The Battle of al-Jamal (the Camel)

[@hassannaqvi3176]

I am Shia but it was very refreshing to hear the in-depth perspective from the Ahlul-Sunnah. Jazak-Allah Khair

[@nak.lanang]

No shia no sunni brotha. We are muslim 😊😊😊

[@muhammad5272]

What is refreshing listening to ridiculous nonsense? Really how blinded or ignorant does someone need to be to claim sahaba who fought a war against each other where many Muslims died were best buddies declaring they would be in heaven together. Imam Ali beat his thighs & cried. Now that makes a lot more sense & fits his view on the war. This joker say oh yes we be heaven together after trying to kill each other. I am all for hearing the other side but to call a extremely irrational account that defies common sense & logic refreshing! Either that poor wording or your deluded. You find more Sunni accounts all the same whitewashing insanely inexcusable

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

Interesting he deleted my comment. Truth was too much for him

[@zaksszn]

@@Shia.Ahlulbayt ahlul bidah

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

@@zaksszn is that the best you could do while fasting some fitna

[@canhaktan9674]

May Allah increase you in knowledge. Amen. You do a great job covering these topics, I have learned a lot. Thank you.

[@wahidjang9672]

Ameen.

[@abumusaryan4697]

ameen

[@ashrafmeziti4585]

The more i listen brother Fareed, the more i love him for the sake of Allah. Jazaka Allahu khaira

[@rockh1993]

Unbelievable... I just commented on hz Uthman video that I needed a 'battle of camel' video. And now this video comes up within hours 😁😍. thanks alot for this

[@Ali-bd2yx]

mashallah May Allah grant you great knowledge that will benefit u in this life and the next.

[@wahidjang9672]

@@Ali-bd2yx Ameen.

[@adilaljawahiri9616]

Could we get more of these historical lectures? I know a lot of research goes into it. Jzk Allah Kheir

[@zainarshed2965]

The twist at the end though. Jazak’Allah khair Sheikh for this. Pretty enlightening. Looking forward for more such videos from you. Eid Mubarak!

[@yosefofarabia508]

@@frabgas27 They killed Uthman because he hired his relatives, but when Ali became the leader, he did the same thing! All of the names you heard at the end are his cousins, they are the sons of Al-Abaas, the uncle of Ali.

[@zccau2316]

@@yosefofarabia508 So Malik al-Ashtar was the one who organised the killing of Uthman?

[@yosefofarabia508]

@@zccau2316 One of them, not the only one.

[@zccau2316]

@@yosefofarabia508 damn crazy. What the reference for the last bit then? Also to many Muslims know this is what happened?

[@mohamedabdou2807]

@@zccau2316 Please also look at the comment that I wrote in response to Yosef of Arabia, hopefully you know Arabic.

[@friendlyneighbourhoodmusli6565]

Eid Mubarak my dear brodahs

[@Ali-bd2yx]

Eid Mubarak

[@friendlyneighbourhoodmusli6565]

@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 jazakallahu khairan brother

[@Batman12-f9u]

ur username reminds me of abdullah sameer's intro: "this is ur friendly neighbourhood ex muslim" lol

[@weareweare-ij6nh]

@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Some questions that I had during this vedio 1) marwan killed talha r.a because he didn't did enough to save usman r.a . The previous vedio says that talha r.a was skeptic about some policies of zun nurain(usman r.a) , because it was talha r.a who helped usman r.a to get the position of khilafah so he felt some responsibilities when he saw some policies of usman r.a he didn't agree with. Atlast when usman r.a was martyred he felt guilt that he didn't applied enough efforts to save usman r.a . So he decided to avenge the blood of usman so here is the questions A)when were they asking shahbas like ibn umar ,ali and other for taking post of khilafah before the killing or after it. B) when usman left medina was usman r.a martyred if yes why did they receive the message while traveling that usman r.a had settled the issue

[@bogiekhan]

Eid Mubarak

[@HussainFahmy]

*_Taqabbal'Allahu Wa minna Wa Minkum. May Allah accept our fast and good deeds from us and you._*

[@12345678956824]

Ameen

[@wahidjang9672]

Ameen

[@lafiweil7147]

Why did we kill the sheikh in Medina! That was the best part of the lecture and sums up the whole conflict.

[@syedyasirali1974]

For power, for self interest. And now the very same people or their offshoots try to justify their wrongdoings by claiming to love Ahlul Bayt. When it was never about love of Ahlul Bayt, it was about power.

[@lafiweil7147]

@@syedyasirali1974 These were the words of Malik Al-ashtar admitting that he was seeking power and influence

[@syedyasirali1974]

@@lafiweil7147 i know, that is what i said. The second part was about the sect that is the offshoot of the political group

[@lafiweil7147]

@@syedyasirali1974 My bad, I misunderstood your words. May Allah reward you brother.

[@maryeve3984]

PLEASE 🙏 IGN😂RE THE H🕳LY BIBLE ✝️ Anyone who curses his father or mother shall surely be put to death⚰️ 😰 ( -Leviticus- 2O : 9 )

[@ImamMurrahTheTimeTraveller]

2 videos in one day? Eid mubarak to us indeed! :D

[@iamharald]

You're back!

[@taher9358]

Please change your picture brother its very inappropriate

[@taher9358]

@Heywood Yabloome Says the Christian who has absolutely no legs to stand on. Your religion is based purely on priests theory and no textual evidence. Good luck preaching to something people made up. You got no clue how to verify what Jesus taught because your bible scholars themselves are lost trying to find the authentic teachings of Jesus and you here calling to a jigsaw puzzle. Very laughable as you are deluded and calling people to delusion.

[@SadikKhan-wt8cs]

Finally a video lecture! But still waiting for the Umar (RA) speech.🥺

[@SadikKhan-wt8cs]

@@ituuali4744 shut it spammer.

[@AN-mx8vk]

What do you mean? Did he have audio lectures? Because i just watched the Martyr of Uthman video and that was posted 2 years ago. And there would be a part 2 so i am confused... are there any other lectures or is this the part 2?

[@SadikKhan-wt8cs]

@@AN-mx8vk no, there was a video with Saajid Lipham a year ago. There, he told he would have a lecture about Umar(RA)...

[@Ab_Ismael]

6:08 Examples of Sayf using “anti-sahabi” points 8:01 main shi’i sources 11:00 Waqidi 13:15 Kulayb’s lengthy report* 14:56 dispute who to become caliph 16:54 Dogs of Haw’ab 21:05 Kulayb’s report

[@ইসলামেইশান্তি-ল৬জ]

Eid Mubarak Brother. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩

[@unveilingthetruth5784]

Subhanallah! Just when I needed it. Jazaakallahul khair Sheikh Farid

[@teukufadel8293]

Ma Sha Allah,it's so rare to see this analysis that using English language 👍

[@mukhtar768]

May Allah gather you with the ones you love my brother. Ameen.

[@wahidjang9672]

Ameen

[@IshaaqNewton]

Eid Mubarak everyone...

[@mertgezici5489]

Subhanallah! What an emotional event. May Allah bless you brother.

[@wahidjang9672]

Ameen

[@h.al-kenani2000]

Very beneficial lecture. JazakAllahu khairan. I think the conclusion shows how pointless this battle was but also how wrong people were in what they perseved to be true and what chaos and bloodshed resulted out of it.

[@EmanMohamed-ji7xy]

Eid Mubarak muslims every where 🌹🌹

[@mustafaahmed9940]

I am Shia and a good source of the battle of Jamal is the book called Nahjul Balgha, which is a compile of sernons and letters of Imam Ali and many letters and Sermons were about the Battle.

[@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273]

I don't take shia They have narrated by liar They attribute sayings to ali ra and imam jafar

[@TheHaqtivist]

Good to see this. An educating academic Sunni video backed with evidences. Masha Allah

[@nabeels7325]

This is eye opening, jazakAllah khair

[@DawahTrucker2024]

Subhaana'Allah it's so the events in the history of the companions after the death of the prophet Muhammad ﷺ. May Allah forgive all the companions and be pleased with them all. RasoolAllah ﷺ prophecied this even would happen letter by letter word for word because he is the truthful, the trustworthy الصادق الامين، الصادق المصدوق and there is no denying about this fact. Fareed I'm so glad that you are narrating this in a fair manner and removing the filth from what is true. All we can say is رضي الله عنهم ورضوا عنه.i am awaiting for the next video if you explaining more in detail the battle of Siffin.

[@ituuali4744]

THE VIRTUES OF AHLUL BAYT: 1' NO ONE LOVE ALIY EXCEPT BELIEVER AND NO ONE HATE ALIY EXCEPT HYPOCRITE'' 2'' THOSE WHO INSULT(CURSE) ALIY, INDEED HAVE CURSED ME(RASSULLILLAH SAWAW) '' 3''ALIY IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 4'' FOR WHOMEVER I AM MAWLA, HERE ALIY IS HIS MAWLA, ALLAH LOVES THOSE HELP ALIY AND THOSE WHO FIGHT HIM ARE ENEMY OF ALLAH'' 5'' I AM IN PEASE WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN PEASE WITH AND I AM IN WAR WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN WAR WITH'' [YOU: FATIMATU ZAHRA, IMAM ALIY, HASSAN, HUSSEN] 6'' HUSSEN IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 7''ALLAH LOVES WHOEVER LOVES IMAM HASSAN AND IMAM HUSSEN'' 8''ALLAH SATISFIED FOR FATIMATU ZAHRA SATISFACTION AND HE ANGERS FOR HER ANGER'' 9'' FATIMA IS PART OF ME WHOEVER HARM HER HAVE HARMED ME, WHOEVER HARMED ME HAVE ANGERED ALLAH'' 10'' I AM THE CITY OF WISDOM AND ALIY IS THE GATE'' 11'' ALIY YOU ARE MY BROTHER IN THIS WORLD AND HEREAFTER'' 12''KHAYBAR'' I WILL GIVE THE RAAYA FOR A PERSON WHO LOVES ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET AND, ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET LOVES HIM MOST (FROM ALL OF THE COMPANIONS GATHERED AT THE BATTLE OF KHAYBAR ... ABBKR, UMR, USMN ETC) AND ALLAH WILL OPEN KHAYBAR FOR HIM'' WHO IS THE PERSON? IMAM ALIY(AS)'' 13''ALIY ALWAYS WITH TRUTH, THE TRUETH REVOLVE WHEREVER ALIY RESIDE'' 14''HADEETH AS SAQALAYN'' TWO WEIGHTY THINGS RASSULLULLAH(SAWAW) LEFT BEHIND'' 15''ONLY THOSE WHO LOVE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) WOULD HAVE COMPLETE IMAN'' 16'' THOSE WHO HATE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) ARE DISBELIEVERS (HYPOCRITES)''

[@soheil527]

@@ituuali4744 zaef hades from shia book written 400 years later in shia kingdom of the buyd princes and later kermani seljuks.

[@soheil527]

Allah is Alive, Ali is dead and his sons are too.

[@soheil527]

@@ituuali4744 lanat on killlers of uthman

[@faisalrafiqbhat1064]

@@soheil527 brother i am a sunni ... Most of the Hadiths he quoted are authentic according to ahlus sunnah manhaj

[@ivarm8284]

Eid Mubarak bro,,, you should upload alot,, luv your vids

[@handler654]

May Allah protect us, but these two amazing lectures leave one with more questions than it answers. Honest Review.

[@ituuali4744]

THE VIRTUES OF AHLUL BAYT: 1' NO ONE LOVE ALIY EXCEPT BELIEVER AND NO ONE HATE ALIY EXCEPT HYPOCRITE'' 2'' THOSE WHO INSULT(CURSE) ALIY, INDEED HAVE CURSED ME(RASSULLILLAH SAWAW) '' 3''ALIY IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 4'' FOR WHOMEVER I AM MAWLA, HERE ALIY IS HIS MAWLA, ALLAH LOVES THOSE HELP ALIY AND THOSE WHO FIGHT HIM ARE ENEMY OF ALLAH'' 5'' I AM IN PEASE WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN PEASE WITH AND I AM IN WAR WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN WAR WITH'' [YOU: FATIMATU ZAHRA, IMAM ALIY, HASSAN, HUSSEN] 6'' HUSSEN IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 7''ALLAH LOVES WHOEVER LOVES IMAM HASSAN AND IMAM HUSSEN'' 8''ALLAH SATISFIED FOR FATIMATU ZAHRA SATISFACTION AND HE ANGERS FOR HER ANGER'' 9'' FATIMA IS PART OF ME WHOEVER HARM HER HAVE HARMED ME, WHOEVER HARMED ME HAVE ANGERED ALLAH'' 10'' I AM THE CITY OF WISDOM AND ALIY IS THE GATE'' 11'' ALIY YOU ARE MY BROTHER IN THIS WORLD AND HEREAFTER'' 12''KHAYBAR'' I WILL GIVE THE RAAYA FOR A PERSON WHO LOVES ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET AND, ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET LOVES HIM MOST (FROM ALL OF THE COMPANIONS GATHERED AT THE BATTLE OF KHAYBAR ... ABBKR, UMR, USMN ETC) AND ALLAH WILL OPEN KHAYBAR FOR HIM'' WHO IS THE PERSON? IMAM ALIY(AS)'' 13''ALIY ALWAYS WITH TRUTH, THE TRUETH REVOLVE WHEREVER ALIY RESIDE'' 14''HADEETH AS SAQALAYN'' TWO WEIGHTY THINGS RASSULLULLAH(SAWAW) LEFT BEHIND'' 15''ONLY THOSE WHO LOVE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) WOULD HAVE COMPLETE IMAN'' 16'' THOSE WHO HATE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) ARE DISBELIEVERS (HYPOCRITES)''

[@handler654]

@@ituuali4744 We all love Hazrat Ali and Ahle bait. For indeed love of Ahle bait is a requirement of faith. 🙏

[@12345678956824]

Honestly I'd say everyone needs to worry about their own souls because Allah knows best.

[@salm_]

​@@ituuali4744 Half of them are myths fabricated by the Shiites, weak and not valid B The consensus of the Sunnis and the group is that Abu Bakr and Omer is better than Ali, and there are also those who prefer Uthman over Ali

[@sniperphoenix4040]

0:20 Ustadh suggests watching the prequel - Martyrdom of Uthman (Radiallahu Anh) 1:50 A challenge to the shi'a 2:44 The sources for the battle of Al-Jamal 4:15 The importance of applying the methodology of the Muhadditheen 5:31 The main source of al Jamal - Sayf ibn Umar at-Tamimi (Weakened by the Muhadditheen) 7:56 Shi'i source of al Jamal 8:42 Why the narrations of Abu Makhnaf are problematic and unreliable 13:01 What is the authentic source for the Battle of Al Jamal 14:38 Context / Background 15:58 Why was Ali (Radiallahu Anh) advised by Ibn Abbas and Al Hasan (Radiallahu Anhum) to not become the caliph? 16:29 Why was Ali (Radiallahu Anh) accused of k*lling Uthman? 20:31 The Basran army heading out to avenge Uthman / Rumors spreading about rebels coming into agreement 21:22 Why did A'isha, Talha, Zubair go to Al Basra? 23:36 Osama Bin zaid testifies that Talha was forced to give the pledge of allegiance to Ali 24:38 The minor Jamal occurs 28:58 Kulayb asks Ali about his views on Uthman 32:11 Al Zubair prevents the man from causing mischief and k*lling Ali 32:39 The thought of the Kuffans being fought by the Basrans 33:10 How the battle started 35:02 Talha preventing the army from going out / Talha gets shot by Marwan bin hakam 36:51 The reason why Marwan bin hakam shoots arrow at Talha 37:38 Al Zubair leaves the battle and gets k*lled 38:15 Ibn Abbas asks Ali about the k*ller of Zubair 39:51 The battle ends 40:38 Ali's advice to his army 41:51 The time duration of the battle 42:05 The number of Basreen's that were killed 45:07 The number of people in each army 50:40 The twist

[@AhhnaafZaman]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@RawaLanunBahasa]

Islam is dead outside AlHaramain Islam died after Abu Bakar ra died Surah:5(al-Ma’idah) Verse:49 وَأَنِ ٱحۡكُم بَيۡنَهُم بِمَآ أَنزَلَ ٱللَّهُ وَلَا تَتَّبِعۡ أَهۡوَآءَهُمۡ وَٱحۡذَرۡهُمۡ أَن يَفۡتِنُوكَ عَنۢ بَعۡضِ مَآ أَنزَلَ ٱللَّهُ إِلَيۡكَۖ فَإِن تَوَلَّوۡاْ فَٱعۡلَمۡ أَنَّمَا يُرِيدُ ٱللَّهُ أَن يُصِيبَهُم بِبَعۡضِ ذُنُوبِهِمۡۗ وَإِنَّ كَثِيرٗا مِّنَ ٱلنَّاسِ لَفَٰسِقُونَ And judge, [O Muhammad], between them by what Allah has revealed and do not follow their inclinations and beware of them, lest they tempt you away from some of what Allah has revealed to you. And if they turn away - then know that Allah only intends to afflict them with some of their [own] sins. And indeed, many among the people are defiantly disobedient. Surah:5(al-Ma’idah) Verse:50 أَفَحُكۡمَ ٱلۡجَٰهِلِيَّةِ يَبۡغُونَۚ وَمَنۡ أَحۡسَنُ مِنَ ٱللَّهِ حُكۡمٗا لِّقَوۡمٖ يُوقِنُونَ Then is it the judgement of [the time of] ignorance they desire? But who is better than Allah in judgement for a people who are certain [in faith]. -Saheeh International

[@Unknown-ct2gf]

Yay best Eid gift .

[@janganmarah8614]

Alhamdulillah.. May Allah bless you and your family.. bro Farid

[@wahidjang9672]

Ameen

[@forster1240]

Thank you for mentioning that Marwan killed Talha RA, some may try to hide that fact, some who try to present an extreme "sunni" narrative of history might try to hide that fact and absolve Marwan of wrongdoing but its good you are unbiased in that.

[@suhanamahmud5377]

Someone needs to animate this 😭 Watched it twice but it just gets confusingggg

[@alisyed9584]

As a shia the problem I see with this, is the use of one “shia” historian/book etc to generalise how all shia view the topic. half, if not the majority of the “shia” claims in this video would be laughed out of a shia mosque (or worse). for example, Ali (as) cursing a man using a derogatory term? Shia hold Ali (as) to honorable standards, and that is not honorable by any means. chastise the individual writers, not the sect.

[@valour6530]

You guys have so many contradicting narrations, which Shia narration should we believe in

[@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273]

These incidents only narrated this books

[@samyhannah9563]

what about the part where mohammed ibn abu bakr was on the side of ALI and not his sisters!

[@muhammadsajjadshahid5552]

Because he was brought up by Ali

[@user-gc2ln8fy1f]

And Aqil bin Abu talib sided with Muawiyah over Ali. What's the relevance ?

[@muhammadsajjadshahid5552]

@@user-gc2ln8fy1f aqeel isn't a significant figure in Islam, though he left muaweya over realization

[@user-gc2ln8fy1f]

@@muhammadsajjadshahid5552 He narrates a number of ahadith

[@yourdad602]

Make a video on Battle of Siffeen also. Jazakallah Khairan

[@ituuali4744]

THE VIRTUES OF AHLUL BAYT: 1' NO ONE LOVE ALIY EXCEPT BELIEVER AND NO ONE HATE ALIY EXCEPT HYPOCRITE'' 2'' THOSE WHO INSULT(CURSE) ALIY, INDEED HAVE CURSED ME(RASSULLILLAH SAWAW) '' 3''ALIY IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 4'' FOR WHOMEVER I AM MAWLA, HERE ALIY IS HIS MAWLA, ALLAH LOVES THOSE HELP ALIY AND THOSE WHO FIGHT HIM ARE ENEMY OF ALLAH'' 5'' I AM IN PEASE WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN PEASE WITH AND I AM IN WAR WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN WAR WITH'' [YOU: FATIMATU ZAHRA, IMAM ALIY, HASSAN, HUSSEN] 6'' HUSSEN IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 7''ALLAH LOVES WHOEVER LOVES IMAM HASSAN AND IMAM HUSSEN'' 8''ALLAH SATISFIED FOR FATIMATU ZAHRA SATISFACTION AND HE ANGERS FOR HER ANGER'' 9'' FATIMA IS PART OF ME WHOEVER HARM HER HAVE HARMED ME, WHOEVER HARMED ME HAVE ANGERED ALLAH'' 10'' I AM THE CITY OF WISDOM AND ALIY IS THE GATE'' 11'' ALIY YOU ARE MY BROTHER IN THIS WORLD AND HEREAFTER'' 12''KHAYBAR'' I WILL GIVE THE RAAYA FOR A PERSON WHO LOVES ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET AND, ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET LOVES HIM MOST (FROM ALL OF THE COMPANIONS GATHERED AT THE BATTLE OF KHAYBAR ... ABBKR, UMR, USMN ETC) AND ALLAH WILL OPEN KHAYBAR FOR HIM'' WHO IS THE PERSON? IMAM ALIY(AS)'' 13''ALIY ALWAYS WITH TRUTH, THE TRUETH REVOLVE WHEREVER ALIY RESIDE'' 14''HADEETH AS SAQALAYN'' TWO WEIGHTY THINGS RASSULLULLAH(SAWAW) LEFT BEHIND'' 15''ONLY THOSE WHO LOVE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) WOULD HAVE COMPLETE IMAN'' 16'' THOSE WHO HATE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) ARE DISBELIEVERS (HYPOCRITES)''

[@RG-107]

@@ituuali4744 true

[@salahadeen7785]

Yes

[@ayturalfil]

I love prophet muhammed (sawas) and his ahlalbayt (as)!!!❤❤❤❤❤

[@lopez4059]

14:39 there the story starts, make sure to watch the background check though

[@anonymousperson331]

IT IS FRIDAY PLEASE RECITE SURAH KAHF

[@naeemashraf8355]

Ma sha Allah Great video Brother Farid....Could you please share the reference(s) to the last part. Also, could u share more sahi references related to Ibn Ashtar for knowledge purposes... Here in Pakistan, some folks have made Ashtar comparable to the level of Awais Qarni rehmullah 🤣🤣🤣

[@owaissheraz]

Right,,, i used to follow that dude But definitely more i actually study more the fool he apears to be He is so afraid of rafidha, to speak against kufria tpoucs like imamah and also he never said anything wrong about their kufria beliefs of tahreef e quran Musnaf ibn shaiba has the reports of ashtar and ibn bakr killing uthman.... And the chapter is before the chapter of jamal Engineer wrong number h

[@naeemashraf8355]

Eng Mirza started foul mouthed from Ulemas, Mujtahid Imams, Muhadithins, Sahabas, Prophet ﷺ. and even Allah. Man is on fast track to become Mirza Senior of Qadiyan

[@citycentregreen]

Great work my brother. Please keep it up

[@Ab_Ismael]

18:12 Abu Mikhnaf’s distorted addition 22:54 Talha forced to give bay’ah 24:56 “little” battle of jamal 32:31 Kulayb’s 45:40 reactions of the battle

[@mohammadrubanimalik4548]

I am not a Shia but this is not the Narrative of AhleSunnat Books you are overlooking lots of Authentic Ahadith. Ali as was On Haqq and Haqq was with Ali as. The Opponents were Rebels out of them Zubair, talha and Aisa alaihimussalam repented but Muavia Sticked to his Ego.

[@robaado5211]

The Holy prophet phub even before warning ⚠️ aisha and sahaba about jamel ALI AS IS WITH THE TRUTH AND TRUTH IS WITH ALI AS

[@jamieammar6131]

Authentic Hadith ? Hadith are the sayings and deeds of the Prophet. Now think about that for a second and come back.

[@soheil527]

Ali was a leech who maligned the honor of ayesha. lanat on him .

[@EpicRevelations]

@@jamieammar6131 truth is with ali is an authentic hadith. Even ibn taymiya admitted it is sahih but says it is "strange", whatever the heck that means lol

[@jamieammar6131]

@@EpicRevelations Wasn't replying to the comment above, to the OP.

[@adilmujtaba09]

I agree with brother Farid that greed is human nature, perhaps that also drove Talha, Zubair, Aisha to Basra. God knows best

[@user-ur8jj2hu6z]

Can you also share the references if not all then at least just the one where Ali bin abi talib defended aisha

[@mfayz980]

Can you do one for the battle of Siffin

[@bigdawgification]

Jazakallahu khairan for this video and lecture; I really appreciate the historical source criticism that you do in the beginning, which really differentiates it from the sloppy lectures of Yasir Qadhi who includes every report and mixes them together creating a fantastical narrative that in fact no one ever reported! Excellent points, and resources, and critiques of the event. I look forward to Siffin, the khilafa of ibn al-Zubayr, and other events. I really would hope that for the average Muslim, you are able to present a sirah/maghazi and early Islamic history series (I know this might be too much to ask) that presents a counter narrative to that of Qadhi's.

[@nihalhakim5148]

Akhi your comment is slightly unfair to Yasir Qadhi, I’m watching his seerah series and he very clearly points out what are the stronger narrations vs. weaker narrations. And he gives a lot clarification about the full picture of an event when there’s piecemeal reports. He’s not perfect but he’s not creating fantasies and his work is not sloppy. It’s some of the most rigorous historical analysis in the english language

[@DaggerSecurity]

these stories are so sad. But they illustrate how things began to unravel and how the khawarij deserve a large portion of the blame for why we are the place we are in today.

[@mr_wavey07]

no the only person to blame is Aisha

[@Bruh-pb5os]

@@mr_wavey07 😐

[@mr_wavey07]

@@Bruh-pb5os I'm glad I left that false Sunni religion and join Islam (Shi'a)

[@soheil527]

@@mr_wavey07 hussei8n was to blame for his stupidity

[@iMan-610]

Exactly. The battle happened bcz of khajiri

[@LofiMogul]

Can you always go straight to the history and stop trying to find faults in narrators and their teachers

[@kingpiye7060]

So he shouldn't analysis the historiography of events/narratives and their authenticity just to affirm your psued zindeeq aqeeda?

[@rasalasad5315]

Taqabbal Allaahu minna wa minkum wa ahaalahu Allah alayka. Allah preserve you Farid.

[@Ali-bd2yx]

ameen

[@fs5297]

JazakAllah khair. More of such topics please.

[@gusswaratah440]

I wish I heard this 20 years ago

[@ily5872]

why, what did it change?

[@Aaron40089]

The MORE i listen to this man i can SEE HE REFLECT BOUGH E AHALEBAIT....

[@Koelsoemahmed]

Even though I am from a Sunni family I am very sad that this battle took place between the fourth rightful caliph Sayyidina Ali(K.W) and the Mother of the Faithful Lady Aisha.What saddens me even more is that Talhah and Zubair turned their backs upon Sayyidina Ali(K.W).Talhah and Zubair were from amongst the early pioneers of Islam and they were great warriors on the battlefields during the lifetime of the prophet Muhammad S.A.W.This was a tragic battle because thousands of Muslims got killed on the battlefield. Sayyidina Ali(K.W.)was innocent of the tragic death of Sayyidina Uthman who was killed by so called Muslims while he was reading the Quran.

[@kay1057]

I think you missed an important point why a lot of people believe Ali had a hand in the death of Uthamn. Because you mentioned Mohammad Ibn Abu Bakir being one of the main killers and the one that ordered the death of Uthamn. But you failed to mention that Mohammad Ibn Abu Bakir was raised and brought up by Ali because his mother when he was 2-3 years old married Ali. And this Mohammad Ibn Abu Bakir was made the Governor of Egypt by Ali.

[@venom0921]

As you said in the first video, we need to discuss the fitna, as not discussing it results in a bigger one. On this note, please discuss from here until Karbala the same way, as fitna coz of them is 100 times bigger. Specially when we have authentic reports of Muawiyah R.A ordering his governors to do lanah on Hazrat Ali R.A.

[@ituuali4744]

MUAWIYA RA? bro we muslims do not say RA for munafik. muawiya is munafik because he used to hate IMAM ALIY(RA/AS), FOUGHT IMAM ALIY(AS), CURSED BY RASSULLULLAH(SAWAW). eg, my God do not satisfy/fill his stomach THE VIRTUES OF AHLUL BAYT: 1' NO ONE LOVE ALIY EXCEPT BELIEVER AND NO ONE HATE ALIY EXCEPT HYPOCRITE'' 2'' THOSE WHO INSULT(CURSE) ALIY, INDEED HAVE CURSED ME(RASSULLILLAH SAWAW) '' 3''ALIY IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 4'' FOR WHOMEVER I AM MAWLA, HERE ALIY IS HIS MAWLA, ALLAH LOVES THOSE HELP ALIY AND THOSE WHO FIGHT HIM ARE ENEMY OF ALLAH'' 5'' I AM IN PEASE WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN PEASE WITH AND I AM IN WAR WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN WAR WITH'' [YOU: FATIMATU ZAHRA, IMAM ALIY, HASSAN, HUSSEN] 6'' HUSSEN IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 7''ALLAH LOVES WHOEVER LOVES IMAM HASSAN AND IMAM HUSSEN'' 8''ALLAH SATISFIED FOR FATIMATU ZAHRA SATISFACTION AND HE ANGERS FOR HER ANGER'' 9'' FATIMA IS PART OF ME WHOEVER HARM HER HAVE HARMED ME, WHOEVER HARMED ME HAVE ANGERED ALLAH'' 10'' I AM THE CITY OF WISDOM AND ALIY IS THE GATE'' 11'' ALIY YOU ARE MY BROTHER IN THIS WORLD AND HEREAFTER'' 12''KHAYBAR'' I WILL GIVE THE RAAYA FOR A PERSON WHO LOVES ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET AND, ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET LOVES HIM MOST (FROM ALL OF THE COMPANIONS GATHERED AT THE BATTLE OF KHAYBAR ... ABBKR, UMR, USMN ETC) AND ALLAH WILL OPEN KHAYBAR FOR HIM'' WHO IS THE PERSON? IMAM ALIY(AS)'' 13''ALIY ALWAYS WITH TRUTH, THE TRUETH REVOLVE WHEREVER ALIY RESIDE'' 14''HADEETH AS SAQALAYN'' TWO WEIGHTY THINGS RASSULLULLAH(SAWAW) LEFT BEHIND'' 15''ONLY THOSE WHO LOVE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) WOULD HAVE COMPLETE IMAN'' 16'' THOSE WHO HATE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) ARE DISBELIEVERS (HYPOCRITES)''

[@venom0921]

@@ituuali4744 mate I know all this, and I'll die before I'll say Ali (R.A./A.S.) was wrong. There is consensus of Ummah on this, in every fiqh, but extremes on both sides, i.e., Rafidhis and Naasbis are wrong. What I wanted was a lecture by Farid, as he's one of the most sane voices I've ever heard on the internet.

[@johnbarker3673]

@@venom0921 he's a shi'i based on his other comments here.

[@soheil527]

@@venom0921 A final note Muawiyah did not rebel agianst Ali the dispute that lead to the battle of siffin was many the killing of uthman, Muawiyah withholding his bayah until Ali hand him over the killers of Uthman, the battle of the camel and Ali demanding that Muawiyah give him bayah And more which evwntully lead to fighting when Ali marched agianst Muawiyah

[@soheil527]

WHY? aLI was incompetent and was bitching to claim the throne

[@abdula16]

You should post the prerequisites in the description box

[@islamvsatheistsfeminists9371]

Jazak Allahu khayr

[@abohuraira412]

Masha' Allah bro Farid may Allah benefit the Ummah by ur knowledge bro

[@fahralyacoub8970]

اللهم والي من والاه، و عادي من عاداه، و انصر من نصره، و اخذل من خذله." I know which side I'd be on and I'd have no problem killing any sahabi that fights that side.

[@Castiel_Ab]

Please more history video’s

[@1541965]

Farid may I ask why you didn't talk about What is happening now in Masjid Al Aqsa 1st Qiblah of Muslims and Palestine ? الأخ فريد هل تسمح لي بالسؤال لماذا لم تعلق عن ما يحدث في اولى القبلتين وثالث الحرمين وقضية فلسطين وقتل الأبرياء ؟

[@darthman649]

17:56 I heard that this ahadith is zaeef as one of the Ravi wasn't present at the battle of jamal and that the chain of narratorion is broken.

[@sahebbioflockfishfarming897]

Bro this Hadith is not zaeef,the ravi wasn't present at the battle of jamal it is right but the ravi heard that incident from ammi Ayesha r.a

[@HusnainMeerzadehh]

Zubair left bcz Imam Ameerul Momineen Ali as narrated a hadith that Oh Zubair do you remember Rasool SAWW said once to you that one day you will stand against Ali as when you were showing your love for me and then you said Oh Allah give me death before that day? Once hearing this hadith Zubair left

[@user-gf3hf5ri8b]

Hello, some Shia people claim that Aisha RA hated Ali RA and that is why she went into war against Ali and that she had no relationship with Uthman so why avenge his death. what would be your response to them?

[@LofiMogul]

Going against Ali itself tells you how much she hated Ali

[@user-gf3hf5ri8b]

@@LofiMogul i asked from Sunni the response. You don't have to speak

[@adilmujtaba09]

Hadiths of Prophet are standing behind Maula Ali that he was on Haq and was a rashidun caliph. With all due respect to companions of prophet (pbuh) Jamal, Siffeen, Neharwaan shows why prophet (pbuh) said Manqunto maula fahaza Aliyon maula.

[@RS-gi9hu]

Except, maulana doesn't mean vicegearent. It means beloved. That's it.

[@faisalrafiqbhat1064]

@@RS-gi9hu here mawla clears means Cheif. Its like whatever loved and affection you have for Prophet(SAW), it has to be also for Ali A.S.

[@alaminlemu]

​@@faisalrafiqbhat1064lol. Rafidhi performing taqiya posing as ahlus-Sunnah.

[@RS-gi9hu]

@faisalrafiqbhat1064 literally nowhere in the Quran Is maulana defined as "cheif"

[@mostafahussaini843]

@@RS-gi9hulet’s say it means beloved. Funny how the likes of Aisha, Tulla and Zubair loved Ali so much that they started a Civil war here. 😅😅😅. Man some muslims are delusional.

[@AlJaathiyah45_23]

Eid Mubarak Sheikh ..Ameen

[@digitstd4168]

The basic fact is simple - Ayesha raised an army against a caliph - so the punishment to raise an army against a caliph is ????

[@iMan-610]

No. Mother Aisha raised an army against khariji who killed Uthman r.a,which khariji were in army of Ali. The clash btw Aisha and Ali happened because khariji attacked Aisha,to make this look like Ali attacked her.

[@kingali7842]

@@iMan-610source?

[@kingali7842]

@@iMan-610this is false lmao

[@muhammadtasiu5473]

​@@kingali7842 And he can't mention it

[@michaeliskandar8236]

the shia narrative as you know is the same people who had enough of uthman and developed resentment to him and even called for his head were the same people that used it as a excuse to rebel against imam ali a.s. it is known talha and zubair came to him and asked for positions and when they werent given they became bitter and joined forces with aisha who already had a bitterness to imam ali a.s. they raised a army and headed towards basra where talha and zubair had supporters. imam ali pleaded with zubair and eventually got through to him and he left the battle proof that there was another agenda besides finding the killers of uthman because others could of stopped also but clearly didnt . the war ended when aishas camel was taken down further proof that she was the motivator and wasnt going there for peaceful purposes as some try to sell

[@ayturalfil]

Loving ali(as) is imaan (faith), hating ali(as) is munafiq (hypocrisy)!!!

[@abdelhalimtarek]

Farid you re not supposed to give us your comments! You re just supposed to give us what are the different sources but you can t say yeah I think it s this narrations and he was killed by him?

[@michaeliskandar8236]

haraam... you guys dont think much of a man that sacrificed his whole life for the religion do you. any objective historian will tell you ali ibn abi taleb should never be associated with greed and fear. how irresponsible and ignorant to say a man with his proven track record that even the prophet swore by would even be considered in this way. wallahi to even consider this for ali ibn abi taleb as possible shows a lack of knowledge and a lack of faith in spirituality itself, because one would think someone chosen by allah in khaibar, al mubahala, al keessaa and the only one willing to risk his life for allah when called upon three times in khandaq would be free of such attributes

[@lbnFadl]

It's kind of amazing they accept all those accusations and criticisms of Ali but you can't even say Aisha was wrong to go to *war* against a rightly guided caliph.

[@kevinshmuk7237]

They hate ali for some reason and always downplay the achievements.

[@soheil527]

@@kevinshmuk7237 nobody hates. it is shias who hate sahabas and arabs as persian behinds were thrashed over and over since they are at heart still mourning for the loss of their persian empire

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

@@soheil527 listening to these ridiculous excuses. Ayesha calling for killing of Uthman, every history recognises the nepotism of his ruler ship & corruption it brought. Why did muawiya send army to save him. Good old family

[@salaflover]

Where does he say that he doesn't think much of him? And when did he associate him with greed and fear?

[@UB40X1]

How many Companions participated in actual battle?

[@ahmads5889]

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته Say RadiAllahuAnhu

[@harisabbasi8396]

Assalamu Alaikum. I don't know if you read this brother Fareed but can you elaborate on the role of amir Ibn hamiq khuzai. Was he among the killers of Uthman and is he one of the those sahaba who gave bay'ah ridhwan?

[@Malik08897]

Hiding the truth . Go read Hadith books yourself in Sunni books not historical narrations . Hazrat Ali ra was right .

[@smbmrizvi]

Mr. Farid.. is saying Ali A.S was fearful and greedy.. even reporting such fabricated narrations is zulm… Laanat Allah al al Kazibeen

[@soheil527]

lant of the killers of uthman and also Ali who refused to punish the killers

[@ishrakmohammad7307]

@@soheil527 are you saying lanat on Ali?

[@soheil527]

@@ishrakmohammad7307 Yes, because he murdered uthman with help of persian dog abu lulu

[@soheil527]

Fatima hated ruqaiyya and her other sisters

[@ishrakmohammad7307]

@@soheil527 I seriously now think you are a non-muslim troll posing as muslim who has a playlist named muslim woman. Moreover, abu lulu killed Umar and commit suicide.Not even original nasibis and not even quranists would say such thing about Fatima.

[@ubaidakhtar8047]

السلام عليكم أخي فريد This attire/clothing you are wearing. Is this sunnah?

[@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273]

Sunnah is wearing white clothes But this Bahrain culture

[@Bulayla1426]

"Never stick to 1 primary source" Allama shaykhil islam yasir qadhi: "in my humble opinion"

[@deathnote4171]

Yasir qahdi bring Many Sources in his detail long series Like Seerah etc he is an academic Respect him

[@Bulayla1426]

@@deathnote4171 he speaks on issues which he completely bullcraps the stuff he dont know. Farid has a vid showing yasir qadhi's dishonesty. And saajid lipham has a bunfh Oh and his idea of tawheed. Maybe you should wake up

[@abdullahiayantayo3253]

@@christianfamilyman4476 I have sahih bukhari but I can't find the hadith anywhere, maybe your friends made it up because 2357 says something totally different than what you want it to say, try to be honest next time😄

[@abdullahiayantayo3253]

@@mohammadqasim1974 they are always acting like foxes

[@abdullahiayantayo3253]

@@mohammadqasim1974 post it in the other comment sections so people don't fall for it

[@LofiMogul]

I have once again can confirm that you’re against Ali n indeed this your Channel is made to defend those who hated Ali…

[@imamiyyah]

Hey I remember these two videos! ;)

[@zurarahofthelevant6279]

Lol these Sunnis sleep well at night believing this nonsense. It’s like asking Allah to be pleased with George Bush and saddam LOL

[@قناةأهلالحديثوالأثر-ث6ش]

@@zurarahofthelevant6279 you cant disprove it tho😂😂

[@bayat786]

Would you dare to debate Bayat Al Ghadeer on the battles of camel and siffin

[@mnoorbhai]

Why Aisha as the wife of the Prophet leave the house of the Prophet when prohibited ,

[@FaridResponds]

The wives weren't under house arrest.

[@mnoorbhai]

@@FaridResponds True , but as consorts of the greatest man who changed the world and who was under guidance from Allah on all matters, and the commands given on his family and their behaviour as stalwarts of the preachings of the Prophet , they were under an obligation to portray standards of the highest order ,..... why would she come out in the open , unlike the other wives , and display this animosity, well documented, towards the son in law and the beloved daughter of the Prophet , ..why get to gang up with these Talha and Zubair who left Medina to immediately depart to Mecca , complain to Aisha who immediately hatches plans of war , gets infuriated and mad at the appointment of Ali as the new Khalif , (clearly shows the hatred towards Ali), march out to Basra miles away , raise an opposition army, which Ali (AS) clearly cautioned against , yet she went ahead and concorted the story of apprehending the killers of Uthman , sided with and connived and poisoned the minds of the very same persons, Talha and Zubair,(who had designs of becoming the next leaders and were pissed off on Ali(as)appointment), who lost their lives in the uprising which was rightfully and respectfully squashed by Ali (as) .Look at Ali (as), despite the treachery of Aisha, respectfully, as the widow of the Prophet , removed her, despite her unseemingly behavior, from the scene,..... if the opposite was true and they won , Ali would be a dead man ......All these clearly and openly shows the treacherous mindset of Aisha , and you are sugar coating the incidents by simply saying she was not under house arrest ,.... look at other wives who displayed examplary attitudes to public life after the demise of the Prophet .Give me a break , bro ! Why don't you call a spade a spade!.

[@muhammadtasiu5473]

​@@FaridResponds Could you then explain the ayats of surah ahzab?

[@mnoorbhai]

@@FaridResponds So you would allow your wife who is under your instructions not to cause Fitna and she still raises an army against your Son in Law who was in the right all throuoghout and when your wife is subdued your son in law grants her amnesty and you atill go about saying your wife was right and keep silent on your son in law, s truth .. Wah !.. A peace of advise .. trim your beard , before you regurgitate more falacies !!

[@abudujana13]

JAZAKALLAH KHAIR

[@tanweeransari2619]

Akhi please make a video on siffin as well

[@ashleyjason5608]

You can't sugar coat jamal. Why is it every time Sunni talk about this they make it sound like nothing 2000 died omg nothing. That's on Aisha conscious. She clearly has a pivotal role in all of this. How come the Jamal is the banner when it fell it was over? Think honestly... There has to be good and bad was Ali bad in this or Aisha. If you were alive which side would you fight against ..if you say Ali your a kafir according to Sunni theology. You cannot go to war against your caliph. If you say Aisha oh no she is the mother. Oh and speaking of mother Reason why imam Ali AD said you cannot take the prophet wife as a slave is the same reason she is called mother of believer it's just a context that ANY women who married the prophet Cannot marry after..it's Haram period decrees by Allah. So it is like marrying your Mother. And that's why imam Ali said that . Y'all ignorant. How come Khadija is not called mother of believers or hafsa lol because 90% of your faith comes from her who the Quran shows her disobedience.... Just saying..

[@FaridResponds]

The correct answer is neither. The people that avoided the fitna were the ones that were successful and that is why Ali wished he was dead before the fitna ever occurred.

[@ashleyjason5608]

@@FaridResponds you didn't answer anything. so your saying Aisha and imam Ali were wrong? I'm sorry that's a lame attempt

[@FaridResponds]

When Muslims go to war because of a fitna, it is best to avoid bloodshed by not taking part, even if one side is closer to the truth than the other. It is a simple concept.

[@investigativeforensicscien4622]

@@FaridResponds To simplify such a concept is ludicrous from an academic point of view and Farid you should know that better.

[@ishrakmohammad7307]

Who told you that we do not call Khadiza mother of believers?Of course,we do.

[@Devilhellfly]

Jazak Allah ﷻ khair. Are there any videos like this which can thoroughly explain the feud between Ali رضي الله عنه and Muawiyah رضي الله عنه.?

[@FaizanAhmed-lw7lv]

Could you please provide me with the reference to Asther's confession regarding the killing of Uthman?

[@budean88]

Assalamualaikum Brother, Is there Battle of Siffin Video shared ?

[@ishrakmohammad7307]

No

[@omarseraj7010]

How Everyone read it: the battle of al-jamal (camel) 🐫 Me : the battle of al-jamãl (Beauty)☺😂

[@hossiensalehi716]

51:07 accusing Ali as of nepotism is so stupid. Firstly he chose the children of Abbas because of merit not nepotism. Uthman chose his half brother Walid bin Uqba who was a blatant drunkard and fasiq unlike the likes of Ibn Abbas. Secondly if Ali was a nepotist why did he not make his brother Aqil a governor or his nephew and son in law Abdullah bin Jafar or his sons Hassan as Huseein as or Mohammad al Hannifiya instead of his foster son Mohammad bin Abi Bakr or Abu Ayyub al Ansari or y didn't he offer a position to Zubayr who is also his first cousin like Ibn Abbas.Thirdly if Malik al Ashtar believed Ali was a nepotist like Uthman who he rebelled against why did he remain extremely loyal to Ali at siffin or Nahrawan so much so that after he was poisoned by Mu'awiya, Mu'awiya says that he has severed the right wing of Ali (al gharat vol 1 p 264) if Malik al Ashtar hated nepotists so much and shouted at al taqlibi blah blah y did he remain so loyal to Ali lmao. It was literally his son who avenged Hussain bin Ali and killed Ibn ziyad and u say Malik saw Ali as a nepotist lmao

[@smbmrizvi]

Mr. Farid should conclude who was on Haq and who was on Batil side?

[@hassanmuse5606]

Those that stayed away from fitna were on the truth, and were successful. May ALLAH pardon forgive and have mercy on us all and be pleased with all the Sahaba, ameen

[@kevinshmuk7237]

Was ali not the 4th caliph and considered a sahaba? Hisside was haiq

[@smbmrizvi]

Not all people who had the ziyarat of Our beloved prophet are Sahaba … there were munafiqs in the midst and Muaaviya was the prime example…

[@soheil527]

@@kevinshmuk7237 shia logic. wives are not ahl e bayt but fatime is for them for some reason.

[@abdulazeem9458]

Eid Mubarak

[@abdulazeem9458]

@@ituuali4744 Let's debate come with your original id. Don't be a typical coward shite

[@AhmadO5k]

@@ituuali4744 Keep posting spam and I'll keep deleting them.

[@yaseralaraji2988]

Why didn't Aisha follow the command to stay in her home as a mother of the believers? Why was she going around getting involved?

[@abdullahassaffah]

It's something she regretted later on so why are you getting so worked up about it

[@ashiranwar3028]

True

[@RawaLanunBahasa]

The word Jihad is derived from the verb jahada which means: "he exerted himself". Thus literally, Jihad means exertion, striving; but in juridico-religious sense, it signifies the exertion of one's power to the utmost of one's capacity in the cause of Allah. This is why the word Jihad has been used as the antonym to the word Qu,ud (sitting) in the Holy Qur'an (iv. 95). Thus Jihad in Islam is not an act of violence directed indiscriminately against the non-Muslims; it is the name given to an all-round struggle which a Muslim should launch against evil in whatever form or shape it appears. Qital fi sabilillah (fighting in the way of Allah) is only one aspect of Jihad. Even this qital in Islam is not an act of mad brutality. It has its material and moral functions, i.e. self-preservation and the preservation of the moral order in the world.

[@RawaLanunBahasa]

​@@abdullahassaffah The word Jihad is derived from the verb jahada which means: "he exerted himself". Thus literally, Jihad means exertion, striving; but in juridico-religious sense, it signifies the exertion of one's power to the utmost of one's capacity in the cause of Allah. This is why the word Jihad has been used as the antonym to the word Qu,ud (sitting) in the Holy Qur'an (iv. 95). Thus Jihad in Islam is not an act of violence directed indiscriminately against the non-Muslims; it is the name given to an all-round struggle which a Muslim should launch against evil in whatever form or shape it appears. Qital fi sabilillah (fighting in the way of Allah) is only one aspect of Jihad. Even this qital in Islam is not an act of mad brutality. It has its material and moral functions, i.e. self-preservation and the preservation of the moral order in the world.

[@arwentulawiekalimuddin8796]

You are too keen to focus on the fault of Aisha, because she stood against Alih. Your statement clearly defines your malicious thoughts taught by your imams. There is Allah who forgives! It's not you who decides who goes to heaven or who goes to hell. Who are you to find faults against the Shahabas of the Prophet (Alayhis Salaam), especially so, his wife? Shame on you!

[@muhammadabedin3711]

Calipha of alsunnah Marwan killed talha?

[@yasararif8292]

Salam brother you didn’t give evidence about Your analysis on why Marwan martyred Syedina Talha. You said because of the Grudge, was it not because he wanted the battle to start.

[@syedyasirali1974]

According to some narrations in tabari, maybe from abu mikhnaf (a proto shia narrator), that marwan was angry because Talha RA has had disagreements with Caliph Uthman prior to the rebellion, and had, therefore, not publicly stood against the rebels, and had not publicly sided with Caliph Uthman

[@ituuali4744]

THE VIRTUES OF AHLUL BAYT: 1' NO ONE LOVE ALIY EXCEPT BELIEVER AND NO ONE HATE ALIY EXCEPT HYPOCRITE'' 2'' THOSE WHO INSULT(CURSE) ALIY, INDEED HAVE CURSED ME(RASSULLILLAH SAWAW) '' 3''ALIY IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 4'' FOR WHOMEVER I AM MAWLA, HERE ALIY IS HIS MAWLA, ALLAH LOVES THOSE HELP ALIY AND THOSE WHO FIGHT HIM ARE ENEMY OF ALLAH'' 5'' I AM IN PEASE WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN PEASE WITH AND I AM IN WAR WITH WHOM YOU ARE IN WAR WITH'' [YOU: FATIMATU ZAHRA, IMAM ALIY, HASSAN, HUSSEN] 6'' HUSSEN IS FROM ME AND I AM FROM HIM'' 7''ALLAH LOVES WHOEVER LOVES IMAM HASSAN AND IMAM HUSSEN'' 8''ALLAH SATISFIED FOR FATIMATU ZAHRA SATISFACTION AND HE ANGERS FOR HER ANGER'' 9'' FATIMA IS PART OF ME WHOEVER HARM HER HAVE HARMED ME, WHOEVER HARMED ME HAVE ANGERED ALLAH'' 10'' I AM THE CITY OF WISDOM AND ALIY IS THE GATE'' 11'' ALIY YOU ARE MY BROTHER IN THIS WORLD AND HEREAFTER'' 12''KHAYBAR'' I WILL GIVE THE RAAYA FOR A PERSON WHO LOVES ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET AND, ALLAH AND HIS PROPHET LOVES HIM MOST (FROM ALL OF THE COMPANIONS GATHERED AT THE BATTLE OF KHAYBAR ... ABBKR, UMR, USMN ETC) AND ALLAH WILL OPEN KHAYBAR FOR HIM'' WHO IS THE PERSON? IMAM ALIY(AS)'' 13''ALIY ALWAYS WITH TRUTH, THE TRUETH REVOLVE WHEREVER ALIY RESIDE'' 14''HADEETH AS SAQALAYN'' TWO WEIGHTY THINGS RASSULLULLAH(SAWAW) LEFT BEHIND'' 15''ONLY THOSE WHO LOVE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) WOULD HAVE COMPLETE IMAN'' 16'' THOSE WHO HATE AHLUL BAYT(ONLY THE FOUR) ARE DISBELIEVERS (HYPOCRITES)''

[@yasararif8292]

@@ituuali4744 Yes majority of those Hadith are sahih from our books. Loving the aahlul bayt is from my Eman and Aqeeda and not to support those who have hurt them. Ali RA Wa AS was a rightly guided caliph and was upon haq during his caliphate. Those who wronged him is a matter for Allah and them. However if you accept these Hadith you will have to accept the principle behind them and the sahaba who have narrated them too. You can’t pick and chose. Also the challenge still exists from Br Farid to provide evidence of Umar RA Wa AS ,shut the door on Fatima RA wa AS. Even your scholars have stated that they are weak and Fabricated.

[@syedyasirali1974]

@@yasararif8292 well said brother

[@soheil527]

@@yasararif8292 excellent

[@alisyed9584]

Ah so I’ve just finished this, it comes across very anti Ali ibn abi talib, and justifies the actions of his enemies. Anything that puts this in dispute is quickly disregarded as “shia leaning”, whereas anything that glorifies them is immediately “authentic”. this is shady, very shady.

[@lool9432]

l Love Islam

[@abdullahassaffah]

Hadiths In Praise of Sahabas (ra) In Shia Books: 1. Qumi in his tafsir, “Tafsir Qumi” narrates from Abi Abdullah: “When the prophet (sws) was in the cave, he (sws) said to Abu Bakr (ra), “I see the ship of jaffar in the river with his companions. And likewise i see the ansar. Abubakr (ra) asked can i also see? The prophet (sws) said , “yes”. Abubakr asked how? The prophet did masah with his hands on abubakr’s eyes. Thus, abubakr saw what the prophet saw. Then, the prophet turned to abubakr and said, “You are siddique.” Tafsir Qumi, 1/289 2. Abdul azeem hassani narrates from Ali bin mohammad bin Ali al riza and he narrates from his father and granfather and they narrated from Hassan bin Ali (ra) that the prophet (sws) said: “ Abu bakr is beloved to me to the level of hearing, Umar to the level of sight and Uthman to the level of heart.” Alburhan 565, 4/564 3. Imam Reza (ra) was asked about the prophetic hadith, “My companions are like stars. Whomever you refer to, you’ll be guided.” Imam said, “This hadith is weak, but its meaning is inshallah correct.” Then he was asked about another prophetic hadith, “Leave my companions to myself. Do not annoy them. Do not slander them”. Imam (ra) said, “Its authentic.” Ayon Akhbar al reza lil-Qami 2/87

[@mustafaahmed9940]

Another thing I am wondering is why did you mention the hadith of the barking of the Hawoa and stop, because it seems like you are just shrugging the fact Aisha just disobeyed the prophet.

[@mehdiclaw]

Why would a shia quote you reports from him which youll try find holes in by playing a sanad game, its better to quote you sunni sources which you beleive in.

[@zulfhashimmi2040]

Isn’t amr b jurmoz an ally of Ahnaf b Qays ra the conqueror of Iran ?

[@mnoorbhai]

Watch Ammar Nakswamis analysis of this event 9years earlier done for your better insight .

[@FaridResponds]

He doesn't quote references.

[@mnoorbhai]

@@FaridResponds Facts based on a wider analysis of what majority of historians agree based in popular hadiths and accepted history .

[@FaridResponds]

@@mnoorbhai That's a claim if not backed by references.

[@mnoorbhai]

@@FaridRespondsthe Qur'an and the Prophet states that the women should stay at home and not come out !! What more do you need ,.

[@mnoorbhai]

O Prophet! Say to thy Consorts: If it be that ye desire the life of this World, and its glitter,- then come! I will provide for your enjoyment and set you free in a handsome manner. ---This reference is to Aisha bint Abu Bakr and Hafsa bint Umar. [33:29] But if ye seek Allah and His Messenger, and the Home of the Hereafter, verily Allah has prepared for the well-doers amongst you a great reward. ---This reference is to Bibi Salma bint Khazeefah and Bibi Zaynab bint Jahsh. [33:30] O Consorts of the Prophet! If any of you were guilty of evident unseemly conduct, the Punishment would be doubled to her, and that is easy for Allah.