THE ISLAMIC INDUSTRY - MONETIZING ISLAM?!?

The issue is connected to the bigger trend of commercialising Islam from which things will slip in the background!
If any point you ask the ummah for money then you need to be transparent!
#brohajji
#sadaqah
#islam

[@muneebiqbal5584]

No one should be angry by being asked to keep everything open and public. Anyone in this video who has a bad attitude about being asked to show ALL the records of money received and spent has a real big issue.

[@muneebiqbal5584]

PS that dawah man ad is cringe beyond belief

[@MouhamadouDiop-lw1sr]

The badr club always gets me going 😂 allahu musta’an

[@saqibkhan5473]

I wonder if he got 313 sheep to fleece 😂

[@MouhamadouDiop-lw1sr]

@@saqibkhan5473 I hope not

[@Shiroyashasama]

@@saqibkhan5473apparently he did. I met a guy who got a wife out of this program

[@thetanweerali]

That was cringe.

[@RA-tc8tr]

What’s that

[@yusufchowdhury5328]

Many of these so-called dawah commercialization efforts employ tactics similar to those used by online "get rich quick" scheme scammers! 😂

[@MrGee2468]

How cringe is Dawah Man? Wallahi I feel embarrassed for him.

[@Web-Anime-Manga]

Bro Hajji is no longer playing around, very good vid. Apparently Ali Dawah is making a waqf- he says that at the start of his videos. In addiction to receipts, we need a full income statement indicating how much is collected and how it is spent. I don't know the Islamic rulings on waqfs, but can they be put solely for the sake of the public and not on anyone's names? Brother can you also look into a certain youtuber called Daud Kim from South Korea? It is alleged he took funds to build a masjid in S Korea, but is going to build himself a house and a salaah room.

[@BroHajji]

I will deal with Waqf’s in a separate video إن شاء الله

[@IqbalKhan-pn5gu]

Yes they should provide all the documentation showing where the money has been spent. Everything should be listed and they should have receipts. As muslims we are happy to donate money for the spread of Islam and the good dawah, but we want the money to be spent wisely on the things that were promised. I hope brother Ali shows us the receipts.

[@1Ummah1924]

Brother Hajji has produced another excellent video. Keep up the great work, brother. The influence of capitalism and consumerism, as propagated by liberal ideology, impacts us all within our environment. We must remain vigilant against these influences encroaching upon our Islamic duties. Brother Hajji raises pertinent questions worth considering.

[@abuAbdul-Mumeet]

This brother really puts in effort because he clearly has much passion for Allah and His messenger and this beautiful deen of islaam al-hamdu-lillah... Allahumma baarik feehaa, this brother is blessed in my opinion. I love you for the sake of Allah brother Muhammad Safdar (aka Bro Hajji), but that doesn't mean I am not peeved you haven't answered back for a long time on Insta hahahahahahaha holler me back inshaa'Allah... I know I monologued a fair bit and explained that is because of my autism (Asperger's syndrome) and the crap I have recently gone through after around 18 years of marriage and 5 children... I have been feeling very traumatised for quite some time because of it, but I am feeling far better; I see it is obviously what is best for me, as whatever Allah decrees is always what is best... I just needed to focus on this fact deeply becausse as I am sure every brother who goes through this or has gone through this kind of thing knows emaan goes up and down dramatically during such a painful experience in life... It is important, during such times, that we focus deeply on such facts as this and things such as the fact Allah alone knows what our future holds for us by His decree and if we trust Allah and are obedient to Him then He will give us whatever He sees fit to grant us and we will eventually be content so long as we obey Allah and strive to earn His pleasure and don't have any outstanding tawbah. "O Allah reward brother Muhammad Safdar for his intentions and efforts and preserve him and increase his knowledge, wisdom and insight, and make him a light from whom the ummah will benefit greatly in this era and after he leaves this world for as long as You see fit, ameen"

[@BroHajji]

@@abuAbdul-Mumeetالسلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته آمين و اياك Apologies my brother if I haven’t responded to your messages. I don’t really monitor my DM’s. Please send me an email to [e-mail], as I am always monitoring my emails. بارك الله فيك

[@tariqtorafder4584]

Excellent video Mashallah

[@ThaqibJameil]

its the same thing for quranly too!!!! they are a uk registered limited company but have raised over £200000 through launchgood. ali dawah, hijab, zishan, muft menk, omar sulaim all support them. donations support their work but they take the profits for themself. how is that ethical? you should make video for that also.

[@BroHajji]

I did not know this. Thanks for bringing this to my attention بارك الله فيك I will need to dig deeper

[@razer0072073]

There's ALWAYS self-interest. When it comes to charities, courses, seminars, and retreats.

[@shahfaisal1382]

The Imams of Masjids in most part of Indian Subcontinent receive a meagre salary of 40 - 50 Dollars for a month... I mean they too have to earn and support their families... This is pathetic..On one side Millions of Dollars are being spent for organizing Islamic talks of prominent speakers and on the other side we have Muslim Imams who live a life of misery.The Muslim Ummah around the globe needs a complete reform, otherwise there seems no hope for the same.

[@DmightyzTROOPER]

Because the fuqahaa did not need to discuss rullings of (imams) living on a payroll in a land other than that of islam of which the rullings of being a resident are pretty clear with its context. Rather the ruler through the wizaar awqaaf is meant to stipulate a salary to all civil servents(even the caller to prayer) serving the state including the managing & running through obligation of necessity ; all islamic institutes & mosques as was done in the past

[@mh4841]

JazakAllah for your endeavour brother.

[@ambreenniazi5842]

Gatekeeping knowledge. Astughfirullah. Knowledge for the rich. جزاك الله خيرا for raising this issue.

[@tjscar2543]

To all muslims please fear Allah never take a penny off anyone for a cause for the sake of Allah and try and benefit

[@malipat5809]

Jzk Thank god for brothers like this, much needed in the ummah

[@maxkuijper000]

That 3950$ summit in turkey is hilarious, seemed like a top private school where only elite rich people can get in. the fact that they don't see it for what it is highlights a serious conern about the state of iman of those so-called Muslim leaders, it is seriously scary to see this happening.

[@bu_muawiyah]

Charity is not for Steve Jobs or Bill Gates. Charity is for the poor. Gifts (Hidayā) may be given to Jobs and Gates but not Sadaqah

[@harismalic5632]

Assalam u alaykum, This is why with the brothers of Tabligh there is a strict tarteeb of no asking for money or giving money while they are on Khurooj. It keeps their work sincere and pure as possible. Dawah is not for money, fame or gain.

[@muhammadabubakr648]

This is one thing I really like about them brothers they always seem extremely sincere

[@fullsendit292]

​@@muhammadabubakr648 tabligh is legit

[@kemchy3838]

If anything They have to sacrifice their own money to fund their Da'wah work. And they have to take time off work etc. that's another financial sacrifice

[@fullsendit292]

@@kemchy3838 yeah they are legit

[@earthwarden8548]

As someone whos been on jamaat i can tell you its the best way of dealing with money. We all put in for fuel cost and food and we all use it equally. When it comes to charging phone its 50p and shower is £1. Which we put in the masjid donation box individually. We spend from our wealth as that is one of the qualities of those who go in the path of Allah. It is sincere work and no other work is better for training your imaan and controlling your nafs

[@mohammeds3114]

This is much needed. While charities can game it by paying key people large salaries, private companies don't need to even pretend to use their funds for charitable purposes.

[@shinobi1_]

Dawah man desperately raised 42k for a studio yet he claims he earns multi 6-figures a year 😂

[@almurabitun]

He's a grifter

[@HarisAkhtarQuran]

One thing no one is talking about is how Muslim charities have been hiring pretty/good looking sisters to be the face of their operations on social media, and many of them go on trips around the world in groups with other young brothers. Something seems so off about that, it all seems very deliberate.

[@pallyali786]

This is a good video Bro Hajji. All we want is transparency. We have a right to know where our money goes.

[@Muztang010]

❤ may Allah help your cause

[@TommyCr7]

Jzkl bro hajji for sharing your financial records. May Allah purify your wealth. Ameen ❤

[@zahirsookoor2673]

"Private limited company" for charity. Hajji brought receipts 🔥🔥

[@tufiayub4975]

brother hajji i agree with almost all your points

[@AM91722]

I had to skip through the badr club promo. So much cringe lol.

[@fullsendit292]

i thought they stopped that?

[@salimaqil3491]

Thanks for the truth

[@theeagle2375]

From what i heard from brother ali dawah streams 1 prayer mat cost 6 euro or usd He donate it for free to people and dawah stall Some of the money also goes to the salat tutors and website and apps

[@yusufchowdhury5328]

$3500!!!! That’s like a trip for umrah 😅

[@jonascarlsson3]

Can be made for just 1k

[@shinobi1_]

Bro Hajji - question for clarification: I understand that organisations that raise money through the ummah by way of sadaqah must be fully transparent, but why are Muslim marriage coaches, and by extension, any Muslim coach, painted with the same brush? They are not charities, they are businesses. They do not 'use Islam to make money' like Dawah man and the badr club clearly do in their insulting advertising. They are simply marriage coaches for Muslims lol. Another example would be life coaches, productivity coaches or leadership coaches for Muslims. The same thing here - Muslims prefer to work with Muslims because they get the Islamic side to it and not just the non-Muslim Tony Robbins type side to it. I don't understand why these are being put under the same light unless of course their marketing is like Dawah man's. I'd love to hear why you've categorised them under the same umbrella as they are not 'commercializing Islam'

[@biggsubz3122]

Wow, this was an excellent breakdown, Jazakallah Khair for your efforts, May Allah preserve you

[@mahishahrear1483]

I find it so strange that it’s a company as opposed to registered charity

[@Mehmet_Fateh]

All charities are registered as companies first

[@MansoorAhmed-me5kf]

@@Mehmet_Fateh who said. show me the rule.

[@Mehmet_Fateh]

@@MansoorAhmed-me5kf I'm not going to respond to curt demands over the Internet. Ask politely, or do your own research.

[@MansoorAhmed-me5kf]

@@Mehmet_Fateh i asked impolitely because you are a bum. Rambling without knowledge. It is absolutely allowed and possible to register a company as charity instead of a private company in several countries in europe and america. The onus is on you to bring the proof when you make a bold statement.

[@07layla1]

Must respect to u brother, without this kind of accountability is good otherwise people become lazy and can lead to people taking advantage of the Ummah's wealth

[@jn6676]

Question about 'wa 3aamileen' those that are working in charity sector as one of the groups that can recieve sadaqah. Can they take for the charity work and or dawah work a percentage?

[@abahm9749]

No, the brother answered this in another video. The aamileen are those employed by the Islamic government. The charity workers today are classed as wukala.

[@tonysykes4917]

Asalaamu alayikum I’m not sure what I watched near the end of this video, the 2 guys with caps and glasses on. I converted to Islam almost 29 years ago, I’m working class bloke from Huddersfield. I’m sorry to say it’s cringe worthy to watch this sort of stuff. Plus all the plonkers at speakers corner. I almost feel like becoming a recluse.

[@Abul_kutub]

Keep up the good work

[@mecha_engineer]

May Allah bless you brother

[@user-sg8ts7lr6s]

Talk to them!!!!!!!!!!!

[@tanweerhussain5423]

Dauuuuuuuuuuud

[@Nuri989]

i just like how when you're a "real man" in the badr club you can no longer smile🤣. just dudes in jalaba mean mugging the camera

[@tiktokviral6218]

😂

[@abyrahman6610]

Dawah man has lost the plot!

[@youbamax]

How bro?

[@tiktokviral6218]

@@youbamaxhis just slandering typical

[@abdullahassaffah]

​@@youbamax from madkhali to now a fraud harram business

[@hasan1980hb]

Alpha males all the way!

[@MegaMucahid]

Salam alaikom brother Mohammed it is pleasing to see how a Muslim can speak openly about this masail because he has nothing to fear because this brother is working and has to obey only Allah only haqq is coming out of his mouth may Allah bless you

[@i.1303]

what an arrogance of the red pill club in an islamic vest... وَلَا تَمْشِ فِي الْأَرْضِ مَرَحًا ۖ إِنَّكَ لَن تَخْرِقَ الْأَرْضَ وَلَن تَبْلُغَ الْجِبَالَ طُولًا (37 سورة الإسراء)

[@lollollol234]

Bloody heck I went to a all enclusive resort for 10 days for 6 people with flights was 2800 😅

[@tjscar2543]

From where in the quran and sunnah or the salafus saliheen can we find they said oh u need help no worries come to my course and bring £499 and i will show u how to fix ur problem? Ya ikhwaan what is this? Why have the dua'aat and ulama gone so money hungry? La hawla wala quwata illa billaah

[@kitz8261]

may allah swt reward u bro, good video

[@Mohammad_ibn_Ansaar]

You should create the same video in questioning 5 pillars uk charity appeal

[@Freshplus3]

We need a nectar response

[@EliteArab89]

Brother his name is LoTfi not LoFti. In the stream you also said it wrong a couple of times 😅

[@comparativeislamapprentice9675]

I noticed that too.

[@IbnSaifi]

Those Yasir Qadhi retreats are always ridiculously expensive...

[@abdullahassaffah]

Not sure about him but they also demand living in expansive hotels which you use to pay for when getting them

[@sadofaraji5999]

​​@@abdullahassaffah if they are expensive to you dont call them,listen audio or go to youtube its free.

[@mujaddid40]

The badr club was cringe I actually thought it was a mockup for some satirical standup until I realised they were serious 😂

[@aminrahman4398]

Couldn't watch properly with that backdrop

[@YungShoe]

The problem I see, is the same as with the ‘Bitter Truth’ show: when we ask, we only get YOU ARE LAYMEN I HAVE A SHEIKH IN MAURITANIA WHO SAID ITS OK SO SU. But we need to know who when where (receipts)

[@sajirshad2261]

Good luck brother haji these people have arrogance in them and will not answer your video maybe Ali dawah might because sometimes he feels a bit guilty like the free mixing marriage thing.

[@nazkhan7141]

A believer doesn’t concern himself with someone else’s affairs which don’t concern him.

[@tiktokviral6218]

This concerns the umah you jahil

[@sol-hb8zg]

I swear umrah costs less than that summit lol

[@mjrstar3757]

They will get their reward according to their intention IA.

[@sfb1219]

It should be a business...

[@sweetsour4823]

The Andrew Tate Effect @31:00 🤮

[@user-qj5nb5tg1d]

I feel like if the brothers you are talking about the deen and creating content educating the people especially the youth for free on yt if they want to capitalise on different parts of their social media platforms to have a stream of income I think its okay, if they are doing things that might seem out of hand for some people, the greater good is being achieved. These people most likely sacrificed their lives (large percentage of there years) on learning and teaching the deen I think its okay for them to earn as a source of livelihood. These people, usually are not looked after by the community via of sadaqah jariyah because people are not learned on supporting the ulamah, they are people - like us, with families to feed - like us so if they want to capitalise on some of there content and by my knowledge forgive me if I'm wrong its usually not a lot based on a subscription type payment plan most of the time, let them be. Anything good I've said is from allah and anything evil I've said is from shaitan.

[@jn6676]

19min. So there are only 313 real men in the ummah today, lol

[@razer0072073]

2:00

[@hasan1980hb]

I love how the badr club are trying to deepen their voice to seem more alpha 😂 come join the badr club so I can go to battle (restaurants) on your bank account!

[@ThaqibJameil]

It's the same thing with Quranly. They are UK registered limited company but have raised over £200,000 via charity! Charity money funds their work, then they make profit for themselves! Shameless tactics. Ali Dawah, Smile2Jannah, Mohammed Hijab all promote them!!!! So does Mufti Menk and Omar Suleiman.

[@Quail_Dad]

The dawah man clip was so cringey

[@Shiroyashasama]

That badr video is cringe and the first time he proposed that bs he came on clubhouse and we called him a scammer and he got mad

[@mrahman2897]

Bro that background is so offputting and Nausiating!

[@AadilKhan-my8wd]

Hahaha BADR CLUB !!😂🤣😂

[@varunkumarr8606]

The dawahman one was so cringe

[@deathcador]

Your questioning is correct, but when you're making assumption of how he (Ali) makes the profit out of it that's wrong, you can easily fell into slander by doing that, you should careful bro.

[@toutvabien3406]

You are not to backbite or slander anyone. Allah is All-Knowing. Anyone who is not correct will have to face Allah on the day of judgment.

[@Asadkhan-pe2je]

Nothing wrong with what your requesting but ask in a more courteous manner. Why don't you ask for a meeting one on one and then confirm this, people will benefit more from your work and you will be providing reassurance to them.

[@BroHajji]

Courteous? I wasn’t disrespectful or rude. I don’t need to deal with this privately, as he is demanding money publicly, so I have the same right to ask for transparency publicly. I am not accusing any one of foul play. For your information I haven’t donated, but it’s the Ummah’s wealth and we have a right to request transparency. It’s upon the believers to follow up and those requesting the donations to provide evidence of expenditure. و الله اعلم

[@Asadkhan-pe2je]

@@BroHajji I support what you doing, it's resonates with me but We would really like see to an outcome from a one on one interview and these matters addressed openly for the benefit of the ummah, otherwise we have KZbin wars, one party does a video, the other then does one back with a bit angst.

[@BroHajji]

I agree habibi, but having a one to one would not resolve any issues as it does not affect me personally rather it’s an issue which has been brought to the public domain once they requesting funding publicly. I don’t enjoy this brother, but sometimes the hard conversations need to be had. Once again, I’m not accusing any one of maliciousness or foul play, but we need transparency by way of documentation, as this issue has been ignored for far too long و الله اعلم جزاك الله خيرا

[@1nternallyy]

​@@BroHajjiDon't have you have his number, aren't you both acquaintances ? Why didn't you contact him yourself without making a KZbin video about it ?

[@HH-fr2gx]

@@BroHajji Assalamualaikum. And maybe that's where you went wrong because Badr Club was something they did in the past and they closed down due to some backlash. They admitted this on their recent podcasts and mentioned something how they should have consulted their sheikh for permission prior to running with. If you look now, they have a free podcast and educate others freely on similar topics. To go straight to making a video on something they stopped doing was incorrect. You should have contacted them, I'm sure they would have been transparent.

[@cubant2258]

😂bro Dawah man was driving a merc GLE new shape the man is here to make money

[@cclan9940]

and do not exchange My verses for a small price [i.e., worldly gain]. Surat Al ma-ida O my people! I do not ask you for a payment for this ˹message˺. My reward is only from Allah. Surat HUD. The sahabas used their DOUNIA for ISLAM Some people today are using ISLAM for their DOUNIA Action will be judged by our -real- intention

[@MM-me8xh]

You don’t know how much these people are helping the Gazans. You should not be dividing the Ummah in such an important time. Please stop backbiting and slandering.

[@toutvabien3406]

You don't know how much these people are working for the Palestinian cause. You'd better be stay away from backbiting.

[@m_saqibali]

Did you reach out to him? I'm pretty sure you didn't 😅

[@BroHajji]

I don’t need to, as he is demanding money publicly, so I have the same right to ask for transparency publicly. I am not accusing any one of foul play.

[@m_saqibali]

@@BroHajji but aren't you a part of the problem? You could have approached him privately where he could have provided receipts/explanations but instead you'd prefer an online response from him to create some online drama.

[@BroHajji]

It’s the ummah’s money. I don’t need to see the receipts the ummah does. We can agree to disagree.

[@m_saqibali]

@@BroHajji From the two options you had - you chose clout

[@slmcodes]

@@m_saqibali how can you judge his intentions? if someone is publicly doing something they can be publicly rebuked/questioned, nothing wrong with that. judging the intentions is a more severe problem that you should look into.

[@SonGoku-io7sh]

This is not a new thing, people have been making ridiculous profits in the name of Islam forever. I remember going into Islamic book shops as a kid and wondering why these were so expensive. Even now it isn't easy buying fiqh books and other resources to study Islam. The issues you have mentioned are an evolution of a sickness which these people inherited.

[@sufyan2297]

You won't hear shamsi asking for money like these other "dawah" people!

[@Snippets635]

Saudi funded, doesn’t need to ask…. Duhhhhh

[@mohammed_888]

​@@Snippets635😂😂😂

[@tiktokviral6218]

@@Snippets635😂😂😂

[@sufyan2297]

@Snippets635 at least he's not begging the ummah for their hard earned money! Saudi if he gets it from them can afford it 🤣

[@umeraziz1533]

@@Snippets635 r u dumb akh have u seen his masjid😂😂😂 go and see Masjid Daar us Sunnah and u dont even have proof

[@Omar_Akhs]

Badr club Spending Ramadhaan in dubai Must of been alot of maza hehehe

[@beardbrosfoodtravelshow5824]

Salam walikum brother Excellent vidoe you have made my brother! These munfiqeen are doing the same as the kafirs profiting off the deen! Look at how the sahabs teaches deen to the people and look at the people now teaching the deen to the people getting rich and enjoying life this is what our beloved nabi kareem saw taught us???

[@faisaliqbal3679]

Ali dawah won't respond to you

[@Snippets635]

He has a relationship with Ali, why doesn’t even just approach him?… this sort of behaviour is quite snakey especially if you have a relationship with someone

[@mohammed_888]

Out of everyone mentioned, I think bro ali dawah will be the only one to respond

[@faisaliqbal3679]

@mohammed_888 hajji don't have enough subscribers for Ali to respond.

[@faisaliqbal3679]

@Snippets635 public appeals for funding require private conversations? If that's the case Ali should of fundraised privately too

[@slmcodes]

@@Snippets635 no need to do it privately since everybody is publicly raising money.

[@ryanbrownx1]

I'm getting tired of this.

[@equityjustice2695]

😕 Your comment on Ali dawah is disturbing, why make him look like a cheat. Don't you fear the anger of Allah swt for slandering him. Shame on you. You could have just asked him for the info and published it. Or ask Ali to publish it. You sound like a gossip with all your speculations. How do you know he is making a profit? You have no evidence 🧾 yet your saying you're sure. That's slandering him.

[@BrotherYusuf]

Maths is fun is all I will say

[@mjrstar3757]

Dawaman is a joke

[@muhammadabdurahman3317]

Khalfi are you 😂

[@mouazzamhussain4172]

Ali needs Dawah aka Goat boy at it again 😂

[@AAm-ff3xn]

Dawah dog

[@astro_jimmy3000]

I don't have a problem paying for islamic services. We pay for everything else.....yet have a problem paying for islamic services.😢

[@BroHajji]

You can pay extortionate costs for Islamic services, that’s your decision. We will not allow our religion to be commercialized. The ummah asking for transparency is the bare minimum when collecting money on behalf of the ummah.

[@astro_jimmy3000]

@BroHajji Brother.....there are far too many divisive Muslims videos online. Do we really need another one at this time? As long as they're imparting correct knowledge, I don't mind if they make money. Like I said we pay for everything else. To me, it's like writing a book and then selling it in a bookstore. This is a waste of your time and resources, brother.....there is no baraka in what you're doing.

[@AM91722]

@@astro_jimmy3000 It's seeking sadaqah donations for private business ventures which is the issue. Selling Islamic goods is obviously no issue. But fund the business yourself, especially if you're already wealthy. It would be different if they were offering the people who donate shares in the businesses.

[@astro_jimmy3000]

@@AM91722 I can't speak to that as I have no inside knowledge.....and Allah swt knows best.

[@tiktokviral6218]

19:00 the brothers in the comment section were saying cringe but man I was not ready 🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️😂

[@Salaman980]

@Hamza's Den

[@abdullahassaffah]

Badr club is dead and dusted

[@beardbrosfoodtravelshow5824]

This is the muslims money they should know where there money is going if a perosn is getting mad 😠 😡 that proves that person is a thief a munfiq!

[@Smell.My.Cheese]

18:36 I nearly died of cringe

[@fromtheperiphery]

Selling their deen for a miserable price.