Why Trixie & Timmy NEVER Would've Worked

[@TheAlphaJayShow]

Should I give the Trixie episodes one more go OR move on to Tootie? Your call in the comments. 🐼Buy me a Bamboo please 🎍- ko-fi.com/alphajayshow

[@marcusyates3044]

Fairly Odd Generation Verses! Where's Wanda VS Mystery She Wished!

[@BrownBearAlt]

@@TheAlphaJayShow Do it for one more go

[@googamp32]

PLEASE do Class Clown.

[@keatonwestbrook2385]

You can give it one more go with Trixie and then you can move on to Tootie.

[@aidanrandall7438]

I think Chole is much better.

[@cerjmedia]

Crocker casually showing content that would definitely classify legally as a felony as a flex in front of kids is wild when rewatching as an adult

[@SapphireQueen09]

Immediately counts as a predator without sexual intellect.

[@maxmeidl4909]

That and with way he was ABUSING his students in the secret origin of denzel crocker really makes you wonder why hasn’t mr. crocker been fired yet.

[@pepito2847]

There was also an episode that revealed that Crocker had a Polaroid of Timmy sitting on his toilet and pushing the camera away aggressive Yikes 😬

[@maxmeidl4909]

That combined with the way he was ABUSING his students in the secret origin of denzel crocker makes you wonder why he hasn’t been fired yet.

[@ElArchivodeDarkSpider094]

Don't forget. They can't fire him if he killed a kid's parents in a Parent teaching meeting because he HAS TENURE!

[@cerebralsamurai8382]

Trixie is a narcissist that's why she went psycho when Timmy was the only boy on Earth she wants people to feed her ego

[@møon.m3rm4id]

And then she don’t even like Timmy back, she just want him to like her bc she think everyone should like her

[@TitanQueen]

"I'm not poor, I'm middle class!" I knew that quote was from something!

[@victorowen2592]

From my home 😂

[@geardog24]

Secret Agents are recruiting emotionless Timmy to stop an adult supervillain. Forget Crocker, put these guys under the jail.

[@ivanbluecool]

The relationship could have worked if the writers remembered trixy had her interest in comic books continue and had her continue keeping it a secret Eventually they could have done a good build up to this relationship but see both of them are just too different due to trixy not wanting to give up her popular girl image. Would work well.

[@Cratossama]

Irl she would’ve cheated on Timmy so it’s for the best 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@almightyk11]

That would imply that characters remained unflanderised

[@girlpower_gacha]

If they had the new wish continuity

[@jaohonaxa]

Unfortunately, they abandoned that side of her immediately after that one episode and fully turned her into another popular girl stereotype

[@apirlfools]

​@@jaohonaxa in the episode where timmy wished to be popular trixie was shown to actually respect timmy for throwing away popularity for his friends i think the original idea was trixie is a popular girl who has her moments of personality behind the scenes but they forgot all about it

[@aj_gen_ace]

5:55 That's the main problem with this show in general. The entire theme revolves around making Timmy miserable. If Timmy isn't reacting to Crocker, Trixie, or Vicky humiliating him, something is wrong. Or if they aren't the nasty people they are to him, it's not normal.

[@jrcrit8843]

Well isn’t that the whole point of having the fairies? Wasn’t the premise that he would have the fairies until he got older or no longer had a miserable life?

[@aj_gen_ace]

@jrcrit8843 It's just mean spirited though, regardless if he has fairies or not.

[@meta527iireviews6]

It really angers me that the show keeps saying Timmy is the bad guy for wanting to flirt with Trixie, but when Tootie constantly stalks and harasses Timmy, that’s seen as perfectly acceptable.

[@KairuHakubi]

as much as I'm sick of the kind of 2020s idiocy you're lamenting and kind of agree with you, that... actually is how it's supposed to work. Females hit on males. Males just show off and wait to be hit on. We are on the demand side of appreciation, they are on the supply side. Girls hate being hit on, guys hate DOING the hit-ons. The problem is women are all terrified of us now because Lifetime. If we had more Tooties, we wouldn't have so many Timmys.

[@Kompatainment]

Thank you! All three of them have their flaws and shouldn't be dating each other.

[@nicholassims9837]

@@meta527iireviews6 when was Timmy called a bad guy

[@cameronhermann9400]

Agreed

[@nicholassims9837]

@lorenzorafael4600 when was that ever said ?

[@lesterwilliamsjr649]

Life Lesson Never date the popular girl because there is a good chance she is not put together as she appears. The irony of being popular is that when your focused on being the center of attention you don't spend much time developing a lot of socal skills because your more focus on looking good then acting good. Exhbit A: Dandadan

[@YukihoDubs]

I see, you are a man of culture as well.

[@xwrecker]

There are girls like that irl and yeah I don’t wanna touch those girls with a 10ft pole

[@victorowen2592]

Nice😊

[@Alex-RavensPeak]

Ah yes because humans are as complex as cartoon characters. Lol

[@Stupaipai]

Can't tell this is a joke or not. You're really using an anime character as your source lmao?

[@XZAVIER-DAA-GOD]

Even in the live action movies Timmy doesn't end up with her when he's a adult

[@youdontknowsponge6218]

She was forgotten in the live action movies.

[@XZAVIER-DAA-GOD]

@youdontknowsponge6218 she was replaced with tuddy

[@dontemorgan1517]

I truly wish these episodes never existed. That way, the Boy would be Queen will still be canon, and they'll follow Trixie's development and relationship with Timmy as series go on.

[@jvanimation9520]

@@dontemorgan1517 Sorry but “Continuity” is not a word that Fairly Odd Parents recognizes.

[@justinpullen1097]

Tootie seemed obvious to be Timmy's future wife. Besides the daughter having similar glasses to her, Tootie actually played a part in Channel Chasers, so it works from a story standpoint.

[@greyworld6242]

3:13 Inside out before we had inside out! XD

[@andykishore]

I just noticed that too.

[@michaelstrong5383]

Momo and Okarun from Dandadan is Timmy & Trixie done right: A boy who no one understands, and the girl who is way out of his league. And yet, throughout the series, their progression towards each other gets better and better.

[@MrSupersonic28]

@michaelstrong5383 the difference is that Momo and Okarun are allowed to progress with their lives and not be hindered by needs of constant reruns

[@icecreamhero2375]

I wouldn't say this is done wrong. I don't think the FOP writers intended Timmy to be with Trxie. Dandadan is a fantastic show. I love Momo and Okarun's relationship.

[@toadlord8594]

Huh, I never thought of that.

[@Lego_Ninjago_]

The show is episodic. They aren't supposed to change.

[@maxmeidl4909]

You know, this kinda makes me glad that they stopped using Trixie all together after all the many failed attempts to make Timmy and Trixie a couple. Kinda like how they also stopped using Tootie all together after she beat the shit out of Timmy with an oar just give him cpr.

[@gontsuk5754]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who likes that Trixie and Tootie stopped appearing after the seventh season, I never liked Trixie and Tootie and I never shipped Timmy with either of those two girls. The only romantic interest of Timmy that I liked was Missy who appeared in the episode "Finding Emo" of the ninth season (one of the few good episodes of this season), unfortunately Missy only appeared in this episode, I wish she appeared in more episodes because she was the Timmy's only love interest who has a healthier relationship

[@metazoxan2]

Honestly I thought Trixie had potential. If they ... you know ... actually gave a shit about character devlopment. They could have had her grow past her more pompous and popular girl persona. And the fact she DOES canonically have some overlapping interest with Timmy makes her ... at least a better candidate than Tootie who was nothing more than the "overly clingy stalker girlfriend" joke that every show at the time had. Seriously ... why did every series do this during the early 2000s? That's why my pick as a Ship is still Trixie ... because she's certainly flawed ... but she's also still a kid and has room to grow. So if you just head canon all of the develpment the writers REFUSED TO DO ... she's at least the better option. Not great ... but the show was pretty devoid of actual character development that didn't just get undone.

[@PLCTheCd]

@@gontsuk5754 Funny you mentioned that, even as a person who liked about TOotie. Her stalking behavior is more creepy than cute in the later seasons. Tootie still had potential, if she realizes that she is no better than Vicky.

[@PLCTheCd]

WAit, what episode was Timmy beaten with an oar to be given CPR?

[@zierragacha5089]

@@gontsuk5754 Here's a fun fact, Missy is voiced by the same actress as Wordgirl/Becky Botsford

[@Cherrytangela]

Being a kid, you're simplified views have you wanting the prettiest girl, regardless of how that girl treats you. Being an adult, its when you realize that the best and truest relationships come from those, regardless of status or looks, who most willingly and enjoy being around you. Its cliche as hell, but that's just because its mostly true.

[@johnlai4129]

Trixie and Timmy were doomed from the start. They were never going too work out.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

All I'll say about the whole Timmy and Trixie thing is, since she barely even knows that Timmy exists it's amazing he continued to pursue Trixie. I mean, if it were me in his situation, I wouldn't bother because if a girl I liked never gave me the time of day or barely even knew I exist, then I wouldn't waste my time.

[@ElArchivodeDarkSpider094]

Crocker's scene definitely aged awfully in the years since. The guy is a menace

[@palacioestrella]

Just the two of us…we can make it if we try…

[@Woobuggy848]

Just the two of us…you and I.

[@MultiBoxingKid]

Expect if it’s with Trixie.

[@rainalystre1877]

But every day that passes by is tearing pages from my mind

[@jellypeach68]

​@@rainalystre1877Just the two of us... Quite a drastic pickup line

[@Bludy_blue]

GE-

[@abthedragon4921]

5:13 Just gonna add this to the list of things in animated kid shows that are supposed to be played as jokes in the context of the show but when you really think about it is really creepy. The list is very long.

[@guillermosierracuellar9812]

Wishology was also a perfect finale for the show if only they didn’t used the memory whipe

[@jonathandias1741]

yeah, I don't get why jorgen had to memory wipe everyone could he bend "Da Rules" for once.

[@andykishore]

@@jonathandias1741 Like as if he doesn't bend the rules enough already.

[@Eragonfrost]

Funny how they always say “if anyone finds out fairies are real then we go away forever” in Wishology a lot of the main cast found out about Timmy’s fairies and nothing happened”

[@ELRIFL]

No it wasn't lmfao, or were you really that entranced by that shitty kissing scene?

[@TheGametubr]

@@Eragonfrost to be fair, they were dealing with a threat bigger than all of fairy world, so it really wasn't necessary for da rules to even be a factor in that

[@ivanbluecool]

This and tootie needing to learn better boundaries with Timmy while he sees she is a much better person compared to Vicky since they both seem to torture Timmy in their own ways since males being abused is somehow funny for people

[@MultiBoxingKid]

Honestly the whole male abuse being funny was something that everyone loved for years, it’s only recently, like late 2000s to early 2010s, that people are seeing that it’s really fucked up.

[@ivanbluecool]

​@@MultiBoxingKidhonestly even then not really since I know a few shows that have this same thing happen like boondocks and some anime I know where a guy getting attacked is scene as funny

[@Blackpapalink]

@@ivanbluecool "At this point it's self-defense, Tom."

[@metazoxan2]

The early 2000s was OBSESSED with the "Clingy stalker girlfriend" trope. I have no idea why but a ton of series had one. Sonic had Amy Nigel from KND had ... whatever he name was. and there are others that I know exist but I can't remember the names of right now. I don't think it was even a popular Trope. Writers just thought it was.

[@PLCTheCd]

Even as a person who likes Timmy and TOotie, I admit her stalking Timmy isn't cute or funny anymore ever since the 6th and 7th seasons. THat being said both Timmy and Tootie had potential

[@sbsv63]

I never liked Trixie's abrupt ending in "Beach Bummed". At first she seemed interested in Timmy and his huge sand castle. However, after Timmy breaks her spine she didn't appear again, even more so when she told him he was a totally hot monster.

[@toonberculosis9574]

something I notice about many FOP season 3-5 episodes is that they have weird pacing and, at times, the main antagonist of the episode switches up completely, or entire b-plots just go unresolved.

[@eeveefennecfox]

10:53 wanda forgets that fairies can't die =_=

[@lesterwilliamsjr649]

The best part about Trixie is her voice actress and the worst part about her Trixie is her never ending need to be popular.

[@calvinmatthews1527]

Actually, this case can be made for literally every other character in FoP. Seriously, there's like always one specific episode that ruins a character sometime in the later seasons.

[@joshuaW5621]

Timmy and Trixie would have had a toxic relationship.

[@LovethedemonWolf2.0]

Trixie :NOW TELL ME IM PREETY !!!😡 trixie was a red flag in my opinion , I’m glad he ended up with Totie at least in the movie universe

[@pch3611]

Nonchalant Timmy just had too much aura

[@furrysunny1300]

The reason for them not working out is simple. Trixie, like basically all "beautiful" girls in American school shows is a mean, rude, unemphathic bee-eye-tea-chikory. Once you date them, or god forbid, marry them in the end, you realize what a demanding monster you let into your live.

[@JT3ONLINE]

I would like to point this out. I do not like when a character who we've grown to love has to change who they are just to get the love interest or when they have a character that pines for them and enjoys them for who they are but they'd rather pick the person who barely acknowledges them. Example: I like Family Matters and I enjoy Steve Urkel but he shouldn't have had to change into Stefan just for Laura to love him. Yes in the end she accepted his nerdy side but only after he went through lots of changes and made himself appealing to her. In Timmy's case I feel like Him and Tootie are good together because she accepts him no matter how dorky he is even when he doesn't accept her back. I see Tootie the same way I see Helga from Hey Arnold because to me they're kinda two sides of the same coin. They both have a massive crush on our main characters because of the fact that their home lives are so terrible that the main character is their only safe haven from their life at home. Please keep in mind I'm not supporting the way these two girls went about their love for the main character because they did go overboard sometimes and they could've handled some things better but I would like to say that In the end both girls did have mostly good intentions for the person that they loved.

[@matthewobasi1659]

I always thought Timmy and Tootie would be better together. Tootie just needed to be less creepy.

[@AJ-xc4qe]

It’s funny how a lot of my favorite childhood shows have questionable endgame love interests. Kai, Sam, Spencer, Mason could’ve been favorable if Peter Murrieta didn’t leave and let the writers ruin him in the last season. It’s even funnier that the one time said love interest actually developed from those questionable traits were in a trilogy of bad movies. Cuz if there’s anything nice I can say about the live action movies, aside from Crocker’s actor’s performance, was that they let her grow up. She’s not the same obsessive stalker that she was when she was 10 which I guess was meant to parallel Timmy’s lack of growth SINCE he was 10. Could’ve been real story potential with that concept if they all weren’t so bad. Daniella Monet Tootie, yes. Stalker Tootie, yikes. I still would’ve loved to see them explore a relationship with Veronica as in the same way Braceface and As Told By Ginger did with their “beta mean girl” characters but that’s just me.

[@gontsuk5754]

I would have liked it if Tootie's design wasn't ugly (I prefer her beta design from season 0) and also if her character didn't revolve around being obsessed with Timmy

[@nicholassims9837]

@gontsuk5754 that's harsh to call Tootie ugly

[@An0therBurner94]

I thought so for a bit, but then on rewatch... Nah, she deserved that restraining order in Kung Timmy in the later seasons. She was fine at the start, but then she admitted to stalking Timmy at night.

[@nicholassims9837]

@PolarityOfNeoSoulCity that was only because writers screwed her over about the restraining order was only in one episode as a gag

[@jonathanpabon4477]

Wait a dam minute Tad.... Chad........ This show was ahead of it's time and teaching us as kids the reality of life while entertaining us and we never even knew it 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@XZAVIER-DAA-GOD]

Ah I miss when Timmy was surrounded by a school social group

[@MasterLu2]

This hits home for me. I remember being a dork but being close to the most popular girl in my school and everyone was “when are you guys going to be together?” “Are you an item?” Ironically enough we now live in the same general area now but we haven’t officially met.

[@deandredukes95]

Trixie’s entire character was wasted potential

[@icecreamhero2375]

In my humble opinion Timmy should date Missy. She debuted in Finding EMO. She is the only girl who said yes to Timmy and he got to go on a date with her. Finding EMO is such a good episode. Its one of the rare episodes where Timmy got a happy ending.

[@gontsuk5754]

I agree with you, I also think Timmy should stay with Missy. I saw a theory on Reddit that the first 5 seasons and the following five seasons (the seasons with Poof, Spark and Chloe) and the Live Action films are set in parallel universes caused by Poof the first five seasons take place in a timeline where Timmy never wanted Poof and ended on Channel Chanse with adult Timmy In the last five seasons we have a universe where Timmy wished for Poof who basically changed the Timeline with his fart (It's not a joke, this actually happened in the premiere episode) causing the continuity to be altered (Croker never had Cosmo and Wanda Since his fairy godparents and Timmy were not to blame for his loss, the Rules were changed because now normal people can know about the existence of fairies and magic as long as they don't know who the fairies belong to, Crocker now knows about existence of fairies because his strong belief is the source of magic and because of this he can know that Timmy has magical godparents), it is also in this timeline that we will follow The New Wish. And to a third timeline which are the Live Action films in which Timmy refuses to grow up and stays with Cosmo and Wanda in adulthood

[@icecreamhero2375]

@@gontsuk5754 But let Sleeper Dogs Lie from season 9 said Crocker had Cosmo, Wanda, and Sparky.

[@nicholassims9837]

@@icecreamhero2375 That was just a dumb retcon that didn't need to exist it ruined Mr Crocker tradegey by making him be a brat that just lost Cosmo and Wanda it also uncharacteristic more Wanda an idiot by saying that ALL faries have bad memories and that she calls Timmy sport because she can't remember his name 🙄. Kyle norty did a kids are Smarter than this on it you should check it out

[@billybarnett9518]

I thought Missy just came outta nowhere and wasn't that well developed, think they would've been better off just bringing Veronica back if they wanted a blonde love interest

[@icecreamhero2375]

@@billybarnett9518 I disagree. Whats wrong with her being a one off? Veronica's personality is very different from Missy's it would be jarring if she said. "I like you for you Timmy." It's about time Timmy moved on and crushed on other girls.

[@paolotorres8537]

Honestly, she’s just not the girl for Timmy. If she can’t accept him for him, she’s not the one for him

[@FrazzleFox1901]

5:13 Correct, Jay. A *teacher* humiliating his own *student* for being naked and showing his shame in front of his classmates is absolutely horrid. "PUT THIS MAN UNDERNEATH THE JAIL!" Yes!

[@monobro141]

Simple answer It was NEVER gonna happened since everything just resets after an episode. And not gonna lie as huge as this show was in my childhood I was NOT a fan of Timmy crying and simping over Trixie

[@icecreamhero2375]

Emotion Commition is one of the funniest episodes ever. Thank you for reviewing this episode.

[@ronlivingstone1634]

well I didn't love how Timmy gets discriminated after Francis forced him to jump down the public pool and losing his trunks.

[@lesterwilliamsjr649]

The whole ignoring someone to get them to like you is a very messed up lesson, I get the idea of making someone work for your attention but it shouldn't be to the extreme of acting like you don't care

[@icecreamhero2375]

That wasn't a lesson. Trixie was just being toxic.

[@lesterwilliamsjr649]

@icecreamhero2375 Clarify I'm not talking about Trixe I'm just talking about the concept in general.

[@lyndseystrait1513]

5:35 Honestly, yeah. Pretty creepy on Crocker's part. Also, yes would love a video reviewing class clown!

[@Kompatainment]

It's crazy that with 294 episodes the show only really explored this fan-favourite topic in 3-4 episodes. And especially with Butch always saying the show got stale after some seasons i just don't understand why adding new characters felt like a good choice to the writers. If you want something fresh give the characters that we already care about some development. Timmy and Trixie could have had a good arch together if the writers allowed her to grow.

[@toonberculosis9574]

1. To be a bit blunt, I thought this video was going to be more. It was really just a summarization of Emotion Commotion. 2. While Trixie has her problems (and I rank her third in terms of potential Timmy ships, behind Tootie and Veronica), she has shown potential for growth at times. 3. I think ANW would be a golden opportunity to give her a happy ending, while not necessarily tying her to Timmy.

[@FrazzleFox1901]

Trixie says she's only interested in popular kids and keeps bragging about it so her showing her true interest would leave her humiliated

[@bullmonty764]

3:23 See that? That explains why Veronica is the least popular of her friend group in one simple sentence. Pool incident aside, what high-ranking student would willingly make fun of someone worse off than they are for doing something that is a societal expectation? Even she herself knows how bad it was, given her rapidly deteriorating laughter afterwards. …Maybe Veronica was a bad fit for the popular crowd and could’ve been written in a stronger way 🤔

[@fighter5583]

"You're weird! WEIRD! GET AWAY FROM ME YOU FREAK!!" Funniest moment in that whole episode.

[@XellosNi]

"Medaka Kuroiwa Is Impervious to My Charms" is borderline this episode as an anime with Trixie Tang as the protagonist and "Timmy" hasn't lost his emotions, but is desperately trying to practice abstinence because he wants to be a monk.

[@davidaamaya1]

I could've seen them being great friends

[@BlitzDemonGamer3032]

6:20 Best Pixar movie ever

[@toniosoflyy]

He’s obsessed with her and he can’t control it and she is out of his league. The episode gives us the glimpse of what happens when popular girls don’t get attention.

[@thecreativemillenial]

Trixie was toxic and narcissistic as heck. I'm glad he chose tootie

[@UltraBooProductions]

There is another episode when Timmy becomes emo and has no emotions.and there is a one time character he had a crush on 😻.

[@maxmeidl4909]

Honestly, considering how every single time the show TRIES to make them a couple, by the end of each episode they do so, it feels like it was all for nothing. Which is the main reason why I don’t ship Timmy x Trixie (or even Timmy x Tootie). I can’t believe I’m saying this, but CHLOE was a far better girl to Timmy in comparison to his two other so-called “love interests”. I mean, would you REALLY want to have a girlfriend who comes off like a rich jackass who constantly rejects you or another one who comes off like more of a creepy staker who can't take a hint he is not into you? Yeah, that’s exactly what I thought.

[@metazoxan2]

The thing is taht the reason it's "all for nothing" is because the series refuses to allow actual character development. Fairly odd parents was one of those shows written episodically with the goal of being viewable in any order. So whenever it happened to be on you could watch it without needing to catch up on missed episodes. As a result the status quo was NEVER allowed to actually change meaningfully. Later seasons tried to finally spice things up ... but instead of allowing old characters to actually develop they just threw in new ones and abandoned old ones instead ... which is when people rapidly stopped caring about the show.

[@maxmeidl4909]

@@metazoxan2that’s what I’m saying (kinda)

[@viruschris3160]

I agree. If the writing involving Chloe in the show was better to include her in Timmy's circle of friends and secret I think Chloe would've been the perfect girl for him growing up. I forgot about Missy as she was in ONE episode. But, Chloe was one girl Timmy had a mostly normal and healthy relationship with.

[@ELRIFL]

It makes no sense to screech about Tootie then say Chloe was the better love interest. Chloe was literally just a reskinned, less funny version of Tootie.

[@martinkreps9946]

OMG this episode! 🙄🤦‍♂️And Just the Two of Us made me hate Trixie, but Emotion Commotion completely ruined their relationship! Honestly Timmy works better with Tootie quite frankly. Tootie may be creepy and annoying, but at least she supports and cares about Timmy much better. Trixie on the other hand? Just... no! Trixie is a crazy psychopath in this goddamn episode! I'm absolutely serious! Trixie and Timmy should never work as a couple at all!

[@gontsuk5754]

I think Timmy works best with Missy (Timmy's third love interest) she is not annoying and has a healthy relationship with Timmy, she also reciprocates Timmy's feelings, unfortunately she only appeared in one episode (Finding Emo from season nine, a one of the few good episodes this season)

[@martinkreps9946]

​@@gontsuk5754Oh yeah. I mean IRYO on Finding Emo, but tbh it's just a mediocre run of the mill episode, it wasn't bad though. But yeah Missy was one of the decent things about that episode. Missy was all right.

[@ELRIFL]

@@gontsuk5754 Missy was trash. Just like her episode. Just like everything you've posted on your channel. Just like your personality, person who calls small children ugly.

[@unseenphantomamvsytp2186]

If Trixy ever shows up in "A New Wish" I hope they show She's finally grown up and just imbraces her tomboy side. Maybe even have her own a comic shop.

[@readsomebooks666]

Why on Earth would anyone interpret that daughter as anything other than Tootie’s? It was not subtle.

[@Zyugo]

I reckon it could be Trixie becomes her teacher at school and Tammy inherits her old headband.

[@toonberculosis9574]

They did INTEND for it to be ambiguous, but you're right, most people just seem to think its just Tootie anyway, her traits are more dominant on the surface, and she played a major role in the movie while Trixie was absent.

[@Fredboi-fo8gu]

I wish Nickelodeon went with Trixie being a tomboy and not the shallow insane popular girl because then she would have actually been a great character. She is my second favorite of the show and the Timmy and Trixie dynamic could have worked out in my opinion wether it was a romantic or platonic, I just wanted Trixie to have more development and have real proper friends like Timmy and his pals.

[@ChrissaTodd]

also unrelated but related i kind of want to know what tad and chad would be up too in the new wish timeline as adults idk just curious

[@Dr.Mlieko]

The only problem is Butch Hartman's allergy to plot progression and character development If Dipper/Pacifica can work, I see no reason why this can't

[@yinyangyt8749]

Oh man. This episode was just really disappointing. It felt like Trixie was gonna change as the episodes went on. They could have made it work. But this episode right here, it just demolishes everything and makes her completely dislikable. Timmy got what he wanted but at what cost.

[@JasLamArr91]

Because of the inconsistency with this show, and how they keep things the same for the status quo, I knew nothing was gonna happen between Timmy and Trixie. So I didn’t care for the ship.

[@maxmeidl4909]

Same can also be said with that one episode where crocker ditches capturing fairies in favor of leprechauns. Because the fact this show just LOVES its status quo, that episode felt like it was all for nothing, even crocker flat-out admitted it at the end. Edit: or the episode where it seemed like Vicky was going to be nice to Timmy at the end of the snow-monster episode, only for it to ALSO be all for nothing by the very end.

[@lesterwilliamsjr649]

Are we going to ignore the fact that Trixe became an escort in one episode and literally was sitting on a mountain of money? Also My Life As A Teenage Robot had a whole episode where a group of teenage girls dated nerds for money. What was Nickeldon thinking, so male pregnancy and escorting are ok.

[@Eddieavina123]

Love your video and keep up the great work you are awesome

[@bochosanchez5160]

I been wondering why I haven't see Trixie since poof ?

[@gontsuk5754]

Poof was introduced in the sixth season and Trixie stopped appearing after the seventh season (good thing because I didn't like Trixie or Tootie)

[@andykishore]

@@gontsuk5754 Dionne Quan retired voicing Trixie Tang in 2011 which is why her character stops speaking after the episode "Cosmo Rules" and is reduced to non-speaking appearances in seasons 8-10.

[@olleselin]

It was a real bummer that Trixie was absent in the latter seasons....

[@Tarnthewarrior]

1:32 for ryl

[@ZapperRS]

One of my first cartoon ships, even if I knew they could never work well together

[@worminaround]

The ship could work if the screenwriters knew how to do it, that wasn't their focus anyways so it was doomed to fail

[@TheGametubr]

i honestly never understood why some people think that timmy and trixie could ever be a good relationship, even the show itself shows reasons it wouldn't work.

[@AJ-xc4qe]

Real talk, I actually always shipped Timmy with Veronica more than either Tootie or Trixie. And I still wish (ha!) both Trixie and Veronica could’ve been more fleshed out as the show went on. Personally, most of the school kids could’ve been interesting if they focused on them. It feels like they wanted us to hate them, especially Veronica and justify Timmy not being interested in her. Especially when she seems to get frequently bullied by her own peers. I know fans love Tootie more and I get the appeal and I would’ve been interested in how that relationship developed if it was at least natural. But if you’ve seen Timmy and Tootie’s relationship, you’ve seen every relationship where one of them is a nerdy and clingy stalker. Timmy never reciprocated Tootie’s feelings unless there’s a couple scenes excluding the live action movies I don’t remember but it feels like the show is telling Timmy that he owes her his love just because she likes him unlike Trixie and has a shitty home life with Vicky. It’s the cliche “hero getting with the homely girl who he actually gets along with vs the pretty girl who he only likes for her looks”. But The Boy Who Would Be Queen establishes that Trixie was basically forced into traditional femininity (even if that’s based on the whole “not like other girls” trope) that she had more depth to her than what Timmy saw. In FOP’s case especially, it feels like they’re telling Timmy to give up on his dreams of being with Trixie because she’s too shallow or just not interested (which wasn’t the case in other episodes) and that he should settle for Tootie. It’s so mean spirited and cynical to say in a kids show which was always one of the show’s biggest problems. And it’s super weird they pushed that so much that they imply they have kids in the future and it’s why I don’t love Channel Chasers as much as everyone else does. Elmer’s other show, Danny Phantom, had the same exact set up almost bar for bar but worse with Paulina not getting ANY real depth and Sam being unlikable in her own right and not telling Danny how she feels even after she loses him to someone else. Valerie should’ve been Danny’s endgame and I still stand by it. Comparing her to Tootie, Veronica admittedly isn’t much better with Trixie as demonstrated by the internet episode, but it’s because she wants her life. The popularity, the respect and Timmy to have a crush on her. I would’ve wanted to see an episode where she stood up to Trixie, Tad and Chad with Trixie admitting her mistakes and apologizing and maybe both eventually becoming a part of Timmy’s friend group. And I'd be down with either of them becoming Timmy’s endgame love interest. With Veronica tho, I just think it’s more compelling for an average kid who no one understands to bond with a popular girl who isn’t as popular as she would’ve wanted to be and isn’t treated much better than how the rich kids treat him. At least Braceface and As Told By Ginger did something similar to this.

[@Princesstallestpink2020]

I'm gonna call him no heart from the care bears mixed With Skeletor from he-man 10:07

[@fan188power6]

Here's my hot takes for the day.cindy>Trixie

[@goryparodiesproductions6561]

11:15 Well considering that Trixie is underage, you can't blame Dr. Vulcan for being scared 😂

[@18karatgold6]

Even villains have standards 😂😂😂

[@Rockmanbalboa]

what i can get from all this is Timmy romance should be with Veronica and that's it.

[@SupermarketSweep777]

Would have been an interesting angle but they kida just tossed Veronica aside.

[@yunidai16]

In other words, a girl who demeans you and stalks you is better than a girl who only does one of those things, or a girl who does neither. /s

[@LovethedemonWolf2.0]

lol I like the inside out reference

[@MrJomalley123]

this makes me think that tootie will be the only person who is actually legit nice to timmy even though she had a restraining order against her

[@artsenalproductions4813]

We need a new girl for Timmy, there I said it.

[@KapustaNicholai]

5:44 honestly ur brains can be strong enough to decide the better whishes, that won't kill anyone, wouldn't cause any catastrophe, and wouldn't cause the loosing of the feries

[@matthew_natividad]

@@KapustaNicholai and obviously da rules won’t allow harm to follow anyone involved with those wishes

[@KapustaNicholai]

@@matthew_natividad they the book rule were supposed to not a llow christmas everyday, but but it happend only after Timmy made that wish, then Cosmo and Wanda granted, until the seasonal spirits and Ms Claus will hatetred Timmy despite that he really didn't meant anything bad

[@zacharymoss2994]

11:08 and with that cosmo and wanda should have been the ones blamed for everything gone wrong in the secret wish episode

[@dfgamingandreviews]

Chris Hanson: Mr. Crocker we have to talk

[@macaelatice-loma1048]

Chloe: they literally share faires might aswell be together as a couple

[@ComicBooksandVideoGameNerd96]

I forgot to give him back his common sense

[@youngman1644]

Really? I thought that was pretty obvious.

[@Hulk2k6]

Homegirl was deranged in that episode where He wished everyone away bar Him and Her. And it's proven she would only want Timmy if he WASN'T into her/was with someone else.

[@TrueReverse74]

For a second I thought this was a reupload lol. I've always accepted that just like Timmy becoming a giga chad, I figured he came around to Tootie at the end of channel chasers.

[@errickray5420]

I always thought that Trixie would've been a much better match for Remy Buxaplenty in my opinion.

[@saugusandsausages]

It would have been nice if they had given Trixie and even Veronica an arc but that’s too much to ask from ol Butch Hartman. Oh well.

[@dontmindme8571]

To be fair (and I'm not defending Hartman, he's a hack), the show was released way before Cartoon Arcs became popular. Those started getting traction with Adventure Time/TAWOG/Regular Show, and FOP released before that and REALLY didn't wanna change.

[@ViewerOnline101]

How does Tammy look in any way like Trixie? She's basically a carbon copy of Tootie, but with Timmy's hair color and a different hairstyle. The only "evidence" that her mom might be Trixie is... they both wear a pink hairband, as if headbands are a genetic thing passed down? Seriously, what? Plus, think about it, do you really want Timmy to end up with some so spoiled, self-centered, needy, attention seeking, and shallow as Trixie over someone like Tootie, who loves him for who he is no matter what?

[@TheAutisticGeek206]

If Timmy ends up with Trixie, he is going to lose his godparents. That is why he does not need her at all!

[@omnidiscord]

Only thing about all these points though is that these are all about who these characters were at the time; i.e. as children! It ignores the fact that people grow and change as they become adults (I never even really shipped these two characters together watching the show but..) when it comes to that clip of the future, with Timmy as an adult with kids *possibly* with Trixie, I think it is totally possible that as she grew up she completely changed, had a full 180, and none of this applied to her anymore! I mean, does *anyone* really feel like they are even remotely the same person they were in middle school?? 🤔

[@benuln8283]

I ship neither Timtoot or Timtrix.... Besides they've both their chance to be romantically involved with Timmy....

[@Adeptuna]

5:05 Certified lover boy, certified p-!🗣️🔥🔥🔥

[@joseph-pf5fr]

The tootie and timmy dynamic was also destroyed,in the episode escape from unwish island,because one of cupids weapons maid a cameo in Timmy's closet which means the episode love struck is Canon and at the end of that episode cupids love arrow makes timmy fall for tootie so I can only deduce that the effects wore off because it wasn't a good match which means they're not ment to be

[@ELRIFL]

This much copium is not healthy for you.

[@aidanrandall7438]

I always believe that Timmy and Chole were the best.

[@eeveefennecfox]

same,I'll never understand the hate towards chloe,people been begging for a girl character for years and the same people that's been begging for a girl are hating on her for the dumbest reasons,I saw 0 issues with chloe,she;s one of my favorite characters

[@nicholassims9837]

@@eeveefennecfox She was a ratings trap in a desperate attemp to make Fairly Oddparents stay a float and failed

[@gontsuk5754]

I also like Chloe, the idea for her character was good, the problem is that it was poorly executed (and it doesn't help that the Tenth season is a bad season)

[@williamdaviddiazcuchimaque7511]

No existe el conejo de pascua no existe el hada de los dientes y no existe cloe

[@monobro141]

Honestly I can see it

[@supermariomaker1734]

I think this relationship was never gonna happen the moment that broke the camels back was when Timmy turner wished that only him and Trixie were the only people on Earth that would have made me so angry I don’t want to talk to him anymore if I was in Trixies shoes. All the other times I would have rejected Timmy would have been done in a gentle and respectful way but in that moment enough is enough and I would have told him that what you done was irresponsible and reckless you endangered all our life’s for a relationship that is illegal and you did not consider my feelings when you did it.

[@8onnie8oyz]

Honestly, both ships kinda suck. One was too pick me and the other was too possessive.

[@lesterwilliamsjr649]

Random Thought This video reminds about Lance from symbiotic titans and how I think he is the most clichie teenage girl dream guy I've seen in a cartoon. The guy who doesn’t care, is always series, works out, gets into trouble, and has a sad backstory. He's a good character, but I just hate how guys like him are seen by teenage girls as an ideal.