The Maliki Position On Where To Put The Hands In Salah

DISCLAIMER: This video is for educational purposes and not meant to cause division, this is meant contribute to academic discussion by giving out more information on this subject matter, not to attack others.
Malik Ibn Anas held the opinion of folding the hands according to all the people who narrated from him apart from Ibn Al Qaasim, this is according to Ibn Abdul Barr Al Maliki who transmitted an ijma of the Sahaba on this issue. Shaykh Hassan Ibn Ali Al Kettani made a video showing that the stronger position in the Maliki madhhab is to fold the hands - • Sh Hassan al Kettani: ...
#hamzayusuf
#maliki
#onemessagefoundation
#masjidribat
#uthmanibnfarooq

[@ibmsulaymani]

DISCLAIMER: *This video is for educational purposes and not meant to cause division, this is meant contribute to academic discussion by giving out more information on this subject matter, not to attack others.* Malik Ibn Anas held the opinion of folding the hands according to all the people who narrated from him apart from Ibn Al Qaasim, this is according to Ibn Abdul Barr Al Maliki who transmitted an ijma of the Sahaba on this issue. Shaykh Hassan Ibn Ali Al Kettani made a video showing that the stronger position in the Maliki madhhab is to fold the hands - kzbin.info/www/bejne/qmO5n5WArZhsqKc

[@ibrahimkabir4359]

praying with sadl is better sorry

[@faraazsiddiqui1450]

​@@ibrahimkabir4359According to you but not according to Sahaba.The majority of sahaba used to fold hands and Ibn Abdal Barr transmitted an ijma on this in his books At Tamheed.You want pray sadl then it's up to you and folding hands in prayer is sunnah and not fard so your prayer is valid.But I advise you brother to research on this topic and accept what is true without any bigottedness.

[@alk4262]

@@faraazsiddiqui1450sorry brother, this whole exposé isn’t serious as those wahhabi arguments against the sunnah of sadl have been debunked repeatedly and easily by scholars and students of the maliki school. The tactics of the anti-madahib and anti-ikhtilaf squad is to disappear for few years once debunked and come back with new spokesmen and new altered printed editions of ancient books.

[@seeker.abdullah]

@@faraazsiddiqui1450 Assalaamu Alaikum. Who compiled this 'Muwatta'? Which edition is this? Here I see the texts that says "Yahia narrated from Malik,..." beginning each narration. Could you please clarify who is "Yahia" and whether he 'wrote or complied' this Muatta? In (378) 53 - the last line say "Abu Hazim said, "I knew that the Messenger of Allah (Pbuh) ordered that." - is there any authentic Hadith concerning this that Prophet Muhammad (saws) ordered the Ummah to put right hand over the left hand during prayers and did Imam Malik himself mentioned as such in his Muwatta?

[@seeker.abdullah]

Assalaamu Alaikum. Who compiled this 'Muwatta'? Which edition is this? Here I see the texts that says "Yahia narrated from Malik,..." beginning each narration. Could you please clarify who is "Yahia" and whether he 'wrote or complied' this Muatta? In (378) 53 - the last line say "Abu Hazim said, "I knew that the Messenger of Allah (Pbuh) ordered that." - is there any authentic Hadith concerning this that Prophet Muhammad (saws) ordered the Ummah to put right hand over the left hand during prayers and did Imam Malik himself mentioned as such in his Muwatta?

[@wanderingtraveler71]

@Ibrahim Ibn Mahmud, Your channel has been a flowing source of knowledge for me over the past couple on months and I thoroughly enjoy every upload. Thank you for your efforts

[@zaheercarrim1035]

Thank you sheikh..may Allah preserve you.

[@tech889]

At least he is trying to spread knowledge by the grace of Allah. Because some people are only about overboard refutation and false tabdee

[@MITISLAM]

JazakAllahu khair

[@RaddeFitnaat]

Read Mudawwantul kubra

[@IbnShaahid]

Exactly. السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته.

[@Snadim2005]

Good 👍 channel . I really appreciate your videos 😊

[@faizannazrawi2657]

✌🏼

[@IAbdullah0986]

Can you please tell me the name of this book i want to buy same book Arabic with english translation

[@wadhakkir]

Al- Muwatta. ARABIC-english. Translated by Aisha Abdurrahman Bewley. 1119 pages. It's on page 145. 9.15 Placing one hand on the other hand in the prayer.

[@IAbdullah0986]

@@wadhakkir shukrnn

[@hamzashahbaz7377]

Immediatly

[@hamzashahbaz7377]

I need this book link

[@wadhakkir]

Al- Muwatta. ARABIC-english. Translated by Aisha Abdurrahman Bewley. 1119 pages. It's on page 145. 9.15 Placing one hand on the other hand in the prayer.

[@hamzamedina146]

Salams alaykum im Maliki but ive always been afraid to pray with my arms to the side, this is because i pray in a hanifi mosque and do not want to be ridicule or crused from those who dont understand what should i do...

[@IbnShaahid]

Wa 'alaykum al-salam wa rahmah Allah. I'm a Non-Denominational/Muslim, I used to be a Maliki/Sunni-Muslim, but when I was performing Salah in Sadl in a Hanafi|Sufi/Sunni-Muslim Mosque, they did what is known as 'beating'. I would recommend you 'perform Salah' in Qabḍ of Hanafis if you do not want to hurt yourself. Even if you do Qabḍ but not in the Hanafi way, they would beat you so much. I was 11 years old at that time, follow my advice please if you want to stay with Hasanah/Goodness. Please, tell me what you would do, I'm fearing.

[@hamzamedina146]

@@IbnShaahid salamu alaykum wa rahmatullah wa barakattahu Thank you for your concern I pray with Qabd in the hanafi mosques as this is acceptable in the malaki fiqh unfortunately our hanafi brother are not as open to this knowledge as the selafi/Wahhabi as I do pray in there mosques also... Alhummduillah with Allah permission I continue to learn.. Allahumma barik

[@IbnShaahid]

@hamzamedina146 Barak Allah feek ya اخي - A Non-Denominational/Muslim bro of yours.

[@hamzamedina146]

@@IbnShaahid I'm still following malaki fiqh my friend alhummduillah

[@m4fital2]

I pray with my hands by my side at Hanafi masjid all the time. Never ever ever even once has anyone said anything to me.

[@araftamim-mx3dw]

Sadl is another thing after single rafaul yadain to defy Sunnati Rasulullah SAW.

[@alk4262]

Sadl is a sunnah of our beloved messenger sayyidana Muhammad ﷺ

[@tahamuhammad1814]

Single Raful Yadain is a sunnah of the Prophet (SAW) as can be seen in a hadith in thirmidhi. Ibn Masood (RA) would teach people this method. The Hanafi Position is that this is the way Prohet prayed his last Salahs, and we do have our evidences fir that.

[@Talibulilm-sc4qd]

​@@tahamuhammad1814 that Tirmidhi 257 hadith is munkar daif hadith Sufiyan sauri is mudallis there

[@tahamuhammad1814]

@@Talibulilm-sc4qd Did you just call the great muhaddith and mujtahid Imam Sufyan Ath Thawri (founder of the short-lived Thawri madhhab) an unreliable narrator?

[@tahamuhammad1814]

@@Talibulilm-sc4qd BTW, who called it munkar daif? Thirmidhi called it Hasan in one nuskha, and Hasan Saheeh in another nuskha, and Al-Albani said its a sahih hadith.

[@araftamim-mx3dw]

Only Qabd is sunnah, even on the chest.

[@djibrilr6s]

both are sunnah

[@faisalrafiq3666]

Sunan Abi Dawood 730.

[@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543]

Abu al Waddak. A youth from the Quraish passed in front of Abu Sa’id al-Khudri who was praying. He repulsed him. He returned again. He then repulsed him for the third time. When he finished the prayer, he said: Nothing cuts off prayer; but the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) said: Repulse as much as you can, for he is just a deviI. Abu Dawud said: If two traditions of the prophet(ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) conflict, the practice of the Companions after him should be taken into consideration. Abi Dawud 720, Salat

[@ahmedahmud5281]

How do we know what the practice of sahabah was? U will take hadiths about folding hands narrated from other conquered areas, despite that tabeen, sons of sahabah in Medina prayed with their hands straight down... They know better what their fathers did, especially muhajiroon and ansar that were in Medinah. Prophet s.a.w.s. spent 10 years in Medina, and that is where prayer is established.

[@faraazsiddiqui1450]

​@@ahmedahmud5281So why Imam Malik didn't narrated hadith of Sadl in his book Al Muwatta.Now don't accuse Imam Malik that he was occupied and bigoted.He was one of the truthful imams of Ahlus Sunnah and didn't surrender to Caliph when Abbasid Caliph had beaten him because he was against forceful divorce.Secondly,if it was amal of so many sahaba so why any of the teachers of Imam Malik who were Tabein didn't narrate from any sahaba the hadith of Sadl and on contrary they have narrated hadith of Qabd.

[@shinmonbenimaru91]

@@ahmedahmud5281long comment yet no evidence was found.