Zack Snyder and The Rebel Moon Problem

[@TexYT]

Fox and I talking about Rebel Moon Part 1 and 2. kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaqZk61tZZZjkKssi=9Gl1fp9Cw2yv1cVs what happened to my boy.

[@SnyderQueen]

Your boy had to make some studio cuts so he can do his insane R rated cuts. Let's wait til they're out before we judge Rebel Moon entirelly maybe?

[@AwesomeShrekku]

@@SnyderQueenthe rating shouldn’t effect the quality. Edit: also this is a streaming exclusive so why does he need a Snyder cut for a streaming exclusive?

[@lloyd777]

​​@@AwesomeShrekku ppl like Snyder Queen are why Snyder is full of himself his fan club refuses to criticize his bad decisions

[@tahnadana5435]

if you can believe that netflix would run with going crazy on zack snyder BS, than why do you object when amazon and games workshop are doing the same thing with henry cavill's BS? hance the female custodes, people with no real talent or power should be careful with what ever they are doing, please stop saying these people seems to be "down to earth" "chill" dudes.. its cringe and embarrassing. from what they are doing, its suffice to say that there have great ambitions to be the "king" of something there, (directing watchman, 300, DC universe and being cast superman, geralt, warhammer 40k isnt enough?) when in reality they biting more than they can chew every single time, and what they represent on interviews aren't the real them

[@shaneweasl]

So how often do you not like the cut versions of his movies but like his director’s or extended cuts? I feel like your answer to that might answer your own question

[@dominiclizcano2947]

Dude can’t write to save his life but he knows to direct memorable scenes and moments. He just needs to stick to directing and have writers

[@firstlast9846]

Icl I don’t remember anything recent from him that was memorable.. JL was made in 2016/17 and since then it’s been consistent misses

[@NiRvAnA6890]

Did you not read the film credits?? There were 2 screenwriters.

[@Keizi]

@@NiRvAnA6890 hes the main credited writer. Meaning he did most of the work by far on the pages.

[@chencho3041]

What moments?

[@luciusnguyen2449]

Let's be real, he shouldn't be directing at all. He should only works on editing and camera, being the director means he still has power over the script. Even when he worked with the most talented screenwriters like Nolan, Chris Terrio, David S. Goyer his movies are still terrible

[@josephstalin9139]

The more freedom Zack Snyder has the worse his movies are all in all, pretty much sums up your point in one sentence.

[@SLJ957]

There's a good case for this from the snyder cut itself. Zack wanted lois lane and bruce to have a relationship after clark died, which would've angered fans if it was put in the finished product but the writers shut him down and told him it was a bad idea. If he had people like that with him on rebel moon then it could've been a good alternative to star wars

[@XxVendetaxX1]

Agreed.

[@luciusnguyen2449]

Not to mention the reason he wanted it to happen is not because it serves anything to the plot but because that he liked the Lancelot and Guinevere affair element in Excalibur (1981). He himself never understood why these elements in the original story work, he just cramped all of them together without actually think if those elements fit a bigger narrative

[@billross9132]

Ye idk wat Snyder was thinking with that idea. It completely contradicts Bruce's arc

[@miladrahim5437]

Doubt

[@GamerDude197]

Not to mention his idea all super powered beings coming from the same kryptonian ancestors that came to earth including Zeus, Wonder Woman etc. Which is kind of a cool twist but you just cant do that

[@Man-of-Steel674]

Dude adapted the unadaptable watchmen. How it went down from there it's really sad and frustrating.

[@Gamingawesomeness121]

Yeah it sucks

[@isacctavares1368]

His fans over inflated his ego. He thinks he's this beloved director. It goes to people heads. It happens to the best of us. He needs no men instead of yes men.

[@firstlast9846]

The general consensus of people who read the comic say he missed the point.. so idk

[@Gamingawesomeness121]

@@isacctavares1368 yup kinda like m. night shamalan made 2 great films and was labeled the next spelberge by everyone and was left to do whatever he wanted and not one of his movies since unbreakable have reached the same level and many were just awful. It is clear it’s the same with Snyder.

[@AweSean-wv3xo]

Watchmen movie is alright but it has little to do with the actual comic

[@Elricsedric]

Honestly I don't think he can see the flaws. In interviews he convinced himself people just hate him

[@TenmasSchoolOfThought]

He literally said "I don't look at online feedback" lmao snyder fans are pure delusional to think that Snyder cares about their opinion.

[@SixActStructure]

His fans also think people only dislike the movie because he made it.

[@sladejoseph6757]

I yeah your right is not like the haters keep mentioning his daughter suicide 24/7 and hating on him 24/7 or want him dead 24/7 which is why he can't read comments,

[@TenmasSchoolOfThought]

@@sladejoseph6757 Do you have actual brain damage or what? If you can't read feedback because a few crazy people(which exists in every industry) sends him death threats, that's L on him. When I had an amulet shop there were a bunch of people who actually tried to take my life before, and I still kept the shop open. Be it gangsters or corrupt cops, I'll take them on. You mean Zack Snyder, a public figure, can't deal with death threats? From crazy internet people?

[@blumoon131]

​@@sladejoseph6757lol the overwhelming majority of people critiquing his films are not doing this, what the fuck are you talking about?

[@kilochampion787]

I feel like if you get Zack Snyder & Michael Bay to collab on a project, they would create one of the most unique and entertaining movies of all time. Not good, not bad… entertaining

[@josem7369]

Chris Terrio and David Goyer did wonders for Snyder’s ideas and concepts. He is severely lacking experienced and hardened writers like these

[@zillauniverse7208]

As well as Chris Nolan during Man of Steel

[@scottyskywalker5768]

I think it was the right combination of people alone. Their solo projects aren't the best ( although terio did write argo ) but together those movies did make DC feel coherent and grand .

[@theroguerider]

I’m sorry, but this is just the evolution of the DCEU. Sizzle with no steak. Zack Snyder in a nutshell. I am glad DC fans got those movies if they liked them, but they deserve better than what they got.

[@Bobby90]

Snyder shouldn't be in charge of "his" projects. Period. He's another George Lucas: decent enough idea man, but *NEEDS* people around him to temper and refine them.

[@TheRumblewagon]

The problem is HOW in the hell does he get the funding to make this garbage? I want a $100 million to make a pile of crap. I know I can do it.

[@TenmasSchoolOfThought]

Is your name Zack Snyder and do you have Man of Steel on your resume?

[@rensaudade]

​@@TenmasSchoolOfThought man of steel was a B-Tier movie. Not much to brag about.

[@TenmasSchoolOfThought]

@@rensaudade Tiers are your opinions. A movie's life time grossing is stats. Can you guess which one Netflix cared about?

[@markw110]

Maybe his career is a money laundering scheme?!

[@harukrentz435]

​@@TenmasSchoolOfThoughtMoS isnt movie to be proud of.

[@Moviemakers05]

My aunt saw army of the dead and said it was 2 hours she would never get back

[@littledudefromacrossthestr5755]

Fr?

[@truthyahweh9877]

Better than most zombie movies.

[@Moviemakers05]

@@truthyahweh9877 not as good as the classics or even Snyder's dawn of the dead cause the film. Sets up a cool idea and play it's too straight where is the fun the opening is amazing but the rest takes itself way to seriously for a fun Concept

[@truthyahweh9877]

@Moviemakers05 well I liked the concept of zombies developing a king and queen where the zombies get smarter and different types of zombies. Not as in depth as znation series but still better than most zombie movies. Also the concept that they have done this multiple times already or in a time loop much more original than most zombies movies where they get walked into getting bit. Dawn of the dead was good but it was basically hide in a mall then try to get to another building and escape. Wow so much better than army of the dead. Quarantine a city instead of all out breakout was also a new cool idea.

[@Moviemakers05]

@@truthyahweh9877 sometimes smaller is better the film never had the terror or the brilliant action it was just aliens without the creative see though no quips or cool characters just boring stail characters it's holding itself back from the great film it could be the film isn't new it's just copying ideas from other things but there is one thing you cannot defend and its the out of focus stuff it's awful is not taking things too seriously too hard for Snyder even Gunn is having more fun

[@Moviemakers05]

This is something that happens to directors given too much control lots of directors don’t fall into like Scorsese or Wes Anderson cause they know the truest fundamentals of film and hell even Gunn doesn’t have full control or he does but he thinks it over fully

[@anonymes2884]

These movies are not "mid at best". These movies are bad. At times they almost seem like parodies of screenwriting because they do pretty much everything you're not supposed to do (large and very obvious exposition dumps, zero organic character development, excruciating pacing etc.). Zack Snyder can create amazing visuals and has some good ideas. But he can't write for shit and his understanding of character apparently froze at age 14. I used to think he was like a George Lucas - good at the broad sweep of storytelling but bad at the mechanics of telling stories i.e. the actual writing of scenes, dialogue etc. - but these movies have me seriously doubting that too. He can't even make something worth watching out of "Seven Samurai", a story that's been told so many times it's basically a trope at this point.

[@JoeChillton]

Same thing as happens to most, less restrictions and they lose their minds. Look at Ridley Scott with Alien stuff or Shaymalan with Last Airbender when it was his idea.

[@lloyd777]

He needs to drop his narcissism and the YES MEN he surrounds himself by🙄

[@godzillazfriction]

ironic... now go baselessly bash me for being an apparent 'sNyDeR fAn'...

[@marvinj1000]

Sounds like George Lucas when he directed the prequels

[@filmgoblin5016]

And I like that. Lucas never liked the studio system in Hollywood and wanted to move away from it for a very long time in his career cus he saw how corrupt they were and didn’t care for artistic integrity.

[@burgergud2804]

This

[@scottyskywalker5768]

The prequels were at least kinda interesting.

[@jasonirizarry9619]

Funny I was thinking the same thing as I watch this sound argument. I have never bothered to rewatch the prequels, don't care for them, just like I don't care for much of Snyder's film output after Watchmen, his writing talent is non existent just checkout Suckerpunch, chock full if action and design, yet bland story, same with many of his later efforts, some cool moments yet it fails to deliver as a whole. I just don't want to waste the time when their a better crafted stories elsewhere.

[@TheBlond49]

At least Prequels had a story to go for, Snyder can't tell any story.

[@Keizi]

didn't expect to wake up and see tex talk like this. You hit the nail on the head though King. Snyder is really talented but netflix has just given him far too much. He's almost become his worst enemy now. He cant go one interview without talking about a directors cut and is taking reigns over scripts after proving himself not to be a talented screenwriter. He has talents but he needs to play to those strengths because they can also be his own weaknesses. Just hope they all learn form this and he can move forward making some bangers again.

[@thatoneguyfaded]

What I learned being a Snyder fan: his best movies are a result of studio interference leading to a Director's Cut. Without Studio interference, you just get loose cannon Snyder with no restraints. As we all know, too much of anything is a bad thing. Someone needs to reel Zack in and say no sometimes, just for the sake of motivation more than anything.

[@Orikon25]

Ironically, I think he would do really, really well in the video game industry. Being able to come up with all the crazy details and worldbuilding is useless if it's not seen in the film. Army of the Dead had the same problem, where in interviews Zack explained how the zombies have this hierarchy, and the king is called Zeus and the queen is called that, and this detail and that... NONE of that was in the film. Same issue in Rebel Moon. Films are a limited medium, but working in a video game would allow him to insert all of that across the entire game. Games with deep details and worldbuilding are always incredible, and his style would shine in that medium.

[@NiRvAnA6890]

I don't think you paid attention to army of the dead. All of that was there. Even the CIA dude called the zombie king Zeus and his girl Lilith.

[@ruslanvictorenko1536]

I doubt it. Even for a video game, this is terrible and unoriginal story writing, and would be considered embarrassingly cookie cutter. Style over substance doesn't work unless the gameplay can carry it, and then you don't need Zach Snyder anyways.

[@infer9]

​@@NiRvAnA6890 Time stamp of the movie?, I saw the movie but can't remember any scene.

[@RyanKarolak]

The first movie should have been a single movie with a very narrowly focused story. It's unfortunate because as you said Snyder, the crew, and cast of the show seem to have had a good time filming the movies and getting into their characters and lore. It's a shame that didn't end up translating on screen.

[@Katarn84]

Netflix was kind of like "frak it, here's a bunch of money, go crazy with your next project". Snyder heard go lazy, and just copy pasted pieces from other better movies.

[@Kami.Asura000]

You saying this!? Man this must be pretty bad.

[@ruslanvictorenko1536]

What ideas? He is blatantly stealing from much better sources and don't know what to do with it and ends with a hollow shell of whatever those sources tried to tell and show.

[@devernepersonal3636]

After seeing both rebel moon movies, I can’t imagine how anyone is a fan of Zach synders “work”

[@THEFANBOY]

Have you watched the animated owl movie, 300 or zsjl?

[@jamesslemmons8453]

Zach Snyder is like Worscheshire Sauce. You add him to something good, he might make it a little better...but nobody wants to drink it by the glass.

[@BlackEagle352]

All he need is some meat

[@shahinshamshiriamirkolairiosec]

Or rather: Uncle Zack has a good eye for finding a great cast and making epic shots. However, he has zero talent for writing scripts and it is something that perhaps no one told him... being a writer is very difficult and creating something that manages to connect with the public is really difficult, for that reason one must know what their strengths and weaknesses, something that perhaps no one told you and is understood. I hope he learns from his mistake and can team up with someone to write the scripts for him while he takes care of the rest and maybe then he can go back to what he was before.

[@santinodewreede3955]

You can be a fan of Snyder & still think he’s made a bad movie. Most directors need someone to tell them “no.” Zack is great with visuals & action. I agree with you in this video

[@yehyafakhro266]

He needs to bring Chris Terrio, asap.

[@TheBlond49]

Why? BvS was hot garbage like TROS

[@metalheadzaki]

Hope the robot has more fight scene in the directors cut because even people who hated the movie liked his scene

[@TheBlond49]

He got the wrong lesson from JLSnyder Cut. Nolan made a big mistake back then

[@JohnDoe-gt3jr]

Zack needs someone to reel him in when he goes full Snyder

[@lanalan4157]

Snyder gets worse and worse....Dawn of the dead was his peak..Movie was written James Gunn..lol

[@brandonkukumayeyi6048]

Yeah facts😂😂

[@SA1NT53]

This should serve as a reminder to companies like Netflix, and Filmmakers like Snyder that the cinematic experience comes first, and to keep ambitions in check

[@lordofthesithvader9430]

Yeah, I honestly didn't even care to watch part 2 considering how uninteresting part 1 was. Even if the directors cuts aren't that great, i'd still rather watch a version of the films that are supposed to be its truest form. I hope Zack does re-evaluate how his next films are going to go, as well as having a more interactive writing team and producers. He does need to be controlled with his ideas, but not completely muted with them. Also, enough with the director cuts.

[@TheGamingManiac]

Its annoying because the people who hate Snyder ae going to use these films as ammunition against his prior films in an "i told you so" kinda way. Sorry but nothing this man does in the future will make me look differently on the films of the past

[@dj_mcfuggernugs507]

IMO, Zack needs a group of ppl similar to the group George Lucas had when he was making the OG trilogy A group of ppl who will reign him in when he goes too far

[@nikolatasev4948]

300 and Watchmen were adaptations of graphic novels. Snyder had a developed story and characters to build upon. Here the training wheels were off, and he had no idea how to present a coherent story or do exposition.

[@montenegroafro4454]

Yea..Snyder just needs better collaboration with screenwriters and producers and the willingness to take ‘No’ for an answer in some decisions. Also I don’t know where you get these weird sus ideas to post at the end of your videos. The aggressively naked and gay Mr. Krabs try to rizz up Plankton killed me! 😂😂🤣

[@husker4life109]

I saw the writing on the walls when sucker punch came out

[@thabreez456]

anyone else wants Zack to continue with The Army of the Dead Franchise instead of rebel moon? I was definitely more excited for Rebel Moon but I have to say I think both of the army of the dead movies were really enjoyable. They both are also some of the few recent Snyder movies that the general audience and critics seemed to enjoy. Theres also so much interesting lore hidden in that first movie. I've been waiting so long for a sequel

[@blumoon131]

Snyder has always been a style over substance director. He has never shown an ability to coherently meld ideas together, nor does he have even a grasp of how to do proper characterization, and that's all really apparent the more control he has on a project. I don't have faith in him to learn from Rebel Moon's failures because he's only doubled-down on all the worst qualities of his films as time has gone on.

[@yammt3148]

The problem is he's arrogant, or this narcissist-streak is his way of coping with his tragic loss... Either way, he just needs a good writer, and a friend to pat him on the shoulder and redirect his bad creative tendencies. Snyder has a vision, he's just too limited to do it all himself... But he thinks he can. The last okay movie he made was 300... That was a long time ago.

[@megadeuce2350]

Thoughts on Part one cracking top 10 again. Let's talk about Netflix strategy. I think that's a more interesting conversation. I'm not a fan of the strategy.

[@MrRmmk1]

Not a fan of it either. They're trying to double dip and it's hurting credibility. I thought rebel moon part 1 was good up until the rest of the 2/3rds was rushed. Just release the whole thing

[@olijakupjohannessen6919]

i think i like army of the dead more then Rebel Moon Great video man and get more from you💪💪 ( sorry the spelling )

[@zillauniverse7208]

It’s pretty obvious that his best to decent movies are the ones we’re he didn’t write the script (minus BVS)

[@Dookieman1975]

I really think rebel moon would’ve worked better as a tv show. Just better pacing. And even that doesn’t completely fix other issues

[@vi8799]

Essentially, Rebel Moon is a set of good visual frames, connected to each other without any meaning.

[@dwainmorris7854]

He gave his lead beautiful actress. A haircut from dumb and dumber plus The movie has A. wash out color palette. And you wonder why the movie failed.

[@TonyMidyett]

I don't understand how some people even have movie careers.

[@Kal_El1994]

I’m a huge Snyder fan. But the Rebel Moon films have really NOT BEEN IT. Such a shame. Really needed a separate cinematographer & writers to do the writing & screenplay.

[@jigokuruler36]

snyder don't know how to make characters that feel real, he doesn't know to make something look good, he can barely direct, the thing that he does well most of the time is hiring people that can make good decisions, like his casting director in the dceu, but he needs people that write well, a good cinematographer and pretty much anyone who's capable, because it has been clear for over a decade that he's mediocre at most at creating stuff, or adapting stuff, after his dc movies show us someone who doesn't understand what he reads

[@theroguerider]

People generally want movie’s to be shorter. Snyder fans want 4 hour movies that still suck.

[@darknemessis6880]

And you just want to hate on movies for the sake of hating like a low life clown

[@spacewinter]

He actually is working on a another project that's supposed to come out on Netflix this year called Twilight of the Gods. Surprise, its a revenge movie with a rag tag gang of heroes

[@Grod2013]

Haven’t seen either one yet, waiting for the rated R extended version of them

[@jasoncarter1869]

He says he doesn't listen to the internet. Soooo he's going to chug along. Why would he change anything at this point?

[@jasoncarter1869]

@JacobJean-ev2dr But unfortunately, deciding to ignore people on the internet...means that you're potentially ignore valid criticisms. I'm sure he does listen to family and friends... his inner circle.... and the fans that go to his private screenings. And how did that work out for Rebel Moon part 2? Nearly every review is saying the same thing. "This is style over substance" and if he was willing to check out a few reviews, even from KZbin, he could've made a much more enjoyable product. The average movie fan doesn't want to sit through 5hrs worth of Rebel Moon part 1 and then an additional 5hrs of Rebel Moon part 2........ just to get the equivalent of one good movie. That's what the internet is saying and he would know that if he listened. Is priorities seem to be cool visuals, epic shots, gore, shock factor, and sex. The fundamentals of story telling seem to take the back seat. And it's not like only a few people have this opinion. And no one is saying that he has to spend the next 3 months on Twitter sifting through toxic threads from people who just want to ruin him. My point being, he's already explained his process enough times and we see the results. So he's most likely just going to keep doing what he's doing until no one is willing to fund his nonsense. And at that point, he'll start up that kickstarter and I'm convinced that the Snyder-cut fans will produce movies for him. Either way, I don't see him changing any time soon.

[@igechasamuel3573]

He's basically going through the George Lucas conundrum. He was great at world building & but he needed directors to bring his vision to life & yet somehow he forgot all about what made the originals great & did the starwars prequels all by himself.

[@SteveKilgore27]

Snyder literally just needs writers to help distill his ideas down into good stories.

[@Elricsedric]

I still haven't watched rebel moon. Im waiting for the directors cut, I'm not saying it's going to make it good. I can believe people but I like Snyder alot so if there's any chance its better in those cuts. I'll make that my first experience.

[@bumblebee6090]

The issues have been occurring since Man of Steel and have gotten worse

[@scottyskywalker5768]

Outside of Tarentino pretty mich any good director who gets into the whole im an auteur thing and its my movie they immediatly start kinda falling off its happened with Francis Ford Coppola Robert Zemekis and to an extent Steven Spielberg. I feel like even to an extent Michal Bay is at least more self aware that hes not a perfect director but that in a recent interview Zack thinks all his movies are perfect minus sucker punch is a stretch Dont get me wrong a lot are good but many do have flaws noticbale flaws that mant people have pointed out being a good director or anything is always trying to learn from your mistakes .

[@Darkseidsolosfiction]

He really needs chris terrio

[@sanketkumar4250]

Rebel moon directors cut release date?

[@GiovanniAlckmimRusso]

Great idea guy? This is the same guy that wanted Bruce and Lois to hook up after Clark's death and the and the same guy that thinks having Clark killing everyone was necessary for him become the Superman.

[@darknemessis6880]

And? That would have been great. I would have loved to see that. Cry more

[@GiovanniAlckmimRusso]

@@darknemessis6880 if you like bad storytelling, good for you

[@lanalan4157]

​@@darknemessis6880no...hell nah

[@darknemessis6880]

@@lanalan4157 yeah..hell yeah

[@brandonkukumayeyi6048]

​@darknemessis6880 are you good bro ???😂😂😂😂

[@filmgoblin5016]

I like that Snyder getting his creative freedom like George Lucas did with the prequels. We need movies like that to help inspire film fans wanting to make films for themselves cus they all feel like high budget Indi films no matter how flawed they are.

[@joshimura1995]

Lucas had that creative freedom right from the start, especially after the first one , when he financed all the movies starting with Empire Strikes Back with his own money.

[@UniqueM16]

Technically that's what Netflix wanted not Zack. So DC scenarios all over again.

[@Hae3ro]

Just stop

[@NiRvAnA6890]

​@@Hae3rotruth hurts, donnit?

[@zillauniverse7208]

Cope

[@moderatecanuck]

Army of the Dead is when I noticed how much he had fallen

[@timmeadows970]

Such an ugly movie. Watchmen and 300 are wonderful to look at.

[@whyequalswhat]

BVS being one of the shittiest piece of crap ever shat out was mine

[@TheRonnieaj]

Here’s my thing. If Zack Snyder is making a PG-13 movie, MAKE A PG-13 MOVIE! Don’t make an R that you have to skim down, and then use that as an excuse for why it sucks. That’s fundamentally different than executive interference, which isn’t an issue here. It’s that Zack can only conceive of certain types of films, and frankly, I feel that shows a lack of imagination.

[@donna25871]

The last decent film Zach Snyder made was….i can’t think back that far. Maybe Dawn of the Dead.

[@degarmoj1]

I highly doubt ZS will really reassess or analyze things. He tends to (like his time with the DC) double down and just focus on any praise received, gas lights “we learned a lot” and excitedly demonstrates this self importance and astonishing vision he thinks he brings cinema/media. I can appreciate directors, producers, and even writers who want to be heavily involved with every aspect of a film, but ZS excitement and commitment does not excuse a bad, frequent, products that are not enriching nor popular.

[@boshwa20]

He's basically releasing patches for his movies

[@Mixen9408]

Watched the director cut o Part 1 last month with some friends, who have seen the original cut. They all agreed it was better when it came to the characters, especial on the android and what the city on the "Rebel Moon" was doing while the main characters were rebeling around. It did not transform into a great movie, but a okay one. Btw i love the whole god machine thing that is going on on the Dreadnaughts. It scream 40K as fuck. xD

[@betterlatethannever2156]

That ending was crazy

[@jimrustler]

He wanted to save some bucks not paying David S. Goyer

[@muaddibnelson]

I used to be a diehard Snyder fan but AOTD, and Rebel Moon Part One was severely disappointing and underwhelming and pretty boring. Snyder typically have decent to great ideas but he need seasonal and experienced writers. I haven’t been able to connect with any of these characters to care about them at all.

[@Kageofyoutube]

This all comes from u must learn and adapt. I personally enjoyed both rebel moons(although I want the rated R versions much more and feel they will be better) I do understand there r issues with both, and I aswell hope zack can learn from these mistakes as Tex said he’s not an egotistical fool. I feel sir Snyder can definitely reevaluate himself and make a comeback without question.

[@kicknowledgesmith8608]

I like Snyder as a director, not so much as a writer. I think Snyder and Gunn should team up for a movie in the DCU, like they did for Dawn of the Dead!

[@georgekostaras]

I'm a Snyder mega fan, but rebel moon is all of his worst traits with none of his strengths.

[@edrickt5907]

I've been trying to say this since he released Army of the Dead, that movie is mid at best because it didn't focus on anything. The fact that the prequel movie that is NOT directed by him, FOR HIS SIDE CHARACTER is 2x BETTER than his actual movie is very very concerning. Now he wants to do Rebel Moon, adding an additional director's cut? Come on man

[@toyninja5959]

Great movie what's the problem 🤔🤷💯

[@accountnme]

He strikes me as the kind of guy who idealizes Rorschach

[@Devilsblood]

He has the same problem that Robert Rodriguez has; good directing style, but awful in the writing departments. I'll be honest, I've never been a zack snyder fan and I really don't understand his fanbase. Sure he could make pretty pictures, but so can Nolan, Ridley Scott and David Fincher. Like I was thinking if Snyder was given the opportunity to direct a live action version of Attack on titan and he 100% followed the original material, he would win some of those fans back.

[@getthecats]

Tell don't show 😉

[@TurboMMaster]

Just make Zack Snyder direct Diablo movie.

[@EliteHitmarkers]

In any story you need good and well built characters. Characters were probably the weakest point for me in the movie.

[@Mohamad-m7md]

That outro 💀

[@TheTruMan196]

Bro what was going on with the last 20 seconds of the video 😭

[@isacctavares1368]

Snyder reminds me of George Lucas during the prequel era. As much as we love those movies now, the writing was never that good. Even George admitted that. George had to many yes men during that era, they didnt challenge him like they did in the OT. Snyder has too many yes men. Netflix isn't challenging him. He has too much power. Fans like Tex are the fans he should listen to. It's okay to critique something. You criticize something because you love it. They have to reign him in, or the 3rd one will be his worst film ever.

[@NiRvAnA6890]

May idk what you smoking but George Lucas got alot of things denied in the prequels. Hell, we even got robbed of a badass Mace Windu/ Palpatine fight cuz of studio interference.

[@abhaysharma4470]

These recent movies are bad, he need some good writers

[@rodneywyatt9441]

Ripoff Moon-The scabies giver is another trash bin vehicle from Zackie boy. The man uses crayons to write his scripts they are SOO bad😂. Now you know why Netflix didn't promote this clunker after the awful reactions to the first film😂 To quote Admiral Akbar, "Its a TRAP"😂😂😂😂😂

[@Gamingawesomeness121]

What you mean the thing that he agreed to again that he kept complaining about before???? Yeah it sucks

[@prakharkirtijajoria5314]

I wish Snyder understands the failings of these films and tries to improve. I love his passion and his visual panache, but he's way too big in his own head to make a good film rn.

[@jonahfalcon1970]

What are you talking about "ideas"? Snyder has NO ORIGINAL THOUGHTS. Army of the Dead is a one-to-one ripoff of Aliens.

[@crapshot]

Man these 2 rebel moon movies were so bad, I've completely lost all faith in him. It's fucking disheartening!

[@charleslarrivee2908]

Why am I getting strong "George Lucas during the prequels" vibes from your thesis?

[@jasontodd6779]

Zack Snyder is a good director but not nearly as good as a writer. He need a good writer to tell him no. Never believe that until i watch Army of the dead, and Rebel Moon part 1-2.

[@hewhoisthere]

Rebel Moon 1 was mediocre at best but with some potential. 2 was a train wreck. I was angry the first time I watched 2 because I like Snyder a lot, but the movie was clearly bad. I'm hoping he can bounce back but it's hard to say. Someone he respects has to tell him the bad news, I dont know if anyone will

[@gos_707]

Love your videos stay Chat Edit: I will also agree I’m just frustration and confusing/disappointment

[@HarishBabuM]

Imma skip this one and wait for that R rated one

[@The_Langley_Ghetto_Filter]

Never go full Synder...

[@MediaCreators]

It's quite simple.. look at the NFVC and compare it to your views and subs and you understand who is the sucker.

[@excellentestevan4488]

How dare you put a freidberg and seltzer in your video?!