TekTopia Villagers | Dev Playthrough: The Miner!

[@jadeystew279]

(just a little suggestion) Tango Tek I think that you should make it so when you make a baby, it will have the same last name as the person that made the heart. this would give it more of a family related feel.

[@dfghj241]

another suggestion, give idle animations to villagers waiting on resources, that way when you pass through the place the NPCS are waiting you don't see them just standing there all day waiting for shit.

[@jadeystew279]

@@andermium yeah that is probably possible, once this mod gets released, I might like to have more of a sense of the villagers have familys and stuff. also just another thing maybe a baby could have like a half or quarter of the skill in the profession that the parent had.

[@marian8161]

Make it so some villagers die of old age

[@braxtoncleveland2993]

I agree

[@TheHighEmpyrean]

And nomads

[@wlebeck6780]

Suggestion: When a child is “born” it should inherit the last name of the parent so you can have a family. Possibly even inherit skill traits from parents. Keep up the good work! Can’t wait to play this for myself!

[@ChavvyChannel]

The baby may inherit a few points that are the max of each of their parents

[@PhenixArcher]

Kids with parents have a chance to gain a point in one or more skills their parents have each day, until they grow up.

[@dadplscomhome5380]

@@ChavvyChannel they dont have parents tho.

[@thedaranesianconfederation7221]

Maybe visit their parents for skill

[@swordzanderson5352]

I dont think they should inherit the skill points, but should instead have an increased leveling speed for skills that their parents have, respective to their parents' skill level. Like how a father who is a technician would pass on his skills to his son which is willing to be one.

[@austinshields5147]

1. Thank you for making this mod. 2. Thank you for troubleshooting/creating a tutorial for this mod. You are awesome!

[@RuneAutomaton]

This is my Favourite Let’s Play Series at the moment! I mean.. “Let’s Dev”

[@ender3960]

It is enjoyable but not a let's play, it's a developer's showcase

[@karmapz464]

This is not really a Let's Play it is more of a Mod Tutorial/ Mod Showcase that has some bugs and adjustments that needs to be fixed before the Official Release of the Mod and for the Real Survival Let's Play

[@nlinchmc9509]

It’d say it’s a let’s play with the Goal of debugging the Mod.

[@puppydragon4862]

To everybody who said it's not a let's play with the exception of MC, r/wooosh.

[@DumplingIX]

@@puppydragon4862 r/youaremeimyouiateme

[@chrisZACKwhitehead]

Soooo, I have a couple of questions. 1. How big can the town's themselves be? 2. Will this be multiplayer compatibile . 3. What happens if you have two town's very close to each other? 4. Is there a nourishment system where villagers need a verity of foods to survive?

[@johnydl]

1 I think in episode 1 of the initial series he said 16x16 chunks is the size of the path finding system 2 it should be but my question is largely how will it be made multiplayer compatible do villages need to be a certain minimum distance apart etc? 3 I'd think the second town hall marker wouldn't work. 4 I kind of hope so :)

[@see3655]

As far as you could tell from the videos: 1. Roughly 8 chunks in each direction from the town hall 2. Yes. 3. ? 4. No, but wait for the next video on that one I guess.

[@rieska178]

Every mod is multiplayer compatible and I think that if you have towns too close to each other they will become one big town, the town hall probably won't work as JohnyDL said

[@johnydl]

@@rieska178 Not every mod is multiplayer compatible some are very much multiplayer unstable although I've never played a mod that hasn't been because I tend to want to play with friends. This mod has however been played with both Tango and Zedaph already on Mixer though both being in the same town I'm still wanting to know how second or third or Nth towns are handled ^_^

[@sincerelysomehumaniguess7610]

i was gonna ask this! but i'll like your comment instead. ;)

[@bluetiger438]

it would be cool if miners could use minecarts

[@Arnie1066]

Blue Tiger love the idea, maybe once they reach a certain skill level, another villager gets minecart & rails added to the list of possible build/create items. The miner could then place rails as he mines, although torch placement would have to change to head height on the wall.

[@samsminecraftschematics200]

Haha true

[@harrisonmathews8740]

Genius everyone like his/her idea!

[@bugrilyus]

@@Arnie1066 He could add mechanic/engineer to make iron structures alongside blacksmith. Like iron golems to fight alongside guards and minecarts mineshafts etc.

[@Nugcon]

yes

[@SystemofEleven]

Miner should pick up cobblestone to make stone tools and repair the tunnels. Wood tools suck and constantly have to be replaced, and this way you can have more profit off the lumberjack. If you're worried about overloading them with cobble, maybe make a max of like 16 that each miner will collect each day? That's five stone axes or pickaxes or swords or whatever that can be made each day, if your village only has one miner.

[@Error_-hh6hc]

or maybe they would collect, say, 1 out of every 20ish piece of cobble they mine?

[@jellyandcream9471]

I think that this is a great idea,i hope tango takes it into consideration.

[@SystemofEleven]

It also just occurred to me to ask whether villagers need the proper tool materials to collect things (ie, stone pickaxe to collect iron, iron pick to collect diamonds, diamond to collect obsidian)?

[@You-jr9xf]

That laugh makes me happy because he enjoy so much for developing this mod

[@mew_the_pinkmin7621]

Perhaps it should be part of the druid’s job to “fix” deactivated tunnels if they are stopped by liquids, so that the player need not keep a close eye on the mineshafts. Maybe by going to the end of the tunnel and filling all liquids within a 4x3x3 area.

[@janfalk4393]

or a builder could fix, and other things

[@oreo1749]

@AppleTank for me the best part of Minecraft is sitting back and watching all of your machines do their thing

[@turbo_jcgll7137]

Make it so villagers (more specifically the miners) can climb ladders.

[@dontquestionit_]

I agree, I want one of my homes to have a ladder with the beds being at the top floor, and they'll need to climb ladders to do this.

[@copperboltwire320]

He has been mocking around with this for a few days now, i asked him about this 4 days ago...

[@formtale6102]

Yes, so that going up and down is a lot easier for mine shafts, faster than stairs. Maybe even have that they take the fastest route for miners so you can have stairs and ladders but they are more likely to use ladders than stairs.

[@bailey69541]

I knew that you would be talking about miners in this video but I wasn't expecting there to be a minor too

[@SpectreLgs]

Lol good joke lol

[@juandreferreira5532]

nice pun

[@bhavyaranjan3807]

Thats a good one😂😂😂

[@seguaye]

badum bum tisss

[@robertmendez8383]

😂

[@AflacMan13]

RESOURCE MANAGER!!! Make a villager who specializes in resource management. Makes rail tracks, send minecarts full or supplies, and creates storage systems to store and transport whatever they are given to wherever storage is. They'd use Donkeys with chests at first, until they can build an automated rails and carts system to transport supplies long distances. The villagers work to gain resources for the merchant to sell and buy. The storage/resource manager will need a storage building, and the merchant will put his permanent shop in town in the front of the storage building! The miners, farmers, blacksmiths, guards, lumberjacks, etcetera will all gather resources, and place them in the main storage... or hand them to the resource manager if he is close enough, OR place them in the nearest "donkey transport pickup station" storage box (if they are still on donkey transportation), or in the nearest "automated storage system receptacle" chest or hopper, and the donkey and resource specialist will come along now and again to transport the goods to the main storage, or if it is automated, the automated receptacles will auto-transport the goods to the resource manager who will ORGANIZE them into an automated chest system, and the merchant will sell goods to and from the town and to the player from those goods, as well as get goods from outside the town as well! If you have a villager wizard/enchanter/cleric (whatever you call it... magic caster villager of some sort, your choice of course. :-P ) you could EVEN have the enchanter be able to take a chest, and enchant it into an Enderchest! Once he/she enchants 2 Enderchests, he/she will place the first one in the Resource Manager's Storage Emporium, and the other will go whereever the Storage Specialist tells the Enchanter to put it! :-) This way the villagers; like the Miner for example; can dump supplies into the Enderchest, a minecart system, or donkey pickup box and the village can move supplies huge distances whenever they want! :-D

[@sirnubless]

Cool idea

[@HonoredSenior]

UnderRated Comment

[@lissethponcedeleon3816]

Amazing!

[@liaharv8161]

A storage manager would be great too... someone who organizes the chests

[@Damused]

Everyone should like it so Tango Tek can see it!

[@kyrokrypt]

I think you should do the blacksmith, because the village could benefit from better tools, especially because it has the ores now from the miner

[@HealthyAndAware]

KyroKrypt if u watched his other vids you would now that he has made a blacksmith

[@zane6633]

Gnotic_nelf riddles bud he meant for the next dev play through

[@dreamproduction9840]

He did made black smith bruh

[@orangejuice1287]

you should add a fisher they will be able to provide a source of food like the farmer and butcher but they have a rare chance to fish up something of use and the more expensive the thing he could fish up is the less the chance to get it edit: i just was thinking and the fish will be able to be traded

[@OutDoorTurtle88]

Great idea they should definitely do that

[@SpectreLgs]

Cool

[@zelic360]

Maybe a villager which could also explore the seas because the aquatic update braught so much great changes into Minecraft. That villager will obviously go fishing, and may explore the depths of the vast oceans.

[@orangejuice1287]

@@zelic360 Great Idea!

[@zelic360]

@@orangejuice1287 Yours is great as well! Hopefully Tango can implement this villager alongside playing through the let's dev series.

[@syberyah]

"...darkness spawns badness and badness.. Eats my face." - Tango 2019

[@deinfamous5293]

Tavin, i agree

[@DumplingIX]

Her name is syberyah or his

[@syberyah]

@@DumplingIX if you're talking yo De Infamous, I think he probably meant Tango and it somehow autocorrected or something

[@globalezernichtung6264]

It would be amazing if you made it so that villagers have the same bed forever once they claimed one. THat would allow more technical players to build systems like u did with the miner falling down all over the village to make it efficient.

[@alfiemac9928]

Probs because thats what the blacksmith is for

[@jadynmcaulay9859]

Yes, I think he should do that to.

[@christianbryan7474]

Could you have the children's last names be the same as their parent's? That would be awesome

[@demeincosmos1164]

Create blood lines for villager could be cool like can't marry any one with same last name(family)

[@ovencake523]

Yeah, nobody wants to marry their sibling.

[@demeincosmos1164]

There is maybe have it only if dont have another villager family but with penalty like child will have like make harder to get skills and will be depressed till marrys villagers with differnt family

[@demeincosmos1164]

May even let player change name to create new family from same family like nomads will never come with same as villagers last name and on marrying marage last name will be one with higher states child will inherit one parents last name

[@jaldinsicon]

you could also link some skills, like if the dad was a lvl 150 farmer, then he would start with 15 farming, maybe running it on a threshold so once parent reaches a certain level they get more skill, or just a straight percentage

[@rolltribe6535]

"What if" there were special enemies that emerged once you had a certain number of villagers. theifs would appear after you have say 8 villagers, the theifs goal would be to steal resources from your town storage. regular villagers would not alert guards of theifs due to them blending in, but if a guard sees them the guard will start attacking and calling over other guards. just an idea i got while watching the videos, you should make some custom mobs that have the common goal of destroying a village. the theif was just a specific idea i got

[@whtdwarfbackhe]

Smart idea! I have a suggestion as well: Traitors. Whenever a guard's happiness gets to zero, there is a low chance he will become a traitor. If your village is small, he will sabotage some things and act like the thief. If the village is big, he will try to kill the guards. Since he himself was a guard, he would know when the guards are weakest. He could also help thieves.

[@nb-the-massive-mediocrity]

Yeah I agree

[@bork6996]

@@whtdwarfbackhe cool idea :D

[@DrinkSoupOrEatSoup]

Eggcelent point sir

[@eririan_]

Thief not theif

[@rashkavar]

One thing to keep in mind regarding the cost of adding villagers: the base cost of adding a villager by adding a house. You've already got it set to something like 5 emeralds per person based solely on the need for a place to sleep. I'm almost tempted to say that the cost of villager tokens should be pretty trivial for the rank-and-file grunt roles like miner, farmer and lumberjack. As you get more specialist professions - blacksmiths, teachers, and especially guys like druids, that's where the cost should be for individual villagers. Guards should probably also be more expensive, so they're not seen as being expendable, since they're the ones with a decent chance of death. That's my view, anyway. All depends on how expensive you want everything to be, of course.

[@theonly5001]

Maybe make it, that the prices ramp slowly up. The first couple are rather cheap. But as you get more and more, they get more and more expensive.

[@rashkavar]

@@theonly5001 There's a good thought. That further increases the incentive to create a well rounded, diverse village rather than taking the monoculture approach and having the town just have a billion lumberjacks or something.

[@rashkavar]

@@stealthninja_o1s no worries, accidents happen. I was tempted to make a snarky comment, but decided that would be mean.

[@3Ppaatt]

I think the first of a profession should be at a discount, since they are how you will get more emeralds. _Every_ villager after that should be a challenge. You think you need two farmers? Prove that your one miner and one lumberjack and one farmer can work together well enough to afford your second farmer.

[@rashkavar]

@@3Ppaatt Maybe there should be a hardcore mode where costs are ramped up for people who want a hardcore grind, and a regular/easy mode where costs are more friendly for people wanting to screw around and have fun. Or just make it something that's adjustable in config files so that people can adjust it accordingly. What you describe sounds like a punishment for growing the village, which, to, me, is boring and grindy. Which does not invalidate the fact that you think it sounds fun; thus my suggestion of differing cost formats.

[@elliotstarkey3014]

That merchant 'STOP WALKING!!' sequence was gold - awesome job Tango!

[@Arnie1066]

Elliot Starkey needs to do the same thing with the nomads too

[@ratgirl34]

What if you want the miner to pick up stone and stuff? For building things, like new houses lol

[@nicolefonoti4637]

ratgirl34 how is that lol dude

[@jacobrispoli1363]

they should! That way all your villagers will start using stone tools instead of wooden ones!

[@ashleysanford8645]

@@jacobrispoli1363 yes!! Stone tools. Then iron so he can mine Diamonds!

[@liljimmy4355]

If A miner finds a special ore like a emerald or diamond the skill and happiness level goes up.🙂

[@Ic1clez_]

Top 10 ways to cure depression

[@strawberrana]

I think just emerald

[@LadyVineXIII]

I agree with the happiness portion of this.

[@CillianMurphy1993]

Amazing as always boss, really like the way you're presenting this series, engaging and still covering all the nitty gritty stuff. Suggestion; The miner does a check on their torch count, and goes to get more at 12 or less currently. Maybe set it lower, to 6, or maybe 4? If they used more of their torches before returning, it cuts down on time spent travelling, which could be considered mining time wasted. I appreciate they shouldn't run them down to 0, just in case they need them on the way back for X reason, but 12 seems too many.

[@jessedaniel5576]

i agrree

[@bbfcgaming8011]

Yeah, if it only goes down to twelve, whats the point of having those extra twelve?

[@demeincosmos1164]

Like why not like 1 lowest so can use to max output. Not waist material

[@CillianMurphy1993]

@@demeincosmos1164 keeping a few covers them for emergencies, maybe miner next door floods the tunnel and knocks off some torch's, or digs some gravel with a torch on it. I still think they should keep a few, just not 12

[@demeincosmos1164]

@@CillianMurphy1993 agreed 4 Probly most ever need for emergency

[@ST-wr6bo]

Day 3- Tango single handily does a better job with villagers then mojang has done in the whole history of Minecraft

[@ajxx9987]

Mojang should hire him

[@harrisonmathews8740]

Lol

[@benschurman8607]

Ajxx 99 no because then he wouldn’t have the freedom he has here

[@yehudahausman4352]

I agree except Mojang would never do this because it changes the goal and core of the game (which is to explore and survive) whereas this mod makes it mainly about villagers.

[@emmanuelgoldbergstein8769]

@@yehudahausman4352 If minecraft is an explore and survive game than the Earth is flat. Exploring MC worlds is the most boring thing ever and survival is as simple as building a 10x10 wheat/carrot/whatever farm and a bed

[@Cynic1254]

Mayby you Should let the villagers stand still a bit more they are literally always moving Also maybe let the miner pick up some stone (like have always a certain amount of stone in the storage) to allow other villagers to craft stone tools + the miner doesn’t have to create cobblestone from thin air

[@smellyfries1834]

3 things: 1: Can you make it so that all villagers stop when you interact/look in their inventory? 2: Shouldn't the miner bring back some of the cobblestone to make better tools? 3: Can the villagers use the furnace in the storage to cook food? Loved the Video, can't wait for the next.

[@robertmendez8383]

Yes the stone tools especially

[@LoGKhepre]

What about the 2x2 sized trees? Larger spruce trees or Dark Oak. Edit: I feel like it would cost less logs to trade for about the same amount of emeralds it has for trading a stack of oak because they'd be breaking their tool a whole lot faster then breaking normal trees and for the larger spruce trees it should take a lot more time cutting it down even at a higher skill level because of the size of the tree. This would rake in more spruce for the village and would be productive. Still keeping the stack for the amount of emeralds in the trade so people can't scam the merchant.

[@CinemainMotion]

Idea to balance the cost of professions: Make them cost more or less depending on how many villagers are already in the village. Either a hard wall after 3 villagers with more walls later on, or a gradual scale. That way the player doesn't have a terrible time starting out, but doesn't feel like they're playing in god mode later on when they have more emerald income from having a larger village.

[@LinaBoeckwurm]

Right! I had this exact thought around the start of the video, but forgot to write it down and add it to my response when I wrote it ar the end of the video. Because I think getting started is really hard, but afterwards the ball gets rolling fast.

[@WilliamHunekeMusic]

You could simply make the cost increase by the number of villagers in that profession already. More miners means they cost more.

[@johnydl]

Maybe have buying villager profession tokens be a little less than the zero sum of the merchant, each time you buy a token that token gets more expensive bbut the others get slightly cheaper but not enough to be zero sum, 1st token 3 emeralds second token 4 emeralds etc... But the prices of all lets say 12 other tokens drop by 1/16th of an emerald (and the player only sees the round up price)

[@emperorsascharoni9577]

I don’t like this idea so much but you do make a point i think you should be able to buy them for a cheap price at first maybe first 3 farmers first 2 miners something like that but then after that go to the normal price because if your city grows it should grow exponentially like in a real city and not stay at the same growth all time (maybe increase a little bit when the city grows but it should still get easier to let your city grow the bigger it is

[@redcoat7453]

i was just about to comment a similar idea

[@rileydurrer2497]

There should be a journalist villager who at the end of each day would tell you what happened. Ex: deaths, gathered materials, children born/aged etc

[@Tenteono]

I like the idea, but at a certain point it becomes too difficult to program for too little benefit... A death message is relatively easy... all resources gathered, not so much.

[@Wizarth]

Or an accountant.

[@aubreyeiselstein1469]

Town crier!

[@dadplscomhome5380]

Just put it in the chat

[@kyuubro]

maybe some kind of info board inside the main hall. By placing a sign below an item frame the villagers could keep track of the number of items they farmed that day by changing the number on the sign and reset it every morning

[@MoreInsane96]

I have two suggestion. Make a custom gui for architect and the other guy (maybe for the merchant too?). Vanilla one is ... bland. The other minor thing is to slight change pathfinding to increase priority to stay on the same Y when walking. I see lots of times villagers walk on chests and things.

[@jordan12962]

For smelting, the villager should put in the max amount of items the fuel can smelt. For example, if one coal was the fuel, the villager will put up to eight items in if possible.

[@negativeentropy3128]

The miners (and all villagers for that matter) AI should allow them climb ladders, allowing people to be more flexible with buildings and mines

[@SpectreLgs]

But when they are hungry what will happen tough? (They will fall)

[@mikedanielespeja6128]

@@SpectreLgs Or ya know how players do it. Eating while sliding up the ladder.

[@negativeentropy3128]

@@SpectreLgs pathfind down the ladder, or up, depending on where the food source is. I more meant this addition as another way for the AI to see a path, instead of finding stairs, if the ladder is quicker to their desired location, they take that instead. They wont eat on the ladder is another fix.

[@slevinchannel7589]

More Flexibility Need the Nomad. Can he open Fencegates and get in 'closed' Villages?

[@Swagerm-qc4kx]

Good punch in the nogin

[@robertmendez8383]

I would pay money for this mod the way it is now great work Tango Tek! I vote to see gaurd next for sure.

[@UnknownUnknown-iv1he]

The kid's last name is "galdrakarl", which means "wizard" in Icelandic.

[@amythistariara]

wait a minute, there are 3 magic classes.... It must be a sign, do a magic class next

[@laynepilcher1574]

We know who is getting the Druid token

[@that1gamerlad98]

ur a wizard wendell!

[@darkalligraph]

I really wanna watch this ... but it's midnight Eh.. fine sure why not. It'll be worth it

[@ml2919]

İt's 18:48 in my country :d

[@demonofsixpaths2078]

It’s 1:50am for me

[@darkalligraph]

Ye.. it was worth it. (Haven't finished but its good so far)

[@suddenapple1818]

You must suffer the torture of enjoyment !

[@nosleepjones4551]

Its 11:58 where I am

[@mcdiamond2405]

Could you put the miners in a minecart to get them up the mine and down?

[@braybuss5379]

Also could you add something where the miner picks up stone for stone tools for the rest of the village

[@robertmendez8383]

Yes! Why is this not getting more attention?

[@slevinchannel7589]

I was really surprised that he makes the Stones just dissapear; makes no sense to me. You can do Things with Stones, can't you?

[@tdstraitjacket1]

Maybe an option to collect the stone instead of having it disappear. Maybe by rotating the pickaxe in the item frame above a tunnel would tell the miner to collect the stone from that tunnel instead of destroying it. So when you have plenty in storage and don't want anymore you can simply run down and rotate the pickaxe back to upright position to stop the collection.

[@danielcoker7063]

Have mining return a percentage of the stone, much like cutting down trees?

[@Arnie1066]

As Daniel said, and ‘check’ storage levels to see if it’s required. If Stone in Storage > 32 then don’t collect Originally thought a stack but if you have multiple miners you could quickly have 3-4 stacks of stone. You only need enough for stone tools to be made for each worker

[@whothehorton901]

I think there should different kinds of gaurd's, for example an archer/crossbow soilder. A heavy sheild soilder, and a flinger gaurd. The flinger should be a special looking iron golem that can pickup and throw things like for example, enemy's into walls, Allies into the enemies, blocks or tnt at the enemy, and may even act as a worker in the mines or other wise lifting gear and people to pasific locations. Edit: I wasn't aware I had bad Grammer and I'm sorry, English is not my first language and I'm still learning it.

[@dennisysj8868]

Hello good sir! Maybe ye should add a hippy dippy POPULATION COUNTER :p

[@robertmendez8383]

Good idea

[@WilliamHunekeMusic]

Can you make a token to designate an input chest for sorted storage systems? That would make the storage building more efficient. You could even have a system that makes the villagers remember where to look for certain items. E.g. when a villager finds what they need they create a tag that says "food is in [specific chest]" The memory tag would work even without an item sorter because if they fail to find the item in the specific chest they remembered they can continue to search randomly and create a new tag when they do find it.

[@johnydl]

Or use profession markers on chests to say this profession dump in this chest (I might like a dump everything in this chest option and build my own sorting system that the village can withdraw from)

[@pafnutiytheartist]

To properly balance the economy you need to make the price of tokens go up the more villager you have. You were barely able to afford anything when you started but after a few days the resources start to becompe plentiful. Basically your resources grow faster the more villagers you get and you need to balance it by making new villagers more and more expensive.

[@Wizarth]

I thought this too, but that kind of presumes you want to keep it at the village level (which probably makes sense for Minecraft). But in the real world, adding more people to a community doesn't have an increasing cost, and that's why cities are a thing. And this is Tango "Iron Golem Farmer" Tek, after all, I bet he's already considering how to turn this system up to 11 and see what exploits happen!

[@see3655]

I have an idea for the miner, since he doesn't pick up stone (and you basically skip stone tools I guess?) Let the miner pick up stone, if he uses a wooden pickaxe. In theory, he should bring a bunch of cobble to the storage room in the evening, which will allow some villagers (including the miner) to craft themselves some stone tools. Once he has a stone pickaxe, he will no longer pick up stone and no chests will get clogged up with cobble.

[@rileydurrer2497]

You should add multiple skins for each villager type

[@jdupree3875]

You should make some.

[@pinkrosekittygames]

Hey can you do the blacksmith next as I think it makes sense as it will make the village more efficient

[@flipfromtheflop1446]

I think the school would be great as he now has a child

[@Anti-HyperLink]

How exactly does the order he does his videos in affect the game?

[@scottdavie7057]

@@Anti-HyperLink Because he's adding villagers in certain professions based on what the video's focussing on. So if next video is about the blacksmith, then he'd add one next, which would make better tools available to the other villagers so they can do their jobs more efficiently.

[@slevinchannel7589]

For those who didn't see it. Part 2, Minute 16:48-17:26!! There's the Confirmation of Archers, Mages, Mages Guild and Global Updates, all Confirmed. Many seem to have overlooked it.

[@pinkrosekittygames]

@@flipfromtheflop1446 true

[@ChrisEllerby]

When trading with a villager, in addition to them stopping walking, they should also face the player. Really loving this series! Hope you can do a series showing the coding/design process at some point too. Thanks for everything!

[@gordonfischer8484]

The miner mined redstone with a wooden pickaxe.... you should add mining levels. And mining speed if if it isn't all ready implemented

[@Wizarth]

Interesting, but that then raises the question of, what should the miner do? They only dig straight shafts. So they go back to village hall and float a pickaxe icon... but then the player checks and says "Yup you HAVE a pickaxe". In short, like the idea, but there are complications.

[@katcyer26]

I prefer it as it is

[@TheHaragarLP]

I actually have multiple questions: 1.) How do miners keep them self save down in the mines. Lets say they dig into a cave and there are 3 zombies there, i would expect them to run away, but they dont call the guards or anything like that. So how does that work? 2.) Do tool qualities (wood, stonen, iron, etc) have an impact on what miners can mine? 3.) Why shouldn´t miners take stones? It would be a resource the village can use for better tools befor getting a blacksmith, for the player for building or even for selling. If the problem is filling up the miner inventory to fast maybe make it so that the collect a max of 3 stacks and then vansih the rest. 4.) Will this mod work in multiplayer?

[@monkeyseatsbananas3695]

I can answer question 2. As we saw that the miner here had a wooden pickaxe and that he mined Redstone, i'm pretty sure that doesn't matter.

[@TheHaragarLP]

@@monkeyseatsbananas3695 oh OK I must have missed that. Thanks for the answer

[@monkeyseatsbananas3695]

@TheHaragarLP no problem!

[@Lapis_Reborn]

I am 100% sure that this mod will work in multiplayer. Everyone will have to have the mod installed though, but that's how mods work!

[@phoenixgaming6647]

TheHaragarLP 1. I think they run away normally and the guards automaticaly gets called 2. No they don’t 3. I agree, it’s a real shame they don’t. I hope he changes that 4. Yes, it is because he is running servers for the mod

[@bryncristie5602]

Tradesman should have the skin of a business man, like a recruitment consultant

[@chroma1932]

But this is more like mid evil times than modern

[@alexb.65]

Enjoying the series! Some feedback: When your village gets bigger it can be harder to find certain villagers (the merchant comes to mind), so I think it would be cool to add a system where you can ask any villager if they've seen a certain villager and if they have seen them that day, they can point in their direction. Also, a sorting system for chests would be useful, maybe by using item frames?

[@rieska178]

That would be REALLY hard to do. But maybe he could make it that the structures would show on maps

[@jamiemccollin438]

I like the item frames idea. I feel a bit lost on the rest of it, though.

[@ncoll36]

He has talked about it before, wanting to implement some form of chest sorting in the storage room, just hasn't got around to it or come up with a nice solution yet.

[@guyochakovsky9100]

Does giving them a fortune pickaxe work?

[@Naokarma]

based off of the lumberjack episode enchants need to be programmed individually but still work

[@nobodyimportant2470]

He stated in one of the earlier videos of the series that when you get a library and librarian that villager will enchant tools for them so yes it should work.

[@Blobby90]

Your energy and love for creating things is fantastic. When your merchant code wasn't working you just laughed and kept trying which is wonderful! As someone who has coded in the past there's nothing quite like watching it work for the first time!

[@rebeldemon8225]

I love Tangos creativity and originality, so inspiring, keep it up man!!

[@tylerdulkis6883]

What if they run into a cave with mobs inside? Death??!!!

[@marc-andreblais5818]

they will repair the tunnel as mentioned in the video

[@XenophonSoulis]

@@marc-andreblais5818 Not if mobs attack first.

[@kylekevinmarquez8697]

I was wondering the same thing, what if the miner was mining his own business then accidentally opened an area large enough for a zombie (we all know zombies quickly rush at any villager) Or a skeleton which is a ranged mob before the miner repairs the tunnel? It could mean death to the miner since it takes time for them to scan everything. The response time of hostile mobs is much more quicker than the scanning of the miner. Correct me if I'm wrong though.

[@MoreInsane96]

@@kylekevinmarquez8697 I'm assuming that the Miner will run away. And I'm pretty sure skeletons don't attack villagers

[@comradeadam7470]

You should make the child's surname match the surname of their parent.

[@SomebodytoRemember]

The fact that you made a better villager update than Mojang says a lot, this is really impressive!!!

[@bagelmeat1146]

I would not want this In Minecraft it would be too moddy Minecraft needs to be simple I it's a good mod but in Minecraft it would be annoining your villagers would die of hunger

[@rivenrime]

It doesn't affect villages that don't use the tokens, so you could have a completely vanilla village in addition to the modded one, if you wanted. And if you have a farmer, the ones in the modded village shouldn't starve. I don't know that it's "better", though. It's more complex and I can't wait to get my hands on it, but Mojang doesn't seem to like to introduce this level of complexity into the game. It kind of takes away from the sandbox aspect. So it's just different goals, imo. 🙂

[@THEWOMBATRULES]

the thing is this wouldn't necessarily work for Minecraft and its normal State because you'll end up playing the mod as opposed to just playing the game as you wish to.

[@robertskitch]

@@THEWOMBATRULES My playstyle is generally building on and fixing up villages anyway, and there's already plenty of stuff that I don't really play with in the game. As someone who's not all that into combat I'd really like for Mojang to add more non-combat challenges into the game. I'd care more about something like this than pillager raids or the ability to create yet another farm.

[@THEWOMBATRULES]

@@robertskitch well congratulations on liking those things, unfortunately for you millions of other people also play the game in different ways.

[@coucksugarplums2272]

Can you add a nitwit token? For if a nomad has a really good skill for a more expensive class like a bard. It might only cost one emerald but could be a good early game investment.

[@DinoBrikGaming]

make's sense, but you can make him a different villager at first like a farmer then turn him into your example: a bard.

[@Woomy42231]

I like your idea, but I think if this existed, it would ONLY work on nomads. Don't ask me why

[@edwardjosh2784]

@@succfusion a nitwit would be cheeper then a farmer so you cold save some emeralds the problem is it would not be worth it .

[@NCPBails]

that is such a great idea, it would give the nitwit a purpose too instead of just killing it off

[@WWEMikano]

@@edwardjosh2784 Although the proposed nitwit would indeed be cheaper, you might as well make them a farmer/miner to get some resources from them while you're earning enough emeralds. In the beginning you need the resources anyway, and you might consider it a waste to have an occupied bed for a villager that does nothing. Idk

[@hcblue]

Not gonna lie, I've been binging through these dev playthrough videos today, because they're all so awesome.

[@All3me1]

Same

[@elay5267]

I have a little idea, you could have every Villager have a favorite food that makes him happy when he eats it. Also love the Letsplay and cant wait to get my hands on the mod

[@nobodyimportant2470]

Could be interesting but personally I think a spice of life approach would be better. The more you feed a villager the same thing the less happiness they will gain(possibly going negative if only 1 food is available) and they automatically go for something they have not had in a while when it becomes available. This would add more importance to the cook profession as they are needed to keep the diets diverse.

[@elay5267]

NobodyImportant good idea, but you could do both ideas: when a Villager has a favorite food he always looks for it, but after some time he doesn’t like it as mutch anymore and searches for new favorite food, and as you said, if they always eat the same food they gain less and less happiness until it’s negative. Very good idea tho

[@flipfromtheflop1446]

I said this last time but "You could make the Scavanger, who can be sacrificed and you make him/her walk away and he/she might return days maybe weeks later but with some good items"

[@Luceshoe13]

I’m getting fallout shelter vibes from this comment.

[@wolframstahl1263]

I like this idea of some adventurer type villager. How would you suggest they would work? Here's an idea from me, but I'd love to see what your vision for that would have been! You'd either send him away manually (by buying a "field trip" token and placing it in a storage chest/giving it to the villager), or have a set of items they require to start an adventure/scavenger hunt (a selection from these suggestions maybe: a full set of leather or better armor, a sword, a bow, a map, a compass, a boat, torches, food etc.) Once they go on a trip, they'll disappear like the hermits, but in the morning. When they are away, they have a chance to, depending on their level and equipment quality: - return home - die/disappear - find loot from any (overworld chest) loot table (- get drops from hostile mobs) or just be away for another day without anything happening. Each day could also cost them an amount of food/torches/durabilities and they'd return to the village not by RNG, but when one of those is depleted. Is that in any way what you had in mind?

[@christofferhjorth2243]

interesting idea, i like it

[@flipfromtheflop1446]

@@Luceshoe13 Oh I have never played fallout so I had no idea, I just thought it would add some strategy to the village

[@revdragonus9917]

@@Luceshoe13 me too lol

[@KavinKannan-t1p]

Profession Ideas: Diver The Diver is a specialized villager who dives into a nearby ocean and looks for treasures. At the end of every day, he comes back with a bunch of goodies. Note: This requires an ocean to be within fifty or a hundred blocks or so. Fisherman Uses a fishing rod and fishes in a nearby river or lake. Generates fish, which is a food supply for the village. Also has a tiny chance to fish other objects like leather boots or enchanted books. Alchemist Lives in a mysterious hut and brews potions. Collects water with water bottles from nearby rivers or lakes and other ingredients from the farmers or chefs (But they don't have to use nether wart for awkward potions - I don't think farmers farm those) Archer A guard who uses a bow and an arrow to shoot enemies from range. Can occupy a tall tower, a sort of lookout post, from where he can fire at enemies with his vantage point. Perhaps increase the range at which he can hit enemies proportionally with the height he is at, but put a hard cap to this limit at maybe 40-50 blocks - snipers haven't been invented yet!

[@grey1213a]

I'd like to see the guards first. In a non-creative play, I would imagine they'd be prioritized about now for defense

[@robertmendez8383]

I would have to agree

[@flying_gorilla8069]

They should have different weapons like bows and shield and maybe even custom weapons like spears

[@JackDjTom6]

Why does the miner not pick up cobblestone to upgrade tools to stone tools ?

[@sarahpetersen6576]

I like this idea, too. Blacksmith can be for more advanced iron or diamond tools.

[@davidfuhr5455]

Most likely because of the absolute ton of cobble that would be left in storage

[@supercables251]

@@davidfuhr5455 Just have the miner stop picking it up after he collects 1 stack, and stop delivering to storage after the storage has 8 stacks.

[@sidassassin9746]

he will eventually

[@pubgfan9751]

Yea true...

[@KaelelMinato]

I really like how this is evolving, In the end, I foresee a "Civilisations"-like mod :p But, damn, I really want to play this mod now! Good job !

[@Robertganca]

Can I set guard post somehow? If no, then that should be added. If yes, then how?

[@fdsfd1]

Nope, guards don't have a building as most sleep during the day and defend at night.

[@fdsfd1]

@Cantley Family you can make a suggestion on that. I doubt that Tango will be looking in the comments for suggestions.

[@kinremnant4616]

I feel that will be thing eventually. Given that doors could be broken. Tho could make doors unbreakable. Feel like it would break the spirit of minecraft tho. Then there will be the rain mech in minecraft so mobs will be a issue during the daytime anyways.

[@aaronking2020]

@@fdsfd1 but he DOES look in the comments for suggestions almost every episode he adds and revamps things and says: some people in the comments were worried about [suggestion] or yeah somebody in the comments said [suggestion] so i decided to add that

[@slevinchannel7589]

There should definetly be Archer Guards, like he said as 'Upcoming' in the Second Part.

[@fractile8915]

Why doesn’t the miner pick up the stone? Makes sense, then he can place his blocks he collected rather than just summon them

[@nilsdock]

If you want to build a village out of stone, you would have to mine stone manually. makes more sense that you pick up stone from a storage chest where the villagers put it after mining. also stone tools.

[@see3655]

Stone would quickly become a problem when your chests get filled with it. But it would be nice if miners could pick up stone depending on their tool. For example, if they use a wooden pickaxe, they will pick up stone, bring it to the storage in the evening, craft a stone pickaxe and then stop picking up stone. That would also allow other villagers to craft themselves some stone tools. And if the storage runs out of stone, the miner will by chance craft a wooden pickaxe and start gathering stone again...

[@nilsdock]

@@see3655 it just seems like a waste. a special storage room for stone would solve the problem, if you don't build it they throw the stone away. if the stone room is full they throw stone away. otherwise they put the stone in the stone room. my solution gives the player the choice to keep the stone or not.

[@see3655]

@@nilsdock that's also a nice idea

[@guid1183]

Maybe its a good Idea to have the player choose of they want the miner to bring cobble

[@TheVampireFreddo]

Tango, I just wanted to show my appreciation for this insane level of work you and your team put into this. I can’t comprehend just how much time and effort go into coding something like this, let alone squashing the bugs that will inevitably pop up. You’re amazing, and please keep up the good work!

[@hassaan3584]

The children should pick up some skills from the villagers in the village

[@redstonerepeater2476]

I agree, like they walk around and watch different classes (the more higher level the worker the kid watches the more chance to get a skill level)

[@fireeagle3352]

suggestion: If a mineshaft is deactivated maybe a druid could solve the problem by deleting the fluid beeing in the way/stopping the miner.

[@braxtoncleveland2993]

I agree

[@IhkyGonn]

Loving your vids, loving your mod, loving your bright mood, loving your work, thanks for all of it :D

[@hamstap85]

I love this series, as a dev it's fun to watch the semi-live debugging process. Merchant doesn't stop on interaction. Fix 1, still doesn't stop. Fix 2, disappears. Fix 3, finally stops! And the breakpoint for the miner's pathfinding! 😂 So much fun

[@braxtoncleveland2993]

You should make idle positions and archers. Keep up the great work!!! 👍

[@eggrolls78]

I appreciate that the developer would upload this gameplay to the audience and let us see how this works. Even if there are still bugs this is still amazing and I can't wait to play this 😯🥰

[@X606]

A lot of devs do that, some even livestream making stuff! And its great

[@eggrolls78]

@@X606 true and yet it seems this one is what I'm most excited for. lol

[@bobothefearless]

my one problem with not picking up cobble stone is that they cant craft a stone pickax and that kinda removes the need to upgrade pickaxes when you can mine out everything with wood.

[@imagine_big9398]

But wood is slow and has low durability. So the miner will take forever to mine ores

[@rivenrime]

I was thinking this a bit, too. I thought they were supposed to be able to upgrade. Maybe they should only pick up a little bit of cobble, so they don't ful up their inventories, but there is still some available. Or maybe I misunderstood something, I don't know.

[@bobothefearless]

@@rivenrime or maybe if you each stone bock mined had a like 10% chance to drop cobblestone so you would still get some with out the overflow

[@demeincosmos1164]

Maybe let in used mined material in mine to to be say turn them in to gems and also tango has them rebuild tunnel with cobblestone but if deletes cobblestone where material come from?

[@Can-bc3jg]

exactly my problem i had with the miner

[@madmen6544]

#idea Give the merchant a donkey, with a saddle and chest on its back, that well follow the merchant with a lead. Add an archer town guard. Make it so town guards can use horses. Add a stable. Add a stable boy to take care of the animals in the stable. Add a barracks building for the town guards. They can train and live in the barracks. Add a market building. The market can be the central part of town where villagers can gather, trade, earn happiness and give the merchant a place to stay. The merchant can also have a much larger selection of goods to sell. Add carts, pulled by horses, mules or donkeys, for some of the villagers. Like the lumberjack, miner, farmer and merchant. This well allow the villagers, and merchant, to carry more goods to the store house. By the way. There are many people who enjoy doing their job. Maybe you could make it so there is a chance for villagers gain happiness when they accomplish something special in their job. Like a miner finding gold and diamonds. Or chief when he makes a cake. Thanks for sharing!

[@TRUSTeTMguest]

dude what you're doing is AMAZING keep up the spectacular work man!

[@lasso8863]

What if miners come along dirt/gravel, do they have a shovel?

[@nuip7936]

they just use their pickaxe, maybe he will implement thme using shovels in the future

[@lasso8863]

Yes your both probably right

[@pimpenders735]

Keep it up tango you are inspiring me to come back to minecraft, your detication is insane.

[@zelic360]

Ikr he's great

[@ryanfloberg5601]

Me too bro!

[@benumin6563]

*dedication

[@pimpenders735]

Ha i am dyslexic succ it

[@benumin6563]

Pim Penders good for you? I was just correcting what you said.

[@StarNanny]

2 block separation between shafts is perfect, considering he only scans what he initially sees. ❤

[@brayden8905]

If you give the miner a bottle, and he breaks an ore, would he be able to collect the xp and make a bottle o enchanting?

[@PhenixArcher]

Yeah what happens to the xp

[@SpiderKoloPL]

I really like this idea, actually. But the same could go for other professions dealing with experience: killing animals, fighting mobs, crafting with furnace... Then enchanter could need those bottles to craft enchanted books and tools. Or you could sell those bottles for few emeralds. Or you could use it yourself and enchant stuff for them... or yourself.

[@brayden8905]

@@SpiderKoloPL Didn't think of that...

[@juandreferreira5532]

thought this was pretty cringe until @@SpiderKoloPL brought up his comment (enchanter profession sounds pretty cool ngl, plus it really adds something to the mod)

[@juandreferreira5532]

@@succfusion aw cool

[@rubenh541]

The houses-beds system seems a little off to me. When you join the game, villagers will pick a random bed to be theirs, this happens everytime you join (at least I think that’s how it is). This means that villagers/families can’t own a house. This makes the game less fun to play, because everytime you join, you come to a “new” village. That’s why I think you should have the ability to link a villager to a bed. I hope you’ll add this! :)

[@safiab.]

Woa! That's a good idea. :D

[@fdsfd1]

I'd say that's not needed. Some places have their inhabitants act like everyone is family. Also, it would just be weird with the whole everybody has a different last name thing.

[@connorlewis2517]

Also, if you have a certain job, you could have the house set to a location close to the worksite. That way when night comes, it's not a long trip home. This can't be the case though if a villager isn't linked to a home

[@Wizarth]

@@connorlewis2517 Related to this, it might also be interesting to have villages swap beds. I think Banished did it this way. Periodically a villager/family would swap, and then the ones pushed out would swap, and such. Eventually, this would settle down into something reasonably efficient. Of course, that requires serializing the bed allocations, rather than regenerating them on each world load, but that seems pretty straightforward.

[@brob1797]

Yea, villagers should be able to get married and obtain their own house, and then there'll be a higher chance of babies (with the sam last name)

[@seeminglymeaningless]

I've only just stumbled onto your channel and have binge-watched all of your "What If" Villagers videos. You are amazing. I honestly can't imagine the dedication you have for this project. If/when you release this mod, I would be willing to pay for it. Some ideas/suggestions/questions: Children - In addition to skipping, kids could explore buildings and talk to adult villagers (which can distract the villagers from their work, making them less efficient, but more happy) - this talking could raise the kid's education/intelligence level. Pets - Animals like dogs, cats and horses could increase villager happiness levels. The animals would need to be fed, and perhaps a child's chore could be to feed the pet animals (or maybe feeding the pet animals befalls the nearest villager when the animal is hungry, so the villager is distracted from its work, but its happiness increases). Dogs and cats would need raw meat products to be stored too for food. Farmers - Develop an affinity for a certain crop. So "Jerryblue Hufflepail" has an affinity for carrots and it makes him happier to farm and even eat carrots. Working with other crops increases his affinity for those other crops, but he has a preference. This would be neat to see, as you'd have the different farmers tending to their own crops, instead of random farmers all over the place. Lumberjack - Have a way of prioritising which type of wood you want more of, so the lumberjacks know which ones to plant. What do they do with the apples, store them for food? Perhaps trees should take longer to grow, based on how your own economy was speeding up. Miners - Miners should collect cobblestone and other stones (granite etc) too, and bring it back to the storeroom for the player to use in their builds and for the other villagers to use (like farmers being able to make stone tools), also keep some in their inventory to use for repairing (instead of pulling blocks from the air). When miners encounter large cave systems (like abandoned mines or caverns), instead of blocking/repairing with cobblestone, fences could be used to partition off the dangerous section, allowing the player to explore the area (they'd need to be notified somehow). Also, mining should obey the mining "rules", so miners should have to trade their tools up in order to mine upper tier ores. Socialising - This is a pet peeve of mine, but why does "having a good time"/happiness = alcohol? I know that it's a sort of fantasy setting and taverns/pubs sell beer. As an Australian, we've got a serious drinking culture and sometimes it's just sad to see young people desperate to fit in/think that drinking is how socialising is done. Sorry for sounding preachy, but maybe in addition to the pints, there could be different drink models, like buckets of milk (that ranchers could collect) or a refreshing glass of watermelon juice - or once cocoa/coffee is added, they could be enjoying a mug of mocha. Skins - It would be neat to see slightly varying skins: keep the same template for the outfit/design per villager model, but change the colour palette just a little for differentiation of each person in a randomised manner. For example, a villager could have black skin, green eyes and blonde hair, but wear the lumberjack outfit. I think that would add some variety to the overall look and also be more inclusive/diverse/representative of the Minecraft playerbase. In that sense I wouldn't limit traditional "gender" colours either, so the female farmer doesn't need to wear a purple/pink undershirt and the male farmer doesn't need to exclusively wear the blue, that could be randomised too. Fishermen - I really think this is a class of villager that would be super neat to include. Fish is another item to trade to the Merchant, another food item, and necessary for pet cats. Fishermen could also possibly attempt to catch squid too. And just like normal fishing, they could also have a chance to "catch" random objects, which would be really cool. Fishing rods would be another item that uses up wood for crafting and eventually able to be enchanted by the cleric/druid/mage. "Death" - If there's a children stage, maybe it makes sense for an elderly stage/passing of old villagers? They could enjoy retirement for a couple of in-game days or weeks before leaving the realm. When they die, their experience isn't lost, perhaps it's passed onto the cleric/druid/mage or whatever so the player doesn't feel like they've invested in a unit's growth to have it just "disappear". Or maybe as they're retired they can take on an apprentice to share some of their education, or be an "elder", walking around and generally improving everyone's happiness with their presence. Well, that's all my ideas for now. You're doing amazing work! jhoi

[@FireallyXTheories]

What happens when the miner walks outside loaded chunks?

[@乂乙丂千乂卩尺]

It'd stop mining and it'd go back most likely

[@elijah613]

looking forward to this mod! Keep The great work up!

[@roxeymcmmo2495]

An idea sorry if someone had already thought of this already but, What if you made chests that were specific to certain Peoples, like a chest with a farmers icon on it, so the farmers will put all their materials in that chest, to help peoples like me have a nice sorted area and the npcs to stick and easier to find a certain chest. Sorry for my bad english :0

[@static7974]

Quick question, if a player puts an enchanted pickaxe in a chest for a miner will the enchantments function as normal? I am especially curious in regards to the mending enchantment.

[@ReedHarston]

Starseeker I believe that he said that was the case in the video where he introduced the librarian/enchanter.

[@Jacob13044]

you can

[@static7974]

I see

[@theaveragejoe7993]

Tango, a villager should put stuff in random chests unless you put an item in a frame on a chest, that way they can have organized storage!

[@thannbanis3639]

And once secondary industry villages (ones who make stuff the primary industry villages gather)like the Butcher, have them deliver raw goods directly to those buildings

[@orestisgeorgatos6725]

This is impossible as AI doesn’t recognize normal item frames only his custom one

[@RyanTosh]

@@succfusion Takes one to know one... Also, that's a really common way of organizing chests, and it sounds like a genius idea to me.

[@thannbanis3639]

Orestis Georgatos I think they meant have markers (villager item frames) for this

[@ReedHarston]

I don’t know how many times I’ve caught myself on a breakpoint I forgot about. ;) I had a thought about crafting. What if villagers gained a ‘crafting’ skill when they made tool instead of gaining experience in their current profession? That way if you were to change a villager to another profession sometime they could keep their crafting skill when making tools for their new profession. Or maybe they just gain blacksmith skill. Or woodworking. I like it how it is now where they gain skill in their profession, I just thought I’d throw that out there. Keep up the awesome stuff Tango. I’m super excited!

[@me_gaming1085]

Give the Miner happiness for finding valuables; that would be more human.

[@woodie232323]

I would like to say again I'm in love with this mod, your doing an amazing job

[@armandsmall9836]

Glad to have you back in this project Tango! But honestly it's good this is not your only priority... Can't have you git sick of this :P This Mod REEEEEEALY is looking amazing!!!! I think the Chef would be a good option, just so your villagers can have some better food to eat, and boost they're happiness. And when you do bring in the rancher, the chef will already be there to cook the meat.

[@jairam3490]

Can the miners break obsidian or even bedrock with wooden pickaxe? Also I guess diamonds don't need to be broken with iron pickaxes

[@austingray-mandala231]

How can a miner with a wooden pickaxe mine diamonds? I love your video but the mechanics should still remain whether it's a player or a villager correct? Also if the miner doesn't collect stone how does he have cobble to repair the tunnel. I can't wait to play your mod and your a genius for all the work you have done. Thank you in advance

[@lexie6238]

Austin Gray-Mandala both of these, and also the random chance to get ore should be limited. Getting diamonds as often as iron is broken

[@Sgrunterundt]

I completely agree. Make miners faster if you think they are too slow, but don't make them make diamonds out of thin air. It is best if they are as like players as possible.

[@wayneing]

Three Ideas: Addition to the Nomad Profession thing, said in the last video, I think you should add a few education levels too, and random happiness levels! Also, you could add a Sanity Level, where the more they work, the more isolated they are from other villagers, like a miner is, and the darker areas they work in, like a miner or a guard, the more they lose sanity. Another way they could lose Sanity, is, say, for example, a guard could lose Sanity and happiness if they accidently don't defend the village enough and another villager gets hurt. Another example is if farmers don't produce enough food, and a lot of villagers lose a lot of hunger. Less Sanity would decrease the amount of happiness they gain, education boosts, lose hunger faster, and even in serious cases, cause them to go on strike for a few minecraft days or kill the villager. A lot of Sanity could increase the amount of happiness gained, like how education increases the amount of skill points gained. Interacting with other villagers, sleeping, and being at parties could increase Sanity levels. Another idea would be to add stationary guards, protecting specific villagers. You could add an item where you right click on a guard, and on another villager, and the guard's priority would be to protect that specific villager. This would help a lot with miners, because even at daytime, their workplace is still dark and dangerous if they run into mobs before they can repair the tunnel. A guard could be there to help the miners and druids.

[@ryanlam1730]

You should make a tutorial book, and when you get a new building or job it tells you what to do with it. For example the storage room you place chests and crafting tables, etc etc. Kinda like other mods that have books that you spawn with

[@redwoodeagle15]

No, I think it's better, if you explore everything on your own.

[@fdsfd1]

Scavenger (taken from the comments of this video): Scavenger goods would be Villager Items (ofc). They would be random goods, maybe spider eyes, bones, sticks, diamonds, etc. The goods would be used by other villagers and would have a connection with the merchant. Merchant Quests (also taken from the comments): Merchant Quests would be a quest to get a certain item. It MUST be a hard to get, uncraftable by the villagers item. Also, it must be a villager item. Only scavengers can complete the quests and when the quest is completed, the merchant will drop off emeralds based on how long it took to finish the quest and the item that was wanted. EDIT: I forgot to add this for the Merchant. Scavengers will ask other villagers for items to help with a quest. Just thought of this for the Scavenger. The Scavenger will have a special building called the Quest Hall. Scavengers that are not searching will hangout in the Quest Hal and a merchant with a quest will be in the Quest Hal. If a Scavenger interacts with the Merchant, that Scavenger is assigned the quest and only he can do it. EDIT 2: Add to this with your ideas!

[@CarlTackett]

fdsfd what kind of items would it give?

[@fdsfd1]

@@CarlTackett Diamond and iron tools with random enchants but it would be really rare, what I said above, enchant books, stuff like that.

[@CarlTackett]

fdsfd oh ok that makes sense

[@mjzl.jakson6372]

Please add two Things 1. A Pinboard on wich is shown what all the villagers want this could implement the Player more Into the Village 2. Please add a Dancing Floor to the Tavern in wich villagers can dance comunity dances together this could give the villagers a bit more life so they dont seem like robots

[@sarc4sticnerd490]

Kids should gain some intelligence by walking around the other villagers if their crafting or working.

[@SpectreLgs]

Good idea

[@pubgfan9751]

Nice idea dude

[@XenophonSoulis]

Great!

[@KelseyCodes]

I’m sure the school would make that void, though.

[@LadyVineXIII]

They will gain this going to the future school. Patience.

[@buttonmash7073]

Watching you interact with the merchant at 4:10 ish made an idea pop into my head. Perhaps if they accepted one random non-villager item per in game [day/week/month] for a villager emerald or 2 to help give a boost to the initial economy. This could all be set in a config file as well - what "normal" items they would/would not accept, how often, and for how much. Just a thought. Still looking really cool and I can't wait to play it.

[@SweeneyDunston]

The miners alone sparked my interest in wanting this mod back when the What If video came out originally. I can hardly wait!

[@etlam262]

What about an independent crafting skill that determines the time it takes a villager to craft an item but isn't related to the profession? That would reduce the impact of changing a villager's profession a bit.