Tesla Bot is 97% fake, with Proof!

Tesla released a new update on their Optimus - Gen 2 and we look at the recent video and debunk the theory that Tesla is a leader in AI or Robotics. The progress they have made it surprising but it's still far behind Boston Dynamics.
Support my channel and join my Patreon:
/ miseseconomics
Tesla Bot
Optimus - Gen 2
Tesla Bot Update
Tesla Bot Optimus Gen 2 Revealed
The Tesla Bot: Explained!

[@miseseconomics]

NOTICE: To all my black brothers out there, im sorry if I offended you guys by saying colored. Im not from the U.S, I had no idea people find this offensive. I only want to offende tesla fanboys, I would never offend my brothers. Sorry guys..

[@mater5930]

Funny enough, mixed race people in South Africa are called coloreds. But it's not a derogatory term. It's even in government forms where you fill out your race.

[@alphamineron]

Lmao, I think anyone sensible wouldn’t care… we know you didn’t mean anything by it, only attention seeking insecure drama queens would be offended.

[@stanpak007]

I am from Poland and living in the US and I said "colored" once because I heard black guy saying such about himself, so I thought it is fine. The snowflake outrage ensued immediately and any explanations did not help. Conclusion: never apologize to the "offended" crowd. Explain but do not apologize. You did mean and do nothing wrong.

[@mater5930]

@@stanvassilev In the US it has negative historical connotations.

[@clutch2827]

People on the internet are offended by everything.

[@xcidgaf]

Elon is the biggest scammer on the planet 😂

[@mampfi]

Wow I did not expect that. I mean if it's rigged I would expect far better Kinetics. The robots walk like they have shit their pants.

[@miseseconomics]

Thats the only live demo they have had....

[@hgbugalou]

🤣🤣🤣

[@fredrik3685]

when walk like they have shit their pants it's real footage. In the faked clips it modes smooth.

[@Irobert1115HD]

because they are rigged. the bots are likely blind so they walk in a way that makes it easier for them to not fall over.

[@FizzleFX]

Well yeah, and even IF it was all true, I saw synchronus dancing robot groups 13 years ago.

[@africaart]

Although they were very small (12 inches), even 20+ years ago.

[@Voltaje_YT]

Where are those dancing robots? were they just for show? it appears so, considering they don't sell them, nor they evolved, optimus is to be produced by the millions, when is ready.

[@coldspring22]

@@Voltaje_YT LOL, just like million tesla-robotaxis with nobody in them by 2020 promised by Elon the great Musk in 2019???

[@FizzleFX]

@@africaart yes with 16 i had 12 inches. you are right

[@patrickfox-roberts7528]

@@Voltaje_YT never gonna happen

[@Luwizart]

I do suspect the robot is fake too, but mostly because of the motion. Your green screen example might be wrong because if an artist were to place a 3d object on the footage, it would just be rendered with transparency, which is very easy to do. so it makes no sense they will render it with a green screen. the green light on the objects is probably just bounce lighting from the exit green light. and it is possible due to the reflective nature of the materials in the room. and if the robot is 3d, the green you see could just be an attempt to light it to fit in with the rest of the scene. finally, the noise could just be from low render samples or noise added in the post

[@miseseconomics]

Nope...I explained it...first 30 sec of video is 3d. The rest is roto/comp job. Thats why they removed the wires.

[@TheAtticusFinch]

So the robot doesn’t really own a gym? That’s all I’m getting from this green screen nonsense.

[@miseseconomics]

He can’t bend down. Just walk. I doubt they can walk much

[@TheAtticusFinch]

@@miseseconomicsBut the robots movements are not CGI, it was just filmed in front of a green screen? The video should be called Tesla robot can’t really bend down, I think,

[@odojang]

I've seen three robots do all that the teslabot does and in exactly the same way. That was at the Universal fair of Montreal back in... 1967.

[@miseseconomics]

ahh yes I totally forgot about universal studios in L.A. all those robots in there

[@odojang]

@@miseseconomics And Disneys animatronics dating back to the 1950's...

[@miseseconomics]

@@odojanglook at these experts with 25 years experience telling me how I’m wrong 🫣

[@odojang]

@@miseseconomics Welcome to the world of ''alternative facts.''

[@Voltaje_YT]

Duh, is the normal process, Optimus just started development, do you expect it start imitating humnas and doing your homework in just 6 months or two years?, it needs its time, it will get better later on, and unlike others, it won't be cancelled, and will be produce in an industrial scale, other companies can't nor won'r do that, only start ups.

[@jtreu107]

Video lacking any real substance, assumptions based on video compression artifacts....

[@miseseconomics]

Right....Musk hasnt done this before...right? kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2jbZpKrpZqqbdU

[@specialkonacid6574]

i don't believe any of it until it does what they show with people in the room and it's filmed with a handheld iphone

[@Voltaje_YT]

It will take 3 yaers for that, it takes time to develope a functional working robot, it only have 2 years of developement, and its advancing fast, but needs time.

[@specialkonacid6574]

@@Voltaje_YT i wish they would hurry, i really need a robot to put my eggs in a different container

[@nossiplays]

I don't quite get what's wrong here. It's an add. I assumed it's green screened partly. I assumed there's probably a few dozen broken eggs while recording this. What's the problem? It's a prototype with very different approach than Atlas. Not comparable. Atlas is cool but useless. Optimus is being engineered for mass production and mass use as labor. Like what perspective do guys hating this have?

[@miseseconomics]

I have tried to explain as simple as possible. I will make one more video showing proof that Tesla fake their videos and why nothing should be believed until seeing live presentations

[@nossiplays]

@@miseseconomics well of course they edit them heavily it's a marketing video. As someone who's quite heavily invested in Tesla and other companies this is a no news. It's a standard in which Tesla is doing its marketing the most effective of companies I know of.

[@szymczak34]

I think what he’s saying is the the robot is only a CGI representation of a robot, not an actual robot. In other words, there may not be an actual functioning one of these in existence.

[@georgeellis6002]

@@miseseconomicsyou take yourself way to serious and you overestimate your intellectual capacity. 🤭

[@rahrahrobbbieee]

Never trust or be a fan boi. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Epiphone1964]

The Optimus 1 body is made of aluminum, and the Optimus 2 body is plastic. That is why they look different. And if you ramp up green in the chroma it will appear first in the blacks. That is not evidence of green screen use. I have used green screen professionally for years. But even if they shot the robot against a green screen to pop in any background. Your wire argument kind of fails when you notice that the thing you think is a wire stays stationary while the robot continues to move past it. I suspect this is just common artifacting from the compression youtube uses on videos.

[@miseseconomics]

What software do you use? Why dont you download the video from teslas youtube chanel in 4k....zoom in and look frame by frame.. If you are any good at green screen you will see it a mile away.... If you dont see it, dont worry...im making a new video to help you out :D

[@Epiphone1964]

@@miseseconomics What about that wire you claim, that only appears after the bot walks past a vertical black line in the wall panels, and the faint black line stays stationary as the bot moves away from it. How is that a wire, and not just a compression artifact? The fact that there are multiple faint black lines close together is sort of a giveaway for artifacting. If I take any picture, and crank up the greens in the chroma, you will start to see them in the blacks. It doesn't prove anything. But as I said... even if they did film the robot against green screen - which I don't think they did - that would only prove that the background is fake, not the robot. Who cares about the background?

[@christiantodorov5065]

​He doesn't want to answer you I think you cornered him lol​@@Epiphone1964

[@hobo1704]

​@@Epiphone1964 who cares about the background 🤣 Really? Why fake it then.. Elon is nothing but a lying POS champ..

[@SquadTwelve12]

You, CSS and Thundeyf00t are 😎

[@miseseconomics]

Man I’m going to keep hammering at this robot….I found more stuff

[@SquadTwelve12]

@@miseseconomics it would be great if we get a employee testimony

[@miseseconomics]

@@SquadTwelve12don’t need it.

[@Shmyrk]

You still standing by this?

[@miseseconomics]

Yes. I

[@Hcloud65]

Colored (or coloured) is a racial descriptor historically used in the United States during the Jim Crow Era to refer to an African American. In many places, it may be considered a slur

[@miseseconomics]

Well I meant well. I thought people would be offended if I said black? I said colored so I don’t offend anyone. People keep changing these definitions who is going to keep up with it

[@SuperFinGuy]

@@miseseconomics Yep say person with darker skin instead.

[@AniWho268]

@@SuperFinGuy No, there are plenty of people with darker skin who aren't black. There's nothing wrong with saying black. Black is fine.

[@AniWho268]

@@miseseconomics It really is getting harder to know what to say. I'm black and it's getting really irritating that some black people are starting to have an issue with being called "black". Some white people are having an issue with being called "white" as well. I don't understand it. Saying "white" or "black" is fine, but unfortunately the response can still be different depending on who is listening. If you want to be safe, I'd say to use the culture or location of whoever you're talking about. Ex African-Americans for black people in America, Afro-British for black people from Britain etc etc.

[@georgeellis6002]

So… how do you call a black person who is not American or of unknown nationality?

[@fredrik3685]

What happened to Elizabeth Holmes?.... She is in prison....

[@miseseconomics]

11 years… Sam Bankman 115 years Musk: 300?

[@FizzleFX]

"Critics say you cant do this - your answer is" -- ""We done it" okay and now i will give you the uncut script. "Critics say you cant do this *you cant constantly lie to customers* - your answer is" -- ""We done it"

[@miseseconomics]

😂

[@zagreus5773]

I always expect Tesla to fake their videos but each time I am impressed of how much of it they fake. Even if you'd assume the video is 100% real, it is not very impressive. Except the obviously faked sorting. But they faked so much of the simple stuff as well. Stuff like this should be illegal, ngl. If I had invested into the company because of this video I would sue.

[@miseseconomics]

People won’t sue until the stock goes down a lot. It’s still up alot the last 2 years. Same thing happened to Enron

[@AaronStarkLinux]

It looks fake to you because it's too real. That's the problem. It's called initial denial. So you have to talk nonsense for more than 30 min combined with the previous one just to make sure you convince yourself and the rest of the people that is not real. Otherwise, you will feel like a clown once you discover that is real. This is a common problem of narcissist behavior, where you don't like when others are cooler than you, so you have to try to do a twist in perception of reality.

[@miseseconomics]

Right…I’ll debunk this robot again in the next video in less then 30 sec.you can watch the first 30 sec and then leave

[@AaronStarkLinux]

@@miseseconomics My dear friend. The only thing you will be able to debunk is your life once you get out of your mom's basement. Merry Christmas 😘

[@kajita2048]

😂 It does not matter if the greenscreen was fake, as long as the robot is real… what’s the point??

[@miseseconomics]

The point is that the robot can only walk and for limited time.

[@origaminefretami3480]

The point is, it cant do what Elon promises. Like the CT, it exists, but cant be used as a boat as Elon mentioned

[@SimonKelk]

My problem is the low amount of footage available on this so-called miracle bot. It's heavily edited and very short because of the amount of work that they had to put into releasing it. If the bot was half as good as what was shown there'd be a tonne of footage. Even Boston Dynamic have released out-take footage of their bots constantly failing, falling and screwing up. They know their bi-pedal bot isn't ready yet, there is no way Tesla can compete with that. It's just as Janky as the car itself, which still can't self drive.

[@miseseconomics]

Exactly...I had to reverse the footage to make it last longer! Good eye to catch that

[@thedualtransition6070]

Musk has been caught lying or making ridiculous claims so often that it is incredible that anyone believes him without being in the room to see the robot perform. He just moves on from one shiny object to another. Tesla stock still has a PE of 80 while BYD is 20, the power of the Tesla fanboys!

[@norbis3939]

It's not fake 😂😂😂They just cleaned up the video to make it more presentable. It's a commercial, that's what they do.

[@miseseconomics]

Yes but it’s not real.

[@norbis3939]

@miseseconomics It's a real robot. It walks and does robot stuff. That's about all it was shown doing. They used a green screen to put it in a more presentable environment for the commercial and they removed the safety frame that it was attached to. Almost every humanoid robot uses a frame like that to catch it in case it falls. The frames typically don't help it walk, they just prevent it from damaging itself if it does fall.

[@liamprincetech]

@@miseseconomics Yes but you're absolutely wrong. I've been in the room with one of these bad boys and I can assure you it's real and can do everything in the video.

[@futilekid]

Why green screen and record something when they're using 3d renders? Also, the green is on more than just the robot. The green light is bouncing from the green exit light sign

[@miseseconomics]

Intro scene is obviously 3d. Rest it different robots.

[@allondeck7768]

It's not fake, next time ask elon for an interview

[@miseseconomics]

How about this? Is this fake? The math is fake that is for sure… Elon Musk's ROBO TAXI DEBUNKED kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2jbZpKrpZqqbdU

[@tl214amos4]

Always look forward to your videos!!! Don’t stop!!!! You are much appreciated!!

[@miseseconomics]

Im glad someone cares, none of my friends care.

[@onsokumaru4663]

What do the following have in common? Tesla Roadster 2.0 Tesla Semi Hype-loop Solar city Tesla Bot SpaceX rocket as a commercial plane

[@miseseconomics]

Bullshit hype. Man he truly did everything to pump up that stock So many people got rich of riding that train

[@stanpak007]

The "wire removal" artifacts look like the shadow left from the edge of the shelf and could be likely a compression artifact. I would not be looking too much into it. Especially, the jiggling wires on the back are likely cause by the shaking of the robot. If you want to suspend 100kg of stuff you attach it to steel frame and not some coiled wires. The green screen itself makes no much sense, as the background does not look worth being replaced by the trick. Again, I think the noise can be just an effect of compression or the camera noise. It would make sense if the robot was rendered, but then, no green screen would be needed.

[@miseseconomics]

Download the videos from teslas website and take a closer look….you will see it a mile away and I’m correct.

[@miseseconomics]

@@TrophicBogdid you even watch the green screen part? Did you even watch tesla faking the whole full self driving video? Just keep writing in the comment section I’ll get pissed and destroy cyber truck next

[@thecall0ut]

It's REAL! The Tesla Bot 2.0 is REAL! *slurp on Elon* Please it's gotta be real! *slurp on Elon* I know it is! I love Elon! *slurp on Elon* - stanpak007

[@thecall0ut]

@@TrophicBog It's REAL! The Tesla Bot 2.0 is REAL! *slurp on Elon* Please it's gotta be real! *slurp on Elon* I know it is! I love Elon! *slurp on Elon* - TrophicBog

[@TrophicBog]

Real Mature @@thecall0ut

[@smartintellectual9995]

5:45 epic fail, if you see closer you will see this "line" is going down, so unless robot was connected to his ass, I don't know whay it would be that long.. So you are wrong. The right answer is the "line" is generated by comrpession of the video and not because someone remove something. But you are an expert, you know better.

[@smartintellectual9995]

6:18 the black cable or something similar to it is bonceing, it's not solid structure.

[@miseseconomics]

Take a look at these two videos: Elon Musk's LOOP DEBUNKED kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5fUaZiGebpseKs

[@miseseconomics]

And this: What Happened To Tesla's Solar Roof Tiles? kzbin.info/www/bejne/nabMh3ych7Gie7s

[@smartintellectual9995]

@@miseseconomics I don't think you have any background to talk about this stuff. It feels like you are just regular guy who doesn't like tesla or got inspired by other channel like thunders... and notice you get more views when talking about musk.

[@BhargavN10]

​@@smartintellectual9995 and you are qualified to judge him how?

[@hama502]

You and Thunderf00t are the best :) Nice work.

[@miseseconomics]

Thanks :) thunderf00t is the best

[@andenxtc]

@@miseseconomics don't forget "common sense skeptic"

[@JamesdelaLoza]

The robot is also leaning so that its center of gravity is off-center. It should fall, but it doesn't!

[@JLCra87]

And so all the shareholders and investors seeing the ad are aware of this also? All the consumers looking to buy a bot in the future? I don't think a company like Tesla has any real benefit of faking a product this big lol.

[@miseseconomics]

What about the hyperloop? Solar city 2.9 billion buyout? How about FSD? Next year....

[@JLCra87]

@@miseseconomics What about them exactly? Hyperloop was a Musk "idea", he nor Tesla or SpaceX has anything to do with those projects. What exactly are you suggesting about Solar City and FSD?

[@tot788]

During a lawsuit over the death of an Apple engineer killed in a Tesla, Ashok Elluswamy, director of Autopilot software at Tesla, said the 2016 video demonstrating full self driving technology was staged. “The intent of the video was not to accurately portray what was available for customers in 2016,” said Elluswamy. “It was to portray what was possible to build into the system.” That was a nice way of saying that they lied because the video instead contained a tagline that read, “The person in the driver’s seat is only there for legal reasons. He is not doing anything. The car is driving itself.” In reality, the car apparently wasn’t even using the Tesla software and it actually crashed trying to park. Despite the major flaws, later that year Tesla started selling a new $3000 (now 15,000) software add on. Considering Tesla just had to recall 2 million vehicles over the safety of their Autopilot (they aren’t allowed to call it FSD anymore), I’m not surprised.

[@zagreus5773]

Musk and Tesla have a long history of faking products. Like the FSD video, the battery exchange, the solar city roof tiles.

[@p.informatico1320]

Every time Musk releases a potential breakthrough,, Tesla shares go up, and his fortune grow...

[@friendryan]

exactly, they used fake footage on the self driving but now you see hundreds of people actually using the self driving which isn't fake.

[@miseseconomics]

You know that fsd is still level 2? We were supposed to have 1 million robot taxi by 2020?

[@hobo1704]

It will never happen champ. FSD is a scam.

[@breezyjr]

Not suggesting you're wrong, but I have a question... The part you said they removed the cable, is it possible what you're seeing is compression artifacts, or some other digital noise from the line in the background ?

I just saw this comment and I commented about this. It is actually a compression artifact, look under his butt and there should be no wire going there but there is still a line there. I don't know why they compressed it as much as they did though or why it's so noisy, they can't afford a better camera?

[@miseseconomics]

Due to you lovely people being so critical, you make me do my best work....so i had another look and saw even more wires in the shoot. in the shoot I broke down..they are everywhere. There is also "ghosting" of thing removed. Im making a new video showing all the fake stuff in the tesla videos. There is so much of it

[@zagreus5773]

@ There are both compression artifacts and hidden wires. They compressed it so much to better hide the video manipulation of course. There is no other reason why the footage is so crappy in some places and so pristine on others.

[@georgeellis6002]

I suggest your next video to proof the moon landings were fake 😂😂😂

[@kenfryer2090]

Isn't this actually fraud? Pretend something is better than it is, showinh fake videos and palming them off as real? Isn't their a law against this

[@miseseconomics]

Yes it is. Same as full-self driving and robot taxi. I made videos about it and exposing the fraud

[@Antares0210]

Is this some kind of satirical take on how Tesla gets criticized? If it is, it's quite well done, but just in case it isn't, here are the explanations for the points in the video: - During the Squatting scene the green color is coming from the big glowing green Exit light behind the robot. - The noise is coming from video compression. - During the Walking scene the lines are similarly coming from video compression artifacts. - The chain hook is bobbing up and down because the robot is walking. Walking creates an up and down motion. And yes, Boston Dynamics is far ahead Tesla in their robotics, but BD is creating the Atlas robots (the humanoid ones) as highly specialized purpose made robots while Tesla is planning to make production robots. Made for mass markets. Comparing these two products is like comparing a prototype Ferrari to a production Volvo. You Can compare them, but what's the point, they're made for different purposes. Edit: Also I just realized: What would be the point of using green screen in any of these scenes anyway? If the Bot is CGI, then they would just film the environment, animate the Bot using some animation software, then with some video editing software they would place the Bot in the filmed environment. No green screen needed anywhere in the process. The green screen would make sense if somehow the environment was faked, and the Bot was filmed separately, but that would make the Bot real. And what would be the point of faking an environment that can be filmed in any random office?

[@miseseconomics]

That little exit light aint going to cast greenscreen and noise...

[@Antares0210]

@@miseseconomics it casts a light on everything else in the environment, which becomes very visible when you show the adjusted hue values. 2:41 The green colors are stronger in the direction that the light is coming from. It's especially visible on the stack of mats (atleast I think they're mats) on the left. I don't see any reason why they would have to CGI in a stack of mats.

[@miseseconomics]

I found even more wires..... its over... cry me a river..... im going to debunk the shit out of this

[@Antares0210]

@@miseseconomics I apologize if this sounds rude but you're starting to not make sense. There's a valid discussion to be had here about video editing, artifacting, compression, 3D rendering, greenscreens, light reflection etc. But if you start throwing around statements like "there are more wires" without any basis or intention for explanation then it just becomes meaningless. The wires already have a perfectly rational and easy explanation. It's due to compression. Even if the video is in 4K, it goes through several forms of compression at each stage of the rendering pipeline. Even when the light hits the sensors of the camera it's a form of compression. The photons are compressed into RGB pixel values.

[@deathorb]

​@@Antares0210the guy is a youtuber and has spent hours on this vid. Fair play to him but he needs to grow up a bit too. I am in the middle, musk has lied about a lot and uses the word optimism to make up for it. And yes the robot maybe can do all these things but it's hardly anything compared to what Boston has done.

[@Donttouchthesnow]

10:55 Tesla lives rent free in my guys head 😂😂

[@miseseconomics]

It used to, but after I made these many videos I rest my case

[@malfonso9036]

@@miseseconomics is the new video of the tesla bot folding laundry fake as well, cant wait on your video for that

[@cg5648]

Without government subsidies, Tesla would be out of business. How many Tesla semis are out there 😂😂 How is the Cyber truck doing? 😂😂

[@origaminefretami3480]

​@@cg5648you cant trust anything Tesla. I dont even believe the 2 million preorders from the Cybertruck, because its Tesla 😂

[@james3803]

well this vid is going to age like a fine milk ^^

[@miseseconomics]

Just like this one aged like fine Milk: Elon Musk's ROBO TAXI DEBUNKED kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2jbZpKrpZqqbdU

[@james3803]

@@miseseconomics i mean part of that one aged quite well your right i have to admit that. but you fail to give the context there on all the numbers and the fact is that there are less accidents and deaths per mail driven with auto pilot engaged then with no auto pilot and that will get better and better over time just wait and see id give it less then 5 years from now that there are way over 10X less accidents/deaths from teslas because of full self driving plus teslas are already causing less accidents/deaths per mail driven then other cars right now end 2023.ps more sources to prove me wrong are much appreciated im always willing to try and prove myself wrong with new info ^^ those 2 vids already helped me to see everything tesla to be a bit less clean/perfect keep questioning everything! especially in the corporate world!

[@hobo1704]

​@@james3803FSD is a scam champ, sorry to tell you..

[@tot788]

@@james3803 “Tesla Autopilot and similar automated driving systems get ‘poor’ rating from prominent safety group” (CNN) published in March 2024

[@jz261]

I love how you try to piss off tesla fanbois but nobody cares. Tesla to busy being the ev leader and innovation be it 48 volts, robots, fsd beta you name it. People like you are always gonna be jealous but at the end of the day we ignore you and you are the one screaming at the screen spending countless hours editing videos to bash tesla and they still could not care less. I'd love to see your face every time a tesla drives by or another tesla bot video releases. You are advertising tesla for free and I thank you for that.

[@miseseconomics]

I love your comment, I’m just exiting the the loop the built. Man what a amazing technology, being driven in a tunnel with a drives in a car. My mind is utterly 🤯 kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5fUaZiGebpseKssi=P2L9lECx8bODGihL

[@jz261]

​@miseseconomics man you prove my point exactly ain't nobody but you talking about the loop, elon hasn't nearly invested as much time in it as you, it's like elon lives rent free in your head. Also you took that clip at the end out of context just like everything else. The interview was about space X and the interviewer asked him about landing a rocket back which he did. Keep being the clown on the internet it's what your good at.

[@Ugo_Goglu]

2:25 I believe the "noise" is a result dithering and Lossy compression. Dither is an intentionally applied form of noise used to randomize quantization error, preventing large-scale patterns such as color banding in images. Its like scrambling random pixels in a gradient to make it look smoother. If you want to learn more Tom Scott made an excellent video on this called "Why dark video is a terrible mess" Some cameras and all streaming sites including KZbin use these compression methods to save money and/or space. 5:14 This could be a result of interframe compression. Interframe compression (also called temporal compression) reduces file size across multiple frames by creating a starting point and then only saving the changes in subsequent frames. Notice how the "wires" appear only right after the gaps of the panel? that's because the wires are the gaps but dragged out. I don't think the walk was fake mainly because its not impressive. Honda has done a better walk like in 1997 so its not too crazy to believe Tesla can (barley) do it in 2023. I think you might be baiting hate views and comments but I thought the video was fun and I like learning stuff so I'm fine with it.

[@miseseconomics]

As I said, the robot can walk. In the other shoots I couldn’t find any wires. But the walk is not smooth as his head keeps floating back and forward. The green screen I pointed out is right on the money. Definitely used green screen. We supposed to be impressed by a robot that walks? And that’s it…. Rest is 3d/cgi and pre programmed robot. I’ll do another video debunking all of the robots. Tesla fakes so much stuff I wouldn’t trust them without testing the product. Remember all the influencers on KZbin claiming full self driving is amazing? While tesla admitted that it’s level 2 to the American authorities while charging people 12-15k for autopilot… Talk about a hype

[@naytewilson]

If you think robot is going to be anything important in the future you’re an idiot.

[@sammadison1172]

He missed the only fake part of the video, theyre not real eggs. I didn't believe rockets could land vertical either, but they can. the goal is to use these robots in the factory and eventually sell them to consumers. Little reason to be misleading. Maybe this increases stock short term but that's not common direction for Tesla or Spacex, delivery is

[@Mrtev215]

​@@sammadison1172okay so where's the Tesla roadster or how about robotaxis that would generate $30,000 in profit a year?, how about the full self-driving you know the autonomous system that must advertising a video all the way back in 2019? But guess what? That video wasn't accurate. A judge just came to that conclusion. But yeah, Tesla totally delivers on all of its promises.

[@Pseudoscience-is-a-scam]

@@sammadison1172of course rockets can land vertically. They’ve been doing it since the ‘90s.

[@Just_a_random_birb]

the only channel that thinks this is fake. just like thunderF00t

[@miseseconomics]

I know :)

[@origaminefretami3480]

The only two critical thinkers in an ocean of Eloncucks 😂

[@TrophicBog]

Ahhhh yes, more good points about the alleged faking if teslas Optimus Robot. Im back again to inform you of some more problems with you points you have pointed out. Starting with the hardest point to debunk, your green screen and grainy video point. Now basically every video ever shot has grain in it, some more visible than others. The way cameras work is they work better in lighted conditions as more light is imputed through the camera lense. The reason for the grain in this video is that the neckpiece has been swapped out for a mesh-like material that doesn't reflect light and therefore the camera struggles more with this area. That's why the white, reflective material has less visible grain, though there is still grain visible. You can prove this by looking at the black mats in the background which has massive amount of grain. And now the green screen point. When you altered the video to enhance the green hues, do notice that other things that wouldnt otherwise be green, even if a green screen was present, was altered green like the shadow of the black mats. Is there an explanation of those shadows turning green. You altered the video so even the slightest green anywere in the video would be boosted. Also if a green screen was used, those shadows under the robot would be near impossible to create with such accuracy. In the end, if a green screen was used, what difrence does it have for the to be robot squating infront of a greenscreen have compared to in that specific room. Now the wire point. Im not the first to notice but the supposed “wire” doesnt actualy move with the robot. When the line is there for the few frames, the robot is moving forward while the wire stays stationary. The part about the faking of the self driving video is also another fair point although that was in 2016. Today is 2023. Tesla was a small company in 2016 and it was probably a test of the self driving concept. As they stated, the path was pre routed, might have been a concept for this self driving concept and could have been what they have imagined as a way for self driving to work. Of course companys makes mistakes and learns from them, and evey sucsess doesnt come without failure and mistakes. Every journey has its downs, but that just makes the end result so much better. All this is only what i believe and remember this is a platform for expressing youself so i dont come with any hatred. Im only here to state my opinion, and ill let you share yours.

[@FutureFusion-gt4cg]

I can't wait for the day this channel is proven Wrong. This explanes everything and its all just common knowledge. :D

[@miseseconomics]

Yes all cameras have noise in it. But I’m this shoot the grain is different on his head and the shoot. It’s obviously that I said, green screen leaking.

[@cg5648]

@@FutureFusion-gt4cg, you will be waiting forever 😂😂😂

[@conceptrat]

Hey not to throw a spanner in the works here. And I'm no Musk fan, that's for sure. But if this Optimus you're debunking, by talking about green screening, is CGI then there would be absolutely no need for green screening whatsoever. Placing a CGI in front of a flat background, what this looks to be, is the complete opposite to the requirement for a green screen. Now if you were trying to put the a CGI behind some objects in the real world then, 100%, one way would require a green to be placed where you are trying to place that object. There are other ways now days but this has been, and still is, one of the ways that its done in film work. I learnt this in first half of the first year in a multimedia diploma.

[@conceptrat]

Also the room reflection in the robots face is fairly consistent with overall room and lighting. Of course, this could also be that the whole space is also part of the render.

[@miseseconomics]

Unfortunately you didn’t understand what I was saying. The robot that is walking is real. The rest is pre programmed and the bending down is green screen

[@Inaf1987]

You need more subs, my guy. But here's my appreceiation all the same, great work

[@miseseconomics]

Thanks. I found even more evidence these robots are fake

[@NextGenart99]

@@miseseconomics So will you delete your channel and apologise next A.I day when the bots are shown live.

[@africaart]

hope you didn't get copyright claim for that song? 12:40

[@miseseconomics]

No idea. It’s old as hell, maybe I will get it. I hope not

[@HermitFab]

But you use green screen to film real objects and place them onto a fake background. For the robot to be showing green screen bleed it means they filmed a real robot in front of a green screen????

[@miseseconomics]

On that shoot, they filmed a robot that was later placed in the gym. I think that the robot can’t bend down so they faked it with wires and green screen and try many times until one succeeds. They you just remove green screen and….you get the shoot. A “robot” bending down. The robot is real but I think it can only walk a few meters without falling over

[@miseseconomics]

Yes, I explained this! They use a mix of 3d and real "robot" that can do some simple tasks... The yellowish robot is 3d, the dancing robot at end of teslas video is also 3d. Rest is robot. A robot that can walk!

[@HermitFab]

Ahh I see.

[@ozymandias_yt]

The wire thing COULD be true and Tesla lying would be nothing new, but I don't get why so much of the video is about the green screen. Seems like they just changed the background in this shoot. So what? In contrast to the removal of wire, which still can't be proved by this "evidence", this has no relevance. It is right to question Optimus ability as long as there is no live demo, but this video gives litte to no evidence, that the demo contains false claims.

[@miseseconomics]

Its not so what....basically they made the robot bend down, what else is fake if they faked this? They should have a disclaimer that some things are overpromised...its like fsd..next year

[@ozymandias_yt]

@@miseseconomics Again: I still don’t get the connection between the background being green screen and the capabilities of the robot. I imagine it like this: 1. robot makes this squat like movement in front of green screen so the PR department can choose a theme for the promotion video. 2. They want a gym environment and add that into the scene, so the association is agility or something else these marketing folks came up with. If you aren’t arguing the robot is fake in this shot, what is the problem here then?

[@treestandsafety3996]

His achievments with Rockets and Cars, already make Musk legendary...Just wait for the factory bots!

[@miseseconomics]

Right…

[@agent5758]

the armor shadowing looks different cus the lighting setup is different. you can't be this dense

[@miseseconomics]

Please anyone with any CGI experience can see if a mile away. Go watch Ironman if you want some good cgi

I don't understand why they would need green screen. If the bot is rendered, they would probably compose the rendered frames using masking (cryptomatte for instance), this is available with any modern raytracer. About the wire removal, it looks as though the vertical line follows the background and not the bot. A wire would follow the bot at all times, no? My first thought was "compression artifact" as sharp edges are known to produce ringing artifacts (vertical black line covered briefly by the bot, that is mostly white) around the vertical line. Look under the butt of the bot, there should be no wire under the bot, but the artifact is actually there as well, so artifact from compression, which is a sin in itself. What I do agree with is that they could just control his arms and fingers like they have done before. It looks really nice, but if it's not AI, it's not really impressive. So actually there is nothing new.

[@miseseconomics]

I tried to explain it....first 30 sec = 3d.. Dancing = 3d. After all your comments I had another look to see if you are right....and then I saw even more wires...everywhere. So I missed 50% of the wires. So thanks for your critical eye, you get me to become better. Im making a new video where there will be 0 doubts about Tesla faking Robot videos.

[@treestandsafety3996]

Superficially, there's nothing new....its not an artisinal BD bot!

@@miseseconomics No problem, happy to help. I think Elon is a big joke and I want to call him out whenever I see bs, but I am just not convinced here, sorry to say. I'm from Sweden and I think we are just tired of Elon's shenanigans at this point (I'm referring to the Tesla license plate gate). I was half-expecting the Bot to give us the middle finger 🤣. The thing I can say is that everything in the video is probably real, but that does not make it impressive, really. I mean, we have lowered our expectations so low that when Tesla does something that actually looks cool and might work, we are impressed 🤨. The Tesla Bot looks a little rusty when it is dancing (like Elon), put some more snake oil in its gears 😉.

[@Foothillpump]

There are countless videos of Tesla user reviews of autonomous driving. Tesla never claimed that 100% of the robot video was real but it is showing what will be.

[@miseseconomics]

Just as they showed full self driving was real? In 2016?

[@miseseconomics]

You should watch my videos about robot taxi. I destroy it with math. He is full of shit

[@Foothillpump]

@@miseseconomics Is it real?

[@Foothillpump]

@@miseseconomics What do you consider self driving? Like I said there are countless videos of people in Teslas NOT DOING THE DRIVING.

[@miseseconomics]

Tesla charged 12k for autopilot...you tell me what Autopilot is....and means...

[@_i_D_G]

Boston Dynamics ATLAS was in development for 40 years ➜ kzbin.info/www/bejne/lXa9gqtubKmssK8 Honda ASIMO was in development for 20 years ➜ kzbin.info/www/bejne/maKvY42sj5KkZ5Ysi=5hgFN1EGc0txGPLl Tesla BOT in development for (AOT) 19 months ➜ kzbin.info/www/bejne/maHVkouXrJyXr8U

[@miseseconomics]

I’m aware about all of that. There is a company that achieved same as tesla in 12 months. They have a video on yt about the robot walking

[@philipduttonlescorlett]

Tesla is a multibillion dollar tech company run by the richest man in the world. It is also a company that can build its own actuators and parts. All of this speeds up the process massively. The guy made a rocket that can land like a Thunderbird ffs. Have faith!

[@babel-fishai]

I think you're just seeing artifacts in the video. I think the robot is actually real and it's not that impressive. But that is due to some key differences. One is that Boston Dynamics has been developing their robots for over a decade. Tesla has only started developing theirs and Tesla is incorporating AI into the design of the robots which means that these robots are moving slower and more deliberate because they're still learning how to do things. The Boston Dynamics robots do not incorporate AI and every single move is choerographed and deliberately programmed in. Now if you could take the Boston Dynamics robot or vice versa and incorporate a deep learning model that preserves all of the previous programming and enhances that with AI then you would really and truly have amazing robots that would be ready for the workplace etc.

[@miseseconomics]

The robot can walk, the rest is motion capture or controlling the robot by a human operator behind the scene

[@miseseconomics]

Tesla Bot DEBUNKED kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYnFo5ennbFssKs

[@NextGenart99]

When a robot is so advanced that people think it is CGI, wow we are truly living in the future. I gotta invest in this company

[@JasonHenderson]

Bye bye money

[@NextGenart99]

@@JasonHenderson We will see, gonna be an interesting 10 years to come.

[@philipparana9225]

Boston dynamics makes. Robots, Elon make cars that make fart noises.

[@NextGenart99]

@@philipparana9225 Nah, that Boston dynamic guys been working on that back-flipping toy for 25 years and still they can't even give the thing hands. I see Tesla products every day on the road I've never seen a Boston dynamic product. I rather invest in Tesla. Everyone knows what a Tesla is, only nerds know what Boston's dynamic is.

[@miseseconomics]

I just stepped out of the hyperloop 🙃

[@johnrussell4788]

You showed images of a man and a woman in front of green screen, and inserted them into the scene. You are suggesting that a 3d image was created and inseryed in the scene, however no green screen is needed to insert a 3d tobot image. So you are wrong in your claims.

[@miseseconomics]

No im not. First 30 sec of video = 3d/cgi. The rest is robots, helped sell a illusion. Dont worry new video will drop and explain everything.

[@fredrik3685]

Elons robot is no better than what we have seen live.

[@miseseconomics]

If he wants us to believe, let them have a live demo. Otherwise they will use green screen and wire

[@Voltaje_YT]

Optimus have just 2 years, other have decades, let them have their development time, is not that the robot will be release to the public like this without any improvements.

[@Vynzent]

@@Voltaje_YT That's no excuse to fake demonstrations. They have yet to show a live demo, and so far every video demo of this robot has been blatantly faked.

[@diybeast3943]

⁠@@miseseconomicsbro It’s a fucking advertisement. Stop being a nitpicker and go touch some grass😂

[@zaibian7]

@@Voltaje_YT Boston Dynamics was valued at $1.1 billion in 2021. In 2021 Tesla was valued at $1 trillion. 1000 times the potential budget. I'm surprise the damn thing can't fly. Elon thinks he is Tony Stark. Tesla can afford to develop the hardware in house. Boston Dynamics is limited to off the shelf hardware developed by other companies. Parts that were not designed for robots. So of course Tesla did in two years what Boston Dynamics took ten years to do. Teslas achievement is not impressive in that context. Elon bought up most of the most talented engineers on the planet. He already has an existing AI platform to include in the robot from his EV's. So why the hell would he even need to fake anything. There is no like for like comparison here. All robotics companies are making incredible progress, but none have the budget and resources of Tesla. So of course Optimus (What is it with Elon giving things awful, and often unoriginal names?) is miles ahead of the competition. There are at most four animation studios in the world that could pull of a hoax as convincing as this video. There is no chance in hell any of them would keep it a secret. They would be screaming it from the roof tops. I've watched the video in 4K and the few artifacts people keep pointing to disappear, so they're just due to compression. They haven't even cranked up the speed like some of the earlier videos. There is no jittering and fast shaking this time, unless the robot is much heavier than they say, it's moving normally. If this video is fake, whoever made it will be getting a visit from some very serious people in the near future.

[@AnubisSolvang]

But you said it was green leaking, so that means we shouldn't have saw any green. How would you see green if it was superimposed? The green wouldn't be present. You disproved yourself.

[@miseseconomics]

It means you seen green leaking into reflective parts which is the black metal. You see it easily when I increase all colors

[@AnubisSolvang]

@@miseseconomics like I just said, it wouldn't be visible once you chroma key. So the fact that you are seeing green at all disproves your argument.

[@Mcullik]

Oof, this won't age well

[@karlakarl3715]

yes musk is rich because the companies creates value for customers. People buy teslas because they are great and spacex are used because they are great and cheap. What have this guy Miseseconomics created? You cant be sucessful 20 years because of fraud and fake:)

[@miseseconomics]

What a billion between friends? www.reuters.com/technology/space/us-agency-will-not-reinstate-900-mln-subsidy-spacex-starlink-unit-2023-12-13/

[@SamWilkinsonn]

bold of you to assume Tesla fanboys watch any criticism of their idol. Great observations btw

[@miseseconomics]

You are probably right...

[@mater5930]

It's easier to play the fool than to admit you've been fooled.

[@andrewnelson4148]

Walking robots today are not that advanced today. Tesla bot are just a walking version of the Tesla truck.

[@miseseconomics]

So they claim....when can I see the live demo?

[@Hustle5.0]

what you are smoking is powerful

[@miseseconomics]

Im not the one that use...Elon... www.wsj.com/articles/silicon-valley-microdosing-ketamine-lsd-magic-mushrooms-d381e214

[@furuwrecker1420]

Cope hard, Elon fan boy

[@Pandabubba9]

@@miseseconomics ketamine Ok but I think he’s high functioning

[@kevinsedwards]

Not nearly as powerful as your copium

[@rickb2432]

Stan

[@basrikartal]

Use of green screen for changing background does not mean the bots and their capabilities are fake. I'll be back here when Tesla bots hit the market and Tesla shares soared many foldes.

[@miseseconomics]

Good luck with your thinking.

[@bryceshinohara9270]

A green screen reflecting on the robot is evidence for it being it real and just the background being fake. Green screens are also not needed for 3d renderings.

[@miseseconomics]

I explained it but you guys seem to miss the point

[@C00LX100]

@@miseseconomics ok so you made the video to poove something, we say you wrong and show how, you say we missed the point, well shit explaining batter, just imagine if Einstein said well you missed the point and did not explain it further. And in his words, if you cannot explain something simply you do not understand it well enough...

[@joeblow2286]

Between this and Google faking their ai demo, I'm a pessimist now

[@miseseconomics]

I looked into Google faking the promo. They kind of faked it yes…basically the video was fake but they did used ai for it and took out information from the answers while feeding it a image. Basically you give it a image and it tells you what it is. Midjourney can do that if you use /description function I found it strange that everyone is faking stuff right now. Are they all trying to pump up their stock values? Or afraid to be left behind? Strange world we live in

[@ricpla6930]

If this is fake then you cannot tell me that Boston dynamics robots doing the flips and stuff is not mixed cgi as well

[@miseseconomics]

Fair point, you can order one and they are 1000 of them around the globe. It looks to real. There are so many videos out there of them I see SoftBank is investing in them and every time I see SoftBank somewhere I become suspicious Are they profitable? That’s a fair question

[@TheShinorochi]

These are normal to me I have seen robot dog do a flips in real life many times, I’ve went many AI robotics convention and meeting

[@FitnessGuru91]

Boston dynamics is all real it has been examined numerous times by CGI creators and they said it was all real. You would see a lot of strange stuff that could not be hidden if it was CGI. Unless they create the best robots and have the best CGI artist on the market working for them...

[@ricpla6930]

@@FitnessGuru91 all of which is second and third hand knowledge, anyone can say anything they want, a person can put on a white coat and say they are a doctor when they aren’t. I’m not saying BD is fake but there is a ton of fake bs going around even on mainstream news that you just have to question everything now

[@philipduttonlescorlett]

Very different beasts. The Tesla runs AI the Boston is a programmable unit.

[@mostfrequencies4981]

If the robot worked as visualized in the promotional video, then hats off to Tesla, in front or behind Boston Dynamics, it doesn't matter, their robot would still rock. The likely use of CGI suggests the Robot division is still years away from what is simulated in the video. The video looks to be fake, the real robot looks fragile and limited in real capacity. You don't see anyone going up to it and giving it a big kick.

[@miseseconomics]

Exactly. This is like a commercial of what the company may do in like 10-15 years or so What is the battery range on this thing? The torso looks not big enough to store any sizable battery. The Honda robot only had an hour

[@MM-eg2pc]

Sorry to disappoint your wish for Tesla to fail, but I'm a seasoned VFX Supervisor and there is clearly no hint of green screening in the squat-shot. It's just lowlight noise. Look at the shadow of the feet: thats not green screened and the floors reflections in the bots head are correct. No wires in the walking shot; those are camera movement artifacts from the toolshed-doors (vertical lines can cause these rippling effects depending on shutter speed and camera movement). To do the nicely lit wall shot in CGI would be an absolute stupid amount of work for the result, especially the rigging. You can even see detailed cloth bending and metal parts behind at elbows height; Especially the plants lighting and lamps clearly suggest that scene is photographic. Lets see how the next years go for this project ;). @miseseconomics

[@miseseconomics]

You should watch it in 4K. If you don’t see the green screen I don’t know what to tell you. The noise in his head is 4x the rest of the shoot. If you don’t see the green screen where I described it then download the video in 4K and have a look. You can’t miss it. It’s not well done

[@uxxix]

The new video of the bot folding a t shirt is even more fake.

[@miseseconomics]

Elon admitted it’s pre-programmed. I haven’t looked into it closely enough

[@JasonHenderson]

Instead of paying twice as much for a social media website then it's worth, he could have put that money into Boston Dynamics and at least owned a controlling share? He could have named it Tesla Boston or Tesla dynamics or something and had an actual robot company. Instead. He just has a worthless website

[@miseseconomics]

He could be he didn’t.

[@JasonHenderson]

@@miseseconomics this is why I don't think anyone should invest in any company that he has his hands in. He's a crazy idiot

[@supergrafxengine4620]

Thanks goodness he didn't our Boston dynamic would have been ruined by Musk. And he would have fired everyone and called himself the founder too the hack.

[@JasonHenderson]

@@supergrafxengine4620 Is Boston Dynamics even publicly traded? Perhaps this is why he didn't just spend half as much money buying an actual robot company rather than a worthless website?

[@Voltaje_YT]

Boston Dynamics uses pre programmed code to move Atlas, and uses hydrolics, its technology is useless to Tesla, which want to use electrical actuators, and make the robot fully electric, additionally, they are building Optimus through AI and machine learning, meaning, the bot will learn through data, the same as FSD, not coding from humans, different approaches make Bosotm Dynamic and Tesla oppsoite.

[@mcsonicteam]

Those Boston dynamics are on another level.

[@miseseconomics]

I know :) they have been making robots for 20years

[@jaydy71]

Regarding the green-screen stuff, doesn't that just prove that the robot was not filmed in the same room, but might otherwise be legitimately doing it's thing before a green-screen? It's obviously still super suspicious though because why bother with green screens in the first place to show a robot doing such utterly trivial things... As an aside, considering it's green-screened, I thought the orange ball reflecting in the robot's 'belly' was a neat touch; probably the only reason that orange ball is in the shot anyway :) But anyway, great job here; Musk's hype train can't be debunked enough.

[@miseseconomics]

I think they did it because they wanted him to bend down like that. It’s funny they missed the green screen. Good point on the green balls

[@turtlejr8911]

@@miseseconomics You know you can render without a greenscreen right? [its common practice] Greenscreen is used for backgrounds that need changing irl.

[@alphamineron]

Green screen does mean that the robot is faked, because green screen allows you to hide support infrastructures attached to the actor. Just like Hollywood movies make superheros… you need green screen even if the background is static but you’re doing a “superhero landing”. Fake motion basically

[@porcus123]

I find it even more funny the tesla stans on the comment section claiming tesla is gonna deliver fully autonomous robots the "year after current year". Like ct, semi, FSD its gonna take years and the delivery will be shit. Imagine anyother companie doing this, and not getting their shit kicked in.

[@miseseconomics]

I was just on a call with many tesla fanboys and I just kept asking them questions. Funny thing is they let me talk… I asked them at the end…who in here believes fsd will be done anytime soon? It was crickets….no one said anything I should post that video here

[@dreamcastdc]

I have FSD Beta and it can drive from point A to B without me doing much of anything.

[@miseseconomics]

Please be careful. A engineer died because he trusted it

[@anonymous-rj6ok]

You don't need a green screen when adding CGI to a real background you silly goose. I'm sure it's CGI but your green screen explanation makes no sense.

[@miseseconomics]

My explanation is perfect.....they used manikin and 3d. You can obviously see that the first part of the video is cgi. its not even good cgi, its avg at best.

[@anonymous-rj6ok]

​@@miseseconomics that's even more delusional. the way CGI like this is made is you put someone in a bodysuit with sensors to use as a model for the movement of the bots movement in CGI. when the CGI animation is added to a real environment no green screen whatsoever is needed.

[@Mrln_Thompson]

In your own video, you said that the Tesla Bot Gen 1 is real and that the Gen 2 robot can walk. So I guess you will just have to wait until the next Tesla bot video before you realise your mistake. It is so weird that it seems easier for you to think that Tesla can't build a robot. Elon Musk built SpaceX(reusable rockets) and Tesla(electric cars) which have all the components and experts needed to build a cheaply manufactured robot with great quality. Boston Dynamics has robots that are mostly hydraulics(little to no electric motors) with expensive parts that don't sell. Honda sells a lot of cheaply manufactured cars with great quality but they could not make ASIMO(a robot) cheap enough to sell. However, Elon Musk and his companies have the best engineers to build electric motors, batteries and autonomous systems. If they can automatically dock a spacecraft with the ISS and have cars driving by themself, I am absolutely sure the robots will just take a little more time (they started in 2021).

[@miseseconomics]

No it’s all fake. It’s a fake robot

[@BartvanderHorst]

@@miseseconomics Yeah, no arguments there.

[@TheLevitatingChin]

Careful the musk rats will form a human shield

[@miseseconomics]

They are just pump and dumpers. Once stock goes down they will run away...

[@MyrKnof]

This channel is not about economics, its literally just musk hate, because that gets the most views. Theres nothing to see here folks.

[@miseseconomics]

Musk will go down in history as the man who destroyed the most amount of money.

[@Factory400]

There are a lot of things to dislike about Musk.....so at least the content is not false.

[@xxBlackpspxx]

Why is it so hard for them to get auto parking to work? Volkswagen can do this since like 10 years. My 6 year old polo can do it. You only have to manually switch gears from reverse/drive and apply throttle/brake due to legal reasons, but it tells you when to brake/accelerate and does steering by its own. And it only uses proximity sensors. No cameras and all that high tech. Worked flawlessly every time so far for 6 years. I mean it's a really old assist feature in cars, probably also other brands than VW

[@miseseconomics]

Because Elon doesn’t listen to engineers, he fires anyone who talks back to him. Elon wants to remove radar: engineer tells him that it will cause problems with measuring speed, accuracy ect…. Elon fires him and still removes it… Then we are surprised it doesn’t work

[@kennyfordham6208]

You forgot to mention the Tesla-bot handling the egg (with very obvious jump-cuts). 😉

[@miseseconomics]

I didn’t bother. Not only jump cuts the fingers are more bent in the 2nd shoot then in the previus one

[@lcnevar]

5:50 no it is compression artefact, data from this wall panels black stripe.

[@miseseconomics]

There are more of it in the shoot. I’m pretty sure it’s wire removal

[@zacaharywood7507]

I look forward to the day when the words “convicted fraudster” are next to Elon’s name on the Wikipedia page.

[@coldspring22]

Yup corporate crooks who did way less than the great Musk wound up in camp fed with nice free room and board. LOL

[@MD-sl7ms]

More will come in his place, the best path for millions of young men in 2023 is to be like him, sadly tech is about to clash with socialists. Hopefully we will get back together to live in peace one day.

[@rohithkumarsp]

even the ppl from Corrider Crew are saying its not Fake

[@miseseconomics]

As I said, the robot can walk that is real. Even the walking is controlled by a remote control. The rest is different robots doing different tasks either pre programmed or remote control.

[@johnfitzpatrick8310]

I'm certain that any Optimus engineers who have viewed this video have had a good laugh at your expense. Your "proof" is utter nonsense. The capabilities demonstrated in the Tesla video are real and rather modest. Elon, with rare pessimism, recently estimated 3-5 years until bot deployment. That may be, because the software challenge is daunting. But the rapid advancement represented by Gen 2 makes it seem closer than that. Otherwise you've made a nice effort to make your video entertaining, as well as misleading.

[@miseseconomics]

The engineers that faked the FSD and then later admitted it? Well I laugh 10 x back: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpjOhZmbrbF-g5Y

[@Ssshortman]

It's shiny so it must be fake 🙄

[@miseseconomics]

Just look at the wall. It’s a typical trick to use textures

[@_Mutineer]

This video will age like milk.

[@miseseconomics]

Already doing a new video debunking it even more

[@itzapeezacake580]

This video is spoiled milk

[@OneLeggedDiver]

for real. dude's just digging himself into a whole. I wonder if he realizes that they mean to start delivering on Optimus bots this year to manufactures and warehouses

[@OneLeggedDiver]

@@miseseconomics can't wait to debunk your next debunk video

[@orderofmagnitude-TPATP]

Tesla bot is terrible. If it was anyone else presenting this other than elon you would be seeing what vapourware or junk this really is.

[@saiine]

I can guarantee that none of the video is CGI.

[@miseseconomics]

But why did I find the wires they removed? All you guys are about to get schooled.....

[@saiine]

@@miseseconomics :-)

[@TrophicBog]

@@miseseconomics :-)

[@origaminefretami3480]

Lol Teslafans show up to defend the Vaporwarebot

[@commonsenseskeptic]

Great job spotting the finest of details :)

[@miseseconomics]

Thanks CS :D

[@xccelera_rift]

So I'm guessing you haven't heard of the article where one of the tesla robots attacked a worker. Which elon denies

[@miseseconomics]

But which robot did that? I suspect its the kuka robots that build the cars. I doubt its these robots as these are manually operated

[@xccelera_rift]

@@miseseconomics I just said which robot, if it helps it was the gen 1 of the tesla robot, it's not the robot that makes cars because if it was I wouldn't have clicked on the article in the first place

[@enamuossuo]

This guy has an history of waporware and false promises yet some people are still defending him like their moms! I begin to think that some people just don't want to see the reality! Anyway thanks for your work!

[@miseseconomics]

Just look at the recent comment. The wire….no need for green screen. Download the video from teslas website and look for yourself. Don’t take my word for it. There is no helping these tesla fanboys

[@Foothillpump]

What was vaporware? SpaceX? Starlink? Boring Company? Tesla? Neuralink?

[@thedualtransition6070]

Just a more successful version of Olivia Holmes, he bought a company that could actually make cars. Everything else is just bullshit.

[@thedualtransition6070]

@@Foothillpump Oh fanboy, control yourself. Neuralink and the Boring company were always vaporware. Starlink and SpaceX no go without massive government subsidies, and the giveaway of NASAs technology and even then they are in trouble - burning investor cash. He bought a company that could make cars, that's just starting to hit the wall hard. Musk will be a footnote in history.

[@Foothillpump]

@@thedualtransition6070 What do you mean everything else is bullshit?

[@franklee663]

Actually if you look at the reflection in the head, the perspective doesn't change at all.

[@miseseconomics]

The head moves strangely, like it’s not connected to the body. But after looking into it so many times I can’t find anything. It may move strangely but it looks real

[@dimitriborcak6698]

I don't think it was faked - simply because the things this robot does are so simple that I would expect any group of students being able to build it in a year on a budget of no more than a few million.

[@wemakecookie]

Ya this video is a massive reach. Along with some other videos I've seen from this guy.

[@ironrobinlandscaping8209]

Maybe you should look for thunderf00ts coverage of Elon musk for the past decade. Elon is a grifter.

[@miseseconomics]

New video in production.....all Tesla robots are going down.....Since you never give up on Elon Bullshit I have to go harder...@@wemakecookie

[@Irobert1115HD]

well its faked when the robots moves smothely or does a complex task.

[@catman8770]

@@miseseconomics bro CANNOT stop shamelessly grifting off elon musk

[@pinchopaxtonsgreatestminds9591]

I'm not sure that the right side is real either.

[@miseseconomics]

It looks real, I checked everything. You can make it in 3d but if so then it’s well done. I know companies that can do that

[@pinchopaxtonsgreatestminds9591]

@@miseseconomics Well the motion blur, and focus look wrong to me.

[@nujum24]

Oh yeah, they got the robot to stand on one leg and stretch its arms forward. But squatting, yeah, that's just too much, gonna have to green screen it. You should have been a professional basketball player, because that Reach amazing😂

[@miseseconomics]

It looks like the rotor can just walk. The rest is pre programmed. I will show in next video why it’s nothing revolutionary or ground breaking.

[@miseseconomics]

Watch this. I’m not reaching Elon is Elon Musk's ROBO TAXI DEBUNKED kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2jbZpKrpZqqbdU

[@SalamAnuar]

This guy is jelly

[@miseseconomics]

I’m not. I actually with spacex succeeds or a company similar to spacex

[@peterjacobsson]

Another thing that speaks for it to be faked is that if the robots worked that good as they tell it do they should have put the production on hyperdrive to try shove it out at soon they can and not say year after year “it will came out next year.

[@hobo1704]

Exactly

[@tomasnilsson866]

Great work sir!

[@samuelpeterson7043]

Does anyone else feel like 2024 is going to be an epically rough one for Elon?

[@miseseconomics]

Who knows how long this will last....I said in one of my previous videos he will have a rough time ahead... 1. X losing AD 2. All EV struggling to sell 3. Spacex not going well even though they are making progress...

[@samuelpeterson7043]

My bet for 2024: 2 more LEO or sub-LEO explosions for Starship and the Starship program gets canceled, FSD is scrapped for an entirely new plan that also sucks so Elon can grift his fanboys some more, Cybertruck production is canceled as Elon claims it's a "collectors edition truck" and by the EOY Twitter goes tits up and Elon has a once in a lifetime public meltdown that gets him canned from Tesla@@miseseconomics

[@fiddlesticks443]

If an orange con man can become president, Musk will be fine. He has a cult following and they will never abandon him....Cyber truck anyone...

[@jaydy71]

@@miseseconomics Also, more and more noise from investors wanting Elon to step down from Tesla (which would imho be the best thing that could happen to Tesla now to get rid of all the insanity there). Also Neuralink being way behind the competition while still in controversy about all those dead monkeys. Boring Company having nothing substantial to show for. It's my understanding though that SpaceX is doing pretty well?

[@Voltaje_YT]

I feel it will be even better for Tesla and SpaceX, interest rates will be lowered, cybertruck produciton will increase, giga mexico will start construction, 4 Starship launches will take place, though i think it will be 5, but lets be conservative, neuralink will start human trials, so yeah, a good time for Elon dude.

[@deedrabbit]

Musk is more like the wizard of Oz, than the wizard of Menlo park. I doubt if he could operate a tv remote successfully.

[@miseseconomics]

He is going to jail...2024 or 2025

[@luisrazi]

You’re a beast. 😎 💪

[@miseseconomics]

Fanboys complained so they summoned me 😂

[@BoazAugustoMatos]

Man you made laugh out loud at that part at the end...with the robots dancing....🤣🤣🤣

[@miseseconomics]

I’m glad I did :) have a nice weekend