he loses or breaks literally everything he touches).

[@fearlesskeys1323]

I once got so hurt after seeing rude comments people said about Taemin. They know nothing and will never ever care about what Taemin has gone through to shape his vocal ability. I will never understand why is it so hard to respect other's hard work. Thank you for making this video, I appreciate it so much.

[@gwendawinston6092]

Maybe because they cant take a fact that taemin much more artistic than their bias.. Sorry for my bad english 🙏

[@goff_tj]

Gwenda Winston And they don’t understand that their bias was inspired by Taemin. Name a popular idol today and I bet my entire bank account they were inspired by Taemin.

[@I-love-Bts]

He is an amazing vocalist. Not only because he can perfectly hit high notes (which he can), but most of all because of his musicality, sensitivity and a deep emotional understanding of what he’s doing on stage and how he’s delivering emotions. I have great respect for him as an artist - both in dancing and singing he doesn’t show off his ego, but he shows us the art itself in a most captivating way. And this is a skill you can’t learn, you have to be born with it.

[@hinasagheer2041]

He was actually..but he was a kid at that time. It was good that he didn't practice at that time. Otherwise, he could have hurt his voice. but Taemin is a true example of hard work and consistency. he is a GREAT singer now. he improvise himself each day. so If a person is blind and deaf in 2020 who doesn't recognize or discover this talent. then just ignore them. I can only feel sad for them. :D :D

[@alynnshortcakes]

True. He's the true definition of hard work. Of course he doesn't have the best vocal, but people can't disagree on his improvement. Compare the old vocal to now, he's improved A LOT. I'm so proud of him💛

[@hinasagheer2041]

@@alynnshortcakes yes this is the point. He works so hard and we should appreciate his efforts. ❤❤

[@deodate2995]

his voice was actually my first favorite when getting into SHINee and his solo endeavours :] i love his timbre and tone it's right up my alley and works fantastically well with his whole style

[@shrutijha8863]

I think there is no need to explain how good of a vocal skills Taemin have. All of the SHINee members are vocal kings.Taemin is a living legend and none can deny this fact . Still you have made a very nice video . This is a good way to smack the haters. Great work.

[@meels9796]

taemin literally singing live every performance IS CRAZYYYYYY WILD SHIT! he is incredibly talented

[@blueberrybop]

If Shawols are clowns, at least we are clowns with ears blessed by 5 beautiful voices~ Onew, Jonghyun, Key, Minho AND Taemin

[@Anonymous-mo7jz]

I love this 😂 It’s their loss if they don’t realize it. Shawols are blessed clowns!

[@Bajdunia_Kaminska]

I love him! Absolutely the best artist in Kpop for me, with the most beautiful, perfect voice, nobody comes even close.

[@donotbangchan]

Not shading anyone in particular but Taemin can SING sing, not just dance and not many idols can do that. He’s talented and exceeds in every aspect, and I hate how people only see him as a great dancer like our boy can sing too y’know. Anyways stream Criminal for clear skin 🤩

[@lori4021]

Here’s the thing, you can’t improve on something you don’t have. Taemin has always had the raw talent for singing. It’s just that he discovered his love of dancing much earlier, so it was his most developed talent when he debuted. Add in the fact that he was going through puberty at the time, which affected his voice. What’s truly amazing is his perseverance to learn, on working so hard to achieve his dreams. So proud of him.

[@crestfalen88]

I feel like such a old Shawol saying this, but does anyone remember when Taemin sang U for the To the Beautiful You soundtrack? I remember the moment I heard that track I knew Taemin had so much more to show the world, and it's been so incredible watching him grow vocally from debut to now.

[@Peertje304]

I think this man was straight up made of music. It resounds through the very fibre of his being.

[@m-candyy]

Fun fact : Taemin was (and is still) in a group before being in SHINee and SuperM. The group is called TAEmin and the members are : Taemin the main vocalist. Taemin the main dancer. Taemin the visual of the group. And... No there's no leader in this group.

[@kimchiiiii0525]

Yasss

[@moonchildj]

l m a o true

[@fifib2275]

The fact that Taemin can cover the very high and difficult note of Jonghyun’s in Lucifer at 04:03 just shows how tremendous of a powerhouse he is now. Jjong would be so damn proud of his baby Taem

[@yewjiaxiansam1962]

Can't blame him though, Taemin was just 12 to 14 years old when he is under training session, which makes him 14 to 16 years oldin shinee's debut years , generally boys voice matures around this period and they need time to get use to this irreversible outcome, so we men have to train our voices in order to sing well

[@joohyunsview5332]

notice the ones saying shit about taemin stan artists that don't even have half his talent, both vocal and dance wise.

[@vitaemint9595]

Of course he is my favorite singer. Just of course. Not only does he hit every note, not only is his range impressive, he also transfers sooooo many emotions in his voice, i love him so much

[@ShawolOT5]

His voice gives me chills! Only Taemin can give goosebumps when it’s 100°F outside. As a vocalist myself, his vocal stamina absolutely astounds me. He’s amazing. Forever Taemin - Forever 5HINee! 💎💎💎💎💎

[@fernandasanchezmireles3054]

I feel really emotional by listening to Taemins voice GOOOD he has improve a lot, he is a really reaspectul artist in the industry because he is a really complete artist. He can dance and sing really well. I dont know why people say that... Some of theire favs or groups debut because of shinee and Taemin inspiration.

[@ahhtoh16]

Taemin is doing his best and he’s still growing and if you guys cant realize that pls shut up

[@AhsanKhan06]

Taemin ah I really love you, stay strong and healthy, fighting......

[@Aromantha]

It makes me sad that people actually think that Taemin can't sing. Like, he spent years sacrificing sleep and his spare time to work on his voice, getting nosebleeds almost every day and even passing out once. This man worked so hard and some people just refuse to acknowledge that ://

[@sandrawoodward8287]

They are very sad people that say he can't sing his voice is so beautiful love him so much he is one off a kind ❤ 💙 my the angels always watch over him ❤ 💙

[@vaishnavivrao6372]

This guy is a TRUE LEGEND 💯🔥

[@frankinsaneandmyrrh1202]

these are all of the belting parts, but I actually enjoy his other vocal moments more! I'm always amazed by how steady his live vocals are even while dancing his solo songs (want, move, etc.). I also remember even back in Love Like Oxygen, I kept replaying his part in the bridge!

[@hellobabyshinee]

i cannot get over the soldier clip ;-; im in tears

[@trcng]

TAEMIN IS AMAZING!!

[@jungwoososick]

He sounds like an angel, I don't know if this is weird but it makes me emotional whenever he sings especially when he hits high notes.

[@DanielaSantausashi-chan]

I just want to tell you that I'm grateful for making this video. I'm new shawol and don't know his singing skills on the stage and it was amazing. 💗

[@ayasayed5665]

He has an amazing talent.. no one can deny that.. truly he's the best idol 💖💖💖💖

[@delulu6969]

You miss Why So Serious era when Taemin took almost all Jonghyun's position because he had an accident.

[@kast3522]

Taemin is such a multi talented person 💖💖💖💖💖

[@wonhuijeon3204]

I've been a shawol since 2010 and for sure, he wasnt this good on vocal as jonghyun and onew been had the vocal on their back but taemin gradually and continuously grow until his improvement on vocal is showing. Until now it still shocked me the way he improved a lot and asking myself about "is he the same kid i know 10 years ago?" I am really proud of him.

[@victoriaking6998]

I LOVE HIS VOICE N VOCALS‼️‼️‼️💕💕💕💕💕🎤🎶🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Bleachshugo]

Interviewer: Do you have any experience? Taemin: *shows the past 13 years* A bit

[@ryuuvv]

2:11 I love how he’s literally screaming, but still slaying the notes

[@jinkisyellowsuit]

some people having the absolute GALL to diss taemin when he has one of the most unique voices in the industry and is such a complete performer is insane. the material is RIGHT THERE, don't be foolish 🚶🏻‍♂️

[@damisslave2406]

I enjoy his singing techniques, he's a more unique vocals for a male Kpop idol. He deserves the appreciation he receives.

[@bluie2889]

i love him with every single piece of my heart

[@camilaclaps]

That's why he is a main vocal on SuperM KINGGG

[@anncabras3961]

Such a unique voice too and very impressive stable notes after dancing real hard

[@microdinooo]

Honestly the fact that SM let him release solo albums and do solo concert tours should just confirm how good a vocalist he is

[@marieconstantia4441]

Taemin can do whatever he wants.

[@Lylahkins21]

Taemin said "Oh really?" Mic is ON sweety!

[@meggnoggs]

Can’t stand seeing new Kpop fans bagging on shinee 🥱 know your roots, your favs have been stanning taem since he was in high school LOOOOL

[@noname-lj5gx]

I'm honest before knowing the positions in shinee I thought taemin was a main vocal And you know what HE IS DAMN ALL OF THEM ARE MAIN VOCALIST PERIOD

[@cocovcoco]

The Jhirt™️ is back 😭 Edit: Taemin covering Jonghyun’s parts hits me directly in my heart.

[@CosmicWin]

He's a stunning singer. And FOR THE RECORD, HIS WHISPERING IS THE BEST WHISPERING EVER.

[@timinm2235]

Taemin did a beautiful job covering Jonghyuns parts.

[@laralara8856]

Taemin Is such a hard-working man He's an inspiration for other idols for a reason! I absolutely love this man with my whole heart

[@marclp27]

Taemin voice is so unique! i really like it. As far as I know, men's voices change after puberty , that's happened to my two brothers, on the other hand, the other members had already passed that phase. What I do believe is in his really hard work to improve vocal techniques, I don't think you can change your voice just by training so much, just his voice is naturally pretty now that he's grown up.

[@leonie2246]

I'm near to crying... he's so frecking talented like 5hinee in general. They all can sing, dance, rap, are understanding, loving and caring, and so much more but most importantly they make me happy ❤️ And I really need it rn so I can't thank them enough... I really hope kpop stans will learn to appreciate and love them as we shawols do

[@gloveryn]

The person that said “teamin and shinee cant sing, Shawols are clowns, and that there’s nothing to be jealous about” whoever said that has got no knowledge at all. Can you even sing or dance like taemin. I think you are jealous that taemin is better than the group/person you are stanning.

[@halak9322]

He is another level that not anybody reach 💚

[@susanan7218]

Just FYI... Taemin was awarded for 2 consecutive years for Best Male Solo Performance in Asia, that’s a fact! The King, the Superstar, the Icon & the Living Legend of KPop is back! Need I say more?

[@finkgudrun5188]

Not to forget the ARENA award - and many more (I found it in a fb group) I saved the picture on my cellphone.