The NDTV Dialogues: Spirituality in modern India

On The NDTV Dialogues our focus is spirituality in modern India, focus at a time when the world is gearing up to celebrate International Yoga Day, a sense of pride in ancient Indian tradition but not without accompanying controversy with some political parties saying this is all about propagating ideology. We however expand the dialogue beyond this. We look at why spirituality is trending like never before. Where does the line end between spirituality and religion? Joining us on this, Javed Akhtar, poet, writer and an atheist; Amish Tripathi, bestselling author of 'The Shiva Trilogy'; Nivedita Joshi, Yoga practitioner; Dr Purushottam Agrawal, former JNU professor; and spiritual leader and founder of Isha foundation Sadghuru Jaggi Vasudev.
Watch full show: www.ndtv.com/video/player/the-...

[@n.p.9997]

Javed sahab is the most logical person that I've ever come across.

[@kartikmudaliar4336]

But when it comes to muslims, he becomes a jihadi.

[@nilakshguleria2449]

True

[@kartikmudaliar4336]

@@nilakshguleria2449 When it comes to islam, he becomes a jihadi.

[@nitishgautam5728]

That intelligence is there because he has mastered language. If you do it , you will have in-depth knowlege of words , you would have clarity in mind , and you will find most people have very shallow level of thinking

[@husainahammed5161]

I remember history the geographical name is Sindhu not hindhu

[@greatramu86]

this anchor is much better than other NDTV anchors

[@coderoad3581]

Sadhguru is a true conman. Javed is the man of logic.

[@trinity396]

Everybody is genius untill jaggi starts to speak. Pranam sadhguru..

[@rishikesh4]

Pseudoscience...!

[@dawnfm00]

more like haggi

[@aadiyogi9031]

Well said.. Akhtar need deep meditation and then he should come in any debate.

[@gurdialsingh9863]

@@aadiyogi9031 meditation 🤣🤣

[@chinzzz388]

Once jaggi starts speaking, logic, science and rationality leave the chat

[@SaiShyamKolachalama]

Haha.. That last punch line from Sadguru: "It's just like calling gravity Jewish!!" Epic!!

[@nishikantmane]

Sai Shyam Kolachalama why it is jewish ? Newton was not a jew, that was the most stupid line.

[@vasanthra9862]

***** Make sure you know about what's being discussed before calling someone talking on that as stupid and making an idiot out of yourself in the process. The recent and more accurate notion of gravity is derived from Einstein's General Theory Of Relativity and Einstein was a Jew.

[@nishikantmane]

Vasanth Ra Sirji Einstein was an atheist, although born as jew.

[@adityanaithani21]

***** newton discovered gravity!!

[@nishikantmane]

aditya naithani read my comment above and trail of comments then offer yours

[@mohitdirect]

It is always a treat to watch and listen to some of the enlightened minds of this country. I wish more Indians could watch this video and maybe learn something.

[@kabitabhaumik5829]

We should leave closed minded non intellectuals out of such discussions to get the fervour of it.

[@kabitabhaumik5829]

Here comes the communal secular. Bye.

[@kunaltipre2619]

no one is enlightened

[@firstal3799]

None of them isn't enlightened. If you think this and are more than 12 years, I pity you.

[@nocapfacts9330]

Religion acts like the know everything Science tells that they don't know all yet and still finding answers.

[@khagenbudo398]

Many people's get enlightenment by following religion. Enlightenment is the biggest achievement in life & religion is about reaching enlightenment.

[@acharya8959]

Science says god doesn't it. And at the same time says it doesn't know everything. That's hypocrisy of the finest

[@SocialCry]

@@acharya8959 "First learn the definition of Science. Science works on evidence and existence of a structure. How can you analyse something that doesn't exist?*

[@adwaitab.3622]

@@khagenbudo398 you can get enlightenment by science and rationality as well. There were lot of great scientists across the world who are enlightened as well.

[@bineshbhaskar6987]

@@adwaitab.3622 true

[@mamathachinmai9249]

When she addressed Sadhguru as, "our special guest",javed aktar would be burning 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@user-dg8zk3gp7g]

really

[@sanjayadaki9198]

throughout the video i was just waiting for sadguru

[@pitamberpatail4686]

Me to

[@naeemkhan7984]

Haha same bro. I listen but in the middle of the video, i skip and there is sadhguru... Soo sonaar ki aik lohaar ki. Love u sadhguru

[@achintyapal1981]

Me too

[@tarunmedi]

This guru says something and does something else..

[@ushasarma4389]

achintya pal .

[@nidhinhs9778]

Sadguru uplifted the standard of the talk

[@mohinderjitaujla6245]

Nidhin HS …My Bhai ,you are right … The Baani of Nanak, Kabir , Ravidas and Bhagat Naam Dev Ji support his Parvachan. JS AUJLA. USA

[@AtulVhale]

Anybody who is educated and religious is a sick person. He hit the nail on its head. Loved it 😀

[@nilakshguleria2449]

😂yeah ...me too

[@adamjani6778]

No 👎👎 it's people who doesn't follow religion religious people supposed to be clear from all errors but unfortunately 99% religious persons doesn't follow religion

[@chalopadhobe7101]

Last line was epic😂😂. Respect🙏🙏

[@charnjitsingh3365]

Haha

[@kunalk2233]

Javed Akhtar claiming to be Atheist and Still supporting Muslims who ganist OM..WOW.. Well done indian secularism.

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

kunal kashyap very true

[@akshayrathore2882]

Om is form of religious symbolism. nothing more

[@SocialCry]

I didn't find him supporting any religion. Give reference to your argument.

[@Zeus-7778]

Where did he support 😂?

[@akscs373]

he never supported, he bashed hirani, owaisi many times

[@jaydevshingala]

How nicely "Hindu" word explained by sadguruji! Hope peoples of India will learn many things from him!

[@saurabh2372]

सद्गुरु बहुत chutiya

[@jaydevshingala]

@@saurabh2372 Whatever we learn and apply on self is what defines us! May be you've learned this way!

[@ssamarr5970]

@@saurabh2372 Hawa hawai kitab ko padhne aur sunne balo ko jitne bhi achi aur gyanki bate karne bale chutiya hi lagenge, Isme tumhara ghata kisika kuch nahi jata. Apni chutiya paan apni andar rakho bahar gandagi maat phelao 1400 saal se bahat phela chuke ho.

[@piyushsikka12]

@@ssamarr5970 Watching videos might not anyone spiritual. It will just show the door. You will have to start a spiritual yogic practice like hatha yoga or kriya yoga to move further in life in spirituality.

[@saurabhbatheja]

@@saurabh2372 bhai I agree with you, Sadhguru is a wrong number, and forming an army of chutiyas. Btw, being an Indian, why is he trying to talk in an American accent? Its hilarious that people still follow him :)

[@HarshSingh-gy4xq]

why does javed akhtar behave like a 7yr old in these debates

[@spicyindian381]

In every debate

[@nikitasharma9708]

he is always angry and extremely judgmental. After all he is an Islamic atheist lol thoda asar to reh jaega

[@tuhinabhattacharya6358]

Sourav Jha very true..in every debate he,as if,tries to say 'im an "intellectual "n im right,just agree accept n 'applaud' thts it,end of discussion..

[@Soniarajpoot006]

I was searching this comment only 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 isne sunne ki himmat hi nhi hai.gaand mei aag lag jati hai iski

[@Rakesh.choudhary0]

I find him logical

[@avisupergaming3074]

Javed akhtar why u consider urself atheist when u are muslim deep inside

[@manroopaf2295]

He's a mole

[@seeker.abdullah]

You couldn't understand his verbose. There is no sign of Religion in his comments. He might be just lost.

[@avisupergaming3074]

@@seeker.abdullah his bias against hindu culture is clearly visible and he is just muslim apologist

[@siddharth__vst]

When a Muslim is on the way to became extremists he shows himself as an atheist to rest of the world.

[@rajeshkhilari]

Sadguru Jaggi Vasudeo always leaves a listener (seeker) spell bound. _/\_

[@smarajitsengupta8168]

Javed Akhtarji is more realistic than sadguruji

[@sandipansengupta9519]

Answered like a true Bengali

[@VSM101]

nah hes a secular fundamentalist

[@skumar093728]

hehe....u got it right...and the irony is that they call themselves liberals

[@sabinlamichhane5143]

It is because He tell, see and is a truth.

[@vamsipandranki]

indian classical languages are tamil,telugu,kannada,malayalam and sanskrit

[@prashanthcm3333]

vamsi pandranki true

[@sangamkumar9912]

And Odia

[@JaskiM9]

What about Tulu and coorgi?

[@rockysingh5563]

only Sanskrit

[@maheshkalkote6645]

Sanskrit :- the mother of all Indian and perhaps some foreign languages.

[@anoopsikchi1]

Javed : I know everything (i have fixed belief in what i say) Sadhguru : I don't know anything, so i will listen and As you know everything you will definitely argue

[@anuragate9282]

Actually it's the other way around. Religious people claim to know every thing right from the start of the universe to the afterlife and it is science who teaches us to dig deeper.

[@444Chandu]

@@anuragate9282 from your comment, I got it as the people who spoke in video are religious and who stayed quiet are not.

[@susamaybhattacharjee8090]

If u carefully notice the entire part of Javed sir,u ll observe that Javed sir's voice and speech throwing is exactly same as Virus of 3idiots movie

[@chetanpatil826]

🤣🤣🤣

[@shubhankarbanerjee1646]

😂😂😂

[@tenzin321t]

🤣🤣🤣

[@palamol]

amish tripathi is awesome speaker , his vocab is rich ....

[@indianmilitary]

+amol palkar "vocabulary" is rich. mehh. English is a flawed and stupid language despite borrowing most of its words from other languages including sanskrit. It does not even have a gender neutral word which contradicts its own grammar. Most of the english words sound the same. eg where is fore-head? well, here it is 1, 2, 3, 4 lol. Blindly aping our white master's flawed language does not make us good speakers. What matters is the content of the speech. Amish trpathi's content is half baked and pathetic

[@charnjitsingh3365]

​@@indianmilitaryaha!

[@greenfield8602]

I was watching for sadguru ji

[@sharadhvyas]

Same here. Who wants to listen to pseudo intellectual.

[@lovekumargupta8851]

You believe in sadguru, love sadguru or something else. You said you came here for sadguru that means you are blind believer like all others

[@lovekumargupta8851]

@anonacc for you

[@lovekumargupta8851]

@anonacc no

[@Alokitam]

Of course bro

[@MukilShelby]

Javed Akthar is a man of reason & Sad guru is man of words. Period.

[@ankurkaushik7190]

Precisely.

[@jellalfernandes1309]

Correct👍

[@charnjitsingh3365]

Yea he knows a way with words

[@A-da-mant]

Certainty is a quality of an ignorant person

[@ashokesingh7682]

In 2019 most of us know javed is a hypocrite of the highest order and this geezer gets deservedly trolled every now and then on Twitter.

[@jsr1827]

I think they should all shut their mouths up and listen to Sadhguru for half an hour. He is very sensible.

[@Fekutogyo]

First you please tell me Who gives you a right to saying anybody to shut their mouth ??? This type of sensibilitys you take when you listen sadhguru ????

[@rachitsingh2420]

Sadhguru just blabber bullshit just my opinion

[@BharathKumar-tr6th]

People like you deserve to be swindled by charlatan like sadhguru.

[@rachitsingh2420]

@@BharathKumar-tr6th good english

[@amitkumargupta5346]

@Rayan kuchh Arabi yha aa gye, aur is subcontinent ki original identity ko destroy krne lge. Isiliye yha k logon ko apni identity bachaaye rkhne k liye khud ko Hindu kahna pda.

[@bujgavna]

It's shows how much knowledge has Javed about India. Why we are giving him importance.?

[@akankshashrivastava6679]

Sadhguru's part : 18:00

[@insanedeadeyedkart7522]

Thanks

[@Lifeofcricket390]

Thanks

[@adi6526]

Javed's part is equally important. .he sounds arrogant though

[@kapilsanadya9372]

I love you👁💌u batane ke liye 😜

[@AnandRaj-pq4wu]

Thanks

[@meggamanfarstrider9998]

Sadhguruji change my life the way I look around . I love you sadhguruji.

[@argumentativeindian8638]

Would have liked to hear more from Sadhguru. Most sensible person..

[@TheWorldTeacher]

I certainly cannot argue with that ;) F.I.S.H Paragraph 6. God has given and continues to give His/Her perfect and pure teachings through His/Her messengers, known as priests. There are literally hundreds of thousands of individuals in this world who claim to be religious leaders/teachers of some kind. However, a true pastor/priest/minister/rabbi/guru/ mullah/spiritual master (call him what you will) is extremely rare. Out of a billion people there may be one or two true prophets (spokesmen) for the God of all gods. The most heinous action possible is to persecute a member of the Holy Priesthood. Thus, murdering billions of non-priests is less sinful than even slandering one of God’s holy prophets, let alone putting him to death. Only a saintly person can find the truth and logic in such a statement. On occasion, God gives specific messages via chosen individuals, whether they are priests or not. However, such messages are usually intended to be spoken to an individual or group of individuals with specific (and normally temporal) repercussions for those individuals in question. Such “prophets” can never ever replace a man who has evolved over millions of lifetimes to be a fully enlightened saintly prophet, appointed to teach Truth to humanity. To read the remaining thirty-nine paragraphs of “A Final Instruction Sheet for Humanity”, which the God of all gods has graciously given to His Prophet on Earth, email: [e-mail] with the acronym “FISH” in the subject field.

[@TheWorldTeacher]

Arjun P Your name reminds me of one of the characters from "The Mahabharata". It's a pity you have NOTHING WHATSOEVER in common with that particular Arjuna Pandava. Incidentally, presumptuous, disrespectful SINNER, you could do with a lesson or two in English grammar insolent fool.

[@TheWorldTeacher]

Arjun P I regret to inform you, SINFUL slave, that your response is incorrect. The correct response is: "Yes, MASTER".

[@TheWorldTeacher]

Arjun P Kindly inform me once your premenstrual affliction has subsided Mrs. Arjuna.

[@TheWorldTeacher]

Arjun P Just give it a few more days Madam....

[@dharmendraparmar930]

why you have cut sadhguru speech ?

[@vaishnavi.21381]

Giving a like only for sadhguru...love you sir

[@rajatchauhan2929]

Ab kya kehenga chahenge aap tweet k baad

[@alakhniranjan1799]

It should end like - "It is just like calling Javed Akhtar an atheist chutiya..!"

[@vip129870]

He's an atheist who has a soft spot for Islamic Supremacists.

[@trignal]

@@vip129870 And you're a nincompoop who got nothing out of this great discussion. BuhBye.

[@rahulupdhy]

Wah re ganwaar 👏🏻👏🏻 senseless

[@rahulupdhy]

@madhusudan Bangalore 😂🤣🤣🤦🏻‍♂️

[@trignal]

@madhusudan Bangalore A little something called the constitution might get in the way. Perhaps you'd prefer to live in China or Russia. India is still a secular democracy. But with people like you maybe not for too long. Enjoy.

[@shudhanshushekhars6846]

Hearing javed sir for the first time and oh man does he resemble Viru shahastra buddhe aka Virus from 3 Idiots :D

[@sayansinha6446]

😁😁😂😂

[@pavan04n55]

😂😂

[@rahulupdhy]

Sidaa sidaa bolna bouncer gaya bole wala 😂😂🤦🏻‍♂️

[@mayankkr2192]

😂😂😂😂👍

[@tuhinabhattacharya6358]

Sudhanshu Shekhar Singh...;hahahaha true

[@rashmisrivastva4315]

Sadhguru ji your are the best 🙏🕉🙏

[@terrorist6928]

@gypsy lab 😂

[@terrorist6928]

@gypsy lab 🍷🍾

[@terrorist6928]

@gypsy lab shuruat tune ki naa Abhi Kha gaali

[@insanedeadeyedkart7522]

@gypsy lab 🌽

[@arefinhoosain654]

If it's so why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik? Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event? It shows his weakness.

[@nitishpathak4564]

Oh Man!!! What a great person this satguru is. No one can prove himself an intellectual till the time he is on the chair...

[@kal-el4746]

Sadhguru get enlightened when he was 25 years old

[@michaeljosephjackson2364]

@@kal-el4746 enlightenment doesn't exist

[@kal-el4746]

@@michaeljosephjackson2364 Scientists experimented on sadhguru and they found sadhguru's brain dead scientists said sadhguru is dead bcos his brain is not working I am from India and in India thousands of people born like gautam budha

[@michaeljosephjackson2364]

@@kal-el4746 but that's not enlightenment

[@kal-el4746]

@@michaeljosephjackson2364 I am a seeker Yogic science means aligning your physical geometry to cosmic geometry. As a seeker I am doing yoga since 7-8year age and I know the possibilities bcos I had experienced many things that today's science can't explain actually we both should not decide it is enlightenment or not until it came to our experience

[@divyanshsharma6458]

This type of people jealous of sadhguru's success because he got international recognition for spirituality,social work, spreading yoga and university like MIT,Oxford, Harvard,all IIMs,IITs and other scientists of world considers sadhguru as GENIUS And he glorifies INDIA before world .... people like javed who have read 2 or 3 books and consider themselves as genius are chutiya

[@Stonedpeep]

sadhguru used to sell weed in Tamilnadu he's actually arrested..for selling it

[@boonslang6689]

but Sadguru chutiya tha hai aur rhega.

[@ashutoshtrivedi918]

@@boonslang6689 tm jhand the aur wahi rahoge

[@boonslang6689]

@@ashutoshtrivedi918 aaina dekhe ho kya. 😂😂

[@unitedbeast6614]

Right bro. What has Javed done for the social?? Just blabbering

[@aryamahima3]

nd dnt forget..pakistan did this silly mistake...they tried to throw out ancient indian culture from their religion and you can see the result. love for sadhuru..

[@libinlink]

+Mahima Arya and rest of the world doesn't exist at all just cuz they din't have ancient Indian culture

[@Saurabh312Pandey]

+Libin Lazar If possible pls read Swami Vivekananda on ur comment / question, provided, u r not this much biased to just reject the referred name by its face value.

[@ratanmali9600]

@Nilesh Sharma replace it .😂

[@atheistsinceborn4903]

@@libinlink chutiye its about sabotaging the original culture. You have any idea how identity crisis hit pakistan? They rejected the languages and adopted so called muslim language.they rejected food and tried to reject everything indian in search of identity.

[@shivthesnakeeyes]

First Javed Akhtar should learn to talk without spitting all over the place :p

[@celebratingilluzion4926]

hahaha

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

shiva narayan very true. someone said he is a snake with two mouth.

[@AryaInk]

+Shiva Narayan lol

[@greatramu86]

+Shiva Narayan lololol

[@nuaso7143]

+Ambalika Datta Roy actually human beings are more dangerous than snakes ! do not blame another creature for no reason ! hygiene !

[@blessedone2002]

Calling gravity Jewish Sadguru : savage 🤣😂

[@pradeepkumar-xp7ff]

Educated person with religious belief a sick person - Javed sir superb words

[@tusharshengule8298]

Then why he is always present on the stage of radical Islam. ? While discussion ,he showed himself secularism. But never except the greatness of other religion. While discussion, he is secular but back stage, he always with radical Islam. Javed you already fool and stupid person, one who don't want upgrade himself as living with such spiritual person because of religious mentality. 3rd class mentality.

[@victorbptst7896]

I see that France is not the only country with issues with religions and their differences ;-) Still you indians seem to have more intelligent people than us to discuss about it. Frankly all of them were very interesting and talked very well. PS : this yogi, Sadhguru was particularly brilliant...

[@varunkumardtsfi]

Ad-Zhafas Thank you

[@MrRightThinker]

Jaggi is bogus. He always gives Mugged Answers.

[@adityachouhan1937]

@@MrRightThinker and yes which only some real right thinkers can understand

[@adityachouhan1937]

Just see more videos of sadguru and feel calmness,happiness and beauty of his mind you will surely be a fan I promise ad zhafas

[@prashantbharti6077]

Mr.Right Thinker , It is a request to deep your thoughts.

[@anshumanthakur7101]

Just simply described the sadhguru one word--- WOW☺☺

[@presunjittripura3795]

He fraud business men

[@acharya8959]

@@presunjittripura3795 like your

[@arefinhoosain654]

If it's so why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik? Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event? It shows his weakness.

[@rajeevSreenivasan]

“Educated person with religious belief a sick person”, Javed Akthar, I like that.

[@charnjitsingh3365]

He always has only one thing to say

[@eternallyseeking2666]

Why can't we have a conversation between Sadhguru and Amish Tripathi? Amish is someone who brought back my interest into Bharat and her culture( maybe it's mythological fiction, yet);his works are just amazing! And Sadhguru, I don't simply have words to describe my emotions towards him...Fills me up with tears of gratitude 🙏

[@0000Neil]

They already have a conversation together, an hour long

[@shaktishivanand]

20:00 minute What is #Hindu ? Sadhguru U defined well the meaning of #HINDU properly Thank You Sadhguru

[@mohandaspisharody5079]

Why does NDTV is inviting people to speak about spirituality who does not know even any basics in spirituality.

[@VV-lq4di]

Mohandas Pisharody so you don’t want skeptics to be invited just yes men. Ok

[@ajanthamusicgadag2435]

Mohandas Pisharody modi n RSS want who don't disagree

[@VV-lq4di]

Mohandas Pisharody Spirituality does not have one definition. One persons definition of spirituality may not agree with another’s. Clearly, since you think your version of spirituality is the only one that is valid, you have shown beyond doubt you have no clue what spirituality represents or is.

[@deepaksagekar8847]

we should ban NDTV in india

[@therightway8960]

Very very truely pointed out. They always very smartly conduct there agenda. Once they put Amitabh bachchan asking sadhguru on rally for rivers

[@kritigautam6374]

"Comfort with different truths is the basis of liberalism" - best line

[@metalfootsoldier699]

@kritigautam6374 I'll have to think about this line for the rest of the year to completely understand it.

[@Muwahid999]

​@@metalfootsoldier699😂

[@aak6067]

The great spiritual values have made man a unique creature in the Universe, with nobody else like him.

[@arunmallah8054]

At the end the hero , comes

[@adityasengupta4416]

😇😌🙏🙏🙏

[@onemanarmy1422]

Varun dhawan jaisa 🤣😂😂

[@saikiranmamidishetty7253]

Yes

[@parnamsaini4751]

Arun...really?

[@vinaytanwar7840]

What i liked is how the debate go ... No fighting or just anything...

[@hyd916]

YEAH, THE DEBATE IS CARRIED IN A VERY CIVIL MATTER WITHOUT SHOUTING N INTEREFERRING. THAT SHOULD BE FOR THE REST OF ENCHORS. SHE IS A VERY CLASSY LADY.

[@mrinal8169]

4:34 Tamil, Sanskrit are Indian Classical languages not Persian and Arabic. This Javed should study a bit of history

[@mohammadafnan8741]

haha, son you just keep on googling. 11:06 check this son

[@patrickdevin1344]

Tamil,, sanskrit...🙏🙏🙏

[@lamoded7926]

yes Persian and Arabic are foreign languages

[@lamoded7926]

@TJ is that a fact? Or speculation

[@lamoded7926]

@TJ no the language part

[@sandeepsaini7945]

First 18 minutes of this video were really difficult to bear with 🤣🤣🤣

[@satpalkaushik8192]

Exactly brother 😂😂😂

[@nishantjaikari2484]

When u only find one intellectual in the panel of different intellectual in different field.....that's what andhbhakt is.😜

[@sandeepsaini7945]

@@nishantjaikari2484 Yes you are absolutely right. And now your sole concern must be - the numbers of Andhbhakt (as you said) are immensely growing day in day out. Apply for a visa to heaven. Because it's not gonna stop 😉😉😉😂

[@nishantjaikari2484]

@@sandeepsaini7945 growing in your dream brother they are decreasing.... Look at the BJP alliances they left for a reason...you will acknowledge in elections..

[@nishantjaikari2484]

@@sandeepsaini7945 very nice of u to make it a political debate insted of sadguru ..😂that's how bhakti works

[@mahadevbhardwaj8334]

Sadguru is great and a true Leader who can take humans on right path with peace, prosperity and happiness for all.

[@Fekutogyo]

What is the right path ? And who decided that ?

[@saveforestanimal2490]

@@Fekutogyo how he define the meaning of hindu...just imagine the truth of land not a single person..

[@Fekutogyo]

@Sanjay Vidwan we all need to study what is right and what is wrong in particular country according to there country law book. because one thing is right in any country may be is worng to another country according to there country law.

[@Fekutogyo]

@Sanjay Vidwan Buddha attained enlightenment, mahaveer attained enlightenment. without help of any guru aur sadguru. we can also ..

[@Fekutogyo]

@Sanjay Vidwan only fools people follow other people . and you doing same thing.

[@shyamranjith6562]

this javed aktar always says himself as atheist..but no where he behaves as atheist..he only uses his athiest line jsut to blame hinduism....he use atheist as shield to cover his anti hindu activities...youi cant find him blaming owasis or malda incident or azad maidan incident..but he jumpp to dadri to hyderabad ..

[@Manojyadav-dz4vs]

+shyam ranjith gooooood catch

[@evaamas7801]

+shyam ranjith so true

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

Very true

[@2002drkrish]

+shyam ranjith . Exactly Ranjit. I just scrolled down to write the same and I found your comment. These pseudo seculars are coming in all sorts of disguises. Some as atheists, some as eminent writers, social workers etc. to convince confused lot of the people.

[@khurmiful]

Then you need research your material harder, mate. If you think he is only having a dig at Hinduism.

[@rengabashyam8015]

Amish Tripathi is underrated

[@roger733]

My son

[@rajputchander6089]

utill the bearded person start speaking evryone is a genius

[@mecaranger1592]

Zakir Nail has entered the chat...

[@siralfrednobel]

Yaggi took the name sadhguru and then calling he is not any kind of guru but yogi.ha ha ha

[@parnamsaini4751]

Rajput...really?

[@arp1869]

@@siralfrednobel zakir naik ke pille

[@arp1869]

@@parnamsaini4751 bro love jihad samjha karo

[@abhibatra2009]

Sadhguru Jaggi was most interesting but stupid NDTV cut it short

[@electraravi]

They didn't cut it short.. The link for full video is given... You are not a seeker dude.. Learned nothing from your guru's bhashan?

[@shreyzone]

Ravi Shankar Singh : Probably you didn't follow the link. Sadguru's interview, what you call "BHASHAN" has been cut short. It seems you are not a seeker yourself.

[@anuragpol]

Ravi Shankar Singh Seems you are a true believer...but you dont know how NDTV works...i have been to many shows, they do have the full video on tubaah, but i am quite sure they have edited sadhguru's part by at least half, they only telecast what they actually want to show..viz anti hindu/bjp/rss views

[@motorcycleonmoon]

Sadhguru lol he is just selling his bullshit to you ha ha. These are the people who keep humanity blind.

[@khamardhaval]

+Arunsundar M thanks mate

[@youtubeanswers2458]

javed uncle hair reminds me of ancient greek statues!

[@JAIPALSINGH-wc9qh]

ohh man i laughed so hard

[@milandorjee5140]

😀

[@prayaasacademy5245]

Javed Akhter is a scholar person no doubt

[@johnnysharp6210]

With all due respect javedji pls restrict your knowledge to lyrics only

[@tuhinabhattacharya6358]

Hahahaha..very true

[@UmeshKumar-fw1ue]

Very true..he made very statement @17@38..

[@LastChance222]

hahahaahahah...so funny but true...maybe he should not write lyrics too..

[@sanyamsingla5961]

@@LastChance222 😂😂😂👌

[@soumyaranjanpradhan4864]

Ohh lolll god !!

[@tanujjaswal2085]

Very rightly said sadguru jee. ..

[@savnnaik606]

Javed sir we have so many people to correct Hinduism in India, you please correct your Islam.....

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

savn naik what a comment. salute u bhai.

[@savnnaik606]

Ambalika Datta Roy thx

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

very true. You can also say as everyone gives their views.

[@brajmohanjoshi9871]

Mast ak number

[@kushaq1173]

Nope he won't.he don't have courage and he hates Hinduism.

[@shiningstar4874]

*Javed G is trying to prove himself as an intellectual and he is unhapy that Persi is not included in Indian Constitution*

[@liberandudeshdrohi5277]

He is always unhappy on Hindus because they are mostly successful and peaceful

[@jaishreeraavan5080]

Does the G in Javed G stand for gandu?

[@subhanhasan990tsikfm]

@@jaishreeraavan5080 ah yes bhakts, always very classy

[@jaishreeraavan5080]

@@subhanhasan990tsikfm thanks mate.

[@pritambanerjee1377]

But Urdu is already included in Indian Constitution..Bruh!

[@rajgupta-mm5fl]

Who came here only for sadhguru???🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@subm2455]

Everybody.

[@kaianderson5871]

ur muo

[@jibran4794]

I came here for Javed Akhtar. It's always refreshing to hear him.

[@arefinhoosain654]

Why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik? Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event? It shows his weakness.

[@astroboy09]

I came here for Sadhguru to be grind by Javed ji with logical arguments

[@Pikachu-mf3vf]

My Sadhguru ❤️🌺 🌺.. he is so cute !! 🙏

[@armstrong2450]

He's not Santa lol

[@jasminbaalss6438]

Everybody had interesting points of view and Sadhguru he spoke from his personal experiences and not some bookish knowledge. Pity, that the video is not till the end and missed what more wisdom Sadhguru had shared.

[@avantikanatasha]

Sad guru is really sad 😂

[@chinmoydas764]

Javed Akhtar doesn't know when to stop talking... Always interupting others

[@ssamarr5970]

Empty vessels sounds much. That is the difference between Javed and Sadguru. One does have any idea about what is spirituality and hindu means and speaks over, it seems his idiot attitude.

[@basantgyawali131]

Chinmoy das ..Javed's such attitude is due to alcohol, it destroys your rational thinking and makes you patience less

[@debabratadeb2244]

first tell me bhai ...do you have any religious believe then u r a seek person ,,,according to the great atheist doctor javed kumar ....

[@nexmindspace7]

Everyone is Gangster until Sadguru come 🤘

[@abhaysharma3374]

Just look at the people who are discussing sipirituality , except Nivedita and Sadhguru ji i bet no other person knows a bit about yoga and medidation. This is intellectual terrorism when you superimpose your opinion on someone.

[@satishm5260]

Abhay Sharma bro u nailed it with that phrase "intellectual terrorism".

[@dipakshinde7802]

Bro amish tripathi was also good

[@AjSinRag]

It's about getting a different perspective from people who might have a difference of opinion. The show is called the dialogue which is just to strike a conversation that helps the viewer to engage the mind to think. That's how stimulation of brain works.

[@rudrax2148]

Intellectual terrorism 😂😂🙏🏼🤭

[@mypowerlevelisover9000]

I think that you don't know the meaning of terrorism It means to terrorise , to make people fear disagreement is not terrorism

[@Snappy27893]

Sadhguru saved us from people like Javed all around us.

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

very true.

[@pinksun1131]

LOL TRUE THAT ASSHOLE JAVED DOES not understand abc of hinduism or hindu philosophy.

[@ikahccbr]

your language tells me neither do you

[@satishsingh3556]

I agree 100%with Javed akhtar smart men , educated people who thinks region is good R sick specially the once that think that theirs is right

[@rajivjha123]

Brother ask Him about Islam and then you will get the answer . He is really dangerous as far as I know Him from several interviews . Thanks

[@gs282]

Sadguru ji is at different levels of intelligence that rest of panelist has never experienced.

[@lovekumargupta8851]

Ya and that different level is called dumb

[@lovekumargupta8851]

@Original Protestant its not i its all the humanity who support a god

[@rahulgaur3192]

And if you understand him that makes you as intelligent. So you are also a guru now.

[@gs282]

@@rahulgaur3192 tell me who one person who is not guru. You are also a guru. There would be something in you that I can learn from you.

[@Tulsithakurchannel]

Thats what he said.. lot difference between seeker n believer.. other on panel already assumed themselves they know everything like Javed😅

[@umeshpardeshi4472]

SADHGURU finished the confusion.

[@sdss315]

why is Javed carrying sooo frustrated face ............

[@sdss315]

ha hahhh

[@rammanohar666]

Satish Babu manufacturing defect

[@sunmersames]

Well observed !! Javed is behaving if Yoga is Abusing "Urdu" :) Sad so sad .........

[@gajendrar1898]

Satish Babu he has gastric plobem bro

[@shubhambali7297]

Constipation !

[@alakhniranjan1799]

Javed Akhtar is high on weeds..!

[@alakhniranjan1799]

@Jyotirmoy Mishra - Not just me. Go through comments and sounds like half the world knows that he should be high on weeds..!

[@gopibahugaming4114]

Kaom

[@Mnch-tn9rh]

Lets assume he's high on weed, what's wrong with that?

[@boonslang6689]

Sadguru ne bechi hongi. Jail gya tha a wo weed bechne k jurm me? Haha.

[@boonslang6689]

@Mayur Kanth hoshiyar atheist b jihadi. Gazab. 😑🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

[@rahullou3387]

Love how sadhguru clarifies many things.🙏

[@JohnDoe19991]

And what did he clarify ?

[@rahullou3387]

@@JohnDoe19991 just watch the video 10 thousand times, till you get it. When you haven't even tried, why are you even asking

[@JohnDoe19991]

@@rahullou3387 lol lazy comeback . I will also give you great esoteric style bullcrap "If you write a line of zeroes, it´s still nothing." I took it out of thin air just like Jaggi the murder suspect

[@dpak39977]

@@JohnDoe19991 the answer you got from the other person is the result of spiritual guru and his preaching... don't expect rationalism

[@rvind000]

@@dpak39977 Stop making assumptions mr./mrs. Rartionalist.

[@mushtaqphysicist8803]

Nice to see such educated glimpse of Civil Society of India. Keep it up

[@MikeMessiah]

Best part start from 16:40

[@savjivanipatil3481]

javed ke movke upar itana gobar bhara huva hii ki use kahibhi badabu dikhai deti hii,bolata hii me youga teacher hu,usaki bodylawange se pata chalata hii o kitana yougake bareme janta hii

[@savjivanipatil3481]

satguruka face or javedka face dekho,kitani sadgi hii sadguruje cheharepe,or javedka face shitan jesa dikhraha hii

[@tenzind4175]

Am here for Sadhguru ji....where is he ?? Pranam Guru ji 🙏🙏🙏

[@blossom7664]

@Siddharth Sriram yup

[@shubhankarbanerjee1646]

Same here.

[@anjalimorye8918]

Javed Akhtar doesn't deserve Om... He deserves only Mughal and Allah

[@trignal]

What does that even mean? Lol. Did you just throw some words together and hoped they made sense?

[@anjalimorye8918]

@@parramattaeels7928 first you do as you said..I think you have habit about the same

[@anjalimorye8918]

@comrade kritanu sharma Do you have any right to poke every where

[@parramattaeels7928]

Anjali Morye Angry anjali 😂

[@tanishqshivanand3376]

What are u speaking😂

[@shikharsinghsarang460]

18:01 Thank me later....😂😂

[@shobhanatomar5443]

Thanks

[@insanedeadeyedkart7522]

Thank you bro

[@Jassi-bg2ub]

thanks bhai 😂👍

[@RaushanKumar-xv7px]

Thanks bro 5 min lag gya dhundhne m fir soche comment mei dhundh lete hai

[@VinodKumar-mr8xs]

Thanks a lot bro.

[@anupampriyadarshi302]

why javed has become so important ??

[@vikramsaini5061]

Anupam Priyadarshi shi bola Bhai Sala chutiya h

[@anupampriyadarshi302]

:D

[@mgowtham5672]

Booz Stupid person in the group entertain the most

[@_sayan_roy_]

Didn't expect to agree with Javed on every single fucking point. Good debate.

[@avisupergaming3074]

sayan roy u must b agree with mamta didi also

[@indiamorningpost117]

Waited so long for Sadhguru!

[@UmeshKumar-ef4te]

Whenever Javed criticise Islamists he tries to demean Hinduism in the same breath.

[@adityasengupta4416]

@Shailendra Pandey sadhguru se takkar nhi le sakta wo mulla us kabil nhi hai

[@shibanitalukdar6462]

I m from a muslim majority village & when I was in LP school we had to sing some Islamic prayer I ddnt know the meaning. Since they force their religion on others they think hindu people want to force hinduism on them. A person can be hindu only by birth, there is no other way.the spirit of God reside in our soul which teaches us to love and live in peace. We blv whoever u r praying the one and only is getting that.For people following other religion thinks Allah, Krishna, Jesus all are different persons in heaven and their Allah is greatest and competing to make it true by making more follower of Allah by killing non followers and giving birth to more children by marrying more. They should know God is one and religion is only a way of praying God and living life.

[@aryamahima3]

There is a difference between religion and region, similarly between culture and custom. A region can have many religions but almost same culture. Yoga is a part of indian culture. Be it hindu or muslim.

[@madhukarlohe8088]

Yoga by Patanjali before 5000 years, no other religion on this earth. No question of religious with respect to yoga.

[@patrioticbritain8225]

One of the best comments I’ve read!!!!!!

[@Rahul_Singh100]

Muslims can't do Surya Namaskar yoga even if they are Indian. It will be sacrilegious for them.

[@Ronin-111]

​@@Rahul_Singh100 Are you that stupid there are a lot of Muslim who practice yoga 🤦‍♂️

[@rambhadala1288]

Anchor is spiritually hypnotized when introducing the participants. She call Jaggi Vasudev " Sadguru Jaggi Vasudev ji" and others with no respect when non of them less important than Jaggi Vasudev.

[@bernielee932]

I could watch or stare at Sadhguru in all his video and feel great, loving and learn from him but I could not even look at Javed Akhtar for a minute, he looks so fearful and I can feel anger and his fight for his rights , It's day and night between Sadhguru and Javed Akhtar,,, Sunny Sadhguru I love you sooo very much for teaching us how to live a free life.

[@anupamshukla1172]

I really want to hear Amish's response on javed

[@trignal]

Finally seeing a decent conversation from a variety of different viewpoints. Well done. I don't really understand the hatred for the only one coming from a materialistic, atheist perspective and not because they disagree with him. I guess some of these people cannot get over his name. They don't even seem to get what Sadhguru is saying either. Just want to blindly worship him, it seems.

[@atharalimaan8509]

Atheism is the actuality of life , life becomes lot easier when answer of every question is "God did it" , there is no God, only indoctrination of fallacy generation after generation, the only three reality of life are Death Taxes and Science

[@thesanatanipride01]

I don't know why you guys have problem if there are peoples who are following Sadguru it's there choice. If you are very good and intelligent then please mind your own business without making any comment on other choices if you don't know why they do that.

[@akscs373]

@@thesanatanipride01 u better understand what he wrote...

[@The.life-long.learner]

@@thesanatanipride01 If we let other people be blinded by sadhguru, India will never improve/

[@debangi_nayak]

That's why I've huge respect for Sadhguru ji after Bhaktivedanta Swami ji.

[@arefinhoosain654]

Why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik? Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event? It shows his weakness.

[@aryadharmasanatanam]

@@arefinhoosain654 Zakir Naik should Need to learn more in his life before debate🤭🤭 Without knowledge debate doesn't make sense it is just oneside entertainment 😜

[@arefinhoosain654]

@@aryadharmasanatanam 1) If Zakir Naik or any international Islamic debaters/ scholars likes to attain in dialogue /debate not to learn more or without knowledge in his life before then he/ they will be defeated due to lack of knowledge. > Let public will Justify > Why you are forcing them to take preparation or gain knowledge before dialogue /debate?

[@arefinhoosain654]

@@aryadharmasanatanam 2) In that case Zakir Naik or any international Islamic debaters/ scholars may be win instead of losing . > So you shouldn’t raised this type of primary condition to earn knowledge & take preparation to win in the dialogue /debate of your opponents

[@frankschest8584]

The first part of this video was not making any sense until last few mins. Loved it.

[@aryamehta007007]

javed akhtar sound like a muslim atheist. Defending muslim with virtue of atheists. well both are opposite polarity things one says this is the only truth and another say this is only truth but not the same truth as what you said. entangled between to radical ideas. Just accept I dont know ? will solve the problem. then saying i know everything which even not at all something near to even a chunk of something.

[@savjivanipatil3481]

Arya Mehta noncences joved

[@VijayPatil-xy3gq]

I don't know why NDTV called this dam Javed Akhtar ,,,,he is not that quality of man to seat with shri.Sadguruji ,,,,

[@ambalikadattaroy1658]

vijay patil absolutely.

[@manojtyagi708]

Actually Javed akhtar is not a spritual person so he didn't understand what sadguru is saying about anything he has no thought level in comparison of sadguru

[@acefire4614]

Looking at akthar face feels like punching to that pointed nose. Looking at yogi its very pleasant feeling

[@Therohitdubey]

@Manoj Tyagi . True. Seconded👍🏻

[@srin6718]

He provides a different point of view

[@rohitbagh5616]

What is the problem of ndtv and Javed sir with yoga... I want to ask Javed sir and ndtv why asto ma sad Gamay removed from Central School logo what was the problem. And why satyam Shivam shundaram removed from durdarshan logo?

[@ipabrol1263]

While every one appears to be at ease with him/herself, Javed Sahib appears somewhat constipated !

[@perfumeblisss]

javed akhtar is such an outdated atheist....with all due respect

[@abrarahmad7113]

Wasim Sheikh but he is nastik not believe Allah.

[@Fekutogyo]

if you don't become a atheist you don't become a believer.

[@Ashukazmii]

@Youthoob Gamer being anti Islamic

[@Az25wx]

No need to respect

[@Az25wx]

@gypsy lab it's easy... say truth always..

[@deepakdoer8507]

Sadhguru ji u rocks! U tell complex things with so ease!

[@arefinhoosain654]

If it's so why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik? Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event? It shows his weakness.

[@adamkunzoon474]

Sad guru ( RATHER FAKE GURU ) doesn't know the difference between spiritually and religion cause religion is based on faith forced over by our parents and society which is based on scientific evidence. So am impressed by Mr javed Akhtar's statement about the issues discussed here. LOVE ❤ YOU MY ATHEST BROTHER MR.JAVED AKHTAR SAHIB from kashmir.

[@pmishraofficial]

It’s good to see how nice the debate used to be earlier on. Everyone on this panel has their own opinion, but still they are calmly, listening to each other’s point of view.