Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Dredd In 17 Minutes or Less

[@DrDeath25]

“Son..those are mill-a seconds” You can hear the disappointment in the voice

[@hernehaugen6878]

Mate, I can practically TASTE the disappoint in the sound. Make of that what you will.

[@cleverpsyche115]

"Why don't these timers make any sense?!?!?" "Milliseconds, son."

[@alhira5098]

Ngl, should have been 10 sins.

[@Gockodile]

Yo Birdman I appreciate you actually taking the time to explain your reason for giving sins. Good stuff man.

[@InfiniteFury2K]

Yeah, the explanations are awesome. Gives an extra spice to the sin which he didn't have to add

[@heitorcr2310]

Sin exposition! **DING!**

[@Murdock_the_Pooch]

So many of Jeremy’s sins could be explained simply by reminding him that this is Judge Dredd, a man so “by the book” and instinctively certain about his judgement that he makes meter maids look laxed by comparison.

[@selonianth]

I wouldn't exactly say he's so by the book, he does give the homeless guy a chance to get a move on, and does pass Anderson despite the multiple reasons to fail her that he points out.

[@MidnightDStroyer]

@@selonianth Considering that the Law just *might* give a judge discretion on such a minor misdemeanor once or twice before making a judgement...Yeah, that's a common theme in real-life systems of law around the world. You know, the same as "giving a warning to cease & desist" before facing actual charges.

[@cy-one]

Also keep in mind, the Judges can only respond to a miniscule percentage of crimes. I doubt it's worth a Judges time to actually process a homeless guy.

[@richdunn3571]

@@selonianth he only does that because he thinks murder is more important so realistically he was putting the homeless to back because it was the in minor offence it does make sense

[@latorasmith]

So by watching the movie and paying attention? As our lord and savoir shrek once said "yeah like that's ever gonna happen"

[@genuinejustin6269]

I'm giving Th3Birdman two sins for not saying *"Makes her moist"* and *"Dredd is not Cinemasins"*

[@GreenCrib]

Another excellent intro to a video. IMO. This is one of the most underrated film of this decade. Low budget. It looks, and feels like a mid to late 1980s/1990s action films. I love it! Still hoping it gets a sequel. Awesome content, keep it coming.

[@DooMSDaY2808]

So here’s my logic for using the hotshot round with that opening gangster: First up, it seems like the round being fired makes less noise than a standard bullet, giving the gangster less time to react and shoot the hostage. A normal bullet could also cause an involuntary squeeze of the trigger if it killed him outright, or not kill him straight away and give him a chance to shoot. The flare on the other hand draws it out and as you can see, gives the hostage a chance to duck away. Pretty smart move from my eyes at least.

[@michalsoukup1021]

Also he gives a voice command that on the surface seems like he was addressing the perp.

[@709mash]

Very fair assessment. This would also have the benefit of showing Dredd's tactical skills and awareness and how is never one in which to fuck with. Fuck around, find out to its extreme.

[@TheSchultinator]

I always thought the pain of Hotshot to the mouth would cause an involuntary squeeze myself, but I don't know anatomy

[@DarkCloudIceX]

After watching your video about not hating CinemaSins I had to actually come back to this one JUST to see what you said about Th3Birdman slowlly becoming Future Birdman actually showing on the subtitles. I mean, I knew it was coming and actually saw it since you've set this "character arc" but before you pointed that detail on the other video, I legit thought it was actually Future Birdman, not present Birdman talking about the "Jeremy points out what's on the screen cliché". It was simple, but genius.

[@LifeAsANoun]

Th3Birdman: "Also, Dredd is not stupid." Script says: "Also, Dredd is not CinemaSins" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Exactly y u don't need subtitles in a video like this

[@deanmottershead8158]

The scene at the beginning of the film where he shoots the guy in the mouth also serves to demonstrate dredds code of ethics Dredd is skilled enough that he could have killed him and moved on but he gave the guy a chance to surrender and lived. Dredd is incredibly efficient in his heh execution of the law but he never kills someone just because it makes his life easier or from a warped pleasure. Damn this film is so good

[@gageanthony3478]

I’ve always been curious. What’s your take on cinemawins?

[@preston000]

Gage Anthony CW is just as bad as CS in my opinion, however is much more tolerable because he is positive rather than negative and often is so in a way that is directed towards the negativity of CS.

[@shilliojr]

Good question! I'd like to think he would like him lol

[@vaultdweller2295]

I like them

[@elton9721]

Honestly Cinemawins has a ton of knowledge on stuff and it's very nice he does research some stuff. And he doesn't pad too much at all. It's really nice to highlight the positives too. It's a great contrast to sins perspective.

[@vaultdweller2295]

Greg's Ecstasy I completely agree

[@dus10Bish0p]

Cinema Sins isn’t the law. I’m the law. - Birdman

[@wiicaaak]

dare I say, bird law?

[@cksmith08]

@@wiicaaak More like Harvey Th3Birdman: Attorney at Law

[@MidnightDStroyer]

@@cksmith08 Hmmm. Considering that a lawyer's primary job is to point out the flaws & holes in the opponents testimony...

[@camiloiribarren1450]

Favorite sins: “Except Judge Dredd is far more perceptive than you, so he’d actually be better suited to being excellent at Th3Birdman” and “Son... those are milliseconds” The sentence: I am the law!

[@Nick-lu1bx]

I feel like the "I love cinema sins" part at the begining of the video isn't true any more

[@StormAlterWorlds]

I pointed that out on a previous video. I was told, in no uncertain terms, that I was wrong.

[@WolfsFleetOps]

@@StormAlterWorlds Birdman takes pride in his voice acting and likes it when people believe his character.

[@James_Bee]

Why wouldn't he love them? They literally keep this content going.

[@karlacrous8361]

I said the same on a previous video... Basically, he plays a CHARACTER who despises CinemaSins, but he himself doesn't. If I understand it correctly

[@sheep2826]

Fox They cover awesome movies like this because their fans ask them to because people enjoy listening to discussion about good movies, as well if a movie is truly good CinemaSins often points that out or takes sins off for the awesome parts.

[@BoomerWarfare]

Re-watched this movie last night and during the intro I swear I could hear Birdman saying MeGaLoDoN’s…

[@Archyoda7]

The only sin of this film is the lack of a sequel/mega franchise.

[@vaiyt]

Sinning Judge Dredd for having bargain basement cyberpunk villains. The series that features criminals such as a guy with a metal jaw whose entire plot is an elaborate Ozzy joke; an uprising of morbidly obese people; and Santa Claus.

[@emjackson81989]

Karl Urban delivering that "I am the law." line remains one of the best scenes in cinema for me. So chilling.

[@Th3Birdman]

Agreed. It's so understated, yet so powerful. I love him as the character; I really wish they hurry up with the sequel television show.

[@709mash]

@@Th3Birdman the fact Urban willingly kept the helmet on the whole film to keep it authentic to the character shows he's the right guy for the role. He gets Dredd, and you can tell he enjoyed himself.

[@MoskHotel]

14:43 - 14:52 That, along with the incendiary and hotshot kills, is one of the most satisfying kills I’ve seen in this movie.

[@potato31415]

Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Endgame Impatiently waiting

[@JackJohnson-dl2mi]

It hasn't even come out to buy yet, and your waiting for Birdman to do an eww cinemasins already! Remember how long it took for cinemasins to do Infinity War?

[@iiSky__]

Didn't the movie literally come out like a month and a half ago?

[@zeenzones6928]

@@iiSky__ -Welcome to cinemasins- look bro , For infinty war, he took 6 months to do it ...so lets wait till the blue-ray i guess

[@iiSky__]

@@zeenzones6928 I guess..

[@xanthippus3190]

faithfully waiting

[@ultimateghostfreak2343]

side note: karl urban killed this fucking role.

[@davidcolby167]

Here's a reason to fire the hotshot: it'll burn out the nerve endings of the brain, rather than allowing them to fire spasmodically - I.E, keeping the gun from going off into the innocent's head. I mean, it's thin, but it's what I think. EDIT: ...did...did fucking Cinima Sins call a FLASH BANG a...gadget? A grenade that has existed since THE FUCKING 70s!?

[@BoomerWarfare]

@14:50 Loving the old MK2 (and others) reference. Warms my old bones.

[@garganrose]

The biggest sin of all was Jeremy not admitting how criminally underrated DREDD was

[@kamavery4477]

...that sentencing tho..."I AM THE LAW!!!"...fuckin clazzic

[@robp1519]

I'm a simple man. I see a birdman vid uploaded, I click it.

[@pduidesign]

Your “food courts” accent was AWESOME!!!!

[@taraishot100]

Dredd was a masterpiece and you know it we need a Dredd 2!!

[@talisredstar1543]

"The hardest of Core." Huhhh Raaa. got me in the feels. This movie is criminally underrated, and it was equally so unadvertised. This movie deserves a sequel or two, but I would happily settle for a Netflix season or two.

[@LifeAsANoun]

actual. heartfelt. laughter. this one seemed personal. you're criminally undersubscribed.

[@Cinderkin]

I typically don't read the text when you're talking, but gawd damn I'm glad I did this time. "Dredd is not Cinemasins" lolol

[@James_Bee]

You really should. He mixes jokes in everywhere. Not just the subtitles, but the sin counter, among others as well.

[@micah4029]

" Son...those are milliseconds"

[@ramblinwriter4987]

"Jeremy mocks Future Birdman" "**** that guy" Spat out my soda lol

[@matthewperry8826]

Asthma. **ding**

[@IdealIdeas100]

I think you should rewrite the opening to "Poke mistakes at most of their sins" and not some of their sins

[@morrisguinn6868]

Found your channel by accident and I’m a fan now Quality videos,smart commentary plus honest breakdowns equals reliable content

[@autisticwriter5763]

After having a marathon of Th3Birdman videos on CInemasins, i see another one has been added to the list. Today is a good day. Keep up the good work, Th3Birdman.

[@jcheck1107]

What gets me is that this movie was a perfect depiction of Dredd. Jeremy has fans that comment stuff like oh thank you for reviewing this movie I thought it would be crap, and those fans are probably why we would never get a sequel

[@sraonline9151]

Jeremy's ..."singing" made me cringe inside out faster than the green fog from the end of Treehouse of Horror V.

[@silobobus3268]

what an obscure refrence.

[@shawtyk3843]

BirdMan you know I rocks with you. But Future BM is the fucking man blunt and charismatic 😂😂

[@christopherthorne8133]

God I love this channel. This smug git in Cinemasins has gone on too long without being called out. Keep it up bro!

[@FloofDog44]

Why, because he's right more often than not? Cry more.

[@silobobus3268]

CinemaSins: ''i am...inevitable.'' ''And i.. am Birdman.''

[@BackburingPyro]

Dredd: I am THE LAW

[@xanthippus3190]

I'm groot

[@kryoruleroftheninthcircleo4151]

Your father.

[@fornaxian]

You know what bugs me about the "Jeremy points out whatever is happening on screen and sins it" cliché is that 9 times out of 10 when he does it, it means he's basically trying to avoid saying "movie does not explain the thing" because the movie is 'showing not telling' and expects you to fill in the blanks. Whatever is happening on the screen that he's pointing out is literally explaining itself by just being on the screen, usually by building a scene/world/character with details about them that the lack of explanation implies to be taken as "that's just how it is" in-universe. Besides, you know full well if it explained it that directly or bluntly he'd immediately sin it for exposition or wasting time or something without a hint or irony. Honestly, what, really bugs me the most is that it's basically sinning a movie for being artistic, subtle or clever in some way and that just makes audiences and filmmakers worse for hearing and believing it.

[@champgreen9985]

Your videos are my favorites and you uploading at this time is even better

[@D3sToD3s]

"Your" Not "you're". "You're" means "You are" wich turns your sentence into "You are videos are my favorites"

[@champgreen9985]

D3sToD3s my bad dam auto correct dam grammar nazis. Here I go to edit the tiny your mistake. Btw I do know the difference and don’t do this 99.9% of the time

[@champgreen9985]

D3sToD3s happy? 😂😂😂

[@Dannyheal]

How did I miss this one, I thought I've seen everything you've done... One of my favorite action films of all time.

[@nickseda5371]

I love that remix of Mask Off at the end, that was fire

[@Autumnwanders]

“Son those are milliseconds” 😂😂😂 im dead

[@rilluma]

oh yeah ! this is so BRUTAL towards cinemasins! i love it!!!

[@709mash]

This film was a cult classics almost immediately! Sins for even sinning this film!

[@KlausKokholmPetersen]

The biggest sin is that we didn't get a sequel or 2.

[@SatyrToon]

Something that got me about a few of Jeremy's sins in this movie was that he was operating off of the belief that a lot of these criminals would have trials - like, modern day court room trials - when the crime rates are so bad that they just don't have time for it; Hence why Dredd says that they are "Judge, Jury and Executioner." They don't have time for that shit, they can only respond to 6% of crime, the justice system has to divert its resources where they count and it's not in a court room.

[@JackJohnson-dl2mi]

I'm 4 minutes into this video, and i have to say; This is one of your funniest videos yet. FoOd CoUrTs. EvErYbOdY hAtEs FoOd CoUrTs, Am I rIgHt?

[@BlackBlade58206]

I like to think that Ma Ma wasn't bluffing, Dredd just dealt with that before (or something similar), and just repeated his solution.

[@shannonparis30]

I think you need to do Cinemasins version of Frozen and Frozen 2 because there is a lot of lack of research that he does in the latter that would answer some of the questions or sins he has

[@KeemCozart]

i think you’d be a great voice actor

[@coolguyhino92]

Should have started with, "Sinning Dread!"

[@professor3138]

“Call me now for ya free reading” And these five sins b**tch lmaooo

[@LordHayabusa85]

I always thought the hobo was just loitering, never realized he was also soliciting.

[@Th3Birdman]

Yeah, his actual crime was vagrancy in the film (which is basically just being homeless), but if you read his sign, he is actually advertising prostitution. It's kind of sad, actually.

[@deflectedsparrow5769]

yes, fav KZbinr uploaded again

[@someonewhocommentsonyoutub3779]

Cinema Sins: *makes an awful joke and passes it off as a sin* Th3Birdman: I'm about to end this man's whole career

[@CoratMcRed]

The real sin of this video is just another reminder that this film isn't getting a sequel and the TV series is in development hell Damn it.

[@thehoodybadger3402]

I feel as though the homeless man deliberately disobeyed so as to get caught and hauled off to the Isocubes, a subtle cue to emphasize the nature of the Mega City. Imprisonment over being homeless in this kind of setting as some homeless have been known to do in big cities.

[@laterferaligatr2947]

Lol you have quickly become one of my favorite KZbinrs. You do the Jeremy laugh so well lol

[@agathaharkness399]

4:14 OMGGG that impressionnn...it was like goofy but dumber like it made me mad laugh cry and die all at once👏👏👏

[@andrewphillips8341]

You missed one. The mini gun is NOT a 50 cal. This just shows Jeremy ignorance in military matters and weapons, in addition to all his other things his is ignorant in.

[@fieldcommanderkurt]

These were fictional mockups, though, according to the production crew. when filming the spent casings ejecting onto the ground, they used spent .50 BMG cases. there are REAL .50 BMG Gatling guns but the one that comes to mind is the GAU/19 with only three barrels. that said there is not a CHANCE IN HELL cinemasins knew this and much more likely just saw a large machine gun and said ".50 CAAAAAALLL" like a moron.links to More info about the films firearms and some background:www.imfdb.org/wiki/Dredd_(2012)#Prop_Minigunwww.imfdb.org/wiki/General_Dynamics_GAU-19/A

[@Th3Birdman]

Those mini guns actually are 50 cal. I looked into it myself

[@whiterabbit75]

@@Th3Birdman Yeah, you don't want to miss a chance to rub Cinema Sins noses in their own ignorance. XD

[@kevins894]

This will be great!! Thank you for what you do

[@chriscarpenter1920]

The laugh that you gave ten sins for was hilarious and way less fake-sounding than his earlier laughs.

[@shoto5371]

I like the Friday reference

[@Goodsoldiersfolleworders99]

Can we make a drinking game on how many times cinemasins put a Sins on how many logos are in every movie, i would die by the drinking game on how many sins he puts for movie logos

[@danydazed4314]

5:16 ish minor note, the gun actually flashes dredd an alert to say he’s low on ammo and the hotshot was the only viable option in that situation. Also Stallone is most definitely not the law.

[@jjthe13th]

I tend to like the title introductions (of which the original predator one and Godzilla are on top) I dig the sin tally outro for this one

[@JoshJenrayAK47]

[Miss Cleo voice] "Call me now for ya free readin'! [regular voice] And these 5 sins, bitch." I cackled so hard I sounded like a demented parrot...kinda scared me

[@Rainok]

Why does Dredd remind me of Captain Falcon just by looking at him... was that phrased right?

[@dennisyoungblood349]

He thought you had to be a good shot with a mini gun? Wtf? Lmao

[@michaeliv284]

While I don't know that much about Judge Dredd, I can say from my little experience that the blood sweeping scene could be a reference to Resyk... the process where corpses are made into food!

[@ando1016]

ive watched probably 7 or 8 of these videos, and i gotta say seems like this one was personal for you XD dredd was such a good movie i dont blame you

[@kalisunreal1076]

14:09 OMG THAT LAUGH 🤣🤣😂😂😂 i could not stop laughing that was soooo hilarious, by far the best jeremy fake laugh yet

[@glassesman15]

One of my favorite movies ! Haven't started your vid yet, but i hope you get'em. Keep up the good work!

[@delayed_reaction_man]

Your avatar with judge duds on looks badass and awesome!

[@ghostnappa2012]

Another reason that Dredd uses the Hotshot mode on his gun against the criminal in the beginning is so that the hostage doesn't get shot. Chances are if you get hit in the face or something, your hand is going to open up reflexively rather than tense up.It's a shock factor as well as rule of cool

[@dennisyoungblood349]

This movie was so good. I hope they make the sequel, or show on Netflix or Amazon

[@khaoscorp999]

this movie needs a sequel.

[@ThraxJay]

That Friday reference was fucking hilarious 10/10

[@jordancabuy]

I love your written sentences, they make the video even more fun!

[@MrsButtersworth82]

2:53 “The more you know” jingle was perfect!!! Reminds me of the 90’s!!!

[@khrashingphantom9632]

So how long has Th3 Birdman been hiding jokes in the subtitles? Lol. Clever man now you can double your views with people going back to watch previous stuff with subtitle easter eggs and jokes. Just playing. People go back and watch because you make awesome content! Thanks again.

[@MarkusxJxKeetz]

I fucking love this movie. Gavin Free did a good job with the slow-mo scenes

[@tomsmith504]

I hope that he just has the “Jeremy makes a pop culture ref-“ as a clip so he doesn’t have to say it every time.

[@agnoshteez7806]

Cinemasins says shit that goes over peoples head Birdman... catches it and tells u

[@cas2762]

Great video! I really loved Dredd. It was totally not what I expected, but I loved it.

[@loud479]

Love the fact you mentioned sector mistake

[@GenericGooner]

“Before I move on ‘someone’ wants me to explain what ‘Jeremy points out something on the screen cliche’ means...” *crunch, crunch* You padding the time bro? -

[@carlosgarlington7822]

This motherfuvking outro Birdman!! 🥶🥶 Jeez loueez PLEASE help me relax

[@shanemccarthy7282]

The way her blood splattered it like the X on Dred's helmet

[@dechha1981]

Judge Dredd is NOT Dudley do-right. Dudley is obsessed with being good. Dredd THINKS he is, but he’s actually obsessed with the letter of the law, not the same thing at all. Dredd himself is a perfect example of how “obey the law” and “good” are not at all the same thing. Dudley would never murder someone for a minor crime.

[@CosmicGoku529]

Dredd never killed someone for a minor crime in this movie. Everyone he killed was trying to kill him.

[@aluskn]

As someone who grew up with 2000AD and dredd, I thought this movie was about as good an adaptation as any hollywood traslation is likely to be. Some of the scenes did a really impressive job of making beautiful cinematography from extreme violence, the grim atmosphere of Mega-City One and the dark anti-hero character of Dredd were captured fairly well, and most importantly Karl Urban didn't insist on having his face visible unlike Stallone in the awful 90s version.

[@nyxcelina219]

I always took the scene of him killing Mama as showing how his character is so straight lined in how he does his job that he would kill a character sentenced to death even if it meant potentially killing thousands of people.

[@fornamnefternamn1532]

I agree. I guess there also could have been a mixture of knowing that the signal cannot reach, experience from earlier crimes like this, and just risking everyone to serve justice. Either way, it is a morbidly beautiful ending.

[@ToyInsanity]

The logo on the building was metal catching sunlinght, not lightbulbs.

[@paulheap1982]

No. It's lights. 😂

[@captaindraco2286]

Something tells me that if I were to choose between watching EWW Dredd and going through a kidney stone again................. I would take the Kidney stone. Would I be wrong?

[@neevious]

This movie is great

[@patrickazzarella6729]

So should be watching these in order, to slowly watch the development into future birdman?