Thayers Witch Hazel Toner...why I stopped using it after 2 years...

[@shayemitchum05]

Thank you for your insight! But, everyone has different skin and reactions. You have to kinda just test it out to see. I’ve heard with my family that witch hazel is great for skincare. It just depends on how your skin reacts ☺️ I’m sensitive to certain skin care (like clean&clear) with strong ingredients they put it, it’s nice to use a natural skincare line.

[@kay5944]

honestly I’ve been usingThayer’s for like 3-4 years and I didn’t really have any reaction mentioned. I heard that it wasn’t too popular and I was so confused. I watched many videos and I feel like it really didn’t leave anything on me and had benefits instead. I might be less sensitive to witch hazel but this is just my own experience with witch hazel.

[@apekshalashiyal9900]

Actually witch hazel is usually distilled in alcohol which is very bad for the skin but dont worry Thayers one is distilled in water But witch hazel in genral can be very striping of oil

[@kay5944]

@@tinatiamz Yea...im still using it though HAHAHAHA

[@ackermanheichou7733]

I've been using this product for almost a year, it helped my face to slowly eradicate acne breakouts. I never had bad encounters from using it. Maybe it varies from skin type that we have. I personally have combination to oily skin.

[@EmeliaKate]

This definitely helped with my breakouts as well with my crazy oily skin. I unfortunately also have super sensitive skin though so that could be why I experienced such a reaction. I really still love the product, my skin however isn't a fan 😭

[@catwhorentfree788]

I been using this toner for quitesometime,especially with rose water,totally help my skin and improved my skin from acne

[@heyrosey7404]

Hi umm when u use witch hazel, do you only use it and go straight to the next step skin care? Or u also use other toner to hydrate skin and go to the next step skincare? Sorry bad english, hope u see this

[@katiekatears]

@@heyrosey7404 I use it and go straight to next step

[@RinaRoss-to6iz]

whats your skin type

[@jacquelinekwang8033]

Try to fix ur skin from inside not only on the top of the skin. Cuz if ur inner body system not fix, then no matter what you use on ur face, it’s not gonna forever change it.

[@EmeliaKate]

Preach! Yes, I am always experimenting with my diet ❤ I've learned that too much sugar and some dairy greatly affects how my skin is. I've still got a lot to learn 😊

[@sunnybe668]

I used to have acne around my mouth also. Then my Korean friend told me I might have a womb problem. So, I checked with a doctor. I had fibroids. He burned them and acne disappeared.

[@sashybeauty]

Thank you for sharing your insights about this toner and about witch hazel in general. I was going to buy one with witch hazel but now I'm scared lol. The one I love using is Neutrogena Alcohol free toner. A light blue bottle. :)

[@EmeliaKate]

I used to use the neutrogena one all the time ❤

[@adryprincess5069]

I have been using Thayers ALCOHOL FREE TONER for about 4 years and it has cleared my hormonal acne. Also, I have combination skin with eczema and it has helped my redness on my chin. I think that if it works for your skin, then use it. Dont knock it until you try it. Also, the big thing is making sure the toner has no alcohol. I rather using natural stuff like with hazel then paying a bunch of money for chemical peels etc.

[@kathiuskaprevos1248]

Can i use it with differin gel or panoxyl please ?

[@adryprincess5069]

@@Mia-vm6pl I am talking about my own experience. Everyone should do their own research. Troll!

[@dominiqueh7409]

I purchased this product 4-5 months ago and for a month now I’ve been trying to figure out why my skin has become so incredibly dry. Within this past month I have purchased so many hydrating facial cleansers and moisturizers and nothing was working! I have pretty normal skin and I purchased this product because I heard so much good things about it. I decided to do some extensive research to see if anyone was having problems with this product or was I just overthinking it. I’m so glad I stumbled across your video because this gave me so much clarity as to why my face is in the current state that it is in. It’s the only thing it could be because all of my other products I use have never done this before and I’ve been using the same products for years. I will be throwing this out immediately and going back to my old toner mist. Don’t believe the hype and please stick to what work best for you is the lesson I learned.

[@jenjenbonnor9759]

This vid made me subscribe. First time I see you and seem so true and honest. Love how nice and genuine you come across. Thanks for teaching me how to use witch hazel literally just bought that product yesterday in a rush and regreted it. But I remember using this when my skin was at its best. So I’ll just have to use it very minimally and then wash off EVERY time. For two days in the week to stay safe. I agree, I used to be really red out the shower but never knew why. Ahhhhhh!!!! 💕💕

[@EmeliaKate]

Awww, thank you so much ❤ your comment just made my entire day! I've always used this when my skin was at its best too so it was incredibly difficult for me to stop using it because I thought for sure I was going to break out. I definitely won't go back to using it daily, but I love your plan of using it minimally and washing it off ❤

[@whereyoubean]

i also stopped using Thayers at the end of last month since I also read that it can overstrip your face. I think, I also used Thayers for 2 yrs. sad cause it does wonders for my skin but its time to move on. LOL. i’m now using Dear, Klairs Supple Preparation Unscented Toner. :)

[@EmeliaKate]

I'll have to check out the Klairs toner ❤

[@nmbnmbnmb]

Supple Prep is great! But it contains citrus oils, not to be used in the morning as it makes skin photosensitive.

[@whereyoubean]

NMB the Unscented one does not have any essential oil. I’m using the Unscented toner

[@iamthedaughteroftheking3704]

I used Dickinson witch hazel made my skin super red. I going to throw it off. I don’t wash my face during showering, because it will cause more pimples. I love this video.

[@cretinousmartyr3522]

I'm glad I'd found videos like this one and Dr dray's before I started having bad reactions to witch hazel. I still use it, and it works great for when I do use it, it's great at degreasing while not being so intense that it can't be used after acne treatments like benzoyl peroxide; I only use it on occasion like a spot treatment, rinse it off after a min or two, use only when my my skin is extremely oily, only use the Thayers brand, (and once I run out of the scented one I'd bought, I'll only buy the unscented, as I'm not wasteful but it was an oopsie). Just be responsible when using strong products like witch hazel and if it doesn't work for you than don't try and make it work because others like it, actually this goes for just about everything in life

[@Daisy-ku8vb]

My skin has always been acne free and redness free but a few days ago I saw my whole face had tiny red/purple dots and was freaking out cause I’ve never experienced this ever!!! So I’m thinking it’s cause of the this product 🥺

[@shashaisaacman499]

i experienced the same thing after a month of using thayers witch hazel rose petal . the red rashes come out at the chin and it make me so stress but i still keep using it . i thought it was because of my cleanser .. so i change my cleanser and the red rash still appear with a big red acne from my forehead till my chin . it was very irritating and painful . after i stop using thayers my skin back to normal. Btw , hye 👋🏽 im from malaysia

[@EmeliaKate]

Oh wow! I'm glad you finally figure out that it was causing your rashes. It took me 2 whole years before I figured it out 😭 it always reminds me to keep going over my current skincare routine!

[@GurenKamisama]

For me as a female I need to change the products I use during a month since my skin is constantly changing according to when my period is. Important for the skin to keep up to the hormones.

[@EmeliaKate]

I've heard a lot of people do this! I used to break out when I was on my period, but lately my skin actually clears up a bit when I'm on it. So that is something I'm still trying to figure out

[@MONi_LALA]

Never get any rashes from a shower. And my skin is super oily. So stripping away some oil is fine. And I'm too lazy to use it everyday anyway. So perfect for me.

[@Noraarosales]

I just bought this not too long ago and I’ve noticed that my skin started to breakout and I NEVER breakout. I was doing research on Amazon and a lot of people have mentioned in the reviews that they have changed the ingredients. Maybe this could’ve caused you to breakout as well? I’m going to stop using it myself because this is embarrassing having all these bumps/pimples on my skin. Thanks for the info!

[@sarah73015]

Omgggg I never breakout as well and now I have been ever since I started using this brand! It's nice to know I'm not the only one! I was so embarrassed at first.

[@lallystar2455]

Sensitive, oily, mixed, dry skin needs moisturizers. Even toner is a moisturizer and provides hydration. It is better for the skin. Exfoliants soothe the skin with the same strong exfoliants. If a light and gentle exfoliant gives sweet skin.

[@kara6722]

Thanks for the in site! I was just researching products to start my own skin care. I will definitely be careful when I use it! Once again thanks a bunch!

[@EmeliaKate]

I'm glad I can help! I love how you are researching skincare ❤ not many do it before they purchase products!

[@everglade7764]

I love this toner, but I only use it sporadically. It seems to help my skin and I’ve found since I only use it ever few days/once a week, it hasn’t dried my skin out or given me any reaction.

[@kiara198923]

I saw Thayer's on an ad & I was thinking about buying the facial cleanser & toner but the comments are making me very skeptical. I purchased an age defying set but realized it didn't do anything to actually cleanse my face. Plus I was putting garnier's no rinse micellar water which made my skin break out even more. The breakout I currently have resembles a heat rash. I have no idea what to try to clear it & I've never worn make up before.

[@Akahana_rosehashira]

Hi there! Thanks for sharing your insights and thoughts on using a skin toners. So, like you, I was curious if it's beneficial for our skin to use the same product on a consistent basis. I've found that our skin chemistry is not meant to use the same product on a recurring basis. Our skin PH levels does change periodically. Continuing to implement different products along with taking breaks can help with having clear skin. 🙂

[@myunqsoo]

this was great to watch I just bought the facial mist I really hope nothing happens

[@SDGunfighter]

You'll be fine. Just don't overdue a skincare routine

[@achdahreuven1490]

Just a thought it could be the cotton balls. I found when I wiped with cotton rounds my skin got sensitive/irritated. Now I spray and use my fingers to rub it in. Now perfect!!

[@isabellaisokay1592]

I usually water down my witch hazel and use it weekly! I will definitely not be repurchasing after this bottle tho

[@EmeliaKate]

That's a smart idea to water it down! I might do that with the rest of my bottle.

[@meaghanmurphy5440]

i just started using this toner a few months ago and have had a few red patches on my skin. I think this explains it! Do you use a different toner now, or did you just take that step out of your routine? 😊 thanks for the video!

[@EmeliaKate]

I just took this step out of my routine. I've been doing research and a lot of articles and youtube videos I've come across tend to say toner is an unnecessary step, I feel like my skin has been doing sooooo much better without toners. Definitely take a break from the toner for a week or so to see how your skin responds. It took my skin about a week for it to fully calm down.

[@4yzell]

also i just started using cucumber witch hazel should i use it 3 times a week monday wedneday friday? and the main reason im using it is to get rid of my dark spots and bumps i have

[@whyjordie]

I randomly came across this video and I just wanted to say...You're so beautiful and I love your smile. I'm subscribing

[@EmeliaKate]

Aww, thank you so incredibly much 😊❤

[@jalahwhite3919]

I would definitely say try witch hazel if u haven’t before.. it definitely helped combat oily skin and large pores which is why I loved it. Recently my skin has started tingling almost burning when I apply it. I’ve used it for 3.5 years but my skin hates it now. My skin is not sensitive or prone to breakouts. So the same as she says. It’s good at first. But you’re going to have to take a break from it sooner or later especially if you’re using every day.

[@stacykrolczyk5776]

Tannins are also found in teas and many other plants and plant parts (like acorns). I wonder what a tea treatment would do?!

[@EmeliaKate]

Yes! I remember seeing that when I was doing research. I hear that's why certain teas are very good for helping clear skin. I've also seen matcha skincare products.

[@sofiaseguracardenas7770]

This happened to me! just that it caused me texture... many bumps all over the face and i was so sad because when i cut it out my skin started to recover! i was going to buy the Purito toner next but! it has witch hazel on it as well... so i think no xd

[@bellhayra9568]

I just bought witch hazel toner like yesterday and i saw this video ")

[@makenna8454]

I just broke out from over-exfoliating, I NEVER breakout, and it’s been taking a long time to repair it. I wonder if this is partially why. Skincare is so confusing ✋🏻

[@serenityparie4596]

You should try cleansers or moisturizers with hydraulic acid

[@Kr-zy5fv]

Have you tried apple cider vinegar toner? I am 31,been making my own acv toner and using thayers witch hazel toner since i was 18. I use the acv toner every morning and night. Great for use on body as well. Really helps with acne and makes skin lighter and brighter. I use the thayers every now and then, mostly as a refresh in the day or right after i shower instead of using the acv toner. Acv toner: use braggs brand acv and pure filtered water. Mix one part acv to two parts water. Apply to skin with cotton pad.

[@EmeliaKate]

I've never tried apple cider vinegar toner. I'll have to look into this, thank you for the recommendation!

[@syaffiraairin]

Does it have a strong smell?

[@carter_1]

SCARY!! I literally just went through your WHOLE PROCESS. Same 2 YTbers (I watched 2NITE), the "The Doctors" then YOU! THAT'S WEIRDas heck! I just learnt this all on one night and changing everything I do!!

[@allisonbonnet3554]

I love witch hazel but I have always paired it with moisturizer or natural oils I also don't use it everyday or buy it's self.its ment to be diluted.

[@08berrin]

Por eso me gusta ver reseñas por que uno aprende si es malo o bueno un producto recien adquiri un thayers de pepino y lavanda pero estoy contenta me gusta como me va quedando la piel ya que la tengo muy grasa la siento mas suave y lisa pero estare al pendiente de cualquier reaccion ya que soy muy alergica

[@gioplease6848]

Witch Hazel is better to use it to wipe off dirt and oil off the face and then washing it off in my opinion. I’ve always used it like that and it helps keep my sink clear. But I don’t use it as an oil.

[@tikienglish813]

Amazing video. I'd been using Thayer's for close to two years and it worked great at first but for the last few months I'd been noticing my skin looking very textured and bumpy and this could be the reason. And I'm sure it's drying out my skin. I'm gonna stop using it and switch to something else. I've heard good things about Heritage store rosewater toner

[@simonecollins2748]

Which one did you use the original? Or the ones with the lavender, lemon or rose petal added. Maybe it was the added stuff that u was allergic to

[@zeldapowers8094]

Was using it everyday to help get excess dirt off skin before bed and started noticing my skin looked really dry when out in the sun. I’ve since stopped using it since I don’t even have oil skin but rather dry/normal. I may use it once in a while for now on but not everyday

[@sarahcheesman627]

I've had allergic red patches appear from rose hip, is that the ingredient in the rose petal witch hazel? I use the cucumber one and my skin has never been better.

[@xihall2424]

You look great. ❤️ subbed

[@angelo89]

STOP CONSUMING COW’S MILK. I found this solved my chin acne in a weeks’s time. I only consume almond or soy milk now.

[@Owlcopettube]

😱 thank you, I’m going to use my thayers less!

[@EmeliaKate]

I'm so glad I can help out ❤

[@tribefenatic]

since the pandemic the shelves have cleared from witch hazel now i know whose buying them, and i thought my best mate next door was the only witch

[@dorothymbawa4617]

I reacted to witch hazel as well after using this product for almost 8 months. I developed a rash around my mouth which was itchy. Turned red when I stratched it.

[@gelalim88]

Thank you!!!!!

[@jamieb.9092]

Sounds like you might have stripped your moisture barrier (especially if you're using a higher ph cleanser AND with any water warmer than lukewarm). Also, have you tried the unscented Thayers? It also contains aloe vera filet.

[@EmeliaKate]

My skin is crazy sensitive. I know my moisture barrier needs a lot of work too though I use very gentle cleansers with lukewarm water. I haven't tried the unscented version, but overall I think it is the witch hazel itself that made my skin react so badly.

[@alfredolopez4092]

@@EmeliaKate witch hazel is alcohol

[@lyzazabahar]

tqsm❤.. act i want buy this toner.. lucky i open utube 1st.

[@4yzell]

is it okay to mostruize after using the cucumber witch hazel instead of washing my face offf with water after?

[@lonalee3530]

You need to ALWAYS moisturize your face after with Hazel. Use something with vitamin E in it

[@crazyjloop89]

Thanks for sharing!

[@lillian.12]

I’ve been using this for 3 years👁👄👁

[@graceraeey]

How is it going?

[@strxbrry13]

you could have developed an allergy to witch hazel. that happened to me with allantoin (basically the extract of the comfrey plant's root) in the kiehl's cucumber toner

[@shade247]

You really should not recommend hyram to anybody. He’s not a licensed professional. He’s not educated enough. You should recommend more real LICENSED PROFESSIONALS like Dr. Dray!

[@MOAB-UT]

Did you buy directly from them or an authorized reseller? If not, you have zero way to know what is actually in it. There are many knock-offs out there. Any product that you put on your skin or ingest, IMO should come directly from the manufacturer. Have you found a alternative product that you like more?

[@rach467]

What did you do to get rid of the redness? When you stopped did it just go away? Thanks!

[@tairtortita5495]

When I bought this product I didn't want to watch this video because I was really enthusiastic to tried It out. After just two weeks, I wish I had seen It, this thing is burning my face and neck :(

[@tamber001]

I’ve came to know about witch hazel for natural deodorant, what’s your take shall i go with it?

[@lexijones8414]

Try the BUrts Bees Sensitive Toner with aloe. It’s good

[@pearliesuarez7263]

This video made me click the subscribe button. I loved it! I think you are a nice person judging from the way you talk and the tone of your voice. ❤️

[@EmeliaKate]

Aww, thank you! I'm so glad you enjoyed the video 😊

[@shrinivasanvenkatachalamk6656]

What is the expiry period of this product as I am not able to find the same in bottom of the bottle. Purchased a year before.

[@Tinalua1986]

I have also stop using this..it worst on my face. Acne breakouts and redness...😪😪😪

[@EmeliaKate]

At least you were able to figure that out! It took me a long time 😅

[@coolstory6193]

Is it thayers or all witch hazel? Cause I read thayers changed there formula they added this other ingredient phenoxyethanol. Well anyways I use witch hazel after shaving since I use a safety razor, but I ended up going with T.N. Dickinson and Humphreys brand. I’ve never had skin problems, but I didn’t want to develop them so I stayed away from thayers since they added that ingredient around 2 years ago I think.

[@thelostmothofwasteland6138]

but thayers is my holy grail but im alternate it week by week, sometimes i use Cica & Sunflower Toner and sometimes the toner of Skin 1004 Madagascar Centella 😊 but i got break out moisturiser of Baroness

[@vectoryglory3722]

after i watched your video , i think im gonna make a minor change in my routine , i will switch using it from a daily use twice a day to 3 times a week once , because i started to notice that my skin is becoming more sensitive than before ( i have been using it for one month )

[@dianaaaaaahhh]

Ok so question for you: how in the world do you always know when a product causes issues or helps you?? You seem to always be able to pinpoint the skincare or makeup product that causes breakouts or sensitivity. I just slather my face with whatever and pray for the best lol. I've had acne since elementary school but only got into skincare for real about 5 years ago, I know my skin has dramatically improved but I can't pick out a single item and say "this helps my breakouts". Anyways, I used Thayers Witch Hazel for 3 or 4 years and never noticed a difference but kept using it since the ingredients sounded good. I stopped around February because I finished a bottle and didn't want to repurchase since I don't think it does anything for me. Do you watch Beauty Within? Ever since I watched a period skincare video from them I've been paying attention to how my skin looks based on where I'm at in my cycle and I'm trying to follow a routine based on my hormones lol. I think it'd be a really cool video idea for you if you're interested. You basically stick to certain ingredients different stages of your cycle to prevent acne. The video was called "what does your period really say about your skin". Def recommend!!

[@EmeliaKate]

It has taken me years to figure out which products affect my skin. I still struggle with it from time to time as you can see it's taken me 2 years to figure this one out! But it also helps when i document my progress everyday and then go and edit the video. I also tend to just stop using products for a week to see if my skin changes as well. I have watched that Beauty Within video which I find very fascinating. Ever since I've gone on birth control though I find that when I do have my time of month my acne actually clears up, which makes me wonder if the dose of birth control im on is too much or too little. It's something I'm still experimenting with.

[@jesusbuenrostro9946]

Gracias, saludos desde México 🇲🇽

[@juliecolinco6041]

I tried it today and my skin is already breaking out :((

[@juleaban7910]

damn I just bought this toner JUST now wtf hahahahahah guess I have to throw it

[@EmeliaKate]

Hahaha, you can still get some use out of it! You can use it sparingly on acne, just wash it off after a few minutes and don't use it for more than a week. It also works great at disinfecting small cuts too!

[@juleaban7910]

@@EmeliaKate I actually tried using it until today and it indeed lessen my pores. I'll probably use it for now but I'll use it atleast once a day or thrice a week.

[@rishel8738]

How is your skin doing a month later, Jule?

[@juleaban7910]

@@rishel8738 Hi! So far there's no side effect with the witch hazel toner on my face - I tried to minimize the used of the product like I only use it atleast twice a week - because i'm pretty scared hahaha

[@zig_ma]

I've used witch hazel every day on my skin and have never had problems. It depends on your skin

[@jahmavlog5330]

What kind of thayers do you use?

[@neetusharma8791]

Can we put it in spray bottle and spray on face

[@PlayaX01]

U didn’t list the desensitizeing spray

[@AgentOffice]

Are you on spironolactone

[@ahernandez0047]

I have yet to try witch hazel

[@EmeliaKate]

I think it is really great, but be super careful if you decide to try it!

[@zoo9830]

Cleanse your liver. That's your problem. Change your diet.

[@SDGunfighter]

Thayers has fragrance. And if you have sensitive skin NEVER use fragrance. Also, you obviously have acne prone skin which once again fragrance is never good. I would reccomend using Paula's Choice Salicylic acid and add a product that contains Bisabolol. One last reccomendation, start slugging now and than at night to build up your barrier again.

[@ygbodybuilder3023]

Sons tic toker says don't buy it and everyone follows wow

[@constantinhurjui275]

Don't use it every day, just use it when you need it.

[@Kake2282]

I literally got out the shower rn And was using my witch hazel as I'm watching your video I have the same redness rash 😩

[@saintdol]

im using the lavendar witch hazel -

[@SM-fi1be]

I patch tested this on my wrist before using it on my face and it was fine. I used it on my face last night and it stung so bad immediately and I got some red bumps. I'm so annoyed because I literally just bought it 😭

[@SDGunfighter]

If it stings its because you need to rest on products for a week or so because you have destroyed your barrier somehow either with over exfoliation etc. I would suggest slugging at night and you should be good to go in just days. Good luck

[@Nanna0708]

Please please don’t use hot showers. PLEASEEE. So bad for your skin. Lukewarm water only. And they don’t need to be long. My showers are literally 7 minutes long and that’s with lathering my hair twice. Naturally I turn the water off while I wash the hair. Please guys be more environmentally conscious.

[@EmeliaKate]

I completely agree with you! There was a time when I only took warm showers, but I've been taking hotter showers to help manage my stress, which I know is not a good excuse for my poor skin 😕 I'm definitely trying to get back into it though!

[@shirl5084]

Informative, however just took to long to get to the point.

[@HardyBunster]

It’s for men.

[@victoriacast98]

maybe because you shouldve used it once a week??

[@rowdee7537]

Bruh I just bought this today 4/18/2021 but shit my skin is already itchy wasted $10 SMH 😤🙄

[@brendon8702]

Don’t over moisturise, ever.

[@catesvlog6491]

Hi kate

[@roses609]

I stopped using it because it was burning my skin

[@EmeliaKate]

Oh no 😕 it's so crazy how a product reacts so differently to everyone !

[@yaya110277]

me too.

[@JmGmail]

So you took influencer opinions over your own experience?

[@nadiachavez9157]

How long can I live this on

[@EmeliaKate]

I haven't really tested this out, but I would say no more than 5 mins

[@nadiachavez9157]

Emelia Kate okay can i use this if I never did

[@user-my1ie3wn9l]

im sorry for u

[@jcoltrane8976]

It doesn’t work on puddin’ faces.

[@jcoltrane8976]

@@joeyconvery2055, you have something against puddin’ faces? That’s very shallow. I was offering practical advice.

[@joeyconvery2055]

@@jcoltrane8976 What does "puddin face" have to do with how well a toner works? You sound disrespectful.

[@jcoltrane8976]

@@joeyconvery2055, you haven’t heard of the puddin’ face retraction? It can damage pores. Obviously, you are not a bowler.

[@jj_xxx13]

What toner do you use now?

[@EmeliaKate]

I currently am not using a toner right now, not sure which one I'll try next.

[@Kr-zy5fv]

@@EmeliaKate try acv toner...use braggs brand acv and pure filtered wate. Mix one part acv to two parts water. Apply to skin with cotton pad

[@ForthQuarter-z2r]

Cute woman 😊

[@mukbangvlogs8148]

😂😂😂