The Best Vegan Mayo Under $3 | Vegan Mayo Taste Test Review

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Do you have a favorite?

[@laurac5451]

Everyone was saying use veganaise. So Walmart only had vegan salad dressing. husband non vegan likes it. Number five sounds like miracle whip to me which I hate.

[@Mmmelisssa]

We just Just! (and my husband/kids aren’t fully vegan) I’m always afraid to try others because I don’t want to waste money! I just started the video. Can’t wait to see your thoughts!

[@barbarab2765]

Helmans 😉

[@barbarab2765]

Andrew that was sneaky 🤣. Yall make me laugh out loud Thank you! . Looking forward to trying the Just mayo, Helmans is my go to mayo currently.

[@lolachenault7185]

I love Soy free Follow Your heart. I don't find it artifical tasting at all. I love most Follow Your Heart products. Oh well to each their own. Everyone's tastes are different. I like Just too but its hard to find in my area.

[@eidacurtis9804]

Thank you so much for doing this video. I was having a serious debate about cheating occasionally because I cannot live without my Hellmann's. They had a vegan mayo that tasted just like their regular one but for some reason they changed it and now it taste more like miracle whip which I don't like at all. After watching this video I ran to Target and got my mayo. I'm soooo happy. I'm relieved I don't have to cheat. :)

[@lydiapetra1211]

Thanks you guys! This is terrific. I love Sir Kensington vegan Chipotle Mayo...and Hellman's...

[@karengrace6890]

I always really liked JUST mayo. I would never ever get Hellman's because I've been allergic to eggs since childhood and my heart always broke when my mom brought out the Hellman's. Plus they never made the choice to make a vegan version until now. Not about to start having Hellman's after all of those years of being ignored by them. I am petty 😶

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Haha, we totally understand

[@Lalalalala...]

Bwahahaha I'm sorry but I cracked up when you said you were petty aha I can relate

[@tinabahena1254]

🤣

[@loveisall5520]

You're right, it's petty. I went vegan in 1973--learned decades ago not to be childish about such things.

[@tiffany2015]

I've only had the Hellman's and a few FYH types (The regular, avocado oil, and grapeseed oil ones). So far, I really like the blue label regular Follow Your Heart Veganaise. My coworkers use it too, and they say it tastes like regular mayo (which I never ate before becoming vegan, was a Miracle Whip girl). Great video, btw! Love y'alls taste tests!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad to hear you like

[@margarett_b]

1:02 I knew your were going to use this opportunity very well :D So nice you decided to switch it up!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks!

[@laurac5451]

I think you should have a new vegan or a non vegan do these taste tests with you.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We've discussed it but we aren't comfortable with Covid doing that right now, maybe in the future

[@laurac5451]

@@MakeItDairyFree I'd give you a love but no hearts here.

[@laurac5451]

you can do it via skype or zoom if they are willing to pick up the same stuff

[@paulaleach6058]

Follow Your Heart original Vegenaise for life!!! It’s the OG!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

It's like tofutti!

[@cheym6254]

I love this vid! Your descriptions are so on point and helpful, I can really grasp which one I might enjoy the most! If I had one critique, it's to please put the brand in the corner on the vid somewhere and not just at the beginning. I found myself having to rewind back to the brand and fast forward to where I left off, bc I wouldn't remember which was which. Other than that, great vid!!

[@margarett_b]

Mayo is such an interesting topic. The preferences are so so personal in terms of texture, taste and acidity...and there are always camps of people liking one mainstream brand over another :D Having said that, I love the fact at this point there are SO MANY vegan options you can really test out what suits you best! Unfortunately, I have not found "the" one - all I have available have some disadvantages - be it the ingredients, texture or taste. But they are fine for from-time-to-time applications XD

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Totally agree Margaret!

[@biancar5606]

marg, its been over 2 years later now , sooo have you found "The One" lol your go to vegan mayonaise if so which brand and ya know some brands switch up their formula every few years so i gues you could have retried a few of them

[@MsSassyMT]

When you mentioned the Follow Your Heart tasted like it had too much mustard, I was like...no wonder I like that one. I love mustard.

[@Kelseyveg]

Me too!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHA, it's funny because I like mustard and I probably wouldn't normally mind but comparing side to side it's noticeable

[@lilyw9324]

Your hair is so long and beautiful!!! Thanks for this video!

[@funkypunkypine]

Haha, I love how he trolled you with sour cream! 🤣

[@MakeItDairyFree]

SMH!

[@DeSoAnna]

Random: I don’t like Mayo either but recently started eating the Follow Your Heart original veganaise on sandwiches and to make grilled cheese in place of ranch or butter and it’s not so bad.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice

[@desirae2683]

great video! If you guys drink protein, could you do a vegan protein powders review? :)

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Great suggestion! We only do on occasion but right now use Vega

[@aeb8895]

Orgain is my favorite

[@Mmmelisssa]

YAAASSS! Can’t wait to watch this!! We use the Just!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice!

[@Martina_E]

I can't find just anywhere.

[@Mmmelisssa]

@@Martina_E I’m USUALLY able to get it at Whole Foods. I don’t have a Walmart by me, but I used to be able to get it on their website for much cheaper. If you have one by you, you could check there!

[@jayneb9412]

Thank you so much for doing this. I am trying to go from vegetarian to vegan so substituting out what I normally buy, I want to know what will be my best choice. You saved me a lot of stress in making a decision. Now, do you have a taste test for sour cream?

[@dallymoo7816]

Never seen a vegan mayo under 5.99 most are 8.99 ( northern BC )

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Oh wow, 5 of the were under $5

[@dallymoo7816]

@@MakeItDairyFree Lol I am in Northern BC Canada though😅

[@HoneyDubey23]

Good & gather at Target is $2.99

[@mija288]

Wow! I have tried 80% of the brands and before I started to use Hellman's "exclusively" it was Earth Balance's Mindful Mayo and to the point I got non-vegans using it! But then? Hellman's got us ALL hooked🤣😂 I will say you've intrigued me with the Target option and I will be checking it out. I had no idea it existed. Thanks again for another great vid!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

It's new! Let us know what you think

[@Glim246]

This is SO confusing to me because I can eat regular Hellman's straight out of the jar and I found the vegan completely inedible. I know taste is subjective but I had to throw it out it was so bad. Back to the drawing board for me😃

[@mija288]

@@Glim246 I haven’t had “to my knowledge” actual Hellman’s in years but the moment I tasted the vegan version I liked it very much. Seriously, I felt the same as you did when I had FYH’s Vegenaise and thought both Sir Kensington and JUST were horrid but, really liked Earth Balance - until Hellman’s came along. I grew up in a home where HAIN Mayo was a mainstay and so maybe my “buds” are outa whack. 😁

[@Glim246]

@@mija288 I think one of the things that really makes the difference is whether you are used to mayo or "dressing" like Miracle whip. The vegan mayos I've tried mostly taste like the dressings to me which I don't like. I'll have to pick up the Earth Balance. It's too bad they are so expensive so it's hard to try them all but I'm going to keep trying😃

[@zurimusic9053]

hellman’s is the best & i’ve only tried one other. but hellman’s is ALWAYS my go to anyway, vegan or nonvegan.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you like it

[@CrystalQuartz]

Of all the vegan mayos I've tried, my favorite is Original Veganaise.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you enjoy it

[@KnowYourProduce]

You are so brave...I can't! Haha, I can't with vegan mayo or yogurt. I liked Hellmann's, but they changed. 😭 Just is my favorite now but I'm going to get the Target brand to try!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

ok so maybe it's that they changed

[@KellyMSharp]

I can’t do Mayo either! Never did before going vegan either! I feel you Andrew!

[@tamcon72]

All I wanna say is, Where are you guys still finding Just? I thought they quit making it. Enjoyed this, because potato salad season is almost upon us, and I usually make my own mayo, but it's good to know what commercial ones are good enough to compete with Just. Also, I snickered at the Sir Kensington's results. It's such a pretentious brand! TFP : )

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Whole Foods!

[@RR-vx1vs]

Curious if any tasted like miracle whip...I buy Hellman’s because it’s the easiest to find but I really miss MW. -Rose

[@MakeItDairyFree]

I never ate Miracle Whip before so I'm not really sure, sorry

[@jennifergreen6109]

Chosen foods vegan avocado oil mayo tastes kinda like MW imho. Very clean ingredients, also

[@glonnief]

Great content guys! I like and use Hellmann's vegan most often(simply because of the availability). I also like Follow Your Heart Vegenaise . Thanks for the video.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Def understand the availability factor

[@Mmmelisssa]

As I’m watching, in the future, for this type of video I think it would be cool if you put which brand it was in text on the screen as you’re trying it.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

The brand shows on the screen right before we start speaking about it.

[@susanhoppe7297]

@@MakeItDairyFree maybe put it up in a corner or something for the whole time, I had to pause, rewind and keep doing it.

[@biancasmiles3350]

It’s crazy how much I hated mayo before being vegan. Now I’m obsessed!!! Crazy hack you can mix mayo and mustard to make a creamy tartar sauce or even faux honey mustard

[@emilywolffe9716]

The best vegan mayo is the Fresh Thyme vegan mayo if you can find it! I like it much more than Just (which used to be my favorite!)

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We'll have to see, but I didn't find it when out shopping

[@hippieista7323]

Hellman’s is my favorite if I have to use it in something.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice!

[@nburris1127]

I haven't tried anyone those except Hellmans bc I grew up eating it seriously since I 1st tried it I could not tell it was vegan so, I stuck! Got my non vegan sister using it now too! Thx 4 all you do🥰🥰👍🏾 Andrew is a trip btw... so silly & fun!

[@juanitaf.m]

I grew up in a Hellmann's house, and that's why I'm here on this video. Curious to try!

[@dash_rabbit]

Fun! Going on record before I watch to cast a vote for Target's Good & Gather Dressing. So damn good, I prefer it to actual mayo. Yay, now I get to watch. 😃

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHA, I can't wait until you come back at the end

[@dash_rabbit]

@@MakeItDairyFree ha! I predicted that G&G was the second one right away because your description was bang on. I couldn't identify Just because 3 and 10 were too similar. (Andrew threw me off my game, too. 😜) ... for any that needed to be spit out, I guessed were Sir. Kensington's. That stuff is a crime against humanity. I hope you didn't feel sickly afterwards. That's a lot of goo to eat. Thanks for doing this one. Now, I know I can pick up Just if I happen to be at Weggies instead of Target. 🌟

[@MakeItDairyFree]

@@dash_rabbit HAHAH that's hilarious

[@cjames3082]

Where oh where did you find the Just Mayo?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Whole Foods and Mom's Organic Market

[@joybrooks564]

I'm surprised you didn't have Nayonaise by Nasoya. I don't know if they still make it, but that is good

[@bethleon7006]

I’ve only tried one Egan Mayo so far and it’s the Celebrate Health. I bought it one day when I was at Home Goods, figured I’d give it a try. I was surprised at how close it tasted to real Mayo just a little thinner consistency. I’d buy it again.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

It's the weirdest place to find it but it works LOL

[@lightningbugtriathol]

We can't get Just in my area anymore. Vegenaise is my top because I can't get Just. Best Foods (Hellman's) is too much like real mayo and I never liked mayo before switching.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

It seems like more and more Whole Foods are stocking Just again

[@aceboogie8774]

I cannot find the Just Mayo anywhere. Where did you buy yours?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Whole Foods and Mom's Organic Market both had it

[@margarett_b]

15:50 I just love the fact you tricked her :D Such a fun touch!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHA, it was a fun one and a cute way to get him involved since he didn't want to try

[@yukjellybeans]

I really don't like the Sir Kinsingtons brand. Everything I've tried has been a thumbs down. Great test ! I will pick up some to try for sure.

[@shimadajapan]

Hellman”s (or Best Foods, depending on where you are from...I’m from South Jersey, in CA for 40 years) and Just Mayo are EQUAL in divine-ness!! IMHO

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice!

[@Scott65J]

I love the JUST but haven't seen it around here in years

[@cimesq]

Can you post the name of your top 4? I still cannot figure out the ones that made it, besides Just Mayo.

[@Mama24loves]

I think it was good and gather, Just, Celebrate heatlth and Hellman's

[@laurafales]

You guys always have helpful videos :)

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you think so!

[@tawanawilliams9618]

Off the subject thanks to you both for recommending me the oui yogurt I loved it

[@moisesmartinez6721]

Yes! Thank you!!!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Enjoy!

[@taylormiller4073]

Where did you purchase the just Mayo? I can’t find it anywhere.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Whole Foods has it (at least here)

[@cgatterson]

For the blind test, think of keeping the names up during the testing time.

[@PeaceRose96]

i think some blind taste tests are actually blindfolded because the person can only judge it based on taste and not the color of the product or the texture of it..but in the case that this is literally mayo and they'll all pretty much look identical it would be too hard to tell the difference in brands just by looking at them! HOWEVER if you were doing more blind taste tests like different vegan meats/cheese etc that would need a blindfold since they all look so different.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Great point!

[@sandygiraffe3396]

Haha! Another awesome thumbnail!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHHA, it's the hardest part of the videos LOL

[@victoriawalker4732]

That Earth Balance reaction🤣🤣🤣

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHAHA

[@pugtales]

Just ,ALL the way! 😭😭 why did they stop making it???

[@MakeItDairyFree]

to ruin our summers LMAO, j/p

[@TammiT69]

Just Mayo is difficult to find in my area!

[@vintagejudie_]

I can only find it at whole foods now :(

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Whole Foods is where we found

[@margarett_b]

17:40 The moment you soo all these mayos on the table...guys, what the heck are you going to do with so much mayo XD You might have to use some of them as a hair/beard mask :D . Anyways, thanks for another fun video! Stay safe and have a gret rest of the week!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHAH, we have some salads coming up that we will use some for but you're right, especially with the Sir Kensington's one LOL

[@jomams1040]

Was perfect. I like the idea of blind taste testing so if you do have a preference you won't have any sort of bias towards it it was cool nice job

[@MakeItDairyFree]

yes!

[@chelleec23]

Good video! I missed Andrew's yuck face though 😂😂😂

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL

[@siscassie1]

Where the heck is just mayo? Haven’t seen it in a long time. That was my fave

[@MakeItDairyFree]

THey stopped making it : (

[@laurac5451]

Never using coconut milk again I hate it and people say they use it

[@dreadfairy6963]

Ok so i just want to know how many fridges you have or how big your fridge is to keep all these vegan products after you open them? 👀🤔😂 How do you use up all these products you try? Especially the bad ones?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL! We have a separate fridge for our blog work. We try to give them away

[@dreadfairy6963]

@@MakeItDairyFree OK well that's good 😅 I found that you can use any vegan Sour cream or yogurt to make cheesecake or ermine frosting. I made a bomb cream cheese ermine frosting using that nasty Forager sour cream as some of the milk called for in the recipe. The more tangy/Sour, the better. Or it makes great ranch dressing or dips.

[@debs2617]

Wouldn't it be better to try them as is without other food

[@MakeItDairyFree]

i mean probably, but spooning mayo didn't seem ideal LOL

[@andriadeane4634]

I am with you, Andrew. I do not like mayo either 😊

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL

[@darith770]

500th Like by me!!! w00t woot

[@shakahbasheer4034]

Loved this!! I prefer to make my own mayo. I have never tried any from the store

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice!

[@katiehemstreet8939]

I'm team Hellmans, but I haven't tried Just brand. I hate Spectrum. 😣

[@MakeItDairyFree]

nice!

[@rn2787]

Don't worry I hate mayonnaise too. I can do ranch, but plain mayonnaise is a no go for me. (I still watched cause I love y'all)

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Aww thanks!

[@ultraprincesskenny6790]

It's 7.99 at big y near me :/

[@irishpixierose]

I didn't realize there were that many vegan mayo. I do not like Hellmann's vegan mayo, but prefer their regular one. I don't like their olive oil mayo or light either. I've tried Veganaise and liked it at the time. My son refuses to eat mayo or sour cream, but he has had both in dishes and enjoyed the food 😉

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We didn't either until we were shopping LOL

[@amandanjax90]

Loved this! I will have to give the target brand a try! Thanks for doing the gross trial and error for me lol 🤪

[@MakeItDairyFree]

HAHAHAH

[@rainmakerjohnson4333]

Nice video but we have to remember that everyone has different taste buds & we should try some things for ourselves. My girlfriend was hesitant to try Sir Kensington's because of this video but she tried it & Likes it. So u never know til you try Yourself. Thanks

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Absolutely!!

[@theworldkatesees8026]

I love the follow your heart, but cannot stand the Hellmann's

[@halimapeterson2677]

My favorite is sir kingsengton chickpea mayo

[@MakeItDairyFree]

OH man! LOL

[@patriciagoree8710]

I like the Simple Truth by Kroger. Even my non vegan husband likes it!!! I was surprised you didn't have it in the video. Sidenote: the plant based chocolate chip cookie dough(break & place) by Simple Truth are delicious, again approved by my husband & kids.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We don't live near a Kroger

[@hollitheexaltedempress6957]

Who makes the best hot dogs?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We'll tell you next week ;)

[@AvoryFaucette]

Late to the party but yesss my favorite topic. Beyonce has hot sauce in her bag, I have vegan mayo 😂 No literally, I used to carry it to restaurants to dip fries. RIP JUST! It definitely was my favorite, especially the garlic mayo. I like the eggs but I don't know why they couldn't keep carrying the mayos as well, sigh. Felt very vindicated by your reaction to Sir Kensington-that's often the only option I have, and ugh, it's so foul on its own, though I'll cook with it. Yuck yuck yuck. WHY does this have to be the default? I was pretty happy with Hellman's staying away from home the last few months, and also liked the Wegman's brand vegan mayo, but my current fave is a Fred Myer (WA grocery store chain, owned by Kroger) vegan garlic aioli. Also like the TJ's truffle aioli taste wise but the texture is SOO gloopy, ugh.

[@katieburns1119]

My favorite is Kroger Simple Truth plant based mayo. It's the only one I'll eat. Lol

[@chelleec23]

I really like their vegan sour cream.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

No Kroger here :/ Glad you like it !

[@joycewilson8513]

Wait a minute. Just mayo costs $3? Not up here. If I can find it at Whole Paycheck, it costs $5.99!!!! Another reason to take a ride down the turnpike...

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL, no we were saying that our best mayo choice is under $3

[@joycewilson8513]

@@MakeItDairyFree I'm confused. Isn't your best mayo choice Just? Let me go back to the videotape 😂😂 I missed something 😂😂😂

[@MakeItDairyFree]

@@joycewilson8513 haha at the end of this we said we liked these 4, but in the description box I said we actually put them in order on our blog post

[@joycewilson8513]

@@MakeItDairyFree my Senior-itis kicked in. Sorry 😂

[@MakeItDairyFree]

@@joycewilson8513 hahahah all good

[@katiehuynh03]

I wish this was uploaded before I bought sir Kensington. 😂 I’m not a fan either, there’s like an aftertaste that’s not mayo.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

OH man! I wish you would have told us to save our money LOL. That was the most expensive one HAHA

[@torigillispie9823]

Before I was Vegan, my fav Mayo was Best foods. I LOVE mayo and I'm picky...sooo I only buy Veganise. Its the BEST....

[@torigillispie9823]

Veganise is by Follow your heart

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you have one you like

[@tawanawilliams9618]

I’m like him I never liked mayo we use to eat Kraft Only on potato salad and tuna salad

[@biancar5606]

lol @ GLOPPy u done made ur own word up lol

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL

[@ea4602]

Thank you. I've only tried follow you heart, but I will try the Target brand Mayo. And Andrew I just wanted to let you know I am starting to say yuck on mushrooms. Just wanted to throw that in

[@MakeItDairyFree]

haha, #TeamNoMushroom

[@prrincesssj]

I wish you put the name of each on the screen for us even though you couldn’t know, I had no idea which one you were talking about it wasn’t too helpful.

[@Inputdonutz]

Target brand is good, just mayo, sir are my top! Can't support helmen after they sued Just. to only come out with their own spread.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Understand

[@dank5770]

(Abby typing) Thanks for this video. I do not like mayo in any form. I was contemplating using a coupon for Hellman's Vegan mayo to see if my husband would like it. Now I am not going to bother. I will say "Nayo" to the Mayo.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

lol

[@maryd8216]

I was surprised by the Earth Balance. I do like their butter, so now I know not to get their mayo

[@ashgemini867]

I hate the earth balance one too but I spent money on it so I’m gonna force myself to use it 😭

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Oh no!

[@erinrieger2278]

Thanks for making a video about vegan Mayo. I like just and follow your heart is okay, but they changed their recipe and it’s not as good. I used to like Sir Kensington’s. It once tasted great, but I think they changed their recipe and now it’s nasty.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hate when companies change recipes that you previously liked

[@meredithe4330]

The thumbnail! LOL

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL!

[@sidneymcfadden3857]

A tasty HEALTHY vegan mayo, under $3, doesn't exist. Soy (unfermented), canola oil are toxic, and xanthum gum questionable as it is artificially derived bacteria waste. Calcium disodium (E385) doesn't seem to present side effects when consumed in low doses, while high intakes affect the absorption of zinc, copper and iron, leading to mineral deficiencies. You get what you pay for and your well-being is a reflection of what you eat. Make your own vegan mayo using organic, non-toxic ingredients or, at least, a brand that offers soy-free/canola-free and gum-free.

[@osvaldodelapenavelasquez4880]

17:40 You're welcome

[@Ldubs80]

What I want to know is...what are you going to do with all that Mayo afterwards? 😂

[@itsaplantlife9850]

Potato salad! TLT's!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We have a couple of summer salads planned that we will use it for

[@pineconey]

So, Hellmann's had made this amazing vegan mayo (brown and blue label) that was almost indistinguishable from the original, and then they changed it (green and blue label), and it was horrible. I hope they change it back, but for now my favorite is Wildwood garlic aoli.

[@Glim246]

So I must have missed the original one because I thought Hellmans was inedible. I thought at first it was rancid it was so bad. I hate food waste but it went straight in to the garbage. Back to the search for me😐

[@oreo1064]

Dam look at that beard for all my beard lovers. Wondering how many years that took

[@Lei9785gha]

Primal Kitchen is the BEST!!!!!!!!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

:)

[@freedomloveequality6593]

That beard is like a whole other person

[@Lalalalala...]

I would never be able to do this. Things like coleslaw, mac salad, potato salads, aioli, tartar sauce and stuff like that are delicious, don't get me wrong. But plain mayo by itself? Ummm... no thank you! Hard pass

[@ashxc]

that's weird. i hate mayo but i love follow your heart.

[@thequeenmothermonarch1813]

I really tried to make it thru this video but it was waaayyyyy tooo mukbang for me. Ewww

[@paulettedrinkwalter4954]

Oh you guys haha

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL

[@mjade1673]

Yall are so adorable🥰. Quit it

[@halimapeterson2677]

Great nice video

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks!