THE LAST OF US 2 - Ellie Kills Abby's Dog, Boyfriend and Pregnant Friend

The Last of Us Part II Gameplay Walkthrough PS4 PRO No Commentary 1080p 60fps HD let's play playthrough review guide
Showcasing all cutscenes movie edition, all boss fights / boss fights, side missions, upgrades, outfits / costumes, all characters, best moments, final boss and true ending, secret ending.
Subscribe for more!
Shirrako Store: teespring.com/...
Discord: / discord
Follow me on Facebook: / shirrakogaming
Follow me on Twitch: / shirrakogaming
Follow me on Twitter: / shirrakogaming

[@cypressketch]

How is no one talking about how Ellie hears Joel's voice calling out to her instead of Tommy's? Such an incredible detail

[@263malice]

Holy-fucking shit. I didn’t notice that.

[@cypressketch]

@@263malice right??! it's the little things about this game that I really appreciate

[@RK-xw2kf]

I might be deaf, in what part?

[@Faheel_56]

@@263malice ya me too

[@lukebristol]

Holy shit. This game is so awesome.

[@reecemannsays]

This why I love Kratos' words "Close your heart to it, On your journey you will be attacked by all manner of creature, close your heart to their desperation, close your heart to their suffering, do not allow yourself to feel for them, They Will Not Feel For You"

[@dovah2162]

Beautiful, unlike this poor exuse of a game

[@yokoyakamori6589]

This is why I love GoW more.

[@mike_izzo]

Ellie had to take example from Kratos he spared no one

[@reecemannsays]

@@mike_izzo Big time facts brother

[@Kaikaifilu1994]

“Yeah, but, that dog wasn’t exactly suf-“ “DID I STUTTER, B O I?”

[@MoonshineBeforeSunshine]

"Yes, I killed everything & everyone on my path connected to Abby, but when I finally got to her, 'revenge is bad.'"

[@samcheer_7711]

The game : is about to get revenge on someone Also the game : revenge is bad ok

[@TommyTipex]

such genius storytelling 10/10 I cried - IGN

[@toxilex4474]

Think for a second, if Ellie killed Abby, Lev would have wanted to come back to kill her, therefore the cycle of revenge will continue. Ellie did the wise decision to let Abby live to end this cycle once and for all. I hope this is clear now

[@rdowg]

@@toxilex4474 "dont start the cycle of revenge by killing her, end it by letting her live and killing everyone else!"

[@rency1803]

@@toxilex4474 then she could just fucking snap Lev's neck or something like anybody would even care. Heck even if she just kill Abby and left Lev might not even survive.

[@devlinorsomething854]

i love how ellie copied joel’s way of interrogation but didn’t quite *execute* it as well.

[@paulorufalco]

she should tie both and keeping torture then to mental esgotation (like Joel did)

[@thecockman]

Oh man 💀

[@jayyy1677]

💀

[@ashishhembrom3905]

Hey man she at least got a bonus kill.

[@ashishhembrom3905]

@KEN ŔEEVE thats the joke

[@kevingarnett2000]

Let's just remember Mel voted yes to kill Ellie in that house

[@briyanapanton7437]

And Abby and Owen were the ones to not kill Ellie that's why I hated Mel and I still do hate her but dang she was pregnant this is hard man

[@JGregory757]

@@briyanapanton7437 how was Ellie supposed to know she was pregnant

[@briyanapanton7437]

@@JGregory757 Well really in that scene it was really Mel's fault for not announcing to Ellie that she's pregnant I feel like Mel just put herself and her baby in danger but either way I still hated Mel.

[@isaacalanis2777]

And let's not forget that Manny even mentioned that Mel wanted more joel dead than the rest of the crew

[@briyanapanton7437]

@@isaacalanis2777 Remember that on Abby's story later she said to Abby that Joel deserved worse I hate Mel man.

[@jakubramisz1337]

The story is like collecting all the infinity stones and not snap at the end.

[@jayharris6087]

Or going back in time to stop Thanos just letting him do everything all over again

[@sbj97]

Fucking facts 😂😂😂

[@-aa6991]

Which is essentially the story of endgame in a nutshell anyways "yeah sorry uno reverse lol ecksdee we made the bad guy go away america fuck yeah lurl!"

[@taytay32865]

Explains why Avengers is trash and TLoU isn't lol

[@thefilmwatcher1302]

Taylor Heil I think that should be the other way around. This game is GARBAGE. The Avengers films are cinematic history. There’s a huge difference.

[@atherinenazarova8044]

In this scene we perfectly see that Owen cared for Abby more, than for Mel. If Mel had been the love of his life, he wouldn't have started a fight with Ellie and would've done everything to keep Mel and his child safe. But Owen chose to protect Abby. There isn't Ellie's fault, she just defended herself.

[@blackcobra3553]

THANK YOU!

[@canoodlepoodle7892]

I LOVE this observation. Owen was a very loving and compassionate character but when the cards were down it was obvious his love for Abby trumped anything else. Him fighting back secured the fate of Mel and THEIR child, on the prayer he could see Abby again. Selfish and heartbreaking considering Mel's pregnancy was the last thing he acknowledged before he died, and what weighed on both characters heavily.

[@hunormagyar1843]

Ikr lol all these people in this story are kinda fucked up... lol

[@RecklessFire29]

@Catherine Nazarova Are you stupid? You don't get to assault someone, then when they defend themselves, claim you're defending yourself. She attacked them first and proceeded to violently murder them for daring to try to fight back rather than give their friend up.

[@Jetrules231]

And Nora actually started this. Ellie was more compromising until Nora was a bitch and had to twist the knife in about joel

[@mosesnathanael1039]

She can kill a pregnant woman but not the girl who bashed Joel’s head

[@thebeezneez3539]

Ah, another shallow gamer who can’t empathize and understand why she did what she did.

[@kinghades3356]

@@thebeezneez3539 nah youre just a casual

[@cosodesign8953]

Douma naw you just lack empathy and critical thinking skills. Basically your a casual when it comes to emotional intelligence.

[@carbonmonoxide8859]

@@cosodesign8953 so... if your dad gets killed you will be with the person who did it? You'll be like: well maybe he deserved it, I'll stay with the killer he might be the good guy here. What's wrong with you?

[@Shensdojo7]

I'm so glad Abby lived... what a warrior

[@johnoguntuase1162]

90% of comments: Ellie kills everyone to get to Abby but doesn't kill Abby 10% of comments: The dog's just doing his job

[@ploobus194]

LOAF LIFE what shit are you on.

[@railenherman6482]

It was a her.

[@eduardocardenas8392]

So, if a dog tries to kill you because "it's not his fault, he was trained to do it" and your only chance to live is assured by killing it, wouldn't you do it?. Come on...

[@johnoguntuase1162]

@@eduardocardenas8392 Yh I would no doubt. But I'm just saying tho🤣🤣🤣

[@TheKokiche]

@@eduardocardenas8392 nah man i better die. Humans are trash egoists while a dog is trying to survive and doesnt try to kill you because he hates you.

[@gamerdudepunk]

Ellie: literally kills everything in the game Also Ellie: spares the main villain because plot

[@MrPatpac24]

You just gotta love plot convinence lol

[@lexluthor3811]

@@StevesSon the fact is. She was. She was willing to kill Dinah even after knowing she was pregnant and it took lev being shook to stop her from doing so

[@Yourlocalscumbag]

@@StevesSon I don’t understand the hate this game gets. Big fan of the first and this one just was the cherry on top. This one really shows that there are always 2 sides to every story. How would anyone be satisfied with Abby getting killed at the end especially seeing how much both have been thru

[@lexluthor3811]

@@StevesSon lol and? That just proves Neil wanted to make Abby the main character even though back in a 2013 interview he straight up says how the revenge plot makes no sense yet shoe horns it into part 2 the moment he has no one to rein him in. Games not as deep as u think it is, and neither are u.

[@casbinwat]

@@StevesSon Except Tlou 1 isnt a disjointed mess of a story, and clearly leaning to one side.

[@Dabomb2394]

I love that Ellie, who has personally felt the impact of information leakage, conveniently leaves a map with a shit ton of personal information lying on the ground.

[@yourboybobert878]

Fr

[@charlottemartin4715]

I took that as more of a warning so Abby knew. Like “look at this I know where your newly dead friends are and now I’m gonna find you”

[@guelspace]

​@@charlottemartin4715What, you guys are inventing something that never happened, she just forgot the map there because she was in shock. Just that.

[@brunish8070]

@@guelspace fr bro XDD

[@Arvigeus]

I love how she also conviniently marked her own location. I also love how Abby never questioned this suspiciously placed map. I love how Mel wears baggy clothes just this time, so she can hide her pregnancy from Ellie. Everyone is as intelligent as the plot demands them to be. Can't believe there are people who hate this game just because Joel dies - they miss this master writing!

[@Zombieshark420x]

Logical person: Ellie: You can survive this... I just want her. Owen: Ok... please, shes pregnant... don't shoot. *Moves Mel behind him, and points to the location on the map first* Mel: What are you doing! Owen: Saving our child... Its the only choice we have. Abby would understand... Mel: *Hesitates, but also points after placing her hand on her belly and looking down* Ellie: *Sees the spots are the same, releasing a relieving breath, but then shifts back to being focused on the two* Now go... I don't want to ever see you again... Do you understand? *Mel and Owen agree and they all part ways* Stupid people: *Everything in this video*

[@thefilmwatcher1302]

Synerix Why does The Last of Us even have a sequel? That was a great game.

[@soulsborne8292]

Ellie killed Nora without esitate a single second, the didn't trust her, and that's why they tried to defend themselves

[@howtoeataham]

Sad that a random comment makes more sense than a game that was developed over 7 years lol

[@EmperorOfChaos]

Owen never even wanted to be involved in it.

[@ricknochefort4941]

souls borne that makes it even worse, they knew the danger and what she wanted and still failed to comply, they deserved it.

[@Derethevil]

"Stupid dog." Close Ellie. Very close. But you should have said: "Stupid Naughty Dog."

[@1996Resistance]

This comment dude😂😂😂🤣

[@brauliozt8754]

This is so underrated

[@ssniperaaron]

HHahahahhahahh

[@sekaibreaker9243]

Tuff bogabogabogaaaaaa!!!

[@AtMr8MinutesIsReal]

Sekai Breaker AAAHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!

[@cadmusravenstag4403]

Naughty Dog: "You won't be forced to kill dogs..." Druckmann: "You see, lies are progressive..."

[@granalmirantethrawn2972]

He really said that?

[@TheCart54321]

Well I mean technically you can sneak past them in the game

[@jessieqk12]

Cool Dude not Alice though

[@gabrielhanson8575]

@Milagro 013 no way 😂😂😂

[@BlueSkullX]

He also said Ellie was the only playable character in this game. That was the biggest lie of all.

[@Duneek]

And people still were mad Abby survived. Ellie killed this girl's entire social network and Abby gets to live knowing that. That IS revenge.

[@sukramreddevil4576]

Exactly, people are so idiotic, Ebby is absolutely innocent

[@jacobramirez8753]

Brainwashed by drukman. Ellie deserved to kill them all

[@Duneek]

@@jacobramirez8753 And Joel deserved to die. So now what?

[@jacobramirez8753]

@@Duneek you’re brainwashed

[@Duneek]

@@jacobramirez8753 Oh no. What will I ever do now that Jacob Ramirez thinks I'm brainwashed? My world is officially ending.

[@TheJoker-qo4fg]

You know a story is bad when “it was all a dream” is a better ending to the story

So true

[@sedukafe]

Nah, you're just liking cheap stories, that's all

[@chegglord490]

sedukafe like this one maybe?

[@angryspy1026]

@@sedukafe yea because "Revenge is bad" isn't already a cheap story narrative....

[@jayazoriginal4879]

You just didn't understand it

[@DMBRNGR-nm8wd]

I never understood why she felt so bad about killing Mel. She clearly told them both she wanted Abby and they didnt have to die, and Mel proceeded to try to jam a knife down her windpipe, she had no choice.

[@jameslanier2510]

Uh, Mel was going to cooperate and only attacked Ellie after Ellie shot Owen. Also, Mel's fetus didn't exactly have a say in what Mel did.

[@DMBRNGR-nm8wd]

@@jameslanier2510 no that's absolutely true but I'm strictly talking about in that moment, she did what she had to do. I get it, Mel was enraged that she shot Owen, but intelligence says dont bring a knife to a gunfight unless you're the Punisher. I just think it was a crappy detail of the story. Mel was smart enough in the game to pull some "wait until she turns around and so what I have to do" type shit. I just dont feel like that was the move she would have made. Know what I'm saying?

[@BreadCatMarcus]

It's moreso the baby that Ellie regrets. Killing Mel and Owen is just another means to an end.

[@sentientbeing8738]

She didnt feel bad about killing Mel she felt bad about killing her kid.

[@TheJadedJames]

It doesn't matter what Ellie said or claimed to want. Once she broke in and drew a gun on them, she put them in a situation where anyone would logically conclude they might have to defend themselves. They knew the best case scenario was just Ellie would leave to go murder their friend.

[@p0neh1]

Ellie accidentally killed a pregnant women without knowing she was pregnant and broke down after finding out, Abby heard that the women she was about to kill was pregnant, and said "Good" with no hesitation.

[@xdarkwolf2255]

They're both bad people in a way. Abby definitely worse cause when she seeks revenge in a sadistic way but I like that Lev tells her not to and Abby chooses to not kill anyone else after that and tries to be a good person

[@firefly9838]

Abby's seeks revenge so she bad. Ellie kills by happenstance so all is forgiven

[@darryljack6612]

You are missing the point entirely... That revenge can drive someone down a path without knowledge. And this is the reason why we are shown two separate perspectives. Ellie's Perspective: Ellie kills Mel and she doesnt know Mel is pregnant, Ellie only finds out because Owen tells her and then Ellie opens Mel's jacket and see's truth and consequences of her revenge and breaks down. But then you have to flip the script. Abby's perspective: She comes in after leaving and sees there was an attack, Mel's jacket is open not closed meaning from Abby's perspective who ever killed Mel knew she was pregnant because it was visible. If the player is to indulge in the notion of an eye for an eye, then that logic continues down to Abby's portion of the game. This is why after stopping for a split second after hearing Dina is pregnant she almost follows through on it, because to her Ellie (or anyone of Ellie's comrades) killed someone she knew who was clearly and visibly pregnant.

[@p0neh1]

@@darryljack6612 And Abby is the one who decides to take revenge on a pregnant woman who didn't kill her pregnant way. I don't care. Abby sucks. Ellie's not much better. The story is told badly and should have been designed and formatted better

[@darryljack6612]

@@p0neh1 Because that's what revenge is is, its cyclical and its blind. All abby knows is that someone from this group killed all of mine so i'll kill all of theirs. Mel was visibly pregnant so if they killed a pregnant woman with no remorse, so can i. And if the player up to this point believes in the notion of an eye for an eye, then that madness is the natural conclusion of that thinking.

[@andrewkane2637]

5:21 When your friend gets a double kill but it's actually a tripple

[@naeemislam8175]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jellyslopefall572]

If you’re going to make jokes like that you’re no better than Abby

[@rishijakhwal5290]

@@jellyslopefall572 ok?😂

[@theredscout1633]

Its a fucking game xd

[@Cartman11111]

@@jellyslopefall572 Abby is better tho

[@Warlike78]

I'm just gonna say it, it was their own fault for attacking Ellie in the first place and Mel went into the front lines herself. Ellie killed Mel and Owen after she said "you can survive this. I just need her" which then the pregnant woman didn't run (or attempt to) or hide, but instead attacked Ellie with a knife. It's Mel's fault for being their in the first place, Owen deserved it anyway.

[@cellP8]

I think it was very stupid and reckless of Mel for trying to fight back in that condition... Same for Owen, he said he was tired of fighting and killing.

[@yocloak]

Owen and mel was also the main reason manny and that other dude didnt kill ellie that was enough to make me feel slightly bad for them

[@anthonydmccormickjr9393]

If Mel and Owen had enough common sense, she wouldn't have to defend herself.

[@carasynthiadune9842]

I think Mel attacked because she loved Owen but then if she had thought for a second, she should have run away, had the baby, then went after Ellie later. That would have honored Owen more since it was his baby.

[@SDSOverfiend]

Should’ve respected the jux. Period. Person got a gun to you and demands somebody whereabouts. You play the hand you was dealt. Owen silly ass could’ve reminded her it was him who stopped Manny from killing her. M el had no business being on the frontlines pregnant. She would’ve made a bad parent

[@antequerini]

Imagine being Abby and finding all your friends are dead, and when she got the opportunity to revenge. Nope revenge its bad.

[@whichDude]

Revenge is fine. Just don't leave 2 witnesses alive who will clearly come back for revenge on you. Don't leave loose ends.

[@Shensdojo7]

If Abby had killed Ellie after Ellie's broken arm It would be so badass.

[@viciiaa3036]

@@whichDude abby is actually smart af

[@chubbyfug4601]

Viciiaa big brain with no charisma

[@deadaccount5730]

Carlos Antequera she got? Don’t you mean you get because we are in Abby's prospection

[@FieuFieu]

Ellie didn't want to kill them, she only wanted informations but those morons attacked her.

[@fauziqasem390]

owen was trying to talk to her and she didnt want to listen so in my opinion she was asking for it

[@darth_ender]

@@San-cb9mj No

[@aibartalgatuly3011]

@@San-cb9mj what the fuck? Ellie is not a cold blooded killer, she only ever kills when other people are not cooperating. You’re the only one who’s stupid here.

[@aibartalgatuly3011]

@@fauziqasem390 Owen literally jumps her in the cutscene, did u even watch it?

[@lemmedrivedaboat5848]

She would’ve killed them regardless

[@EchoBoomer1987]

TLOUS Part III, you play the part of a female dog because that was her father you killed, so you get revenge by killing Ellie. Then you play a campaign that humanizes the dog.

[@IKnowImGayWhenISayThisBut]

Please don't give Drunkman ideas

[@muchduck3754]

@@IKnowImGayWhenISayThisBut Drunkman 🤣🤣🤣

[@nave712]

👎🏼👎🏼

[@ibrahimlodhi9637]

Beautifully illustrated narrative. 10/10

[@Matt_Underwood]

Drunkman: Anita, is this the right way to do it? Anita Sarkeesian: Yes, but give the female dog more male dog features to... appeal to both genders... and muscles, lots and lots of muscles Drunkman: Like the Buffed Doge meme? Anita Sarkeesian: Exactly like that Buffed Doge meme... but female... and male... at the same time Drunkman: You are a God!!

[@prafullarjeria]

All three attacked her first and tried to kill her.. Title should say Ellie saves herself.

[@marcor6284]

Uhm, no? Actually it's Owen who SAVES Ellies Life in that house in the beginning...

[@Emolt76]

Ehhhh sort of! Besides I don't know about you, but Ellie ain't no Sociopath. The revelation understandably still wounded her.

[@RAPNTUDO]

It's funny How they made the game to make you feel for Abby and abby's friends, but I couldn't care less about them...

[@crisdominguez5403]

Bro fr i went through the whole game wanting to kill Abby lmao

[@MrSoBitchy]

same

[@melyshrimp3558]

Fr

[@ilikeslushxp4377]

Tell me you can’t feel empathy without telling me you can’t feel empathy

[@jesse3584]

@@ilikeslushxp4377 bruh why should we feel empathy for a person that literally hates her friends. She treats them like shit. She's literally only nice to owen even she gives him attitude for no reason. She was cool with manny but didn't give a fuck when he died

[@smoker5989]

How did Ellie go from the cute sarcastic little girl from the first game to this?

[@kyiaao]

Probably after helplessly witnessing Joel get his head clubbed in front of her

[@LuccatielD7]

Easy: bad writing.

[@samc5306]

What? Cute sarcastic little girl? She's always been like this. You know how many people she's killed in the first game? You remember when she killed David? Also she gave all these people a chance to survive as she only wanted Abby but yet they chose to attack her instead which made them die.

[@HomeDefender30]

I’m not standing up for this game so don’t take this the wrong way.... but she has been killing people since she was what 12-13? That kind of takes a toll on people.

[@ggamesgarner8027]

Comrade Doggo it really seemed like she was like this before Joel died tho.

[@PonyJarCollector]

All this to not kill Abbomination in the end. Pitiful...

[@valen8560]

yeah wtf, and she showed the strong desire to even left Dina too, all these only to bring out the fight with Abby who didn't want to AND spared her when Ellie could've choked her to death seriously wtf

[@HappyPotat]

Think pf it this way, it's got to hurt more being the only one to not die.

[@JT044-iz1cv]

Gotta sequel bait somehow.Even though K doubt many people will buy the 3rd game.

[@julianmarco4185]

@@HappyPotat Giagantor Abby held a grudge for 4 years with her daddy. And she didn't end Ellie when she had the chance. And now all her friends are dead. Do you think she is just going to let this go?

[@user-ti6hq2tc9o]

feminist logic. there can be no consequences for wamen

[@amiciprocul8501]

Anyone else forget what Owen looked like whenever he was offscreen.

[@daltonio6001]

No because he’s an amazing character

[@rebotsomat]

@@daltonio6001 You can tell who read the leaks before giving the game an honest chance on its own.

[@seraviloxelavlogs]

He’s a generic white guy lol

[@VileVamp]

@@rebotsomat Found the shill.

[@rebotsomat]

@@VileVamp where's my money then

[@jetstreamchad4712]

TBH im just glad tommy survived tho

[@christopherv623]

You’re in for a treat buddy

[@slight7596]

Christopher Vidal pretty sure he just loses an eye lol

[@samjr1151]

@@christopherv623 Hes still alive just lost his eyesight on his right eye.

[@legendoflegends1698]

me too, but he lost everything

[@GenshinLover283]

@@samjr1151 at least Ellie still has him, I guess.

[@twistednipz7182]

The writers tried way too hard to manipulate you into hating Ellie and loving Abby. It’s like they took advice straight from Rian Johnson

[@kevingame3198]

And the death threats didn’t work either take advice from homelander you don’t decide what goes on the 7 I decide

[@thelookingcat]

Exactly, because Ellie is awesome and Abby cannot be forgiven

[@cinderfall1396]

@@thelookingcat facts

[@niazshah320]

More like the writers tried to provide some context to undeserving players such as yourself

[@thelookingcat]

@@niazshah320 how's he undeserving? We just took a liking to the only human character, and that character was murdered in the game, so we all want revenge. Simple

[@JRMAV1]

Here’s Ellie, showing remorse Then there’s Abby who shows ZERO remorse the entire game.

[@aaron.y2k]

she did show remorse… she cared for lev and yara

[@kyree4695]

@@aaron.y2kAbby only saved them so she don’t live with the guilt of leaving 2 kids who save her life to die btw

[@aaron.y2k]

@@kyree4695 she literally cared about them so much what…

[@cherryflack1114]

so we forget when abby spared ellie n tommy in the beginning? when she saves yara and lev? when she just silently nods after mel tells her shes a piece of sh\t? when she spared dina AND ellie( the person who killed all her friends AND dog)? yes abby never shows remorse😁

[@superman-007]

The acting graphics and game mechanics are good but the story script is horrible

[@badreedinedjellali1328]

why the hell would Lora builly voices a character like abby oh yeah because of money

[@calvingonsalves7293]

The story wasn't bad, it just wasn't real like the first part.

[@boryontotheleader2328]

@@calvingonsalves7293 in other words, it's shit

[@somestuff7468]

BoRyonto The Leader agreed

[@rebotsomat]

The dialogue is fine, you are talking about the actual story beats.

[@Kuchen_Dienstag]

So actually a triple kill plus the dog. That's impressive! I really liked this scene

[@GermaTroo]

Your weird

[@timelordastrodo6408]

I felt sympathy for the dog. She was a real sweetheart in Abby's gameplay

[@xfdmx7dolorit629]

RIP ALICE

[@zenituragaming5043]

That's what they wanted you to feel to sympathize with abby

[@ShadowKari]

well still protecting evil so good riddance.

[@FreshZCORD]

@@zenituragaming5043 me sympathizing with the dog doesn't make me sympathize with abby

[@zenituragaming5043]

@@FreshZCORD no you see abby pets the dog ellie kills the dog it's just a fucking cheap storytelling mechanic

[@alvarojokerpersona5757]

4:44 you can hear owen says "pregnant" more or less , thats why ellie after says no no and open the jacket of mel

[@liam6170]

I never understand why they did not bring that up at the very least

[@shardulsatrange]

Okay for the confuses ones in the comments saying , " but the dog trying to kill her" ..yes exactly and so was Abby.

[@Beforezzz]

Abby only tried killing Ellie after she wasted pretty much everyone she ever cared about. In the end, Ellie threatened Lev to force Abby to fight her sooo...

[@mariatsv5503]

@@Beforezzz Mate, Abby's reactions to the deaths of her friends were undeniably underwhelming. She only went full crisis mode once she discovered Owens body. Apart from that, not once did she mention Nora, Jordan, Lea and even Mel. Even in S.Barbara she only "wrote" to Owen. Besides, not once did she show any signs of remorse for her actions. Also, she only spared Dina cause of Lev. On the other hand, Ellie s revenge (I personally really vibed with that unlike her) mentally and physically drained her. In my opinion, she should have died, I really wanted her to die. It seems to me that the whole story is pointless and I strongly believe that the reason behind that ending wasnt "revenge is bad" , but "lets make a 3rd game about Abby and Lev and try to parallel their relationship with Joel and Ellie's".

[@Beforezzz]

@@mariatsv5503 I'm not your mate, and I was only explaining to that guy why Ellie letting Abby go isn't the same as letting the dog rip her throat out.

[@Beforezzz]

@@aakarshpai75 I know what they meant by mate. My goodness, I'm not five.

[@marcomarco6834]

@@mariatsv5503 u wish

[@axeld2150]

And yet she couldn't kill the one and only abby Edit: what the fuck happen in the comments?

[@pierregotwings]

ツᴍʀ.ᴀsᴄᴇɴᴅ the whole thing pisses me off and let’s start with Joel death.

[@jogymogy3691]

In Part 3: Abbey and Ellie join forces... Or even worse: Abbey is the new central character...

[@rebotsomat]

Lemme guess, you read the leaks and just watched other people play, but never did it yourself without influence.

[@MoarRobots]

If you think killing Abby is what the narrative needed, please look over what the game's themes are again

[@Mr.Scott86]

@@MoarRobots so what are the themes of this game, neil himself said it was hate

[@muhammadsyafiqadli4685]

I feel bad for the people who made the graphics and the details of this game. The person who direct the story narrative is the one to blame for all of this dumpster fire.

[@franciscomacedo4667]

@Jack Adams you salty bro?

[@TwoBlockAnime]

@Jack Adams What a pathetic soyboy

[@thefilmwatcher1302]

Jack Adams I’d like to see you do something better.

[@suchtigershroob3987]

@Jack Adams How old are you, 10 ?

[@redxhand]

@@suchtigershroob3987 he's 10.

[@hanhnguyen5344]

4:44 it said "inaudible" but if you listen closely you can actually hear Owen saying "pregnant". That's why Ellie know about the baby.

[@dy031101]

So she killed, on account of mere association, people who didn't club Joel to death but spared the person who did? What is this crap!? That's Naughty Dogs' idea of revenge? No, I'm sorry, I'd expect this sort of things from Hentai, but at least that subset of Hentai doesn't take itself seriously.

[@baconingbad]

No, this is their idea of anti-revenge narrative. It sucks bad either way though.

[@Wimmig43at339]

She also forgave Abby but not the bigot sandwich dude for making fun of her.

[@queenastrid4278]

you're just being inmature since the moment that you assumed that the game is about avenging Joel. Ellie regreted this and she showed it when she saw Mel was pregnant, and the same hapenned with those that attacked her even when she tried to be mercyful. This is not Naughty Dog's idea of revenge, this is Naughty Dog showing how revenge ends taking away more things of what it gives. And how people from this cruel world are still humans that can empathyze with the others like Abby did with Yara and Lev and like Ellie did with Abby in the end. Grow up, they aren't just some animals killing each other to entertain you

[@Zeegoku1007]

@@queenastrid4278 Finally someone with a decent criticism !

[@realpplayers3]

@@queenastrid4278 say whatever you want, the storyline is pointless

[@joshw9426]

If u listen closely to when Tommy comes in and says Ellie thats actually Joel’s voice, a pre cool detail

[@jordanverbeek5121]

4:44 He's not "inaudible" here. He clearly gasps "pregnant."

[@aynoooo8692]

The game just put inaudible lmao

[@hayleymsiebert7526]

Yer he says pregnant

[@TheRealGara]

They set all this up to manipulate the player into feeling bad, but it just doesn't work. It's like they wanted an, "oh what have I done" moment, but it landed flat for me. I constantly felt like I was being beat over the head in to feeling sorry for characters rather than letting me reach those conclusions on my own with good writing.

[@oogabooga9100]

lazy writing from this game = overly privileged white liberals that have had everything handed to them.

[@anotherrandomguy8871]

I just really don’t give a shit about Mel and Owen. Like nice, the hired murderer mercenaries that are part of a group that would kill a civilian for any petty reason, have a backstory, cool can I get back to playing as Ellie? Doesn’t even Abby say that they’ve killed kids before out of defense? But oh look at the poor dog that Abby killed in self defense, Ellie is so evil for that!

[@homiesoprano]

Best part of the game

[@SuperVoidBoyz]

You know what else is kinda funny. Mel the pregnant lady put up more of a fight then Owen did.

[@baconingbad]

The Void Boyz Owen didn’t even manage to fight Ellie, lol. He got shot in an attempt to disarm her and Mel used the situation to attack Ellie.

[@ethanbradshaw2858]

Poor doggy tho

[@Joeyy1024]

Ya, the flashbacks were the best part of the game.

[@chiyosake]

Hell yeah brother!

[@CowboyBebopCrew]

Man, I remember this and the scene that followed. There were definitely no winners in this game - everyone suffered. It was a great game, but extremely hard to play through.

[@apocalypsebricksstopmotion6193]

I agree.

[@xaviervega468]

Meh, Abby still has Lev and a possible future with the Fireflies. Elle has absolutely NOTHING.

[@sukramreddevil4576]

@@xaviervega468 She only lost jessie, who she didnt care about and Joel idiot! She has Tommy, Dina, JJ and home and Jackson, unlike ebby who lost her home!!!

[@David-vq7kc]

thank you! I feel like everyone misses this point and just care about Joel and Ellie.

[@elliswrigley4570]

@@xaviervega468 Well, that's because Lev was Abby's reason to live, Ellie just lived off vengeance until she was empty, despite seemingly living a happy life with Dina on the farm. I'm not excusing the crappy writing in moralising the antagonist half-way through the game and expecting the audience to sympathise with her through recency-bias, she is objectively more morally corrupt than Ellie, but damn I had at least wished the game gave us a CHOICE to kill her. The same scene can play out with Ellie drowning her (she doesn't lose her fingers because that felt unnecessarily cruel) and the user can stop mashing square and come to their own judgement. I know the age difference between Abby and Ellie is temporal but both were on that same track. The game ends with Ellie trying to find her reason to live after her cyclical violence comes to an end, rather than being alone and not being able to play the guitar anymore.

[@XXXTENTAClON227]

“Don’t worry he doesn’t bite” The dog in question: 0:17

[@hugoandreasalmasol3439]

Joel: "You're mumbling in your sleep, i hate nightmares" Ellie: "yeah, me too"

[@themajesticbulldog3832]

Isn’t that from the first game?

[@Jay501st]

@@themajesticbulldog3832 Yes, but it's the other way around lmao

[@underta1egaminggaming683]

10/10 riveting story true tlou

[@keviune]

I hate the excuses or criticisms/reasons on Abby's story that people think the game is trying to tell you "Abby is good, Ellie is bad" which it is clearly not doing. In the first game, we see the world and story through joels and Ellies eyes, we see their backstories etc. We learn that Joel is definitely not a good person but not a bad one either. Ellie kills people to the ones that is a threat to her and Joel e.g David. She does what's necessary for her survival. In Abbys perspective, she had a Dad that was killed by Joel, and she had a rage to kill him to get it over with. They show her good side and her perspective to the story when all the crap went down. Both of them had flaws, they killed they murdered in both sides and perspectives, When we played voth of them, we killed, tortured and made people suffered, Abby and Ellie. Each one of them are doing what they want to do for theirselves, they're in it for their selves and their own greed. None of them is good, each one of them has flaws and they're evil and good in a way. No one is an antagonist or "hero" in the game. It's two sides that they think they're doing good by fighting each otherand getting revenge but for Abby, Joel and ellie are the bad guys in her perspective. For Ellie, Abby and her group are the bad guys for killing Joel. Its two neutral sides fighting each other blindly by revenge and rage. Abby has a right to get angry and pissed by her dad being murdered and her long time friends, and so does Ellie. There's no real good side. Both are fighting for their own reasons, and it's not because of pure evil. If your dad got murdered, you'd go after his killer. If your Caretaker thats like a dad gets murdered, you're going after that/those killers.

[@Mrgramzo96]

>be Ellie >kill woman >find out shes pregnant >feel immediate remorse >feel shame >sick to stomach >traumatized >Be Abby >about to kill woman >get told she is pregnant >relish the idea of killing her >with barely contained glee say "good" Naw, Abby is straight up evil

[@Ismael-kc3ry]

@@Mrgramzo96minutes after learning her friends were murdered, one of them also being pregnant and not knowing Ellie felt remorse. Ellie also murders far more people in cold blood over only one person. If one of them is “evil” (if you want to reduce it to that) then they both are.

[@uzomaemmanuel3760]

Lol don't waste your breath on these ones, outrage is way better than reasoning.

[@codyeaster290]

Dude, you should totally write speeches.

[@mjmb2017]

Show aby with a dog Make ellie kill dog. Oldest trick in the book

[@tmaziriri]

Joel saving Ellie put Abby on her revenge trail. Abby's revenge trail put Ellie on a revenge trail. At the end of it everyone they both loved was pretty much dead. Always remember kids, “ *He who seeks revenge digs two graves* .”

[@pughuky5018]

literally only person in this whole comment section to actually understand the game. makes my mind swirl seeing a hundred comments pissy that everything didnt go perfect

[@DakotaofRaptors]

That's why you finish the job: Abby could very well come back

[@mono3826]

mel put her and her baby in danger first. idc

[@Coco_724]

5:03 Ellie in her mind: "I just got a triple. I just got a fucking triple!"

[@itspizzatime4084]

So I’m are we supposed to be sad cause I ain’t

[@l3igbozz542]

Yup it feel so damn good

[@TronCincojb]

I’m kinda sad about the dog but everyone else I don’t care about and hate

[@vicentserrano9268]

@@TronCincojb yeah, I feel really bad for the dog but the others had it coming, except the pregnant girl which is wrong for killing her.

[@yocloak]

The fact that ellie is only still alive because owen and mel stopped manny and that other guy from killing her is the only thing that made me feel kinda sad for them although im 100% with the fact they died since they killed joel

[@pierregotwings]

Cloaky such a shame that us fans supported this game but then they kills Joel and let us play the fucking BASTARD ABBY FOR 10 FUCKIN HOURS

[@andykim6123]

I never noticed Owen's last word was literally "pregnant." "she's pregnant" was his last words wow

[@sharjitachowdhury5639]

Nice catch

[@spideyfan1278]

Stupid idiot shoulda gave in to Ellie’s demands instead of trying to wrestle her over the gun if he was so concerned for his pregnant girlfriend.

[@Gamemaker151]

So you're telling me she kills everyone in sight except for the person that killed Joel..........

[@legend_creed8083]

Jack Adams so what’s your problem?

[@Shensdojo7]

Glad she didn't

[@DarKoGameplaysyMas]

@Jack Adams Or better let's criticize this game as everyone should

[@DarKoGameplaysyMas]

@@Shensdojo7 The game wouldn't be so hated if she did

[@Shensdojo7]

@@DarKoGameplaysyMas I'm still glad she didn't

[@mrsandhu1215]

Everyone feels sorry for Abby and her friends. Let’s rewind to the beginning of the game when they all watched Abby bash Joel’s head in with an iron golf club and did nothing to stop her. In this scene, the dog attacked Ellie, she killed it out of self defence. Owen and Mel tried to make a move on her, and Mel nearly killed her. All Ellie did was defend herself.

[@jameslanier2510]

Ellie didn't have to be there at all. Owen was trying to defend Mel. Mel was trying to defend herself, as she had no reason to believe Ellie would let her live.

[@evilhorst2249]

If this was real law. Ellie would be guilty of murder 100%

[@Noneofyourbusiness_.I._]

@@lutzaby1997 my guy if someone points a gun to you and you attack them, why the fuck isn’t it self defense?

[@Noneofyourbusiness_.I._]

@@lutzaby1997 she was the instigator of the situation. If I were to pull a gun on you in the streets, and you overcome me by tackling me, you are defending yourself in that situation. Ellie literally caused this whole scene and her only self defense was against the dog.

[@Noneofyourbusiness_.I._]

@@lutzaby1997 I agree with your second part. Nevertheless, if you were the instigator in an incident (ie you are the one who initiates a threat to another person, like pointing a gun at someone, etc) and someone defends themselves against that threat and that person who instigated it kills them, in a court of law, they would not be acting in self defense. Ellie was the one in the wrong here.

[@mashriqafnan2372]

John Wick: "So you killed my fucking dog. I shall have revenge" TLOU2: "Revenge is baaaaad. Kill randoms. Its all good in the hood."

[@Gan3eL]

Don't you think this thing is little more complicated than a fucking John Wick?

[@officercat7907]

@@Gan3eL not really.

[@Gan3eL]

@@officercat7907 A liiiil bit

[@cokechang]

Considering their weight difference and muscle mass, Owen is such a wuss for not tackling down Ellie when he got hold of her gun.

[@Bragglord]

When I think of Joel dying, I always come back to this clip to cheer myself up.

[@ChristopherRojas13]

wtf

[@mehdigeek]

wtf is wrong with y’all

[@LifeisaBeautifulting]

Weird

[@rabbit0.023]

Huh

[@goofyindividual-pl1bd]

Fr

[@LightningCayo]

The game expects us to pretend to care about their deaths when playing as Abby? No. Pathetic.

[@emilymurillo4676]

yea its a game not rl.

[@Shensdojo7]

I like Abby more than Ellie, so in my case...

[@jacobsaunders1092]

@@Shensdojo7 then you are lost!

[@Shensdojo7]

@@jacobsaunders1092 xD

[@HaYouGotRekTed]

I feel bad for abbys freinds because they all died due to abbys mistakes.

[@yamuna6154]

For all Ellie knows that could of been her 87th time killing a pregnant woman. Like what Joel said “Don’t dwell on it.”

[@qrimsonrex7836]

0:32 "You made me look bad! Booga-booga-booga!"

[@christianwelch4206]

"AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!"

[@SuperBronySparkle97]

And yet she spares Abby. Great story 10 out of 10.

[@krasmasov6852]

This but unironically

[@SuperBronySparkle97]

@@krasmasov6852 it'll always be trash.

[@vk2877]

@@SuperBronySparkle97 Its ok to be stupid and wrong. Many people are.

[@jackhughes9811]

Abby will live on knowing the decision to go to Jackson cost her greatly. She will likely be tormented by this for the rest of her life, to kill Abby would have almost been more merciful.

[@SuperBronySparkle97]

@@jackhughes9811 that's if they decide to go through with that but I doubt they'd care to portray that in any meaningful way and just act all hunky dory with it all next game. Heck I doubt we'll even see Abby again and if so then everything in part 2 would have been pointless.

[@firemanshadow8577]

“Pregnant Friend” should actually say: “Pregnant Friend who now hates her and now hates her even more because Ellie showed up”

[@bawdydaram8114]

Something a friend said his Discord perfectly exemplified Abby’s lack of being a good protag in this TLOu story line: “When Ellie found out a woman she killed was pregnant, she collapsed and started hyperventilating and needed Tommy to snap her out of the trauma so she could move, But hey, Ellie is the villain guys! also she needed to torture a woman for info, clearly showed trauma as she could barely make up a sentance the scene after meanwhile Abby takes great pleasure to the fact of slitting a pregnant womans throat, taking pleasure in torturing a man for hours before killing him. Abby takes care of a little asian boy so she is a good person though!”

[@wdarkfenix]

It's not like that stopped her, even when she got a happy ending with her wife and child she gave it all up for her revenge

[@FredVF241]

I think the point here is there is no such thing as heroes or villains. They're just people with their reasons to do what they do, good or bad. People somehow misses this point while playing the game, either seeing Ellie as the hero and Abby as the villain and vice versa. The point is they are enemies, yes, but they're not villains or heroes at all. This game makes you face what you've been doing all the time at the moment you change to Abby's perspective. And yes, she killed Joel out of revenge and it's pretty easy to just hate her or consider her a villain. Well, she's not: she had her reasons, and even when she had the chance, she didn't kill Ellie. She had the chance twice, indeed, and she didn't do it. Maybe Lev had something to do with this, ok, but the point is she let Ellie go. This game is not for everyone, I think. You need to empathize with both sides in order to enjoy it. If you don't, you'll just find yourself hating it. I guess people didn't like to be forced to play as the woman who killed their beloved main character from the first game, and that's the reason for so much hate. I enjoyed personally, but it made me feel bad from time to time. I'm even trying to convince myself to play a second time and go through Joel's death again. I'm not sure I'm gonna be able to do it right now.

[@codfather111ify]

@@FredVF241 "you need to empathize with both sides". That's exactly where they got it wrong. They made it impossible for most ppl to empathize with Abby because they've known Ellie and Joel for almost a decade. They also made her way less human than Ellie, constantly feeling zero remorse for her actions. She killed the face of the franchise. Hard to make ppl like her after that. That's like Game of Thrones trying to make you like Joffrey after killing Ned in season 1.

[@thompoz7114]

Ellie did kill a pregnant woman, Abby did not. No matter how you try to distort reality.

[@Faliat]

@@thompoz7114 She only didn't because she was stopped. She was going to. The intent was still there. Difference is, Ellie killed Mel not knowing she was pregnant and she pulled a blade on her and would have killed her if she didn't fight back. Abby had Dina in her arms not fighting back completely at her mercy and was still going to kill her until Lev asked her not to. Abby STILL comes off worse with direct comparisons between them both.

[@bateshell2]

During the production of TLOU1, Tess was originally supposed to be a villian traveling all over the country to kill Joel. The developers decided that Tess travelling all around the country was too unrealistic and also changed her into an ally. Now, that "unrealistic" concept has materialised, in form of both Ellie and Abby travelling all "across the country" to kill each other.

[@calwu8252]

Not really. They travel to 3 states, Wyoming, Washington and California. And in the first game they literally travel across the country anyway. I swear you find the most dogshit arguments to nitpick at the game.

[@GenericProtagonist7]

@@calwu8252 It baffles me that you people still rabidly defend this game

[@calwu8252]

@@GenericProtagonist7 Not like it’s hard to defend when 90% of the “criticisms” are bandwagoning hate with surface level analysis lmao. Honestly it’s kind of fun seeing how stupid so many of peoples complaints are. Just look at the comments further down, you have people that think Ellie killing a dog (that was trying to kill her) is ‘too far’ and thus bad writing. Utter morons.

[@bateshell2]

Don't get me wrong, I still love TLOU2, especially for the graphics, atmosphere and the vastly superior gameplay mechanics. I just find certain story points baffling, especially when the "unrealistic concept" earlier scrapped by the developers is implemented in full force here. But I'll respect whatever the game producer wants us to see.

[@msaadah1223]

@@GenericProtagonist7 How tf is that a rabid defense? They're literally just saying "Well that's a bad argument since the first game did this" (which is a good argument)

[@coladict]

They could have both lived if they hadn't tried to kill Ellie. Someone fights their way through that city all the way to where they are and they think they stand a chance?

[@5os4ku]

4:40 she really did the batman asswhoop and “now talk”

[@xViperGTR]

That quote that Arthur mentions in RDR2 applies here, “Revenge is a fools game”, think about all the stuff that Ellie lost going after Abby, just to let her live in the end of Part 2

[@sukramreddevil4576]

If she killed Ebby she would lose even more in the future violence breeds violence🤷‍♂🤷‍♂

[@memoryofsalem4474]

@@sukramreddevil4576 no it doesnt, just kill everyone and leave. Done. No ones gonna chase after you if no one's left

[@zaerberus9623]

The saddest part was when Abby found Alice (her dog) and I realized that was the random dog I killed. :(

[@MiguelGarcia-dn8qm]

Anyone notice that when Tommy arrives and you hear “Ellie...Ellie...” it’s not Tommy’s voice actor? It’s Troy Baker. Ellie was so out of it and gone she heard Joel’s voice instead of Tommy. It’s easy to miss but so cool.

[@jslartey2]

Revenge is complicated, guys. By the time Ellie had the opportunity to kill Abby, she probably realized it wouldn’t bring her the peace she was looking for. She would’ve had to kill Lev to prevent him from going after her for killing Abby. That’s more blood on her hands, and innocent blood at that. I think Ellie chose to let them live as a means to an end for all of it.

[@imptheemperor6334]

When you Think you Got double Kill But Triple Kill pops up on The screen

[@ThePatriots010304]

How does killing Abby bring Joel back? How does killing Joel bring Abby’s father back? Ellie and Abby lost everything and everybody for what? Revenge? Arthur Morgan was right. Revenge is a fool’s game.

[@QuanLovesGaming]

This game is a fool's game.

[@OZAMA]

But the thing is it's a game. Where ellie kills hundreds to get to abby but abby go in the end

[@flyleaf8256]

This game is fckin hurts..

[@Devil_deity1]

If only Ellie didn’t kill anyone...

[@teddyloyyan1878]

John Wick: "so you kill a dog..."

[@fwzikurdistan7345]

If you put john wick in this, he will annihilate everyone

[@TheLatiosnlatias02]

Fuck John Wick

[@KayamaKoomori]

I love it how this game goes out of it's way to make you believe that Ellie is the bad guy.

[@DeutscherPatrick]

Where does the Game do That

[@muchduck3754]

@@DeutscherPatrick when you’re forced to kill dogs, when you kill a pregnant lady, the fact that she has a completely different personality from the first game, etc.

[@DeutscherPatrick]

@@muchduck3754 you know that you have to kill them or you die. It’s all self defense and what did you expect her to have the same personality she had years ago as a 14 year old after all she experienced?

[@deriksandoval5263]

@@muchduck3754 I know I'm late but after playing the first game, Ellie is not okay at all after David. Ellie went thru some shit.

[@ZatoBravo]

Ellie: Stupid Dog *Eustace: 👀👀*

[@5f4gunbraell]

4:30: double kill

[@Riley-dh5le]

Nah triple kill

[@eiji862]

The worst part about scenes like this is that literally after we then play from Abby’s perspective and the game tries to make us feel terrible for what we did as Ellie. You know what would’ve made this structure work? If We played Abby’s section first. And keep it a secret up until the beginning of Ellie’s section what became of Joel. That would’ve helped us form a bind with Abby’s character and we’d have understood more as to why she killed Joel so that when the scene came we’d be rooting for her as well as against her since we love Joel and by this point in the story we’d understand where Abby was coming from. Literally this entire story could’ve been fixed for the most part had the structure of the story been designed to not mess with your feelings.

[@dustinjones7458]

Yeah, it'd have a much stronger impact of we got to know Abby and her motivations...before she killed the loved main character of the last game we spent time with lol we're supposed to emphasize with this stranger and her crazy friends before we even know or care about them. Or were we intended to forgive her? Because I never could. It's why the ending strikes so many people as awkward. You got it right. The game goes for moving storytelling, but it comes across emotionally manipulative.

[@dragonl4d216]

I played TLOU 2 being very sympathetic to both Abby and Ellie. It has an entirely different theme from Part 1 but most people were blinded by their attachment to Joel to not enjoy the beauty of part 2.

[@James-kd2qm]

The entire point of this story is to mess with your feelings your supposed to feel conflicted. Any nuanced story will be like this.

[@c3cee]

literally the entire video shows how abbie originally had no intention of killing abby’s friends + dog and how she’s overwhelmed with guilt when she ends up killing them and y’all just like ‘i pretend i do not see 😌’

[@jamesmuise2499]

And finally find someone with a brain. Thank you.

[@TheAnhphuong92]

the problem is all this actually didn't affect her much. She kept looking for revenge and she only stopped because "revenge's baaaad" not because of the guilt for her murders.

[@TheAnhphuong92]

now explain to me why she called the dog "stupid dog", like she really thought the dog could understand her language and leave her alone so that she could kill Abby??

[@alegend2337]

One of the few games where I wish they would do the "it was all a dream" thing at the end.

[@hinatahyuga9311]

Okay I think this game has gone to far cause this game has nothing to do with revenge this mass murder of a teen girl going on a Blood Rampage and genocide and just like rambo said killing is easy as breathing

[@yonkoumb900]

I didn’t know you hated this game too, it’s basically like me sparing Cell after I kill the Cell juniors: complete dumb bs

[@sparknazo]

@@yonkoumb900 cell was an absolute evil though who killed for the sake of killing

[@hinatahyuga9311]

@Channel07 it's just an expression plus the game has nothing to do with revenge

[@generalraven6866]

Tlou2 be like :Oh no no no no revenge is bad is very very bad it is so bad don’t do it revenge is bad

[@Ben-uc9xn]

This game straight up makes me mad. I was so hyped for the game, and I wanted it to be the best game of the generation. I heard a lot of stuff from the leaks… but I just love naughty dog so I wasn’t going to discredit this game without playing it. The gameplay, the acting, the animations, the level design… everything is just beautiful. That’s the main reason why I got it. But I loved the story of the first one… if it was just an Ellie game and we weren’t lied to in the trailers… pretty sure everyone would accept this as a masterpiece. But the story just rubbed me the wrong way… as a fan of the first game and a person who wanted this game to succeed. I didn’t think i’d be that bothered by it… but I am and it sucks lol.

[@dantemiles689]

Same bro

[@homelessperson3005]

This game is about hate, it wants you to hate it. The first was about love, and now joel and ellie loved each other

[@Lazumaus]

@@homelessperson3005 Honestly, if a games goal is to make you hate the game..it failed as a game, games can have stories and make you feel. but if it makes you actively say 'i hate this game.' Then you're not having fun.

[@daelin9759]

The way they tried to make you feel sympathetic for Abby is so cheap

[@krasmasov6852]

How?

[@メキシコ人-k2v]

This game was like a watching a train on a path to collision. By the end of the game people started dying left and right, no one's cause was right or wrong anymore, just wanted to finish the game 😂

[@lalexonelifer]

If you only knew how much I don't give a f*ck about her pregnancy, you'd start crying.

[@Portal-ht3ub]

I want to know. Because I despise everyone in this game.

[@TheEbrietas]

“wHy dId aBbY sAy ‘GoOD’ wHeN sHe fOuNd ouT diNa waS pREgnAnT” now u know lol

[@taquay]

Considering their reactions to similar situations, that makes Abby look much worse than Ellie.

[@aibartalgatuly3011]

Ellie did not intend to kill, even after killing her she was in shock upon realization that Mel was pregnant. Abbie just said “fuck it, makes it even better”. I know that Abby didn’t witness Ellies’s reaction, but it just shows how different they are.

[@TheEbrietas]

@@aibartalgatuly3011 i get that. abby was also in a heightened state of emotion and lev being able to calm her down is massive character growth from the beginning of the game

[@jacket98]

I still don’t feel bad for killing Mel because she chose to go on dangerous tasks while pregnant. I mean what did she think was going to happen.

[@magicscreenman]

The dog is literally the only one I felt bad for killing.

[@luker8342]

I'm so happy I cancelled my pre order when the leaks came out. Absolute rubbish storyline.

[@sofasito2053]

five months later I'm still saying this is shit

[@hookintheshoulder8936]

Luke Russell just cause you don’t want to see both sides doesn’t mean it’s rubbish, just your taste

[@sofasito2053]

@@hookintheshoulder8936 it actually it's rubbish, my friend, it's not me or they, almost everyone is saying that

[@hookintheshoulder8936]

Sofasito just cause a lot of people are not willing to see both sides doesn’t mean it’s rubbish, people just shit on the game cause Joel died. I felt the same but I sympathize with Abby

[@GameGuy9100]

@jaime becerra acosta garcia Explain why it's such a shit game then?

[@homataha5626]

This is not fair!>! she should have killed abby in the end! she killed everyone else!

[@rafaelraintama9757]

everybody in the naughty dog studio messed up (except for my man gustavo. Hes one of the goats of video game music.)

[@jimmyj5703]

Everyone didn't mess up. Just the writers.

[@ra5bruce737]

I still can't get over the fact that she killed people that witnessed Joel's death, but not his actual murderer

[@anotherrandomguy8871]

The game really goes with the whole “revenge is bad” storyline but does it poorly because Abby gets revenge and is mostly fine, but Ellie at most only gets to kill the mere assistants of Joel’s death while letting Abby go free.

[@Callimero89]

That's because in the end Ellie understood that killing people wont help her and revenge has no benefit. That's the point of the whole game.

[@sizzlebuzz]

@@Callimero89 "in the end", not the entire week doing it. Lol. As if it happening suddenly is bad writing.

[@Portal-ht3ub]

Terrible writing advice covers this terrible trope : the protagonist kills all the minions, but spares the villain for no reason.

[@thecollector4574]

@@anotherrandomguy8871 that isn’t the fking storyline. The storyline is “revenge is killing me”

[@yocloak]

I remember from the old trailers i thought it was dina that was gonna die and abby wanted revenge...would have much preferred that

[@jessec.6876]

What a boring story that would be imo.

[@jessec.6876]

@JL-CptAtom this might actually be one of the most pathetic and pointless comments I've ever read. Zero substance whatsoever

[@jessec.6876]

@JL-CptAtom Jesus Christ, this is what's so annoying about casuals attempting to be critics, they think because they found "Plot holes" and "plot armor" then something is objectively bad. Its called storytelling, STORYTELLING ITS FICTION. They say "aha! this doesn't add up" without actually going in-depth with the creativeness behind a story, what the story means and what the storyteller is trying express. Also, its been like 3 months did you really feel the need to spend over 20 minutes coming up with every possible baseless pothole you could think of? Get over it

[@leiwond675]

@@jessec.6876 casuals? Even Professionals said the plot sucked - and who are you to judge about what's a "Casual point of view" and what's not?

[@medievalducky1590]

Ellie: Is horrified she killed a pregnant woman and gets PTSD from doing it. Abby: *G O O D*

[@Death_InOne_Form]

TBF, that's after this. Abby kinda and kinda didn't have the right to fuck Dina up.

[@the_doot_slayer7015]

Ellie to abby at the end of the game: "Guess you will live"

[@rjsmith5339]

4:55 Ellie shows her pro life stance

[@dio1474]

I remember when I saw the map on the ground at 5:44 I knew it was a big mistake...I haven't finished the game yet...I'm at Seattle day 1 with Abby, and I think she found them at the theater because of the map...

[@microblast3700]

Even knowing the characters i would have killed them anyway

[@morg2040]

Was this their attempt at making Ellie look bad so we sympathise with Abby because it just makes them both look unreasonable

[@sparknazo]

It's revenge it shows nobody is a hero just like joel wasn't in the first game

[@MASJYT]

@@sparknazo They probably went like -guys this is bad, Ellie is too likable and people aren't warming up to Abby, what do we do? -Uh make her kill a pregnant woman...ooh! and a dog!!!

[@jessec.6876]

@@MASJYT you kill dogs all throughout the game and ellie isn't a psychopath she had clear regret for killing mel