The COMPLETE History of Edward the Blue Engine - Sodor's Finest

[@GTP2763]

When Gordon got retired from the express, he should’ve went back to the Sheds next to Edward and Edward said “so how does it feel to be such an old engine?” Gordon says nothing and smiles, frowns, and apologizes for all the years of putting him down. Edward accepts his apology. Both sit and reminiscent of the old days.

[@fanofeverything30465]

I like to think that happened off-page

[@saintsheepy6682]

Makes me wish Christopher put that as the last story in the last Railway Series book.

[@huntergauld5923]

Thinking about a scene like that makes me almost cry 🥹

[@jalenjackson740]

If only this would be amazing to see

[@22Tesla]

That would have been a sweet way to show Gordon's full arc from the newest thing in express passenger service to humbly bowing out as an old man, and Edward is there waiting for him to join his side.

[@comicfan1324]

Honestly, although Wilbert Awdry deserves most of the praise, (as he is the storyteller and writer of these books,) can we give a shout out to Christopher and Margaret? If Christopher wasn’t so willing to ask questions, or if Margaret didn’t push her husband to seek out a publisher for these stories, we probably would’ve never gotten the Railway Series nor the television series.

[@Thomasmemoryscentral]

In a weird way, Christopher’s measles is a blessing for him to ask his father for stories and that lead to him creating the plots for engines that became the railway series

[@comicfan1324]

@@Thomasmemoryscentral Agreed. If Christopher didn’t question things like “why is that engines sad?“ and just took it at face value that it was just a picture we would’ve never had the story of Edward the blue engine

[@fanofeverything30465]

@@Thomasmemoryscentral Christopher getting measles was a blessing in disguise

[@Jediah-s6p]

This comment makes me tear up and think of the current state of the show back in the Brenner era ttte was one of the most popular shows and now it's a cash grab

[@legoboy7107]

Yeah. Imagine if Christopher had never asked "Why is that engine sad?" What a different place we'd be in.

[@FabuVinny]

A protagonist doesn't need their own character arc if they have an impact on the characters around them. Edward's great. It just takes time for everyone to realise it.

[@AndriuV2]

*I just realized that Season 1 is now turning 4️⃣0️⃣ years old!* *(1984-2024)*

[@fanofeverything30465]

That's why he did a Sodor's Finest on the first character ever created

[@Thomasmemoryscentral]

Other things turning 40: 1. Twisted Sister’s We’re Not Gonna Take It 2. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3. Van Halens 1984 album 4. Usagi Yojimbo

[@s.p.d.magentaranger1822]

Also Transformers.

[@connerhills5665]

@@Thomasmemoryscentral Not to mention Pentrex, the finest in railroad entertainment... ;)

[@CaptainCat101]

Neat

[@LegendaryCaptain]

"You thought this was Thomas but it was me Edward, again" time to watch what will be a masterpiece. going to edit my thoughts after I watch this.

[@selinapersaud7629]

I don’t think there is any way in hell that he’ll ever touch Thomas. Lol I feel like he dislikes him far too much to deserve this kind of honor.

[@mrconagher]

​@@selinapersaud7629i dont think he hates thomas, he probably doesnt wanna do a sodors finest with him cause he thinks its a massive task to take on, as he stated in the henry sodors finest

[@LBSC_71]

Ok dio

[@truckercowboyed2638]

It was Edward all along....!!!

[@karenfan010]

@@selinapersaud7629 actually if you look at his sodors finest cover list thomas is on it meaning he’ll eventually have to give him his own sodors finest.

[@hannahbruno6236]

Edward is such a wise and caring character. He brings out the best in every engine.

[@danielparra6672]

I wasn’t expecting a remake on Edward but I’m not complaining. I really like the character Edward. Hope in the future soon, you will do a remake on Gordon too

[@rainierbagatsing1073]

I wasn't expecting a remake of Edward to, but the good thing is we get to see what version on what's his favorite version of Edward RWS, Model, or CGI

[@BrandonPaez-o5t]

I wasn't expecting a remake of the history of Edward too, but I wish that The Unlucky Tug could do a remake of The history of Gordon.

[@joshuaW5621]

Same here.

[@cheukyinglau8011]

Me too!

[@JAdg75oo00]

I actually felt like the original was too short so I had a hunch he would dable with this eventually 😄🚂

[@ATSF669]

The ending sequence with the Little Engine that could music put a big stupid smile on my face. This is easily the best Sodor’s Finest. I cannot wait for how Gordon’s remastered episode will turn out

[@thenvpshow7627]

Edward represents everything so real about the island of Sodor. The embodiment of never giving up no matter what is being thrown at you!

[@22Tesla]

I love the little bits you have between sections where you have the characters voice a scene. "Not.... appreciating... the commentary...!!" XD Honestly, if they REALLY wanted to have Edward be naive or dumb or "out of character" they should have just written a flashback episode! One where Edward tells a story to a troubled engine who's either misbehaving or misinformed, which takes place back when Edward was young and in his pre-sodor days. Doing that in the model series would have been difficult, but it would be easy in CGI

[@harold5337]

Edward is the glue that holds everything together. He may be quiet and appear not very often, but he doesn’t need to. He is the Merlin or Obi Wan of the line, the wise old man whom knows best. Edward is a fan favourite, for a great reason. One of my favourites

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

Edward was a more prominent main character than Toby and Duck in the classic series. But he was unfortunately not as prominent as Henry, Gordon, Percy, James and Thomas.

[@MegaKrayZay]

Edward: What you need is a Deputation. Percy: Edward says we need a Depot Station! Bruh

[@MarckbryanBalang]

That part made me laugh a little 😂

[@joshuaW5621]

The fact that people have a problem with Percy mispronouncing words in season 6 when this has been going on since season 2 is so mind boggling to me.

[@BringMayFlowers]

Gordon mishears him too so I just like to assume engines have horrible hearing and are only just guessing what they're hearing and generally get it right until it's something they don't know.

[@jmann6130]

@@joshuaW5621I think it’s the fact at first it’s established Percy has a small vocabulary but then it got flanderized to the point where Percy is basically a 4 year old!

[@thegermanofsodor]

You have no idea how big the smile on my face was when Nothing Can Stop Us Now played during Exploit's climax I had never imaged that song working so well for that scene, but given the whole moral for Little Engine That Could it just works too well! Massive props to Isaiah for the fantastic score!

[@ShukakuTheCrazy1]

I fully agree. I did a double take. The best rendition of the little engine that could. I could listen to just the musical score with no dialog all day

[@TheTrueRealTre]

I took a double take and was like "NO WAYY" the song was so fitting

[@ShukakuTheCrazy1]

@ethanschmid4104 I'll be a fan until I die. It's so good! I even found a copy on vhs at a garage sale a few years ago. Picked that up asap.

[@primrosevale1995]

I really hope Isiah uploads that song somewhere.

[@ShukakuTheCrazy1]

@@primrosevale1995 who

[@thegreensaddletank1636]

DID I JUST HEAR NOTHING CAN STOP US NOW FROM THE LITTLE ENGINE THAT COULD????

[@3xfaster]

Oh absolutely, it just hit me so hard I wept whenI recognized it!

[@3xfaster]

Oh absolutely, it just hit me so hard I wept whenI recognized it!

[@josephsoczka3757]

100%! Was one of my most treasured vhs tapes back in the day.

[@fanofeverything30465]

​@@3xfasterDid you mean to post this comment twice

[@Steamenginesunited3456]

Tom Marshall's narration is always spot on. He's a natural

[@joshuaW5621]

Tom Marshall should definitely narrate Thomas in it’s revival era.

[@kevin-2.1]

I feel like Kyle Dennison voice was on the trampy channel when he was voicing James. Maybe is was the actual voice actor who played James on trampy?

[@kevin-2.1]

Wait Kyle is the voice of James! 😃

[@雪者]

The small bits inbetween this epsiode were just.. WOW. This felt like Thomas & Friends if it was in the TUGS style episodes.

[@supermariof0521]

TUG: What does Edward have against cranes? EDWARD: BECAUSE CRANES KILLED MY GRANDMA, OKAY?!

[@LukeOfSodor22]

BECAUSE A CRANE KILLED ALBERT, OKAY?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@supermariof0521]

@@LukeOfSodor22 LOL

[@fanofeverything30465]

​​@@LukeOfSodor22BECAUSE A CRANE TRIED TO KILL ME, OKAY?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@NitroIndigo]

"BIG MICKEY!"

[@joshuaW5621]

As someone who recently lost his grandma, this meme hits differently for me at this time.

[@ChiknNuggs_EditZ]

"Babe wake up, a new Sodors Finest just dropped"

[@fanofeverything30465]

OK honey

[@SmudgerStudiosYT]

Bro I was so happy when it dropped

[@aaronthekidofficial9912]

MOM! DAD! CAN I WATCH THE NEW SODOR'S FINEST??? iT'S ABOUT EDWARD AGAIN!

[@dripthanos7068]

​@@aaronthekidofficial9912 NOT WITHOUT US KID IM BRINGING HOTDOGS

[@aaronthekidofficial9912]

WOOOOO!!! I'M GONNA INVITE MY FRIENDS!

[@supermariof0521]

You know what would've been nice? What if "Edward The Very Useful Engine" went like this. Edward begins clanking after helping Gordon, and while Gordon is greatful, he's worried that Edward could actually be breaking down and possibly be sent for scrap, and Gordon doesn't want that to happen since he's come to really respect him. Gordon goes to see Edward at the works, and Edward assures him that he just needed repairs, and Gordon apologizes for all the times he was rude to him in the past. Then when Gordon sees Duck stuck on his hill, Gordon decides to honor Edward by being Duck's back engine. But the rails were very slippery and just when all hope is lost, Edward arrives to help Gordon and as Edward chants "We can it! We can do it! We can do it!", Gordon chants "We WILL do it! We WILL do it! We WILL do it!" as a sorta nod to "Edward and Gordon".

[@dylanlyles9453]

That would be way better!

[@supermariof0521]

@@dylanlyles9453 IKR?

[@jordenfilmz]

So much better!!!

[@supermariof0521]

@@jordenfilmz IKR?

[@jordenfilmz]

@@supermariof0521 Yes, I also had another idea for a story, and that's "Saving Edward". Instead of it being an Edward mopes around and thinks he'll be scrapped all because he's clanking and wheezing story, I instead turned it around. I would make it a Bill and Ben story, instead of Edward thinking he'll be scrapped, they would think that he would be scrapped over mishearing Edward himself, like Edward would be talking to Topham or something and they mishear him. They would worry but try their best to make sure Edward doesn't get the cutter's torch, which would lead into them getting into an accident and Edward coming to their rescue. Edward asks them why they were acting weird and Bill and Ben fess up, only for Edward to laugh and tell them what he really said. Only for them to be silly for thinking something of the sort and to argue with each other at the end for their own doings. Now, I know this sounds like "Percy's Big Mistake", but I feel this would be more appropriate for Bill and Ben's character because they're both young and naive. Yeah, I know Edward would be sidelined but at least he wouldn't be out of character.

[@Randomstuffs261]

Our fearless leader, Lord Tug has bequeathed unto us, his loyal subjects. A gift of unparalleled proportions - An Edward episode of Sodor's finest. For which we are eternally grateful!

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

An Edward remake of epic proportions

[@Invincible_Ages]

Most indubitably, here here.

[@Louie-WanKenobi-og4rk]

The original one was good, but man, this is better!

[@GibberishDraw]

Here, Here

[@SPANISH_INQUISITION589]

It's a very nice (monty python reference)

[@khdayskh1314]

The voice casting for the engines in the beginning were EXCELLENT. Immersion levels 1000%

[@christov7789]

Gordon's lines at 48: 38 are so raw and well delivered it caught me off guard, to the point o nearly sprayed water over my keyboard. Its just such a realistic line yet also go right along with your commentary on Edward so far that it feels too real. So you did a fantastic job in that case.

[@slowturtle11fan]

48:38

[@christov7789]

@@slowturtle11fan Thank you, I appreciate that!

[@tylerkane1238]

the outro with Edwards exploit, Unlucky Tug, what you did, you plucked my hearts strings as in the background “Nothing can stop us now” from the Little Engine that Could… my all time FAVORITE MOVIE and by far, my version of Edward and by far, a suitible fanfare for Edward in this scenario

[@tylerkane1238]

When I found out that you were doing Edward, I’m glad actually as the first two videos with Edward and Gordon, they were more of the pioneer that started this series and consider them your take as to who is truly the main character of the series and who is your favorite. As for this episode, love your take for Edward’s day out and Edward’s exploit, going so far and above compared to the previous episodes, with reasons too. I will admit that your take to Edward’s triumph scene, my emotional dam burst, shedding tears as that episode by far is my favorite for season 2 and your version 2.0, you outdid the original and your first take. As for the ending, GOD I LOVE CHEEKY THOMAS, being the instigator, pushing Gordon to apologize. I can’t tell you how many times I replayed the ending. I know these episodes takes time, but I look forward to the next episode, and hopefully, it will be Gordon. Well done Unlucky Tug…

[@Dwurban64]

The use of the theme from The Little Engine That Could was absolutely perfect for Edward's triumph, it gave me chills. One of your best and most well produced videos Tug, a grand and fitting showcase of work for the character who started it all

[@chillhilld]

Legit stopped what I was doing just to rewind and listen again, and wouldn’t ya know I end up crying. So unexpected, so close to my heart…

[@sappymy]

Thomas 0 Sodor finest Edward 2 Sodor finest

[@Poppy-z2g]

Edward is js better

[@allison122477]

@@Poppy-z2g true true

[@buddy0571]

Goat things

[@DeathValley1103]

We need Thomas to have one, and maybe an MVP.

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

@@DeathValley1103He got an MVP alright. 11 Seasons in, he finally got one.

[@napsbrickrailways2290]

This is without a doubt the best sodor’s finest yet. It really feels like a triumph, not just Edward’s history but for the project as a whole. Absolute perfection.

[@Disspam777]

I see the relationship of Edward and Gordon in the Railway Series is kind of like Doc and Lightning McQueen. Doc basically foreshadowed what will eventually will happen to McQueen in Cars 3

[@joshuaW5621]

I get that feeling from them. I also think the King could also be a counterpart to Edward in Gordon’s journey as well seeing as he was the old veteran when the new guy who is the protagonist comes in.

[@ink_blot25]

Edward is that comfort character. He may not show up much, but you always feel that warmth and comfort when he is around. Plus, whenever there's any kind of debate between the characters and Edward shows up, it always gives a sense of "Oh thank goodness Edward is here. He'll set things right!"

[@MaraKleiber]

Ever since I was a child, Edward has always been my favorite engine. His character has a unique personality that has always captivated me and I've always admired his good intentions and his willingness to help others. And as an adult, he is still a true example of kindness for me. Thanks for the video.

[@SgtAJ218]

Honestly, when I was a kid I never really cared for Edward since he barely appeared in the Classic Era. However, after reading the Railway Series and watching all of the Classic Era on Prime Video, Edward has really grown on me and he's now actually become one of my favorite characters in the show. And I can definitely see why he is Unlucky Tug's favorite character in Thomas & Friends.

[@giulianodervelociraptorder734]

If I'm honest for myself CGI Edward is the best version of Edward. Simply because he represents what a stepfather is all about. One thing I love about the CGI era is that the dynamic between Thomas and Edward has a lot more time to shine than in the Model or RWS era. In TAB, Edward took good care of Thomas as if he were his son. He supported him and was always on his side and gave him advice. In the episode "Old reliable Edward" that wheel turned a bit. In this episode, Thomas shows how important Edward is to him. When Gordon insulted Edward, Thomas thought, "You know what? You helped me back then, now I'll help you!" I always think that the episode before the Miller era would explain why Gordon is mean to Edward in the episode, but not in S13-S16. The Miller era also had some good moments between the two. In HOTR Edward defended (with Gordon and James) against Spencer. And he was also the first to notice that Thomas had something on his mind. In the questionable S13 episode where Thomas chases a dragon, Edward supported him. When Phillip goes to Sodor is similar to Thomas in TAB. Phillip is supposed to show that Thomas can stand on his own without Edward and from then on Edward is also a stepfather to Phillip. And in S21 Thomas says goodbye to his stepfather. CGI Edward represents what a stepfather is all about and why CGI Edward is (imo) peak Edward.

[@jeremiahsisaias8677]

Which S13 episode are you talking about? "Old reliable Edward" is Edward's along with Thomas' epic Chad episode to me. ;) Totally satisfying to see Thomas putting Gordon in his place for being an ungrateful prick to Edward by leaving him stuck on his hill again and having Edward leave him there to die.

[@giulianodervelociraptorder734]

​@@jeremiahsisaias8677Sorry for the late message. "Thomas and the Runaway Kate" was the episode I was referring to.

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

The episode A shed for Edward genuinely makes me wish that Percy was female instead of male (but still have her be named Percy and have her look and sound identical to her male counterpart in every single way) so Edward doesn’t get written off in season 21 since he would’ve been the 5th boy instead of the 6th. This would’ve been all of Edward’s episodes in the Brenner era if Percy was female. 1. No more Mr. nice engine (The roles of Hiro and Edward reversed and the episode retitled as Edward’s sticky spill) (season 17) 2. Old reliable Edward (Gordon swapped out with Spencer) (season 18) 3. Edward, Henry and the spots (A rewritten version of Henry’s spots trouble) (season 19) 4. Rocky Rescue (Thomas swapped out with Edward) (season 19) 5. 3 blue engines gruff (season 20) (Edward taking Thomas’s role as the voice of reason and Edward does not get frightened along with Toby swapped out with Gordon and Percy swapped out with Thomas) 6. Dowager Hatt’s busy day (if Duck stays a main character throughout the Hit, Miller, and Brenner eras) (season 21) 7. Edward In The Middle (if Duck stays a main character throughout the Hit, Miller, and Brenner eras) (season 21) 8. P.A Problems (season 21)

[@maddtoonerthegreencup1436]

I was So Not Expecting Edward's SF to be Remade!! But Holy Hell is This such an Amazing Step up from his First Video from Years ago!! Edward is so definitely a Sodor's Finest and that Introduction was just Magical!! 13/10 Nic!!

[@Disgruntledcoach]

The unlucky tug: age is just a number Me: mate. You could've chosen some different words.

[@fanofeverything30465]

@@Matts_Conrail_Chicago_Mainline What does that have to do with it

[@osprey_06]

not the smartest thing to have a clip of him saying that lol

[@ThomasTheorist]

Really loved what you said about Edward and Philip in ASFE. The way Edward was written in TAB was perfect, and Philip acted as like a parallel to Thomas in that movie (see 54:39) so putting them together at wellsworth made perfect sence. I only wish they got something to do in Philips/Edwards episodes in S22. Honestly wish ASFE had Bill and Ben in place of Philip, since it would've called back to S2/S3/RWS, and would've payed off with Hunt the Truck in S22. Anyway, great video!

[@rodemus18]

Tug, thank you for using “nothing can stop us now!” The little engine that could from the 90s was one of my favorite films as a kid, and it was used very appropriately and in a great moment! You sir are magnificent!

[@robertrowley4929]

I wasn’t expecting an Edward remake; but knowing Tug, it’s going to be a full blown masterpiece.

[@SmudgerStudiosYT]

Hell yeah

[@shinobipizza]

I still firmly believe that in Edward Strikes Out, "Edward" is actually James. The Fat Contoller caught James messing up for the last time, and finally painted him blue. Still pissy, he decided to ruin Edward's name when Rocky came around.

[@randomnessetc5600]

For the umpteenth time, ignoring Edward being OUC, how is the story by itself?

[@fruitloops2058]

​@@randomnessetc5600 Mid but you can't ignore the OOC when the story relies on it

[@DRMF7]

@@randomnessetc5600the story is good. It feels like something that could happen in the RWS with a little bit of better writing. The only thing that ruins the story is the character leading it.

[@randomnessetc5600]

@@DRMF7 I keep saying that James was originally supposed to be the lead character but his model broke down and they couldn't fix him in time so Edward is basically filling in as a substitute hence why James doesn't cameo in the episode.

[@DRMF7]

@@randomnessetc5600 That is a good theory. I always wonder why James (the character that was marketed as the main 3 in this era of the show) didn’t appear in this episode not even as a cameo.

[@Mafaldamou]

It's hard to believe you'd make Edward. After all, you said in the Henry video that you wouldn't be doing Edward or Gordon any time soon, but that was a long time ago... I LOVE IT! COME ON, WE NEED GORDON TOO!

[@cheukyinglau8011]

Absolutely👍🏻👏🏻🤘🏻✌🏻!

[@fanofeverything30465]

He'll probably be next

[@MiguelTheMan]

No matter what anyone think or feels about Edward, he will always be known as the wise, old, yet determined blue tender engine that all the engines on Sodor and the members of the Thomas fandom will forever know, cherish and love. 💙

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

“It’s hard being number two” Even Tug isn’t immune from making poop jokes

[@PatRex11]

I was expecting Thomas but best engine will do nicely

[@josiuwu]

I dont think that was supposed to be a poop joke

[@huntergauld5923]

Not the intention

[@jaredhebert942]

More "it's not easy being green," but also not wrong; not too far an extrapolation, I suppose

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

I love the fact that Thomas cares for Edward in the intro and segments between parts. It’s so sweet. I love their dynamic!!

[@idontlikeitproductions3509]

Great vid. One thing I adore about CGI Edward is his UK voice, the accent and tone is just so perfect, that older English gentleman thing, not pompous but refined.

[@JZJ7777]

I agree. That’s why I prefer the UK dub of most CGI episodes. I just prefer how the voices in that dub sound, including his.

[@traintrack3761]

I honestly didn’t expect Edward to be today’s Sodor’s Finest but this took me by surprise and I found my love for Edward has been doubled thanks to this! Such a majestic video a really useful engine who’s been through a lot. Not to mention the cast and crew who made this were fantastic! I give this a 10/10.

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

39:27 - That is nothing like Edward. This is how I would describe him: Edward is a kind and wise engine. He is one of the oldest engines on Sodor which means he has lots of experience and mentors younger engines (Percy). Although Edward used to be looked down upon by others he showed time after time that he is still useful and the others now respect him. He never gives up and despite what others say or his condition he still carries on.

[@azmcpe4406]

I'll admit it. You described my relation with Edward perfectly (4:49) Thomas was my favorite character as a I child, and later as I aged a bit it became James. But even among my years I never understood Edward. He always seemed like a Blue James to me that never appeared much. But as an Adult I can immediately understand, empathize, and even admire Edward for always doing his best no matter how many obstacles are thrown his way, even the harsh words from fellow engines. He leads others from example and not arrogance like Gordon would, and never hesitates to people in their place when they are full of it. I'm sorry Edward. For not realizing how important you are until after all these years.

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

21:15 With what Tug said… that’s actually kinda interesting. Gordon’s warmed up enough to rather have Edward be preserved than let Edward be scrapped. It’s kinda cool

[@therenamonstan]

Edward is truly an astonishing character. He's taught us that no matter how old we are, we must never give up, no matter the cost. He's our hero!

[@voltsiano116]

1:06:10 I like this bit. I often reimagine the scene with Edward's driver trying to talk him into just phoning for another engine from the get-go after such a damaging accident, but with Edward insisting that they let him keep pulling the train.

[@splat-trainproductions]

Kinda like Skarloey in Old Faithful.

[@voltsiano116]

@@splat-trainproductions Yeah!

[@MatthewLiu]

The "Nothing Can Stop Us Now" (from the Little Engine That Could movie) instrumental over Edward's Exploit just did it for me - burst into tears 😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏 Thank you Unlucky Tug this was so so special. Edward our fav, Edward the best!

[@TheAlmightyBassist]

The Abby Grant testimony was so interesting. Makes total sense as to why Season 6 was a mess.

[@liladoodle]

Alice could've been a separate character. Still a 4-4-0 mind you, but a newer built one. As an example, the GCR Class 11F's (Or the D11 during their LNER days) were built between 1919-1924, 19 years after Edward's class had finished being built.

[@clockwork3494]

​@@liladoodleHonestly Alice could've also possibly worked as Molly imo

[@liladoodle]

​@@clockwork3494You meant Alice, right?

[@clockwork3494]

@@liladoodle Yes lol Thank you for pointing out my mistake, didn't even realize until now

[@omegamaximus1727]

I love the voice acting skit. Feels like the good ol’ Classic Era of Thomas.!😊

[@joshuaW5621]

It feels like it’s going for they style of Tugs as well when it comes to the dialogue.

[@fanofeverything30465]

​@@joshuaW5621Also like the Brenner era in terms of voice acting

[@ryanangelastro504]

@@fanofeverything30465so basically Tugs meets the Brenner era.

[@whiteninji352]

Oh it’s a Sodor’s Finest of Edward in the new style. Wasn’t expecting that but perfectly fine in my books

[@Thomas_Boom]

Edward’s arc in the railway series can inspire anyone. I was biking along the beach a few weeks ago and I had to turn around, and the wind was pelting against me and the sand kept sinking in. I managed to get home without getting off the bike once, and the entire time Edward’s theme was playing in my head lol. Anyways great job to everyone who worked on this, this is a really special installment to Sodor’s Finest

[@emersoninfinitystone5785]

Edward deserved a prequel book. Just imagine... *Book #43 "Edward's Early Years"* telling us the 4-Part arc of his life back on the FR in the 1800s, following him when he was young, smug, foolish and how he eventually grew into the wise old fatherly elder he is now. An extra 5th story in the book could be about him arriving to Sodor, meeting Thomas, and them building the NWR together, the very last page showing him being left in the shed as time goes on, bringing the RWS full circle back to the beginning of The Three Railway Engines. I also think that the idea of there being a K2 named Alice is a really great opportunity for a new OC in my opinion. The headcannon here is pretty simple: She could be Edward's long forgotten older sister who was sadly scrapped just before he left for Sodor. Although Edward rarely talks about her... Alice was in fact the very one who mentored HIM, teaching him everything he knows today. She was the Qui-Gon Jinn to Edward's Obi-Wan Kenobi if you will, with their sibling dynamic being an exact parallel and foreshadowing what Edward & Thomas's future friendship would become.

[@TheLazyFusspot_3428]

So like Very Old Engines, huh?

[@megariderfire1994]

Yeah and I felt like Albert plus Victoria and Helena could've been tied into his backstory...hell IMO, Thomas & Victoria SHOULD'VE been Edward & Victoria.

[@captainsmartass3368]

I like that idea

[@fanofeverything30465]

So does that make Thomas Luke

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

I find it genuinely shocking that Christopher Awdry never made a book about that in the 80s or 90s and I do genuinely believe that if Percy was female then Christopher would’ve done a Edward pre Sodor days book.

[@comicfan1324]

Edward may not be my favorite, even if he is quite high up on my tear list, but I think he’s the character I have the most admiration for. As I get older and older, I relate to Edward more and more. Edward knows that age is catching up to him, and the world has changed a lot from the one he was brought into, but he doesn’t let that stop him from doing his best and showing kindness to others. After all, he wants to help and share.

[@comicfan1324]

For those wondering, my favorite character is actually Thomas. When he is written correctly, I like how he clearly has a good heart, but his cheeky, cocky. Nature often gets the best of him. As a fan, and as a storyteller, that’s a very fun character to work with. And I love how throughout the original five seasons, Thomas really grew up and matured, but never fully lost that cheeky edge of his

[@TheLazyFusspot_3428]

@@comicfan1324 My most relatable character was Henry. Growing up, it's either Duck or the main man Edward himself.

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

@@comicfan1324 And the Brenner era got him correct as well with cheekiness in tact.

[@songopaul5863]

When I heard James I had to check the description as I knew it was Trampy. Love that James voice! I also love the extra detail compared to the original Sodor's Finest on our favorite number 2.

[@superguy4491]

Absolutely beautiful Edward was done justice now we need a Gordon remake as well

[@cheukyinglau8011]

Absolutely!

[@dadocta5168]

I was not expecting a remake! Glad to see a proper Sodor's finest on Edward :) Worried it would be Thomas as he should be the big finale to Sodor's Finest. Right after Daisy, Emily, Mavis, Oliver, Duncan, Bertie, Harold, Donald & Douglas, Bill & Ben and The Fat Controller.

[@levidarling5107]

A very awesome recreation. Not only did I learn something new about Edward, but also the reason why CGI Thomas & Friends suddenly went down hill at the end of the Brenner era and beginning of BWBA.

[@ryankelly8902]

James will always be my favourite character, but Tug has really made a great case for Edward. He may be number 2 on the railway, but he’s number 1 to the rest of us.

[@the.sketch.projekt8851]

The Little Engine That Could music at the end was a nice touch.

[@MrIngo-fe7su]

Edward definitely deserves a remake video. And also Gordon ☺️

[@fanofeverything30465]

I think the next Sodor's Finest will be a remake of Gordon Then The Fat Controller Then Thomas

[@OctaviaHughesFalcon]

@@fanofeverything30465 I feel like Thomas will probably be the grand finale to Sodor's Finest, after the Thomas Retrospective is complete. In the meantime, I think we'll get Sodor's Finest installments on Donald & Douglas, Oliver, and several others too!

[@dermie10]

God lord, first the Tom Marshall dub and then “the little engine that could” theme - why am I crying??

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

If BoCo returned to CGI, he would help Edward mentor Philip since it would be nice to see him interact with the boxcab on account of being diesels.

[@cheukyinglau8011]

BoCo could have stayed with Philip in Wellsworth Sheds, while Edward can still be part of the Steam Team.

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

@@cheukyinglau8011 Yeah, I suppose so.

[@joshuaW5621]

When BoCo returns in the revival era, I can see him being a mentor to Phillip too.

[@thisinduvidual]

When I was a child Edward never stuck out to me, that’s to be expected. However now that I’ve watched this video, I have found myself having a slight interest in Edward now, thanks unlucky tug

[@BuggleskellyStation]

Thanks for having me onboard again for this special video mate. A pleasure to celebrate my favourite character Edward with you :)

[@deadchannel733]

I love Rebecca myself, but Edward will always hold a special place in every Thomas fan’s heart.

[@Mafaldamou]

44:35 I think Edward hated cranes so much that Big Mickey just decided to teach him a lesson

[@railwayroundhouse3792]

Honestly? I don’t think anyone could ask for a better look or tribute for a character as special as Edward. You’ve seriously outdone yourself this time! The cutaways to the adaptations of Edward and Gordon and Edward’s Exploit were superb and incredibly enjoyable to watch. I had to laugh when watching Thomas playfully probing Gordon during his speech at the end! The dialogue, banter and overall dynamic between the engines is captured perfectly! Very well done on this!

[@danishmorgan22]

The blue veteran fighter himself - Sodor's version of Captain America👍👍 we must never forget how important Edward the Blue Engine is to the franchise. Without him, none of the later stories would probably have been published. Sadly, the later seasons rarely gave him the respect that he deserves

[@williamjeffries5074]

“I can do it! I can do it! I can do this all day!”

[@Branchout1097]

Nice use of the song "Nothing Can Stop Us Now" Tug! Edward really was the little engine that could.

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Why doesn't it surprise me that Edward would be the one to get his own Complete History video? Still, this was really good!😄 As for why Edward wasn't in TATMR, it's likely that he went with The Fat Controller on his holiday.

[@joshuaW5621]

Speaking of TATMR, while I don’t consider it canon as much as the next person, I heard that Britt Allcroft does consider it canon.

[@stuartbarclay7940]

@@joshuaW5621 She does? Well, that's a surprise! I'm also glad to hear as I consider TATMR canon too.

[@Steamtheamaricanengine]

Yea i consider it as a dream thomas had (side note:i am 11 and i have a mindset of an aduilt ttte fan would)sorry if this a stupid to put in

[@joshuaW5621]

@@Steamtheamaricanengine don’t worry, I too see it as a dream that Thomas had that may have played an inspiration into the very movie in-universe.

[@Steamtheamaricanengine]

@@joshuaW5621 yea but i was talking about when i said i have a mindset of an aduilt ttte fan

[@Talex-td6xf]

The little stories with all the VA's was just incredible, and the final re-telling of Edward's Exploit, that really felt magical!

[@christov7789]

I re-watched the original 1991 " The Little Engine that Could" movie and the music at the end now reminds me of your version of "Edward's Exploit" rather than the other way around and still hits emotionally for this man is his mid 30's. As someone aging and needing surgery again, much like an aging engine, this was exactly what I needed in my life at this time and will always remind me that even as I age, I know I can do it and, after each challenge life throws at me I can stand up and say, "Yes, I did it, and with was worth it."

[@ExpressRhubarb]

One thing I always found very endearing about Edward's basis being a K2 was how they didn't make it to nationalisation- being phased out and scrapped by the late 30s by the LMS. But despite this, he soldiers on nearly 90 years after the last of his kin were retired. Edward lives on thanks to grit, determination, a comendable work ethic and lots and lots of love. An absolutely stellar video Nic. Absolutely smashing stuff! Never have I wanted to model Edward more!

[@joshuaW5621]

For some reason I used to think that a few of the K2s lasted into nationalisation. Unfortunately the D5s were the only Furness locomotives to make it into British Railways service.

[@Iron_Blood_Enjoyer1933]

If Edward got himself a remaster, then I'm expecting a Gordon remaster in the future. Edit: 14:45 LOL! I always forget about this bit from the Johnny Morris narrations.

[@liladoodle]

Amen to that brother.

[@cheukyinglau8011]

Yes, me too!

[@Steamtheamaricanengine]

Is that the part where percy says we need a depostation and then theres a bruh sound effect

[@Iron_Blood_Enjoyer1933]

@@Steamtheamaricanengine No, it's that bit of Johnny Morris where Percy whistles at Henry.

[@Steamtheamaricanengine]

@@Iron_Blood_Enjoyer1933 ohhhh that ok

[@toxicheadshot50]

1:14:37 It makes me so happy knowing that Tug has watched or even knows about the 1991 Little Engine That Could film. It's so niche and forgotten about! I hope he does some kind of "Best Show You've Never Seen"-esque video about it!

[@TopHatTITAN]

I wanna read an Edward story set during his YOUNGER years, when he was basically 1890s Gordon.

[@Daniel_Huffman]

That would also allow for an occasion where Edward makes some egregious mistake without being out of character, as this would be set before he matured, similar to how _Very Old Engines_ showed Skarloey as once being like that.

[@Criskena]

You can clearly tell Nic loves Edward based on how long this video is😂

[@EternityKingdomsHeadHoncho]

There's something so fitting about Edward's RWS book not really being about him so much as it is his relationships with others. "Cows" is about his wisdom triumphing over Gordon and Henry's folly, "Bertie's Chase" is about his relationship with Bertie, "Saved From Scrap" hinges on his relationship with the people of Sodor to save Trevor, and "Old Iron" brings his rivalry with James to a thrilling close while also highlighting how highly respected by Thomas and Percy he is. Good Gresley, _Edward the Blue Engine_ is such a wonderful, underrated book.

[@Woodenrailwayoliver20]

Actually all the stories are half about Edward but I get what you’re saying.

[@Horizon_Flyer]

34:35 "SCRAP" ,said Edward quietly... Dang Edward with the burn

[@gordonpacific04]

Me anticipating the video: Can’t wait to see what he has to add to his original video on Edward. (The video releases) Me: AN HOUR AND 15 MINUTES?!??!?

[@LimpBizkitMix]

David Mitton writing an episode as bad as Edward the Really Useful Engine is genuinely one of the most mind-boggling things about the entire franchise to me Edit: honestly Edward being scared of a possible ghost engine in Henry in the Dark doesn’t bother me THAT much because in the classic series they were always flirtatious with the supernatural and since many other characters believed in ghosts back then, I don’t think it’d be far off to say Edward does believe in ghosts and even they kinda freak him out because it’s something beyond even human understanding

[@fanofeverything30465]

Maybe the script editor did a crap job

[@thewillofabeast9079]

Well, if I remember correctly, the reason David left was due to corporate meddling. I think the people from HiT were too controlling into what stories they wanted David to right, which is what I think led to him leaving. And it’s understandably so. They wouldn’t give him the freedom to write his own stories. I’m not sure if there’s more to David’s departure but I do think it has to do with not having the creative freedom of writing his own plots and stories. And I also agree that Edward being a bit spooked of the supernatural isn’t out of the ordinary. It’s also the same how I feel with the episode “The Old Bridge”. Everyone bashes this episode as it’s not in character for a character like Skarloey to be scared. While I am sad with how HiT had slowly turned him and the the narrow gauge engines to act more like children, Skarloey having PTSD with a bridge after almost falling off of it isn’t really that out of character. Even the bravest characters can have trauma especially with being that close to falling and being injured or killed.

[@christianvillapando4060]

This video is literally like going from Halo 2 to Halo 2 Anniversary. BIG ASS W

[@RedPigSpartan]

I'm both a Thomas fan and a Halo fan

[@christianvillapando4060]

@@RedPigSpartan interesting how those things intersect 😄

[@s.p.d.magentaranger1822]

From Marvel vs Capcome 3 to 3 Ultimate?

[@RedPigSpartan]

@@s.p.d.magentaranger1822 What are you talking about?

[@Samuel31nation]

24:14 "Give Edward an inch of hope. He'll bring your train home"

[@justinkwong8071]

A Sodor's Finest on Edward? Homework will have to wait.

[@Jojo.F87]

1:07:36 can't believe im crying over a train rn currently binging your videos, they're such a comfort. I feel like I may have already commented this on another video lmao. Constantly blown away by the quality and effort you put into these long form videos about model trains and the real life engines that inspired them. Thanks for all you do to keep us entertained!

[@Muppetjedi]

What a really touching and indepth commentary on Edward in the railway series. I hope it continues when the CGI series is brought up

[@burneyboys02]

Edward is definitely one of the best characters of the series. If Awdry never had the idea when telling the story to his son then the Railway Series or Thomas and friends wouldn't be here. Edward is always useful and reliable and yet nothing stands in his way from triumph. What a champ! Also for a rant, yeah Mattel really did him dirty. The writing team was pretty much put in the crossroads when it came to Edward's departure. They really could've written an episode that keened to the books but Mattel being the company that it is obviously wanted to keep their revenue just so they could make their "necessary" changes to the show, but then seeing outcome wasn't well received and yet they just don't care.

[@tge_iii]

If Edward is getting a remake, Gordon getting the same treatment gets me excited.

[@thewillofabeast9079]

I truly loved the dynamic between Thomas and Edward, with Thomas trying to make Edward feel better when the others were bringing down about not going out. That’s also one of the things I loved about Trampy’s videos. It gives more depth into why Thomas rebels and makes fun of the bigger engines since they look down on him, never give any appreciation for his hard work, and make fun of him. Edward isn’t like them and instead comforts Thomas and looks out for him. This is why Thomas respects Edward. The latter never looks down at Thomas and instead treats him as an equal. And as atrocious as the HiT era handled Edward, I liked how Thomas was determined to hep Edward in Saving Edward.

[@joshuaW5621]

These two have a bit of a student and sna dynamic going on between them.

[@visionarylocomotiveworks9703]

I’m curious why no one talks about Edward’s Brass Band. While not a groundbreaking episode, I think it’s a very nice episode of Season 7, where Edward feels in character, and we see a side of him we didn’t see before. Definitely a sort of overlooked gem. I particularly love the use of Nothing Can Stop Us Now - super clever!

[@e-122psi3]

Yeah, I feel like one of few that likes seeing a more fallible side to Edward, one that has insecurities and accidents sometimes, even if preferably in a way that fits his character (likely why I love Brenner era Edward). Edward's Brass Band was an interesting moment, the first time he had a severe accident and is super unhappy about not being able to do his job.

[@thesudriana016]

Wow! For a remastered episode on a previous Sodor's Finest episode you did before, this is really excellent! Edward really is a true example to us all, he may not appear as much after his character arc is complete and not every generation knows who he is, but he still surprises us all just like the other engines! When I was younger, I wasn't interested in Edward as a character cause I was more interested in the other characters get into crazy antics. But with time as I grew older and learning his backstory and the series' creation, I slowly grow on the wise old blue engine. So now he's become my forth favorite character! I literally choked and teared up at the character dialogue segments in between the analysis. Richard Browning's Gordon voice sounds like Neil Crone precisely and even Robin's Thomas voice sounds accurately like John Hasler (Eddie Glen in your case), I thought you had hired him to do the voice. For Edward's character, I too prefer him as a supporting character like in S3-5. Giving him too many flaws would make him unlikable like the childish HiT era did (and I think maybe the writers too didn't like the Steam Team concept either, who knows?). This is why I gave Edward one episode in S1 of Great Sodor Engines and a few supporting roles to make him consistent to his true persona in the original eras of the show (RWS Books and Classic TV Series). I hope you do a remake of Gordon soon!

[@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967]

Edward is mostly consistent to his true persona in the CGI Brenner era too.

[@fanofeverything30465]

Who are your first, second and third favourite characters

[@thesudriana016]

@@fanofeverything30465 1. Gordon, 2. Percy, and 3. Rebecca (yes, I like her. Don't ask).

[@ctmajka]

The theme from The Little Engine that Could at 1:07:51 was a FANTASTIC choice! "There's not a mountain that we can't climb. There's not a river we can't make it over There's no tomorrow that we can't find, if we try. I know we're gonna make it, NOTHING CAN STOP US NOWWWW!!!"

[@Railroadracer49]

That ending was incredible I especially love you included the theme from the 1991 film the little engine that could and it was redone in the Thomas style definitely brought back memories And overall Edward is a character that should always be remembered The one that started it all If it weren’t for him there would be no Thomas & none of our love for it wouldn’t have existed

[@Noah-ey5zf]

The Unlucky Tug’s done it again taking the first 2 Pilot Episodes of Sodor’s Finest “Edward & Gordon” and redoing them to be consistent for others. Whenever Gordon the Big Engine gets redone, I will be glue on the channel for updates! keep it going Nic, you’re doing great!

[@TitanXecutor]

Wow. Glad to see a full analysis of Edward. Can't wait to see a remake for Gordon. Speaking of, excellent ending with him.

[@cheukyinglau8011]

Me too! Gordon is my favorite character!

[@adamgoncalves1591]

Even after being picked on by all the big engines on Sodor for being old and not as strong as Gordon or Henry, Edward still proves each and every day that even he is a really useful and hardworking engine. Because of this he is easily my favorite character in Thomas and Friends.

[@weezingisastoner]

Edward was always my favorite character in Thomas & Friends. When I first saw the episode where he beat Spencer in a race to the Duke and Dutchess' Summer Home when I was a wee-lad, it sparked an interest and when I got him as my very first T&F toy, I knew he was my favorite.

[@reeheehee9615]

It says alot about a video when it only takes a few minutes for me to decide it's one of my favourites, Edward fan bias aside. Very well done Nic and to the team behind this one. Easily for me the best Sodor's Finest.

[@marty6779]

You just keep hitting it out of the park mate. Edward's always been my favourite character too. This video is more than doing him justice. Well done.