The Kulture Study: Red Velvet 'Birthday' MV REACTION & REVIEW

Want to help keep the channel alive? Support us on patreon @ patreon.com/formoftherapy
Want to just make a one time donation? You can donate to the channel via PAYPAL: [e-mail]
Watch the original video here: • Red Velvet 레드벨벳 'Birth...
For business & professional inquiries only:
[e-mail]
Follow us on social media @formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
#redvelvet #birthday #레드벨벳

[@jaeminlover3000]

idc what anyone says, red velvet are THE whimsical kpop group. every time they comeback they never fail to make something fresh and new AND FUN. they're always gonna be different in some way, even if they add in a trend or two. tbh rookie has been my fav title track from them since its release but the more i listen to this song the more i think its becoming my new fav, its just so catchy and like you said, each member really does shine

[@octopusmusic332]

I am disappointed bro i want badly a badass comback like WILDSIDE Stop with this fairy type songs for fuck sake red velvet

[@mbae123]

@@octopusmusic332 look at their title tracks. You can't make them conform to suggestions they'll make their own

[@octopusmusic332]

@@mbae123 yes i am red velvet fanboy and i am done with their fairy taleish songs 😭

[@riffgroove]

"Like it or not, Red Velvet is quite simply the most joyous and idiosyncratic pop group from ANY country working today." - Chase McCullen. The 405 - music and culture magazine.

[@lunarialoonatic]

Queens of multi concepts But I am gonna pretend I didn’t hear the Rookie part, I pretend that song doesn’t exist in their perfect discography 😭

[@riffgroove]

Nobody does sophisticated chaos better than Red Velvet!

[@samj.r_]

Indeed

[@andreaignacio7898]

Idk why people why saying this is flop era when this song is THAT GOOD THAT PD EVEN SAID HE LIKES THIS BETTER THAN PSYCHO?!! GAHD PEOPLE WAKE UP! NO FLOP ERA FOR RV 🤧 U just have to understand RED VELVET thru heart and soul 🤪

[@de68a]

Idk either... they just won Show Champion 2 weeks in a row!!

[@riffgroove]

Bandwagon stans suck.... If ITZY put this song out, everybody would be losing their shit and calling it the best thing they ever put out. But because it's Red Velvet, some people cross their arms and go "Hmph... this isn't Bad Boy."

[@azurean7183]

@@riffgroove i mean it is a good song though? the production is amazing and the vocal/rap performance was outstanding

[@bdzmru8489]

I agree how could be people be calling this flop when this entire comeback is awesome and signature red velvet but with equal glory between all members

[@CK-kd5pn]

I feel like I see this sort of reaction in every group nowadays whenever they make a comeback.

[@anabananaha2965]

Video explainer: Each of individual monsters that they fight: edward scissor hands, that furry yeti thing, the lions in the elevator, the large cat, etc are all "gate keepers" to them getting into the party. It's why they grab a key after every face off. So they "level up" and then face the "final boss" which is the ginger bread man. You see the final battle during the bridge of the song where it's animated and each animated version of the members use their weapons ( Irene with her pink brass knuckles, Joy and Yeri w/ their barbed bats, Seulgi w/ her chain is a solid throwback to 28 reasons) to fight him. It's how they get into the party at the end. Notice that all the monsters they fought to get into the party are at the party in the end. Red Velvet start out as the ones excluded from the party, end up being the party leaders..

[@arelyolivares677]

After reading the explanation now I’ll enjoy watching the mv even more than I already do💗

[@reggiebell7291]

The battle sequence is all Seulgi actually

[@anabananaha2965]

@@reggiebell7291 upon re-watching... you're right! Seulgi was already my bias-wrecker, now i think she is even cooler.

[@jenseulnade9147]

and then they even ate gingerbread at the end 😭😭😭 we stan

[@mai-t6s]

pretty sure it’s not a throwback to 28 reasons but it’s somehow connected ig (?) because it’s referencing the movie “krampus” (2015) where one of the gingerbread man kills/kidnaps people using chains that seulgi is holding in the mv

[@ssphfdrc]

some kpop fans just don't understand and seem cant keep up with how complex and packed the productions and composition of red velvet's songs in general. of course, most of em would easily go with the mainstream girlcrushy, into your face type of songs. but with red velvet, you have gotta appreciate how brave they are to take such musical risk and that speaks insane capabilities. that's why i still stand with the notion, red velvet is the best kpop girl group now, with the best discography ever.

[@MrKinsenas]

I see no lies here.

[@LOL-VBE]

Real

[@septiyami8456]

true

[@FlowerLotusThe]

That's why i love SM, for their music and risk they take.

[@Jasruler]

Don’t be a jerk about it.

[@charchachachar]

Red Velvet being Red Velvet. That's it. They can never go wrong because they can pull off anything. That's how good they are! Reveluv!!

[@MaluSilva-yx8nl]

From the first time I saw this MV I was sure that no one could do that like they can... This era is just peak Red Velvet!

[@poot2939]

i agree ! i have no idea why people hate this song it’s literally insane

[@olivia-su7hl]

i think you may enjoy their behind the scenes video of recording the song, they do all their own harmonies and layering :)

[@rakhmath21]

Their songs will always make our ears feel full of experience. The production, vocals, harmonies, and ad-libs are legit every time 😌

[@louu.crossing]

This song and its entire album have been playing on repeat. I absolutely enjoy this comeback. Birthday is crazily stuck in my head that I had to listen to white noise on my earphones just so I could sleep at night.

[@jasonmok8072]

From what I understand of the story… They get blocked from going to the party. Then, they come back with a vengeance and take out that bodyguard and enter this weird complex of rooms that are in the way of them reaching the birthday party. Each member or group of members had their own challenges to go through to get their keys: that white furry thing with seulgi Wendy and yeri, the board game where Joy and Irene just poofed that guy and got a key, and seulgi exploding that ghost dog. Then once they got the keys (Joy in the elevator), they start getting chased. Then Irene freezes all of them with a Wii remote (?) then they summon a giant teddy bear to stop the rest of the guys from following them. Then seulgi fights the gingerbread guy and they finally make it to the party.

[@evicas]

AND RED VELVET DID IT AGAIN!!! there’s no one doing it like them that’s how it is

[@reveluvly]

Birthday is SO fucking good and nobody gets it man. I literally can’t stop listening to it, it’s in my head constantly. And the rest of the album is also just FANTASTIC, such an incredible mini album. It feels like a return to form after the FMR album which I didn’t love and the Queendom album whose title track I didn’t totally love. Such a perfectly iconically Red Velvet track

[@wheeinthepooh3906]

So many people are sleeping on this! The bridge alone is so phenomenal. The instrumental is so good T^T the whole album is chefs kiss

[@mroao1988]

this is their first comeback in a while where i love the title track more than the bsides and that says A LOT

[@Luvrenebebe]

THIS , this is true omg

[@fadexx84]

tbh i like zoom and pose more

[@katyagrossman2974]

Red Velvet sampling all of these OG classical pieces is really hitting the spot for me... as someone who really loves/plays classical music

[@laurad4277]

Yes, I hope they keep doing because it keeps making really unique, awesome songs

[@rathvanna]

I really loved this song too. It reminded me of older Red Velvet music. I think you’d also really enjoy a new group called Fifty Fifty. They have music that isn’t trying to be weird haha.

[@sb1363]

I said this elsewhere, but I want this as the opening song of their next tour.

[@TonyKimtheamusementparkfan]

Agreed, this song is literally sooooo Red Velvet and amazing~ Absolutely no way anyone else can pull off a concept like this. Their MVs are honestly one of a kind too, I mean the sets, the weird scenes, I mean no other group does this. Also, I'm a classical music junkie, and it's awesome how they did this again, using first Bach's "Air on the G String" in "Feel My Rhythm", and now Gershwin's "Rhapsody in Blue" for "Birthday" ~~ And I have to agree, I think this song is dominated by a lot of Wendy, and I love that :)

[@sg0648]

Although some have said that this is an easier song vocally compared to the rest of their discography I disagree, there are no other groups that could do justice to this insane of a song

[@thezircadia]

Hopefully when people watch the recording behind they'll see how complex it is and eat their words whoever has said that because it's literally ridiculous

[@putritere3433]

@@thezircadia yesss they def should watch the recording behind

[@inklover8168]

"nervous looks thrown my way" - Red Velvet definitely knows their audience.

[@chrystalamos8273]

You should heck out Red Velvet & Aespa new song Beautiful Christmas. It was released today

[@tek900]

I loved Birthday too. There are so many layers to the song and the production is great. Joy actually was the first to record and stacked a lot of the harmonies for the chorus. I loved Joy beginning the bridge too. The EP is phenomenal, I really recommend it.

[@xD4rkSl4y3r]

I always tell people that Red Velvet is like Wine: It’s an acquired taste. When I first tried listening to them it was jarring and weird. After listening more and more, nothing hits like them

[@Soyeons_mom]

"Red Flavor" is still my favorite RED song, and "Automatic" is still my favorite VELVET song. But "Birthday" (the song) is great. And I personally like the performance video even more than the MV.

[@markkostecki4558]

My SOTY is Feel My Rhythm still. Red Velvet are for sure my favorite group. The GOATs

[@danijones8314]

my friend and i were just discussing this album & talking about not every song has to be mature or have mind blowing deep lyrics. i adore cute songs that make you feel good. this has been a rough couple of months for me and birthday has genuinely brightened my mood so much!! you just can’t help but feel happy listening to it! people saying reve flopped are delusional lol

[@maverickjudd]

cake girls looking so damn fine and vocally is an eargasm. They never disappoint!

[@AK12king]

Birthday has been on repeat for me all week

[@thezircadia]

11/10 for me title track, but still not my favorite track on the album - that is how good this album is. Like the album may be my favorite??? It's definitely top 3 Red Velvet albums of all time for me. The video is incredible!

[@xSummeraain]

I didn't mind birthday the first time i listened to it. It was ok, but now I like it a lot more. It's such a fun song! Also, PD if you haven't checked out BoA's Forgive me you absolutley should!

[@here_for_the_memes]

RV (and SM) tend to use tons of Western writers, composers, producers and they’re the ones bringing the ingenuity and creativity when it comes to music composition, producing, and sampling _Western_ classical music. I wonder when the day will come when they start to use and sample Korean traditional classical music.

[@oqkakil3zqo]

4:36 Also my face when listen to this song 1st time. Until now still confuse why people say it's flop ???

[@lil_loonatic4237]

I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION YAAAAAY

[@wtvrnouis]

I LOVED this song right away. I think when red velvet have a comeback people are always hoping/wanting for something like bad boy or psycho and get disappointed when they release something on their red/quirky side. But im obsessed with this song, I loved the whole mini album!

[@ae-karinasunbaenim2819]

I LOVE BIRTHDAY ESPECIALLY THE ALBUM RV NEVER DISAPPOINTS SINCE DAY 1

[@andiej5573]

I enjoy this song. It took a second listen but it’s so catchy! As for the video, also took a few rewatches. But it looks like the gingerbread man blocked them from the party, RV battles the other guests for keys ( for access?) and in the end RV become guests of honor and cookie man a cake ornament 😂, while the defeated guests look on.

[@Noctis198]

Definitely an underrated song already!

[@fairytalesrv7223]

Sometimes ART is so hard to get for some people... That's the only reason I can forgive people say BIRTHDAY is a bad song... And it's amazing how Red Velvet as a whole allow they level of creativity. I'm not saying the just the girls I meant as the brand of RV.

[@danielpeyrou]

soo good and the live stages served so hard

[@rebeccawhite2155]

Kole is a semi-regular writer for SM artists and has credits for several other kpop groups. As far as SM goes, she has written for NCT, BoA, Red Velvet multiple times, Taeyeon, and Exo. I follow her on tiktok and she shares enough of her demos thatI knew a few second into Birthday she had to have written it!

[@danielizama25]

Full mini album is perfect 💯 On A Ride is so good.

[@dreamergirl173]

Red Velvet is iconic!! I was so looking forward to your reaction and it did not disappoint!

[@moshii.s.9361]

I'm not sure of the seance either but sm really added to our witchery this comeback with the members having superpowers. Irene's being time slip, Seulgi teleportation, Wendy size manipulation, Joy super fast and Yeri fall in love (according to schedule teaser). I love how they support our red velvet witch agenda now 😂 Anyway, Birthday is definitely a hit for me. It's very quirky and very red velvet-sounding. Not my fav in the album though because the album is 🔥 A contender for their RBB EP indeed. Anyway, can't wait for the b-side reactions!

[@bxyrk6422]

I'm not sure but maybe Irene's power is size manipulation, at least in the video. Cuz the cat was larger than her

[@moshii.s.9361]

@@bxyrk6422 I thought so too, or maybe the superpowers mentioned in the scheduler are only for the teaser photos, because they definitely have so much more in the MV 🤔 There are Joy's telekinesis and Yeri's wind (according to Irene) too.

[@ca55b1ak8]

I liked the storyline but it still feels like the mv didn’t do the song justice… especially at the bridge/final chorus

[@markkostecki4558]

Its definitely good and wild, I wouldnt put in the top 5 for RV but istill good. (and yes the EP is amazing, especially Bye Bye and Zoom)

[@beatricep103]

Red Velvet. The cutest and most endearing evil witches/seductresses I know 🪄💖🥰💞 Beware, they're gonna put a spell on you 😘

[@connie2406]

PLEASEEEEEEEE LISTEN TO THE WHOLE ALBUM. BYE BYE, ON A RIDE AND ZOOM ARE SOOOOO GOOD💗

[@DarkFoncho]

One of these nights is one of my favorites title track, but Birthday got a top position close to Psycho and Feel My Rhythm...just WOW! Wow wow...and again wow and thank you to exist Red Velvet!!!

[@anur_B]

you should react to BIBI's comebacks, still feeling for Animal farm and BIBI's vengeance, this is her best era, the cinematography is something of a kind

[@Hrathen39]

I have absolutely no idea what's going on in the MV lol

[@98TMT]

The rest of the album is even better, in my opinion 👌🏼

[@bretthollingsworth9866]

Joy is incredible, nice react, amigo! REQUEST, can you pleeeeeez react to XG Galz Xypher? English, Japanese and korean lyrics, and it's ridiculously astonishing💥😎💪

[@rain4est133]

I think the production of this song and its music video were on high budget here. I love the CGI, the storyline here that is straightforward but still has a lot of references, I don't know how many Luvies fantasize getting their arse wrecked by RV after watching this one. If I can summarize one thing about Red Velvet Discography: They deconstructed the pragmatic mind of the audiences and presented the other side of their works. One more thing I saw, Red Velvet kept outdoing themselves every bloody comeback.

[@NathyIsabella]

dang, you just missed Wendy playing rock paper scissors with the scissors hand guy 🤣 they were playing games/slaying the guys to get the keys to advance to the "next level" and the final boss was the gingerbread

[@abdulrahmanazmi7042]

Red Velvet song getting more unique. If you like it, your are unique person. If you not like it, you just a normal person.

[@mrlately]

lol the delusion is far too much

[@Twivampcaro]

Love to see that PD continues his Red Velvet Supremacy era

[@Alena-cq1ze]

The way the pre-chorus builds kinda reminds me of K/DA POP/STARS.

[@ellanote2260]

pd why u dont react to albums too ?

[@TheJoeri98]

Hey PD!! 😊 How are you?? 😊 Please do not forget that * *UP10TION - WHAT IF LOVE* * , has been uploaded on 12 10-2022 !! 🔥❤ A STUNNING COMEBACK!! and ... YOU LOVE THEM !! 💞 These boys DESERVE your valuable opinion !!❤ Take care! & Please do stay SAFE & HEALTHY💕 🌷🌸🍀 JOERI 🇳🇱

[@sun8843]

I feel like this song was the 4th gen-ification of Red Velvet and I feel like they out 4th gen-ed the 4th gen groups.

[@wonderlucky1912]

Hi! Thank you so much of your reaction! This song birthday sampled a classical song called Rhapsody in Blue by George Gershwin. *i am so happy Red Velvet is back sampling classical/orchestramusic like Bach's "Air on the G String" in "Feel My Rhythm",

[@de68a]

Just for info Rhapsody in Blue is actually orchestral jazz ( piano and jazz band) not purely classical. It uses classical elements in its composition (eg. the opening is Beethoven's 5th) The titular use of Rhapsody is a classical reference but only in this piece to highlight it just being one continuous movement broken into episodes. It's a composition which defined the Jazz Age of the 1920s/1930s.

[@wonderlucky1912]

@@de68a Thank you for sharing! I like learning about classical and orchestral music.

[@de68a]

@@wonderlucky1912 No worries, i like RV even more for sampling different genres. It shows how comfortable they and their producers are fitting into those styles!

[@arjaypalero8477]

Only people with diverse knowledge on music will like this music. It was actually good but only few people appreciate it.

[@bluaaahhhh]

I absolutely love this type of creativity within the whole production, and the quality I just saw Jackson's come alive one, and my artsy soul cannot be happier I also want to recommend you MINHO's CHASE, I think you will love the cinematography of it. It is angsty and deep, but in a really cool way movie like way

[@rebeccadeangeli9408]

Please react to Birthday by ten! It’s a work of art. I would love to see your reaction

[@niniess8611]

I GOT INTO RED VELVET BECAUSE OF THIS SONG. Ive been obsessed since it released!!

[@lootee4139]

This song remains in my head since its release.

[@PeaceB825]

I like RV because they always bring some Revolutionary Videos with Real Vocals as following their signature "R to V"

[@hshshs2191]

Best comeback in 2022!

[@bdzmru8489]

This to me was amazing as a cb top to bottom from the mv to the title track to the styling and live stages but also full album… istg my opinion is unpopular af

[@wonderlucky1912]

I think the storyline in the Birthday Music Video is that Red Velvet are trying to attend the Gingerbread man birthday and they were rejected. *So I think the Red Velvet members are trying to get their revenge throughout the music video.The members have to face through obstacles like the monsters/creatures they encounter. The members have different magical powers and they were trying to find keys to get to the party. *Seulgi has the final boss fight with the Gingerbread Man and at the end, the members are allow to the party and are Birthday party leaders.

[@exokalbiminvokalleri2769]

I actually love the song apart from the chorus

[@jerienethsual2790]

You might like their b-sides too..On a ride is to die for😊

[@kelsey3576]

plss im begging you to react to any of bibi's new mvs

[@juliamrls943]

Please do a rection to the latest p1harmony comeback ✨👌🏻

[@putragabe8654]

Tbh for this cb , this song is not my type for the first time . But i know some rv song is typical that growing in your mind, and after i'm repeating this song , i'm enjoy and like this song. 😂😂😂

[@michi-bi]

it also takes me a while to warm up to the RV title track, i prefer their b sides. I start to like the song after i watch the choreography

[@arturomonasterio9371]

That's what I specially think...Birthday is a Rock Song with a classical Sample...how weird is that?? Only Red Velvet can do that!

[@emotchola3016]

please react to the ep you're gonna love it

[@vernonscat4655]

LMAO the opinion on this song is so divided it's actually fascinating to hear as an old reveluv

[@duckchoco9630]

People who say this era's a flop have never listened to their side tracks foe this album. "Celebrate" is soooo amazing

[@TY_Track]

Think of like them going through escape rooms. They each get a key to get to the room with the party. They also said they were using their powers, Yeri blows on the white fluffy man thing and it makes him move when they're supposed to be still, so he gives them the key. And Joy makes that other man thingy disappear and take his key. And then Seulgi fights the cookie man with a chain which she says ties into her solo, referring to the part where she's holding onto herself with chains.

[@rvjoyjunkie2301]

Everything they do is DIFFERENT and FRESH and ASTOUNDING. Their music is so full of layers, that over time it only gets better. New theories about their music and MVs are continuously discovered as time goes on. Their music will be listened to, years from now.

[@auliaalif2174]

I just remembering you people who said this song is flop because not have good position in chart, they are RED VELVET, they will never comeback with same conceps, and remember they also have 3 sides (Red, Velvet, And Red Velvet). And also they didn't care about chart, they just doing whatever they want. So you guys who say this song is flop because you guys always stuck in psycho era. If you still hoping RV comeback like Psycho era, you just got nothing.

[@mvz]

The behind the scenes studio footage of this is nuts. Wendy especially just crushes it.

[@yoonriqq]

Red Velvet always crazy🔥

[@alicedattebayo9141]

I liked this song, but it's not one of my favourites from RV by far. I enjoyed it more after listening to it more, but I'd still have many other RV title tracks that I like more. Would love to see your reaction to Mamamoo+ (Solar and Moonbyul) Chico Malo and GGBB (I know GGBB is the title track, but I am more interested in hearing your thoughts on Chico Malo) :D

[@sakesojusoda]

every single rv song is a true masterpiece 💗💛💙💚💜

[@infinidhrey]

i swear red velvet thought me what complexity is.

[@irawannathasa5550]

I didn't expect that you would mention Birthday with Psycho, but it is true this title track so good and Red Velvet always make a really awesome comeback, it's so hard for me to choose what is better than what when talking about Red Velvet's music

[@winisning]

Fun fact: 28 reasons is actually linked with birthday, in the bridge animation you can see SEULGI

[@seulgixsus]

The fact that this song when from being my 3rd fav in the album to being my favorite song rn like I kept singing to it

[@min_yoon_8001]

hello pd can you react to BIBI-Blade and BIBI vengeance? these music videos are super amazing, and I love your reaction videos!!!!!!!

[@xcynder6000]

Yes! Finally someone who appreciates birthday at its fair value! This song is just SO GOOD! I loved it from the 1st listen too I don't get why so many people didn't like it...I guess it's too original? Not too easy to listen to? I don't know haha

[@chiroptophilia]

I was kinda nervous clicking on this but yaayyyy of course PD loves it 😆 I loved it on first listen too!

[@albedo0point39]

I think you’d enjoy watching the Behind The Scenes vocal recording session they posted to YT. Really interesting process, and the harmonies each member lays down are amazing. I was especially impressed with Joy.

[@ABrunnaGoncalves]

Some parts of this MV reminded me of Rookie, especially the many doors and places that they go through and the blue room scene (0:52 to 1:00 of their MV). Yeri does the same pose that is even in the thumbnail of Rookie.

[@oatmilkandcoffee]

the gershwin sample got me instant goosebumps for days! so so so AMAZING❤

[@pikapikapitiful]

Really your favorite title track lol. Did you forget Russian roulette? Haha jk like what you like man but nothing can beat Russian roulette or dumb dumb in my opinion haha but rv are always amazing

[@yaso_pexy3737]

Pd boa made a comeback with "forgive me" i know you were mind blown by her songs lately so i am sure you would love this song and it's rock too