The Review...

[@Tomkektv]

Bit of a different format here. This kind of video is a lot quicker and easier to make, so if you guys enjoy it I can make more like it when there is new art to review and fill in the channel a bit more :) (If you have any other ideas in a similar vein, absolutely do let me know) New art vid is on its way too. I'm actually working on 2 right now, which I think you folks will enjoy. Also, if you have disagreements with the Tier list, my commentary on the sets or something to add, don't hold back!

[@EnderGoku9001]

yo tom love your stuff

[@ShadowZeroFlame]

wish you would've done more direct comparison between your judgement set & blizzard's, but overall nice format. Doin' these every other month wouldn't hurt.

[@IgorEngelen1974]

Love this. Just an idea but maybe a comparison of art/styles in classic starting zones?

[@SakugaZai]

I like it.

[@John_Conner222]

no no no, your stuff is WAY better. I'm sorry but this tier 2 reveal just sealed the deal, you now have to do all of tier 2 (heck I would love to see tier 1). You art style is way more fleshed out and way more detailed. Your art style makes me want to play the game again, blizzards does not. The only set I even remotely liked was the druid, everything else is B tier and below and that Paladin set is straight up @$$. The death knight set is just too cartoony. You have to save us you have to make all the sets.

[@EnderGoku9001]

demon hunter's looks like a mob you'd fight in legion

[@Kenji-117]

Wasted potential to make a dragonhunter set for DH

[@simondemoulin5815]

Unfortunately, Blibli is stuck in a corner with the DH "style-wise" : The dark energy they used are either fell green or purple void, fast attacker so not much pieces of clothes, the Legion is gone and they are stuck in the past, both elves already have their heritage armor... The only way I could see it change is if they became relevant again with some kind of reformation in a proper order OR if blibli add a new specialisation for them that shake their style... maybe like a Warden from the N-E society.

[@Tazytots]

Mobs in this game consistently have better gear than players, sooo..

[@Dronesh_Tythun]

Yea it looks bad

[@minimalisticmj3113]

It looks like a test version of the TWW tier set. wasted potential.

[@scionicog]

I genuinely like your Judgement better than the Remake. But I also think you likely used more polygons and used a richer gold coloration, where they tried to keep it closer to the original yellow. I like the rich gold farrr more. Sanctum of Domination Gold needs more pieces that match that color palate. Overall though, still S tier. I just think your version is S+ 👍

[@MegaChickenfish]

Fair. I also think his judgement benefitted from only being rigged to human males, so he could really go to town with the extra bits and bobs. It's like, do I want the shaman set to have real 3D chains? Obviously. Do I realize from watching these videos that rigging 3D objects to variable character models is a nightmare? Also yes.

I don't like that the girdle just hangs kinda in the air and the cross on the chest just kinda hovers on the chest in between the chest and tabard.

[@TonysTechAndCars]

The gold isn't like the original. It's off and is noticeable when using the shield and weapons that go with the old judgment set. Only annoying part about the new one

[@naderm.7701]

the cross can atleast be used for transmog if you have a tabard but the belt feels like a bug when it just hangs in the air

[@Simplemalk]

Yeah definitely comes down to the more grim tone that Tomkek captures. New WoW has a lot softer look now.

[@Krul2895]

My buddy Josh designed the death knight set, definitely going to link him the video. He’s gonna be stoked to see your reaction to it

[@paulblankenship8344]

Tell your buddy Josh that some random guy named Paul thinks it's the best DK set in the game right now!

[@Tomkektv]

Tell Josh he is next level talented. They should have him do all DK sets from now on :D It gets better everytime I look at it

[@schippes24]

Thanks Josh, the set is the reason i dusted off my dk, leveled him and have him stand around in an awesome set :D

[@Revilex100]

is honestly one of the best sets in the game, he did a great job, Feels like a "dark" or death knight version of the Judgement set

[@thetheropodguy]

Tell Josh that he did an AMAZING job!!!

[@AFO3310]

Your judgement set is SO much better imho. I like the upgrade don't get me wrong but yours was just out of this world

[@wpelfeta]

Woah. This is the first time I've seen Tomkek in the flesh. What a handsome fellow.

[@theturtlearchives]

agreed i wouldn't complain if we saw more of him

[@Karine-108]

Thats funny because through his voice I always thought he was a cute guy... And it came right 😄

[@Miller1107]

So freaking adorable. I was looking at him more than the sets 🙈

[@FreelancerCZ]

Imagine the number of "b*****s" he is able to attract and is having fun with. 😁 A real chad.

[@Alucardd-tt8eb]

He’s got them puppy dog eyes

[@SwedetasticGames]

My biggest gripe with Bloodfang is the extra metal pieces added and how shiny they are. Should've been alot more matted.

[@wowprobeast7543]

I just wish the eyes glowed more. The new sets eyes are less glow than the old one

[@andybanan1992]

And that the red tone is much brighter than the original. Overall its a much brighter set compared to the og set

[@dsmania]

The evoker is based on the armor that Nefarian is wearing in Blackwing Lair, you can see several elements like the chest piece, the gem in the helm, the belt buckle...

[@HawkknightXC88]

Just wished the Dracthyr Dragon form could show more armor pieces than just shoulders and belts.

[@philipje1]

@@HawkknightXC88 I wish Dracthyr were removed from the game and everyone involved in the concept of it were fired. Ah well...

[@thebearded4427]

The main difference between your and Blizzards judgement is this: The Tomkek version looks like a gritty crusader who is more on the battlefield than in a church. The Blizzard version looks like someone trying to look like a crusader but they spend all day praying in the church. It's way to clean and tidy, almost dainty, while the OG and Tomkek versions are darker and way more sinister. When you saw the OG judgement you thought "This man wont listen to a word I'm about to say. He will murder me for the rightful cause no matter what" When you see the new version you think "Why does his helmet look like a owl and why does his eyes glow blue if he's using holy power? Is there a gas burner in there?"

[@nutcrackit7396]

Well given their somewhat revised roll in the legion class hall It sort of makes sense. These are the honor guard of the silver hand in a sense. The silver and blue color being the basic and the gold being the elite.

[@heroicxidiot]

I think it's fine for keeping the Classic aesthetic. A lot of the sets back then were really bright and stick out. If they made it too dark or gritty, kind of defeats that intention. I think it's fine but that's not to say I don't like tomkek's

[@maxpowers4436]

Wow isnt grimdark and neither were the original sets.

[@lordsloth9337]

Another thing I think lends to the idea that Tomkek's is more of an, in the field crusader, is that, it's overall shape to me, seems much bulkier. Its primarily around the shoulders on the new Blizzard version, where I feel they flatten outwards a bit more? I'm not entirely sure how to describe it, but when I look at the two side by side, Tomkek's version invokes more of a feeling that this man is an unstoppable Bulwark in the face of Evil, nothing will bring him down, where the Blizzard one feels a bit less unstoppable, if that makes sense?

[@Nick-4K]

Now all we need is an updated gold alliance pvp set with the griffin shoulder.

[@HawkknightXC88]

That I could easily support as well as for the horde as well.

[@HarbingerofHyol940]

THISSSS but with Paladins being able to obtain the BLUE clothed versions, and look like OG Silver Hand knights!

[@borga6566]

While it's not my favorite of the bunch, I do have to give them props for the Evoker set's idea. Most tier 2 sets (Hunter being the only exception) were effectively meant to fit the theme of the class, rather than the raid. Evoker, however, fits 3 ideas. It represents the Evoker class on a thematic level, *and* it has lore significance because it's based on Nefarian's armor, *and* because it's based on Nef's armor it also ties into the raid. It's super neat to me that they decided to base it on the armor of the final boss.

[@fosterbennington6405]

I just wish they let more of the armour show on the dracthyr, it’s such a shame since evokers are forced to play in dragon form most of the time.

[@borga6566]

@@fosterbennington6405 Absolutely agree lol. I love playing Evoker and I think Dracthyr are pretty cool, but it's an immense disappointment that they cannot enjoy transmog. In my opinion, if they can make it work on something as different as a Tauren, then Dracthyr should be no major issue.

[@ryantwomey3463]

If only it was on a class where you could see the transmog on the class in combat >.> God they fumbled evokers biggest reason I dropped my evoker in favor of my warlock for Whore within is because you can't see transmog in your shitty dragon form

[@Jorvalt]

One thing I didn't like about new judgement was the fact that they changed the wax seals on the robe to weird red orbs for some reason.

[@nickb5492]

I agree with the comments, you need to give yourself credit. I bet the new sets where heavy influenced by your work. Blizzard did do a good job, but if I had a choice, I would go with your models hands down!

[@TN_Nadaclos]

Judgement doesn't deserve S tier on my opinion, because clearly Blizzard work the upper part of the set, but then they got bored in the bottom part. Every other artist and even you did the extra work to make the lower part of the set look cooler, but Blizzard just put a skirt and those ugly black stuff to the side and call it a day, not a fan of the rigid belt too. Again artist like you did far way better work in the remake than blizz.

[@Audon4150]

New Judgement chest is boring-gray, and the reds are very dull :x Lots of those sets are very disappointing. and I wasn't expecting anything, really.

[@emptyforrest]

yhea the lower part of the set looks bad, and honestly so does the hood. i really do not like the bright blue glow. they are not deathknights, should have been a yellow or more white glow.

[@Thalarion]

Nah this is incredible and your coping sorry

[@MadX8]

​@emptyforrest you guys really don't deserve anything. Never happy, that's crazy

[@emptyforrest]

@@MadX8 i pay for the expansions and game time. i expect the absolute best. blizzard didn't offer the best, a youtuber did.

[@markibear8251]

i still prefer your judgement set honestly. i get that blizzards is true to the original but i love how the colouring is on yours. how the yellow/gold isnt as bright. it looks so much better on yours in my opinion. dont get me wrong, the new one from blizz is amazing too just not as good as yours. just my opinion.

[@MilkBeard555]

9:20 Yes you are. You are that special.

[@duzoone3838]

the shaman set looks like its made for a Heroes of the storm character

[@Deathl_O_r_d]

Well Shaman is a hero of the storm, the set is cool and iconic idk why ppl are low rating it.

[@duzoone3838]

@@Deathl_O_r_d im talking about the moba game blizzard made, it feels like i was made for that game, not wow

[@vhaelen326]

also with the deathknight set: i have one issue, and for me personally its a MASSIVE issue: the gap between gloves and the sleeves of the chestpiece... WHY? there are sets that CAN do that (although i still dislike them for it) but "fully armored knight of undeath" is not a set that can or should do that, there should be no skin visible in that set

[@dragonheart4332]

Heavy agree, I don't usually like gaps on plate armour, the thing I've found to help for the DK set is wearing either the shirt Master Builder's Shirt or the Stylish Black Shirt. It covers up the arm gaps fairly smoothly

[@Deathl_O_r_d]

Bro just use a black shirt, literally what I did and it looks fully armoured.

[@TatsuyaWow]

lack of armor it almost full cloth b tier

[@vhaelen326]

@@Deathl_O_r_d by that same logic why not draw with sharpy on your monitor to cover the area... i know that there is a fix, im saying there shouldnt be a need for a fix in the first place

[@vhaelen326]

@@dragonheart4332 oh yeah i figured there'd be a shirt that works, its still horrendously stupid that it needs a shirt in the first place

[@hookemup9216]

You could take a picture of the DH gear and go back in time to 2017 to show players. They would say thats just random legion gear.

[@arishiakoneko]

The evoker disrespect! D= How absolutely dare you, sir! XD

[@Raffalius]

For the shaman set i would probably open the mouth on the shoulder wolves and show off their fangs. I would add a little electric glow on the headpiece as well. I would also make the pouch and chains 3D. Then i would add some 3D metal piece on the feets. The crystals at the bottom of the robe should also be 3D and should have a dim glow effect, the glow effect applies to the crystals on the gloves too.

[@monkeyswithshoes308]

I would have darkened the blues just a bit, and made the metals a touch more shiny so theres a bit more contrast. So much wow art these days just has a washed out feel to me. I don't like it.

[@TheSaltyAdmiral]

Remember, Gen Z gamers unlike Millennial gamers are unable to experience positive emotions, they can only live through being outraged at others. Therefore these criticisms should be taken with a truck load of salt. *The only possible reason to shit at this Judgement T2 remake is that yours was arguably even better... If they released this without having seen yours, everyone would have loved it.* I think the fact that Blizzard even bothered to revisit and update a 20 year old set is a win for everyone.

[@Recomification]

"I'm not as good as a Blizzard artist" - makes a better Paladin set than a Blizzard artist kek, I get the diplomatic talk tho

[@Deathl_O_r_d]

Not trying to defend Blizzard but Artists like him got more resources than Blizzard artists, they can't just make a set like Tomkek on a regular day and also wow's engine blocks some possibilities.

[@borga6566]

It's generally a pretty distasteful stance for any artist to say their work is better than someone else's - at least publically. Some people take that pretty seriously in the art world. But yeah I think I agree, Tomkek's is baller lmao

[@nacidocoqui]

Blizz cooked with Wrath, Transcendence, and (of course) Judgement. These sets where the sole reasons I dusted off my Warrior, Priest, and Pallies, respectively. I have a pocket Druid parked on an old guild, and I'm debating farming the last handful of tokens for Stormrage. I was... disappointed with Dragonstalker because the FEET ARE TOO DAMN BIG, especially on skinny Belf legs!

[@MarkusDBurner]

i hope blizzard comments on this video and says "yeah you pretty much inspired us" xD that would be nice

[@yeye1600]

This DH set truly represents the care, love and amount of ideas/ inspiration blizzard has for us. Sad as everytime.

[@Saimeren]

I'm willing to be that Blizzard 100% took inspiration from your work. Whether they'll admit it or not, I'm betting they had a sit down meeting when they were first discussing remaking these and I wouldn't be surprised if your name came up as homework to study your Judgement video as references and inspiration for making the new sets.

[@octane9576]

Your Judgement model completely shits on the Blizzard one, it's not even close. They made it childish, colors are way to bright, it lacks detail, and what they did to the helmet is unforgivable. I knew it was never going to be as good, but man, it's sad to see what they dumped out.

[@phantom0456]

Monk>DK. The monk set is INCREDIBLE, and the other coloration of it that Blizz showed looked even cooler than the green set.

[@billjohnson2307]

I think both are S tier sets tbh but hands down Monk got the biggest W in this one. I cant see myself using any other monk mog now that i bought it cause its just the best they have gotten since they released xD

[@MiracleGamesFtw]

When I saw blizzard did that, first thing i thought of was you! I was like, "I wonder how Tomkek feels about these." Judgement armor looks sooo good!

[@reddragonstudios1]

DH Set F Tier.... THANK YOU! I couldnt agree more, they phoned our set in man, its such BS

[@rettbull9100]

T1 felheart and T5 corrupt raiment were the best warlock set for looks. T4 and T6 were good but the colors didn't feel like a warlock.

[@fosterbennington6405]

Tier 10 was one of my favourites, especially the 25normal one.

[@UltimateGamerCC]

the Rogue Set is literally showing light refacting off of it, like Black Leather Pants would irl. idk why everybody just says Gray when you can see Black where it doesnt refract.

[@Stridertriller]

The first thing I thought about when I heard they were remaking Tier2 was your Judgement remake video. And after getting it in-game, I have to say its nice but I was disappointed. Your version is way freaking better!

[@teej143]

Call me a simp, but what I find really visually appealing is Tom's face, especially his eyes 😍😍😍

[@tcsnowdream9975]

Long time Holy Priest player here: OG Transcendence was supposed to be based on the coloured glass windows in cathedrals. It’s been given a more Naaru, space/light vibe which is pretty cool. If you wanna see it in full glory - I play a Tauren. The helm moves forwards and slants back to look like a mask of covering. It’s awesome.

[@spoopywendee8327]

nice to see you again, tom! great video, love the easy "popcorn" format. your insight into design is always great. 💜

[@PatrickHenryWoW]

salamander pic ftw LOL // Came here for the Judgment set, but the monk set I swear, almost made me reroll. That's how good it is.

[@wolfanator81]

I think your re release of Judgement set caused this and they should be paying you for the idea.

[@vhaelen326]

by that same logic wouldnt he have to pay all the revenue for the remake video to blizzard/the original artist?

[@Raffalius]

I don't know about paying him for it. But i do feel like they should reach out to him and hire him to do some work for them every now and then and give him a shout out for the things he does. If i was Blizzard i would hire him to do some cosmetic pieces to highlight in that traders outpost.

[@SirDeltis]

I appreciate how humble you are about the art and how you respect the blizzard artists. HOWEVER, in my opinion your Judgement set was a tier above the blizzards updated version. I know there are probably layers of compilations when taking art from a 3D modeler into the actual game that blizzard has to tackle, but your video and redesign was amazing.

[@peagames2002]

I believe World of Warcraft artist team had an inspiration from your creation and gave it their own touch. It's quite great to see that art team is checking out the works of WoW fans and such.

[@theMoofin]

I really wish we had your version of judgment, looking at it hypes me up, it's incredibly menacing. It's like a medieval space marine.

[@CloneWarsrulz]

Absolutely think more content like this would be awesome to see! At the very least, I think your remaster sparked more of an interest in seeing tier 2 redone and Blizz responded in kind. Personally I still have a bias to your redesign, but the Blizz artists did really well too. The reviews were very fair and the commentary was really entertaining to listen to I lost it at all the evoker shade, near-naked dracthyr haunt my dreams Definitely looking forward to what's next for the channel!

[@Saimeren]

Pally, Warlock, DK and Druid are all S tier for me. They're SO good. Rogue comes in at A tier, and then everything else is B or worse, with DH coming in a far, far last place.

[@silbertukan7472]

can you maybe making the Tier 2 rouge?

[@popojaga7312]

Yea please proper remake with darker colors

[@phantom0456]

Aaaaawwwperator! Won’t you put me on through?! Gonna send all my love down to BATON ROGUE!!! 😂

[@coolst0rybruh]

S - Paladin Monk Druid A - Warrior Dk B - Priest C - Warlock Hunter Evoker D - Shaman Mage E - Nothing F - Rogue Dh (but both a big fat F)

[@thetheropodguy]

Enjoyed the video and your reactions! It gave me a good chuckle! Can’t wait to get the Pally and Warrior set for my characters!

[@customizablemilk353]

the problem with the chains on the shaman set is that he is basically wearing an old school skirt/robe and thus it will stretch weirdly around the legs which would be hard to make 3d chains to not clip through it while walking.

[@dbfblackbull]

Boy did Christmas come early this year! I was so hoping you would do a review of Blizzards updated Judgement! :D

[@apelzin9]

talking about the warlock set like its almost perfect, brings back memories and nostalgia. and then you put it at A. KEKW, i honestly thought you would put it in S because of how fondly you spoke about the tier set.

[@jd33109]

I like your paladin better, the eyes on yours fit better I think

[@AmorphisBob]

"that's starting gear" pulls up the mythic set from the first Legion raid

[@1337Higgins]

I appreciate this video. Especially when you pointed out nearly the same things I initially did. You've got a good eye for these things!

[@xzBorn_]

You could for sure mine out a lot of content with in depth to semi-in depth analysis of each new tier’s worth of designs as well as old designs. Would 100% watch.

[@Tomkektv]

Honestly I would totally be down to do like a tier 1 tier list and maybe go up lol. Classic wow weapons would be fun too. People seem to like the format a lot more than I expected and it's easy to do so why not. I would love to fill up my upload schedule more too and this is a great way

[@xzBorn_]

@@Tomkektv Everyone loves tier lists ;)

[@ramistotle]

After all those comments you made, did you really put that Rogue set alongside with the Monk one 😢

[@FratinandMadrik]

How the hell did you pick the order? It's not alphabetical based on class, it's not alphabetical based on set name, it's not as following the WowHead list, it's not following the initial layout of the tierlist, nor the final result in any way... How the hell did you come up with "Yeah let's start with mage then move onto warrior, then evoker, then druid! That makes sense!"

[@nohbdyz3]

"the dad volunteered to be the dragon in the kid's school play" got me, lol.

[@xkarasu9705]

I think this whole thing perfectly encapsulates the idea that just because you're talented doesn't mean you're exactly in tune with the artistic flow of something. Tomkek's rendition is by no means bad but compared to the Blizz remake it's clear that his revision lacks the Classic feel and aesthetic that made the original loved so much. The current If-It-Aint-Broke-Dont-Fix-It approach with a slight touch up was the perfect answer to all the T2 sets.

[@mortadelainc]

They making the judgement set looking like yours is a really cool thing to me, your remake was awesome and the blizz one is great as well

[@Nagassh]

Surprised to see the Priest set so low - it's the only set that I think the artists turned from a set I wasn't fond of into one that I thought looked fantastic.

[@DookieLikid]

I couldn't agree more with this Tier list. And I recreated a DK just for this set (I used to play DK during Lich King only). Incredible details, incredible vibe. In fact, I feel that Blizzard did incredible set for the classes who were not here 20 years ago (DK, Monk). And i think it is for a reason.

[@shadowdragon8168]

I guess I'm in the minority that absolutely loves the dragonstalker set and the remake set lol, I do desperately hope they release a red recolor of the dragonstalker set in the trading post or something. The red sod dragonstalker set just looks so good and I think the remake version in that coloration would be one of the best looking hunter sets ever.

[@Miller1107]

Regarding the chains on Ten Storms, I don’t think rigging was a concern. I was *very* disappointed in-game to find out half the sets have clipping issues on most races. Even human, which is used to model them, has clipping. Mage set your hands are halfway inside your robe, Priest as well. It was a let down. Also, Ten Storms looks too cartoonish. It’s soft and weirdly plastic looking? It looks like what I imagine a Ten Storms Shaman Funko Pop would look like. Unrelated.. your eyes are damn gorgeous.

[@rob-p9k]

You're very modest. You could indeed do as well as the developers. Keep up the great content my man.

[@Em-ne4gk]

Lets all just simply canonize that Tomkek's model remasters were the inspiration for Blizzard to HD Tier2. Now that is all settled, imo Wrath should be S teir, yea i might be a little sloghtly lot biased since i played warrior since Vanilla through TBC and usually donned Battlegear of Wrath or Dreadnaught T3. The HD Wrath one can see it extra agressive look is taken from Heroes if the Storm Wrath rendition. Overall great vid and heres to more HD remasters from Blizzard and Tomkek as well

[@lordstarscreamy329]

I agree with the death knight S tier, I may be 100% biased, but it's awesome :)

[@Polomance862]

I think the Demon Hunter set really missed out on the opportunity to go with a "classic" Demon hunter look. Remember the physical copy of WoW with the night elf holding a glaive? Where it's the kilt, the blindfold, some body markings, and less green and more of a dark feather outfit. Something that isn't so jagged and torn, but rather more draconic.

[@asmosmeden]

Murpharooni here! Dragonstalker was the reason I continued to play WoW after I started it. It was my goal, to get the whole set. The bracers was the last piece I got and I got it 1 month before TBC. Man loved the set and still do... however, I have mixed feelings about this one. The boots and belt feels so, sloppy, like they lacked the time to finish it. I'll forgive them if they give us the recolor version fot them, like the red one we got for tbc but got reverted to something else later on! Or a full black one!

[@Tomkektv]

I definitely agree that recolors would go a long way for it! I think a lot of people like the idea fo dragonstalker but just don't like the crazy color scheme. I don't mind it personally but it is a bit out there xD I imagine we will see recolors at some point though. It's way too much work that went into this not to repurpose Thanks for the classic wow story though. I always feel so nostalgic hearing those :D

[@bullethellbattler2478]

"Incredible, I love it. Blizzard blew it out of the water. Astounding! D tier." 😂

[@Lionwoman]

The monk artist was cooking.

[@billbadson7598]

Hot Take: Dragonstalker armor looks great, if you just use a different helmet or no helmet.

[@DEUS_VULT_INFIDEL]

Weird thing about the Transcendence set, the helm actually sits differently if you're on a Worgen or a Tauren than it does if you're on pretty much any other race. Instead of sitting behind the head it goes over the front like a sort of hood or cowl or something.

[@rwyot767]

We’re getting a bit too used to these little sun dresses they keep giving us. Give it a couple of slits at the front so the legs show, armor would look so much more badass when you’re able to see the leg armor.

[@rwyot767]

Also I love your Judgement set much better, it’s so much more beefier 💪

[@dAstroboy]

Putting Druid set in S Tier and Warlock in A Tier is crazy work :D

[@NorthAvion]

"This set is missing a lot, A tier. Now this set is well done. C tier"

[@lautaroalbornoz7745]

Awesome video Tom. Great review! Maybe you can try some reworks for the new classes that didnt have a previous set in Vanilla Wow

[@CallMeMaku]

I didn't know Vincent van Gogh was a priest. 😁👂

[@panathaninf]

we need to make a petition to blizzard to reveal the artist of paladin t2, then we can give him all of our money and make him head of our sect

[@phantom0456]

I think Hunter would look a lot better if the colors weren’t so cartoony… I’d like to see it in a black and red or even in the TBC dungeon recolor. The modeling is great, it’s just the OG colorstyle that makes it a bit goofy looking. I really hope that Blizz puts out recolors of all of these sets at some point bc that would be awesome. Finally, Warrior’s T2 Wrath remake is ABSOLUTELY S-tier. Just saying.

[@TonyJ1776]

The new Judgement helmet is shit, the upturned eye corners is horrid. The boots are shit, at least they don't have claws like Hunter set but the HUGE central ridge is ass.

[@Deathl_O_r_d]

Brother we are lucky that we got a remastered Judgement set, It's not anything regular so what good can come from your complain? If you don't like it don't use it.

[@HippocritterXD]

Your paladin tier set looks so much better. Can't Believe they just ask you to create these tier sets

[@nuggsy7085]

I'm gonna be honest with you. The new one they did is pretty good, but yours is actually leagues better. The weird penguin flaps on the sides of the skirt on the official one are meh.

[@polishpaddy1991]

Your Judgement Set was way better! I agree that Bloodfang set could've been better, I would love to see your attempt to remake it! ^^

[@djbapt]

Btw DK and DH set are base on the intro quest sets in Acherus and Mardum.

[@Lovehandels]

You ate Blizzard lunch and Blizzard is like "would you like seconds?"

[@RunehearthCL]

to be fair, starting gear of demon hunters isn't the roast you think, because they started at level 90 originally lol

[@cybucybu1849]

Tomkek you have one of the most important youtube channels about wow modeling, from an artist's perspective (i just started to make 3d objects) the main reason i believe they don't get your sets in the game isn't that they look bad or noobish, i believe that your colors and detail match to another game , like assassin's creed, i also paint but seems i have the same ''problem'', my art doesn't fit in blizzards taste, they need more cartoonish and colorful

[@MoZeZ92]

The comparison set you used for DH is from night hold. The lookalike you're thinking is mix and match of legion dungeon gear and tomb of sargeras set. Judgement remake was so close but the eye slits just make it cartoony as you said. The original has almost no emotion attached to it which makes it look indifferent, almost robot like. It's kinda like "less is more" element of the set when everything else is already so busy.

[@DraphEnjoyer]

I like how the DK set has an open waist coat but theyre still forcing the plate dress on paladins Even the arathi set has it

[@adaml3010]

for me C: Shaman Hunter Rogue Evoker B: Mage Priest A: Druid Warrior Monk S: Paladin Warlock and Death Knight AND for me DH is not as bad as F but its for sure D maybe E PS. Demo Warlock is REALY fun to play this Xpack so that AND the fact its t2 set is SOOOOOO nice has made me start rethinking my main(Paladin)

[@krabix1855]

I think the main reason why yours is better is the tassels on the dress look separate tassels on yours but more like a solid mass in their version.

[@Gior89]

I HATE that the judgment helmet is ANGRY, it doesnt need to be.

[@MrCodeman2036]

Swap Driud and Monk, and Swap Warrior and DK...Also Hunter should be Low A, or High B Tier. Otherwise pretty good list

[@Khaogar]

Let’s be honnest everyone who saw your judgement remake wished it was gonna be yours in the game. I personally would pay for it in the shop if it was yours!

[@vhaelen326]

11:16 oh my god, ive seen that model on sketchfab its gorgeous, i love that its abit more stocky, almost 40k-ish imo that model > your remake > blizzards remake (which im still more than happy with, just saying) also IMO the hunter set (both original and remake) deserve to go into their own tier below F tier like honestly this is where the "hunter sets suck 99% of the time" trend started, tier 1 is questionable but tier 2 is awful

[@theannoyedfiremage8721]

As a mage main, I HATE it. I've never liked the colour purple in any case but it reminds me what a kindergarten-age child would make with paper cardboard. I mean, great for a kid to have imagination and work to something they have fun with. But we're adults and that particular aesthetic they gave us for T2 mage is simply undignified.

[@Inxx89]

Love the extra content and hope to see more of it in the future! Here is my hot take for the T2 stuff: I don't like plate and mail sets being skirts/dresses, so Judgement and Ten Storms is very low on my list of priorities. Even the DK one is teetering on being too skirt-y for me. I know the Judgement and Ten Storms have pants variants, but let's be honest: it looses its appeal if you use pants. I mained a blood elf paladin most of my WoW days, and seeing the BE heritage armor I was hoping we would get some chonky pants and boots so we can not run the dress version...but alas it was not meant to be.

[@zimtot]

Ten storms has been my favorite set in game since vanilla. I was very happy with this remake.

[@darwinxavier3516]

DH simply suffers from not having much variety in it's thematic aesthetic. Take away their fel green bits and they just look like rogues. They're not really the type to heavily model their armor after the things they're trying to exterminate, so no variety of inspiration there. They're rarely in anything bright and colorful. And they wear barely more armor than barbarians much of the time.

[@dawgatemybrain]

The Demon Hunter "Teir 2" set should just be pants and a blindfold. Maybe wearable tattoos that glow.