The Mysteries Of North America's Great Lakes | Naked Science | Spark

[@sativagirl1885]

It's no mystery. The Great Lakes are *entirely Canada's fault.* For thousands of years after Zambonis resurfaced ice rinks, the shaved ice was dumped outside, eh?

[@seanreid349]

No, we put it in our beer coolers

[@kennethwatchorn3821]

Sorry

[@laughingoutloud5742]

Take Off, Hoser

[@noyencortezgomez7220]

Huh???!!!

[@benjaminnevins5211]

Blame Canada

[@viserproductions1]

Crazy to think this episode is almost 15 years old, it really does bring back a lot of memories of watching childhood science documentaries. The music, the narrator, the effects, everything. Glad to have found this channel!

[@Doingstuff.since76]

The synthesyzer haha

[@voornaam3191]

And I run away. That stupid over the top narrator, I can't stand him. Man, relax! Tell your boss they are crazy! They are! Yuck! Talk like you talk at home! Jesus!

[@voornaam3191]

And still, these American narratars, I can't stand it. Over the top. Exagerated.

[@nanaman]

I have to agree with you on this I didn’t know how to pay attention in 7th grade . It’s great to see these documentaries today

[@josephhausser3096]

this is definitely older. youtube is 15. videos cant be dated to before youtubes invention

[@OlePaddy]

As an Ohio native who grew up hearing the Michigan-bashing tales, I never had the chance to visit until I was an adult. Michigan blew me away! From crossing the Mighty Mac to learning what a Yooper was and trying my first pastie. Camped on the shores of Lake Superior near the pictured rocks during the summer solstice. Skipped out on Florida this year and plan on returning, hopefully this time I can find an Agate! *edit I returned to Lake Superior for camping and finally found an Agate. The video is on my channel if you’re interested in watching.

[@worldadventuretravel]

For the rest of us not anywhere near the Great Lakes, what *is* a Yooper?

[@BlakeH97]

​@@worldadventuretravel as someone from Michigan's lower peninsula a Yooper is someone from the Upper peninsula. A U.P.-er

[@Magdalenasfears]

Aww, being a Michigan girl who's family has been here since well before it was a state, this makes me smile.

[@topdogalpha]

Just avoid all of our cities. Demmy's have done a master class on how to ruin thriving industry in 7 once beautiful cities

[@thefashiongoddesschannel8099]

Try Chicago Lake Michigan. You'll be amazed. Spring is nice. Northern suburbs are best.

[@2msvalkyrie529]

As a Brit I'm constantly amazed how many Americans simply don't appreciate what a magnificent variety of landscapes they live among ! From the Great Lakes to the Rockies , the deserts of South West and swamps in Florida etc. America is an amazing place !! Don't listen to the whining critics !! 👍🇬🇧 !

[@crandonborth]

I think most Americans living here don’t appreciate it as they have never seen what’s out there… if you see the Grand Canyon up close it’s far different than a picture. I think geographically the US has some of the best landscapes in the world… but Europe hands down beats us in architecture.

[@Kaz.Klay.]

Ignorance is bliss. As they say 😮 :-/

[@Cimmaronisson]

Thank you for recognizing the beauty and diversity of America. Many of us do know how lucky we are to live in this amazing place.

[@robinsmith1218]

I hope I do! I grew up on California beaches, spent most of my life in the Rockies, and am now by the Great Lakes. I've missed a few states, but I've traveled through most of them. Thank you for your kind words. But there is beauty ALL OVER this incredible planet.

[@jj3449]

If you would fly as far as I need to see these different landscapes you’d see lots of the same things in Europe. I’m in the Mid Atlantic region and the pyramids in Egypt are slightly closer to London than I am to Yellowstone Park.

[@clairewyndham1971]

I lived the first 18 years of my life up between the Copper Harbor area and the Soo. Now I live right on Lake Michigan. I cant imagine being away from these Insanely beautiful lakes.

[@gryph01]

I live close to the Huron coast in Ontario. Lake Huron is my favorite

[@clairewyndham1971]

@gryph01 - Once you connect..really connect with these Lakes, you know that's where you must stay. I wish I could explain it, but I can't. When I lived in the UP, it sounds crazy but the big storms-the downright vicious ones would rear the lake up on her hind legs, you're memorized. You can't help but feel them in your soul. And you really realize how small and insignificant you, your trouble and worries are..

[@BrianPeloso-ln4ry]

Sault Canada here...I've circumnavigated Superior by Land. our north shore exhibits the glacial deposits mentioned...lots of smooth stone. Great smooth cliffs that plunge to the water. ✌️🇨🇦👍

[@icosthop9998]

​@@BrianPeloso-ln4ry Nice

[@djquinn11]

@@BrianPeloso-ln4ry:I would love to drive the Lake Superior shoreline on the Canadian side.

[@gmaureen]

I was born and lived most of my adult life in Michigan. The lakes are beautiful. My father helped build the Mackinac Bridge in the 50's, I drove across in the 80's and couldn't believe how scary it was. The wind will try to dump your car into the water. Apples are everywhere, raspberries too, but most of all I miss the Lilacs.

[@SamM-gl9zc]

I'm in West Michigan, about 25 miles from the eastern coast of Lake Michigan... One of the craziest things about the Great Lakes for those of us living downwind, is the affect they have on weather. Even today, for instance, the sun is out now - in 5 minutes, it may be snowing so hard that you can't see 100 yards, and then sunny-ish again 5-10 min later. This will continue most of the day. There is no weather system in the area... but there are 30+ mph, 10 degree winds going over 40 degree water - so we get bands of heavy snow only a couple miles wide, over and over. Even when there's not enough instability to make snow, there WILL be clouds. From Nov-April, Western Michigan is the cloudiest place in America and one of the cloudiest on the entire planet. It's pretty depressing, almost never seeing the sun for months, but it's not all bad - the water staying relatively warm like that means that when it's 20 below zero right on the other side of the lake in Wisonsin, it's still 10 above here. And in the summer heat, storms that drop tornadoes in IL & WI get out over the 70 degree water and frequently lose the punch they had, saving us from a lot of the worst damage. And, of course, there is having beautiful beaches at a freshwater sea to enjoy all summer.

[@akeleven]

You could be talking about Seattle or Juneau Alaska.

[@indianastan]

Yes Cherry 🍒🍒🍒 picking season in a few months 😋

[@SamM-gl9zc]

@akeleven - Except for not being on an ocean, and the freshwater sea to enjoy, and storms that had been severe for hours in Iowa, Illinois & Wisconsin weakening as they leave land, go over the cooler water, and back over land in Michigan... but yeah, kind of. Everybody knows oceans affect everything about the weather - part of my point was that a lot of people don't realize how big The Great Lakes are, and that they also have a pretty big affect.

[@SamM-gl9zc]

@indianastan - Fresh-picked cherries are so good!!!

[@RowanHawkins]

​@@SamM-gl9zcIts the same downwind of Erie and Ontario. We get some of the worst snow, because both lakes often line up with prevailing winds. The fetch across a few hundred miles of open water and you might as well be shoveling the lake onto land. Then there is the seich causing flooding. They behave like giant bathtubs. Because the lakes line up with the wind, surface water is blown to the east end of the lake and when the wind stops it sloshes back to the west side. Just like pushing water in a tub with your arm. Compounding the problem on Erie is the fact that the west end is much shallower than the east end so it doesn't handle the return slosh very well.

[@FjHenderson]

And at one time the ice sheets thickness was supposedly at 7 miles thick, a lot thicker than 2 miles. The sheer weight of the sheet was so heavy it pushed the land around the great lakes down. The land to this day is still rising upwards from the weight being gone.

[@ronjon7942]

Yes. It’s measurable from satellites..

[@m.pearce3273]

The Ice sheet depth over the Ottawa Valley 10km thick so the depts they propose in this doc is way way off. Now if we factor in the sun's pulse every 12K years. Pulse Water comes into play as all this ice melted very very quickly

[@StewartDuncanJr]

Imagine the waterfalls back in that time. 5 to 6 miles high.

[@andrewsteen1427]

@@StewartDuncanJrwith that height you’d think by the time it came down, it’d prob just be heavy rain/mist? Idk 🤷‍♂️

[@GTCloud_9]

​@@andrewsteen1427 yeah it would be

[@pudermcgavin4462]

MN born and raised and my fav city is Duluth, and I am in awe of lake Superior and how destructive and powerful it can be!

[@BigTimeRushFan2112]

the lake it is said, never gives up her dead when the skies of November turn gloomy...

[@w-dad4040]

I'm from London Ontario, but I've driven past Lake Superior many times driving to Calgary and it is my favorite for sure. It is like Ocean water in a lake surrounded by beauty (at least in Northern Ontario)

[@ryanquintana3739]

Go to canal park brewery, best food and beer in Duluth.

[@neilcashaback2987]

Thunder Bay here and I'll second that

[@Jenny2dicks]

It’s the earths pussy

[@peterpiper4619]

I was born and raised near Detroit but my parents were from upper Michigan so I've been going there since I was born twice a year once in the summer and once during deer hunting. What amazes me is the place never changed, I'm 76 years old.

[@jinxacres]

Michigan is hands down the most BEAUTIFUL state in the summer, combined beautiful Forrest, farm lands and sand dunes and Beaches Michigan truly is a unique state and #1. I love winter so makes it even better when you get dumped on by lake effect snow.

[@finnmcginn9931]

Upper Peninsula is beautiful. Grew up on a farm in Southwestern Ontario (on the shores of Erie and visited your state often growing up).

[@Jenny2dicks]

Yeeeaaahhhhh this my state arf arf. This is my state I think.

[@terrybennetts7898]

Embrace it. As long as you can remove the snow and the gov does not infringe, MI is the best state there is.

[@matthewjason5330]

@@terrybennetts7898much have the snow than the government any day lol

[@worldadventuretravel]

After watching documentaries abut the Fitz and all the other shipping disasters on the Great Lakes, it's the only think I can think about now when that region comes to mind. That and the "November witch."

[@ricjonez1816]

Native American Ojibwe Michigan, Our Elders told us we are the keepers of the freshest water of the world and are to respect it. Women with Cooper buckets honor the water in all the four directions ❤❤❤❤

[@atimnile2401]

Some of us living in the Great lakes Region are so lucky to enjoy these Beautiful lakes & some have Gorgeous State Parks such as Pictured Rocks National Lake Shore Off Lake Superior!!! States like California, Nevada & Arizona are facing A water 💦 crisis 💯🤓!!!!

[@donnaw9040]

The SW water crisis is actually man made. It’s a water mis-management problem, created by minds and decisions of man,aka politicians.

[@joyreno1034]

I grew up in Michigan and brought up my family here. I will forever fight any idea/plan of a water pipeline to the west.

[@Norah56s]

​​@@joyreno1034 I've lived in West Coast states my whole life (60+ years) and I support and agree with you. I wouldn't feel at all right about your water being stolen to be used here.

[@chasetonga]

⁠​⁠@@joyreno1034I’m from WI and I agree. Many weren’t happy when Waukesha got water piped from Lake Michigan since it is out of the basin area. I don’t know how the gov pulled that off since I thought there was an agreement with all the Great Lakes states and Canada that water couldn’t just be piped out.

[@hambix1032]

california is actually out of a drought for now, most of our reservoirs are full.

[@mvc9178]

Failed to mention Nestle and their giant siphon…

[@rjaquaponics9266]

"too obvious it hurts YT brains" LOL

[@Michadoo]

amen

[@Mr.FuzzyDingo]

Yet Californians wonder why they have droughts 🤣🤦

[@JohnRHeil1]

Nestle uses way less water than your local craft breweries and wineries and bread yeast makers, like less than 1%. You just like to be angry.

[@Mr.FuzzyDingo]

@@JohnRHeil1 apparently you no not of what you speak grasshopper. Try Googling "Nestle buying water rights to California aquifer". California sold their (& 2 other states) largest water reserve to a private company.

[@ronjon7942]

There’s always something surreal about seeing a place on a documentary, tv show, or movie that one has personally visited.

[@ssilent8202]

Fun fact: some of the Great Lakes freighters are so large that they actually can’t fit through the St. Lawrence Seaway. Those ships will never sail the saltwater oceans simply because they literally can’t fit. (Just for reference, the max size for the Panama Canal is *smaller* than the max size for through the St. Lawrence Seaway)

[@danieldeanmasterfinisher4715]

You can take the man out of Michigan, but you can never take Michigan out of the man. Born and raised here, and I’ll be buried here a true gem to the continental United States. No other state in the lower 48 can really compare and I’ve been to most . Colorado and it’s pure beauty would be a close second in my book..

[@batzzz2044]

No truer words spoken. Love this land.

[@ronjon7942]

Nope, AZ’s my close second. The distances twixt towns always reminds me of the UP. I was raised in Northern Wisconsin and thoroughly explored the UP but still only feel like I’ve barely scratched the surface - so much to see. But for all my screwin’ around, somehow I always seem to go back to the Sturgeon River. The river’s gorge, Canyon Falls, Tibbet’s Falls…she just makes my heart ache. I swear to God, before I pass I’m going to explore it upstream to where it starts. Kayaking, rock climbing, skiing - the Upper Peninsula just has so much. Laf, except an easy living.

[@batzzz2044]

@@ronjon7942 I bought my first Estwing pickaxe in Copper Harbor.

[@ronjon7942]

@@batzzz2044That I have never tried. I think I’d be too chicken now, even though I understand it is quite the sport there. I seem to recall it being really popular in Munising? Munising Falls, Miner’s Falls, maybe the Lakeshore? I guess I’d try it, but maybe with a bona fide ice climber…gettin’ too old to learn that stuff the younger me way. :)

[@Jenny2dicks]

Hell yeah Detroit. I from here and we out here doiiiin it.

[@just_kos99]

When I went to Illinois to see my son graduate from Navy boot camp, we stopped on the shore of Lake Michigan in Chicago. I was simply floored. I stressed to my sister, "This is FRESH WATER! No lake should be so big that you can't see the other side!" We saw ocean-going vessels off in the distance. I mean, these Lakes are seriously humongous. I live in Ohio now, bordering Lake Erie and I'm sad to say I haven't actually seen it yet, but I'm hoping to some day.

[@wallyman292]

I sailed Lake Michigan for a good chunk of my life. It's amazing how beautiful it is when you're out in the middle, no land in sight. Especially at nighttime. Just an incredible experience each time I crossed.

[@ssilent8202]

Fun fact: some of the Great Lakes freighters are so large that they actually can’t fit through the St. Lawrence Seaway. Those ships will never sail the saltwater oceans simply because they literally can’t fit. (Just for reference, the max size for the Panama Canal is *smaller* than the max size for through the St. Lawrence Seaway)

[@kaykaystern]

I live on lake Huron in Tawas, Michigan It's such a gorgeous place. Pure Michigan is pure beauty. I've learned not to take it for granted. I feel blessed to live here🙌🏼🖤🖤🖤

[@jeff-ds2pr]

Used to camp on Tawas Point all the time as a kid. Very nice area.

[@BlainesMommy]

I also live on Lake Huron on the Canadian side.. Sarnia here!

[@sparkeyjames]

Did they rid of those Fog Horns located near the point? I remember as a kid going to the state park because an uncle resided in a nearby air force base. Those horns kept us up all night on more than one occasion.

[@BlainesMommy]

@@sparkeyjames to be totally honest with you I'm not familiar with the fog horns in Point Edward, to be honest lol. I know that in Sarnia they still do the plant alarm testing every Monday at 12:30pm, if you remember that

[@peterblack3665]

Ontario has numerous beach towns dotting the shore of Lake Huron Bayfield , Grand Bend , Port Elgin, Sauble; South Hampton all enjoying enjoying the Lake Huron shore line.....

[@erubielalanis6658]

I’ve lived in the Chicago area all of my life and I took Lake Michigan for granted until I started to visit other states and see how differently water is treated elsewhere.

[@judd0112]

Why is it treated better or worse in other places? Chicago has had its share of bad water issues in the past and I think one that wasn’t too long ago. They started taking their water from the lake like 10 miles offshore and I think their raw sewage discharge was flowing into the water intake. I can’t remember exactly. But maybe you know.

[@benjaminnevins5211]

@@judd0112Chicago reversed the river flow.

[@erubielalanis6658]

@@judd0112 Water is more carefully used in other states that I've visited, they don't have the supply we do. There hasn't been any problems with our water supply, when we get a lot of rain there is sewage that gets released into the lake which spikes bacteria. It's no problem for the water treatment plants.

[@johnsalomone5101]

What you never knew the lake closest to you ? You had to notice it well on vacation away from your area ?

[@atimnile2401]

@@johnsalomone5101; He’s just stating that he’s Appreciating it more than he initially did . I feel the same way living in Wisconsin & having some beautiful Parks to enjoy right off Lake Michigan Shore & Really nice beaches too. Visited Flagstaff; Arizona last year & property there has skyrocketed & also water distribution 💦 is A huge problem if you buy rural land & want to build property out there !!! In all the Mid-West States we don’t have that problem. Nevada, Arizona, & California are all facing A H20 crisis that we in the Midwest will never have ; at least not anytime soon !!!

[@cecilponsaing2749]

A beautiful video. Too much to cover in a comment. So, one part only ... the water level in the south is rising because of the rebound of the crust of the earth in the north after the disappearence of the great weight of the former ice sheet in the north, while the south is not rebounding. I learned from that, that it is the same reason that Lappland in the north of Europe is rising 10 cm a year and Venice is sinking 10 cm a year. I learned that result in school in Sweeden, but the reason for it in this video.

[@jamestomkin8784]

I live a mile south of the Great Lake Ontario! Proud to be a Great Laker!

[@xochitl9161]

Me too !

[@DMUSA536]

I’m 10 miles away.

[@jeffhampton2767]

Migrants are pooping all over the beaches😊

[@Bruce22027]

I am from Michigan and have not seen any major changes in the Great Lakes water level in the past 30 years. Some years the level is up and some it’s down.

[@kissthesky40]

They are climate shills.

[@warrengee-f9l]

what they dont go into is the area was under a massive inland sea during the cretaceous period , the Niagara Escarpment is an ancient coral reef cutting north from Niagara through Southern Ontario to beyond Georgian Bay.... at places its a few hundred feet above the current level of Lake Huron .....

[@antonioarroyas7662]

It forms a crescent and extends down the western edge of Lake Michigan.

[@ronaldviens7862]

The Niagara Escarpment is composed of dolostone, not coral. Although one is uncertain whether or not that section of Pangaea had the tropical climate necessary for coral to propagate.

[@warrengee-f9l]

its Impressive in its own right :)@@ronaldviens7862

[@warrengee-f9l]

its impressive in its own right :) its full of fossils @@ronaldviens7862

[@ronjon7942]

Yeah, and down to the Milwaukee area. We’ve done some fun climbing on it in Appleton (High Cliff), Hustisford (Ledge Park), and, laf, Niagara too! - although Niagara, Wisconsin, isn’t park of the Niagara Escarpment.

[@aint_no_saint8782]

Ahhh, Niagara Falls is between Lakes Erie and Michigan?? Really. Better check their maps. Last time I saw one, they're between Lakes Erie and ONTARIO. Good editing work there!

[@christinewittmann1806]

I live on the island in the middle of those two lakes. Erie and Ontario that is! One foot in each!

[@sebastienloyer9471]

​@@christinewittmann1806🎉. Real nice. To be on an island.

[@RowanHawkins]

​@@christinewittmann1806there is no island you can do that on. Lake Erie and Ontario are separated by the Niagara river. Grand Island is in the river and because of the falls no one would consider it part of Lake Ontario. If you're trying to claim the south western end of the Niagara Peninsula is an island just because some humans dug a ditch across it a couple hundred years ago, then the Erie canal has you beat by at least 50 years.

[@christinewittmann1806]

@@RowanHawkins I misspoke, a foot in each culturally. Yes, Grand Island is in the Niagara River which is miles long and connects the two lakes. Living in this region is interesting because you can very literally spend part of your day on Lake Erie and drive less than an hour to Lake Ontario.. I am sorry if I misrepresented my home geographically.

[@johannahowardpurdy1340]

​@@christinewittmann1806 No biggie; you're good 😊

[@jameswestberg6549]

Michigander born and raised. I've been from Maine to LA and Florida to Wyoming and so far there is no place like Michigan. All four seasons but never too hot (like Texas), never too cold (like Montana), no hurricanes no mudslides no earthquakes. Just tons of water and beautiful beaches...

[@thetitansofbrahma6702]

Too many name and place bloopers, but this vid was better than most KZbin presentation on the Lakes.

[@SquareRootOf4761]

Right away called United States a continent.... 🙄

[@icosthop9998]

I'm not usually into these kind of documentaries but they kept it interesting.

[@man_in_space]

@@SquareRootOf4761”Continental United States” is a term that refers to the Lower 48 plus Alaska.

[@SquareRootOf4761]

@@man_in_space I won’t question it. Americans made up their own language. “Americanish”

[@JamesLydon1]

youngstown ohio state university lolol

[@cyan1616]

Growing up on lakes Michigan and Superior and being interested in geology, I am convinced that the state of Lower Michigan is a giant impact crater from something that hit our planet and punched a giant hole into the edge of the land mass that would become Canada. After that sea water poured in and created the salt layer that underlies the state. I even approached a professor from the University of Chicago about my theory... he actually said it was his theory too and could be entirely possible. If you look ate the rock formation layers it looks just like an impact crater. Other academics say I'm wrong, but then go on to say that no one really knows the processes that created these unique features... but I'm wrong.

[@judd0112]

They think a comet that caused the younger dryas die off just when the glaciers started to melt and massive chunks of ice were stuck there and formed lakes. The impact signs are called Carolina bay’s. Very interesting

[@okboomer6201]

The Saginaw Bay is a recent meteor or comet strike. Goog: "saginaw bay impact crater" The deep underground salt under in the Michigan Basin is from way way back before Pangea. More like Gondwana age.

[@PaulBrown-uj5le]

Is it tho?​@judd0112

[@NorthernMike]

We know how they were formed. No impact involved. If the oceans were forced into these areas there would be proof of it.

[@sarahdawn7075]

I agree there has probably been at least one and probably more extraterrestrial impacts that have contributed to the formation of the great lakes. The lakes are very deep in places and glaciers alone can't account for such deep basins.

[@ironiccookies2320]

There are boulders originating from the great lakes that are found further south than they should be. On a scientific trip to southwest Minnesota, we were told and shown boulders that originated from Lake Superior. From Lake Superior to southwest Minnesota that's a 7-8 hour drive so just imagine a giant boulder getting moved there by massive glaciers over thousands of years

[@ZeligUbique]

they’re called erratics

[@boxsterman77]

They’re known as erratics. Glaciers move them there.

[@Chiamex]

Lake ONTARIO is the best of them all!! I've lived on its southern shore for 74 years, and this will be my forever home. Hurray for the great state of New York and its lake-sharing neighbor, Canada!!

[@lonewolf1401]

i live on lake st.clair the forgotten unrecognized lake

[@antonioarroyas7662]

@@lonewolf1401 Shhh, don't tell them about the hidden gem.

[@dough7612]

"the great state of NY?"

[@ajcook7777]

Lake Huron is better actually just ask us

[@Chiamex]

@ajcook7777 too funny, but my money is still on Ontario;)

[@jessielee5460]

I live right on lake Erie in huron, Ohio. This was super cool to learn about!

[@daveotuwa5596]

Michael Jackson lived near Lake Michigan. 'Twas where he was born, and my autistic sixth grade classmate was born near the Great Lake.

[@shawnbutler6274]

Love that town go tigers 🐅

[@icosthop9998]

Nice

[@tan-ne4zi]

my cottage is directly across from you on the canadian side

[@nbuckanaga6840]

better be careful on what you think you learned and please do some proper research on this subject and re-educate yourself on some of the false information throughout this particular documentary. noticed many false statements.

[@HostileOfficial92]

IM FROM MICHIGAN & WE LOVE OUR LAKES

[@daveotuwa5596]

Give it up 2 SISTER, SISTER 'n MARTIN!!!!!!! VROOM!!!!!!!!!!! Don't forget about the automotive companyz!

[@HostileOfficial92]

@@daveotuwa5596 uhhh .. autistic huh 🤔

[@batzzz2044]

Tip of the mit here and I frequent Michigan Huron and superior. Charlevoix and Torch are my inland gems

[@riverlady982]

Same but I can't watch this it's too ridiculously melodramatic. I also feel like they're talking to me like they think I'm some kind of mental midget 😒

[@theunspoke815]

I live on the south Shore of Lake Erie & I'm 48. I can stand witness to this fact!! Don't have some of our fishing spots anymore & the residents on the shore have been dumping broken up concrete from old buildings that get torn down to try to slow down the erosion for decades!!! GREAT VIDEO!!! ❤ (and I also hear that residents along the shore in Cuyahoga County have to deal with rats)😝 I'm trying to move Southeast about an hour!! The city areas really have too many people in them!!

[@colintilbrook]

The Wild Rice evidence is interesting, but the premise doesn't doesn't "hold water" (pun intended) for me. I'm a Landscape Architect with most of my experience in natural restoration and I have some familiarity with Wild Rice. I've planted it on my farm in a shallow and very calm pond less than an acre in size, and it did just fine. Wild rice was and is to this day, cultivated by Native people here in Ontario in muddy shallow lakes, that is actually where it tends to thrive. It likes nutrient rich, muddy bottomed fairly calm water at depths ranging from consistently saturated mud, to about 60cm or 2 feet of depth, it can grow in greater depth or less moisture, but a heavily wave battered shoreline is certainly not what it likes.

[@firetakesall8000]

Yes, wild rice is cultivated in shallow muddy wetlands in Michigan also.

[@shannonspage9360]

You are correct native Americans/first nations of that region did cultivate wild rice. That doesn't mean it wasn't brought here originally by the geologic forces discussed in the video. Once brought into the area the wild rice thrived due to favorable environment and conditions.

[@shannonspage9360]

You are correct native Americans/first nations of that region did cultivate wild rice. That doesn't mean it wasn't brought here originally by the geologic forces discussed in the video. Once brought into the area the wild rice thrived due to favorable environment and conditions.

[@shannonspage9360]

You are correct native Americans/first nations of that region did cultivate wild rice. That doesn't mean it wasn't brought here originally by the geologic forces discussed in the video. Once brought into the area the wild rice thrived due to favorable environment and conditions.

[@shannonspage9360]

You are correct native Americans/first nations of that region did cultivate wild rice. That doesn't mean it wasn't brought here originally by the geologic forces discussed in the video. Once brought into the area the wild rice thrived due to favorable environment and conditions.

[@canaanval]

Should have mentioned the Alpena-Amberly Ridge which cut Lake Huron in half

[@brandysears3546]

Dude. Sending support, love, and kindness from Lexington, Michigan, USA

[@crazyfingers_kc]

Well hey neighbor. Port Huron here

[@Jenny2dicks]

Hello from croswell. I have titties

[@rickwilliams967]

Why? We're talking about lakes.

[@roskene]

Thank you for this. I grew up near Lake Erie in Lorain County Ohio. As a child I saw the lake heavily polluted because of industry,Now thanks to changes in industry and the Zebra mussel she is a beautiful clear blue. Still not pristine. My father who was born in either Fairport Harbor or Lorain in 1895 and loved the lake told stories of fishing for yellow perch and the now extinct Blue Pike; and saw Sturgeon piled up along the shore because it was considered a trash fish good only for fertilizer. For reference I was born in 1946, a post war baby boomer to my mother born in 1908 . my father fought at Chateau Thierry Sept 14 to 18 , 1918.

[@historyjunkie3144]

My gr grandpa fought and was severely wounded at the battle of chateau thierry , he made it home but unfortunately died 6 mo later from complications due to the leftover shrapnel in his body. He was posthumously awarded the purple heart 💜

[@yungkermit]

Lifelong MI resident. I'll guard these Lakes with my life if it ever comes down to it. If you plan on visiting, I sincerely hope you treat them with the same reverence. Lake Michigan beaches get decimated by tourists. Their kids dredge channels from our streams to the lake and decimate the local habitat. Our lakes are a more sensitive ecosystem than an ocean or sea, even if you can't see across them.

[@MeMyselfAndUs903]

So I’m sure you’ve heard about the pipeline in Mackinac Straits.

[@yungkermit]

@@MeMyselfAndUs903 Yeah, and it shouldn’t be there. Like disrespectful tourists.

[@swampman5014]

They should have added St Davids creek that was where Lake Iroquois "Ontario" flowed into Lake Erie prior to Niagara falls existence. Niagara falls was formed around 4500-6000 years ago with the aid of Glacial lake Tonawanda.

[@spuds6423]

Check out the "Great Flood of New York" by the Woods Hole Institute...very interesting

[@swampman5014]

@spuds6423 Look into the history of glacial lake Tonawanda. I'm very familiar with the subject.

[@spuds6423]

@@swampman5014 Cool!! Thanks for the information....Ice Ages are Climate Change!!😂

[@marvinmauldin4361]

There is also a theory that a comet or asteroid strike in that area wiped out the Clovis culture around that time, and that the object hit the thick ice sheet. The crater was mainly in the ice, and subsequent movement of the ice would have erased the effects on the ground. In addition to the expected adverse effects of such an event on humans in the area, diversion of the drainage patterns would have caused even more problems.

[@m.pearce3273]

Clovis hahaha no comet it's the sun always proof in abundance but you are not looking for it

[@DavidNPS]

Absolutely Fascinating. Living in Michigan , not far from Lake Mich , I Loved this from Start to Finish.

[@kathyorourke9273]

I know approximately where the glacier stopped on the west US coast. I lived in Seattle and bought a new house. Just to dig a hole to plant a bush took an hour! The ground around Kirkland (across Lake Washington) is practically solid round rocks. I moved to Oregon a not a rock was to be found! I was so happy.

[@danielbernier9115]

Lol same thing in Massachusetts.

[@TDurden527]

Ya . . . around Enumclaw they called it hard pan I think it was. Hitting it with a pick was like hitting concrete, and it was just dirt and smaller sized pebbles and rock.

[@judd0112]

That could have been from the Tsunamis that have in undated the northwest coast repeatedly for thousands of years. And they are due for another one anytime. Not a question of if ,it’s when it pushed ocean rocks etc miles inland. Also the Montana ice age flood that glacial lake in Montana that was let loose and it flooded the entire western Washington carving the in not from the area but it looks like the Grand Canyon kinda. Massive water erosion. Went all the way to the pacific. And the academics didn’t think it was possible that if could have been eroded it such a massive single event rather than over thousands of years they claimed. Not new information has demonstrated that it was a huge event and it was not thousands of years was relatively quick on earth time scale.

[@Chris_at_Home]

I live on a glacier moraine with hardpan a foot down. The glacier is still only 30 miles away.

[@JayYoung-ro3vu]

Glacial grooves don"t exist only on Kelley's Island. Middle Bass Island has them. They aren't as grand as on Kelley's but they are there. You just have to know where to look. I worked for a bit on a college practicum in the very late 1980s on Middle Bass. Lonz Winery was still operating.

[@ulfricstormcloak5080]

Love those glacial grooves. I found a nice hand specimen of a glacial groove near Cleveland. Honestly one of my favorite rocks I have

[@richardbonner2354]

I hear that in Manhattan's famous Central Park, huge glaciers sheared some serious grooves into the ancient bedrock of the Catskills and Appalachian Mountains. 🙂 Rick Bonner Pennsyltuck

[@JayYoung-ro3vu]

@richardbonner2354 You heard correctly. There is a locally famous boulder in Central Pak that shows the grooves. I saw it on a ' Hidden places/secrets of NYC/Manhatten' program. I don't recall them being as pronounced as the ones on Kelley's Island. They are more like the ones on nearby Middle Bass Island. We have an erratic sitting near our local reservoir. I believe geologists 'tracked' it from somewhere in central Quebec? The Army Corps of Engineers has an information marker adjacent to it. Also, if interested, another plaque shows how the ice sheets changed the courses of rivers or filled in their valleys. Pittsburgh wouldn't have three rivers if not for the glaciers. The Ohio River (would be another name) would have flowed west and empty into the Mississippi River just north of St. Louis. The dry valley can be traced backed east into Ohio.

[@todd3205]

My Grandpappy had a cabin on Kelleys Island back in the 60s. These grooves were ALWAYS known as The Glacial Grooves. When we were kids, only about a hundred feet of these were uncovered, but since have have been excavated more for research.

[@Spike-sk7ql]

Lived near Lake Erie my whole life. I have seen Lakes Ontario, and Huron. I REALLY want to visit Lake Superior, and Michigan someday. Nothing beats camping on the lakes during a nice summer night.

[@WillArtie]

great vid! I love geology, history, sciences vids. could watch them all day and turn into a part of the couch.

[@lonewolf1401]

thank you ...i live in michigan and you just explained everything we never learned in school...keep up the great work very interesting and knoledgable

[@Jenny2dicks]

Breh

[@danw.7935]

If you can't stand cold, only visit in the summer, which lasts about 3 months. But it's unbeatable. I learned how to drive there and it's the only place I'll drive in the snow, cuz everyone is so used to it. Still sketchy, but tenable

[@DesertGal.7]

Lake Huron is beautiful! I grew up there. Great beaches in the summer. And, no sharks...

[@gurnblanston5000]

Can you smell Chicago on the west shore, Benton Harbor or Holland area?

[@WatchWitMe]

As a Wisconsinite I feel so lucky to live near the driftless region and the Great Lakes.

[@sealyoness]

Good for you... those erratic boulders and drumlins we find all over WI and IL... they only sound scary.

[@jeffhampton2767]

You can have the bitterly cold state😊

[@VandelayIndusties]

This makes me quite proud to be a Michigander. This talked a lot about Erie and Ontario, but man going to up to the traverse city/Sleeping Bear Dunes area is absolutely beautiful

[@stanleybarton]

Why am I hearing in 2024 the same explanation that I was taught about how the Great Lakes were formed in 1954 when I was in third grade?

[@JLP80]

Most of them didn’t learn it then

[@BeeHash]

It didn’t change.

[@Thallidus]

Proud to have grown up in Owen Sound Ontario. Right on Georgian bay in Lake Huron.

[@WillN2Go1]

at 7:50 'leaves behind glacial melt water' forming kettle lakes. This misses something key. As glacier melt/recede they leave behind erratics, rocks and boulders that have been transported. In this rubble are also large chunks of ice left behind like boulders. But unlike boulders this ice melts leaving a void a depression that fills with water as a lake. At the bottom of some of these lakes buried in the rubble and silt are bits of ice left over from the last ice age. The rubble and silt insulate. Something else that is missing. By far the most powerful tool of ice and glaciers is the freezing thawing cycle that occurs along the margins. If you've ever climb or hiked along an arete, usually called sawtooth, jagged, or in Japan Dikiretto, you'll notice that a lot of the of rock is loose. This is because the thawing cycle allows water to fill in any crack and the freezing cycle expands the volume widening the cracks. Quarrying. The aretes are still there because this is what the glaciers on both sides were working at when they began to recede. This is where all the gravel, sand and boulders in glacier ice comes from.

[@Roylamx]

'At the bottom of some of these lakes buried in the rubble and silt are bits of ice left over from the last ice age. The rubble and silt insulate.' Are you really saying there is still glacial ice there today?

[@ronjon7942]

Wait, what?? You’re trying to say there exists bits of ice, underground, underwater, from over 10,000 years ago? That there is such a dramatic NEGATIVE geothermal gradient that ice exists underground in the Great Lakes regions? That’s really the story you’re sticking with? This must be how Alfred Wegener must have been viewed, although in his case he was proven correct.

[@asha8443]

Fun fact: Long Island (NY) is also formed by the action of the ice sheets that deposited sediments from further north to create the island.

[@exmcairgunner]

I was a child when my family visited Niagara Falls in 1969, when the falls were shutoff. It was a sight that told the story.

[@spuds6423]

Actually, they were diverted because they needed to produce the necessary power.

[@RowanHawkins]

​@@spuds6423no, they were diverted to try and reinforce the face of the rock to slow erosion caused by the caprock calving off. Due to the Niagara Commission treaty between US & Canada, the amount of water diverted for night time hydro drives pumps which fill two massive holding ponds. However, I think 70% of the summer flow has to go over the falls all the time. In the daytime tourist season hours that is increased to 85% of the flow. At a state park downriver (north) of Lewiston you see about a foot of temporary river height in the morning when both more water is going over the falls and the storage is being released through both the Canadian and US hydro plants.

[@patriciamedaris8552]

As a michigander i can tell you that they have been selling water from the great lakes to other countries for years, and not in small quantities.

[@dinodadinosaur]

This documentary reminds me of falling asleep on a desk in highschool

[@pierrelabounty9917]

😂

[@austins.2495]

Michigan is hella underrated 🤙 Midwest just hits different

[@PongoXBongo]

Based on the narrator's voice, I was half expecting him to say they were created by ancient aliens. 😅

[@drafthorseswithalexa]

Great stuff - grew up sailing the North Channel of Lake Huron, widely considered one of the most beautiful boating/sailing regions of the world. Killarney is just at the eastern tip, stunning white mountains line the northern side (Lacloche Mountains) - some geological evidence indicating they were higher than Everest millions of years ago. The drive around the northern shore of Lake Superior is rugged and absolutely stunning.

[@scott4482]

Acting like it's some big mystery, it's been established for centuries that it was ice

[@albeit1]

They didn’t mention what happens when Niagra Falls is done eroding away all that rock. The level of the Lake Erie falls to Lake Ontario’s level. It is expected to permanently increase Lake Ontario’s depth and size.

[@intuitknit]

Nestle - that"s where the water is going.

[@Lea-is-sleeping]

Fr

[@donhagerty5669]

I LIVED ABOUT A YEAR IN SUPERIOR WISCONSIN WHICH WAS CLOSE TO LAKE SUPERIOR. I EVEN GOT TO GO SAILING FOR THE DAY ON LAKE SUPERIOR

[@NorthernMike]

Ouch, Why are you screaming?

[@justinfloyd1096]

Calm down bro.

[@FoxDragon]

The tinfoil example annoys me because he's not even trying to hide the fact that he is just barely setting the 'clean' ice on the foil while he is actively pushing the 'dirty' ice down to cause as much damage as possible. XD

[@timothykeith1367]

I saw that too, but he needed another prop and the cameraman was already there

[@2msvalkyrie529]

Why did it annoy you ? What he stated was a fact which he did his best to illustrate while being in the Middle of nowhere ! If it had been Graham Hancock you would have called him a genius ??

[@FoxDragon]

@@2msvalkyrie529 LMAO nah, hanckock is a complete quack. It annoys me because the example would have worked fine without him very obviously pushing on it, by doing so it makes it seem like he doesn't trust his own example.

[@rickwilliams967]

You don't really get science huh?

[@kenpamanian9428]

I mean the ice was a mile thick you don't think it pressed down ?

[@AnubisGamingBytes]

Upper Michigan is the most beautiful place. If you haven’t seen it you should. It’s been my home all my life and I wouldn’t want to live anywhere else.

[@167curly]

An interesting similarity to the Great Lake's drowned forests is in Bermuda where the rising Atlantic Ocean covered cedar groves 7,000 years ago. Cedar stumps and roots have been raised from Bermuda's shallow shelf areas.

[@qman8816]

Not similar other than both are ice age stories. The tilt of the crust and its resulting rebound were due to the weight of the ice above. The ocean's were approx 400ft below what they are today when all that water was stored on top of Canada etc. When the ice melted, slowly or rapidly, the water filled up the oceans to near what they are today. Lots of evidence this happened very fast, but still not generally accepted.

[@shawnpepin7890]

I camp on manitolin Island regularly, and yes, the big water can be crazy scary sometimes

[@nikeprojock]

we needed this because no one ever talks about these lakes

[@PhilipCockram]

The presence of continuous and well-defined northeast-trending lineations that cut across both the Charity Shoal Crater and adjacent bedrock indicates that this landform has been significantly eroded by glacial processes and predates the last glacial advance of the Laurentide Ice Sheet. As the existing research indicates that the rim of this crater is draped by layers of Middle Ordovician limestone, the Charity Shoal Crater must be at least as old as the Middle Ordovician.

[@emmahardesty4330]

This was rather spell-binding. Just great. Thank you

[@leelandglover7777]

Glacier's are lakes melting... glaciers carved the bottom of lakes cutting into the rock's learned this in middle school in 1987.

[@murphyjulian7393]

Michigan was under a lot of ice

[@ronjon7942]

@@murphyjulian7393heh, yep. Not underwater either, last time I checked.

[@2msvalkyrie529]

Not everyone has your genius level IQ...?

[@IllyrianPrinces00]

Crazy. I love Michigan. The lakes are stunning. Although Lake St Clair is very polluted. Huron is as well. Lake michigan is ASTONISHING! Looks like the ocean. Superior is very ridged. It scares me.

[@marshferguson4737]

Ontario is a giant crater from the Sudbury impact a billion years ago. That's how all the nickel and copper got here.

[@dianne11ca]

This was fascinating to watch, and I learned much. I heard years ago that Nova Scotia was created by uplift from the glacier coving the mainland to the west and has slowly been sinking since the ice retreat. I live in NS and we are sinking by about an inch per year. Our planet is ever-evolving, changing, being shaped by natural forces. People have been here for only a blink of an eye in the grand scale of time Earth has existed. We are unlocking age-old mysteries, adding to our knowledge base, which is truly gratifying. God bless, and thanks for this video.

[@LegendCampbell]

Love how hard he pushed on the "dirty ice" compared to letting the smooth ice just side, even with that barley tore the tin foil! It took so long into the video to get to glacier when we all knew that already! 🤦

[@TheTenof12]

EXCELLENT - really informative. Thank you, Spark

[@JakobLogan]

So much of the editing in this is overproduced and frenetic that Im not even interested in finishing.

[@legitbeans9078]

Yep. Im actually interested in this topic but i hate when the editing is this bad

[@icosthop9998]

I'm not usually into these kind of documentaries, but they kept it interesting. 👌 🧐 📚📚📚

[@icosthop9998]

Thank You 👍

[@bugsea54]

I live in Michigan eastern side and just love it.

[@sgrenis]

As a resident of Toronto I do appreciate the magnificent variety of landscape I live near. Many are leaving Canada not because we don't love this land! I wonder what Graham Hancock's take is on the Great Lakes. It wasn't really covered on Ancient Apocalypse(Netflix). The time line fits though.

[@leeadickes7235]

Just say turbidity, the guy measuring the cloudy water is measuring turbidity.

[@live_wire14]

I live 9 miles off the coast of Lake Michigan in Northern Illinois . The weather that we get from the Lakefront affects is astounding.

[@A_Bone1972]

"the perfect crime, the ice bullet", he said. i can think of 1 better, the air bullet ✌️🐝➕

[@2msvalkyrie529]

You read too.much Agatha Christie...!! 😂

[@willpowell6487]

Answers many questions. Thank you for putting this on KZbin.

[@bryandepaepe5984]

I live at the mouth of the St. Clair river and the water levels did lower by almost a foot almost 10 years ago but have come back up to normal if not a little higher. One big change is the ice, the river used to freeze solid every year without fail. The first year it didn't was winter 91/92 with mostly heavy pack ice flowing by and every since the pack ice has become thinner and more sparse often seeing the water between the ice. This year there was practically no ice, a couple of days of thin ice that formed along Lake Huron shorelines was about it.

[@NorthernMike]

Biggest freshwater delta on the planet

[@timstorey7915]

Right and the ice cover prevents evaporation or slows it down. I live in Macomb by the way and go fishing on Lake St Clair every summer. This year even the UP didn’t get much snow. My concern is the lake levels may drop as the climate gets warmer.

[@thomaskirchoff2027]

Global warming just a china hoax. Ask any republican😊

[@dannydaw59]

Didn't the ice damage the shoreline 2 or 3 years ago around Marine City? The ice got stuck or something. The ferries to Canada couldn't cross.

[@thecynic9232]

I live in Hamilton, Ontario in the shadow of the Niagara Escarpment. We have a lower city and an upper city. Escarpment is roughly 250’ high. When we were kids we used to collect tiny fossils from the gravel in driveways.

[@canag0d]

@21:00 I’m sorry but how could a professor from Brock University (a university 20 minutes away)… A geological professor… ONLY have gotten this close to The Falls for this documentary? Such hyperbole in this “professionally” created documentary. It’s so annoying. *For context I live in Niagara Falls and can tell you 100% this was not his first trip to The Falls.

[@Momcat_maggiefelinefan]

I grew up in Northern Ontario. We used to hike to and explore a huge outcropping of the Canadian Shield that was scored with grooves like the images here. Glacier dragging along boulders had to be the culprit. Told my geography teacher, who checked it out himself and agreed with my conclusion. Tonnes of glacial ice sculpted many of the strange formations we find in Ontario. A friend and I found a perfectly round hole about 10 feet deep with a smooth boulder at the bottom. Glaciation again, but too young to have a camera with us to record our find. Amazing ancient formations found by hiking teens in the Boreal Forest! 🇨🇦🖖🏻🇨🇦

[@brianarnold8666]

7:21 dude lightly dragged the clean ice but pushed down on the dirty ice

[@chriskellenmurphy]

😂

[@GsoNice]

The great lakes are worth more than all the gold in the world.

[@matdyke5046]

The rising of the western lakes, aside from ice compression, could possibly be a result of magmatic activity under yellowstone. Its far away, but all solids are elastic to a degree and the energy driving that rise could strech that far.

[@douglydooright4580]

Wait until Yellowstone decides to blow its cork again. Last time, probably had 2 miles worth of ice on top of it. Would have made for a nice little flood, eh…

[@ronjon7942]

I think you’d see more evidence for uplift between here (Lake MI) and Yellowstone as well for such a direct link. The lake basin uplift is measurable and well supported with consistent theories. Besides, the Yellowstone Caldera is actually sinking, not uplifting. But…magma plumes simply have to be enormous, so maybe? Maybe there’s some magma plume wacamole goin’ on! :)

[@michiganman8383]

That's scary lol.

[@heatherkuhn6559]

@@ronjon7942 The Yellowstone Caldera sinking may result in a compensatory rise elsewhere (albeit I would think, somewhat nearby). That certainly seems to be the case with the Hawaiian Islands. The Big Island is sinking under the weight of magma rising up through Kilauea while Haleakala on Maui experiences a compensatory rise.

[@thomashillmer429]

When I was an under graduate student at the University of Wisconsin -Parkside I under took a project to determine if the large depression ( mile wide or so) near Baraboo was caused by a meteor impact. Was unable to find the minerals to prove that. But interesting it mentioned meteor material in show being found in the Great Lakes.

[@TDurden527]

Little tazz jumping up saying "I know, I know." Looking around the class and everyone is screwing around, slowly withdraws hand.

[@lassesrensen300]

You feel overlooked my guy ?

[@Jenny2dicks]

Lmoaooo this my state. Hooolllyyy. Shiiiitttt. I’m here arf arf doin it now.

[@euromaestro]

It’s a great video. Has Spark not heard of the metric system?

[@kissthesky40]

F the metric system.

[@kellyarnett4062]

The early lakes were salt water. We mine salt below the lakes and rock layer covering it.

[@Helmuesi911]

Correct.. under Lake Huron are massive salt mines.

[@FeliciaMay13]

This was quite interesting. Thank you for supplying this video!

[@benjaminnevins5211]

Oh wait, we forgot when the Army Core of Engineers decided to dredge it... RIP great lakes

[@rjaquaponics9266]

lol