The Kulture Study: ATEEZ 'Turbulence' MV REACTION & REVIEW

Want to help keep the channel alive? Support us on patreon @ patreon.com/formoftherapy
Want to just make a one time donation? You can donate to the channel via PAYPAL: [e-mail]
Watch the original video here: • ATEEZ(에이티즈) - ‘야간비행 (T...
For business & professional inquiries only:
[e-mail]
Follow us on social media @formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
#ATEEZ #turbulence #에이티즈 #야간비행

[@kellenft7015]

the last "oh" melody is literally Wave's melody and I think that's beautiful ♥️ *cries in hakuna matata

[@marssnow7985]

yes. it fits since Fever series came before Treasure series. Also Wave is the song that brings them 1st win :') it's like telling people that don't give up, one day that day when we win will come.

[@nellurban7826]

I get chills every time I hear it

[@felixssausages840]

@@marssnow7985 yes exactly

[@claudeernestbarcelona2465]

We weren’t expecting this song to drop, but we are somehow in a time where we actually needed to hear this song.

[@80zpauer9]

For real tho

[@nineplustentwentyone26]

This is the real reason why ateez drop the music that they do pun intended

[@kpopscenario1406]

Yea

[@jooniecbz3832]

I get chills every time I see Wooyoung flying with Jongho's vocals EVERY SINGLE TIME. One of the most beautiful moments in 4th gen music.

[@bettatwilight]

YES. I was holding on the whole time but when that scene came I broke down ugly crying. It's so powerful ❤

[@luvletter93]

ARGH ikr sending feeeelssss

[@beatricep103]

Side note, you know how we all agree that Answer was like, their grand finale to the Treasure era? I honestly think that Turbulence is just as an epic conclusion to this era as Answer was for theirs. In a different way obviously, way more emotional. But it's fitting, since the Zero era put more emphasis on exploring different emotions and feelings anyways (desperation, celebration, frustration, attraction, happiness, sadness...), whereas Treasure was more focused on that pirate swagger, as PD likes to call it lol We don't know if this is going to be the official title track to this epilogue ep or if there's gonna to be more, but for me, if it is, it's the perfect ending already!

[@FoxMario9512]

Theres gonna be 2 title tracks , turbulence and the real (heung version ) !

[@justjimmy1906]

I like how Fever Part start with Inception n Thankxx then end with Turbulance n The Real.

[@munchkin5679]

I totally agree, it feels like a finale x

[@DrMomT]

I graduated from high school in 1979 so I'm definitely an older Atiny, and this song reminds me of the power ballads/anthems I loved in the 70's and 80's. I'm a vocalist so I'm always a fan of songs that show off vocals and I really appreciate being able to hear the individual members and their vocal timbres. I got into K-Pop December 2020, falling in love and falling down the Astro rabbit hole. My eldest daughter has consistently campaigned to get me into Ateez and she's succeeded. Back in March, when she was bombarding me with links to Ateez songs, I said "That guy, Yeosang, doesn't get enough lines--we need to hear more of his singing." I've also wondered why he didn't get more lines. After hearing more from him, I think that maybe one of the issues is that Yeosang has a deep, rich voice but he is still working on finding his niche when it comes to singing in Ateez songs. His cover of "Me After You" is from early 2020 and he sings very softly at the lowest part and seems to be still not that confident switching to his higher range. I think it would be easy for his lines to "get lost" in the mix of some of the other voices of Ateez--the louder and more confident ones. "Turbulence" uses his voice in a way where he is paired in duos responding back and forth to each other and his voice quality, which has a raw passion, really suits the song and how it is utilized keeps his voice from getting overwhelmed by the others. He's young and I think that with continuing vocal lessons and experience, we'll hear more from Yeosang, which would make me and apparently lots of other people, very happy!

[@DrMomT]

Here's a link to "my boy's" cover of "Me After You." kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYSUiquZeK6jl8U Can't wait to watch his continuing progress with his singing because "8 makes 1 team" is always better when we get to hear all of their voices coming together!

[@potaytowpopotee4580]

Ikr huhuhu :') he needs to show his vocal more!!! His voice suits to sing ballad!! Btw, if u love songs that shows off vocals. You can also check SVT songs. They're one of the few groups that has a strong vocal line. Even the rappers can sing well.

[@mochiyeosang1908]

YES JUST YES i'm also a (semi) trained singer and yeosang and wooyoung have my favorite vocal colors in ateez (san and jongho close behind). i'm just waiting for the day i get to tell yeosang how goddamn beautiful his voice is at like a fansign or something.

[@DrMomT]

@@potaytowpopotee4580 Oh yes, I've dipped a little into Seventeen and particularly love their ballads/soft songs! I have quite a few of them on my playlist. I even own a couple of their albums because I'm "old school" and own a boom box that I take around to where I'm doing chores or outside for parties, and SVT albums add a lot to my mix of songs.

[@DrMomT]

@@mochiyeosang1908 I hope you get that chance! I'm always so intrigued by the unique vocal tones that people have and love how those differences can add so much texture and interest when people sing together. I'm a fairly new Atiny so I haven't had that much chance to look into each of them and their voices individually, but Wooyoung is definitely on my radar to check out.

[@lightopxia]

I think that ever since Fever part 1, they have described these eras as trying to convey that in life it’s okay if you don’t know what you’re doing, if you’re lost, that even when the unknown is scary, day by day you can overcome it, and that at some point everyone feels like they have no idea what the future holds, that you’re not alone. And it not only makes their songs incredibly relatable, but it also makes you feel better. It bothers me so much when people on the internet (Im looking at you stan twitter) say that all Ateez songs sound the same, think that, for people that have only listened to their tittle tracks, they may not be familiar with the soft emotional side of Ateez, but they’ve really been doing a great job at giving us this kind of emotional songs, maybe not exactly in the same style as turbulence, but for example: twilight, light, MIST, with you, sunrise, star 1117, fever, take me home, and most recently with not too late. Man, I remember listening to “One day at a time” for the first time and crying my eyes out because it felt like something I really needed to hear in that moment. That’s what this songs feels like, a message of reassurance and almost like a hug of “hey, it’s okay”. Loved how they brought back the iconic line “Passion, young fever” loved the back and forth between Yunho and Yeosang, I loved Mingi’s verse, even more when one stops and thinks on how much they’ve gone through as a group this year alone. In my opinion, Turbulence is going to be one of those songs that you listen every time you’re sad. They really knocked it out of the park.

[@valentina.strmecki]

i agree!

[@meow-el7ce]

fr one day at a time was my comfort song

[@edenshelovely500]

One day at a time, maybe will be my forever comfort song

[@nineplustentwentyone26]

A beautiful description of everything I feel when I listen to Ateez's music. Everything is so comforting. Especially their b-sides. Their title tracks give me the energy I need to go through a long day.

[@ubu8]

Everytime i see the line "ateez songs sound the same"..i laugh in "Thanxx" and "Star117" and many other songs like these even their title tracks sound distinctly different even with them adding their previous title tracks intro in some of the new title tracks like treasure intro in say my name..and wave intro in turbulence yet they sound completely different😂😂

[@luluntuli9254]

answer and inception passed the baton on to turbulence; extremely powerful vocal layers, high emotional factor and some classic epic ateez momentum leading up to the last chorus and outro i pulled out tears for this song it’s incredible to see a group being able to pull off a concept like fireworks and go straight into deja vu and now this… versatility at its finest

[@mochiyeosang1908]

dude answer and inception are literally my favorite title tracks of theirs it makes sense why i love this song so much

[@cyndi1639]

I personally think Yeosang's voice is a bit too deep for some of their brighter songs or songs with high climax - hence why his opening was perfect for this song because the ending was just so explosive. He has said that he is more confident now so hopefully they can give him more lines!

[@iiamshayyy9570]

It’s actually the hook to wave that you hear at the end, and I think that’s amazing considering joong said that the fever series comes before the treasure series.

[@munchkin5679]

Ah I didn't think about that! That's so cool. Its like the Treasure ruff at the end of the Say my name MV

[@ruzenaprivett3161]

Agree with most of the comments and yours in that Yeosang and Wooyoung got fewer lines but the ones they did get were extremely powerful. Yeosang has really been coming into his own as far as these last couple eras. His newfound confidence may have shown a little differently in Fireworks and especially Deja Vu (*cough* *cough*) but that's all important too as far as the end game of being an overall confident performer. Both he and Wooyoung have softer vocals that may in some ways require more time and training in order to stand out. But it's clear the difference that's already being made and how much they're growing. With Wooyoung's lines in particular you can hear how much stronger and clearer he sounds. It's probably a combination of him working really hard and the song giving him some great space to do his thing but the couple lines he does get in this one are extremely impactful. I've noticed a lot of reactors don't even realize at first that it's him singing there. That sort of desperate-sounding way he often lets off his last notes (Dreamers is another good example) worked really really well for this song.

[@beatricep103]

Tbh I was waiting for them to release a title track that reflects their emotional side! Because while they are (rightfully) know for their intense and high energy songs, we know that they excel in emotionally driven songs too. It was really about time they gave us one as title track, I am so happy! Tbh it could be considered a risky move for KQ, the producers and Ateez, since they haven't done this before, but it really shows how they wanted to expand their repertoire and explore and push themselves. And I believe it'll pay off. Also, that throwback to Wave at the end made me fucking emotional man

[@kellylima649]

That’s it!! I get REALLY frustrated seeing K-pop Stan’s saying that 4gen boy groups only make noisy all-the-same music! I know most of the time this criticism is directed to SKZ (which is a group that I also like but I’m not really familiar with their discography), but I can’t SEE how these listeners can say that if they really get familiar with Ateez songs!! Even only the title tracks and b-sides they have promoted so far (like wave, answer and inception), it’s not only the pop-club-hardcore music

[@aki6605]

I first watched this when I was on my way home in the bus. If there weren't other people in there and I wouldn't be to embarrassed, I would have cried. The song speaks to me on so many levels, I would have ugly cried so hard xD Something interesting to this MV: None of the members are ever seen together in this MV. I think that speaks so much as well

[@scottievm6868]

The members all being separated struck me, too, and makes this so much more visually powerful.

[@MarshMarllowART]

I was thinking that this song was probably how the members felt leading up to their first win. They didn't know what kind of idol to become, what they had to do, and were just uncertain of their future in general. So when *they all* sang the intro to Wave at the end of this song, it was like them breathing a sigh of relief, cause their "flight" landed safely or at least got out of the "turbulence" that worried them 🥺 Also, this song was probably made a while ago, cause Hongjoong said on his PM that he got emotional after listening to turbulence again and that he messaged Eden (their producer/his mentor) and said something along the lines of "thank you for letting us/helping us get this far" 😭😭 Edit: Oh yeah, from what I understand, the members and Eden figure out the line distribution by letting all the members sing the whole song and just picking and choosing who sounds the best at what part. For Yeosang, I think he said somewhere that he was a bit shy with his vocal parts at first, but now he's more comfortable with getting more lines! So I hope they get to utilize his voice more, it really suits the warm/mellow parts of their songs :")

[@edenshelovely500]

Wait, this makes sense. This totally makes sense.

[@Megan-bw5zh]

You were right about the melody at the end sounding like the treasure era, it's literally a melody from Wave!

[@cixglowing]

this song was directed by the same team that did inception!! thats why it has this very cinematic visual and i love it so much

[@gemmasmith1667]

I love Turbulence as a title track as like... representative of certain songs in their discography like Mist and Take Me Home and One Day At A Time that are almost always counted among fan's top songs. That raw emotional power is something Ateez does SO WELL and stands out for but doesn't necessarily get the credit they deserve for, along with their vocals as a whole. Turbulence instantly shot up to my top 5. I love the themes of the song and music video going along with the transition out of youth. One thing that really resonated with me was that they all seem to be in different places or stages at the end. Wooyoung's taken off, Hongjoong started running, San got off the bus, Yeosang is still in the classroom looking at the sky. It reminded me of the Fever Part 2 teaser with 'the stars in the sky could not be seen because people never raised their heads' and the climax Turbulence having the lyric 'I can see it there, follow the lights'. With Yeosang, he absolutely hasn't had the amount of presence on songs that he deserves, and I get the feeling that they perhaps didn't know how best to utilize his voice with the rest, but I also see a lot of changes coinciding with the way his confidence seems to have gone up a lot this last year and I can only hope that we just get more and more because his voice is stunning.

[@breelix8672]

Hongjoong's rap at the end paired along with Wooyoung climbing in the sky gives a feeling of elevating higher and higher and that part is what hit the song straight home for me. I've got goosebumps. The song was well put together for a ballad and its minimalistic nature suited it very well.

[@misun4086]

Turbulence kind of shows Ateez's musical self taking a solid shape and the scenery of their growth which looks magnificent! it gives me so much pride as a fan and so much power as a human being I think it marks a milestone for both Ateez and Atiny

[@jenny0491]

i love what you say about yeosangs parts. I think Wooyoung has gotten more lines over the time but he used to also get little to no parts. But he always got killing parts and center parts which gave him opportunity to stand out. I would love for Yeosang to get more impactful moments and center choreo if the line distribution is still lacking.

[@martinaruffovicino9007]

the last part of the song, the “oooh ohh” is wave’s begin, a happy song about living and being together

[@isaaldunce2783]

Songs usually don't make me cry, but this one broke me. I love it so much, it gives me chills every time I listen to it. Also, the song is so emotional that I actually appreciate the simplicity of the MV and how cinematic it is.

[@Elizabeth-tx3wn]

"At the end of all this turbulence, there is a light"

[@innoutt8351]

Yeosang did so well in this song we need more bass-baritone voice to balance the harmony please let him sing more Mr. Eden :(

[@Yar5952]

He has such a deep voice! How would it suit ATEEZ :( come on Eden if you can give our Maltese more lines

[@harlaylaymarie]

I love this song. When I first listened to it I thought "this would have been a great Japanese title track" because the song gives me that emotional end of an anime finale feeling

[@gyuuuuuuu5182]

Omg this is what i thought at first 🥺

[@Redd_Meneses]

Your wish has granted! We are getting Turbulence Japanese version coming on their Japanese album release Beyond Zero!

[@am-gg1lg]

the "woah~" tune at the end is actually the instrumental to wave! On top of the song lyrics being very hopeful and comforting that little inclusion of wave really ties into that message. Turbulence reassuring its okay to have uncertainties bc there will be a time where you'll be able to face the journey ahead of you, that time here being wave and the message of that song. I just really love that part bc it connects both the treasure series w fever not necessarily in terms of storyline, but in terms of what the message of series has been. Really takes the song to another emotional level

[@Misha-fv2vd]

I almost cry every time I watch this video it's something about the acting and the song all together TT TT

[@hongjoongsbutterfly]

My two favorite moments of this MV/song: Yunho's falsettos, and the scene where the paper (plane) gets torn from Hongjoong's hand and flies down the tunnel and all the lights light up as it goes. I was so struck by both of those things the very first watch through and continue to be every time I watch it. I can't get through the song without crying yet, either. I am lucky enough to get to see them in concert next month (first time!) and I don't know how I'm going to survive this performance.

[@ruzenaprivett3161]

Still crying even after 3 days and countless Turbulence streams and reaction videos. Like you said, this song is just special. It came out right when it was supposed to and it's reached a lot of people who really needed it. It was the right time for Ateez and for us. It's just so powerful.

[@mirsolus7789]

This song made me cry. I am already having a hard time because of Uni finals and this just made me break.

[@xeniasnoir7815]

Same. I was a mess when it came out. 😭

[@brendenlim2158]

Good luck.... last weekend grind :(

[@ikkyoda7098]

Ateez’s discography is just the best in kpop. Speaking as multistan

[@InsomniaDC]

This song is so BEAUTIFUL

[@talesofsymphonia295]

I really didn't expect an MV to be released for this song and I'm all for how they shot and produced it! The lyrics really resonated me, this year especially, and I got goosebumps throughout the entire song. Looking at the whole album lineup, it's gonna be up there as one of my favourite ATEEZ albums.

[@wacksound]

I definitely enjoy ATEEZ's more emotional music. I feel like this song was needed after Take Me Home was relegated to a B-side. A lot of the fans wanted to get the feelings out with ATEEZ. I love that they can switch from a dance track like Horizon or Dazzling Light, to this so seamlessly. It doesn't feel awkward or out of place. Their music feels very intentional, which I appreciate as a fan.

[@barbarac6095]

Honestly, I think Turbulence is my favourite song of theirs, I love all of them of course, but this song just makes me feel so much, I literally cried at the last part of it

[@illurora4285]

on the topic of turbulence's music video style, i think they intentionally did it in such a way so it calls back to the diary film which was released last year before thanxx/inception dropped. as a song it does fit the overarching theme of youth and the unknown future which has been present throughout the fever series, and the music video calling back to this message as well as the diary film gives it a much bigger impact in combination with a song which seeks to comfort those who are lost in their journey to the future.

[@juliana-xu9kw]

the outro with hongjoong is my favorite part like wow it hits SO different. there's something so emotional and even comforting about it idek how to explain

[@shelbystrand5592]

Regarding what you said in terms of Yeosang's line distribution, he's actually slowly starting to get more lines as well as the memorable parts, starting in Fever era (at least in my opinion). I do think KQ could do better with putting him in the front for the choreography more though so he could have more camera time since he does consistently get the least amount of lines. However with the consideration that it is an 8-member group with others who are main-vocalists and rappers when the songs can get rap heavy, I actually don't think he has that bad of a line distribution, especially since it seems like KQ has been working on which lines and he should deliver. But that doesn't mean I don't want more for him overall too!

[@insane_t1605]

really i dont see the number increasing

[@amya6939]

@@insane_t1605 same here, the only time im okay with the distribution is when he has center like deja vu, but if you see their songs like illusion, ( kind of )wave, answer, and so forth, they really under utilized his skills. He needs more lines

[@nashwaf9]

@@insane_t1605 in debut era, he got 1 line in pirate king and 1/2 a line in treasure ... now is definitely better but there is a long way to go

[@insane_t1605]

@@nashwaf9 he still got 1 line and adlib like In pirate king iirc he did the humming for pirate king

[@mr_mikrokosmos]

when you said that ending "woahhh" sound reminiscent of treasure era, you were right! it's actually directly from wave, just sadder :')

[@Avi.joyyy12]

This song is absolutely beautiful, and the lyrics are something we all need to hear!!

[@me1onade]

its the raw emotion in their voices that gets me the most; having an emotional song is one thing, but if you dont sing it with any emotion to it, it's just... it doesn't sound good. but ateez just always deliver, and this is another example. their voices carry the emotion of the song and thats what always gets me in a song like this. especially if the lyrics hit close to home... this song was a huge gift for me

[@me1onade]

this song literally feels like you're being hugged during a depressive episode

[@babymetalic]

i know u already heard eternal sunshine but whether it be on here or in ur own time u should watch the mv if u havent already!! its rlly cute

[@illurora4285]

another comment from me, i love how they call back to the night sky very often (both visually and lyrics-wise) SPECIFICALLY dark night skies; when you illustrate night skies as a feeling you can invoke two different types depending on the visualisation: a sense of calm and comfort when there are lights, stars or the moon present, or a sense of uncertainty and discomfort when those lights are not present. in a song which really emphasises the message of uncertainty and assurance, i think the use of such dark settings visually really does show those feelings and makes the viewer feel just as uncertain, to which when the last chorus hits, and the lights begin to shine brighter, there's a feeling of being safe, assured, knowing that you can always still take that step, you just have to believe in yourself and believe that you are on the right path.

[@samminicksm]

*disclaimer*: Wooyoung and Yeosang are literally my biases. I love them to the moon and back. Something to be said for Yeosang’s and Wooyoung’s line distributions: Of the vocal line, those two probably are the “weakest”, and **I say that in quotes because I mean they have the least vocal training.** Yeosang and Wooyoung were primarily dancers/visuals/performers before they debuted. You can really see their growth just between predebut and debut when it comes to their singing. From the beginning, you can see Jongho, San, and Seonghwa especially had a head start training-wise when it came to vocals. Yunho had less training than those three (because he was primarily a dancer) but more than Woo and Yeo. As time has gone on, the growth from vocal training and in confidence has been immense. I think we’re just now seeing them really take more prominent lines now that they themselves are gaining more stability to perform live while maintaining their position as dancers. Because that’s another thing. Their lines have been limited, therefore the performances have become heavily reliant on them to be dancing hard for the nearly the entire song. Yeosang is usually framing the rap line(Deja Vu is a really good example) and Wooyoung frequently leads dance breaks (Say My Name and Fireworks come to mind) especially when Jongho is singing adlibs and has to stand still for stability. Maintaining that level of activity and picking up extra vocal lines (because ATEEZ rarely ever uses backtracking during live performances) is really hard on singers. Jongho pointedly doesn’t dance as hard as Wooyoung and Yeosang throughout most performances because he sings at least 20% of every song, so he needs to conserve energy. San, Seonghwa, and Yunho are prime examples of where Woo and Yeo are/are headed as far as vocal ability. All three of them can maintain vocal stability and dance at near full strength. You can tell when one is about to sing because their moves lighten up a bit to give them time to get their breathing under control, it’s subtle and hard to catch because of their training, but it’s there. Breath control like that is hard to train, and that’s what they’ve been doing. Their immortal songs and KD performances have proven that Woo and Yeo are finally getting to the point where they can be confident enough to pick up more lines.

[@mr_mikrokosmos]

i think this might be my favorite ateez music video and one of my favorite atz title tracks (answer and wonderland are still up there though)

[@ateezlideresdela4ta100]

ATEEZ is coming back on Friday DECEMBER 10TH with their new album ZERO: FEVER EPILOGUE and the title track the real. ...

[@nuvas3242]

This whole video just made me realize how freaking proud I am of Ateez and their team. This is exactly the kind of song I've been waiting for from them, and I'm so glad they made it a title track, and released it first, for this song to get all the glory it deserves. (Also thank you so much pd for your in-depth videos as always ! They're so informative and I notice so many new things that just make me appreciate the song/MV so much more)

[@pnandi]

9:57 I think the fact that Yeosang doesn't get much lines is slowly shifting into the unfair line distribution territory. During the early days when ateez had debuted, he indeed wasn't that confident with his voice so it was natural that he had less parts. Eventually though, he mentioned specifically in an interview that he would like to do more or have more parts in title tracks but even after countless comebacks, it is still the same. This is sad because you can clearly see that this bothers him and in fan calls whenever anyone mentions how they love his voice he seems genuinely surprised. I might seem bitter (and I really am a little), but I wish he had few more lines. At least, if the producers think his voice doesn't suit much in the TTs they can give him more parts in the bsides as well but even that doesn't happen. Im so happy to see Yunho get a fair amount of lines here in turbulence because even he was under utilised I believe. But personally, out of all the vocalists, I love Yeosang's deep, warm, soothing tone the most and it sucks that he sings only for a very few seconds. I was hoping to hear him more at least towards the end, so as much as I love the song, it also was a bit of a disappointment - both in terms of the lack of lines and screentime for Yeo. I hope to god they improve this in future comebacks or do something with their storyline which can explain Yeosang's constant absence.

[@Yar5952]

I think the same :((( Comback in July 🤞🏾

[@JessicaLopez-wc4oh]

Tears. Down my face. Mascara. Down my face.

[@emilykerr5154]

It's similar to the Oneus situation with Yeosang and Wooyoung as there confidence has grown so has the number of lines they them selves have said this

[@juanantonioromoreta8865]

This song is soooooooo beautiful

[@Maggiekls]

I have been waiting for this!!! Thank you pd🔥🔥

[@MistyIsles]

This song hit me so hard, and I think it hits even harder emotionally every time I listen to it. Even more than a song about hope as you said, I'd almost describe it as a desperate prayer FOR hope. Which is why the shot I just can't get over is the one that transitions from Mingi with his hands folded to Yunho looking up out the window, almost like they can hear each other's silent call. It gives me chills every time.

[@jigglyvids]

this song is BEAUTIFUL, the production is top tier I am so excited for the comeback! hopefully they get some long rest after though ateez has had such a busy last half of 2021!

[@jerico6851]

breathtaking title track i must say, one of the best releases for me this 2021

[@Daphienie]

EDEN used to work with BTOB (Missing You, Beautiful Pain etc) so I was surprised in the genre shift when I first got to know ATEEZ earlier this year. I get a bit of the part in Missing you where they all sang together without music near the end. I LOVE THIS SO MUCH

[@l123tiny]

I'm happy that we got more Yeosang. His voice is my favorite and it makes me sad that kq doesn't use it enough

[@aleruz31]

when you said that the ending was very reminiscent of the treasure era just gave me goosebumps because the ending melody is the same melody in the beginning of Wave! and wave is such a bright and hopeful song so the fact that they decided to tie Turbulence and Wave together just speaks a lot on their artistry

[@letylopez6815]

My first time I heard of them was when I saw a reel with this song and I knew I had to look up the video and I’m glad because from that I was able to listen to a lot more of their songs and honestly they’re so good.

[@egghead168]

I literally cried when i first listened to this song!! It's SUCH A BEAUTIFUL AND AMAZING SONG😭💞💞💞💞💞 Ps: Turbulence somehow gave me the same feeling/vibe "Answer" gave me when i listened to it. The same emotions🥺🥺🥺

[@Shayed07121997]

this might be my new favorite ateez song. its just.. wow.

[@Shayed07121997]

"this is the kind of bside that you wish would get a mv" exactly what I thought when i first listened to it. Fever was that song for me before, a beautiful song that deserved an MV. this is kind of the same thing

[@JRHunter-ys5ft]

It’s trending on 25th on music! I really love this song so much and it’s so emotional. Ateez really knows how to make you feel things.

[@notsokeen]

Happy Monday! I put off listening to this song (only for a day, mind you) because I saw other reaction channels hinting that the song made them cry. I cry easily, especially when it comes to music. As I predicted, I was fighting tears upon first viewing (and all subsequent ones). I am the same age as most of the ATEEZ members, so the lyrics resonated a whole lot; I also become more sentimental during autumn/winter, so that made the song hit a lot harder than I originally anticipated. I agree with you on loving Yunho's voice; he is one of my biases and while I love seeing him dance, I would love to hear more of his singing, too! INCEPTION also has a special place in my heart (I did a short dance cover of it and it's one of my favorite performances I've done), but I see myself listening to Turbulence a lot more this season. My partner loves INCEPTION and enjoyed Deja Vu, so I look forward to playing this in the car when it's my turn with the AUX. Sending support from Hawaii, always! Take care and stay cozy.

[@BeWithATEEZ619]

fun fact: i heard eden, the producer for ateez, mentioning before that essentially all of the members "audition" for lines so he listens to all of the members sing all of the parts and then decides which members get which lines from there and yeosang has mentioned before too that he wasn't as comfortable getting many lines yet but he's been gaining confidence and wanting more lines nowadays! I love love love that he had more lines that were impactful in the beginning of this and i think they really suited his voice and matched well with yunho's as well!!! this song really showcased all of the members' vocal abilities and showed off their voices as well so beautifully! wanna hear more of their voices all the time ^_^ thank you for the review of this music video :)

[@Beanjuicemom]

I was looking for your reaction video to this song and 3 mins later…it’s up! Lol 🙌🏼 And I totally agree about yeosang. I loved that they put him in the beginning and I hope to see/hear more of him in future songs!

[@zareennawar7951]

Love Yeosang's voice cause he seems to be have the type of deep voice that Taehyungie has and just so much can be done with his voice D':

[@amya6939]

Same hereee we need to hear more

[@multitoolss636]

As someone whi has been pained by Yeosangs line distribution, they have defenitely recently tried to give yeosang more highlight moments, at least in coreography, but I've also realised/accrpted that it might be a story driven desicion. Even in this mv, if the overaal colour scheme is blue, red and white, Yeosang's main scene is in a sunlight lit classroom. Overall, they are getting better at also bringing people with less lines forward and maybe we'll see a big difference when story progresses.

[@malaki.h]

This really made me cry, it really felt like a culmination of everything they've done. And when I heard the wave harmonies at the end too I was done for

[@american0000]

turbulence live stage makes me tear up fr

[@janiemclemore4756]

Loved your take on this. I too love this song and video. The fact that the song ends with the sample of wave shows me they will ride the wave through any turbulence. Perfect, relatable. Beautiful way to wrap up the fever series.

[@vanessarl8]

Exactlyyy they are emo kings specially Hongjoong so they have to have more emo songs!! And a thing with Atz vocalists it's that all of them have a warm tone(Woo mostly not but still has that undertone? raspiness and warmth) ALSO, they convey their emotions SO fking well!! Specially Seonghwa and rap parts Hongjoong, but really, everyone! So they really suit emotional songs like also Thank U and Fever are perfect examples(Hongjoong bridge rap there is my favorite thing soo emotional 😭), we need them pls KQ!!

[@rileyonthatbeat3047]

Ugh, I just love *ATEEZ* the ending of *"Deja Vu"* is the beginning of *"Turbulence"* they always gives us, *Atinys* a sneak peek of their other album. These guys are just talented and an all rounder. Love them!

[@lovenafeeza9342]

PD I was WAITING for this one

[@DeLexie]

I tend to forget how amazing slow songs ATEEZ make but gosh, Turbulence is such an emotional bop, type of crying tears of happiness at 3am in the morning

[@pilotkey6526]

I love this song. It had to grow on me a little, but now I get goosebumps every time I hear it. Also it's a song that I really needed right now, going through a lot of difficulties.

[@emmawang6403]

I cry everytime I listen to this song. As a current hs senior(in a competitive hs) dealing with college app/finals szn(thank goodness the worst of it is over but currently stressed abt finals), I am under a lot of stress and the upcoming decisions weigh heavily on my mind. In addition, things in my personal life affect my mood everyday, the passion can be heard from their vocals in this song. As an avid videographer, I love the storyline and cinematography. ATEEZ gives me the motivation to continue pursing my passions and dance. Since I am a self taught dancer inspired by kpop, it is hard for me to match up to the level of my friends who have been dancing for years. I am known to be able to express harder hitting guy choreos, so ATEEZ allows me to test my limits with their various choreography. Thank you PD for always giving your true opinions abt ATEEZ mvs!

[@cyndi1639]

EVERYTIME i listen to this song I start with goosebumps and end in tears T_T

[@priestboy16]

I cried first time I heard this T_T they've come so far, so so far, since that day when they were out and about on the streets hoping people recognize them

[@gaiapiazza5329]

I always start crying earing this song... it's so meaningful to me, it's beautiful

[@marse8666]

I can’t get over the little inserts connecting this song to previous songs ie. the beginning melody connects to the end of the deja vu MV which is also the end melody of Not Too Late. As well as hongjoong’s killing part in Fever: Passion. Young. Fever. And finally ending on the iconic wave chorus!! Ah this song is truly special and the perfect end to the Fever series. 💜

[@flawlesslyxx]

how is u so ACTIVE THESE DAYSSSS???? i love it fghnhds

[@brynmarie9655]

The ending feels reminiscent of the Treasure seried because woah’s at the end are from Wave! It gives it this final touch of hope after the switch up of the lyrics because it points to probably their brightest song. And it’s so nostalgic

[@goldception1260]

So there's a theory going on how this is a sequel to their Diary Film video. This is their first mv without any of them being together in the mv, similary to what happened in the diary film when we saw the "mirror or glass" that shattered and split all of them. So they went back in time. But over all the emotions for me are the exact same as you explained. Its just different,a feeling of comfort and relief saying that they are also humans going through the same stuff as us.

[@hanoody1117]

So... this is gonna be long, but I'll put out there anyway xD I'm not korean, and I only understand a little bit of Korean, but this song made me cry so much the first time I listened to it (without even reading the eng subs) It felt DEEP ... & it IS DEEP ! I agree with what you say about this song being so special and produced cinematically, I already said this many times but I'll say it again... this is a song that should be seen on BIG SCREENS :') !!!!! That's how well made it is !!! About Yeosang & Wooyoung's line distribution, it is true that these two members specifically have the least lines, BUT... my personal opinion: when I was still a babytiny and barely recognized the members, Yeosang's voice was one of the first voices I could easily recognize! Eventhough he didn't have much lines, his voice is so special and distinctive! And I do believe that Yeosang gets killing parts in some performances, cuz otherwise, I wouldn't have even noticed him ! He captures my eyes in his parts specially this year, 2021 :) Wooyoung's voice ALWAYS surprises me.... that boy has many colors to his voice and it's insane !! I sometimes can't even recognize his voice!!! Yunho and San also have many colors to their voices, like you could hear them singing in tones you'd NEVER expect ! AND THEY'RE ALL SO PERFECT !!! I do agree that Wooyoung have more killing parts in the performances too

[@skyyaaaa]

The mv is rather simple but it's definitely very artistic and cinematic

[@salomebrandenberg1010]

thank you so much for appreciating yunho's voice and singing skills!!

[@innoutt8351]

their discography is very diverse, more diverse than i thought. as someone who just got to know ateez this year, i've always thought that this group always has hardcore? i wanna say noisy but it would be very offensive (even for me, i am an 8 months old atiny now, KD-atiny) yeah but thats what i thought about them without actually listening to their discography but thanks to my curiosity, i started listening to WAVE until their entire treasure albums (treasure ep 3 is uhh cheff kiss) their discography are FAR from to be called noise music. I am so glad that i found them. and this release just shows me once again that Ateez is serious about showing their musicality. They dont go with mainstream sound like hip-hop or electronic music (looking at the competitors who have similar comeback date with them), and choose heart-wrenching rock-ballad that not every group can pull-off.

[@hanamohamed6267]

honestly i think turbulence is such a nice way to i guess finish off the “fever” series, everything about it from the way they put the melody from wave at the end to hongjoong saying “passion, young, fever” just like he did in fever, it just felt so emotional and even tho no one was expecting this to drop i’m kinda glad they released it before the real

[@Samy.10VE]

Made me absolutely ball my eyes, they never disappoint! What a powerful song!

[@luvletter93]

This is probably one of my favourite ATEEZ releases, it's a very relatable track at any point and I think ATEEZ has conveyed it very well alongside the FEVER series. Love this track composed by EDEN, KQ got talents right there. Jongho mentioned that he almost teared up while recording it too and I can srsly tell why. His vocals in this is incredible, I mean he's always been great, but there's just something about his vocals here alongside the lyrics that's just so... emotional. I love it. And also Hongjoong's rapping in here - GOSH, he's always taken higher tone parts but in here, he went from real deep heavy to his usual high energetic, incredible, I loooove.

[@neonlight-iwo8567]

the way ateez has such amazing bridges none of them could be named forgettable. they perfected their bridge game since day one. inception bridge? can't get better than that.

[@andrcgs]

every mv directed by digipedi is a masterpiece at this point...

[@champbuch5646]

For me atm this song is most impactful because of its relation to Ateez's lore, so I loved the visual callbacks to Inception and mostly musical callbacks to Wave. It was powerful to see how the boys, who were clearly separated and suffering because of that, were emotionally ready to re-unite around HJ and then fly and/or dream their way to the New World aka moving to Treasure-era events (SMN, HH, PK, TREAS for ex). I'm excited for what might come in post-Fever events and hope we do get some kind of a return to their more eclectic and edgy feel of the Treasure-period title tracks, but also with a difference to show their growth and extended artistic range.

[@SecondFloor2311]

I noticed that when Yunho looks through the window we sometimes see the city’s tall buildings reflected in it, but sometimes you see him in the same place but we see clouds and warm yellow sunlight, Seonghwa has a few shots like this too; like they’re flying above the clouds, I think that’s beautiful. Since Ateez’ stories usually make sense on multiple levels, I also feel like this is once again a reference to the ‘gas’ (if u know the storyline u know) since they’ve often shown yellow/colorful fog and in this case clouds. The fog around Wooyoung may be referring to this too but since it’s just ‘plain’ fog I’m not sure, but he IS the one literally flying so it could work. If the ‘gas’ is indeed a component here, I don’t believe they’re under the influence of it, but it may be a warning like it’s nearing, or it’s a memory or vision of the other world (kinda symbolic since they’re not looking straight at it but through a window so it feels like a sense of seperation from it; we know they probably got back to their own worlds - temporarily - since their seperation from Yeosang, who btw is clearly in a very different (and seemingly confined) environment compared to the others’ here)

[@mirsolus7789]

I think this is also my favourite Ateez song

[@eba.videos]

My jaw literally dropped cuz I didn't expect such a move from them. This MV is definitely going to have a special place in my heart! You can literally pause this MV in any second you want and it gives the cinematic look in every frame with the precise color scheme, the emphasis on lighting and such (hats off for Digipedi again and again) and even though we do not see the members together at all in a single shot, their vocals compliment each other so well that you feel their union from distance. Everything about this cb is so intentionally and elegantly chosen which makes me feel so proud for them. They did a risky move yet they pulled that off really well with extending their repertoires visually and vocally through this song. I would say this is definitely another turning point for Ateez! Hats off 🎩

[@eba.videos]

(Additional things) + When I heard the outro with Hongjoong's rapping, I remembered the thing you said in their Fireworks reaction: Ateez really knows how to end a song! Hell yeah + when Wooyoung started to run through the fog, I got chills and tears oh my- + Not only Yunho's falsettos but Yunho's bittersweet attitude in the mv added another level to the maturity on this video + The lightning during Yeosang's part in front of the wall looks like watefall/wave literally :')

[@FurosutoJouku]

FINALLY! The only Channel that acknowledged the outro part of the song. Thank you so much PD-nim. Yes, it was a slower version for the intro of "Wave". That being said, I can clearly see who follows and listen to ATEEZ wholeheartedly (which is you PD-nim), compared to other KZbin Reactors who just reacts with screams, pauses, jaw drops, and still forget ATEEZ's musicality and simply "comment down below about this blah blah blah part of the video coz I don't know". Thank you PD-nim for a proper feedback/reaction.

[@koya3903]

FINALLY. Someone who like's Yunho's voice the most. I feel less alone; XD

[@IamGiamma]

I'm watching too many reaction videos of Ateez songs and OMG "Turbulence" keeps making me cry!!! I've started listening Ateez since January of this year, I've never been into Kpop so deeply as I am with Ateez. They are making me doing a lot of things that I thought I would never do, like stanning a KPOP group, listening ALL THEIR SONGS, watching ALL their MV etc. Music for me is something superficial, shallow, I've never been into music even though I've always thought how amazing MUSIC as an ART is. And with ATEEZ I've just realized how KPOP is an amazing phenomenon, I've listened a lot of KPOP songs, especially Kdrama OST but for the first time in my life I'm also trying to UNDERSTAND ATEEZ's songs and what their messages are.

[@qraee]

one second I’m crying to turbulence then I’m twerking to the real, classic ateez

[@naxx__sg]

No because when "passion, young, fever" and the little wave throwback at the end came up I started bawling