Why were there three popes at the same time? - Joëlle Rollo-Koster

[@Apero1Spritz]

The way of a story is told and illustrated is sometimes even more fascinating than the story itself.

[@gkjaerby2441]

Agreed!

[@ItsJericho]

❤

[@pedroneto5]

Someone should get a raise for illustrations.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

Tbh, I didn't really follow the story but the animations were great

[@gkjaerby2441]

@@pedroneto5 yep.

[@sandygod]

These illustrations are unreal, the artists truly do an amazing job making the stories even more interesting

[@maxhill9254]

true!

[@megangibson5170]

I love how they always mimic the art style of whatever civilization they’re talking about.

[@Yummerrrrssssssssss2]

Agreed

[@keidot2.058]

I love that different videos are animated in different styles too

[@imnimbusy2885]

This specific one reminds me of DOUBLE KING - the music, the floating hands and the comedy.

[@kylenetherwood8734]

This was surprisingly civil. I thought there would be a war.

[@ElizabethUkeh]

Not everything was a war😅

[@TR4G1C4LLY]

​@@ElizabethUkeh A lot of history is war, though.

[@duckymomo7935]

@@ElizabethUkeh this isn't like the 30 years war - the popes were ralatively civil to each other but refused to concede to the other

[@sajdwajha]

There actually were conflicts and battles fought, but not directly by the popes. These were fought by the various countries that supported them. Really countries used the fact that since one side supported a different pope, they could justify their choice to go to war and not be excommunicated for fighting one another, as their pope was a "heretic". This schism laid the groundwork (along with the corruption/abuses of power of the papacy in general) for the protestant reformation that came after.

[@liliu5250]

Me too 😂

[@fakeskyler2305]

Really feels like I'm watching a medieval manuscript. The art and animation are beautiful - please, more like this!

[@fakeskyler2305]

@@sehajmeetsohal2397 No . . . just emulating the style of actual medieval manuscripts. Pentiment emulates that style, so does Inkulinati, and probably some other ones out there. It's a cool style but it's not owned by anyone

[@fakeskyler2305]

@@sehajmeetsohal2397 Very similar style was also used in the animated segments from Monty Python and the Holy Grail. And the characters move how you would expect a 2d book character to move. I don't think there's any real link besides being inspired by the same artstyle.

[@thomasecker9405]

Agreed! We see a lot of this three-quarter head turn in many medieval manuscripts and tapestries.

[@christopherbove1760]

Dr. Rollo-Koster was my professor for my first ever college class. She is absolutely brilliant, and I’m so glad to see her work featured here!

[@shiven513]

Me too! it's really amazing.

[@TheWchurchill4pm]

@christopherbove1760 Any interesting stories from class?

[@jakobthorpe8233]

Same here!

[@yxx_chris_xxy]

Must have been a wild ride with someone called Rollo-Koster.

[@ThatTeleseryeGirl]

As a Catholic, I thank Ted-Ed for this. Church History is long, wild and complicated.

[@jigsaw2253]

Catholics are not Christians though

[@bobbymoss6160]

Yes, like a fairytale.

[@duckymomo7935]

thats why I cant take the doctrine of the papacy seriously, papacy ends if the papal line cannot trace their roots to St Peter nvm that apostolic succession is not even for papacy

[@niccolopaganini1782]

@@bobbymoss6160 yeah you can put it that way, very interesting and fascinating. 😄

[@opwave79]

Fellow Catholic here. It’s important to learn the Church history for sure. Every aspect of it.

[@frostincubus4045]

Love this medieval art-style animation! Ted-Ed never disappoints

[@artiemanable]

Using medieval style of painting to make this video was one of the best artistic decisions this channel made in a very long time. Adding some Gregorian Chant was also a nice touch!

[@gorgon6680]

The animation style and artwork is stunning in this video

[@johnnyearp52]

I agree. I don't care that much about Popes but the art is interesting and imaginative!

[@powermaster9838]

The thumbnail is a Spider man meme

[@rlznns]

I took a silence moment just to admire the beauty of the illustration, animation, and the sfx.

[@sahlahanifa8402]

i had to watch this twice because the first time i was too enamoured by the amazing visual storytelling. the football game with death, the "almighty hand from above" which turned out to be controlled by the cardinals, slurping others' pasta, soooo creative

[@robynbrowne1277]

it was the death and the music players for me

[@janmichaelcjamisola]

I am digging this Pythonesque animation, it really fits the subject matter!

[@gorgon6680]

This was well said

[@SlowToe]

❤

[@Dorgpoop]

I just hope their animator didn't die of a heart attack

[@jmsaffroy]

And there was much rejoicing.

[@Juan-ps3gg]

@@Dorgpoop And the Lord did grin

[@kevin8712]

I like how they put the execution of Jan Hus at 4:59-5:09. Nice touch, TED-Ed. Nice touch indeed.

[@brunocostamonteiro1117]

The illustrators should be awarded for this! Amazing work of art, history and clever humor. Congratulations

[@jacobvanderhoeven1008]

This is gorgeous video. The animators truly deserve a bonus for the magnificant artwork. One thing I think should have been added though, is that the Great Schism corresponded with the Hundred Years War between England and France (England of course, supported Rome, and France Avignon). Though this war did not take on a religious tinge, it did provide an interesting focal point for politics with English allies supporting Rome and France's allies Avignon. Lastly, the video says that this schism did not effect average Catholics. While it is correct that there were no major doctrinal differences, the schism did contribute to a growing apathy towards the Church and rise in popular piety. Amazing video.

[@veramae4098]

... then, Luther.

[@Inky_101]

Nice Ted Ed used a meme in the thumbnail

[@caindain2179]

I KNOW AND ITS GREAT

[@blazer9547]

They did the thing

[@svenandersen]

I was thought no one gonna noticed it

[@BearIchi]

Spidah men

[@jarekwrzosek2048]

Speaking of medieval Papacy shennanigans, You should also portray the conflict between the Pope and the Holy Roman Emperor, and their supporters: Guelphs and Ghibelines.

[@battlesheep2552]

There are two competing -standards- popes. -Engineers- Cardinals: "lets create a new -standard- pope to unite everything" There are three competing -standards- popes.

[@auwanho]

I hope that in a few hundred years people dig up KZbin and saw this video and say that this is the art of the time.

[@yuuko5ichihara]

This is one of the most beautiful animated ted-ed videos, very interesting too , and I love the medieval touch❤

[@margomez7074]

The style for the animation is so obvious yet wonderfully executed. Love this!

[@yourroyalchungusness]

I like the fact that Ted-Ed used the medieval artstyle to this video even though this event took place in the late medieval age and hats off to Buzasi, Dementeva & Shmidt for drawing and animating this masterpiece

[@y_wintersnow]

"...even those who are supposed to be pious are prone to petty power struggles." Man, that is deep.

[@JoseLuis-rj9kq]

The animation, the chroma, the timing. Everything in this video is sublime and beautiful.

[@skwagwok4097]

My favorite bit of animation at 1:54 😂😂😂 stunning work and storytelling TED-Ed!

[@sherlynandria4894]

I was searching for this comment 😂😂

[@johnbuhrmanfegan]

Here for the Spider-Man meme thumbnail

[@mariustan9275]

My respect for Ted ed has increase exponentially for that meme in the thumbnail.

[@ST0AT]

This entire episode reads like a Monty Python skit, and I love it

[@opwave79]

I’m indulging in medieval history since I brainlessly never thought to take a class in it during college. It’s fascinating to me. Also, this video production top notch stuff.

[@ebonymaw8457]

Needless toss of money if it's not related to your degree anyways. You can learn everything they would have taught yourself, as you are doing!

[@alalalala57]

​@@ebonymaw8457 Only as an amateur tho. Not where the cutting-edge conversations on the topics are happening.

[@G.Standfast]

6:00 i did not expect that

[@holakfun8243]

Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition

[@jessicawang4632]

I love the medieval style, but the little floating hands made this video. Thank you Ted-Ed for another wonderful work.

[@SowerOfMustardSeed]

As a devout Catholic, I enjoyed this video. Nicely done. But to be clear, the Catholic Church has always had only one pope at a time as far as the office goes. The others are considered as anti-popes, or in Benedict XIV’s case, he was Pope Emeritus (a title, not the office) upon abdication.

[@alalalala57]

The anti-pope is whoever your faction doesn't support lol.

[@ironkraken7157]

@@alalalala57 its almost as if its all made up.

[@HodgePodgeVids1]

@@ironkraken7157 lazy thinking

[@ironkraken7157]

@@HodgePodgeVids1 lazy comment

[@HodgePodgeVids1]

@@ironkraken7157 Yea, but it’s not made up. The fact there is a unbroken chain of successors from Francis to Peter is testament to that. Fake anti popes claiming to be the bishop of Rome does not negate the real chosen successor.

[@BeaverChainsaw]

Monty python aesthetic and Spider-Man pointing as cherry on top, well done!

[@jessicajayes8326]

Alright folks, get ready for the next Pope Fight!

[@jerseygirlinatl7701]

OSP represent!

[@marcobuncit7539]

@@jerseygirlinatl7701 with ERB rap battles of 3 of them.

[@jessicajayes8326]

@@jerseygirlinatl7701 That's right!

[@innocentlyjaded]

I was looking for these specific words in the comments. OSP represent, indeed!

[@joannadziedzinska1337]

Using danse macabre trope in this video is like a cherry on the top of awesomeness. So creative!

[@pisces2569]

1:52 i never thought I needed a skeleton and a pope holding hands and dancing but here I am watching this video a second time just for this.

[@jahidtanvir]

"But regardless of how the schism ended, its existence proves that even those who are supposed to be pious are prone to petty power struggles." Truth at the end.

[@mankytoes]

If you are a pretender to the papacy you're known as the Antipope which is the coolest title out there.

[@robertfaler1947]

By the same logic, we should call Trump the Antipresident.

[@razi_man]

I guess they're made of antimatter.

[@jhalak5452]

The thumbnail is where the iconic *Office Gun-pointing* meme originated 😂

[@bozumoyo3277]

MOREE, we need a whole series of history done like this thank you!! 💯✨

[@dylanfoto4356]

MOREEEEEE!!!!

[@sandradermark8463]

I am from the Castellón Province and I have been more than once to the castle of Pope Benedict XIII, Papa Luna, in Peñíscola; we say of a stubborn person that they "sigue en sus trece;" they stay in their thirteen, after his papal number.

[@Moon-li9ki]

fun fact, in ancient Rome, the highest religious office was that of the Pontifex Maximus. That title survived for over 2000 years, as popes still retain Pontifex Maximus as one of their official titles. Julius Caesar was pontifex maximus before he died, meaning that besides being dictator of Rome, he was also the pope

[@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana]

Isn’t the Pope normally the dictator of Rome 😜?

[@_jpg]

J.C. definitely wasn't a pope. The Romans in his time still had their "own" pantheon copied by the Greek and others ^^'

[@whitebeans7292]

Pope is a different title. Pontifex Maximus just means "ultimate bridge-builder" as priests are supposed to be the bridge between the earthly and the spiritual. Is Xi Jinping the President of the United States just because he uses the word President after George Washington used it?

[@Frimpa-MJEB]

I never thought I would one day witness Popes playing football

[@byjordi2185]

As someone coming from the region of Constance I really like the story around the council

[@nickzardiashvili624]

The follow up video you suggested at the end, I must say, I did not expect that!

[@gamechip06]

I love the spiderman reference in the thumbnail

[@jeffreygao3956]

“Stop pointing! It’s rude to point!”

[@GanesaAudrey]

The little sounds the tiny pope makes near the end. So cute and hilarious. lol

[@harishankergopakumar8324]

This is probably The BEST Animated Work of TED ever !!!🔥🔥🔥

[@makanathanao01]

King: * kills the old pope* Singers: *gasps* Meh whatever Singers: *continues to sing*

[@noahwarrior]

As a catholic I would’ve loved if you added more context to this historical situation. But I understand time and budget constraints. Good video. God is good, God bless✝️🙏

[@rakaswara_vyatrantra]

1:22 good ilustration I Always appreciate and respect to this animators

[@kubikkuratko188]

Love the detail of the burning of Jan Hus.

[@ramkumarm8957]

the music in this episode is sooo fun

[@barbarak2836]

I just love the jester and the monk playing it! This video was delightful. I have studied this in school, but this was the best I have ever understood it, while being entertained at the same time.

[@hannahdawg6829]

I can just hear Blue chanting "POPE FIGHT POPE FIGHT POPE FIGHT!" in the background XD

[@KTChamberlain]

1296? Ironically, in the movie version of Lord of the Rings Bilbo Baggins said that 1296 was a very good year, almost as old as he was at 111. Maybe he meant it was a good year in terms of wine vintage since he was referring to wine in that line. Who knows. lol

[@dianemiller2173]

WOW! last millennium, when I studied history there were only two popes, where did you find this guy?. how exciting!!

[@carlocumino824]

The Raid with Bonifaciis is very from in Italy, especially becasue a noble roman allied with Philp slapped the Pope when he was in his palace in Agnagni. We commonly called those episode as "Slap of Angagni"

[@cinemanuggets24]

This has to be in top 10 among most interesting ted ed videos ever 🤣😅. Kudos to the filmmakers

[@chuck9693]

3:13 was so creative

[@queenj.a.3311]

I love how the art style matches the time period of the video

[@kubdep]

The alliteration in this episode is just top notch

[@jessicacat1206]

Forget the story, the illustrations were everything. The "Boxing of the Popes" will remain forever in my mind.

[@mohamed_saleh]

The illustrations are good, but the music is very annoying

[@lindseyw5449]

I so appreciate the time and effort that go into the illustration and lesson! What a fun and different way to learn :) it always reinvests me into learning various topics they discuss ❤ keep up the hard work, we love it!

[@udhaybalamurali8901]

The Vivid evolution of human story telling and illustration in unmatchable! One of real success for our tribes

[@israelm87]

Devout Catholic here. Thanks Ted Ed for this

[@Basta11]

I’m plentifully pleased by the presentation of this perplexing papal predicament.

[@Cora.T]

Osp's blue has done several very interesting videos about the dramas with popes throughout the years they are called "pope fights"

[@MuddieRain]

“Where would Catholicism be without the popes” Oscar Nunez

[@marcobuncit7539]

"Well, you got us the brainy discussing over liturgy & stuffs." --probably John Calvin ---

[@østkantproprietæren]

The munk and the jester playing the flute really got me, hilarious 😂

[@gantagavin]

The satire, the witty banters, the irony!

[@jlshel42]

Kept waiting for someone to say “And now for something completely different.”

[@writethatdown100]

The animation in this video is really fun to watch

[@neccosan]

The animator had a blast doing the flute players

[@tommyofaquino]

I'm sure this will be a fair and complete explanation on the ecclesiological landscape of the time

[@bncumali1555]

I love how they used the spiderman meme as the thumbnail

[@ryanEstandarte]

5:00 Thank you Sigismund for pressing to create a council to resolve this issue.

[@enclavesoldier8893]

True but I heard he sacked Skalitz back during the wars in Bohemia, quite a shame for that lad Henry.

[@TolkienOtaku]

That feel when you learned all about this a couple years ago in OverlySarcasticProductions' Pope Fights video.

[@lark613]

I hope the animators are being paid well! This is so entertaining to watch

[@DanielRisberg]

How else could Blackadder get a relic signed by all three popes?

[@hanve]

The way it's presented and the animation 😍😍😍❤️❤️

[@squidsbizarreadventure]

I did not expect the end to mention the Spanish Inquisition!

[@kaloarepo288]

Same type of power conflict was going on in the Holy Roman Empire (basically Germany and north Italy) at the same time when there were several contenders for being emperor at the same time and these now being known as anti-kings.

[@dinodude4039]

The real question is, which Pope pointed first?

[@HodgePodgeVids1]

At the time there were three claims to the Papacy. There was antipope John XXIII, antipope Benedict XIII, and Pope Gregory XII. The Council of Constance was called and at the council Pope Gregory XII resigned and antipope John XXIII also resigned so that the Church could elect a new universally recognized Pope. Antipope Benedict XIII refused to resign but by this point he had no support from any existing Cardinals. With 2 of the 3 claimants to the Papacy officially resigned, the Council then declared the antipope Benedict XIII excommunicated. The Council then elected Pope Martin V who was universally accepted by the Church.

[@BallotBoxer]

Absolutely perfect mix of animation, script, and narration.

[@censusgary]

I have toured the “Palace of the Popes” at Avignon. Avignon also has some interesting old houses of papal “nephews” (sons).

[@amanjain4817]

This is a cinematic masterpiece. Live action movie makers, start taking notes from Ted-Ed.

[@robertstone9150]

Great animation and a great depiction of nothing like a good old pope fight.

[@m.barrera7273]

In Spanish there's always three: papa (as in the pope), papa (as in potato), and papa (or papá, as in father)

[@magicalwatermelon5147]

I always knew that potatoes are too amazing to not be godly.

[@m.barrera7273]

@@magicalwatermelon5147 and the pope is definitely not the father of the potato 😁

[@aleksandarvil5718]

El papa/Papa = the pope in Rome/Vatican La papa = potato 🥔🥔🥔 😂

[@revinhatol]

Rome/Avignon/Pisa

[@lisamith]

Greetings from Constance, location of the council. It actually took four years from 1414 to 1418 until one pope was elected. There's a statue in the harbor of Constance commemorating the prostitutes that were frequented during those years.

[@Phadokus]

The music is fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@magicalwatermelon5147]

Clement VII: hey, I’m the pope now, not you. Urban VI: lalalalah I can’t hear you, too busy doing Pope stuff

[@normanryan9145]

I love how the thumbnail is like a medieval rendition of the Spiderman meme where they are pointing at each other 😂😂😂

[@angelrios5897]

The little clarinet jingle that went off every time a pope died in this video, really did me in. 🤣

[@oogawhama3559]

For me it's the same reason as the why there was 3 Caliphs. Power...

[@sgsm424]

Absolutely loved the narrator and the illustrations😍

[@fahimahsan3603]

I wonder why no one is discussing, how religious leaders can fight against each other ? while they are the main responsible Authority of religion itself.

[@lancasterose]

Those rowdy mobs were just WAITING for an opportunity to raid the conclave and plunder the papal wine cellar, weren't they?

[@MinsEducation]

This reminds me of The office, when people would complain about having two leaders (Michael and Jim as co-managers) and they gave not having two popes as an example to mock having two managers. Gasp it has been a lie allll along!