The Kulture Study: The Rose 'Beauty and the Beast' MV REACTION & REVIEW

[@pooge7510]

it’s an indescribable feeling to be able to hear the rose again

[@kimvious]

true

[@KiGeprak]

I just get into kbands on late 2020, and it's great to finally able to experience a new release from The Rose!

[@andreina3251]

i know 😭 i cried when i first heard this song

[@briegetch09]

It really is! Such a bittersweet moment, and I cried my heart out watching this.

[@SteffiAkira]

AND that Dojoon sang the other half of the song again, after he didn't sing in Red. It made me so sad. because i love that contrast between Woosung and Dojoon's voices.

[@rinrinau]

the rose is such a comfort group for me. their music, even when a little more upbeat, tends to always have that same warm, almost nostalgic feel to it, just like a big hug. i dont really know how to describe it but its magic to me and this song had that same magic running through its veins i tell ya

[@andreina3251]

you described it perfectly!

[@morenamontes9504]

Yes me too !! Their voices touch the heart and I start sobbing

[@ojallae]

agree! idk what it is in their music but i love it. biggest regret of my life is that i didn't go to see them live when they were in my country.

[@andreina3251]

@@ojallae sameee. they were in my city just a month before I discovered them 😭

[@ojallae]

@@andreina3251 the pain is real :( hope we'll both still see them one day!!

[@chiquita.milenita]

Woosung has confirmed that the members are staying together as The Rose and will be releasing music once their enlistment period ends. He's been focusing on his solo career and released his first solo album Genre last year under his own label (woolfpack). It's more pop-oriented than his work with The Rose but it still has that chill vibe, I really recommend checking it out! It has two mvs (lazy and dimples).

[@netta9581]

The thing about The Rose is, even their standard songs are moving and heavenly

[@aussiecountry9320]

Ive missed hearing woosungs voice, and of course the Rose as a whole. Incredible as always

[@Marie45610]

He has a number of solo tracks, his most recent one he did with BM from KARD. CWS, great song.

[@chiquita.milenita]

He released an album called Genre recently!! It's a masterpiece.

[@deadbird6585]

Personally, kbands are really something. They deserved a huge fanbase as kpop groups as well. PD-nim, please check "Ha Hyunsang's Lighthouse" out! He's such a gem. Please make it happen HUHU

[@Marie45610]

I actually cried when I first watched this MV. I've been following Woosung in his Solo career these past couple of years, but seeing and hearing them together, made me realize how much I miss them as a band.

[@itscelinalam]

Looking back at this now, and to see where The Rose has come and are now, I am so proud of them for not giving up on their sound, music and identity as a band. This year they've toured the world on a sold-out tour, crowded music festivals and are finally getting the recognition they deserve. Maybe not as much in Korea (given the niche rock bands are in Korea) but internationally they are finally getting seen and honoured for their talent. UGH as a Black Rose that have known them since their busking days I am so proud of them for staying together.

[@beatricep103]

Oh. I thought the other couple was two dudes. That their story was about friendship yk Personally I interpreted the three storylines as three different versions of love basically. The grandfather and the child represent familiar love, the fallen angel guy and the girl romantic love and the other two platonic love, and how, regardless of any situation, the love shown through acceptance, trust and support can help to guide and heal. For the two people separated by the spider webs, since the long haired one is counting days and jumps off a hospital bed like structure, I thought it was about somebody who felt confined, either because of a physical illness or a mental one, or even just as a metaphor, and the other befriends them and helps them break out, sort of? I just assumed their role was about friendship because I associated family and romance with the other two pairs. But it could also just be a second romantic couple I suppose. Still cute. And btw it could be two dudes in that scenario too, not like I wouldn't trust The Rose to actually pull it off and not care about any social criticism they might face. Or maybe it is a guy and a girl and the friendship aspect still applies, who knows. If any of the members said anything about the process regarding the creation of this mv I would be curious to know, some behind the scenes or an interview idc. And Pd is right, that storyline is kept sort of vague, maybe intentionally, so as to give the viewer the chance to interpret the story however they like and seem fit, in their own way. In any case, it is a gorgeous song, gorgeous music video. Maybe it's an end, maybe it's a beginning of a chapter, maybe it's a promise that The Rose always has and will continue to write moving, comforting, heartfelt music. I for one can't wait to see what they're up to next!

[@beatricep103]

@Yanaína Irrazábal are they?!! Because Pd talks about them being a boy and a girl at 13:28 so it made me question if I did see it correctly 😂

[@sneakitty9304]

They're two dudes hahaha I think PD just mistook the long haired guy as a girl 😅

[@Yino_lemmon]

I was confused too cuz I've always thought he is a boy, but then PD says he is a girl lol I guess he just didn't realize

[@kcteldra]

omg this was my exact interpretation lol, with the different types of love

[@NomadFlow]

"Personally I interpreted the three storylines as three different versions of love basically" Sure but these are clearly some kind of old fables being referenced. The older man and child is CLEARLY Pinocchio. To ignore that and just say it's "familiar love" is to miss the obvious visual cues. So that means the other two stories have to be some kind of old fables that are also referenced but I don't know what they are and so far I've been frustrated that I haven't seen any comments on youtube that have even attempted to answer the question.

[@myradiantstarrr1302]

I agree 100%. This is just stunning. I love many groups but the Rose has a special place in my heart, they have a unique talent musically to weave a story and draw you into this ethereal world. Their synergy is breathtaking and Woosung-he is a shaman. Meaning he has a command over energy and sound that is so exquisitely powerful. Thank you for your great review. You put into words what I feel.💜

[@ankomitarashi-488]

The rest of the rose members will be finishing military services by june/july, and luckily they will stay together 💆

[@ash.0325]

seeing the rose back makes me so incredibly happy. they have arguably one of the best discographies in the kpop/kband scene, and seeing them together making music again is just 🥲 it had me in my feels, in a great way. beauty and the beast is a masterpiece, hands down, no questions asked 😌

[@moniiflores7113]

For me, discovering The Rose has been one of the most amazing things that had happened in my life. Honestly they make amazing music, that as you say and something that I feel really represents The Rose's songs is that they transport you. I feel each of their song has a magic and beautiful storie. Thank you so much for your reactions, I enjoy so much hearing to your feedback. Also, I think that one of the couples in the video, is two boys. Or at least that was what I could see. I feel like all the stories are love stories, love to yourself, love to someone else, a friend, a lover, family. It's just so beautiful. I've missed The Rose sooo much. I could listen to their songs all day in repeat and I wouldn't get bored. Thanks The Rose

[@rocksellerman]

I don't know how to describe it other than this song feels like a tragic first love kind of song, like that song you will always remember.

[@formoftherapy]

Oh damn you made me sad

[@edithlieraphotography1437]

The Rose is severely underrated. Their talent is incredible and i'm so happy to be able to hear them. This song is amazing and I can't wait to see what the future has in store for them

[@TrishMilburn]

The way I interpreted this was that it was three stories of being in a dark place (the cooler, blue/gray tones in the beginning) but then love helping to bring them out through the literal thorns and briars (the trials that have to be overcome to achieve happiness) to a brighter, happier place (the warmer tones). I think this is done most obviously through the the Beauty and the Beast and Pinocchio storylines, but I think the third could possibly be representing Rapunzel when she was trapped in the tower. I think also that the gender is left ambiguous on purpose, but the actor/actress with the longer hair and marking off the days on the wall is what led me to Rapunzel. And instead of a tower, the cobwebs are perhaps representing how that person is trapped by having to hide who they are from the world. But then the "prince" tears down the wall of cobwebs, extends his hand and leads them into the light. Also, I have to say that The Rose's concert is one of the best I've ever been to, of any type of music. Just a phenomenal show.

[@hlashite85]

The Rose was one of the last live performances I saw at the end of 2019 when they came to London. They’re able to create a genuine feeling and atmosphere on stage and then pull the audience into that. They’re so dynamic, even in the quiet moments they command your attention. I hope I get to experience it again.

[@deniseday6377]

That's the last concert I went to as well, it was amazing 🖤

[@hannah-elea]

I'm not gonna lie, I full-on sobbed when this song came out. It's been so long and I love The Rose so much, they bring so much comfort and warmth.

[@cherrycherrycherry1491]

I know you don’t typically like ballad songs PD but I’m so glad you reacted to this ❤️ THANK YOU!

[@formoftherapy]

To be fair, I just say I don't like ballads because that's an easier explanation than the more nuanced answer which is that I actually LOVE ballads. But ballads rely on the same instruments, same tone and style song after song which means there is WAY less diversity in the ballad sound. Because of that, I don't like a lot of ballads due to the fact that they tend to be rather "soulless" or extremely commercial. There's nothing wrong with that in music, after all a lot of K-Pop songs are written by other people and not the group, and all title tracks are commercial songs. But I think pop music gets a pass due to the varying types of sounds and experimentation. I just hold ballads to a MUCH higher standard. But I'll say this, there's not a single ballad from THE ROSE that didn't hit. They know what they're doing!

[@ورد-س7ج8م]

You must see their two recent albums, they are incredible ♥️

[@x9ov0x93]

Being with the Rose since the beginning, I can't wait for them to come back officially together sharing their talent

[@dadian803]

YES! I was hoping for this. They are such a comfort group plus Woosung's voice is just *chef's kiss* This is their last song with their label and I hope once the rest finish their military service, they get a much better one.

[@kellen5545]

I can't wait for a proper comeback. With this was as good as it is and is 2 years old just imagine what they have in store.

[@Rando3085]

I get goosebumps every time I hear this song it’s so beautifully written and sung🤌

[@alisonrenaud6432]

The Rose just hits differently, Woosungs voice is heaven. Im really looking forward to their music when they come back!. Also you should check out Woosungs new solo album its amazing!! Also Woosung is touring with Epik High! Also if you love songs like this I'm gonna request Gaho his song Right Now!! It is so beautiful! Its an epic song that just builds up and leaves you breathless at the end. It gives me chills and his voice is insane!!

[@KiGeprak]

Now that you're reacting to The Rose (and ONEWE back on the release date), I really hope you can check LUCY and FTISLAND's latest release from December. Especially for LUCY, there has been a first EP (August 2020), three single physical releases (Nov '20, Feb' 21, May '21, with at least 2 songs each), a digital single (back in August' 21), a collab with AKMU's Suhyun, and a second EP just last month. I hope you can at least check the title track, Rolling Rolling, publicly. It's a song rich with textures :") FTISLAND's song, Unthinkable, is their first release after all three members finished enlistment! Both FTISLAND and LUCY songs were released in the same date (with unfortunately no music show promotions, sadly...) I hope you can check them out. Thank you very much, PD and Blaire!

[@isalvim]

their music just always has a way to get me.. the last chorus hitting so much harder with all the harmonies and Dojoon's "my beauty" was impeccable it's the same feeling i had when i listened to "Black Rose" for the first time. it was already very emotional because of the whole situation, but i didn't expect to be literally bawling out when the mv ended

[@PhoenixInLove]

I found The Rose so late, and I wish I heard them earlier. I have been binging their music since late last year, their sound is incredible.

[@PotatoPotataaa]

K bands are really good, I love how each band just brings smth totally new. The Rose though is different, unique, like on another level TvT that's why I really hope for them to get the recognition they deserve and get a good company to back them up, they're so precious I love them and miss them so much. I nearly cried when this came out. And I hope K bands get more support as much as groups

[@aliciapark6241]

Pentagon made a comeback! The album is crazy good i really wonder what you’ll think about ‘The Game’ bside. It combines Classical music with Rock!!

[@beatricep103]

Also, Pd, since we're talking bands, if you're not too busy these days I suggest you check out LUCY. They are under Mystic, same as Billlie, and you reacted to their debut song Flowering and the It's Live performance to their song Snooze, but nothing else, yet I'm convinced you would like their songs, b-sides just as much as titke tracks! Recently they released a mini album with the title track Rolling Rolling, it is very bright and has a healing vibe to it. You could give it a listen, if you're curious ;)

[@snortingkuromi1325]

i remember being at a the rose concert in 2019 and i met this girl from korea who traveled around for the concerts and she really said most fans in korea are older which is so sad they´re sooooo talented

[@sungiesmile]

everything the rose releases is just marvellous, their music always makes me feel warm and kind of nostalgic 🤍 woosung has also released a solo album recently and it's amazing!!

[@marinathr4890]

no one has the voice like sammy, it’s one of a kind and simply unforgettable

[@woosungcloud]

i struggled to find words describing how i felt the first time i heard 'Beauty And The Beast', and you did such an amazing job with it✋ they are INCREDIBLE i hope they continue to grow and receive the love they deserve🥲

[@ورد-س7ج8م]

You really should see how they do this days ,they performed in Coachella. they are becoming bigger and bigger🥀♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@adjailialoua7932]

The rose has got to be the only kpop band that makes me spiritually transcend to heaven with their music. I never thouht I'd ever get to love a group this much. Thank you for your reaction.

[@pockeitaa]

This comeback song is just simply a masterpiece. I literally cried while listen to this song for the first time, it's just so beautiful

[@hirohiwo]

I think one's Pinocchio, one is the female accepting the fallen angel, then I think the other will be 2 guys trying break that divide between them and be together.

[@ngairegreenwood8608]

I love when PD gets poetic, to paraphrase them "Like the petals on a rose, there are many layers and detail." ❤

[@todorovskat]

PD i also had the chance to see them live in LA in 2019, and oh God, what an unforgettable night that was!!

[@sneakitty9304]

Same, when the bridge came, I teared up realizing how much I miss The Rose so much. At the beginning, the excitement took over me more because it's been a long time since we had a new song from them but when the song went on further, tears were already bottling up on my eyes. Beauty and the Beast is indeed a beautiful and magical song and anticipating to see what The Rose will bring to us in the future 🥀

[@skywalker73690]

Hey bro, The Rose is back. Full album with 2 MVs, looking forward to a reaction for that!

[@kyu8481]

I've watched the music video several times since it came out and never doubted that the two people separated by the webs are two men (the one in black is androgynous but you can clearly see his Adam's apple ^^). The first idea I had, although the lyrics clearly evoke the love story of the famous tale, is that the clip shows different forms of love. That's how I interpreted it myself at least.

[@theAllycat797]

I have you to thank for introducing me to this amazing band wtf i'm actually obsessed right now. WHY AM I TEARING UP I CANNOT EVEN UNDERSTAND THE LYRICS. i NEED MORE holy shiz

[@careyv]

WooSung has said that all the members are out of their military service now. He himself is going on a tour with Epik High. But he said they have so many songs written a DJ he’s excited to start working with the group as a whole again. I cannot wait!! They really are very special. The Rose and ATEEZ are my groups. I love them both so much. 🥰🥰

[@jessicacabrales9322]

The Rose is like no other...their music is so exquisite. I miss them so much.

[@Er-Budd]

My ears thank me every time I listen to The Rose. I can’t wait for them to get back together and start writing again. I’m so looking forward to their next album. I think they said it would be out before the end of the year but I could be wrong

[@j3nnie98]

Hearing the rose again made me extremely emotional but I'm glad that they are back and I'm glad I can listen to them again

[@jhierold]

Thank you for your reaction😇 I love this band so much! Such a Talent but underrated band! I hope that they will make a comeback when everyone get back together!

[@LindsayWench]

I'm so glad you reacted to this! I never would have found this song otherwise - and I just LOVE it!

[@mp4jas]

there is so much strength and uniqueness in woosung's voice and then there's so much gentleness and warmth in dojoon's voice T-T I've miss all of them together but I'll be waiting for them to finish their service and then hopefully we'll get new music huhu

[@user-yooshark1122]

OMG, I don't expect to see a reaction video of THE ROSE!! If PD loves the combination of the story line and the music, hope PD can react to "Enough" by Hoppipolla, that is also an emotional music video!!

[@dOntkNowHolol]

So true, we missed to see The Rose on stage again 🥲🥲🥲

[@lj_blackrose]

this reaction video made me miss the rose even more. i like how you said that 'i will watch this not to support the lable but to support the rose'. beauty and the beast is such a masterpiece and they will surely be back with new music as soon as the members came out from the army. so excited for the upcoming reaction video soon if ever. thank you form of therapy. we rose you ❤︎

[@dani-dd2my]

thank you so much for this great reaction to The Rose! I can't wait for them to start making music and performing together again.

[@nikki402150]

I'm not 100% certain but I'm fairly sure the longer haired actor in the second pairing is actually a guy(though gender presentation is as always a guess unless someone knows the actual actor)? Probably left purposefully ambiguous as to whether they're meant to be a couple or 'friends'. One of the themes for the video was sincere love in all forms.

[@mandubela4234]

Coming back to rewatch this and ask when you will react for their last comeback, Sour and the album Heal

[@_DevilishDarlin]

This makes my heart happy. They are the bestest boys and they deserve everything! And only the best.

[@padadaaaaa]

every time i listen to this song, i end up bawling. the rose always feels like home to me and this made me realize just how grateful i am for their music and just how much i miss them.

[@kat-thee111]

The rose is so amazing, I'm so glad you're highlighting their music.

[@nuvas3242]

I’ve been absolutely obsessed with song for weeks. What a masterpiece

[@JoobieLoobieSoobie]

YOUR WISH CAME TRUE!!!! Sold out tour and comeback 9/16!!!!

[@kennethlundberg6975]

Yaaaaaasssss! Thank You so much for covering this video, and updating us on all the information with The Rose and their label. Thank You, Thank You, PD and your crew 😁

[@unknownjourney]

Right! i saw The Rose live a few times and they were so amazing. Watching bands perform live just hits differently.

[@jessi5288]

I think this year, everyone will be free so I’m excited to see what they have coming for us…

[@katy123614]

The Rose did their best every time when coming out with a new song, they're truly so talented and to think that they were misstreated and not paid for doing such a great job in creating literal masterpieces makes me so, so angry.

[@bernandinocamilo1946]

This song gives me goosebumps.

[@Yino_lemmon]

Thank you so much for reacting to this song!!! I'm glad you knew about this because it's so beautiful. It's really sad that not much people even know they had a new song

[@rumd00dle]

The Rose are so special. I've genuinely never felt so invested in any other artist. Thank you for your reaction/review! Totally agree about the cinematic feel and arrangement of the song - their content really pulls in the viewer/listener. I feel there is so much more to come from The Rose, and I can't wait! 🌹

[@jisungsguitar]

i’m beyond glad to see you react to this. it’s just such a beauty song and i’m just so happy to see them playing together again

[@kayumanggi922]

The song and the whole M/V gave me chills... goosebumps all throughout. Soo good!

[@bxhija7898]

i think with the cobweb story, the woman is in a dark lonely place in her life where she feels like no one understands her and she’s counting down the days on the wall bc she’s hoping that one day, all her pain will go away. the guy that shows up can see through the webs (her pain) unlike others and actually understands her because maybe he’s going through the same thing or HAS gone thought it before (since he’s on the side that had the light) which shows he can help her get through her problems

[@ivelis1876]

Should definitely looking into LUCY’S Rolling Rolling even though it’s been out for over a month- it feels like a hopeful/freeing version of DAY6 Zombie in terms of lyrics imo. The album BLUE is chefs kiss👌

[@marinaconsegliere9054]

YESSS!!! THEY'RE BACK!❤ I'M SO EXCITED FOR THE NEXT SONGS!!!

[@mavirye2410]

Thank you for reacting to 'the rose'😭❤️

[@SCCKeyboardist]

I couldnt help but tear up. The music and the video was majestic

[@alchemist1588]

I'm so happy you reviewed this song. I honestly cry every time I watch the music video. This song is so well crafted and beautiful. I love the dynamic between the two main vocalists. It's so damn powerful

[@eudenmoje]

I KNEW IT YOU'LL GONNA REACT TO THIS. THANK YOU, PD-NIM!!

[@jessecura528]

they came out with this song a day after their old label released them. and i think they released this with their new label (Stone Music Entertainment - same label as wannaone) coz this video was also released on Stone Music Entertainment's YT

[@gazngl2134]

I can't... just can't... you're the best 👌 when it comes to reaction

[@assiabensaidi7300]

What this song is so heavenly and comforting

[@jingcc0121]

Great review and reaction. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I’ve not heard their music before, I was told about them, but never heard their stuff. Your review was a welcomed surprise and now I will be searching them out. Love this song and the video.

[@frontadoelisa037]

The Rose se a Convertido en un Fenómeno Musical ellos se Merecen todo Sus Reconocimientos Todas Sus Canciones son Demasiadas Hermosas Espectaculares Plissss ,❤❤❤

[@serabilempit2985]

THE ROSE FOREVER 🌹🌹🌹

[@jenL_7]

This song reminds me of 90s alt rock… The Rose is definitely unique and I really enjoy their music.

[@pokerface4848]

It feels like early 2000's alt rock to me... which reminds me of Coldplay's Fix You

[@jenitarizkiana123]

I totaly agree, thats why i realy love this song

[@docphil9602]

Hearing this reminded me of when I first heard congratulations by day6 just to learn that junhyeok was no longer a part of the group. I want junhyeok back :(

[@just_a_fangirl]

I believe if someone wants to describe their music they only need to say "magically cinematic" The only-instruments section before the 1st chorus is so beautiful and sets the mood for the song so well. I personally enjoyed Dojoon's portions so so much bc I missed his voice in their previous single album. Excited for what The Rose will bring us in the future ❣️

[@amgproductions08]

the rose just came out with sour! Such a good song

[@pinkfan1086]

Your analisis makes me more emotional, it is a beautiful song, thank you for this reaction

[@magazineme936]

this analysis of this amazing video makes me love even more this group and the song !! thanks for it, the words cannot express how much i love your channel, THANKS !

[@aquashine93shawol4life8]

I also thought that this was very beautiful and emotional! I'm new to The Rose but familiar with Woosung and it was interesting to see the difference between how he sounds as a solo artist vs how he sounds with the rest of The Rose. It is truly awful what happened to them and I really hope that things will get better once the other members come back from their military service.

[@btsismyheartbeatrhythm0153]

I heard about this band like maybe a year ago and i have fallen in love with them as much as i have BTS all there songs are really good 🥰🥰🥰

[@prezrenn]

I love this song didn't even know they were back

[@filippa1434]

I also thought the shirtless guy was Woosung at first XD his side profile looked so similar

[@bh5169]

they are incredible

[@eykayang]

if i remember it correctly, the controversy broke about 1 month before their comeback back in march 2020. i believe they have already fully prepared for the comeback.

[@therosammy-jf7wv]

PD, i hope you do reaction for the rose's music again for their comeback since 2022..

[@djjaewon]

Am I the only one who hears, "a tale as old as time..." when they walk into the lighted door?