The Black American National Anthem - Judy Garland

[@MartinaLaird]

Worth noting that as an adult, Judy Garland went on to be an active supporter of the Civil Rights movement in the USA. She also joined in the March on Washington amongst other things.

[@bigpimpingbignosipping9947]

Yeah that won’t help this druggie whore. Glad she suffered n got what she deserved by them munchkins on set lol

[@greatsol2444]

Both minor, token gestures after this.

[@marissamayhem6504]

@@user-ux6tk8pi9i a white person telling people of color how they should view their degradation at the hands of white Americans is very rich & beyond disgraceful.

[@aaliyahyisrael7461]

Whatever lmbo she probably did that to get attention you must ain't never watched her one documentary on how she died she was starving for attention every step of the way like damn ain't nobody that important lady she was constantly trying to hurt herself for attention smh how many accolades does one need to actually "feel" accomplished so sad her life story is so very sick oh my goodness and to see this wow 😒😒😒

[@johngallipani2781]

LBJ’s civil rights passage intentionally destroyed the black community

[@aionwild6881]

This is a deep scar in her drug addiction. MGM forced her to commit to roles contractually. Judy Garland was notorious as a huge civil rights advocate and I feel just as ashamed for knowing MGM producers marginalized actresses. Judy Garland was deeply misunderstood and unbelievably lovely.

[@st4rdustlumin4ls96]

@@TheCondescendingRedditor this is terrible. I dont see how anyone could consider this her best role. Its straight up mocking black people. Being a snowflake is being sensitive to everything. This is important and disturbing

[@st4rdustlumin4ls96]

@@TheCondescendingRedditor you probably used to box with all the stupid shit youre spewing in this comment section. The brain damage/cte is coming through.

[@Superman-oj2rp]

Yeah you knew her huh?

[@DiddyKongVsLuigi]

@@TheCondescendingRedditor “Don’t be a snowflake?” 😂 People that comment that are usually snowflakes. Watch you respond to this like.

[@DiddyKongVsLuigi]

@@TheCondescendingRedditor I don’t follow pop culture. I’d rather learn more about the lore of the Mcu or an anime, rather real life. Boring tbh

[@strugglingcollegestudent]

I don't remember this part of the Wizard of Oz EDIT: I do not support black face or racism in any way. I made a joke because the wizard of oz is so happy, and this is so horrible. Go watch the wizard of oz if you think this joke is racist.

[@flyswatter45]

It was the Wiz

[@ellowyn8561]

this is in everybody sing not wizard of oz okay?

[@judygarlandfan22]

@@ellowyn8561 it was a joke-

[@ellowyn8561]

@@judygarlandfan22 oh I see;))

[@darylwizzard]

Lol

[@ManicMaiaYT]

She was 15 and was forced to do this. She was under a conservator who forced her to perform the act. When she became an adult I believe around 10 years later in the 40’s she was upset she had done this act. From what I read anyways 😊

[@savannahtollison4425]

She was forced to take drugs while on the set of wizard of OZ and basically starve herself. Her mother and everyone in the business used her.

[@captainmeow2771]

No different than what they do today, just different faces are being made fun of.

[@DavidByrd-r3d]

The amount of likes received from this comment just affirms the passive aggressive nature of you racist but passive aggressive pigs…..let me guess you all have black friends🙄

[@theHermitofEngedi]

It took 10 years? She was an adult for 7 of those years. White people are always making excuses to cover up their racist behavior.

[@mattjames4978]

What's the problem with it? Imitation Is the Sincerest Form of Flattery.

[@ashleysell5709]

rewatching this again. poor girl. she got so much hate for something truly disgusting that she was forced to do. what a utter shame. crazy how times have changed.

[@tristanbruns5968]

No one is hating on Judy Garland! It’s the blackface we hate!

[@theuniverseisme432]

Blackface wasn’t controversial back then and wasn’t seen as wrong.

[@andyhu7205]

@@theuniverseisme432They also dressed as Asian and Native people. But we know it's wrong now.

[@andyhu7205]

@@JakeKoenig The movie is a social commentary on blackface. The point sailed over that empty noggin of yours. Does your head make maraca noises when you shake it? Cuz there ain’t but a few skittles and some pocket lint in there!

[@moonflower6607]

@@JakeKoenig Whiteface isn't really a thing...

[@zahraisonline8794]

What disgusts me even more is the fact that she was forced to do this by the company she worked for Pretty messed up how they made her do blackface against her will

[@Rapztress]

Ummm...forced...really...backbone dignity pride...no gun to her head.

[@LuisGarzaHo]

@@Rapztress She was 15, she was sexually abused on Hollywood, forced to smoke and get drugged, and being quiet about, it was pretty common those days because you were slaved by producers and filmakers, remember it was the damn 20's-30's, hard days worldwide, you're blessed to live in this generation, alot of these millenial kids would have ended worse than her

[@therealgodessisis]

@@LuisGarzaHo thanks for whitesplaining

[@LuisGarzaHo]

@@therealgodessisis Thanks for don't understand any context even if this happened 80 years ago, thank you much, you're changing the world, keep going!

[@Johny_Truant]

@@therealgodessisis racist

[@enceladus2263]

Her eyes look absolutely lifeless in this performance

[@naitthegr8131]

yes, it's like she knew what she was doing was fucked up.

[@midnalazuli793]

She doesn’t smile much either. You can tell she wasn’t comfortable with this.

[@naitthegr8131]

@@midnalazuli793 no smile at all

[@ayeshak6822]

I love how all the empathy is aimed at Judy Garland and not the people damaged by this disgusting depiction. ;)

[@Madmen604]

I was going to say the same thing! I don't think she was happy about that song...

[@IsaiahCarroll95]

Even though the optics are terrible and the backstory with the people that forced a minor Judy to do this... she sounds incredible.

[@ChildovGhad]

She had to sound incredible. The alternative wasn't pleasant.

[@CITA140GDDM]

OMG, I was just thinking the same thing. And she's doing it with attitude! (My identity = 67 year-old black woman)

[@asilreyom2698]

She could never! Black face can't make her sound soulful, she still sound "unseasoned"

[@asilreyom2698]

@@CITA140GDDM LOL

[@craiglittle1437]

Fair shout mate

[@chrissyw9173]

Reading the comments I'm glad people actually know Judy Garland's history It's sad that she had to do this because she was under contract but her voice is very beautiful My opinion the reason why this hasn't really gotten any attention in Media is because people are aware and very vocal about what Judy Garland went through and they would go after the studio's instead At least that's what I hoped would happen

[@Floridad25]

Or it doesn't get any attention in media because face it, the media has two sides and right now they're too busy screaming at each other.

[@lexii8809]

as a black person, I don't think it's her fault. she was exploited and was unwillingly on dr*gs. chances are she genuinely didn't want to do this so they dr*gged her or she could've been overwhelmed. I mean look at her eyes they look so dead

[@Fireglo]

No contract in the world can force you to be racist.

[@lexii8809]

@@Fireglo it can if it involves overworking which leads to dr*g ab*se

[@ihaylz]

@@Fireglo when you're a neglected child with a shitty agency/mother, it definitely can.

[@noncatholiccatholicrat6309]

For those of you who are saying “she still had a choice to do this performance” there are a few things you should know: Back then when an actor signed a contract(especially a child actor), the studios had control over everything on them including their bodies(many actresses were even forced to get abortions; Judy garland is thought to be one of them). In addition to this, Judy had an abusive stage mom(and her father had been dead for a year at this point). If she refused to perform this she could’ve 1. Been beaten by her abusive mother 2. Fired from MGM leaving her entire family without money, and her mother would’ve definitely abused her 3. Be beaten by her mother AND drugged into submission. For all we know she could’ve been heavily drugged here. She was forced to take drugs and alcohol throughout her entire career to get her to perform the way the producers wanted her to. Edit: I'm disgusted by the amount of people responding to this comment who are saying this blackface doesn't matter anymore because there are no more slaves. Educate yourself on how these mindsets become systematically ingrained into our society and laws; leaving the after-effects to generations to come. I am also discouraged by the people who assume only the worst,, especially without doing their research. Whether you would like to believe it or not, I 100% understand where you are coming from, and where your mindset is. But if you have no experience being indoctrinated by any ideology or bigotry, I highly suggest you educate yourself. You cannot hold people accountable for things they did when they were children, yet alone things they did before they had un-indoctrinated themselves.

[@cinqsaw4358]

That’s sad

[@brianew]

@@JoshTheTechnoShaman She was a child when she did this, No apologizes necessary. She gets a pass

[@gbioabngd]

"For all we know she was drugged", drop the cop outs. This is what it is, and no amount of gaslighting will save it. Go back to your rat hole.

[@elyh2159]

@@brianew no tf she doesn’t haha. There’s no passes to be racist

[@8to5oncleveland27]

@@JoshTheTechnoShaman you're not feeling it because you have no humanity.

[@nubbinthemonkey]

Good lord, the sublime beauty of her voice contrasted against the grotesque spectacle of her presentation is breathtaking

[@Charles-ij1ow]

It really was something to watch

[@turnne]

@nubbinthemonkey Grotesque is the word I would use How could anyone have thought this was entertainment?

[@turnne]

@George Costanza Its a mockery making fun of someone. What was the point of her being in blackface.....could her talent not carry it?

[@jyt74]

I admire the way you expressed this. "Grotesque" is an excellent word choice. This clip broke my heart--such heaven in her voice and such an ugly hell behind it as a performance I noticed that her performance here lacked the over-the-top enthusiasm so typical of blackface actors during "happy"/upbeat songs. I don't know enough about Garland to know if she typically brought that underlying distance/melancholy to her roles, but here it adds an extra layer of unease. Everything about this clip feels like a metaphor and a juxtaposition--on one end social horror, on the other personal tragedy. Heartbreak in 2 minutes.

[@someone_something_yeah7552]

@@jyt74 Your comment just won the internet today.

[@ArmanIRL]

Don't you dare let anyone forget how people were perceived, treated, spoken of, and portrayed back then. They had the magic to produce films and preserve stories, and this is what they chose to create. Edit: People in the comments are why we should never forget this. Sorry your hearts are so full of hatred.

[@CHRISANDREOU4199]

Yeah and alot of other stuff

[@darthparallax5207]

It's hard to sort out "who started it" and "did it ever stop" People can show how someone else told them to And people can show how they all were just going with what's popular and they all only meant to make a living. There's a reason that the world that produced this, leads up to WW2. And Hitler didn't have his ideas on his own. He heard them from Henry Ford who heard them from someone else. Conspiracy theories just spreading. And getting out of hand. I pity that people got hurt real bad by it. But honestly it's hard to figure out how to fix the world. They thought they were being either good, or funny. They thought the horrors were over so it was time to relieve stress and make parodies. Thought they'd freed the slaves and deserved a break from war. That just movies isn't so bad. And they were ignorant of some things and just accepting of other things. But really, its the same today. The bottom is poorer than the middle realizes. It's not over. Parodies can hurt feelings and come across as cringe and callous and tone deaf. Other people do worse. It's all messed up. And sometimes they want to represent things but they're too dumb to do it accurately and it reveals not even as much their hate but their ignorance. Like.....the way William Shatner overacts his lines. When you see it on Family Guy you see how absurd it really is. There was a time that a lot of people thought this was real. There was a time a lot of people thought this was progress. Which makes one wonder: what if right now, what we have today isn't good enough, and will one day look just as embarrassingly cringe? It feels unnecessary to assume hate if ignorance would seem to explain it completely. Oh real people still get hurt by the cringe even if it comes out of ignorance more than hate.

[@CHRISANDREOU4199]

Prolly best all round if eryone just go tha fkk back home to Africa and get the hell out of this white racsism hell hole,😔

[@RD210]

the way of life back then. Dont be ignorant and judge a persons character with todays standards

[@OGStarlightKY]

@@RD210This was not that long ago..You’re saying it like this was in the Middle Ages

[@jeffbrehove2614]

The most unbelievable part is that Garland was 16 roughly, and she still sings like she's 50

[@trevorzane272]

She was 14...

[@mibukdesjarlais534]

Wasn't she 14 tho? 😕

[@jeffbrehove2614]

@@mibukdesjarlais534 I stand corrected, but the point still stands

[@mibukdesjarlais534]

@@jeffbrehove2614 Yep. It's so fascinating that even at the tender age of 14 her voice was still very polished and refined. Just goes to show how truly talented Judy Garland was. This cruel world did not deserve her at all. 👠👠🌈❤

[@mischka4]

She was put on drugs at 10. By 14 she had already been abused for years.

[@benzz2006]

Considering she was actually a tool by the industry, that terribly hung her dry in her darkest hours, I won't hold this against her. Just by looking at her eyes, I can tell her heart is not in it the same way it was in Meet Me in St. Louis' or the Wizard.' Not saying it's right..just saying we know what really' initiated this. Still a fan because she was an underdog like me.

[@elizabethowen8559]

Yes she has an angry look in her eyes.

[@JimmyBmusic1]

@Dionysus down where?

[@themrbendewy]

@@JimmyBmusic1 hell sajsjajaj

[@Abebabe413]

@Dionysus God forgives her

[@Abebabe413]

@@rfeyman3682 agreed

[@BeccaBee20]

This is terrifying.

[@beebeexoxo4823]

Becca Bee it's creepy

[@tillnextyear3758]

Becca Bee and racist

[@x_kendall_x7502]

Becca Bee I know I am so scared of this, idk why

[@ruthhadeee446]

IKR

[@YTUA1983]

@@beebeexoxo4823 I was just thinking da same thing! 😱

[@michaelknight5097]

I’m black and I love this

[@ColcaadaSmith]

Tap dancing huh

[@michaelknight5097]

@@ColcaadaSmith sa da tay my dammie

[@ColcaadaSmith]

@@michaelknight5097 I’m sure someone will give you some head pats

[@Kold1Muzik]

Sambos on the loose

[@LauraLegends]

Childish Gambino brought me here

[@kevenr5492]

Laura Legends me to

[@KeeliaSilvis]

Me too

[@ranger4242]

Me to

[@antoniap3290]

same

[@oopsfn]

Laura Legends same

[@cayanne3420]

Damn it. I could've lived my whole life without knowing Dorothy from Wizard of Oz did blackface.

[@hailietheidioticskeleton8202]

She was forced to do it sadly :(

[@MC-nl2jk]

This was 80+ years ago. Times were different. Do be a pussy

[@offcialmusicvotes7140]

Judy garland was drugged, threatened and forced by contract to do everything she has ever done including the wizard of oz, so your childhood would be ruined anyways.

[@snowfacekiller5777]

Ex fucking xactly

[@user-by9hw4wm3c]

It's really sad. It's all her mother's fault. Her mom made her be in the entertainment business, and then MGM forced her to do drugs, blackface, etc. One of the producers sexually harassed her too. But she didn't know any better. :(

[@roro515_video]

I can’t believe anyone ever thought this was OK. Happy to see people acknowledging that Judy was forced into doing this, and many other things, to stay employed. Great vocals, if you can get the visuals out of your head.

[@King710.]

I smell coal

[@charliebrownatemybro]

do you think it has to do with the microphone work? Was the audio recorded live with the visuals or was it done after?

[@VictorHLopez33]

Exactly

[@nboykinjr]

Can't GET THE VISUALS OUT OF YOUR HEAD when your black. Period

[@Nbomber]

@@King710. toll paid

[@CategoricalImperative]

This should be remembered to learn from it..... HOWEVER, it should not be used to attack those in the present.

[@Isabel-jb7vd]

True. This performance is disgusting I reckon. She looks so ridiculous

[@rukiddinbro]

Don't ever take down this horror video. Those who forget the history are doomed to repeat it.

[@Assdafflabaff]

What's horrifying about this? Are you really that sensitive about black people lol? Grow up.

[@jamesa2482]

Oh you’re so cringe stfu. You really think we would bring back blackface in for any reason let alone because they simply take a video down. I’m not saying we should take the video down but don’t act like we’ll return to the 30s or 40s.

[@paulgreengod]

Horror 😆 this is hilarious Best comedy I've seen in years

[@olivercharles2930]

@@twentyfifthdui4717 Whataboutism much? No need to turn this shit into a competition, neanderthal.

[@olivercharles2930]

@@paulgreengod Exactly what everyone will say at your funeral.

[@casualcrybaby]

I totally believe she absolutely hated doing this. She was a civic rights activist. Her eyes don’t look happy.

[@chrishultgren777]

She rode in the front of the bus

[@jimmycricket7946]

It's called virtue signaling everyone in Hollywood does it. If she hated it so much she wouldn't have refused to do it it's not like she had a pistol put to her head. Besides back then this was totally normal and today we have movies like white chick's so what's the difference? The only thing I that really could be called offensive is the white lips otherwise she's doing an impression of a young black girl from the south. This performance if taken in it's intended context isn't really that bad, it's sort of like a man singing in drag if you ask me.

[@barrycollins795]

No doubt she cared let’s be real

[@LegionIvory]

Yeah, apparently she was forced to film this, and she was only 14 at the time.

[@nawelsaidi9717]

@@barrycollins795she was a baby in this

[@jasonparker3925]

God, she looks like she’s in a mix a pain, embarrassment, and sadness. It’s terrifying, not to mention the joy of the audience.

[@AlyssaTaylor9]

I'm glad someone brought that up, she looks miserable.

[@monkey6207]

This is basically Dylan Mulvaney of how he portrays women.

[@barrycollins795]

No she don’t

[@MySpineMySpineMySpine]

​@@monkey6207 not even close to similar

[@monkey6207]

@@MySpineMySpineMySpine Speak for yourself if you weren't insulted.

[@brendanwalsh5213]

Im just laughing at people expecting other people from 75 years ago to act like its todays times😂😂😂

[@sillyabluble_]

literally nobody is saying this?? stop making stuff up dude

[@joeneighbor]

Yea, a lot of virtue signaling.

[@johnolsovsky]

many of the comments are indeed saying this

[@handwritingofunhingedgerbil621]

For people who are saying Judy is racist, enjoyed this, or was fine with this since it was normal in this time period need to stop. Judy was *forced* into doing these things under the rigid contract of the studio and her own mother, which is incredibly difficult to resist especially for child actors and in a time period where children had very little autonomy. And just because blackface was common and normalized didn't mean people were okay with it everywhere. Slavery was common and there were people who opposed it even when it was happening, normalization ≠ agreement. And Judy was a notorious Civil Rights activist, she was forced into a racist role. And you can see in her expression she didn't like it, people may think she did but she was an actress, she had to act like she did for the studio but you can tell she didn't if you bother to actually look, such as the lifelessness in her eyes

[@marktaha2701]

At the age of 16,I named Louis ./ Mayer as the most unpleasant bastard I'd ever heard of. The film "Judy" sort of confirmed it.

[@cattuslavandula]

In addition to the obvious issues, Judy's appearance, the makeup, the costume, the expressions, are like something from a horror film. This clip is monstrous.

[@solidcobalt]

This is tight

[@adambomb0108]

Something tells me you're more of a bad person than Judy Garland

[@registame2878]

So true

[@haruruben]

This was very common representation of black people in that time. Many people today look back at Amos and Andy and see it as racist but it’s downright modern compared to the horrific blackface portrayals. At least Amos and Andy depicted them as actual normal humans and they were usually played by actual black people.

[@cattuslavandula]

@@haruruben Yes, the whole display is awful. But there's something disturbing about Judy's performance specifically to me. The movements, the facial expressions, the weird eyes. She seems deranged or zombie like to me. I could barely watch the whole video.

[@TrangPakbaby]

I blame the studio and the adults around her. She was a child contract player, she was legally obligated to do what they told her. She was fed on a diet of chicken broth and was put on an aggressive regime of uppers and downers to maintain her weight and keep her working. She didn’t even have a choice to keep her first pregnancy and was forced into an abortion. As an adult she was a big supporter of civil rights, she donated to the families of the little blk girls who were unalived in a church bombing, fought for the Nicholas Brothers and other black entertainers.

[@Geraldine_Dinkins]

People in this time didn't perceive this the same as you do. This wasn't thought of as wrong until years later.

[@TrangPakbaby]

@@Geraldine_Dinkins what are u talking abt and how does it relate to my post?

[@lit3home]

@@Geraldine_DinkinsThe comment simply pointed out that Garland was severely mistreated growing up. Your defensiveness around it shows a lot about you

[@VB-mn6is]

Shut up dumb bitch you sound slow ​@@Geraldine_Dinkins

[@lampad4549]

​@@lit3homehis comment was this wasnt mistreatment this was the norm.

[@Jeremiascenourita]

Her voice was beautiful but that video is one of the most horrifying things ever recorded...

[@bobnewfart]

Blackface did not mean what it means to you to her numb numb

[@bosshamton9040]

If you're eyes are covered then you will not be able to see that she opposed it. She was a woman who had to do it because that's how it was in Hollywood back in the day.

[@deliseovpstudio2978]

And that's how it was for the African Americans who were ALSO forced by "the way things were" in Hollywood, Vaudeville and Burlesque theater as well to PUT "cork" on their already Black Skin to perform IN "Black Face" or not perform at all unless they were performing in an all-Negro production, for an all Black audience in a "Chittlin' Circuit" performance space/auditorium. The lunacy of this country's treatment of HUEman beings is something that has a 400 year+ debt of hell-to-pay

[@fredrickkenley674]

Had to? Like, at gunpoint?

[@kennanlukacs]

@@fredrickkenley674 have you done research to know? She was 14 here. The studio pretty much owned her at this point and she was forced into these roles as contractual obligations. Judy was known as a huge civil rights activist and no doubt had no interest in the slightest in performing this heinous role - she was drugged and starved until the companies she was under were satisfied that she’d do what they needed her to do. A lot of this contributed to her issues with drugs that led to her demise and overdose.

[@fredrickkenley674]

@@kennanlukacs Who ordered the bull shit sandwich?

[@Dm-tu4wf]

@@kennanlukacs I didn’t realize her life played out like this. I got recommended a bio of her life after watching videos of bobby Driscoll

[@capncookie1110]

After looking at Judy’s entire history, I just feel so horrible for her and everything she had to live through until her death. She really didn’t deserve any of that. Edit: Jesus Christ, I think I might’ve started WWIII here

[@JStephs1950]

Having to do this sort of thing probably contributed to her mental issues, which eventually led to her early death.

[@velvetstar9300]

Neither did the group she was portraying 🙄

[@intermezzono1]

@@velvetstar9300 nothing of the contrary was said.

[@jls238]

@@velvetstar9300but who’s responsible for their hardship if their own sold them into that😔

[@velvetstar9300]

@@intermezzono1 I know that. I still stand firm on my comment. It's strange to feel sorry for someone in blackface yet not enraged by it.

[@velveetafromage]

This was the time of “Pigskin Parade”, so she was 12 or 13. Even as an adult she had to do what the studio told her to, so it’s pretty obvious she’s not to blame for this awfulness. Her singing voice is extraordinary, my word. No wonder they signed her, too bad they didn’t know what to do with her.

[@toxxxickay3553]

THEN EXPLAIN WHY TF SHE DID IT TWICE

[@Myjacob99]

​@toxxxickay3553 her mother forced her too

[@velveetafromage]

@@toxxxickay3553 ? All the stars were forced to make movies they didn’t want to make. It was a famously corrupt system.

[@michaelcastro8625]

@@toxxxickay3553 actors didn’t have freedom like they do today. Back then if a studio signed you, it meant they owned you. You did what they said or they sued you for breach of contract and bankrupted your entire family. There are a ton of horror stories of this era of Hollywood

[@coldacre]

its 1938... she's 16 here

[@arithelion5946]

What film is this from? Edit: It's from Everybody Sing (1938)

[@ramisamman1095]

Imagine if she was singing in German.... everyone would be out of their minds

[@JakeKoenig]

I think it's from the movie White Chicks. Oh wait, that's black actors doing whiteface to mock white women. And nobody had a problem with it.

[@lizpolaris]

Also, why on earth is this titled the Black national anthem? I came here expecting to hear Lift Every Voice rather than this disgusting minstrelry.

[@jenniferjimenez677]

She was only around 15 years old here. It's not like she had any say in the situation.

[@jenniferjimenez677]

@Hell Raisers MC Los Santos she was only 16 when she filmed Wizard, it's amazing. I think she grew up super fast. She had a lot of weight on her shoulders all her life.

[@TheCondescendingRedditor]

This is by far my favorite role of hers

[@jordynsimmons1107]

She did it again when she was 20

[@jenniferjimenez677]

Remember Mama and the studio called the shots. Until she got married. Then whatever husband she had and the studio called the shots.

[@trevorzane272]

@@jordynsimmons1107 I guess you don't know what a contract is...

[@sydneydufauchard]

Who else came here because of the Childish Gambino Video?

[@shamaiahedwards8250]

Sydney Dufauchard Yuppp from this is America

[@thomasm0310]

Raising my hand! This is sick

[@OutsideTheRopes]

I did...I never knew Judy Garland did this.

[@mocoman6280]

Sydney Dufauchard Yes. This was why saw this video. I never knew before. Mandela effect.

[@stefunyie]

Sydney Dufauchard Yas I'm here from insider.

[@blurryfacegrrrl4468]

Whoa, this is so unbelievable and shocking.. My mouth hung open for a straight minute at how disgusting as a society we once were. Poor little girl and all who were mocked with this look. Inhumane 💔

[@MorningView4]

Were? Even worse now.

[@LittleRedMads]

@@MorningView4 not even close. You are braindead

[@morganepg]

"Are"

[@lov3zone32]

@@MorningView4 not even close

[@lov3zone32]

we are now on the righteous path....those old beliefs are exposed ...most people are loving and kind ...no matter what "fake internet news" may say

[@nerrade]

It starts a little slow but picks up nicely. She puts her own spin on this old timey mash up and has some very unique dance moves/mannerisms. Make-up' s a little heavy though.

[@TheMeghaniscool21]

I cannot UNSEE

[@MeowPants28]

to be fair, she did not want to do this film, her mom forced her to because she needed money.

[@mocoman6280]

I never knew.... my mouth hit the floor????

[@TheCondescendingRedditor]

It's awesome isn't it

[@preppychrisbou]

This is awesome.

[@yournewfavoriteloser]

I feel so bad for her here. It’s literally abuse that they made her do something this disturbing. I can’t imagine how hard it must’ve been for her especially looking at how unhappy she looks here

[@josbar2835]

Many people may not realize that, in America's past, African-Americans were not allowed in films (or on radio stations). There were no black actors or actresses (or black professional athletes). Our country had segregation which included having restrooms for "Whites Only". So, the only way to have a film with a black character was for a white performer to do the role in blackface. Judy Garland may not have even seen this as distatsteful as we do today. She was doing her job as an actress. I am not saying this was right, just reminding people to take it easy on Judy Garland.

[@jyqavonowens5577]

And black people back then who was shown as this when were not sit tf down

[@alicial3320]

@@josbar2835 What are you talking about??? Just look at movies from that era you will see MANY famous black actors during segregation: Sidney poitier, Dorothy Dandridge, Hattie McDaniels... They purposedly CHOOSE to not cast black people, to ridicule us and not make any black person more famous than a white person.

[@takfam07]

She probably thought nothing of it, other than a great break and opportunity. Blackface was a standard part of American entertainment back then. Let's not project our 21st century social posturing with how people thought and felt in the 1930s. If you were there, you'd have thought and felt the exact same way as the majority of people at the time.

[@amaitilasso]

@@josbar2835 When were blacks banned from movies? In school we watched Uncle Toms Cabin from 1914 and it had black actors. In fact the main character is black. Hattie McDaniel won the academy award for Gone with the wind in 1939. I am not questioning segregation at all but there have been black actors (and great ones) since the beginning.

[@Fangirl-Nerd12]

Hopefully this won't get taken down since it's part of History

[@therussianblin2175]

Indeed, we can't just ignore a part of history just because it was obscure. Insted we should watch these videos to learn from our ancesters mistakes and do better

[@Kira7London-Spencer]

Confederate statues are part of history too

[@AdamBechtol]

Aye

[@Panpunk420]

@@Kira7London-Spencerdef agree!! Since day 1!!

[@vincem2759]

This nonsense never gets said about Hitler statues....

[@tias.6675]

It's so weird how people are hung up on the past. Meanwhile, the country live in os falling apart and is ridiculously corrupt.

[@tsrebelgoddess4753]

racism is still happening, so it's not being "hung up on the past."

[@robmulero3554]

The NFL brought me here.

[@BitcoinJake09]

Same. But WTF... I wish the movie wasnt so scary so I could focus on the soundtrack....

[@zmantastic08]

Right! Lol way to go NFL

[@xaviergonzalez5390]

Same here

[@cootingram6265]

And stayed for black face haha

[@chonrubio7277]

Yep.. me too

[@Kait16xo]

Thinking of Dorothy as blackface is the weirdest thing to me Edit: is anyone else unable to see the video anymore? Mine’s just a black screen with audio playing. Odd.

[@offcialmusicvotes7140]

Judy garland was drugged, threatened and forced by contract to do everything she has ever done including the wizard of oz, so your childhood would be ruined anyways.

[@hisbeautifultruth5931]

She wasn't drugged to do this. Face your legacy.

[@wys4463]

Hisbeautiful Truth she was drugged every day and forced to do it ✌🏻

[@wys4463]

Hisbeautiful Truth do your fucking research she had to take drugs every day

[@hisbeautifultruth5931]

@@poppyisyourmommy6956 - Yes, I'm aware. But afterward had she ever recanted or renounced her offensive acts? That's my point. She wasnt totally wasted throughout her life and was coherent enough at some point to recognize the gravity of what shes done.

[@billbill3890]

This is just weird as well as offensive.

[@naturalmystic251]

Bill Bill America!!

[@sfcmac8971]

Lots of shit is offensive. I'm offended by assholes called "Bill Bill'

[@gerald8051]

SFC MAC you called him an asshole because he said that blackface was offensive? Lmaooo

[@sfcmac8971]

@@gerald8051 I called him an asshole because he is.

[@sfcmac8971]

@@gerald8051 STFU. You're still an asshole.

[@THETOYTIMEMACHINE]

Is that Justin Trudeau?

[@jaymorris3468]

Don't be insulting, its Joy Behar

[@Corrie-Lee]

😂

[@seangeary7100]

Lol

[@AirShay]

People need to understand something... This took place when women had not even been voting for 20 years yet. She was 14 years old here. Do you really think a 14 year old female could have said no to this? She had to lose a significant amount of weight to even be considered for The Wizard of Oz and that came out the year after this did. She was still shamed for being too heavy. She was even smacked in the face while shooting The Wizard of Oz by the director. Please try to understand all of this before you shame her for it. It's obviously racist but consider the circumstances.

[@AirShay]

Women back then had to do a lot of things I'm sure they didn't want to do because they simply weren't allowed to say no.

[@DeepScreenAnalysis]

Exactly. This was an unfortunate part of American culture at the time but anyone who knows Judy knows she didn't have a prejudiced bone in her body.

[@AirShay]

welp hello I didn't know her personally but neither did you, so that's not a valid argument. Also, not sure if you can read, but I said "It's obviously racist"... Not once did I defend blackface OR racism. I defended a 14 year old girl. There's a difference.

[@AirShay]

welp hello My apologies "welp hello" didn't seem like a username to me and it WAS my comment originally so... Thank YOU annnd BYE to you too.

[@AirShay]

welp hello Bless your heart. I can tell you're a little slow... Messylin commented on MY original comment. Go back and check if you're not sure. Smh

[@drsunshine1959]

Garland not only objected to blackface, she didn't care to perform swing music at all. At the time she said, "I'd rathed be singing opera, but they tell me that swing is where the money is." Dick Cavett once asked acclaimed Oscar winning actor Gale Sondergaard if she objected to making silly movies like "The Spider Woman". She told him she was under contract and she did what she was told to do. Under the studio system, actors were property.

[@denniskane1870]

Talented Actors and entertainers were money makers for the studios and themselves..

[@jjgeoffphhcinkkllee]

Preferring opera to swing is pretty racist. Then again, performing swing or blues as a white person is evil appropriation. You see where this goes? The white person is DEFINED so as to make being good impossible.

[@tiahnarodriguez3809]

@@denniskane1870 Mostly for the studios and their managers. Judy’s money mostly went to her mom and sisters, and MGM.

[@denniskane1870]

Yes that is what I wrote , themselves would be the family, particularly the parents. Child stars were not protected by law back then when Judy was in the line light. However the only thing judy probably cared about was the makeup session . Not the blackface. Black face is is makeup. Only liberal ,Democrat,woke cult idiots cry about blackface.

[@mimiadams247]

@@denniskane1870 Eh, they often never actually paid the actors, instead setting them up with room and board, then pocketed all the profits.

[@skaskeyoli7621]

I didn’t expect this to show up in my feed, but frankly I’m glad it did. Looking at the comments, I’ve learned a bit about Judy garlands life and legacy, the film industry, and some history of racist performances/ blackface. This is a horrifying display of racism and abuse- and being reminded of its existence (for me) is sobering and eye opening.

[@namenameson9065]

It's funny. The only thing horrifying about it is modern virtue signallers like you get to feel self-righteous for complaining about it on social media.

[@cg5617]

Oh yes, painting of the face. Ohhhh how horrifying! You know what's horrifying? Violent crime statistics. That's horrifying. This is mildly offensive.

[@cocodriloco7780]

@@namenameson9065 You're so mad about people being upset about racism. That's weird as fuck lmao

[@namenameson9065]

@@cocodriloco7780 I have simply recognized their Communist trick and call it out for what it is. People who are upset about racism typically aren't actually upset at all, nor is the accused even guilty of actual racism. It's all about Communist control. Typically the ones making the accusations are themselves perpetrating the offences in question, like Rabbi's spray-painting swastika's on their own synagogues. It's an evil trick. It's also evil to judge history by modern standards without the proper context which is what's going on in this comment section. But that's how these Communist tyrants operate. Be careful! Don't let yourself be used!

[@jamessalllen0097]

@cocodriloco7780 Look at this NPC. Mad cause they got called out on their BS. Lmao Chill.

[@TheNerdReich]

I seriously wonder if they knew how bad down the line this would probably look Like at a certain point this has to feel weird and just evil

[@mingdiao5199]

You know there's like a least 50 ppl or even more involved in the production of this clip before it was released into the public view，yet no one said a word

[@TheTurkaderr]

It's a relief to be able to visibly tell that Garland is miserable doing this and was under contract and didn't want to. There were actresses back then that would have done this and more to get noticed, but Garland clearly didn't need to or want to. Poor thing.All they did to her, is it any wonder she ended up the way she did. Bless you Judy.

[@BLTKellys]

Oh please she did blackface again singing FDR Jones. You white gays are always looking for excuses!

[@cheaserceaser]

What a beautiful song. I like her makeup.

[@user-et9mc6gv3y]

​@@cheaserceaser racist much? Why would you like this

[@cheaserceaser]

@@user-et9mc6gv3y I don't see anything racis' here. It was normal to do black face in the 1930s (e.g. speak-easy bars and venues).

[@lisatm4914]

@@cheaserceaser doing black face is literally racist..

[@ricperez3367]

I love Judy Garland and her legacy. I thought I knew it all about her...I didn't know about this performance.

[@Mwsicsntn]

She was sadly forced to do its and she was 14 that’s so sad

[@valuecalc]

Ric, it wasn't the end of the world.

[@ricperez3367]

@@valuecalc you are right...after all she was an actress too...

[@valuecalc]

@@ricperez3367, yes. It's entertainment.

[@AcidicMentality]

@Wowo Bawowo It's very entertaining and hilarious to boot. I think we need to follow Trudeau's lead and bring back Minstrel Shows.

[@deborahkelly2206]

😢Discussing. I am 74 and I remember this BS. I would cringe then, and I cringe now!!! This country is being eaten by racism at this very moment. I pray that this place has changed, but has it!!!!

[@-carly-]

It wasn’t her fault she had to do this. This poor girl was forced into doing stuff like this. She was treated like an actual marionette puppet, unable to break free from the “strings”. This is truly disgusting. The Hollywood industry did terrible things to her. Her phenomenal voice combined with the horror visuals has left me with something I feel ambivalent about.

[@CattMofu]

How could they do this to her.

[@-carly-]

@@CattMofu that’s what I thought. Truly disgusting.

[@chickensprint]

@@CattMofu It was normal for the time, stop trying to overlay modern societal values on the past, she did it because blackface wasn't out of the ordinary.

[@CattMofu]

@@chickensprint oh ok

[@eliciaellis7428]

@@chickensprint Normal for that time,but not normal for the spirit.

[@viviandelgado5614]

Who also came from "This is America"?

[@melvram]

wierdo girl meeee

[@Guest-gi1rc]

wierdo girl me😂

[@catterinaraffo3496]

idk it hoow does it relate to the song ? hehe sorry i need help

[@samsosa9923]

ME LMAOO

[@samiyahal-amin29]

wierdo girl me

[@MuzikFreak161]

To the people who have entertained “canceling” Judy, just look into her life in the industry. Especially her early life with MGM. That little girl didn’t even have any type of autonomy over what she did with her own body. They forced her to take hard drugs to keep up with a sleep depriving schedule so she could perform how they wanted her to. You think she had a choice in playing this park? Blame the disgusting directors, producers, and writers for this who thought that this was a brilliant isea

[@Maw0]

Luckily, I haven't seen anyone "cancel" her yet.

[@E.Niggma]

So they forced her to wear blackface? DAMN

[@ttdanimations1231]

nobody is canceling judy garland, she died half a century ago. you’re fighting invisible enemies dawg

[@Minina_7431]

@@ttdanimations1231, Look at the responses in the comments, there are many people who blame Judy for her "choice" to act there.

[@meek__1522]

To be honest all I think about was how my family felt back in the day.When black face was introduced.All I could say is that I’m black and I will always be proud of that.

[@HaveAniceDay2450]

😂😂😂

[@Red-yb8qp]

Lmao

[@nicolaverma3868]

You know you want to be angry at anyone for racism look to the governments ,we were fine in our tribes before they came along ,well everything was fine ,we looked after everyone, the land ,visitors from other tribes and nations,look around today see the state of everything, poverty,sickness,racism,pollutants especially our seas we always looked after everything and everyone, now we under rule look at the damage to our planet,the violence, depression need I go on . And are not things supposed to be better under a government I would say it very scary at the times we live in. When you listion to people who have been traumatized by governments who declared war,stripped people of their culture threw them into towns and cities and make us function this ridiculous way of life ,who is to blame?,people are realising and moving back into nature away from governments who in my opinion have caused all the damage. No one is happy well those under a government ,and they force their unjust way of life on us. When I heard that once governments brought over Africans into America they had a water fountain that said blacks and whotes WHATON EARTH,blacks was not allowed to drink from the white man's fountain, how disgraceful and quite shocking to me ,we are all God's creatures . I feel for everyone over the centuries for how badly they have been treated as they are all God's creatures equal whether a human,a fly a forest a stream even a speck of dust as this was all created all has a use and all must be respected. Alot of people are forced to do what they don't want to do and we give them backlash ,that is making a mockery of Judy and insulting her as a human being. No one would want to be part of that and I bet even she had nightmares I feel sick watching it ,it is the first and last time for me. There is so much we do against our will,or we are repressed ,not even being able to speak our minds without being made to believe even our thoughts are wrong. I'm fed up with the world and it has got to the stage rich or poor this is now a very depressing planet to live on ,God created a happy human,a beautiful planet,enough for every man's need not his greed. I know all this for fact I'm a shaman and see how we functioned before a rule ,and I will not be repressed I will say it how it is I will not be silenced like everyone else ,I would be willing to be thrown in jail for speaking up ,about time everyone said enough is enough, many can see we just spiraling downwards no way out ,you all need to make your lives better ,you don't need to be ruled and keep putting up with the madness around you ,do you not see where it is leading,those gone back into nature ate so happy ,spiritually fulfilled ,stress free ,different people who are no longer lost.

[@CashelOConnolly]

@@nicolaverma3868 as a gay guy,whom I know your ancestors treated equally I stand with you ✊🏳️‍🌈

[@CashelOConnolly]

@@nicolaverma3868 amazingly beautiful comment thank you From Dublin 💚

[@youforget1000thingsaday]

Judy did NOT wanna do this and you can tell.

[@ceeceetracey9839]

she shouldnt have done it then

[@uoohknk6881]

And those Manson girls didnt want to rip out that baby, devil made them do it

[@shadowsoulless6227]

​@@ceeceetracey9839 kind of hard to say no whenever there are a bunch of men coercing you telling that you have to do that that you're under a contract and that they will do horrible things to you and your family if you don't comply, then they drug you up and abuse you. I think in that situation a lot of 14-year-olds would go along with it because from what I've found out she was around 14 in this performance that are 16. You go back in time to that social era Be a 16 or 14-year-old girl And get the same treatment as her and see what you do

[@ceeceetracey9839]

@@shadowsoulless6227 I’m not co-signing your words or her actions on the strength of this era being a terrible time. It was a terrible time for Black Americans as well and this didn’t help and still doesn’t.

[@youforget1000thingsaday]

@@ceeceetracey9839 I believe she was a kid here. Not sure.

[@shaniahudson2513]

Ok for the people who don’t know Judy garland was forced to do this so do not attack her

[@coalyboi7939]

Yes have you seen? They litrally had a rpg to her head behind the camera. What a disgrace...

[@Sueuhevffbcjjidis]

isn't she dead?

[@raybenitez9699]

@Ligma Balls playing the racist card? This is the whole deck. Racist.

[@eyelandgyal1951]

I don’t give a shit. I don’t like my race being made fun of so I can be upset if I want to

[@eyelandgyal1951]

@Ligma Balls *someone does blackface* *someone doesn’t like blackface* You: GROW UP

[@custommusic2433]

00:56 those dudes were in Reefer Madness! 😂 I came across this video by typing in Turkey in the straw, what a trip!

[@filthforce]

yeah this is a top result for "wicked witch" for some reason.... which is the moniker of some goofball Scientologist "celebrity" whose KZbin account i'm trying to find

[@fmmaj9noname332]

I can never unsee this. The disparity between the the auditory beauty and the visual horror is literally breathtaking.

[@alliwishis_2]

My first thoughts exactly👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍🔥

[@rickyrayrosenberg420]

You folks have been brainwashed. You have been trained by propaganda to think something everyone of all races didn't care about at the time is a HUGE deal. When in reality - it was a media fad being done by people in an industry that was filled with degenerates, drunks, addicts, pedophiles, rapists and power hungry goons. LOL - and the makeup has you pressed.

[@TheAutumnWind_RN4L]

Guess we're not in Kansas anymore.

[@1godonlyone119]

She's still beautiful, even when she's wearing democrat makeup.

[@westerngroovetv]

as a black person im kinda distraught. 😂😂 but my God she straight up sangin' that shit.

[@LC-tg3rt]

No words. Jaw wide open every time I see this.

[@Death_By_Rebirth]

A novel method of date rape... I approve.

[@Person-tj2sw]

@@JakeKoenig how is it awesome

[@antonellapuchi9086]

@@JakeKoenig It’s not awesome, its an exploited young girl being forced to do something extremely racist :(

[@JohnnyBGood11]

You keep coming back to say that?...leave and never watch again

[@JohnnyBGood11]

@@antonellapuchi9086 It's not racist is it racist when black people say the n word all the time?

[@beechristy7033]

This certainly isn’t the “Black National Anthem!” and it sure does nothing for Judy Garland’s character! It shows how acceptable this image of black people was among white America! It wasn’t okay then and although black people have surpassed the sting of kinda this ignorance, it’s still unacceptable! The Black anthem is a beautiful song born out of pain and despair. “LIFT EVERY VOICE AND SING” is picking up momentum once again and I’m proud to see it!

[@txzombie8282]

@@fukgoogle4912 LMFAO 🤣👍

[@TheGreatResist]

I love it.

[@stevejarrettnc]

Judy has NOTHING to do with it, other than, “Do as you’re told.” She was not a big star at this point. Either do it, or we’ll find someone who will.

[@reginaldforthright805]

What’s the problem with it? Lighten up

[@reginaldforthright805]

@Cheap Coffee oh sure, kid, where you come from was always perfect. The moon, I’m guessing

[@BaronAmerican]

Is this a Wizard of Oz outtake?

[@Vixx89]

Lmfao😂😂😂

[@SeeburgMusic]

yes it is

[@AdamBechtol]

:p

[@RafflesProductions]

😂😂😂

[@cyberpunkin742]

wizard of bet

[@charlespetersonsheppard6551]

I think the most poignant part is the line “Listen here you won’t let me speak…” Tellingly, she sounds remarkably sincere there, imo.

[@Fireglo]

Kay...

[@RE-nv4we]

That's a lot of reaching, she was a kid and wasn't thinking that far, nor being political about something that was clearly widely accepted.

[@pagantalks5993]

I agree.

[@lauren578]

​@@pagantalks5993 Of course you do Cletus😉

[@Brakathor]

Judy Garland was a vapid bimbo, and that's ok. People need to stop trying to bend her into their own ideas of reality and social conscience.

[@glowgirl8171]

Holy cow imagine my surprise when I stumbled over this ! Poor Judy. Her breasts were strapped for The Wizard of Oz ,she was put on speed to lose weight, and who knows what else happened to her. Such a sweet woman. I always loved her. R.I.P. Judy . You're a shining star.

[@precioussweet636]

Lmao you gotta do better

[@glowgirl8171]

@@precioussweet636 ?

[@Malchus13]

She was likely on speed for this as well.. ive seen those kind of eyes before. (Im an ex addict)

[@ArchibaldBagge]

True. She was known as Speedy Strapped Tits around the MGM studio.

[@ayeshak6822]

I love how all the empathy is aimed at Judy Garland and not the people damaged by this disgusting depiction. ;)

[@Slept-on-one]

Thank you KZbin for still allowing it to air and not being a dick

[@gLu3r]

Yeah , I can't get this out of my head it's actually catchy lol .

[@jyt74]

Thank god there are so many recordings available to us of Judy Garland's talent, so that we don't have to depend on this nastiness to enjoy it. This clip can be our way into learning about and improving upon what America was like at that time. So much other Garland media is here for us so that we can just swoon over a person (a child!) having her level of talent.

[@reginaldforthright805]

Nothing wrong with this, move along son

[@jamalamapoo]

@@reginaldforthright805 nothing wrong w blackface? Lol

[@Rising_Steel]

@@jamalamapoo Nothing wrong with an old fashioned comedic depiction of black face. If you get upset about a joke that’s your oversensitivity problem you should deal with. Go watch white chicks and laugh at the black men wearing white face.

[@MECHACOMICS]

@@Rising_Steel There’s a difference between a joke and a racist one that is supposed to hurt a particular race Make fun of them

[@slightlypeevedpossom8510]

@@Rising_Steel except white people weren't enslaved or segregated against or lynched? do you actually not see the difference here?

[@mogmason6920]

“Mom, can I get The Wiz?” Mom: “We have The Wiz at home” The Wiz at home:

[@summerbunbury3391]

HA niiiiiice🤣

[@doiknowyou.]

💀💀

[@jayowen5824]

lmao

[@rommix0]

Oof. The racist version of the Wiz. It sucks because Michael Jackson isn't in it to balance it out lol.

[@suckedintothevoid]

I'm glad that this piece of history was shared - I had no idea Judy Garland was contractually forced into performing in blackface during her career. Acknowledging and learning from our nation's past (speaking as someone from the US) is the only way to move forward toward equity and inclusion. I hope that we reach that goal in my lifetime.

[@tiahnarodriguez3809]

Lots of across and actresses were against black face, but were forced to do it by their companies. An actress of the same generation as Judy was forced to do black face for an advertisement, but when interviewed about it, she said she did not want to do it and wished she stuck to her fine about not doing it. An actor of an earlier generation said the same thing about a part he did in a movie.

[@johnboy992]

We already have reached that lol there just people that wine about things they don't have and blame it on racial inequality name one thing a black or brown person can't do in America?? As a brown Dude there's nothing I can't do even if people like u say there is

[@awh5963]

Guarantee he loved every minute of it, I don't believe for once second he didnt want to do it.

[@WindDancer435]

Yes, I agree. I find this shocking and very offensive. I don't believe Judy was a racist though. Just the song and costume and makeup is horrendous.

[@rayyanez3527]

Oh ! Come on !!🙄 Everybody !.. Just !.. RELAX !!!!! At that time !!! It was Not ! Looked at !. The Same way !.. WE Do Nowadays !!!!;

[@libertas_americana]

Sure it’s racist and sure she went through hell… but you got to admit Judy Garland killed it in this song.

[@MagnusN-hh1gh]

Ikr she ate this up

[@AlanaeImontae]

That part.

[@Bagawould]

You're sick man

[@markboyce6950]

Truth. It's an amazing performance.

[@kdw75]

How is this racist????

[@igobyrell]

You can just obviously tell by how she's performing and the look in her eyes that she was most definitely against doing this whole thing and understandably so too. Something like this happen today on TV or a movie, ion think it would slide at all.

[@ninjacrumbs]

Really? You can judge that by watching an actor`s eyes acting? To me it just seems you are echoing what most of the comments purport to know. If by "happening today" you mean in the last couple of decades, yeah, I can truly believe it would slide ie. Jimmy Kimmel; Jimmy Fallon; Justin Trudeau, and more....

[@johnpauljones9310]

@@ninjacrumbs She was 15 or 16 when this was filmed and the studio was drugging her out of her mind. At 17, she was addicted to barbiturates and amphetamines. Look it up yourself. Her studio handlers and mother should have all gone to prison for child abuse.

[@LovelyroseZz]

@@johnpauljones9310 she deserves it

[@sknight8621]

@@ninjacrumbs plus Trump supporters would probably vote for anyone that did something like this lol

[@MsMrFlintStone]

Lol, you got all that from the look in her eyes? Something tells me you imagined all that to validate why what she did doesn’t really bother you.

[@marysabamennuti6303]

After many research for my studies I can claim that this is not the Black American National Anthem but the song Swing Low, Sweet Chariot which is an American black spiritual song written in 1880s

[@AaronGarton666]

Correct. "Lift Every Voice and Sing" is a song that is often referred to as an unofficial "Black American National Anthem"

[@karinalombrozo3257]

We know

[@javlopez1889]

The song is catchy hinestky

[@tonyperez2204]

lol and you research this lol

[@weso2103]

Oh!! Thank you lol

[@artetface]

I am so glad this was documented. If it wasn’t people would do more than make excuses for why it happened. They would just say that it didn’t.

[@LesserMoffHootkins]

Tote dat barge, lif’ dat bale!

[@MeiClover]

@@LesserMoffHootkins edgy

[@mikefitz6957]

Sniff sniff....pttttt!

[@futuresick100]

They're definitely trying.

[@unapprovedtruth7116]

It's a rich Jewish thang, y'all wouldn't undastand

[@SpoopyBoy]

Why are there so many dislikes?

[@CIAOFFlCAL]

colored people

[@SpoopyBoy]

@@CIAOFFlCAL Ah I see. Yeah they'll be like that

[@queenofhearts7503]

People who hate racism and seeing little girls beings exploited? That’s why

[@phoebevaughan5095]

Judy was forced into this - poor girl had no control over her life since others took that from her RIP Judy

[@savinghistory642]

this reminds me of when i was 7 and jimmy carter was president. we lived in a duplex that shared a porch with the unit next door. they had a little girl not yet 18 months old. they taught her that her diaper was a pocketbook and they would sneak up behind her and put wet leaves down the front of her diaper and tell her jimmy carter did it. she would scream STOP JIMMY CARTER and rip her diaper off then they would laugh hysterically. they did it until she was exhausted from screaming. then they taught her to cuss. they told her that as long as she danced jimmy carter would not come and get her. she danced on that front porch all the time. they told her if she would cuss jimmy carter from the porch he would not come and get her. she spent so much time holding onto the bars of the porch railing like she was in jail and cussing jimmy carter as loudly as she could. the neighbors all hated her. the year they told her jimmy carter not santa was bringing the presents she went to bed crying and saying she did not want anything. it got to where if you just said his name she would start screaming and run hide in the bushes. it was a long 4 years for her.

[@savinghistory642]

how is this different from a p diddy party

[@Mtl_boi]

We should all forgive her cuz at that time she was abused by producers by giving her drugs etc

[@LL-bl8hd]

Remember that Judy had no choice in what roles she took. She was a child when this was filmed and in those days actors were under contract with a single studio. She did whatever they told her or she would have never worked in Hollywood again.

[@imsleepingbeauty]

She was such a great performer ❤

[@DcardenasPodcast]

Her voice was amazing but everything else is terrifying

[@MeadeSkeltonMusic]

Not really

[@MakkoriBusto]

Her hair and makeup was totally spot on. Very believable in this era. I see them at night tryna take my bike.

[@JadeAkelaONeal]

That is the right word. This is SO FUCKING terrifying. Horrifying, creepy, scary... And racist. Obvi.

[@MakkoriBusto]

She stole my bike

[@JadeAkelaONeal]

@Randy marsh no it was definitely racist. They wore black paint to deny black People opportunities in theater. That is racist. There is no misunderstanding but yours

[@elysewaller598]

Our American history is so sad and ignorant and eventhough a great deal has changed, there's still so much more that needs to be done

[@bonbuttbonniefnaf9306]

Jasmine Waller preach gurl✊✊✊

[@TheCondescendingRedditor]

How? This is great!

[@TheCondescendingRedditor]

@smadge100 Don't bother, she doesn't understand. She is self centered and only cares about her own "issues"

[@chrisbennett606]

smadge100 yeah it was fucked up Adolf

[@Death_By_Rebirth]

@@chrisbennett606 Man, you know a lot of guys named Adolf, don't you?

[@sissysovereign1294]

Dear god anybody else find the blackface really creepy looking and unsettling?😰😰😰😰

[@SimpsonDG]

I think EVERYBODY finds it so. This "entertainment" belongs to another era.

[@hueyiroquois3839]

I thought it was pretty funny considering the NFL's recent decision.

[@TheRetardedbackpack]

Yes looks demonic

[@fuzzyunicorns8294]

Huey Iroquois blackface is funny now? Black most black people didn’t even ask for this. We just want stop racial injustice

[@hisbeautifultruth5931]

@@hueyiroquois3839 You do know this was BEFORE the NFL, right?

[@timothyjohnson5699]

Oh my word... Even the tongue is painted. That's got to be the most disturbing makeup I've ever seen. The only reason- *the only reason* for this I think is because the makers of this film wanted to experiment -weird- interesting ideas to incorporate into black and white footage to grab attention. A black woman wearing long white socks, a white dress, and for whatever reason, white bows sprawled all over her head and *white paint over her mouth.* It's just freaky!

[@onlinefriend3889]

I think the comment section is split between "this is racist", "this is breathtaking" and "this is heartbreaking"

[@cruella4341]

It’s all of those things. But it’s not the good kind of breathtaking, it’s more like “Fucking Christ this is a horrifying part of history”

[@christofl6523]

@@cruella4341 Really? It was a better time then than now.

[@np4511]

@@christofl6523 you've GOT to be joking.

[@christofl6523]

@@np4511 Not at all.

[@baconmmm9327]

Isn’t that the Prime Minister of Canada?

[@kluge1245]

This is from 1938. And the song is called "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot" from the movie Everybody Sing.

[@collegeguy799]

It’s crazy that it hasn’t even been 100 years.

[@SeeburgMusic]

@@collegeguy799 whys that?

[@collegeguy799]

@@SeeburgMusic ummm because this is the type of entertainment people watched not even a century ago. Do you turn on the tv and watch this on a regular basis?

[@oliverclosehoff8036]

I think judy garland wore black face much better then Canadian pm trudeau did

[@zmmmmkm]

You would find this disgusting shyt cute.🤬🤬🤬

[@chrishasyourkeys2808]

😂

[@alona1351]

Justin Trudeau is a versatile leader.

[@ramen1k]

This is an underappreciated comment

[@AntiFakeJewsRev2-9-0Zach9-6]

😁

[@tonywebb1403]

Well done are you sure this isn't the governor of Virginia

[@MichaelJ44]

She has more testosterone than Justina

[@The_Greipist]

@@tonywebb1403 Could be, well...not anymore, lol

[@nunyabuissness8058]

Out of any celebrity I always recognize Judy garlands voice

[@ertavampy4622]

Its the mic.

[@Randy-ry9ss]

Michael Clark Duncan has a voice you could pick out of a crowd.

[@jjgeoffphhcinkkllee]

Even when she's "N"-ing up her dialect?

[@hueyiroquois3839]

I'm here because of the Hodge Twins.

[@fmart3617]

Me too

[@elh3fe88]

I actually landed here randomly but i watch all things hodgetwins. I must have missed this one though. I'm off to watch that video now lol.

[@hueyiroquois3839]

@@elh3fe88 They didn't specifically mention this, but I found it after watching their video about the "Black National Anthem".

[@roccot31]

Me too lol

[@charlotteprocter4887]

Same!

[@ashtonwinter1616]

This just goes to show you how ruthless people can force an artist into something that they don’t want to do and it shows how propaganda is used to try to portray a lie. My family lineage and ethnicity is Native American Cherokee, Scandinavian Norwegian, and Ethiopian African. Also part of my family is from the American South, Respectfully All Women, but to emphasize that Black American Women Are Intelligent, Graceful, Beautiful, Talented, and The Truth Is We Are All Made Equally.

[@lsubandtrumpet2014]

This isn't the Black National Anthem. The Black National Anthem is "Lift Every Voice"

[@Deport_All_nonWhites]

but they dont lift every voice, they just do White-erasure

[@mrlego611]

@@Deport_All_nonWhites White erasure doesn’t exist ❤

[@frogglen6350]

Wow. That is a good singing voice. Shame it's being used for this

[@thinkingallowed6485]

@Retard Lives Matter u r a caveman

[@jadegarza4857]

Nick Gamez well she was drugged and forced into this so uhh

[@Greenalexc]

This is some wild stuff here, I cant imagine Judy showing up to work that day, I’d be pounding booze and pills too,

[@lifeis2171]

Yall are so obsessed with us. Lol that yall dress uss up as uss. We live in yall head rent free

[@bsb3210]

Is this what conservatives mean by "the good ol' days"?

[@HaydenD1776]

No

[@TheVCRTimeMachine]

I'm not sure "cringe" is a strong enough word to describe the feeling I get watching this...

[@waffle8364]

I had no idea this was filmed. I can't imagine how frustrated she must have felt to do this. But she did it because she was forced to do it and she did it as best as she could. we've come a long way in such a short amount of time.

[@davidgerald133]

We look back through our sensibilities now and think they viewed it the same way.

[@KingpinTBM]

What makes you think she felt frustrated by doing it? She looks pretty cool with it to me. 🤮

[@felix_a_fiend]

@@KingpinTBM she was also a child in the 30’s, with little to no control of her own life.

[@peterwallis4288]

@@KingpinTBM because later in her life she was into the civil rights movement. Although we don't know what she thought at the time. But anyway, she's a child here, raised in a society where this was regarded as normal. Seeing she redeemed herself later, I don't see why this should be held against her.

[@lmss3309]

Stop giving excuses for being racist in those days…She was talented 16 years old actor in 30s. America was racist those days….. it is not her fault but she was a racist too… tho she redeemed herself in later days of her life

[@Cardsmaster]

What a piece of history…if you look at it for what it is and how the industry was at the time but the talent of Judy. It’s a lot to take in.

[@LinkRocks]

You also have to acknowledge the racism behind it, to no fault of Judy's. You can't ignore that because you enjoy her performance.

[@gregorybriscoe-hough6530]

Who ran Hollywood

[@AnastasiaBeaverhousn]

@@LinkRocks who's fault, she's the one on the stage!!! Damn when is racism EVER a white persons fault!!! 🤡🙄

[@erinbean344]

It never changed this is no different then any work in today's puppet show.

[@xpropriation8505]

@@gregorybriscoe-hough6530 Wealthy white men

[@kingsley9352]

It's amazing because in every other performance of hers she's as alive with her expressions and mannerisms as she is with her voice, and in this she seems completely disconnected and disinterested, and is simply doing the lines and choreography because she had to. Hollywood... what a mess.

[@no_peace]

I don't know anything about the background and what level of agency she had, she's not the only/main victim here anyway, but disclaimers aside the fact that her body seems like it's operating on its own without permission from her brain makes this clip even more upsetting

[@tiahnarodriguez3809]

@@no_peace She had zero agency. She was totally controlled by her mother and MGM. When she speaks in later interviews, she makes it clear that she never agreed with doing these things, but had to because she was under contract and her mom put immense pressure on her to support the family. She had a lot of sisters. They also were forced in show business by their mom, but Judy was the stand out star.

[@mimiadams247]

@@no_peace She was probably also drugged up to her eyeballs to get her to do it- still against her will.

[@emanueldelove8170]

​@Tiahna Rodriguez I hear a lot of sympathy for Judy who had to do this but I hear zero sympathy for black people who had to endure this. Maybe you intended to write a balanced comment but it didn't turn out that way

[@romellohodge6547]

I'm black and it's making me laugh and a bit pissed at the same time🤣🤬

[@cameron_fairchild]

I'm Black and don't blame her, it's weird and she's doing whatever they tell her. She's a kid in a big business run by powerful men, who back then were also racist!

[@bamboosho0t]

It doesn’t bother me, and I’m also Black. The only thing that does irritate me a bit are the comments attempting to sanitize this film. Context isn’t needed in a Minstrel performance. It was racism. End of story.

[@Hack_The_Planet_]

@@bamboosho0t it’s people like you that are the problem, context *IS* needed

[@TyeArtisik]

I watched with a straight face

[@bamboosho0t]

@@Hack_The_Planet_ That’s cute. Was that supposed to resemble a coherent thought?

[@harrycojones4273]

What a voice she had