When the Killer Thinks He's Going Home

Get NordVPN 2Y plan + 4 months free here ➼ nordvpn.com/thatchapter It’s risk-free with Nord’s 30-day money-back guarantee!
Allyzibeth Lamont never returned after finishing her work shift at Halloween. The search to find her came up empty, until the police could finally speak with her employers, James Duffy and Georgios Kakavelos. And James had quite the story to tell...
Exclusive Stories on That Chapter Podcast, available on all podcast platforms
Bonus Videos on Patreon ► / thatchapter
Follow me on Twitter ► / that_chapter
Follow me on Instagram ► / that_chapter
Sources► pastebin.com/udEpKQCm
For business enquires please email [e-mail]

[@ThatChapter]

🌏 Get NordVPN 2Y plan + 4 months free here ➼ nordvpn.com/thatchapter It’s risk-free with Nord’s 30-day money-back guarantee! ✌

[@dinapaul6176]

Hey mine just love your videos. I've seen every single one

[@here4funyadig]

Thanks for always putting out such great content ! I hope you have an amazing week as well !

[@superwildside4585]

Those chemtrails you say don't exist are outlawed in Maine and Texas now, and the world is still flat.

[@starryadventure8922]

I went back to 6 years ago when I first started watching, and im re watching the videos. They're so funny to watch and see how far you've come. I just wanted to say thanks for sticking with giving us great content. Do miss some of you dropping your f bombs on weird things, though 😂

[@anjachan]

@@superwildside4585 what 😂

[@leveluppupgaming7207]

Hey Mike, you don't know me but a while back I left you a comment about how I left me stressful and toxic job for something else. I found a job that's isn't toxic or poisonous and got back into gaming. I just wanted to say that watching you when you had 5k subscribers to 1.9 million is one of the things that encouraged me to try something on my own and you know....give it a goo. So I just wanted to say if you've ever wondered if your work has effected anyone's life on a personal level, the answer is yes, for what it's worth. Best of luck in 2024 good sir. I'm sure I speak for all of your viewers when I say we love you too

[@victorialee7270]

Woop woop 🙌🏻

[@LookingAround-rs2km]

💙💙💙 Such a nice post. I don't know you but I'm so happy you're in a better place. Praise the Lord!

[@-xirx-]

5k, my god!

[@dsmusicbird]

Aw 🥹 Good for you! Got teary eyed reading your comment. Glad you’re out of a toxic environment.

[@aaronproctor4745]

Congrats on the new job

[@victoryv9575]

I'm amazed that people think murder will make a problem better...

[@KarmicSalt]

there are those that get away with it

[@jusbus92]

It does! Humans have lost their way if they're delusional enough to think that murder is never justified.

[@cletusgadsden2969]

He probably has done that before and got away with the crime.

[@RaccoonNation]

@@KarmicSaltthey never truly FULLY get away with it. If the law doesn’t catch them then they either get that weird “guilt cancer” or they end up in one form or another of karmic hell

[@ksgnation]

@@RaccoonNation I also think the longer they get away with it, the worse it’ll be once they’re finally caught

[@andysmith1996]

22:00 Did that lawyer really think wearing a bandana like an old west bandit instead of a face mask was going to make the jury like him?

[@kristinwojtowich8902]

🤭🤭🤭

[@troyromeyn5081]

I like the dudes mask with the screen around the mouth!😅

[@theresabreaud]

The mask don't work dummies

[@Malewifecore]

gloversville is a backwards ass place... lawyer in the bandana facemask makes sense

[@annika_panicka]

Maybe he'd just come from robbing a bank.

[@jamiekickaholeinthesky9513]

Will never be able to comprehend these people who commit murder as a way to cover up some much lesser crime

[@madsdee7803]

I bet he has murdered in the past and was covering up millions in scamming he's been doing in all of his businesses and private life. They never 'just' kill like that for so little. He was worried about his future scams not going ahead too.

[@sdriza]

​@madsdee7803 yeah, I bet this guy has a whole slew of skeletons in his closet

[@jazzliaz2789]

Its always insane when someone weighs their options and a human life comes out as the least valued.

[@goldenglowable]

Damn, what you said gave me chills.

[@NeffieJane85]

Well said

[@rabbit_bum]

Don't read the comments then. People are literally blaming the victim for not expecting to be murdered instead of blaming the murderers.... People literally too scared to blame bad people for doing bad things.

[@jazzliaz2789]

@rabbit_bum it's horrible. No one should expect to be killed for something like this. That poor girl was within her rights to go to work and expect to be respected. Like you said, horrible victim blaming, when it's reasonable to assume you won't be murdered for things.

[@davidhollenshead4892]

I understand her position working for criminals. For a while, I was unable to find a better job and also had to work under "apparent" criminals... When my manager at Domino's Pizza found out that I was supporting myself during my senior year of high school, and had even lived out of my car before finding shelter in an unfinished basement, my manager started keeping twenty dollars of my pay a night, for his "beer money". This was in Ann Arbor Michigan, which was and is not "a small town". When I tried to get a better job, I eventually learned that calls about my work reference "apparently" included being accused of "drunk driving while delivering pizzas" that I was moved into a non-driving position because they "felt sorry for me". As a Halfbreed, this was an easy false accusation to make, as the prejudiced view of Native Americans is that we "are all alcoholics". By the way, I was never moved into a "non-driving role" despite it being illegal to hire a minor for a delivery position. Keep in mind that the owners of the Ann Arbor Stores at that time was a couple whose main business "apparently" was importing cocaine, something that Mr. Tom Monahan knew as these were the first franchise owners of his empire. When the corporation, which bought the company from Mr. Monahan learned about Mr. and Mrs. Belnap's "business accivity", they took over their franchises by force, something they could easily do if they suspected criminal activity [like money laundering]...@@rabbit_bum

[@EvilFinian]

Never trust a company that say they will treat the employees like family. Pretty much a code for they will take advantage of you.

[@finleyrosebud5791]

Yeah that always sounds like "we expect you to do more than we pay you for" to me.

[@lostandfound5145]

I have to ask, is there a good Finian?

[@Garbeaux.]

Like nah. I want you to be professional and treat me like an employee.

[@twobrokeguyz1214]

Weird, sad when we treat our family worse than we do our friends and acquaintances.

[@jackcole1120]

​@@lostandfound5145evil Finian is a good Finian, he took the time to write a comment telling us all a good tid bit of advice to avoid a toxic workplace.

[@TheOnlyDTM]

she literally died for no reason. some people are just evil. smh. rip to ally

[@JohnP538]

When you owe the IRS $120K, you know you are going to end up in jail.

[@nacho_ncam]

​@JohnP538 when you mvrder someone, you're going to go prison for life most likely. I bet he would've loved to take that tax evasion charge at this point. Like the OP said: she died for no reason.

[@user-pq6xi8ls1o]

My God. How do these clowns find each other? To even consider something as evil and sick as this deed was is just unfathomable to me. They are where they belong forever, and poor Elizabeth didn't deserve this. My sincerest condolences to her loved ones. Senseless and unforgivable.

[@dementedpuppy]

Food service apparently lol

[@supme7558]

What would somone do too deserve this ?

[@kbb3672]

The younger guy seems to have some kind of slow minded mental issues, like he probably was very easily manipulated. Probably the bosses number one yes man

[@user-pq6xi8ls1o]

@@kbb3672 It don't take much for him apparently. Just a case of beer, meth + pipe, porn, 20-50 bucks, he will do whatever to whomever, whenever, just keep it flowing. They were both unsuspecting monsters. I can't even imagine the conversations while preparing deli sandwiches and taking out the trash. Unbelievable

[@razztazz1982]

When you're dealing with a criminal boss, it's always best to leave before turning them in to the Authorities. Poor woman.

[@BrianKenney-ob5uv]

Of course she had no right to be killed by staying but how did they know it was her who filed the complaint? I imagine you can file complaints with most of not all government agencies anonymously. I find it odd she be so willing to be alone with them after her knowing they knew she was the one turning them in

[@BrianKenney-ob5uv]

Like did the investigator say “ ally told us “ or did the numbers just point to her since it was just George and James running the place with Ally ? There had to be more employees.. idk I guess we will never know I just think it be total BS and a tragedy that a government official put Ally at risk by admitting she’s the one turning in the business and her know knowing . I just personally would not wanna be alone with someone I just turned into the government

[@BrianKenney-ob5uv]

*not knowing

[@Ze_Moose]

I kinda wish she left after 2 weeks when her paycheck didn't look right 😔

[@BornIn1500]

@@BrianKenney-ob5uv Seems like very few people worked there. And when only one employee is complaining, it's easy to see who turned them in. He also said she was threatening turning them in and that when they showed up, she was telling them everything. It was obvious and she didn't hide it.

[@pickles3128]

Whenever a boss says "we're all a big family here" it's a red flag that really means, "I expect you to put in extra without compensation; also don't expect a raise or too much.. You wouldn't be so greedy with your own family, would you?"

[@tanyaedwards4574]

yep, I work as an independent franchisee, and the whole franchise is built on "family values, until you need help...

[@kenw2225]

This 👆

[@CantTellYou]

but... it’s the American way! 😢 🇺🇸

[@ordinaryadonis8711]

I’ve had many jobs in my 36 yrs. Only the ones that play the family card have ever tried shady crap.

[@paulcarpenter7844]

Your right

[@lifesajoke6965]

The first time an employer doesn't pay you on time, in full, walk away. It will never end well.

[@annabambus6572]

The lrish are simply some of the world's best story tellers. Mike is definitely one. Combining facts with humour, both tongue in cheek and dark, with little doses of sarcasm, irony and down to earth no BS. Love it ❤🎉

[@portishphonic]

Very well said. The Irish are a gift to the world.

[@prisonersforprofit]

brave girl to expose this corrupt p.o.s. whistle blowers need to be protected, not mocked and shamed, or put in danger.

[@damac5136]

Tell that to your government.

[@footrot17]

Snitches

[@TheRoadhammer379]

Whistleblowers are protected in the United States unless you are blowing the whistle on the government, 😂

[@golderp]

Brave I agree, but stupid. May her soul rest in peace.

[@MarioGoatse]

What if you’re trying to sleep and they’re really really loud though? They’re in your ear like *BRRRRRRRRR BRRRRRRRRR BRRRRRR*?

[@Carlzz92]

"She's a great worker we just want her back to work" What a bizarre statement.

[@Lokisdottir1964]

I thought it was suspicious when he said "he doesn't have the balls to do that". Do what? What do you know about what was done?

[@onaematopia]

For some reason, I instantly thought of Tony Soprano when I heard that 🤣

[@tictacmothma]

What's bizarre about that? It's a very nice compliment. I've been glad to have it said about me many times when seasonal employers want me to return.

[@chrisjackman9102]

@@tictacmothmayou weren’t missing or dead 🤣

[@tictacmothma]

@@chrisjackman9102If you feel that you have to be missing or dead to be appreciated at work, you are in a sad life.

[@pattysplayland2511]

Hey Mike, before I even watch this video I want to tell you I live near where this took place. I'm from Schenectady, NY and there was a murder in November 2022 that you should look into. It hasn't been solved. A 15 year old girl named Samantha Humphrey was murdered and dumped in the Mohawk River. If you could look into it and make a video about it, it could possibly help solve it. Thanks Mike.

[@Protagonistinfluence]

Wearing a bandit scarf as a face mask in court was certainly a choice

[@veronicamarrs]

And a bold one at that

[@MrDwarfpitcher]

I passed it off as 'this lawyer really does not want this case on his curricula'. Such a clear cut case of who was guilty, yet you took the job and now have to try and defend the undefendable. That or the lawyer was thinking with a very different strategy

[@masterbanguzai805]

when your lawyer shows up with a bandanna as a face mask "classic wild west American outlaw style" your goose is cooked

[@selecttravelvacations7472]

It was probably early on during Covid when there was a a shortage of masks and it was recommended we use what we can.

[@A6Legit]

And the Hannibal lector clear face mask 😂 wtf

[@TheRealEMURSE]

@@selecttravelvacations7472 we recommended common sense was used , as well

[@alisong2328]

He looked like an outlaw - a highwayman. 🥷🏽

[@annika_panicka]

He probably just came from holding up a bank.

[@sandibaker5298]

Wow! If he treated her like his own daughters, the’d better check on the daughters! What a HUGE POS!

[@rabbott9938]

George said that James doesn't have the balls to do anything like this but meanwhile they hadn't even figured out what had happened yet. So how did he know what this was?

[@kaylaloveslilpeepforever6825]

Also he said they WERE friends...

[@SnowWhite717_]

The thing that makes me know that our Mike here is a good egg is the fact he’s been wearing that shirt for 2 1/2 years. The blue one like it too. Why have I noticed you ask? Well I’m a type A OCD type and the collars have always driven me crazy… I just want to iron the neck for him. 😅 But knowing he has been wearing the same things since the beginning shows he’s still good ol Mike, and that is wonderful thing to know. ❤ Tanks Mike

[@tapoemt3995]

Calling him a crackhead while wrapped up in a bandana. 🤣🤣

[@michaels.330]

Your neurons must be firing at it's lowest capacity

[@tapoemt3995]

@@michaels.330 Did you mean to say "Your neurons must be firing at THEIR lowest capacities" or "Your neuron must be firing at it's lowest capacity"? We see how yours are firing. Go back to the kiddie table, the adults are talking.

[@abiadams5957]

I think it's just his covid mask haha I would rather wear a bandana then mask tbf

[@lllaaauuurrraaa]

"You don't hire an angel to do the devil's job." Someone in the DA's office has a creative writing degree. *chef's kiss*

[@tictacmothma]

It's a common figure of speech. 🤷

[@jonathancasillas218]

I know this is a small detail but thank you for not having overplayed stock hip-hop beats in your intros that a lot of other channels have

[@johns1625]

21:48 World's Greasiest Defense Attorney?? This guy could tell me there's 26 letters in the alphabet and I'd still feel the need to wash my hands and count them myself rather than take his word for it.

[@George-ri6vg]

I am originally from Greece and I had to work in the restaurants for many years as a waiter. The Greek employers are the worst. They treat their employees like crap and they evade taxes. I’m so sorry to hear this story . It’s terrible to hear happened to this girl

[@ZeusKabooze]

100% worst boss I ever had. Purposely underpaid me, stole my tips and overall douche bag. His wife was worst!

[@sammygirl6910]

My two worst bosses were Greek.

[@Unfluencer]

immigrants in general are best to avoid.

[@denisehagwood4542]

​@@ZeusKabooze how was the wife worse than the person literally stealing your money?

[@supme7558]

Thats pretty much anyware

[@divinedevil]

Does another life mean nothing to people now? Killing an innocent girl just because she wanted to be paid legally! That's just horrendous. RIP Ally

[@jordanbabcock9349]

Now..? This story is a million years old.

[@lainyfromrainypnw]

It has been going since the beginning of humankind. Look at the story of Cain & Able. A family member killing another family member bc of jealousy & greed.

[@bocephusbirchcull4044]

@@lainyfromrainypnwCain and Abel weren’t real people.

[@user-gq5su8ek7h]

@@bocephusbirchcull4044still a similar concept though even so

[@laleona776]

​@@bocephusbirchcull4044 of course they were. Next you'll be saying Napoleon, Cleopatra & Anthony weren't real either huh😂🤣

[@thejayst3r]

Ive seen a lot of people in the comments say that they knew that the owner was guilty because he said the other guy wouldn’t have the balls, but personally I thought he was guilty because he said the phrase “they were buddies” past tense. Before they even found a body. At that point, she was still a missing person, but he clearly knew she was dead.

[@-BUGZ-]

As soon as the boss said they “were” friends, they “were” buddies, I knew it.

[@timgreen2426]

I noticed they both did that, referred to her in past tense

[@-BUGZ-]

@@timgreen2426 Yep, and this was obviously while they “just wanted their friend/ coworker back” and thought she was just missing. No idea how it wasn’t mentioned lol I don’t normally catch things like that either.

[@a_lucientes]

What an absolute psychopath. Just unbelievable. Over what was prbly a few thousand dollars. To do that to this innocent, child really, bc he's a thief who refused to pay people what he owed .

[@mab5710]

A few thousand dollars?? Did you miss the part where she reported him and completely ruined his business/life that he spent 30 years building? She could've walked away, quit and gotten a new job. But she chose to rat him out.

[@sunlitmanna3698]

​@@mab5710 ain't no way bruv is shaming her 💀

[@sunnykim4791]

@@sunlitmanna3698watch him change his mind quickly once he’s the one in Ally’s predicament

[@Stephjvb]

Are you that stupid? ​@@mab5710

[@madsdee7803]

It would have worked out at more than a few thousand since he'd have been doing that scamming in his other businesses and personal enterprises. I wouldn't be surprised if he's a serial killer in the US and where he moved from.

[@joeymims5852]

I knew the boss was guilty of something half way through when they askled him if he thought James could have done something to her, and his response was " he doesnt have the balls" I think is what he said. That was such a weird response, and which makes the story of how James gave him drugs and beer and 500 dlrs to do it believable to me.

[@SabrinaMeShell]

For me, it was the moment when he stated that he supposedly gave her the money and told her to "be good." Also when he stated he treated her like his own daughter was chilling. Nope! Thankfully Mr G was transparent as glass. He and JD are both monsters.

[@eh1702]

Absolutely! I thought he was gonna say, “he doesn’t have” that sort of character, or any reason to, or no anger issues, or something.

[@DocBree13]

Yep

[@supme7558]

Not realy tgats street talk for no he dosnt have the personality..slang is slang dont make things up to fit a naritive

[@eh1702]

@@supme7558 Oh, come ON, how dumb do you think people are?! He was asked, could his employee have “done something to her”. Saying “he doesn’t have the balls for it” means he doesn’t have the COURAGE. So *inappropriate* a word when talking about harming an unsuspecting young girl.

[@Lokisdottir1964]

OK, that Gordon Ramsey insert was hysterical - and true! I love how people who take advantage of others expect loyalty from those people and call them "traitors" when they object to being used.

[@Mega888888881]

I am from Greece and very sad for this evil man who disgrased our country .So sorry for this brave girl!

[@supme7558]

They do not represent you ..unless you feel guilty about something

[@ronjames4151]

Greece is pretty well known for how bad women are treated as far as sexual assault and harassment

[@molybdomancer195]

I thought it was weird when the owner said James wouldn’t have the balls to murder Ally. If someone asked me if a colleague murdered someone my first reaction would be they didn’t have the anger or violence to do it, not the balls.

[@jenniehughes6927]

Not that bright to report someone for fraud and then continue working for them. Js

[@laurenwest3090]

And that he was talking about her in past tense, big red flag!

[@meganlynn83]

RIGHT?!? In my head I'd be like, 'Sir, you sound sus as hell.'

[@Ze_Moose]

Why Almond Joy bar though? Does that help with anxiety after committing a crime? 🤔

[@pw6002]

@@jenniehughes6927 You don’t always have the choice, especially in small towns.

[@Delicate_Disaster]

I love how Mike always says "If you can believe that" after the most reasonable and believable parts of the story. "It was under renovations ar that time; if you can believe that." 😂

[@amazing_bastard]

It just sounded too suspicious to be a coincidence, which turns out, was in fact not a coincidence

[@ajdarko8531]

When I was 19, I worked at a nursery (plants and landscaping). The owner paid me under the table for a year..and I thought, cool..don't have to give my money to the government. More in my pocket. He bought my lunch every day and promised me a weeks paid vacation if I stayed a whole year, which I did. Called out twice for being sick. When the year had passed, he told me I hadn't worked hard enough and I didn't deserve it. I didn't know he was about to go out of business at the time. Told my dad, who lived 50 miles away everything that had happened and he drove straight down and threatened to have him audited. I had never told him I was being paid under the table. He was mad at me for taking a job like that but I often wonder what he would have done had I confronted my boss about turning him in to the IRS instead of my dad. Long story short..he wrote him a check for my vacation time to keep him from calling anyone. He lost his business about a year later. I still wonder if my dad called them anyway lol.

[@AwildaOcasio]

Ask your daddy

[@sdriza]

Just be careful when doing stuff like this... seemingly normal people are capable of doing some crazy stuff when money is involved

[@bleq6zzz586]

Yeah you might be the next video if you keep running around putting yourself in stupid dangerous situations with people be more aware the world is a dangerous place I was shot at over 20$ worth of pot lok

[@WillowAnne0]

This happened where I live so incredibly sad! The sandwich shop, when it was open, is right next to a liquor store… it’s all boarded up there now. 😢 There is soooo much corruption in the Gloversville police department and court system, I’m so glad this was solved and not covered up.

[@kristinwojtowich8902]

Oh shit, really? I wonder if that's why "statistically," the crime rate is seen as so low there? 🤔

[@WillowAnne0]

@@kristinwojtowich8902 that’s exactly what I was thinking because for a small town there is a lot going on there. What’s weird is Johnstown which is literally right next to Gloversville is soooo much better. As far as I know the police seem to do there jobs better, at least it seems that way. I just moved out of Gloversville because of how bad the police department is. I want to file a complaint but I’m scared. They’ve threatened to have me committed. You just never know what people are capable of.

[@rhondasisco-cleveland2665]

Employers, right? They expect you to keep their secrets, and enable them to break rules… or drive yourself into the ground to perform all that’s required. This girl didn’t play the game, she had spunk & that might have taken her a long way. She must have had some sense of her worth, how terrible that will never have a chance to be realized. Her family isn’t focused on here, but I wonder how they are. I wonder what they think she would have done & what she dreamt of becoming as a child. Hope you’re doing ok, family people.

[@davidhollenshead4892]

Ouch, yes it really sucks to think about the victim's stolen life.......

[@justinx9892]

She could’ve just quit the job but became a snitch.

[@kristinwojtowich8902]

​@@justinx9892once again, here you are victim blaming. It's not snitching to do what's necessary to get a fair wage, snd it's actually commendable that she reported it so no future employees got taken advantage of either. Your comment says alot about you as a person; I hope you don't own a business. Ppl might have to keep you on a watch list.

[@rhondasisco-cleveland2665]

@@justinx9892 snitch? What are you 9? 😂

[@rhondasisco-cleveland2665]

@@kristinwojtowich8902 they are probably a child. It’s a childish thing to say, isn’t it?

[@LeilaniOhMy]

I’m actually from and still live where this case happened. The place where, unfortunately, Allyzibeth’s life was taken from her is like maybe two streets away from where I currently live-it’s a shipping center now. My mom used to waitress for Georgios Kakavelos way back in the day at a restaurant him and his now ex-wife owned. She told me (even before all this happened) that he would always hit on the younger female employees (my mom included).

[@melissamoonchild9216]

why am I not surprised

[@MKUltra42]

These a-holes always do. 😠

[@LeilaniOhMy]

@@MKUltra42and unfortunately he’s not the only creep restaurant owner around here 🙄

[@MKUltra42]

@@LeilaniOhMy So gross. We had one who was notorious in the town where I live. Some people had no idea and absolutely loved him but all the women who were servers at his restaurants knew and word got around. Drunk all the time, crashed his car into the restaurant, all sorts of money shenanigans. Things were starting to get out and they found him hanged in the restaurant restroom. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@LeilaniOhMy]

@@MKUltra42 oh wow 😯 and I’m honestly surprised this other restaurant owner hasn’t been officially “outed” yet. My mom worked for this one too and I’m pretty sure he fired her for not sleeping with him 🤢

[@jeremygarcia1396]

Honestly seeing the many different masks they used during the court case made me chuckle a little 💀

[@perfectlyimperfectangie]

One part that stood out to me was when the owner said James didn't have the balls to do something to her. Who says that in that way, no one but a guilty person.

[@freeshrugs63]

Absolutely despicable. I worked for a pizza joint as a teenager and trusted my managers completely. Turns out they were great people. But would I have known the difference?

[@badgalriri2354]

Yet another great video Mike! Thanks for the past 4Years helping me through Chemo & thanks to the That Chapter Family for support too! Love you back 😅❤

[@wallhagens2001]

Cancer survivor myself. Hope you are clear and recovering from chemo. ❤ It’s a slog.

[@arkansaninva]

I'm also a cancer survivor. I hope you're doing well! Chemo is awful

[@sassycat6468]

Sending you love and prayers x

[@harridan.]

sending love from new mexico

[@Amy-iq7dd]

❤ from Michigan

[@GarageMuzik]

As soon as I saw their pictures, I knew it 100%. Such a sad story and poor girl did not deserve that. My deepest condolences to her family, Im sure she is terribly missed by everyone she knew. I hope everyone sees their paperwork in prison and they get what they deserve, every single day.

[@gwenna1161]

he would have gotten a lot less time had he just made right on the books and tax charges. how he thought a drug addict would be able to keep his mouth shut is mind boggling.

[@andrewhosfeld]

"In fact he made a demand that he wanted a document or something signed by the DA if he said something he wanted to be immune from prosecution.” All I could think after hearing that was, "It's a bold strategy, Cotton... let's see if it pays off for him..."

[@TheSharna23]

I didn't want to laugh, given the subject matter. But... That quote cracked me up! 😀🤣

[@alison5009]

If you can dodge a wrench, you can dodge a ball.

[@DocBree13]

😂

[@PersephoneRising333]

Effin A, Cotton..

[@Megan-wr6er]

LMAO

[@coreyfunk9313]

I was born and raised in Gloversville, never thought my hometown would be on That Chapter! I remember this when it happened, couldn’t believe it. Keep it up Mike, you’re doing great.

[@WVgirl1959]

Her boss wanted to kill her because he felt that she was getting the other employees against him in a union dispute. Can you imagine going to work (Or school) and being murdered? Every time I hear these stories, it amazes me.

[@switestgal1051]

“Drinking in the local graveyard” you say it with ease like it’s a normal thing to do

[@IamPinhead]

The defense attorney wearing a bandana and crackhead mullet might have harmed the character assassination attempt on James.

[@catdaddie]

LMFAO my first thought too, like, rich coming from THIS guy of all people

[@michaels.330]

Everything is perception Charles. What you perceive as mullet others perceive as slicked back. And when you perceive the bandanna as a negative connotation, again others might look at it as a piece of cloth. Or a simple item that is being utilized as a safety measure during COVID 19 restrictions. This perception might be your reality but it certainly isn't everyone's.

[@qossl6727]

Absolutely, I had to double check who this guy was, an unprofessional look never helps the defendant

[@evieyukihara7873]

I had just moved back to the area in Jan 2019 I remember this case so well. I feel so fucking bad for this girl to this day. It's so GROSS having a murder doc in your hometown. Chilling truly.

[@stonedsasquatch]

Not quite as weird as hearing our crime is so low

[@evieyukihara7873]

@@stonedsasquatch lol fr I glossed over that bc I thought it was absurd 🤣

[@strykersteel3914]

I had one in my old town too 😂 it's crazy to see the videos of the town throughout the storyline

[@sheenachristina2385]

I’m down the 29 in Galway. When I heard Johnston and Gloversville, my ears perked up, and I was transported back to 2019 when this all happened. I remember driving to work at Global Foundries and hearing they found her body in Malta. 😔

[@evieyukihara7873]

@@sheenachristina2385 she was a friend of my friends so I was basically there every step of the way. It's still so disheartening to think about.

[@nicogravel6645]

Hey Mike me and my friend used to watch you together hes sadly passed away recently… thank you for the memories you’ve provided me with him keep up the great work mate and much love from Canada . Much love

[@robertmosher7418]

If you know anyone being paid under the table like this, you do not have to be currently employed by anyone in order to report them and hire an employment attorney so you can recover lost wages. They will be forced to mail your attorney any lost pay.

[@TUNTALKS]

I'm from Birmingham in the U.K. But I spent a lot of time in Gloversville and Johnstown as I attended the SUNY Community College there. The thing many people do not understand about these up state "city's" is just how remote it is. I met so many people in Gloversville in Up State New York who had never been to New York City!!! The people up there are super strange, they're intelligent but they literally have nothing else to do, so I'm not surprised at all that something like this had happened there.

[@MM_CRWN]

I'd hate to die at work, feel for this girl

[@Ektalon]

What convinced me of his guilt was that he had all that time away from the shop and he didn’t call 911, he didn’t go to a police station, or even flag down a passing cop car.

[@Itsmemaiteg]

When they were being interviewed, they were talking about her in the past tense. That was a huge give away to me.

[@tokiwartuthe]

My favorite thing about being snowed in? Having a That Chapter video to watch!

[@ZkBublitz]

Mike: and it involves the two things I’m always thing about Me: life insurance and Halloween? Mike: Sandwiches and Halloween.

[@loveforeignaccents]

How awful for poor Allyzibeth and her family. Too bad James would do anything for that man and for money for drugs. And the big boss man is just a pure sleaze ball and ruined his own family's lives as well. Thanks for the video & have a good one!

[@shannsimms9072]

So I worked in sooo many different pizza places in my teenage/early 20’s. And this is so creepy. Because as a young girl working in pizza places you are CONSTANTLY harassed by the guys working the kitchen. Honestly anyone who’s ever worked at a pizza shop as a young woman can attest to this.

[@shannsimms9072]

God and I’ve seen soo many owners do so much shady ish

[@denisehagwood4542]

I've been harassed by men at every job I've had except one. It's such a shitty, scary feeling. The vet my dog goes to only has female employees (not on purpose. Most vets and vet techs are women for some reason) and I daydream about working there lol.

[@ElaAusDemTal]

​@@denisehagwood4542go and apply! Even if they don't have a job now, they might give you a chance later!

[@supme7558]

Worked in many sorry if the pizza joints you worked at had poor management many times i saw the wait staff herassing the kitchen staff ..they think there so much better becouse there the front face for the business and make tips ...even if it happend what did you do about it other then fawn?

[@shannsimms9072]

@@supme7558 none of the pizza stores I worked at had anything close to wait staff so I’m sure we’re talking about different types of establishments.

[@maryscott9430]

I cannot express adequately how much i appreciate that most of your videos cover less known cases. I get frustrated when i see dahmer, bundy, btk, watts, arias, anthony, blanchard,peterson etc over and over and over again. IMO its absolute crap that we continue to harp on these extremely well known cases.. keeping these pos murderers names in the spotlight. How about instead we cover less known cases whose victims deserve to have their names and stories told just as much, even if they werent killed by serial killers?? So thank you Mike.

[@lovewins7412]

Hey you! @ThatChapter Mike, just wanted to tell you something that you always tell your subscribers, take care, cuz I love ya! ❤ Truly appreciate your hard work and dedication to your channel. You help me out as a disabled 44 year old with severe spinal cord injuries that keep me bedridden 80% of each day. Thank you for your awesome content and your dedication to your fans by keeping That Chapter going. You always pay respect to the victims while telling the truth about the terrible,disgusting and truly stupid these monsters really are! There is no one else that compares to your authentic and unique character! You are a rare diamond on this massive platform and I look forward to always Giving it a goo with you so you stay safe out there, cuz I really do luv ya!

[@lovewins7412]

Just read my comment and saw that I left out the word “how” when commenting on HOW stupid these monsters are. Ironic? Hell no! I’m not a shady shit show like this killing “sack of shit”💩 😂 Again, take care of yourself, cuz I love ya!

[@rudolphsteiner6797]

It amazes me how far people will go for petty bullsh1t. I hope they are having a real hard time in jail.

[@kristienorsedragonwebber1328]

Also, “drinking in a graveyard with friends?” What? That doesn’t seem like a normal place to drink.

[@GhostlyEcheveria]

Thank you for reminding me that the term "Manson Lamps" exists. It takes me out every single time.

[@brookecole4300]

It's 10° outside and my day off! Nothing better then laying in bed under the covers watching a new video from Mike! Thank you!

[@LincolnJamesHeathrowIII]

Ny?

[@brookecole4300]

@@LincolnJamesHeathrowIII Oklahoma

[@LincolnJamesHeathrowIII]

@@brookecole4300 HELLO Oklahoma, this is Canada, it's like-14 celcus here we to, are mildy chilly. But like you, I'm in bed. Best place ever!.

[@LincolnJamesHeathrowIII]

@@brookecole4300 and have a good day. Its2:50pm here

[@hellpoint7534]

Also Canada but 3C/37F here and raining.

[@kimberlypatton205]

It only took 4 days to find the killers?What a couple of mental giants!

[@JDCullum]

I always appreciate it when an articulate judge publicly summarizes the callous, heinous behavior of the convicted criminal. It provides some consolation to hear the condemned being soundly condemned. Thank you, your Honor. Oh, and - as always- thank YOU Mike,

[@meghanhoulihan4512]

I live in Albany and worked in Saratoga at the time and I remember driving by when all the crime scene tape was up when they were recovering her body. It’s such a busy exit, very odd spot to choose to dispose of a body.

[@BrianKenney-ob5uv]

Can you make complaints to the department of labor anonymously or did the investigator come in and throw her under the bus without her knowing? I know a total irrelevant detail but interesting if to know if she knew that the owner knew it was her

[@WhatAWonderfulNameItIs]

Knowing the boss is a crook and a total cheapskate, Ally was probably his only worker…besides alcoholic/addict Jimmy…who wasn’t going to tell that he had a job being paid under the table. Like another commenter said, too bad she couldn’t have quit first, then reported it. Still might have gotten her killed, though. Dang! People are evil!

[@selecttravelvacations7472]

That’s what I wondered.

[@yelenaleszczynsky149]

I personally knew her sister...this was such a horrific crime in our area!

[@scalorasfx]

When I was 16/17 I worked in a restaurant for about week & half. Just long enough to collect my first check. One of the dishwashers who didn’t speak a lot of English told me he doesn’t pay her. I asked for how long & she said 2 months. I knew then s@!* wasn’t right & quite. Took me 2 weeks & a lot of demanding to get my check but I got paid (he gave me a money order) 🧐 Told her to tell everyone else to leave to. Place shut down 3 months later. People Sux! I feel so bad for that girl. She was just trying to make a living.

[@SLP0101]

Rest in peace to this poor girl

[@horrortackleharry]

Any time someone in a police interview says that the victim "was like a brother/sister/son/daughter to me".... GUILTY!

[@halstonspohn3690]

Mainly referring to them in past tense is what gives it away

[@bocephusbirchcull4044]

@traybernYou obviously don’t know the story of Cain and Abel…

[@nicholaszigich8895]

I’ve lived in Saratoga my whole life and I can remember when this happened. So surreal to see Mike covering this case! Such a sad one, and I can only hope the family are doing as well as they can.

[@foxy2loxy]

Hey Mike , I am wondering if you would do me a favor . A friend of mine disappeared from Little Rock California in August 2022 (I hope I am accurate) her name is Gloria Jessica Huertas , She's still missing and I haven't heard any updates or recent news at all. Seems like life forgot about her. I'm hoping you can bring her case back to life and maybe with a program about her , she may be found and brought home to her mom and family . I was praying she just went to Vegas but Gloria would have been back out here sooner or later . Please , with your ability and videos , she might get home faster please please . It's really scary knowing someone is out here who could do this to anyone .

[@MsSilverTulip]

Reach out to Kendall Rae or Stephanie Harlowe

[@foxy2loxy]

@@MsSilverTulip do I messege via Facebook or messenger?

[@ZenobiaDecrespin]

I worked for a Greek diner in the 80s my boss was so cheap he would never pay us until the banks closed to get one more day of interest on his payroll money. He hid and would spy on us. It was a simple job great food, monster boss. This case is just horrible. I love ya Mike always and forever

[@hotdogwater8520]

I work for a Greek guy. Same thing with the money and food. He's the nicest guy though 😂

[@howgreenwasmyvalley9686]

There was a creepy pair of brothers who ran the Salonika Inn in Sasckaton, Saskatchewan Jimmy was cheap as evil hell and the other one you to make you go in the back color for a 5 min touch up before we get out checks. Jimmy used to make us split the tips up with all staff even him. A complete jerk, I was 16 years old serving drink to drunks. Jimmy would say keep them happy. Having fingers jammed up you didn't keep any 16 year old happy. Dirty old greasy men. I lived alone and did not know labour laws.

[@Deimonik1]

The Chef Ramsey drop just made me spit coffee everywhere.

[@kristinwojtowich8902]

Omg same, I tell you I SNORTED. 😆😆😆

[@Tabiannax84x]

Only 22 years old. That is so sad. Rest easy beautiful.

[@judithgannon5642]

I grew up in Central NY, and looked at the town and mountains and countryside with hungry eyes. Thanks for always showing the places, it's a special part of the stories. (Ancestors from Dublin and County Mayo)

[@fatherofmimes4236]

Hey Mike! Snowed in, in Arkansas so... yes indeed let's do give it a GOO! Thanks to TC and the commenters for brightening my snow day!

[@Noctessa]

So glad to see your upload while snowed in. Toxic bosses are the worst!! If you try to leave they can make getting new jobs awfully difficult and when they dont pay taxes, unemployment or social security its life altering. Stay warm and safe my fellow TC fans!

[@brittanyreed4377]

I worked for people like that, when I left I blocked everyone cause it was so toxic..owners wife starting fights between us all, being rude to customers and getting mad at us when we don’t defend her being judgmental towards certain people, kicking people out for no reason, expecting people to leave early on family vacations that were pre approved cause she made someone mad and they walked out. Another girl worked for them for years and when she would leave for a couple weeks or months at a time they would try to figure out her new employer to call them to get her fired

[@sweetmissypetuniawilson9206]

So if you can, I'd give notice the first whiff of toxic behavior and if you haven't worked there long, you can leave them off your resume (unless you desperately need to show experience) and replace it with volunteer work. If you haven't done any, sometimes they don't check and you can say you were temporarily caring for an incapacitated/sick relative. ☮️💜

[@peternolan4107]

I had a boss straight out of hell. She was truly psychopathic. After I left, she did everything she could to keep me from getting a good job. This wasn't at a sandwich shop. This was at a nationally renowned university. There are very many people who are even more evil than they are smart.

[@kristinwojtowich8902]

I just recently had to leave a job bc I got injured at work and they wouldn't let me work within my restrictions, and my bosses did everything they could, including straight up lying under oath, to try and make sure I couldn't get workers comp. I wouldn't have gone back anyway, even if they hadn't done that- the actual worst employer I ever had. Always putting employees down, talking to them like shit and God forbid you tried to stick up for yourself, you'd get a writeup quicker than you could blink; she was never wrong, nothing was ever her fault. She made multiple girls actually cry on the job, when it was already a stressful career path. Over 50 ppl started and quit that place within a 2 year period and it was ALWAYS that person's fault, never had ANYTHING to do with her. I'm so glad I'm out if there. Sorry for the rant 😅

[@judithgannon5642]

​@@peternolan4107they also exist in those even whiter towers, libraries. Just as you describe.

[@wesadams5128]

How he thought this was a better alternative than probably just getting a fine and maybe a year of jail is beyond me. Some people are crazy. They both got a couple screws loose

[@LoucheWoman]

When someone is being questioned about a missing person and they use the past tense... right after saying that their other employee "wouldn't have the balls" to hurt her. Just sign the confession now, my dude.

[@futuredog7877]

I knew Steve-O was up to his old shenanigans.

[@ms.bkaraokeb4307]

Hey Mike! Thank you for all your hard work for us. LOVE YOU!!!💙💚💙💚💚

[@CantTellYou]

I find it so adorable that he pronounces “aluminum” with an extra vowel like “aluminium” lol

[@MiThreeSunz]

A truly sad and tragic story. A needless death at the hands of a greedy and selfish monster! 🇨🇦

[@kayclark8443]

Hi Mike, can you look at the Boston Mass. case of Carol Stewart? Pregnant woman shot by her husband who blamed a black guy? Was a massive case 1989. Love your videos!

[@skthechef8075]

Mike without glasses doesn't feel weird anymore 😂

[@maggiemolly111]

The girl already lodged a complaint against him and he killed her. How would anyone not think he was responsible? Unbelievable.

[@nyeeeeeee]

I'm a local from Johnstown. Born and raised, still living there, and have been watching your content for years now. I heard my town name come up and almost instantly knew it was about this case. My fiancé and I freaked out realizing it, haha. EVERYONE talked about it when it happened, and everyone was trying to figure out what happened and who did it. There was so much gossip about it. It's all my mom would talk about. My fiancé remembers seeing the news trucks at the deli. This is so surreal to see on KZbin, especially on a channel I've loved for so long. Really glad to finally have the full story though. My love goes out to the family and everyone affected. It was truly horrifying. Also, hearing the one guy call him a crackhead made me giggle. That's just Johnstown slang. Anyone "crazy" is automatically a crackhead around here. Great stuff, made me laugh.

[@NJRDC]

Always nice to see a story from my neck of the woods. I grew up next county over. It is beautiful.

[@rosemadder5547]

Sick AND snowed in. This will be just what the Dr ordered 😉 Howdy from the Great Smoky Mountains ❤

[@jeffreywingham5302]

The owner practically told on himself as he spoke of her in the past tense.

[@stellah1643]

That sucks!!! Why would they kill that poor girl? Over not paying his taxes, trying to hide money? Ridiculous!!

[@scott6828]

@22:06: why is that defense attorney wearing a cowboy scarf over his face in court? This country has literally gone bat shit crazy

[@sjworrier0613]

I think this trial was during COVID, some people wore bandanas lol but I agree that it looks bat s*t crazy and maybe not the ideal choice when defending a client

[@laratheplanespotter]

Hey hey everybody! Have a great week! Love you all. Thanks Mike! Now let’s gooooo

[@ThatChapter]

Thanks Lara!

[@laratheplanespotter]

@@ThatChapterno worries my friend!

[@badgalriri2354]

@@ThatChapterThanks for another great video 2 Million on the way!!!! 🎉❤

[@badgalriri2354]

Have a great week too! God bless everyone & have a safe week HAPPY NEW YEARRR 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤

[@breakfast4]

Thanks Mike

[@empressmarowynn]

When someone uses "was" instead of "is" to describe someone who's been missing for a short time it's a pretty big red flag. That part always catches my attention during interviews.

[@RandolphTheWhite1]

"...you don't hire an angel to do the devil's job" Good line, Mr