The SECRET of GOD VALLEY - One Piece

[@MrMorj]

Hey everyone, from here on I'm going to be putting out post-chapter vids on Saturday mornings! Full chapter reviews will still be on Patreon Podcast, but the Saturday morning vids will be focusing on some first take thoughts on just one topic coming out of the new chapter, so look out for those! And of course, big Blackbeard Vid still coming out this Monday =)

[@Pete_the_Fuzzball]

You have yourself a new patron... Patreon... Whatever! Looking forward to more great one piece analysis 👍

[@ubertgold]

I think it might be worth it to wait until the official translation is out because we do see some translation differences that are at least minorly impactful

[@TheBlo24]

you sir. are oda. take the. mask. off.

[@babloomiah1707]

Mr Morj just went gear 4!!!

[@frankbarrie6785]

hey man keep uup the good work! thanks for the vids! and btw, ur totally sayin Urouge wrong, lol i didnt even kno what u were sayin at first.. and TWO people with the Will Of D. stopped Rocks that I think is important to mention.. Monkey D. Garp and Gol D. Roger teamed up.. awesome and crazy at the same time lol

[@Ohara-the-Fox]

Wild Morj video: Appears Ohara: Throw's Masterball at it

[@fwp707norcal7]

Ohara What's up OHara

[@Ohara-the-Fox]

@@fwp707norcal7 Working on my next video, but I can use a break haha 🦊

[@robertgnallmedia]

Ohara shoot, so close too

[@dmonkillr]

hey, just wanna mention that they tell us about the three eyed people and how that their people develop the ability, its not something they all have otherwise it would brake the story having an entire race that can read ponigliphs. on pages 3 and 4 of chapter 853 mama say's "I'm not going to screw up like i did with Roger!!!" "he used that strange ability to hear the VOICE OF ALL THINGS and read the stone..." "but i've got a secret weapon of my own who will one day wield that power" pudding arrives and mama says "oh, speak of the devil! my sweet little pudding" "what brings you here? has your THIRD EYE finally opened in the truest sense?" to which pudding replies "thats all you ever talk about. I'm just half-blood remember?" "there's no guarantee my power will ever develop." so basically i think that the power that mama is referring to with her secret weapon is the voice of all things. as for the three eyed people, from the way they talk about it, its something that has to progress with the person(probably similar to conqueror's haki) kinda like a coming of age thing. i think mama has a little more knowledge about them the we do obviously but i think, the same way she looks at pudding as a tool, she also treats her as a full blood, and expects pudding to acquire these powers as quickly as possible. Mama also states after pudding's comment "but you do indeed have the rare blood of the three-eyed people." stating that the race is rare.

[@zsmith4853]

@@dmonkillr Wow. Just wow.

[@selwyntan4014]

Actually Gol D. Roger wasn't the only "D" who fought Rocks D. Xebec. Monkey D. Garp did as well. so 2 D's fought 1 D (that we know of)

[@zoeking95]

Roger and Garp defeated rocks and garp gets the credit Sengoku and Garp going to deal with shiki Garp: sengoku I’m gna take out that shiki dw you can take all the credit 😂😂 Garp be around roger to much 😂😂😂

[@truffle6082]

@@Marco..1 yes he was the first it explains how they got the idea from

[@ew275x]

@ReginGaliliofficial Or he took his mothers name just like Ace

[@imsentinelprime9279]

@ReginGaliliofficial xeberrrrrrtrthdbfcidochycicdkdjddyr7eiifhur8r8i384i48tititnntbtbrbr rnent

[@ericcorder9083]

Edwar. D. Newgate

[@fullmetalalchemist1758]

The secret of God valley is that it is where Oda was born

[@basantadhamala3715]

All hail GODA 😣😣

[@abolkasimadir1342]

snipe king too. Coz he is a god.

[@basantadhamala3715]

@@abolkasimadir1342 Btuh if God valley ends up being Sniper Island Lmfao imma die. Tho Sogeking did say it was in your heart. Jokes, bt if it happens i actually fear getting a heart attack 😶

[@AHeranam]

Then maybe God d. Ussop and Buggy d. Sama and Con d. Oriano is his childhood :)

[@michaelh4227]

His true name is O D. A

[@Zegha]

You know what the world government calls me nowadays? - "God" Valley. _But what is it really?_ *My name is Go D. Valley!*

[@jfrd-pw4hk]

His son is Go D. Usopp

[@creavesk5667]

Your profile looks like xebec

[@siddharthrao6147]

Also known as Sniper Island!!! Sniper Island and Sogeking is the next arc confirmed?

[@SaintHanger]

Watch as you’re right

[@ytproject3526]

Funny man 🤣😂

[@calliopeshif7581]

I absolutely LOVE the 3-Eyed Tribe theory!!! It brings a few immediate questions up for me: 1. Pudding is 16 years old, so, unless there was play with time somehow, Big Mom was only able to have a child with a member of the 3-Eyed Tribe 16 years ago. If the Tribe was wiped out 38 years ago, how do you explain the 22-year gap between the God Valley incident and Pudding's birth? You say that she may have tracked down the last survivor, but where would they have been in the meantime? Hiding? Possibly they had already left God Valley prior, and so survived the God Valley battle? Maybe this survivor's departure from the island drew the attention of Rocks? Seriously, how is it that no one really seems to know about them? How would anyone have survived, let alone for 22 years after the God Valley incident, such that they eventually joined up with/were captured by Big Mom 16 years ago? What happened to this supposed "pure" 3-Eyed Tribe member - Pudding's father? Did Big Mom kill him because he rebelled or tried to take Pudding? Is that why Pudding's third eye disgusts Big Mom? 2. If the 3-Eyed Tribe genuinely has the ability to hear the Voice of All Things, then they must have been crucial to the plans of several top pirates of Rocks' time, as well as the entire time since the Void Century. Moreover, I see no reason for the Celestial Dragons to have kept them alive this entire time. So...... was their existence hidden prior to the God Valley incident? I think this actually lends credence to your idea that they lived on God Valley, because a tribe like theirs would've been hiding from scrutiny, from ANYONE. They must have been targets for a long time, unless they lived in secret. Is there a chance that Rocks discovered their existence and that this triggered the God Valley incident? Seriously lol how did they remain hidden? Even if they didn't live on God Valley, how would anyone have left any of them alive long enough for Big Mom to find one? WHAT IF NICO ROBIN'S DAD WAS THIS SAME MEMBER OF THE 3-EYED TRIBE BUT GOT CAPTURED BY BIG MOM DURING HIS VOYAGE??? AND NICO ROBIN JUST DIDN'T INHERIT THE THIRD-EYE TRAIT?? AND HE HAD BEEN HIDING OUT IN OHARA, WHICH IS WHY THEY GOT SO CLOSE TO THE FULL TRUTH?? Apparently everyone on the island was told to stay away from her, which clearly wasn't only due to her Devil Fruit Powers, right? And I doubt it was due to Nico Olvia, her mother, researching taboo subjects, because all of the Scholars did that. So maybe... her father is from the 3-Eyed-Tribe? 3. 3-Eyed Tribe, 3 members of the D. clan fighting, and Blackbeard's ship - Saber of Xebex - has 3 heads on its flag. Moreover, Marco (I think?) said that Blackbeard's body has always been strange, and Zoro referred to Blackbeard with a plural pronoun on Jaya. What exactly is going on here??? (lol this point was mostly a throwaway) 4. According to Sengoku, Garp was forced to defend the Celestial Dragons, AND THEIR SLAVES. I believe that this leaves two major possibilities - and I'm ignoring the people interpreting that to mean that the Celestial Dragons and their slaves were literally there, which seems like a silly possibility. A. There was information on the island which would have put the Celestial Dragons in danger of being overthrown, maybe by containing history on their roots in slavery vs. the Ancient Kingdom's supposed freedom. B. There was something on God Valley which would have literally destroyed the Red Line, thus directly putting both the Celestial Dragons and their slaves in physical danger. Maybe Pluton was there, or it was Pluton; maybe it has to do with the third ancient weapon, of which we know nothing; or............ maybe the Three-Eyed Tribe's ability to hear the Voice of All Things put the Red Line - or just Mariegois - in very real danger. 5. Last point lol - why would Garp and Roger work together on this? More importantly... what if Roger was not yet aware of much of the truth of the world prior to the God Valley incident? What if that incident actually served as a turning point because he learned something dramatic? What if Big Mom and Kaido, who were also present at God Valley, also learned of this mysterious truth? Let's say that it's not as thorough as the actual history of the world, but what if it was exactly learning of the 3-Eyed Tribe - and their destruction - that changed Roger? Also, Roger can hear the Voice of All Things, but brought Oden with him on his last voyage anyway. If Roger can understand the poneglyphs, why bring Oden? Did he need Oden to craft a new poneglyph, or confirm what it was that he learned on Raftel? What I'm saying is this: What if Roger really didn't learn anything on Raftel, and it actually is just stuff/info he deposited there? What if Roger learned about the history of the world earlier, relating to the God Valley incident, as did Garp and Rayleigh? Big Mom and Kaido may have deserted Rocks and the entire battle before this ultimate truth was revealed, so that Roger remained aware and Garp became disgusted with the Celestial Dragons, while Big Mom and Kaido are still searching for info?

[@corsijtsma3546]

I still want to believe this. Considering the shape of god valley: it might be in the florian triangle. The 'monster' we saw could just be the island that needs to be kept secret there, hence why it is in the fog. Also, every ship that gets there will be shot down and sink and that is the reason why so many ships never get back out of the triangle.

[@Zatora11]

hmmm very smart. I always wondered why they showed that clip in the anime and never followed up on it. interesting take

[@islandboy9381]

BRUH

[@IbbyMelbourne]

An island of gods where 3 Ds fought to the death.

[@Seryung01]

Rocks, roger, garp..

[@secretasian8165]

3DS

[@jasonfanclub4267]

@@secretasian8165 3DS XL

[@secretasian8165]

New 3DS

[@jrdsm]

3ds new gen: Monkey D Luffy, Marshall D Teach, Smoker D White Hunter

[@sreekargunda3915]

Rocks D Xebec is Zaraki Kenpachi, only that could explain his monstrous strength.

[@godson7891]

Sreekar Gunda Kenpachi tested is Bankai and cut a portal to the One Piece verse

[@itamar4117]

and his hair style

[@muhamadrizkhan9253]

In page 7, his arm was cut off

[@godson7891]

Muhamad Rizkhan he grew it back

[@dreamcastdazia4753]

LOOOOOL

[@ultimategamer5067]

3:08 first Time I heard someone pronounce Urouge like that

[@spies444]

I don't like change, put it back the way its supposed to sound

[@michaeldmingo1525]

Thats how it's suppose to be pronounced.

[@nomongosinthaworld]

PorkPie Hat D Mingo it’s not

[@acatwithamustache3708]

@@michaeldmingo1525 nigga what's wrong with you, that's not how you pronounce urouge

[@patrickwhipple3097]

Look up how brulee says it in whole cake

[@pianotensai2492]

Alright here's what i found out 579 : Shankes's entrance to Marine ford ( Great chapter ) 597 : (WB and Roger) on cover page: Luffy starts training with Rayleigh ( amazing chapter ) 759 : Fight against doffy and the shambles + Redhawk combo ( this one is the weakest but still good chapter) 795 : Kaido's first appearance ( Great chapter again ) 957 : All bounties Reveal + Rocks ( another sick chapter ) 975 : This one is going to be huge too And today i officially converts to GODAISM

[@MochaPhilanthropist]

I see oda sensie was playing with the numbers 5,7,9 almost like an anagrams.good observation 👍, we need people like you to break down godaism wisdom 😂😂

[@kevbeenballin9]

At least say you took it from reddit

[@alucard1128]

What about 907 When imu and the giant straw hat is revealed?

[@chinuaalibatya7345]

Wheres the Luffy declares war on the world gov chapter?

[@kevbeenballin9]

@@chinuaalibatya7345 398 i think

[@BreakingTheGleipnir]

You know, everytime I think about Roger not liberating the world as pirate king I always think that roger had to bet on the next generation because there are some unidentified factors making it impossible for him to end the god's reign in his lifetime and that it had something to do with the One Piece. I just think that Roger needed to stop The Rocks Pirates because whatever they wanted to do, was worse than the status quo of the WG (which is crazy). It's confusing to think about the nature of the One Piece because it somehow makes you the worlds freest man yet wont liberate the world itself - or for a certain time it seems! It seems like now the One Piece evolved into something that could end the god's reign and put an end to oppression worldwide.

[@BreakingTheGleipnir]

@@everestaexillifek doesnt it make you think though? Like him having/possessing/finding the One Piece not making him able to liberate the world? Its really confusing because we cant be sure about the nature of the object.

[@BreakingTheGleipnir]

@@everestaexillifek Makes sense, thank you!

[@AHeranam]

It is roger by dying is like giving his bet to the future generation , i also believe in that theory too, roger came early she doesnt even meet sirahoshi since she is not yet alive that time . So theirs a possibility that he can't continue his journey aside from he is sick its because some factors to complete is not yet in his era.

[@b21ghtside]

i think no matter what roger did he was always not that man to bring about the DAWN OF THE WORLD because poseidon was not born during his time assuming the ancient weapons are somewhat someway that important to the story.

[@realityofx-avi3749]

Whiskey Ylrych he probably found one of the ancient weapons and gave it to dragon. That's why dragon can control weather and is the most wanted man. Dragon was probably highly influence by roger and became close. Roger probably told him everything about the D's, IMU, the void century. That's probably why dragon became a revolutionary to overthrow the government.

[@adityasinghkushwah9714]

There is some kind of connection between wano and raftel considering the Smith of wano knew the location of raftel to mark it on poneglyphs. And also the location of legendary weapons.

[@Mohinsh]

8:50 & 15:29 you can hear the frustration in his voice lol, I can understand tho. 8:50 is something thats comeback in the story a ton of times and so many things always tie back to this. 15:29 is a different story tho, literally frustration of not fully understanding all these connections. Good work man, you really understand One Piece on a whole new level than most of us.

[@Pete_the_Fuzzball]

Yes! I read the chapter and my mind melted then I thought... "I need to hear what Morj thinks about this"

[@RyogaEchizen]

did you have a hard time understanding the chapter?

[@Pete_the_Fuzzball]

@@RyogaEchizen Not understanding the chapter itself but the implications of all the new information in the chapter

[@RyogaEchizen]

@@Pete_the_Fuzzball hmmm ok

[@GoldenNara60]

Maybe God Valley is where the celestial dragons are originally from, before they moved up to the top of the red line. The original kingdom that waged war against the former most advanced civilization, the clan of D, which might have been based on Raftel since all (or most) Ds are naturally drawn to it. I believe Rocks' ambition (and by extension, Blackbeard's) is directly tied to taking Imu's place as the "King of the world" which is why Teach is often regarded as a fake D: he doesn't want freedom, his ultimate goal is to rule like the celestial dragons, his natural enemies. And going one step further, since this story is about inherited will, perhaps the reason why the D clan lost in the first place is because the Blackbeard from ages ago betrayed them and chose to side with the authoritarian clan and Joy Boy is the original Roger, who sought to destroy them and bring forth freedom to the world, but ultimately couldn't.

[@jojolafrite90]

Yes. I agree.

[@juthikam]

Morj videos are the Gold standard of one piece videos

[@sobversion3]

No Cap 💯

[@bartiz12]

Glad to see you back at smaller more recent topics. I hope you have fresh videos like that in store.

[@saivenkatesh1906]

I think that during the war of God valley, Kaido would have been very badly injured to such an extent where Bigmom gave a part of her life to save Kaido's. This is the debt he probably owes her

[@Ronin11111111]

I can feel Pudding staring into my soul

[@youeggs7128]

Dunno if that's hot or scary

[@youeggs7128]

or both

[@chinuaalibatya7345]

Both :)

[@ToiletPkay]

My guesss is the reason why god valley somehow "vanished" has to do with shiki and when he first used his devil fruit power not many would know about his powers he made the island float where nobody could see it so xebec could escape, were yet to see the lurking legend and im thinking xebec is it, big mom and kaido making a alliance was really bad news that could get the old rocks pirates out of hiding and group back up again

[@jobo8868]

Toilet Pkay If Shiki is dead, then wouldn’t that mean that the island would have fallen back down?

[@ToiletPkay]

@@jobo8868 yeah it should have fallen down if he died, i doubt oda would even shadow out shiki and xebec if they are dead

[@ChilltheImpaler]

I think we're about to see a lot of lies uncovered in one piece. While I've been reading One Piece I've noticed a few things that came out at me as centers of lies. Clearly lies and truth are an important theme in one piece a two strawhats embody those concepts. There are many secrets in one piece, and secrets are kept with good lies. I think the Marines have been getting lied to by the WG. Clearly their goals aren't perfectly aligned as the WG primarily wants to preserve the WG, which at times counters the Marines mission of ending the plauge of piracy. The WG benefits from the system of deadlock created by the Yonko. It's a system of risks that ensures no one entity will ever hold all the road poneglyphs. That deadlock will be broken by the fall of Kaido. The WG will not remain an ally of the Marines if the they become a threat that can learn the truth of the world. I think we've been mislead about how long the Marines have been around compared to the WG. As we have never been revealed exactly how old the Marines are. The oldest point of reference we have for the Marines is Monkey D Kong. Think about it. Why would a bunch of waring nations opt into a global military to fight against piracy when they have militaries of their own to fight piracy and pirates may be able to pick off their weaker enemies? It doesn't make sense unless they came about to respond to a global threat. I think we've been mislead about Shanks. Luffy from the beginning of the story aspires to be like Shanks however while Luffy is an agent of freedom, Shanks is more like an slave to tranquility, binding himself in doctrines declaring that he must take every effort to minimize change for the betterment of mankind. Their ideals are on track to clash. BB ideals will clash with shanks too. One clash will end in loss another in death. Finally and perhaps the biggest lie. The celestial dragons are NOT Gods. They are just mislead men. (which is obvious). Mislead by who? A new race. Devils. "Im" being a representative of that race. Where do they live? At the bottom of the world. The bottom of a deep valley. A valley they dubbed God's valley after they lured the rulers of the world there and convinced them to overthrow the ancient kingdom to become the Gods of the world. Only the wise Nefertari family realize their deception and refused to ascend to "Godhood" at Mariejoise (this retaining a bit of their freedom from the devils). - a one piece fanfiction about God's valley In all actuality a race of 3 eyed people at the bottom of the world makes "one piece sense" because there would be less light down there. Less light = more eyes.

[@Channelthatprovidesplaylists]

Brilliant comment

[@timothypolanco8622]

Once I read this chapter, I knew the G.O.A.T of the one piece community was gonna make a video on this subject 💯

[@adityasinghkushwah9714]

I guess at that time Roger was yet to become a pirate King , before knowing the history of the world whereas rocks already knew that . Rocks aim was to become the king of the world not to just rule over the seas.

[@zoeking95]

adi sK you think rocks went to raftel and learning the entire history of the void century?? it’s definitely possible which is why he hated the world government lol

[@adityasinghkushwah9714]

@@zoeking95 it is not necessary for him to go to raftel to know the truth . As being the descendant of D his family members could have told him the history . All he need is more proofs !!

[@vaiyt]

Roger gained the title after finding Raftel so yeah, he wasn't the pirate king yet

[@islandboy9381]

Remember that Roger didn't want to conquer anyhting but Xebec did and it pissed Xebec off that someone was surpassing him. The previous era didn't even have the concept of a ''Pirate King'' until Roger conquered all of the Grand Line.

[@kennethdavy4051]

adi sK true and they did say he messed with the “taboos” of the world Based on the translation I read

[@ZanarkandFFX]

Oda stated a while ago that a lurking legend will make his return... i am telling you Rocks D Xebec will make his come back.. Oda WTF

[@jrdsm]

akira toriyama will let fortune-teller baba make a debut to one piece universe just to bring rocks back to the living world

[@realityofx-avi3749]

MissTheOldKanYeah Shiki is the lurking legend. He had to disappear until Dr.Indigo finish with the experiments. So basically, indigo experiments will probably be introduce and that's when vegapunk will release his experiments.

[@ew275x]

Well Blackbeard has Moria's fruit, mahbe he could create a Rocks Zombie and it could be powerful enough to withstand sunlight and Salt.

[@rayjohnnercacao3703]

We still have Silver Axe, Ochoku, and Shiki to categorize as "Lurking Legend" if Rocks D. Xebec was indeed dead.

[@diedichtung2183]

maybe rocks ate a ship-ship-fruit?! maybe he IS teach's ship?!

[@savannahhaney7209]

You're the only channel I take my ad block off for. You deserve all of the support both from viewers and monetarily. Thank you for always creating an in depth look at one piece and not a 10min video where the first 5 min is you talking about your channel, absently screaming LiKe fOlLoW SMASH THAT SUBSCRIBE bUy mY mErCh OH AND LETS GET IN TO THE VIDEO BUT BEFORE THAT LEMME TELL YOU ABOUT WHO SPONSORED THIS VIDEO etc. And after all that to only mutter off bullshit everyone already knows with no substance. I'm projecting a bit but really, your channel is a breath of fresh air. Keep up the great work buddy. Just subbed to your patreon. Please never change.

[@ferassalah9695]

It could be that god valley is where devil fruits originated

[@dreamcastdazia4753]

I thought they came from Elbaf

[@MochaPhilanthropist]

They came from the grand line, so nowhere in the north,south,east, and west blue.because grand line is the horizontal line that determines the one piece map just like the red line

[@dreamcastdazia4753]

@@MochaPhilanthropist who are u replying to?

[@ferassalah9695]

DarkHound I mean that something happened there that creates devil fruits. They’ve spread from there. Cuz looking at how black beard is similar to rock (as far as we know) and how he’s obsessed with devil fruits. I have nothing to back it up, it was just a thought

[@shayoko6]

Rock name= Xebec BB ship name= Saber of Xebec

[@zangetsuzero1386]

Woah! I didn't even think about that!

[@afroman529973]

Luffy carries Rogers will and BB carries Xebecs will

[@shravanpradeep8434]

There is a theory that Blackbeard is Rock's son. Lots of similarities.

[@k9beast_122]

@@shravanpradeep8434 if that was true it could be possible that rocks had the dark fruit

[@somniloguy12]

He mentions that in the video...

[@Shuffledhearts]

How do the last two chapters change the perception of Shanks' meeting with the Gorosei? First it seems to me that with Sword's reveal the hidden politics between the World Government and the Marines create an interesting context for Shanks' meeting. Does Shanks know of Sword and why does he approach the Gorosei to talk about a pirate instead of going to the Marines? If Sword and Aegis are opposed, does Shanks fall on the side of the Aegis? Secondly, is the pirate who Shanks wants to talk about still Blackbeard but now with a Rocks connection? Does he see history repeating itself and Blackbeard as inheriting the will of Rocks? Or, perhaps Shanks is wanting to talk about Oden. Sengoku's comments on Oden and Wano at the end of the chapter seem to suggest that there is more going on than we currently understand. I personally want Oden to be dead, but if Sengoku thinks Oden's place in the pirate politics back then was more than a coincidence, perhaps Shanks also picked up on that and Wano's importance to the current situation. Finally, Rocks and Wano are introduced/visited around the same time and are growing in importance together, Big Mom and Kaido being allies for the first time since Rocks in Wano. Here's a question to end these thoughts, does Oden have a connection with Rocks? Was he allied with Whitebeard at that point? When did Oden scar Kaido? Maybe it was during the God Valley incident. But we are left only with questions for now, and hype for Wano's third act.

[@revolvingworld2676]

DSAIF DSAIF I dont think Sword and Aegis are necessarily apposed as a group. Aegis just isn't probably aware of Swords existance and Aegis does things without even the Marines knowledge so it can get difficult. Ots interesting that even though the Marines and the World Government are supposed to be one, they both do things in secret from each other.

[@giovannigam]

I think that at this point it's pretty clear that Oden was the one who read the poneglyphs for Roger, right?

[@darrenraphael]

@@giovannigam Roger could read the ponelglypgs himself. Unlike Luffy, his Voice of All things is active.

[@giovannigam]

@@darrenraphael you're right

[@abdoul5176]

@@darrenraphael No he cannot. He recruited Oden expressly for his ability to read Poneglyphs. Although you probably know this by now.

[@pierre3920]

Theory: I think due to the fact that his death isn't explicitly mentioned it's safe to say that Rocks isn't dead and therefore will reappear in the series. But since he's probably older than WB and therefore would be way over his prime now I thought about something else: what if after his defeat Rocks somehow was able to transfer his soul into a different human being and the one he chose was no other than BB who was a slave child at God Valley at this time. This would explain why the slaves living there were explicitly mentioned, why BB has always been such a mastermind and also why he was able to eat two fruits at the same time. And it also would give us a great WTF moment when he finally reveals his true identity while fighting Luffy.

[@monkeybrain2976]

Wow that would be amazing

[@karthik319]

Bruh. Him being able to eat two fruits makes sense now. But then if you could make sense of how he transferred his soul, this theory would be legit.

[@famingo4363]

Wow, this would explain the "weird body" that Marco mentioned

[@dylaninfinity9756]

Sengoku in the official translation says "...though he is no longer alive to speak of it." referring to Xebec. This is in the panel where Xebec's full name is given. Source - Viz One Piece:: www.viz.com/shonenjump/chapters/one-piece Source - Viz Ch. 957: www.viz.com/shonenjump/one-piece-chapter-957/chapter/19245?action=read Edit: Of course, it is still possible Xebec is alive. However, I did want to mention it is explicitly stated otherwise.

[@ZanarkandFFX]

Tien Shinhan is Puddings big brother, it all makes sense

[@johnnymoreno5065]

Lmao😂😂

[@johnnymoreno5065]

He would fit in one piece but probably wrecked everyone in that world. I'll say this he's the strongest human since krillin gave up on training. This man could destroy a planet if he wants

[@SonnyChenova]

and Hiei is their rebellious middle-child brother.

[@islandboy9381]

Con D. Oriano is IMU sama

[@JP-zb3yb]

I think you're idea of people residing there who can read Poneglyphs is a start, but its not enough. Why were the Celestial Dragons there IN PERSON? They didnt just send a buster call or their strongest fighters like Admirals. There was something that compelled them to be there themselves. The only other thing I can think of that makes Celestial Dragons that anxious would be stuff regarding the national treasure and Im sama, a secret not even most of the World Goverment allows knowledge of. Is it possible that something relating to these two, maybe the national treasure itself, was hidden there till Rocks was unearthing it? Something fundamentally important to the Celestial Dragons was housed by that island, and this plays into what you were saying about the name, that God Valley could signify an piece or essence of the gods (the celestial dragons) was resting there, whether in a dead or dormant state, till the God Valley incident, and this is why the celestial dragons themselves had a presence

[@adela3153]

What if the celestial dragons are Im sama’s slaves....

[@martimontolio3542]

Keep it up bro! I'm in love with your content!🔥❤

[@MrKidori]

Nice review as always ! You always get/remember some things that I didn't so it's good watching your videos ! Also I'd like to know if you mind if I translate your videos for the non english speaker ? That'd be great to see new people enjoy this greatness 🙏

[@felixp535]

I think Roger and Garp decided that it was too early for the Tenryuubitos to fall, and they fought Xebec not to protect them, but to gain some time, to delay something.

[@consumerjtc5835]

I don't think that both would be the type to plan ahead that far looking at how their behaviour was portrayed. There is also the fact that they had met coincidentally on the island and probably only made the alliance due to how the Rocks are an immediate threat to their lives.

[@michaeldmingo1525]

I dought Roger wanted to protect them, just was fighting Rocks for his own reasons.

[@fakescorpion112]

Guess it is just too difficult to wrap your head around the fact that Roger and Garp can actually be the bad guy in this, shocking right. I'm not even joking.

[@michaeldmingo1525]

Luffy is a bad guy too. He's so bad!

[@dreamcastdazia4753]

@@consumerjtc5835 Nah he is right

[@shahnulislam9897]

Pudding is only 16 years old. According to the timeline big mom was last there 38 years ago. Tekking101 has a really good time line reference

[@DeCode343]

I watched 3, or 4 videos of yours. Big time quality and fact based thought process you are showcasing! :)

[@henrypeters5291]

I don't know why no one is asking what the Celestial Dragons were doing there with their slaves. Either it belonged to them and Rocks attacked them to reveal everything or Rocks took the Celestial Dragons to God Valley in an attempt to torture them to reveal something.

[@LirikSnaps]

Plot Twist: The silhouette of Rocks D. Xebec looked eerily similar to Dragon. WHAT IF Dragon is adopted the same way Ace was and he's Xebec's son? The parallel goes even further. Remember how Ace died acting exactly like Roger? The Revolutionary Army is essentially a TERRORIST GROUP AGAINST THE WORLD GOVERNMENT. Doesn't that sound familiar? Almost like INHERITED WILL.

[@OP-ig1fj]

Dragon is a revolutionary, he's not evil

[@sebizzus]

Dragon was 17 at the time of the battle,Luffy is obviously geneticaly related to Garp

[@LirikSnaps]

@@OP-ig1fj I didn't say he was evil, I meant the world government considers them terrorists.

[@LirikSnaps]

@@sebizzus I didn't say Dragon was conceived during the fight did I? Plus him acting like Garp doesn't automatically mean hes "obviously genetically related" to Luffy. Dragon is supposed to be Garp's son, but we havent seen the family resemblance there yet have we?

[@sebizzus]

@@LirikSnaps so in your mind Rock made a child ,thats dragon ,gave it to a 23 years old marine for some unknown reason(unlike Roger,where we perfectly know why,and its even more justified now)and that child made a child ,that LOOKS like garp .I'm not saying they act the same i'm saying they look related(and you made the same assumption with Rock and Dragon based on a silhouette) ,look at the drawing of 60 years old Luffy Oda made ,he looks just like garp

[@bizarreworld2510]

Morj, IMO God's Valley sounds more like a stronghold located in a island which is split in two creating a island long valley. Sengoku mentioned Garp and Roger SAVED both Celestial Dragons AND THEIR SLAVES which mean 1)they were kidnapped and were about to be killed 2)they were attacked and were about to be killed

[@senseisama3974]

Another Mr Morj upload LET'S GOOOO

[@zsmith4853]

I know, right?

[@ZanarkandFFX]

Anyone else feels like Oda gave Shanks a lower bounty than Kaido & Big Mom so we wouldn't pay that much more attention to him? Oda got something in store for Shanks which i am sure will shock the OP community. Also he became a Yonko six years ago and already has a bounty of 4B on him, makes you wonder how strong this guy really is...

[@jorph1]

Shanks ships name is the East Wind. The east wind is always seen in our past as kinda a foreboding for bad things on the horizon which is usually followed by something good.

[@giovannigam]

If Shanks has been a yonko for only 6 years, who was the yonko before him? Is there someone we don't know about yet or there were only 3 emperors (sanko?) before Shanks? If this is the case, crazy to think how Roxs former crew were the ones who took over after Roger, don't you think?

[@prestontable]

@@giovannigam Shiki and Whitebeard

[@giovannigam]

@@prestontable And maybe, it crossed my mind just now, Captain. John... Althought we know almost nothing about him we just learned that he was once part of Rocks crew and also he had a huge treasure.

[@giovannigam]

@@prestontable Wasn't Shiki defeated before Roger's death?

[@iansantiago7545]

Rock is probably SUPER evil, so he probably paved the way for Blackbeard.

[@iansantiago7545]

Ideologically at least

[@oceanwavesandcocaine1129]

Yeah Blackbeard even named his ship Saber of Xebec after Rocks D. Xebec himself so he probably knows something about the Will of D

[@BoyWonder1914]

The thing is the God Valley Incident preceded Roger's final journey into the Grand Line by quite a bit. God Valley was 38 years ago, Roger's meeting with Whitebeard & Oden where he showed them all he had learned so far was 26 years ago. Just what the hell was Roger up to in those 12 years after God Valley, and what was he up to 38 years ago to be having such monumental clashes with Xebec & Garp? We got a nice bit of Roger's journey with Oden's flashback, but compared to how much we still haven't seen, that was nothing unfortunately.

[@redfootzeff1212]

Since BB has rocks will, do yall believe hes capable to form an alliance with BM an Kaido That could be the reason why shanks might of warn the 5 elders about a certain pirate..

[@abdoul5176]

Yeah it would make sense if Blackbeard gets involved in Wano seeing as Rocks is making a resurgence there.

[@Haxerous]

I think the three eyed race probably has access to Voice of all things/ some extremely rare kind of observation haki. It could be that God valley is where the gods (CDs) brought an end to the ancient kingdom, instead of it being representative of the death of Gods it is a place where Gods brought death. And so the CDs used this as a commemorative place of their victory over the devils. Could also parallel how Laugh Tale holds the truth of the world possibly, like the tale of the laughter of the D clan and so on.

[@Oblivionknight]

Only problem I have with God's Valley being the home of the three-eyed tribe is that Pudding would be much older. There's no way Big Mom wouldn't have hooked up with one them earlier if she had the chance to.

[@quitehandsomedude6412]

Maybe she carried one civilian from that island with her.

[@userusernomi]

well, maybe Big Mom didn't know right away about the existence of a survivor from that island. Maybe she kept looking around until she found one years later and _then_ hooked up with him. It makes sense since she's known to be looking around for different races to bring into her family.

[@mainak_das]

maybe blackbeard inherited rocks's will and luffy inherited roger's!!

[@zoeking95]

Mainak Das not a maybe it’s a definite lol I don’t see any other who qualify But then whose will did law inherit ?

[@mainak_das]

@@zoeking95 we havent seen the character yet😂. wait for another year maybe we will see 😆😆😆

[@mainak_das]

@@zoeking95 maybe blackbeard was present at god vally and he saw rocks defeat???

[@zoeking95]

Mainak Das the only two people who fit in the timeline is teach and shanks they are about 39-40 years old I may be mistaken lol

[@mainak_das]

@@zoeking95 yeah i thought about the age too!!

[@samsson6430]

The biggest secret in One Piece is this: who is Monkey D. Luffy? And, why is Shanks interested in him?

[@oceanwavesandcocaine1129]

Sams Son Shanks is interested in him because he knew he was going to carry on Gold Rogers will

[@chinuaalibatya7345]

Lmaooooo what? Luffy is Luffy. Shanks is interested in him because of his will, which he most likely sensed at a young age

[@chinuaalibatya7345]

Ayyy a Mr. Morj review 😁

[@heyarnold7256]

An early Morj video? What is this a Holiday?

[@ghosthand9109]

I think BB is the son of Rocks. D Xebec . 38 years ago Rocks was defeated by Garp and Roger . BB is 40 years old. Remember BB was an Orphan. Maybe he became the Name of his Morher .D Teach . Furthermore his Base is in Beehive and his Ships Name is Saber of Xebec. He clearly has the will of his Father Rocks and Luffy has the will of Roger. That means that Coby has the will of Garp. Rocks had legendary Pirates in his Crew Rocks too

[@gunfighterdrummer]

I love this guys videos. Some of the most thought through theories and informative conclusions.

[@captainjoemama]

I bet god valley was a place where celestial dragons go and have fun with rabbits

[@JD-ee4df]

Maybe they chase the rabbits around in a competition or something? Idk just spitballing

[@_MintArcade]

Maybe there are 2 factions of celestial dragon? One that preferred luxury The other that is more sage like The ones that Garp and Roger protects is the latter... That's why they are protecting them

[@jaker721]

Good stuff as always, Morj! Looking forward to that Blackbeard video!

[@adityasinghkushwah9714]

God valley seems to be some kind of paradise for the celestial dragons

[@SlashinatorZ]

Just came up with the huge theory that Rocks Xebec was the previous user of Vegapunk's brain brain fruit! The timing adds up as we can assume Vegapunk ate the fruit shortly after the God Valley incident & Xebec's death. For one, Xebec has a huge head of hair in his silouettes which could be hiding his elongated skull. And if you think of what a user of that fruit could learn if they were a naturally strong warrior, it would explain everything! With the brain brain fruit, Xebec could quickly learn & master all these forms of martial arts within little time. He could have gone dojo to dojo & quickly memorized everything. He could have the sword skills of Mihawk, Haki of Rayleigh, culinary & kickboxing skills of Zeff, strategy of Beckman, cp9 powers, etc. Hell he could learn & master every role on a pirate ship too. He could've learned the ship building skills of Tom, the navigation skills of Nami, the culinary skills of Zeff, the doctor knowledge of Kureia, each taking less than a month to learn. He may have played dumb to not let his trainers know how smart he is otherwise they'd be creeped out by how fast he learned their crafts. Being the most smart well-rounded captain of all-time would explain why he had a powerful pirate crew filled with brutes like Whitebeard, Kaido, & Big Mom who didn't have many skills outside of brawling. He could have literally been their cook, doctor, Navigator, shipwright, strategist etc all-in-one. Mastering all these forms of fighting & strategy would have allowed him to win many Davy Back fights to earn him the strongest crew in the first place. On top of that he could have discovered a form of Haki that allowed him to cancel the weakness of ocean water & sea prism stone, making it appear that he was not a DF user. That ability alone would terrify pirates & gov officials alike to the point that they would want God Valley erased. Being a BB fruit user would also explain how he kept such a powerful dysfunctional crew under his belt, he could manipulate them, cook for them, etc. If you imagine the potential fighting abilities that a brain brain fruit user could develop, it's a miracle that Roger & Garp were able to defeat him at all. I predict that Xebec kept outsmarting all his other marine & pirate opponents cause they tried to fight smart like him but were outclassed. For Roger & Garp, it was only when they embraced their unpredictable nature that they took Rocks by surprise & defeated him. Thats how ultra smart villains are usually defeated.

[@abdalla8558]

That’s the end of One piece Luffy = Roger Marshall d Teach = Rocks D Koby = Garp

[@timurmahmud6061]

smoker is luffy's garp

[@whoswho2762]

@@timurmahmud6061 no he's not tf u tripping if u think smoker is garp for luffy cause last time I check coby the 1 training under him and coby is one of the most developed characters in one piece he's 16 an he's an admiral already an I think coby can whooped smoker

[@andrewgonzales384]

Gerardo Mendoza smoker whoops coby rn but coby should be getting a power up or might already have gotten a power up we haven’t seen yet

[@Elitist]

I'm sorry but unless there's a timeskip Coby should not be matching Luffy by the EoS. Stop trying to force even more parallels with him and Roger. Coby is not surpassing Akainu.

[@tonymanzano4965]

Both of you do know that coby has observation and advanced armament haki right? He is definitely at least at smokers level. Don't sleep on Coby.

[@Artimes.]

Its funny how people always thought in their head that oda would end the series just after wano. Like most fans were saying there will be Wano > elbaf > maybe something with Shanks and Blackbeard > Final war against the celestials and WG, END!!. I knew all along it wasn't that simple and the propensity of oda introducing more lore and new locations in the new world is something that alot of fans never factored was a possibility. Well you all see how very wrong must of you were. Also how do we even know the final war will be against the WG and marines. That is almost looking like a turn of event that may drastically be altered based on new threats that are now present in the world of one piece. You just never know and just recently editor Naito said that one piece will not end in 5 years and there is still quite alot of stories left to tell.

[@ew275x]

I do think we'll get: - Wano which will end with Big Mom and Kaido defeated. - Elbaf, which will be focused on Luffy, Usopp and Zoro fighting their mentors. - Some Zou like arc on an island which will help dump a lot of exposition. - Final Arc against Blackbeard and WG, hell I'd think by then the Marines.

[@definitelynotblitzcrank5566]

If anything, this chapter was an indicator of the series ending soon more than it was a breath of life for the series to go on five more years. Yes, god valley was introduced. Yes we got closure on some stuff. But nothing here seems to make it more likely to span further than what people have been saying. Besides, most people who you're referencing, me included, have always seemed open to the idea that this "forecast" of events might be expanded a bit upon. We've all heard theories of Wano/Kaidou's conflict being multiple islands. Luffy is going to destroy Fishman Island (Does this happen with a fight against a yonkou, with the pluton, with the collapse of the grand line before or after fighting WG...). It's not like everything is as simple as you make it out to be. A lot of stuff can and will undoubtedly happen that we cannot predict, but the events you listed WILL happen. They've been foreshadowed for too long.

[@oscargomezrivera]

That chapter was like watching an episode of game of thrones

[@goharjudge8458]

GOT SUCKS NOW

[@theace3164]

2 morj uploads in one week So this is what heaven feels like

[@ChilltheImpaler]

Nico Robin can read the poneglyphs. But pudding isn't the only other person who we've gotten a hint might be able to read the Poneglyphs. Monet thought Doffy was going to become the pirate King. And that was one of his goals. But notice in Dressrosa he was willing to give Nico Robin a 1-star bounty. Why was Doffy, a contender for the PK, willing to kill the only person who could help him read the poneglyphs? Does doffy have access to a member of the 3-eyed race? Considering how rare they are probably not. Something else that was strange. Why was Doffy planning to kill all the members of the Royal family except Viola on the night of his take over? The simplest answer: her devil fruit is useful to him. Viola's fruit allows her to peer into something and see the truth of what she looks at. What would happen if she looked at a poneglyphs? But wait! Why would Doffy put a star bounty on Viola if SHE can read the poneglyphs due to her devil fruit? Well just like Cesar said in punk hazard when a df user dies their power goes to the nearest fruit and that becomes the reincarnated devil fruit. Doffy doesn't care if Viola dies as long as he can control her power. But wait! Why wouldn't Doffy just kill her to begin with if he just wanted the df power? He could feed it to someone loyal to him! Like who, a member of his chosen family? See how much risk Robin is in for knowing how to read the Poneglyphs, would Doffy risk his family like that? No he'll risk this little girl that he can control and doesn't care about. In fact he's done this before with devil fruits he's wanted. See: corazon and law. But wait?! It's too much of a coincidence! Dressrosa can't be his forefathers homeland and where Doffy's ticket to PK is. Well doffy didn't seek out Dressrosa because that's where the the DonQuixote family originated from. Doffy isn't a sentimental man. He killed his brother and father with pleasure. Doffy sought out Dressrosa for Viola. The family connection was just fate. Think about it. Taking over Dressrosa was doing the most. This is the new world. Doffy could've just went to an island that was actually being ravaged by petty Pirates, actually save it, actually be considered a hero, and actually become the King. That's simpler and easier than tricking the Riku family and the people of Dressrosa. -- a one piece fan fiction by a crazed theorist.

[@daemonspade8316]

Pretty dope theory.

[@Obhin]

Awesome as always, Mr Morj! : D I love your reasoning and theories!

[@davidmedina3031]

MR. MORJ GOOOAAAAAAAAATTTTT!!!!!! 🐐🐐🐐🐐

[@MaggotKing556]

I don't get it

[@blueeyednick]

@@MaggotKing556 goat = god

[@zsmith4853]

@@MaggotKing556 GOAT: (Greatest Of All Time).

[@gogozeppeli9267]

Rocks knew about the void century thus he wanted to overthrow IM sama and become the new king! But he was evil ...

[@EmptyMan000]

@Dxrk Zoom Don't equate one bastard trying to kill another as a good act. That's foolish. Rocks wanted to be King and he had to take down anyone who threatened his power to do so. Nothing more. He was an evil monster.

[@abdoul5176]

@Dxrk Zoom Yeah everything we heard about him was according to Sengoku's recollection. I'm eager to learn more about him.

[@userusernomi]

Remember that Xebec wanted to be the king of the world, so it makes that he would eventually go to an island where there is a race of people that are able to read poneglyphs and awaken ancient weapons. To me it makes complete sense that such a huge event involving so many important characters would happen in such an important place. As always, good job man.

[@SehaChan]

I just read the other day an interesting theory about Blackbeard being a three-eyed person(his forehead has consistently been covered throughout all his appearances at all ages). This would tie in so nicely in Morj's theory here...and you know, Pudding must have had a father...(he would have been 24 at the time)she even has a sorta split personality.

[@nickargeny8467]

Even two years later and this is still solid gold and right. What if xebec was the leader of the revolutionary army and maybe that's joyboys role in completing the one piece. What if garp knew he could have took out the celestial (that's why he resents that incident) dragons out of he truly wanted to. I think rogar went to God Valley to help garp because he asked and rogar said yes. What if rogar laughed at laughtale because he needed help from xebec instead of defeating him. Maybe he could have got the one piece (rogar didn't know the one piece at the time of the God Valley incident) without poseidon and he laughed because the world government made tricked them into helping the celestial dragons.

[@ddb1014]

I personally think dragons lived on God Valley

[@sebizzus]

Reading comments is painful,people make theoris that can be completly ignored just by having read the series

[@zoeking95]

So far we know three road poneglyphs ( kaido, big mom, and zou) god valley is most likely the location of the last road poneglyph 🤔🤔

[@BakaryD]

Mr.morj + Chapter 957 : Holy Mother of God

[@staskilinkaridis6184]

Do not create a mystery when there isn't one, God valley is the tenryubito slave farm !!!!! Most probably rocks went there ti kill everyone, roger went to free the slaves and garp..... followed roger or the rocks there

[@pianotensai2492]

slave farm , how does that work !!! and if there is a slave farm why isn't it located in Mary Geoise

[@staskilinkaridis6184]

@@pianotensai2492 because google how a farm works

[@pianotensai2492]

@@staskilinkaridis6184 '' because google how a farm works '' That's not a sentence

[@LiLBankai]

Slaves like boa? 🤔

[@MoviespoofTV1]

I believe that Mystery island in Thriller Bark is God Valley since it has similar mountains and its covered in mist and they said the island disappear

[@blyzer7373]

@@mohq9573 He's not talking about Thriller Bark but the giant monster that appears in the end of the arc.

[@yusukeurameshi5877]

When’s the next Wano report? I really wanna see you and Ohara discus this wild chapter

[@Silly_Illidan]

Rocks passed the will to Roger. Roger passed it to shanks. Shanks passed it to Luffy. Luffy forgot that in favour of meat

[@nekthomatah7558]

I hope Oda makes a movie about God Valley...it would be epic

[@mervynns4475]

Very interesting theory, I find it weird how Kaido mentions finding the One Piece alongside Big Mom but he never mentions/shows interest in Nico Robin. Maybe he knows where this race is and will use one of them to read the red poneglyphs for him.

[@user-hz6dd5bj3s]

Garp watching this video: Damn niggas really dont wanna acknowledge me

[@seraphlord]

Man, How wild would that be if Blackbeard really did turn out to be Rocks' son. Rocks was potentially killed by Roger and the Garp(the marines) and Ace, Rogers son was in turn killed by the Marines and Blackbeard. What a reversal.

[@DeathRex88]

I think God valley could be Punk Hazard. We have no real idea what it looked like before the Admiral fight and it had signs of a ruined civilization that you can see when The SH fight that dragon when they meet Kin'emon. The government taking God Valley and turning it into its secret research station doesn't sound all that farfetched and its also not possible to log effectively being hidden away. The Map in the latest chapter shows God Valley on a map where you see a few land masses near it and as we saw when Smoker was trying to catch the SH coming out from Fishman Island we saw three islands that his compass would point from fishman island which were Risky Red island, Raijin island and Mystoria island, where he chose Raijin island to ambush the SH. It couldn't of been that far given how quickly he arrived on Punk Hazard afterword. I think it fits.

[@erlandochoa8278]

Isn't it kind of specific of Big Mom to say "lost to the mist of time"? Could the third race be the giant monsters hiding in the mist of the florian triangle? I know many people think the monsters will never become relevant to the story again because they could be supposed to symbolise that there's always something greater or something unknown in the world or something like that but that quote is very specific

[@joelcoll4034]

While you were talking about Pueding's mistery I had the idea that maybe she can't actually read poneglyphs, that was just a memory that she insterted on Big Mom so she would care about Pudding

[@jojolafrite90]

I bet Garp sank the whole island with one of his punches.

[@BatmanBateman.]

a 20min-Morj-vid including this beautiful soundtrack omgg

[@suspiciousdoge9yand104]

Rocks D. Xebec is Blackbeard's father. It explains the "book" that BB mentioned where he read about dark dark fruit. His father mightve given it to him.

[@frandaesquina]

"protecting the Tenryuubito" may mean that Garp only prevented the Rocks pirates from getting in touch with the Three-eyed tribe. And it would explain why Roger helped Garp then. Roger may also be the responsible for vanishing the Island. Since he knows that the world government is trying to whipe out the void century from history, he could have reached Oden and Toki and sent the Island to the future. Toki would agree to do that (if possible) since she may be from the void century herself. It seems that the marines do not know what happened to the island for it to vanish. So... I don't think that they were involved, since that seemed to be a meeting with high ranked marines.

[@aviral0015]

Blackbeard inherited the will of rocks and luffy inherited of roger. God valley will repeat itself someday with the showdown happening between the two main characters carrying the initial 'D'

[@MastersOfDisaster491]

have a theory about gods valley. Considering how the world government wanted to cover up the existence of gods valley I’m inclined to believe that’s gods valley is the place where the ancient civilization lived before the creation of the world government and that gods valley was where the battle between the world government and those ancient people occurred during the 100 year void. It’s far fetched, but it might be the place that those ancient people that made the poneglyphs lived before WG wiped them out.

[@ThemTwoGamerGuys]

I believe the island is where the celestial dragons got their dragons from. The valley looks like a cool place for dragons to fly through. Garp could have also decided to name his son Dragon after going there.

[@mcurran6505]

Just a theory I think Luffy and Teach may very well be the reincarnations of Roger and Rocks. The example being that the incident at God Valley occur just 38 years ago and that's were Rocks has died, now if you at Blackbeard's age he was 38 years old when he made his debut and after the timeskip he is now 40 so maybe there could be a connection. Now if you remember Roger's execution occur just 24 years ago and Luffy was born just five years later and he is now aged 19. Okay so maybe it's a bit far off but you gotta admit they are very much alike.

[@mcurran6505]

@Thanatos Ragnarok Good point, how about this maybe Rocks was the original user of the Dark Dark Fruit before being killed.

[@dafirabud2341]

Hey, late to the game on your channel, but glad to be discovering your content. What if Gods Valley is a celestial dragon graveyard? I doubt they would want to bury bodies around Mariejois, even if they are the bodies of CDs. They're mad petty like that. Why else would Rocks have such a big battle there? Maybe that's where the 4th red ponlyglyph was at first?? Lol oh the theories

[@aSaiyan_Cloeku]

Ohh god it all makes sense. Imu, I believe is the one that erased god valley. Pudding is the daughter of Imu, who is also from where the three eyed people came from. What makes this all more unsettling is trying to force the marriage of vinsmoke Sanji and Pudding. In a sense making the ultimate bloodline. All Sanji not being important caps aside. But just think about it for it a bit.

[@manofculture8666]

Calling it now, God Valley is Onigashima. Marco was surprised about the name Onigashima and said "Is that what they're calling it now?". Implying it had a different name before.

[@jaredhall5169]

Perhaps Rocks was like a Shanks to Blackbeard? A person that inspired hm in the same way Roger inspired Shanks and Shanks inspired Luffy.

[@xvhq_chapsticktributary_ap1666]

I honestly think Pedro lived, and Pedro will be the next Straw Hat (he’ll come along with Jinbei and there will be a brief flashback on how Pedro survived + when/how/where Jinbei found him + how the two together escape to Wano)

[@fakescorpion112]

Or maybe Roger stopped Rocks, then years later went to Raftel himself only to belated realize he actually fucked up that one time at God Valley. Roger is not all-knowing all the time, whatever he discovered at Raftel come AFTER that God Valley incident, so Roger may very well have made the wrong choice at one time.

[@secretasian8165]

Holy shit Rocks is probably the pirate shanks wanted to talk about with the gorosei

[@ozaomar]

Mr Morj back at it again !