What Openers Make The ALL-TIME ULTIMATE Cricket XI?🔥| Bumble & Kimber

Subscribe: bit.ly/3QocmCr
talkSPORT's Cricket editor and presenter Jon Norman sits down with former England cricket player, umpire, coach and commentator David 'Bumble' Lloyd and cricket writer Jarrod Kimber to discuss all things cricket.
In today's episode, Bumble & Kimber discuss which openers would make their all-time ultimate cricket XI.
talkSPORT Cricket is where you will find the best cricket content from talkSPORT, the world's biggest sports radio station.
Subscribe for weekly cricket content from our multi-award-winning sports commentary team featuring the likes of Kevin Pietersen, Harsha Bhogle, David Bumble' Lloyd, Jarrod Kimber, Steve Harmison, Darren Gough and Neil Manthorp.
Join top broadcaster Neil Manthorp and Former England fast-bowler Steve Harmison every Tuesday for Following On, a weekly and topical cricket show that mixes guests, debate and insight. Following On is available wherever you get your podcasts.
🖥️ talkSPORT's Website: /talksport.com/
📲 talkSPORT's Twitter: Cricket_TS
📷 talkSPORT's Instagram: talksport?...
👤 talkSPORT's Facebook: / talksport
📱 talkSPORT's Tik Tok: / talksport
🔴 Download the talkSPORT app HERE! - talksport.com/apps/
#talksport
#cricket
#cricketnews
#cricketlover
#englandcricket
#indiacricket
#australiacricket
#pakistancricket
#jaspritbumrah
#hardikpandya
#alastaircook
#sunilgavaskar
#t20worldcup
#t20worldcup2024
#subscribe
#top5

[@highbury4life899]

Sunil Gavaskars batting averages at 70 against the West Indies and that too against the pace quartet of Andy Roberts, Michael Holding, Joel Garner and Colin Croft who are considered at the greatest pace quartet in the history of Test Cricket.

[@ClydeMillerWynant]

Obviously a truly great player and a great record against West Indies. His average against them is 65 though, not 70. Pretty sure he never faced that line-up and his record is boosted by probably the best debut series anyone ever had which was way back before they went to four fast bowlers and another big series for him against the weakened side (still had some great players but not the first choice attack) they put out during Packer. He got eight centuries over those two series. Doesn't stop him being the first choice for this of course!

[@ashishnair12]

I wouldn't pick Greenidge & Hayden because both of them didnt have to face the best bowling attack of their generation because they had them in their teams. Gavaskar faced probably 3 generations of the fearsome WI attack, Lillee, Thompson, Imran, Sarfaraz, Wasim, Hadlee without a helmet & averaged 50. Gavaskar is an absolute no brainer.

[@PoetofHateSpeech]

Gooch did the same

[@ashishnair12]

@@PoetofHateSpeech Yeah you're right. But Gavaskar did a little better than Gooch against them. Both great players though.

[@jetpark3743]

Gavaskar without a doubt

[@rajaguruperiasamy8845]

Sehwag with a near 50 average and a strike rate of well over 80 is mental. If he has a good innings, the team wins, that's it. Attacking against the new ball, excellent attacker of spin - probably only next to brain Lara. A spectacle to watch if he gets going. I would have him in my all time 11, just for the excitement he brings to the game of cricket.

[@natarajkrishnaswamy3354]

He wouldn't make an all conditions opener, his record in Eng, SA and NZ is mediocre.

[@avishmaharaj5941]

Yes he was beast in home conditions but not very good away record.

[@CuriosityLearning-op8of]

Sehwags records look good on paper bcoz he was a home track bully.... he was never dependable in away tests especially in SENA countries... He bashed Sri Lanka Pakistan and Bangladesh though 😂

[@AbhishekSharma-mm9tv]

​@@CuriosityLearning-op8ofAustralia?? U serious?

[@CuriosityLearning-op8of]

@@AbhishekSharma-mm9tv yes...

[@GMalik1923]

Surprisingly they didnt mention Saeed Anwar was successful almost everywhere. In the 90s averaged 48 away from home and 48 as an opener. He is extremely underrated. And 90s is a tough era. Overall averaged 47 as an opener. He averaged 59 against Australia the best side of his era.

[@rrao7963]

@@GMalik1923 greatest opener scored centuries in all sena countries never they mentioned him disgusting

[@RVG1203]

Barry Richards played one series.. take a look at Gavaskar's first series against West Indies

[@rufioswitch2132]

Gooch scored runs against the very best opening bowlers, and played Warne incredibly well, even at age 38-40. Warne said he was the best English player he ever bowled against (including KP). He averaged roughly 50 for the last 7 years of his career. Hi 154 against West Indies is one of the greatest test knocks ever. Gavaskar was incredible, in an era of slow over rates, unlimited bouncers and no helmets, and played spin incredibly. Got something like 13 tons against the windies!! Hayden fantastic in all conditions, proven over a long period.. only downside that the best bowling attack was his own side, which he never had to face. Greenidge amazing, I absolutely loved watching him, but again didn’t play against the ultimate best bowling attacks so for me less proven than Gooch or Gavaskar. Barry Richards was *probably* better than all of them, but no test match data to back it up, especially against top level spin in Asia. Sehwag was very good but only averaged 30 odd against aus and England combined so can’t be in the conversation. Graeme Smith is the one that did it against the best bowling attacks - England and Aus in 2000s were very strong and he averaged 50 against them. Ugly as sin to watch bat, but proven against the very best and tough as anything. Very tough choice! Personally I’d go Gooch and Gavaskar, or if being pragmatic with a Left-Right combo then Hayden and Gavaskar. The one I’d most like to watch would be Barry Richards - from the little available on KZbin he was utter genius.

[@saurabhb1041]

In an all time XI, with Bradman, Sachin and Viv playing 3,4,5 (all excellent stroke makers), you want technically sound openers. So Gavaskar and Cook would be my choice

[@gsanks]

Cook? No English man would make any position on a World XI.

[@saurabhb1041]

@@gsanks Ian Botham is as good an all rounder as they come. Not sure what you’re smoking.

[@joebowden4065]

@@gsankswhy so bitter

[@gsanks]

@@joebowden4065 Quite simple really. Admittedly no Englishman would lay claim to the 4 bowling slots on an all time Test XI. No spinner and definitely no fast bowler, statistically or otherwise. As far as batsmen are concerned, in the top 30 all time Test run getters, Cook and Root are the only Englishmen, and they both average less than 50. In any event, which English batsman would you insert to replace Bradman, Tendulkar, Gavaskar, Richards, Waugh, Ponting, Lara? Almost any Test XI will choose 5 of those 7. Sangakkara and Gilchrist have the wicketkeeper slot sewn up. As for the allrounder position, nobody (not even Botham) would choose Botham over Sobers or Kallis. No need to be bitter. Thanks for inventing the game.

[@cliffardgerber3830]

Any world team selected without Kallis is absurd.

[@abhishekchhazed8974]

I have slight reservations in extrapolating performances from domestic cricket to international. Barry Richards might have been the best batsman in the whole world but didn't play much internationally. Picking him above some of the proven greats is a bit obnoxious. Interestingly, they wanted to pick an attacking batsman and they somehow picked Hayden above Sehwag. Sehwag has identical numbers and a Test strike rate of 80 which is better than Haydens ODI strike rate. Some can argue about the quality as they always do, but numbers don't lie when you have that long career.

[@sonnyrust8479]

Richards is a proven great, just because he didn’t play Tests due to apartheid. He scored 80 FC centuries at 54 back when FC cricket mattered. Don Bradman had him opening in his 20th century XI. I was upset they didn’t talk more about Cook. Player of the Series in away series wins in Australia and India, most runs by a leftie of all time and most runs by an opener. This is all a bit of fun, don’t read too much into it

[@abhishekchhazed8974]

@@sonnyrust8479 Richards records speaks for himself but I still have my reservations. Bradman played in that era and there is always that bias. My point being, Wasim Jaffer has the most runs in Ranji Trophy but couldn't make it at the top level. Would you consider him same as Richards if Wasim didnt play for India and only had great domestic numbers. Domestic cricket would be tough but they are still home conditions. Your option of Cook completely make sense because he went across countries and did it against top oppositions. Thats the difference that Richards lacks. No doubt on his ability but he still hasn't done what others have done.

[@karamjitdedyal752]

Sehwag scored centuries in Australia, England and South Africa. Averaged almost 50 and very attacking. I would have him in.

[@nooneknows19]

He wasn't good in England and South Africa though. The one hundred in South Africa came at 6. He was brilliant against spin. And pace and bounce. But was dreadful against the lateral ball.

[@sathvikraomp2006]

@@nooneknows19 Sehwag doesn't even average 30 in South afric and england

[@sambhavraichand2601]

Sehwag was one of the worst players of swing bowling ...third class batsman in English swinging conditions

[@akshayabhatt9073]

From the cricketer i have seen (Mid 70s onwards) Gavaskar Greenidge Viv Tendulkar Lara Gilchrist Imran Warne Marshall Lillee Holding

[@himankphillaur]

Barry Richards might have been a great player, but cannot be preferred over players who have proved themselves at the highest level for more than 10-15 years like Greenidge, Gavaskar etc. His great county record doesn't make him a pick in an all time XI. To my mind, Sunil Gavaskar is the greatest post war (even all-time) opener great against all comers in all conditions.

[@natarajkrishnaswamy3354]

True. We can't go with iffs and buts had Barry Richarss played more.any other opener who would've played a consider number of tests should've been considered. In that case are we considering Adam Voges who had a wonderful but short career.

[@TheOfficialEmirati]

Bradman watched Barry richards play internationally, and I think in Sheffield Shield. Bradman included barry richards in his all time xi.

[@natarajkrishnaswamy3354]

@@TheOfficialEmirati the other openers that are in discussion have all performed. Nothing against Barry Richards , but we can't consider a cricketer that has played 4 tests over cricketers that have played 100 tests. Then we should also consider Adam Voges over others in the middle order as Voges has an average of 61 over a 20 test career.

[@ksundares]

Sunny G Alwar for tests- one thing these bozos failed to mention is he was very decent against the best bowling in his day - the Windies

[@markbateman9222]

At the opening of the video the words "post war" were uttered. But the names listed are all very recent. No Hutton? Carried his bat twice in tests, almost single handedly carried England on the 1950-5 tour of Australia (and lost the best years of his career to the war)

[@PoetofHateSpeech]

L Hutton and B Simpson. Highest average openers of all time that played after WW2

[@rohitseth818]

Where do I watch the entire of this discussion?

[@TheOfficialEmirati]

They will post the other videos over the next few days/week

[@AM2K2]

I love this channel...keep the content coming!

[@saulsmith2939]

If it's test series, you go cook Smith, and draw the first test with the bowlers having bowled 50 over each, second test you have a second string bowling attack and win

[@shubhamkumar-zy8yx]

Sunil Gavaskar Barry Richards Vivian Richards Brian Lara Sachin Tendulkar Garfield Sobers Adam Gilchrist (wk) Imran Khan Shane Warne (C) Malcolm Marshall Curtly Ambrose This will be my all time xi

[@hubbybell]

Not bad at all

[@abhijithanand8770]

Great list, but I would try squeeze in Don Bradman instead of brain lara

[@adrianneale3368]

@@abhijithanand8770 Bradman was pre-war wasn't he?

[@adrianneale3368]

Strong line up that 👍

[@thiefoftomorrow]

Wasim for imran as there’s plenty of batting and maybe McGrath for Ambrose. Good list. Not a sexy pick but everyone should have kallis in too to squeeze in an extra bowler or bat

[@runitstraight2637]

Matthew Hayden had a test average of 50 as an opener. Incredible after 103 test matches

[@Specter45909]

Sehwag too, almost identical averages and identical runs

[@esthermartin6699]

Hayden and Greenidge never faced their own bowling attack. Hayden struggled against swing in 2005 in England.

[@GMalik1923]

​​@@esthermartin6699he also averaged 28 in NZ and 34 in SA. Hayden that is.

[@briansukhu4392]

Hayden struggled during the 90's when the bowling attacks were world class, struggled post 2005 when the attacks improved.

[@MrCarrera28]

@@esthermartin6699 So does that mean Viv Richards missed out since he never faced probably the greatest combined pace attack in cricket history?

[@roboticduniya1731]

I can pick Gavaskar and Bradman as my openers, come on Bradman can bat anywhere, this will give space going down the order...

[@WesleyMcpherson-lu1rf]

Roy Fredericks Fellas. Don't forget 169 against the fearsome Lillie and Thompson in the 1975/76 tour of Australia. Thompson was never the same.

[@yashsheth577]

Last time England won a series in Australia and India there was one very significant and common factor Alastair Cook scored runs by the truckload Criminally underrated players especially by his own people

[@nikhilgawade6831]

they spent 20 hrs arguing why sehwag and Hayden wont make the list becuase they are not consitent. But finally picked 2 players who have not played in all conditions

[@MaheshKumar-yj8nc]

David want to impose - these openers will throw their wickets within first 10 overs and then the team will be back to defending a better to have Sunil gavaskar who is assured to stay at the crease for long.

[@lonestar6709]

Jack Hobbs. Sunni Gavaskar. Don Bradman. Graeme Pollock. Garry Sobers. Kumar Sangakkara. Keith Miller. Imran Khan. Richard Hadlee. Malcolm Marshall. SF Barnes. That's the greatest team, of all time.

[@PeakFictionWithAms]

You guys should do this for odis and t20s once youre done with the test list

[@shyam2630]

I can't get over the fact how underrated is Alistair Cook is. I would have him as he performed in all types of conditions.

[@rihitjamb3757]

He had a long period where he was not very consistent from like 2013 till retirement

[@prathamprakash6098]

From 2006 -2013 Alastair Cook is Goat opener..My God his stats and impact was tremendous ( conquered both Aus and Ind during that time period, won 3 back to back ashes for Eng too).. But those last 5 years did not have the same impact and was one of the reasons for his premature retirement...( He had some purple patch but was few nd far between)

[@rahulmodi8706]

Ony for Test cricket

[@jinayvora6240]

Picking bazball style openers when England are floating at the bottom of the WTC points table feels like a cop out to me ...

[@harinagarajan2296]

Gosh. Marvellous discussion this. Against extreme pace all were vulnerable. Gavaskar against malcolm Marshall going round the wicket is one example. Counterfactuals are not there. Haydn against Patrick Patterson. Uncovered pitches and facing Griffith or Underwood. I think len hutton and Gavaskar.

[@shaktiswami662]

When did Haydn face patterson?

[@harinagarajan2296]

@@shaktiswami662 In such discussions we do not have counterfactuals. This is what i meant. I know Haydn never faced Patterson. But what if we could simulate such a scenario? This is why picking an all time anything is problematic. This is what i meant.

[@shaktiswami662]

@@harinagarajan2296 Sorry! I did not know the meaning of counterfactuals. New learning :)

[@LenandlarSingh1979]

Is strike rate a factor in 'moving the game along'? If yes, then Hayden's strike rate is surely a factor. Yes they played in different times but his Test SR is almost that of Greenridge's ODI's (there's no test SR data for GG - fair to say it might be about or lower than his ODI'S?)

[@joshuasamaraweera3174]

Hayden and Sehwag are the most fearsome test openers. Both averaged near 50 and capable of hitting a triple century

[@PJ-cm8ix]

Alistair Cook and Sehwag, Honourable mention: Barry Richards

[@cliffardgerber3830]

Cook never

[@vivekanand5563]

Among post-war openers, Bobby Simpson, Len Hutton, Dennis Amiss averaged the highest after playing a significant amount of matches. But if you want to look at players who were good for over a decade, you have to go with Gavaskar and Hayden. My personal favourites are Barry Richards, Gordon Greenidge and perhaps Saeed Anwar.

[@calvinrulez]

Gavaskar Don Bradman (c) Viv Richards Sachin Tendulkar Brian Lara Gary Sobers Gilchrist (w) Wasim Akram Shane Warne Malcolm Marshall Glenn McGrath Twelfth Man - Kallis Honorable mentions - Imran Khan, Jack Hobbs, Muralidharan, Ambrose

[@kartikeyatiwari2502]

Why not murali?

[@calvinrulez]

@@kartikeyatiwari2502 Personal preference. Murali is almost as good as Warne. It's hard to pick one among the two. All the other bowlers are irreplaceable. Can't pick more than 1 spinner, because Sachin and Viv are decent part-time spinners, and even they'll be hardly needed. If the match happens on a dust bowl, I'd maybe drop McGrath with Murali and play two spinners.

[@kartikeyatiwari2502]

@@calvinrulez Murali is straight up better than warne but he isn't white so doesn't get enough credit

[@cudpug2233]

strauss and trescothick? Mentioned in the close rejects list along with sunny G? That's some english bias there. They might be great players no doubt, but come on! Sunny G?? I understand them picking aggressive openers, but still? I don't think that should be that big of a criteria to drop undeniable quality.of this sort.

[@ritabanbanerjee5744]

Trescothick 🤣🤣🤣 that was hilarious

[@shadrianshadrach3804]

Dream Test Team 1. Gavaskar 2. Smith 3. Lara 4. Richards 5. Waugh 6. Border (Captain) 7. Gilchrist (Wicket Keeper) 8. Marshall 9. Warne (Vice Captain) 10. Steyn 11. McGrath 12'th Man Keith Miller

[@kennethcarter3494]

Jack Hobbs and Herbert Sutcliffe are the greatest opening pair by a long way. They averaged 57 and 61 as individuals, and they averaged as a partnership together 88 in 38 innings. Which is 33 runs better than the next pest partnership. I notice this all the time when people select all-time teams. It is not all-time, it is recent time selections.

[@gsanks]

They didn't face Akram, Holding and Warne. They were a different era

[@neilgovender7450]

Attacking Barry Richards and Matthew Hayden, left right combination and dominant. or Greenidge and Sehwag,.Cook and Gavaskar to take off the shine of the ball

[@goldenboots507]

Sunil gavaskar Ricky ponting Brian lara Sachin tendulkar Viv richards Kumar sangakara/ gilchrist Imran khan (c) / kallis. Wasim akram Shane warne Malcolm marshall Glen mcgrath

[@aawharver4948]

My guy chose Gooch, he averaged 42 lmfao for all time 11😂😂😂 these guys are jokes

[@MrCarrera28]

He did have a truly spectacular moustache 😁

[@Chris-wj8fz]

Greenidge and Haynes..you must pick opening bats and bowlers who know how to play together like Lillee and Thommo Warne and McGrath Hayden and Langer

[@shreyanshpranshuchauhan5991]

These are all small videos where is the full video?

[@karthikpatra]

Selecting a player who just played 4 tests at home, whatever his potential may be is just nuts. Vinod Kambli demolished Warne, averaged 136 after his first 4 tests, and has 10k FC runs @60. Shall we select him over Sachin in the middle order?

[@nitinaggarwal9379]

My all time test XI: Virender Sehwag Sunil Gavaskar Don Bradman Brian Lara Steve Waugh (c) Garfield Sobers Adam Gilchrist (wk) Shane Warne Wasim Akram Malcolm Marshall Dennis Lillee

[@123animit]

Dam, a all time list with no Viv or Sachin!

[@nitinaggarwal9379]

@@123animit Yes, that's a very hard decision to drop Tendulkar, but I couldn't play him ahead of Lara. Also, Don Bradman vs Viv Richards. Viv RIchards, the great batsman would have to make way for Bradman.

[@MrCarrera28]

@@nitinaggarwal9379 Personally I would consider replacing Brian Lara with either Alan Border or Greg Chappell. Coming in after Bradman you don't necessarily need a glamour batsmen as much as you need grit and determination. Chappell averaged over 50 against the great West Indies pace attack without wearing a helmet for most of his career and his style was about as perfect as you would want a batsmen to be, my only caveat would making sure he would be a good team mate under Steve Waugh as captain. Or alternatively Border, he averaged over 50 for his entire career, batted with grit that Lara or Tendulkar did not have away from home and consistently score runs when the rest of the team collapsed around him. Not as pretty in terms of style as Chappell or Lara but certainly a guy who focused and consistently delivered runs in difficult conditions. I would not want to face that bowling attack, imagine those bowlers and still having Sir Garfield Sobers in reserve!!

[@santugk]

Shewag had 2 triple tons and another 293 as an opener. The world feared him while at the crease .Enforcer or otherwise, he is better than any opener anywhere. Gavaskar was good across the globe. They would make the perfect ice and fire combo..

[@Jaydoggie1]

Segway was a flat track bully

[@samuelking6432]

Wasn't he dominated by the English and the Australians? He looked like a rabbit stuck in the headlights in front of them.

[@santugk]

@@samuelking6432 You must have had a stroke been in coma when he smoked Aussie for 195 at MCG & 155 at Adelaide or 151 at Chennai!!

[@samuelking6432]

@@santugk With that logic, Jason Gillespie is the greatest batter. He made a double hundred you know 😂.

[@sathvikraomp2006]

Sehwag was pathetic in South Africa and England. Doesn't even avg 30 in those countries

[@rajivnivas7546]

Gavaskar and Greenige

[@MrCarrera28]

Gordon Greenridge is critically under rated because he was in a team of stars.

[@ryangarraton8400]

My all time XI would be: Alastair cook Matthew hayden Ricky ponting (c) Sachin Tendulkar Brian lara Jacques kallis Adam gilchrist (wk) Shane warne Wasim akram Muttiah muralitharan Glenn mcgrath Honorable mention to kumar sangakkara who just misses out but the only place he might fit in there is as an opener. A couple of batsmen in lower positions maybe but i think they could be effective.

[@susheelchandra2913]

Biasness should be allowed till it doesn't harm anybody

[@calvinrulez]

Gavaskar and Jack Hobbs

[@craigrodgers9693]

The criteria was post war. I presume ww2

[@rihitjamb3757]

Barry Richard’s and gavaskar. Greenidge and pollock reserves

[@khurmiful]

We should pick two best all time teams and then discuss who would win under which conditions. The ultimate 11 is boring, who are they playing is what I want to know. You can have Gordon and Hydos and I’ll have Veru and Goochie for example.

[@kunalgill2511]

I did this exercise for football and cricket. These are my two greatest cricket XIs: Gavaskar Hayden Bradman Tendulkar Richards Sobers Gilchrist (wk) Akram Warne © Marshall Lillee Vs Hutton Greenidge Lara Kallis Sangakarra (wk)© Sehwag Ambrose Waqar Steyn McGrath Murali

[@vratysanu]

Where is part 2 of this series ?

[@samuelking6432]

Sunil Gavaskar and Alistair Cook would be such a formidable pair for any team.

[@vantheman1238]

People will disagree with me; however, I am picking the opening batsman who scored runs on every type of surface and in every country across the world over the course of three decades. A man who whenever he scored a hundred his country never lost a Test Match and he scored hundreds against Dennis Lillee, Terry Alderman, Andy Roberts, Colin Croft, Joel Garner, and Michael Holding when over the age of forty. My opening batsman Sir Geoffrey Boycott. Centenary Test Match was at Melbourne in 1977. You can watch the programme where they interview all the former old players on KZbin. It is a great watch.

[@MrCarrera28]

I would not dare criticise someone who choose Boycott. Style and grace in batting are irrelevant and Boycott made his wicket hard to get and put a very high price on getting him out. If you had Hayden as other opener he could progress the pace if necessary and Boycott would lock down the other end down tiring the opening bowlers. Plus if you had Gilchrist as WK in a scenario where you need runs quickly to chase a win you could elevate Gilchrist to open or of course simply put Bradman in as opener. The more I think about it in a world class team Boycott would be the second bedrock (after Bradman obviously) to build a innings around.

[@mountainman9145]

Barry Richards and Gavaskar. True openers that were capable of dealing with that great West Indian pace attack of Marshall, Croft,Holding,Garner etc

[@Jaydoggie1]

Barry Richards and Gavaskar easy pick

[@spookytoothable1911]

I'd have Barry Richards & Gavaskar. And I don't care that he only played 4 tests. During the WSC era, when he played for the Rest of the world 11, he batted against some of the most intimidating fast bowlers ever & dominated. And this was towards the end of his career. And Gavaskar could play aggressively as well. He once hit a hundred against a Malcolm Marshall led Windies in 94 balls.

[@arkzbh]

As opener - Hayden Gavaskar Sehwag Grame Smith - I dont know how ill choose between these 4, but imo unquestionably these 4 were the best. Gooch , a great player, but he is not even in the league imo. Gordon and Boycott can be considered obviously, but no way Gooch. I have watched each of them playing

[@hrishikeshnambiar2449]

1)Sunil Gasvaskar 2)Alastair Cook 3)Steven smith(Best since bradman but acc to me he better than bradman) 4)Sachin tendulkar 5)Steve waugh(c) 6)Garfield Sobers/Ben stokes 7)Adam gilchrist(wk) 8)Wasim akram 9)Shane warne 10)Pat cummins/Morne morkel 11)malcolm marshall my xi

[@ksundares]

Look at S Smith 4th innings average ( conditions are most tough)- really bad for the greatest batsman as per you - just saying

[@MrCarrera28]

Good choice of Steve Waugh as captain. I would however consider having Sobers bat at 5 as Steve Waugh was superb at batting with the tail

[@hrishikeshnambiar2449]

@@MrCarrera28 i agree that waugh was great in batting with the the tail, but my team is kind of postionless , as in if we want a quick declaration maybe gilly might open.But ya i get ur point

[@billybank2012]

Gooch could play attacking and defensive... But when you see his 154 against the west Indies then it's an obvious choice... Mind you I'm being biased cos Gooch was my favourite batsman to watch.. But if I'm in opposition to him I'll call Terry alderman to get him out quickly cos medium paced was his weakness.

[@devkoli1483]

Sunil gavaskar arguably the best opener of all time..face the best pace attack of all time. .and hit most centuries against the most dangerous side of his era windies...surely he would be the first pick🛐

[@ramaniganesh9477]

Gooch is not the same calibre as Gavaskar - he has more centuries against the WI pace battery.

[@craigrodgers9693]

Not really. Most of Gavaskar's centuries against WI were in 71 when they had no fast bowlers. And 79 when they had a third team. And one in 75/76 when just Holding was bowling.

[@johnwalsh1990]

Sir Geoffrey batted on uncovered wickets without a helmet against all the great Australian and West Indian fast bowlers he may not be the best but hes got to be pretty close..

[@everygamersdream72]

Gooch and Hayden were my picks then he said them!

[@cd11645]

My All time Test and ODI XI - NOTE : maximum 4 players from a single country so that it won't get biased. Test XI = 1. Virender Sehwag 2. Matthew Hayden 3. Brian Lara 4. Sachin Tendulkar 5. Jacques Kallis 6. Adam Gilchrist 7. Ravindra Jadeja* 8. Wasim Akram 9. Shane Warne 10. Glenn McGrath 11. Dale Steyn *Took Jadeja bcos I'm making all time 11, not list of best players. so I have gone for Jadeja bcos I need a player who is bowling all rounder, someone who is a fantastic spinner & can support Warne and can do a lot of spin bowling alongside Warne as well as can bat & stay at crease when needed. And Jadeja who has 300 Test wickets at avg of 24 with SR of 57 and also he has 5 Test centuries & 21 test fifties with an average of 37 as batsman. So Jadeja fits perfectly in the role which I need as he is a very good spin bowler and a fine batsman. And also he is an extremely great fielder which is a bonus point ODI XI = 1. Sachin Tendulkar 2. Sanath Jayasuriya 3. Virat Kohli 4. Jacques Kallis 5. Ab de Villiers 6. Yuvraj Singh 7. MS Dhoni 8. Wasim Akram 9. Muralitharan 10. Glenn McGrath 11. Brett Lee

[@MrCarrera28]

This is the test team I would pick to play your Test XI 1) Graeme Smith 2) Gavaskar 3) Bradman 4) Greg Chappell/Border 5) Sir Garfield Sobers 6) Steve Waugh (C) 7) Mark Boucher 8) Hadlee 9) Curtly Ambrose 10) Muralitharan 11) Lillee The opening bowling would have the perfect combination of the wild unpredictable pace of Ambrose and the searing but thinking pace of Lillee, followed by Hadlee's accuracy and consistency and Muri's hard to read spin, runs would be difficult to get and just as batsmen are getting frustrated Waugh would bring in Sobers pace or spin depending on conditions. My only question in my XI is whether to include Greg Chappell or Border at no. 4. Chappell scored ruins against the West Indies great pace attack with an average over 50 without a helmet and his batting style was about as perfect as you would want. But ultimately with Bradman in the XI there is an argument that the next batsmen do not need to be 'gunslingers' but rather batters who can dig in and grind out runs in difficult conditions on the rare occasions that Bradman fails and Border would be perfect for this role. This is why I have Waugh batting below Sobers as he was a master of batting with the tail and grinding out extra runs that helped the Australian team win so many tests.

[@rahult1518]

Gavaskar Greenidge : gavaskar attacked when needed .

[@BineeshSilent]

Don’t call it all time XI, call it “ all time XI type of game these guys are looking for “

[@somdutta7322]

Also, no mention of Sehwag ?

[@aawharver4948]

My guy said gooch would take on West Indies, Sunny G has 11 hundreds against them smh

[@mrh1096]

You left out Gary Kirsten, Len Hutton, Herbert Sutcliffe, Jack hobbs

[@craigrodgers9693]

The criteria was after world war 2. Rules Hobbs and Sutcliffe out. Amazed Hutton wasn't mentioned though.

[@kumarsuneet7070]

Grenidge did not face Loyd's pace battery. And Gavaskar handled them with a degree of authority, scoring most of his centuries against them. And please do not equate Sunny with Geoffrey Boycott. Sunny had a few shots too. I would agree with Gavaskar and Gooch.

[@MrCarrera28]

Gooch averaged 43?

[@RVG1203]

How can you pick someone who played only a handful at the test level albeit a great talent

[@vinayb5746]

Akash chopra and sanjay Bangar

[@razorzagaming]

Best captain player is Greame Smith. So his in any 11 the Captain and opening batsman. No one has his stats. His win record and second inngs record as player and captain.

[@MrCarrera28]

Its worth remembering that he has won the most tests as captain, but also lost the most tests. On a percentage wins basis he is behind Waugh, Bradman, Ponting, Kohli, Hassett and Brearley. Smith has away wins percentage as captain of 42% compared to Waugh's 68%. Plus the only player guaranteed a position in all time Test XI is Bradman, so perhaps there is an argument that he should captain.

[@vinaytripathi157]

Gavaskar is dispensable as an opening batsman in test cricket..put your heads together to pick the other one of the pair.

[@MrCarrera28]

You probably mean indispensable :)

[@ContentGramophone-tp9gw]

Gooch gillchrist lara tendulkar kalas m crowe...warne akram marshall mcgrath murali

[@MegatronRacing237]

Matthew Hayden IS A MUST!!!!

[@souravverma8861]

On Sehwag and Hayden Debate I want to add that Sehwags Test Strike rate is better than Haydens ODI Strike Rate and average is almost the same scored almost the same amount of Runs, so if you want to go with attacking option, there is no one ahead of Sehwag

[@sambhavraichand2601]

Sehwag couldn't play swing and seam ..was pathetic in England and south Africa

[@souravverma8861]

@@sambhavraichand2601 and yet still the best attacking batsmen ever in Test Cricket

[@psychonaut4650]

Barry Richards is honestly a great pick.

[@sodea13]

sehwag struggled in swinging, bouncy conditions...gavaskar could handle everything...greenidge and gavaskar should be the way,,,,

[@mavirk]

Gavasker & Cook, PERIOD!

[@Legendgaming-tp1is]

Gream smith, virendra sehwag left hand right hand great combination thank me later.

[@Ramanjitsd]

Greenidge and Gavaskar

[@harrygodber4655]

Langer? Ave 48 as an opener with a 58 Sr. Mediocre record in Asia I suppose though.

[@AMB5]

Barry Richards and Cook for me without any hesitation.

[@ujjwalbachwani1764]

Should Amla and Warner get a mention?

[@Iam-zi3my]

Warner who shits his pant away from home

[@craigrodgers9693]

Amazed Hutton not mentioned.

[@tenmeh]

Gavaskar and Hayden 🔝

[@samarthbagwe1736]

Picking boycott over Gavaskar Yeah absolutely zero cricketing knowledge What's was boycott achievement gavaskar smashed the scary west indies bowler soo much They created a song for him smashing the west indies

[@Nostalgic14-zo3pk]

They are English hence they would want to pick their own...

[@hubbybell]

You did know boycott held the record for most runs for a while

[@Tiggerc67]

Boycott did pretty very very well against all opposition including against holding, Marshall Croft and co. He was a mighty fine opener. Slow strike rate yes but not that much different to Alistair cooks

[@nooneknows19]

⁠Jarrod is an Australian...

[@craigrodgers9693]

​@@Nostalgic14-zo3pkdid you watch the video?? Do you recognise accents? They are not both English!! And they pick Greenidge and Barry Richards.....neither are English!! What are you talking about??

[@robertbaldwin5771]

Glen Turner

[@chriswatson7965]

Hayden and Gavaskar

[@raheelakhtar7]

Richie Benaud picked an all time XI (2004) with 2 reserves in each position. He picked Gavaskar and Jack Hobbs to open with Greenidge, Hutton, Arthur Morris and Victor Trumper as reserves. All Time, not post WW2.

[@russhouldin5774]

Exactly. I expect recency bias in general but not from someone (Jarrod) who wrote a history of test cricket.

[@rrao7963]

Saeed Anwar best opener

[@russhouldin5774]

@@rrao7963 You're aware he has a test average of 45?

[@rrao7963]

@@russhouldin5774 only asian opener to score centuries in all sena countries in test no other opener in 90s did it his 118 in Durban best even Lara Sachin could not score centuries when fanie devillers played for sa check out the stats he could have averaged more than 50s against aus he scored three centuries five fifties in test likes of McGrath Warne averaged 60 scored 840 runs in eight test

[@russhouldin5774]

@@rrao7963 So Gordon Greenidge doesnt count because he's not Asian?

[@sachin233]

Gooch.. avg so mediocre in test .. not in all time test team . Bias English selection

[@craigrodgers9693]

If we go on average, after WW2 which was the selection criteria, then Hutton would be above everyone who played more than 50 tests. So not sure there is much English bias tbh

[@freddielepine]

Going on numbers fastest to 1k 3k 3 k 4 k runs hashim amla every day of the week.

[@rohitpratap4174]

All time Test Gavaskar and Hobbs. Gooch much shorter period of domination was weak in late 70s early 80s unlike above 2 who were consistent for 2 decades. ODI Sachin and Gilchrist

[@rohitpratap4174]

What I'm surprised these guys (esp Jarrod) is forgetting is OFTEN in Test cricket you can't smash the bowlers around day 1 on a green top. You need to blunt them to get the middle order dominating the more tired bowling later (even today!). Gavaskar could dominate when needed, not just against spin, but he scored a blistering ton in Kanpur Vs Marshall & co hooking them off his skull cap for a ton at a faster than a run a ball. Need to respect conditions more in Test cricket so surprised at their conclusions.

[@princesinghrajput3412]

Sehwag

[@FranssensM]

Geoffrey

[@TheDPgamer]

Graeme smith and Sachin( yes I’m using sachin as an opener)

[@MrCarrera28]

Not crazy since he Tendulkar has no chance of batting at no. 3 against Bradman.

[@somdutta7322]

Hayden over Gavaskar ? even Hayden wouldn't endorse that 🤣😅

[@utsavdave4747]

Chris Gayle and Hayden is the greatest opening pair in all 3 formats