205: Why Didn't The Prophet Divorce Ayesha and did Muawiya Kill Her? | Our Prophet

[@Thaqlain]

Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on KZbin & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

[@mnoorbhai]

You are a gem from the bottom of my heart , learnt a lot from your videos

[@mnoorbhai]

X amazing insight , why can't you join hands with the likes of Amaar Nakswani and take the world by storm by taking these fakologist Sunni KZbinrs and take them head in for the better benefit of common Sunnis who have been fed falacies for centuries .

[@AbuFadl]

if the prophet was told to be patient, where does it say this in the Qur'an? because in the very chapter that you mention, Surah Tahrim, Allah actually gives him the opportunity to marry other women and divorce them, and those women would be better. And allah also gives ayesha and hafsa advice to repent. As opposed to wives of lut and nuh, they were destroyed and made clear to their husbands they are disbelievers. Why isn't this same clarity of made about Ayesha that she was a hyporcite and disbeliever in the Qur'an? why do we then need to rely on esoteric interpretation of the Shia?

[@MUZLIM1234]

I’m so glad I am Muslim who follows the Quran and Sunnah. No Shia stuff. May Allah guide them all. They truly think they’re on the straight path.

[@Thaqlain]

But according to Sahih Muslim the Prophet commanded to follow Quran and Ahlulbayt :(

[@zaraibragim2690]

AlhamduliLlah after 20 years in “sunnah” sect i found the truth way with ahlul beyt as . And this is the truth and only straight way, because it has proofs.,but others they dont Where you proof to follow buhari muslim and so on as a sours of sunnah?!

[@Rizvi-2]

Astagfirullah, Prophet said to follow his family, how can u learn the Sunnah WITHOUT HIS FAMILY???

[@saminatahir8665]

We also pray for the same for people who don’t accept their own books. May Allah guide you and your parents to the right path.

[@carllere7682]

Find it interesting that whenever something that’s written does not serve your purpose. It’s fabricated but when it does, it’s authentic.

[@Thaqlain]

Thus, there is Ilm al-Rijal (the science of narrators), Ilm al-Hadith (the science of narrations), and Ilm al-Kalam (the science of theology). These sciences require examinations of narrations to verify their authenticity.

[@aliimanoha8221]

Wallahi, these people are completely misguided. Can you imagine comparing Aisha (ra) to those who have been damned in the Qur'an by Allah (swt)? It's crazy how some people think the Sahabah were supposed to be perfect, like angels, when the Seerah and the Qur'an both show they were just human. Now, they're picking out one of their actions, twisting it, and wrongly accusing them of evil.

[@Nothingiswhatitis]

Events that occurred over 1400 years ago.. two groups one saying one thing and the other saying that ..we reject your hadith in Bukhari bla bla bla .. you are playing a dangerous game - leave the past where it is and look forward to bringing sunni and shia together - i mean after palestine have you scholars not realised who is your enemy .. you argue basically who the vice captain should have been etc etc and the enemy sits there laughing at us - if thats what you want keep making these decisive windows. I prefer the scholars who love Alhle Bait but so not spend time maligning the Sahabbah based on disputed evidence

[@Thaqlain]

Your comment is on the 205th episode of a series on the life of Prophet Muhammad (sallalahu alaihe wa'alehi). We hope you have watched the previous episodes before commenting :)

[@lilbubble-is6yz]

Perfectly said. Loved your answers and explaination!

[@MM-rb6lu]

The prominent Quranic scholar Shaykh Yasir AL Habib FADAK TV London has written a 1200 page response to every objection against Shia Islam called كتاب الفاحشة الوجه الاخر لعائشة This ground-breaking book is fully referenced and is a must read for all students of Arabic and Quranic studies. This amazing book is rocking the entire Arab world and is available from FADAK TV center Fulmer London. Alhamdullilah 🎉

[@ahmadvahab968]

For all these people, leaving comments how great this speech was, are you crazy?! What type of subject matter is this? Really, we have nothing to talk about rather than this nonsense topic? We look at conditions of life in Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan and wonder why! These clerics with this type of absolute nonsense, are part of the problem.

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you missed the point here. The idea we are examining here is evaluating the position of Ayesha as a source of the Sunnah of the Prophet. The mess Muslims are today in is because we have left the Sunnah of the Prophet. And the reason we are away from Sunnah is because we have chosen wrong sources for it. So to clear the mess we have to first clear the sources. Now we hope you realize how significant this topic is 🙂

[@ahmadvahab968]

@@Thaqlain What you are saying is in theory and practice not true. 1) How about Iran, with over 90% Shia or Iraq, with 70% Shia? 2) The reason we are in this mess is because we put the Quran aside and built a whole new religion based on Hadith, most of which are dubious. 3) Does it really make a difference in the condition of Muslims if they hate Ayesha? Or, would it actually make a difference if Muslims get closer and more familiar with the Quran? 4) Are Ayesha, Usman, etc. really our problem today? 5) what is sad is that you have so much potential, not only as a Muslim, but also the impact you can have. Yet, you are going arnold preaching as if you are in some village in Iraq or Iran. Very sad!

[@Thaqlain]

Please reread Hadith al-Thaqalayn. Word by word. And you will have the answer 🙂

[@Thaqlain]

Moreover, we hope you have watched the 204 episodes before this one and will continue to watch the 50 more after these. 🙂

[@user-eh2pv4sc7h]

What about your wahabi sunni who follow a different sunnah from what rasoollah told his ummah to follow quran and alhul bayt.

[@batk5381]

The more I learn about Shia the more grateful I become for not being one. Believing in the 12 imans is no different than believing in the unicorn

[@Thaqlain]

The Prophet commanded you to hold tight his progeny. Seems like he commanded you to hold tight to unicorns who will meet him at the Hawdh alongside the Quran in the hereafter.

[@batk5381]

@@Thaqlain fine line but never obeyed by certain type.. the amount of delusion some people live in is unmatched. Our beloved prophet said to love his family not to worship them, as worshipping is a shirk. What's is the definition of a family? How many generations down is considered a family by an old and a modern definition. Who loves the beloved prophet's family and who worships them (+ hate one of the wives) in today's world? The answer is obvious.. No one can nor will ever prove the 12 imans by any verifiable evidence as much as the unicorn. Brainwashed can only be unwashed if it dares to open and let in this light of truth. It's happening every day and many are accepting the true Islam EVERY DAY!

[@Thaqlain]

What is the definition of family? Ask the Prophet What is the extent of love we should show? Ask the Prophet Who are the 12 Imams after the Prophet? Ask the Prophet Brainwashed can only be unwashed if it dares to open and let in this light of truth. It's happening every day, and many are accepting true Islam EVERY DAY! One such story is here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/foDReqaBipyMlaM

[@batk5381]

@@Thaqlain So now is it just you or everyone of you are confused? you need to ask the prophet what is the definition of a family is? Pathetic! Ask the prophet about the 12 Iman? How? I hope you know he is no longer with us. Do you even hear yourself? Again no one will be able to prove them because they don't exist, never did and never will. You can not prove a lie because it has zero evidence except for excuses. Lies after lie and excuses of excuse.. You are not a Shia if you don't consider the made up imans Divine. Imans are divine according to all Shia with their godly attributes. Don't lie and deny that now. Considering anything divine is what all people worship to. As per the video, I can't tell whether it's authentic or not but he clearly doesn't look like Shia I mean look at him. Also, he seems more confused than been enlightened by the truth

[@Thaqlain]

So, asking the Prophet about who is included in the term Ahlulbayt is pathetic? Seems like you haven't read the Quran, which states to make the Prophet a judge in disputes (Surah Nisa verse 65). So if Allah wants us to make the Prophet the judge in case we dispute, he better have guided his Prophet on matters we dispute. Seek, and you will see that Allah has not lied in his book.

[@MM-rb6lu]

Let's just be rational Quranic Muslims and follow our beloved Rasulullah, Ahlul Bait and the Quran. Best Quran translations are M Asad Leopold Weiss, Asi, Hammad Zaki, Kepler, Ali Qarai..

[@tuqaraafat1919]

إِنَّ الَّذِينَ جَاءُوا بِالْإِفْكِ عُصْبَةٌ مِنْكُمْ لَا تَحْسَبُوهُ شَرًّا لَكُمْ بَلْ هُوَ خَيْرٌ لَكُمْ لِكُلِّ امْرِئٍ مِنْهُمْ مَا اكْتَسَبَ مِنَ الْإِثْمِ وَالَّذِي تَوَلَّى كِبْرَهُ مِنْهُمْ لَهُ عَذَابٌ عَظِيمٌ

[@straight_path_123]

Alhamdulillah greap reply

[@fadelalkarbalai9766]

Alhamdulillah an amazing lecture. I was literally waiting for it to be uploaded. Love from Niagara Falls Ontario.

[@NN-fz4pd]

This is the first time I’m seeing Baqer qazwini being real instead of being overly chipper and smiley and “on” for the crowd. Refreshing to see.

[@yoursolosquad6283]

Sayed Mohammad Baqir Al-Qazwini

[@Abc-ks2is]

JazakAllah. Great lectures

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Syed..is there any website of yours or thaqlain where we can post our questions and queries regarding our day to day problems and get their solutions in the light of islam .. It would be really helpful

[@KwikkiCat]

Ask Those Who Know app

[@towardshidayat]

This is from a seminary called al-hujjah seminary. This is the course called "the biography of the Prophet". If you are interested in doing courses on islam, you can enroll and youll get access to a discord group where you may ask your questions.

[@tasneembootwala8308]

@@towardshidayat thank you

[@Sufi2017]

After listening to several videos about Ayesha (although I disagree with a few while most of his arguments make sense) I'm having my second thought about Ayesha. He is speaking based on evidence.

[@Thaqlain]

Alhamdolillah. May Allah guide you to path of An'amta alaihim while saving you from the path of Maghzoob and Dhaaleen.

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

Corrections false evidence, u just get source from the real Sunni Hadith, because he is changing statements and will surely be questioned on the Day of resurrection

[@self-sufficient9315]

This means you do not study Islam and are among those people who just believe in what they hear… what a shame

[@Mesopotamian-tt9mb]

God bless upon our lady Aisha 💙💙💙 Mother of believers

[@Thaqlain]

May Allah bless all the righteous wives of the Prophet.

[@muthamizh3942]

When he needs something, he will quote Buhari. When he wants, he will say it is fabricated. You dont have any right or reason to talk about Prophet's wives. Dont get cursed automatically by Allah!

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you missed the point 🙂

[@AliJawad-q5d]

Yeah, and when he quotes our books you say it's fabricated and you won't believe since it's " Shia " source. Grow up.

[@ismailkedir5728]

​@@ThaqlainI pity you, but Alhamdulillah we Ethiopian, the land of Bilal and Nejashi , have no a single Shia who have no any objective other than insulting and blasphemy. May Allah guide to the right path.

[@Thaqlain]

1) Shias do exist in Ethiopia 2) Had you watched atleast from episode 193 onwards, you would have realised that the aim is not to insult or do blasphemy. May Allah protect us from insulting wives of the Prophet.

[@muthamizh3942]

@@Thaqlain If that is the case, you need to build your theology based on more piousness and hardwork towards Allah and His messenger, instead of picking mostly on fabrication, ill talking about Rasullulah's wives and talking bad about Sahabas! Pls abstain from such things and focus on your Amal! May Allah protect you bring your towards his Deen fully!

[@mustafaabbas2959]

Asslamu Aleykum @Thaqlain. I would appreciate if you also could post or direct me to videos about virtous of the Imams, their characteristics, about their lives, examples of their ethics and conducts etc. I am interested to learn about their lives and have an example that I can follow.

[@mustafaabbas2959]

@Bahrom Olimov Thank you very much.

[@zak992]

Read the Quran at fajr time take time to understand what you have read in your own language, then take time to ponder over what you have read, do that and inshallah you will get to where you want to get to. Allah through the Quran is talking to you directly follow His commands and His advice, remember Him much, you really do not need the advice of other people no matter how pious, not when you have the kalam of Allah right in front of you

[@Thaqlain]

And where has Allah said that you don't need advice of pious people? Last time we checked Quran has at various points commanded Muslims to follow the pious leaders.

[@Hadi.Hussein]

@@mustafaabbas2959^

[@Zanskar7749]

If Aisha and Three Khalifa was unjust distracted companion then why did the beloved Prophet Muhammad SAW didn't get the revelation about his mislead companion even Prophet Was directly getting revelation All the Ten companion which Imam Ali includes Prophet Muhammad given guarantee of Paradise when he was Alive . During the Time of Uthman Assisnatio Imam Ali give him protection in form of his two son if their was enmity between them the how it could be possible to give protection to his enemy , Imam Ali Married the widow Wife of Abu Bakar if their was enemity then how a person marry his enemy wife......during the time of Battale of Camel Aisha was given safe guard and protection by the Imam Ali her brother was a commanding head of Imam Ali if their was an enmity then how it can be possible to keep the son of his enemy at commanding post ....this all the example which their was a no enmity between the Companion... When Imam Ali was asked by his Companions in Kufa to retribute Aisha he refuse to given him retribution just saying she is wife of Prophet...don't try to misled the ummah give some logical lecture which can unite the Ummah May Almighty Guide u

[@ahmadalif2609]

Very true bro. Please help us. May Allah reward you

[@commercialandresidentialpl7337]

The widow of the 1st caliph was married to Jaffer ibn Abu Talib ra prior to his martyrdom. Now it makes a little more sense.

[@Zulfiqar32]

There are hadith that literally talk about the companions of Muhammad(saw) and how they innovated after his death.

[@Zanskar7749]

@Fahad H Majority of Islamic world follow the four Kalifah in Islamic world u means majority are fool they are fool to analyze the Khalifah who Shia curse ...even in history itself mention that The Khalifa Omar Usman And Ali RA are the only Khalifa they are we assisnated by the traitor ......those who support Ali in Kufa against Mawiyah was the only among those who assisnated Ali in Kufa Islam is a religion of peace but Munakif play important role in dividing the ummah during the time of Four Khalifa and in even today

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Bcoz he is imam Ali a.s. His virtues are beyond our perception. He was justice personified. Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad

[@manjunathbhatt6606]

Wives has no say.? All ladies surrendered to prophet and got married without any resistance even some of them lost their relatives who were killed by prophet army.

[@Thaqlain]

We have already covered all of this in detail in the previous episodes :)

[@AhmadRaza-xe5bp]

So if prophet knows about that, did He ever cursed Ayesha (R.A),if not then why your voices are rising above the voice of Prophet? What was the part of sinful wives of Prophets in their religion? What kind of bad things they added in religion to destroy it and Prophets were ignoring all of that?

[@Thaqlain]

We have covered these questions in great detail in the preceding episodes. We will urge you to watch them with an open mind :) kzbin.info/aero/PLOXzVYnjThorUIEtu2YYLNRMq6CBgUOu3

[@guiders14]

Wow - how could someone even ask this question if Ayesha died as “Shaheed”. Great reply by the Sayyid.

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

Hmm. These people are only misleading u from the truth, please study the Sunni Hadith and then u will realize that he is changing statements, he is misleading u all

[@humblebee8334]

Misunderstandings happened at the time but there is no enmity between the sahabas and the prophets family.

[@Thaqlain]

Please share proof :)

[@ibrahimharith9878]

There was so much love in the battle of Jamal so much in the battle of siffin and nahrawan ,akhi where is your intellect ?

[@Crime_pays]

I’m Shia and I agree but ultimately I love Amir al-Mu'minin and Ahlulbayt more

[@shamiemaaboobaker539]

That’s not correct… there WAS great enmity between sahabas and AHLULBAYT (AS)….

[@tameemansari707]

According to a Hadith, Rasoolallah stated, With Enmity, Grudge On Me, My Family, Ahlul Baith ( prophet s a w. Fatema Zahra s a. Imaam Ali a s. Imaam Hassan a s. Imaam Hussain a s. ) Even if muslimeen offer salah five times a day, performing Haj, making rounds in between Marwa Safa till Doomsday, Salah, Haj, Deeds would not be approved, accepted by Allah. Sunni Aalims refute such Hadith. With Enmity such Hadith recorded,got recorded deliberately. Who is accountable?

[@25rizwana68]

Why is no one saying peace be upon him , when mentioning prophet Mohammad ( peace br upon him) . Even on the white board this is not mentioned, is there a reason or just ?

[@Thaqlain]

Whenever Prophet's name is mentioned, salutations are in order 🙂

[@25rizwana68]

@@Thaqlain why no one says it aloud or it's just that they prefer to say it silently

[@Thaqlain]

Every time the Sayed took the name of the Prophet he does say it out loudly 🙂

[@youssssef]

The previous prophets didn’t have Quran ordering them to divorce the non believers.. Prophet Muhammad got the order 60:10.

[@Thaqlain]

This verse is about those who have not accepted Islam.

[@youssssef]

@@Thaqlain No, it explicitly tells the muslims not to keep the non-believing wives.

[@Thaqlain]

Please read Arabic of the verse. It is talking about Kuffar :)

[@youssssef]

@@Thaqlain I know it's talking about the kuffar الكوافر. Now how do u think the prophet kept a kafir after this verse was revealed ?

[@Thaqlain]

We don't consider any of the Prophet's wife as a Kaafir.

[@kashansamad197]

3:29 Except that ALLAH did give the Prophet (pbuh) the option to divorce in Quran. So it is not true to say that ALLAH didn't allow this because of patience. 2ndly just like the disbelief of wives of earlier prophets (pbut) is proven from Quran and you accept that why don't you accept verse 33 Ahzab (full verse not just the part you like) which is a proof of the faith of the wives of Prophet (pbuh) 3rdly, probably ALLAH or the earlier prophets (pbut) decided against the divorcing of disbelieving wives because the message was still on-going and those nations still had a chance to accept so they wanted the wives to have same chance while Hazrat Aisha (ra) was married in Madinah where the majority of community was in fold of Islam. 4thly, there's a difference in Sharia of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and other prophets (pbut) and Quran explicitly forbids marrying with a mushrik woman, so this is a big lie to equate Hazrat Aisha (ra) with mushrik wives of earlier propets (pbut). It is comparing two different situations, a common tactic used by Shia clerics at large, also called Straw man argument. Lastly but most importantly, you should be ashamed of yourself that in your enemosity of Hazrat Aisha (an Ahle Bayt) you accuse our beloved Prophet (pbuh) of low standards nauzubillah. Are you a better judge of what's acceptable standard or Imam Al anbia (pbuh)? If you have any shame you should repent.

[@Thaqlain]

1) Allah did allow the Prophet to divorce yet it was the will of Allah to not divorce them 2) Wives are not part of the Ahlulbayt. Proves are here: www.al-islam.org/shiite-encyclopedia/word-house-ahlul-bayt-quran www.al-islam.org/shiite-encyclopedia/who-are-ahlul-bayt-part-2 3) We have discussed. That Ayesha was a test for the Ummah. More details in the episode that discusses her going the Quran in Battle of Jamal 4) It is not us who equated them. It is the Quran which does so in Surah Tahrim 5) We have covered the opinion of the Prophet and other members of Ahlulbayt regarding Ayesha in detail in the previous episodes.

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

Ver True, u can't compare THE MOTHER TO THE BELIEVERS with previous wives of the prophets🎉

[@-7x70]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته From Sunan Ibn Majah Hadith No: 3960 Narrated/Authority of Udaisah bint Uhban Listed in: The Chapters on Tribulations "When Ali bin Abu Talib came to Basrah, he entered upon my father and said: 'O Abu Muslim, will you not help me against these people?' He said: 'Of course.' So he called a slave woman of his and said: 'O slave woman, bring me my sword.' So she brought it, and he unsheathed it a span, and (I saw that) it was made of wood. He said: 'My close friend and your cousin (saw) advised me, if tribulation (Fitnah) arose among the Muslims, that I should take a sword of wood. If you wish I will go out with you.' He said: 'I have no need of you or of your sword.'" Thank you for the video. Can you pleas help me understand this Hadith, it seems to be similar to what is being taught. Allah Akbar Allah Taala For the Love of Our Prophet Muhammad (SAW) we must deal with how it all started. -Morteza Ali

[@naveedkhan8023]

Anyone saying bad things about Prophet’s wives is a kafir. According to Quran, Allah calls prophet’s wife as the mother of Muslim ummah.

[@Thaqlain]

We will urge you to watch from episode 173 onwards to understand the context.

[@anverhemraj2397]

When Allah had warned her about even giving the Prophet better wives than these two.. Brother open your ears.. and hear… these two wives were involved in killing the prophet..

[@a.6852]

U never use prophet peace be upon him show ur love prophet

[@Thaqlain]

One has to send Salawat when he takes the name of the Prophet :)

[@Thaqlain]

Please reread our comment 🙂🙏

[@serignendiaye536]

Brillant lecture truth is coming out well done congratulations SWT bless you

[@mohamedshow9985]

What is the name of this Shik

[@Thaqlain]

Sayed Muhammad Baqer Qazwini

[@arrdiy9603]

Taking prophets words out of context is just outrageous

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you missed the purpose of these episodes.

[@mariorodrigues3276]

In surah v 71 - 19:71 it Reads: There is not one of you but shall pass by Hell. This is a decree which your Lord will fulfil.

[@Goodfella0485]

The verse in Surah At-Tahrim is criminally taken out of context. The example is given of 2 disbelieving wives of 2 (righteous) prophets, and of a believing wife of the (treacherous) Pharoah, and of the chaste Mary. The good wives and the bad whom all got what they deserved. Prior to this, the 2 wives of the prophet are told to repent or face consequences. No one is being likened to anyone the way he is alluding.

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. Surah Tahrim is already explored in detail in EP174 and EP198. We will urge you to listen to them as it will allow you to understand the context :)

[@carllere7682]

You keep saying that these were fabricated, well, how do you know that all the rest were not fabricated as well?

[@Thaqlain]

Thus, there is Ilm al-Rijal (the science of narrators), Ilm al-Hadith (the science of narrations), and Ilm al-Kalam (the science of theology). These sciences require examinations of narrations to verify their authenticity.

[@nikoutoajaisai6310]

Alhamdulillah my brother may Allah reward you well.

[@yakubumusa5855]

Truth ya imam god blessing

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

Why r u speaking negative things abt the Mother of Nations, because if u say that she is impure then so Is Allah, Subuhanallahu Watallah, then u r not a true believer if u dare say that Ayesha is impute because you are questioning Allah's view on Ayesha, and yes if the prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) was nervous to talk about her behaviors then Allah was never wrong, he would hv led him to the right path, in Quran there's a verse that talks about those who question Ayesha's purity, then you have really proven to be a NON_BELIEVER. U should know that Allah could hv never chosen Ayesha to be the wife of the Prophet Muhammad if she was really impure as u say, Wallahi ALLAH WILL QUESTION YOU ALL ON THE DAY OF JUDGMENT FOR WHY YOU MADE THIS ACCUSATIONS ABOUT THE MOTHER OF THE BELIEVERS. And yes Allah can't mention sth wrong in the Quran if it Is not true, Ayesha, was very pure and innocent that is y she was talked about in the Quran... LET US WAIT AND SEE ON THE DAY OF JUDGMENT WHO WILL REGRET AND WHO WILL CELEBRATE, WHAT u r doing is breaking ur symbols of a true believer because a true believer believes in whatever Allah says and leaves whatever Allah refused.. And yes please stop misleading people u will only understand this when u r in front of Allah. I beg that you accept that Ayesha is our Mother, because this one person will make ur future with Jannah fall down

[@Thaqlain]

And where have we said she is impure? It seems you have not watched the previous episodes of this chapter 🙂

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

Hmm. U r still questioning her status, u r making false accusations about her in this very video, am not afraid to say that am a Sunni, but still I will always respect whatever Allah chose for his beloved Prophet

[@shehnamrazvi2059]

Beautifully explained

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Jazakallah khair

[@ethandouro4334]

I will watch the entire series of lectures today, after this video, thank you!

[@rumanaadam7604]

Asalamunalıakum Alahuma sualıy ala Mohammed waalı Mohammed wa'ajılfarahum

[@fadelalkarbalai9766]

First ❤️😁

[@NN-fz4pd]

Why did he marry her is the real question

[@Thaqlain]

We have covered this too in this chapter.

[@rameezshah7440]

Mashallah

[@raeesmustafa8763]

I can see some sunni brethren trying to appease their creed by discrediting the sayed and what he is saying, but as usual... they are unable to step up with some intellect and evidence. I suppose it reflects their accumen and inability to view history in a critical lens.

[@Thaqlain]

This has been always the case. Whenever Quraysh were not able to respond to the Prophet, the resorted to discredit.

[@humblebee8334]

Time to unite the ummah than ever before! not to divide “fear Allah”

[@Thaqlain]

The unity lies in following Quran and Prophet's progeny (Thaqalayn) as mentioned in Sahih Muslim.

[@aqidahsunnahsahihah]

lanaa a'maalunaa wa lakum a'maalukum..

[@ShamimVazirAli]

Your assumptions your reality

[@JUMBO747-4U]

Why not debate with a sunni scholar instead of preaching to the congregation! Anyone is free to say whatever they wish, it's only when his statements are counteracted with evidence, then the lecture (debate) becomes worthy of believing (or not). Until such a time, I neither believe nor trust a word you're saying here.

[@Thaqlain]

We will urge you to watch previous episodes. Then you will realize that the purpose here is not debate 🙂

[@mikailislam6790]

And even if u are ready for a debate, the most of the sunni scholars will not come.

[@arrdiy9603]

U can’t disrespect aisha she is a part of ahl e bait its just no right

[@Thaqlain]

Firstly, no disrespect intended. Secondly, she is not the part of Ahlulbayt.

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

True 🎉

[@kashansamad197]

So opposing Yazid nomination was not fi-sabilillah? Maybe you have someone else in mind instead of ALLAH when you say fi-sabilillah!

[@Thaqlain]

Was Ayesha killed because she opposed Yazid's nomination?

[@harrissajid4674]

Did Aisha and Hafsa poison the prophet Muhammad pbuh. It’s stated in bihar al anwar by our respected sixth imam Jaffar al Sadiq alaihis salaam. Is it authentic?

[@Thaqlain]

This shall be covered in the episodes related to Prophet's martyrdom.

[@thekids2176]

Mashallha

[@moono9614]

2:36 Yes, that was the akhlak of our beloved prophet saws that's how he spoke that's how amazing he is, why are you questioning the prophet saws? Been referred to watch this video to apparently “make me have more sense” But i guess when you're just shown more falseness you only get more confusing questions?? STOP LYING! ESPECIALLY THAT MAN WHO IS SPEAKING! He looks like a liar. Let’s say that’s how the prophet saws praised her like that there is nothing wrong with it because it's the prophet saws saying it! I'm not even gonna continue you once that man said he would lose respect if a prophet said that. Authobila May Allah swt guide you to the straight path ameen, this is truly shocking and very sad.

[@Loyalsurly]

You are truly blind

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. Are you saying all narrations we have received about the Prophet are authentic? Even those that degrade the Prophet? Has the Prophet ever said that all narrations you receive about me are to be taken as absolute truth?

[@muhammadhamza5467]

@@Thaqlain shia hadeeth books were compile after 400 years of prophet death, while sunni books within 200 years period , so historically our source of hadees of prophets are more reliable then yours bro.

[@H00H-H00H]

@@muhammadhamza5467are you joking? Do you even know from where do we get our authentic hadiths ? And btw bukhari and Ahmed and Muslim came after 300,500,700 years after the prophet

[@user-eh2pv4sc7h]

He is guided more than you sunnis.

[@HKHasty]

There are ahadith that her and Imam Ali AS eventually made up. And also that she was regretful. Are these true?

[@Thaqlain]

Covered in the previous episode :)

[@HKHasty]

@@ThaqlainJAK

[@ItzSpekk]

Mashallah powerful answers

[@sonabarnes6670]

❤

[@baraslim]

Sayeda Aisha angry with Muawiyah from 2 big incident 1. The horor murderer of her younger brother Sayidina Muhammad Ibn abi Bakar by Muawiyah party... Egyptian side amar Ibn al ash Remember... Sayeda Aisha is the one who raised Sayidina qosim Ibn Muhammad Ibn abi Bakar Father of Fatimah (umu farwah) future wife of Sayidina Muhammad al baghir and mother of Sayidina Jaffr as Shodiq 2. The death penalty to Sayidina hujr Ibn Adhi al kindly by Muawiyah dzalim trial Maybe 3. Is like Syed said The rumor told also abu Hurairah is the one who lead the final pray for her after successful death plot by dinner accident But in our ahli sunnah rummour, we did not hear about that murder as confirmation Just like Muawiyah poison Sayidina Hassan as more confirmation

[@Thaqlain]

As Sayed mentioned, we cannot say this with certainty. But there are clues.

[@baraslim]

@@Thaqlain Correct...

[@baraslim]

@@Thaqlain But sayeda aisha is famous had a SHARP tounge!!!!

[@salmaathman3388]

Probably talking noneses😅😅😅😮😮😮😢😢😢😂😂😂😅

[@Thaqlain]

You cannot understand context unless you watch previous episodes.

[@mrir2008]

So, basically what you are saying is: the Prophet (peace be upon him) did not know and understand what you, the Shias, know and understand.

[@Thaqlain]

Where did we said so?

[@mrir2008]

Your claims about Ayesha (RA) implies that, doesn't it?@@Thaqlain

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you haven't watched the preceding episodes. We will urge you to watch at least episode 198 and onwards if you wish to know the reason we have explored this topic in-depth. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n4DQZ5eOqcuSZrM&pp=gAQBiAQB

[@mrir2008]

Thank you for your suggestion. But before I do so, as you suggested, could you please tell me if the Prophet (pbuh) loved, respected and cared about Ayesha enough to be in an active marital relationship with her till his death?@@Thaqlain

[@Thaqlain]

The relationship between each wife of the Prophet differed significantly. However, with some, the relationship was so tricky that Allah had to interfere by revealing the verses of the Quran. So, the link provides details of his relationships and the lessons we can learn from them.

[@rrrayhan8508]

R u guys muslim? 😢 I m scared listening to u guys

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you have missed the purpose of this episode. This episode is the part of a 400+ episode series exploring the life of the Prophet. From episode 198 to 205, we have explored why Ayesha bint Abi Bakr is a controversial figure to be considered as an authority for Sunnah of the Prophet.

[@rrrayhan8508]

@@Thaqlain Quran confirms Aisha's innocence. So u better work on yourself rather than making someone controversial at any cost.

[@Thaqlain]

We have explored those verses in Surah Nur, too 🙂

[@DifferentVvibez]

​@@Thaqlain explored, misinterpreted, and denied..

[@alialshammari537]

If you said molokhia is your favorite food i just wanna say your special to me 😂

[@sonabarnes6670]

God bless you!

[@hayderpak]

Living in 2023 and still this is the biggest concern? calling Ayesha a trial for the prophet whereas sources claim her to be his most favourite after Hazrat khadija. May Allah remove all the hatred in your heart for the righteous wife and caliphs and cleanse your heart. We however won’t stoop to your level and belittle the great Hazrat Ali just because your scholars repeatedly do that with the rightly guided caliphs and Ayesha. You being asked such foolish questions that ‘did the prophet know about Ayesha having bad in her heart for imam Ali?’ And you actually answering it with we believe he did literally disqualifies you as a scholar since a more simple and rather apt answer would’ve been Allah knows best because we literally can’t know that 🤦‍♂️ may Allah guide you sheikh.

[@Zulfiqar32]

History will always be relevant. Those who ignore history are doomed to repeat it.

[@zak992]

@@Zulfiqar32 NOT this kind of history. seems you getting your history mixed up as this lecture is sectarianism, should be titled long live sunni shia sectarianism and hatred, shame this is the best we can do shame on us all

[@Zulfiqar32]

@@zak992 the Shiekh is simply narrating references from history. If this goes against your preconceptions and makes you uncomfortable, you can simply choose to ignore the facts and pretend what you believe is still as true as ever. But you being uncomfortable shouldnt stop anyone else from discussing these topics

[@moono9614]

EXACTLY!

[@HadithOfThaqlain]

You need to study your own books. Here are some hadiths for you to read that would likely boggle your mind: Imam Ali Telling Rasulallah To Divorce Aisha: bukhari:4750 bukhari:4141 bukhari:2661 muslim:2770a Aisha Was A Test: bukhari:7100 bukhari:3772 Aisha’s House is where Satan's head would come out: bukhari:3104 Aisha & Hafsa Against Rasulallah: bukhari:4915 bukhari:4914 bukhari:4913 bukhari:4916 muslim:1479b muslim:1479d muslim:1479e ahmad:222 ahmad:339 Umar Talking Trash About Aisha: muslim:1479b ahmad:222 bukhari:5843 muslim:1479e muslim:1479a Aisha Hitting Rasulallah: nasai:3955 ibnmajah:2334 Aisha Has A Devil with her: nasai:3960 Do Not Be Misled By Aisha: bukhari:5218 bukhari:4913 muslim:1479a muslim:1479b muslim:1479e ahmad:222 Prophet telling aisha to breastfeed a man (sahih hadith) muslim:1453a abudawud:2061 Wives Differed With Aisha On Breastfeeding: ibnmajah:1947 Aisha Doesn’t Like Mentioning Imam Ali: bukhari:665 tirmidhi:3657 ibnmajah:1235 muslim:418b muslim:418c Abu Bakr Scolding Aisha: muslim:367a abudawud:320 Aisha Spying On Rasulallah: muslim:974b nasai:3964 nasai:3963 Aisha Was Bewitched: adab:162 Aisha used to hate praying with hands on the flank bukhari:3458 Aisha Desired Abu Bakr To Be Caliph: muslim:418d muslim:418e Aisha’s Lies/Obscenity: mishkat:3278 muslim:1474b muslim:1474a bukhari:6691 bukhari:5268 nasai:3958 Aisha Beating Children: adab:142 Rasulallah Doesn’t Trust Aisha (incident of ifk): muslim:2770a bukhari:4141 Rasulallah Anxious With Aisha: bukhari:3774 Aisha Sharing Others Private Life: bukhari:5825 Aisha’s Blood Play: bukhari:312 ibnmajah:652 abudawud:364 muslim:293b bukhari:309 Aisha Compared To Bone Broth: bukhari:3769 bukhari:3770 tirmidhi:3887 bukhari:3411 Abu Bakr Hitting Aisha: bukhari:6845 bukhari:6844 bukhari:4608 muslim:1478 Aisha/Women Compared To Animals: muslim:512d bukhari:511 bukhari:514 bukhari:519 ibnmajah:950 tirmidhi:338 ibnmajah:951 ibnmajah:952 ibnmajah:953 Aisha’s suspicion: bukhari:299 bukhari:297 muslim:290 ibnmajah:538 muslim:288a abudawud:371 muslim:1453d tirmidhi:116 bukhari:4450 bukhari:302 bukhari:261 abudawud:2061 bukhari:2647 mishkat:546 muslim:350 tirmidhi:728 muslim:293b bukhari:5191 ibnmajah:1943 muslim:1453e muslim:301 muslim:288b muslim:288c muslim:291a muslim:293a muslim:294 muslim:321d tirmidhi:116 bukhari:303 muslim:1449a muslim:1453a muslim:1453b muslim:1454 muslim:1453c muslim:1455a ibnmajah:1945 ibnmajah:608 tirmidhi:132 ibnmajah:539 ibnmajah:538 ibnmajah:537 ibnmajah:536 muslim:301 bukhari:5102 Aisha’s Obscenity/Disrespect: nasai:3957 mishkat:3278 muslim:1464a tirmidhi:3691 muslim:1474b bukhari:3818 muslim:2435d bukhari:3821 muslim:2435b riyadussalihin:344 muslim:1479a bukhari:5843 bukhari:2468 bukhari:6691 bukhari:5268 nasai:3955 ibnmajah:2334 nasai:3956 abudawud:3567 nasai:3958 nasai:3959 tirmidhi:2502 muslim:2437 tirmidhi:1359 bukhari:513 bukhari:519 bukhari:3816 bukhari:3817 ahmad:772 bukhari:4913 bukhari:4912 bukhari:4915 bukhari:4916 muslim:1479b muslim:1479d muslim:1479e ahmad:222 ahmad:339 muslim:314b muslim:310 tirmidhi:3875 tirmidhi:3876 muslim:2165c muslim:2165a muslim:2165d bukhari:7484 bukhari:382 bukhari:383 bukhari:384 bukhari:6004 muslim:1462 bukhari:515 bukhari:514 bukhari:511 bukhari:5229 bukhari:5267 abudawud:4875 nasai:3421 Aisha Using Excuses For Laziness: muslim:298a muslim:298b muslim:299 tirmidhi:134 Go through the above hadiths with an open mind and see how it contradicts commonly held beliefs among Ahl-e-"Sunnat". Try again.

[@moono9614]

I can't remember where the comments are, but someone said something about the horns of Satan in Aisha's house! Well, I got the truthful information I would like to share with you all to educate and teach the uneducated, ignorant and the source of fitnah as it is my duty as a Muslim to spread the truth for the future In sha Allah :) !!! So basically I did my research about “The horns of shaytan” and as I suspected you got it completely and utterly wrong!, not surprised, from the channel :( Praise be to Allah for giving us this opportunity to defend the Prophet’s wife. Truly what an amazing honor this is. May Allah raise us up with those who defend the Ahlel Bayt, as opposed to those who slander the blessed Ahlel Bayt. As for those who slander and insult the Prophet’s own wives, we can only imagine the Prophet’s anger towards these erring people; indeed, not even the vilest and most debased Shia would tolerate someone insulting his own wife! It will be the Ahlus Sunnah wal Jama’ah that will forever guard the honor of our Beloved’s beloved. Despite the fact that Umm al Mu’mineen Aisha is part of the blessed Ahlel Bayt, the Shia propagandists revile her; of the many slanders they utter against her, one of their favorites is to claim that the “horns of Satan” or the “head of Satan” would emerge from Aisha’s house. This is based on their horrible misinterpretation of Sunni Hadith which they then propagate amongst the ignorant ones amongst the Sunnis. The Prophet of Allah (PBUH&HF) warned the Ummah against her on several occasions… Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith: 4.336 Narrated Abdullah: The Prophet stood up and delivered a sermon, and pointed to the house of Aisha, and said: “Fitna (trouble/sedition) is right here,” saying three times, “from where the side of the Satan’s head comes out.” In the above tradition the Prophet predicted the sedition which Aisha will bring for Muslims and that she will be seduced by Satan for instigating the first civil war in the history of Islam. Muslim has also related in his Sahih from Ikrima Ibn Ammar from Salim from Ibn Umar who said: “The Prophet of Allah (PBUH&HF) emerged from the house of Aisha and said. ‘The pivot of disbelief is from here, where the horns of Satan will rise.’” Sunni reference: Sahih Muslim, Arabic version, the Chapter of Seditions, v4, p2229 Unbeknownst to many Shia is the fact that this same Hadith is used by the Anti-Islam Orientalists (i.e. Non-Muslims) who seek to defile the good name of Prophet Muhammad. These Orientalists argue that the Prophet predicted that Satan’s horns would emerge from Aisha’s house, and then they are quick to mention that the Prophet himself was buried inside Aisha’s house! It is disconcerting how the Shia propagandists-in their overzealous attempts to slander the Ahlel Bayt (i.e. the Prophet’s wives)-have unwittingly allied themselves with Orientalists. Indeed, if the Hadith in question is actually in reference to Aisha’s house, then nobody can deny that the Orientalists have rightfully pointed out that the Prophet was buried in that same house. If we take this interpretation, then we are led to the conclusion that Satan’s horn emerged from the Prophet himself; this claim has been made by the Christians for a very long time, whereby they argue that Prophet Muhammad was not sent by Allah but was rather one of Satan’s agents. The Christians argue that the Prophet was doomed by his own prophecy, in a similar fashion that Mirza Ghulam Ahmed of the Qadianis was doomed by his own prophecy. (Mirza Ghulam Ahmed had claimed to be a prophet after our Prophet Muhammad; he also prophecized that false prophets die from illnesses such as cholera. Ironically, Mirza Ghulam Ahmed himself died from cholera.) Today, a very large mosque is built over Aisha’s house, known as al-Masjid al-Nabawi (the Prophet’s Mosque). Are the Shia implying that the Horn of Satan would emerge from the second holiest mosque of Islam? Do they say that the Horn of Satan would emerge from the Prophet’s Mosque (not “Aisha’s Mosque”)? The Shia are agreed upon the sanctity of the Prophet’s Mosque, and yet at the same time they dare to make accusations that this was the site from where Satan’s horns would emerge? The Hadiths in Question In fact, the Hadiths in question have nothing at all to do with Aisha, but rather the Prophet was simply pointing in the direction of the East towards Iraq (i.e. the Persian Empire at that time). An analogy of this is if a man asks which direction is Qiblah, and his friend points towards a certain house on the street. This simply means that Qiblah is in that direction. The Prophet did not at all mean that Aisha’s house would be the source of Satan’s horns, but rather he meant the East. In relation to where the Prophet was standing, Aisha’s house simply happened to be in the direction of the East.

[@Thaqlain]

Episode on the "Horn of Shaytaan": kzbin.info/www/bejne/iarTmaZjbNWHfc0 Episode of "Burial of Prophet in Ayesha's room": kzbin.info/www/bejne/jHnakmOZqbagnLM The point here is simple, being someone who has so much of a controversial character in the Quran (Surah Tahrim), in hadith (horn of Shaytan and Ifk), in history (Jamal and standing against the Imam of her time), should we consider her a source to know Prophet's seerah? We have nothing personal against her but being a wife of a Prophet is never a virtue. Prophet's had wives who were evil and Pharaoh's wives is promised heaven.

[@playstation9435]

Maybe he meant India, that's also East. We have a big Shaitaan called Modi there!! Or it could be even far east, like China. Given what they are doing to our Muslim brothers there I don't see them less than any Shaitaan. Or could it be Myanmar? After what they have done to Rohingya Muslims. All of these countries in the East.

[@sraabia]

Jazakallah!! i really appreaciate your efforts in favor of Syeda Aisha r.z may Allah SWT give you ajr for it

[@moono9614]

@@sraabia Ameen ❤❤❤ JazakAllah khairun :) I tried my best, even though I know I wouldn't be able to fully do justice to what she deserves. May Allah SWT bless you and your family ameen!

[@H00H-H00H]

I can’t believe that u are using sunni hadiths to prove to the shia that she was at right 🤦‍♂️ please know how to use hadiths to prove ur point in front of who

[@raihaankhattak6753]

The wives of the prophets that went to hell were disbelievers

[@Thaqlain]

This lecture is not focused on whether Ayesha is in hell or not :)

[@QuestVault]

Third!!!

[@QuestVault]

@Bahrom Olimov 🤣🤣🤣 Salamalikoum brother

[@observer3814]

Very poisonous lecture. This speech will lead a man to the Hell

[@Thaqlain]

We will urge you to listen from episode 198. Will answer a lot of your concerns.

[@user-eh2pv4sc7h]

How can that be. Read quran and see what Allah says about the two wives.

[@chirazzk8095]

ayesha as is ahl bayt and umm al momineen .. double the honor ... shias need to read the quran for a change.....

[@Thaqlain]

She never claimed she was Ahlulbayt and her status in the Quran has been covered in detail in this chapter.

[@chirazzk8095]

@@Thaqlain Allah is claiming she s ahl bayt ……… Don’t you read the Quran

[@Thaqlain]

Nope. Nowhere has Allah claimed wives to be Ahlulbayt. The tenses Allah has used in the portion related to Ahlulbayt is different from the portion where he has talked about wives. Also, Ayesha herself has shared the names of those who are Ahlulbayt. Please check Tafsir al-Kashhaf by Allama Zamakshari.

[@chirazzk8095]

@@Thaqlain the context of 33:33 are only wives the tense goes to masculine plural cuz Allah is addressing the prophet saw and his wives and اهل is masculine by nature …. Further proof from the Quran is 11:73 … where the wife of Ibrahim is called ahl bayt directly …. You Shias don’t read the Quran

[@Thaqlain]

Seems like Ayesha, Umm Salamah and the rest of the wives were not aware of it 🙂 Neither was Allah (subhanahu wa ta'ala) who rebuked two wives in Surah Tahrim. Neither were countless Ahlal Sunnah scholars who shared the incident of the cloak. And neither was the Prophet who denied his wives access to the cloak. So please, don't force your meanings onto the Quran. And if you have a differing opinion, ask the Prophet. That's what the Quran commands you to do.

[@fatimaaaedits]

Second

[@chapabazindicator]

Your intellect is Better than prophet?

[@Thaqlain]

And how is that related to this video?

[@raihaankhattak6753]

This lecture is deranged.

[@Thaqlain]

If you haven't watched previous episodes , which share the aim of this examination, you will definitely find this episode to be disturbing.

[@Yondaime_Legacy]

Remember no matter how much or how many times you insult aisha, she is still gonna be praised and will remain praiseworthy for eternity. She is the wife of the prophet and the prophet loved her than everyone (Including All The Ahlul Bayt). The only one whom maybe the prophet loved than Aisha is ABU BAKR THE GREA. You are the real hypocrites o shias.

[@tariqabbas14]

Hazrat Khatija alaihissalam was dear to Prophet Muhammad saww because she believed and helped Prophet Muhammad saww when nobody did. Prophet Muhammad saww never married to another woman until Hazart Khatija alaihissalam was alive and Prophet Muhammad saww declared one whole year of sorrow on her death. After Hazart Khatija as, Prophet Muhammad saww married many women and he treated them equally although some of wives (Hazart Ashiah and Hafsa) created problems for Prophet Muhammad saww. Most loved people for Prophet Muhammad saww are his own progeny (Ahlulbait a.s).

[@Yondaime_Legacy]

@@tariqabbas14 no need to debate a person who believes in fabricated lies

[@tariqabbas14]

@@Yondaime_Legacy I can only say to those who knowingly believe on fabricated lies "lanatullah alal qomez zalim wa kazibeen ✋" Wsalam

[@Yondaime_Legacy]

@@tariqabbas14 its funny how you guys think your curses are working but are actually working on yourselves

[@ethandouro4334]

@@Yondaime_Legacy Changing the topic isn't innit

[@ShahiidiMaseruka]

True 🎉