The (Lack of) Evidence Supporting Gender-Affirming Care

[@catalyst3713]

Finally, a channel that comprehensively addresses this topic, without being so politicized. Im going to recommend this channel to whomever I can.

[@markshepperson3603]

Colin Wright of SwipeWright and also ‘realities last stand’ is a PHD and brilliant.

[@sarral2008]

@@markshepperson3603 Where is this SwipeWright, it is not on KZbin|?

[@markshepperson3603]

@@sarral2008 kzbin.info/www/bejne/r6eoppJ4qtCpbrc

[@Djanck000]

This is extremely political, what are you talking about?

[@thesignalproductions]

​@@Djanck000 How?

[@GordieGii]

I have seen dozens of interviews with desisters and detransitioners and a surprising number of them report that when they called their clinic saying that the regretted their choice, the clinic stopped returning their calls.

[@susanhill833]

Less than 1% of those that transition detransition, that is 1 out of 100, Here is the REAL TRUTH about Gay and Transgenderism: It is NOT about chromosomes (the XX or the XY) or the BODY, it is about the STRUCTURE of the human brain. A Doctor with a Ph.D. in Genetics and his team did research on the STRUCTURE of the human brain. They studied the brain of straight women and straight men, gay women, and gay men, as well as transgendered women and transgendered men. What they found is this, the STRUCTURE of the brain between a male and a female is as different from each other as night is from the day. They also found that there are two distinct and separate areas of the brain that deal with sexuality and gender. They found that the area for sexual orientation in gay men is STRUCTURED the same as in straight women, NOT straight men, and in gay women, that area is STRUCTURED the same as in straight men, NOT straight women. Likewise, the center in the brain that deals with gender identity is the same, in transgender women (male to a female) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-women, (born and identify as female) NOT cis-men, (born and identify as male), and in transgender men, (female to male) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-men, NOT cis-women. It has been STRUCTURED this way since BEFORE birth. Two other teams in different parts of the world doing the same study all independent of each other found the exact same results. When a baby is first formed in the womb it is formed 100% female. Then after a few weeks, a signal from the father's genes tells the baby's body, the body only, to change and become male. The baby goes on for a few more weeks this way until it can produce a massive amount of the male hormone testosterone, which then tells the brain to change into the male pattern, such a massive amount will never be seen in that Child's life again except at the onset of puberty. If for some reason that baby does not get that massive dose of testosterone in the womb then the brain, or parts of it, continues to develop in the female pattern. Or in the case of gay women or Trans men, at some time in the mother's pregnancy that baby received a small dose of testosterone at the wrong time, either the mother ingested it somehow or her body produced it or the baby’s own body produced it all of which can and have happened. When a baby is being formed in the womb, any variation, even in the slightest, of the chemicals can cause birth defects. You have seen these birth defects in babies being born all the time, some born blind, or deaf, born with missing limbs, or heart problems, or even with a spine outside of the body, and many, many others. So why is it so hard for the right to believe that a person’s BRAIN can be STRUCTURED in the opposite way from what their bodies say they should be? You can believe in all other birth defects so why not this? I will use transgender women for this example, even though the body is male she likes all the same things a cis-gender woman likes, her emotional likes, wants and needs are the same as any woman's, and the way she sees the world is the same. Her interactions are the same, everything about her is the same as any cis-gender woman except the body. Sexual characteristics (the body) are set by the genes (the XX or the XY) but Gender is set by the STRUCTURE of the BRAIN, this has been proven through sound scientific study. Gender is how one see themselves and their place in the world and how they interact with it. If your body is set one way and your brain the other it causes a disharmony of mind and body (gender dysphoria) it is not now or ever has been a DELUSION or a PERVERSION or a MENTAL ILLNESS. When someone is going through life with this Dysphoria their life is a living hell, when people tell them that they can't be WHO they are inside because that person is uncomfortable with it then you are forcing the trans person to live in severe PAIN, Anxiety, and Depression, a PAIN that having your arms and legs cut off with a dull rusty hacksaw without any anesthetics seem like nothing in comparison, a pain that kills, LITERALLY KILLS. Think of everything you like and want as a man or a woman, everything that makes you, you, and then think how you would feel if you were constantly told that you can't have it, or be it, or do the things you love, because you are the opposite of who and what you are now, that you must bury everything that makes you, you because other people don't like it because it makes them uncomfortable, If constantly you were told that you were evil and dammed because you are who you are, denied a job, or a home, insulted, belittled, assaulted and even targeted to be KILLED just because you exist, how would you feel? Women, think how would you feel if you were forced to live, think, told to feel like and be a man, And told that you MUST do what men do, how men do it, see things the way men see them in order to be a man and you MUST be a man and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? Men, think how you would feel if you were forced to live, think, feel, and be a woman? Told that you MUST do what women do, how women do it, see things the way women see them in order to be a woman and you MUST be a woman and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? A trans woman does NOT fit, in a man’s social circle the same way a man does and yet they are expected to if they do not go through transition, they are expected to think, feel, and act just like any cis-gender man in that circle, but they can’t because their brain is STRUCTURED differently, so they are insulted, belittled beat on ridiculed, and humiliated by these men, constantly, all because their brain is STRUCTURED the same way a cis-gender woman’s brain is STRUCTURED. With their brain being STRUCTURED that way they would fit into a woman’s social circle but with their bodies being male, again they don’t fit in and they are excluded. They want to wear the same outfits the women wear because their brains tell them they should be just like them. Everything inside them SCREAMS that they are just like the people who are of the opposite gender and yet they are NOT allowed to be because other people are uncomfortable with them doing so, so they are FORCED to live in severe PAIN, anxiety, and depression. Trans people just want to be accepted for who they are, they want and are deserving of the very same rights as everyone else, no more and NO LESS. Here is the truth about the road to transition: First, the person MUST go to therapy, no therapy no transition, they will meet with a therapist who has knowledge and experience with transgender people. During this time they will begin social transitioning, social transitioning is nothing more than changing one's name and pronouns, and appearance such as hairstyle and clothing. Then after a number of sessions with the therapist (usually about a year) if the Dysphoria continues, and depending on the age of the person they may be given puberty blockers, (which are reversible). Then after many more sessions with the therapist and again if the Dysphoria continues they may be given hormones, it is these that have irreversible effects. Last: when they reach the age of CONSENT (CONSENT, NOT A KID, NO ONE IS DOING SURGERY ON KIDS) and if the Dysphoria continues, and if they have lived in the gender of their choice for a MINIMUM of 1 full year, and have letters from two therapists with one having a P.HD in psychology with both therapists having seen the person over a period of time they may get a consult from the surgeon, and there is usually a long waiting list for that, after the consult if the surgeon agrees then you get on the long waiting list for the surgery. IF ANYONE TELLS YOU DIFFERENTLY FROM THIS THEY ARE LYING TO YOU. Definition of a woman: How you define a woman is by how she sees herself, a woman is one who sees herself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a woman, thinks as a woman, acts as a woman, and lives as a woman, then what is the harm to treat and respect her as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Definition of a Man: How you define a man is by how he sees himself, a man is one who sees himself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a man, thinks as a man, acts as a man, and lives as a man, then what is the harm to treat and respect him as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you have a need to feel morally superior to others, “pull the beam out of your own eyes before you try to pull the mote out of another’s”. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you don’t understand it and it fills you with fear, fear of something that is different from what you are used to, different from YOU, either one goes forward or one stagnates and dies, you limit your thinking and can’t or won’t learn, grow, and adapt. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you just want to hate and hurt others, it gives you a sick thrill, and you use the LGBTQ as an excuse to do so. But ALL of you who do these are small, weak, insecure, monumentally stupid, and utterly pathetic excuses of human beings.

[@illjusthavecoffee]

The clinics have absolutely no idea how to handle a detransitioner

[@GordieGii]

@@illjusthavecoffee I get that. My point is that they keep insisting that the rate of detransition is very low, but it seems like they are avoiding keeping track of the detransitioners.

[@illjusthavecoffee]

@@GordieGii I see what you're saying. I do think that's part of the problem, But it's exacerbated by the decentralized nature of the healthcare system in the US. There's no designated body that records what every clinician in the country does for every one of their patients, so any data we have is from insurance companies. And things like patient dissatisfaction, or serious side effects of drugs are handled with lawsuits. We have a process of drug trials and animal testing, and experimental surgery, that the industry just completely neglected to do for GAC. A rate of regret would have been found during that process, we don't have any mechanism in our medical system to find something like a regret rate because the whole thing is designed with the assumption that we now know how to avoid a medical scandal like lobotomies. I think it's probably a vicious cycle of clinicians believing there's a low regret rate, getting a surprising call from a detransitioner, brushing it off as an anomaly, and going on to the next. And the majority of detransitioners aren't going to confront their doctors and demand accountability.

[@teeprince279]

thank you! I myself am detrans. After 3 years of testosterone I finally understood, that I wanted to escape the experience of being female due to sexual abuse, sexualisation, trauma and how society told me what a girl can and cannot do. Im just a masculine, traumatized woman, a tomboy lesbian. I was very happy at first for 1-2 years, testosterone makes you have a lot of energy and you are excited about every change. I got treated differently by people and didnt get sexualized anymore. But I basically just destroyed my body with a hormone that it neither needs nor wants and made me smth that is neither really woman nor really male. I needed only ONE appointment by some woke therapist, eventho in my country its required to have a year of therapy (2020). But you just get it easily and I even told her that I have trauma disorders and she gave it to me anyways without any further therapeutic treatment. I dont want any more kids making the mistake I did. I was 19, I made this choice. But i got a diagnosis of gender dysphoria after a 50min talk, that isnt right. I have so many mental health issues, that was just irresponsible of that therapist and didnt even matched the official guide lines.

[@sarral2008]

Thank you for sharing your story. I am a bit older than you but I had exactly the same experience when I was young, and if it was today I would be "diagnosed" with gender dysphoria, even though my bad feelings were due to how the society viewed females at that time. A lot of kids like you are simply misdiagnosed, and that ruins their lives, all in order to promote transgenderism. People seek help for different reasons, it is a major mistake to diagnose and treat all of them in the same way.

[@amaryllisequistra]

Thank you and i hope you are ok 💗

[@jelleepit]

❤❤

[@florencedenham9395]

Thank you

[@AndyJarman]

The commentary failed to point out that the Dutch study gave post operative girls a questionnaire that was designed for men to answer. And the post operative boys were given the women's questionnaire. So girls that had their breasts and uterus removed were asked whether they experienced erections, and surgically altered boys were asked if they experienced worse period pains. Totally insane.

[@The_Rock_Princess]

Can you plz site the sources for your info? If this is true, it is truly disturbing and disgraceful. I would like to put it in my arsenal of points that help trans-kids who are being abused. ❤️‍🩹

[@CiaranDillaneOfficial]

Powerful video. Thank you.

[@rjohn4143]

This is an important series!

[@BTiffney71]

The most glaring question is where were all those youths who supposedly cannot live according to their biology or "assigned gender" before the miraculous advet of gender "medicine"? If synthetic hormones and surgeries are "life saving" for these kids then wouldnt there be a documented historic precedent of kids ending themselves because they couldnt be their "true" self? The whole thing falls a part under the minimum of scrutiny so how did it get this far, and hurt so many people...

[@lovelover4408]

“How did it get so far and hurt so many people”… $$$$$$$

[@theresearcher253]

The entire proposition is based on a lie. Your 'true self' is you: your mind and your body. If you have a problem with that, then it's a mental health problem, not a physical health problem.

[@frankzed7684]

Thank you for this. Excellent work.

[@Hans-qi3wq]

"First do no harm" they promised. Clearly someone needs to go to jail for this 🐂💩.

[@markrussell3428]

DONT BELIEVE THIS. You would be very naive if you believe there is any legal culpability. There should be but you are missing a piece. "Primum non nocere" goes along with a doctors other moral responsibility to "alleviate suffering". This is the counter balance and it provides the justification (protection) essential to support state sanctioned euthanasia (assisted suicide) and catastrophic programs like "safer supply drug programs" proposed by public health advocates (keep homeless people on drugs until the eventual overdose).. Gender "care" activist have seized upon the "alleviate suffering" concept to coerce doctors so they keep children happy in the moment. They will point to outcomes based research where the short term post-op euphoria of top surgery . It Is often compared with hip and knee replacement surgery. Its fraudulent, but just one more sign of how despicable and manipulative the ideologues are. No one goes looking for knee surgery given the recovery time and demanding physio-therapy involved. "Top-surgery" (like other cosmetic procedures) is something you "dream" about getting. Compare these after 10 years and you will find its hard to locate some of the top surgery patients. Another attribute of trans-research that goes unreported.

[@sarral2008]

Diagnosing is a huge problem, and the increasing amount of detransitioners is the proof.

[@dreimalnein22]

you can't say some anorexis are truly still too fat and need to not be stopped starving themselfes, it's just hard diagnosing. It is just another body dysmorphic disorder, a mental illness that is not true for anybody and not as good an outcome as leading one to self-acceptance!

[@baconsarny-geddon8298]

What can you expect, from a """diagnosis""" that uses exactly ZERO evidence-based criteria? But which instead, relies 100% on THE PATIENT (including children) just saying whether they FEEL like they have this (supposed) "condition". (which believers insist ISN'T "a medical condition"... but they also insist it's super-duper medically valid, despite the 100% absence of evidence, and that this """healthcare""" MUST be given, or else these people risk death... but that's NOT trying to present this stuff as "a medical" condition"?!? It's all a self-contradictory mess...) Patients "diagnose" THEMSELVES as "trans", and the doctor is just there as a rubber stamp, with virtually ZERO real decision-making power... Even the children, are "diagnosing" THEMSELVES... We shouldn't be shocked this turned into such a disaster, since we removed basically ALL standard medical safeguards, just for this one 100% evidence-free non-"condition"...

[@sarral2008]

@@baconsarny-geddon8298 Exactly my thoughts but I was afraid to write it because YT sees it as a h@te speech. :(

[@Rudy137]

Regret rates are below 1% tho

[@sarral2008]

@@Rudy137 There is no reliable data to support your claim.

[@dubaiedge]

I missed this by a generation or two, skin of my teeth. I'd have done nearly *anything* to disguise being female growing up to ward off all the male abuse. Had this been available, I'd have maybe gone for it. We need to take a far deeper look at girls trying to escape their bodies.

[@amaryllisequistra]

#metoo

[@florencedenham9395]

Verbatim my story...I was a tomboy in an extremely abusive situation...this would have been me.

[@koffeekage]

Surgical intervention to psychological disorders have a very poor history.

[@XxYwise]

And they didn't even pad it out to 10 minutes... BASED.

[@wrmlm37]

Love the intelligent, educated and focused videos this channel uploads! A million thanks if you help even 1 child or adult from this choice of a constantly painful and medicalized future. Nevermind the effects of sterility and lack of sexual function/graticification which is an important aspect adult loving relationships. Good luck to all of the folks in the DeTrans community! You deserve a happy, productive life, doing the things regular adults do, like having a job, and a friend group that isn't based on fear and cult-like behaviors. There are wonderful therapists out there who would never consider this as appropriate for their clients. Good, ethical therapists do exist.

[@susanhill833]

You really have NO idea what you are talking about, at all. Here is the REAL TRUTH about Gay and Transgenderism: It is NOT about chromosomes (the XX or the XY) or the BODY, it is about the STRUCTURE of the human brain. A Doctor with a Ph.D. in Genetics and his team did research on the STRUCTURE of the human brain. They studied the brain of straight women and straight men, gay women, and gay men, as well as transgendered women and transgendered men. What they found is this, the STRUCTURE of the brain between a male and a female is as different from each other as night is from the day. They also found that there are two distinct and separate areas of the brain that deal with sexuality and gender. They found that the area for sexual orientation in gay men is STRUCTURED the same as in straight women, NOT straight men, and in gay women, that area is STRUCTURED the same as in straight men, NOT straight women. Likewise, the center in the brain that deals with gender identity is the same, in transgender women (male to a female) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-women, (born and identify as female) NOT cis-men, (born and identify as male), and in transgender men, (female to male) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-men, NOT cis-women. It has been STRUCTURED this way since BEFORE birth. Two other teams in different parts of the world doing the same study all independent of each other found the exact same results. When a baby is first formed in the womb it is formed 100% female. Then after a few weeks, a signal from the father's genes tells the baby's body, the body only, to change and become male. The baby goes on for a few more weeks this way until it can produce a massive amount of the male hormone testosterone, which then tells the brain to change into the male pattern, such a massive amount will never be seen in that Child's life again except at the onset of puberty. If for some reason that baby does not get that massive dose of testosterone in the womb then the brain, or parts of it, continues to develop in the female pattern. Or in the case of gay women or Trans men, at some time in the mother's pregnancy that baby received a small dose of testosterone at the wrong time, either the mother ingested it somehow or her body produced it or the baby’s own body produced it all of which can and have happened. When a baby is being formed in the womb, any variation, even in the slightest, of the chemicals can cause birth defects. You have seen these birth defects in babies being born all the time, some born blind, or deaf, born with missing limbs, or heart problems, or even with a spine outside of the body, and many, many others. So why is it so hard for the right to believe that a person’s BRAIN can be STRUCTURED in the opposite way from what their bodies say they should be? You can believe in all other birth defects so why not this? I will use transgender women for this example, even though the body is male she likes all the same things a cis-gender woman likes, her emotional likes, wants and needs are the same as any woman's, and the way she sees the world is the same. Her interactions are the same, everything about her is the same as any cis-gender woman except the body. Sexual characteristics (the body) are set by the genes (the XX or the XY) but Gender is set by the STRUCTURE of the BRAIN, this has been proven through sound scientific study. Gender is how one see themselves and their place in the world and how they interact with it. If your body is set one way and your brain the other it causes a disharmony of mind and body (gender dysphoria) it is not now or ever has been a DELUSION or a PERVERSION or a MENTAL ILLNESS. When someone is going through life with this Dysphoria their life is a living hell, when people tell them that they can't be WHO they are inside because that person is uncomfortable with it then you are forcing the trans person to live in severe PAIN, Anxiety, and Depression, a PAIN that having your arms and legs cut off with a dull rusty hacksaw without any anesthetics seem like nothing in comparison, a pain that kills, LITERALLY KILLS. Think of everything you like and want as a man or a woman, everything that makes you, you, and then think how you would feel if you were constantly told that you can't have it, or be it, or do the things you love, because you are the opposite of who and what you are now, that you must bury everything that makes you, you because other people don't like it because it makes them uncomfortable, If constantly you were told that you were evil and dammed because you are who you are, denied a job, or a home, insulted, belittled, assaulted and even targeted to be KILLED just because you exist, how would you feel? Women, think how would you feel if you were forced to live, think, told to feel like and be a man, And told that you MUST do what men do, how men do it, see things the way men see them in order to be a man and you MUST be a man and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? Men, think how you would feel if you were forced to live, think, feel, and be a woman? Told that you MUST do what women do, how women do it, see things the way women see them in order to be a woman and you MUST be a woman and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? A trans woman does NOT fit, in a man’s social circle the same way a man does and yet they are expected to if they do not go through transition, they are expected to think, feel, and act just like any cis-gender man in that circle, but they can’t because their brain is STRUCTURED differently, so they are insulted, belittled beat on ridiculed, and humiliated by these men, constantly, all because their brain is STRUCTURED the same way a cis-gender woman’s brain is STRUCTURED. With their brain being STRUCTURED that way they would fit into a woman’s social circle but with their bodies being male, again they don’t fit in and they are excluded. They want to wear the same outfits the women wear because their brains tell them they should be just like them. Everything inside them SCREAMS that they are just like the people who are of the opposite gender and yet they are NOT allowed to be because other people are uncomfortable with them doing so, so they are FORCED to live in severe PAIN, anxiety, and depression. Trans people just want to be accepted for who they are, they want and are deserving of the very same rights as everyone else, no more and NO LESS. Here is the truth about the road to transition: First, the person MUST go to therapy, no therapy no transition, they will meet with a therapist who has knowledge and experience with transgender people. During this time they will begin social transitioning, social transitioning is nothing more than changing one's name and pronouns, and appearance such as hairstyle and clothing. Then after a number of sessions with the therapist (usually about a year) if the Dysphoria continues, and depending on the age of the person they may be given puberty blockers, (which are reversible). Then after many more sessions with the therapist and again if the Dysphoria continues they may be given hormones, it is these that have irreversible effects. Last: when they reach the age of CONSENT (CONSENT, NOT A KID, NO ONE IS DOING SURGERY ON KIDS) and if the Dysphoria continues, and if they have lived in the gender of their choice for a MINIMUM of 1 full year, and have letters from two therapists with one having a P.HD in psychology with both therapists having seen the person over a period of time they may get a consult from the surgeon, and there is usually a long waiting list for that, after the consult if the surgeon agrees then you get on the long waiting list for the surgery. IF ANYONE TELLS YOU DIFFERENTLY FROM THIS THEY ARE LYING TO YOU. Definition of a woman: How you define a woman is by how she sees herself, a woman is one who sees herself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a woman, thinks as a woman, acts as a woman, and lives as a woman, then what is the harm to treat and respect her as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Definition of a Man: How you define a man is by how he sees himself, a man is one who sees himself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a man, thinks as a man, acts as a man, and lives as a man, then what is the harm to treat and respect him as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you have a need to feel morally superior to others, “pull the beam out of your own eyes before you try to pull the mote out of another’s”. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you don’t understand it and it fills you with fear, fear of something that is different from what you are used to, different from YOU, either one goes forward or one stagnates and dies, you limit your thinking and can’t or won’t learn, grow, and adapt. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you just want to hate and hurt others, it gives you a sick thrill, and you use the LGBTQ as an excuse to do so. But ALL of you who do these are small, weak, insecure, monumentally stupid, and utterly pathetic excuses of human beings.

[@edwardsinger4043]

Ideology plus financial incentives equals frankenchildren

[@Transkriget]

I created English subtitles for a documentary on transgender care produced by Swedish public service, featuring interviews with Mikael Landén, Helen Joyce, transgender care providers, and some detransitioners. It's on my channel.

[@marcofreyssonnet9673]

When such things exist, it confirms that the whole medical industry is rotten and needs radical reform and accountability

[@patuertbecado]

Thanks you for this true

[@apocalypse12345]

Dysphoria is a symptom not a illness

[@susanhill833]

Here is the REAL TRUTH about Gay and Transgenderism: It is NOT about chromosomes (the XX or the XY) or the BODY, it is about the STRUCTURE of the human brain. A Doctor with a Ph.D. in Genetics and his team did research on the STRUCTURE of the human brain. They studied the brain of straight women and straight men, gay women, and gay men, as well as transgendered women and transgendered men. What they found is this, the STRUCTURE of the brain between a male and a female is as different from each other as night is from the day. They also found that there are two distinct and separate areas of the brain that deal with sexuality and gender. They found that the area for sexual orientation in gay men is STRUCTURED the same as in straight women, NOT straight men, and in gay women, that area is STRUCTURED the same as in straight men, NOT straight women. Likewise, the center in the brain that deals with gender identity is the same, in transgender women (male to a female) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-women, (born and identify as female) NOT cis-men, (born and identify as male), and in transgender men, (female to male) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-men, NOT cis-women. It has been STRUCTURED this way since BEFORE birth. Two other teams in different parts of the world doing the same study all independent of each other found the exact same results. When a baby is first formed in the womb it is formed 100% female. Then after a few weeks, a signal from the father's genes tells the baby's body, the body only, to change and become male. The baby goes on for a few more weeks this way until it can produce a massive amount of the male hormone testosterone, which then tells the brain to change into the male pattern, such a massive amount will never be seen in that Child's life again except at the onset of puberty. If for some reason that baby does not get that massive dose of testosterone in the womb then the brain, or parts of it, continues to develop in the female pattern. Or in the case of gay women or Trans men, at some time in the mother's pregnancy that baby received a small dose of testosterone at the wrong time, either the mother ingested it somehow or her body produced it or the baby’s own body produced it all of which can and have happened. When a baby is being formed in the womb, any variation, even in the slightest, of the chemicals can cause birth defects. You have seen these birth defects in babies being born all the time, some born blind, or deaf, born with missing limbs, or heart problems, or even with a spine outside of the body, and many, many others. So why is it so hard for the right to believe that a person’s BRAIN can be STRUCTURED in the opposite way from what their bodies say they should be? You can believe in all other birth defects so why not this? I will use transgender women for this example, even though the body is male she likes all the same things a cis-gender woman likes, her emotional likes, wants and needs are the same as any woman's, and the way she sees the world is the same. Her interactions are the same, everything about her is the same as any cis-gender woman except the body. Sexual characteristics (the body) are set by the genes (the XX or the XY) but Gender is set by the STRUCTURE of the BRAIN, this has been proven through sound scientific study. Gender is how one see themselves and their place in the world and how they interact with it. If your body is set one way and your brain the other it causes a disharmony of mind and body (gender dysphoria) it is not now or ever has been a DELUSION or a PERVERSION or a MENTAL ILLNESS. When someone is going through life with this Dysphoria their life is a living hell, when people tell them that they can't be WHO they are inside because that person is uncomfortable with it then you are forcing the trans person to live in severe PAIN, Anxiety, and Depression, a PAIN that having your arms and legs cut off with a dull rusty hacksaw without any anesthetics seem like nothing in comparison, a pain that kills, LITERALLY KILLS. Think of everything you like and want as a man or a woman, everything that makes you, you, and then think how you would feel if you were constantly told that you can't have it, or be it, or do the things you love, because you are the opposite of who and what you are now, that you must bury everything that makes you, you because other people don't like it because it makes them uncomfortable, If constantly you were told that you were evil and dammed because you are who you are, denied a job, or a home, insulted, belittled, assaulted and even targeted to be KILLED just because you exist, how would you feel? Women, think how would you feel if you were forced to live, think, told to feel like and be a man, And told that you MUST do what men do, how men do it, see things the way men see them in order to be a man and you MUST be a man and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? Men, think how you would feel if you were forced to live, think, feel, and be a woman? Told that you MUST do what women do, how women do it, see things the way women see them in order to be a woman and you MUST be a woman and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? A trans woman does NOT fit, in a man’s social circle the same way a man does and yet they are expected to if they do not go through transition, they are expected to think, feel, and act just like any cis-gender man in that circle, but they can’t because their brain is STRUCTURED differently, so they are insulted, belittled beat on ridiculed, and humiliated by these men, constantly, all because their brain is STRUCTURED the same way a cis-gender woman’s brain is STRUCTURED. With their brain being STRUCTURED that way they would fit into a woman’s social circle but with their bodies being male, again they don’t fit in and they are excluded. They want to wear the same outfits the women wear because their brains tell them they should be just like them. Everything inside them SCREAMS that they are just like the people who are of the opposite gender and yet they are NOT allowed to be because other people are uncomfortable with them doing so, so they are FORCED to live in severe PAIN, anxiety, and depression. Trans people just want to be accepted for who they are, they want and are deserving of the very same rights as everyone else, no more and NO LESS. Here is the truth about the road to transition: First, the person MUST go to therapy, no therapy no transition, they will meet with a therapist who has knowledge and experience with transgender people. During this time they will begin social transitioning, social transitioning is nothing more than changing one's name and pronouns, and appearance such as hairstyle and clothing. Then after a number of sessions with the therapist (usually about a year) if the Dysphoria continues, and depending on the age of the person they may be given puberty blockers, (which are reversible). Then after many more sessions with the therapist and again if the Dysphoria continues they may be given hormones, it is these that have irreversible effects. Last: when they reach the age of CONSENT (CONSENT, NOT A KID, NO ONE IS DOING SURGERY ON KIDS) and if the Dysphoria continues, and if they have lived in the gender of their choice for a MINIMUM of 1 full year, and have letters from two therapists with one having a P.HD in psychology with both therapists having seen the person over a period of time they may get a consult from the surgeon, and there is usually a long waiting list for that, after the consult if the surgeon agrees then you get on the long waiting list for the surgery. IF ANYONE TELLS YOU DIFFERENTLY FROM THIS THEY ARE LYING TO YOU. Definition of a woman: How you define a woman is by how she sees herself, a woman is one who sees herself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a woman, thinks as a woman, acts as a woman, and lives as a woman, then what is the harm to treat and respect her as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Definition of a Man: How you define a man is by how he sees himself, a man is one who sees himself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a man, thinks as a man, acts as a man, and lives as a man, then what is the harm to treat and respect him as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you have a need to feel morally superior to others, “pull the beam out of your own eyes before you try to pull the mote out of another’s”. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you don’t understand it and it fills you with fear, fear of something that is different from what you are used to, different from YOU, either one goes forward or one stagnates and dies, you limit your thinking and can’t or won’t learn, grow, and adapt. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you just want to hate and hurt others, it gives you a sick thrill, and you use the LGBTQ as an excuse to do so. But ALL of you who do these are small, weak, insecure, monumentally stupid, and utterly pathetic excuses of human beings.

[@ye333]

The real question is why should gender be affirmed. If the answer is yes, then why dont we also affirm age, race, etc.

[@sarral2008]

And why it has to be affirmed by trying to emulate the biological opposite sex if biological sex doesn't matter.

[@muadhnate]

Medical access for adults isn't an issue, but kids - no. Just plain no.

[@susanhill833]

Here is the truth about the road to transition: First, the person MUST go to therapy, no therapy no transition, they will meet with a therapist who has knowledge and experience with transgender people. During this time they will begin social transitioning, social transitioning is nothing more than changing one's name and pronouns, and appearance such as hairstyle and clothing. Then after a number of sessions with the therapist (usually about a year) if the Dysphoria continues, and depending on the age of the person they may be given puberty blockers, (which are reversible). Then after many more sessions with the therapist and again if the Dysphoria continues they may be given hormones, it is these that have irreversible effects. Last: when they reach the age of CONSENT (CONSENT, NOT A KID, NO ONE IS DOING SURGERY ON KIDS) and if the Dysphoria continues, and if they have lived in the gender of their choice for a MINIMUM of 1 full year, and have letters from two therapists with one having a P.HD in psychology with both therapists having seen the person over a period of time they may get a consult from the surgeon, and there is usually a long waiting list for that, after the consult if the surgeon agrees then you get on the long waiting list for the surgery. IF ANYONE TELLS YOU DIFFERENTLY FROM THIS THEY ARE LYING TO YOU.

[@Daveomabegin]

I have shared this with my gay and lesbian friends. Thank you so much for making this video 😊

[@AndyJarman]

Not "cross sex" but synthetic "wrong sex" hormones.

[@markrussell3428]

Brilliant - SEGM please turn your focus on "Consent" and "malpractice/negligence". When does a lack of properly informed consent shift from negligence and give rise to a criminal case of battery or assault? How is it even possible for minors to actually fathom the life long consequences of what they are consenting to. Medical professionals should understand this and it is no different than over-prescribing drugs or failing to monitor vital signs. The videos in the WPATH files make it clear that clinicians openly postulate the issue of consent. We try to get consent but they know they cant achieve it and reluctantly go along with providing care so a child will be happy in the moment. The capacity to consent is best captured in the words of Prisha Mosely as part of her "detransition" coming out video: “I decided that I didn’t want to be a woman before I had ever experienced being a woman. I had no idea what being a woman was like, because I was a child". To quote from a report on the SEGM site: "There has never been a dispute about whether medical and surgical interventions can feminize or masculinize secondary and some primary sex characteristics. For children and adolescents [minors], the debate is not whether such transformations are possible, but [SHOULD WE and ] “at what age can youth meaningfully consent". The "should we" question opens up a whole other discussion about negligence given the "standards of care" for transgender health are dubious and predicted on deeply flawed evidence (as Biggs point out). So applying these standards to children when it is clear there is little to no evidence rises to negligence given minors require a higher standard before implementing medical interventions.

[@AndyJarman]

Ah, but the guardian can now sign for consent, if they don't they can be accused of harm and promoting conversion therapy - this brings with it a five year jail sentence.

[@AndyJarman]

You mean that paying a Chinese virology clinic to create a deadly virus, then forcing your population to undergo experimental gene therapy jabs to see if it worked should be illegal ? Hah, what nonsense.

[@AndyJarman]

Consent has nothing to do with this. Even consenting adults shouldn't receive experimental life long medicalisation for a mental disorder. That died out with frontal lobotomies. The insurance that pays for these mutilations does not pay for repairs when the surgery and wrong sex hormones create life threatening health conditions (necrosis, brittle bones, broken teeth, phantom pain). Nobody of sound mind can possibly consent to that - especially if they can't fund the rest of their lives undergoing corrective and remedial procedures.

[@sarral2008]

@@AndyJarman Was the guardian properly informed? I suspect not.

[@markrussell3428]

@@AndyJarman You nailed it! There are two stages here and both are aimed at undermining a parents ability to lead their child through to a meaningful life and achieve agency. The goal is to make the parent responsible for shortening their transitioned child's life span and shield the gender affirming service providers from liability. Its done this way: 1. Coercion, "do you want a dead daughter or live son". When this fails, given informed parents now see the lies the activist spew, they go straight to the jugular. 2. Forced compliance. Use the state apparatus to challenge custody using another euphemism "child protective services". The threat here is to have the state takeover conservatorship and/or guardianship. Abigail Martinez's case in California is a sad example of how this essential "life saving care" plays out. After taking her child away from her and placing the child in CPS, Abby's daughter was transitioned under state control. The 19-year-old, Yaeli, would later step in front of a train. There are large numbers of children being fed into this machine. Just try to get state/provinces to report the number of children in state care that are going through gender affirming care. They wont report.

[@newmonikermusic]

Excellent. Great work.

[@kashesan]

Thanks!

[@kashesan]

Thank you for this information. It seems to be quashed in the media.

[@stevencasteel6799]

I think the best first corrective action is a simple one. Get this stuff the hell out of our children's schools. The mental development should come from family and friends. It should not be in the hands of TOTAL STRANGERS.!

[@rosablume4346]

I like the very factual style. Hearing of all those flaws and weaknesses I am totally flumoxed how it was possible to shoehorn so much pro trans legislation in many countries into daily life.

[@charlesbruneski9670]

'Standards of care' can not be the evidence this care is good. It has to be based on prior evidence. Lobotomy was 'standard of care' at one point. The history of how they became the Standard is similar.

[@Traderbear]

I hope you are feeling better, Brother. Your anti woke content is exceptional 😊

[@susanhill833]

Here is the REAL TRUTH about Gay and Transgenderism: It is NOT about chromosomes (the XX or the XY) or the BODY, it is about the STRUCTURE of the human brain. A Doctor with a Ph.D. in Genetics and his team did research on the STRUCTURE of the human brain. They studied the brain of straight women and straight men, gay women, and gay men, as well as transgendered women and transgendered men. What they found is this, the STRUCTURE of the brain between a male and a female is as different from each other as night is from the day. They also found that there are two distinct and separate areas of the brain that deal with sexuality and gender. They found that the area for sexual orientation in gay men is STRUCTURED the same as in straight women, NOT straight men, and in gay women, that area is STRUCTURED the same as in straight men, NOT straight women. Likewise, the center in the brain that deals with gender identity is the same, in transgender women (male to a female) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-women, (born and identify as female) NOT cis-men, (born and identify as male), and in transgender men, (female to male) it is STRUCTURED the same as in cis-men, NOT cis-women. It has been STRUCTURED this way since BEFORE birth. Two other teams in different parts of the world doing the same study all independent of each other found the exact same results. When a baby is first formed in the womb it is formed 100% female. Then after a few weeks, a signal from the father's genes tells the baby's body, the body only, to change and become male. The baby goes on for a few more weeks this way until it can produce a massive amount of the male hormone testosterone, which then tells the brain to change into the male pattern, such a massive amount will never be seen in that Child's life again except at the onset of puberty. If for some reason that baby does not get that massive dose of testosterone in the womb then the brain, or parts of it, continues to develop in the female pattern. Or in the case of gay women or Trans men, at some time in the mother's pregnancy that baby received a small dose of testosterone at the wrong time, either the mother ingested it somehow or her body produced it or the baby’s own body produced it all of which can and have happened. When a baby is being formed in the womb, any variation, even in the slightest, of the chemicals can cause birth defects. You have seen these birth defects in babies being born all the time, some born blind, or deaf, born with missing limbs, or heart problems, or even with a spine outside of the body, and many, many others. So why is it so hard for the right to believe that a person’s BRAIN can be STRUCTURED in the opposite way from what their bodies say they should be? You can believe in all other birth defects so why not this? I will use transgender women for this example, even though the body is male she likes all the same things a cis-gender woman likes, her emotional likes, wants and needs are the same as any woman's, and the way she sees the world is the same. Her interactions are the same, everything about her is the same as any cis-gender woman except the body. Sexual characteristics (the body) are set by the genes (the XX or the XY) but Gender is set by the STRUCTURE of the BRAIN, this has been proven through sound scientific study. Gender is how one see themselves and their place in the world and how they interact with it. If your body is set one way and your brain the other it causes a disharmony of mind and body (gender dysphoria) it is not now or ever has been a DELUSION or a PERVERSION or a MENTAL ILLNESS. When someone is going through life with this Dysphoria their life is a living hell, when people tell them that they can't be WHO they are inside because that person is uncomfortable with it then you are forcing the trans person to live in severe PAIN, Anxiety, and Depression, a PAIN that having your arms and legs cut off with a dull rusty hacksaw without any anesthetics seem like nothing in comparison, a pain that kills, LITERALLY KILLS. Think of everything you like and want as a man or a woman, everything that makes you, you, and then think how you would feel if you were constantly told that you can't have it, or be it, or do the things you love, because you are the opposite of who and what you are now, that you must bury everything that makes you, you because other people don't like it because it makes them uncomfortable, If constantly you were told that you were evil and dammed because you are who you are, denied a job, or a home, insulted, belittled, assaulted and even targeted to be KILLED just because you exist, how would you feel? Women, think how would you feel if you were forced to live, think, told to feel like and be a man, And told that you MUST do what men do, how men do it, see things the way men see them in order to be a man and you MUST be a man and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? Men, think how you would feel if you were forced to live, think, feel, and be a woman? Told that you MUST do what women do, how women do it, see things the way women see them in order to be a woman and you MUST be a woman and that something is wrong with you if you don’t? How would you handle that? A trans woman does NOT fit, in a man’s social circle the same way a man does and yet they are expected to if they do not go through transition, they are expected to think, feel, and act just like any cis-gender man in that circle, but they can’t because their brain is STRUCTURED differently, so they are insulted, belittled beat on ridiculed, and humiliated by these men, constantly, all because their brain is STRUCTURED the same way a cis-gender woman’s brain is STRUCTURED. With their brain being STRUCTURED that way they would fit into a woman’s social circle but with their bodies being male, again they don’t fit in and they are excluded. They want to wear the same outfits the women wear because their brains tell them they should be just like them. Everything inside them SCREAMS that they are just like the people who are of the opposite gender and yet they are NOT allowed to be because other people are uncomfortable with them doing so, so they are FORCED to live in severe PAIN, anxiety, and depression. Trans people just want to be accepted for who they are, they want and are deserving of the very same rights as everyone else, no more and NO LESS. Here is the truth about the road to transition: First, the person MUST go to therapy, no therapy no transition, they will meet with a therapist who has knowledge and experience with transgender people. During this time they will begin social transitioning, social transitioning is nothing more than changing one's name and pronouns, and appearance such as hairstyle and clothing. Then after a number of sessions with the therapist (usually about a year) if the Dysphoria continues, and depending on the age of the person they may be given puberty blockers, (which are reversible). Then after many more sessions with the therapist and again if the Dysphoria continues they may be given hormones, it is these that have irreversible effects. Last: when they reach the age of CONSENT (CONSENT, NOT A KID, NO ONE IS DOING SURGERY ON KIDS) and if the Dysphoria continues, and if they have lived in the gender of their choice for a MINIMUM of 1 full year, and have letters from two therapists with one having a P.HD in psychology with both therapists having seen the person over a period of time they may get a consult from the surgeon, and there is usually a long waiting list for that, after the consult if the surgeon agrees then you get on the long waiting list for the surgery. IF ANYONE TELLS YOU DIFFERENTLY FROM THIS THEY ARE LYING TO YOU. Definition of a woman: How you define a woman is by how she sees herself, a woman is one who sees herself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a woman, thinks as a woman, acts as a woman, and lives as a woman, then what is the harm to treat and respect her as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Definition of a Man: How you define a man is by how he sees himself, a man is one who sees himself as one in mind and soul. If a person sees themselves as a man, thinks as a man, acts as a man, and lives as a man, then what is the harm to treat and respect him as one? If you cannot have compassion for another human being then how can you ask others to have compassion for you? Show compassion, empathy, and respect by calling them the name they prefer and with the pronouns they prefer. It does NOT harm you to do so but it does great harm to them when you don’t. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you have a need to feel morally superior to others, “pull the beam out of your own eyes before you try to pull the mote out of another’s”. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you don’t understand it and it fills you with fear, fear of something that is different from what you are used to, different from YOU, either one goes forward or one stagnates and dies, you limit your thinking and can’t or won’t learn, grow, and adapt. Some of you reject the LGBTQ community because you just want to hate and hurt others, it gives you a sick thrill, and you use the LGBTQ as an excuse to do so. But ALL of you who do these are small, weak, insecure, monumentally stupid, and utterly pathetic excuses of human beings.

[@UberBri]

How is Planned Parenthood involved in this?

[@sarral2008]

Seems contra-intuitive.

[@lindsaypaige4628]

Planned parenthood gives young girls testosterone, pretty sure is where my sister got access to it

[@nihilismistheonlyway4680]

I don't get this "it saves trans kids lives" alluding to the self delete. But as far as I personally understand it its untreated depression & anxiety that causes more "self deletes" than trans issues.... so why isn't mental health getting THIS kind of attention and momentum!???

[@user-rv7ph1jl5y]

Agree with what MikeB said on substack..The video clips of Levine, and the girl claiming it's needed for staying alive seem to have no direct meaning and clarity as to what is being said or what their purpose is. It feels a little disconnected. If someone doesn't know about the issue, it's not super engaging. Even the first clip of Scott just seems unsupported. Overall, it's a little dry and clinical but perhaps its just the arrangement and delivery.

[@noodleperson17]

Does anyone think these confused unhappy kids are attention seeking from all the professionals etc and the procedures that they get. Makes them feel important.

[@layaR3047]

You should add more about the money being made off these vulnerable people, like the "doctors" at Vanderbilt

[@youtubecensors5419]

Man here. I have to say I get a little annoyed when women poison and distort themselves to larp as a male. I imagine women feel similar. My gender isn't just a costume you put on because you don't like being a girl. Every boy struggles hard in his journey through masculinity to find himself and prioritize traits and values he wants to pursue or avoid, all while testing himself and avoiding prison or worse. You don't get to leapfrog that and claim you're "one of us". I absolutely guarantee that females, who can really alter the trajectory of their lives during youth, have additional emotional climates to navigate, and of course have a wider breadth of life opportunities in front of them to assess feel even more strongly about counterfeit women.

[@lindsaypaige4628]

The frog voiced girls trying to be men are always so cringe too. They reeeeeally like to overuse bro talk. It is insulting both ways, both groups of trans are just portraying a caricature of what they think the opposite sex is

[@lovelover4408]

Woman here - I relate to what you’re saying! It’s straight up insulting what some of these men think it means to be a woman. According to them it’s makeup and dresses and… shopping and hating bugs… and being sexy. So a big bag of stereotypes and zero respect for the reality of what it means to be a woman

[@janebennetto5655]

❤🇬🇧

[@TheCentristChad]

0:00 was that a transman?

[@lovelover4408]

Yep. Look closely at her left arm, looks like she got the skin removed to create a faux p.en.is. 🙁

[@ebert8756]

❤

[@The_Rock_Princess]

3:19 in video I noticed the fresh cuttings on that kids belly and arms!? What happened?! Not including what appears to be breast removal? This is sick on so many levels 🤦‍♀️😞 Thank you for bring attention to this issue❤️‍🩹