The Evolution of Mac Miller | Discography Review

[@LovesteinJr]

How are you not gonna talk about Faces

[@nathanieldamon3939]

Exactly

[@brantleylansing7696]

Yeah what the fuck an album that's already not spoken about too smh these mac miller review people never talk about faces

[@Giovannax427]

literally blows my mind. faces is too great not to be spoken about

[@destineeberry3125]

🙌

[@pevce47]

Literally my first thought when I stopped the video, like...what?!? Probably one of the best mixtapes of all time and it just gets glanced over?

[@ilovecody7514]

Mac Miller is one of the most genuine and diverse hip hop artists out there. Faces and Watching Movies With the Sound Off are two albums which have made him one of my favorite rappers as far as this generation.

[@likeaufoyobro9567]

Tha Swami stop 😂

[@ilovecody7514]

JMAHTHAG Nah, you can take that shit somewhere else though.

[@likeaufoyobro9567]

Tha Swami Mac miller is such a commercial rapper u will learn nothing from listening to him

[@ilovecody7514]

JMAHTHAG And that shows you haven't listened to much of his music nor watched the video your allowed to have an opinion of an artist, but this is such a retarded statement to make on this video.

[@iiiRevize]

Faces was a mixtape not an album. Faces is his best work, WMWTSO is close and Swimming is damn good. His early years isn't good but since KIDS, it's been great work and it's hard to top what Faces, but he'll continue to produce amazing music.

[@LiarofShinovar]

Rest In Peace Mac. Your last project was so inspiring and we were all so excited for your future.

[@LiarofShinovar]

@HikingKingPepe936 disagree

[@poserjacob1280]

@Hunter Does Debates god you have terrible taste in music😃

[@thoonalia]

​@harold l

[@andreashildebrandt4373]

the new tiny desk concert he just did is amazing.

[@andywray2170]

truly incredible, brought me back to him

[@kyekye1]

Andreas Hildebrandt it’s soooooo goood

[@chvIry]

Wait you say him on tour? I see him dec 9

[@andreashildebrandt4373]

Beuq nah gotta wait til europe

[@chvIry]

@Pack1Attack nah bro. I cried my heart out. I lost a friend when he died. I just framed my tickets

[@PackerBT137]

2:50 Skipthony Adtano 2:50

[@theR0ck3tsumm3r]

Jabari thx

[@hojamismo]

*light 3*

[@alejandrorapag9032]

DAMN./KIDS SEE GHOSTS

[@norymusic]

God bless you

[@ANerdygangsta]

Fun fact for you guys; Schoolboy Q once said in an interview that Watching Movies with the Sound Off was his favorite album of 2013.

[@sebastiancole7883]

that is freaking epic

[@codymorse2484]

I didn't know that. I'm thankful you let us know. ❤

[@mnq8154]

Faces and GOOD AM arent comparable at all

[@INSYA]

Opinion

[@MarcosVinicius-oz6kl]

skill wise it is

[@mnq8154]

Marcos Vinicius I disagree, rapping wise, production wise and features wise Faces is far superior. But that is just my opinion obviously.

[@bryan3164]

I was hoping someone would say that

[@MarcosVinicius-oz6kl]

Matthew Quellin I don't think he was talking about quality, I honestly could see songs from good am being on faces and vice versa, insomniak could've been on good am, here we go could've been on good am, ros could've been on faces (there are more songs than these 3), but I really don't see any song from the divine feminine being on faces/good am, I think he said they are comparable because mac's style didn't change too much from faces to good am

[@TheRookyMarky]

I don’t give a fuck, his early songs are still fun to listen to. Music doesn’t always have to be so deeply analyzed.

[@2013_Shox]

Nikes on my feet still heavily in rotation.

[@cxrtichris]

Facts, I'd take his early shit over the divine feminine, music doesn't have to be so deep I don't get people

[@ianmunoz1668]

This guys analysis was trash anyway he skipped over 2 of the best projects (faces, good am) but then praised a divine feminine because of "intoxicating" beats even though both faces and good am had some of the best instrumentals word play and clever bars in his discography

[@user-mt9pg8qd4n]

This is why I like Mac so much because he has both

[@curranfrank2854]

@@ianmunoz1668 I think his analysis was mostly fine, but yeah he totally downplayed those projects, both are better than divine feminine. Faces low key may be his best project, Circles included

[@_saintoj]

Dawg... you gave zero attention to Faces. Man, it really shouldn’t have been skipped over.

[@Giovannax427]

You focused too much on the downfalls of his earlier stuff. there were a lot of really iconic songs back then, especially nike’s on my feet senior skip day and best day ever. On macadelic the song fight the feeling has unreal production value i really wish you spoke about that. i feel like you missed a lot of really important points about his music and you were way too harsh about it. i’ve been listening to mac since the beginning and as his music evolved so did my music taste along with it. All of us mac fans loved every album i never even knew blue slide park was rated so low. it’s sad to see so much negativy around something i thought the world of as a teenager.

[@hellboymax]

Just this guys opinion its ok to critique

[@Giovannax427]

@@hellboymax which is fine just as i'm allowed to critique his opinion lol but i dont believe this to be his opinion it seems he just read each album review and based his video off of them.

[@hellboymax]

@@Giovannax427 idk bout that one sounds like he knows his catalogue pretty well that's a hell of an assumption to make but whatever you do you

[@Giovannax427]

@@hellboymax i've watched several vids and its very obvious, especially the Conan Mockasin one. He didn't even mention faces !! do u even fuck with mac like that cause damn

[@brauliocastillo5858]

Sophia Esposito alfo media clearly didn’t know a thing about Mac miller you can’t make the type of video he did about Mac when you don’t know shit about him it honestly grossed me out to see him talk down on macs begging projects calling him corny no one will ever be like Mac Mac could go from straight bars to hitting you in your soul he could go from hip hop to jazz to slow music to singing he was honestly a god for the music industry sad to not have him here no more since he’s passed I haven’t listen to any music but his cause I feel like music won’t be the same no more I remember I would always wait for August or September cause that’s when he would usually release his albums

[@ImxPhreme]

Obviously his early work isn’t so deep, he was a kid. Just as Tyler did, he grew up and guess what, matured. He’s always been talented!

[@gabrielruggiero2419]

yeah but K.I.D.S is still so good to listen to

[@Zaybeezy]

exactly

[@emmit9636]

I loved The Divine Feminine because of the heart and soul Mac's spills through his lyrics talking about love and women, however; I didn't love it entirely because I always thought there was something missing. Mac's Swimming is exactly what I wanted The Divine Feminine to be. The touching and lightheartedness of his voice hits but he also includes the jazz, as well as what I like to call his "chill bangers". Mac made a complete album here and I suggest this project to anyone!

[@victoriaappiagei1482]

the divine feminist awesome Cool good music now swimming album favorite

[@ianmunoz1668]

Jet Fuel

[@wids]

I need Faces on Spotify immediately. Great video!

[@Pac12Football]

Download the mixtape online then use local files on the desktop version of spotify to save it to your library

[@thefunxion7693]

ITS FINALLY HAPPENING!!

[@eliza_miaaaaa]

blue slide park was actually a pretty great album which had a great production and definitely talked about deeper things about his life in some of the songs.

[@cinemapure.e]

Rest in peace Mac Miller

[@mixedbyskeed]

i think you're sleeping on his bars a little too much for his first two albums he's a pretty good lyricist

[@AquaBlueTea]

EXACTLY

[@runaway_hideout]

Faces and swimming are my personal favorites

[@codymorse2484]

Absolutely agree. Both albums are truly extraordinary. They're the most honest, relatable, detailed, and profound records he made, in my opinion. Malcolm actually shifted my perspective on life and everything contained in it. I can't say that about anyone else. Not even someone I personally know. I hope heaven is real so he can be there.

[@liyelathimakalima]

Swimming, Circles and K.I.D.S for me

[@NinjaIsLaw]

PLEASE DO ONE OF THEESE ON EARL SWEATSHIRT

[@jtrosen2001]

NinjaIsLaw _ I think he should wait until he drops- man got 3 projects

[@NinjaIsLaw]

ok true but at the same time that just means we would get deeper analysis for each project this video was good but i would like it to go deeper

[@LouMurk]

Also you can tell that after Earl came back he changed a lot.

[@fayewestwood4193]

JT Rosen next Friday his third albums dropping

[@lubbers825]

Please

[@georgecapper4356]

What about his larry lovestein YOU ep? I think that's really where you see mac's mindset on music change and see that he's more than a corny college kid

[@imboutamakeafoolofmyself]

Contrary to progression, you should make a video on Hopsin's discography, and how little he's actually progressed as an artist

[@CJVP99]

you're a hater on Mac's early stuff my guy you have to see it through the eyes of a person his age back in the day he was talking about relatable things for that generation, Mac miller had fans because his fans grew up along with Mac

[@ryancarson8461]

I always viewed Mac as a rapper so I never listened to his music but I gave his new album a chance and it's so good. He's one of the rappers that combines R&B and rap which leads to good music.

[@BeckCurtis]

Mac, please come back to earth

[@ktfrostbite1338]

How do you talk about Mac peaking without talking about Faces

[@johnnyjb99]

Can’t wait to see Mac, thundercat and J.I.D in concert

[@Narcissist-xf5rh]

Winslow I envy you, enjoy!!

[@johnnyjb99]

Brendan Bergh hell yeah it’ll be dope, I’ll take some vids

[@theresagozzo7797]

ME NEITHER!

[@mg6945]

I'm sorry man RIP

[@ashtonebinger5651]

Oof

[@adamfeldman9222]

I just hope swimming gets the reception it deserves

[@anthonytruman]

Actually in 2010 he still had some more heartfelt songs on KIDS like “Poppy” which is about his Grandpa who died . Also he has a song “I’ll Be There” which is about his mom. I don’t think you listened to all of the music

[@kyleat126]

Faces by far is my favorite project. I have a lot of love current Mac with Divine Feminine and Swimming but Faces just resonates with me on an emotional level considering the mind state I was in back in 2014.

[@nicknugent8019]

BigKid99 Faces is the second most influential album in my life after American Idiot.

[@wardrockingham6830]

That 3 minute ad at the beginning was so great. Hope using macs name to pull views and then have an ad for 3 mins at the beginning helps you, I see it as sad.

[@kosmaroginski9949]

idk if you watched the video but it was made before his passing

[@drivedonniedrive]

underrated channel, i love your editing and what you chose to make videos about.

[@AquaBlueTea]

I have how people never take the time to talk about "I Love Life, Thank You" it's such a great mixtape. And how do you just skip FACES like that!? Also, you're sleeping on his early bars heavily

[@arceus521]

I genuinely agree that Mac’s early projects are subpar but I still love everything from kids to hell can wait (with Vince staples) to blue slide park. And it’s not because it was relatable at all. In fact I was almost the polar opposite of Mac In school. The music just made me happy whenever I listened to it. It was just this fun, charismatic energy about him and i thoroughly needed that kind of energy in my life at the time. Now, I’m still nothing like Mac was then, never done drugs, don’t drink and stopped smoking. His music and personality just helped me a lot when I was younger and he’s still one of my favorite artists to date.

[@codymorse2484]

I appreciate that you said this. He really did have something about him that I've never seen before, personal or otherwise.

[@owenwhite598]

That last line before the outro 💔

[@hunterwaechter2931]

Video Starts at 2:50

[@chvIry]

Hunter Waechter not all heroes wear capes

[@natiep3964]

im so glad that someone else agrees that mac’s best album was swimming. it was there for me through a lot. i know every word to every song in that album. It’s absolutely beautiful

[@cers6886]

This vid was made a month before his passing...

[@kiddfruit]

Was waiting on you to comment on Mac, i think you gave a good review of his discography, one of my favourite artists rn

[@noahsteward]

You’re something special man. Whereas I may not agree with everything you say, you deliver it in such a way that I find myself fully respecting your stance. Your shit doesn’t go unnoticed, keep going. I truly think you’re on to something really great with this channel and I support the shit out of it. ✌🏼✌🏼

[@_totallynotscott]

this had to be the best video based on mac miller i’ve ever seen, very well put together, keep up the strong work

[@Charlesyo_]

I think Swimming is my favorite Mac project ever, I truly do think its a fantastic album. Of my favs from 2018 easily. Good video man.

[@Cameron-hw5kh]

Really dig these discography review videos!

[@goldwincs]

i remember finding Mac Miller when i was looking for an alternative of Asher Roth, "Kool Aid & Frozen Pizza" is the only song i have ever heard from him. Now I'm interested to listen to his newer music.

[@Lui_Cee]

goldwincs listen to his new album swimming!

[@planbskaterchu]

goldwincs Listen to the entire Faces mixtape

[@chvIry]

Of the soul

[@chvIry]

Aquarium and all of his WMWTSO album

[@chvIry]

I second entire faces mixtape

[@malcolmgray81]

“I can’t wait to see where he goes from here” if only we knew what was to come. Rest In Peace Mac

[@johnhanson5527]

Came back to watch a video that truly appreciates who he was. Thank you for this.

[@_.HENRY319]

John Hanson same bro sucks that he’s gone

[@GeorgetheGreat]

REST EASY MAC WOP, I feel like I lost a friend I grew up and went to school with. Lets all continue to keep his family and friends in prayer. He had progressed so much as an artist and is def one of the best this decade.

[@guidoguido2245]

"And I can’t wait to see where he goes from here" made me cry.

[@graydy8624]

Love your vids

[@jobbas6083]

Jesus fucking christ why do you only have 50k subs, you deserve unlimited amounts moreeeee.... Will join patreon the second I get a job!

[@sdk9443]

favorite music channel behind tnd, good work

[@tal914]

The end to Mac's story is too sad

[@anotherpersondude4024]

"and I can't wait to see where he goes from here" this shit is so sad man.

[@OtterPup_]

Corrupt Trash To die young legend, or live a long life

[@fabianm1134]

2012-2015 was my favorite Mac Miller years. Macadelic, WMWTSO, Faces, GOOD:AM.

[@ajrumely6727]

not even gonna lie, i love kids and blue slide park and i’ll die on that hill

[@jeppekjr349]

I thank you for introducing to many of the artists I listen to now

[@M.Sleeze]

R.I.P Mac. Such a talented, great and lovely person, sooo damn underrated SMFH

[@brooklinakers3637]

One of my favorite mac tracks is off of but my mackin ain’t easy, that’s shit goes hard for a 15 year old

[@Who_am_i54321]

Hey man just an idea I had for your website, maybe you can have a "music I've listened to lately" tab or section where whenever you find a new musician or band that you like you can put it on their so other people can discover them

[@tynamco3068]

Love the video! I’d be interested to hear your opinion on individual projects more in-depth!!

[@samsonmcharaly8536]

This makes me sad now but also more appreciative of such a talented man

[@tylermatthys3668]

I was dreading getting to the end knowing you’d say you can’t wait to see what he does next...

[@obeyhellokitty143]

delusional thomas is my favorite project from Mac

[@nerrizenitroc9991]

Maurqui I know it was great at the time

[@cheese81301]

I used to think the same way about Blue Slide Park, but I took a deeper dive and now it is one of my favorite projects of his. Sure he was still in his “frat rap” phase, but each track brings something new sonically, and is definitely worth listening to again. Rip Mac

[@felixlarsson2665]

Mac Miller is my faaaavorite artist it just makes may day seeing an insightful guy like you make a video on him

[@jagna2531]

"I'm genuinely proud of Mac Miller's evolution and I can't wait to see where he goes from here." Little did he know what would happen month later, after the video...

[@EpicPalmTree]

10:47 along with the mixtape "Delusional Thomas" Mac Miller also released the "You EP" around the same time either before or after I can't recall. I was looking forward to you discussing it but it was skipped over 😔 if this means you weren't aware or anyone else isn't as well then please check it out! It's mac Miller's love jazz persona Larry Lovestien where he dives more into singing.

[@Joni-521]

That video when he was a little man always makes me 😢 which I know do all his music. I’ve said from day one hearing him. I knew he was filled wt genius 😢I love his later yrs. Hand me dws. You Foria.is my go to song. I feel sadness & happiness when I watch all his videos & interviews. I get sad 😞 when his songs end..😢 definitely underrated album 2024 & ppl r only talking about how great he was. My regrets r like texts 😢😢deeply missed love as if he was my son. Thx u to his family 😇🙏🎸💥💥

[@elzz3]

As a fellow Mac fan, this was just the video I needed, a reflection on his growth as a person through his music and career

[@killowatraibikio2855]

4 weeks later now his gone for ever! His music will live on.

[@kitparsons6680]

Congrats on the sponsor!

[@NickSixties]

Finally someone put into words how I’d been feeling about Mac for so long, I thought I was crazy when I told people I couldn’t stand his music before Watching Movies and they would respond with “you didn’t love Blue Slide Park?” - I love Mac, but I hate the old Mac

[@jakeecker1648]

I like how you put the little song snippets

[@matthewmendez1173]

The only reason I disliked is cause he didn’t cover FACES like cmon bro it was his most important project ever imo

[@KaentukiTheFuki]

So sad to know this video was made exactly 1 month (take away a day) before his death......

[@aishymoo5]

That lengthy intro 😩

[@Pac12Football]

For me... Faces is unrivaled. I love all of Mac's music, but good god Faces just never gets old

[@nicknugent8019]

Pac12Football Faces rivals Dark Side of the Moon.

[@tvdurdurs554]

The video actually starts at 2:50 you're welcome

[@afternoonscion]

Your channel gives such good criticism and opinions for what music sounds like and what it could sound like. I'm now majoring in music and trying to teach myself as many instruments as possible to be able to find my sound and hopefully one day get you to check out my music. When I have some stuff I'm proud of, I hope you'll be interested in it too.

[@taxmane1526]

not sure how faces and go:od am are pretty similar lol but ok

[@beachboytyler7574]

Hmm hating on Easy Mac huh? Not even mentioning faces and started with a 2 minute advertisement. Terrible smh.

[@Dontreadthis0]

3:24 what music video was this?

[@lances.6850]

I want a “jump” or “when in Rome” from him again, something like “loud”

[@chimichangaguy8735]

cant wait to see where he goes from here

[@johnw2984]

Have you thought of adding a page to your website of artists showing appreciation for your coverage on them? For example, when Roy Blair tweeted the video you made on him.

[@Discgolfology]

His snap back rap was still really good him chris webby and asher roth all gave white suburban kids relatable music it was refreshing plus all three rappers grew and made deeper stuff pretty cool transition

[@FAKIECROWS]

such an amazing artist

[@pokemonm4niac]

Delusional Thomas is one of my favorite mixtapes of all time.

[@javieraviles6914]

What about Larry Lovestein?!! His side project jazzy stuff that's just gold

[@astrofishsticks9640]

You should make another video going into more depth on Faces and GO:OD AM!

[@perspikio8110]

These vids are great

[@emmanuelarriola9049]

Rest Easy Malcom ❤️

[@rakanmug.]

Great video , thanks keep it up.

[@shaka2352]

1st time on your channel. Pls let me know when the content I want to watch is 3 whole minutes into the video bc your in-video sponsored ad comes 1st (not the ad KZbin played before the video even loaded). I might have subscribed and thumbs-up'd with the extra time I had waiting...

[@jewlian1992]

What about the Larry fisherman mixtape? So much love. Emotion. I bump that on the regular

[@jewlian1992]

Larry lovenstein mixtape**

[@adamfeldman9222]

Have you listened to Loyle Carner? UK rapper with some really nice flow and subject matter that hits you right in the feels

[@gtankcorsi8018]

I’d love more complete discography reviews! Imagine Kanye’s🤔

[@AlfoMedia]

did the same sort of thing in this video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXOmlI19nZqVmrc be warned though, it was one of my first videos ever. very slow and monotone

[@jacobwatson3267]

Rip Mac you were the best

[@bobbycritz]

You hold some similar stances I have on him. I listened to him when I was a youngling and his music was just what I thought I needed to pass through the days because I felt like it was all I needed. When he started his more drug-influenced music, he went from fun and admirable to fantastic. Yes I really do overrate Mac MIller but he just stands as my favorite hip hop artist to listen to. Not GZA or MF Doom or Tribe, but just Mac. There was a period when I listened to really only Faces (as a whole album) for like more than a semester because how his sound just resonated so well with the extremity of my mindset. I will never knock him, and I will always play him, so on and so forth.

[@Biscuit_432]

For any Mac Miller fans, I have made a couple songs with his signed artist, Choo Jackson. Those songs are on my channel, along with Mac’s new “Swimming” album review. Check it out!

[@tylerstankelis8040]

Theres something to be said about his transition from blue slide park to macadelic. Something definately happened to him other than him just saying "eh, I'll try something else"

[@tareqsalah1959]

Great video! even tho I have no interest in Mac but watched it just to see your point of view. Also, I wanna ask, how the hell do you manage to listen to this much amount of music?