TATA TIAGO.EV v/s MG COMET | EV Comparison | Best Budget EV

Tata Tiago EV and MG Comet are the two most affordable EVs currently available in our market. In this video, we compare both these models to find out which one is the best.
Note: This video contains paid promotion like a product placement, sponsorship, or endorsement
Follow Us On Facebook - bit.ly/2mc9BbS
Follow Us On Instagram - / piloton_wheels
Follow Us On Twitter - / pilot_on_wheels
Follow Our Website - www.pilotonwheels.in
#tatatiagoev #mgcomet #mg #tata

[@Audiobibles]

Here are some disadvantages to MG Comet EV that made me go for Tata Tiago EV Tech lux variant. (These are personal opinions only and i am sure that there maybe advantages to MG comet too including the lower price. Feel free to do your own research and diligence while making your choice) 1. No Fast Charging - Hence strictly only city use, can be considered as second or third car. Cannot be considered as a primary car, if you want to go for a long distance travel and plan your journey using available fast chargers- Hence time required for ROI will be longer. 2. Horn is as if it is fitted inside the car - loud and annoying. (Since the front engine compartment is almost not there) 3. Front co-passenger seat belt rubs against the neck 4. Access to back seat is difficult - since only two doors and seats have to be slid to the front -almost impossible for elderly people 5. Sitting in the back seat is uncomfortable ( sitting in knees raised position) not meant for long drives 6. Hardly any boot space- most basic requirement for any car 7. Top speed is 100kmph vs 119kmph (Tiago EV) - High way drives/overtaking may be a challenge 8. More body roll while changing lanes due to Tall boy design with 12" wheels 9. 12" TIres with suspension of less travel - less comfortable, Less road grip than Tiago EV (14" Tires) and better suspension 10. Front Bonnet access is limited- user cannot replace/disconnect lead-acid battery if required, require visit to service station 11. Sound system is basic (2 Speakers and 2 Tweeters) vs Tiago EV's top variant's Harman Kardan (4 speakers and 4 tweeter) system. 12. No cruise control - Some buttons on steering wheel are just dummy buttons 13. White interior (light color tone) will get soiled easily (especially seat fabric and door armrests) 14. Driver's dashboard display font size is small, making it difficult to read the information displayed. 15. The design is boxy and odd - Not everyone will like it. (purely my subjective opinion) 16. Doors are large - Hence it may be difficult to open the doors sufficiently for all persons to come out in tight parking spots. 17. Front crumple zone is limited- Crash test - NCAP rating not available- Tiago EV has an NCAP rating of 4 18. Large fixed windows at the back - rear passenger cannot lower windows if he requires. 19. No glove box (Cooled glove box available in Tiago EV top variant)

[@sdhineshkumar1984]

Lovely list for the new buyers looking to compare

[@sanalkumarvg2602]

Comet - Fast charging ഇല്ല , Handling, Stability ഇവ കുറവ് , Safety കുറവ് , space is low Citroen EV - Air cooled battery Tiago EV - Full package തീരെ അറിവ് ഇല്ലാത്ത ആളുകളെ marketing ടീമിന് കിട്ടിയാല്‍ sales നടക്കും , അല്ലാത്തവര്‍ tiago ev എടുക്കും ...ഇന്നത്തെ കാലത്ത് 2023 ല് fast charging ഇല്ലാത്ത EV കാര്‍ പത്തു ലക്ഷം കൊടുത്തു വാങ്ങുക എന്നത് ചിന്തിക്കുന്നത് തന്നെ മണ്ടത്തരം

[@MT-re7ip]

It's not for the masses ,it's a rich households second or third car.

[@sanalkumarvg2602]

@@MT-re7ip same price Tiago also can be chosen as second or third car, with fast charging, safety and many other extra aspects

[@MT-re7ip]

@@sanalkumarvg2602 no snob value ,just an ordinary mans four door hatch.Comet is not for the masses,Tiago is for them

[@sanalkumarvg2602]

@@MT-re7ip then check with the comet sale charts, about 90% of them are middle class, who fell on the marketing and ignorance.

[@anoopa607]

Instead of this the comparison of Tiago could have been done with citroen ec3 which is more similar or little bigger. Comet is altogether a smaller and different segment and no ev is there for comparison. But is a well built car basically for city with range from 150 to 180 kms with AC (city / highway). Tiago buyers will not choose Comet instead they will prefer an ec3. Every model has its pros and cons and its buyers based on their requirement. Also would like to correct you guys! Primary car is one which you drive daily and not a 2nd one. My choice goes to Comet cos you will use it daily in city as a primary car. Thought process needs to change. Secondary car is the one used in weekends or for long drives....

[@jitheshyogakshetra6455]

Commet is just an auto taxi car. But tiago is real hatchback car. Thats all...

[@roshanjoseph8030]

I have different opinion , comet is definitely a small car. But it’s more premium. So I would like to place it as city premium car . A secondary car for people who wants to save money, save traffic and premium.

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Tiago is more of a typical car. May be people who wants a primary car can think of this

[@riteshgupta3245]

Comet is best for long-term use, btw how much you're getting in Tiago ev 150 km? Comet has the best and most efficient battery. it can go more than 200 km.

[@roshanjoseph8030]

I totally will disagree ti the auto taxi thg. It’s an unnecessary pre judgement. Drive it and then see. It wil impress you . But just fr a city ride. Imagine an EV auto now will cost more than 4 lakhs. So let’s make that into a stylish AC feature filled car. Makes sense now? Haha

[@akhilaadhi8919]

Comet desingn 😒

[@alwinxavier6727]

Tiago can consider primary car,but comet can consider only as secondary car..that is the main difference...both are good..

[@roshanjoseph8030]

True

[@sajithreghu1]

Well said Bro…

[@shameerali9311]

ഞാൻ ഒരു മാസം ആയി comet ev എടുത്തിട്ട് 2500 km ഓടി. ഇതുവരെ ഹാപ്പി ആണ്. എന്റെ use ന് comet ആണ് ബെസ്റ്റ്. Tiago വേണ്ടവർ അത് എടുക്കട്ടെ. ഇതൊന്നും വേണ്ടാത്ത ആളുകൾ ആണ് കണ്ണും അടച്ചു കുറ്റം പറയുന്നത്.

[@itsme1938]

പുറത്ത് നിന്ന് ചാർജ്ജ് ചെയ്യാൻ എത്ര സമയം എടുക്കും ?

[@MT-re7ip]

​@@itsme1938charge it at house ,take it for city runs.These people who are commenting here are clueless and can't even buy a one lakh rupee bike.Comet is a premium city commuter

[@MT-re7ip]

I bought one ,fantastic it is.

[@itsme1938]

@@MT-re7ip പുറമെ നിന്ന് ചാർജ്ജ് ചെയ്യാൻ എത്ര സമയം എടുക്കും

[@abhinavraj1001]

​@@itsme1938അങ്ങനെ ഒരു പരിപാടി ഇല്ലാത്തതുകൊണ്ട് , സമയം എടുക്കാറേ.. ഇല്ല 😅

[@sandeepsreesai881]

എംജി യിൽ വർക്ക്‌ ചെയ്യുന്നവർ കോമറ്റ് നെ പൊക്കി comt ഇടേണ്ടത് ആണ് ❤️❤️

[@rishabhmalhotraa911]

Comparing the Tata Tiago EV and MG Comet, two of the most affordable EVs, is an excellent way to make an informed choice for a sustainable and eco-friendly ride. 🚗

[@thebikerman_]

Glad you liked it

[@davidbinoy2341]

Compare comet with Autorickshaw

[@malluinmysuru]

Auto riksha alla. ശെരിക്കും വേണ്ടത് tata iris vs comet aanu

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Let’s fix all these in an auto and check the price. Now an auto itself will cost almost 3 lakhs. So, now what?

[@malluinmysuru]

@@roshanjoseph8030 now you plug the auto to main power socket, and put the hands to it and you will see the heaven

[@sivapriyaiktara]

Cheriya car kanda malayalikalku athu autoriksha...

[@pawsandclaws92]

​​@@sivapriyaiktaraബോധം ഇല്ലാത്തവരുടെ സ്ഥിരം അതിക്ഷേപിക്കൽ ആയി അതിനെ കണ്ടാ മതി. ഇത് wuling air ev എന്ന പേരിൽ ലോകത്ത് എത്ര മാത്രം വിറ്റുപോയ വണ്ടി ആണെന്നൊന്നും ആ കിഴങ്ങന്മാർക്ക് അറിയാൻ സാധ്യത ഇല്ല.

[@rsknjn2200]

Ice car ev ആകിയതാണ് tiago... but proper ev platform ആണ് comet... ഈ പ്ലാറ്ഫോം ഇൽ 10ലക്ഷം വണ്ടികൾ ഇറങ്ങിയിട്ടുണ്ട്..അതിലെ ലറെസ്റ് iteration ആണ് air ev (ഇന്ത്യയിൽ comet)..tiago പോലെ safe ആണ് structure.. ഇപ്പോൾ വില കുറച് 6.99 ഇൽ ആണ് base മോഡൽ(160km range ഉള്ള tiago mr മോഡൽ നേകൾ 1.1L കുറവ്)..range 180-190km.. tiago lr ന് 190-210 ഉം..സോ ഫാസ്റ്റ് ചർജിങ് ഇല്ല എന്ന പോരായ്മ കുഴപ്പമില്ല എന്നുളവർക് ഡെയിലി use car ആയി നല്ലത് comet തന്നെ..

[@ENGINEMAPS-qw9fm]

വളരെ നല്ല വാഹനമാണ് എംജി COMET. ഫുൾ ചാർജിൽ 230 KM റേഞ്ച് കിട്ടിയ, ഒരു വർഷത്തോളം ഉപയോഗിച്ച ആളുടെ അനുഭവം ഞാൻ വിഡിയോ ചെയ്തിട്ടുണ്ട്❤️❤️❤️

[@midhunchandrank7187]

Kannur il kurach month munne oru car kathi pregnant lady and husband marana pettirunnu.avide door and seat belt lock aayi enn kettu, athupole oru emergency situation varikayanenkil comet pole front seat fold cheyth pirakil kayarunna design oru tragedy aavan chance ind, so personally i dont choose this type design.

[@user-sw2rd7fk2o]

Trivandrum പോയപ്പോ city muzhuvan Tiago ev ആണ്

[@muneerabubakar4728]

Tiago performance unbelievable

[@user-je8jn4jm5k]

Due to safety concern Comet is not approved in UK, Europe market. They are upgrading to compete with micro ev cars market in UK/Europe.... So definitely safety really matters...

[@itsme1938]

It's fun with facts; More videos like this are needed

[@PilotOnWheels]

Subscribe to our channel, more interesting contents are loading

[@235504859691]

Tvm city ipo full tiago ev aanu.

[@thebikerman_]

Kochi too

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Avide MG showroom ille

[@235504859691]

@@roshanjoseph8030 randennam und showroom✌🏻

[@235504859691]

Aalkar vicharichkanum mgyekal tiago aanu mich better enu

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Mg should project this comet as a premium city car. And it is a good city car. Especially a city like tvm. It makes a lot of sense.

[@FOODARTmix]

Does comet has home fast charging, cruise control, cooled glove box, Fatc, projector headlamps, reverse camera, IP67 battery and motor, Auto wipers, Auto headlamps, boot space of 240 ltrs, fog lamps, leather seats, peps etc etc etc. And can comet match the warranty of Tata TiagoEV? 8year,1,60,000km. For both motors and battery. These features are not available in Comet. Tiago has 4 star GNCAP rating also.

[@roshanjoseph8030]

I think you are trying to mislead here. No dc fast charging. True. Reverse camera , ip 67 battery warranty projected head lamps etc is definitely there in Comet

[@roshanjoseph8030]

I think rather than seeing some part of the video and u comment on that, will misguide others.

[@FOODARTmix]

@@roshanjoseph8030 prove it

[@riteshgupta3245]

MG Comet is better option in terms of build quality, Features and Range TATA claims 315 but car goes around 280-200 and Comet EV claimed 230 km and goes 200kms.

[@roshanjoseph8030]

But need to see the purpose also

[@praveenkumart4106]

MG using TATA's battery

[@sreejithchm]

Veh. Weight and size koodi consider cheythite mileage parayavu...

[@Vks1992]

Build quality?? Tiago is 5 star rated car where comet feels like very light weight

[@itsme1938]

What happens when the Comet runs out of charge? It takes 8-10 hours to fully charge. The Tiago EV has a fast charging option so it can be fully charged in one hour from an external charging station.

[@abdulmajeed-bb3dp]

COMPARISON OF !. COST 2. GROUND CLEARENCE,3. MOTOR SPECS,4. TYRE WEAR 5.SAFETY RATING IS RQUIRED. BETTER TO COMPARE WITH C3

[@CampusWeddingCollectionsAdoor]

Tiago ഒരു ചെറിയ കാർ ഒരു സാധാരണ കാർ ആണ്. ..ബട്ട്‌ കോമെറ്റ് വേറെ ലെവൽ. ..അത്‌ ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്നവർ കൂടുതലും പ്രീമിയം കാർ ഓണർസ് ആണ്. ..

[@jpsworld108]

TATA is the best. Main advantage is D.C Fast charging facility Another is mileage And 5 people can sit comfortably And all above SAFETY 🦺

[@deveshshrivastav8554]

I guess you don't about the after-sales service and reliability concern. They have used cheap plastic in the interior and looks completely old school. Feels very normal like other cars and in comet it gives a refreshing feel.

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Having a DC fast charging is a big advantage for Tata. But as the video says , this comet will be a perfect car for city commuters. Parking is super easy, getting in and out is easy and it’s electric too

[@Vks1992]

​@@deveshshrivastav8554after sales depends upon dealers.new dealer doing it much better i think and as a car its proper one with decent boot space,dc fast charging..better ride quality,better range and power,saftey,better second row with comfortable seats..

[@itsme1938]

​@@deveshshrivastav8554Don't worry, Maruti's EV will come in 2024 or 2025

[@sunobsunu4540]

Comet വെറും ഒരു വണ്ടി മാത്രം പോകാം വരാം അതും 2 ആളെ ഇരുത്തി മാത്രം... ഒരു ഉപയോഗത്തിന് കൊള്ളില്ല ഒരു അതിശയത്തിന് മാത്രം കൊള്ളാം ഫുൾ നെഗറ്റീവ് ആണ് 25 ദിവസത്തെ ഉപയോഗം കൊണ്ട് ഞാൻ പഠിച്ച കാര്യം comet door ഡ്രൈവർ സീറ്റ്‌ കഴിഞ്ഞു 1.5അടിയോളം പുറകിലോട്ടാണ് അപ്പോ ഇടുങ്ങിയ സ്ഥലത്തു door മുഴുവനും തുറക്കാനും ആകില്ല പുറത്തിറങ്ങൽ ചടങ്ങ് ആകും പിന്നെ storage- 🖕ഇതുപോലെ നടുവിരൽ വച്ചു കുത്തിയാൽ അതുപോലെ നടുവിരൽ കൊളുത്ത് അതിൽ വല്ലതും തൂക്കിയാൽ അടിയോടടി- ബുക്കും പേപ്പരും സീറ്റിനു ബാക്കിൽ ഇടണം ഏതേലും തലതിരിഞ്ഞ കുട്ടികൾ ഉണ്ടേൽ ബുക്കും പേപ്പറും കപ്പലും വിമാനവും ആകും എന്തിനോ വേണ്ടിയുള്ള ഒരു ഡിക്കി 🖕പിന്നെ ബാറ്ററി അത് tata കൊടുത്താ😂 range 230അവരുടെ പറച്ചിൽ 200അവരുടെ ഡിസ്പ്ലേയിൽ മാത്രം 25day എനിക്ക് 170പരമാവധി ആദ്യ സർവീസ് കഴിയുമ്പോ കിട്ടിമെന്ന് അവർ പറയുന്നു 😜 so ഞാൻ പറയും tiago is a city car a utility car... Comet is a curious item with wheels steering etc👎 റിവ്യൂ ഞാനും ഇടുന്നുണ്ട് 😢ശോകം

[@Ordinaryperson1986]

If nano was not stopped it would have naturally evolved and got shape of this China commet

[@user-gi6ul7uj9u]

Commet is just an autoriksha.. 🤣🤣🤣tiago is a real car strengthen by Tata steel💪💪

[@jeevankannamaly-mw5yy]

നമുക്ക് മലയാളിക്ക് ഉള്ള വൈദേശിക - ഫോറിൻ ഭ്രമം മാത്രമേ കോമറ്റ് ( നാനോയിൽ ) കാണാനുള്ളൂ.. 10 - ലക്ഷത്തിന് നാനോ സെഗ്മന്റ്കാർ !!...... മനോഭാവം മാറ്റി ലോക നിലവാരത്തിൽ എത്തിയ മേക്കിൻ ഇന്ത്യയെ - ടാറ്റയെ അംഗീകരിക്കേണ്ട അവസ്ഥ ....

[@karanbharti9366]

Comet EV is a well-rounded electric car that offers a compelling combination of style, practicality, and value for money😍

[@thebikerman_]

❤

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Always opt for an EV depending on ur purpose and utility

[@Vks1992]

Its not an suv..its a mini car

[@somethingfishy5811]

Comet is like a premium electric autorickshaw😅

[@sandeepchandran7969]

TATA ❤

[@irshadchalil8907]

13:12 സൗണ്ട് ക്വാളിറ്റി is superb... but ഇങ്ങളെ സൗണ്ട് ക്വാളിറ്റി കുറച്ചൂടെ കൂട്ടാമായിരുന്നു...(ഇത്തിരി ലൗഡ് ആകാമായിരുന്നു)

[@mu-jq9th]

ഈ കമ്പനികൾ ആരുടെ നിയന്ത്രണത്തിലാണെന്ന് പറയുമോ?

[@dzynarchitecturetravel1672]

അവർ പറഞ്ഞത് 100% കറക്റ്റ് രണ്ടും ടെസ്റ്റ്‌ ഡ്രൈവ് ചെയ്തു ഡിസൈൻ കോമറ്റ് 👍travel കംഫേർട്ട് tigao and 4 ഡോർ

[@anilkumarthayannur]

ആനയും അണ്ണാനും compare ചെയ്യരുത് . നാനോ വരുബോൾ നോക്കാം

[@basil93]

Sathyam… Ithu medikkan pokunnavante bodham …. 😂😂😂😂

[@edwinharvey2226]

No need for comparison. Tiago is a clear winner in all aspects..

[@vishnumohan7041]

Comet is a premium vellimoonga ( Iris)

[@jistojoy]

Price not mentioned

[@rishadar]

Commet ന് ചൈന യിൽ 3500 ഡോളർ ഉള്ളു

[@girishkumar9498]

Name of the bgm please

[@muhammedriyas493]

🤔Enthoonnadey karivandum carum thammil compare cheyyunnooo 😂😇

[@ukn1140]

New presentation super

[@Askmedestination]

Nice combo ❤

[@deviprasadprasad6796]

Tiago is the best.🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@prasadpk4429]

Tiago👍👍👍

[@madminder3516]

nice

[@deveshshrivastav8554]

Tiago EV normal basic ev hai and vhi comet smart features loaded ev hai even interior bhi bhot refreshing hai and service bhi not like Tata.

[@FOODARTmix]

What are those smart features? Does comet has home fast charging, cruise control, cooled glove box, Fatc, projector headlamps, IP67 battery and motor, Auto wipers, Auto headlamps, boot space of 240 ltrs, fog lamps, leather seats, peps etc etc etc. And can comet match the warranty of Tata TiagoEV? 8year,1,6000km. For both motors and battery. These features are not available in Comet.

[@roshanjoseph8030]

Hello, I think you have totally gone wrong about the features comet offers. Yes, a big set is that comet doesn’t have a dc fast charger . But comet offers projected head lamps, it has expandable boot space, it has good reverse camera and it has good warranty on both battery as well as motor. We can talk good and bad about both the cars , but pls give wrong impression on any car. Thank you

[@arjunforeman6055]

Price comparison is an essential factor one missed.🙁

[@jrtech5206]

Tata tiago price etra....

[@erbiju8610]

ഒരു ഹാച്ച് ബാക്കും കളിപ്പാട്ടവും ആയി താരതമ്യം ചെയ്യാമോ

[@jasmitsc]

Guys would love to have English subs for us non native speakers

[@Unscripted_by_syam]

I like mg as a city car

[@ajayphilip8475]

Comet is a quadricycle where as tiago is a car

[@roshanjoseph8030]

I don’t agree half of what you said. Tiago is a complete 4 door car. But many people want to break the conventional style and opt for a stylish city car and that makes sense in many ways too

[@RahoozVLOG]

Auto car india is doing same comparison video long time ago..lol 😂

[@thebikerman_]

So what dude?

[@user-tj3ch8sn5i]

Sad owner of tata Tiago very disappointing

[@user-tj3ch8sn5i]

Comet ev is vere level

[@indhumanikandan]

2:58 nano athra kochakaruthu pandu nanokku patti vilayayirunnu ippo oru nano kittan polum kure paisa kodukkanam

[@zeroplus143]

Machanmaree.. nalla reethiyil mg ye polich koduthu😂😅

[@thebikerman_]

😂😂

[@Piku3.141]

Ee designil nano alla vellimoonga anu kandittullath😂

[@മല്ലുപയ്യൻ]

Nice❤

[@mail2aneespk]

for best Make in india ev charger - kzbin.info/www/bejne/kHPFdYetnL-We6M

[@sulfikar.asulfikar.9520]

Comet Front Face 😇🙏

[@Indian425]

Tiago EV 💙💙

[@bobbphill]

No fast charging for MG Comet

[@roshanjoseph8030]

It’s a big set back for comet. But I would consider this only as a short commuting or a city car . Might won’t bother that if we condisider comet only that way.

[@amaldev7736]

Tiago❤

[@basiljohns8537]

❤❤

[@thebikerman_]

❤❤

[@comet14145]

Tiago 👍🌹

[@rajkumarsahu8337]

Comet looks like the best option in the segment.

[@BinoyJayadevan]

TATA super

[@sevenstar775]

comet Ev എടുത്ത് ശശി ആയ ഒരു Doctor എൻ്റെ നാട്ടിലുണ്ട് ആ വണ്ടി പുള്ളിയുടെ Driver ഇപ്പോ മാർക്കറ്റിൽ നിന്നും മീനും പച്ചക്കറിയും വാങ്ങാൻ ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്നു😊

[@mohammedfazilkk1584]

Homeo dr ano

[@sevenstar775]

@@mohammedfazilkk1584 S

[@mrsreejithsasidharan]

കോമറ്റ് അൾട്രാ മോഡേൺ ലുക്ക്‌ 😂😂😂

[@amitpatel8854]

MG Comet excels in both range and performance, offering a more compelling electric driving experience compared to the Tiago EV while retaining MG's commitment to innovation and quality.

[@Vks1992]

Don't think so..tiago is more powerful and better ride quality compared to comet.more over its a proper car in terms of long journey and practicality..adding DC fast charging is plus point..

[@ashokshaji2540]

Don't compare auto with proper car

[@soorajnitturan]

Babettaaa 😂