Ammar Nakshawani Accuses Umar (ra) of Denying the Will of the Prophet ﷺ

Рет қаралды 28,691

Farid Responds

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 1 800

@prodigy0ne272 10 ай бұрын

If the Prophets asks for pen and paper, you bring pen and paper simple.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

So if the prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) asks for title to be erased by Ali (may Allah be pleased with him), this makes that person a deviant Sahaba? Ofcourse not, it's a mistake out of wrong opinion, Omar (may Allah be pleased with him) was referring to RasulAllah (SAW)'s severe sickness and this was his reasoning and wrong opinion, which is a mistake just like the former.

@razadahri7146 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidoishow are these two things even related? One is a gesture out of respect for Prophet's name, other is pure disrespect.

@الحقيقةالمغيبة-خ9خ 10 ай бұрын

The Messenger, may God bless him and grant him peace, was on his deathbed and was very stressed, and Omar Ibn Al-Khattab, may God be pleased with him, wanted him to rest.

@razadahri7146 10 ай бұрын

@@-------....___ we curse only the zalimoon, worship only Allah.

@razadahri7146 10 ай бұрын

@@-------....___ ignorant.

@riverside5637 10 ай бұрын

Thank you Farid for this video - your arguments made me even more firm on the teachings of Ahlulbayt. Al hamdoulillah for the path of Ahlulbayt (as)

@hf8547 10 ай бұрын

Right? No sources, all excuses and speculation. The more I watch these types of videos trying to counter the teachings of Shiasm, the stronger my faith in it becomes.

@abhmd4481 10 ай бұрын

@@hf8547 He doesn't have to provide sources since the source you use backfires at you. Ali didn't bring the pen and paper, Ali disobeyed the prophet, Ali isn't infallible, Shiism is false.

@hf8547 10 ай бұрын

Replace Ali(as) with Umar (LA) in your sentences. Disrespected gods greatest creation in the Prophet pbuh and attempted an assassination and you worship him and his daughter more than Allah and Muhammad astaghfurallah. Subhan Allah you have the protectors of umayads who killed the prophets bloodline and the protectors of the prophet and his family. Fear god.

@doncorleone8733 10 ай бұрын

@@abhmd4481 🤣🤣🤣 you make such a coherent and intelligent argument. Cannot stop laughing 😆 🤪

@bjay12 10 ай бұрын

Ali slept in Prophets bed when Prophet made the Hijra to protect the Faith while Umar fled from the wars, WHY? Explanation will be appreciated for your argument @@abhmd4481

@taaat9589 10 ай бұрын

So the Prophet a literal messenger of Allah alive in front of you asks for a pen and paper to write something that WILL NOT LEAD YOU ASTRAY. Yet you call him seriously ill and say the quran is enough. There is no excuse for that. Why would you ever reject something this important especially before the death of Rasool Allah

@guccibase 10 ай бұрын

Ali Ra was one of them

@ibrahimihsan2090 10 ай бұрын

Why would the man RA who fought in the name of Allah and His Prophet SAWW, who gave his daughter to Rasullullah SAWW, who killed his own family members for oppressing his Islamic coreligionists, who would follow The Prophet SAWW's teachings even if they sometimes didn't make sense to him, who rejected his(SAWW) death, even threatening people's lives for acknowledging his death before Abu Bakr RA consoled him, do so for anything other than a fear for the Prophet's SAWW health while he was seriously ill and they hoped against hope that he would get better? What if he believed that he(SAWW) would be able to give such a message at a better time? Is it kufr to have concern for the Messenger SAWW and hope for a better time for the message?

@Ishi1XP 10 ай бұрын

@@ibrahimihsan2090 he wanted to usurper the caliphate, for himself and his friend. This event clearly showed his intention.

@Mohammed-Baqer-313 10 ай бұрын

what do you mean say the message at another time, in gahdeer the prophet said i am leaving this world so how else can he give the message, he would simply if omar would just shut up for a sec and do something like smack abu huraira or question the prophet then questioning abu bakr the prophet would have easily given by a pen paper and not only that THEY ANGERED THE PROPHET AND TOLD THEM GET UP AND LEAVE. its like the prophet smiled when he said that.@@ibrahimihsan2090

@ibrahimihsan2090 10 ай бұрын

@@Ishi1XP No it doesn't. Is this really what you Shi'ites are taught? I understand that the words of a prophet are very important but we have to consider that he(SAWW) was human and that people would worry about his health at the time. We have little reason to believe they thought he was about to die(in fact, he may have died a few days later) so it is easy to argue that Umar RA was simply concerned for his health and hoped the Prophet SAWW would give his message at a later time. Also, can you curb your conspiracy theories and at the very least acknowledge that when it comes to this Sunni hadith, the Prophet SAWW wasn't talking about succession but about certain Islamic rulings, most of which he eventually got the chance to inform them about?

@kaiquecrisostomo846 10 ай бұрын

5:43 totally weak argument. He said: The Qur'an is enough not "wait until you(oh prophet) get better" or "until the prophet gets better". It Simply doesnt work.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

It says in the beginning, "the prophet may peace and blessings be upon him is seriously ill", and then adds that in after, why would he say the prophet is seriously ill if his opinion was only that only the Quran is sufficient for all of time even after him becoming better? It was a wrong opinion of his and a mistake like any human, but you unfortunately will take this as evidence but not the other praises of Umar Al Farooq (Allah be pleases with him).

@kaiquecrisostomo846 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois He was Very clear. What you are saying makes no Sense, he Said that the Qur'an is enough and that is not his opinion?

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

@@kaiquecrisostomo846Then why did he have to bring up the prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) being severely ill? It would be pointless according to your narrative because he should have just said "tHe Quran is enough". Handwaving is not a proper response. How about when Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) did said "no" to RasulAllah (SAW) and did not erase what he commanded? You will give a good twist to that, but not to this due to your bias?

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois You disobey RasoolAllah to his face then claim this person was great enough to be prophet! That is where your & farid logic is at gutter level

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

the prophet pbuh lived for 3 more days, and even gave a sermon in which he said what he would've wrote. so you majoosis stay coping, because you got no evidence for Ali's successorship after the prophet and the infallibility of the 12 ''imams.''

@hussainhussaini2267 10 ай бұрын

Mashallah. Sunni brothers can never escape from the Hadith of paper and pen! All they can do is to play around and try to justify what Umar did

@altamashbaibars9477 10 ай бұрын

Play around lol at least no one rejecting and the explanation is given. Shias have no case

@mdshagor7762 10 ай бұрын

Pen paper for what?

@VeKlutz 10 ай бұрын

Narrated by Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her): "When Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) was in his last illness, he asked for a sheet (to cover his body), and he wore it as a garment; then he fainted and, when he recovered consciousness, he asked for a pen and a paper and wrote, 'Write: No one has the right to be worshipped but Allah; and Muhammad is His Messenger.' " (Sahih al-Bukhari, Book 64, Hadith 468)

@Mehmet_Fateh 9 ай бұрын

Amazing how the Shi'a claim to love Ali, yet interpret hadith to portray him as a coward incapable of standing up to Umar. Here we have Umar somehow stopping the guidance of the Ummah, and Ali's just letting it happen? A bit like the lies about Fatima's house. Again, Ali, the infallible Imam and praised warrior, fails to stand up for what is right.

@timeread3099 9 ай бұрын

Ali also refused orders from the prophet when writing his name. This is your infallible imam by the way you have bigger problems.

@PsychedOutSoul 10 ай бұрын

Oh ok. So according to u the incident of Ghadeer e khum never happened before the Holy Prophet pbuh passed away? He didn't announce his successor before? The incident of hadees e kisaa never happened where Allah said he has kept all types of impurities away from the ahlulbayt?? And said that they cannot ever commit a sin, let alone talk back to the Holy Prophet. Secondly i dont understand why u defend someone who has been a kafir for 40 years and only accepted islam out of fear of being killed. Then he angered the only remaining daughter of the Holy Prophet pbuh, burned her door, pushed it upon her, killed the Child in her womb (this is all in ur books btw) and she died angry with him and abu bakr I mean, seriously, to what level will u go to in defending him? As if speaking above the Messenger of Allah is not enough, let alone calling him delirious nauzobillah. U will even throw ur own prophet under the bus for defending a fallible human being?? Astaghfirullah To anyone reading this i advise u to plz watch the whole video of Dr Ammar and then decide which side u r on. MY PROPHET PBUH IS THE GREATEST AND MOST COMPLETE CREATION OF GOD, WHETHER IN SICKNESS OR IN HEALTH. WHETHER IN PAIN OR NOT. I HAVE BEEN TOLD TO OBEY HIM REGARDLESS OF HIS HEALTH CONDITIONS. THEN WHO THE HELL IS OMAR TO DECIDE WHAT HE SHOULD AND SHOULDN'T DO??!

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Accepted islam out of fear of being smited, no authentic evidence. "Burned her door, pushed it upon her, ...", not authentic according to shia and sunni sources, sorry. Didn't say he specifically called him delerious in the source. The incident of the pen and paper was a mistake because Omar (RA) made a mistake in his opinion of thinking he (SAW) was too sick to do it and should wait until after but you will use this as evidence against Omar (RA) and disregard the same sources showing Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) praising him. He is not infallible though. "The Prophet said, "Among the nation of Bani Israel who lived before you, there were men who used to be inspired with guidance though they were not prophets, and if there is any of such persons amongst my followers, it is 'Umar."" - Sahih Bukhari And many others, but you will deny ofcourse. How much more can you lie about Omar Al Farooq (Allah be pleased with him). As for the other topics about Imama, you can watch Mohammed Hijab's londoniyya on Shiasm where he goes over Imama and the understandings and evidences and weak evidences used.

@PsychedOutSoul 10 ай бұрын

Ohh so sahih bukhari and muslim are not authentic sunni books?? Wonder why they are called sahih then Just answer me this: did omar know more than the Prophet pbuh?? Did he come with the book of Allah? Was he the messenger? If your Prophet pbuh is telling u to bring Him pbuh something, would you ever deny him? Was he asking for a knife?? No. Just a pen and paper. The thing is: sunnis have associated the hypocrite sahabas with their own identity. So questioning them is like questioning your whole life and everything u have believed uptil now. I get it. Its hard. But not if u love the truth. And actually want to seek out the true path. Please brush up on ur islamic history and then decide whats right and wrong. That alone will be enough for u

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

@@PsychedOutSoulDon't play sarcastic as you provided no evidence for the counterclaims I made, you said, "burned her (Fatima may Allah be pleased with her) door, pushed it upon her, and smited the baby"... Go ahead and show me this in the two sahih books please, if not please stay quiet because you are just parroting other shia people and doing blind following of your shia clerics without properly looking in. As for the issue pertaining to Omar Al-Farooq (may Allah be pleased with him), I told you that he made a mistake in his judgment in thinking it was a better decision to not happen as Prophet Muhammad (may peace and blessings be upon him) was very sick. I also showed you the same source, sahih bukhari, showing Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) praising Omar (RA) but I know you guys will reject that because you cherry pick. Again, on the issue of Imama please check out Mohammed Hijab as he addresses this on "londoniyya shiaism".

@PsychedOutSoul 10 ай бұрын

Allah would never choose a Prophet who always ran away from battles. Who used to drink even after islam (also in muslim and bukhari), who was kicked out by the Prophet on his deathbed, a whole ayah was revealed for him that do not raise ur voices above the voice of the Prophet pbuh bcz if u do that, every good deed u have ever done will become zero. (surah hujarat) Go and read ur tafaseer. That ayah is about omar and abu bakr. Apni books parhi nai hoteen aise hi behas karne aa jate hain And I'll say it again The incident of the door is mentioned in both ur books. Khud mehnat kar k Google karlo I'm not gonna spoonfeed u

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@@PsychedOutSoul Answer my questions so your admitting sayidna Ali ra refused an order of the prophet saas? It’s ok when sayidna Ali ra does it but when sayidna Umar ra does it it’s a problem. Do you know that sayidna Ali ra was in the room when all this was going on? Why didn’t he get involved and bring him the pen and paper? Did he also sin? Believe me if the the prophet saas wanted that pen and paper he would of got it. Do you know that the prophet saas was taken to the mimbar before he died to deliver a very important speech to the people so he had the chance to say anything he wanted to say on the mimbar which was the largest gathering of the sahaba if he wanted to deliver that message why wouldn’t he deliver it to the sahaba on that day? He even said Towards the end of his sermon, the Prophet asked "O people, have I faithfully delivered unto you my message?" A powerful murmur of assents "O Allah! yes!"arose from thousands of pilgrims and the vibrant words "Allahumma Na'm," rolled like thunder throughout the valley. Do you believe there is anything missing from religion because of this Hadith that the prophet saas said bring me the pen and paper otherwise you will go astray? If you do your saying that Allah swt sent the prophet saas and couldn’t deliver his message to the people instead they ended up being astray so that means the prophet saas failed as a prophet in your eyes.

@HusnaiNFx4 10 ай бұрын

To cover umar's bad intentions farid gave this hadith in respond to make umar look like he really cared: Sa'id bin Al-Musaiyab told me that 'Umar said, "By Allah, when I heard Abu Bakr reciting it, my legs could not support me and I fell down at the very moment of hearing him reciting it, declaring that the Prophet had died." This hadith has weak isnad, the chain is missing so it cannot be considered strong. Love playing back the chain of narrators game on you. Because thats what you do on some of your videos focusing of weak chains but you urself provide hadith with weak chain.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Evidence?

@EpicRevelations 10 ай бұрын

Haha some? He does that I ALL his refutations because he knows people don't know what he's talking about but then he uses hadiths that have weak narrators as well. Literally his only comeback because he knew he can get away with it

@abdelqadir5227 10 ай бұрын

Points to refute in summary: Is it Ammar's words or Sahih hadeeth? Is the Qur'an truly enough for us?When it comes to ibadat atleast? Are hadeeth compilers wrong then? Would you deny a man with the best decision making, protected from mistakes and sinning and greatest leader in the world something he wants no matter the situation? Did Umar make it clear that he will ensure Rasoulullah gets them at a later time? If Umar did it out of love, why is he being chased out? (NB companions NOT Family chased out) :) Umar din't say teach us hadeeth. Rasoullullah asked for it. He asks. You obey. Simple

@syedyasirali1974 7 ай бұрын

why didnt Ali RA bring the pen and paper? or any of the ahlul bayt? on that day or alter on? they disobeyed, too then, didnt they? and where does it say that it was to mention Ali RA as successor? provide that detail from the Sahih Ahadith. not feelings and ammar's words.

@HiHi-ek1dd 4 ай бұрын

@@syedyasirali1974 The eye's are not blind but the hearts. My friend if we care about the akhirah then atleast listen from the words of the ahlulbayte (AS). Dua kumayl dua abu humza thumali cmon buddy.

@hammadhussain4422 10 ай бұрын

He denied pen and paper just because he was caring so much about the PAIN of holy prophet but didnt denied when he was asked to leave and acted upon it 😂. If he was really that much caring person why did he left the prophet in pain instead of staying .

@abdelqadir5227 10 ай бұрын

also them saying if Allah really wanted it to happen it would have happened. He would have gotten the pen and paper. it is like saying that if Allah really wanted His creation to worship Him then He would have created us as robots. It is like saying if Allah loves His prophets H e would have given Nabii Nuh and Lut obedient sons and wives. Weak arguments. Anything to defend Umar. Funny thing when he says Ammar says.. no it is not Ammar but Saheeh books

@andrewsarinas1180 10 ай бұрын

When RasulAllah says he wants something to stop people from going astray, if you truthfully believe his Nubuwwa you would not say anything and you would listen. If the Prophet kicks you out on his deathbed, YOU did something wrong. Wake up akhi, Umar has done a lot of wrong in your own books. It's time we stop making excuses. Politics was as real then as it is now

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

@@andrewsarinas1180 All the shias in the comments. It's funny everyone says this is "insufficient" and he "needs evidence" when they don't understand that intepreting the text Nakshawani brings forth is using evidence since you could take a bad turn or good turn depending on how you know the person and what people after did. For instance, after this incident, Ibn Abbas RA actually stated that Prophet Muhammad SAW passed away being pleased with Umar RA. We should also make notice that they are humans and they will make mistakes because their judgment of what they think gets in the way like Ali RA refusing (swearing) to erase the title of RasulAllah at treaty of hudaybiyyah. People could take this to a bad turn or good turn, but we know through context that this person was loved by RasulAllah SAW so similarly when Umar RA refers to severe sickness we can assume it was because he RA did not want more pain to Prophet SAW at that moment and knew the message of Islam was complete as Allah revealed so he thought later but he was wrong ofcourse as was Ali RA in that case, so he would wait and the Prophet SAW had three days to say whatever he wanted SAW.

@altamashbaibars9477 10 ай бұрын

That means nothing, because Ali didn't give the pen and paper either and probably he also had to leave.

@hammadhussain4422 10 ай бұрын

@@altamashbaibars9477 who told you that ? This happens when you subscribe to the wrong history channel.

@sayedimmam1207 10 ай бұрын

What a poor translation of events. You were better of staying silent!

@whereztheEvidence 10 ай бұрын

@10:10 honestly im starting to doubt you actually watched ammars full lecture. His claim wasn't that he couldn't deliver the message his claim was that he was being stopped from putting it writing and that despite years of delivering the message he wanted it in writing one final time so that you dont go astray. Sadly he was prevented and indeed we all went astray

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Well maybe he wanted Abu Bakr (may Allah be pleased with him's) name on their? It's just an endless circle and assumptions won't help just like my case here.

@whereztheEvidence 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois that's fair brother. Maybe he did maybe he didn't although this wasn't the point. And I am not assuming that he was going to appoint Ali (3s) the point is that he was prevented from doing so

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

@@whereztheEvidence It isn't fair it is pathetic conjecture. There is overwhelming evidence RasoolAllah want Ali (as) to be his successor. There zero evidence for RasoolAllah wanting Abu Bakar to be his successor. They come out with he lead the salaah when he was ill but never should have been there if he had obeyed RasoolAllah. It is very clear what he wanted to write and Umar clearly knew what he was doing. There is a lot evidence for this all they give is pathetic excuse to Ghadir khum

@whereztheEvidence 10 ай бұрын

@@Shia.Ahlulbayt while I agree with you wholeheartedly. I am giving the poor man the benefit of the doubt for the sake of argument. Afterall I am commenting to clarify Sayed Ammars point and position which is clearly being misinterpreted by creator of the video

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

@@whereztheEvidence Exactly that all they have to throw conjecture at it. It could mean this or that etc. That is all they have. That is why we shouldn't give inch to these disingenuous arguments. Look at the comments Farid fan club they were desperate for any kind of response. This feeble one from Farid they will still cheer on. I remember how bad his video on the battle of jamal was. He ended by saying it was like a dispute with your family. Normal families don't go to war and kill each other. That is how bad his arguments are. But they praised that video so much because they were desperate to make any excuse for the inexcusable. That is all he does

@whereztheEvidence 10 ай бұрын

Convenient that you managed to clip out the part where Ammar questions "but Umar said" when this was a big question during this talk. In other words when the Rasul (s.a) speaks you comply. You don't "but"

@roffi_daijoubu 10 ай бұрын

He also conveniently clip out the part of his Syaikh Assim Al-Hakim literally explaining Umar prevented Prophet because he think the Prophet may say/write things that will hurt the Deen. Instead he keep yapping his own personal interpretation that Umar is just worried Prophet is too much in pain to say/write. One is Umar questioning the mental capability of Prophet, one is Umar questioning the physical capability of Prophet, BIG DIFFERENCE

@muhammadtasiu5473 10 ай бұрын

@@roffi_daijoubuThat's what I don't really find his videos convincing.

@hotcharizard874 10 ай бұрын

you do realize he fainted afterwards?? imagine the prophet saw asking you to get some paper and he immeditely faints and you leave him and get some paper

@whereztheEvidence 10 ай бұрын

@@hotcharizard874 you're kidding right? Imagine the Rasul (swt) asked you for anything and you replied with "but".

@wonderingsoul5011 10 ай бұрын

The point remains, why didn't the Prophet (as) have it dictated at a later time, if it was so important. And why would he have to say it again if he already declared Ali (ra) the caliph. It's total speculation on the part of the Shia. Regarding Umar(ra), there is nothing in Umar's history (post reversion) and his time as Caliph that would make you suspect he had ulterior motives, yet the Shia want you to believe this. One of his most closest companions, fighting and defending the Prophet all his life, and as Caliph lived meagerly and spread Islam. I know it's hard to imagine saying 'but' to the Prophet, but these were his companions, they didn't always have to be formal with the Prophet(sa). Also, I don't see the problem with questioning the Prophets mental capabilities. There are many illnesses that can cause delirium, including pneumonia, which could have been what the Prophet (sa) was inflicted with before his death. Allah knows best. @@roffi_daijoubu

@Ccccc825 10 ай бұрын

im going to be very honest this was a weak explanation you gotta take an L on this one sunnis

@dinam1349 10 ай бұрын

Exctly 😂👏🏼

@kledmohd4230 10 ай бұрын

There are quite some concerns here, one the prophet pbuh was unlettered so how could he write, and let's say he did say something to that effect. It would be just another hadith so there would be variations in it, disputed upon, difference of opinion etc etc. It would not weigh against even a single quranic verse. Thirdy, he could've said anything, infinite number of possibilities but it's always , we know what he wanted to say. Pray tell how do you guys know that.

@VeKlutz 10 ай бұрын

@SK-eg6dp 10 ай бұрын

its so interesting how sunnis are using sunni hadith to refute sunni hadith

@155stw 10 ай бұрын

Farid rightly said that the hadith which Ammar quoted did not mention of Umar. But there is another hadith in Bukhari which clearly mentions Umar. 'Bring for me (writing) paper and I will write for you a statement after which you will not go astray.' But `Umar said, 'The Prophet is seriously ill, and we have got Allah's Book with us and that is sufficient for us. 'Sahih al-Bukhari 3053. In-book reference : Book 56, Hadith 259

@a7bkx204 10 ай бұрын

My friends usually discuss these topics and the shi3a mentioned this but the sunni claimed it was weak? Is there any information about the authenticity of this narration?

@155stw 10 ай бұрын

@@a7bkx204 brother this is in Sahih Bukhari. So there is no question of isnad.

@LeonardoIIX 10 ай бұрын

Umar believed the prophet was too ill to write at that point in time, I don't see any issue with that. You shias are forcing a maleficent intent when there is none. The prophet had multiple days after this to write or say what he wished, but chose not to, which goes to show that it was not needed in that time. Also Allah SWT said he has perfected the religion in the Quran, so there was nothing left to add after that point.

@a7bkx204 10 ай бұрын

Forgive me for my knowledge but does that it means it is authentic? Isnad is what we used to determine if the narrators are truthful/reliable?

@a7bkx204 10 ай бұрын

Once upon a time this shi3a guy I know informed me that in his final days the Prophet PBUH instructed to companions to go to war under the command of Usama but they refused. Any information on that?

@atizaz-ali 10 ай бұрын

Wallahi this Hadith was a turning point for me. I was brought up into a Sunni household (Deoband school). After I read this Hadith in front of my own eyes from Bukhari (I still remember it vividly. It was Ramadan and I went to pray taraweeh at Shah Faisal Mosque back then in Islamabad, Pakistan. Went to the library and read that with my own eyes). From that day onward I am a proud follower of Ahlulbayt school of thought. Your arguments or repose to Ammar didn’t make any sense. The bottom line is that The last prophet of Allah (which do not speak form his own whims and desires, rather whatever the prophet says is from Allah) he was disobeyed. Umar Ibn Khattab et al., did not let prophet put his will to writing so ummah doesn’t go astray. And indeed, from that day onward, Muslims have strayed. What an unfortunate event, Ibn abbas says and cried while narrating this. That messenger of Allah was prevented from writing his will! Alas.

@drzulqarnain1461 10 ай бұрын

Seeing people like you reminds me of Christian converts 😂

@aksjcre8 10 ай бұрын

ٱلْـحَـمْـدُ للهِ

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

Towards the end of his sermon, the Prophet asked "O people, have I faithfully delivered unto you my message?" A powerful murmur of assents "O Allah! yes!"arose from thousands of pilgrims and the vibrant words "Allahumma Na'm," rolled like thunder throughout the valley.

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@@aksjcre8 Towards the end of his sermon, the Prophet asked "O people, have I faithfully delivered unto you my message?" A powerful murmur of assents "O Allah! yes!"arose from thousands of pilgrims and the vibrant words "Allahumma Na'm," rolled like thunder throughout the valley.

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

Answer my questions so your admitting sayidna Ali ra refused an order of the prophet saas? It’s ok when sayidna Ali ra does it but when sayidna Umar ra does it it’s a problem. Do you know that sayidna Ali ra was in the room when all this was going on? Why didn’t he get involved and bring him the pen and paper? Did he also sin? Believe me if the the prophet saas wanted that pen and paper he would of got it. Do you know that the prophet saas was taken to the mimbar before he died to deliver a very important speech to the people so he had the chance to say anything he wanted to say on the mimbar which was the largest gathering of the sahaba if he wanted to deliver that message why wouldn’t he deliver it to the sahaba on that day? He even said Towards the end of his sermon, the Prophet asked "O people, have I faithfully delivered unto you my message?" A powerful murmur of assents "O Allah! yes!"arose from thousands of pilgrims and the vibrant words "Allahumma Na'm," rolled like thunder throughout the valley. Do you believe there is anything missing from religion because of this Hadith that the prophet saas said bring me the pen and paper otherwise you will go astray? If you do your saying that Allah swt sent the prophet saas and couldn’t deliver his message to the people instead they ended up being astray so that means the prophet saas failed as a prophet in your eyes.

@MiiiRSANTANA 10 ай бұрын

How do you justify this??? It’s the PROPHET of GOD! What gives Umar the right to say “the Quran is sufficient”

@abhmd4481 10 ай бұрын

Your infallible imam gave him the right to say that, Ali stood with Omar and refused to get the pen and paper.

@MiiiRSANTANA 10 ай бұрын

@@abhmd4481 What a stupid counter argument. If anything, it goes to show how incredible Ali’s character is to not speak or take action unless the prophet of Allah permits him to. If Omar wasn’t a Kafir before that action he certainly was afterwards.

@Harith112 10 ай бұрын

This pen and paper incident happened on Thursday. The Prophet (saw) died on Monday, 3 days later. Why didn't the Prophet (saw) mention this important thing in the 3 days he was alive? I'm Sunni and I believe Umar (ra) made a mistake on the pen and paper incident. But I believe he had good intentions. Obviously Shias believe he had bad intentions

@MiiiRSANTANA 10 ай бұрын

@@Harith112 so that today, people like you and I can use all this information 1400 years later to see the difference between Haq and Batil. I’m not going to generalize Sunnis as a whole but I think we can establish that when the prophet does or says anything it is all by the order of ALLAH. Disobeying the prophet is KUFR. Especially when the matter is so severe and regarding something that will help us “never go astray.” The truth is prevalent within your own books and you still make excuses. I pray for you on the day of judgement if you choose to ignore these matters, may Allah guide you and the rest who seek truth.

@haydayalltime6260 10 ай бұрын

@@Harith112Even after a clear hadees from your books you are using your nonsense mind Because you don't want to say Umar wrong even if Prophet s.a.w said so

@Hamzz25 10 ай бұрын

5:49 comparing a sheikh to the greatest creation of Allah that is infallible and only speaks in wahi 53:4 is wild to me . They’ll do anything to protect umar ….

@MohamedSaad-pn1wn 10 ай бұрын

You will protect umat over the prophet

@bigmanfoundlove 7 ай бұрын

May. Allah SWT bless Farid. Without his help and Allah's guidance so many would have been lost. Alhamdulillah i had a few doubts regarding the hadith and the other statements of Ammar but Farid answered them all in other videos swell. Never stop doing this Farid and may Allah reward you the highest rank in Jannah and bless all you family.

@Ahmad62637 10 ай бұрын

The face of the shii who commented he’s Sunni rn: 👁️👄👁️💧

@ahmddeed7898 10 ай бұрын

HAHAHAHAHAHA

@akhinummetett2102 10 ай бұрын

💀💀

@ath_thabaat 10 ай бұрын

You can find them everywhere on the internet since decades, always the same "im not shia im sunni but..."

@thetruthwithproof8802 10 ай бұрын

✝ ( 📖 1 TIMOTHY 2 : 5 ) There is ONE God & there is one mediator between God & Men, the MAN Christ Jesus ➜ According to this verse the mediator between God & men was a MAN, this proves Jesus is NOT God

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

This shows how deflection is seen as the best argument farid has for his fanboys. Never mind he defending blatantly disobeying RasoolAllah to his face. Not just what but telling RasoolAllah what is enough for Muslims.

@giovannioro1642 10 ай бұрын

Doesnt it say in Ibn Sa'd that Umar states that the prophet PBUH is in delirium? Ammar Nakshawani also uses Quran that no one is to speak over the Prophet PBUH. You cant say that Umar was in the right at all. Obviously there was something he wanted to write down (not sure what it was even though Shia may say it was to name the successor) and Umar should not have stopped the Prophet PBUH from doing so.

@darktirad 10 ай бұрын

He verse not to speak over was given at another time before this incident

@giovannioro1642 10 ай бұрын

@@darktirad One should never speak over the Prophet PBUH was the point. We are, including Umar, lower than he is. We shouldn't interrupt him out of respect and just the fact that he is Rasullulah.

@Khalid-qk3tq 10 ай бұрын

Ali did the same thing when the prophet told him to write for him

@kingmosesix432 10 ай бұрын

U didnt even watch the video…

@giovannioro1642 10 ай бұрын

@kamranahmed6446 The prophet wanted to write something, he got in the way of it (whether it was out of concern or not is not important) and as a result the prophet ended up not writing what he wanted down. Shia will say he was going to write down the successor but we will never know but it's clear he wanted to write something down. Ibn Sa'd hadith it says that Umar said he might be delirious. This isn't that big of a deal if you think about Hadiths also saying that the Prophet wasn't sure whether he had sex or not and even had witchcraft placed on him. Farid says Umar didn't know that the Prophet would die 4 days later. Ok, and? The issue is that there was something he wanted to write down and he didn't.

@noorhussain6462 10 ай бұрын

Sayed Ammar provides facts on this matter Farid provides his personal opinion on the matter ... ahlul sunna is amazed by farid 🤣 Always amazes me how easy it is to misguide people The prophet pbuh has appointed imam ali at ghadeer khum , dont deny history.

@jaclynholland-strauss7054 10 ай бұрын

Well pointed out

@syed2194 10 ай бұрын

Ammar provides personal opinions and extrapolates from the Hadith.

@noorhussain6462 10 ай бұрын

@syed2194 so the factual hadiths from your SAHIH books are not enough? Did you needed to be physically present at the event to believe ?

@syed2194 10 ай бұрын

@@noorhussain6462 I fully believe in all sahih ahadith.

@noorhussain6462 10 ай бұрын

@syed2194 sayed ammar needs to do a topic on the fabrications of abu huraira next.

@sk-gk7rr 10 ай бұрын

Ustadh we need more of these us laymen can really utilities the knowledge what you people have may Allah bless us all

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

What knowledge let's just see how Farid made excuses for disobeying RasoolAllah. 3:45 doesn't mention Umar beat his sister, doesn't mention he beat her husband, doesn't mention he didn't risk his life when RasoolAllah was under boycott, doesn't mention sahih hadith Umar fled jihad, doesn't mention sahih hadith Umar hit his daughter, doesn't mention he beat Abu Bakr sister & other women mourn his death. Instead he claims someone fled jihad was so good. Whitewash everything to justify him disobeying RasoolAllah.

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

4:19 fleeing jihad he fails to mention.

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

4:48 excuses for disobeying RasoolAllah. How he didn't tell RasoolAllah what to do & obeyed Allah messenger?

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

5:39 Farid dishonesty again when Umar said he wasn't dead it could have been for other reasons. That is no evidence to not believe RasoolAllah was on his, deathbed. There more references him saying he wouldn't live for long like his farewell sermon. Selective Farid manipulating the narrative. There is hadith where actually discuss it. It was common knowledge RasoolAllah was on his death bed.

@Shia.Ahlulbayt 10 ай бұрын

5:54 making up fake analogy using a sheikh instead of RasoolAllah 🙄 No one was asking RasoolAllah to teach them! RasoolAllah order them to do an action he disobeyed. See how he manipulates his example

@antishia_com 10 ай бұрын

Ma shaa Allah, Farid. We love you, brother. From Kazakhstan 🇰🇿

@jaclynholland-strauss7054 10 ай бұрын

Hi, Dimash! 😎

@thetruthwithproof8802 10 ай бұрын

✝ ( 📖 ISAIAH 40 : 28 - 29 ) God does NOT die ➜ According to Christianity Jesus died and this proves Jesus is NOT God

@nyeeunfa8487 10 ай бұрын

@@jaclynholland-strauss7054Dimash Kudaibergen 😁

@flag_bearertruth6257 10 ай бұрын

Kazakhstan ? do u have wahabi in Kazakhstan as well? i heard Kazakhstan is a beautful country with sufi style mosque not wahabi like mosques? confused?

@Anarchist369 10 ай бұрын

@@flag_bearertruth6257 sunni and wahabi warw beautiful people as but shia are evil

@user-dd2xe8my1j 10 ай бұрын

Salam alaikum jameean. Plain and simple: Does the Hadith say the prophet asked for a pen and paper? Clearly it does. Did somebody say the prophet is Ill thereby stopping him from getting that paper? Clearly yes again. Did the prophet want the pen and paper? Yes? Did he get the pen and paper? No. Then clearly it means that the prophet was disobeyed. The Quran in 4:59 clearly states to obey Allah and his messenger. Whatever Omar’s intentions good or bad he clearly disobeyed the prophet it’s that simple.

@Harith112 10 ай бұрын

This pen and paper incident happened on Thursday. The Prophet (saw) died on Monday, 3 days later. If it was something important, the Prophet (saw) had enough time to say it. Also, Allah says in the Quran that in Surah Maeda (5) ayah 3 "...This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed my favour upon you...". This means Islam was perfect and complete when the Prophet (saw) died. If Shias say the Prophet didn't have a chance to deliver this information to us, that means they saying Islam wasn't perfect and complete which is against the ayah of the Quran

@user-dd2xe8my1j 10 ай бұрын

@@Harith112 Brother the point I’m making is that the prophet was disobeyed. The Shias and Sunnis can believe what they want clearly they each believe what they believe because they think it will take them closer to Allah so He can judge. The point is that the Quran clearly commands the believers to obey Allah and His prophet that means if the prophet says “dont move from this position on mountain” then you don’t move or if he says get me this pen and paper then you get him this pen and paper. The Hadith doesn’t say “don’t get me this pen and paper because I’m ill I can write what I want in a couple of days when I’m better” what it does say is get me this pen and paper so however you feel about Umar the point is he disobeyed Allah and his prophet-plain and simple.

@iMan-610 10 ай бұрын

Quran 7:158 shows that Prophet a.s was UNLETTERED. How can an UNLETTERED person ask for paper & letter to write something. This hadith doesnt sound authentic to me. Umar was from FIRST EMIGRANTS that Allah promised Paradise in Quran 9:100.

@user-dd2xe8my1j 10 ай бұрын

@@iMan-610 The point of my comment is that the prophet was disobeyed. If he clearly asks for a pen and paper to write something who is any person to deny him this? It is in a sahih book so clearly the incident happened and he clearly asked for a pen and paper and was disobeyed. The Quran is clear Obey Allah and His messenger. By not obeying him they are disobeying him are they not? Put it another way: if someone is said to be a rightly guided person doesn’t this rightly guided part mean that they obey Allah and his prophet? If they were to disobey Allah and his prophet would you say they are still rightly guided in disobeying the lord of all creation and his final and greatest prophet? It is very simple. He asked for a pen and a paper and it was denied him. God has commanded him to be obeyed if you don’t bring him that pen and paper then you have disobeyed a command of Allah to obey Him and His messenger. It doesn’t matter why Umar disobeyed him. The point is that he did disobey him. Plain and simple.

@dudeperfect8720 10 ай бұрын

& does that verse apply to imam ali too during hudaibiyya

@jh4892 10 ай бұрын

Loool that guy in the beginning got caught like a thief 😂

@SM_Umair 10 ай бұрын

lol

@the5ivers61 10 ай бұрын

They won't ditch Umar. It doesn't matter what he did really. If they ditch Umar, Sunnism collapses. This is all expected

@Thevalour-g3g 10 ай бұрын

bro what do you mean ditch? Are you in your right mind???? who are we to ditch him? when he literally was one of the closest companions of the prophet pbuh to this day his grave lies besides the prophet pbuh. History bears the witness.

@the5ivers61 10 ай бұрын

@@Thevalour-g3g We ditch those who ditch the commandments of the Prophet (SAWWS). At least Shias do, Sunnis make excuses for Umar.

@haroonramola5983 10 ай бұрын

@@Thevalour-g3g the closest companion to the prophet was unable to realise that the Prophet's words are wahy. With our low level faith, would you dare deny the Prophet (saww) anything?

@Thevalour-g3g 10 ай бұрын

@@haroonramola5983 this incident happened on thursday the prophet pbuh died on monday if he would have wanted to ask for the same thing again he would but he didn't that explains that umar ra knew the prophet pbuh's condition and did what he thought was best.

@Thevalour-g3g 10 ай бұрын

@@the5ivers61 When ali ra literally named his children after the people you apparently ditch jokes on you.

@joegage1 10 ай бұрын

This is an innovation, but it is a good innovation. My fave.

@aaminissa5392 10 ай бұрын

And the Shia hit themselves and make shirk and invent there own timings for there prayers 👍

@hf8547 10 ай бұрын

Who on earth is Umar to tell the prophet what he should do and do deny him his request. May Allah guide you.

@_Calaven 10 ай бұрын

Didn't Imam Ali r.a do the same thing in the treaty of Hudaybiyyah...?

@redstonexgamer4238 10 ай бұрын

Because he cares about his well being. And so did Ali do when the prophet commanded him to erase "Prophet of God" from the treaty of Hudaybiyyah, Ali refused the prophet’s command and the prophet erased it himself.

@user-co8uf1mj6c 10 ай бұрын

@_Calaven no

@redstonexgamer4238 8 ай бұрын

@@user-co8uf1mj6c He did, sorry to tell you, but that doesn’t make him a bad person 🤷‍♂️

@user-co8uf1mj6c 8 ай бұрын

@@redstonexgamer4238 he didn't.

@ZombieCast115 10 ай бұрын

Farid, I am a Zaydi, not Sunni. You and I both know that you not even noting this act was the incorrect one is pure bias. It is impossible to say anything except this hadith is a grave mistake. May the peace, blessings, and mercy of Allah be upon Umar. No Muslim can affirm Sheikh Umar (Rahimahullah) was correct in his act without betraying his own intellect. I am not defending the Rafidhi, but this is the reality.

@H16-y9h 10 ай бұрын

I totally agree. Umar disobeyed a direct order of the prophet. Perhaps with Omar doing so he fell outside the fold of islam.

@ZombieCast115 10 ай бұрын

@@H16-y9hSheikh Umar (Rahimahullah) is one of the 10 promised paradise and paradise is not promised to those who fell into apostasy, so take heed.

@Suleiman212 10 ай бұрын

The purpose of the video wasn't to discuss whether Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, made the best or correct decision in that moment. It was to address the claims and extrapolations that Nakshawani made from the event in question. Farid never "affirmed [he] was correct in his act". No Sunni denies that companions are capable of making mistakes, so proving or conceding that a specific companion made a specific mistake isn't the item in question. That would be shifting the goal post. The question is about the exact implications and ramifications of this specific act, and that's what Farid was discussing and challenging.

@ZombieCast115 10 ай бұрын

@@Suleiman212How shall I put this brother... I disagree with the Rafidhi as apparently his point was that Sheikh Umar (Rahimahullah) is not a reliable narrator, and he is. To reject a narration because Umar is in the chain is irrational. Even Zaydis who are harsher than me in narrations from certain people do not oppose Sheikh Umar (Rahimahullah) as a narrator, that I have read. So in this sense I agree with Farid. At the same time this horrific event is of high significance to the shi`a. The General Muslim Community, due to their desire to not say anything which could have bad implications on the Sahaba (Radi Allahu Anhuma,) peculiarly assert that what was going to be written may not have been what the ummah was to do, after our Prophet (Salullahu Alayhi Wa Alihi Wa Salam) left us. To the rational intellect, given that the theology and law of the religion had already been completed prior to this, it is clear to me that our Prophet (Salullahu Alayhi Wa Alihi Wa Salam) desired to save us from this fitnah we fell into, where the ummah could not agree on a Caliph at first, etc. Without even the slightest doubt the line which deserves the title of horrifying is that The Book of Allah is enough. Without doubt, as someone who identifies yourself as "Sunni," you must object to this statement, as the Book of Alllah itself instructs us to turn to the words of The Messenger of Allah (Salullahu Alayhi Wa Alihi Wa Salam) for guidance, so the idea that The Book of Allah could suffice us *without* the Sunnah is rejected. Shi`a feel that this day we were deprived of yet another affirmation of a crucial element of the Sunnah: The Imamate of Imam Ali Ibn Abu Talib. I mention all of this only to clarify why I originally called this video bias... reading such an error out loud, without mentioning the error of it, is a strange thing. Certainly if Farid had read a Quranist saying similar, that the Quran is enough, he would refute it, but here there is someone he heavily respects, so we have silence...

@syed2194 10 ай бұрын

He’s not saying it’s correct or incorrect. He’s simply explaining possible reasons why Umar RA did not provide the pen. Nakhshwani and Farid are looking at the same Hadith and extrapolate from it. Nakhshwani extrapolates maliciously and Farid extrapolates positively, citing Umar RA’s early contributions towards Islam.

@hf8547 10 ай бұрын

0 sources weak arguments. You didn’t prove him wrong on anything. Amazing that some people be informed through their own books the truth and they still twist the facts.

@tayamkay 5 ай бұрын

Question, let's assume Nakhshawani is right about everything and Umar radhiallahu anhu did indeed prevent rasulullah from writing down something very important that has never been revealed yet, to guide humanity. That would mean rasulullah still had some revelation that he did not spread/share yet. Did rasulullah then use another occasion to share this message?

@azadshah79 10 ай бұрын

Amar is in the right. Farid, why are you making up excuses? Fear the day of judgement.

@ShreddMortem 10 ай бұрын

Thanks for plugging the video of Ammar Nakshawani.

@fcbarcelona4eva 10 ай бұрын

That is such a weak response. If the prophet asks for a pen and paper stating the importance of this, you will obviously do it. Whenever the prophet speaks, it is from allah and their is no suggestion of "let's wait until he is better" In some literature, he even says the proper has gone "Crazy". Umar has disrespected the prophet many times and introduced multiple innovations.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Text does not say Umar says he (SAW) is delarious. That is false. What about when Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) refused to erase the title of RasulAllah (SAW) when it was commanded by RasulAllah (SAW), excuses, let's play your game of assuming the worst but I won't stoop that low.

@fcbarcelona4eva 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois i am not sure what contradiction you have on imam Ali, can you expand ? No one ever called him rasul allah. He was the rightly chosen khalifa during ghadir khum by our Prophet (SAW) which can not be disputed. Many Hadith’s in your sunni literature point the prophet leaving behind the book of allah and his ahulbayt. Not Abu Bakr and Umar who went against the prophets will. Lets not even go to Umar bringing wood to burn the house of the prophets (SAW) beloved daughter Fatimah El Zahra

@sammyjukes2676 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidoisand do you know the response Imam Ali gab the prophet and do you know what the Prophet said after and did it cause the companions to fight and get angry did it cause the Prophet to say remove yourselves from me well Gies what it didn’t so I want you trying to prove here

@IjtabaAli-q1p 9 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidoisDid Imam Ali (a.s) prevent Rasool ULLAH (s) from erasing the title?? Your argument is weak and baseless. In the incident of Pen and Paper.. Prophet (s) was prevented from writing some important message which would have saved Ummah from misguidance.

@mariamahmed8645 10 ай бұрын

His reference to the Hadith is from Sahih Al Bukhara. A text the Ahle Sunnah use as a very authentic book.

@iamibrahim99 10 ай бұрын

This video is why I'm shia.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Lol, Shiaism is based on Imamat, this video speaks nothing of Imamat so I am confused

@yt_juicy_fn 10 ай бұрын

If this video is y u r shia then u have serious problems 😂😂😂

@aliiqbali6384 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidoisyour guy is arguing against Sunni literature, everything Sayed says was from Sunni literature.

@jaymarbrase3736 9 ай бұрын

Allahumma salli 'ala Muhammad wa aali Muhammad!

@shdjdjdj12389 9 ай бұрын

Hope you become a muslim one day

@mohammadkhorramshahgol6781 10 ай бұрын

According to Quran 53:3 the Prophet does not speak from his own inclination but speaks what Allah tells him. Why would Allah tell Prophet to write the will if he was too seriously ill? Does Umar know more about Prophet’s condition than Umar? Him asking to write the will down is what Allah has told him to do and Umar denied him that and disobeyed the Prophet.

@VeKlutz 10 ай бұрын

He did wrote something in the end

@faiyazkhan5970 10 ай бұрын

I'm just here to see the self-satisfied look of Nakshawani to his own argument.

@muhammadtasiu5473 10 ай бұрын

You could watch his videos instead 😂

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@HR-313 10 ай бұрын

Bro you are hilarious. At 5 mins in, the holy prophet tells you to get a pen and a paper for which you will never go astray and you still stick up for umar in this case saying he was in a good position to do so. Then why oh farid did rasulAllah sawas kick them out? Why was there a bust up in there? Tell me you don't know the aya that whatever rasulAllah sawas tells you it is from Allah swt? You don't know this oh farid? Oh farid you compare rasulAllah sawas who receives wahi and everything he tells you is from Allah swt, you compare this to your local sheikh if he was sick and you dont trouble him with a hadith?? Its not like the sahabis told.the holy Prophet tell us a hadith. It was RasulAllah sawas who said I will write something for you.that you wont go astray. Now dear farid you are running like usayn bolt you have all these hadiths in their multitudes that it was umar who stopped the prophet from writing this.formula but now you say it wasnt umar who called the prophet dilarious? Be honeat to yourself and your subscribers and be just coz you will be held accountable. The man provided you source after source from your own books that clearly umar wanted to stop the prophet otherwise there wouldnt have been a fight. Im intrigued why you only do an extremly short reaction. I mean ammar nakshawani provides many many sources and you skip a whole heap. Of course its clear why.

@muhammadtasiu5473 10 ай бұрын

Masha Allah brother, I hope farid sees this comment and responds to it instead of the comment he responded to in this video.

@LeonardoIIX 10 ай бұрын

The prophet SAW is still a human being, and as Farid showed before this event he was in extremely bad health (constantly passing out, not being able to pray in congregation and we know how important praying in congregation was for him SAW, if he couldn't do that, than that shows the intense state he was in). For any loved one, if you see them in such a state you want to them rest as much as possible. Umar RA did not say we don't need it explicitly, he said "the prophet of Allah SAW has been overcome with pain", that's his excuse for not listening to the prophet in this particular scenario, and if he had indeed made a mistake and this paper was in fact something needed in Islam, Allah SWT would not have said your religion has been perfected in Quran 5:3, hence why Umar RA said that the Quran is enough for us here, as it has been completed, nonetheless the prophet SAW had multiple days after this event to write this down and or say it, which he did not, again pointing to the fact that it was simply something that he thought would be a good idea at that time but later decided it wasn't.

@muhammadtasiu5473 10 ай бұрын

@@LeonardoIIX Now what you are implying is that Umar knows the health of the prophet PBUH more than he himself (The greatest creation of Allah SWT since the beginning of time) that he can stop the prophet from doing something he decided? Also we all know the actions of the prophet PBUH are dictated by Allah the almighty, and the prophet PBUH decided to write something and later felt it wasn't necessary?

@elprofesor8571 10 ай бұрын

@@muhammadtasiu5473prophet muhammad at the end was but a man. It says that in quran and hadeeth of the prophet himself. Surah abas is allahs reprimend for the prophet frowning on a poor blind sahabi. It tells you even nabi saw was a human at the end of the day and succeptible to mistake (not sin or insincerity) ali r.a also denied the prophets command when he refused to alter the contract between the quraysh and nabi saw.

@LeonardoIIX 10 ай бұрын

@@muhammadtasiu5473 Everyone who loves anyone and sees them in bad health generally tries to make decisions for them as though said person isn't as a tuned to their own health. It is not hard to see that. You shiites just like to dramatize and twist things to fit your own agendas.

@1bzerro 10 ай бұрын

Thank you Farid, please upload more videos like this as they are very important and beneficial to the ummah.

@flag_bearertruth6257 10 ай бұрын

never heard this guy, if farid organic wahabi means follow M wahab or taymiah whabai and if make mawlid? cox i think farid is a khwariji the way he talks?

@OnePullUpKing 10 ай бұрын

@@flag_bearertruth6257I swear you don’t even know what any of the words u used mean, you’re just a parrot

@flag_bearertruth6257 10 ай бұрын

somrtimes a person is heart inside and jujust coz u cannot ansnwer, there is a easy way out. I saw this guy farid who is answering ammar, i wanted to know his madhab, aeeqdah so i can get to the bottom of it, nakhwani address all of them sunni, nakhwani is wrong, coz mufti menk is awahabi, hakeen sound like khwariji so i wanted to know if farid is a wahabi or jhwaiji menaing his view on mawlid, and miraj??@@OnePullUpKing

@flag_bearertruth6257 10 ай бұрын

if farid can defend umar and abu bakr, it means he will be resurrected with abu bakr and umar, wow ..... think and reflect all. does farid also like miuawia and yazid? this changes everything, is farid organic wahabi (taymiah) or khwariji (reject ali and uthman khaifat)? think and decide?

@singalongme1 10 ай бұрын

I also have some doubts in this Hadith since "prophet could not write", the hadith says "I (Rasool Allah) will write for you a statement" and this is a well documented history. Another doubt with this Hadith is that Prophet said people to go away so who would a scribe be documenting the statement if Prophet did not want anyone near him ? if the Prophet wanted someone to write for him then he would have said it verbally.

@FaridResponds 10 ай бұрын

It means he'll dictate.

@singalongme1 10 ай бұрын

@@FaridResponds Thank you Farid for clarification but I also had a comment earlier that when prophet ordered everyone to leave was Ali (r.a) also included in everyone ?

@FaridResponds 10 ай бұрын

@@singalongme1 Everyone means everyone.

@andrewsarinas1180 10 ай бұрын

Something I realised is the Sunni hadith will expose the sahaba themselves committing atrocities against the Prophet and Allah swt and you will still make excuses. Even on occasion you will belittle the Prophet to justify their actions. Wake up my brothers, your own books expose your sahaba.

@abulhasan923 10 ай бұрын

So Umar cares about prophet so much that he called him delirious?

@justjustjustify 10 ай бұрын

Umer always questioned and doubted prophethood , also Allah said in quran obery the messenger , who is umer to make decision what to follow and when to follow, plus this sugar coating technique is not going to save umer , he said quran is enough , he did not say oh Prpphet please write it later and take some rest , the fact that he said quran is enough was a desperate move from him, he knew very well that prophet was about to state the leader alongside the quran in writing The will would have finished his conspiracy and plot

@Markus-gj2qg 10 ай бұрын

The religion is already completed in hajjat al wada (surah al Maida verse 3). And why the prophet (pbuh) didn't mention the most important thing which is imamah of Ali (Ra) according to shia, why didin't he mention it in front of a huge number of people in hajjat al wada and wait until his dying day after the deen was already completed. and why shia assume that the prophet was about to write something about Ali imamah in that day. Does not make any sense

@EpicRevelations 10 ай бұрын

He did over and over again but people like you lived during that time so they kept fighting against it. The Prophet called Ali his successor from the beginning during the feast. He called him his Caliph and successor but it's like Allah says in the Quran plenty of times about you people.... you just make excuses

@user-co8uf1mj6c 10 ай бұрын

Good argument, next vid try defending sayyidna Ibles r.a when he disobeyed Allah azwj.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Are you going to defend Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) when he was asked to erase the title of RasulAllah (SAW), but he refused to and swore to not in front of RasulAllah (SAW) thereby disobeying RasulAllah (SAW) for a reason he thought was right. So disobedience to RasulAllah (SAW) is relative and cannot be looked at in a way of a human mistake whereby the person thinks for instance RasulAllah (SAW) is severely sick so therefore does not grab pen and paper, a mistake but condemnation forever? No.

@user-co8uf1mj6c 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois He didn't disobey, he just needed a help.

@TheMahdi12349 10 ай бұрын

😂😂😂

@tyroneolaoluwa6593 9 ай бұрын

😭😭😭😭😭😭

@Warlock786 9 ай бұрын

LMAO

@PL_Con 10 ай бұрын

May Allah guide you Sunnis

@The-servant-of-ALLAH1 10 ай бұрын

You guys, we cannot trust you. Who do you mean by ALLAH? You mean Ali or who exactly?

@SlaveOfAllah1000 10 ай бұрын

Stop Worshipping 12 imams and calling out to other than Allah .

@altamashbaibars9477 10 ай бұрын

It doesnt make shiism sahih Even if we say Sunnism is wrong it doesn't make shiism sahih

@Anarchist369 10 ай бұрын

😂lol..... first look at yourself.. SUNNI is more logical than Shia cult

@khursheedbaquer1221 10 ай бұрын

So ghadeer never happened?

@justjustjustify 10 ай бұрын

Sugar coating umar deeds

@altamashbaibars9477 10 ай бұрын

No need if it was so important prophet would have noted it

@gr3en_jamfatima295 10 ай бұрын

@@altamashbaibars9477 Why should he note anything if people like Umar are ready to refuse the order of Prophet Muhmmad SAW in the first place. He is not obliged to do things a second time if his orders are rejected the first time.

@altamashbaibars9477 10 ай бұрын

@@gr3en_jamfatima295 those who wanted him to write it also defied him by not giving pen and paper. It was a spontaneous decision prophet that would have noted it . He lived 3 more days.

@gr3en_jamfatima295 10 ай бұрын

@@samy7013 so instead of condemning Umars actions you want to not only throw our Prophet SAW under the bus by saying hes delerious but you Also want to drag Imam Ali (as) into the mess of what Umar created. The biggest proof for us is that already there were followers of Umar and another group agreed to bring a pen and paper, then according to the hadith the two groups started to quarrel. Then the Prophet SAW didn't thank Umar for anything he made Everyone leave! EVERYONE. So it does not matter What Imam Alis actions are next, he is obedient enough to listen to our Prophet Muhammad SAW. Since you want to talk about Ali (as) why not talk about Umar? All Umar could've litterally done was grab a pen and paper, but he had the audacity to tell the very man who brought the Quran In the first place that: "Quran is suffienct for us, you are ill." Don't scramble after what could've happened next. focus on the hadith.

@gr3en_jamfatima295 10 ай бұрын

@@samy7013 our concern is the treatment of our Prophet Muhammad SAW. No one in their right mind would speak up against the orders of a Prophet SAW, But Umar did, and the sunnis are running in circles to protect Umar.

@alisatchu3312 10 ай бұрын

Another confusing video. You don't open a single book to defend the claims. Only what you think happened. I wonder why do people only mention Aisha and not khadija

@Warlock786 9 ай бұрын

Very good point. They love Aisha but never even mention Khadijah

@battekyake6107 10 ай бұрын

Noor Ali got violated 😭😭😭

@aksjcre8 10 ай бұрын

An entire video by Farid and his laanthi face trying to “refute” and the most you took from the video is this 🤣 Mentally challenged and intellectually diminished lot

@shaheensssss 10 ай бұрын

I don’t even think it’s about Sunni vs Shia. It’s about truth vs falsehood. Nakshawani’s lectures are evidence based and yours are not.

@condorianonegdiffsgoku 10 ай бұрын

If the Prophet (saws) really wanted to wright it, he would have done so afterwards. He at the end decided to not write it. You can't take individual incidents and then give judgements based on that. The final judgement about Umar (ra) in our hadiths is that he is from the ten who were promised paradise so ofcourse we defend him. He is not specially mentioned in Quran so we can't judge him based on Quran itself. However we know in Quran the final verdict about the wives of the prophet (saws) is that they are mother of believers and other things which contradict shiism. Therefore we accept sunnism and based on sunni hadiths, he will go to jannah. I know you guys like to go to surah tahreem. But it gives option of repentence. You probably never read about Adam (as) or Yunus (as).

@abbas_glzadh6809 10 ай бұрын

@@condorianonegdiffsgoku he was going to write but was denied by umar, its clear as day and keep trying to justify it

@shaheensssss 10 ай бұрын

@@condorianonegdiffsgokualso I have to reject that Abu Bakr and Umar are granted paradise have you not seen the evidence in Bukhari and Muslim regarding their treatment of the Prophet (SAW) of his daughter Fatima (who is one of the four women granted paradise?) you really need to consider these items brother. Inshallah.

@proud_saracen 10 ай бұрын

@@abbas_glzadh6809But was denied by Umer? Why don't you think Allah didn't just destroy the man into pieces for doing this? And are you accusing the Prophet SAW for not completing his duty, i.e, giving us the message of GOD? The Prophet SAW didn't wrote what he wanted to write later because it was most likely something that the Prophet SAW said already otherwise you are just accusing the Prophet SAW for not doing what GOD told him to do.

@condorianonegdiffsgoku 10 ай бұрын

@@shaheensssss You are taking snippets of different incidents and then giving a judgement of your own (obviously you haven't looked at his whole life). That can't overturn the decision of Allah Himself of being with Abu Bakr (ra). Your approach does not work. The same approach is used by kuffar against our prophets and you know that very well. Let's take your idea of certain wives apostating. Does that not mean the prophet (saws) knowingly remained married to kuffar? Why Allah protect her in surah nur and warnered those who slander "believers"? Why He call wives of prophet (saws) mothers of believers directly after saying the prophet is closest to believers? (It was not in the context of marriage which shais falsely claim) Why were they called ahlul bayt? (Shais don't know the preceding and following verses) You accuse Abu bark (ra) as well as most sahaba of apsotating. But overall reading of Quran says otherwise. He was said to be someone with whose side Allah was in the cave incident. Allah praised the muhajiroon. He promised the successors to be of those who believe and not do shirk. All of these plus his overall life makes his status clear. All you have are just snippets of some incidents.

@abiabi9353 10 ай бұрын

I think this wahabi Farid should restraint himself from responding to Dr.Ammar lectures. Because every time hecomes out he can not respond to anything academically. And this proves the sound arguments of Sayeed Ammar. Farid is only being defensive but his arguments can not convince any person of sound thinking

@FaridResponds 10 ай бұрын

Restrain*

@Gunz1234 10 ай бұрын

😂@@FaridResponds

@abiabi9353 10 ай бұрын

@@FaridResponds Thank you

@syed2194 10 ай бұрын

Sound arguments? Ammar takes a ambiguous Hadith and spins it to portray a Sahaba negatively. The basic fact is the Prophet ﷺ asked for a pen from one of the Sahaba, Umar, at that moment, said it would be best not to. Why he said that could be 1000 different reasons. Looking at Umar RA’s contributions to Islam prior to this incident, we can assume that he wanted the best for Muslims and the Prophet ﷺ at this moment, and didn’t provide it out of concern for the prophet in his condition. Was he wrong in doing so? If the Prophet ﷺ asks you to do something you do it, but if he was wrong, so too were all the other Sahaba in attendance who also did not provide the Pen, not just Umar RA.

@abiabi9353 10 ай бұрын

@@syed2194 Omar contribution in Islam is only exaggerated by sunnis without any evidence. Omar was a coward because he ran away from uhud and he was defeated in the war against jews and he couldn't face Amr bin Abdulwud in the battle of handaq. Omar was disrespectful to the daughter of the prophet. Omar made alot of fabrications in Islam against Quran and prophet.agood example is about talaka and hijatu tamatui. You know Omar thought he was so intelligent that could give his opinion against Quran and prophet .The worst thing is to tell the prophet Quran is sufficient. This is kufru by itself.

@hussainasad7988 10 ай бұрын

Seriously the hate for the family of the prophet is so evident here we don’t even need our books to prove you wrong your own books do it for you

@Ishi1XP 10 ай бұрын

This!

@hecker4342 10 ай бұрын

Question: Why did the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم want paper to write if he didnt know how to write?

@roneddy 10 ай бұрын

He could have given it to his scribe to write.

@Warlock786 9 ай бұрын

You need to watch Ammar Naqshwanis Ramadan event. He has spoken purely from Sunni sources

@roneddy 9 ай бұрын

@@Warlock786 ammar is a liar lol

@Warlock786 9 ай бұрын

@roneddy is he lol...then I suppose Sunni Hadith is lies also ? Lol

@roneddy 9 ай бұрын

@@Warlock786 You literally are on a video that shows ammar is a liar, bruh what 😂😂

@AbidHussain-ko8su 10 ай бұрын

Very poor Farid. What's the point of your video.

@jaleel42 10 ай бұрын

We believe at every junction of the prophet’s (saws) mission Ali (as) was there ,. And he glorified him,. And made an allusion that he was the successor,. Starting with when he was mocked by his own family,. In the beginning of his mission,.

@assassinwithalqalam 10 ай бұрын

Omg his voice, if anyone wants to see surah Al Munafiqoon in action one only needs to look at Ammar

@mhmd1854 10 ай бұрын

The manifiqeen are you and the ones you follow, you can't argue from facts

@Ishi1XP 10 ай бұрын

Whoever calls a man ‘kafir’ [disbeliever] or said ‘O, enemy of Allah’, when he is not one, (the accusation) will rebound to him” (narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim). Read your kalma again brother don’t make such accusations lightly. Fear Allah

@assassinwithalqalam 10 ай бұрын

@@Ishi1XP indeed, and Ammar is indeed the enemy, I understand it may hurt you and others, but once you realize that shiism is not from Allah, you will understand why I said what I said

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

@@Ishi1XP Who said he is not one? he is out there misquoting Allah and his prophet, so he is a clear Kafir.

@madaxwayne 10 ай бұрын

@@Ishi1XPone who curses the sahaba and our mother Aisha is kafir Run along now rafidhi

@almiskea 10 ай бұрын

I am Shia, thank you Farid for creating this video, it just shows how you don’t have an actual defense ما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه Whatsoever the prophet gives you, you should take it Also ولا تقدموا بين يدي الله ورسوله No one is allowed to have oppose the suggestion of the prophet Keep providing such videos

@senpai_7867 10 ай бұрын

Bad argument. If that was the case then he wouldnt say "the quran is sufficient for us". He is straight denying the message the prophet was going to give.

@bolaelegbede7843 10 ай бұрын

Let us assume you are right, so what should we bring out of that? Are you implying that Allah willed the prophet to tell us something and Umar prevented it?

@senpai_7867 10 ай бұрын

@bolaelegbede7843 I'm not implying. It's what actually happened. Is that so hard to grasp. He ask for a pen and paper to write something that we can never go astray. You know how valuable that information is. It's the difference of heaven and hell. If someone were to take away a trillion dollars and all the riches in the world away from you, will you be happy?

@senpai_7867 10 ай бұрын

@bolaelegbede7843 listen to ammars lectures. You'll see why he did that.

@bolaelegbede7843 10 ай бұрын

@@senpai_7867 You must be joking. I used the word "WILLED " by Allah and you still said Umar stopped it. Are you on drugs?

@bolaelegbede7843 10 ай бұрын

@@senpai_7867 Both of you are jokes.

@Gasimba785 10 ай бұрын

Always, the truth hurts, I am sunni but What sayed Ammar is exposing everything is in our books 📚; Alhamndulillah;tried to buy all theses books to teach my self and I am still asking why our sheikh don't tell us the truth?😢😢😢

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@arshmash5340 10 ай бұрын

" i am sUNnI"

@abumusaryan4697 10 ай бұрын

Munaafiq

@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul 10 ай бұрын

You are a 🤡

@hmmJustmeK 10 ай бұрын

Lmao u shia behind the niqab of sunni but ur niqab also aint proper 😂🤣🤣 we can see you👀

@Ummsarah27 10 ай бұрын

The book shelf in the background holding on to dear life, Farid please save it😫

@farwajaffrey 10 ай бұрын

Lol, thanks for saying all this and making my belief much much stronger as a Shia muslim as compared to before. Just for once think what you are saying yourself and imagine not Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) but only your dearest teacher would you imagine calling your teacher even that "is he delirious?" Would you know more than the teacher if he needs "pen and paper"?? You are throwing naozubillah Hazrah Muhammad PBUh under the bus just to support Umar. These are simple common sense answers which one doesn't need a sharp brain even to answer. Thank to Allah Subhanwutallah we have scholars like Ammar Nakwashni to guide us. May Allah bless you all to the righteous path as well.

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@maryamdw 9 ай бұрын

I’m a Shia, and I love how respectfully you respond! You understand that we are all trying to figure out the truth. And one looks at their own books for guidance. So I respect the way you respond without mocking or insulting other beliefs. This all is really confusing and I can’t wait for Imam Mahdi (ajf) to finally TELL US THE TRUTH. Both Sunni and Shia only have their books to rely on. So until then, May god guide us to the truth!

@Moody.Smiruai 9 ай бұрын

Sunnis dont have "their" book. They only really on the Quran and the teachings of the prophet PBUH. Dont project your shia suppositions onto the sunni belief. There is no "extra" material required.

@maryamdw 9 ай бұрын

So tell me, where do you get your teachings of the prophet from? And if you say you only rely on the Quran, how do you understand the deeper meanings of the Quran?

@maryamdw 9 ай бұрын

You don’t need to be defensive. I respect you as you are also a creation of god :)

@tofutofu137 10 ай бұрын

Asalaamou alaykum wa rahmatou Allahi wa barakaatouhou son. You are doing a job. I ask Allah to grant you jannat al firdous 🤲🏻

@abdelqadir5227 10 ай бұрын

no it's not Ammar saying it is your own books!

@zed_313 10 ай бұрын

😂 farid farid.. no level mental acrobatics or intellectual contortionism can sugar coat those hadith and exonerate who they clearly incriminate. Save it for the cheerleaders

@SparringHighlights 10 ай бұрын

You gave a bad example. The Prophet specifically commanded them to give a pen and paper and Umar rejected him! It’s clear

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

Umar never rejected, but simply offered his opinion which was derived from a place of care for the prophets wellbeing, and was not shared by him alone. But you know who rejected the prophets commands multiple times to erase his name? Ali, so maybe you should worry about that.

@SparringHighlights 10 ай бұрын

@@noface9375 please re read the Hadith. Prophet commanded something, and Umar saying the Quran is sufficient. Like he knows more than the Prophet lol that’s not a place of care. That’s arrogance.

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

@@SparringHighlights We can use the same argument for Ali, the prophet told him to erase his name from the letter and Ali blatantly rejected, like he knows more than the prophet lol that's not a place of care. that arrogance. See how I can also use your dense logic? Atleast Umar didn't blatantly reject and offered his opinion, unlike Ali who clearly refused the prophets commands multiple times.

@SparringHighlights 10 ай бұрын

@@noface9375 wait so your only argument is “well what about Ali” that’s not a rebuttal. Also, what story are you even referring to, what name on what letter?

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

@@SparringHighlights No, I already gave you many reasons and have others for reserve, but the reason why I am using Ali is to show you your double standards and hypocrisy. One rule for Umar another One for Ali, everything Umar does is bad while everything Ali does is good, ygm. As sunnis are consistent, and say both of them did it out of love & care for the prophet. Btw the incident I am referring to is (Bhukhari 4251).

@ALJ1HAD 10 ай бұрын

Jazakallah Khair FARID BHAI Here , Ex muslims of INDIA were also quoting that hadith with their stupid claim that prophet was dictated by UMAR RA (Astagfirullah) aur prophet feared him

@ssifr3331 10 ай бұрын

One of the most famous atsar was when Umar refused to believe that Rasulullah has died and even threaten everyone from speaking so until Abu Bakr recited one ayah (Ali Imran : 144) to him and he accepted it. In some narration it was mentioned that after hearing that ayah, Umar fell to the ground.

@mande-lorean2182 10 ай бұрын

In fact, he was so shocked. He directly went to saqifa without any care of the prophet's funeral. Cut the crap dude!!

@abbasiabbasi7518 10 ай бұрын

Don't know why but my respect for farid has sky rocketed in last few months. Jazakallah bro

@irtazza133 10 ай бұрын

@xxxdded622 The Pakistani Shia that says saying ya Ali Madad is okay and not shirk? yeah, no, thank you.

@Johnny-xk7vw 10 ай бұрын

Sayed ammar smashed your doctrine.

@zk116 10 ай бұрын

@@Johnny-xk7vwthe only thing getting smashed will "Sayed" Amar's head into the hellfire if he doesn't repent. How can someone even be a Shia man It makes no sense. You believe that the prophet SAW was exceedingly naive to the point where he constantly kept these so called munafiqeen around him and allowed them to maintain their status and power amongst the Muslims -- all while apparently marrying wicked women. You also have no choice but to believe in tahreef due to the way the Qur'an has been transmitted and preserved -- any excuse from you lot in this regard is sheer cope.

@muhammadtasiu5473 10 ай бұрын

@@zk116 Even in sunnah munafiqun were living in madina with the prophet, so I don't get what you are saying.

@zk116 10 ай бұрын

@@muhammadtasiu5473 I'm refering to Abu Bakr and Umār and Uthmān __ may Allah be pleased with them. The company of the prophet numbered in the thousands, so of course some of them may have been munafiqeen -- but Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthmān? These people had very lofty positions amongst the Muslims, and to say that the prophet was oblivious to their alleged evil is ridiculous

@msarain 9 ай бұрын

Excellent point at 5:36. All those arguing Omar (RA) should've just brought pen and paper, would’ve been the first to argue how insensitive Omar (RA) was had he just listened without being concerned about the Prophet (PBUH)'s health especially since he didn’t know and didn’t expect the Prophet (PBUH) to be on his deathbed. Perhaps they have so quickly forgotten that it was on Omar (RA)'s recommendation that the Prophet (PBUH) ordered preaching the Quran openly in Makkah without fear. Did we also forget that it was Salam Farsi (RA)'s recommendation that the Prophet (PBUH) ordered the building of the trench in the Battle of the Trench? Let all of this sink in!

@A7ibAllah 10 ай бұрын

Farid, any chance you could make these videos without showing Nakshawani? Hearing his camp voice and mannerisms really puts me off. ‎جزاك الله خير

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

nah people need to see his face so they're aware

@roffi_daijoubu 10 ай бұрын

So you want a response video that already conveniently clips out parts he can't refute, to clip out all parts? At that point it's not a response video anymore, brow will just be yapping into the void😂

@A7ibAllah 10 ай бұрын

He can cut out his face, his gay voice is enough and unmistakable lol or at least blur it, I can’t stand it 😂

@roffi_daijoubu 10 ай бұрын

@@A7ibAllah curious how you'd identified enough of "gay voice" to categorise Nakshawani of having a "gay voice"🤔

@A7ibAllah 10 ай бұрын

@@roffi_daijoubu I’m from ultra liberal England, they’re everywhere here and this guy would definitely be knocking about with them, he’s as queer as the day.

@Harith112 10 ай бұрын

@ihsanalsaleh 10 ай бұрын

So you are of the opinion that the Prophet was delirious while on his deathbed, had nothing "important" to say, nothing "that would not make you go astray after him" WHO ARE YOU, to judge what the Prophet wanted to say was important or not? The Prophet says something, you comply, not give your opinion, or ijtihad, like Umar and Abu bakr seem to like to do a lot

@thebeliever9646 10 ай бұрын

@@ihsanalsalehali r.a refused to obey the prophets command on the incident of hudaybiyah

@Harith112 10 ай бұрын

@ihsanalsaleh I agree Omar (ra) made a mistake. He is not infallable. But the Prophet (saw) was still alive for the next 3 days. I'm just saying its impossible thar the Prophet (saw) failed to deliver a wahyi before he passed away because we have that ayah I mentioned above

@UnDeAd_X 10 ай бұрын

Read about Ghadeer Al Khum please. Prophet Mohammed (saww) APPOINTED Ali(as) as his successor. And PROPHET OF ALLAH (SAWW) asks for Pen and Paper and there’s NO MORE ARGUMENT!! You just OBEY THE PROPHET OF ALLAH!!!

@UnDeAd_X 10 ай бұрын

And how can you possibly think that Rasool Allah didn’t appoint anyone as his successor and left the Ummah to decide the leader??? Where in the history of Islam there’s Saqifa?? Go read the event of Ghadeer Al Khum and you’ll realise. May Allah guide you to the true path, Aameen

@adammalik196 10 ай бұрын

Alhamdulillah another excellent response by Farid To the Shi’as here’s a question to you all, was the prophet ﷺ prevented from delivering wahy?

@adammalik196 10 ай бұрын

So what he wanted to write wasn’t wahy? So it wasn’t direct revelation and the prophet ﷺ didn’t withhold stuff from the ummah. Ali Ra was one of the prophet ﷺ personal scribes, why didn’t he bring the writing material then? Why did Ali Ra “go against” the prophet ﷺ at the treaty of hudaibiyah when he didn’t listen to what he ﷺ had requested from him.

@Harith112 10 ай бұрын

@AhmadFakih123 Omar (ra) probably made a mistake. Maybe Allah has forgiven already. Still this incident is not proof for your beliefs because of what I mentioned before. Also, there are many ayats in the Quran that praise the sahabas. You should just keep going against the Quran by saying bad things about sahabas when Allah praised them like this: "And the first to embrace Islam of the Muhajirun (those who migrated from Makkah to Al-Madinah) and the Ansar (the citizens of Al-Madinah who helped and gave aid to the Muhajirun) and also those who followed them exactly (in Faith). Allah is well-pleased with them as they are well-pleased with Him. He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow (Paradise), to dwell therein forever. That is the supreme success." Allah (swt) knows the future. He wouldn't have praised them like if He knew the majority of sahabas were going to go against Islam after the Prophet (saw) passes away.

@adammalik196 10 ай бұрын

@@AhmadFakih123ali Ra disobeyed the prophet ﷺ at the writing of the treaty of hudaibiya. What do you have to say for that? Did he know better than the prophet ﷺ when he didn’t comply with the command that was given to him ?

@soheil527 10 ай бұрын

@@AhmadFakih123 Quran 7:158 shows that Prophet a.s was UNLETTERED. How can an UNLETTERED person ask for paper & letter to write something. This hadith doesnt sound authentic to me. Umar was from FIRST EMIGRANTS that Allah promised Paradise in Quran 9:100

@don313 17 күн бұрын

Umar accepted islam in 616. 6 years after the early converts such as Ali, Abu bakr, etc... Also when Umar accepted islam, he came out in the open and challenged the quraysh. Thus becoming a backbone of the early muslims. Also this is 1 year after the migration to Abyssinia

@nemz9548 10 ай бұрын

Ur comparing the prophet to a “Sheikh”. What umar did was wrong. Have some shame. Astagfirallah

@ihsanalsaleh 10 ай бұрын

2 points, for the Sunnis, that seem to think they have it "in the bag": -Ali (a.s) was not a companion, but family of the prophet PBUHAF. The hadiths of sahih say companions were kicked out. Ali would not be out. Remember HE is the one who took care of the funeral while others ran searching for Dunya! -Abu Bakr DID NOT lead the prayer, argument that you claim shows his leadership role after the Prophet PBUHAF Weak weak weak. Remember, you have an interpretation of history, so do the shias.

@africa241 10 ай бұрын

Sayed Ammar states what your own Hadiths say. Fixed the title of the video for you.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

Let me fix it even more... "Sayyed Ammar points out a mistake of fallible Omar (RA) on his refusal to get pen and paper due to his opinion of the Prophet's (SAW) severe sickness but forgets fallible Ali (RA) also made a mistake like any human when refusing to erase name of RasulAllah (SAW) when commanded to by him (SAW) because of his (Ali RA) incorrect opinion in the matter" "Sayyed Ammar quotes a bunch of people and makes it seem like the one Sahaba he has a grudge against called him (SAW) delarious"

@africa241 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois first off, nice whataboutism that has nothing to do with the subject at hand. Second, there's a difference between saying straight up no to the Prophet and calling him delirious, and asking to be excused from doing something out of respect from him. Nice try though.

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

@@africa241See I suspected this is how you would respond, and I was right; the text does not say Omar (RA) called him (SAW) delirious. Omar (RA) never said "no", the same way Ali (RA) never said "no". They both, may Allah be pleased with both, responded in unique ways with reasons, one being saying the prophet (SAW) is severely sick and the other swearing to never erase it. So apparently now there is room for disobedience of RasulAllah (SAW) if it fits your narrative🤔, strange. I see shias saying the disobedience is everything, but clearly they are playing games. According to you, "asking to be excused" is swearing to never do something in front of the person who commanded it being RasulAllah (SAW). Ofcourse we understand why he (RA) did, so we excuse him for his mistake. But you can keep coping.

@africa241 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois yOu CaN kEeP cOpInG Bro, you're the one seething so hard you're changing the words of YOUR OWN books because you can't accept having believed a lie your entire life. You may need to argue about this to protect your brainwashed programming, but I don't. I'm too chill and at peace with my beliefs for that. So I'm off to cOpE about the whole thing now :)

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

@@africa241the fact you didn't respond to my rebuttals and just focused in on me telling you to cope and went on a rant about that and me "changing words" when I clearly gave my argument that it did not say "Omar said" but you ignored that because you got triggered shows me you are not sincere in this conversation.

@FThisW 10 ай бұрын

Thank you for. Making this video. In trying to dispel shias you have made it mainly clear by highlighting Nakshawani's teachings that Shiasm is unequivocally clear which Islam is correct. Spoiler alert, it's nit Sunni'ism

@TayyabaAli-vo8kh 10 ай бұрын

If he asks for a pen , simple give him , but umar dint give him , the reality is because he was affraid prophet will write Ali's name as his successor stop giving illogical excuses.

@megamuslimchad 13 күн бұрын

Do Umar was doing mind reading? Stop being a conspiracy theorist 😂

@Eggwrath 10 ай бұрын

In regards to this question you pose at 5:00 - (I’m Shia) - I believe Omar and other companions who were close to the prophet had genuine envy in their heart for Ali, and knew that if the prophet put Ali’s caliphate in writing, it would be over I don’t doubt that Omar was a companion, and maybe at times a great one. But look how many question marks arise on his character DESPITE the first few hundred years of Islam, all the rulers and Hadith transcribers (and fabricators) were fans of his? Hadiths fabricated like “shaytan sees Omar and walks the other way” can only do so much to whitewash a character In short - from his mischief while the prophet was alive, his cowardice in some battles, his anger issues, his threat to burn the house of Fatima, etc… I don’t dare take gods role and say he’s in hell, a3uthubillah. However, historically, I can be fairly certain that he doesn’t have a clean record, and there was probably jealousy towards Ali being so favorited by the prophet So maybe he suspected Prophet Muhammad would appoint Ali in writing, to make it abundantly clear, and also as a test for us Muslims of the future when we’re selecting our leaders, to see who had the utmost obedience to Allah and his messenger AGAIN - it is inappropriate for any Shia to say x y or z is in hell. The vast majority of Shia scholars reject cursing. But we CAN say “this person has proved themselves to be worth/not worth taking Islam from”

@adammalik196 10 ай бұрын

If over 100,000 sahaba witnessed “the appointment” of imam Ali at Ghadeer as is said by Shias, then why would it need to be written down as well? Shias and their speculations never fail to make me laugh

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@@adammalik196 Answer my questions so your admitting sayidna Ali ra refused an order of the prophet saas? It’s ok when sayidna Ali ra does it but when sayidna Umar ra does it it’s a problem. Do you know that sayidna Ali ra was in the room when all this was going on? Why didn’t he get involved and bring him the pen and paper? Did he also sin? Believe me if the the prophet saas wanted that pen and paper he would of got it. Do you know that the prophet saas was taken to the mimbar before he died to deliver a very important speech to the people so he had the chance to say anything he wanted to say on the mimbar which was the largest gathering of the sahaba if he wanted to deliver that message why wouldn’t he deliver it to the sahaba on that day? He even said Towards the end of his sermon, the Prophet asked "O people, have I faithfully delivered unto you my message?" A powerful murmur of assents "O Allah! yes!"arose from thousands of pilgrims and the vibrant words "Allahumma Na'm," rolled like thunder throughout the valley. Do you believe there is anything missing from religion because of this Hadith that the prophet saas said bring me the pen and paper otherwise you will go astray? If you do your saying that Allah swt sent the prophet saas and couldn’t deliver his message to the people instead they ended up being astray so that means the prophet saas failed as a prophet in your eyes.

@hammadhussain4422 10 ай бұрын

Yeah , you can make excuses for satan also , he used to care so much about The God that he disobeyed Him by not following His instruction but eventually accepted to get out when he was asked to get out 😂

@everythingandroidois 10 ай бұрын

What about when Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) refused to erase the title of RasulAllah (SAW) when it was commanded by RasulAllah (SAW), excuses, let's play your game of assuming the worst but I won't stoop that low. Excuses...

@hammadhussain4422 10 ай бұрын

@@everythingandroidois we don't have any such narration mentioning Ali ( A.S) refused to erase any statement despite ordered by the Holly prophet. The sunni sources that mention this event are weak , unreliable and lack uniformity in details of the event You can search all those narrations if you want for yourself , for us , these sources are not reliable at all to make an opinion about those divinely guided people.

@timeread3099 9 ай бұрын

@@hammadhussain4422 no the sunni sources are not weak on ali refusing prophets order. This is is your infallible imam, u have bigger problems.

@hammadhussain4422 9 ай бұрын

@@timeread3099 mention those sources which are strong and explicitly says imam Ali refused holly prophet.

@timeread3099 9 ай бұрын

@@hammadhussain4422 its literally in our must authentic book Sahih al-Bukhari 3184 "By Allah I will never erase it" Dont lie on our Sources. Ali is not infallible.

@Goks135 10 ай бұрын

Did Ali (ra) also disobey the Prophet ﷺ at Hudaibiyah when he was ordered to write or edit the treaty? Of course Ali (ra) did refuse to obey the Prophet ﷺ but that was done out of love for the Prophet ﷺ likewise Umar (ra) also refused the pen and paper for the Prophet ﷺ out love and compassion for the Prophet ﷺ as he was seriously unwell and wanted him to rest. Of course the Prophet ﷺ should never be disobeyed but context is important and for anyohe to accuse Umar (ra) of any malice has to have a sick heart.

@AbuKarrar57 10 ай бұрын

Continue to be deluded my friend, denial is the first sign of either 1. Insanity OR (and perhaps more plausible) 2. Brainwashed. Imam Ali (as) couldn’t bare not write (Rasul’allah). Whereas the calamity of Thursday, the prophet saww wanted to give the best advice before he passes away! “Let me write that which you will not go astray”. Then the one you worship, Umar, calls him delirious. Why did the companions fight at this point? Because right there and then, this is where the Shia and Sunni split happened, right there!

@abdelqadir5227 10 ай бұрын

The prophet wasnt angry at Ali though, nor did he call Rasoullulah DELIRIOUS! Nor is he ignorant. Do you believe the Qur'an is enough for you? Can you perform namaz solely on reading the Holy Qur'an? A sahabi doesnt know this??????

@saqh.4439 10 ай бұрын

But Ammar nakshawani is not lying its written in sunni books ,umar was disrespectful to the prophet sawaw

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@joury5504 7 ай бұрын

None of this changes the fact that umar disobeyed nabi Muhammed (saw). If the nabi asks for a pen and paper to write something for the believers (something super important), then you do it. The sheikh example also does not apply. No one was asking the nabi for a hadith or anything, but he asked them.

@zeea3500 10 ай бұрын

Jazak Allah khyr Ustaadh...As surgical as ever

@noorhussain6462 10 ай бұрын

In providing no facts but pure personal opinions ?

@syed2194 10 ай бұрын

@@noorhussain6462That’s what Ammar did.

@ShipMyPants 10 ай бұрын

⁠⁠@@syed2194I haven’t finished watching Farid’s video yet but I have to comment on this. If you saw Ammar’s video he’s using sahih Hadith such as Muslim and Bukhari. So how exactly is it an opinion when he’s using facts from Sunni literature. What he speaks of isn’t ambiguous either it is very clear cut and easy to understand.

@Rrrrr-ty9id 10 ай бұрын

@@ShipMyPantsYeah, using Sunni Ahadith to fit in his own narrative. Farid is just putting some logical context. That‘s what he did in the previous refutation. I haven‘t watched this yet, but I‘m sure it will go the same way as the last one.

@kingmosesix432 10 ай бұрын

@@ShipMyPantscan u guys do anything other than lying and manipulating our narrative of wht they dont say ? And accusing of the prophet and his companies of severe accusations??

@mirrorreflection3479 10 ай бұрын

So basically Umar was concerned about not pushing the Prophet when he was extremely sick. Fair enough, but if the Prophet asked for something and even put a high value to it (no misguidance after that) then why would anyone have to put forth his opinion above the wish of the Prophet? The disturbance sprouted when this request was denied otherwise there was nothing before that. You gave an example of a sheikh you admire, well wouldn't you want to do everything for that sheikh when he is sick and when asks you for something? I mean you can care for him to ensure he doesn't trouble himself but there is no trouble of bringing because he asked you to bring it and there is no way of knowing that writing would cause him any trouble (he can tell you to write if it will become a trouble for him, is it fair to deny him only because you think he needs to rest while he is asking you to do it?). And if the sheikh is your biggest teacher, won't even his words during sickness be a gem for you especially when he has put a very high value to this action (no misguidance after this). Won't it be a regret that you caused him not to have that written and he passed away? Why put forth an opinion above his opinion in the first place? If you have a fatherly care for him then true you wouldn't want him disturbed but would you be ready to miss guidance only because you know he is sick and you have another guidance in the meantime that is sufficient so it is fair to stop this guidance from coming at this time?

@YALR-nh2tv 10 ай бұрын

@hussainhussaini2267 10 ай бұрын

Dear Sunni brothers, please make your mind. Sheikh Asem Hakeem says "Umar was not sure if prophet is in sound state of mind", and Farid says "Umar just thinks prophet is in pain and it's better to dictate whatever he wants later". Well, if Umar really means that, why he doesn't he explicitly mention that by saying for example "Ya Rasullullah, let's do it later when you are better", rather he says clearly "The book of Allah is enough for us".

@steveryder1174 10 ай бұрын

Sunnis are astray from there own books

@muhithg 10 ай бұрын

I usually don't message or comment/respond to any videos but I am glad Br Farid that you managed to see and respond the videos. I don't know why in Ramadan Ammar wants to discuss of sunni/shia conflict when he never faced Br Asrar and then on a show contradicted his own words.

@mande-lorean2182 10 ай бұрын

He never actually answered anything.

@aksjcre8 10 ай бұрын

Asrar Rashid 🤣🤣 that wobbler 🤣🤣

@Syy-q5h 10 ай бұрын

He answered EVERYTHING and will continue just make sure ur strapped in it’s gonna be a hell of a ride! He has been called out directly MANY MANY times. There doesn’t need to be any direct calling anyways, you point a finger at one you’ve pointed it all jus as we Muslims feel when we’re targeted by non Muslims.

@aksjcre8 10 ай бұрын

@@Syy-q5h he answered nothing with any credible source. Just his own opinion. Farid should stick to eating mint chocolate and put some weight on instead of pretending to be a man of wisdom

@flag_bearertruth6257 10 ай бұрын

everyone one makes mistakes, nashwani addresses mufti menk, zakir naik, Assim al hakeem & M hijab as sunnis, it is s amistake while ther are super wahabis , i dont know about farid guy, but if he does not celebrate mawlid, 27 rajab & 15 shaban which i believe, then he is also wahabi. also The objective of farid video was to address envy and hatred against nakhswani , yet it lacks authentic evidence, relying solely on personal opinions. and attacks, nakshwani is not saying do mutas and not pray tarawee, it is fact from sunii sources the muta was allowed in islam, Prophet wives hafa and aisha was critisiced in quran, umar did so manty things wrong and look like h did not care about the Prophet PBUH, i even read he wanted to kill the Prophet PBUH which nakshwani didnot say. the Q is iff faird guy thinks umar was a nice guy and will be first to go to jannah even before prophet, because this is what is actually saying, i think it is a bold think to say. Think and decide !!!!! . After conducting critical and rational analysis alongside research, it is evident that Umar displayed traits of being shady and emotional, merely paying lip service to Islam without progressing beyond stage one, a facet often overlooked. meaning he was not a momin, left alone sideem, arif, alwaiya while on the other side Imam Ali was arif, awiliya, siddiqeen and sabirren, being a sufi, this is my conlusion which no one talking about yet. Think and decide !!!!! @@Syy-q5h

@kazshah5371 10 ай бұрын

Once again, weak rebuttals. If the Prophet asks he is clearly strong enough to do it, secondly if the Prophet asks me to do it, I'd do it without question. Sayed Ammar didn't say that they're all kafir, love how you said misrepresentation and then go on to misrepresent what he said.

@abdelqadir5227 10 ай бұрын

Sayyed Ammar is pointing out the disobedience of Umar as shown in Saheeh books!

@rowiemomo4684 25 күн бұрын

Allah ﷻ says in Surah Nisa 59 that when we differn in opinion, we should turn to Allah ﷻ and his messenger ﷺ. So let’s do that, firstly, the argument that ‘Umar ibn Al-Khattab wanted him ﷺ to write it later- there is no clear evidence for this. Allahu Aa’lam. What ‘Umar ibn Al-Khattab (May Allah be pleased with him) did was wrong. When RasoolAllah ﷺ orders, we obey. But saying that ‘Umar did this purposefully with bad intentions is evil. We have millions of ahadith, surely in one or two you’ll find something which you can assume the worst of! This is not what a muslim does, he assumes the best. Especially when we see the things which ‘Umar did CLEARLY, and we know that was good. Why would we then assume the one unclear and confusing matter to be bad now? This is the action of the shaytaan. But no doubt, what he (may Allah be pleased with him) did was not right. I nor anyone else should care who it is, this was the order from the prophet ﷺ. But, this was also the Qadr of Allah ﷻ. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said: The writing of this document is not something that Allah enjoined upon him to write or convey at that time. If that had been the case, he (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) would not have failed to do what Allah instructed him to do. Minhaaj as-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah (6/315, 316) He ﷺ has lots of patience, if this was truely important, he’d have written it with the will of Allah ﷻ. And yes i say it is not that important, because Allah ﷻ His words are a clear evidence for us. The Deen is complete. Which is why he ﷺ didn’t succeed in writing it. The people make this a bigger matter than it is. And he Shaykh Ul Islam (may Allah have mercy on him) said: It was not permissible for him to abandon writing the document because of the doubts that some had about (its importance). If what he intended to write in the document was something that he was obliged to convey and disclose, then the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) would have disclosed it and written it in a document, and he would not have paid any attention to the view of anybody, for he was the most obedient of creation to Allah. Thus it is known that when he decided not to write the document, the document was not obligatory and it would not have contained anything of religious matters that he was obliged to write at that time, because if that had been necessary, he would have done it. Minhaaj as-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah (6/12) So if any rafidhi kalb accuses the prophet ﷺ of not being able to write the important document. Then he’ll accuse him ﷺ of disobeying Allah and failing to deliver his message!

@alimohammed5934 10 ай бұрын

5:04 agreed, that Umar ra was genuinely worried about rasool health but once rasool has ordered to bring a pen and paper its an order and as good muslim we have to be submisive to the order of rasool rather than having your own opinion and moreover they were more knowledgeable people in that circle like Ali ra. As a sunni muslim i imagine if rasool had written down what he intended to write down we would not have soo many sects in muslim. someone calls themself a deobandi, ahle hadees , shia etc etc i am sick and tired watching different sects calling out each other maybe this would'nt have happened if we followed what rasool intented to write.thats my opinion. thank you farid

@benyaminkeyf5300 10 ай бұрын

Why your hearts so blind he told them to get out worried or not as you wanna say prophet as clearly wasn’t happy with him telling him to get out , you wanna keep raising a dispute while your prophet as is dying then go ahead

@jlmoodhd7415 10 ай бұрын

that's what Allah ordained, we shouldn't blame anyone but ourselves since the Quran and Sunnah are already finished and clear.

@alimohammed5934 10 ай бұрын

@@jlmoodhd7415 with passing time i have become more skeptical about this retoric of quran and sunnah. ahle sunnat jamat claim to follow quran and sunna yet they have 70+ sects within ahle sunnat forget the sects we cannot have a comman consensus on simple act like rafa yadain within ahle sunnat.

@sheikhshakilakhtar1865 10 ай бұрын

The source of Islaam is Quran and Sunnah as understood by the Sahaba, Taabieen and Atbaauttaabieen. Your first mistake is thinking you understand the command of the Prophet(salAllaahu 'alayhi wa sallam) more than Umar ibn al Khattab. >"As a sunni muslim i imagine if rasool had written down what he intended to write down we would not have soo many sects in muslim. someone calls themself a deobandi, ahle hadees" This is a second mistake. You imagine? What is Islaam for you to imagine? Have you studied the history of these sects? And these would have come into existence anyway as mentioned in another Hadeeth. Your imagination requires that the Prophet(salAllaahu 'alayhi wa sallam) was wrong or even lying - we seek in refuge in Allaah - when he mentioned that his ummah will divide into 73 sects. Allaahul Musta'an!! @@alimohammed5934

@alimohammed5934 10 ай бұрын

@@sheikhshakilakhtar1865 brother i completely agree that islam is not based on person imagination and opinion except for what rasool had told us but i was building a hypothetical scenario. but there are some facts which are hard to digest the respect for sahaba is only because of rasool, yet we see that he had a opinion about islam over ruling the opinion of prophet by saying quran is enough for us even when prophet had ordered pen and paper that he would write down after which we would never go astray i see that as an guarantee that rasool is providing but sadly we lost that opportunity. funny enough it's only now that i have truely understood the meaning of surah hujjarat ayat no 1

@abdulrazaqamedu3839 10 ай бұрын

Again.. Thanks for making this very civil. Jazakallahu khair

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

May Allah sw bless you for exposing this Ashwagandhi guy.

@thelion2087 10 ай бұрын

🤡🤡 your boy ran away like umar in the discord

@noface9375 10 ай бұрын

@@thelion2087 Umar never ran, but you know who did? your 12th Imam. Bro has been running for 1200+ years, scared and quivering in his little cave. Deliver this message from me, and tell him that the Abbasids are gone, so he can touch grass once more.

@yusarafat123 10 ай бұрын

@@noface9375 lol imaginary 12th imam

@aksjcre8 10 ай бұрын

@@noface9375 may your face squirm and disfigure upon his return

@AdilNazir-wr5yh 5 ай бұрын

Hazrat Umer(R.A) KA NAAM PAAK SUN KAR SHAITAN BE BAAGTAY HA AUR UN SE BUGUZ RAKHNAY Wale be.

@hotneuro5195 10 ай бұрын

Your arguments make shia more firm believer in their faith and will make sunni's more wobbling. Keep putting weak arguments and people will find the hard truth.