The Analogues - She Said She Said

[@robertoluiz8094]

She said she said, one of my favorites Beatles' songs! Great performance!

[@fr8466]

Every time I listen to this song, I realize that the secret of Beatles sound is Ringo's drum.

[@JordiPujadesGirona]

And Macca's bass, for sure.

[@ags8294]

Jordi Pujades Girona it was George on bass on this one. Paul went out of the sessions for She Said She Said after having an argument with at least one of the rest, I guess John for sure and maybe George too.

[@pangloss9]

Word!

[@jono5900]

For sure a very underrated drummer as has been stated on KZbin ad nauseam..Also for this song in particular, his great fills were brought more forward in the mix..George Martin's genius? McCartney cooling down later on and doing what was best for the song? Lennon being ok with that because it was his song on the album? Prob a little bit of all.............

[@charlescuba5487]

@@jono5900 have you seen Sina-drums and her tribute to Ringo. On KZbin, very interesting, her take on and her understanding of Ringo and his genius within the Beatles.

[@musgrave6886]

for me, this track is definitely ahead of its time as it still sounds fresh, modern, and contemporary. i can't think of any other act who'd been making such sonic majesty as the beatles did back then.

[@timfronimos459]

I love this band !!!!!

[@r.fernandes9526]

It's amazing to me that here are The Analogues who are helping us get through these incredibly uncertain times, just like The Beatles did when John Fitzgerald Kennedy was assassinated. I never in my wildest imagination did I ever think we would have the same fear and uncertainty now that we had in 1963. Thank You Analogues.

[@eel700]

Fear and uncertainty? You've seen nothing yet! We _do_ need John.

[@tedknowlegy]

This is so cool to watch these live 'studio' versions of the Beatles repertoire. Secrets are revealed, mysteries solved, and more than that, just enjoying hearing these wonderful compositions is very fulfilling.

[@TonyLovell]

These guys are so professional, and good. That said, they squeeze the love out of everything they tackle.

[@um773]

I can see that. There's that lack of joy in their playing. No glimmer in their eyes or any smiles.

[@amadeomenavicente546]

The very Soul of the Lads live in the Analogues.

[@countalucard4226]

John was a word master for sure.

[@gpiano88]

Yes! A word master with a rapier wit.

[@Brucemcleod2345]

These guys have made me appreciate this song so much that it’s now one of my favourite Beatles songs. Listening to this live, the Beatles had great song writers, good harmonies, a fantastic lead guitarist and a brilliant drummer.

[@eugenemodzelewski6471]

The Analogues, Thank you for playing the BeaTles music and taking me back to my youth. Without the BeaTles where would music be now? You guys are the BEST in performing BeaTle tunes and I've seen many cover bands. I went to a 9 hour BeaTle fest a number of years ago, many bands playing BeaTle music, all good but can't compare to the Analogues ! I don't care about looking like the BeaTles but the SOUND, the sound of the BeaTles you master to the nth !!!!!! Thank You , Thank you.... A splendid time is guaranteed for all

[@MegaSickcat]

They are fantastic! Paying the best HOMAGE to The Beatles I've ever heard. You don't have to dress up to sound like The Beatles...These guys NAILED every song, every note...AMAZING

[@SissyShamrock]

One of my favorite Beatles songs. Kudos to you guys for a job VERY well-done!

[@wilsonmcphert]

Interesting that the Beatles wrote incredible songs such as this and then never performed them again. Great to hear this version.

[@danny-ee8ye]

@Jeff Strange the beatles themselves didnt want to perform anymore after candlestick park

[@danny-ee8ye]

@Danny Corr yoo danny gang

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

@@danny-ee8ye They never sung In My Life, Michelle, Norwegian Wood in any of their Concerts.

[@wezlo8733]

Just shows how big they were, they only performed live the first half of their careers. The best stuff didn’t get shown but still considered best of all time. Interesting.

[@stlmopoet]

Listening to this nine years later I appreciate their voices are younger. I think the instrumentation is sharper now. Wish I could marry today's playing with their voices from nine years ago. They're still absolutely great, but there is a slight difference in the voices.

[@paulcooke1]

Amazing..Wish they would come to Vancouver...

[@57RickH]

These guys are awesome! Would love to hear Sean or Julian do a guest vocal on this

[@platinumpokitaru]

@@zahar8976I always thought Julian sounded Just like John. I mean listen to "Too late for goodbyes" Its like if a young John made 80s pop music

[@jaapklein1600]

Toen, life in en rondom paleis Soestdijk..The white album..Zo mooi, onvoorstelbaar knap.. Dit nummer op mijn tablet is ook fijn, zeker in deze binnenzit tijd..Dank jullie wel, subliem!

[@valinormons1128]

I think this is the best non Beatles version of this song ever done and the Analogues perform it live splendidly. I don't know for sure, because I've never met a Beatle, but the reason they never performed this song live was because they'd given up touring to make recordings. They did play some of the Revolver songs when they were in Japan in 1966, but that's the only time I know. It was difficult to replicate some of the studio effects but not impossible. It would have been time consuming for the group and for the event promoters to have done so anyway. Besides, with all the screaming going on, it would have been a waste of time. So, they just made their music in the studio and attended a few events here and there and that's what we have. But before they stopped touring, they had performed live thousands of times, just not after 1966. That's why it's nice to have the Analogues with their love of the music, do what the Beatles couldn't, or didn't do.

[@genegantii8638]

I've read that they briefly rehearsed i want to tell you and this song during rehearsals for 66 tour but just said sod it

[@valinormons]

@@genegantii8638 I also read that John had a difficult time with "I want to tell you" because of the tricky beat and off kilter chord structure and suggested to George that he simplify it a bit but George told him that it was written that way so that's how it goes. Of course I wasn't there and I doubt the person who wrote the words to the story were there also...

[@valinormons]

@yaba daba No, I never met one, and I'll most likely not ever. I've always been a fan of them since I saw them on the ESS that winter day long ago. It was nice back then when not too much time would pass before the radio played a new song of theirs. They were amazing. I've moved on to other music now, but every once in a while I go back to focus on a certain song. It depends on how I feel at the time. I'm happy that you were able to meet them though. All 4 of them. Not many can say the same.

[@graniterhythm53]

The Beatles didn't perform ANYTHING off Revolver in '66. They did perform Paperback Writer, the single from the Revolver sessions. Apparently they were booked for concerts a few days after completing Revolver & were under rehearsed for the gigs.

[@JustVisiting]

If you haven’t seen the documentary, you’ll be missing the backstory about the acquisition of all the Analogue instruments from the 1960’s. Quite an endeavor. The idea was that no modern digital synths, etc, would be used. I’ve ordered the book about the Beatles recording sessions, which they used to research everything about the equipment used in the studio.

[@SouthLoop20]

The bass is so spot on here. Really enjoying it

[@JOEKIN2011]

Brilliant...best yet

[@antonioantonini5724]

Kelosparió. !! No se puede hacerlo tan perfecto !!!! Son análogos...!!!

[@maceain]

Excellent!

[@jrstafford5821]

Spot on lead guitar sound and playing!

[@rolandoarmandogonzalessaba3492]

Excelente grupo tributo a The Beatles.. Felicitaciones!!!

[@jettrink7510]

Harrison's guitar contribution can be realized in this performance.

[@rodrigosouza8389]

How does anybody give dislike for this performance?

[@arnaldolc]

brain damage, maybe?

[@salvadormarley]

Might have been Paul. He didn't appera on the track - he walked out sulking.

[@Bowwow30]

@@salvadormarley Paul loves the Analogues.

[@countalucard4226]

Revolver was a true masterpiece.

[@rubaventura7803]

Lovely!

[@donnap8816]

The drummer is so like Ringo's style, brilliant all round

[@jeffreykaufmann4625]

Was Ringo the one who decided how the drums should be played for a song or was it the songwriter?

[@meanderer06513]

@@jeffreykaufmann4625 On bootlegs, you can often hear Paul (and sometimes John) 'suggesting' certain patterns to Ringo. Sometimes, these were difficult for him to get - the sessions for "Thank You Girl" show that the ending was particularly rough for Ringo to get right, with John offering to scratch out a rhythm on his guitar to keep Ringo on the beat.

[@jeffreykaufmann4625]

@@meanderer06513 ok

[@TheSanityInspector]

That's on purpose: The Analogues' mission is to perform live versions of Beatles songs, lick for lick on original instruments, songs that The Beatles never performed themselves.

[@Bowwow30]

And don't forget Ringo wasn't even the best drummer in The Beatles

[@dhscpa1956]

She's making me feel like I've never been born.....

[@lazoolazoo3771]

Fantastic

[@carlosanjust6393]

....and GREAT PERFORMANCE●●●●

[@lynntempleton9640]

I would love to see them tour the US. I'd be there.

[@rosemarie92123]

MY FAVE JOHN AND THEY ROCK IT HARD. JT FROM MEX

[@ArtFernandez1]

These guys got it!!!

[@favilar1]

Excelente interpretacion de este grupo

[@gasgorv]

Excelente banda, acabei de descobrir!!! Eles usam praticamente os mesmos instrumentos que a banda original. Prezam pelo timbre e pela execução, buscando a maior fidelidade possível. Estava ouvindo execuções que, ao vivo, são muito difíceis, como I am the Walrus e tantas outras que nunca foram executadas ao vivo pelos seus próprios compositores. Quanto aos Beatles, nunca é demais ouvir uma releitura de qualquer sucesso deles. Amo essa música, em especial...amo profundamente os Beatles...

[@G.GP.]

Great! I didn't know that John played the Rickenbacker! I thought was the Casino.

[@scottcreedon7405]

Ringo was the right drummer for 1966-1970

[@ludwigbittmann808]

absolutely agree!

[@jeffreykaufmann2867]

Same for 1962-65

[@carlosanjust6393]

one of best 5 beatles songs●●●

[@jward9637]

Nice job gents!

[@otakacururur6805]

Muito bom esse conjunto The Analogues. Recomendo.

[@jamiesinclair9841]

great take..

[@moboutmen]

Revolver ...... their best album.

[@themastroiannis]

one of lennon's most underrated gems! what a terrific song!

[@berthaaliciamartinezbueno7021]

Simplemente un cover maravillosamente bien trazado felicidades

[@arnesaknussemm2427]

And she’s making me feel like my trousers are torn..

[@malcolmgilbert3420]

Technically, it should have been titled 'He said. He said'. Because it was about things Peter Fonda said at an L.A. party.

[@corrievanbinsbergen]

He ja fijn Jan, wat zing je toch lekker!

[@rocker6565]

Difficult song to play. You guys pulled it off well

[@benfranckenfelder1827]

In every way fucking brilliant.

[@franciscomanrique6862]

Fabuloso

[@steveconn]

I thunk the guitar phrasing following the vocal is what makes it.

[@robertyount313]

is it the drumming yes but the story about the chick he's talking about anyway they did justice to this song a good one from way bac when!!!!!!!

[@enriqueleon1380]

Muy Bien!!!!

[@Guitaroverkill]

The Analogues make you realize The Beatles truly played as a band with no member trying to outdo the others. I’ve heard Ringo say he only played what the song called for. Money and ego always seems to ruin a good thing.

[@rafaelzengo5534]

Macca is a billionaire just by mere accident

[@Guitaroverkill]

@@rafaelzengo5534 If you call being one of the most prolific artist and songwriters of all time an accident.

[@bigjohno242]

Great cover ……. And then you realise just how unique a drummer Ringo was….

[@thebakery5555]

Ringo was the goat. He knew exactly what the song needed

[@championhairpuller]

Love it!! When are you guys coming to the states????

[@markbrophy5454]

They have a full orchestra that would be too expensive to move.

[@jackhana7374]

Prachtig

[@JoeWestcottVFX]

Steve Wozniak's alter ego!

[@danielibarra0796]

NO es un descubrimiento, se trata de una reiterada reafirmación (así mismo), los Beatles son unos verdaderos monstruos.

[@courtbeall7768]

Ringo is to Beatles what Moon is to The Who,and Watts is to The Stones.

[@gianlucacapacciola2099]

the drummer.

[@shinyoneincarnate5565]

The Beatles were the (Pete) Best. When Ringo joined, he was already a Star(r). It's all in their names, THE BEAT-ALLS!!! Sour Johnny Lemmon, Paul/Faul MccART-Knee(dead), Goswami Hairry-son. E> Piece 'N Luv

[@clysoniko]

Es una muy buena versión, hubiese sido mejor si el baterista hubiese reproducido el trabajo de Ringo que en ésta canción es un Masterwork, su pattern es una creación con sello Ringo. Saludos.

[@turquisestones]

One of those rare Beatles songs with zero McCartney in it.

[@stevenhaberer4067]

Who played bass on " She Said, She Said" ?

[@turquisestones]

@@stevenhaberer4067 Harrison did.

[@stevenhaberer4067]

@@turquisestones Thanks! I LOVE learning one new thing a day!

[@slouhend]

Macca did.

[@turquisestones]

@@slouhend No, he didn't.

[@rubaventura7803]

SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL SENSACIONAL

[@lindameersschau2630]

Zouden jullie aub niet overwegen om toch nog een concert te geven in België ?

[@Hplarrialb]

Wow

[@bonniebickett4520]

I saw the redhead dancing that would be me too!

[@maxteclaguitar]

Os TIOS mandando a VERA!!!

[@leesanna7835]

One of the very few times Paul wasn't on a Beatles recording...

[@slouhend]

He was. He played bass. He left after the backing track was recorded, so that's why he did not contribute on vocals.

[@leesanna7835]

@@slouhend I'm sure you're aware of the photos of George with the rented Burns Bisen Bass? But it was possible they abandoned that idea, I did read Paul commenting in response to he was absent from the recording, he had said "I had a blarney and walked out" or something like that, lol...

[@slouhend]

​@@leesanna7835 Paul had an argument with the others, but he left after the backing track was recorded. He played bass. Then he left, so only John and George are on vocals. The backing track of She Said She Said was recorded as follows: track 1 - drums, bass track 2 - lead guitar, rhythm guitar Tracks 3 and 4 were left for vocals and overdubs. So, the recording of the backing track (track 1+2) requires 4 players. Or if George did not play guitar and bass simultaneously. Or John did not play two guitars at the same time. On track 3 and 4 there are vocals and organ, but not bass. So the bass HAD TO BE played on the backing track, so it had to be Paul. And, as the new proof, if you listen to She Said She Said backing track, as it's released on Revolver Deluxe Version, there is a speech before the recording and Paul is very audible here. Very audible. All of them were here. (Paul does not remember everything. As seen on Anthology in a discussion on Golden Slumbers. Paul played piano, George bass and Ringo was on the drums. But when listening to the tape, George said to Paul it was Paul playing the bass. And he did not contradict.)

[@leesanna7835]

Ahhh, ok, slouhend, thank you so much, Mate 🙏🙏🙏

[@scappaticciu]

Ce qui est bien avec eux c'est qu'il n'y a pas de clone, pas de costumes, pas de coupes de cheveux... Juste la musique.

[@dimebag77]

What happened to the mod looking guy?

[@woutersfrans4695]

Waar is dit te zien buiten NL ?

[@jackhana7374]

Wouters Frans I hope they come to California or Arizona

[@Schol205]

Kijk maar op hun website / check their website theanalogues.net/tourdates Nu gepland buiten NL: Belgie/Duitsland, only planned Belgium/Germany. I suppose they don’t like to go on a lengty tour. That touring is wat made the Beatles stop performing live.

[@5thBeatIe]

Should have gone further with the organ noise. You were smart enough to include it.

[@danielmelo7146]

🇳🇱🇧🇷🤘

[@dhscpa1956]

Call him the Hollan Woz....

[@johnmccartney9418]

Nice version ,but a little bit to slow in my opinion

[@DD_Davey]

Pretty darn good but the bass guitar could have been a lot closer. Bugs me. No biggie just saying.

[@rafaelzengo5534]

At times I had the impression that big old chap fell asleep mid song

[@TotalSinging]

for fucks sake look like you're having fun - bass player needs more caffeine

[@jamesmcdermott1550]

Tempo s little slow

[@patricio9469]

Unfortunately the drummer does not play the same as Ringo

[@jameswilliamjohnson]

OK but not as faithful as their other covers.

[@ludwigbittmann808]

yes, a bit to slow and the drum pattern ain't right. but that may be a Ringo's special, anyway I think that makes the difference

[@ReyesCarlos86]

Biblical.

[@ginpoolmanchegodiaz5017]

Que mal toca la batería

[@potopeludo2335]

Too difficult or impossible emulate ringo's drumming on this song...

[@rafaelzengo5534]

Yes. That's one of those things - captured on tape for the good of posterity, and never again.

[@hansvandijk1487]

Absolute masterpiece! Dear John RIP.

[@didonggadro]

I am very like this song.. but is differend. the beatles as well as the analogue in this song. I am sorry.

[@Bolognesechris]

Should be using a Rick, not a Hofner.

[@fredgien]

Ritmisch loopt het net niet lekker op de een of andere manier…

[@rafaelzengo5534]

These guys are great but here they sound a bit like the drunken russian beatles tribute band

[@jarambah6336]

drums a little bit off this one, and tempo is slower, but still great!

[@РустамТореев-о1у]

тут был ринго это его соло имею в виду оригинал the beatles-66

[@issbergzoom1586]

Леннон. Записывали без Мак.

[@michaelcartwright4012]

Nice, but this track needs a snarling Lennon to do it justice.

[@rosemarie92123]

I KNOW , BUT THIS IS THE BEST WE CAN GET NOW!!! 2 FUCKN BAD. MISS HIS SONGS. JT FROM MEX

[@rafaelzengo5534]

Its lacking in the nose&throat department

[@wuselkillefit]

Please stay in Germany! Please stay in Hamburg! GRAET !!!!

[@steveclark2662]

Macca never played on this song !

[@slouhend]

Nonsense. That's just a rumour.

[@steveclark2662]

@@slouhend Bollocks ! Read the facts . He even said it himself

[@slouhend]

@@steveclark2662 Yes, you have to read the facts. Paul had an argument with the others, but he left after the backing track was recorded. He played bass on it. Then he left, so that's why only John and George were on vocals. The backing track of She Said She Said was recorded as follows: track 1 - drums, bass track 2 - lead guitar, rhythm guitar Tracks 3 and 4 were left for vocals and overdubs. Acc. to Lewisohn who heard the original studio tapes. So, technically, the recording of the backing track (track 1+2) requires 4 players. Or George had to play guitar and bass simultaneously - I doubt it. Or John played lead and rhythm guitars at the same time? On track 3 and 4 there are vocals, organ and percussion, but no bass. Again, acc. to Lewisohn. So the bass HAD TO BE played on the backing track, so it was Paul. And, as the new proof, if you listen to She Said She Said backing track, as it's released on Revolver 2022 studio sessions second disc, there is a speech before the recording of She Said She Said and Paul is very audible here. Very audible. All of them were here. And, a few weeks ago, when asked, even Giles Martin who prepared Revolver 2022 version, confirmed it was Paul. By the way, Paul does not remember everything. As seen on Anthology in a discussion on Golden Slumbers. Paul played piano, George bass and Ringo was on the drums on this record. But, when listening to the tape, George said to Paul it was Paul playing the bass. And he did not contradict.

[@BrutusMcCrunch]

The drummer is wildly inaccurate

[@ericstewart9742]

Terrible