TESLA MODEL Y VS. MODEL X... An Opinion From Someone Who Owns BOTH!

If you are buying a new Tesla and my videos have helped you, please use my referral link, which is ts.la/marc57969 .
I have received a lot of questions asking my opinion on the Model X and the Model Y since we took delivery of our Model Y. So here are my thoughts on both vehicles. I know I probably left a lot of info out but I did try to hit the most important things and the questions that I get asked the most.
I hope you enjoy!
If you or someone you know is looking to buy a Tesla, please use my referral code. It is ts.la/marc57969 Both of us get 1000 miles of FREE Supercharging, as well as get entered into a drawing to win a Model Y or Next Gen Roadster.

[@marc_benton]

Many have asked about the measurements for the trunk in Model X versus Model Y. I did the length and width in the video but didn’t do the height. The height is almost identical at 27”! If you want to see the measurements, check my twitter feed. 👍

[@silvabullet13]

That's because he sucks at reviewing and describing cars. He needs to focus on his kids and family bc that whole video was awful

[@emmajadeeaston4854]

@@silvabullet13 Oh hush, it was a great video, really opened my eyes about the doors. Stop being a hater.

[@AlanCypress]

Buy a big bag of plastic balls that are used for children's play pits. Count the number that fit in frunks and trunks of X & Y. That will give you volume percentages.

[@ericleszkowicz898]

This made it MUCH hard to justify getting an X or a used S.

[@jackananian117]

Question about range of both vehicles

[@sanctred]

Summary: They are almost exactly the same, but the falcon wing doors are cool.... You're welcome.

[@Ksubsbefore-qu3iv]

no??

[@sanctred]

@@Ksubsbefore-qu3iv but kind of yes...

[@Ksubsbefore-qu3iv]

sanctred but kind of no...

[@marc_benton]

They are not the same ... they ARE about the same size though. Model X is a nicer vehicle overall, no doubt.

[@dulla93]

Marc Benton The more expensive car is nicer? What a shocker

[@kevinle6490]

this is the most honest review of x and y in youtube as an owner!

[@marc_benton]

Thank you! 🙏

[@life-20gen68]

I agree, very honest and clear review !

[@msoldate]

Model X is the one you want, Model Y is the one you can afford

[@ame4195]

I have drivin the model x and i think it has just too much bodyroll.. so i would rather have the model y than the model x

[@wg4476]

@@ame4195 Drive the P100D. Changing the wheels and tires make a big difference. It blew my mind how something so big and so heavy can feel so sporty.

[@tabithawilson6270]

Period

[@zman3254]

Nah. I can afford both. X just ain’t worth the money given how close the Y compares to the X.

[@wg4476]

@Marco Deo I did mention that it is "big" and "heavy" (it won't out turn a Miata in the tightest twists), but it is probably the best vehicle I can think of at that size of interior space and cargo room. It drives a lot better than one would expect, but don't expect a magic carpet ride; just a magical aspect of design and engineering for the weight and dimensions that it has to work with. If you want to go on a 90+ mph canyon twist, there are much smaller and lighter cars for that type of task; it shouldn't be any 7 seat vehicle.

[@JeffLenney]

Thanks for Taking the time to do this, Marc, good stuff - appreciate the perspective on both! Looks like you put a lot of work into this, so ty again!

[@seb.]

For the international people around, 4:18 that gives: X Y Depth 128,91 118,11 Rear Bottom 105,41 101,60 Rear Top 105,41 108,59

[@victoriakyivua6929]

Thank u, that was helpful

[@Jk-cx7ko]

Thank you

[@GadgetBoyea]

I agree with you, the price point of the model Y is better for most people and will be very popular.

[@racingpixel]

A HUGE THANK YOU, for making this video. This was EXACTLY what I was looking for. You have the keen ability to denote what’s actually important to showcase, plus you add just the right amount of narrative to accentuate a particular detail. BRAVO!

[@marc_benton]

Thanks for watching!

[@Daelen]

The way you were able to articulate that was lowkey inspiring. i need to broaden my vocab 😂

[@jali276]

I have ordered my Model Y and can't wait to get it soon! Model X is out of my price range but I think I only wanted it because of the wing doors 😜

[@kristelarabit3511]

I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@Torry8188]

Thank you Marc for taking the time to put together this excellent, thorough and informative video. Keep up the good work.

[@ytmndan]

Model X looks better from the front. Model Y looks better from the back.

[@omnomnomrawr11]

very very true

[@ayylmao8562]

I prefer the more minimalist look of the Y, the front of the X looks dated to me.

[@ctuna2011]

I disagree x looks Like a bug

[@ekoprasetiyo]

Well you can always put a sticker or paint the front of model X so it would look like a model Y :D

[@a.banana]

@@ctuna2011 Y looks like a frog to me lol

[@OveToranger]

Thank you for taking the time and effort in showing all of this !

[@chefalbino]

great personal review with strait reasons. agree - model X is "death" bevor the Cyber comes out

[@WhatsInside]

Good video. Only thing keeping me with the X is the number of people in our family. I need the bucket seats.

[@marc_benton]

What's Inside? Thanks Dan, Yea that makes total sense. That’s a great point I should have mentioned in the video. The 6 or 7 seater X is going to be quite a bit bigger than the Model Y 7 seater because it’s longer. I’ll pin this comment, thanks for mentioning that.

[@Euain]

Model X has bio-defense for the model why doesn't. Is this a feature any of you to use on the regular?

[@DSRTSLA]

Definately a good point. For the money new, its a 30k dif, Used X might just be the toss up between a new Y or used X if you need a bit more room.

[@10melvis]

@@Euain I have a model s and the bio defense is just a second hepa filter. The first one will get 95% of pollutants and the 2nd 4.9% more. Your car will also use max fan to force air out of cabin.

[@farhanusmani2439]

Marc,dan isnt free supercharging a big deal in comparison X vs Y. X users are also getting free supercharging for life with 30k price difference

[@paulbenton2342]

Really appreciated your comparison and especially your honesty. Thank you!

[@U_1984]

Excellent review. I really enjoyed it. A lot of other reviewers do not actually focus on these type of details.

[@GetIn2uitwithChristine]

Hey Marc, thanks for the comparison review! It was really helpful. I agree with you about the "wood". I can't wait to see your customizations.

[@kristelarabit3511]

Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@MarkAndNico]

Great review! We really appreciate the honesty. We’ve been debating between the X and the Y for such a long time. Very helpful!

[@amberwagner9091]

If you do not need the seating space get a Y. My husband just traded in his 3 (which was amazing) for a Y. The seating in the back of the Y is slightly bigger than the 3, I did not like how small the 3 was but it wasn’t our family vehicle. We will need an X because we need the seating, we have 4 kids, yes they just released a 7 seat Model Y but then you lose all trunk space and getting to the back will present a lot of issues and we do not need 2 Y’s! We LOVE the Y!

[@kristelarabit3511]

I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@maroonmike398]

Marc, as a former MX owner thinking about a Model Y (saw and sat in the first one today), this video was VERY helpful. Thanks for all the details!

[@ThreeGreenthumbs]

really down-to-earth comparison. You convinced me to look at the Y before going automatically going to the X.

[@ankit__9827]

You should go on Model X!

[@warzoneshenanigans1251]

I love how this video matched exactly what I was looking for. Thank you so much 🤙🏻

[@aaronbounds1336]

It is great to see all of the solar panels on all of the roofs again The neighborhood you did the filming. My neighborhood has changed a little bit over the last few years and we're getting many more people going solar.

[@espencapable]

Great review! For the rest of the world: Model X: 129cm deep 105.5cm wide 105cm opening Model Y: 118cm deep 102cm wide 108,5cm opening

[@tamkim2828]

Very intuitive comparison. Thank you so much for your time. Super informative video. Love it and subscribed!

[@jaysway007]

Great side by side comparison! Thank you for posting

[@kirtlyewheeler5482]

Thank you so much, was really struggling to find a good comparison...you saved me $30,000!

[@shaunasamuel2796]

Thank you for the comparison video. It was very helpful. ! I’ve debated this very issue. I have been leaning towards the model Y and you’ve confirmed my thoughts!

[@michelluttikhold9474]

Thank you very much for this clear video! I am from the Netherlands myself and many questions I had have been answered. Thanks again!

[@DouglasKramer]

Thanks for pointing out that the Falcon Wng doors rub, I hadn't heard that before.

[@jake-kent5159]

Thank you for this content I’m getting a model y within the next week or so and have been watching videos till it gets here haha

[@johngrimm5927]

I think that some people want the X (in spite of cost) as it symbolizes ELITE and differentiates itself from the other models.

[@vce.john1734]

For me I’m planning to get an model y just for now then when I date a girl and she want to start a family with me then I will consider get the model x but plaid version and every option you can get

[@kristelarabit3511]

I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@geronwilliams6014]

I literally have been holding off on ordering my car for weeks! This video helped A LOT! Thx my man.

[@cooltyagi]

Finally some good comparison video. 25 min of this video were worth more than 25 videos I watched on this topic before.

[@waynebyers2935]

Thanks Marc....Really helpful in making a decision to go either Model X or Y. Model Y it is! Look forward to seeing your custom work on the Y.

[@sbender9518]

Love my 2020 Model X. It has the new, super comfy seats, free super charging for life, love the look of the "built-in" screen and no issues with rubbing of the Falcon Wing doors. Perhaps they've fixed that since 2017. I also love the air suspension on the X and being able to adjust it up or down with a touch on the screen. My favorite body style is the Model 3. Great video, though. Loved seeing a comparison. Thank you.

[@JonEpicLepic]

Sheril Bender they don’t offer free super charging for life anymore. So not really a selling point anymore.

[@paulbenton2342]

Thank you for validating my thoughts as well. I just purchased the X and can't wait for delivery.

[@andrewhobbs486]

@@JonEpicLepic I pick up my new 2020 Model X Saturday, and it includes Free Supercharging. They have brought it back for existing inventory.

[@agoodauthority]

Same, got one from inventory with free supercharging. That said, had an S for three years with unlimited and it's really not that big a deal to pay for it on the rare occasions most will use it. No bad choices in the tesla lineup!

[@agoodauthority]

tommygirl20247 I leased mine through a business. Went with LR+ with the 22 wheels.

[@ldstiesto]

This video is amazing! No room for BS. Thanks for the info man

[@PALJamesKC]

Thanks brother. Great tips and information. Appreciate you taking the time to do that

[@mrinvincible8]

You did an amazing job with this video great video very detailed thank you for giving us exactly what we were thinking we wanted to see. This will surely help people on the fence cause even I wanted to see a great detailed comparison. So thank you and great great job!

[@Dartchy]

I prefer the Model X. But it’s not worth paying the extra money when the Model Y is so similar.

[@mcplutt]

@Comeonuseyourbrain Model Y is a drivers car. Model X is a passengers car.

[@arvins.7064]

I want the x but i would feel stupid not getting a Y performance for so much cheaper

[@ebarke7]

Adjustable suspension and towing that's what makes the big difference.

[@kingprone7846]

@Comeonuseyourbrain the X is NOT a drivers car. And neither is the S. Driving those feels more like driving a landboat and cant be compared at all to i.e. a 3 or 5 series.

[@arvins.7064]

@Ayush Malpeddi i just want the useless falcon wing doors😂

[@syedhakim4244]

This is the most useful review of both cars. Thank you.

[@mikewollock7635]

Thanks Marc. This is the honest opinion of the x & y that I was looking for.

[@DSRTSLA]

Awesome Video Marc. You made it easier to Confirm Im making the right choice. I love my 75D MS, but I knew It would be replaced. We thought about getting an X but Im glad that for the money we are definately making the right choice. I cant wait to get my Model Y buddy🤙🏽

[@suzanneso7671]

Appreciate your review on the two cars! Honest opinion that seems on point.

[@craigfleming4156]

I own a Y and took it to Highway One Timber Cove over the weekend to get away from the East Bay heat (+100°!!!). What a fantastic road machine! All the curves, views, deceleration, acceleration, an incredible experience that totally took away my blues! Loving the view looking up! Just installed a removable sunshade to block intense sun, big improvement but miss that view! Need to glue in clips, too easily lost!

[@angus10292]

Probably THE most practical comparison of tesla cars i've seen on the internet. Kudos !!

[@oblivionfox]

Appreciated your comments. I’ve got a Model x with 3.0 software. Tight fit in the garage, which is a pain every day. Can’t get past its drive and performance, tho. I like the falcon wings, tho not essential. Still enjoy my short commute every day, hope to keep this for a decade. Nice review.

[@kristelarabit3511]

Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@anabellebrooking3486]

Thanks for this. I’m picking up my model y on the June 7th..

[@sonyfxi]

Detailed. Concise. Excellent review. Thank you!

[@GeoffreyHodies]

Thanks! I keep seeing you on Twitter great to see your KZbin channel. Thanks for sharing your personal experience

[@mikeurban9476]

Thanks for a great comparison as I tormented over the choice and finally ordered a Model Y!

[@rkalla]

Great video, thanks for putting this together. Really surprised HOW similar they were on dimensions and such. Also, never thought of that Model X falcon wing door use case (operating while trying to get in/out front) but we have kids at the age you describe and that was a big Ah Ha moment for me. Thanks!

[@Rajjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj]

Really like the way you explained the issues with the door on model x and comparison of the seating positions and the sun roof. These are the things you wouldn’t know straight off just by viewing once , unless you use it in real life.

[@thenar]

Thank you Mark...that answered so questions for me. I appreciate your time.

[@wendysaavedra]

Thank you for the great comparison! I have a Model X 2016 and my husband has a model 3 2019. My X is sooo comfortable and the ride is so smooth compared to the model 3. The drawbacks are I do not get Netflix and my range is only 200mi, which sucks on road trips! I do however, love my biohazard filter, which is not on the 3. And I transport many children so having seven seats in the X is critical for me. I look forward to trying the Model Y one day though....I love Tesla and can’t imagine owning any other car but one of Elon’s models because going to a gas station is crazy to me.... thanks again for your comparison it was help others choose what works best for them.

[@kelsielee6082]

How are the falcon doors for you? Do you think they are dangerous at all? I watched another review on them not opening up all the way sometimes and it kinda dropping on them. Thats the only drawback on me getting the X!

[@kristelarabit3511]

Good day! I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@williamschaub3488]

great job on posting the difference of the Y and X model. Love the gull wing doors but looks like trouble. Order the Y and excited to get it....

[@anniewu2963]

Thanks for showing both models, I was pretty confused but now I can definitely tell my hubby I want the Y mainly because of similarities with big price difference.

[@danielhammer7919]

Thank you for this very useful review! You basically answered all my questions! 👍

[@ozz81]

I'm currently driving my second Model S (got my first one in 2013). I definitely want a higher seating position. I would have bought a Model X, but opted for the S again because the X is too big (I live in Switzerland, very narrow streets and parking spots here). I'm more and more convinced that my next car will be a Model Y. Thank you for your video!

[@kristelarabit3511]

I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@maludasilvagabriel]

Hallo :) wie viel zahlst du effektiv um es zu laden?

[@AC-vo2ft]

Great video Marc, well balanced and factual. I own a Model X and couldn’t be happier. I have not had any issues with the rubbing by the Falcon doors so far, had the car for 16 months now. The only issue is that tyre wear is about half of what other SUV’s will give. This is because they use 220 PLY tyres I’m told, also I hear the car applies a negative camber especially if using the Low suspension setting. However the tyre cost is offset by the fact that due to the regenerative braking, there should never be a need to replace the brake pads during the life of the car. I love the Tesla brand, on the list for the Cyber truck! Keep the videos coming Marc, awesome job!

[@tizio5103]

Our 2017 X is awesome. The doors don't rub. However the critique of door operation annoyances is spot on. The one thing keeping us in our X is the 6-seat configuration and the Y's lack of air suspension. If the Y got both of those, we'd order one right away.

[@Zeldaturtles]

Thanks for taking the time to do this

[@Trinity636]

Great and informative review! Going to order the Y via lease while waiting on Cybertruck order. Thx!

[@magicsmurfy]

Very honest, in your case, u should buy the Y. But in my case, I will keep my X coz mine is 2019 with the right software already. So what it boils down is the software and the latest battery tech.

[@recreation330]

This was so helpful! Thank you for sharing this with us!

[@olivierpothier2538]

Thank you so much for your good explainations, Mr.Benton. It confirms what I really thought about Model Y.

[@tmnd878]

Door automation has me hooked. I agree with you about the issues with the FWDs. Even ours, a Oct 2019 build, has some rub concerns, especially on windy days. We have PPF put into the troubled spots and they are holding up well. Ours has actual indention areas where the door should rest, which does help, that your specific model year X does not have. Getting in and out, you do get used to when you should or should not open the Driver and Passenger door. However, that's not really something that I've had to ever compromise with for our Model 3 or S. You also have to plan on time, when to open and close a FWD. It just seems like an odd thing do, timing a door open action. Another issue is pulling into the Garage with the 3 or S, next to the X. If you have a key fob for the X on your person, and you start to open the door, the X drivers door thinks you want to get in. We've had our X door hit our Model 3 door, because my Wife had her X fob with her, while I was getting out. My heart stopped because the collision was between the two pieces of door glass. No damage, but now, it's some thing we have to be aware of. But having to move two weeks ago, our 5 seater X was really able to just about move everything we had, that wasn't going to be handled by the Movers, to include book cases and shelving units. We have a 5 seater option X, and can lay our middle row down completely, to create a completely flat interior storage area. Being able to operate the doors with the fob, open or close when your hands are full, is awesome. We had lots of rainy days, so leaving doors open, while moving things back and forth wasn't always an option. That's where the door automation of the X really shined. At least the Y has an automated lift gate. That's what we really liked about our Model S, when we first bought it. We've yet to take the X on it's first maiden voyage for a Road Trip. Now that we've moved, selling our old home, building a new home and are currently following guidelines for Shelter in Place, our Road Trip we wanted to do, was shelved. I'd imagine the Y would still be a good road trip vehicle, too.

[@jacobwilliams658]

John Garcia Nice comment, I’m just a kid interested in Tesla’s, who wouldn’t dream of having any other car

[@fred0c]

Appreciate the vid, answered a lot of my questions i had between the two.

[@dank213]

Thanks for the video. Helped us out in choosing.

[@givaldolins1449]

Very helpful! Thanks for making this video!

[@warmonger2500]

I appreciate you taking your time to share this information.

[@mikaela4392]

This is so helpful with our decision! Thank u

[@landoncarter547]

Thank You! Appreciate all the information.. Very helpful.

[@treyroth1925]

Great video! Very well explained. Very helpful. Thank you!

[@ankurmehtajd]

I thank you so sincerely, I have been on the fence and even renting cars because of indecision which you resolved for me!

[@marc_benton]

Glad I could help!

[@stephan24297]

thanks for the video. very informative I heard a lot of complaints about the model x especially the falcon-wing doors and being in cold climates.

[@ericleszkowicz898]

This is a really good comparison. Not the same boring stats but new information.

[@ronstandley5635]

This side-by-side comparison is very helpful. Actual measurements is valuable, while styling is a matter of personal taste. One detail that's important to us (because we travel with older dogs who need to jump into the car) s the height of the hatch sill above the ground. Thanks for adding this dimension. I applaud your great camera work, sir. Very nicely done.

[@kristelarabit3511]

I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@Adman-wh6oj]

Awesome video Mark. Got my PYD and love it!! I had the same dilemma. Used X at $70K or new PYD. Easy decision for me coming from a 3. Excellent ROI video for most!!

[@mortenguttormsen8806]

I’ve just ordered the Model Y and waiting for the release date here in Norway. I currently have the Model 3 but wanted a bigger car. I’ve also considered buying a used Model X instead which sometimes has made me second guess my choice of buying the Y but this video really put things in perspective and was very helpful. Thanks!

[@kristelarabit3511]

I wanted to reach out and inform you that we currently have some fantastic deals in Tesla Accessories on our eBay listing.

[@peony2263]

Thanks for the comparison. I'm with you. I can't justify the price difference. The Y is a solid option.

[@29Dhorton]

Nice job on the video. Thanks for taking the time to do this.

[@alexanderjohnson8945]

Thank you so much. This was very helpful.

[@arianaruthbaltay684]

Thanks, Marc. This is so helpful. I went to see the Teslas today and was told that the Model X was a few months wait plus they didn't have one I could drive. I did drive a model Y and am considering it over the X after watching your video.

[@areyouonboardpodcast8363]

Thanks for this review... you’re totally honest🙌🏾

[@wesleyirish5624]

Thank you so much. Ironically I test drove the model Y today and love it. I think the model X is more of a younger generation style, with the falcon doors And I don’t think it’s worth the difference in price.. The comparison you Give make it much easier for me now to choose the model Y thank you thank you

[@reighngold]

This has been an insanely helpful video. I can't even tell you how much I've been going back and forth between an X and a Y. The X new is just too damned much to feel good about, so was gonna do an X used, this comparison is EXACTLY what I needed.

[@marc_benton]

Glad I could help Emma. Good luck with your decision! :)

[@MrCarpediem6]

which way did you go (X/Y) ? :)

[@MelanieLe]

Great video! You helped answer a lot of questions I had between the two models. I’m a fan!!! Big thumbs up!! 👍🏼 👍🏼

[@creedence111]

Great video man ...appreciate your honesty and insights

[@xo_kylem6735]

It's very interesting because it really shows how Tesla has thought about these 2 cars and how they can make it so that the Y won't necessarily eat into the sales of the X. Just with the little things you mentioned like the sunroof. It would be personal taste at that point.. which do you love more? The falcon wing doors or the sunroof? Both are really good selling points of the cars. The Y is really just a bigger version of the 3 much like the X is a bigger version of the S. A more apt comparison for the Model Y is the model 3 because it's that Model's potential customers that the Y is going to be hi-jacking. lol

[@joeyinau]

Thank you sharing. In China the Model 3 has just realized localization. Model Y may takes at least 2 years.

[@anetteeuropa5597]

awesome advice and such a heartfelt honest comparison!!!

[@yx427]

Extremely helpful video. Thank you!

[@samlee6152]

I've heard from several people who own both the X and Y, and they seem to always bring up a lot of issues with the X. The X might be a more "premium" car, but the Y seems to give you a much more pleasant ownership experience.

[@ryanalanmelchione9790]

Just the video I needed it was perfect really solidifies my purchase of the model Y

[@Hellonaptime]

This was very helpful! Thank you!

[@michaelnicola5210]

Thank You. Am going through this process right now. Definitely going Y.

[@dcloser9779]

I have model 3 that I like so much and thinking to swap it for the Y because of the space specially with the kids ect. thanks for the review mich appreciated👍

[@danburkland]

Great video, been looking forward to this comparison since the Y was announced.

[@alguillory7148]

I had a chance today to look at the Model Y at one of the hospitals here in Longview, TX today and it is amazing! It was white with white interior, not my favorite choice, but gorgeous, in any case. For the price, I would definitely go with this model over the expensive Model X, but that’s just me. Have a nice day!

[@andypatterson9848]

Thank you! I have been on the fence about a used X and a new Y. You helped me solidify my decision.

[@marc_benton]

Awesome! Make sure you use a referral code to get your 1000 miles of free supercharging. If you need a code, mine is ts.la/marc57969